Opinion

Godbold v. Cherokee County

Court
District Court, W.D. North Carolina
Filed
Feb 3, 2023
Cited by
0 cases
Authority
More cited than 24.9%

The opinion

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF NORTH CAROLINA

ASHEVILLE DIVISION

CIVIL CASE NO. 1:20-cv-00202-MR-WCM

STEPHANIE GODBOLD, by and )

through her Guardian ad Litem )

Joy McIver, )

)

Plaintiff, )

) ORDER APPROVING

vs. ) SETTLEMENT

)

CHEROKEE COUNTY, et al., )

)

Defendants. )

________________________________ )

THIS MATTER is before the Court on the Plaintiff’s Consent Motion to

Approve Settlement [Doc. 33].1

BACKGROUND

This action arises from the alleged use of an extra-judicial Custody and

Visitation Agreement (“CVA”) by the Cherokee County Department of Social

Services (“Cherokee County DSS”), which caused the Plaintiff Stephanie

Godbold to lose the care, custody, and control of her minor child.

1 The Plaintiff’s Consent Motion was initially denied without prejudice on June 13, 2022.

[Doc. 34]. The Plaintiff, through counsel, renewed the motion orally before the Court

during a hearing held for the approval of settlements in a related consolidated matter,

Simonds v. Cherokee County, No. 1:20-cv-00250-MR-WCM.

On June 25, 2020, the Plaintiff, by and through Teresa Holloway, the

guardian of her person, filed a Complaint in the Superior Court Division of

the North Carolina General Court of Justice, Cherokee County, against

Defendant Cherokee County, Defendant Scott Lindsay, Defendant Cindy

Palmer, and Defendant Donna Crawford, asserting claims under 42 U.S.C.

§ 1983 for violation of her constitutional rights, as well as claims under North

Carolina state law, for the wrongful removal of her minor child.2 [Doc. 1-1].

Thereafter, the Plaintiff filed an Amended Complaint. [Doc. 2]. On July 27,

2020, the Defendants removed the action to this Court. [Doc. 1]. On August

3, 2020, the Defendants filed a motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim;

the Plaintiff responded, and the Defendants replied. [Docs. 3, 5, 6]. On

November 20, 2020, the Plaintiff filed a stipulation of dismissal against

Defendant Crawford. [Doc. 11]. The Court ultimately denied the motion to

dismiss on March 29, 2021. [Doc. 15]. Subsequently, the Defendants filed

answers. [Docs. 16, 17, 18].

2 Defendants Lindsay, Palmer, and Crawford were sued in both their individual and official

capacities.

2

On May 5, 2021, the Court issued a Pretrial Order and Case

Management Plan, establishing deadlines for Rule 26 disclosures, expert

reports, discovery, mediation, dispositive motions, and trial. [Doc. 20].

During discovery, the parties served initial disclosures and exchanged

thousands of documents, including many documents that had been obtained

in related litigation against Cherokee County DSS.3 The parties also

engaged in ongoing settlement negotiations throughout the discovery

process. Finally, in May 2022, the parties agreed to settle this action.

Thereafter, the Plaintiff filed a Consent Motion to Approve the Settlement.

[Doc. 33]. The Court denied that Consent Motion without prejudice, however,

due to a lack of documentation to support the settlement. [Doc. 34].

In November 2022, the Plaintiff moved for the appointment of Joy

McIver as Guardian ad Litem to prosecute and complete the settlement of

this action on Ms. Godbold’s behalf. [Doc. 36]. The Court granted this

motion and dismissed Ms. Holloway as a plaintiff representative. [Doc. 37].

3 This related litigation includes Hogan v. Cherokee County, 1:18-cv-96 (W.D.N.C.); Molly

Cordell v. Cherokee County, 1:20-cv-199 (W.D.N.C.); Heaven Cordell v. Cherokee

County, 1:20-cv-200 (W.D.N.C.); and a number of other cases that were subsequently

consolidated into one action, Simonds v. Cherokee County, 1:20-cv-250 (W.D.N.C.). All

of these related actions were assigned to and heard by the undersigned.

3

In the meantime, the attorneys for the Plaintiff and the attorneys for the

Defendants in this action were also actively involved in settling the related

Cherokee County litigation, resulting in a global settlement of those actions.

The Court held a hearing to approve these settlements on December 12, 13,

and 14, 2022. During those hearings, counsel requested that the Court also

conduct a hearing to approve the parties’ settlement in the present action

and to approve the creation of a special needs trust to receive any and all

settlement proceeds payable to the Plaintiff.4

This matter came to be heard on December 14, 2022. Present for the

proceeding were the Plaintiff Stephanie Godbold; the Plaintiff’s guardian of

the person, Teresa Holloway; the Guardian ad Litem, Joy McIver; the

proposed Trustee Brian T. Lawler; attorneys Ronald L. Moore and David A.

Wijewickrama, as counsel for the Plaintiff; and attorneys Sean F. Perrin,

Patrick H. Flanagan, and Mary E. Euler, as counsel for the Defendants. Prior

to the hearing, the Court reviewed the pleadings filed in this case, as well as

the Settlement Agreement and Release executed by the parties [Doc. 40]

and the proposed Special Needs Trust for the benefit of the Plaintiff [Doc.

38-1]. At the hearing, the Court requested that counsel for the Plaintiff and

4 The Plaintiff has filed a Petition for Creation of Trust [Doc. 38], which will be addressed

by a separate Order entered contemporaneously herewith.

4

the Defendants give a forecast of their trial evidence and provide a candid

evaluation of the strengths and weaknesses of the Plaintiff’s claims and any

defenses thereto. The parties complied with the Court’s request and

proffered a detailed description of the factual and legal circumstances of this

matter.

At the hearing, the Court heard from Ms. McIver as the Guardian ad

Litem and from Ms. Holloway as the Plaintiff’s guardian of the person, and

they each expressed their opinion that the amount of the settlement and the

proposed distribution of those funds are fair and reasonable and in the best

interests of the Plaintiff. The Court further heard from Mr. Lawler, as the

proposed Trustee of the Special Needs Trust, who explained the manner in

which the Special Needs Trust would operate for the benefit of the Plaintiff.

No other family member or interested person has appeared before the Court

to enter any objection to the proposed settlement or to the proposed

distribution of the settlement funds.

FINDINGS OF FACT

Based on the foregoing, the Court makes the following findings of fact:

1. On January 27, 2010, social workers employed by Cherokee County

DSS approached the Plaintiff and presented her with a CVA to sign.

The CVA purported to transfer physical and legal custody of the

5

Plaintiff’s minor child to another person. While formatted to look like a

court order and containing language concerning the home state of the

minor child as defined in the Uniform Child Custody Jurisdiction and

Enforcement Act as well as other legally significant terms of art, the

CVA was executed without court oversight or approval. A Cherokee

County DSS social worker directed the Plaintiff to sign the CVA, and

the Plaintiff, in fact, signed the document in the belief that she had no

choice other than to do so.

2. Within months of presenting the CVA to the Plaintiff, Cherokee County

DSS brought an action before the Clerk of Superior Court for Cherokee

County seeking an adjudication that the Plaintiff was incompetent. The

Clerk granted this petition and appointed Teresa Holloway as guardian

of the person for the Plaintiff on March 23, 2010. [See Doc. 36-2].

3. Ms. Holloway has acted, without fail, as the guardian of the person for

the Plaintiff since that time, and the Plaintiff continues to reside with

Ms. Holloway to this day.

4. As a result of the CVA, the Plaintiff lost care, custody, and control of

her minor child, lost all ability to control the medical care and physical

placement of her minor child, and lost the opportunity to have love,

affection, care, companionship, and kindly offices of her minor child.

6

5. Based on the evidence obtained during discovery in the present action,

as well as during the discovery phase of the related Cherokee County

cases, counsel for the Plaintiff believed that they had a strong case for

liability based upon Cherokee County DSS’s use of an extra-judicial

custody agreement, which the Plaintiff was pressured to sign only

weeks before the very same agency sought to have her declared

incompetent. Counsel acknowledged, however, that given the

Plaintiff’s intellectual and emotional limitations, subjecting the Plaintiff

to a discovery deposition and possibly to testifying at trial would be

extremely detrimental to her. Counsel also acknowledged that the

period of time that the Plaintiff was wrongfully deprived of the custody

of her minor child was relatively short (approximately 48 days), which

would likely have resulted in a lower damages award had the case

proceeded to a jury trial.

6. Despite the noted strengths of the Plaintiff’s case, counsel also

acknowledged the inherent uncertainties that exist in proceeding to a

trial, including the risk of a defense verdict, thereby recovering nothing

on behalf of the Plaintiff, and the aforementioned harm that testifying

would possibly cause the Plaintiff. Counsel further noted the existence

of various defenses that could be asserted by the Defendants at trial,

7

including the defenses of qualified immunity, sovereign immunity, and

public official immunity. Counsel also noted that there were legitimate

concerns regarding the Defendants’ ability to pay any judgment that

would result from a trial, including issues of the individual Defendants’

solvency, the difficulty of establishing the County’s liability under

Monell,5 and whether adequate insurance coverage existed, if at all, to

pay any verdict obtained against Cherokee County and the related

Defendants.

7. Finally, Plaintiff’s counsel noted that they do not intend to seek an

award of fees in this case, and that the settlement amount agreed upon

is in line with the net amount paid to plaintiffs in other similar cases

brought against the Cherokee County Defendants and settled around

the same time.

8. In light of these considerations, as well as the uncertainty of submitting

the case to a jury, both the Plaintiff’s and the Defendants’ counsel

stated they believed that the settlement reached is a fair resolution of

the Plaintiff’s claims.

5 Monell v. Dep’t of Soc. Servs. of City of New York, 436 U.S. 658 (1978).

8

9. At the hearing held on December 14, 2022, the Guardian Ad Litem

opined that the settlement is fair and reasonable and in the best

interest of the Plaintiff, and therefore recommended that the settlement

be approved.

10. At the hearing held on December 14, 2022, Teresa Holloway, as the

guardian of the person of the Plaintiff, acknowledged that she:

(a) had read the settlement documents filed in this matter, including

the Settlement and Release Agreement, and that she

understands and assents to the terms thereof.

(b) had an adequate opportunity to confer with counsel regarding the

settlement of this matter.

(c) understands that the settlement documents propose that certain

consideration be paid for the benefit of the Plaintiff.

(d) believes, in her capacity as guardian of the person of the Plaintiff,

that the proposed settlement is fair and reasonable for the

Plaintiff under the circumstances of this case, particularly as to

the nature of the settlement, the amount of monetary payments

to be made under the settlement, and the proposed

disbursements of the settlement funds.

9

(e) understands that, if the Court approves the Settlement

Agreement and Release and creates a Trust as requested, the

consideration due will be provided as described in the settlement

documents filed herewith.

(f) understands that, if the Court approves the Settlement

Agreement and Release, the provision of the consideration for

the settlement by the Defendants will terminate any claims of the

Plaintiff against the Defendants, and that the Plaintiff will be

enjoined from seeking any future redress against the Defendants

based upon the acts and omissions alleged in the Complaint.

11. Based on all the foregoing, the Court finds and concludes that the

Settlement Agreement and Release is fair and reasonable under all of

the circumstances of this case; that the consideration to be provided

under the terms of the Settlement Agreement and Release is fair and

reasonable; and that the proposed disbursement of such consideration

is fair and reasonable.

CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Based upon the foregoing findings of fact, the Court makes the

following conclusions of law:

10

1. As an incompetent adult, the Plaintiff lacks sufficient capacity to

manage her own affairs or to make or communicate important

decisions concerning her person, family, or property, and she therefore

requires the assistance of a guardian in order to help her exercise her

rights, including the management of her property and personal affairs.

N.C. Gen. Stat. §§ 35A-1101(7), 35A-1201(a).

2. Attorney Joy McIver, acting in her capacity as the Guardian ad Litem

for the Plaintiff, is competent in all respects; is able to understand the

ramifications of the Settlement Agreement and Release, as well as the

effect such agreement would have upon the Plaintiff; and is competent

and able to execute her duties accordingly.

3. Teresa Holloway, acting in her capacity as guardian of the person for

the Plaintiff, is competent in all respects; is able to understand the

ramifications of the Settlement Agreement and Release, as well as the

effect such agreement would have upon the Plaintiff; and is competent

and able to execute her duties accordingly.

4. Having reviewed the details of the proposed disbursement of funds for

the Plaintiff, including the payment dates and amounts, the Court finds

that the extent, nature, and amount of recovery for the Plaintiff are all

fair and reasonable, and the disbursement of such funds as provided

11

in the Settlement Agreement and Release is in the best interests of the

Plaintiff.

5. The disbursement of the settlement proceeds, as set forth in the

Settlement Agreement and Release, benefits Ms. Godbold by the way

in which the funds are to be disbursed. The parties have specifically

informed the Court that all are in agreement as to the manner of

distribution set forth therein and are capable of carrying into effect the

same.

6. Attorney Joy McIver, acting in her capacity as the Guardian ad Litem

for the Plaintiff, and Teresa Holloway, acting in her capacity as

guardian of the person for the Plaintiff, have bound the Plaintiff herein

in the same manner as if the Plaintiff had consented to the settlement

as a competent adult.

7. The Settlement and Release Agreement should be approved.

IT IS, THEREFORE, ORDERED that the Plaintiff’s Consent Motion to

Approve Settlement [Doc. 33] is GRANTED, and the parties’ Settlement

Agreement and Release [Doc. 40] is hereby APPROVED.

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the parties shall file a Stipulation of

Dismissal of this action no later than 90 days from the entry of this Order.

12

An Order creating a trust to receive the settlement proceeds payable

to the Plaintiff is hereby entered contemporaneously herewith.

IT IS SO ORDERED.

Signed: February 3, 2023

Martifi Reidinger ey

Chief United States District Judge “lly

13

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.