The opinion
STATE OF MAINE - SUPERIOR COURT
LINCOLN, SS. _. CIVIL ACTION |
. DOCKET NO. CV-98-006
EAe— LIN ~ l0/ee/osee
As Per
KEITH E. PLUMMER, BOARD LLC RABREG Hi
Plaintiff, . LAW Lota
v. ORDER _
OCT 30 28 1!
TOWN OF EDGECOMB, | 3
Defendant.
Posy Oe ee eT eae
On February 6, 1998, Keith Plummer ("Plummer") filed a complaint seeking
declaratory relief against the Town of Edgecomb (“Town”) concerning the status of a
portion of the Old County Road.! In 1992 Mr. Plummer purchased a large piece of OS
property that abuts that portion of the Old County Road located between Paine's
Corner and the intersection with the Mount Hunger Roads. The land he purchased
was directly east and south of over 700 acres of undeveloped land known as the
Schmid Preserve. Sometime after 1992, Mr. Plummer sold three parcels from the
original piece. However, he still owns - either in his name or in the name of his
wife - two parcels on either side of the Old County Road. Those parcels, identified
as numbers 83.01 and 84 on the Town tax map, are currently accessible only by the
Old County Road. The Town has identified the Old County Road east of the Town
1 Although defendant's trial brief states that "there is an initial issue as to
whether the road section in question is part of any road formally laid out and
accepted by the Town," no such issue was presented at trial.
2
turnaround at Paine's Corner as abandoned, and has refused to perform any
maintenance or improvements on it. Mr. Plummer brought this action in an
effortto have the court determine the road's legal status.
The parties appeared in court on October 23, 2000 to present their evidence
through witnesses and exhibits, and to argue their interpretations of that evidence.
DISCUSSION
A. Presumption of Abandonment
In deciding the question posed by Mr. Plummer, the court must first
determine whether the Town has established prima facie evidence of abandonment.
Earwood v. Town of York, 1999 ME 3, 722 A.2d 865 (Me. 1999). Here, the Town
presented evidence that, for at least the thirty years preceding February 6, 1998, it did
not maintain or improve the Old Country Road beyond the turnaround at Paine's
Corner. The "demise" of what was apparently once an active thruway between the
east and west portions of the town was explained by Robert Brown, an original and
current member of the Schmid Preserve Committee. Mr. Brown testified that, at
one time, the Old Country Road and the Mount Hunger Road _ were collectively
known as the Upper Cross Road. In 1927, a large fire devastated much of the forest
surrounding the road, and destroyed all of the buildings along it. Thereafter,
persons traveling from one side of town to the other bypassed the Upper Cross Road
in favor of the Lower Cross Road (now known as the McKay Road.) As the traffic on
the Upper Cross Road decreased, the Town decided not to maintain it, and spent its
limited resources on maintaining and improving the Lower Cross Road.
The Town's decision to abandon the former corridor between the east and
west portions of town can be demonstrated as early as 1981. At the Selectman's
meeting on October 21, 1981, a resident of what is now known as the Mount Hunger
Road North requested that the road be repaired as far as his residence. The notes for
that meeting include the following statement: "Since the road has not been used in
many years 30 or more the town is not sure this has to be done." While that
particular entry did not refer directly to the road now in dispute, it does lend general
support to the Town's position.
The question, however, is not what the Selectmen intended, but what was
done:
It is prima facie evidence that a town or county way not kept
passable for the use of motor vehicles at the expense of the
municipality or county for a period of 30 or more consecutive years has
been discontinued by abandonment. A presumption of abandonment
may be rebutted by evidence that manifests a clear intent by the
municipality or county and the public to consider or use the way as if it
were a public way. A proceeding to discontinue a town or county way
may not prevent or estop a municipality from asserting a presumption
of abandonment... A municipality or its officials are not liable for
nonperformance of a legal duty with respect to such ways if there has
been a good faith reliance on a presumption of abandonment. Any
person affected by a presumption of abandonment, including the State
or municipality, may seek declaratory relief to finally resolve the status
of such ways. A way that has been abandoned under this section is
relegated to the same status as it would have had after a discontinuance
pursuant to section 3026, except that this status is at all times subject to
an affirmative vote of the legislative body of the municipality within
which the way lies making that way an easement for recreational use.
A presumption of abandonment is not rebutted by evidence that shows
isolated acts of maintenance, unless other evidence exists that shows a
clear intent by the municipality or county to consider or use the way as -
if it were a public way.
23 M.R.S.A. § 3028.
Mr. Plummer has argued that, on at least three occasions during the thirty-
year period preceding the filing of this action, the Town paid for work done on the
disputed section. The earliest work occurred in either 1970 or 1971. At that time,
Malcolm Giles graded the road once at the request of the former Road
Commissioner, Charlie Roberts. Mr. Giles testified that the grading was not done at
the behest of the Selectmen, but was done to appease what was then a privately-
operated Fire Company. At about the same time, Mr. Giles installed culverts to
prevent the road from washing out just beyond what is now known as the Town
turnaround.* Again, Mr. Giles asserted that the work was done only to allow
firefighting equipment to have access to the land that was eventually known as the
34
Schmid Preserve’*. He testified that the Selectmen were concerned that doing any
2 The second page of joint exhibit 25 is the 1979 report from then-Road _
Commissioner Jack L. Tenney. In that report he noted that: "Several culverts were
replaced, Old County, Mt. Hunger and the Shore Road... . The Mt. Hunger Road
from the River Road to the Old County Road is now passable for four wheel drive
vehicles due to extensive clearing and brush cutting. Additional work is till
required on this road." Mr. Giles was unable to recall where the culvert work on the
Old Country Road had occurred, but he was certain that no work had been done on
the disputed portion since 1970 or 1971. .
3 Before 1979, much of the land in this general area was owned by Charles
and Constance Schmid. On July 12, 1979, they signed a Declaration of Intent,
“AD
5
work on the road would improve access to the Schmid woods, and access was
something they wanted to limit. They believed public access would lead to
vandalism, fire, or other damage to the property. For safety purposes, the Fire
Company wanted access to a large, undeveloped area of land that had previously
been the site of a large fire.
The third episode of maintenance or repair occurred in 1992. During the
spring of that year, the Fire Department arranged to have the Maine National Guard
construct a new parking lot at its headquarters on Route 27. While the work was
progressing, the Guard members camped in the Schmid Preserve. At the end of
their stay, the Guard also replaced a culvert on the disputed section of road. . It is not
‘clear whether this work was done to "repair" damage done by the Guard's heavy
equipment, or whether this was done at’ the behest of the Fire Department in
another attempt to improve its access to the land along the Old County Road. In any
event, the cost of the materials used in that repair was paid for by the Schmid
Preserve Committee.
Because no Town funds were spent on the repairs done by the Maine
essentially offering the land to the Town as a nature preserve. Their offer was
accepted by the Town during its general meeting in March 1980. In May 1980, the
Town voted to create the Charles O. Schmid Preserve Fund and, in March 2000, it
adopted the Management Plan for the Preserve.
6
National Guard, the court finds that the 1992 repairs were not done at "the expense
of the municipality ...." That work, therefore, does not act as an impediment to the
Town's assertion that the road is abandoned.
That leaves the work done in 1970 or 1971 by the Town's road crew. The
Town argued that, although the work was done at its expense, it should not be
deemed work done to keep the way "passable for the use of motor vehicles.” While
it acknowledged that the work was done to allow access for "vehicles," the Town
argued that its only concern was access for firefighting vehicles. Public safety, rather
than access for general motor traffic, was the motivation behind this work.
In Town of South Berwick v. White, 412 A.2d 1225 (Me. 1980 ) the referee who
heard the case held that, in order for the Town to establish a prima facie case of
abandonment, it would have to establish that no municipal funds could be
expended to keep the road passable during the thirty-year period. The Law Court
did not specifically adopt that holding by the trial court, but it did hold that
"passable" was a relatively low standard: .
Although section 3028 undoubtedly refers to more than de minimis
"public expense," we emphatically reject the notion that the public
could lose its rights to continuation of a public way by a town's
defaulting on its obligation to maintain a road to a full "safe and
convenient standard." By its plain terms section 3028 prevents the
presumption of abandonment from arising if the town way is kept at
public expense at least "passable for the use of motor vehicles,"
whether or not it also meets the higher test of being "safe and
convenient for travelers with motor vehicles."
Id., at 1227.
Plummer has used the photographs admitted by agreement to demonstrate
7
that the road is "passable." However, passability is not really the issue. The issue is
whether the Town expended its funds to make or keep it that way.
In Earwood v. Town of York, supra, the Law Court held that the grading of a
road two or three times per year between 1960 and 1977, when added to a one-time
application of gravel, should have precluded the trial court from finding that the
Town had not expended funds to keep the road passable for thirty consecutive years.
Id., at 868. If it is possible to determine a mathematical formula from that decision,
then perhaps thirty-six to fifty-two episodes of maintenance are more than a de
minimis expense. However, no mathematical formula exists, and the court must
consider not only the expense of the work done, but also its purpose. In Earwood,
supra, the work was done to keep the road passable for regular, seasonal traffic. The
same observation does not fit the facts of this case.
Based upon the evidence submitted, the court finds that the expenditures
made in 1970 or 1971 were de minimis efforts to keep the road open for emergency
vehicles; there was no work done to make the road "passable for the use of motor ~
vehicles." The Town has presented a prima facie case of abandonment.
B. Plaintiff's Rebuttal
The “isolated acts of maintenance" listed above could rebut the presumption
of abandonment if the evidence showed a clear intent by the municipality or the
public to consider or use the way as if it were a public way. The evidence, however,
does not show such intent. All of the evidence from defendant's witnesses, as well
8
as the minutes of the Selectmen's Meetings demonstrates exactly the opposite. The
municipality clearly intended to abandon this road, and was careful to ensure that ©
there were no missteps.
Although the Old County Road did historically provide access to the Schmid
Preserve, the long-term plan adopted this spring calls for an end to almost all |
vehicular traffic. That plan, adopted by the residents at the Town Meeting,
recognized the abandoned status of the roads that had, in the past, provided
vehicular access. Its recommendation for the future called for the construction of a
parking area near the Town turnaround on the Old County Road. At least in their
adoption of this Plan, the Town and its residents did not foresee any further
vehicular use of the disputed portion of the Old County Road.
While the photographs presented by the plaintiff do demonstrate that at least
some members of the public make drive their vehicles along the disputed area and
into the Preserve, that isolated use is not sufficient to demonstrate any intent by the
municipality or by the public to consider or use the disputed section of the Old
County Road as a public way. The plaintiff has failed to rebut the presumption of
abandonment.
C. Conclusion
After review of all of the evidence, and after consideration of the arguments,
the court is convinced that the Town of Edgecomb abandoned the Old County Road
east of the Town turnaround at Paine's Corner.
> ORDER
Based upon the evidence presented, the court finds that the portion of the Old
County Road between lots 83 and 84, Map R-2 of the Town of Edgecomb's tax maps
is determined to be abandoned.
The Clerk is directed to incorporate this order -by reference in the docket for
this case.
Dated: October 26, 2000
Pltff: (622-3693) Def: (882-9446)
Clifford H. Goodall, Esquire Eliot Field, Esquire