“[W]here documents are used to determine litigants’ substantive legal rights, a strong presumption of [public] access attaches.”
How later courts described this case
- “[W]here documents are used to determine litigants’ substantive legal rights, a strong presumption of [public] access attaches.”
Written by the judges who cited it.
The opinion
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
FUBOTV INC., et al.,
Plaintiffs,
-against- 24-CV-01363 (MMG)
THE WALT DISNEY COMPANY, et al., ORDER
Defendants.
MARGARET M. GARNETT, United States District Judge:
Attached hereto this Order is Court Exhibit 1, which is the consent list submitted by the
parties to the Court of all exhibits admitted into evidence during the preliminary injunction
hearing (the “Hearing”) held in this matter from August 6-12, 2024.
The parties aae HEREBY ORDERED to meet and confer regarding unsealing of (1) the
transcript of the Hearing, and (11) the underlying documents employed or referenced therein and,
by no later than August 23, 2024, identify any portions of the Hearing transcript and exhibits
that the parties jointly agree should remain sealed. The parties shall also identify any portions as
to which there is disagreement. For any testimony provided by third-party witnesses (or
documents produced by third parties) to this litigation, e.g., DIRECTV, the consent of those third
parties shall be obtained before any such portion of the transcript or relevant document is
designated to be unsealed.
Any testimony provided in open court at the Hearing shall be considered by the parties to
be presumptively unsealed. Furthermore, any portions of the Hearing transcript or portions of
documents which the Court has included unredacted in the public Order and Opinion at Dkt. No.
290 shall likewise be considered presumptively unsealed. See Lugosch v. Pyramid Co. of
Onondaga, 435 F.3d 110, 121 (2d Cir. 2006) (“[W]here documents are used to determine
litigants’ substantive legal rights, a strong presumption of [public] access attaches.”) Any
portions of the Order and Opinion which the Court has redacted shall remain sealed pending
consideration of the parties’ submissions directed above and further order of the Court.
Dated: August 16, 2024
New York, New York
SO ORDERED.
MARGARE
United States District Judge
Case 1:24-cv-01363-MMG Document 292 Filed 08/16/24 Page 2 of 41
COURT EXHIBIT 1
Case 1:24-cv-01363-MMG Document 292 Filed 08/16/24 Page 3 of 41
fuboTV Inc., et al. v. The Walt Disney Company, et al.
Civil Action No. 1:24-cv-1363
Admitted Exhibit List
Exhibit Authenticity Admissibility Date Date
Description
Number1 Objection Objection Identified Admitted
JX001 Email from G. Schanman to J. Blum re: Video Services Information, with attachment 8/12
Email from A. LeCuyer to H. Akhavan re: Programming Deep Dive on 1/5/24, with
JX002 8/7
attachment
Pls.’ Obj.:
JX003 Email from J. Lancer to D. Espinosa, et al. re: A debate 8/12
Hearsay
JX004 Astound Broadband - Global Agreement 1-1-23 8/12
JX005 First Amendment to Affiliation Agreement between Fox and Cox Communications 8/12
JX006 DISH-Fox Global Affiliation Agreement 8/12
JX007 Third Amendment to Affiliation Agreement between Fox and Mediacom 8/12
JX008 Global Affiliation Agreement between Fox and Verizon 8/12
JX009 Sixth Amendment to Fox/YT Affiliation Agreement 8/12
Pls.’ Obj.:
JX010 Email from J. Nallen to M. Biard re: Potential partnership 8/12
Hearsay
Pls.’ Obj.:
JX011 Project Raptor OOC Approval Request Deck 8/12
Hearsay
Pls.’ Obj.:
JX012 Project Raptor: Future of Paytv and Implications of Flagship and Raptor Deck 8/12
Hearsay
Pls.’ Obj.:
JX013 Email from J. Lancer to K. Menzier re: Favor for raptor, with attachments 8/12
Hearsay
Email from J. Nallen to J. Lancer re: Project Raptor: OOC Approval Request [Approval Pls.’ Obj.:
JX014 8/7
Requested], with attachment Hearsay
Pls.’ Obj.:
JX015 Venu Deck 8/12
Hearsay
JX016 Declaration of Alberto Horihuela in Support of PI Motion Defs.’ Obj: 802 8/12
JX017 Digital MVPD Affiliation License Agreement between TWDC and Fubo 8/12
JX018 Defendant Channel List Excel 8/12
JX019 Full Channel List 04012024 Excel 8/12
1 “JX” exhibits are joint exhibits, “PX” exhibits are Plaintiffs’ exhibits and “DX” are Defendants’ exhibits.
1
Case 1:24-cv-01363-MMG Document 292 Filed 08/16/24 Page 4 of 41
fuboTV Inc., et al. v. The Walt Disney Company, et al.
Civil Action No. 1:24-cv-1363
Admitted Exhibit List
Exhibit Authenticity Admissibility Date Date
Description
Number1 Objection Objection Identified Admitted
JX020 Percentage Hours by Channel Excel 8/7
Defs.’ Obj.:
JX021 Email from S. Miller to T. Mathers re: Renewal 8/6
802, 805
JX022 JV Impact Excel Spreadsheet 8/12
JX023 Fubo Estimated Impact of JV on NA Streaming Business (2024 & 2025) Deck 8/8
Pls.’ Obj.:
JX024 Email from T. Mathers to L. Morrissey, et al. re: Disney Discussion Topics 8/6
Hearsay
Pls.’ Obj.: 602
JX025 Email from T. Mathers to L. Morrissey, et al. re: Revised Disney draft, with attachments 8/12
Defs.’ Obj.: 802
Email from T. Mathers to L. Morrissey, et al. re: Revised Disney Agreement, with
JX026 Pls.’ Obj.: 602 8/6
attachments
JX027 Consumer Receptivity to New Sports Bundling Services Defs.’ Obj: 802 8/8
JX028 Updated JV Baseline Excel 8/8
JX029 OM 2024_Budget Media 0131_20240618 8/12
JX030 Percent first views by Network Excel Spreadsheet 8/12
JX031 FUBO OM 2024_Budget Media 0131 JV Excel Defs.’ Obj: 802 8/12
JX032 Fubo Subscriber Comparison Excel 8/12
Pls.’ Obj.:
Hearsay
JX033 Email from D. Pietrycha to C. Kohl and A. Izaguirre re: Sports JV, with attachment 8/12
Defs. Obj.: 602,
802
Email from A. Matts to D. Pietrycha re: Sports JV Subscriber Impact - CDG, with Pls.’ Obj.:
JX034 8/12
attachments Hearsay
Email from J. Zasowski to S. Breen re: In-Person - LRP/AOP and Distribution Strategy Pls.’ Obj.: Pls.’ Obj.:
JX035 8/12
Discussion, with attachment 901/902 Hearsay
Email from S. Flood to S. Breen, et al. re: Fubo 6.30 Proposed Executive Summary, with Pls.’ Obj.:
JX036 8/12
attachment Hearsay
Email from R. Thapar to S. Breen re: can you send me the finished doc we were just Pls.’ Obj.:
JX037 8/12
reviewing, with attachment Hearsay
2
Case 1:24-cv-01363-MMG Document 292 Filed 08/16/24 Page 5 of 41
fuboTV Inc., et al. v. The Walt Disney Company, et al.
Civil Action No. 1:24-cv-1363
Admitted Exhibit List
Exhibit Authenticity Admissibility Date Date
Description
Number1 Objection Objection Identified Admitted
Pls.’ Obj.:
JX038 Email from J. Connolly to C. LaPlaca re: Charter IR deck, with attachment 8/12
Hearsay
Pls.’ Obj.:
JX039 Email from S. Breen to J. Connolly re: Fubo 7/21 Proposal Summary, with attachment 8/12
Hearsay
Email from S. Breen to J. Connolly re: Fubo Deal Announcement- Executive Summary, Pls.’ Obj.:
JX040 8/12
with attachment Hearsay
Pls.’ Obj.:
JX041 Email from J. Connolly to J. Landgraf re: notes, with attachments 8/12
Hearsay
Pls.’ Obj.:
JX042 Email from J. Earley to A. Bergman, et al. re: Hulu Live + TV Carriage, with attachment 8/12
Hearsay, 602
JX043 Non-Binding Term Sheet 8/12
JX044 Flagship DTC Update Slide Deck 8/7
JX045 Joint Venture Term Sheet 8/7
JX046 ESPN 5-Year Plan - Corporate Preview Deck 8/7
JX047 Master MVPD License Agreement between TWDC and Altice 8/12
JX048 Master MVPD License Agreement between TWDC and Charter 8/12
JX049 Primary MVPD License Agreement between TWDC and Comcast 8/12
JX050 Master MVPD License Agreement between TWDC and Cox 8/12
JX051 Digital MVPD Affiliation License Agreement between TWDC and DirecTV 8/12
JX052 Digital MVPD Affiliation License Agreement between TWDC and Fubo 8/8
JX053 Digital MVPD Affiliation License Agreement between TWDC and Hulu 8/12
JX054 Master MVPD License Agreement between TWDC and Mediacom 8/12
JX055 Digital Affiliation License Agreement between TWDC and Google 8/12
Email from K. Shirley to J. Perrette, et al. re: Project Zenith: Initial research findings, with Pls.’ Obj.:
JX056 8/9
attachment Hearsay
Pls.’ Obj.:
JX057 Domestic Distribution & Ad Sales Deck 8/12
Hearsay
Pls.’ Obj.:
JX058 Raptor Slide Deck 8/9
Hearsay
3
Case 1:24-cv-01363-MMG Document 292 Filed 08/16/24 Page 6 of 41
fuboTV Inc., et al. v. The Walt Disney Company, et al.
Civil Action No. 1:24-cv-1363
Admitted Exhibit List
Exhibit Authenticity Admissibility Date Date
Description
Number1 Objection Objection Identified Admitted
Pls.’ Obj.:
JX059 Project Raptor Overview Slide Deck 8/9
Hearsay
Pls.’ Obj.:
JX060 Warner Bros. Discovery - Board Update: Streaming Deck 8/12
Hearsay
Pls.’ Obj.:
JX061 The Walt Disney Company Q1 FY24 Earnings Conference Call 8/12
Hearsay
JX062 Fubo Annual Report, 2022 8/6
JX063 Fubo 2023 Annual Report 8/12
Declaration of Anthony Petitti in Support of Defendants' Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion Pls.’ Obj.: 802,
JX064 8/9
for Preliminary Injunction 805
JX065 Renewal Agreement 8/12
JX066 OTT Distribution Agreement 8/12
JX067 OTT Distribution Agreement 8/7
JX068 Renewal Agreement 8/7
JX069 Affiliate Agreement between fuboTV Inc. and Turner Network Sales, Inc. 8/12
JX070 Affiliate Agreement between fuboTV Inc. and Turner Network Sales, Inc. 8/9
DirecTV Slides titled: DirecTV Services, JV Channel Bundling Requirements, JV
Channel Packaging Requirements on OTT, JV Channel Minimum Penetration and
PX001 901 602; 802
Required Packages on OTT, JV Partner Channels in Current DirecTV Packages Bundling
+ Packaging + Minimum Penetrations
DirecTV Slides titled: DirecTV Packaging “Then” and “Now,” Programmers Dictate
Packaging Uniformity, Multipronged Restrictions Perpetuate Oversize Bundles,
PX002 901 602; 802
Competitive Packaging Comparison, Evolution of OTT Packaging Constraints,
Competitive Landscape
PX003 CX&Research, “Inflow/Outflow Research April Results” presentation (May 2024) 901 602; 802; 805
PX004 CX&Research, “Inflow/Outflow Research January Results” presentation (Feb. 2024) 901 602; 802; 805
PX005 CX&Research, “Inflow/Outflow Research March Results” presentation (Apr. 2024) 901 602; 802; 805
PX006 EchoStar Viewership Analysis & Excess Cost Calculation (Apr. 17, 2024) 602; 1006
PX007 DISH, “Disney-FOX-WBD JV” presentation (Feb. 28, 2024)
4
Case 1:24-cv-01363-MMG Document 292 Filed 08/16/24 Page 7 of 41
fuboTV Inc., et al. v. The Walt Disney Company, et al.
Civil Action No. 1:24-cv-1363
Admitted Exhibit List
Exhibit Authenticity Admissibility Date Date
Description
Number1 Objection Objection Identified Admitted
Email from A. LeCuyer to G. Schanman et al. re. talking points for potential conversation
PX008
with Bruce
Email from M. Oria to G. Schanman et al. re. Programming Update: DEMN/Fox/WBD
PX009
Sports JV
Email from J. Rosengard Hill to G. Schanman re. Impact of New Sports Streaming
PX010 802
Service
Email from G. Schanman to H. Akhavan et al. re. Pending sports offering from
PX011
programmers - to be announced on 2/6
PX012 Email from M. Cyran to B. Tauber et al. re. NFL Update
Imaging
problem at
PX013 Email from T. Wise to A. Ahmed et al. re. Video Services Weekly Staff Meeting
ECHO0003181-
3182
PX014 Email from J. Lancer to S. Tomsic re. Call with SVR 602
PX015 Email from J. Nallen to J. Lancer et al. re. Marketing for Raptor 106 8/7
PX016 Email from D. Espinosa to J. Lancer et al. re. Project Raptor - Preliminary IR / RP Q&A 8/12
PX017 Email from J. Nallen to D. Espinosa et al. re. Final Press Release 106
PX018 Email from D. Espinosa to D. Wong et al. re. Project Raptor | Fubo Seasonality 8/12
PX019 Email from P. Cheesbrough to J. Nallen et al. re. Raptor / Fox Sports 8/12
PX020 Email from J. Nallen to S. Tomsic et al. re. Raptor Business Plan November 13 vSent 8/12
PX021 Email from J. Nallen re. Raptor CEO Bonus Proposal
PX022 Email from P. Cheesbrough to J. Nallen
PX023 Email from P. Cheesbrough to J. Nallen et al. re. Zenith readout
PX024 Email to S. Tomsic et al. re. A debate 8/7
PX025 Email from D. Espinosa to J. Lancer et al. re. Project Raptor - Preliminary IR / RP Q&A
PX026 Email from D. Espinosa to J. Fang et al. re. Project Raptor - INTERNAL Talking Points 8/9
PX027 Email from P. Cheesbrough to J. Nallen et al. re. Fubo TV Deck
PX028 Email from J. Lancer to T. Najera et al. re. Raptor 106 8/12
5
Case 1:24-cv-01363-MMG Document 292 Filed 08/16/24 Page 8 of 41
fuboTV Inc., et al. v. The Walt Disney Company, et al.
Civil Action No. 1:24-cv-1363
Admitted Exhibit List
Exhibit Authenticity Admissibility Date Date
Description
Number1 Objection Objection Identified Admitted
Email from J. Nallen to B. Nick et al. re. Deadline: ESPN is “A Great Product”, Fox
PX029 Corp. CFO Steve Tomsic Says, But It’s Only “A Sliver of Sports” Given Fragmentation In 805
U.S. Market
Affiliation Agreement between Fox Cable Network Services, LLC and CSC Holdings,
PX030
LLC (Oct. 1, 2014)
Amendment to Fox News Channel & Fox Business Network Affiliation Agreements
PX031
between Fox News Network, L.L.C. and CSC Holdings, LLC (Oct. 1, 2014)
Affiliation Agreement between Fox Cable Network Services, LLC, Fox News Network,
PX032
L.L.C and Grande Communications Networks, LLC (Jan. 1, 2020)
Affiliation Agreement between Fox Cable Network Services, LLC, Fox News Network,
PX033
L.L.C and RCN Telecom Services, LLC (Jan. 1, 2020)
Affiliation Agreement between Fox Cable Network Services, LLC, Fox News Network,
PX034
L.L.C and Wave Division Holdings, LLC (Jan. 1, 2020)
Affiliation Agreement between Fox Cable Network Services, LLC, Fox News Network,
PX035
L.L.C and Spectrum Management Holding Company LLC (Oct. 16, 2019)
Affiliation Agreement between Fox Cable Network Services, LLC, Fox News Network,
PX036
L.L.C and Cox Communications, Inc. (Oct. 1, 2019)
Amended and Restated Affiliation Agreement between Fox Cable Network Services, LLC
PX037
and Hulu (Dec. 20, 2019)
Affiliation Agreement between Fox Cable Network Services, LLC, Fox Television
PX038
Holdings, Inc. and Mediacom LLC, Mediacom Broadband LLC (Apr. 1, 2014)
First Amendment to Affiliation Agreement between Fox Cable Network Services, LLC,
PX039 Fox Television Holdings, Inc. and Mediacom LLC, Mediacom Broadband LLC (Apr. 1,
2018)
Second Amendment to Affiliation Agreement between Fox Cable Network Services, LLC,
PX040 Fox Television Holdings, Inc. and Mediacom LLC, Mediacom Broadband LLC (Oct. 30,
2019)
Global Master Affiliation Agreement between Fox Cable Network Services, LLC, Fox
PX041
News Network, L.L.C and National Cable Television Cooperative, Inc. (Jan. 1, 2020)
Amendment No. 1 to Affiliation Agreement between Fox Cable Network Service, LLC
PX042
and Verizon Corporate Services Group, Inc. (Jan. 1, 2016)
6
Case 1:24-cv-01363-MMG Document 292 Filed 08/16/24 Page 9 of 41
fuboTV Inc., et al. v. The Walt Disney Company, et al.
Civil Action No. 1:24-cv-1363
Admitted Exhibit List
Exhibit Authenticity Admissibility Date Date
Description
Number1 Objection Objection Identified Admitted
Amendment No. 2 to the Affiliation Agreement between Fox Cable Network Services,
PX043 LLC, Fox Television Holdings, LLC and Verizon Corporate Services Group, Inc. (Aug. 1,
2019)
Amendment No. 3 to the Affiliation Agreement between Fox Cable Network Services,
PX044 LLC, Fox News Network, L.L.C., Fox Television Holdings, LLC and Verizon Corporate
Services Group, Inc. (Aug. 1, 2022)
Second Amendment to Fox/YT Affiliation Agreement between Fox News Network,
PX045 L.L.C., Fox Television Holdings, LLC, Fox Cable Networks Services, LLC, and Google
Inc. (July 30, 2018)
Affiliation Agreement between Fox Cable Network Services, LLC, Fox News Network,
PX046
LLC, and Fox Television Holdings, LLC and Google Inc. (Dec. 17, 2016)
Third Amendment to Fox/YT Affiliation Agreement between Fox News Network, L.L.C.,
PX047 Fox Television Holdings, LLC, Fox Cable Networks Services, LLC, and Google LLC
(Nov. 30, 2018)
Fourth Amendment to Fox/YT Affiliation Agreement between Fox News Network,
PX048 L.L.C., Fox Television Holdings, LLC, Fox Cable Networks Services, LLC, and Google
LLC (Aug. 30, 2019)
Fifth Amendment to Fox/YT Affiliation Agreement between Fox News Network, L.L.C.,
PX049 Fox Television Holdings, LLC, Fox Cable Networks Services, LLC, and Google LLC
(June 10, 2021)
PX050 Email from D. Wong to R. Gottlieb et al. re. Raptor Research 8/9
PX051 Email from J. Nallen to L. Murdoch re. Talking points for Iger/Zaslav next week
PX052 Email to S. Tomsic et al. re. Raptor call 106 8/7
PX053 Email to J. Lancer et al. re. Raptor call 106 8/7
PX054 Email from J. Nallen to D. Espinosa et al. re. Raptor Covered Distributor
PX055 Email from J. Lancer to A. Reiss et al. re. Raptor - Kicker Arguments 8/12
PX056 Email from L. Murdoch to J. Nallen et al. re. Directv
PX057 Email from M. Mulvihill to E. Shanks re. FOX-ESPN Consumption 602
PX058 Email from E. Shanks to J. Lancer et al. re. Branding deck
PX059 CY 2023 Telecast Counts on Nielsen Nationally Measured Entities (May 8, 2024) 602 8/9
7
Case 1:24-cv-01363-MMG Document 292 Filed 08/16/24 Page 10 of 41
fuboTV Inc., et al. v. The Walt Disney Company, et al.
Civil Action No. 1:24-cv-1363
Admitted Exhibit List
Exhibit Authenticity Admissibility Date Date
Description
Number1 Objection Objection Identified Admitted
PX060 Direct Message between A. Croxson, J. Lancer, and M. Park 602; 802
PX061 Direct Message between D. Wong and B. O’Neal 602; 802
PX062 Direct Message between BJ Elias and D. Espinosa
PX063 Email from J. Lancer to T. Najera et al. re. copy for the drive 8/12
PX064 Email from E. Shanks to J. Lancer et al. re. Branding deck 8/12
PX065 Email from T. Najera to A. Reiss et al. re. Project Raptor Overview Materials 8/12
PX066 Email from J. Lancer to A. Reiss et al. re. Raptor - Kicker Arguments 8/12
Email from J. Nallen to J. Lancer et al. re. Project Raptor: OOC Approval Request
PX067 8/12
[Approval Requested]
PX068 Email from P. Cheesbrough to L. Murdoch et al. re. Zenith Research Headlines and Deck 8/12
Employment Agreement between Fox Cable Network Services, LLC and Pete Distad
PX069 602 8/12
(March 15, 2024)
PX070 Email from D. Espinosa to A. Reiss re. Raptor proposed Hulu distribution 106
PX071 Email to B. Nick et al. re. Raptor release 106
PX072 Email from J. Lutzky to D. Espinosa et al. re. Updated Budget Presentation
PX073 Email from C. Lebowitz to D. Espinosa et al. re. Risks & Opportunities Budget Slide
Email from M. Mulvihill to E. Shanks re. Project Raptor | Preliminary Governance +
PX074 602
Structural Considerations
PX075 Fox, “Project Raptor OOC Approval Request” presentation (Jan. 2024)
PX076 Fox, “Project Raptor OOC Approval Request” presentation (Jan. 2024)
PX077 Email from P. Cheesbrough to L. Murdoch et al. re. Summary of Raptor Plan and Risks
PX078 Email from S. Tomsic to L. Murdoch et al. re. Board Slides
PX079 Email from S. Tomsic to J. Nallen re. Raptor 8/7
PX080 Email from S. Tomsic to L. Murdoch et al. re. Board Slides
PX081 Message forwarding Fox MMM Materials (July 24, 2023) 8/7
PX082 Email from J. Lancer to J. Nallen et al. re. Raptor Model Discussion
PX083 Email from J. Lancer to J. Nallen et al. re. Raptor Release
PX084 Email from G. Brown to L. Murdoch et al. re. Q2 Fiscal 2024 Executive Pack
8
Case 1:24-cv-01363-MMG Document 292 Filed 08/16/24 Page 11 of 41
fuboTV Inc., et al. v. The Walt Disney Company, et al.
Civil Action No. 1:24-cv-1363
Admitted Exhibit List
Exhibit Authenticity Admissibility Date Date
Description
Number1 Objection Objection Identified Admitted
PX085 Email from J. Lancer to J. Nallen et al. re. Raptor Strategic Considerations
PX086 Email from M. Mulvihill to P. Distad re. 2023 Sports Consumption Summary 8/9
PX087 Consumption summary FOX-Disney-Turner 8/12
PX088 Venu presentation (July 1, 2024) 8/12
PX089 Venu, “Venu Marketing Launch Strategy” presentation (July 15, 2024) 602 8/9
PX090 Venu advertisement (July 19, 2024) 106; 602
BA Viewership Pulls for Legal - Privileged and Confidential (Exhibit 9 to the Expert
PX091 602
Declaration of Jonathan Orszag in Support of Fubo’s Motion for Preliminary Injunction)
Digital MVPD Affiliation License Agreement between FuboTV Media Inc. and Disney
PX092 Affiliates (Aug. 1, 2023) (Exhibit 10 to the Expert Declaration of Jonathan Orszag in
Support of Fubo’s Motion for Preliminary Injunction)
Affiliation Agreement between fuboTV, Inc. and Fox Cable Network Services, LLC and
PX093 Affiliates (Nov. 15, 2016) (Exhibit 11 to the Expert Declaration of Jonathan Orszag (Part 106
1) in Support of Fubo’s Motion for Preliminary Injunction)
Fox Corporation, “Fox Corporation Company Conference Presentation,” at Morgan
Stanley Technology, Media & Telecom Conference (Mar. 4, 2024) (Exhibit 12 to the
PX094
Expert Declaration of Jonathan Orszag in Support of Fubo’s Motion for Preliminary
Injunction)
Fox Corporation, “2022 Q1 Earnings Conference Call Transcript” (Nov. 3, 2021) (Exhibit
PX095 13 to the Expert Declaration of Jonathan Orszag in Support of Fubo’s Motion for
Preliminary Injunction)
Warner Bros. Discovery, Inc., “2022 Q3 Earnings Conference Call Transcript” (Nov. 3,
PX096 2022) (Exhibit 14 to the Expert Declaration of Jonathan Orszag in Support of Fubo’s
Motion for Preliminary Injunction)
Fox Corporation, “2024 Q2 Earnings Conference Call Transcript” (Feb. 7, 2024) (Exhibit
PX097 15 to the Expert Declaration of Jonathan Orszag in Support of Fubo’s Motion for
Preliminary Injunction)
Warner Bros. Discovery, Inc., “2023 Q4 Earnings Conference Call Transcript” (Feb. 23,
PX098 2024) (Exhibit 16 to the Expert Declaration of Jonathan Orszag in Support of Fubo’s
Motion for Preliminary Injunction)
9
Case 1:24-cv-01363-MMG Document 292 Filed 08/16/24 Page 12 of 41
fuboTV Inc., et al. v. The Walt Disney Company, et al.
Civil Action No. 1:24-cv-1363
Admitted Exhibit List
Exhibit Authenticity Admissibility Date Date
Description
Number1 Objection Objection Identified Admitted
Digital MVPD Affiliation License Agreement between fuboTV Media Inc. and Disney
PX099 Affiliates (Aug. 1, 2023) (Exhibit 10 to the Expert Declaration of James Trautman in
Support of Fubo’s Motion for Preliminary Injunction)
Fubo, “US-English Total Channels Watched” (2023) (Exhibit 11 to the Expert Declaration
PX100
of James Trautman in Support of Fubo’s Motion for Preliminary Injunction)
Second Amendment to Affiliation Agreement between fuboTV Media, Inc. and Fox
PX101 Affiliates (Dec. 1, 2021) (Exhibit 17 to the Expert Declaration of James Trautman in
Support of Fubo’s Motion for Preliminary Injunction)
Declaration of David Gandler in Support of Fubo’s Motion for Preliminary Injunction
PX102 8/6
(Apr. 8, 2024)
Declaration of Jon Janedis in Support of Fubo’s Motion for Preliminary Injunction (Apr.
PX103
8, 2024)
Fubo, “Summary: Estimated Impact of JV on Streaming Business” (Apr. 3, 2024) (Exhibit
PX104 1 to the Declaration of Jon Janedis in Support of Fubo’s Motion for Preliminary 8/8
Injunction)
Declaration of Todd Mathers in Support of Fubo’s Motion for Preliminary Injunction
PX105 802; 805
(Apr. 8, 2024)
Digital MVPD Affiliation License Agreement between fuboTV Inc. and Disney Affiliates
PX106 (Aug. 1, 2023) (Exhibit 2 to the Declaration of Todd Mathers in Support of Fubo’s Motion
for Preliminary Injunction)
Affiliation Agreement between fuboTV Inc. and Fox Affiliates (Nov. 15, 2016), Part 1 of
PX107 3 (Exhibit 3 to the Declaration of Todd Mathers (Part 1) in Support of Fubo’s Motion for
Preliminary Injunction)
Affiliation Agreement between fuboTV Inc. and Fox Affiliates (Nov. 15, 2016), Part 2 of
PX108 3 (Exhibit 3 to the Declaration of Todd Mathers (Part 2) in Support of Fubo’s Motion for
Preliminary Injunction
Affiliation Agreement between fuboTV Inc. and Fox Affiliates (Nov. 15, 2016), Part 3 of
PX109 3 (Exhibit 3 to the Declaration of Todd Mathers (Part 3) in Support of Fubo’s Motion for
Preliminary Injunction)
10
Case 1:24-cv-01363-MMG Document 292 Filed 08/16/24 Page 13 of 41
fuboTV Inc., et al. v. The Walt Disney Company, et al.
Civil Action No. 1:24-cv-1363
Admitted Exhibit List
Exhibit Authenticity Admissibility Date Date
Description
Number1 Objection Objection Identified Admitted
Amendment to Affiliation Agreement between fuboTV, Inc. and Fox Affiliates (Dec. 31,
PX110 2019) (Exhibit 4 to the Declaration of Todd Mathers in Support of Fubo’s Motion for
Preliminary Injunction)
Second Amendment to Affiliation Agreement between fuboTV Media, Inc. (fuboTV, Inc
PX111 affiliate) and Fox Affiliates (Dec. 1, 2021) (Exhibit 5 to the Declaration of Todd Mathers
in Support of Fubo’s Motion for Preliminary Injunction)
PX112 Intentionally Omitted
PX113 Intentionally Omitted
Email from T. Mathers to S. Miller re. Renewal (Exhibit 8 to the Declaration of Todd
PX114 106; 802; 805
Mathers in Support of Fubo’s Motion for Preliminary Injunction)
Email from S. Flood to T. Mathers et al. re. Revised Disney draft (Exhibit 9 to the
PX115 106; 802
Declaration of Todd Mathers in Support of Fubo’s Motion for Preliminary Injunction)
Declaration of Gary Schanman in Support of Fubo’s Motion for Preliminary Injunction
PX116 8/7
(Apr. 5, 2024)
Declaration of Robert Thun in Support of Fubo’s Motion for Preliminary Injunction (Apr.
PX117 602; 802
5, 2024)
PX118 Fubo, “2024 Global Stream Budget Review” presentation (Jan. 31, 2024)
fuboTV Inc. “Action by Unanimous Written Consent of the Board of Directors” (Feb. 7,
PX119 401/402
2024)
PX120 Fubo Subscriber Margins (US English)
Aluma Insights, “Aluma: The New Disney-Fox-WBD Sports Bundle Could Put a Dent in
PX121 802
Pay-TV Subscriptions” (2024)
Aluma, “Consumer Receptivity to New Sports Bundling Services: ESPN D2C Streaming
PX122 602; 802; 805
& the Disney-Fox-WBD Bundle” (Apr. 2024)
David Satin, “Young Viewers Expected to Flock to Venu Sports in What Could Be Sports
PX123 802
Broadcasting Tipping Point,” The Streamable (May 29, 2024)
PX124 Email from T. Mathers to A. Horihuela re. Connecting 802
PX125 Email fromT. Mathers to P. O’Connell et al. re. New rights 802; 805
PX126 Email from J. Sweetwood to S. Marchesano et al. re. Updated Overview Deck 802
PX127 Email from S. Breen to T. Mathers re. renewal
11
Case 1:24-cv-01363-MMG Document 292 Filed 08/16/24 Page 14 of 41
fuboTV Inc., et al. v. The Walt Disney Company, et al.
Civil Action No. 1:24-cv-1363
Admitted Exhibit List
Exhibit Authenticity Admissibility Date Date
Description
Number1 Objection Objection Identified Admitted
PX128 Email from T. Mathers to L. Morrissey et al. re. New rights 802; 805
Email from A. Padte to J. Janedis re. Bridge to Profitability / Operational Metrics - Draft
PX129
for review
Renewal Agreement between fuboTV Media Inc. and Warner Bros. Discovery affiliates
PX130
(Jan. 1, 2022)
PX131 Email from T. Mathers to P. O’Connell et al. re. Disney open issues list 8/6
PX132 Email from P. O’Connell to T. Mathers et al. re. Disney open issues list
PX133 Email from T. Mathers to E. Hunter et al. re. Disney open issues list
PX134 Email from S. Flood to T. Mathers et al. re. Revised Disney draft 106; 802 8/6
PX135 Email from S. Flood to T. Mathers et al. re. Revised Disney Agreement 106 8/6
PX136 Email from P. O’Connell to T. Mathers et al. re. Disney Discussion Topics
PX137 Email from T. Mathers to S. Miller re. Renewal 106; 802; 805
Email from A. Sternberg to Fubo General Assembly re. Post Q3 Analyst Feedback and
PX138 602; 802; 805 8/12
Reports Published
Affilation Agreement between Fox Cable Network Services, Fox News Network, LLC,
PX139
Fox Television Holdings, and fuboTV, Inc. (Nov. 15, 2016)
First Amendment to Affiliate Agreement between Turner Network Sales, Inc. and fuboTV
PX140
Inc. (Dec. 21, 2018)
PX141 Marketing Finance Monthly Model
PX142 First Views by Network spreadsheet
PX143 Percent First Views by Network
Email from J. Connolly to D. Fox re. Zoom: Justin Connolly (Disney) <> David Gandler
PX144
(Fubo)
PX145 Email from M. Maggs to D. Gandler re. DG Tomorrow - Thursday, January 25
PX146 Email from J. Braccino to M. Anoshin re. Avg rev per employee 802
PX147 2023 Conversions by campaign type Google Paid Ads 8/12
PX148 First Views by Network
PX149 The Fubo Subscriber 802
PX150 Fubo Demographics (US) 802
12
Case 1:24-cv-01363-MMG Document 292 Filed 08/16/24 Page 15 of 41
fuboTV Inc., et al. v. The Walt Disney Company, et al.
Civil Action No. 1:24-cv-1363
Admitted Exhibit List
Exhibit Authenticity Admissibility Date Date
Description
Number1 Objection Objection Identified Admitted
PX151 First Views by Station Genre and First Views by Station Genre (%) 802
PX152 Survey responses spreadsheet 802 8/12
PX153 What streaming services do you pay for? 802
PX154 Trial First Views - Last 12M 8/12
PX155 Retention Curves by Year - Updated thru May 2024 (US English)
Response summary: prior to subscribing to Fubo were you a cable customer and were you
PX156 802
ever a cable customer
PX157 Sub Projections and Real Subs
PX158 YOY Fubo Churned Customers SOW by Competitor 602
PX159 fubo Ad Index February 2024
PX160 Fubo - Custom Insight 2023 Complete Data
fubo + Cardlytics: Dec. ’23 - Feb. ’24 Campaign Performance Review, Q1 Ad Index
PX161 602
Refresh & Insights Timeline
PX162 Latino + Ultimate Package Customer Insights 602
PX163 Cancelation reasons spreadsheet 802
PX164 Responses spreadsheet 802
PX165 Responses spreadsheet 802
PX166 Please tell us why you decided to end your fuboTV subscription 802
PX167 Please tell us why you decided to end your fuboTV subscription 802
PX168 FUBO OM 2024 Budget Media JV low 802
PX169 Hours by station
PX170 ABC Broadcast Programs Mapped to Primary Genre Group (7/1/23-6/30/24) 8/12
PX171 Conversion % by Primary Genre First View
PX172 Fox Broadcast Programs Mapped to Primary Genre Group (7/1/23-6/30/24) 8/12
PX173 Sports FV by Station 8/12
PX174 New Subs by Trial Type - US English Plans
PX175 Email from J. Glassel to D. Gandler et al. re. FOX Sports/FuboTV: potential partnership FRCP 37(c)
PX176 Email from D. Gandler to S. Brennan et al. re. FuboTV: Thank you FRCP 37(c) 8/6
13
Case 1:24-cv-01363-MMG Document 292 Filed 08/16/24 Page 16 of 41
fuboTV Inc., et al. v. The Walt Disney Company, et al.
Civil Action No. 1:24-cv-1363
Admitted Exhibit List
Exhibit Authenticity Admissibility Date Date
Description
Number1 Objection Objection Identified Admitted
PX177 Email from J. Glassel to D. Gandler et al. re. In LA 28th-30th FRCP 37(c)
PX178 Email from J. Fang to D. Gandler re. Fubo FRCP 37(c) 8/6
PX179 Sum of longest views 602 8/12
PX180 Raw Search Campaign Data 602
September 2023 Broadcaster Report (English Plans Only - Non-Brand Only - No
PX181 602
Latino/Canada Campaigns)
PX182 Email from B. Grad to P. O’Connell re. SEMN / fubo proposal 8/7
PX183 Email from S. Flood to B. Grad et al. re. Updated Proposal 3-13-18 8/7
PX184 FuboTV DMVPD Service Proposal draft
Response Summary: prior to subscribing to Fubo were you a cable customer and Were
PX185 602; 802
you ever a cable customer
PX186 Responses spreadsheet 602; 802
PX187 Affiliate Agreement between Turner Network Sales, Inc. and fuboTV Inc. (Aug. 17, 2018)
Email from P. O’Connell to B. Grad et al. re. FuboTV (FXNG Networks) Term Sheet
PX188
11/22/1
Amendment to Affiliation Agreement between Fox Cable Network Services, Fox News
PX189 FRCP 37(c)
Network, LLC, Fox Television Holdings, and fuboTV, Inc. (Dec. 31, 2019)
Digital MVPD Affiliation License Agreement between fuboTV Inc. and Disney Affiliates
PX190 8/12
(June 24, 2020)
Second Amendment to Affiliation Agreement between Fox Cable Network Services, Fox
PX191 FRCP 37(c) 8/12
News Network, LLC, Fox Television Holdings, LLC and fuboTV, Inc. (Dec. 1, 2021)
Digital MVPD Affiliation License Agreement between fuboTV Media Inc. and Disney
PX192 8/6
Affiliates (Aug. 1, 2023)
PX193 Rate By Channel - 2024 FUBO versus Defendants “Kagan + 30%” Modeled Rate 602; 802
PX194 Orszag New Exhibit 106; 602; 802
PX195 Responses spreadsheet 602; 802
PX196 Response Summary: Aside from Fubo, how many streaming services do you use? 602; 802
PX197 Response Summary: What streaming services do you pay for? 602; 802
14
Case 1:24-cv-01363-MMG Document 292 Filed 08/16/24 Page 17 of 41
fuboTV Inc., et al. v. The Walt Disney Company, et al.
Civil Action No. 1:24-cv-1363
Admitted Exhibit List
Exhibit Authenticity Admissibility Date Date
Description
Number1 Objection Objection Identified Admitted
Response Summary: What other streaming services do you currently use that you don’t
PX198 602; 802
pay for but have access to?
PX199 Response Summary: What about Fubo appeals to you most? 602; 802
Response Summary: In addition to your Fubo subscriptions, do you subscribe to any other
PX200 602; 802
cable or satellite tv services? and If yes, which one?
PX201 2022 - 1Q24 Content Expense & Viewership for US-Eng-Base 602
PX202 ESPN - Fox News - FX Channel Ad Revenue per Hour Viewed 602
PX203 Trials and Top Shows - 10 Minute Intervals 602 8/12
Horowitz, State of Media, Entertainment, and Tech Volume II: Viewing Behaviors 2024
PX204 802 8/8
Edition
Google slide titled: “NewCo JV will contain all providers’ premier sports networks and is
PX205 901 106; 602; 802
expected to cost $40-50 /month; publicly stated launch: Aug ’24”
PX206 Google presentation titled: “NewCo JV - YT workstreams” 901 106; 602; 802
Google staff L. Conkling et al., “Disney/WBD/Fox Sports Streaming Announcement
PX207 901 602; 802
Briefing”
Google staff A. Shorey & A. Newman, “Implications for Google: ESPN (Disney), Warner
PX208 901 602; 802
Bros. Discovery and Fox JV Streaming-Sports Service,” (Apr. 30, 2024)
Email from S. Mannapperuma to C. Orski et al. re. Deck for CFO Meeting - February 8,
PX209 602; 802
2024
PX210 Email from D. Pietrycha to M. Schnaars et al. re. Sports JV 602; 802
PX211 Email from C. Kohl to D. Arya et al. re. Sports Rights Contribution Analysis 602; 802 8/8
PX212 Email from C. Kilgore to A. Kini et al. re. Might be obvious 602; 802
PX213 Email from D. Arya to C. Kilgore et al. re. 2 quick turn-around items 602; 802
PX214 Email from M. Valkosky to A. Kini et al. re. Update on GRP Dataset 602; 802
PX215 Email from S. Beltrame to D. DAmico et al. 602; 802
PX216 Email from A. Kini to M. Valkosky et al. re. Ask for some Sports customer data 602; 802 8/9
PX217 Email from S. Beltrame to D. Arya et al. re. Sports JV - Pay TV TAM Draft 602; 802
PX218 Email from D. DAmico to D. Arya et al. re. Sports JV - Pay TV TAM 602; 802
15
Case 1:24-cv-01363-MMG Document 292 Filed 08/16/24 Page 18 of 41
fuboTV Inc., et al. v. The Walt Disney Company, et al.
Civil Action No. 1:24-cv-1363
Admitted Exhibit List
Exhibit Authenticity Admissibility Date Date
Description
Number1 Objection Objection Identified Admitted
Email from J. Zasowski to J. Connolly et al. re. Verizon tech / production services in-kind
PX219 802; 805
value
PX220 Email from J. Connolly to S. Breen et al. re. Raptor 8/12
PX221 Email from S. Flood to S. Breen et al. re. Fubo
PX222 Email from J. Connolly to S. Breen re. Verizon / Fubo Feedback 802
PX223 Email from S. Breen to P. O’Connell et al. re. Fubo fully executed
Email from J. Connolly to S. Breen et al. re. FY24 LRP | PD Exec Assumption Check-in
PX224
(Affiliate)
PX225 Email from P. Garrison to S. Breen et al. re. Question: Project Raptor Rev Share
Email from J. Lee to S. Breen et al. re. ESPN+ Blackout Solution - Content Gating by
PX226
Provider
PX227 Email from J. Zasowski to S. Breen et al. re. VZ/DTV Renewal - Point Counterpoint deck
PX228 Email from P. Garrison to J. Warbrooke et al. re. Raptor Rate Compare
Email from J. Connolly to S. Breen et al. re. FY24 LRP Renewals - Verizon, DTV,
PX229
Google - Latest Materials
PX230 Email from N. Suh to J. Zasowski et al. re. VZ and DirecTV Renewals
PX231 Email from R. Blood to S. Breen re. Point Counter Point
PX232 Email from S. Breen to S. Breen re. FY24 LRP Renewals 040124 10PM ET (4).pptx
Email from S. Breen to S. Breen re. FY24 LRP Renewals - Verizon, DTV, Google - Latest
PX233
Materials
PX234 Email from S. Breen to S. Breen re. (D)MVPD Renewal - - updated slides
Email from C. Aguiar to J. Connolly re. Importance of ESPN nets to a sports-focused
PX235
streaming service
Email from J. Warbrooke to J. Zasowski et al. re. VC: Amazon / Google Strategic
PX236 8/9
Thoughts
PX237 Email from R. Langer to J. Connolly re. On sports and ESPN 401/402; 802
PX238 Email from J. Connolly to B. Magnus et al. re. Fox meeting 8/7
PX239 Email from J. Warbrooke to J. Pitaro et al. re. Amazon pres
PX240 Email from J. Pitaro to J. Pitaro re. First NBA question for panel
16
Case 1:24-cv-01363-MMG Document 292 Filed 08/16/24 Page 19 of 41
fuboTV Inc., et al. v. The Walt Disney Company, et al.
Civil Action No. 1:24-cv-1363
Admitted Exhibit List
Exhibit Authenticity Admissibility Date Date
Description
Number1 Objection Objection Identified Admitted
PX241 Email from J. Pitaro to J. Pitaro re. Churn NBA question
PX242 Email from J. Pitaro to J. Pitaro re. Talking points on Raptor
PX243 Email from J. Pitaro to R. Ferro et al. re. U.S. Sports Rights Breakdown 403
PX244 Email from J. Pitaro to C. Aguiar et al. re. Board Approval for Sports Rights Agreements
Email from J. Pitaro to C. Aguiar re. Pre-read materials for the February board meeting -
PX245
ESPN
PX246 Email from J. Pitaro to C. Aguiar et al. re. Raptor Update 602; 802 8/6
PX247 Email from J. Pitaro to K. Mayer re. Turner
Email from J. Pitaro to A. Quadrani re. Disney: Is a Less Profitable Future Inevitable at
PX248 802
ESPN?
PX249 Email from B. Boyle to J. Pitaro et al. re. 2024 5YP Kick-off Meeting - Sports
PX250 Email from J. Pitaro to J. Pitaro re. My staff
PX251 Email from C. Aguiar to J. Pitaro re. Raptor
PX252 Email from J. Pitaro to J. Warbrooke et al. re. raptor
PX253 Email from J. Warbrooke to J. Pitaro et al. re. Raptor / Sports DMVPD update 8/7
Email from K. Jacobsen to J. Warbrooke et al. re. VC: Project Raptor - Modeling Follow-
PX254
Up
PX255 Email from C. Aguiar to T. Bayus et al. re. Business Model with Falcon Scenarios 8/12
Email from J. Pitaro to J. Connolly et al. re. Verizon tech / production services in-kind
PX256 802; 805
value
Email From P. Garrison to J. Warbrooke et al. re. Project Evolution - Latest deck and
PX257 8/12
backup
PX258 Email from J. Warbrooke to P. Garrison et al. re. Raptor - Modeling Follow-Up 602
PX259 Email from S. Breen to J. Warbrooke et al. re. MFN discussion
PX260 Email from J. Warbrooke to P. Garrison et al re. Raptor Rate Compare
PX261 ESPN, “ESPN-Fox Pricing Conjoint” presentation (Aug. 2023) 106; 802; 805 8/7
PX262 License Agreement between DISH Network L.L.C. and Disney Affiliates (Nov. 23, 2022)
PX263 Email from J. Zasowski to J. Connolly et al. re. ESPN / Fox Compare
PX264 Email from J. Connolly to D. O’Connell re. Final Raptor Docs
17
Case 1:24-cv-01363-MMG Document 292 Filed 08/16/24 Page 20 of 41
fuboTV Inc., et al. v. The Walt Disney Company, et al.
Civil Action No. 1:24-cv-1363
Admitted Exhibit List
Exhibit Authenticity Admissibility Date Date
Description
Number1 Objection Objection Identified Admitted
PX265 Email from K. Lansberry to R. Bay et al. re. Project Evolution Pre-Read materials
PX266 Email from C. Robertson to H. Johnston et al. re. Earnings Materials 602
Email from J. Pitaro to R. Bay et al re. PULSE: Media & Entertainment: Disney-Fox-
PX267 602; 802
WBD Create New Sports-First Streaming Venture, Product Coming Fall 2024
401/402; 403;
PX268 Email from J. Pitaro to C. Aguiar re. Roger Goodell Call 8/7
802
PX269 Email from J. Pitaro to R. Bay et al. re. ESPN Board decks 8/7
PX270 Email from J. Pitaro to C. Aguiar re. Bristol Trip - Agenda and Pre-Reads 8/12
PX271 Email from J. Warbrooke to J. Pitaro et al. re. NFL follow up
The Walt Disney Company, “Board of Directors Strategic Initiatives Briefing” (Feb.
PX272 8/12
2024)
PX273 Email From K. Uhrle to J. Kapenstein et al. re. Project Evolution - Key next steps
PX274 Email from M. Borrero to J. Warbrooke et al. re. Project Neptune | Discussion 106 8/12
PX275 Email from J. Kapenstein to J. Warbrooke et al. re. Raptor - research 8/12
Email from K. Mayer to J. Warbrooke et al. re. 230819 Privileged and Confidential --
PX276 8/12
Project Evolution Discussion Materials
PX277 Email from L. Keiling to C. Aguiar et al. re. FOX
PX278 Raptor Study Simulator (Aug. 22, 2023) 106; 602
PX279 Email from P. Garrison to J. Warbrooke et al. re. Raptor Partnership considerations 8/12
PX280 Disney, “Strategic Initiatives Briefing” presentation (Jan. 18, 2024)
PX281 Altman Solon, “Project Zenith Discussion Materials” presentation (Aug. 16, 2023) 8/12
PX282 Warner Bros. Discovery, “Raptor” presentation (Jan. 31, 2024)
PX283 Email to C. McAllister et al. re. Project Raptor | Business Model Comments
PX284 Email from J. Walker to C. McAllister et al. re. Raptor pgs for DZ
PX285 Email from B. Campbell to JB Perrette et al. re. ESPN
Email from B. Campbell to J. Nallen et al. re. Please Read: Project Raptor - Remaining
PX286 8/7
Open Term Sheet Issues
PX287 Email from B. Campbell to D. Fox re. Raptor: Loss of NBA Rights (Disney Proposal)
PX288 Email from D. Fox to B. Campbell re. Raptor Noncompete Issue 8/12
18
Case 1:24-cv-01363-MMG Document 292 Filed 08/16/24 Page 21 of 41
fuboTV Inc., et al. v. The Walt Disney Company, et al.
Civil Action No. 1:24-cv-1363
Admitted Exhibit List
Exhibit Authenticity Admissibility Date Date
Description
Number1 Objection Objection Identified Admitted
Joint Venture Term Sheet between Fox Sports Holdings, LLC, WarnerMedia Direct, LLC,
PX289 8/12
and ESPN, Inc. (May 29, 2024)
PX290 Email to G. Wiedenfels et al. re. Raptor Materials 8/9
PX291 Email from D. Fox to J. Warbrooke et al. re. Business Model Overview Pages
PX292 Email from D. Fox to C. Aguiar re. Business Model with Falcon Scenarios
PX293 Email to B. Campbell re. fubo
PX294 Email from S. Miller to M. Diaz et al. re. NBS Follow-Up
PX295 Email from K. Clark to S. Miller et al. re. Zenith Project Sync / Distribution
Email from B. Bryant to S. Miller et al. re. CNN Business: Live sports is migrating to
PX296
streaming, taking with it a superpower of the cable TV bundle
PX297 Email from R. Golomb to D. Barnes et al. re. Raptor
PX298 Email from K. Clark to S. Miller et al.
PX299 Email from S. Bergman to S. Miller et al. re. DTV Lunch 401/402
PX300 Email to S. Miller re. QBR Slides
PX301 Email from B. Bryant to S. Miller re. Raptor Release timing
PX302 Email from S. Miller to S. Duncan et al. re. Fubo
PX303 Email from S. Miller to B. Campbell re. NBA Review: Distribution Follow-Up
PX304 Email from JB Perrette to B. Campbell et al. re. Confidential: Revised draft Raptor release
PX305 Email from D. Fox to B. Campbell re. Project Raptor
PX306 Email from B. Campbell to S. Miller re. fubo
PX307 Email from S. Miller to B. Campbell re. Fubo - Intel
PX308 Email from B. Campbell to S. Miller re. Charter - Draft Summary
Email from P. Lee to B. Campbell et al. re. Lachlan said Sports JV business plan is for 5M
PX309
subs within 5 years
PX310 Email from B. Campbell to S. Miller et al. re. Renewal 8/9
PX311 Email from L. Silberwasser to B. Campbell re. Product - Raptor
PX312 Email from P. Distad to B. Campbell et al. re. Follow-up from this mornings meeting
Email from B. Campbell to F. Merchant et al. re. Privileged and Confidential: Pending
PX313
Announcement Regarding Project Raptor (Sports JV)
19
Case 1:24-cv-01363-MMG Document 292 Filed 08/16/24 Page 22 of 41
fuboTV Inc., et al. v. The Walt Disney Company, et al.
Civil Action No. 1:24-cv-1363
Admitted Exhibit List
Exhibit Authenticity Admissibility Date Date
Description
Number1 Objection Objection Identified Admitted
PX314 Email from B. Campbell to S. Miller re. fuboTV
PX315 Email from D. Fox to B. Campbell et al. re. Raptor Strawman Marketing Commitments
PX316 Email from S. Miller to B. Campbell re. Next steps
PX317 Email from S. Miller to B. Campbell re. Fubo 2Q’23 Earnings Summary - 8/4/23
PX318 Email from B. Campbell to S. Miller re. 1-Pager on Scope/Focus
PX319 Email from D. Fox to B. Campbell re. Raptor Deck
PX320 Email from S. Miller to B. Campbell re. Raptor
PX321 Email from C. McAllister to B. Campbell et al. re. Zenith Research & Financial Impact
PX322 Email from S. Bisaria to B. Campbell et al. re. BC & GW : Strat Planning/LRP
PX323 Email from C. McAllister to B. Campbell et al. re. Raptor pgs for DZ
PX324 Warner Bros. Discovery, “Raptor” presentation (Jan. 31, 2024)
Warner Bros. Discovery, “WBD Sports - Board of Directors Update” presentation (Aug.
PX325 8/9
2023)
Affiliate Agreement between WarnerMedia Network Sales, Inc. and Cox Communications
PX326 401/402
(July 21, 2023)
Affiliate Agreement between WarnerMedia Network Sales, Inc. and National Cable
PX327 401/402
Television Cooperative, Inc. (May 1, 2023)
Affiliate Agreement between WarnerMedia Network Sales, Inc. and Hulu, LLC (Dec. 19,
PX328 401/402
2022)
PX329 DMVPD Distribution Agreement between Discovery and Hulu, LLC (Dec. 19, 2022) 401/402
PX330 DMVPD Distribution Agreement between Scripps and Hulu, LLC (Dec. 19, 2022) 401/402
Affiliate Agreement between Scripps Networks, LLC and WarnerMedia Network Sales,
PX331 401/402
Inc. (Dec. 1, 2022)
Affiliation Agreement between Warnermedia Network Sales, Inc. (f.k.a. Turner Network
PX332 401/402
Sales, Inc.) and DISH Network L.L.C. (Nov. 12, 2021)
Affiliate Agreement between WarnerMedia Network Sales, Inc. and DirecTV, LLC (Oct.
PX333 401/402
9, 2020)
PX334 NASDAQ, fuboTV Inc. Common Stock (FUBO) Historical Data (July 22, 2023) 8/12
20
Case 1:24-cv-01363-MMG Document 292 Filed 08/16/24 Page 23 of 41
fuboTV Inc., et al. v. The Walt Disney Company, et al.
Civil Action No. 1:24-cv-1363
Admitted Exhibit List
Exhibit Authenticity Admissibility Date Date
Description
Number1 Objection Objection Identified Admitted
The Walt Disney Company, “2024 Notice of Annual Meeting of Shareholders and Proxy
PX335 8/12
Statement” (Feb. 1, 2024)
PX336 The Walt Disney Company, “Q1 FY24 Earnings Conference Call” (Feb. 7, 2024) 8/12
The Walt Disney Company, “3rd Annual MoffettNathanson Media and Communications
PX337 8/9
Summit” (May 18, 2016)
PX338 DealBook Summit, “2023 Bob Iger Interview” (Nov. 30, 2023) 8/12
PX339 Disney Privilege Log (June 21, 2024) 401/402; 602
PX340 Fox Privilege Log (June 21, 2024) 401/402; 403
PX341 WBD Privilege Log (June 21, 2024) 401/402; 602
PX342 Disney Amended Privilege Log (July 12, 2024) 401/402; 602
PX343 Fox Amended Privilege Log (July 12, 2024) 401/402; 403
PX344 Fubo Shareholder Letter (May 11, 2021)
PX345 Fubo Q1 2021 Earnings Webcast (May 12, 2021) 802
PX346 Fubo Q1 2021 Quarterly Filing (May 13, 2021)
PX347 Fubo Shareholder Letter (Aug. 10, 2021)
PX348 Fubo Q2 2021 Quarterly Filing (Aug. 11, 2021)
Fubo Press Release, “fuboTV Delivered Recrd $130.9M Revenue and 681,721 Total
PX349
Subscribers in Q2 2021; Raises 2021 Guidance” (Aug. 19, 2021)
PX350 Fubo Q2 2021 Earnings Webcast (Aug. 19, 2021) 802
PX351 Fubo Press Release, “fuboTV Reaches One Million Subscribers” (Nov. 9, 2021)
PX352 Fubo Q3 2021 Earnings Call Transcript (Nov. 9, 2021) 802
PX353 Fubo Shareholder Letter (Nov. 9, 2021)
PX354 Fubo Q3 2021 Quarterly Filing (Nov. 10, 2021)
Fubo Press Release, “fuboTV Closed Q4 and FY 2021 With Record 1.13 Million
PX355
Subscribers; Expects to Exceed $1 Billion Revenue In 2022” (Feb. 23, 2022)
PX356 Fubo Q4 2021 Earnings Call Transcript (Feb. 23, 2022)
PX357 Fubo Shareholder Letter (Feb. 23, 2022) 8/12
PX358 Fubo Q4 2021 Quarterly Filing (Feb. 28, 2022) 802 8/12
PX359 Fubo 2021 Annual Report (Apr. 27, 2022) 8/12
21
Case 1:24-cv-01363-MMG Document 292 Filed 08/16/24 Page 24 of 41
fuboTV Inc., et al. v. The Walt Disney Company, et al.
Civil Action No. 1:24-cv-1363
Admitted Exhibit List
Exhibit Authenticity Admissibility Date Date
Description
Number1 Objection Objection Identified Admitted
Fubo Press Release, “fuboTV Closed Q1 2022 with $236.7M Revenue, 1.056 Million
PX360
Subscribers in North America” (May 5, 2022)
PX361 Fubo Q1 2022 Earnings Call Transcript (May 5, 2022) 802
PX362 Fubo Shareholder Letter (May 5, 2022) 805 8/12
PX363 Fubo Q1 2022 Quarterly Filing (May 9, 2022) 8/12
PX364 Fubo Press Release, “FuboTV Releases Q2 2022 Financial Results” (Aug. 4, 2022)
PX365 Fubo Q2 2022 Earnings Call Transcript (Aug. 4, 2022) 802
PX366 Fubo Shareholder Letter (Aug. 4, 2022) 8/12
PX367 Fubo Q2 2022 Quarterly Filing (Aug. 8, 2022) 8/12
Fubo Press Release, “FuboTV Announces Q3 2022 Results; North American Streaming
PX368 Business Delivered Record High 1,231,000 Subscribers, Exceeded Revenue Forecast”
(Nov. 4, 2022)
PX369 Fubo Q3 2022 Earnings Call Transcript (Nov. 4, 2022) 802
PX370 Fubo Shareholder Letter (Nov. 4, 2022) 805 8/12
PX371 Fubo Q3 2022 Quarterly Filing (Nov. 7, 2022) 8/12
Fubo Press Release, “FuboTV Delivered Over $1 Billion in Global Annual Revenue in
PX372 2022; Closed Year With $984 Million in Revenue and 1.445 Million Subscribers in North
America” (Feb. 27, 2023)
PX373 Fubo Q4 2022 Earnings Call Transcript (Feb. 27, 2023) 802
PX374 Fubo Q4 2022 Quarterly Filing (Feb. 27, 2023) 8/12
PX375 Fubo Shareholder Letter (Feb. 27, 2023) 8/12
Fubo Press Release, “Fubo Exceeded Q1 2023 Guidance for North America With $316.5
PX376 Million Total Revenue and 1.285 Million Paid Subscribers, Raises Full Year 2023
Guidance; Reaffirms Expected 2025 Profitability Timeline” (May 5, 2023)
PX377 Fubo Q1 2023 Earnings Call Transcript (May 5, 2023) 802
PX378 Fubo Shareholder Letter (May 5, 2023) 8/12
PX379 Fubo Q1 2023 Quarterly Filing (May 8, 2023) 8/12
22
Case 1:24-cv-01363-MMG Document 292 Filed 08/16/24 Page 25 of 41
fuboTV Inc., et al. v. The Walt Disney Company, et al.
Civil Action No. 1:24-cv-1363
Admitted Exhibit List
Exhibit Authenticity Admissibility Date Date
Description
Number1 Objection Objection Identified Admitted
Fubo Press Release, “Fubo Delivered $305 Million Total Revenue in North America in Q2
PX380 2023, Achieved Double Digit Year-Over-Year Revenue, Subscriber Growth and Exceeded
Guidance” (Aug. 4, 2023)
PX381 Fubo Q2 2023 Earnings Call Transcript (Aug. 4, 2023) 802
PX382 Fubo Shareholder Letter (Aug. 4, 2023) 8/12
PX383 Fubo Q2 2023 Quarterly Filing (Aug. 7, 2023) 8/12
Fubo Press Release, “Fubo Exceeded Guidance in Q3 2023 With $313 Million Total
PX384 Revenue, up 43% Year-Over-Year, and Record 1.477 Million Paid Subscribers in North
America; Raises Full Year 2023 Outlook” (Nov. 3, 2023)
PX385 Fubo Q3 2023 Earnings Call Transcript (Nov. 3, 2023) 802
PX386 Fubo Q3 2023 Quarterly Filing (Nov. 3, 2023) 8/12
PX387 Fubo Shareholder Letter (Nov. 3, 2023) 8/12
Fubo Press Release, “Fubo’s North American Business Closed Q4 2023 With Record
PX388 1.618 Million Paid Subscribers, 29% Year-Over-Year Revenue Growth; Exceeded
Guidance Across Key Performance Metrics” (Mar. 1, 2024)
PX389 Fubo Shareholder Letter (Mar. 1, 2024) 8/12
PX390 Fubo Q4 2023 Quarterly Filing (Mar. 4, 2024) 8/12
Fubo Press Release, “Fubo Exceeded Q1 2024 Guidance in North America, Delivering
PX391
1.511M Paid Subscribers, $394M Total Revenue” (May 3, 2024)
PX392 Fubo Q1 2024 Quarterly Filing (May 3, 2024) 8/12
PX393 Fubo Shareholder Letter (May 3, 2024) 8/12
PX394 Fubo Transcript of Earnings Call (May 3, 2024) 802
PX395 PLACEHOLDER Q2 financial statements and/or earnings call transcripts for Fubo 802
Objections
PX396 PLACEHOLDER Q2 financial statements and/or earnings call transcripts for Disney
TBD
PX397 PLACEHOLDER Q2 financial statements and/or earnings call transcripts for Fox 802
106; 602;
Further
PX398 PLACEHOLDER Q2 financial statements and/or earnings call transcripts for WBD
Objections
TBD
23
Case 1:24-cv-01363-MMG Document 292 Filed 08/16/24 Page 26 of 41
fuboTV Inc., et al. v. The Walt Disney Company, et al.
Civil Action No. 1:24-cv-1363
Admitted Exhibit List
Exhibit Authenticity Admissibility Date Date
Description
Number1 Objection Objection Identified Admitted
PX399 Fox Corporation 2023 Form 10-K
PX400 WBD Metadata Log | Documents Withheld for Common Interest Privilege (July 21, 2024) 401/402
FRCP 37(c);
PX401 Fubo Slide titled: “Other services that Fubo subscribers pay for” 901 403; 602; 802; 8/12
1006
Competitive Impact Statement, United States v. The Walt Disney Company et al., Case 401/402; 403;
PX402
No. 18-cv-5800 (S.D.N.Y. Aug. 7, 2018), ECF No. 21 602; 802
Michael D. Whinston, GE-Electrolux Merger Anaylsis (Nov. 23, 2015), PX02015, United
401/402; 403;
PX403 States. v. AB Electrolux, Case No. 1:15-cv-01039-EGS (D.D.C. Nov. 25, 2015), ECF No.
802
342-1
CNBC, “Warner Bros. Discovery CEO David Zaslav Talks Sports Streaming Bundle
PX404 ‘Venu,’” (July 10, 2024), https://www.cnbc.com/video/2024/07/10/warner-bros-ceo- 403; 602; 802 8/12
david-zaslav-on-sports-streaming-bundle-venue.html
Heather Dinich, “TNT Sports to Air Select CFP Games Through Sublicense with ESPN,” 401/402; 602;
PX405
ESPN (May 22, 2024) 802
Peacock, Your Go-To for Hit Moveis, TV, Live Sports & More, Pick Your Plan webpage,
PX406 (July 22, 2024), https://www.peacocktv.com/#:~:text=With%20Peacock%20 602 8/12
Premium%2C%20you%20can,more%20to%20satisfy%20your%20FOMO
Paramount+, A Mountain of Entertainment, Pick Your Plan webpage (July 22, 2024),
PX407 602; 802 8/12
https://www.paramountplus.com/?intcid=CIA-16-10bah4e
PX408 Fubo Investor Day 2022 presentation (Aug. 17, 2022)
Sling, Programming and Plans webpage (July 23, 2024),
PX409 https://www.sling.com/programming/sports?msockid=1c1dfa1c05496735043df7d904cb66 802
f2
Letter from FuboTV Inc. et al. to Congressional Committees re. future of competition in 401/402; 403;
PX410
pay-TV 602; 802
401/402; 403;
PX411 DOJ Civil Investigative Demand Letter to DISH
602; 802
401/402; 403;
PX412 Email from J. Nallen to E. Shanks et al. re. Sports DTC - 2 Reports
602; 802
24
Case 1:24-cv-01363-MMG Document 292 Filed 08/16/24 Page 27 of 41
fuboTV Inc., et al. v. The Walt Disney Company, et al.
Civil Action No. 1:24-cv-1363
Admitted Exhibit List
Exhibit Authenticity Admissibility Date Date
Description
Number1 Objection Objection Identified Admitted
401/402; 403;
PX413 Email from G. Brown to J. Nallen et al. re. UBS Q&A 8/7
602; 802
401/402; 403;
PX414 Fox presentation titled: Project Raptor OOC Approval Request 8/12
602; 802
NFL Network Affiliation Agreement between NFL Enterprises LLC and fuboTV Media
PX415 401/402
Inc. (July 30, 2021)
PX416 Email from Dropbox Sign to T. Mathers re. You just signed Sinclair - KJZZ
Email from DocuSign to A. Marchesano et al. re. Completed: Complete with DocuSign:
PX417
beIN-Fubo US Twelfth Amendment (BEIN CLEAN 8.24.2023)
PX418 Email from Dropbox Sign to T. Mathers re. You just signed MASN - Executive Copy 602; 802; 805
PX419 Email from T. Mathers to J. Shin re. MSGN/Fubo - fully executed 602; 802; 805
PX420 Email from T. Mathers to J. Reyna re. KNSN
PX421 Email from T. Mathers to J. Reyna re. fubo
PX422 Email from S. Marchesano to T. Mathers re. MLB Network Agreements 602; 802
PX423 Email from J. Sweetwood to T. Mathers re. Renewals 106
Email from T. Mathers to B. Grad re. Completed: Complete with DocuSign: Fubo - NBA
PX424 802
TV and LP 2023 Agreement FINAL
PX425 Email from J. Sweetwood to T. Mathers re. Renewals
Content Distribution Agreement between fuboTV Media Inc. and Scripps Media, Inc. 802 (parent
PX426
(Jan. 24, 2024) email)
802 (parent
PX427 Email from M. Chin to J. Earley et al. re. DTC 101 for Hugh
email)
802 (parent
PX428 Advertising Revenue
email)
802 (parent
PX429 Email from B. Campbell to J.B. Perrette et al. re. ESPN
email)
PX430 Email from D. Fox to P. Distad re. Raptor
“US to scrutinize Disney, Fox, Warner sports streaming deal, Bloomberg Law reports,”
PX431 602
Reuters (Feb. 16, 2024)
25
Case 1:24-cv-01363-MMG Document 292 Filed 08/16/24 Page 28 of 41
fuboTV Inc., et al. v. The Walt Disney Company, et al.
Civil Action No. 1:24-cv-1363
Admitted Exhibit List
Exhibit Authenticity Admissibility Date Date
Description
Number1 Objection Objection Identified Admitted
ACA Press Release, “ACA Connects Statement on the Anticompetitive Sports Streaming 106; 403; 602;
PX432
Juggernaut” (Feb. 7, 2024) 802
Arbitration Agreement, United States v. AT&T Inc., DIRECTV Group Holdings, LLC, and
PX433
Time Warner Inc., Case No. 1:17-cv-02511 (D.D.C. Mar. 13, 2018)
Comments of the ACA Connects, In the Matter of Fostering Independent and Diverse
PX434 802; 805
Sources of Video Programming, MB Docket No. 24-115 (FCC June 6, 2024)
Comments of the American Independent Media, Inc., In the Matter of Fostering
401/402; 403;
PX435 Independent and Diverse Sources of Video Programming, MB Docket No. 24-115 (FCC
602; 802; 805
June 6, 2024)
Comments of the American Television Alliance, In the Matter of Fostering Independent
PX436 802; 805
and Diverse Sources of Video Programming, MB Docket No. 24-115 (FCC June 6, 2024)
Competitive Impact Statement, United States v. The Walt Disney Company et al., Case 403; 602; 802;
PX437
No. 18-cv-5800 (S.D.N.Y. Aug. 7, 2018) 805
Complaint, Turner Broadcasting System, Inc. and Warner Bros. Discovery, Inc. v.
PX438 National Basketball Association, NBA Ventures, LLC and NBA Properties, Inc., Index No. 602 8/9
653721/2024 (N.Y. Sup. Ct. July 26, 2024)
Complaint, United States v. AT&T Inc., DIRECTV Group Holdings, LLC, and Time
PX439 602
Warner Inc., Case No. 1:17-cv-02511 (D.D.C. Nov. 20, 2017)
Complaint, United States v. The Walt Disney Company et al., Case No. 18-cv-5800 403; 602; 802;
PX440 8/9
(S.D.N.Y. June 27, 2018) 805
Dan Weil, “ESPN Streaming Channel May Be coming, but It Won’t be Cheap,” The
PX441 802; 805
Street (May 23, 2023)
David Halberstam, “In a changing world, TV experts Ed Desser nad John Kosner share
PX442 403; 602; 802
how fans will watch sports in the future,” Sports Broadcast Journal (Apr. 22, 2021)
PX443 Ed Desser, “Weathering Climate Change in Sports Media,” LinkedIn (Sept. 21, 2015)
Fox Corporation, “Earnings Release for the Quarter Ended March 31, 2024” (May 8, 401/402; 403;
PX444
2024) 602; 802; 805
PX445 Fox Investor Day Transcript (May 9, 2019)
John Ourand, “Sports Media: Fox Sports consults Big Ten in media rights negotiations,” 106; 403; 602;
PX446
Sports Business Journal (Apr. 18, 2022) 802; 805; 1002
26
Case 1:24-cv-01363-MMG Document 292 Filed 08/16/24 Page 29 of 41
fuboTV Inc., et al. v. The Walt Disney Company, et al.
Civil Action No. 1:24-cv-1363
Admitted Exhibit List
Exhibit Authenticity Admissibility Date Date
Description
Number1 Objection Objection Identified Admitted
Letter from U.S. Reps. J. Nadler and J. Castro to B. Iger, L. Murdoch, and D. Zaslav re.
PX447 602
proposed sports streaming joint venture (Apr. 16, 2024)
Letter from U.S. Reps. J. Nadler and J. Castro to B. Iger, L. Murdoch, and D. Zaslav re.
PX448
response to April 16 letter (June 7, 2024)
403; 602; 802;
PX449 Status Conference Hearing Transcript (July 25, 2024) 901
805
PX450 Slide titled: Big Ten football games available on live pay TV services (2023-24) 901 602; 802; 1006
PX451 Supplemental Expert Declaration of Jonathan Orszag 602
The Walt Disney Company, “The Walt Disney Company Reports Second Quarter and Six 401/402; 403;
PX452
Months Earnings for Fiscal 2024” (May 7, 2024) 602; 802; 805
PX453 Updated Expert Declaration of James Trautman 401/402; 602 8/12
401/402; 602;
PX454 Updated Expert Declaration of Jonathan Orszag 8/8
802
Warner Bros. Discovery, “Warner Bros. Discovery, Inc. Reports First Quarter 2024 106; 403; 602;
PX455
Earnings Results” (May 9, 2024) 802; 805; 1002
PX456 Email from J. Lancer to P. Cheesbrough et al. re. Raptor - remaining exec level issues 8/12
PX457 Email from D. Fox to J. Lancer re. Eagle Comments
PX458 Email from A. Reiss to C. Neal et al. re. Project Raptor Antitrust Call - Agenda Items
PX459 Email from M. Dugan to A. Verveer et al. re. Project Raptor | Talking Points + Q&A
PX460 Email from J. Connolly to C. LaPlaca et al. re. Charter IR deck 8/9
PX461 Intentionally Omitted
PX462 Intentionally Omitted
PX463 Intentionally Omitted
PX464 Intentionally Omitted
PX465 Intentionally Omitted
Draft email forwarding email from R. Blood to R. Nelson et al. re. DIRECTV/TWDC
PX466 8/9
Renewal Term Sheet
PDX
Fubo Opening Demonstrative 8/6 8/12
001-034
27
Case 1:24-cv-01363-MMG Document 292 Filed 08/16/24 Page 30 of 41
fuboTV Inc., et al. v. The Walt Disney Company, et al.
Civil Action No. 1:24-cv-1363
Admitted Exhibit List
Exhibit Authenticity Admissibility Date Date
Description
Number1 Objection Objection Identified Admitted
PDX
101-105, J. Trautman Demonstrative 8/6 8/12
107-124
PDX
D. Gandler Demonstrative 8/6 8/12
201-202
PDX
T. Mathers Demonstrative 8/6 8/12
301-306
PDX
S. Marchesano Demonstrative 8/7 8/12
401-405
PDX
A. Horihuela Demonstratives 8/8
501-516
PDX
J. Janedis Demonstratives 8/8
601-612
PDX
J. Orszag Demonstratives 8/8
701-714
PDX
Fubo Closing Demonstrative 8/12
901-1020
DX001 Yahoo! Finance article, "fuboTV Inc. (FUBO): Historical Data" 8/12
CNBC article, "FuboTV CEO David Gandler thinks 5 million people could subscribe to Hearsay;
DX002 8/6
its bundle of TV networks by 2026" 401/402; 403
Business Insider article, "FuboTV insiders describe how its 'doomed' sportsbook collapsed Hearsay;
DX003 8/12
in a year--and what it means for the future of the streaming company" 401/402; 403
Hearsay;
DX004 Fool.com article, "fuboTV Stock Is Tumbling Because It's a Terrible Business" 901/902 8/6
401/402; 403
Hearsay;
DX005 Nasdaq article, "3 Reasons to Avoid fuboTV Stock" 901/902 8/6
401/402; 403
Letter to D. Gandler re: Clean Slate Agreement (Exhibit 2 of Declaration of J. Wesley
DX006
Earnhardt in Support of Disney’s Motion to Dismiss [dkt. 130-2]
Los Angeles Times article, "Disney and Charter end blackout, returning ESPN and ABC
DX007 Hearsay
to Spectrum TV "
DX008 Sports Business Journal article, "YES, MSG partner for new GAME streaming offering" 401/402
28
Case 1:24-cv-01363-MMG Document 292 Filed 08/16/24 Page 31 of 41
fuboTV Inc., et al. v. The Walt Disney Company, et al.
Civil Action No. 1:24-cv-1363
Admitted Exhibit List
Exhibit Authenticity Admissibility Date Date
Description
Number1 Objection Objection Identified Admitted
DX009 Fubo article, "Statement From Fubo Regarding Sports Streaming JV" 8/6
The Streamable article, "How Joint Venture Sports Streamer From Disney, Fox and
DX010 Hearsay
Warner Bros. Discovery Points to Streaming's Possible Future"
DX011 Form 10-K, EchoStar Hearsay
DX012 The Motley Fool article, "Fubo FYQ4 2023 Earnings Call Transcript" 8/6
DX013 Fubo Form 10-K FY 2023 8/6
Yahoo Finance article, "EchoStar Corporation (NASDAQ:SATS) Q4 2023 Earnings Call
DX014 Hearsay
Transcript"
Hearsay;
DX015 Initial Pretrial Conference Transcript
401/402
DX016 Sports Business Journal article, "Many possibilities for NBA rights as market opens"
The Hollywood Reporter article, "FuboTV Drops to 1.5M North American Subscribers in Hearsay;
DX017
First Quarter" 401/402; 403
DX018 Fubo article, "Fubo - Governance - Management Team: David Gandler" 901/902
DX019 List of Channels from Fubo's Website 8/6
Reuters article, "NBA finalizes $76 bln broadcasting deal with Disney, Amazon, Comcast,
DX020 Hearsay
the Athletic reports"
DX021 Expert Declaration of Edwin S. Desser 8/12
DX022 Rebuttal Expert Declaration of Michael D. Whinston, PHD 8/12
Plaintiffs' Third Supplemental Responses and Objections to Disney Defendants' First Set
DX023
of Interrogatories
Lack of
DX024 Inflow/Outflow Research May Results Deck 901/902 Foundation;
Hearsay
Lack of
DX025 Weekly Market & Competitive Insights Deck 901/902 Foundation;
Hearsay
Lack of
DX026 Weekly Market & Competitive Insights Deck 901/902 Foundation;
Hearsay
29
Case 1:24-cv-01363-MMG Document 292 Filed 08/16/24 Page 32 of 41
fuboTV Inc., et al. v. The Walt Disney Company, et al.
Civil Action No. 1:24-cv-1363
Admitted Exhibit List
Exhibit Authenticity Admissibility Date Date
Description
Number1 Objection Objection Identified Admitted
Lack of
DX027 Weekly Market & Competitive Insights Deck 901/902 Foundation;
Hearsay
Lack of
DX028 Service and Platform Requirement Excel 901/902 Foundation;
Hearsay
DX029 DirecTV and Viacom - Affiliation Agreement
Agreement between AT&T and American Movie Classic Company LLC, Women’s
DX030 901/902
Entertainment LLC, The Independent Film Channel LLC, Sundance Channel LLC
DX031 Agreement between AT&T and New Video Channel America, LLC 901/902
Agreement between DIRECTV, LLC and AMC Network Entertainment LLC, IFC TV
DX032 901/902
LLC, Sundance TV LLC, WE TV LLC, and New Video Channel America, LLC
Agreement between DIRECTV, LLC and AMC Network Entertainment LLC, IFC TV
DX033 901/902
LLC, Sundance TV LLC, WE TV LLC, and New Video Channel America, LLC
Agreement between DIRECTV, LLC and AMC Network Entertainment LLC, IFC TV
DX034 901/902
LLC, Sundance TV LLC, WE TV LLC, and New Video Channel America, LLC
Amendment to 9/1/2020 Agreement between DIRECTV, LLC and AMC Network
DX035 Entertainment LLC, IFC TV LLC, Sundance TV LLC WE TV LLC, and New Video 901/902
Channel America, LLC
DX036 Agreement between AT&T and Bloomberg L.P. 901/902
DX037 Agreement between AT&T and Bloomberg L.P. 901/902
DX038 Amendment to Bloomberg Television MVPD Affiliation Agreement 901/902
DX039 Amendment to 1/13/2006 Agreement between AT&T and Bloomberg L.P. 901/902
DX040 Amendment to 1/1/2008 Agreement between AT&T and Bloomberg L.P. 901/902
DX041 Amendment to 1/1/2008 Agreement between AT&T and Bloomberg L.P. 901/902
DX042 Fifth Amendment to Short-Form Agreement
DX043 Email from D. Wong to D. Espinosa and T. Najera re: Falcon market rates Hearsay
DX044 Email from D. Espinosa to J. Nallen, et al. re: A debate Hearsay; 106
DX045 Amendment to Affiliation Agreement
DX046 Amendment between Fox B10 Channel Partner, Inc. and CSC Holdings, LLC
30
Case 1:24-cv-01363-MMG Document 292 Filed 08/16/24 Page 33 of 41
fuboTV Inc., et al. v. The Walt Disney Company, et al.
Civil Action No. 1:24-cv-1363
Admitted Exhibit List
Exhibit Authenticity Admissibility Date Date
Description
Number1 Objection Objection Identified Admitted
DX047 Amendment to Fox News Channel and Fox Business Network Affiliation Agreements
DX048 Fox-Charter Letter Agreement
DX049 2020 Term Sheet
DX050 Fox-DIRECTV Renewal Term Sheet
Citizens Telecom Service Co dba Frontier Communications Global Affiliation Agreement
DX051
(10-24-14)
DX052 FuboTV Media, Inc. - Second Amendment to Affiliation Agreement 8/8
DX053 Affiliation Agreement between Fubo and Fox
DX054 First Amendment to Affiliation Agreement between Fubo and Fox
DX055 Second Amended and Restated Affiliation Agreement between Fox and Hulu
DX056 First Amendment to Global Master Affiliation Agreement between Fox and NCTC
DX057 Affiliation Agreement between Fox and Puerto Rico Telephone Company
Lack of
DX058 Fox Financial Snapshot Excel Foundation;
Hearsay
DX059 Email from J. Nallen to G. Brown re: MS Q&A For Review, with attachment Hearsay
DX060 E-mail from D. Espinosa to R. Thun, et al. re: Thank you! Hearsay
DX061 Email from D. Espinosa to H. Nguyen and J. Fang re: Raptor Rates, with attachment Hearsay
DX062 Email from J. Lutzky to D. Espinosa and J. Fang re: Fubo June Subs Hearsay; 403
DX063 Email from D. Espinosa to J. Nallen re: DIRECTV "No Locals" Announcement Hearsay
DX064 Email from L. Murdoch to J. Nallen re: Directv Hearsay
DX065 Project Zenith Research Overview Slide Deck Hearsay
Hearsay;
DX066 Fox Sunday NFC Package Term Sheet
401/402; 403
DX067 Email from J. Nallen to D. Martin re: 2/28 Update, with attachment Hearsay 8/8
DX068 Email from D. Espinosa to J. Lancer, et al. re: Initial notes for Raptor discussion Hearsay
DX069 Email from P. Distad to T. Connolly, et al re: Next steps on rates Hearsay
DX070 Venu Firewall Policy for Third Party Competitively Sensitive Information Hearsay 8/7
31
Case 1:24-cv-01363-MMG Document 292 Filed 08/16/24 Page 34 of 41
fuboTV Inc., et al. v. The Walt Disney Company, et al.
Civil Action No. 1:24-cv-1363
Admitted Exhibit List
Exhibit Authenticity Admissibility Date Date
Description
Number1 Objection Objection Identified Admitted
Email from T. Mathers to S. Miller re: WBD - Fubo Discussion Points Draft, with
DX071
attachment
DX072 Email from S. Marchesano to T. Mathers re: Turner / Discovery Sub Scenarios
DX073 Email from T. Mathers to J. Sweetwood re: Updated Overview Deck, with attachments
DX074 Email from S. Miller to T. Mathers re: Fubo/Turner nets
DX075 Email from J. Janedis to T. Mathers re: Disney 401/402; 403
DX076 Email from S. Miller to T. Mathers re: Fubo/Turner nets
DX077 Email from L. Morrissey to T. Mathers re: Disney Renewal
DX078 Email from T. Mathers to L. Morrissey re: Disney Renewal, with attachments
DX079 Email from T. Mathers to P. O'Connell re: follow-up
DX080 Email from T. Mathers to P. O'Connell re: Kagan Numbers
DX081 Email from T. Mathers to P. O'Connell re: Kagan numbers, with attachment
DX082 Email from S. Marchesano to T. Mathers re: Kagan numbers, with attachment
DX083 Email from T. Mathers to M. Elizondo and S. Marchesano re: Disney Renewal
Email from T. Mathers to J. Sweetwood re: Disney Competitive Analysis Deck, with
DX084
attachment
DX085 Email from T. Mathers to L. Morrissey re: Disney Proposal
DX086 Email from M. Elizondo to T. Mathers re: Turner/Discovery
Email from M. Berkley to D. Gandler re: Barclays: Why Bundles May Not Be Effective in
DX087
Video Streaming
Email from M. Berkley to D. Gandler re: Barclays: Why Bundles May Not Be Effective in
DX088
Video Streaming
DX089 Email from A. Horihuela to Fubo Team re: What's a SupAg?, with attachment
DX090 FuboTV Strategic Context and Approach Deck
DX091 First Views (2021-2024) by Sports vs. Non-Sports Excel
Email from T. Mathers to D. Gandler and A. Horihuela re: WBD vs. NBCU Scenario
DX092
Slides
DX093 Email from T. Mathers to J. Shin re: WBD vs. NBCU Scenario slides, with attachment
DX094 Email from S. Miller to T. Mathers re: fubo/WBD, with attachment 8/9
32
Case 1:24-cv-01363-MMG Document 292 Filed 08/16/24 Page 35 of 41
fuboTV Inc., et al. v. The Walt Disney Company, et al.
Civil Action No. 1:24-cv-1363
Admitted Exhibit List
Exhibit Authenticity Admissibility Date Date
Description
Number1 Objection Objection Identified Admitted
Email from B. Grad to S. Marchesano re: Fubo/Flames/Oilers @ Tue, Nov 14, 2023
DX095
5:30pm-6:00pm (GMT-05), with attachments
DX096 Fubo Investor Day Talking Points - Content - Talk Track
Email from A. Padte to A. Sternberg re: Q1 Shareholder Outline to Guide Tomorrow's
DX097 8/12
Discussion, with attachment
Email from A. Padte to J. Janedis re: 2Q/FY24 Guidance Draft (April 16, 2024), with
DX098 8/12
attachment
Email from B. Varma to J. Janedis and D. Gandler re: Analyst Estimates Revisions - Post
DX099 8/12
4Q23, with attachment
Email from J. Shin to A. Horihuela re: Bridge to Profitability / Operational Metrics - Draft
DX100
for review, with attachment
Email from A. Padte to J. Janedis and A. Sternberg re: fubo Transcripts - 4Q22 and 1Q23,
DX101
with attachments
Email from A. Horihuela to Y. Wang re: INPUT NEEDED // Re: WBD | Max | NBA
DX102
Playoffs | 4/16-6/3 | FuboTV |RFP
Email from A. Horihuela to I. Josephson, et al. re: Subscriber Pacing [Feb, 2024], with
DX103
attachment
DX104 Email from Y. Wang to A. Horihuela re: Fubo <> Antenna Follow Up
DX105 Email from B. Grad to A. Horihuela re: The state of things
Email from A. Horihula to D. Gandler re: Bridge to Profitability / Operational Metrics -
DX106
Draft for review, with attachment
Email from D. Gandler to M. Berkley and A. Horihuela re: CBS streaming 30 fps issue for
DX107 Hearsay; 403
2+ years
DX108 Email from D. Gandler to A. Horihuela re: B&T Budget for 2023
DX109 Email from J. Blanc to A. Horihuela re: Risk Mitigation on the Path to Profitability Hearsay
Email from A. Horihuela to Fubo Management re: Risk Mitigation on the Path to
DX110
Profitability
Email from A. Horihuela to Y. Wang re: Offsite Pre-Read - This is misleading since we
DX111
don't eve...
33
Case 1:24-cv-01363-MMG Document 292 Filed 08/16/24 Page 36 of 41
fuboTV Inc., et al. v. The Walt Disney Company, et al.
Civil Action No. 1:24-cv-1363
Admitted Exhibit List
Exhibit Authenticity Admissibility Date Date
Description
Number1 Objection Objection Identified Admitted
Email from Y. Wang to C. Savio and C. Voight re: Mariners & Fubo Followup, with
DX112 602
attachment
DX113 Email from B. Grad to A. Horihuela re: Risk Mitigation on the Path to Profitability
DX114 Email from J. Sweetwood to B. Grad re: Freemium Offsite Deck, with attachment
Research Report Topic: OTT & Sports: Services and Strategies for Growth Industry
DX115 901/902 Hearsay; 602
Report
DX116 SVP Strategic Partnerships Press Release
DX117 Instant Messages, April 6, 2024 8/12
DX118 Instant Messages, July 13, 2023
DX119 Instant Messages, January 10, 2024 8/8
DX120 Instant Messages, May 18, 2023
DX121 Instant Messages, February 26, 2024
DX122 Instant Messages, May 5, 2023
DX123 Instant Messages, May 22, 2023
DX124 Instant Messages, August 18, 2023 8/8
DX125 Instant Messages, August 1, 2023
DX126 Instant Messages, December 20, 2023
DX127 Instant Messages, January 3, 2024
DX128 Instant Messages, April 25, 2024
DX129 Instant Messages, April 24, 2023
DX130 Instant Messages, February 6, 2024
DX131 Instant Messages, February 19, 2024 8/7
DX132 Instant Messages, April 12, 2024
DX133 Fubo Content Overview Deck 8/6
DX134 Fubo 2023-Present Content Overview Excel Spreadsheet
DX135 Offsite Pre-Read: What’s Next?
DX136 Fubo Board Meeting Slide Deck
DX137 NBCUniversal Distribution Agreement
34
Case 1:24-cv-01363-MMG Document 292 Filed 08/16/24 Page 37 of 41
fuboTV Inc., et al. v. The Walt Disney Company, et al.
Civil Action No. 1:24-cv-1363
Admitted Exhibit List
Exhibit Authenticity Admissibility Date Date
Description
Number1 Objection Objection Identified Admitted
DX138 Charge!/TBD/The Nest - Fubo Binding Term Sheet
DX139 YES Network/Fubo Term Sheet
DX140 POP Network Digital Simulcast Agreement "POP Network OTT and VOD Agreement" 8/12
DX141 CBS Sports Network Digital Simulcast Agreement
DX142 Smithsonian Networks Service Agreement for Internet Distribution 8/12
DX143 Viacom Media Networks/fuboTV Binding Term Sheet 8/7
DX144 Distribution Agreement
DX145 Ninth Amendment to Distribution Agreement (TelevisaUnivision)
DX146 Thirteenth Amendment to Distribution Agreement (TelevisaUnivision) 8/12
DX147 Letter from E. McIlvain to B. Grad re: Over-the-top distribution terms 8/7
DX148 Second Amendment to Amended and Restated Letter Agreement 8/7
DX149 Content Distribution Agreement between FuboTV, Inc. and Newsmax Broadcasting, LLC
Email from A. Horihuela to Fubo General Assembly re: The state of things, with
DX150
attachment
DX151 Email from E. Gerson to A. Horihuela re: NBC/turner
DX152 Email from P. O'Connell to T. Mathers re: Disney open issues list
DX153 Email from T. Mathers to A. Horihuela, et al. re: NBC/turner
DX154 Email from A. Horihuela to T. Mathers re: NBC/turner strategy
DX155 Email from A. Horihuela to D. Gandler re: Sorry for length... 8/8
Email from WBD Affiliate Relations to T. Mathers re: Notice of Extension Option, with
DX156 8/9
attachment
DX157 Email from T. Mathers to A. Horihuela re: NBC/turner strategy
Email from A. Horihuela to T. Mathers re: Presentation shared with you: "Offsite", with
DX158
attachment
DX159 Email from T. Mathers to D. Gandler, et al. re: Revised Disney Draft, with attachments 8/7
DX160 Email from T. Mathers to G. Sheldon re: Revised Disney Agreement, with attachments
DX161 Affiliate Agreement with Turner Network Sales, Inc. 8/6
DX162 Email from S. Miller to T. Mathers re: Proposed WBD Term Sheet Hearsay
35
Case 1:24-cv-01363-MMG Document 292 Filed 08/16/24 Page 38 of 41
fuboTV Inc., et al. v. The Walt Disney Company, et al.
Civil Action No. 1:24-cv-1363
Admitted Exhibit List
Exhibit Authenticity Admissibility Date Date
Description
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.