Opinion

Brown v. McConnell

Court
District Court, W.D. Louisiana
Filed
Jan 26, 2022
Cited by
0 cases
Authority
More cited than 22.6%

“it is ‘malicious’ for a pauper to file a lawsuit that duplicates allegations of another pending federal lawsuit by the same plaintiff’

How later courts described this case

  • “it is ‘malicious’ for a pauper to file a lawsuit that duplicates allegations of another pending federal lawsuit by the same plaintiff’

Written by the judges who cited it.

The opinion

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

WESTERN DISTRICT OF LOUISIANA

ALEXANDRIA DIVISION

JARVIS BROWN, CIVIL DOCKET NO. 1:20-CV-885-P

Petitioner

VERSUS JUDGE DAVID C. JOSEPH

CHRIS McCONNELL, MAGISTRATE JUDGE JOSEPH H.L.

Respondent PEREZ-MONTES

MEMORANDUM RULING

The captioned matter is before the Court on remand from the United States

Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit. [ECF No. 18]. For the reasons that follow, the

remanded claim is DENIED AND DISMISSED.

PROCEDURAL HISTORY

Petitioner Jarvis Brown (“Brown”) filed a pro se Petition for Writ of Habeas

Corpus under 28 U.S.C. § 2241 asserting that he was denied due process of law in a

prison disciplinary hearing. [ECF No. 1]. The Court denied and dismissed the

Petition with prejudice, and Brown appealed. The Fifth Circuit affirmed the denial

of Brown’s habeas petition. See Brown v. McConnell, 20-30671, 2021 WL 5751450

(5th Cir. 2021). However, finding that this Court failed to “address whether Brown

was denied a property interest or otherwise stated a cognizable civil rights claim,”

the Fifth Circuit remanded the case to this Court “to consider whether Brown has

alleged a cognizable civil rights claim where a Bivens remedy is available.” Id.

BACKGROUND

Brown is an inmate in the custody of the United States Bureau of Prisons

(“BOP”), incarcerated at the United States Penitentiary in Pollock, Louisiana. Brown

challenges a disciplinary conviction [Incident Report #3088393] from the United

States Penitentiary – Atwater (“USP-Atwater”).

The factual details of Brown’s disciplinary charge are outlined in the REPORT

AND RECOMMENDATION of the Magistrate Judge. [ECF No. 8]. Ultimately, Brown was

convicted at USP-Atwater of violating Code 224, assault without serious injury. [ECF

No. 7-1 at 2]. Brown was sanctioned with 35 days of disciplinary segregation, 15 days

of which were suspended pending clear conduct; three months loss of commissary

privileges; two months loss of email privileges; 30 days loss of other privileges; and a

$20.00 fine to deter future misconduct. [ECF No. 7-1 at 10].

DISCUSSION

Brown’s disciplinary charge and conviction occurred at USP-Atwater in

Atwater, California, which is located within the Eastern District of California. [ECF

No. 7-1 at 2]. Prior to filing his § 2241 Petition in this Court, Brown filed a Complaint

in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of California pursuant to

Bivens v. Six Unknown Named Agents of Federal Bureau of Narcotics, 403 U.S. 388

(1971). In that Bivens Complaint, Brown sued the officers who charged and convicted

him of the disciplinary violations. Brown raised, among other claims, a due process

claim based on the same disciplinary conviction at issue in this case [Incident Report

#3088393]. See Brown v. Matevousian, 1:20-CV-00204, 2021 WL 1210002, at *9 (E.D.

Cal. Mar. 31, 2021), report and recommendation adopted, 2021 WL 3674620 (E.D.

Cal. Aug. 19, 2021).

Therefore, at the time his § 2241 Petition was filed here, a Bivens claim arising

out of the same disciplinary charge and conviction was pending in another district

court. See id. That Court has since denied and dismissed Brown’s complaint, and an

appeal is pending in the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, No. 21-

16446.

Accordingly, to the extent Brown also intends to raise a Bivens claim in this

Court regarding the same disciplinary proceeding and alleged denial of due process,

his claim is barred by the doctrine of res judicata.

Res judicata prevents “the litigation of claims that either have been litigated

or should have been raised in an earlier suit.” Test Masters Educ. Servs., Inc. v.

Singh, 428 F.3d 559, 571 (5th Cir. 2005), 428 F.3d at 571. The doctrine of “res

judicata,” or claim preclusion, prevents a litigant from bringing a claim that

previously has been adjudicated when four requirements are satisfied: (1) the parties

in the latter case are identical to, or in privity with, the parties of the prior case; (2)

the prior judgment was rendered by a court of competent jurisdiction; (3) the prior

case concluded with a final judgment on the merits; and (4) the same claim or cause

of action is involved in both cases. See United States v. Davenport, 484 F.3d 321, 325-

26 (5th Cir. 2007). When two cases “are based on the same nucleus of operative facts,”

the preclusive effect of a prior final judgment on the merits bars a party from bringing

a new suit raising the same claim. Id. at 326.

Generally, res judicata is an affirmative defense that must be pleaded, not

raised sua sponte. Fed. R. Civ. P. 8(c). However, the Fifth Circuit has recognized two

limited exceptions to this rule. The first exception allows “[d]ismissal . . . in the

interest of judicial economy where both actions were brought before the same court.”

Mowbray v. Cameron Cty., Tex., 274 F.3d 269, 281–82 (5th Cir.2001 (quoting Boone

v. Kurtz, 617 F.2d 435, 436 (5th Cir. 1980)); United Home Rentals, Inc. v. Tex. Real

Estate Comm’n, 716 F.2d 324, 330 (5th Cir.1983). The second applies “where all of

the relevant facts are contained in the record . . . and all are uncontroverted. . . .” Id.

(quoting Am. Furniture Co. v. Int'l Accommodations Supply, 721 F.2d 478, 482 (5th

Cir. 1981).

Brown provided this Court with a copy of the disciplinary charge and

conviction that he challenges in both civil actions. It is clear that both cases: (1)

involve Incident Report #3088393; (2) are based on events that took place at USP-

Atwater on February 12, 2018; (3) involve the disciplinary hearing of February 22,

2018, at USP-Atwater; and (4) challenge the Disciplinary Hearing Officer Report and

conviction of March 20, 2018. [ECF No. 7-1 at 10-12]. Although the named

Respondent in this case is Warden McConnell at USP-Pollock, and the named

Defendants in the California Bivens case are officers at USP-Atwater, the parties are

in privity. Moreover, a Bivens claim here would certainly be based on the same

nucleus of operative facts as the Bivens claim challenging the same disciplinary

conviction in the California case.

Additionally Brown’s Bivens claim in the Eastern District of California was

denied and dismissed on the merits. Brown, 2021 WL 1210002, at *9 (finding that

“[t]he Supreme Court has never extended Bivens in the context of a prisoner’s due

process claim arising out of a prison disciplinary proceeding or a placement

determination”). Although Brown has appealed that judgment, a “case pending

appeal is res judicata . . . until reversed on appeal.” Fidelity Standard Life Ins. Co.

v. First Nat’l Bank & Trust Co., 510 F.2d 272, 273 (5th Cir. 1975) cert. denied, 423

U.S. 864 (1975); Hernandez v. Rice, 5 F.3d 529, n.1 (5th Cir. 1993).

Additionally, any concerns that may prevent a court from raising res judicata

sua sponte are not at issue here. Brown “can claim no surprise or prejudice.” Am.

Furniture Co., 721 F.2d at 482. He filed the two cases within months of each other

and was simultaneously litigating both claims. And Brown is clearly aware of the

adverse judgment in California as he has appealed the judgment to the Ninth Circuit.

Alternatively, to the extent a Bivens claim in this Court is not barred by res

judicata raised sua sponte, it must be dismissed for improper venue.1 Furthermore,

even if venue were proper, the claim only makes allegations against Warden

McConnell, who was not involved in the disciplinary charge or conviction at USP-

Atwater.

1 Title 28 U.S.C. § 1391(b) permits venue only in the judicial district where all the

defendants reside or in which a substantial part of the events or omissions giving rise to the

claim occurred. The disciplinary conviction and events leading to Brown’s conviction

occurred in California, which is also where all involved parties are located.

In the event the Ninth Circuit would reverse the Judgment in California

thereby reopening the Bivens claim there, a potential Bivens claim in this Court

arising out of the disciplinary conviction at USP-Atwater would be subject to

dismissal as duplicative.2

CONCLUSION

For the forgoing reasons, any intended Bivens claim based upon Brown’s

disciplinary conviction at USP-Atwater is hereby DENIED as barred by the doctrine

of res judicata and the Complaint [ECF No. 1] is DISMISSED WITH PREJUDICE.

THUS, DONE AND SIGNED in Chambers on this 26 day of January 2022.

Cbaid C

DAVID C. JOSEPH

UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE

2 See Pittman v. Moore, 980 F.2d 994, 995 (5th Cir. 1993) (“it is ‘malicious’ for a pauper

to file a lawsuit that duplicates allegations of another pending federal lawsuit by the same

plaintiff’).

Page 6 of 6

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.