Opinion

Nation v. Piedmont Schools Board of Education

Court
District Court, W.D. Oklahoma
Filed
Jul 23, 2021
Cited by
0 cases
Authority
More cited than 28.6%

“Trial courts should use the uniform jury instructions if they state the applicable law.” (emphasis added)

How later courts described this case

  • “Trial courts should use the uniform jury instructions if they state the applicable law.” (emphasis added)
  • “The bystander Plaintiffs were not directly involved in the accident … and their claims for negligent and intentional emotional distress … must be dismissed”
  • explaining that the opposing party must make a showing sufficient to establish the existence of those elements essential to that party’s case

Written by the judges who cited it.

The opinion

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE

WESTERN DISTRICT OF OKLAHOMA

RUSSELL NATION, individually )

and as parent and next friend of J.N., )

a minor and CAROL NATION, )

individually and as parent and next )

friend of J.N., a minor, )

)

Plaintiffs, )

)

v. ) Case No. CIV-18-1090-R

)

PIEDMONT INDEPENDENT SCHOOL )

DISTRICT NO. 22 and HOLLY )

NOELLE MORRIS, )

)

Defendants. )

ORDER

Before the Court is the Motion for Partial Summary Judgment filed by Defendant

Holly Morris (Doc. No. 77), directed to the claims of Russell and Carol Nation,

individually, whereby each seeks damages for alleged emotional distress. Plaintiffs

responded in opposition to the motion and Defendant filed a reply in support of her position

(Doc. Nos. 80 and 83). Upon consideration of the parties’ submissions, the Court finds as

follows:

Summary judgment is appropriate “if the movant shows that there is no genuine

dispute as to any material fact and the movant is entitled to judgment as a matter of law.”

Fed. R. Civ. P. 56(a). The movant bears the burden of showing that no genuine issue of

material fact exists. Adler v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., 144 F.3d 664, 670–71 (10th Cir. 1998)

(citing Celotex Corp. v. Catrett, 477 U.S. 317, 323 (1986)). The Court resolves all factual

disputes and draws all reasonable inferences in favor of the non-moving party. Macon v.

United Parcel Serv., Inc., 743 F.3d 708, 712–13 (10th Cir. 2014). However, the party

opposing a motion for summary judgment may not rely on “[t]he mere existence of a

scintilla of evidence in support of [its position]; there must be evidence on which the [trier

of fact] could reasonably find for the plaintiff.” Anderson v. Liberty Lobby, Inc., 477 U.S.

242, 252 (1986); see also Celotex Corp. v. Catrett, 477 U.S. 317, 323-33 (1986) (explaining

that the opposing party must make a showing sufficient to establish the existence of those

elements essential to that party’s case).

Plaintiffs filed this action on behalf of themselves and their minor child, J.N., who

is non-verbal and autistic, for injuries allegedly inflicted by Defendant Morris, who served

as J.N.’s teacher at Piedmont Middle School. Plaintiffs allege that J.N. was physically and

verbally abused while at school. Plaintiffs contend they suffered emotional distress as a

result of the harm allegedly inflicted by Ms. Morris. Plaintiffs, individually, seek to

recover from Defendant Morris on a theory of intentional infliction of emotional distress.

Defendant Morris contends that their claims are not cognizable under Oklahoma law,

because Mr. and Mrs. Nation were not directly involved in the incidents whereby J.N. was

allegedly injured by Ms. Morris. Plaintiffs admit they did not witness Ms. Morris mistreat

J.N., their minor child. Although Plaintiffs admit the above, they contend that Carol Nation

had near daily contact with Ms. Morris, that they communicated via text message and that

Mr. Nation saw Ms. Morris while dropping J.N. at school. They argue that they trusted

her, invited her into their home for J.N.’s birthday, and communicated with her regarding

the origin of bruises they found on J.N. Plaintiffs contend that recent updates to the

Oklahoma Uniform Jury Instructions indicate a shift in Oklahoma law, such that the

authorities upon which Defendant Morris relies no longer require that summary judgment

be granted in her favor.

Plaintiffs are correct that the Oklahoma Supreme Court recently updated the “Notes

on Use” section of Oklahoma Uniform Jury Instruction 20.1, which sets forth the elements

of liability for an intentional infliction of emotional distress claim.1 The Oklahoma

Supreme Court removed the following:

The Oklahoma Supreme Court decided in Kraszewskii v. Baptist Ctr., 1996

OK 141, 916 P.2d 241, that a claim for intentional infliction of emotional

distress could arise from a plaintiff’s witnessing an accident, if 1) the plaintiff

was directly physically involved in the accident, 2) the plaintiff was damaged

from viewing the injury, rather than from learning of it later, and 3) the

plaintiff had a familial or other close relationship with the person whose

injury gave rise to the plaintiff’s mental anguish. 1996 OK 141, ¶ 18, 916

P.2d at 250. If any of these matters are in controversy and need to be

presented to the jury, the trial judge should draft an appropriate instruction.

2020 OK 3. Although the Oklahoma Uniform Jury Instructions are instructive as to the

state of Oklahoma law, the Court does not read modifications to the instructions as changes

in the substantive law set forth by the relevant courts.2 The position of the Oklahoma courts

is set forth in a recent unpublished decision of the Tenth Circuit.

“To recover damages for intentional infliction of emotional distress

[(‘IIED’)], a plaintiff must prove: (1) the defendant acted intentionally or

recklessly; (2) the defendant’s conduct was extreme and outrageous; (3) the

1 The elements of the claim did not change.

2 As noted by the court in United States v. Cantu, 964 F.3d 924 (10th Cir. 2020),

… Oklahoma jury instructions are not treated as definitive, see Mitchell v State, 387 P.3d 934, 943

(Okla. Crim. App. 2016) (“Trial courts should use the uniform jury instructions if they state the

applicable law.” (emphasis added)); Okla. Stat. Ann. tit. 12 § 577.2 (“Whenever Oklahoma Uniform

Jury Instructions (OUJI) contains an instruction applicable in a civil case or a criminal case, giving

due consideration to the facts and the prevailing law, and the court determines that the jury should

be instructed on the subject, the OUJI instructions shall be used unless the court determines that it

does not accurately state the law.”).

defendant’s conduct caused the plaintiff emotional distress; and (4) the

resulting emotional distress was severe.” Comput. Publ’ns, Inc. v. Welton,

49 P.3d 732, 735 (Okla. 2002). Additionally, Oklahoma has adopted a

bystander rule: to recover, the plaintiff must have been “directly physically

involved in the incident.” Kraszewski v. Baptist Med. Ctr. of Okla., Inc., 916

P.2d 241, 250 (Okla. 1996); see also Ridings v. Maze, 414 P.3d 835, 840

(Okla. 2018) (“The bystander Plaintiffs were not directly involved in the

accident … and their claims for negligent and intentional emotional distress

… must be dismissed”)

Lynch v. Bd. of Cnty. Comm’rs of Muskogee Cnty., Oklahoma, 786 F. App’x 774, 789 (10th

Cir. 2019). Accordingly, it is apparent to the Court that the intentional infliction of

emotional distress claims of Russell and Carol National cannot be premised on any distress

they suffered as a result of injuries inflicted by Ms. Morris on their son, J.N. That is, to

avoid summary judgment, Plaintiffs Russell and Carol Nation may rely only on actions

directed toward them. The only evidence presented by Plaintiffs in response to the

summary judgment motion is evidence of two meetings between the Nations and

Defendant Morris wherein she allegedly lied and indicated she did not know how J.N.

obtained certain scratches and bruises. (Doc. No. 80-1, pp. 6 and 8). The Court finds this

evidence insufficient to sustain a claim for the intentional infliction of emotional distress.3

For the reasons set forth herein, Defendant Morris’s Motion for Partial Summary

Judgment is GRANTED.

3 Defendant argues in her Reply that Plaintiffs are limited to the claim pled in the Amended Complaint, wherein they

alleged they suffered severe emotional distress due to the abuse directed toward their son. However, the Tenth Circuit

recognizes that “[a]n issue raised for the first time in a motion for summary judgment may properly be considered a

request to amend the complaint, pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 15.” Pater v. City of Casper, 646 F.3d

1209, 1299 (10th Cir. 2011). Accordingly, had Plaintiffs submitted sufficient evidence to support their theory of

liability, the failure to include such allegations in the Amended Complaint, absent a valid claim of prejudice to

Defendant, would not preclude their ability to pursue such a theory.

IT IS SO ORDERED this 23" day of July 2021.

DAVID L. RUSSELL

UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.