Opinion

Pecoraro v. City of New York

  • 2024 NY Slip Op 33623(U)
Court
New York Supreme Court, New York County
Filed
Oct 9, 2024
Status
Unpublished
Author
Jeanine R. Johnson
Cited by
0 cases
Authority
More cited than 30.8%

The opinion

Pecoraro v City of New York

2024 NY Slip Op 33623(U)

October 9, 2024

Supreme Court, New York County

Docket Number: Index No. 160517/2018

Judge: Jeanine R. Johnson

Cases posted with a "30000" identifier, i.e., 2013 NY Slip

Op 30001(U), are republished from various New York

State and local government sources, including the New

York State Unified Court System's eCourts Service.

This opinion is uncorrected and not selected for official

publication.

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 10/11/2024 12:10 PM INDEX NO. 160517/2018

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 142 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 10/11/2024

SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK

NEW YORK COUNTY

PRESENT: HON. JEANINE R. JOHNSON PART 52-M

Justice

-------------------X INDEX NO. 160517/2018

FRANK MARIO PECORARO,

MOTION DATE 02/27/2024

Plaintiff,

MOTION SEQ. NO. 004

-v-

THE CITY OF NEW YORK, THE CARNEGIE HALL

CORPORATION, TRANSEL ELEVATOR & ELECTRIC, INC. DECISION + ORDER ON

D/8/A TEI GROUP MOTION

Defendant.

-------------------X

The following e-filed documents, listed by NYSCEF document number (Motion 004) 114, 115, 116, 117,

118,119,120,121,122,123,124,125,126,127,129,133,134,136,139

were read on this motion to/for DISMISSAL

Upon the foregoing documents and oral argument held on 07/31/2024, Third-Party

Defendant-Transel Elevator & Electric Inc., d/b/a/ TEI Group's (hereinafter "TEI") motion for

summary judgment pursuant to CPLR §3212 against Third-Party Plaintiff-The Carnegie Hall

Corporation (hereinafter "Carnegie Hall") is granted as to the dismissal of Carnegie Hall's

breach of contract claim. The motion is denied as to Carnegie Hall's contractual and common

law indemnification claims and in all other respects.

To succeed on a motion for summary judgment, the moving party must make a prima

facie showing of entitlement to summary judgment as a matter of law by demonstrating the

absence of any material issues of fact. See generally Friends of Thayer Lake LLC v. Brown, 27

N.Y.3d 1039 (2016). Jacobsen v. New York City Health & Hosps. Corp., 22 N.Y.3d 824 (2014);

CPLR §3212(b). "If the moving party makes out a prima facie showing, the burden then shifts to

the non-moving party to establish the existence of material issues of fact which preclude

160517/2018 PECORARO, FRANK MARIO vs. CITY OF NEW YORK Page 1 of4

Motion No. 004

[* 1] 1 of 4

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 10/11/2024 12:10 PM INDEX NO. 160517/2018

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 142 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 10/11/2024

judgment as a matter oflaw." Jacobsen, 22 N.Y.3d at 833. If there are no material, triable issues

of fact, summary judgment must be granted. See Sillman v. Twentieth Century-Fox Film Corp., 3

N.Y.2d 395 (1957).

Breach of Contract Claim

TEI moves for summary judgment dismissing Carnegie Hall's breach of contract claim

for failure to procure insurance. TEI argues that pursuant to the subcontract with Carnegie Hall,

TEI was required to obtain and maintain commercial liability insurance with limits of $1,000,000

per occurrence and $2,000,000 in the aggregate. (NYSCEF Doc. No. 126). TEI asserts that it

procured sufficient insurance pursuant to its policy with First Specialty for coverage required by

its contract with Carnegie Hall. (NYSCEF Doc. No. 127). TEI contends that the subcontract was

executed prior to the accident, and it properly obtained the required insurance.

This Court finds that TEI met its prima facie burden because there is no material fact in

dispute that it procured insurance under the subcontract agreement with Carnegie Hall. TEI

sufficiently provided evidence pf the subcontract agreement and its insurance policy.

Additionally, Carnegie Hall did not oppose TEI's motion for summary judgment on this issue.

Therefore, TEI's motion for summary judgment to dismiss Carnegie Hall's breach of contract

claim for failure to procure insurance is granted without opposition.

Contractual and Common Law Indemnification Claims

"A party is entitled to full contractual indemnification [for damages incurred in a

personal injury suit] provided that the 'intention can be clearly implied from the language and

purposes of the entire agreement and the surrounding facts and circumstances."' Masciotta v.

Morse Diesel International, Inc., 303 A.D.2d 309,310 (1st Dep't 2003). Under common law

indemnification, there must be evidence that the employer "was negligent or that it exercised

160517/2018 PECORARO, FRANK MARIO vs. CITY OF NEW YORK Page2of4

Motion No. 004

[* 2] 2 of 4

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 10/11/2024 12:10 PM INDEX NO. 160517/2018

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 142 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 10/11/2024

actual supervision or control over the injury-producing work." See Balcazar v. Commet 380, Inc.,

199 A.D.3d 403,403 (1st Dep't 2021).

TEI argues that Carnegie Hall.is not entitled to indemnification because Carnegie Hall

cannot establish that the injury sustained by Plaintiff - Frank Mario Pecoraro (hereinafter

"Plaintiff') arose out of negligence by TEI, thus negating the indemnification provision. TEI

contends that Carnegie Hall had exclusive control over Plaintiff. TEI contends that the sole

proximate cause of Plaintiffs-accident was ·a slippery condition on the gondola rail, which

Plaintiff only climbed·because Carnegie Hall blocked the walkway to the elevator machine room.

(NYSCEF Doc. No. 116).

Carnegie Hall argues that the contractual indemnification clause is triggered because TEI

did exercise supervision or control over Plaintiff. Carnegie Hall contends that Plaintiff provided

testimony that TEI approved the route to the elevator machine room and instructed Plaintiff to

walk on the gondola rail. (NYSCEF Doc. No. 122). This resulted in Plaintiff falling and

suffering from a medical meniscal tear which required in surgery. Id.

This Court finds that TEI did not meet its prima facie burden and there is a material fact

in dispute as to .whether TEI exercised supervision or control over Plaintiff which would trigger

contractual and common law indemnification. Thus, TEI's motion for summary judgment is

denied.

Accordingly it is hereby,

ORDERED that Third-Party Defendant - Transel Elevator & Electric Inc., d/b/a/ TEI

Group's motion for summary judgment against Third~Party Plaintiff-The Carnegie Hall

Corporation is granted as to the breach of contract claim for failure to procure insurance, it is

further

160517/2018 PECORARO, FRANK MARIO vs. CITY OF NEW YORK Page 3 of4

Motion No. 004 ·

[* 3] 3 of 4

FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 10/11/2024 12:10 PM INDEX NO. 160517/2018

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 142 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 10/11/2024

ORDERED that Third-Party Defendant-Transel Elevator & Electric Inc., d/b/a/ TEI Group' s

motion for summary judgment against Third-Party Plaintiff - The Carnegie Hall Corporation is

denied as to the contractual and common Jaw indemnification claims and in all other respects

This constitutes the Decision and Orderofthe Court.

10/9/2024

DATE

~

CHECK ONE: CASE DISPOSED .

GRANTED □ DENIED GRA · □ OTHER

APPLICATION : SETTLE ORDER SUBMIT ORDER

CHECK IF APPROPRIATE : INCLUDES TRANSFER/REASSIGN FIDUCIARY APPOINTMENT □ REFERENCE

160517/2018 PECORARO, FRANK MARIO vs. CITY OF NEW YORK Page4of4

Motion No. 004

[* 4] 4 of 4

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.