Opinion

Daniel Walker and Kristen Walker v. Baptist St. Anthony's Hospital and Rhodesia Castillo, M.D.

Court
Texas Supreme Court
Filed
Dec 13, 2024
Status
Published
Cited by
0 cases
Authority
More cited than 33.3%

explaining that “[Rule 47.1] is mandatory, and the courts of appeals are not at liberty to disregard it”

How later courts described this case

  • explaining that “[Rule 47.1] is mandatory, and the courts of appeals are not at liberty to disregard it”
  • construing briefs reasonably and liberally to avoid the loss of a party’s rights
  • explaining that “expert qualifications should not be too narrowly drawn”
  • “[Section 13] is, quite plainly, a due process guarantee.”

Written by the judges who cited it.

The opinion

Supreme Court of Texas

══════════

No. 23-0010

══════════

Daniel Walker and Kristen Walker,

Petitioners,

v.

Baptist St. Anthony’s Hospital and Rhodesia Castillo, M.D.,

Respondents

═══════════════════════════════════════

On Petition for Review from the

Court of Appeals for the Seventh District of Texas

═══════════════════════════════════════

JUSTICE BLAND, joined by JUSTICE BOYD, concurring.

Honoring our Constitution’s promise of open courts and an

opportunity to be heard, we endeavor to consider every appeal on its

merits. TEX. CONST. art. I § 13; see Sax v. Votteler, 648 S.W.2d 661, 664

(Tex. 1983) (“[Section 13] is, quite plainly, a due process guarantee.”).

We construe briefs liberally, disdain immaterial briefing waiver, and

elevate justice over procedural deficiencies of many stripes. 1 For that

1 E.g., Horton v. Stovall, 591 S.W.3d 567, 570 (Tex. 2019) (“The interests

of justice and fair play demand that cases be decided on the merits when

technical deficiencies in appellate briefs ‘can be easily corrected.’” (quoting Silk

v. Terrill, 898 S.W.2d 764, 766 (Tex. 1995))); Willis v. Donnelly, 199 S.W.3d

reason, when error exists in the reasoning of the court of appeals, a

respondent is entitled to resolution of dispositive unaddressed issues,

either by our Court or on remand. Stanglin v. Keda Dev. Corp., 713

S.W.2d 94, 95 (Tex. 1986), op. on reh’g. “We have the option of

‘(1) examining the points not considered by the court of appeals in order

to determine whether any will support affirmance of that court’s

judgment, or (2) remanding the cause to the court of appeals for it to

pass on those points.’” Id. (quoting Roark v. Allen, 633 S.W.2d 804, 811

(Tex. 1982)).

There is no third way, such as the path the Court takes in this

case: the rejection of two never-considered appellate challenges with no

more explanation than it need not do so “in the interest of judicial

economy.” Cf. Indus. Specialists, LLC v. Blanchard Refin. Co. LLC, 652

S.W.3d 11, 23 (Tex. 2022) (Busby, J., dissenting) (“For many years, this

Court has demonstrated its commitment to the efficient administration

of justice, transparency, and a substance-over-form approach to

procedure. Regrettably, the plurality and concurrence sound a retreat

on all these fronts today, allowing courts of appeals to avoid hearing

permissive appeals at their pleasure and with no explanation so long as

their standard-form denials recite the following pass-phrase: ‘the

petition fails to establish each requirement.’”).

Judicial economy is meaningful; inefficient justice is hardly

justice at all. In reading the Court’s opinion, however, the respondents

262, 270 (Tex. 2006) (“[A] party should not lose its right to appeal based on an

unduly technical application of procedural rules.”); Weeks Marine, Inc. v.

Garza, 371 S.W.3d 157, 162 (Tex. 2012) (construing briefs reasonably and

liberally to avoid the loss of a party’s rights).

2

have no assurance that their unconsidered issues—those the court of

appeals did not reach—were afforded any application of the law to the

facts. Such an omission occludes the transparency of our legal system

and disappoints the reasonable expectations of parties seeking redress.

See id. at 28 (citing In re Columbia Med. Ctr. of Las Colinas, Subsidiary,

L.P., 290 S.W.3d 204, 213 (Tex. 2009)).

We may decide how judicial economy is best served. RSL

Funding, LLC v. Newsome, 569 S.W.3d 116, 124 (Tex. 2018) (“When

presented with an issue the court of appeals could have but did not

decide, we may either remand the case or consider the issue ourselves.”).

When the remaining issues are fully briefed and straightforward, as the

issues in this case are, we often address them in the first instance. 2 But

2 See, e.g., Baty v. Futrell, 543 S.W.3d 689, 697 (Tex. 2018) (“Although

the court of appeals did not address the report’s sufficiency as to breach and

causation, the parties argued those issues here, and we will address them in

the interest of judicial economy.”); Pedernal Energy, LLC v. Bruington Eng’g,

Ltd., 536 S.W.3d 487, 495 (Tex. 2017) (“The parties have briefed and argued

the issue here, so in the interest of judicial economy we will address it rather

than remanding to the court of appeals.”); Rusk State Hosp. v. Black, 392

S.W.3d 88, 97 (Tex. 2012) (“The court of appeals did not address the Hospital’s

claim of immunity. Rather than remanding the case to the court of appeals for

it to do so, however, we address the issue in the interest of judicial economy.”).

The Court cites inapposite cases in which the underlying courts of appeal had

discretionary review or decided the issue on the merits, and we held that

decision to contain no reversible error. See Indus. Specialists, 652 S.W.3d at

19 (Tex. 2022) (plurality opinion of Boyd, J.) (“The opinion addressed the only

issue raised and necessary to final disposition of the [permissive] appeal, as

rule 47.1 requires, and advised the parties of the court’s decision to refuse the

appeal and the basic reasons for it, as rule 47.4 requires.”) (internal quotations

and original brackets omitted); Virlar v. Puente, 664 S.W.3d 53, 66 (Tex. 2023)

(declining to discuss an issue further when “the court of appeals thoroughly

reviewed” it); Columbia Valley Healthcare Sys., L.P. v. A.M.A. ex rel. Ramirez,

654 S.W.3d 135, 141 n.3 (Tex. 2022) (the court of appeals’ reasoning presented

3

when we elect not to do so, the proper course is to remand the remaining

issues to the court of appeals, which must hand down a written opinion

that addresses any issue raised and necessary to a final disposition.

TEX. R. APP. P. 47.1; see also West v. Robinson, 180 S.W.3d 575, 577 (Tex.

2005) (explaining that “[Rule 47.1] is mandatory, and the courts of

appeals are not at liberty to disregard it”).

I join the court’s opinion regarding causation. I write separately

to address the two issues the court of appeals did not reach, because this

Court neither remands these issues nor addresses them in its opinion.

In addition to the causation challenge that the court of appeals

sustained, the health care respondents present two issues the court of

appeals never reached: (1) the proffering physicians are not qualified to

offer the opinions at the heart of this appeal; and (2) the reports fail to

adequately explain the applicable standard of care and breach for the

hospital nurses. TEX. R. APP. P. 53.4 (a party may request that the Court

consider issues unaddressed in the court of appeals’ opinion). Because

these alternative bases for affirming the court of appeals’ judgment also

lack merit, I concur in the Court’s judgment.

I

The health care respondents urge that Drs. Tappan and Null are

not qualified to proffer opinions on causation sufficient to comply with

no reversible error and further discussion would be unimportant to the

jurisprudence of the State); Regent Care of San Antonio, L.P. v. Detrick, 610

S.W.3d 830, 839 (Tex. 2020) (same). In contrast to these cases, no appellate

court has addressed two issues necessary to the disposition of this appeal.

Proper stewardship of scarce judicial resources cannot be to withhold them

entirely.

4

Chapter 74 of the Civil Practice and Remedies Code. TEX. CIV. PRAC. &

REM. CODE § 74.351(a). Our precedent on witness qualification is

spartan and easily understood. See Broders v. Heise, 924 S.W.2d 148

(Tex. 1996). Chapter 74 imports its expert criteria from the Texas Rules

of Evidence. TEX. CIV. PRAC. & REM. CODE. § 74.351(r)(5)(C). The

relevant rule provides:

A witness who is qualified as an expert by knowledge, skill,

experience, training, or education may testify in the form

of an opinion or otherwise if the expert’s scientific,

technical, or other specialized knowledge will help the trier

of fact to understand the evidence or to determine a fact in

issue.

TEX. R. EVID. 702.

Not every medical doctor is qualified to testify on every medical

issue. Broders, 924 S.W.2d at 152. The offering party must establish

that the witness has “knowledge, skill, experience, training, or

education” pertaining to the specific issue before the court “which would

qualify the expert to give an opinion on that particular subject.” Id. at

153. However, the inquiry is not myopic. See Larson v. Downing, 197

S.W.3d 303, 305 (Tex. 2006) (explaining that “expert qualifications

should not be too narrowly drawn”).

Relevant here, testimony on the cause of an injury to the brain is

not categorically restricted to neurosurgeons. Broders, 924 S.W.2d at

153. Rather, a trial court must examine whether the witness has

sufficient expertise through education, training, and experience such

that the witness’s opinion in the relevant subject area rises “above mere

speculation to offer genuine assistance to the jury.” Id.

5

Ample evidence supports the trial court’s determination that Dr.

Tappan possesses sufficient qualifications to proffer an opinion as to the

cause of the injuries in this case. Dr. Tappan is a licensed physician in

California with an active clinical practice that includes obstetrics and

gynecology. He has experience diagnosing, evaluating, and managing

pregnant patients near delivery, including managing patients with

non-reassuring fetal heart-rate patterns. He states that he is “aware of

the indications and techniques for operative vaginal delivery and

cesarean section and the prevention and management of fetal head

impaction in the maternal pelvis at the time of cesarean delivery.”

The health care respondents dispute whether Dr. Tappan is

qualified to opine on the causes of neurological injuries to newborns. In

doing so, they impermissibly restrict the inquiry at this early stage of

the proceedings, which do not subject an expert’s stated qualifications

to substantive investigation or cross-examination. See id. (“Our holding

does not mean that only a neurosurgeon can testify about the cause in

fact of death from an injury to the brain . . . .”). The injury in this case

allegedly occurred as a result of breaches of the standard of care during

birth. An obstetrician trained in preventing neurological injuries of the

type alleged to have occurred here may have experience in assessing

those injuries, and Dr. Tappan indicates that he has such experience. A

reasonable court could determine that Dr. Tappan’s training and

experience qualify him to offer an opinion as to the cause of the alleged

fetal injury in this case, when combined with Dr. Null’s report.

Dr. Null has experience managing hundreds of patients with

birth asphyxia. His research focused on neonatal respiratory problems.

6

He headed several pediatric care units and was the assistant chief of

neonatology at Wilford Hall USAF Medical Center. As Dr. Null had

extensive experience with both newborns and birth asphyxia, his report

sufficiently indicates that he is qualified to proffer an opinion as to the

alleged cause of the injury in this case.

Taking the two reports together, there is no basis to conclude that

the trial court acted in “an arbitrary or unreasonable manner” in

determining Drs. Tappan and Null were sufficiently qualified to testify

on causation. See Bowie Mem’l Hosp. v. Wright, 79 S.W.3d 48, 52 (Tex.

2002); TEX. CIV. PRAC. & REM. CODE § 74.351(i) (explaining that “a

claimant may satisfy any requirement of this section for serving an

expert report by serving reports of separate experts regarding different

physicians or health care providers or regarding different issues arising

from the conduct of a physician or health care provider”).

II

The health care respondents also contend that the expert reports

inadequately address the applicable standard of care and breach of that

standard by the hospital nurses. Chapter 74 requires that expert

reports provide a fair summary of the applicable standard of care. See

TEX. CIV. PRAC. & REM. CODE § 74.351(a), (l), (r)(6). Identifying the

proper standard of care is “critical,” as a breach of duty cannot be

determined “absent specific information about what the defendant

should have done differently.” Am. Transitional Care Ctrs. of Tex., Inc.

v. Palacios, 46 S.W.3d 873, 880 (Tex. 2001). The standard focuses on

poor conduct, not poor results. See Baty, 543 S.W.3d at 696 (approving

7

a report identifying specific conduct and opining that it fell below the

standard of care).

Dr. Tappan explained with specificity his view as to what the

nurses should have done differently. For example, he states that the

nurses should have used proper monitoring equipment, recorded critical

pressure-change data, properly adjusted oxytocin, and reported

problems to their superiors when they appeared. Dr. Tappan references

a hospital protocol, signed by Dr. Castillo, as part of the basis for these

standards. See Bowie, 79 S.W.3d at 52 (requiring the expert’s opinion to

be contained within the “four corners” of the report). While “a company’s

internal policies alone do not determine the governing standard of care,”

they may be evidence of one. See FFE Transp. Servs., Inc. v. Fulgham,

154 S.W.3d 84, 92 (Tex. 2004) (internal quotation marks omitted); Fence

v. Hospice in the Pines, 4 S.W.3d 476, 481 (Tex. App.—Beaumont 1999,

pet. denied) (“We may also look to Hospice’s internal policies for evidence

regarding the standard of care; however, those policies alone do not

determine the governing standard of care.”).

Nurse Beach’s expert opinion combines with Dr. Tappan’s to

elucidate the standard of care, noting that a reasonably prudent nurse

should “apply a fetal scalp electrode when the fetal heart rate signal was

intermittent,” and that the nurses failed to do so here. She seconded

Dr. Tappan’s assertion that nurses should “proceed up the chain of

command after the attending physician . . . was no longer present at the

hospital while Pitocin was being administered and the fetal heart rate

revealed a non-reassuring pattern.” Read together, the trial court

reasonably could determine that the testimony of Dr. Tappan and Nurse

8

Beach sufficiently provided the applicable standard of care and breach

for the hospital nurses. See TEX. CIV. PRAC. & REM. CODE § 74.351(i)

(“Nothing in this section shall be construed to mean that a single expert

must address all liability and causation issues with respect to all

physicians or health care providers or with respect to both liability and

causation issues for a physician or health care provider.”).

* * *

Judicial efficiency is not a proxy for shortcuts—haphazardly

placing issues on appeal into a new category deemed unworthy of an

appellate decision at any level. Having resolved the alternate grounds

necessary to the Court’s disposition, I join the Court’s judgment

remanding the case to the trial court for further proceedings.

Jane N. Bland

Justice

OPINION FILED: December 13, 2024

9

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.