Opinion

Brown v. Raymond

Court
District Court, S.D. Illinois
Filed
May 2, 2024
Cited by
0 cases
Authority
More cited than 21.3%

The opinion

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS

ROBERT BROWN, #N62623, )

)

Plaintiff, )

)

v. ) Case No. 23-cv-1554-RJD

)

)

SHAUN REIMAN, )

)

Defendant. )

ORDER

DALY, Magistrate Judge:

This matter comes before the Court on Plaintiff’s various motions. For the reasons set

forth below, Plaintiff’s motions found at docket entries 57, 58, 59, and 60 are GRANTED.

Plaintiff’s motion found at docket 56 is DENIED. The Court further notes that Defendant has

failed to file a Rule 56.1 Notice along with his Motion for Summary Judgment on the Issue of

Exhaustion of Administrative Remedies (Doc. 54). Defendant is ORDERED to file the Rule 56.1

Notice by May 6, 2024.

Motion for Subpoenas (Doc. 56)

Plaintiff filed a motion seeking to subpoena video footage of an incident that occurred in

Menard Correctional Center (“Menard”), where he is incarcerated, on April 10, 2024, as well as a

document titled “Reclassification Form,” which he was allegedly forced to sign at Menard on

September 12, 2023. Plaintiff argues this is evidence of the mistreatment he receives at Menard.

The Court entered an Initial Scheduling Order in this case, staying any merits discovery while the

issue of exhaustion of administrative remedies is pending and advising Parties that any motion

Page 1 of 6

filed regarding discovery on the merits will be summarily denied with leave to refile after the stay

has been lifted. (Doc. 52). Plaintiff’s motion is a request for discovery on the merits of this case.

Defendants have filed a motion for summary judgment on the issue of exhaustion of administrative

remedies, which is currently pending before the Court. Accordingly, Plaintiff’s Motion for

Subpoenas (Doc. 56) is DENIED without prejudice. Plaintiff may refile his motion after the issue

of exhaustion of administrative remedies has been resolved and the stay in merits discovery has

been lifted.

Motion to Clarify Document 38 (Doc. 57)

Plaintiff asks the Court to clarify the Notice found at docket entry 38, in which the Clerk

of Court advised Plaintiff that the Court had received his Request for Production of Documents,

but it would not file it with the record pursuant to Rule 26.1. Plaintiff’s motion is GRANTED.

Local Rule 26.1(b) provides that written discovery requests and responses must “be served upon

other counsel or parties but shall not be filed with the Clerk of Court.” SDIL-LR 26.1(b) (emphasis

added). Accordingly, Plaintiff should have mailed any requests for production of documents to

Defendants’ counsel instead of mailing them to the Court for filing. Plaintiff is REMINDED that

unless his request for the production of documents is related to the issue of exhaustion of

administrative remedies, he should not attempt to serve it to Defendant until the Court has lifted

the stay on merits discovery.

Motion to Clarify Document 33 (Doc. 58)

Plaintiff asks the Court to clarify the Order found at docket entry 33 as well as Defendant’s

correct name in light of some inconsistency in the spelling of his first name in his filings with this

Court. Plaintiff’s motion is GRANTED. Plaintiff originally brought his Complaint against “C/O

Page 2 of 6

Raymond.” The Menard Warden was thereafter added as Defendant solely for identifying “C/O

Raymond.” The Menard Warden identified “Defendant Raymond” as Shaun Reiman, and the

Court entered the Order in docket entry 33 instructing Plaintiff to file a motion to substitute

Defendant Shaun Reiman for “C/O Raymond.” After Defendant was served with summons of the

Complaint, he filed his Answer, in which his first name was spelled as “Shawn Reiman.” (Doc.

49). Defendant admitted “he was a sergeant on July 19, 2022,” but denied “he maced Plaintiff for

no reason while he stood in his cell.” (Id.). Thereafter, Plaintiff filed a Motion for Summary

Judgment in which his first name is spelled “Shaun.” (Doc. 54). It appears that the correct spelling

of Defendant’s first name is “Shaun.” If, however, this is not the case, Defendant shall notify the

Court accordingly by May 6, 2024.

Motion to Clarify Document 46 (Doc. 59)

Plaintiff asks the Court to clarify the Notice found in docket entry 46 regarding the Parties’

consent to the undersigned conducting all proceedings in this case “including a trial and final

judgment.” (Doc. 46). He specifically asks whether trial means a “jury trial,” since he did not

request one and opposes Defendant’s jury demand. Plaintiff’s motion is GRANTED. Plaintiff is

ADVISED that under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 38, any party, including defendants, may

demand a jury trial as to any issue triable by jury. FED. R. CIV. P. 38(b). Once a party makes a

timely jury demand in accordance with Rule 38, the trial on all issues so demanded must be by

jury unless: “(1) the parties or their attorneys file a stipulation to a nonjury trial or so stipulate on

the record; or (2) the court, on motion or on its own, finds that on some or all of those issues there

is no federal right to a jury trial.” FED. R. CIV. P. 39(b). Here, Defendant made a timely jury

demand with his Answer (Doc. 49). While Plaintiff has not argued that Defendant does not have

Page 3 of 6

a federal right to a jury trial, the Court notes that Plaintiff is bringing an action under Section 1983

seeking monetary damages. (Doc. 1 at 8-9). The United States Supreme Court has found that a

suit under Section 1983 seeking monetary damages is an action at law within the meaning of the

Seventh Amendment, which warrants the right to a trial by jury. City of Monterey v. Del Monte

Dunes at Monterey, Ltd., 526 U.S. 687, 709 (1999). Therefore, this case will be set for a jury trial

once the issue of exhaustion of administrative remedies is resolved.

Motion to Clarify “Piecemeal” (Doc. 60)

In his final motion, Plaintiff asks the Court to clarify what it means when it refers to the

compensation Plaintiff seeks as “piecemeal.” While Plaintiff does not indicate a specific docket

entry, the Court assumes Plaintiff refers to the Court’s Order denying Plaintiff’s Motion to Amend

Complaint. (Doc. 39). There, the Court denied Plaintiff’s motion because Plaintiff attempted only

to amend the relief sought in his original Complaint without asserting any factual allegations to

independently allege a cause of action. The Court noted that it does not accept piecemeal

amendments and instructed Plaintiff that if he wanted to file a proposed amended complaint, he

would have to include all factual allegations supporting the claims so that the proposed amended

complaint stands on its own without reference to his original complaint. Plaintiff’s motion is

GRANTED. The Court clarifies that the term “piecemeal” was referring to Plaintiff’s proposed

amended complaint and not the compensation sought therein. “Piecemeal” means “in pieces or

fragments.” See Piecemeal Definition & Meaning - Merriam-Webster. Under Local Rule15(b),

the Court does not accept amendments of pleadings into pieces. In this case, if Plaintiff wants to

amend the complaint to only ask for additional compensation, he should submit a proposed

amended complaint that includes all factual allegations he had asserted in his original complaint

Page 4 of 6

and make any necessary amendments to his prayer for relief so as to seek the additional

compensation. The Court ADVISES Plaintiff to carefully review Local Rule15(b), which sets

forth specific requirements for the filing of an amended pleading:

(b) Amendment

(1) Amendment by interlineation is not permitted. An amended pleading must

contain all claims against all parties, as if starting anew.

(2) All new or amended material in a proposed amended pleading must be

underlined or submitted in redlined form. It is sufficient to simply underline the

names of new parties the first place they appear in amended pleadings. Similarly,

when new claims or defenses are raised by an amendment, it is sufficient that the

number of the designated count or paragraph identifying the amendment be

underlined. Minor spelling and stylistic changes need not be underlined. If leave is

granted, a clean version of the operative pleading must be filed on the docket. This

provision does not apply to appointed counsel appearing on behalf of a previously

unrepresented party.

(3) Unless otherwise ordered by the Court, whenever an amended pleading is filed,

any motion attacking the original pleading will be deemed moot.

Conclusion

For the reasons stated above, Plaintiff’s Motion to Clarify Document 38 (Doc. 57), Motion

to Clarify Document 33 (Doc. 58), Motion to Clarify Document 46 (Doc. 59), and Motion to

Clarify “Piecemeal” (Doc. 60) are GRANTED. Plaintiff’s Motion for Subpoenas (Doc. 56) is

DENIED without prejudice. Defendant is ORDERED to file the Rule 56.1 Notice by May 6,

2024, and to also notify the Court of the proper spelling of his first name by that same deadline,

but only if his first name is misspelled in this case’s docket.

Page 5 of 6

IT IS SO ORDERED.

DATED: May 2, 2024

s/ Reona J. Daly

Hon. Reona J. Daly

United States Magistrate Judge

Page 6 of 6

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.