Opinion

Brown v. Commissioner of Social Security

Court
District Court, M.D. Florida
Filed
Mar 6, 2025
Cited by
0 cases
Authority
More cited than 34.3%

“[T]he task of determining a claimant’s [RFC] and ability to work is within the province of the ALJ, not of doctors.”

How later courts described this case

  • “[T]he task of determining a claimant’s [RFC] and ability to work is within the province of the ALJ, not of doctors.”

Written by the judges who cited it.

The opinion

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

MIDDLE DISTRICT OF FLORIDA

OCALA DIVISION

CHRISTOPHER ALLEN BROWN,

Plaintiff,

v.

Case No. 5:23-cv-698-RMN

COMMISSIONER OF SOCIAL

SECURITY,

Defendant.

MEMORANDUM DECISION AND ORDER1

Plaintiff, Christopher Allen Brown, seeks review of the

Commissioner of Social Security’s final decision denying his application

for disability insurance and supplemental security income. Dkt. 1.2

Because the Commissioner’s final decision is not supported by substantial

evidence, pursuant to sentence four of 42 U.S.C. § 405(g), this case is

REVERSED and REMANDED.

1 With the parties’ consent, this matter was referred to me to conduct all

proceedings and order the entry of a final judgment in accordance with 28

U.S.C. § 636(c) and Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 73. See Dkts. 11, 12.

2 In this decision, citations to the administrative record are denoted as “R.

___.” The citations reference the Bates number annotated on the bottom

of each page. See Dkt. 9.

I. BACKGROUND

A. Agency Proceedings

Brown applied for disability benefits and supplemental security

income on April 9, 2021, alleging a disability onset date of November 28,

2020. R. 17, 223–24. The agency denied his claim initially and upon

reconsideration. R. 112–121, 127–140. Brown then requested a hearing

before an Administrative Law Judge (“ALJ”), which was held on March

30, 2023. R. 148, 731–758. On May 3, 2023, the ALJ issued a written

decision denying the application. R. 14–61. Brown sought review of that

decision by the agency, but his request for review was denied. R. 1–6. The

ALJ’s decision is the Commissioner’s final decision. R. 1.

B. The ALJ’s Decision

Brown was 38 years old on the alleged disability onset date. R. 27.

Brown has a high school education, completed two years of college, and

took a leave of absence from school after being hospitalized for COVID-19

in December 2020. R. 384–406, 822. He has past relevant work as an

electrician apprentice, store laborer, electrician technician, and security

guard. R. 27, 55, 241. He alleged disability arising from post-traumatic

stress disorder (“PTSD”), COVID-19, back injury, lung condition, and

sleep apnea. R. 240.

The ALJ evaluated Brown’s application using the five-step

sequential evaluation process. R. 18–29. The ALJ first found that Brown

met the insured status requirement of the Social Security Act through

December 31, 2025. R. 20. At step one, the ALJ found that Brown had not

engaged in substantial gainful activity since his alleged onset date. R. 20.

At step two, the ALJ found Brown had severe impairments, including

back disorder (lumbago and cervicalgia), tinnitus, diabetes mellitus

type 2, hypertension, hypothyroidism, hyperlipidemia, sleep apnea,

obesity, depressive disorder, PTSD, anxiety, and Asperger’s syndrome.

R. 20. The ALJ then determined at step three that Brown did not have an

impairment or combination of impairments that met or equaled the

severity of one of the listed impairments in 20 C.F.R. Part 404, Subpart

P, Appendix 1. R. 20–21.

Moving to the next part of the evaluation process, the ALJ found

that Brown had the residual functional capacity (“RFC”) to perform a

modified range of light work with the following additional limitations:

[H]e can lift, carry, push and/or pull twenty (20) pounds

occasionally and ten (10) pounds frequently. He can

stand and walk for six (6) hours and can sit for six (6)

hours in an 8-hour workday with normal breaks. He

could occasionally climb stairs, balance, stoop, kneel,

crouch and crawl, but should never climb ladders or

scaffolds. He must avoid exposure to vibration,

unprotected heights and hazardous machinery. This

individual can handle exposure to a noise level intensity

not above the “moderate” level as defined in the Selected

Characteristics of Occupations (SCO). . . . During the

eight-hour workday, he must avoid concentrated

exposure to extreme heat, cold, wetness, humidity, and

irritants such as fumes, odors, dust, and gases. This

individual can follow only simple instructions. This

person should have no interaction with the general

public unless it is merely superficial, and only occasional

interaction with co-workers. . . . This person is limited to

jobs requiring only occasional decision-making and

changes in the work setting.

R. 21–27. Based on this determination, at step four, the ALJ concluded

that Brown could not perform his past relevant work. R. 27.

At the last step, the ALJ considered Brown’s age, education, work

experience, residual functional capacity, and the testimony of a vocational

expert (“VE”). R. 28, 56–57. Because the ALJ determined other jobs exist

in significant numbers in the national economy that Brown can perform—

such as marker, garment sorter, and office—the ALJ concluded that he

was not disabled. R. 27–28.

II. STANDARD OF REVIEW

A court’s only task in reviewing a denial of disability benefits is to

determine whether the Commissioner’s decision is “supported by

substantial evidence and based on proper legal standards.” Winschel v.

Comm’r of Soc. Sec., 631 F.3d 1176, 1178 (11th Cir. 2011). Substantial

evidence “is such relevant evidence as a reasonable person would accept

as adequate to support a conclusion.” Id.

Courts reviewing a decision denying disability benefits may not

“decide the facts anew, make credibility determinations, or re-weigh the

evidence.” Moore v. Barnhart, 405 F.3d 1208, 1211 (11th Cir. 2005)

(cleaned up). Rather, courts must affirm the decision if the denial is

supported by substantial evidence, even if the preponderance of the

evidence weighs against the Commissioner’s findings. Henry v. Comm’r of

Soc. Sec., 802 F.3d 1264, 1267 (11th Cir. 2015). Courts review the

Commissioner’s legal conclusions de novo. Lewis v. Barnhart, 285 F.3d

1329, 1330 (11th Cir. 2002).

III. ANALYSIS

Brown argues that the ALJ’s decision is not supported by

substantial evidence and that the ALJ erred in not discussing whether

Brown’s COVID-19 was a medically determinable impairment, likening

the purported error to those made in prior decisions in which a claimant

suffered from fibromyalgia. Dkt. 16 at 3–11. The Commissioner argues

that substantial evidence supports the limitations assessed by the ALJ,

and that the RFC includes the necessary limitations related to Brown’s

COVID-19 diagnosis. Dkt. 17 at 12–13.

The ALJ is tasked with assessing a claimant’s RFC and ability to

perform past relevant work. See 20 C.F.R. § 404.1546(c); 20 C.F.R.

§ 404.1527(d)(2) (the assessment of a claimant’s RFC is an issue reserved

for the Commissioner); see also Robinson v. Astrue, 365 F. App’x 993, 999

(11th Cir. 2010) (“[T]he task of determining a claimant’s [RFC] and ability

to work is within the province of the ALJ, not of doctors.”).3 The RFC “is

an assessment, based upon all of the relevant evidence, of a claimant’s

remaining ability to do work despite [her] impairments.” Lewis v.

Callahan, 125 F.3d 1436, 1440 (11th Cir. 1997). In determining a

claimant’s RFC, the ALJ must consider all relevant evidence, including

the opinions of medical and non-medical sources. See 20 C.F.R.

§ 404.1545(a)(3).

A. Medical Evidence Summary

In rendering the RFC finding, the ALJ discussed objective medical

evidence as follows. Brown presented in the emergency department with

a fever and vomiting two days after having a surgical procedure on his left

foot. R. 23, 369. His physical examination was normal, except for a

bandage to his left lower extremity. R. 23, 369, 371. An x-ray showed right

perihilar opacities, which could be secondary to pneumonia. R. 23, 374.

Brown was hospitalized for COVID-19 on December 22, 2020.

R. 384–406, 822. He developed severe hypoxia and was placed on high-

flow oxygen. R. 389. He was diagnosed with pneumonia secondary to

COVID-19 infection and was placed in ICU for seven days. R. 23, 389, 409,

3 “Unpublished opinions are not controlling authority and are persuasive

only insofar as their legal analysis warrants.” Bonilla v. Baker Concrete

Const., Inc., 487 F.3d 1340, 1345 (11th Cir. 2007).

581. The ALJ noted Brown’s admission records detail past medical history

of hypertension, type II diabetes, and hypothyroidism. R. 23, 392.

On January 8, 2021, one week after Brown’s discharge, he returned

to the emergency department complaining of shortness of breath and mild

cough. R. 23, 552. He tested positive for COVID. R. 556. Upon

examination, his lungs were clear to auscultation, he had equal breath

sounds and regular respirations, his range of motion of the back and

musculoskeletal system were normal, he had regular heart rate and

rhythm, and was cooperative, alert, and oriented, with normal mood and

affect. R. 23, 552–54. Brown was assessed with dyspnea (shortness of

breath). R. 554. After several hours he left the emergency department

against medical advice because he was upset that his wife could not be

with him in the hospital, and he refused the recommended EKG, chest

X-ray, and CT chest. R. 556. He was discharged in “improved condition.”

R. 23, 556. It was noted he appeared dyspneic. R. 554.

In his decision, the ALJ explained that January 11, 2021 pulmonary

treatment records reveal “normal physical examination findings,

including normal respiratory examination, normal cardiovascular

examination, no edema, and normal visual overview of all extremities.”

R. 23, 584, 588. The ALJ again noted that Brown was assessed with

history of COVID-19, shortness of breath, and sleep apnea. R. 23, 584,

588–89. The ALJ noted that treatment records from December 2020

through March 2021 showed complaints of exercise intolerance,

diaphoresis, pallor, shortness of breath, decreased cognitive functioning,

stuttering, and anxiety. R. 23, 598, 603, 608, 62–13, 617. The ALJ also

recognized Brown’s history of musculoskeletal impairments, including

left-sided moderate spurring in the cervical spine, and multilevel

degeneration in the lumbar spine without the necessity of surgical

intervention. R. 23, 630. These symptoms were treated with muscle

relaxants, anti-inflammatories, and physical therapy. R. 23, 630.

As the ALJ explained, January and February 2021 physical

examinations showed that Brown had limited ambulation, ambulation

with a cane, dyspneic on exertion, and irregular gait, but were otherwise

normal. R. 23, 603–04, 608–09, 613. On March 11, 2021, Brown had a

telehealth primary care office visit, complaining of shortness of breath,

decreased cognitive functioning, stuttering, and anxiety. R. 598. He was

described as being “confused” with an “abnormal affect.” R. 598. He had

normal motor strength and movement of all extremities and was assessed

as having COVID-19 with a slow recovery; treatment notes stated this

condition was “somewhat improved” but “not improved enough to return

to work” and he suffered from acute respiratory distress syndrome that

was improving. R. 23, 599–600, 604. There was a concern for post-COVID

cerebral vascular accident (stroke). R. 599. He was referred to neurology

due to his cognitive changes after COVID and to cardiology due to his

tachycardia post-COVID. R. 599–600.

The ALJ recognized that Brown had been diagnosed with essential

hypertension, obstructive sleep apnea (treated with CPAP, noted non-

compliance), and type II diabetes (uncontrolled) during the relevant

period. R. 24, 634–35, 1838. As the ALJ observed, Brown’s brain CT and

EKG were normal. R. 24, 692–93, 1830.

Treatment records from Brown’s neurologist from June 2021

revealed that Brown had normal gait, normal sensation, and normal

cardiovascular and respiratory examinations. R. 24, 745–46. Brown

complained of shortness of breath, back pain, muscle weakness, anxiety,

depression, and memory loss. R. 744. The physical examination showed

the following: BP 157/106, BMI 42.17, neck weakness, right sided

weakness 4/5 but 5/5 otherwise, normal hearing, normal sensation,

bilateral upper extremity intention tremor, normal gait, no

rales/rhonchi/wheezes, regular heart rate and rhythm, no

murmur/rub/gallop, and intact cranial nerves. R. 24, 745–46.

On May 27, 2021, Brown was seen by the neurologist with

complaints of impaired cognition, reporting “[h]e often forgets what he is

doing and it is difficult for him to complete tasks.” R. 748. The medical

neurological team member stated, “[w]e will consider [n]europsychological

evaluation” but “[w]e should holdoff on formal evaluation since the patient

is still recovering from Covid-19.” R. 748. Brown was reported as having

back pain, muscle weakness, anxiety, depression, memory loss, and a

history of cognitive changes after COVID. R. 749. Psychiatric progress

notes from June 10, 2021, note his chief complaint of anxiety, and he

explained that after COVID diagnosis from January “he has been feeling

fatigue, gets short of breath with exertion” and feels anxious with two or

three anxiety attacks per day. R. 810. His mood was depressed and

anxious, but his concentration and memory were normal. R. 813. He was

diagnosed with major depressive disorder, social anxiety disorder,

Asperger’s Syndrome, sleep apnea, and diabetes. R. 813.

The ALJ discussed that Brown’s June 21, 2021 VA records show

non-antalgic gait that was steady and independent, “good and clear” lungs

bilaterally, blood pressure within normal limitations, no edema, and no

acute distress. R. 24, 808. He asked for a referral to psychiatry because he

had been unable to attend previous appointments because of COVID-19

illness, reporting his “recovery was slow” but he “[f]eels a whole lot better,”

except for occasional dyspnea helped by his prescribed inhaler. R. 807. As

of that date his prescriptions included albuterol inhaler for shortness of

breath, benzonatate as needed for cough, budesonide inhaler, medications

for anxiety and diabetes, and guaifenesin as needed to thin mucous.

R. 807–08. His lungs were good and clear. R. 808.

Brown was assessed by his primary care team on September 29,

2021, complaining of shortness of breath but no cough, wheezing, or

coughing up blood, as well as anxiety. R. 1759. On exam he was noted as

having dyspneic (mild on exertion) with good air movement, and showed

good judgment, alert and anxious on mental stats exam, with recent

memory abnormal. R. 1759. It was noted he had chronic bronchitis, with

suspected relation to post-COVID lung disease. R. 1760.

The ALJ noted that Brown had independent mobility and ability to

perform self-care without assistance with tenderness of the lumbar spine

and SI joint and decreased range of motion of the lumbar spine. R. 24,

1332–33. Brown’s October 2021 pulmonary function test showed normal

findings indicating the absence of any significant degree of obstructive

pulmonary impairment or restrictive ventilatory defect. R. 24, 1280.

Treatment records from December 2021 also showed normal respiratory

findings, normal gait and station, no dyspnea, normal movement of all

extremities, and tenderness of the lumbar spine. R. 24, 1752. His anxiety

and major depressive disorder were noted, as were posterior rhinorrhea

with chronic cough. R. 1752. The ALJ also considered Brown’s history of

chronic tinnitus in making the RFC finding, noting that Plaintiff used

binaural hearing aids for tinnitus management, but that he could hear

and understand normal conversational speech with bilateral hearing aids

during evaluation. R. 24, 1846, 1868.

As the ALJ noted, consultative examination notes, dated October 6,

2022, continued to reveal that Brown had normal gait, no pain or

discomfort, regular heart rate and rhythm, no murmurs, “mildly

decreased bilateral breath sounds,” mild difficulty getting in/out of a chair

and examination table, no cyanosis/clubbing/edema, no spinal tenderness,

intact sensation, 2+ reflexes, negative straight leg raise testing, mild

difficulty with tandem/heel/toe walk, moderate difficulty squatting, full

grip strength, full strength in the upper extremities, 4/5 strength in the

lower extremities, and normal hearing with the use of hearing aids. R. 25,

1872–73. The ALJ reported that Brown was assessed with hypertension,

history of COVID infection, history of dyspnea on exertion, history of

chronic low back pain, history of chronic tinnitus, use of bilateral hearing

aids with fair results, generalized anxiety disorder, and PTSD. R. 25,

1874. Brown’s blood pressure readings showed improvement. R. 25, 1911.

The ALJ also noted Brown’s obesity, with his body mass index of 39,

coupled with his hyperlipidemia, weight loss recommendations, and

dietary restrictions. R. 25, 1853.

As for Brown’s mental health impairments, records indicate Brown

suffered from mixed anxiety and depressive disorder with an onset date

of December 3, 2018. R. 596. The ALJ explained that Brown had normal

psychiatric findings on physical examination from 2020 and 2021. R. 25,

371, 390, 519, 554, 584, 745. The ALJ recognized that Brown suffered from

anxiety and depression with associated symptoms of worrying,

restlessness, deficits in sleep, deficits in concentration/focus, and financial

stress. R. 25, 797–98, 827. Mental health treatment records from 2022

revealed some abnormal findings, including anxious/dysthymic mood and

restricted/tearful affect, but Brown was cooperative and adequately

groomed, with normal attention and concentration, normal memory, fair

insight and judgment, coherent/logical/goal-directed thought process,

realistic thought content, self-awareness, and he understood the likely

outcome of behavior. R. 26, 1768, 1786–87, 1789, 1803–04, 1806, 1809,

1952.

As the ALJ noted, Brown’s October 2022 mental status examination

revealed that he was alert with appropriate dress, and he was cooperative

with normal speech, irritable mood, restricted affect, normal attention

and concentration, normal memory, normal thought processes, no

auditory or visual hallucinations, no delusional thoughts, fair judgment

and insight, and full orientation. R. 26, 1856. The ALJ further recognized

that Plaintiff’s mental health impairments were treated conservatively

throughout the relevant period, with medication and therapy. R. 26.

B. Plaintiff’s Claims

As previously noted, the ALJ found that Brown could perform a less

than light exertional work with environmental limitations, occasional

postural limitations, limitations in interacting with others, as well as

limitations in concentration, persistence, and maintenance of pace. R. 26–

27. Brown challenges the ALJ’s consideration of the residual effects from

his COVID-19 hospitalization and his subjective complaints related to

these residuals, when he failed to discuss whether COVID-19 was a

medically determinable impairment (“MDI”).

Citing to Marcus v. Commissioner of Social Security, No. 6:21-cv-

1745, 2023 WL 1860638, at *3 (M.D. Fla. Feb. 9, 2023), and Nowaczyk v.

Kijakazi, No. 5:21-cv-63, 2022 WL 3031230, at *5 (N.D. Fla. July 12,

2022), report and recommendation adopted, No. 5:21-cv-63, 2022 WL

3030546 (N.D. Fla. Aug. 1, 2022), Brown argues that the ALJ similarly

erred because in those cases, the ALJ discussed medical records showing

that the claimants had been diagnosed with fibromyalgia but did not

consider fibromyalgia a medically determinable impairment.4 Dkt. 18 at

4 The Social Security Administration issued SSR 12-2p to provide

guidance on how to determine whether a person has a medically

determinable impairment of fibromyalgia and how it will evaluate this

impairment in a disability claim. See SSR 12-2p, 2012 WL 3104869 (July

1. In Marcus, the Court found error because the Eleventh Circuit had

loosened the need for objective evidence to establish disability from

fibromyalgia since a “hallmark” of that disease was the lack of objective

evidence, referring to the Circuit’s finding that “a claimant’s subjective

complaints may be the only means of determining the severity of [her]

condition and the functional limitations she experiences.” Horowitz v.

Comm’r of Soc. Sec., 688 F. App’x 855, 863 (11th Cir. 2017).

Brown argues that COVID has a similar hallmark due to lack

objective evidence. Dkt. 18 at 2. He relies on the Centers for Disease

Control and Prevention’s Long COVID or Post COVID Conditions paper,

which “states that people with Long-COVID may have symptoms that are

hard to explain and manage and that clinical evaluations and objective

testing and imaging are often normal.”5 Dkt. 18 at 4. He also relies on the

25, 2012); Francis v. Saul, No. 8:18-cv-2492, 2020 WL 1227589, *3 (M.D.

Fla. Mar. 13, 2020). The ruling informs ALJs in how to consider

fibromyalgia in the five-step process. SSR 12-2p, 2012 WL 3104869 (July

25, 2012). “Although SSRs do not have the same force and effect as

statutes or regulations, they are binding on all components of the Social

Security Administration.” 20 C.F.R. 402.35(b)(1). Soc. Sec. Ruling, SSR

12-2p; Titles II & XVI: Evaluation of Fibromyalgia, SSR 12-2P (S.S.A. July

25, 2012).

5 See Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, COVID-19, Long

COVID, Symptoms that are hard to explain and manage (“CDC Long

COVID Paper”), https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/long-term-

effects/index.html.

Brown’s reference to Long COVID requires some background to

understand. When someone is infected with a virus called SARS-CoV-2,

Social Security Administration’s Emergency Message (“EM”) regarding

evaluation of COVID-10 cases.6 The EM provides policy guidance for

they may suffer an acute medical condition called COVID-19. See

Coronaviridae Study Grp. of the Int’l Comm. on Taxonomy of Viruses, The

species Severe acute respiratory syndrome-related coronavirus: classifying

2019-nCoV and naming it SARS-CoV-2, 5 Nat. Microbiol. 536, 539 (Mar.

2020). The infected person becomes ill and may be hospitalized, but the

person’s innate and adaptive immune responses usually clear the virus

within a short time and resolve the symptoms caused by infection. See,

e.g., Acute, Dorland’s Illustrated Medical Dictionary 24 (33rd ed. 2020).

For the unlucky, however, SARS-CoV-2 infection can cause a different,

chronic medical condition called post-acute sequelae of COVID-19 or,

more simply, Long COVID.

6 The guidance further states:

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19) is a relatively

new disease caused by the virus SARS-CoV-2. COVID-19

is highly variable in presentation, ranging from

asymptomatic infection to severe illness. While COVID-

19 presents primarily as a respiratory disease, it may

also lead to cardiovascular, renal, dermatological,

neurological, psychiatric, or other complications. The

medical community is still learning about the severity of

the illness, its long-term effects, and emerging variants

of the virus.

Studies have found that about one in five people who

recover from the acute or initial phase COVID-19 illness

report long-term health effects they had not experienced

before contracting the virus. These lingering or chronic

health problems following the acute phase of illness is

clinically described as Post-acute Sequelae of SARS-CoV-

2 infection (PASC) – more commonly known as Long

COVID.

https://secure.ssa.gov/apps10/reference.nsf/links/03282024111904AM

(last visited October 16, 2024) (“EM Message”). This EM was initially

evaluating disability cases that include an allegation or diagnosis of

COVID-19. It states:

Studies have found generally poorer long-term health

outcomes among older individuals; people with pre-

existing comorbidities (such as hypertension, diabetes,

asthma, and obesity); and those with a history of

cigarette smoking or substance abuse. People who were

hospitalized during the acute phase of COVID-19 tend to

experience more severe and persistent Long COVID

symptoms. Sometimes, COVID-19 causes no post-acute

effects. When there are such post-acute effects, their

severity can range from mild to extreme. Therefore, we

must evaluate Long COVID symptoms on an individual

basis.

* * *

We must consider whether COVID-19, Long COVID, a

new MDI(s) caused by COVID-19, or any MDI(s) that has

worsened because of COVID-19 meets or medically

equals a listing (DI 22001.001D.3 and DI 28005.015A.2).

COVID-19, on its own, cannot meet a listing, but it may

equal a listing as an unlisted impairment or as part of a

combination of impairments (DI 24508.010). The same is

true for Long COVID. COVID-19 and Long COVID may

affect respiratory, cardiovascular, renal, neurological, or

other body systems. In most cases, the listing relevant to

a new MDI(s) caused by COVID-19, or any MDI(s) that

has worsened because of COVID-19 will be the

appropriate listing to consider.

EM Message.

Disability evaluators are to consider whether any COVID-related

impairment was “of ‘listing level’ severity,” and, if not, to “assess [the

claimant’s] residual functional capacity (RFC) to determine whether they

issued on August 9, 2022, before the date of the ALJ’s decision, and was

revised effective March 28, 2024. Id.

have any functional limitations caused by symptoms of COVID-19 or any

resulting MDI(s).” Anthony Edward G. v. O’Malley, No. 23-cv-1611, 2024

WL 3442415, at *5 (S.D. Cal. July 17, 2024), report and recommendation

adopted, No. 23-CV-1611, 2024 WL 3799439 (S.D. Cal. Aug. 12, 2024).

According to Brown, the ALJ erred when, although discussing the

symptoms Brown alleged, he used largely unremarkable objective

evidence to dismiss these symptoms. Dkt. 18 at 3.

The Commissioner argues that Brown has shown no error because

the ALJ discussed Plaintiff’s COVID-19 diagnosis, hospitalization, and

treatment throughout the decision, including noting that he had a slow

recovery from COVID-19 and discussing his respiratory, cardiovascular,

musculoskeletal, and mental health treatment records. Dkt. 17 at 12. The

Commissioner also argues that Brown essentially asks the Court to re-

weigh the medical evidence of record, and he suggests that any errors by

the ALJ are harmless because the RFC assessment accounts for any

limitations supported by the record. Dkt. 17 at 12.

I disagree with the Commissioner. Another federal court recently

remanded a similar case, finding the ALJ’s failure to appropriately

consider the evidence related to the residual impact of the claimant’s

COVID-19 was not harmless:

Most significantly, although the ALJ acknowledged that

Plaintiff was hospitalized and placed on a ventilator due

to COVID-19 and that she continued to experience

dyspnea on exertion and shortness of breath following

her discharge and while at home with oxygen, the ALJ

failed to acknowledge that shortness of breath on

exertion remained a persistent and limiting problem

throughout the medical record, extending beyond the

twelve-month durational requirement. As the medical

summary following her hospitalization demonstrates,

the record is replete with references to Plaintiff's

shortness of breath and/or fatigue with exertion,

including when walking or climbing stairs.

A.H. v. O’Malley, No. cv-22-4942, 2024 WL 4190865, at *7 (E.D. Pa. Sept.

13, 2024). So too here.

Remand is required because the ALJ erred in evaluating evidence

of Plaintiff's COVID-19 residuals, particularly as to persistent dyspnea on

exertion and increased anxiety and difficulty in concentration. Brown

testified that after being diagnosed with COVID, he suffered from labored

breathing, problems with exertion, and shortness of breath on a daily

basis. R. 48. On March 11, 2021, Brown complained of shortness of breath,

decreased cognitive functioning, stuttering, and anxiety. R. 598. On May

27, 2021, Brown was reported as having back pain, muscle weakness,

anxiety, depression, memory loss, and a history of cognitive changes after

COVID. R. 749. On September 29, 2021, he again complained of shortness

of breath as well as anxiety. R. 1759. On exam he was noted as dyspneic,

alert and anxious on mental stats exam, with recent memory abnormal,

suffering from chronic bronchitis, with suspected relation to post-COVID

lung disease. R. 1759–60. The ALJ failed to acknowledge that shortness

of breath on exertion remained a persistent and limiting problem

throughout the medical record, possibly extending beyond the twelve-

month durational requirement.

As to Brown’s mental impairments, the ALJ found Plaintiff's

depressive disorder, PTSD, anxiety, and Asperger’s syndrome to be

severe, but after considering whether the “paragraph B” criteria are

satisfied, found that Brown does not have an impairment or combination

of impairments that meets or medically equals the severity of one of the

listed impairments.7 R. 20–21. But the ALJ did not consider whether and

to what extent depression, anxiety, or any of his other mental or physical

health problems were attributable to COVID-19. Nor did he consider if

any of these conditions satisfied the severity of duration requirements, as

required by the Commissioner’s policy guidance.

In his decision denying benefits, the ALJ acknowledged Brown’s

reports of decreased concentration and mental status reports evidencing

anxiety and depression, R. 25, but he did not address whether Brown’s

7 The ALJ considered whether the severity of Brown’s physical

impairments met Listing 1.15, (disorders of the skeletal spine resulting in

compromise of a nerve root) and Listing 1.16 (lumbar spinal stenosis

resulting in compromise of the cauda equina) and whether his mental

impairments met Listing 12.04 (depressive, bipolar, and related

disorders), Listing 12.06 (anxiety and obsessive-compulsive disorder) and

Listing 12.15 (trauma and stressor related disorders). R. 20.

mental health issues could be attributable to COVID-19 residuals,

although he did include mental health limitations in his RFC assessment.

On remand, the ALJ shall reconsider all the evidence in light of

Social Security guidance regarding the impact of COVID-19, and obtain

an updated expert medical opinion, if deemed necessary. The ALJ shall

also consider the evidence of Long COVID and evaluate whether the

evidence shows that Long COVID was a medically determinable

impairment of sufficient duration.8

8 A careful review of the record demonstrates the ALJ did not comply with

the Commissioner’s guidance. For instance, to determine if a claimant has

an MDI for COVID-19, the ALJ was instructed to look for objective

medical evidence of a positive viral test, diagnostic tests with findings

consistent with COVID-19, or a diagnosis of COVID-19 with signs

consistent with COVID-19.

The record contains objective medical evidence that falls within all

three categories. It contains a positive viral test. R. 425–26. It contains

multiple reports of diagnostic tests with findings consistent with COVID-

19. Compare R. 392–93, 401, 404–11 (noting diagnostic test findings

consistent with COVID-19) with R. 362 (pre-operative hospital admission

noting finding of clear lungs on chest x-rays). And it contains records

documenting Brown’s hospitalization based on a diagnosis of COVID-19

with signs consistent with COVID-19. See, e.g., R. 392–93 (admission

summary documenting fever and shortness of breath), 395 (consult

confirming COVID-19 diagnosis), 437 (noting “multifocal pneumonia

secondary to COVID-19” was “present on admission”).

On remand, the ALJ shall evaluate all the record evidence, make

the determinations required by the Commissioner’s guidance, and provide

a written explanation on each determination.

IV. CONCLUSION

Accordingly, it is ORDERED:

1. Pursuant to sentence four of 42 U.S.C. § 405(g), the

Commissioner’s final decision is REVERSED and REMANDED for

further proceedings consistent with the findings of this Order; and

2. The Clerk is DIRECTED to enter a judgment accordingly

and thereafter close the file.

DONE and ORDERED in Orlando, Florida, on March 6, 2025.

yd sry

ROBERT M. NORWAY

United States Magistrate Judge

Copies furnished to:

Counsel of Record

-22.-

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.