Opinion

IN RE PORK ANTITRUST LITIGATION

Court
District Court, D. Minnesota
Filed
Nov 14, 2021
Cited by
0 cases
Authority
More cited than 23.9%

The opinion

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

DISTRICT OF MINNESOTA

IN RE PORK ANTITRUST LITIGATION No. 18-1776 (JRT/HB)

No. 21-2998 (JRT/HB)

This Document Relates to: ALL ACTIONS

MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER

CONSOLIDATING ACTIONS

The issue of whether to consolidate these actions for pretrial proceedings is before

the Court following the Court’s Briefing Order requesting the parties address whether the

member cases of ECF Case No. 18-1776 and ECF Case No. 21-2998 should be formally

consolidated into a single multidistrict litigation (MDL) or simply coordinated as much as

possible without formal consolidation. The Court will consolidate the cases for all future

pretrial proceedings into a single MDL because the Court concludes that consolidation

will best promote efficiency, prevent confusion and unnecessary complication, and

prevent duplicative or conflicting decisions.

BACKGROUND

Beginning in 2018, a series of class actions and individual actions were filed against

the leading American pork producers alleging the producers had engaged in a price fixing

conspiracy in violation of federal and state antitrust laws. (See, e.g., Case No. 18-1776,

Compl., June 28, 2018, Docket No. 1.) Pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 42(a),

the Court began consolidating the related cases filed in the District of Minnesota for

pretrial proceedings in September 2018 under Case Number 181776. (Case No. 18-1776,

Initial Case Mgmt. Order, Sept. 21, 2018, Docket No. 85.) The Case Management Order

provided that related “actions later instituted in, removed to, or transferred to this Court”

under 28 U.S.C. § 1407 would be consolidated with 18-1776. (Id. ¶¶ 9–10.) This Order

also renamed the consolidated litigation “In Re Pork Antitrust Litigation.” (Id. ¶ 6.) As

more cases were filed in the District of Minnesota, the Court consolidated these cases.

(Case No. 18-1776, Order Stip. Regarding Consolidation, Jan. 21, 2021, Docket No. 644.)

In 2021, additional cases brought by individual plaintiffs were filed in other federal

district courts involving the same issues. In re Pork Direct & Indirect Purchaser Antitrust

Litig., No. 2998, 2021 WL 2369199, at *1 (J.P.M.L. June 9, 2021). Pursuant to 28 U.S.C.

§ 1407(a), the Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation (“JPML”) formed MDL Number

2998 and transferred two cases to this Court on June 9, 2021, finding that the cases

involved common questions of fact and centralization in this Court would “serve the

convenience of the parties and witnesses and promote the just and efficient conduct of

this litigation.” Id. The JPML has continued transferring additional cases from other

districts to this Court. (E.g., Case No. 21-2998, Conditional Transfer Order, July 15, 2021,

Docket No. 8.)

In its initial Transfer Order, the JPML concluded that transfer to this Court would

best accomplish the purposes of MDL centralization under 28 U.S.C. § 1407, because this

Court has presided over the consolidated Minnesota litigation since 2018 including

dealing with motions to dismiss. In re Pork, 2021 WL 2369199, at *1. Specifically, it found

that centralizing the cases would prevent “duplicative pretrial proceedings and

potentially inconsistent pretrial rulings.” Id. Accordingly, the JPML transferred the

actions to this Court for “coordinated or consolidated pretrial proceedings” and named

the MDL it created “In re: Pork Antitrust Litigation.” Id. at *2.

The Court held a status conference on July 14, 2021, for all parties in both Case

Number 18-1776 and Case Number 21-2998. (Case No. 18-1776, Min. Entry Status Conf.,

July 14, 2021, Docket No. 835; Case No. 21-2998, Min. Entry Status Conf., July 14, 2021,

Docket No. 9.) The main purpose of this status conference was to determine the most

efficient and just manner of handling all the cases and how to best coordinate the MDL

and the previously filed cases. (See Case No. 18-1776, Tr. at 4:15–19, July 27, 2021,

Docket No. 839; Case No. 21-2998, Tr. at 4:15–19, July 27, 2021, Docket No. 14.) A central

question was whether the cases should be formally consolidated or just coordinated to

the greatest extent possible. The Court ordered the parties to address this question in

written submissions. (Case No. 18-1776, Briefing Order, Aug. 5, 2021, Docket No. 869;

Case No. 21-2998, Briefing Order, Aug. 5, 2021, Docket No. 23.)

In response, the parties took different positions:

• The Direct Purchaser Plaintiffs (“DPPs”) support consolidation. (Case No.

18-1776, DPPs’ Br. Regarding Consolidation, Aug. 19, 2021, Docket No. 895;

Case No. 21-2998, DPPs’ Br. Regarding Consolidation, Aug. 19, 2021, Docket

No. 35.)

• The Defendants support consolidation. (Case No. 18-1776, Defs.’ Br.

Regarding Consolidation, Aug. 19, 2021, Docket No. 896; Case No. 21-2998,

Aug. 19, 2021, Docket No. 31.)

• The Consumer Indirect Purchase Plaintiffs (“CIPs”) argued that regardless of

whether the Court coordinated or consolidated the cases, the JPML already

centralized the cases in an MDL and the Court should allow all parties to

benefit from MDL procedures. (Case No. 18-1776, CIPs’ Br. Regarding

Briefing Order, Aug. 19, 2021, Docket No. 897; Case No. 21-2998, CIPs’ Br.

Regarding Briefing Order, Aug. 19, 2021, Docket No. 33.)

• The Commercial and Institutional Indirect Purchaser Plaintiffs (“CIIPPs”)

support consolidation. (Case No. 18-1776, CIIPPs’ Br. Regarding

Consolidation, Aug. 19, 2019, Docket No. 899; Case No. 21-2998, CIIPPs’ Br.

Regarding Consolidation, Aug. 19, 2019, Docket No. 36.)

• The MDL Direct Action Plaintiffs (“DAPs”), whose cases were specifically

transferred by the JPML, oppose consolidation. (Case No. 21-2998, MDL

DAPs’ Resp. Regarding Briefing Order, Aug. 19, 2019, Docket No. 32.)

DISCUSSION

If civil actions in different districts involve one or more common questions of fact,

the JPML may set up an MDL and transfer the actions to one district for coordinated or

consolidated pretrial proceeding if the JPML determines that this “will be for the

convenience of parties and witnesses and will promote the just and efficient conduct of

such actions.” 28 U.S.C. § 1407(a). The purpose of MDL centralization is to “eliminate

duplicative discovery, avoid inconsistent pretrial rulings, and conserve the resources of

the parties, their counsel and the judiciary.” In re Vioxx Prod. Liab. Litig., 360 F. Supp. 2d

1352, 1354 (J.P.M.L. 2005); see also In re Pork, 2021 WL 2369199, at *1. Once transferred,

the JPML leaves “the extent and manner of coordination or consolidation of these actions

to the discretion of the transferee court.” In re Vioxx, 360 F. Supp. 2d at 1354.

Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 42, if “actions before the court involve a

common question of law or fact, the court may: (1) join for hearing or trial any or all

matters at issue in the actions; (2) consolidate the actions; or (3) issue any other orders

to avoid unnecessary cost or delay.” Fed. R. Civ. P. 42(a). Rule 42 permits consolidation

even if the claims arise out of independent transactions. Madison v. Hennepin Cnty., No.

02-4756, 2003 WL 21639221, at *1 (D. Minn. July 1, 2003). When deciding whether to

consolidate cases, courts consider the risk of inconsistent rulings and the burden on and

cost to parties, witnesses, and the court. Chill v. Green Tree Fin. Corp., 181 F.R.D. 398,

405 (D. Minn. 1998) (citing Cantrell v. GAF, 999 F.2d 1007, 1011 (6th Cir. 1993)).

“Consolidation is inappropriate, however, if it leads to inefficiency, inconvenience, or

unfair prejudice to a party.” EEOC v. HBE Corp., 135 F.3d 543, 551 (8th Cir. 1998). Under

Rule 42(a), “[d]istrict courts enjoy substantial discretion in deciding whether and to what

extent to consolidate cases.” Hall v. Hall, 138 S. Ct. 1118, 1131 (2018).

In sum, the purposes of forming MDLs through transfer by the JPML under 28

U.S.C. § 1407(a) and the purposes of Rule 42(a) consolidation are substantially identical

as is the discretion left to the district court on these matters.

The Court concludes that consolidation of all the related pork antitrust cases

pending in the District of Minnesota is the best method to fulfill these purposes. It would

be unwieldy and unnecessary for both the Court and the parties to attempt to maintain

these actions under two separate case numbers. The Court would have to issue different

scheduling orders, hear separate motions, and attempt to avoid inconsistent rulings.

Parties—and in some cases nonparties—would have to comply with two sets of orders

and file on multiple dockets after making changes to each filing. The cases raise identical

issues of fact, many identical issues of law, and other similar if not identical issues of law.

Consolidation will reduce the problems posed by having the cases on separate

dockets while addressing both similar and identical issues on each docket. The parties

and the Court will generally need to only file in one centralized place and will not have to

deal with making minor changes to satisfy the different case numbers. The parties,

affected nonparties, and the Court will generally need only follow developments on one

unified docket. This unified docket reduces the risk of a party or the Court making a filing

error, eliminating the need for additional proceedings to address these issues and the risk

of increased costs or prejudice affecting resolution of the cases on the merits. A

consolidated case will decrease the risk that the Court will inadvertently enter conflicting

or inconsistent rulings and, if the Court were to do so, centralizes and simplifies resolution

of these issues. Finally, as the parties supporting consolidation note, a protective order

applicable in one case would not necessarily apply in the other case, potentially increasing

the burdens on parties and nonparties and the legal risks to parties.

The process of deciding whether to consolidate these cases demonstrates why

consolidation will be the most efficient manner of managing these cases. Parties were

forced to file their briefs on multiple dockets. The Court had to review each submission

on each docket to ensure they were in fact identical. In the future, consolidation will

conserve resources for the parties and the Court by eliminating these redundancies

especially as the Court and parties deal with more complicated and substantive issues.

Consolidation of the cases into a single MDL has yet another advantage. An MDL

authorizes the Court to “exercise the powers of a district judge in any district for the

purpose of conducting pretrial depositions.” 28 U.S.C. § 1407(b) (emphasis added).

Consolidating the cases into the MDL will therefore further increase efficiency and

decrease the risk of inconsistent discovery rulings by eliminating the need for multiple

courts to get involved in addressing nonparty subpoenas.1

Finally, the Court concludes that consolidating all pending cases into one MDL is

consistent with the JPML’s orders creating the MDL and transferring cases from other

districts to this Court. Centralizing the DAP cases outside this district would have resulted

“in duplicative pretrial proceedings and potentially inconsistent pretrial rulings.” In re

Pork, 2021 WL 2369199, at *1. Consolidation further eliminates the need for duplicative

proceedings and the risk of inconsistency.

DAPs oppose consolidation for several reasons. First, the DAPs argue their pretrial

proceedings will be substantially different as they are not structured around class

certification issues. They argue that these class certification issues may also delay

resolution of their own cases as class certification issues are resolved. Second, they argue

that DAPs have a materially different procedural posture than the other cases and that

additional DAPs are in the process of being filed and transferred. They note that this

causes problem with the existing scheduling order because several dates have already or

will soon pass. Third, the DAPs argue they will be prejudiced by the existing case which

has been driven by issues related to class certification, by the existing orders that the

1 Although the language of 28 U.S.C. § 1407(b) only explicitly grants authority to the MDL judge to oversee

nonparty depositions outside its district, this grant of authority is generally understood to apply to all pretrial

proceedings including nonparty, document-only subpoenas. See United States ex rel. Pogue v. Diabetes Treatment

Ctrs. of Am., Inc., 444 F.3d 462, 469 n.4 (6th Cir. 2006); In re Disposable Contact Lens Antitrust Litig., 306 F. Supp. 3d

372, 378 (D.D.C. 2017) (collecting cases); In re Bank of N.Y. Mellon Corp. Forex Transactions Litig., No. 11-9175, 2014

WL 2884726, at *1 (S.D.N.Y. June 26, 2014) (collecting cases).

DAPs did not participate in developing, and because DAPs have not yet engaged in early

discovery issues.

The Court recognizes that there may be some bumps on the consolidation road,

but still concludes it will be the smoothest, most efficient route to resolving this case.

First, the parties and the Court will need to harmonize the existing orders between the

cases. This, however, is a temporary burden that will be offset by the decreased burden

in the long term. Second, the differences between the cases may create individualized

discovery and motions issues that only apply to some parties. The Court, however, can

accommodate these issues as they arise or create separate tracks within the consolidated

case as necessary to ensure each member case is resolved on its own legal theories and

merits and decrease the risk of delay. See In re: Darvocet, Darvon & Propoxyphene Prod.

Liab. Litig., 780 F. Supp. 2d 1379, 1381 (J.P.M.L. 2011); In re: Checking Acct. Overdraft

Litig., 626 F. Supp. 2d 1333, 1335 (J.P.M.L. 2009). For example, if such differences become

unwieldy or issues such as those surrounding class certification create a risk of undue

delay or prejudice to the DAPs, the Court may create an expedited track for them within

the consolidated case or separate the cases again. Third, to the extent a party may be

prejudiced by an existing order, the Court can address this by issuing new orders. The

Court will ensure that no party is prejudiced or otherwise burdened to the extent

practicable by this Order by delaying deadlines, staying orders, and denying sanctions

against a party that cannot reasonably comply with a deadline or order due to this Order.

To ensure that these issues are addressed, the Court will order the parties to file motions

and otherwise notify the Court of the existing orders that they seek to modify or be

excused from complying with, and the Court will set a new case management conference

as soon as practicable after the receipt of these motions and objections.

CONCLUSION

The Court will consolidate all the related pork antitrust cases pending in the District

of Minnesota into a single MDL. The Court recognizes this will create some new case

management issues. Just like managing any complex litigation with numerous parties,

there is no perfect solution. The Court, however, concludes that consolidation is more

likely to fulfill the purposes of Rule 42 and 28 U.S.C. § 1407 by increasing efficiency,

decreasing the burdens and costs to parties, nonparties, witnesses, and the Court, and

decreasing the risk of inconsistent rulings.

The Court is committed to addressing any issues that arise to ensure the most

efficient and just outcome for all parties. It will do everything it can to resolve all member

cases efficiently and expeditiously including considering multiple timelines to resolve

pretrial disputes between the parties and to prevent unfair prejudice to any party.

ORDER

Based on the foregoing, and all the files, records, and proceedings herein, IT IS

HEREBY ORDERED that:

1. Civil case number 18-1776 and its member cases (18-1803, 18-1810, 18-1891, 18-

1946, 18-2008, 18-2044, 18-2058, 18-2113, 18-2337, 18-2338, 18-2390, 18-2405,

19-1578, 19-2723, and 20-2642) are consolidated with civil case number 21-

2998—the existing Multidistrict Litigation—and its member cases (21-1373, 21-

1374, 21-1454, 21-1605, 21-1697, 21-1715, 21-1872, 21-1873, 21-1874, 21-1875,

and 21-2046) for pretrial proceedings into a single multidistrict litigation.

2. The Clerk of Court is directed to consolidate the above cases for pretrial

proceedings before Chief Judge John R. Tunheim and Magistrate Judge Hildy

Bowbeer. The Clerk of Court is directed to transfer all documents in civil case

number 21-2998 to civil case number 18-1776. All future filings shall be filed in

civil case number 18-1776 and shall be considered filed in each individual case.

Future filings should not be separately docketed in the individual cases.

3. The Clerk of Court is directed to add all Plaintiffs, Defendants, and their attorneys

of record from civil case number 21-2998 to civil case number 18-1776 to the

extent they are not duplicative. All pro hac vice admissions in civil case number

21-2998 are valid for civil case number 18-1776.

4. The caption of civil case number 18-1776 will remain unchanged.

5. Civil case number 18-1776 is redesignated as the multidistrict litigation authorized

by the Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation.

6. All existing orders and deadlines remain in effect on parties to whom they

previously applied.

7. As of twenty-one days from the date of this Order, all existing orders and deadlines

from case numbers 18-1776 and 21-2998 relating to pretrial matters will be

applied to all parties unless a party moves to amend an order or objects in writing

to the application of an order as it relates to the party before that date.

8. The terms of this Order automatically apply to actions later instituted in, removed

to, or transferred to this Court (including cases transferred for pretrial purposes

under 28 U.S.C. § 1407) that involve allegations of antitrust violations concerning

pork producers by Defendant entities in the above-references actions.

9. When an action that relates to the same subject matter as these consolidated

actions is hereafter filed in or transferred to this Court and assigned to the

undersigned, it shall be consolidated for pretrial purposes with the appropriate

group of actions.

10. Counsel must call to the attention of the Clerk the filing or transfer of any case that

might properly be consolidated with these actions and identify the group of actions

to which it belongs.

11. With respect to such newly filed or transferred actions, the Clerk of Court shall:

a. docket a copy of this Order in the separate file for such action,

b. make an appropriate entry in the docket for 0:18-cv-1776 that a new case has

been assigned, and

c. note on the docket of the new action that, upon entry of this Order, all papers

shall be filed in civil case number 18-cv-1776 and no further papers shall be

filed in that individual case docket.

DATED: November 12, 2021 din W. ( eedein—

at Minneapolis, Minnesota. JOHN R. TUNHEIM

Chief Judge

United States District Court

-13-

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.