Opinion

Kelly v. Bell

Court
District Court, M.D. Pennsylvania
Filed
Dec 13, 2024
Cited by
0 cases
Authority
More cited than 33.3%

“Takings claims against local governments should be handled the same as other claims under the Bill of Rights.”

How later courts described this case

  • “Takings claims against local governments should be handled the same as other claims under the Bill of Rights.”

Written by the judges who cited it.

The opinion

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE MIDDLE DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA

FARRAH KELLY, : No. 4:22cv1940

Plaintiff :

: (Judge Munley)

Vv. :

JOSHUA BELL, JUSTIN SNYDER, :

and CITY OF WILLIAMSPORT, :

Defendants :

and :

CHRISTOPHER SALISBURY and :

CITY OF WILLIAMSPORT, :

Consolidated Defendants :

SEEM MORA DUM

Before the court is a motion to dismiss filed by Defendants Christopher

Salisbury and City of Williamsport in this action brought pursuant to 42 U.S.C. §

1983 (“Section 1983”).

Background

On April 5, 2022, the Williamsport Bureau of Police obtained a warrant to

search Plaintiff Farrah Kelly’s vehicle.! (Doc. 35, Compl. J 8). Defendant

Salisbury signed the warrant application as the affiant. (Id. Ex. A, ECIF p. 13).

These brief background facts are derived from plaintiffs amended complaint and the exhibits

attached thereto. At this stage of the proceedings, the court must accept all factual allegations

in the amended complaint as true. Phillips v. Cnty. of Allegheny, 515 F.3d 224, 233 (3d Cir.

2008). The court makes no determination, however, as to the ultimate veracity of these

assertions.

Per the application, the Williamsport police were investigating an incident

involving two other individuals, identified as Beyah and Durrant, which occurred

on April 3, 2022. @ (Id.) Salisbury indicated that Beyah operated Kelly’s vehicle ir

relation to the incident. (Id.) The police department sought evidence “consistent

with evidence on scene,” specifically 9mm firearms, ammunition, and certain

clothing worn by the other individuals. (Id.) After Judge Butts from the Lycoming

County Court of Common Pleas authorized the search warrant, the Williamsport

police department seized Kelly’s vehicle. (Id. J 8 & Ex. A).

The next day, April 6, 2022, Kelly contacted the police department. (Id. J]

14). She spoke to Defendant Joshua Bell. (Id.) Kelly met with an unknown

officer at the police station that same day. (Id. J 15). Kelly provided the officer

with keys to the vehicle. (Id.) The police then searched Kelly’s car pursuant to

the warrant on April 7, 2022 at 8:00 AM. (Id. □□ 35). No items were found, and no

property was seized as the result of the search. (Id. J 36).

Kelly then encountered difficulties recovering her vehicle. She called the

police department frequently, leaving messages for Defendant Salisbury,

Defendant Bell, and Defendant Justin Snyder, Williamsport’s police chief. (Id. J

16). She also contacted the mayor's office. (Id.)

2 The search warrant application references an affidavit of probable cause. (Doc. 35, Ex. A).

The affidavit of probable cause is not attached to the search warrant application as filed with

the complaint.

After the Kelly spoke to an individual at the mayor's office, Defendant Bell

contacted the plaintiff. (Id. J 18). Defendant Bell, however, refused to provide

information to Kelly about her vehicle and stated that he was getting additional

search warrants. (Id. J 19). Although Defendant Bell made that statement to the

plaintiff, Defendant Salisbury, the investigating officer, did not apply for any

further warrants. (Id. J] 21).

Kelly continued to leave messages for Defendant Bell and Defendant

Snyder regarding the return of her vehicle. (Id. □ 22). She called the mayor's

office a second time. (Id. □ 23). She called the Lycoming County District

Attorney’s office. (Id. J 24). When her repeated calls went unanswered, she

sought the assistance of counsel. (Id. {J 25).

On May 9, 2022, counsel sent correspondence to Chief Snyder at the

police administration office by hand delivery. (Id. ] 26). Counsel advised that, if

the police did not return Kelly’s vehicle by May 11, 2022, a motion would be filed

in state court for its return. (Id., Ex. B, ECF p. 15). No one from police

administration contacted Kelly or Kelly’s counsel. (Id. 27). Kelly's counsel filed

the motion, and the Lycoming County Court of Common Pleas scheduled a

hearing for June 6, 2022. (Id. J] 28-30; see also Ex. C, ECF pp. 17-20). But,

four days before the hearing, on June 2, 2022, Kelly’s vehicle was returned

without explanation. (id. J 31). To date, Kelly has not been compensated for the

time her vehicle stayed in police control after the expiration of the search warrant

(Id. 7 41). The state trial court denied Kelly’s attempt to recoup attorneys’ fees

and costs through the motion for return of property. (Id., Ex. C).

Kelly initially filed a Section 1983 action against Defendants Bell, Snyder,

and the City of Williamsport in December 2022. The Honorable Chief Judge

Matthew W. Brann denied a previous motion to dismiss filed by those

defendants. Kelly v. Bell, No. 4:22-CV-01940, 2023 WL 3161643 (M.D. Pa. Apr.

28, 2023). During discovery, Kelly learned that the police department has

adopted, in practice, “a policy of complete deference to the officer who has

seized a car pursuant to a warrant and permits the officer in his sole discretion to

make all decisions related to retention and return of the car to its owner.” (Id. J

33). Defendant Salisbury oversaw the investigation. (id. J] 8, 20, 34 & Ex. A).

Per Kelly, Defendant Salisbury “independently decided, in accordance with the

established practice of the Defendant City of Williamsport, that he would continue

to deprive [her] of the possession of her car, simply because in his sole judgment

he was not done with the car.” (id. J] 38).

Kelly filed a second action against Defendant Salisbury and the City of

Williamsport in Apri! 2024. Her complaint asserts three claims against these

defendants as follows: Count 1, a Section 1983 claim against Defendant

Salisbury for violation of her Fifth Amendment rights; Count 1I, a municipal liability

claim against the City of Williamsport premised upon its lack of policies and/or

training resulting in the practice of allowing investigating officers sole discretion t

keep possession of a vehicle after a search warrant has been executed and has

expired; and Count Ill, a Section 1983 claim against the City of Williamsport

seeking just compensation for the temporary taking of her property as provided

by the Fifth Amendment.

On June 11, 2024, Defendant Salisbury and Defendant City of Williamspor

filed the instant motion to dismiss.* (Doc. 28). Having been fully briefed, this

matter is ripe for disposition.

Jurisdiction

Based on the alleged violations of Section 1983, this court has jurisdiction

pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1331. (“The district courts shall have original jurisdiction

of all civil actions arising under the Constitution, laws, or treaties of the United

States.”).

Legal Standard

Defendants filed the instant motion to dismiss pursuant to Federal Rule of

Civil Procedure 12(b)(6) for failure to state a claim upon which relief can be

3 By order dated June 13, 2024, the court granted defendants’ unopposed motion to

consolidate the two related lawsuits. (Doc. 27).

granted. The court tests the sufficiency of the complaint’s allegations when

considering a Rule 12(b)(6) motion.

To survive a motion to dismiss, “a complaint must provide “a short and

plain statement of the claim showing that the pleader is entitled to relief.” Doe v.

Princeton Univ., 30 F.4th 335, 341-42 (3d Cir. 2022)(quoting FED. R. Clv. P.

8(a)(2)). That means, a complaint must contain sufficient factual matter,

accepted as true, to state a claim to relief that is plausible on its face. Ashcroft v.

Igbal, 556 U.S. 662, 678 (2009) (citing Bell Atl. Corp. v. Twombly, 550 U.S. 544,

570 (2007)). Aclaim has facial plausibility when factual content is pled that

allows the court to draw the reasonable inference that the defendant is liable for

the misconduct alleged. Id. (citing Twombly, 550 U.S. at 570). “Threadbare

recitals of the elements of a cause of action, supported by mere conclusory

statements, do not suffice.” Id. (citing Twombly, 550 U.S. at 555).

On a motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim, district courts accept all

factual allegations as true, construe the complaint in the light most favorable to

the plaintiff, and determine whether, under any reasonable reading of the

complaint, the plaintiff may be entitled to relief. See Phillips, 515 F.3d at 233

(citations omitted).

Analysis

Defendants move to dismiss each cause of action. Defendant Salisbury

argues that he is entitled to qualified immunity on the Section 1983 claim raised

against him. The City of Williamsport asserts that the complaint fails to state

sufficient facts to proceed with a municipal liability claim. The city also argues

that plaintiff has not stated a cognizable claim for violation of her Fifth

Amendment rights from the two-month period she was deprived of her vehicle.

The court will address these issues in turn.

1. Qualified Immunity

Defendant Salisbury asserts that he is entitled to qualified immunity in this

action. The doctrine of qualified immunity shields government officials

performing discretionary functions from liability for civil damages “insofar as their

conduct does not violate clearly established statutory or constitutional rights of

which a reasonable person would have known.” Harlow v. Fitzgerald, 457 U.S.

800, 818 (1982). The doctrine “protects ‘all but the plainly incompetent or those

who knowingly violate the law.’ ” Mullenix v. Luna, 577 U.S. 7, 12 (2015) (quoting

Malley v. Briggs, 475 U.S. 335, 341 (1986)).

The two-part test to determine whether government officials should receive

qualified immunity is well settled. Montemuro v. Jim Thorpe Area Sch. Dist., 99

F.4th 639, 642 (3d Cir. 2024) (citing Anglemeyer v. Ammons, 92 F.4th 184, 188

(3d Cir. 2024)). Under the first prong of the qualified immunity analysis, a court

must decide whether the facts that plaintiff has alleged make out a violation of a

constitutional right. Pearson v. Callahan, 555 U.S. 223, 232 (2009)(citation

omitted). Under the second prong, “the court must decide whether the right at

issue was ‘clearly established’ at the time of defendant's alleged misconduct.” Id.

(citation omitted). To be clearly established, “[t]he contours of the right must be

sufficiently clear that a reasonable official would understand that what he is doing

violates that right.” Anderson v. Creighton, 483 U.S. 635, 640 (1987). In

considering qualified immunity, the court may address the prongs of this test in

any order. See Pearson, 555 U.S. at 242. The defendant bears the burden of

establishing that he is entitled to qualified immunity. Burns v. PA Dep't of Corr.,

642 F.3d 163, 176 (3d Cir. 2011)(citing Harlow, 457 U.S. at 819).

Judge Brann previously addressed this issue when Defendants Bell and

Snyder asserted qualified immunity in the prior motion to dismiss. Kelly, 2023

WL 3161643, at *4, n. 54. Per the earlier decision arising from the same set of

operative alleged facts, Judge Brann concluded that the officers’ alleged actions

“violated Kelly's rights secured by the Fifth Amendment and that the unlawfulnes

of their conduct was clearly established at the time it occurred.” Id. (citing Frein v

Pennsylvania State Police, 47 F.4th 247, 251-53 (3d Cir. 2022)). He rejected the

argument that Bell and Snyder are entitled to qualified immunity. Id.

At this juncture, the court will not address Defendant Salisbury’s qualified

immunity. The officers subject to Judge Brann’s earlier ruling, Defendants Bell

and Snyder, are alleged to be a police captain and the chief of police,

respectively. Defendant Salisbury, the investigating officer and search warrant

affiant, was presumably under the command of Bell and Snyder. Defendants

Bell and Salisbury were already deposed following disposition of the earlier

motion to dismiss, and their counsel lodged no objection to the deposition of

Defendant Snyder during a discovery dispute contemporaneous to the filing of

the new action. (Doc. 22, Defs. Mot. for Prot. Order 3, 6-7). Defendants also

indicate that discovery is complete and that they intend to file a motion for

summary judgment once their motion to dismiss is resolved and the pleadings

are closed. (Docs. 31, 33).

Under the law, a defendant pleading qualified immunity is entitled to

dismissal before the commencement of discovery unless the plaintiff's allegation

state a claim for violation of clearly established law. Mitchell v. Forsyth, 472 U.S.

511, 526 (1985)(citing Harlow, 457 U.S. at 817). Put more simply, “liberal

discovery rules are at odds with the doctrine of qualified immunity[.]” Graber v.

Dales, 511 F. Supp. 3d 594, 599 (E.D. Pa. 2021). “And qualified immunity may

be implicitly denied when a government official otherwise entitled to immunity is

nonetheless subjected to ‘the burdens of such pretrial matters as discovery.’ ”

Oliver v. Roquet, 858 F.3d 180, 188 (3d Cir. 2017) (quoting Behrens VY. Pelletier,

516 U.S. 299, 308 (1996)).

Here, under some peculiar procedural circumstances, Defendant Salisbury

has already been subjected to pretrial discovery burdens. On a motion to

dismiss, the evidence obtained from that discovery is not in full view. For

example, the complaint contains Defendant Salisbury’s search warrant

application, but it does not contain his affidavit of probable cause to support that

application. (See Doc. 35, Ex. A). The limited details in that warrant application

suggest that Kelly’s vehicle was involved in some type of incident in Williamsport

where 9mm firearms were discharged. (Id.) Details into the investigation of that

incident are crucial in evaluating the prongs of the qualified immunity test. See

United States v. Chambers, 192 F.3d 374, 376 (3d Cir. 1999)(citations

omitted)(“It is well settled that the government is permitted to seize evidence for

use in investigation and trial, but that such property must be returned once

criminal proceedings have concluded, unless it is contraband or subject to

forfeiture.”). The court will thus preserve the issue and defer ruling on Defendan

Salisbury’s qualified immunity arguments until the time of summary judgment.

2. Kelly’s Claims Against the City of Williamsport

Kelly asserts two claims against the City of Williamsport. Count II

advances a Section 1983 claim premised upon Monell v. Dep't of Soc. Servs. of

10

City of New York, 436 U.S. 658, 694 (1978) for the city’s alleged violation of her

Fifth Amendment rights. While Count III also asserts a violation of Section 1983,

Kelly alleges that the city directly violated the Fifth Amendment's Takings Clause

by temporarily taking her vehicle for public use without paying her for it.

a. Kelly’s Monell Claim

Count II of Kelly’s complaint asserts a Monell claim against the City of

Williamsport. A local government may not be sued under Section 1983 for an

injury inflicted solely by its employees or agents. Monell, 436 U.S. at 694.

Rather, liability extends when injuries are inflicted by “execution of a

government's policy or custom, whether made by its lawmakers or by those

whose edicts or acts may fairly be said to represent official policy[.]” Id.

The city asserts that Kelly failed to plead sufficient facts to state a Monell

claim, that is, she failed to identify a municipal policy or custom that was the

basis of her alleged constitutional deprivation. Kelly counters that she has

asserted a viable claim premised on a lack of written policies relative to vehicle

returns after the expiration of a search warrant. (See Doc. 30, Pl. Br. in Opp. at

12). In that void, per Kelly, the City of Williamsport has adarted a custom or

practice of deferring to the investigating officer as to the length of time to keep

the vehicle, even after the search warrant has been executed, regardless of

whether items have been found. (See Doc. 35, Compl. Jf] 47-52). Moreover,

11

according to the plaintiff, the City of Williamsport did not train its officers

regarding any obligation to return a vehicle after a search warrant was executed,

which caused Kelly’s Fifth Amendment rights to be violated. (Id. ff] 52-53).

Kelly has thus pled a policy or custom of deference to investigating officers

and a failure to train officers about citizens’ personal property rights in the vehicle

search and seizure context, which led to a violation of her rights by Defendant

Salisbury. “Failure to adopt a policy” Monell claims require a showing that the

injuries were caused by inaction that manifests a deliberate indifference like the

showing required in the failure-to-train context. See Semerod v. Siko, No. 4:24-

CV-1165, 2024 WL 4374973, at *3 & n. 37 (M.D. Pa. Oct. 2, 2024)(Brann,

J.)(citing Forrest v. Parry, 930 F.3d 93, 105—06 (3d Cir. 2019)(additional citations

omitted).

“In limited circumstances, a local government's decision not to train certain

employees about their legal duty to avoid violating citizens’ rights may rise to the

level of an official government policy for purposes of § 1983.” Connick v.

Thompson, 563 U.S. 51, 61 (2011). To satisfy Section 1983, a municipality's

failure to train its police officers must amount “to deliberate indiffererice to the

rights of persons with whom the police come into contact.” City of Cantor, Ohio

v. Harris, 489 U.S. 378, 388 (1989)(footnote omitted).

12

“A plaintiff sufficiently pleads deliberate indifference by showing that ‘(1)

municipal policy makers know that employees will confront a particular situation,

(2) the situation involves a difficult choice or a history of employees mishandling,

and (3) the wrong choice by an employee will frequently cause deprivation of

constitutional rights.’ ” Est. of Roman v. City of Newark, 914 F.3d 789, 798 (3d

Cir. 2019)(brackets omitted)(quoting Doe v. Luzerne Cnty., 660 F.3d 169, 180

(3d Cir. 2011); Carter v. City of Phila., 181 F.3d 339, 357 (3d Cir. 1999)).

“Establishing municipal liability on a failure to train claim under § 1983 is

difficult.” Reitz v. Cnty. of Bucks, 125 F.3d 139, 145 (3d Cir. 1997). A pattern of

similar constitutional violations by untrained employees is ordinarily necessary to

demonstrate deliberate indifference. Connick, 563 U.S. at 62 (citing Board of

Comm'rs of Bryan Cnty. v. Brown, 520 U.S. 397, 403 (1997)). However, “‘ina

narrow range of circumstances,’ a pattern of similar violations might not be

necessary to show deliberate indifference.” Id. (quoting Bryan Cnty., 520 U.S. at

409). “[A] single violation of federal rights, accompanied by a showing that a

municipality has failed to train its employees to handle recurring situations

presenting an obvious potential for such a violation, could trigger municipal

liability.” Bryan Cnty., 520 U.S. at 409 (citing City of Canton, 489 US. at 390 & n.

10).

13

Kelly does not allege that this is a single incident situation. Rather, she has

alleged that the City of Williamsport received complaints related to the failure of

its police department to return vehicles after the expiration of search warrants.

(No. 4:24cv608, Doc. 1, Compl. J] 47). Accordingly, for the purposes of a

motion to dismiss, plaintiff has made a sufficient allegation regarding a pattern of

alleged constitutional violations. Defendants’ motion to dismiss Count !I will thus

be denied.

b. Kelly’s Takings Clause Claim

Count Ill of Kelly’s complaint asserts a separate cause of action premised

upon the Takings Clause of the Fifth Amendment. That provision “states that

‘private property [shall not] be taken for public use, without just compensation.’ ”

Knick v. Twp. of Scott, Pa., 588 U.S. 180, 184 (2019).

The parties dispute the legal framework as to how such claims proceed

against a municipality. Defendants assert that “in order to establish liability unde

the Fifth Amendment against the [c]ity, [p]laintiff would have to establish or set

forth [what] was required in Monell[.]” (Doc. 29, Defs. Br. in Supp. at 7). Kelly

counters that liability against the city under the Takings Clause exists

independently: “Count Ill is not a Monell claim, it is a claim against a local

4 Kelly has offered no other facts about these complaints other than those related to her own

case. At summary judgment, Kelly’s allegations must be supported by the evidence.

14

government seeking compensation for a ‘taking’ without just compensation.”

(Doc. 30, PI. Br. in Opp. at 10).

In Knick, the United States Supreme Court concluded that “a government

violates the Takings Clause when it takes property without compensation, and

that a property owner may bring a Fifth Amendment claim under § 1983 at that

time.” 588 U.S. at 202. In the same paragraph, the majority stated, “Takings

claims against local governments should be handled the same as other claims

under the Bill of Rights.” Id. These references indicate that Kelly's path forward

against the City of Williamsport goes through Section 1983 and Monell.

But the Knick Court also discussed the “self-executing” character of the

Takings Clause “with respect to compensation,” that is, “a property owner has a

constitutional claim for just compensation at the time of the taking.” 588 U.S. at

192 (citing First Eng. Evangelical Lutheran Church of Glendale v. Los Angeles

Cnty., Cal., 482 U.S. 304, 316 (1987)(“First English”)). Moreover, as stated in

First English, claims for just compensation are grounded in the Constitution itself.

482 U.S. at 315 (discussing Jacobs v. United States, 290 U.S. 13, 16 (1933)).

Some district courts have read Knick, First English, and Jacobs to mean that a

Takings Clause claim is not dependent on the Section 1983 cause of action and

that a plaintiff need not establish the requirements for municipal liability under

Monell. See Baker v. City of McKinney, Tex, 601 F. Supp. 3d 124, 146 (E.D. Tex

15

2022), rev'd and remanded on other grounds, 84 F.4th 378 (5th Cir. 2023), pet.

for cert. denied, No. 23-1363, 2024 WL 4874818 (U.S. Nov. 25, 2024).

Similarly, the petitioners in DeVillier v. Texas asserted that “the just-

compensation requirement of the Takings Clause is self-executing and that

statutory recognition is not necessary for takings claims because they are

grounded in the Constitution itself.” 601 U.S. 285, 291 (2024)(citing First English,

482 U.S. at 315)(brackets omitted). After the Fifth Circuit disagreed with that

theory, the Supreme Court granted certiorari “to decide whether a property owne'

may sue for just compensation directly under the Takings Clause.” Id. at 290.

The Supreme Court, however, did not answer that question. See Vargo v.

Casey, No. 20-CV-1109-JDP, --- F. Supp. 3d ----, 2024 WL 4794692, at *8—*9

(W.D. Wis. Nov. 14, 2024)(Peterson, J.)(discussing DeViliier, 601 U.S. at 288—

90, 292). Rather, Justice Thomas, writing for a unanimous Court, focused on

whether the petitioners had an already-existing cause of action under state law tc

proceed with their Takings Clause claim. DeVillier, 601 U.S. at 292-93. They

did. Id. at 293. The state defendant, Texas, also agreed at oral argument that it

would not oppose the petitioners’ request to amend their complaint to assert that

state law cause of action. Id. So, the decision of the Fifth Circuit was vacated,

and the case was remanded for that state law claim to be asserted. Id.

16

DeVillier, like the Supreme Court’s other precedents, “[did] not cleanly

answer the question [of] whether a plaintiff has a cause of action arising directly

under the Takings Clause.” Id. at 292—93. But it did make clear that

“constitutional rights are generally invoked defensively in cases arising under

other sources of law, or asserted offensively pursuant to an independent cause

of action designed for that purpose.” Id. at 291 (citing 42 U.S.C. § 1983).

Kelly already has an independent cause of action designed to remedy the

City of Williamsport’s alleged violations of her Takings Clause rights, Section

1983. Indeed, her Takings Clause claim in Count III explicitly relies upon Sectior

1983 in the heading of that cause of action.

As for whether a Takings Clause claim under Section 1983 needs to

comport with Monell and its progeny, the contours of a Section 1983 claim

against a municipality are well-settled. Absent further guidance from the Third

Circuit Court of Appeals and the United States Supreme Court, Kelly must set

forth a plausible municipal liability claim to proceed pursuant to that statute for

alleged Takings Clause violations. See Knick, 588 U.S. at 202 (“Takings claims

against local governments should be handled the same as other claims under the

Bill of Rights.”). The court concludes above that she has in Count II.

Nonetheless, Count III is redundant to Count II and will be dismissed as such.

17

Conclusion

For the reasons set forth above, defendants’ motion to dismiss will be

granted in part and denied in part. Defendants’ motion is granted as to Count Ill.

Otherwise, the motion is denied with the issue of Defendant Salisbury’s qualified

immunity preserved for summary judgment. An appropriate order follows.

Date: ay (VW ——

J JULIA KAMUNLEY

U States

18

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.