Opinion

In re GSE Bonds Antitrust Litigation

Court
District Court, S.D. New York
Filed
Jan 31, 2020
Cited by
0 cases
Authority
More cited than 27.0%

The opinion

| USDC SDNy |

UN eee

SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK Doce CALS

bare rep. L/ S/o |

=!

IN RE GSE BONDS ANTITRUST 19-cv-1704 (JSR)

LITIGATION

mm ~

JED S. RAKOFF, U.S.D.J.

The Court has received letters from three potential class

members in the above captioned case regarding plaintiffs’

settlements with Deutsche Bank Securities, Inc., First Tennessee

Bank, N.A. and FTN Financial Securities Corp., and Goldman Sachs

& Co. LLC. The Court ordered plaintiffs’ counsel to respond in

writing to the letters, which raised assorted concerns about the

settlement process. The Court is satisfied with the response of

plaintiffs’ counsel, attached as Exhibit A to this order.

However, in order to address concerns that one of these

potential class members raised about the timing of the mailing

notice, the Court extends the opt-out and objection deadline to

February 14, 2020 for class members who did not receive a Notice

Packet before the original January 16, 2020 opt-out and

objection deadline. Further, the Court extends the deadline for

all class members to submit their claims to February 28, 2020.

SO ORDERED.

Dated: New York, NY

January Jo 2020 2 S. RAKOFF, U.S.D.Jd.

LAUD

January 24, 2020 ‘

. VIA EMAIL

The Honorable Jed S. Rakoff

United States District Court for the

Southern District of New York

500 Pearl Street

New York, NY 10007-1312

rakoffnysdchambers@nysd.uscourts.gov

Re: = Inre GSE Bonds Antitrust Litig.,

No. 1:19-cy-01704 (JSR) (S.D.N.Y.)

Dear Judge Rakoff:

Pursuant to the Court’s requests, we write to address three inquiries the Court received

from potential Class Members about the settlements with Deutsche Bank Securities, Inc.

(“Deutsche Bank”), First Tennessee Bank, N.A. and FTN Financial Securities Corp. (“FTN”), and

Goldman Sachs & Co. LLC (“Goldman Sachs”).

First, Patrick McGraw emailed the Court on January 18, 2020 regarding the timing of the

mailing of the Notice Packets. Mr. McGraw received his Notice Packet on January 17, 2020

because his broker, Fidelity Investments (“Fidelity”), did not timely provide his mailing

information to A.B. Data, Ltd. (“A.B. Data”). To address Mr. McGraw’s concern, we ask that the

Court extend the opt-out and objection deadline to February 14, 2020 for him and all similarly-

situated Class Members who did not receive a Notice Packet before the original January 16, 2020

opt-out and objection deadline. For all Class Members, we request that the Court extend the

deadline for submitting their claims to February 28, 2020.

Second, Joel Margolis wrote to the Court on January 18, 2020 concerning the usability of

the online claim portal. That same day, Co-Lead Counsel fully addressed Mr. Margolis’s concerns.

Third, Eric Jurist, Esq. sent a letter to the Court dated January 21, 2020 concerning the

substance of the Notice Packet, duration of the Class Period, and claims filing process including

the filing deadline. We believe his complaints about the Notice Packets and Class Period are

unfounded, and the proposed extension of the claims deadline will address his concern about

having sufficient time to submit a claim.

These issues are discussed in detail below.

The Hon. Jed S. Rakoff

January 24, 2020

Page 2

1. NOMINEES FAILED TO TIMELY PROVIDE BENEFICIAL OWNER

INFORMATION, WHICH DELAYED MAILING OF MR. MCGRAW’S AND

OTHER POTENTIAL CLASS MEMBERS’ NOTICE PACKETS

The Court preliminarily approved the notice plan requiring A.B. Data to: (i) mail the

Notice Packet to Class Members who can be identified through reasonable effort; (ii) post the

Notice Packet on the settlement website; (iii) publish notice in The Wall Street Journal, The New

York Times, The Financial Times, and The Bond Buyer; (iv) transmit notice over the PR Newswire;

and (v) implement banner ads on Zacks.com and Barchart.com. ECF Nos. 268, 94; 337, 94.

Further, the Court directed A.B. Data to send Notice to nominee owners, such as brokerage firms

and other persons or entities who or which transacted for the beneficial interest of persons or

organizations other than themselves (“Nominees”), requesting that such Nominees within seven

days of receipt of the Notice: (i) request from the Claims Administrator sufficient copies of the

Notice to forward to beneficial owners; or (ii) provide a list of the names and addresses of

beneficial owners to the Claims Administrator for prompt distribution. ECF Nos. 268, 96; 337,

96.

Providing notice to class members through brokers, financial institutions, and other

relevant nominees is common in securities and financial antitrust class actions because some

individuals and entities purchase instruments under a “street name” — i.e., in the name of a nominee

or brokerage house. Weinberger v. Kendrick, 698 F.2d 61, 71 (2d Cir. 1982) (noting the “difficulty

of ensuring that notice is received by persons whose purchases are recorded in ‘street names’ —

typically banks or brokerage houses” and indicating approval “of the use of bank and brokerage

house records to compile a list of actual holders of securities to whom individual notices would be

mailed”); see also In re AOL Time Warner, Inc., No. 02 Civ. 5575 (SWK), 2006 WL 903236, at

*3 (S.D.N.Y. Apr. 6, 2006) (providing notice of settlements to beneficial owners through brokers

and other nominees in securities class action); Buxbaum v. Deutsche Bank AG, 216 F.R.D. 72, 74

(S.D.N.Y. 2003) (same); Jn re Foreign Exchange Benchmark Rates Antitrust Litig., No. 1:13-cv-

07789-LGS, ECF No. 883, 13 (S.D.N.Y. Sept. 29, 2017) (same in financial antitrust class action);

Alaska Electrical Pension Fund v. Bank of Am., No. 14-cv-7126 (JMF), ECF No. 669, 416

(S.D.N.Y. June 26, 2018) (same in financial antitrust class action).

A.B. Data mailed Notice Packets to 5,005 Nominees on November 12, 2019 (Deutsche

Bank and FTN settlements) and December 23, 2019 (Goldman Sachs settlement). Additionally,

A.B. Data followed up by email on December 9, 2019 (Deutsche Bank and FTN settlements) and

December 23, 2019 (Goldman Sachs settlement) with 870 of the Nominees who previously opted

in to receive email communications from A.B. Data, requesting that the Nominees immediately

request copies of the Notice Packet to mail directly to beneficial owners or provide A.B. Data with

the names and mailing addresses of such beneficial owners. As of January 2, 2020, A.B. Data

received 49,419 names and addresses through the Nominee procedure. ECF No. 350, 410.

The Hon. Jed S. Rakoff

January 24, 2020

Page 3

A, Fidelity Investments and Other Nominees Failed to Timely Provide Beneficial

Owner Information

Despite multiple requests for beneficial owner names and addresses, certain Nominees

were late providing information to A.B. Data. Specifically, A.B. Data received Mr. McGraw’s

contact information from Fidelity on January 6, 2020. A timeline of A.B. Data’s correspondence,

in addition to the general correspondence mentioned above, with Fidelity follows:

e Thursday, December 5, 2019: Fidelity emailed A.B. Data to obtain a CUSIP list.

That same day, A.B. Data responded to Fidelity with an electronic list of CUSIPs

that may qualify as GSE Bond Transactions and be eligible to participate in the

settlements.

e Monday, January 6, 2020: Fidelity emailed A.B. Data a file containing 136,119

names and addresses of potential Class Members (the “Fidelity Data”). A.B.

Data’s internal “Data Formatting Team” began to review the Fidelity Data for

consistency, e.g., ensuring that all fields were in the proper columns and the list

did not combine addresses in the same column with name fields. This process

lasted two days due to the non-standard formatting of the names and addresses in

the Fidelity Data.

e Wednesday, January 8, 2020: The A.B. Data “IS Team” de-duplicated the names

and addresses in the Fidelity Data, added the names and addresses to its database

and created unique identification numbers for all entries (known as the “Notice

ID”), and generated a mailing output to provide to the printer. A.B. Data provided

the revised Fidelity Data to its external printer to compare the names and addresses

against USPS’s National Change of Address (“NCOA”) database and update the

addresses accordingly. The NCOA review lasted a day.

e Thursday, January 9, 2020: Ink jetting the Notice Packets commenced and

continued through Friday, January 10.

e Monday, January 13, 2020: Finalized Notice Packets to the names provided in the

Fidelity Data were delivered to USPS and mailed.

As the timeline demonstrates, A.B. Data corresponded with Fidelity in a timely manner

and processed, printed, and disseminated Notice Packets for Fidelity customers within five

business days of receipt of the Fidelity Data.

In addition to Fidelity, the following Nominees also failed to promptly provide beneficial

owner names and addresses to A.B. Data and submitted such information on the following dates:

(i) Stifel Nicolaus on January 8; (ii) Daiwa Capital Markets America on January 9; (iii) Jefferies

& Co. on January 14; (iv) Stephens, Inc. on January 14; and (v) U.S. Bancorp Investments on

The Hon. Jed S. Rakoff

January 24, 2020

Page 4

January 17. Collectively, these Nominees sent 44,606 names and addresses that A.B. Data has

been handling as quickly as possible. A.B. Data estimates that these potential Class Members will

receive Notice Packets within the next week. In addition, Broadridge Financial Solutions, Inc.

(“Broadridge”), an aggregator that acts on behalf of Nominees to gather and clean their data,

previously requested 347,000 Notice Packets on January 2 to mail directly to beneficial owners.

ECF No. 350, 410.

B. Proposed Extensions for Class Members that Received Notice After the Opt-Out

and Objection Deadline and Extension of the Claims Deadline for All Class

Members

To resolve the issue of certain Nominees’ failure to timely provide beneficial owner

information, Co-Lead Counsel request that the Court extend Mr. McGraw’s and similarly-situated

Class Members’ deadline to opt out or object to the settlements with Deutsche Bank, FTN, and/or

Goldman Sachs to February 14, 2020.! The proposed extension is limited to Class Members who

did not receive a Notice Packet before the original January 16, 2020 opt-out and objection deadline

due to Nominees’ untimely production of beneficial owner information. Deutsche Bank, FTN,

and Goldman Sachs consent to the proposed extensions.

Pursuant to the Preliminary Approval Orders, an opt out must be mailed or delivered such

that it is received by February 14, 2020, to GSE Bond Antitrust Settlement Exclusions c/o A.B.

Data, Ltd., P.O. Box 173001, Milwaukee, WI 53217; and (a) state the name, address, and telephone

number of the person or entity seeking exclusion, and in the case of entities, the name and

telephone number of the appropriate contact person; (b) state that such person or entity requests to

be excluded from the Deutsche Bank, FTN, and/or Goldman Sachs Settlement Class in the Action

(In re GSE Bonds Antitrust Litigation, Lead Case No. 1:19-cv-01704-JSR (S.D.N.Y.)); (c) provide

documents sufficient to prove membership in the Settlement Class; and (d) be signed by such

person or entity requesting the exclusion or an authorized representative, as well as provide proof

of authorization if submitted by an authorized representative. ECF Nos. 268, {11; 337, (11. To

file an objection, a Class Member must file with the Clerk of Court a written objection, and serve

copies on Co-Lead Counsel, Deutsche Bank’s Counsel, FTN’s Counsel, and Goldman Sachs’

Counsel, such that they are received on or before February 14, 2020. ECF Nos. 268, 13-16; 337,

q{13-16. The written objection must include: (i) the name, address, and telephone number of the

person or entity objecting and must be signed by the Settlement Class Member (an attorney’s

signature is not sufficient); (ii) the name of the Action (Jn re GSE Bonds Antitrust Litigation, Lead

Case No. 1:19-cv-01704-JSR (S.D.N.Y.)) and which settlement or settlements the objection

applies to; (iii) a statement of the Settlement Class Member’s objection or objections, and the

specific reasons for each objection, including any legal and evidentiary support the Settlement

Class Member wishes to bring to the Court’s attention; (iv) whether the objection applies only to

the Settlement Class Member, a specific subset of the Settlement Class, or the entire Settlement

Class; and (v) documents sufficient to prove the Settlement Class Member’s membership in the

Settlement Class. Jd.

The Hon. Jed S. Rakoff

January 24, 2020

Page 5

For all Class Members, Co-Lead Counsel request that the claims submission deadline be

extended to February 28, 2020. This will ensure that all Class Members who would like to

participate in the settlements will be afforded the opportunity to do so prior to the Fairness Hearing

on February 28.

To notify potential Class Members of this update, A.B. Data will post the following alert

on the homepage of the settlement website: “ATTENTION: For all Class Members, the deadline

for you to file claims for the Deutsche Bank, FTN, and Goldman Sachs settlements has been

extended to February 28, 2020. For all Class Members who did not receive a Notice Packet before

the original January 16, 2020 opt-out and objection deadline, the deadline for you to opt out or

object to the settlements with Deutsche Bank, FTN, and/or Goldman Sachs has been extended to

February 14, 2020.”

C. Many Beneficial Owners that Received Notice Packets Are Not Class Members

Because Nominees Were Likely Over-Inclusive in Identifying Customers

Since January 16, when the Notice Packets to beneficial owners began arriving at homes

and businesses, Co-Lead Counsel and A.B. Data have been fielding numerous telephone and email

inquiries from beneficial owners who did not directly invest in GSE Bonds, but held shares of

ETFs and mutual funds that contained GSE Bonds along with a mix of other securities.

Accordingly, A.B. Data contacted the Nominees to determine how beneficial owners were

identified and is working with Nominees to better tailor their searches to the contours of the

Settlement Class definition for the future round of notices, if the additional settlements are

approved.

D. The Notice Program Meets Due Process and Rule 23 Standards

“Tt is ‘widely recognized that for the due process standard to be met it is not necessary that

every class member receive actual notice, so long as class counsel acted reasonably in selecting

means likely to inform persons affected.”’ Buxbaum, 216 F.R.D. at 80 (citation omitted); see, e.g.,

Inre Marsh & McLennan Companies, Inc. Sec. Litig., No. 04 Civ. 8144 (CM), 2009 WL 5178546,

at *24 (S.D.N.Y. Dec. 23, 2009) (rejecting challenge to notice program and reasoning “[t]hat

certain objectors’ brokers failed to comply with the Preliminary Approval Order and forward their

clients the necessary paperwork in a timely fashion is no fault of Lead Counsel”); id. “Moreover,

‘notice provided to the class members’ nominees — i.e., the brokerage houses — has been deemed

sufficient even if brokerage houses failed to timely forward the notice to the beneficial owners.’”)

(collecting cases); In re Facebook, Inc., IPO Sec. & Derivative Litig., 343 F. Supp. 3d 394, 411

(S.D.N.Y. 2018) (rejecting challenge to timeliness of notice program and stating “[w]hile it is less

than ideal for certain investors not to have received Notice Packets prior to relevant deadlines,

alternate notice was provided in widely distributed publications, such as Investor’s Business Daily,

at least one national newswire, and on the internet.”).

The Hon. Jed S. Rakoff ‘

January 24, 2020

Page 6

Because notice of the settlements was mailed to individual Class Members who could be

identified through reasonable effort, publicized in widely-distributed publications and two

financial websites, distributed by one national newswire, and posted on the settlement website, the

notice program satisfies due process and Rule 23. Moreover, given the proposed extensions, Co-

Lead Counsel believes that the issues created by Nominees’ untimeliness will be remedied. Co-

Lead Counsel will further address the notice plan in their reply brief in support of final approval

of the settlements with Deutsche Bank, FTN, and Goldman Sachs on February 18.

Il. MARGOLIS’S CLAIMS-FILING ISSUES HAVE BEEN RESOLVED

Co-Lead Counsel received an email from Mr. Margolis on January 17 expressing concern

about the online claim form and promptly responded on January 17 and January 18. The emails

explained to Mr. Margolis how to access the online portal for claims submission. After receiving

the Court’s January 22 letter, we contacted Mr. Margolis again. Mr. Margolis said that he sent the

letter before seeing Co-Lead Counsel’s email responses and that he had, in fact, submitted his

claim online. After speaking with Mr. Margolis further about the nature of his transactions, we

learned that he purchased a Fannie Mae bond through a non-defendant broker and, thus, is not a

Class Member.

A.B. Data updated the settlement website to make it clearer that Class Members should use

the portal link to file a claim. A.B. Data also added language to inform Class Members that the

.pdf version of the claim form is intended as a reference to assist with gathering information before

submitting the claim electronically. If for any reason a Class Member is unable to complete the

online claim form, A.B. Data will accept the paper version and manually enter the data into its

system.

Il. MR. JURIST’S CONCERNS REGARDING THE SUBSTANCE OF THE NOTICES

AND THE LENGTH OF THE CLASS PERIOD ARE UNFOUNDED, AND THE

PROPOSED EXTENSION OF THE CLAIMS-FILING DEADLINE WILL

ADDRESS HIS REMAINING CONCERN

Mr. Jurist’s concerns about the format and substance of the Notice Packet are unfounded.

The Notice states in plain, easily understood language each of the Notice requirements of Rule

23(c)(2)(B)(i)-(vii). We recognize that certain aspects of this complex antitrust action may be

difficult for Class Members to understand. This is why the Notice included contact information

for Co-Lead Counsel and the Claims Administrator and repeatedly invited Class Members to reach

out with questions.

While we understand the difficulty of obtaining records for the entirety of the Class Period,

the Class Period was selected based on the duration of the alleged conduct. Further, Mr. Jurist

himself was able to obtain relevant records for seven of the ten years in the Class Period.

The Hon. Jed S. Rakoff

January 24, 2020

Page 7

Finally, Mr. Jurist’s concern regarding the time to complete the online claims submission

process would be addressed by Co-Lead Counsel’s proposed extension of the claims deadline.

* * * * *

In conclusion, Co-Lead Counsel requests that the Court extend the opt-out and objection

deadlines to February 14, 2020 for Class Members who did not receive a Notice Packet before the

original January 16, 2020 opt-out and objection deadline. For all Class Members, Co-Lead

Counsel requests that the Court extend the claims deadline to February 28, 2020.

Respectfully submitted,

SCOTT+SCOTT ATTORNEYS AT LOWEY DANNENBERG, P.C.

LAW LLP

s/ Christopher M. Burke s/ Vincent Briganti

Christopher M. Burke Vincent Briganti

600 W. Broadway, Suite 3300 44 South Broadway, Suite 1100

San Diego, CA 92101 White Plains, NY 10601

Tel: (619) 233-4565 Tel: (914) 997-0500

cburke@scott-scott.com vbriganti@lowey.com

ce: Patrick A. McGraw (mpmcgraw@att.net)

Joel Margolis (jmargolis@juno.com)

Eric Jurist (ejurist@optimum.net)

Abram Ellis '

John Terzaken

Robert Wick

Henry Liu

Richard Pepperman II

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.