Opinion

In re Broiler Chicken Antitrust Litigation

Court
District Court, N.D. Illinois
Filed
Apr 13, 2018
Cited by
0 cases
Authority
More cited than 20.8%

The opinion

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS

EASTERN DIVISION

IN RE BROILER CHICKEN ANTITRUST Case No. 1:16-cv-08637

LITIGATION

This Document Relates To: All Actions Magistrate Judge Jeffrey T. Gilbert

ORDER

Tyson Defendants’ Motion for Protective Order to Preclude Non-Parties’ Production of

Documents as to Non-Custodians [725] is denied without prejudice. See Statement for further

details,

STATEMENT

This matter is before the Court on Tyson Defendants’ Motion for Protective Order to Preclude

Non-Parties’ Production of Documents as to Non-Custodians [725]. Tyson Defendants seek a

protective order to prevent non-party AT&T from producing documents, specifically telephone

records for telephone numbers purportedly used by three former Tyson executives, pursuant to a

subpoena to be served upon AT&T by Plaintiffs. Tyson Defendants argue that the subpoenaed

telephone records are irrelevant and that allowing Plaintiffs to serve their subpoena would

impose upon Tyson Defendants an undue burden because they would have to review the

subpoenaed records, potentially review other records relating to the three former Tyson

executives, and defend against likely follow-up discovery.

The Federal Rules of Civil Procedure allow for liberal discovery, Swierkiewicz v, Sorema N.

A., 534 U.S. 506, 512 (2002). Under Rule 26, “[p]arties may obtain regarding any nonprivileged

matter that is relevant to any party’s claim or defense and proportional to the needs of the

case.,..” FED, R. Civ. P. 26(b)(1). Nonetheless, under Rule 26(c)(1), a court has the broad

authority to enter a protective order to limit discovery “for good cause shown ... to protect a party

or person from annoyance, embarrassment, oppression, or undue burden or expense....” FED. R.

Civ. P. 26(c)(1). The burden to show good cause is on the party seeking the order. Jepson, Inc.

v. Makita Elec. Works, Lid, 30 F.3d 854, 858 (7th Cir, 1994), Conclusory statements are not

sufficient. See Zenith Electronics Corp. v. Exzec, Inc., 1998 WL 9181, at *8 (N.D. IIL. Jan. 5,

1998); 8 C. Wright & A. Miller, Federal Practice and Procedure § 2035 (1970). So, the Court

must decide whether Tyson Defendants have shown good cause for the protective order they

want the Court to enter.

The Court has reviewed the parties’ submissions and concludes that Tyson Defendants have not

shown good cause for entry of a protective order under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26(c).

Plaintiffs appear to seek what may be relevant information that is proportionate in scope and

timing. On a sliding scale, the Court acknowledges that Plaintiffs seem to have made more of a

showing of relevance as to telephone calls made by the late Don Tyson than they have done with

respect to John Tyson or Archie Schaffer. But parsing relevance with respect to a relatively

focused third-party subpoena this early in the case in the face of the threshold showing Plaintiffs

have made and in the context of an objection by a party required to do nothing directly in

response to the subpoena can be a perilous task.

Further, and importantly, Tyson Defendants have not shown that Plaintiffs’ subpoena to AT&T

would impose any .specific or substantial burden on them at this time. Rather, Tyson

Defendants’ burden argument is more diffuse and ephemeral. The burden on Tyson Defendants

as a result of AT&T producing documents in response to Plaintiffs’ subpoena is, in the general

scheme of things, relatively minor, even if Tyson Defendants have to review the documents

produced and do some internal vetting and investigation secondary to whatever those documents

might show. It does not, in the Court’s view, constitute good cause for the issuance of a

protective order at this juncture. Also, to the extent certain of the phone numbers flagged by

Plaintiffs are not even associated with Tyson or any of its three former executives as Tyson

Defendants seem to say in their Reply memorandum, the burden argument pales to de minimis

for that aspect of Plaintiffs’ subpoena.

In addition, Tyson Defendants’ argument that production of the AT&T phone records “will

almost certainly spawn yet more discovery” in the future ([ECF No. 773, at 6]) does not translate

into good cause to block the third-party discovery Plaintiffs actually are seeking now. If

Plaintiffs seek additional discovery from Tyson Defendants in the future because of the phone

records Plaintiffs may receive from AT&T, and that additional discovery runs afoul of the

requirements of Rule 26(b)(1), then the Court can address that particular discovery at that time

and evaluate it in context and on the merits rather than on the basis of speculation and

supposition about what that future discovery might entail.

Finally, the Court concludes that Plaintiffs did not waive their ability, as Tyson Defendants

argue, to seek this information, The Court understands Tyson Defendants believe they were

whipsawed by Plaintiffs when they agreed to produce certain information last year or agreed to

particular custodians only to have Plaintiffs seemingly go back on what Tyson Defendants

believed to be a negotiated compromise to a discovery dispute that had been put to bed. The

Court does not read the relevant emails that way. See [ECF No. 754-2] (“[Plaintiffs] obviously

reserve all rights as discovery proceeds, and in turn, we understand Tyson reserves all rights.”’).

In any event, Plaintiffs present a credible argument that their thinking may have evolved after

they obtained additional information. In short, the Court does not see any major unfairness here.

For all of these reasons, Tyson Defendants’ Motion for Protective Order to Preclude Non-

Parties’ Production of Documents as to Non-Custodians [725] is denied without prejudice to

Tyson Defendants’ ability to oppose any future discovery directed to them by Plaintiffs that may

grow out of the information produced pursuant to Plaintiff's’ subpoena to AT&T,

It is so ordered.

Mal. bs (|

effrey T.Acilbert

United States Magistrate Judge

Dated: April 13, 2018

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.