Opinion

Matter of NYP Holdings, Inc. v. New York City Dept. of Social Servs.

  • 2024 NY Slip Op 32540(U)
Court
New York Supreme Court, New York County
Filed
Jul 24, 2024
Status
Unpublished
Author
John J. Kelley
Cited by
0 cases
Authority
More cited than 30.4%

The opinion

Matter of NYP Holdings, Inc. v New York City Dept.

of Social Servs.

2024 NY Slip Op 32540(U)

July 24, 2024

Supreme Court, New York County

Docket Number: Index No. 158909/2023

Judge: John J. Kelley

Cases posted with a "30000" identifier, i.e., 2013 NY Slip

Op 30001(U), are republished from various New York

State and local government sources, including the New

York State Unified Court System's eCourts Service.

This opinion is uncorrected and not selected for official

publication.

INDEX NO. 158909/2023

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 47 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 07/24/2024

SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK

NEW YORK COUNTY

PRESENT: HON. JOHN J. KELLEY PART 56M

Justice

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------X INDEX NO. 158909/2023

In the Matter of

MOTION DATE 07/12/2024

NYP HOLDINGS, INC., and NOLAN HICKS,

MOTION SEQ. NO. 001

Petitioners,

-v-

NEW YORK CITY DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL SERVICES DECISION, ORDER, AND

and NEW YORK CITY DEPARTMENT OF HOMELESS JUDGMENT

SERVICES,

Respondents.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------X

The following e-filed documents, listed by NYSCEF document number (Motion 001) 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8,

9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36,

37, 42, 43, 44, 45, 46

were read on this motion to/for ARTICLE 78 (BODY OR OFFICER) .

In this CPLR article 78 proceeding, the petitioners seek judicial review of the May 9,

2023 partial denial of their administrative appeal from a March 23, 2023 New York City

Department of Social Services/New York City Department of Homeless Services (DSS/DHS)

Records Access Officer’s (RAO) determination that had denied their request for agency records

pursuant to the Freedom of Information Law (Public Officers Law § 84, et seq.; hereinafter

FOIL). The DSS/DHS answers the petition, submits the administrative record, and opposes the

relief sought by the petitioners. The petition is granted, and, on or before August 26, 2024, the

DSS/DHS shall produce the documents requested by the petitioners, but the petitioners are

preliminarily enjoined, until September 25, 2024, from publishing the addresses of the homeless

shelters that were the subject of their FOIL request, to permit the DSS/DHS to appeal this

decision, order, and judgment, and seek a either a continued injunction or stay pending appeal

from the Appellate Division.

158909/2023 NYP HOLDINGS, INC. ET AL vs. NEW YORK CITY DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL Page 1 of 11

SERVICES ET AL

Motion No. 001

1 of 11

[* 1]

INDEX NO. 158909/2023

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 47 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 07/24/2024

In its initial FOIL request, dated March 15, 2023, the petitioners---the corporate owner of

the New York Post newspaper and an individual reporter for that newspaper---requested that

the DSS/DHS produce “[a] spreadsheet or database of shelter locations, number of beds

provided, operator and landlord.” In his denial, the RAO explained that,

“[a]ddresses of individuals applying for or receiving public assistance, including

DHS shelter addresses, are confidential pursuant to NYS Social Services Law

(SSL) §136 and are therefore withheld under NY Public Officers Law §87(2)(a).

“However, while this information cannot be provided under FOIL for the above

reasons, in handling requests from representatives of bona fide news

organizations the Agency will acknowledge that there is a separate entitlement to

access information contained in the Agency’s books and records of

disbursement, including addresses, so long as the relevant statutory

requirements are met. Specifically, SSL 136(1) requires the news organization to

‘give assurances in writing that it will not publicly disclose, or participate or

acquiesce in the public disclosure of, the names and addresses of applicants for

and recipients of public assistance and care . . .’ It is for these reasons the

Agency requires completion of the attached agreement prior to release of the

requested information, which would otherwise be exempt pursuant to NY POL

§87(2)(a).

“Once we receive the completed form, the Agency will work to compile

responsive records and provide a response.”

Rather than executing and submitting that form to the DSS/DHS, the petitioners administratively

appealed that determination to the DSS/DHS’s Records Access Appeal Officer (RAAO).

In a May 9, 2023 determination, the RAAO explained that Social Services Law § 136

prohibited

“the release of ‘the names or addresses of persons applying for or receiving

public assistance.’ More specifically, the statute provides that ‘[t]he names or

addresses of persons applying for or receiving public assistance and care shall

not be included in any published report or printed in any newspaper . . .’ SSL

§136(1) [emphasis added]. It is acknowledged that the underlying legislative

intent of this section of the SSL is ‘to preserve the dignity and self-respect of the

recipient of social assistance and to assure the integrity and efficiency of the

administration of the related programs.’ Malowsky v. D’Elia, 160 A.D.2d 798, 800

(2d Dep’t 1990) (citing Early v. Cnty. of Nassau, 98 A.D.2d 798, 790 (2d Dep’t

1983). Courts and the Agency also recognize the law’s intent to ‘prevent a

recipient’s exposure to exploitation or embarrassment’ (People v. Prim, 47

A.D.2d 409, 416). DHS agrees that the legislative intent behind SSL §136 is

what drives this conversation. The dignity, self-respect, and additionally the

safety, of our clients is of the utmost importance. The Agency’s plain language

reading and application of the statute support[ ] these goals.”

158909/2023 NYP HOLDINGS, INC. ET AL vs. NEW YORK CITY DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL Page 2 of 11

SERVICES ET AL

Motion No. 001

2 of 11

[* 2]

INDEX NO. 158909/2023

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 47 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 07/24/2024

The RAAO rejected the petitioners’ reliance upon the decision in Krauskopf v Giannelli (121

Misc 2d 186, 190 [Sup Ct, N.Y. County 1983]), for the proposition that “the demand for

addresses requires minimal intrusion into the confidentiality of records and cannot serve, as

such, to embarrass, demean or exploit either the assistance recipient or the program

administration.” In this regard, the RAAO explained that Krauskopf involved the disclosure of

the addresses of only three particular public assistance recipients in the context of a grand jury

subpoena related to a homicide investigation. As the RAAO characterized it, apart from the fact

that Social Services Law § 136(1), by its very terms, already contemplated grand jury

disclosures, limited to the “names and addresses and the amount received by or expended for”

public assistance, the Krauskopf court explicitly noted that the disclosures there in dispute were

“not being made to the general public, but only to a small and select group, all of whose

members are obligated by law to keep secret information they receive” (Krauskopf v Giannelli,

121 Misc 2d at 190).

In response to the petitioners’ arguments that “addresses do not implicitly identify

inhabitants,” and that “[a]n individual receiving public benefits cannot be deduced from the

existence of a shelter at a particular building,” the RAAO emphatically asserted that these

contentions were “not necessarily true.” Specifically, she adverted that,

“[t]he fact that an individual resides at a DHS shelter location is in itself

confirmation that they are receiving public assistance and care. These

addresses, for all intents and purposes, are DHS clients’ ‘home’ addresses

during the time in which they reside there. Disclosure of addresses enables third

parties both to identify and locate individuals residing at the sites as recipients of

public assistance, the result of which is the potential exploitation and

embarrassment of Agency clients that SSL §136 aims to avoid. There is no

requirement under the statute that addresses be ‘tethered’ to names of recipients

before the statutory protections apply. In fact, as emphasized above, SSL §136

couches the language in terms of either/or: prohibiting the disclosure of names or

addresses.”

According to the RAAO, under the New York City Identifying Information Law (Admin. Code of

City of N.Y., §§ 23-1201-23-1205), which is applicable to the DSS/DHS, “information obtained

158909/2023 NYP HOLDINGS, INC. ET AL vs. NEW YORK CITY DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL Page 3 of 11

SERVICES ET AL

Motion No. 001

3 of 11

[* 3]

INDEX NO. 158909/2023

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 47 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 07/24/2024

by or on behalf of the city that may be used on its own or with other information to identify or

locate an individual” (Admin. Code of City of N.Y., §§ 23-1201, ¶ 6 [emphasis added])

constitutes “identifying information” that can be disclosed only in limited circumstances,

regardless of whether that individual is a recipient of DSS/DHS benefits. Hence, the RAAO, in

reaching her decision, concluded that the Identifying Information Law lent further support to the

applicability of Social Services Law § 136 as a basis for denying access to the records sought,

and bolstered her determination also to withhold the disclosure of documents containing such

addresses under Public Officers Law § 87(2)(b), so as to avoid any unwarranted invasions of

personal privacy.

The RAAO further characterized, as “inaccurate,” the petitioners’ allegation that

DSS/DHS inconsistently applied Social Services Law § 136 because it had disclosed shelter

addresses in other contexts, and that the examples of disclosure cited in the petitioners’ appeal

letter were distinguishable from their current request to release a complete list of shelter

addresses to a member of the public under FOIL. Rather, according to the RAAO, the

examples cited by the petitioners did not include situations in which the addresses of homeless

shelters were published in a wholesale fashion in one easily or readily searchable or widely

publicized single place or document. Rather, she explained that the DSS/DHS previously had

disclosed or otherwise made public DHS shelter addresses solely for purposes directly

connected to the administration of public assistance and shelter programs, and to fulfill those

agencies’ various legal obligations related to procurement, proposed contracts, and public

hearings. Hence, she concluded that, “[w]hile the Agency may be required under some

circumstances to provide address information in limited forums, this does not mean that the

Agency should or must shirk its duty to protect this information outside of those limited contexts

to the fullest extent permitted under the law.” In this regard, the RAAO noted that the

Humanitarian Emergency Response and Relief Centers identified by the petitioners as having

previously been identified to the public were not DHS homeless shelter sites.

158909/2023 NYP HOLDINGS, INC. ET AL vs. NEW YORK CITY DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL Page 4 of 11

SERVICES ET AL

Motion No. 001

4 of 11

[* 4]

INDEX NO. 158909/2023

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 47 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 07/24/2024

Nonetheless, the RAAO granted the petitioners’ administrative appeal to the extent of

directing the DSS/DHS FOIL office to provide materials responsive to the portions of the

petitioners’ request seeking non-confidential records and data, specifically, the identities of the

“operator[s] (i.e., contracted shelter providers)” and “number of beds provided.” She otherwise

denied the appeal on the ground that the remaining documents were exempt from disclosure by

virtue of Public Officers Law § 87(2)(a) (records specifically exempted from disclosure by the

Social Services Law) and Public Officers Law §87(2)(b) and §89(2) (records that, if released,

would create an unwarranted invasion of personal privacy). This CPLR article 78 proceeding

ensued.

“While the Legislature established a general policy of disclosure by enacting the

Freedom of Information Law, it nevertheless recognized a legitimate need on the part of

government to keep some matters confidential” (Matter of Fink v Lefkowitz, 47 NY2d 567, 571

[1979]). When denying a FOIL request, a state or municipal agency must “state, in writing, the

reason for the denial of access” (Matter of West Harlem Bus. Group v Empire State Dev. Corp.,

13 NY3d 882, 884 [2009]). If the requesting party administratively appeals the denial, the

agency's appeals officer must also provide written reasoning for upholding the denial (see id.).

“[O]n the issue of whether a particular document is exempt from disclosure under

the Freedom of Information Law, the oft-stated standard of review in CPLR article

78 proceedings, i.e., that the agency's determination will not be set aside unless

arbitrary or capricious or without rational basis, is not applicable”

(Matter of Capital Newspapers Div. of Hearst Corp. v Burns, 109 AD2d 92, 94 [3rd Dept. 1985],

affd 67 NY2d 562 [1986]; see Matter of Prall v New York City Dept. of Corrections, 129 AD3d

734 [2d Dept 2015]; Matter of New York Comm. for Occupational Safety & Health v Bloomberg,

72 AD3d 153 [1st Dept 2010]). Rather, upon judicial review of an agency's determination to

deny a FOIL request, the court must assess whether “the requested material falls squarely

within a FOIL exemption” and whether the agency, upon denying such access, “articulat[ed] a

particularized and specific justification for denying access” (Matter of Capital Newspapers Div.

158909/2023 NYP HOLDINGS, INC. ET AL vs. NEW YORK CITY DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL Page 5 of 11

SERVICES ET AL

Motion No. 001

5 of 11

[* 5]

INDEX NO. 158909/2023

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 47 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 07/24/2024

of Hearst Corp. v Burns, 67 NY2d at 566). In other words, the court may only review an

agency’s FOIL determination to ascertain whether the determination to invoke a particular

statutory exemption was affected by an error of law (see Matter of Abdur-Rashid v New York

City Police Dept., 31 NY3d 217, 246 & n 2 [2018], affg 140 AD3d 419, 420-421 [1st Dept 2016];

Matter of Asian Am. Legal Defense & Educ. Fund v New York City Police Dept., 125 AD3d 531,

531 [1st Dept 2015]; CPLR 7803[3]).

Under Public Officers Law § 87(2)(a), records must be withheld that “are specifically

exempted from disclosure by state or federal statute.” Social Services Law § 136(1) provides, in

relevant part, with certain exceptions not relevant here, that,

“[t]he names or addresses of persons applying for or receiving public assistance

and care shall not be included in any published report or printed in any

newspaper or reported at any public meeting . . . ; nor shall such names and

addresses and the amount received by or expended for such persons be

disclosed”

(emphasis added). That statute, however, further provides that,

“if a bona fide news disseminating firm or organization makes a written request to

the social services official or the appropriating board or body of a county, city or

town to allow inspection by an authorized representative of such firm or

organization of the books and records of the disbursements made by such

county, city or town for public assistance and care, such requests shall be

granted within five days and such firm or organization shall be considered

entitled to the information contained in such books and records, provided such

firm or organization shall give assurances in writing that it will not publicly

disclose, or participate or acquiesce in the public disclosure of, the names and

addresses of applicants for and recipients of public assistance and care except

as expressly permitted by subdivision four.”

(emphasis added). The public dissemination of such information by a news organization, made

after it has provided such assurances to the applicable agency, constitutes a misdemeanor

(Social Services Law § 136[1]).

The purpose of these restrictions is “to preserve the dignity and self-respect of a

recipient of public assistance” (Rampe v Giuliani, 253 AD2d 486, 487 [2d Dept 1998]). Although

the protections accorded such records are not absolute, the petitioners must show some

entitlement to the information under some regulatory exception (D & Z Holding Corp. v City of

158909/2023 NYP HOLDINGS, INC. ET AL vs. NEW YORK CITY DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL Page 6 of 11

SERVICES ET AL

Motion No. 001

6 of 11

[* 6]

INDEX NO. 158909/2023

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 47 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 07/24/2024

N.Y. Dept. of Fin., 179 AD2d 796, 798 [2d Dept 1992]), or demonstrate that their suppression

would “exceed the purpose of the statute” (Rampe v Giuliani, 253 AD2d at 487). Generally,

even disinterested applicants for production of agency records, such as academic researchers,

may not employ FOIL to obtain records that reveal the name of public assistance benefit

recipients (see Matter of Rabinowitz v Hammons, 228 AD2d 369, 369 [1st Dept 1996] [rejecting

researcher’s request for production of approximately 1,900 intake referral forms maintained by

the Visiting Psychiatric Service unit of the New York State Office of Health and Mental Health

Services]). As relevant to this dispute, in Matter of Citizens for a Better Maspeth, Inc. v City of

New York (2017 NY Slip Op 32024[U], 2017 NY Misc LEXIS 3692 [Sup Ct, Queens County,

Sep. 27, 2017]), the court rejeected a judicial challenge to the DHS’s denial of a FOIL request,

made jointly by a community organization opposed to the siting of shelters in its neighborhood

and a local resident affiliated with that organization, that “specifically sought individual

addresses---both the last known addresses and the current shelter location---of each New York

City shelter resident.” More particularly, the individual resident requested documents, among

other things, containing the

“[m]ost recent data available pertaining to the number of homeless, stratified by

type (ex. families with children, adult families, single adults), data pertaining to

their last residence/last known address (country, state, borough, city zip code,

and community board of last residence), primary reason for homelessness,

indicator if currently employed, if employed, indicator if full time or part time,

gross monthly income, if any, indicator of mental health issues, indicator of drug

abuse/dependency, indicator of alcohol abuse/dependency, shelter entry date,

current length of shelter stay (in days), anticipated length of shelter stay, shelter

provider, shelter location (borough, city, zip code and community board of shelter

location), repeat shelter status (meaning they have returned to the shelter system

after being transitioned out)”

(id., 2017 NY Slip Op 32024[U], *2, 2017 NY Misc LEXIS 3692, *2 [emphasis added]). In

denying the entirety of the challenge, the court explicitly ruled that the petitioners were not

entitled to the addresses of all current DHS shelter residents (id., 2017 NY Slip Op 32024[U], *9,

2017 NY Misc LEXIS 3692, *16; cf. Matter of New York Times Co. v City of New York, 176 Misc

2d 872 [Sup Ct, N.Y. County 1998] [newspaper publisher that agreed not to publish individual

158909/2023 NYP HOLDINGS, INC. ET AL vs. NEW YORK CITY DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL Page 7 of 11

SERVICES ET AL

Motion No. 001

7 of 11

[* 7]

INDEX NO. 158909/2023

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 47 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 07/24/2024

names and addresses of “workfare” recipients is entitled to agency records identifying those

recipients so that it could interview recipients, and anonymously report on the effects of the

recently imposed work requirement for receipt of welfare benefits]).

The court concludes that the DSS/DHS incorrectly invoked the exemption articulated by

Public Officers Law § 87(2)(a), and improperly withheld the requested records on the ground

that they were “specifically exempted from disclosure by state . . . statute,” particularly Social

Services Law § 136(1). Although Social Services Law § 136(1) exempts disclosure of the name

“or” address of a public benefit recipient, the request made by the petitioners here was not for

the addresses of any specific recipients but, rather, for the addresses of DHS-managed

facilities. While those facilities do serve as temporary locations of the recipients of homeless

benefits and other public benefits, contrary to the DSS/DHS’s contention, they are not formal

“addresses” of public benefit recipients, who rarely reside therein for more than a few months,

and they are neither a permanent residence nor a domicile of those receiving benefits.

Moreover, the Maspeth decision is distinguishable from the instant dispute, in that the party

requesting records there specifically sought the addresses of the recipients themselves, not the

addresses of facilities in a general fashion.

It is not clear whether Admin. Code of City of N.Y., §§ 23-1201, ¶ 6, which is a section of

the Administrative Code that imposes a specific duty upon City agencies, has the “force of

statute” in the City and thus, whether it is a provision of the Administrative Code, similar to a

statute, that is the controlling authority “within its sphere of operation” (see Juarez v Wavecrest

Mgt. Team, 88 NY2d 628, 645 [1996]; Bittrolff v Ho's Dev. Corp., 77 NY2d 896, 899 n [1991];

Guzman v Haven Plaza Hous. Dev. Fund Co., 69 NY2d 559, 565 n 3 [1987]; see also Martin v

Herzog, supra, 228 NY 164, 169 [1920]). To the extent that it is deemed to have the force of

statute, the same analysis that applies to Social Services Law § 136(1) applies to that Code

provision, in that it prohibits the disclosure of specific identifying information but does not, by its

terms, prohibit the disclosure of the location of City-operated facilities.

158909/2023 NYP HOLDINGS, INC. ET AL vs. NEW YORK CITY DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL Page 8 of 11

SERVICES ET AL

Motion No. 001

8 of 11

[* 8]

INDEX NO. 158909/2023

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 47 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 07/24/2024

Public Officers Law § 87(2)(b) provides that an “agency may deny access to records or

portions thereof that . . . if disclosed would constitute an unwarranted invasion of personal

privacy under the provisions of subdivision two of section eighty-nine of this article.” In general,

that provision of law requires a balancing test, and warrants a finding of an “unwarranted

invasion” where “privacy interests” outweigh the “public interest in disclosure of the information”

(Matter of Harbatkin v New York City Dept. of Records & Info. Servs., 19 NY3d 373, 380 [2012];

see Matter of New York Times Co. v City of N.Y. Fire Dept., 4 NY3d 477, 485-487 [2005];

Matter of Thomas v New York City Dept. of Educ., 103 AD3d 495, 496-497 [1st Dept 2013]). In

interpreting the federal Freedom of Information Act, on which FOIL is based, the United States

Supreme Court explained that, where an agency asserts an exemption based on personal

privacy, the “usual rule that the citizen need not offer a reason for requesting the information

must be inapplicable” (National Archives & Records Admin. v Favish, 541 US 157, 172 [2004]).

In order to “give practical meaning” to the exemption, which “requires the courts to balance the

competing interests in privacy and disclosure,” courts must examine whether the requestor has

established a “sufficient reason for the disclosure” outweighing the privacy interests (id.). The

Court of Appeals, in both Harbatkin and New York Times, effectively has adopted the Favish

test, since it expressly applied such a balancing test to FOIL in the context of claimed

exemptions based on privacy.

Notably, “‘what constitutes an unwarranted invasion of personal privacy is measured by

what would be offensive and objectionable to a reasonable person of ordinary sensibilities’”

(Matter of Hepps v New York State Dept. of Health, 183 AD3d 283, 287-288 [3rd Dept 2020],

quoting Matter of Ruberti, Girvin & Ferlazzo v New York State Div. of State Police, 218 AD2d

494, 498 [3d Dept 1996] [internal quotation marks, brackets, and citation omitted]; see Matter of

Massaro v New York State Thruway Auth., 111 AD3d 1001, 1003 [3d Dept 2013]; see generally

Matter of Castorina v New York City Human Resources Admin./Dept. of Social Servs., 2019 NY

Slip Op 32351[U], 2019 NY Misc LEXIS 4325 [Sup Ct, N.Y. County, Jul. 31, 2019] [rejecting

158909/2023 NYP HOLDINGS, INC. ET AL vs. NEW YORK CITY DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL Page 9 of 11

SERVICES ET AL

Motion No. 001

9 of 11

[* 9]

INDEX NO. 158909/2023

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 47 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 07/24/2024

FOIL request by two members of the New York State Assembly for the underlying personal

information required on City residents’ applications for issuance of IDNYC identification cards]).

Although the court recognizes the importance of the privacy interests of recipients of

public benefits who reside in homeless shelters, and their concomitant interest in freedom from

potential harassment, exploitation, and embarrassment that could arise were the shelter

addresses to be made public, the public has a valid interest in obtaining knowledge of where

DHS homeless shelters are situated. In this regard, however, the court notes the recent

incident in the Bensonhurst section of Brooklyn, in which a public protest to the siting of a

homeless shelter led to the alleged assault of a New York City Police officer by a member of the

New York City Council. The court expresses its fervent hope that the publication of a list of

shelter locations will not lead to similar occurrences. It further recognizes that many victims of

domestic abuse initially seek refuge in homeless shelters, and that the disclosure of all of the

addresses at which such shelters are situated may pose an increased danger of stalking and

violence. The court nonetheless concludes that the public’s interest in disclosure outweighs the

interest of recipients of public benefits in this case. The addresses of virtually all shelters

already have been made public during the acquisition, siting, and budgeting processes, and, as

the DSS/DHS explained, in those particular instances in which the agency must hold a public

hearing, or in which applications for certain other governmental approvals, appropriations, and

funding are publicly known, the residents of any neighborhood in which a shelter is anticipated

to be sited already will have learned of the particular address of that shelter. Moreover, in a

recent article, the petitioners published the general locations of other facilities providing services

to recent immigrants, apparently without any perceivable backlash. Hence, the court concludes

that the DSS/DHS incorrectly invoked the exemption from FOIL disclosure set forth in Public

Officers Law § 87(2)(b).

Accordingly, it is,

158909/2023 NYP HOLDINGS, INC. ET AL vs. NEW YORK CITY DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL Page 10 of 11

SERVICES ET AL

Motion No. 001

10 of 11

[* 10]

INDEX NO. 158909/2023

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 47 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 07/24/2024

ORDERED and ADJUDGED that the petition is granted, so much of the May 9, 2023

determination of the respondent’s Records Access Appeals Officer as denied the petitioners’

request for access to agency records is annulled, and, on or before August 26, 2024, the

respondent shall produce all records responsive to the petitioners’ March 15, 2023 request for

the production of “[a] spreadsheet or database of shelter locations, number of beds provided,

operator and landlord”; and it is further,

ORDERED that, on the court’s own motion, the petitioners be, and hereby are,

preliminarily enjoined, until September 25, 2024, from publishing the addresses of homeless

shelters identified in the records that are produced by the respondent, to permit the respondent

to appeal this decision, order, and judgment, and to seek, from the Appellate Division, First

Department, any further injunctive relief or a stay pending appeal.

This constitutes the Decision, Order, and Judgment of the court.

7/24/2024 $SIG$

DATE JOHN J. KELLEY, J.S.C.

CHECK ONE: X CASE DISPOSED NON-FINAL DISPOSITION

□

X GRANTED DENIED GRANTED IN PART OTHER

APPLICATION: SETTLE ORDER SUBMIT ORDER

□

CHECK IF APPROPRIATE: INCLUDES TRANSFER/REASSIGN FIDUCIARY APPOINTMENT REFERENCE

158909/2023 NYP HOLDINGS, INC. ET AL vs. NEW YORK CITY DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL Page 11 of 11

SERVICES ET AL

Motion No. 001

11 of 11

[* 11]

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.