Opinion

Brink v. County of San Diego

Court
District Court, S.D. California
Filed
Jul 3, 2024
Cited by
0 cases
Authority
More cited than 31.3%

dismissal without leave to amend is proper only when it is clear “the 16 complaint could not be saved by any amendment”

How later courts described this case

  • dismissal without leave to amend is proper only when it is clear “the 16 complaint could not be saved by any amendment”
  • plaintiff “must set forth specific facts as to each individual 27 defendant's” wrongdoing
  • “[m]entioning an argument ‘in the most skeletal way, 19 leaving the court to do counsel's work, create the ossature for the argument, and put flesh 20 on its bones’ is tantamount to failing to raise it.”
  • the ADA is not 27 violated by prison's failure to attend to medical needs of disabled prisoners

Written by the judges who cited it.

The opinion

1

2

3

4

5

6

7 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

8 SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

9 Case No.: 23cv1756 DMS (SBC)

JEREMY BRINK,

10 Plaintiff, ORDER RE: DEFENDANT’S

11 v. MOTION TO DISMISS

PLAINTIFF’S FIRST AMENDED

12 COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO; DOE

COMPLAINT

SHERIFF'S DEPUTIES 1-5, Individually;

13

DOE SHERIFF'S NURSES 6-10,

14 Individually; and DOES 11-15,

Individually, Inclusive

15

Defendants.

16

17 Pending before the Court is Defendant San Diego County’s (“Defendant” or “the

18 County”) motion to dismiss, (ECF No. 7), Plaintiff Jeremy Brink’s First Amended

19 Complaint, ((“FAC”), ECF No. 6), for failure to state a claim under Federal Rule of Civil

20 Procedure Rule 12(b)(6). Plaintiff filed a response in opposition, (ECF No. 10), and

21 Defendant filed a reply. (ECF No. 12.) For the reasons set forth below, the Court grants

22 in part and denies in part Defendant’s motion to dismiss.

23 I. BACKGROUND

24 In July 2022, the San Diego County Sheriff’s Department arrested Plaintiff for a

25 felony warrant and parole violation and detained him at the Vista Detention Facility.

26 Plaintiff alleges that, while detained, in early August he was exposed to Covid-19 and

27 exhibited Covid related symptoms. (FAC ¶ 2.) Subsequently, on August 13, Plaintiff

28 submitted a medical request form seeking testing and treatment for his Covid-19

1 symptoms. (Id.) The next day Plaintiff informed a Doe nurse (“Nurse One”) that he had

2 been exposed to Covid-19 and was exhibiting symptoms. (Id. ¶ 3.) She recorded Plaintiff’s

3 temperature as 102.1 degrees Fahrenheit, yet Nurse One did not test Plaintiff for Covid-19

4 or implement quarantine procedures. (Id. ¶¶ 3–4.) Over the next two days Plaintiff’s

5 Covid-19 symptoms worsened. (Id. ¶ 4.) And during those two days Plaintiff submitted

6 two more medical request forms requesting treatment. (Id.) Both requests were ignored.

7 (Id.)

8 Then, on August 18, 2022, Plaintiff was transported to court for a hearing. (Id. ¶ 5.)

9 Later that day he was excused from court and taken to a court holding cell. (Id.) While in

10 the holding cell he asked every deputy that came into the holding area for help, told several

11 about his illness and symptoms, and asked several for medical intervention. (Id. ¶ 5–6.)

12 But each deputy declined to act on his requests for help. (Id.) Eventually a deputy

13 (“Deputy One”) escorted Plaintiff back to his cell. (Id. ¶ 6.) Plaintiff told Deputy One that

14 he felt faint, feverish, too weak to walk, and asked to go to medical first for treatment. (Id.)

15 Yet, Deputy One denied Plaintiff’s request. (Id.) Then, on the way to his cell, while

16 walking upstairs, he fainted, fell to ground, and remained unconscious. (Id. ¶¶ 6–7.)

17 Plaintiff awoke in the hospital with little to no feeling below his waist. (Id. ¶ 8.)

18 The hospital diagnosed him with Covid-19 and Guillain-Bare Syndrome (“GBS”).1 (Id. ¶

19 9.) Plaintiff alleges that his GBS was a direct result from his untreated Covid-19 infection.

20 (Id.) His fall, also caused by his GBS, herniated two disks in his back. (Id.) To treat his

21 GBS he received intravenous immunoglobulin treatment for eight days. (Id. ¶ 9.) Upon

22 discharge the hospital prescribed Plaintiff a wheelchair because he could not walk. (Id. ¶

23

24

25

1 According to the Mayo Clinic, GBS is a “rare disorder in which your body's immune system attacks

your nerves. Weakness and tingling in your hands and feet are usually the first symptoms.” Guillain-Barre

26 syndrome, Mayo Clinic, https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/guillain-barre-

syndrome/diagnosis-treatment/drc-20363006 (last visited June 20, 2024). “As Guillain-Barre syndrome

27 progresses, muscle weakness can turn into paralysis.” Id. Other symptoms or complications can also

occur. See id.; see also (FAC ¶¶ 9, 41) (citing the Mayo Clinic to provide information about GBS).

28

1 11.) It also issued discharge instructions for Plaintiff’s ongoing GBS treatment: a

2 neurology consult within 24-hours and physical therapy. (Id.)

3 When Plaintiff returned to jail, he did not receive the care that the hospital prescribed

4 or an ADA compliant cell for his wheelchair. (Id. ¶¶ 11–12.) A Doe nurse (“Nurse Two”)

5 knew about the hospital’s discharge order and Plaintiff’s care information but did not

6 ensure that Plaintiff received a neurology consult or physical therapy. (Id. ¶ 11.) And a

7 classification deputy2 (“Deputy Two”) that knew of Plaintiff’s medical condition did not

8 house him in an ADA or a wheelchair compliant cell. (Id. ¶ 12.) Plaintiff alleges that the

9 inadequate care prolonged and worsened his GBS symptoms. (Id. ¶ 11.)

10 Then, on August 27, 2022, Plaintiff tried to move himself from his cell’s toilet to his

11 wheelchair. (Id. ¶ 13.) During the move he fell, hitting his head on a table and reinjuring

12 his back. (Id.) Plaintiff alleges that he fell because his cell was not ADA compliant. (Id.)

13 His cellmate and other inmates called for help, (id. ¶¶ 13–14), and after 45-minutes deputies

14 responded and transferred Plaintiff to the hospital. (Id. ¶ 14.) Due to the fall Plaintiff lost

15 a tooth, fractured a vertebra, and suffered from a concussion. (Id.) Moreover, following

16 these events he was paralyzed from the waist down for eight months, required a wheelchair

17 for mobility, and had trouble using his legs. (Id. ¶¶ 15–16.)

18 In September 2023 Plaintiff sued the County of San Diego and 15 Doe Defendants

19 (collectively “Defendants”). (ECF No. 1.) Following a status conference, (ECF No. 5),

20 Plaintiff filed his FAC on January 4, 2024. (ECF No. 6.) The FAC alleges five causes of

21 action under:

22 1) 42 U.S.C. § 1983 for violation of the Fourteenth Amendment against

Doe Sheriff’s Deputies 1-5 and Doe Sheriff’s Nurses 6-10. (FAC ¶¶ 27–52.)

23

24

25

26

2 Per the complaint a classification deputy is responsible for classifying and housing all inmates, especially

27 those requiring medical accommodations, and is trained to house inmates with wheelchairs in ADA

compliant cells. (ECF No. 6 ¶ 12.)

28

1 2) California Government Code Section 52.1 (also known as the Bane

Act), against Doe Sheriff’s Deputies 1-5, Doe Sheriff’s Nurses 6-10, and San Diego

2

County. (Id. ¶¶ 53–64.)

3

3) The Americans with Disabilities Act (“ADA”), against all Doe

4

Defendants. (Id. ¶¶65–78.)

5

4) Common law negligence and California Government Code §§ 815.2

6

and 845.6, against all Doe Defendants and San Deigo County. (Id. ¶¶ 79–86.)

7

5) The Rehabilitation Act (“RA”), against all Doe Defendants. (Id. ¶¶87–

8

100.)

9

10 Defendants then filed a motion to dismiss, arguing that the FAC fails to state a claim upon

11 which relief can be granted. (ECF No. 7.) Plaintiff responded in opposition, (ECF No.

12 10), and Defendants replied, (ECF No. 12.) This Court vacated oral argument and took the

13 matter under submission on February 26, 2024. (ECF No. 13.)

14 II. LEGAL STANDARD

15 A. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(6).

16 A party may file a motion to dismiss on the grounds that a complaint “fail[s] to state

17 a claim upon which relief can be granted.” Fed. R. Civ. P. 12(b)(6). To survive a motion

18 to dismiss, “a complaint must contain sufficient factual matter, accepted as true, to ‘state a

19 claim to relief that is plausible on its face.’” Ashcroft v. Iqbal, 556 U.S. 662, 678 (2009)

20 (quoting Bell Atl. Corp. v. Twombly, 550 U.S. 544, 570 (2007)). “A claim has facial

21 plausibility when the plaintiff pleads factual content that allows the court to draw the

22 reasonable inference that the defendant is liable for the misconduct alleged.” Id.

23 “Determining whether a complaint states a plausible claim for relief will . . . be a context-

24 specific task that requires the reviewing court to draw on its judicial experience and

25 common sense.” Id. at 679. “Factual allegations must be enough to raise a right to relief

26 above the speculative level.” Twombly, 550 U.S. at 555. If Plaintiff “ha[s] not nudged”

27 her “claims across the line from conceivable to plausible,” then the complaint “must be

28 dismissed.” Id. at 570.

1 In reviewing the plausibility of a complaint on a motion to dismiss, a court must

2 “accept factual allegations in the complaint as true and construe the pleadings in the light

3 most favorable to the nonmoving party.” Manzarek v. St. Paul Fire & Marine Ins. Co.,

4 519 F.3d 1025, 1031 (9th Cir. 2008). But courts are not “required to accept as true

5 allegations that are merely conclusory, unwarranted deductions of fact, or unreasonable

6 inferences.” In re Gilead Scis. Secs. Litig., 536 F.3d 1049, 1055 (9th Cir. 2008) (quoting

7 Sprewell v. Golden State Warriors, 266 F.3d 979, 988 (9th Cir. 2001)).

8 When a court grants a motion to dismiss a complaint, it must then decide whether to

9 grant leave to amend. Leave to amend should be “freely given” where there is no (1)

10 “undue delay,” (2) “bad faith or dilatory motive,” (3) “undue prejudice to the opposing

11 party” if amendment were allowed, or (4) “futility” in allowing amendment. Foman v.

12 Davis, 371 U.S. 178, 182 (1962). Dismissal without leave to amend is proper only if it is

13 clear that “the complaint could not be saved by any amendment.” Intri-Plex Techs. v. Crest

14 Grp, Inc., 499 F.3d 1048, 1056 (9th Cir. 2007).

15 B. Pleading Standard for “Doe” Defendants.

16 “[W]hen a plaintiff has claims against an unknown defendant, the plaintiff must still

17 meet federal pleading standards when alleging facts against such defendants” in federal

18 court. Lomeli v. Cty. of San Diego, 637 F. Supp. 3d 1046, 1058 (S.D. Cal. 2022). A

19 complaint must contain “a short and plain statement of the claim showing that the pleader

20 is entitled to relief.” Fed. R. Civ. P. 8(a)(2). Plaintiffs “may refer to unknown defendants

21 as ‘Does’” at the pleading stage but Rule 8 nevertheless requires a plaintiff to “‘allege

22 specific facts showing how each particular doe defendant violated’” the plaintiff's rights.

23 Thomas ex rel. Thomas v. Cty. of San Diego, No. 20-cv-1979-CAB, 2021 WL 2715086, at

24 *3 (S.D. Cal. July 1, 2021) (quoting Keavney v. Cty. of San Diego, No. 19-cv-1947-AJB,

25 2020 WL 4192286, at *4 (S.D. Cal. July 21, 2020)); see Leer v. Murphy, 844 F.2d 628,

26 634 (9th Cir. 1988) (plaintiff “must set forth specific facts as to each individual

27 defendant's” wrongdoing). A district court should dismiss claims against Doe defendants

28 in a Section 1983 suit when the complaint does not “even minimally explain how any of

1 the unidentified parties . . . personally caused a violation of [the claimant's] constitutional

2 rights.” Estate of Serna v. Cty. of San Diego, No. 20-cv-2096-LAB, 2022 WL 827123, at

3 *3 (S.D. Cal. Mar. 18, 2022).

4 III. DISCUSSION

5 Defendants raise several arguments that the FAC should be dismissed. For the

6 reasons explained below, the Court holds that: (A) the FAC states a Section 1983 claim

7 against Nurse One, Nurse Two, Deputy One, and Deputy Two; (B) the Doe Defendants are

8 not entitled to qualified immunity; (C) the FAC states a Bane Act claim against the County

9 and some of the Doe Defendants; (D) the FAC does not state claims under the ADA or RA;

10 (E) the FAC states a negligence claim against Defendants; and (F) the FAC fails to allege

11 any claims against Doe Defendants 11–15.

12 A. Count 1: Section 1983 Individual Capacity Claims.

13 Plaintiff sued the Doe Defendants under Section 1983 and the Fourteenth

14 Amendment. He alleges that, while he was a pretrial detainee in county custody,

15 Defendants violated his Fourteenth Amendment right to adequate medical care. (FAC ¶¶

16 21, 28.) “Individuals in state custody have a constitutional right to adequate medical

17 treatment.” Sandoval v. Cty. of San Diego, 985 F.3d 657, 667 (9th Cir. 2021) (citing Estelle

18 v. Gamble, 429 U.S. 97, 104–05 (1976)). And for pretrial detainees, this right arises under

19 the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. Id. (citing Bell v. Wolfish, 441 U.S.

20 520, 535–36 (1979)). When a pretrial detainee alleges that they received deficient medical

21 care under the Fourteenth Amendment the Ninth Circuit applies an “objective deliberate

22 indifference” standard. Gordon v. County of Orange (Gordon I), 888 F.3d 1118, 1124–25

23 (9th Cir. 2018). Under this standard, pretrial detainees alleging that jail officials failed to

24 provide constitutionally adequate medical care must show:

25 (1) The defendant made an intentional decision with respect to

the conditions under which the plaintiff was confined

26

[including a decision with respect to medical treatment];

27

(2) Those conditions put the plaintiff at substantial risk of

28 suffering serious harm;

1 (3) The defendant did not take reasonable available measures to

abate that risk, even though a reasonable official in the

2

circumstances would have appreciated the high degree of risk

3 involved—making the consequences of the defendant's

conduct obvious; and

4

(4) By not taking such measures, the defendant caused the

5

plaintiff's injuries.

6

7 Sandoval, 985 F.3d at 669 (quoting Gordon I, 888 F.3d at 1125) (alteration in original).

8 “To satisfy the third element, the plaintiff must show that the defendant's actions were

9 ‘objectively unreasonable,’ which requires a showing of ‘more than negligence but less

10 than subjective intent—something akin to reckless disregard.’” Id. (quoting Gordon I, 888

11 F.3d at 1125). For the reasons explained, the Court finds that the FAC states a claim against

12 Nurse One, Nurse Two, Deputy One, and Deputy Two.

13 Nurse One and Nurse Two. The FAC alleges that Nurse One knew Plaintiff had

14 Covid symptoms and did not treat him according to protocol, creating a substantial risk of

15 injury. (FAC ¶¶ 31–34.) Moreover, Plaintiff’s symptoms worsened over the next few days

16 because of Nurse one’s decision, causing further injuries. (Id. ¶¶ 35–36.) Taken together,

17 the FAC satisfies the Gordon standard as to Nurse One: it plausibly alleges that Nurse One

18 intentionally decided not to provide medical care to Plaintiff, (id. ¶¶ 2–4, 35), that Nurse

19 One’s intentional decision placed Plaintiff at substantial risk of further harm, (id. ¶¶ 32–

20 33), that Nurse One did not take action to abate that risk even though there were reasonable

21 available measures to abate that risk, (id. ¶ 35), and that Nurse One’s failure to provide

22 treatment caused Plaintiff further injuries, (id. ¶¶ 36, 41–43).

23 Similarly, the FAC alleges that following Plaintiff’s first fall Nurse Two knew about

24 his Covid-19; but did not treat Plaintiff according to protocol. (Id. ¶¶ 31–32.) Nurse Two

25 also knew of the hospital’s discharge instructions for physical therapy and a neurology

26 consult. (Id. ¶ 11.) Yet Nurse Two did not ensure Plaintiff received such care. (Id. ¶¶ 11–

27 12, 45–46.) The FAC alleges that Nurse Two failed to house Plaintiff in a wheelchair

28 compliant cell, (id. ¶ 46), and that Nurse Two’s failure to provide adequate treatment

1 exacerbated Plaintiff’s injuries. (Id. ¶ 45–47.) Like the allegations against Nurse One,

2 these allegations against Nurse Two satisfy the Gordon standard.

3 Additionally, the allegations against Nurse One and Nurse Two are like other cases

4 that have survived pleading challenges. See Est. of Schuck v. Cty. of San Diego, No. 23-

5 CV-785-DMS-AHG, 2024 WL 500711, at *6 (S.D. Cal. Feb. 8, 2024) (plaintiff plausibly

6 alleged that medical provider provided inadequate medical care when he ignored plaintiff’s

7 deteriorating health) (“Schuck”); Greer v. Cty. of San Diego, No. 3:19-CV-0378-GPC-

8 AGS, 2021 WL 615046, at *5 (S.D. Cal. Feb. 17, 2021) (reasonable jury could conclude

9 that the nurse provided inadequate medical care when she failed to follow seizure protocol

10 and provide care for plaintiff with seizure disorder). Thus, the FAC’s allegations against

11 Nurse One and Nurse Two are plausible at this stage.

12 Deputy One. The FAC alleges that Deputy One knew Plaintiff was feeling faint

13 and feverish, and that Deputy One escorted Plaintiff to the housing unit rather than

14 medical—intentionally denying him medical treatment. (Id. ¶ 6.) The FAC also alleges

15 that the decision to deny him medical treatment further caused Plaintiff’s GBS and fall.

16 (Id. ¶ 43.) Altogether, the FAC satisfies the Gordon standard with respect to Deputy One:

17 He made an intentional decision by exhibiting “deliberate indifference to his serious

18 medical need.” Greer, 2021 WL 615046, at *5. And the decision not to refer Plaintiff for

19 further medical care put him at “‘at substantial risk of suffering’ the medical

20 complications” which led to his subsequent injuries. Schuck, 2024 WL 500711, at *7. As

21 a result, the allegations against Deputy One are plausible at this stage.

22 Deputy Two. Likewise, the FAC alleges that Deputy Two knew of Plaintiff’s

23 condition and that he required a wheelchair but did not assign him to a wheelchair

24 compliant cell. (Id. ¶ 12.) It further alleges that, as noted above, the failure to assign him

25 a wheelchair compliant cell contributed to his second fall. (Id. ¶¶ 46–47.) These

26 allegations satisfy the Gordon standard against Deputy Two. See Greer, 2021 WL 615046,

27 at *5 (plaintiff stated a claim against a deputy by failing to provide reasonable cell

28

1 accommodations to disabled inmate). Deputy Two’s decision not to assign Plaintiff to an

2 ADA compliant cell satisfies the deliberate indifference standard.

3 The remaining Doe Defendants. However, the FAC does not state a Section 1983

4 claim against the other Doe Defendants. In federal court, a plaintiff must “‘allege specific

5 facts showing how each particular doe defendant violated’” the plaintiff’s rights. Thomas

6 ex rel. Thomas, 2021 WL 2715086, at *3 (quoting Keavney v. Cty. of San Diego, No. 19-

7 cv-1947-AJB, 2020 WL 4192286, at *4 (S.D. Cal. July 21, 2020)). The FAC does not

8 explain how the remaining Doe Defendants contributed to Plaintiff’s injuries. Similarly,

9 the allegations against the remaining Doe deputies are too generalized to show how each

10 Doe violated Plaintiff’s rights. Consequently, the FAC fails to state a Section 1983 claim

11 against the remaining Doe Defendants.

12 In sum, the Court grants in part and denies in part Defendants’ motion to dismiss the

13 Section 1983 claim against Does 1–10. The Court dismisses, with leave to amend, all but

14 Nurse One, Nurse Two, Deputy One, and Deputy Two from the first count. See Intri-Plex,

15 499 F.3d at 1056 (dismissal without leave to amend is proper only when it is clear “the

16 complaint could not be saved by any amendment”).

17 B. Qualified Immunity.

18 Defendants assert they have qualified immunity, and so the Section 1983 claims

19 against them must be dismissed. At this stage of the proceedings, the Court declines to

20 find that Defendants have qualified immunity. Qualified immunity is an affirmative

21 defense that must be raised by a defendant. O’Brien v. Welty, 818 F.3d 920, 936 (9th Cir.

22 2016). It shields government officials from liability for civil damages, (Sabra v. Maricopa

23 Cty. Cmty. Coll. Dist., 44 F.4th 867, 886 (9th Cir. 2022)), but only if the official is

24 performing discretionary functions and “their conduct does not violate clearly established

25 statutory or constitutional rights of which a reasonable person would have known.” Id. To

26 determine whether a state official is entitled to qualified immunity, the Court must

27 consider: (1) “whether the evidence viewed in the light most favorable to the plaintiff is

28 sufficient to show a violation of a constitutional right”; and (2) “whether that right was

1 clearly established at the time of the violation.” Sandoval, 985 F.3d at 671. Additionally,

2 if a defendant asserts qualified immunity in a motion to dismiss then “dismissal is not

3 appropriate unless [the court] can determine, based on the complaint itself, that qualified

4 immunity applies.” O’Brien, 818 F.3d at 936 (internal quotation marks omitted). Plaintiff

5 fails to meet this burden.

6 As explained above, the FAC plausibly alleges that Nurse One, Nurse Two, Deputy

7 One, and Deputy Two violated Plaintiff’s Fourteenth Amendment Right to adequate

8 medical care. And so, the Court must turn to the second qualified immunity prong—

9 whether that right was “clearly established at the time of the violation.” Pauluk v. Savage,

10 836 F.3d 1117, 1125 (9th Cir. 2016) (quoting Espinosa v. City & Cty. of San Francisco,

11 598 F.3d 528, 532 (9th Cir. 2010)). The unlawfulness of an officer’s conduct is “clearly

12 established,” when, “at the time of the officer's conduct, the law was ‘sufficiently clear that

13 every reasonable official would understand that what he [wa]s doing’ [wa]s unlawful.”

14 District of Columbia v. Wesby, 583 U.S. 48 (2018). “In other words, existing law must

15 place the [un]constitutionality of the officer's conduct ‘beyond debate.’” Id. If not, then

16 the officers are entitled to qualified immunity. See id.

17 The Fourteenth Amendment right to medical care was clearly established at the time

18 of the violation. In 2021, the Ninth Circuit held that “a prison official who is aware that

19 an inmate is suffering from a serious acute medical condition violates the Constitution

20 when he stands idly by rather than responding with reasonable diligence to treat the

21 condition.” Sandoval, 985 F.3d at 680; see also id. at 667 (“Individuals in state custody

22 have a constitutional right to adequate medical treatment.”). As alleged, Doe Defendants

23 knew Plaintiff had Covid-19 and GBS but declined to provide treatment or other

24 accommodations. For example, Nurse One knew Plaintiff had Covid-19 symptoms but did

25 not initiate care or Covid protocols. (FAC ¶ 4.) Similarly, Deputy One knew that Plaintiff

26 had Covid-19 and declined to treat his condition. (Id. ¶ 6–7.) Likewise, Nurse Two and

27 Deputy Two allegedly knew Plaintiff was disabled from GBS yet declined to treat him or

28 arrange for appropriate housing. (Id. ¶¶ 11–13.) Plaintiff plausibly alleges Defendants

1 stood by without reasonably responding to treat him from a known medical condition.

2 Those allegations are sufficient to withstand Defendants’ qualified immunity challenge at

3 this stage of the proceedings.

4 Defendants argue that Plaintiff cannot satisfy the clearly established prong because

5 he “must identify a case where an individual plaintiff presented with symptoms of COVID-

6 19, and the individual’s condition worsened due to jail staff’s failure to do some

7 unspecified act.” (ECF No. 7-1 at 16.) In addition, Defendants argue Sandoval does not

8 govern because “‘clearly established law’ must be ‘particularized’ to the facts of the case

9 rather than ‘defined at a high level of generality.’” (ECF No. 12 at 4) (citing White v.

10 Pauly, 137 S. Ct. 548, 552 (2017)). But those arguments are unpersuasive. The Supreme

11 Court does not require “a case directly on point for a right to be clearly established.” White,

12 580 U.S. at 79 (cleaned up). Moreover, general statements are capable “of giving fair and

13 clear warning to officers.” White, 137 S. Ct. at 552 (internal quotations omitted); see also

14 Polanco v. Diaz, 76 F.4th 918, 931 (9th Cir. 2023) (“COVID-19 may have been

15 unprecedented, but the legal theory that Plaintiffs assert is not.”). It is true that Sandoval

16 does not expressly address the facts presented here. However, Sandoval’s general holding

17 places the constitutional issue beyond debate: when a prison official knows a prisoner is

18 suffering from a serious acute medical condition, the official must treat the condition with

19 reasonable diligence. Sandoval, 985 F.3d at 680. That is what Plaintiff has alleged here.

20 (FAC ¶¶ 27–52.) As a result, Nurse One, Nurse Two, Deputy One, and Deputy Two do

21 not have qualified immunity.

22 C. Count 2: The Bane Act.

23 The FAC alleges that Defendants are liable under California Civil Code section 52.1,

24 codified as the Bane Act. Defendants make two arguments that the Bane Act claims should

25 be dismissed: First, that the FAC does not claim the Doe Defendants acted with specific

26 intent, an element of Bane Act liability; second, that the County cannot be sued, or is

27 immune, under the Bane Act. For the reasons below, the Court does not agree with

28 Defendants’ arguments.

1 1. The Bane Act claims against the Doe Defendants.

2 “The essence of a Bane Act claim is that the defendant, by the specified improper

3 means (i.e., ‘threats, intimidation or coercion’), tried to or did prevent the plaintiff from

4 doing something he or she had the right to do under the law . . . .” Cornell v. City and

5 County of San Francisco, 17 Cal. App. 5th 766, 791 (2017) (quoting Cal. Civ. Code §

6 52.1). Violations of federal constitutional and statutory rights are all cognizable under the

7 Bane Act. See Cal. Civ. Code § 52.1(b). “The elements of a Bane Act claim are essentially

8 identical to the elements of a § 1983 claim, with the added requirement that the government

9 official had a “specific intent to violate” a constitutional right.” Hughes v. Rodriguez, 31

10 F.4th 1211, 1224 (9th Cir. 2022). The Court has already determined that the FAC states a

11 Section 1983 claim against Nurse One, Nurse Two, Deputy One, and Deputy Two. So, if

12 they acted with specific intent, then the Bane Act Claim against them will survive.

13 To show specific intent, a plaintiff must satisfy two requirements. First, the right at

14 issue must be “clearly delineated and plainly applicable under the circumstances of the

15 case[.]” Cornell, 17 Cal. App. 5th at 803. Second, the defendant must have “commit[ted]

16 the act in question with the particular purpose of depriving” the victim of his enjoyment of

17 the interests protected by that right. Id. The specific intent requirement “is satisfied where

18 the defendant . . . acted with ‘[r]eckless disregard of the right at issue.’” Est. of Serna v.

19 Cty. of San Diego, No. 20CV2096-LAB-MSB, 2022 WL 827123, at *8 (S.D. Cal. Mar. 18,

20 2022) (alteration in original).

21 The FAC satisfies both inquiries. First, as explained above, the right to adequate

22 medical care under the Fourteenth Amendment is clearly delineated and plainly applicable

23 under the circumstances of this case. See Sandoval, 985 F.3d at 667, 680; Gordon I, 888

24 F.3d at 1125. Second, the FAC alleges that Nurse One, Nurse Two, Deputy One, and

25 Deputy Two “acted with the specific intent of denying Plaintiff much needed medical care

26 despite knowing he was in severe medical distress.” (FAC ¶ 59). It further alleges facts

27 to support that claim. (Id. ¶¶ 53, 56–58) (alleging that Nurse One knew Plaintiff had Covid

28 symptoms and failed to treat him, that Nurse Two intentionally denied Plaintiff care for his

1 GBS symptoms, and that Deputy One and Deputy Two failed to summon medical care

2 despite Plaintiff’s obvious medical distress). As noted, under the Bane Act, “[r]eckless

3 disregard of the ‘right at issue’ is all that [i]s necessary.” Cornell, 17 Cal. App. 5th at 803.

4 In the Section 1983 context, a claim under the objective deliberate indifference standard is

5 akin to showing reckless disregard. See Sandoval, 985 F.3d at 669 (“[T]he plaintiff must

6 show that the defendant’s actions were objectively unreasonable, which requires a showing

7 of . . . something akin to reckless disregard”) (internal quotations omitted). Here, as set

8 forth above, the Court has determined that the FAC alleges a claim under the objective

9 deliberate indifference standard regarding Plaintiff’s right to adequate medical care. (See,

10 e.g., FAC ¶¶ 27–52.) Thus, the FAC states a Bane Act claim against Nurse One, Nurse

11 Two, Deputy One, and Deputy Two.3

12 2. The FAC states a Bane Act claim against the County.

13 Defendants also argue that the Bane Act claims against the County must be

14 dismissed for two reasons. First, Defendants argue that the County cannot be sued directly

15 under the Bane Act. (ECF No. 7-1 at 17.) However, the Bane Act “allows for vicarious

16 liability of public entities based on the acts or omissions of employees.” Astorga v. Cty. of

17 San Diego, No. 3:21-cv-00463, 2022 WL 1556164, at *3 (S.D. Cal. May 17, 2022); Cal.

18 Gov't Code § 815.2 (“A public entity is liable for injury proximately caused by an act or

19 omission of an employee of the public entity within the scope of his employment if the act

20 or omission would, apart from this section, have given rise to a cause of action against that

21 employee or his personal representative.”) The FAC alleges that the County is vicariously

22 liable under the Bane Act for the Doe Defendants’ acts. (FAC ¶ 63.) The FAC cites section

23 815.2 of the California Government Code as the basis for vicarious liability. (Id. ¶ 82);

24

25

26 3 For the reasons explained above, the FAC does not state a Section 1983 claim against the remaining Doe

Defendants. Therefore, the FAC does not state a Bane Act claim against the remaining Doe Defendants.

27

28

1 Astorga, No. 3:21-cv-00463, 2022 WL 1556164, at *4. As a result, reading the FAC in the

2 light most favorable to Plaintiff, Defendants’ first argument opposing the Bane Act claim

3 against the County fails.

4 Second, Defendants argue that the County is “immune from the Bane Act Claim

5 under California Government Code Section 844.6.” (ECF No. 7-1 at 17.) It is true that

6 under Section 844.6 “[a] public entity is not liable for an injury to any prisoner.” Cal. Gov't

7 Code § 844.6(a)(2) (emphasis added). Yet, the analysis does not end there. Section 844.6

8 further provides that “[n]othing in this section exonerates a public employee from liability

9 for injury proximately caused by his negligent or wrongful act or omission.” Id. § 844.6(d)

10 (emphasis added). And Section 845.6 further modifies that provision, stating that

11 “[n]either a public entity nor a public employee is liable for injury proximately caused by

12 the failure of the employee to furnish or obtain medical care for a prisoner in his custody.”

13 Id. § 845.6. However, Section 845.6 has another exception: “the public entity where the

14 employee is acting within the scope of his employment, is liable if the employee knows or

15 has reason to know that the prisoner is in need of immediate medical care and he fails to

16 take reasonable action to summon such medical care.” Id. (emphasis added). This statutory

17 rabbit hole can be summarized as follows:

18 (1) public entities cannot be held liable for wrongfully or

negligently injuring prisoners but public employees can be;

19

unless (2) the prisoner's injury resulted from a failure to furnish

20 medical care (in which case, neither the public employee or

public entity are liable); except (3) when the public employee

21

knew or had reason to know that the injured prisoner was in need

22 of immediate medical care and failed to take reasonable action to

summon such medical care (in which case, both the public

23

employee and the public entity are liable).

24

25 Bousman v. Cty. of San Diego, No. 3:23-CV-1648-W-JLB, 2024 WL 1496220, at *11 (S.D.

26 Cal. Apr. 5, 2024) (internal footnotes and citations omitted).

27 Here, Section 844.6 does not require that the Bane Act claim against the County be

28 dismissed. Reading the FAC in the light most favorable to Plaintiff, the FAC alleges that

1 Nurse One failed to summon immediate medical care for Plaintiff’s Covid-19. (FAC ¶ 56.)

2 Likewise, Nurse Two failed to summon immediate medical care to mitigate Plaintiff’s

3 ongoing GBS symptoms. (Id. ¶ 57.) And Deputies One and Two failed to summon medical

4 care despite Plaintiff’s obvious symptoms. (Id. ¶ 58.) As a result, “the County is not

5 immune from the Bane Act insofar as it would be vicariously liable for Does’ alleged

6 failure to reasonably summon immediate medical care under California Government Code

7 section 845.6.” Bousman, 2024 WL 1496220, at *12.

8 In sum, the Court grants in part and denies in part Defendants’ motion with respect

9 to the Bane Act Claims. The Bane Act claims against Nurse One, Nurse Two, Deputy One,

10 and Deputy Two survive. In addition, the Bane Act claim that the County is vicariously

11 liable for those Doe Defendants survives under the theory that they knew Plaintiff needed

12 immediate medical care and failed to take reasonable action to summon such medical care.

13 However, the remaining Bane Act claims are dismissed without prejudice.

14 D. Counts 3 and 5: The ADA and Rehabilitation Act.

15 Plaintiff alleges causes of actions under the ADA and RA for failure to provide

16 reasonable accommodations. Defendants argue that the FAC does not state a claim because

17 it does not allege Plaintiff was treated differently because of his disability. For the reasons

18 below, the ADA and RA Claims should be dismissed without prejudice for failure to state

19 a claim for which relief can be granted. To state a claim under Title II of the ADA, the

20 plaintiff must allege:

21 (1) he is an individual with a disability; (2) he is otherwise qualified to

participate in or receive the benefit of some public entity's services, programs,

22

or activities; (3) he was either excluded from participation in or denied the

23 benefits of the public entity's services, programs, or activities, or was

otherwise discriminated against by the public entity; and (4) such exclusion,

24

denial of benefits, or discrimination was by reason of [his] disability.

25

26 Simmons v. Navajo Cty., Ariz., 609 F.3d 1011, 1022 (9th Cir. 2010) (the ADA is not

27 violated by prison's failure to attend to medical needs of disabled prisoners) rev’d on other

28 grounds, Castro v. Cty. of Los Angeles, 833 F.3d 1060 (9th Cir. 2016) (en banc). Similarly,

1 to state an RA claim, a plaintiff must allege: “(1) he is an individual with a disability; (2)

2 he is otherwise qualified to receive the benefit; (3) he was denied the benefits of the

3 program solely by reason of his disability; and (4) the program receives federal financial

4 assistance.” O’Guinn v. Lovelock Correctional Center, 502 F.3d 1056, 1060 (9th Cir.

5 2007). “There is no significant difference in analysis of the rights and obligations created

6 by the ADA and the Rehabilitation Act.” Zukle v. Regents of Univ. of Calif., 166 F.3d

7 1041, 1045 and n.11 (9th Cir. 1999).

8 Here, the FAC does not state an ADA or RA claim because it does not allege that

9 Plaintiff was discriminated against because of his disability. See Pierce v. Cty. of Orange,

10 526 F.3d 1190, 1214 (9th Cir. 2008). While the FAC has other allegations regarding

11 Plaintiff’s ADA and RA claims, it does not plead sufficient facts to satisfy all required

12 elements. Specifically, it lacks the critical allegation that Plaintiff was discriminated

13 against by reason of his disability. Indeed, the FAC does allege that the Doe Nurses and

14 Doe Deputies denied him physical therapy and rendered inadequate treatment. (FAC ¶¶

15 69–71.) However, “the ADA prohibits discrimination because of disability, not inadequate

16 treatment for disability.” Simmons, 609 F.3d at 1022. At this stage, the FAC’s ADA and

17 RA claims only amount to a claim that Plaintiff received inadequate treatment for a

18 disability. While Plaintiff may have needed an ADA compliant cell, the failure to provide

19 him with one does not mean he was discriminated against. Thus, the Court dismisses

20 Plaintiff's ADA and RA claims as to all Doe Defendants without prejudice.4

21

22

23

24

4 The ADA and RA claims also appear defective for another reason: Neither Title II of the ADA nor

25 Section 504 of the RA authorizes claims against state officials in their individual capacities. See Vinson v.

Thomas, 288 F.3d 1145, 1156 (9th Cir. 2002) (holding that “a plaintiff cannot bring an action under 42

26 U.S.C. § 1983 against a State official in her individual capacity to vindicate rights created by Title II of

the ADA or section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act”). Plaintiff brought his ADA and RA claims against all

27 Doe Defendants individually. However, neither party raised this issue, so the Court does not dismiss the

ADA or RA claims for these grounds.

28

1 E. Count 4: Negligence.

2 The FAC alleges that the Doe Defendants and the County are liable for negligence

3 under a failure to summon care theory. (FAC ¶¶ 79–86.) As to the Doe Defendants, the

4 FAC alleges that they are liable for failing to summon medical care and provide proper

5 housing accommodations. (FAC ¶ 81.) And as to the County, the FAC alleges that it is

6 liable under California Government Code §§ 815.2 and 845.6 for the acts of its employees.

7 (Id. ¶¶ 82–83.) Defendants argue that they are immune from Plaintiff’s negligence claim

8 under three laws: (1) the California Government Tort Claims Act, California Government

9 Code §§ 810 et. seq.; (2) California Government Code § 844.6(a)(2); and (3) California

10 Government Code §§ 856.4, 855.4, and 855.6. Explained below, Defendants’ arguments

11 for immunity lack merit.

12 First, Defendants argue that the County is immune under California Government

13 Code § 815. (ECF No. 7-1 at 20.) Section 815 provides that a public entity is not liable for

14 injury “[e]xcept as otherwise provided by statute.” Cal. Gov’t Code § 815 (preamble). The

15 next section states that “a public entity is liable for injury proximately caused by an act or

16 omission of an employee of the public entity within the scope of his employment.” Cal.

17 Gov’t Code § 815.2(a). Indeed, the FAC alleges that the County is liable for the

18 misconduct of its employees under Section 815.2(a). (FAC ¶ 82). Simply, the County is

19 not immune under § 815 because another statute provides for liability. Feldman v. Sutton,

20 No. 22-cv-341, 2022 WL 3019936, at *9 (S.D. Cal. July 29, 2022) (“while CGC § 815

21 provides that public entities are not generally liable for injuries caused by their employees

22 unless otherwise provided by statute, see Cal. Gov. Code § 815, § 815.2 provides the

23 statutory vehicle for such municipal liability”). Thus, the Court rejects Defendants’ § 815

24 argument.

25 Second, Defendants argue that the County is immune under California Government

26 Code § 844.6(a)(2). (ECF No. 7-1 at 20.) The same argument failed under the Bane Act

27 claim, and the same reasoning applies here. Accordingly, the negligence claims can

28 “proceed against the County, insofar as it would be vicariously liable for [the Doe

1 Defendants’] alleged failure to reasonably summon immediate medical care under

2 California Government Code section 845.6.” Bousman, 2024 WL 1496220, at *12.

3 Third, Defendants argue that the County and Doe Defendants are immune under

4 California Government Code sections 856.4, 855.4, and 855.6. (ECF No. 7-1 at 21.)

5 Defendants have failed to carry their burden for this argument. Under Fed. R. Civ. P.

6 7(b)(1)(B) a movant must “state with particularity the grounds for seeking” a court order.

7 See also Levi Strauss & Co. v. Connolly, 2023 WL 2347433, at *8 (N.D. Cal. Mar. 2, 2023)

8 (“[Defendant] has not identified any pleading deficiency in [plaintiffs] claims and therefore

9 has not met his burden to show that no claim has been stated.”); Carlson v. Colorado Ctr.

10 for Reproductive Med., LLC, 2021 WL 5494273, at *3 (N.D. Cal. Nov. 23, 2021) (finding

11 that defendants’ conclusory arguments that plaintiffs’ allegations did “not amount to any

12 viable cause of action” were insufficient to satisfy their burden to show that no claim had

13 been stated). Here, Defendants have dedicated two sentences to their final immunity

14 argument: one in their opening brief, (ECF No. 7-1 at 21), and one in their reply, (ECF No.

15 12 at 5). They cite statutes that may be relevant, but do not elaborate on how those statutes

16 apply to the FAC. In other words, Defendants advance a conclusory claim that they are

17 immune. Other courts have rejected unsupported arguments. See Al-Tamimi v. Adelson,

18 916 F.3d 1, 6 (D.C. Cir. 2019) (“[m]entioning an argument ‘in the most skeletal way,

19 leaving the court to do counsel's work, create the ossature for the argument, and put flesh

20 on its bones’ is tantamount to failing to raise it.”). And so have courts in this district.

21 Rhodes v. Robinson, 399 F. App’x 160, 164 (9th Cir. 2010) (“The district court also

22 correctly disregarded Rhodes' motion for cross-summary judgment because it did not ‘state

23 with particularity the grounds for seeking the order’ as required by Federal Rule of Civil

24 Procedure 7(b)(1)(B).”); Bousman, 2024 WL 1496220, at *7 (movant did not meet its

25 burden when it did not state with particularity the grounds for their motion); Dias v.

26 Burberry Ltd., No. 21-cv-192, 2021 WL 2349730, at *10 (S.D. Cal. June 9, 2021) (“A mere

27 request for fees and costs in the table of contents without any argument is insufficient.”).

28

1 As a result, the Court declines to find that Defendants have carried their burden for their

2 final immunity argument.5

3 F. The FAC fails to allege any claims against Doe Defendants 11–15.

4 Finally, the FAC, in its pleading caption, references Doe Defendants 11–15. Upon

5 review, the FAC contains no allegations or other references to those Doe Defendants. In

6 fact, Section III of the FAC, entitled “The Parties”, describes Does 1–5 and 6–10. (FAC

7 ¶¶ 24–26.) However, neither that section nor any other part of the FAC mentions Does

8 11–15. Because there are no allegations against them, the Court dismisses any claims

9 against Does 11–15 without prejudice.

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23 5 The Court’s decision on this issue does not impact the doctrine of sovereign immunity because the

provisions that Defendants cite are defenses to liability, not immunities from suit. Hampton v. California,

24

83 F.4th 754, 772 (9th Cir. 2023) petition for cert. filed sub. nom., Diaz et al., v. Polanco et al., Dkt. No.

25 23-722 (distributed for conference). Moreover, the provisions that Defendants cite do not provide them

with immunity from Plaintiff’s negligence claim. Plaintiff alleges that Defendants are negligent under a

26 failure to summon care theory. However, the statutes that Defendants cite provide immunity for other

types of acts. See Cal. Gov't Code §§ 855.4 (failure to prevent disease), 855.6 (failure to make physical

27 examination); 856.4 (failure to admit to medical facility). Thus, Defendants’ final immunity argument

does not address Plaintiff’s theory of negligence.

28

I IV. CONCLUSION AND ORDER

2 For the reasons explained above the Court GRANTS IN PART and DENIES IN

3 || PART Defendants’ motion to dismiss the FAC. The Court ORDERS as follows:

4 (1) Count 1: The Court DENIES the motion to dismiss Nurse One, Nurse Two, Deputy

5 One, and Deputy Two from the Section 1983 individual capacity claims and

6 GRANTS the motion to dismiss as to all other Doe Defendants.

7 (2) Count 2: The Court DENIES the motion to dismiss the County, Nurse One, Nurse

8 Two, Deputy One, and Deputy Two from the Bane Act claims, and GRANTS the

9 motion to dismiss as to all other Doe Defendants.

10 (3) Count 3: The Court GRANTS the motion to dismiss all Defendants from the ADA

11 claims.

12 (4)Count 4: The Count DENIES the motion to dismiss all Defendants from the

13 negligence claims.

14 (5)Count 5: The Court GRANTS the motion to dismiss all Defendants from the RA

15 claims.

16 Within 14-days of the date of this Order, the Plaintiff may file a second amended

17 complaint which cures the pleading deficiencies identified in this Order.

18 IT IS SO ORDERED.

19 Dated: July 3, 2024 2»

20 nm Bb

>] Hon. Dana M. Sabraw, Chief Judge

United States District Court

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.