finding no bad faith where pro se plaintiff served summons three days late, commenting that instead of seeking to quash service, the defendants could have simply moved to extend the time to answer
How later courts described this case
- finding no bad faith where pro se plaintiff served summons three days late, commenting that instead of seeking to quash service, the defendants could have simply moved to extend the time to answer
- “The purpose of the rules governing service of process is to insure that parties receive actual notice of claims against them.”
- “Inadvertent failure to serve process within the time permitted does not constitute good cause.”
- stating of creditor’s counsel “Failure to read a rule is the antithesis of good cause.”
Written by the judges who cited it.
The opinion
. PILED
JEANNE A. NAUGHTON, CLER
FEB 25 2020.
UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT U.S, BANKRUPTCY COURT
DISTRICT OF NEW JERSEY ms ts CAMDEN, □□□□
BY □□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□ □□
NOT FOR PUBLICATION
In Re: Case No.: 18-30798-ABA
Regina Perfetti, Adv. No.: 19-1182-ABA
Debtor.
Adam Ripa and Kim Ripa, Plaintiffs Chapter: 7
Vv, Judge: Andrew B. Altenburg, Jr.
Regina Perfetti, Defendant.
MEMORANDUM DECISION
Before the court is defendant Regina Perfetti’s latest Motion for me to reconsider my order
denying her Third Motion to Dismiss Adversary Proceeding (Doc. No. 58), Ms. Perfetti’s Fourth
Motion to Dismiss the Adversary Proceeding (Doc. No. 61), the Ripas’ Responses to both (Doc.
Nos, 63, 67), Ms. Perfetti’s Response to the Ripas’ Response to her Motion to Reconsider (Doc.
No. 70), the Ripas’ allegation that Ms. Perfetti failed to serve them with her Third Motion to
Dismiss and her Motion to Strike Issuance of Amended Alias Summons (Doc, No. 57), and Ms.
Perfetti’s Response to that allegation (Doc, No. 63).
For the reasons that follow, the court will deny Ms. Perfetti’s Motion to Reconsider and
Motion to Dismiss.
JURISDICTION AND VENUE
This matter before the court is a core proceeding pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 157(b)(2)(D) and
(QO), and the court has jurisdiction pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1334, 28 U.S.C. § 157(a) and the
Standing Order of Reference issued by the United States District Court for the District of New
Jersey on July 23, 1984, as amended on September 18, 2012, referring all bankruptcy cases to the
bankruptcy court. The following constitutes this court’s findings of fact and conclusions of law as
required by Federal Rule of Bankruptcy Procedure 7052.
Page 1 of 9
PROCEDURAL HISTORY/ FENDINGS OF FACT
Pursuant to Fed. R. Bankr. P. 7052, the court issues the following findings of fact and
conclusions of law.
The Ripas filed an adversary proceeding and the Clerk’s Office issued a Summons on April
22, 2019. Doc, Nos. 1, 2 (the “First Summons”). Ms. Perfetti then filed a Motion to Dismiss,
arguing that the complaint was “so vague and ambiguous that Defendant cannot reasonably prepare
a proper response as Plaintiff is in fact attempt use [sic] (un-numbered paragraphs) supposed
events that are irrelevant to the complaint,” and that the Ripas failed to properly serve her. Doc.
No, 4-1 (the “First Motion to Dismiss”). Regarding the service issue, the Ripas responded that Ms.
Perfetti had refused to give them her new address. Doc. No. 5. In a response filed to the Ripas’
response, Ms. Perfetti repeated that service was deficient and then argued that in their complaint
the Ripas had not pled reliance on the alleged misrepresentation, for example “running their own
credit report to verify and to follow the direction in the credit report provided, as not all screening □
companies are alike, nor are they all accurate, and, thus, perform due diligence... .” Doc, No. 10.
Though the court found the complaint quite clear, it ordered the Ripas to file and serve an amended
complaint together, with numbered paragraphs, with a new summons. Doc. No. 12.
The Ripas filed an Amended Complaint on July 8, 2019, Doc, No. 14, and a new summons
was issued by the Clerk’s Office that same day. Doc. No. 15 (the “Second Summons”). Ms. Perfetti
filed a Motion to Dismiss on July 22, 2019, arguing that the Amended Complaint failed to state a
cause of action and that it failed to allege fraud with particularity. Doc. No. 17 (the “Second Motion
to Dismiss”). She also alleged that she also sought dismissal “for improper service of summons
_and complaint” but did not explain how service was deficient. Doc. No. 17-1, p. 1. On August 14,
2019, the court denied this Second Motion to Dismiss, stating that it was “at a loss here to ascertain
how Ms. Perfetti cannot understand the Ripas’ complaint against her.” Doc. No. 21, p. 3. Regarding
the failure to properly serve, the court stated: “Ms. Perfetti also contends that the Ripas did not
serve her properly, but did not explain how, therefore the court will not consider that allegation,”
Id, p. 2. At that time then, the adversary proceeding could have promptly progressed to discovery
and mediation and/or trial in due course.
Instead, on August 21, 2019, Ms. Perfetti filed her first Motion to Reconsider (“First
Motion to Reconsider”). Doc. No. 25. She denied filing the Second Motion to Dismiss in bad faith,
and submitted a copy of the summons that she received with the Amended Complaint that showed
that rather than serve her with the summons issued by the court, the Ripas apparently filled out a
summons form themselves and served it, without the signature of the Clerk of the Bankruptcy
Court. See Doc. No. 25-8. The court denied the Motion to Reconsider despite that this fact was not
newly discovered by Ms. Perfetti, as required in a motion for reconsideration, Max's Seafood Cafe
ex rel, Lou-Ann, Ine. v. Quinteros,176 F.3d 669, 677 (3d Cir. 1999), and the court ordered the
Ripas to obtain a new court-issued summons from the Clerk’s Office and serve it upon Ms. Perfetti.
Doc, No. 32.
The Ripas had a new alias summons (the “Third Summons”) issued on October 16, 2019
and served it and the Amended Complaint on Ms. Perfetti. Doc. No. 39 (Certificate of Service).
Unfortunately, this summons, prepared by the Clerk's Office, incorrectly captioned the proceeding
Page 2 of 9
as “Adam Ripa v. Kim Ripa.” Doc. No. 36. On November 7, 2019, Ms. Perfetti filed another Motion □
to Dismiss on this basis. Doc. No. 40 (the “Third Motion to Dismiss”). On November 8, 2019, the
Clerk’s Office re-issued the Alias Summons with the parties corrected, citing “Clerk’s Office
Error,” Doc. No. 42, prompting Ms. Perfetti to file a Motion to Strike Issuance of this Alias
Summons on November 12, 2019. Doc. No. 44, On December 11, 2019, the court issued a
Memorandum Decision and Order denying the Third Motion to Dismiss and the Motion to Strike
Issuance of this Alias Summons. Doc. Nos. 51, 52.
That brings the court to the latest motions and responses. On December 23, 2019, the court
received a letter from Mr. Ripa alleging that he and Mrs. Ripa never received from Ms. Perfetti
the Third Motion to Dismiss, the Motion to Strike Issuance of this Alias Summons, or the Notices
of Hearing for either. Doc. No. 57, Ms. Perfetti had filed Certificates of Service for all of these
documents. See Doc. Nos. 47-50.
On December 26, 2019, Ms. Perfetti filed a Motion to Reconsider the court’s denial of her
Third Motion to Dismiss. Doc. No. 58 (the “Second Motion to Reconsider), On December 30,
2019, she filed a Motion to Dismiss. Doc. No. 61 (the “Fourth Motion to Dismiss”). On December
30, 2019, she filed a response to the Ripas’ allegation that she did not serve the Third Motion to
Dismiss, the Motion to Strike Issuance of this Alias Summons, or the Notices of Hearing. Doc.
No. 63.
On January 6, 2020, Mr. Ripa filed a Response to the Second Motion to Reconsider and
the Fourth Motion to Dismiss. Doc. No, 67.' Ms. Perfetti filed a Response to that Response on
January 8, 2020. Doc. No. 70.
Both parties contacted the court ex parte to express a preference that the court rule on the
papers. The court denied this request and ultimately set a hearing for February 4, 2020 at 10:00
a.m. At that hearing, the court expressed its frustration with the excessive motion practice and the
failures to properly serve by the parties. It asked the parties to consider mediation of their dispute
at no expense. While Mr. Ripa agreed to this, Ms, Perfetti asked for some days to think it over. By
February 7, 2020, Ms. Perfetti contacted the court to decline the mediation offer, asking instead
that the court consider her motions. The matter is now ripe for determination.
DISCUSSION
In making these findings, the court has considered the arguments of the parties, the
credibility and the plausibility of their testimony, and the totality of the evidentiary record.
I: Motion to Reconsider Third Motion to Dismiss
Ms, Perfetti has been apprised of the standard applied to a motion for reconsideration, that
is: “(1) an intervening change in controlling law; (2) the availability of new evidence not available
previously; or (3) the need to correct clear error of law or prevent manifest injustice.” Scofto-
| Though the Clerk’s Office docketed this as a response only to the Motion to Reconsider, the Response addressed
both motions.
Page 3 of 9
DiClemente, 463 B.R, [308,] 310 [(Bankr. D.N.J. 2012)] (citing Walzer v. Muriel Siebert & Co.,
Inc,, 2010 WL 4366197, at *8, 2010 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 115245, at *24 (D.N.J, 2010) (citing North
River Ins. Co. v. CIGNA Reins. Co., 52 F.3d 1194, 1218 Gd Cir. 1995))).” Doc. No. 31, p. 2.
Despite that, in this latest motion, Ms. Perfetti did not suggest that there was any change in
controlling law but mentions facts previously unsubmitted to the court and complains that the court
committed clear error in denying her Third Motion to Dismiss. See Doc. Nos. 52, 53). None of
these “new” facts were previously unavailable. Most of the motion concerns previously available
facts about service of the First Summons, an issue not relevant to denial of the Third Motion to
Dismiss for failure to serve the Third Summons.
Ms. Perfetti also argues that Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 4(m) mandates dismissal if a
defendant is not served within 90 days after the complaint is filed, and alleges that this court stated
“to the contrary.” Doc. No. 58-1, | 6. However, the court actually stated in its Memorandum
Decision the following:
[When a plaintiff fails to serve a defendant within 90 days after the complaint is
filed, instead of dismissing the action, the court must extend the period for service
on motion of the plaintiff if the plaintiff shows good cause for the failure, or may
extend the period for service on its own discretion. Fed. R. Civ. P. 4(m); Petrucelli
yv. Bohringer & Ratzinger, 46 F.3d 1298, 1305 (3d Cir. 1995).
Doc. No. 51, p. 9 (emphasis supplied). Thus, the court did not commit clear error in failing to
dismiss the complaint but instead applied its discretion to give the Ripas another opportunity to
effect service.
Ms. Perfetti further argues that the Ripas should have attempted to serve the Amended
Alias Summons despite the pendency of her motion to strike that summons that she claims she
served on them. Doc. No. 58-1, { 12. Though certainly the Ripas could have so done, betting that
the court would not grant Ms. Perfetti’s motion, the court does not read their lack of doing so as a
“flagrant disregard of Rule 4,” id, as Ms, Perfetti suggests.
Ms. Perfetti on reconsideration now states that she has been prejudiced by the delay in this
proceeding because she lost “some very crucial evidence [that] disappeared from [her] phone due
to the phone deleting (on its own) various text messages that [she] could have used for evidence[.]”
Doc, No. 58-1, □ 13. First, any prejudice should have been raised in the Motion to Dismiss and is
inappropriately raised in reconsideration. Second, though the court is sympathetic to the vagaries
of cell phone storage, the preservation of evidence is the responsibility of the litigant in control of
that evidence. Kronisch v. United States, 150 F.3d 112, 126 (2d Cir. 1998) (“[O]bligation to
_ preserve evidence arises when the party has notice that the evidence is relevant to litigation—most
commonly when suit has already been filed, .. . as for example when a party should have known
that the evidence may be relevant to future litigation.”); Treppel v. Biovail Corp., 233 F.R.D, 363,
373 (S.D.N.Y. 2006) “Certainly, the presumption is that the party possessing information must
bear the expense of preserving it for litigation.”); Wm. T. Thompson Co. v. Gen. Nutrition Corp.,
593 F. Supp. 1443, 1455 (C.D. Cal. 1984) (“While a litigant is under no duty to keep or retain
every document in its possession once a complaint is filed, it is under a duty to preserve what it
knows, or reasonably should know, is relevant in the action, is reasonably calculated to lead to the
Page 4 of 9
discovery of admissible evidence, is reasonably likely to be requested during discovery, and/or is
the subject of a pending discovery request.”),
That Ms. Perfetti may have gambled that no trial would ever be held due to her persistent
Motions to Dismiss is no excuse for not preserving evidence she felt she might need at trial (or
that the Ripas might from her in discovery}—the court understands that she proceeds as a self-
represented litigant, but certainly she did not expect to enter her cell phone into evidence, thus she
should have copied the messages into a form that she could offer into evidence. See United States
v. Browne, 834 F.3d 403, 412 (3d Cir. 2016) (regarding authentication of social media evidence).
The internet is replete with instructions on how to do this. See also Mosaid Techs, Inc. v. Samsung
Elecs. Co., 348 F. Supp. 2d 332, 338 (D.N.J. 2004) (“Samsung knew it had a duty to preserve
potentially discoverable evidence. Samsung knew that e-mails were potentially relevant to this
litigation, Indeed, Samsung itself asked for e-mails in its discovery requests. Samsung also knew
how to [prevent deletion of the email], having done so in one of its divisions in another litigation
beginning in 2002.”). Nevertheless, Ms. Perfetti might also be able to obtain copies of those text
messages from the recipients or from her cell phone provider itself through discovery in this
proceeding.
Accordingly, the court will deny the Second Motion for Reconsideration.
A. Service Issues
As related above, by letter sent to this court, Mr. Ripa complained that he and Mrs. Ripa
never received service of Ms. Perfetti?s Motion to Dismiss Adversary Proceeding or Motion to
Strike Issuance of Amended Alias Summons, or the notices of hearings for either. Doc. No. 57.
Mr. Ripa then asked that the court ensure that he and Mrs. Ripa are properly served by Ms. Perfetti.
id. Ms, Perfetti filed Certificates of Service stating that she served the Ripas with both Motions,
see Doc. Nos. 47, 48, and the Notices of Hearing for each. See Doc. Nos. 49, 50. Notably, there is
no indication that Mr. Ripa served his December 19 letter on Ms. Perfetti.
The court will not attempt to determine which party is lying? since, the court having denied
the two motions, there is no prejudice to the Ripas in not having the opportunity to respond.
The court does not condone lack of service by either party, whether, if true, by Ms. Perfetti
not serving the Ripas, or the Ripas not serving their letter on Ms, Ripa. No party should
communicate with the court, including filing documents or sending letters or email messages,
without the other party’s knowledge. Hartzell v, Miami Cty. Incarceration Facility, 3:17-CV-63,
2017 WL 2590199, at *2 (S.D. Ohio June 15, 2017) (“Parties are not permitted to have ex-parte
communications with the Court. This means that you cannot communicate with the Court about
the merits of your case, orally or in writing, without the other party’s participation.”).
Ms, Perfetti stated in her Response that she mailed the motions “together in one big envelope.” Doc. No. 63. But she
cartier certified that she served the Motion to Dismiss on November 12, 2019 and the Motion to Strike on November
18, 2019. See Doc. Nos. 47, 48. Either she lied or she did not mean that she sent both motions together.
Page 5 of 9
Regarding Mr. Ripa’s request that the court ensure service by Ms. Perfetti, the Ripas should
understand by now that the court is not responsible for serving a party’s filings on the other party.
If the Ripas believe that Ms. Perfetti did not properly serve them, instead of a letter to the court
they should have filed the appropriate motion, with service on Ms, Perfetti to allow her to respond,
II. Fourth Motion to Dismiss
Ms, Perfetti seeks dismissal for lack of personal jurisdiction, alleging that the plaintiffs
failed to properly serve her because they did not serve her within seven days as required by Federal
Rule of Bankruptcy Procedure 7004(e). That rule provides that when service is made under Federal
Rule of Civil Procedure “4(e), (2), (C1), (i) or G2)’, it “shall be by delivery of the summons
and complaint within 7 days after the summons is issued.” Fed. R. Bankr. P. 7004(e).
The Ripas served Ms. Perfetti by mail as permitted by Federal Rule of Bankruptcy
Procedure 7004(b)(9). That rule states that service may be made “[uJpon the debtor . . . by mailing
a copy of the summons and complaint to the debtor at the address shown in the petition or to such
other address as the debtor may designate in a filed writing.” Fed. R. Bankr. P. 7004(b)(9).
However, the summons was issued on December 11, 2019 and not served until December 19,
2019. Doc. No. 56.
As stated in the court’s previous Memorandum, the primary purpose of a summons is to
alert a defendant that a lawsuit has been filed against him or her. Hanna v. Plumer, 380 U.S. 460,
463 n.1 (1965) (purpose of service of process rules is to ensure that defendants receive actual
notice of claims); Eli Lilly & Co. v. Roussel Corp., 23 F. Supp. 2d 460, 474 (D.N.J. 1998) (“The
purpose of the rules governing service of process is to insure that parties receive actual notice of
claims against them.”). See Oklahoma Radio Associates v. F.D.L.C., 969 F.2d 940 (10th Cir. 1992):
Personal service under Rule 4 serves two purposes: notifying a defendant of the
commencement of an action against him and providing a ritual that marks the
court’s assertion of jurisdiction over the lawsuit. See Hagmeyer v. United States
Dep't of Treasury, 647 F, Supp. 1300, 1303 (D.D.C. 1986) (citing 4 Charles A.
Wright and Arthur R, Miller, Federal Practice and Procedure § 1063). Rule 4
service of process provides the mechanism by which a court having venue and
jurisdiction over the subject matter of an action asserts jurisdiction over the person
of the party served. Onmi Capital Int'l v. Rudolf Wolff & Co., 484 U.S. 97, 104, 108
S. Ct. 404, 409, 98 L.Ed.2d 415 (1987) (citing Mississippi Publishing Corp. v.
Murphree, 326 U.S. 438, 444-45, 66 S. Ct. 242, 246, 90 L. Ed. 185 (1946)).
at 943.
There is no question that Ms. Perfetti has received actual notice of the action against her.
She even filed her First Motion to Dismiss before being served with a summons or the complaint.
However, she has not experienced the ritual marking the court’s assertion of jurisdiction over her.
The court has previously explained why it has given the Ripas additional chances to properly serve
Ms. Perfetti, see Doc. No. 51, and will not repeat that reasoning here. But again, as set forth in
. Page 6 of 9 .
prior memorandums, when a plaintiff fails to serve a defendant within 90 days after the complaint
is filed, instead of dismissing the action, the court must extend the period for service on motion of
the plaintiff if the plaintiff shows good cause for the failure, or may extend the period for service
on its own discretion. Fed. R. Civ, P. 4(m) (emphasis supplied); Petrucelli v. Bohringer &
Ratzinger, 46 F.3d 1298, 1305 (Gd Cir. 1995). See In re Tier I JEG Telecommunications Cases,
3:09-CV-00055, 2011 WL 13151969, at *2 (S.D. lowa Sept. 28, 2011) (stating that the error there
“was more than purely technical, but Rule 4(a)(2) is not limited to the correction of purely technical
or trivial misnomers.”). In other words, the grant of an extension is mandatory where a plaintiff
shows good cause but otherwise discretionary with the court when good cause is lacking.
Petrucelli, 46 F.3d at 1305 (“Thus, the logical inference that can be drawn from these two clauses
is that the district court may, in its discretion, extend time even absent a finding of good cause.”).
District Courts in New Jersey consider the following factors in determining whether a
discretionary extension is appropriate in the absence of good cause:
whether the statute of limitations forecloses re-filing of the complaint; the conduct
of the defendant, in particular whether the defendant attempted to evade service;
the conduct of the plaintiff, specifically whether the plaintiff is represented by
counsel; and other equitable reasons for granting relief.
Miles v. City of Newark, 15-1032 (KSH) (CLW), 2016 WL 4923504, at *3 (D.N.J. Sept. 14, 2016).
See also Advisory Committee Note to Rule 4(m) (“[rJelief may be justified . . . if the applicable
statute of limitations would bar the refiled action, or if the defendant is evading service or conceals
a defect in attempted service.”).
The court does not find good cause here. As Ms, Perfetti points out, even as pro se parties,
- the Ripas should be familiar with the Rules by now. See Tuke v. United States, 76 F.3d 155, 156
(7th Cir. 1996) (stating of creditor’s counsel “Failure to read a rule is the antithesis of good
cause.”), Mr. Ripa explained that he received the summons in the mail on December 14, left for a
work trip abroad, and mailed the summons to Ms. Perfetti on his “first day off which was”
December 19, 2019. Doc. No. 67. Since the summons was issued December 11, 2019, it was not
served within seven days of its issuance. But Mr. Ripa does not explain why he did not put the
summons in the mail before leaving the country or why Mrs. Ripa did not mail it while he was
away. Accordingly, the court will not extend the period for service for good cause. See In re
Flaherty, 432 B.R. 742, 752 (Bankr, N.D. Ill. 2010) (“Inadvertent failure to serve process within
the time permitted does not constitute good cause.”).
However, the court yet may extend the period for service on its own discretion. Petrucelli,
46 F.3d at 1306 (“Ef the district court determines that good cause does not exist, only then may it
consider whether the running of the statute of limitations would warrant granting an extension of
time.”), Considering the various factors listed above, this court notes that dismissal of the
adversary proceeding for lack of personal service would terribly prejudice the Ripas as they would
not be able to re-file the proceeding as the deadline to do so has passed. See Jn re Wait, 18-16622-
MKN, 2019 WL 5777654, at *3 (Bankr. D. Nev. Oct. 10, 2019) (“Denying this Motion on
procedural grounds will also result in a final disposition on procedural grounds of Plaintiff's claim
Page 7 of
under Section 523(a)(2), as the time to file such a complaint expired on February 19, 2019.”)
(footnote omitted).
The court also notes that neither the Ripas nor Ms. Perfetti is represented by counsel,
supporting that the court can be more lenient than it would with experienced counsel. As noted
above, had the court not shown lenience to Ms. Perfetti in entertaining her First Motion to
Reconsider, the proceeding would have moved to discovery and mediation and/or trial after the
court denied her Second Motion to Dismiss on July 22, 2019. Thus, it will not countenance Ms.
Perfetti’s claim of prejudice due to the passage of time. The allegations of the Amended Complaint
are plain, and through Ms. Perfetti’s multiple Motions to Dismiss and/or Motions to Reconsider
alleging failure to state a claim, she has demonstrated that she understands the Ripas’ complaint
against her. Moreover, the court is mindful of the Third Circuit’s preference to hear matters on the
merits. Hritz v. Woma Corp., 732 F.2d 1178, 1181 (3d Cir. 1984), See In re Watt, 18-16622-MKN,
2019 WL 5777654, at *3 (Bankr. D, Nev. Oct. 10, 2019) (However, decisions on the merits are
favored over dispositions based on procedural grounds.”). See also In re Barr, 217 BR. 626
(Bankr, W.D. Wash. 1998) (extending deadline for service, despite absence of “good cause,”
where no allegation that creditor was not acting in good faith, was engaged in abuse or unduly
dilatory tactics; errors of creditor’s counsel in failing to properly effectuate service were clearly
technical and easily rectifiable; debtor and his counsel were admittedly aware of filed action and
were not prejudiced by creditor’s delay in effecting service, and deadline for filing
nondischargeability complaints had since expired, such that any dismissal would in effect be with
prejudice to creditor’s ability to refile); Jn re Menges, 337 B.R. 191, 194 (Bankr. N.D. Til. 2006)
(finding no good cause to extend the deadline where counsel merely unfamiliar with the
Bankruptcy Rule, but using its discretion to extend time anyway, noting that “First, Louis has
shown no prejudice from the delay in service, no harm to his ability to defend the adversary.
Second, it appears Louis and his counsel had actual notice of the adversary shortly after it was
filed. And third, a dismissal without prejudice (which is all Rule 4(m) authorizes) would have the
effect, at least in part, of a dismissal with prejudice: because the bankruptcy court has exclusive
jurisdiction over a section 523(a)(15) claim, . . . and because . . . Christine will lose her section
§23(a)(15) claim altogether if the adversary is dismissed.”) (footnote omitted).
The court has already addressed Ms. Perfetti’s alleged prejudice regarding loss of evidence
and has rejected it.
The court notes that while the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure set the time for a defendant
to answer a complaint from the date of service, the Federal Rules of Bankruptcy Procedure set it
from the date of the issuance of the summons. Compare Fed. R. Civ. P. 12(a)(1)(A)(D (21 days
after service) with Fed. R, Bankr. P. 7012(a) (30 days from date of issuance). Thus, the time for
Ms. Perfetti to answer the complaint was shortened by the late service. The court hardly finds that
prejudicial, since Ms. Perfetti is exceedingly familiar with the allegations of the Ripas by now. Jn
701 Mariposa Project, LLC, 514 B.R. 10, 18 (B.A.P. 9th Cir. 2014) (“being denied a quick
victory’ and instead having to defend the merits of a claim typically constitutes little or no
prejudice.”).
But though this court would have liked to cure the service issue by extending Ms. Perfetti’s
time to answer the complaint, some courts have held that service of a stale summons is no service.
Page 8 of 9
See, e.g., Inve S. Design Grp., Inc., 16-51628 MPP, 2018 WL 7016625, at *1 (Bankr. E.D. Tenn.
May 24, 2018) (citing Menges); In re Cutuli, 389 F, Supp. 3d 1051, 1056 (M.D, Fla. 2019) (quoting .
Menges); In re Menges, 337 B.R. 191, 194 (Bankr, N.D, III. 2006); Jn re Dohring, 245 B.R. 262,
263 (Bankr. N.D. Tex. 2000) (service of expired summons is a nullity). See also Advisory
Committee Notes to 2014 Amendment of Fed. R. Bankr. P. 7004 (“If service of the summons
within any seven-day period is impracticable, a court retains the discretion to enlarge that period
of time under Rule 9006(b).”). Since service otherwise complied with Rule 7004, Ms. Perfetti
could have merely asked for an extension of time to answer the complaint rather than to dismiss,
which would have allowed the matter to proceed on the merits. See In re Pasley, 596 B.R. 577,
§83 (Bankr. W.D. Ky. 2019) (finding no bad faith where pro se plaintiff served summons three
days late, commenting that instead of seeking to quash service, the defendants could have simply
moved to extend the time to answer).
But having sought to dismiss, the court will deny Ms. Perfetti*s motion and direct the Ripas
to once more attempt to properly effect service. The court having already ruled that the Amended
Complaint states a claim and alleged fraud with particularity, it expects that this proceeding will
then proceed to discovery and trial and hopefully, no more motions to dismiss.
CONCLUSION
Accordingly, Ms. Perfetti’s Motion to Reconsider and her Motion to Dismiss are denied.
An appropriate order has been entered consistent with this decision.
The court reserves the right to revise its findings of fact and conclusions of law.
/sf Andrew B. Altenburg, Jr.
| United States Bankruptcy Judge
Dated: February 25, 2020
Page 9 of 9