The opinion
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
WESTERN DISTRICT OF LOUISIANA
SHREVEPORT DIVISION
CANDYCE BOWLING CIVIL ACTION NO. 21-cv-2346
Related to
CIVIL ACTION NO 20-cv-504
VERSUS JUDGE ELIZABETH E. FOOTE
MARCUS BROWN ET AL MAGISTRATE JUDGE HORNSBY
MEMORANDUM ORDER
Facts and Proceedings
This is a personal injury lawsuit filed by Candyce Bowling (“Plaintiff”) against
Marcus Brown, Southern Refrigerated Transport, Inc., and IQS Insurance Risk Retention
Group, Inc. (“Defendants”) arising out of a motor vehicle accident that occurred in
Greenwood, Louisiana. Following the accident, Plaintiff sought treatment from various
doctors and medical providers. A third-party litigation funding company, MedPort LA,
LLC (“MedPort”) funded that treatment by purchasing the accounts receivable of
Plaintiff’s medical providers.
Defendants issued a subpoena to MedPort to produce 23 categories of documents
relating to treatment, billing, discounts, negotiations, and other types of documents related
to Plaintiff or other plaintiffs/patients represented by Plaintiff’s counsel. MedPort refused
to produce the requested documents, so Defendants filed an Emergency Motion to
Compel. Doc. 1. Defendants argue that the subpoenaed documents are relevant to the
issues of causation, damages, bias, and credibility.
MedPort’s response (Doc. 8) argues that the information sought would violate the
confidential business relationship between MedPort and various medical providers.
MedPort argues that it purchased accounts receivable, which means MedPort has the right
to payment under the contract but bears the risk of nonpayment, partial payment, and the
costs associated with obtaining payment. MedPort argues that, even though it purchased
the accounts receivable at a discount from the medical providers, Plaintiff remains legally
obligated to pay MedPort for the full amount of her medical bills. MedPort also argues
that the real issue before the court is Defendants’ attempts to discover MedPort’s
confidential, proprietary, and trade secret information.
Defendants’ motion was originally filed in the District of Nevada. Following
briefing and oral argument, that court transferred the discovery dispute to this court. Doc.
13. The discovery dispute was opened as a new civil action and assigned number 21-cv-
2346.
In the related tort case, 20-cv-504, the court refused to quash an almost identical
subpoena issued by Defendants to one of Plaintiff’s treaters, Guardian Care, LLC
(“Guardian”). The medical records produced in discovery showed that Plaintiff’s treatment
at Guardian was being funded by MedPort. The court agreed with Defendants that any
agreements between Guardian and MedPort were relevant to determine whether the
collateral source rule will apply to Plaintiff’s recovery of medical expenses. The court
found that the evidence would also be relevant to bias and credibility, because the evidence
may show that Guardian and its doctors have a financial relationship with MedPort that
would tend to prove Guardian’s bias. The court did, however, sustain and modify some of
the requests in the subpoena to Guardian due to overbreadth and/or proportionality. See
20-cv-0504, Doc. 40.
The documents produced by Guardian are in the record as exhibits to Defendants’
current motion. These include medical evaluations and medical bills. The bills include
cover sheets by an organization named MoveDocs.com, LLC (“MoveDocs”). The cover
sheets, for example Bates No. Med000050, explain that the providers “SOLD” the
accounts to MedPort and that payment should be made to MedPort. Doc. 1-7 [Emphasis
in original].
MedPort and MoveDocs are closely related. They share the same street address, the
same named individual with authority to act, and the same registered agent for service.
Doc. 9-1. The bills sent for MoveDocs state that MoveDocs “is now servicing all your
needs (e.g. medical records, balance requests and reductions) with regard to the following
account receivable(s) ….” [Emphasis added]. Doc. 1-7 at p. 30.
Law and Analysis
Collateral Source Rule
Pursuant to Fed. R. Evid. 409, “[e]vidence of furnishing, promising to pay, or
offering to pay medical, hospital, or similar expenses resulting from an injury is not
admissible to prove liability for the injury.” Collins v. Benton, 2021 WL 638116, *5 (E.D.
La. 2021). Under Louisiana law, the collateral source rule provides that “an injured
plaintiff’s tort recovery may not be reduced[ ] because of monies received by the plaintiff
from sources independent of the tortfeasor’s procuration or contribution.” Id. Under this
doctrine, “the payments received from the independent source are not deducted from the
award the [plaintiff] would otherwise receive from the [tortfeasor].” Id. The underlying
rationale is that “a tortfeasor should not benefit by a reduction in damages from outside
benefits provided to the plaintiff.” Id.
The Louisiana Supreme Court articulated an exception to the collateral source rule
in Hoffman v. 21st Century North American Insurance Co., 209 So.3d 702, 704 (La. 2015).
In that case, the plaintiff’s attorney negotiated a discount on the client’s medical bills. The
court declined to apply the collateral source rule to the attorney-negotiated discount.
Indeed, the court reasoned that “allowing the plaintiff to recover an amount for which he
has not paid, and for which he has no obligation to pay, is at cross purposes with the basic
principles of tort recovery in our Civil Code.” The court concluded that a defendant cannot
be “held responsible for any medical bills or services the plaintiff did not actually incur
and which the plaintiff need not repay.” Id.
The Louisiana Supreme Court articulated another exception to the collateral source
rule in Simmons v. Cornerstone Investments, LLC, 282 So.3d 199 (La. 2019). In that case,
the plaintiff suffered an injury while working for Cintas Corporation. The plaintiff’s
medical expenses totaled $24,435, but that amount was reduced to $18,435 (a $6,000
reduction) under the Louisiana Workers’ Compensation Act. The legal issue was whether
the plaintiff could recover the “written off” amount of $6,000.85. The court held that the
$6,000 reduction entailed a “phantom charge” that the plaintiff never needed to pay back.
For that reason, the Court held that the collateral source rule was inapplicable to the $6,000
phantom charge.
In Collins, supra, Chief Judge Brown denied a plaintiff’s motion in limine seeking
to bar the defendants from introducing the MedPort documentation into evidence at trial.
The court found that the MedPort documents were relevant to a determination of the
appropriate damages award if the jury concluded that the medical expenses were incurred
in bad faith. The court also found the documents were admissible for the purpose of
impeaching the credibility of Plaintiff’s healthcare providers who would testify at trial. Id.
at *7-8.
In McClain v. Sysco New Orleans, Civil Action No. 19-cv-1801 (E.D. La. 2019)
(unpublished), Magistrate Judge Janis van Meerveld faced issues identical to those in this
case. In that case, MedPort, which was referred to as a “medical-factoring company,”
purchased about $300,000 in accounts receivable from a neurosurgeon. Judge Meerveld
exhaustively reviewed the relevant cases on this subject, some of which are in conflict.
After reviewing the documentation and the caselaw, Judge Meerveld found that the
documents sought were, in fact, relevant to the collateral source rule. She noted the
affidavit of MedPort’s principal Kenneth Fust, the same affidavit that was filed in this case,
explained that when MedPort purchases accounts receivables for less than the billed
amount, it is assigned the right to collect the full amount from the Plaintiff. See Doc. 8-2.
The affidavit further provides that MedPort contracts with medical providers to purchase
their receivables at a discount, and MedPort’s profit is derived from the difference between
the amount for which it purchased a receivable and the amount ultimately collected from
the patient.
The undersigned agrees with and hereby adopts Judge Meerveld’s thorough
analysis and conclusions. The MedPort documents are relevant to a determination of
whether the collateral source rule will apply. The MoveDocs bills referenced above tell
plaintiffs and their attorneys who to call for reductions in MedPort’s bills. The affidavit of
general counsel admits that MedPort negotiates with attorneys. Although there is no
attorney guarantee of payment, it seems that the sale of receivables to MedPort is an
alternative to requiring that guarantee. This leads the court to question whether the parties
involved are operating at arm’s length. Common sense says that there must be at least
some “understanding” between plaintiff’s counsel and MedPort that some reduction in the
medical expenses will be provided to plaintiff. Keeping the amount of that reduction secret
from the court and opposing parties frustrates the litigation process and casts an
unnecessary cloud over the medical expenses for purposes of settlement. Production of the
agreements and the amounts evens the playing field and facilitates resolution.
Bias, Credibility, and Causation
The MedPort documents are also relevant to bias, credibility, and causation.
MedPort might be inclined to make future purchases from medical providers whose
accounts receivable result in better recovery, and this might give medical providers
incentive to overtreat and give testimony that is favorable to a finding of causation and a
bigger damages award. Those treating physicians have a financial interest in Plaintiff
winning her case because a win for Plaintiff increases the likelihood that the provider will
continue to receive referrals from MedPort. A jury could infer that the physicians
overcharged Plaintiff in order to satisfy MedPort and continue to receive MedPort’s
referrals. That physician is more likely to testify favorably on the issue of causation so that
MedPort will provide other referrals and approve funding of treatment in the future for the
next plaintiff or the next time a contract is negotiated. In this situation, the treating
physicians “may have a substantial financial incentive to provide a favorable medical
causation analysis.” Collins v. Benton, 2020 WL 3618984, *7 (E.D. La. 2020).
Confidentiality Concerns
The affidavit of Marissa Stearns (Doc. 8-3), in-house counsel for MedPort, states
that the agreements between MedPort and the medical providers all contain confidentiality
clauses, and if the contracts were made public, “MedPort would be at a serious
disadvantage in negotiations with other providers, attorneys, and insurance companies ….”
(Emphasis added). The undersigned finds that this concern is easily addressed by a
protective order limiting disclosure to the parties in this case and for use only in this
litigation.
Conclusion
For the foregoing reasons, Defendants’ Emergency Motion to Compel (Doc. 1) is
granted in part and denied in part. MedPort is directed to comply with the subpoena (Doc.
1-4) as follows:
Item 1: MedPort shall produce.
Item 2: Limited to documents in MedPort’s possession related to Plaintiff
and/or Plaintiff’s counsel’s retention of your service for the instant
litigation. The rest of Item 2 is overbroad and not proportional to the
needs of the case.
Items 3-14: MedPort shall produce.
Item 15: MedPort’s objection is sustained.
Item 16: MedPort’s objections are sustained.
Item 17: MedPort’s objections are sustained.
Item 18: This request is modified to remove “any Louisiana litigation” and
replace that phrase with the name “Candyce Bowling.”
Items 19-22: MedPort’s objections are sustained.
Item 23: MedPort shall produce.
The information is subject to the following protective order: The information is
deemed confidential and shall be labeled as such. Defendants shall use the documents
produced only for the purpose of this litigation (and in no other litigation or proceeding),
and disclosure shall be limited only to Defendants, their counsel, and others directly
involved in the defense of this case (including experts and witnesses). A precondition of
such disclosure is the execution of an agreement that acknowledges the confidentiality of
the documents and agreement to maintain the documents in strict confidence.
All requests for fees or expenses in connection with the motion are denied.
The deadline for production is 14 days from the date of this order.
THUS DONE AND SIGNED in Shreveport, Louisiana, this 18th day of August,
2021.
=|
Mark L. Hornsby
U.S. Magistrate Judge
Page 8 of 8