affirming dismissal of § 1983 claims against a judge and court 23 clerk under judicial and quasi-judicial immunity
How later courts described this case
- affirming dismissal of § 1983 claims against a judge and court 23 clerk under judicial and quasi-judicial immunity
- “Vague and 10 conclusory allegations of official participation in civil rights violations are not sufficient to 11 withstand a motion to dismiss.”
- taking judicial notice of court filings and other matters of public record
Written by the judges who cited it.
The opinion
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
9 SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
10
11 NIGEL CAIRNS, Case No.: 22cv1979-LL-KSC
12 Plaintiff,
ORDER GRANTING
13 v. MOTION TO DISMISS
14 TOMMY QUINN, et al.,
[ECF No. 9]
15 Defendants.
16
17 This matter is before the Court on the Motion to Dismiss filed by Defendants Robert
18 Longstreth and Abraham Barragan (together, the “Superior Court Defendants”), filed on
19 February 10, 2023. ECF No. 9. Plaintiff filed his response in opposition on July 19, 2023
20 [ECF No. 17], and the Superior Court Defendants filed their Reply on August 2, 2023 [ECF
21 No. 18]. The Court finds this matter suitable for determination on the papers and without
22 oral argument pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 78(b) and Civil Local Rule
23 7.1.d.1. Upon review of the parties’ submissions and the applicable law, the Court
24 GRANTS the Motion to Dismiss because the Superior Court Defendants are entitled to
25 absolute judicial and quasi-judicial immunity, respectively.
26 I. BACKGROUND
27 On December 14, 2022, Plaintiff Nigel Cairns filed this action against Defendants
28 Tommy Quinn, Tamatha Thomas, Dewayne Frost, Jamie Sloan, John Boyce, Robert
1 Longstreth, Abraham Barragan, and Stephen Paz. ECF No. 1. On January 12, 2023, the
2 case was transferred to the undersigned pursuant to the “low number rule” because Plaintiff
3 filed a case arising from the same or substantially identical transactions, happenings, or
4 events, involving the same or substantially the same parties or property as a case which
5 was terminated by the Court less than one year prior to the current case being filed. ECF
6 No. 5. Plaintiff’s previous case before the undersigned, brought against Quinn, Boyce, Paz,
7 Longstreth, and Barragan, was dismissed without prejudice on November 8, 2022. See
8 Cairns v. Quinn et al., No. 3:22-cv-1081-LL-KSC, ECF No. 7. On June 7, 2023, the Court
9 dismissed all defendants in the instant case, other than the Superior Court Defendants, for
10 failure to serve those defendants with the summons and complaint within ninety days of
11 filing his complaint. ECF No. 14.
12 II. LEGAL STANDARD
13 “It is well established that state judges are entitled to absolute immunity for their
14 judicial acts.” Swift v. California, 384 F.3d 1184, 1188 (9th Cir. 2004) (citing Pierson v.
15 Ray, 386 U.S. 547, 553-55 (1967)). This “reflects the long-standing ‘general principle of
16 the highest importance to the proper administration of justice that a judicial officer, in
17 exercising the authority vested in him, shall be free to act upon his own convictions,
18 without apprehension of personal consequences to himself.’” Olsen v. Idaho State Bd. of
19 Med., 363 F.3d 916, 922 (9th Cir. 2004) (quoting Bradley v. Fisher, 80 U.S. 335, 347
20 (1871)). Consistent with this principle, “[a] judge will not be deprived of immunity because
21 the action he took was in error, was done maliciously, or was in excess of his authority;
22 rather, he will be subject to liability only when he has acted in the clear absence of all
23 jurisdiction.” Stump v. Sparkman, 435 U.S. 349, 356-57 (1978) (quoting Bradley, 80 U.S.
24 at 351).
25 “Absolute judicial immunity is not reserved solely for judges, but extends to
26 nonjudicial officers for ‘all claims relating to the exercise of judicial functions.’” In re
27 Castillo, 297 F.3d 940, 947 (9th Cir. 2002) (quoting Burns v. Reed, 500 U.S. 478, 499
28 (1991) (Scalia, J., concurring in part and dissenting in part)). As such, “[c]ourt clerks have
1 absolute quasi-judicial immunity . . . when they perform tasks that are an integral part of
2 the judicial process.” Mullis v. U.S. Bankr. Ct., 828 F.2d 1385, 1390 (9th Cir. 1987)
3 (collecting cases) (emphasis added). Furthermore, absolute quasi-judicial immunity has
4 been extended “to court clerks and other nonjudicial officers for purely administrative acts
5 -- acts which taken out of context would appear ministerial, but when viewed in context
6 are actually a part of the judicial function.” In re Castillo, 297 F.3d at 952 (citing Moore v.
7 Brewster, 96 F.3d 1240 (9th Cir. 1996)).
8 III. DISCUSSION
9 Plaintiff’s allegations, which include those against the now-dismissed defendants in
10 this case, revolve around events in 2021 related to his residence at the Island Inn. See ECF
11 No. 1 at 6-8. According to Plaintiff, after several disputes with individuals either contracted
12 by or employed directly by the Island Inn, and suffering an assault by Defendant Sloan,
13 Plaintiff filed a lawsuit against the Island Inn, and Sloan filed and was granted a temporary
14 restraining order (“TRO”) against Plaintiff. Id. at 7-8.1 The ROAs in those cases show that
15 the cases were filed on the same day [ECF Nos. 17-3 at 1, 17-4 at 1], that Sloan was granted
16 a restraining order against Plaintiff on January 20, 2022 [ECF No. 17-3 at 2], and that
17 Plaintiff’s restraining order against Sloan (sued as “Jamie Doe”) was denied without
18 prejudice on that same date [ECF No. 17-4 at 2]. Plaintiff appealed the restraining order
19 granted against him in Sloan v. Cairns [ECF No. 17-3 at 2], and in designating the record
20 for his appeal, wrote in “Please see related case 37-2021-00044796-CU-PT-CTL” in the
21 section directing the appellant to designate any exhibits admitted, refused, or lodged in the
22
23
1 The Court takes judicial notice of the register of actions (“ROA”) in Sloan v. Cairns, 37-
24
2021-00044690-CU-HR-CTL [ECF No. 17-3, Ex. 1], the ROA in Cairns v. Doe, 37-2021-
25 00044796-CU-PT-CTL [ECF No. 17-4, Ex. 2], and the page three of the “Appellant’s
Notice Designating Record on Appeal (Unlimited Civil Case), APP-003 (Rev. January 1,
26
2019)” [ECF No. 17-5 at 1, Ex. 3]. See Reyn’s Pasta Bella, LLC v. Visa USA, Inc., 442
27 F.3d 741, 746 n.6 (9th Cir. 2006) (taking judicial notice of court filings and other matters
of public record) (citing Burbank-Glendale-Pasadena Airport Auth. v. City of Burbank,
28
1 underlying case [ECF No. 17-5 at 1]. Following those actions in the state court, Plaintiff
2 brought the instant action alleging a denial of due process under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 and
3 seeking compensatory and punitive damages in the amount of one million dollars. ECF No.
4 1 at 7-9. Because the remaining Defendants have been dismissed, the Court limits its
5 discussion to the allegations pertaining to the two remaining defendants: Robert
6 Longstreth, a judge of the Superior Court of California for the County of San Diego, and
7 Abraham Barragan, a court operations clerk of the same court. Plaintiff brings suit against
8 both Defendants in their individual capacities. Id. at 5.
9 Plaintiff alleges that the Superior Court Defendants were involved in the
10 aforementioned state court legal actions in their roles as judge and as clerk. See ECF Nos.
11 1 at 7-8; 17 at 1-2. Although he does not allege specific acts or omissions by either
12 Longstreth or Barragan, Plaintiff alleges that he “could not obtain a copy of evidence [he]
13 has submitted to [Defendant Longstreth’s] department which [he] needed for [his] appeal,”
14 and that, “[t]he Court Record on Appeal did not contain the material [he] had submitted as
15 a plaintiff.” Id. at 7. Without making any more specific claims as to Longstreth or Barragan,
16 Plaintiff alleges that “Judge Longstreth dismissed my case and made Jamie Sloan’s
17 [temporary restraining order (“TRO”)] permanent. I could not get a copy of the material I
18 had submitted to Judge Longstreth to include in my appeal. Furthermore . . . the ‘Court
19 Record on Appeal” [] did not contain my original TRO filings[.]” Id. at 8. Plaintiff’s
20 opposition to the Motion to Dismiss states that he was “unable to obtain the material [he]
21 had submitted” in Cairns v. Doe by emailing Longstreth’s judicial department, and
22 subsequently attempted to include those filings to his appeal of the TRO granted against
23 him in Sloan v. Cairns by adding “please see related case 37-2021-000444796-CU-PT-
24 CTL” on his notice designating his record on appeal in Sloan v. Cairns. See ECF No. 17 at
25 2. Plaintiff also alleges that he “presume[s]” that he also appealed the denial of his
26 restraining order in Cairns v. Doe, and questions, based on its absence on the ROA, whether
27 his notice of appeal in the case was ever received. Id.
28
1 Although Plaintiff’s allegations are threadbare, the Court construes his complaint
2 liberally in light of his pro se status. See Eldridge v. Block, 832 F.2d 1132, 1137 (9th Cir.
3 1987). The Court understands Plaintiff’s claims against the Superior Court Defendants as
4 twofold: (1) that his appeal in Cairns v. Doe was never filed by the state court; and (2) that
5 the record in Cairns v. Doe was not included in his record on appeal of Sloan v. Cairns.2
6 Plaintiff fails to explicate these claims, but based on Plaintiff’s allegations and the ROAs
7 in Plaintiff’s state court cases, it would appear that Plaintiff argues that Longstreth is
8 responsible for Plaintiff’s inability to receive a copy of the record in Cairns v. Doe by
9 emailing Longstreth’s judicial department, and that Plaintiff argues that Barragan is
10 responsible for the non-filing of his appeal in Cairns v. Doe as well as the superior court’s
11 failure to include the record in Cairns v. Doe on his appeal in Sloan v. Cairns.
12 There are multiple grounds for granting the Superior Court Defendants’ Motion to
13 Dismiss. Rule 8 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure requires that a complaint clearly
14 identify which defendant(s) are named in which claim(s) and specify—for each claim and
15 each defendant—the factual allegations that support liability for each defendant such that
16 they have fair notice of a plaintiff’s claim(s) and the grounds for their claim(s). See Dura
17 Pharms, Inc. v. Broudo, 544 U.S. 336, 346 (2005) (quoting Conley v. Gibson, 355 U.S. 41,
18 47 (1957)); see also Fed. R. Civ. P. 8(a). To state a claim against Defendants in their
19 individual capacities under § 1983, Plaintiff must allege with specificity: (1) that he
20 possessed and was deprived of a constitutional right; (2) by an individual; (3) who acted
21 under color of state law. See Lopez v. Dep’t of Health Servs., 939 F.2d 881, 883 (9th Cir.
22
23
24 2 As addressed by the Superior Court Defendants in their Motion to Dismiss, to the extent
25 that Plaintiff wishes to challenge Longstreth’s rulings in the state court cases, such claim(s)
are barred by the Rooker-Feldman doctrine. See Reusser v. Wachovia Bank, N.A., 525 F.3d
26
855, 858–59 (9th Cir. 2008) (“The Rooker-Feldman doctrine is a well-established
27 jurisdictional rule prohibiting federal courts from exercising appellate review over final
state court final judgments.”).
28
1 1991) (citation omitted). Plaintiff must allege that each defendant personally participated
2 in the constitutional deprivation alleged. Taylor v. List, 880 F.2d 1040, 1045 (9th Cir. 1989)
3 (citing Fayle v. Stapley, 607 F.2d 858, 862 (9th Cir. 1979)). Though Plaintiff’s complaint
4 makes reference to a denial of due process under § 1983, none of the allegations currently
5 before the Court constitute specific allegations that either articulate the deprivation of due
6 process or any other constitutional right, or that Longstreth or Barragan personally
7 participated in any of the alleged misconduct. In the absence of specific allegations
8 concerning Defendants’ involvement, Plaintiff’s complaint fails to state a plausible claim
9 under § 1983. See Ivey v. Bd. of Regents, 673 F.2d 266, 268 (9th Cir. 1982) (“Vague and
10 conclusory allegations of official participation in civil rights violations are not sufficient to
11 withstand a motion to dismiss.”).
12 Beyond Plaintiff’s failure to state a plausible § 1983 claim, his complaint also fails
13 to state a claim upon which relief may be granted because his claims are barred by the
14 doctrines of judicial and quasi-judicial immunity. As discussed above, although Plaintiff
15 has not made any specific allegations about how Longstreth or Barragan personally
16 participated in the alleged misconduct, but it is clear that all of the actions or omissions
17 alleged by Plaintiff relate to Longstreth’s judicial capacity and Barragan’s administrative
18 acts in the context of judicial functions. Plaintiff has not alleged that Longstreth or
19 Barragan have acted in the clear absence of jurisdiction or that their acts were non-judicial
20 in nature. Accordingly, Longstreth and Barragan are entitled to absolute judicial immunity
21 and absolute quasi-judicial immunity for their actions. See Haile v. Sawyer, 76 F. App’x
22 129, 130 (9th Cir. 2003) (affirming dismissal of § 1983 claims against a judge and court
23 clerk under judicial and quasi-judicial immunity). As such, the Superior Court Defendants’
24 Motion to Dismiss is GRANTED.
25 Having considered the factors articulated in Foman v. Davis, the Court finds that any
26 amendment would be futile to overcome judicial and quasi-judicial immunity in this case.
27 371 U.S. 178, 182 (1962). Although the district court normally grants leave to amend when
28
1 dismissing a complaint for failure to state a claim, Lopez v. Smith, 203 F.3d 1122, 1127
2 Cir. 2000) (en banc), the Court DENIES leave to amend as futile.
3 IV. CONCLUSION
4 In accordance with the above, the Court hereby:
5 1. GRANTS the Superior Court Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss □□□□□□□□□□□
6 || complaint [ECF No. 9];
7 2. DISMISSES WITH PREJUDICE Plaintiffs complaint [ECF No. 1]; and
8 3. DIRECTS the Clerk of Court to close this case.
9 IT IS SO ORDERED.
10 || Dated: August 17, 2023 NO
1] QF |
12 Honorable Linda Lopez
3 United States District Judge
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28