Opinion

Roberge v. Dept. of Rev.

  • 20 Or. Tax 423
Court
Oregon Tax Court
Filed
Feb 7, 2012
Status
Published
On the bench
Breithaupt
Cited by
0 cases
Authority
More cited than 30.8%

The opinion

No. 51 February 7, 2012 423

IN THE OREGON TAX COURT

REGULAR DIVISION

Daniel ROBERGE

and Kathy Lynn Roberge,

Plaintiffs,

v.

DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE,

Defendant.

(TC 5040)

Plaintiffs (taxpayers) appealed from a Magistrate Division decision of dis-

missal and sought a judgment to have the court order a classification correction

be made for the 2007-08 year and to change the maximum assessed value of tax-

payers’ real property for that year. Granting Defendant (the department)’s motion

to dismiss, the court ruled that the tax years at issue were closed to appeal and

the court was without statutory jurisdiction to provide a remedy to taxpayers.

Oral argument on Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss was

held in the courtroom of the Oregon Tax Court, Salem on

January 20, 2012.

William H. Sumerfield, Attorney at Law, Hood River, filed

the response and argued the cause for Plaintiffs (taxpayers).

Nathan Carter, Assistant Attorney General, Department

of Justice, Salem, filed the motion and argued the cause for

Defendant (the department).

Decision for Defendant rendered February 7, 2012.

HENRY C. BREITHAUPT, Judge.

This matter is before the court on the motion to

dismiss filed by Defendant Department of Revenue (the

department) on November 28, 2011. Plaintiffs (taxpayers)

responded and a hearing was held on January 20, 2012.

In this property tax case, the property in question

is an improvement that is in part residential and in part

commercial. In the year it was first added to the assessment

and tax rolls, the 2007-08 tax year, the assessor considered

the property as commercial for purposes of determining the

maximum assessed value and the assessed value under ORS

424 Roberge v. Dept. of Rev.

308.146 through ORS 308.166, and in particular what is

generally referred to as the changed property ratio (CPR).1

Taxpayers assert that they inquired of the assessor

as to whether there was a more favorable classification for

the property given its mixed use, but were told that no other

classification was available. Taxpayers did not challenge the

determination of the CPR as established by the assessor for

the 2007-08 year.2

In this proceeding, taxpayers seek to have the court

order a classification correction be made for the 2007-08

year and to change the maximum assessed value for that

year. The taxpayers note, correctly, that unless such a cor-

rection is made for the 2007-08 year, the initial maximum

assessed value for the property determined in that year will,

most likely, cause the assessed value of the property to be

greater than it would be if the correction in classification is

made.

Under Measure 50, the facts and actions taken in

the first year a property goes on the rolls can have continu-

ing effect.3 That said, unless a timely appeal of any allegedly

incorrect action is taken, the initial actions of the assessor

are immune from attack by taxpayers and may be binding

on the assessor. That is the teaching of cases such as Ellis

v. Lorati, 14 OTR 525 (1999); Zervis v. Dept. of Rev., 20 OTR

79 (2010); Kaufman v. Dept. of Rev., 20 OTR 159 (2010); and

Clackamas Cty. Assessor v. Village at Main Street II, 20 OTR

96 (2010).

As stated above, taxpayers took no appeal under

ORS 305.275, or otherwise, from the original action of the

assessor in classifying the property. Although they did file

an appeal with BOPTA as to the valuation of the property

1

All references to the Oregon Revised Statutes (ORS) are to 2009.

2

As to the 2007-08 tax year, taxpayers appealed to the Board of Property Tax

Appeals (BOPTA) with respect to the real market value placed on the property

but did not raise any question as to the classification of the property. Taxpayers

also appealed with respect to the 2008-09 and 2009-10 years and a Magistrate

Division decision determined that for those years the classification of the prop-

erty on the rolls should be changed. That decision did not purport to address

the 2007-08 year nor did it purport to alter the maximum assessed value of the

property as determined for the 2007-08 tax year.

3

See, e.g., Oregon Constitution, Art XI, § 11(1)(b).

Cite as 20 OTR 423 (2012) 425

and did obtain some relief, the action of BOPTA did not

address the proper classification of the property for Measure

50 purposes. No appeal from that BOPTA order was taken.

In this proceeding, taxpayers assert that the court

can provide relief to them pursuant to ORS 305.288. That

statue provides for certain types of relief, but only for the cur-

rent tax year or either of the two tax years immediately pre-

ceding the current tax year. Under ORS 305.288(5)(a) and

ORS 306.115, the current tax year in this case is the 2010-11

year and the two years preceding that are the 2009-10

and 2008-09 years.

Accordingly, the court is without statutory jurisdic-

tion to provide a remedy to taxpayers for the 2007-08 tax

year. The motion of the department is granted. Counsel for

the department is directed to prepare an appropriate form

of judgment. Now, therefore,

IT IS ORDERED that Defendant’s Motion to

Dismiss is granted.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.