holding district court's sua sponte dismissal of Doe defendants was merited where 27 plaintiff had failed to identify defendants within allotted discovery period
How later courts described this case
- holding district court's sua sponte dismissal of Doe defendants was merited where 27 plaintiff had failed to identify defendants within allotted discovery period
- noting that while 21 the Saucier sequence is often appropriate and beneficial, it is no longer mandatory
- extending Saucier to Eighth Amendment claims
- qualified immunity analysis requiring (1) determining the 17 contours of the clearly established right at the time of the challenged conduct and (2) examining 18 whether a reasonable official would have understood that the challenged conduct violated such 19 right
Written by the judges who cited it.
The opinion
1
2
3
4
5
6
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
7
8 EASTERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
9
SANDRO S. PEREZ, Case No. 1:20-cv-00840-ADA-SAB (PC)
10
Plaintiff,
11 FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
v. RECOMMENDING DEFENDANTS’
12 MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT BE
A. SMITH, et al., DENIED, AND DEFENDANT DOE BE
13 DISMISSED FROM THE ACTION
Defendants.
14 (ECF No. 68)
15
16 Plaintiff Sandro S. Perez is proceeding pro se and in forma pauperis in this civil rights
17 action filed pursuant to 42 U.S.C. § 1983.
18 Currently before the Court is Defendants’ motion for summary judgment, filed April 22,
19 2022.
20 I.
21 RELEVANT BACKGROUND
22 This action is proceeding against Defendants A. Smith, D. Schuller, G. Nwachukwu, J.
23 Burell, V. Giannandrea, J. Trujillo-Villa, J. Szalai, J. Alvarez, and an unidentified designated
24 custody supervisor at Avenal State Prison (ASP) for deliberate indifference to plaintiff’s safety
25 in violation of the Eighth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution.1 (ECF No. 15.)
26
27
1 This unnamed Defendant was never identified by Plaintiff, despite advisement to do so, and this individual is
1 Defendants filed an answer to the complaint on December 21, 2020. (ECF No. 23.)
2 On December 22, 2020, the Court issued the discovery and scheduling order. (ECF No.
3 25.)
4 Defendants filed a first amended answer on January 7, 2021. (ECF No. 28.)
5 After an unsuccessful settlement conference, the Court issued an amended discovery and
6 scheduling order on March 17, 2021. (ECF No. 37.)
7 On April 22, 2022, Defendants filed the instant motion for summary judgment. (ECF No.
8 68.)
9 On May 9, 2022, the Court granted Plaintiff an extension of time to file an opposition.
10 (ECF No. 71.)
11 On June 10, 2022, Plaintiff filed a motion to continue consideration of Defendants’
12 motion for summary judgment. (ECF No. 72.) On July 15, 2022, Defendants filed an opposition
13 to Plaintiff’s motion. (ECF No. 74.)
14 On August 10, 2022, the Court denied Plaintiff’s motion to continue consideration of
15 Defendants’ motion for summary judgment, and Plaintiff was granted thirty days to file
16 opposition. (ECF No. 75.)
17 No opposition has been filed and the time to do so has expired.
18 II.
19 LEGAL STANDARD
20 A. Summary Judgment Standard
21 Any party may move for summary judgment, and the Court shall grant summary
22 judgment if the movant shows that there is no genuine dispute as to any material fact and the
23 movant is entitled to judgment as a matter of law. Fed. R. Civ. P. 56(a) (quotation marks
24 omitted); Washington Mut. Inc. v. U.S., 636 F.3d 1207, 1216 (9th Cir. 2011). Each party’s
25 position, whether it be that a fact is disputed or undisputed, must be supported by (1) citing to
26 particular parts of materials in the record, including but not limited to depositions, documents,
27 declarations, or discovery; or (2) showing that the materials cited do not establish the presence or
1 support the fact. Fed. R. Civ. P. 56(c)(1) (quotation marks omitted). The Court may consider
2 other materials in the record not cited to by the parties, but it is not required to do so. Fed. R.
3 Civ. P. 56(c)(3); Carmen v. San Francisco Unified Sch. Dist., 237 F.3d 1026, 1031 (9th Cir.
4 2001); accord Simmons v. Navajo Cnty., Ariz., 609 F.3d 1011, 1017 (9th Cir. 2010).
5 In judging the evidence at the summary judgment stage, the Court does not make
6 credibility determinations or weigh conflicting evidence, Soremekun v. Thrifty Payless, Inc., 509
7 F.3d 978, 984 (9th Cir. 2007) (quotation marks and citation omitted), and it must draw all
8 inferences in the light most favorable to the nonmoving party and determine whether a genuine
9 issue of material fact precludes entry of judgment, Comite de Jornaleros de Redondo Beach v.
10 City of Redondo Beach, 657 F.3d 936, 942 (9th Cir. 2011) (quotation marks and citation
11 omitted).
12 In arriving at these Findings and Recommendations, the Court carefully reviewed and
13 considered all arguments, points and authorities, declarations, exhibits, statements of undisputed
14 facts and responses thereto, if any, objections, and other papers filed by the parties. Omission of
15 reference to an argument, document, paper, or objection is not to be construed to the effect that
16 this Court did not consider the argument, document, paper, or objection. This Court thoroughly
17 reviewed and considered the evidence it deemed admissible, material, and appropriate.
18 III.
19 DISCUSSION
20 A. Summary of Plaintiff’s Complaint
21 On December 18, 2018, in the course of his employment as a facility C program office
22 clerk, Plaintiff was assisting Defendants Smith, Schuller, Nwachukwu, Burell, Giannadrea and
23 Trujillo-Villa in preparing for an initial “Unit Classification Committee” (UCC” where inmates
24 newly arrived at Avenal State Prison (ASP) facility C are classified.
25 After preparing a list of inmates scheduled for UCC that morning and circulating it to the
26 housing unit officers, Plaintiff was informed that the Committee (which consists of Defendants
27 Smith, Schuller, Nwachukwu, Burell, Giannadrea and Trujillo-Villa) wanted to see inmate Dante
1 frequently observed that the Committee would ask to see an inmate first if they were anticipating
2 some kind of issue with him, behavioral or otherwise.
3 Inmate Quezada arrived for his initial UCC at around 9:00 a.m. and was shown to the
4 room where Defendants Smith, Schuller, Nwachukwu, Burell, Giannadrea and Trujillo-Villa
5 were waiting for him, but then left almost immediately. After existing the program office,
6 inmate Quezada stood outside speaking to a friend (later identified as inmate A. Galindo who
7 had arrived at ASP with Quezada). From the window of the office, Plaintiff observed Quezada
8 acting erratically and glancing back toward the program office frequently.
9 Approximately twenty minutes later after Plaintiff had exited the program office, inmate
10 Quezada returned and knocked on the door (which was kept locked for security). Plaintiff, in
11 accordance with his job duties, opened the door and asked Quezada what he needed. Quezada
12 asked if his counselor was available, and as Plaintiff turned back toward the Committee
13 conference room to check, he felt a sharp and sudden pain in the side of his neck.
14 Plaintiff jumped back in the program office, and after a brief verbal exchange with
15 Quezada, realized he was bleeding profusely from the left side of his neck. Plaintiff waved to
16 the counselors through the conference room window and yelled, “He cut me!” at which time they
17 all came out to investigate. At that point, Quezada fled on foot, but he was apprehended
18 moments later by Defendant Trujillo-Villa. A homemade weapon consisting of several razor
19 blades attached to a plastic handle (commonly referred to in prison vernacular as a “tomahawk”)
20 was found on the ground where Quezada was taken into custody, and a “sheath” for the weapon
21 was found on his person.
22 Medical staff were requested to respond to Plaintiff via radio, and while waiting, some in
23 the office asked who had done this. Defendant Schuller responded, “A Level 3, Level 4 type,”
24 meaning an inmate generally housed on a high-security yard.
25 ASP medical staff arrived at 9:29 a.m. and confirmed that Plaintiff’s throat had been
26 slashed by inmate Quezada. Plaintiff was transported to the ASP central medical facility where
27 he was informed by the doctor treating him that Quezada had “just missed” his carotid artery (it
1 he was so close to losing his life). The resulting jagged laceration measured 5cm x 0.3mm and
2 penetrated all layers of the skin to the subcutaneous tissue, requiring seven sutures to close.
3 Inmate Quezada was read his Miranda rights, charged with attempted murder, and
4 transported to Pleasant Valley State Prison (PVSP) administrative segregation unit.
5 After returning to facility C, Plaintiff was approached by inmate Galindo who informed
6 him that he and Quezada had both come together from PVSP, a level 3 (high quality) SNY
7 facility, and that both had agreed that if they didn’t like ASP they would “do something” to get
8 sent back. Galindo further explained that while he had decided to stay, Quezada had told him
9 (while speaking to him outside the program office that morning) that he did not want to be on an
10 NDFF yard and was trying to get sent back to PVSP. Galindo said he tried to talk Quezada out
11 of doing anything violent (though he denied knowing what Quezada planned to do) to no avail.
12 Galindo indicated he had further information to share, but Plaintiff, in severe pain and wanting to
13 lay down, asked to speak to him about it later.
14 Inmate Galindo was subsequently assigned a job on another yard at ASP, and was
15 transferred to that facility before Plaintiff was able to follow up with him.
16 The day after the incident (12/19/2018), Defendant Nwachukwu entered the program
17 office and, joking about the incident, asked Plaintiff “why didn’t you even fight back, Perez? I
18 would have at least tried to defend myself.”
19 In the days and weeks that followed, Defendant Smith repeatedly mocked Plaintiff about
20 being attacked, telling Plaintiff (as Plaintiff was leaving the office) to “Be careful, they’re cutting
21 clerks out there,” or asking, “Do you need someone to go with you for protection.”
22 Plaintiff was already enrolled in the institution’s mental health program [“CCCMF”]
23 when this occurred, being treated for pre-existing anxiety and depression, including regulation
24 sessions with a staff psychologist. Plaintiff’s anxiety and depression were profoundly
25 exacerbated by not only the incident, but eh subsequent teasing by the Defendants, memories of
26 which continue to trigger enhanced episodes of both conditions and accounts for the primary
27 topic of discussion during his psych sessions.
1 In February of 2019, during Plaintiff’s annual CCCMF review committee, attended by,
2 inter alia, Plaintiff’s psychologist, and his assigned correctional counselor, Defendant Schuller,
3 Plaintiff was discussing the heightened anxiety that continued to torment him following the
4 incident. Defendant Schuller then commented that Plaintiff “shouldn’t feel that way” because
5 Quezada had “intended to attack [him], not [Plaintiff].” This alerted Plaintiff that Defendant
6 Schuller knew of Quezada’s intentions prior to the attack, and Plaintiff began to ask other
7 inmates on the yard if they had seen or heard anything that day.
8 “In March of 2019, Defendant Smith asked Plaintiff if he wanted to be transferred to ‘5
9 yard’ [ASP Facility E] he ‘heard they’re cutting clerks on this yard.’ Then he said, ‘Oops, too
10 late,’ and laughed about it. Defendant Schuller was present when this occurred and pulled Smith
11 aside to speak to him, presumably about his comment [NOTE: Defendant Smith frequently made
12 these kinds of comments in front of other correctional staff and inmates with the intention of
13 embarrassing and shaming Plaintiff about being attacked].”
14 Several days later, when Plaintiff stopped into the newly-remodeled counselor’s office
15 and commented that it looked like an insurance office, Defendant Burell asked if Plaintiff wanted
16 to buy any life insurance because he was prone to assault. This comment triggered an extended
17 episode of severe depression that lasted for several days.
18 In April of 2019, unable to cope with the Defendants’ incessant taunts, Plaintiff was
19 forced to quit his job in the program office for the sake of his mental health Prison jobs
20 (especially those that pay) on ASP Facility C are scarce, and the job of program office clerk is
21 one of the most coveted, well-paying positions on the yard. Plaintiff’s decision to give it up was
22 a measure born out of desperation to avert a complete nervous breakdown.
23 In May of 2019, Plaintiff was approached by two inmates who informed him that they
24 were near the program office on 12/18/2018 when the attack occurred, and said that while Inmate
25 Quezada was being handcuffed, they heard him tell Defendant Trujillo-Villa and Sergeant
26 Gonzales (not named in this action), “I told you I was going to cut someone if you didn’t put me
27 back on Level Three.”
1 These inmates also reported that after the incident, inmate Galindo told them that when
2 he and Quezada arrived at ASP, Quezada told the R&R sergeant who interviewed him that he
3 didn’t want to stay and would “do something” to get sent back to PVSP if they put him on a yard
4 at ASP, but the sergeant told him to take it up with his counselor.
5 Galindo then told these witnesses that Quezada had told Defendant Nwachukwu (who
6 had an office in Housing Unit 330 where Quezada was housed) prior to the day of the assault that
7 he didn’t want to stay at ASP, and if he had to, he would assault another inmate to get off the
8 yard. Defendant Nwachukwu responded by telling Quezada he could not help him because he
9 was not his assigned counselor.
10 Galindo further told the inmate witnesses that on the morning of the assault, Quezada
11 approached the two Housing Unit 330 officers named as Defendants and repeated his threat to
12 assault another inmate if he was not removed from the yard, but they told him to bring it up at his
13 UCC that morning.
14 Finally, Galindo conveyed to these witnesses that when Quezada walked into the
15 committee conference room with the six correctional counselors named as Defendants, he
16 repeated his threat again, and his assigned correctional counselor told him to “do what [he had]
17 to do,” at which point Quezada left, only to return twenty minutes later to cut Plaintiff’s throat.
18 B. Statement of Undisputed Facts2,3
19 Defendant L. Szalai
20 1. Inmate Quezada arrived at Avenal State Prison in early December of 2018. Upon
21 arrival, he was housed at Facility C. (Declaration of L. Szalazi (Szalai Decl.) ¶ 1; Declaration of
22 J. Alvarez (Alvarez Decl.) ¶ 1.)
23 2. As a new arrival, Quezada was awaiting an initial classification committee
24
2 Hereinafter referred to as “UF.”
25 3 Although Plaintiff did not file an opposition, a verified complaint may be used as an opposing affidavit under Rule
56, as long as it is based on personal knowledge and sets forth specific facts admissible in evidence. See Schroeder
26
v. McDonald, 55 F.3d 454, 460 & nn.10-11 (9th Cir. 1995) (treating plaintiff's verified complaint as opposing
affidavit where, even though verification not in conformity with 28 U.S.C. § 1746, plaintiff stated under penalty of
27 perjury that contents were true and correct, and allegations were not based purely on his belief but on his personal
knowledge). Here, Plaintiff’s complaint is made under penalty of perjury (see ECF No. 1) and is considered as part
1 review, generally scheduled to take place within two weeks of an inmate’s arrival at Avenal State
2 Prison. (Declaration of A. Smith (Smith Decl.) ¶ 2; Declaration of D. Schuller (Schuller Decl.) ¶
3 2; Declaration of G. Nwachukwu (Nwachukwu Decl.) ¶ 2; Declaration of J. Burell (Burell Decl.)
4 ¶ 2; Declaration of J. Trujillo-Villa (Trujillo Decl.) ¶ 2; Declaration of V. Giannandrea
5 (Giannandrea Decl.) ¶ 2.)
6 3. Szalai was a correctional officer who was assigned as the floor officer in the
7 building that housed inmate Quezada. (Szalai Decl. ¶ 2; Alvarez Decl. ¶ 2.)
8 4. Based on general practices, there may have been interactions between Plaintiff
9 and officers Szalai and Quezada. First, if Quezada first arrived to the housing unit during
10 Szalai’s shift, then Szalai or Alvarez would have provided Quezada a basic orientation. Second,
11 on the morning of December 18, 2018, one of them would have received a phone call from the
12 classification committee’s office informing them that Quezada had his initial classification
13 committee review, and would have communicated to Quezada to go to the review office. (Szalai
14 Decl. ¶ 4; Alvarez Decl. ¶ 4.)
15 Defendant J. Alvarez
16 5. Inmate Dante Quezada arrived at Avenal State Prison in early December of 2018.
17 Upon arrival, he was housed at Facility C. (Szalai Decl. ¶ 1; Alvarez Decl. ¶ 1.)
18 6. As a new arrival, Quezada was awaiting an initial classification committee
19 review, generally scheduled to take place within two weeks of an inmate’s arrival at Avenal State
20 Prison. (Smith Decl. ¶ 2; Schuller Decl. ¶ 2; Nwachukwu Decl. ¶ 2; Burell Decl. ¶ 2; Trujillo
21 Decl. ¶ 2; Giannandrea Decl. ¶ 2.)
22 7. Alvarez was a correctional officer who was assigned as a floor officer in the
23 building housing inmate Quezada. (Szalai Decl. ¶ 2; Alvarez Decl. ¶ 2.)
24 8. Based on general practices, there may have been interactions between Plaintiff
25 and officers Szalai and Quezada. First, if Quezada first arrived to the housing unit during
26 Szalai’s shift, then Szalai or Alvarez would have provided Quezada a basic orientation. Second,
27 on the morning of December 18, 2018, one of them would have received a phone call from the
1 committee review, and would have communicated to Quezada to go to the review office. (Szalai
2 Decl. ¶ 4; Alvarez Decl. ¶ 4.)
3 Defendant D. Schuller
4 9. Inmate Dante Quezada arrived at Avenal State Prison in early December of 2018.
5 Upon arrival, he was housed at Facility C. (Szalai Decl. ¶ 1; Alvarez Decl. ¶ 1.)
6 10. As a new arrival, Quezada was awaiting an initial classification committee
7 review, generally scheduled to take place within two weeks of an inmate’s arrival at Avenal State
8 Prison. (Smith Decl. ¶ 2; Schuller Decl. ¶ 2; Nwachukwu Decl. ¶ 2; Burell Decl. ¶ 2; Trujillo
9 Decl. ¶ 2; Giannandrea Decl. ¶ 2.)
10 11. In preparation of the review, a number of correctional counselor assigned to the
11 Facility would be given a caseload of inmates who recently arrived at Avenal State Prison.
12 (Schuller Decl. ¶ 2.)
13 12. The assigned correctional counselor would conduct research into the inmate’s
14 background and create a summary chronology that would be presented at the initial classification
15 committee review. (Schuller Decl. ¶ 2.)
16 13. The counselor would look at an inmate’s case factors, which included custody
17 status, previous housing institutions, time left on the sentence, time spent in prison, and whether
18 the inmate had any discipline. (Schuller Decl. ¶ 2.)
19 14. Further, the counselor may interview the subject inmate as part of the research
20 process. (Schuller Decl. ¶ 2.)
21 15. Inmate Quezada was assigned to D. Schuller’s caseload. (Schuller Decl. ¶ 3.)
22 16. At that point, staff responded, and Schuller stayed with Plaintiff until he received
23 medical attention. (Schuller Decl. ¶ 5.)
24 Defendant J. Burrell
25 17. Inmate Dante Quezada arrived at Avenal State Prison in early December of 2018.
26 Upon arrival, he was housed at Facility C. (Szalai Decl. ¶ 1; Alvarez Decl. ¶ 1.)
27 18. As a new arrival, Quezada was awaiting an initial classification committee
1 Prison. (Smith Decl. ¶ 2; Schuller Decl. ¶ 2; Nwachukwu Decl. ¶ 2; Burell Decl. ¶ 2; Trujillo
2 Decl. ¶ 2; Giannandrea Decl. ¶ 2.)
3 19. In preparation of the review, a number of correctional counselor assigned to the
4 Facility would be given a caseload of inmates who recently arrived at Avenal State Prison.
5 (Schuller Decl. ¶ 2.)
6 20. The assigned correctional counselor would conduct research into the inmate’s
7 background and create a summary chronology that would be presented at the initial classification
8 committee review. (Schuller Decl. ¶ 2.)
9 21. The counselor would look at an inmate’s case factors, which included custody
10 status, previous housing institutions, time left on the sentence, time spent in prison, and whether
11 the inmate had any discipline. (Schuller Decl. ¶ 2.)
12 22. Further, the counselor may interview the subject inmate as part of the research
13 process. (Schuller Decl. ¶ 2.)
14 23. Inmate Quezada was not assigned to Burell’s caseload. (Schuller Decl. ¶ 3.)
15 24. Schuller had a medical appointment scheduled on the morning of December 18,
16 2018, the day of Quezada’s initial classification committee review. Fearing he may be late, he
17 recruited J. Burell to present in place of him during the review if Quezada was called and he was
18 not there. (Schuller Decl. ¶ 4; Burell Decl. ¶ 4.)
19 25. Schuller was late, and Burell presented during Quezada’s review on December
20 18, 2018. (Burell Decl. ¶ 3.)
21 26. Burell knew something occurred when the alarm was triggered and he responded
22 to the yard. (Burell Decl. ¶ 7.)
23 Defendant J. Trujillo-Villa
24 27. Inmate Dante Quezada arrived at Avenal State Prison in early December of 2018.
25 Upon arrival, he was housed at Facility C. (Szalai Decl. ¶ 1; Alvarez Decl. ¶ 1.)
26 28. As a new arrival, Quezada was awaiting an initial classification committee
27 review, generally scheduled to take place within two weeks of an inmate’s arrival at Avenal State
1 Decl. ¶ 2; Giannandrea Decl. ¶ 2.)
2 29. Quezada was not assigned to Trujillo-Villa’s caseload. (Schuller Decl. ¶ 3.)
3 30. Trujillo-Villa was present for Plaintiff’s classification hearing. (Trujillo Decl. ¶
4 3.)
5 Defendant G. Nwachukwu
6 31. Inmate Dante Quezada arrived at Avenal State Prison in early December of 2018.
7 Upon arrival, he was housed at Facility C. (Szalai Decl. ¶ 1; Alvarez Decl. ¶ 1.)
8 32. As a new arrival, Quezada was awaiting an initial classification committee
9 review, generally scheduled to take place within two weeks of an inmate’s arrival at Avenal State
10 Prison. (Smith Decl. ¶ 2; Schuller Decl. ¶ 2; Nwachukwu Decl. ¶ 2; Burell Decl. ¶ 2; Trujillo
11 Decl. ¶ 2; Giannandrea Decl. ¶ 2.)
12 33. Quezada was not assigned to Nwachukwu’s caseload. (Schuller Decl. ¶ 3.)
13 34. Nwakchuwu was present for Plaintiff’s classification hearing. (Nwachukwu Decl.
14 ¶ 3.)
15 Defendant V. Giannandrea
16 35. Inmate Dante Quezada arrived at Avenal State Prison in early December of 2018.
17 Upon arrival, he was housed at Facility C. (Szalai Decl. ¶ 1; Alvarez Decl. ¶ 1.)
18 36. As a new arrival, Quezada was awaiting an initial classification committee
19 review, generally scheduled to take place within two weeks of an inmate’s arrival at Avenal State
20 Prison. (Smith Decl. ¶ 2; Schuller Decl. ¶ 2; Nwachukwu Decl. ¶ 2; Burell Decl. ¶ 2; Trujillo
21 Decl. ¶ 2; Giannandrea Decl. ¶ 2.)
22 37. Quezada was not assigned to Giannandrea’s caseload. (Schuller Decl. ¶ 3.)
23 38. Giannandrea was present for Plaintiff’s classification hearing. (Giannandrea
24 Decl. ¶ 3.)
25 C. Analysis of Defendants’ Motion
26 Defendants argue the undisputed records show that Defendants did not have knowledge
27 and were not subjectively aware of any threat posed by Quezada to Plaintiff. Defendants also
1 1. Merits of Plaintiff’s Claim
2 Prison officials have a duty under the Eighth Amendment to protect prisoners from
3 violence at the hands of other prisoners because being violently assaulted in prison is simply not
4 part of the penalty that criminal offenders pay for their offenses against society. Farmer v.
5 Brennan, 511 U.S. 825, 833-34 (1994); Clem v. Lomeli, 566 F.3d 1177, 1181 (9th Cir. 2009);
6 Hearns v. Terhune, 413 F.3d 1036, 1040 (9th Cir. 2005); Cortez v. Skol, 776 F.3d 1046, 1050
7 (9th Cir. 2015). However, prison officials are liable under the Eighth Amendment only if they
8 demonstrate deliberate indifference to conditions posing a substantial risk of serious harm to an
9 inmate; and it is well settled that deliberate indifference occurs when an official acted or failed to
10 act despite his knowledge of a substantial risk of serious harm. Farmer, 511 U.S. at 834, 841
11 (quotations omitted); Clem, 566 F.3d at 1181; Hearns, 413 F.3d at 1040.
12 In short, direct evidence of actual knowledge is not required. Farmer, 511 U.S. at 842.
13 The question is whether prison officials, acting with deliberate indifference, exposed a prisoner
14 to a sufficiently substantial “risk of serious damage to his future health ... and it does not matter
15 whether the risk comes from a single source or multiple sources, any more than it matters
16 whether a prisoner faces an excessive risk of attack for reasons personal to him or because
17 all prisoners in his situation face such a risk.” Farmer, 511 U.S. at 843.
18 In this instance, Defendants do not appear to dispute that the alleged deprivation is
19 objectively, sufficiently serious, especially that Plaintiff was stabbed by inmate Quezada.
20 Instead, Defendants argue that the undisputed facts demonstrate that Defendants were not
21 subjectively, deliberately indifferent to the need to protect Plaintiff from an attack by inmate
22 Quezada.
23 Inmate Dante Quezada arrived at Avenal State Prison in early December of 2018. Upon
24 arrival, he was housed at Facility C. (UF 1, 5, 9, 17, 27, 31, 35.) As a new arrival, Quezada was
25 awaiting an initial classification committee review, generally scheduled to take place within two
26 weeks of an inmate’s arrival at Avenal State Prison. (UF 2, 6, 10, 18, 28, 31, 35.) In preparation
27 of the review, a number of correctional counselor assigned to the Facility would be given a
1 correctional counselor would conduct research into the inmate’s background and create a
2 summary chronology that would be presented at the initial classification committee review. (UF
3 12.) The counselor would look at an inmate’s case factors, which included custody status,
4 previous housing institutions, time left on the sentence, time spent in prison, and whether the
5 inmate had any discipline. (UF 13.) Further, the counselor may interview the subject inmate as
6 part of the research process. (UF 14.) Inmate Quezada was assigned to D. Schuller’s caseload.
7 (UF 15.)
8 There is no dispute that Defendants Burell, Trujillo-Villa, Nwachukwu, Giannandrea, and
9 Smith were present at Plaintiff’s classification committee hearing. (UF 25, 30, 34, 38 Smith
10 Decl. ¶ 3.) Defendant Schuller declares that he was not present at the hearing, but he arrived at
11 the facility prior to the assault by inmate Quezada and specifically saw Quezada lunge at
12 Plaintiff. (Schuller Decl. ¶ 4.) Defendants all declare that during the classification review, they
13 were “not made aware of a threat or anything to a threat from Quezada, specifically against
14 Plaintiff Perez, against anyone else, or generally.” (Burell Decl. ¶ 6; Trujillo Decl. ¶ 5;
15 Nwachukwu Decl. ¶ 5; Giannandrea Decl. ¶ 4 ; Smith Decl. ¶ 4.) Defendants further declare that
16 if Quezada “had voiced some assertion to harm himself or others, [they] would have followed
17 standard protocol, which was to immediately place handcuffs on Quezada, placed him in a
18 holding cell, and allow custody officers to conduct an investigation.” (Burell Decl. ¶ 7; Trujillo
19 Decl. ¶ 6; Nwachukwu Decl. ¶ 6; Giannandrea Decl. ¶ 5 ; Smith Decl. ¶ 6.) Thus, Defendants
20 declare that prior to the incident on December 18, 2018, they had no knowledge of any threat
21 against Plaintiff by Quezada, nor any knowledge of a generalized threat by Quezada. (Burell
22 Decl. ¶ 10; Trujillo Decl. ¶ 9; Nwachukwu Decl. ¶ 9; Giannandrea Decl. ¶ 8 ; Smith Decl. ¶ 9.)
23 However, by way of verified complaint, Plaintiff submits that in February 2019, during
24 an annual classification review, attended by Defendant Schuller, Plaintiff was discussing the
25 heightened anxiety following the incident with inmate Quezada, and Schuller commented that
26 Plaintiff “‘shouldn’t feel that way’ because Quezada had ‘intended to attack [him], not
27
1 [Plaintiff].”4 (Compl. at 12.) In May of 2019, Plaintiff was approached by two inmates who
2 informed him that they were near the program office on December 18, 2018, when the attack
3 occurred, and they heard Quezada tell Defendant Trujillo-Villa, “I told you I was going to cut
4 someone if you didn’t put me back on Level Three.” (Compl. at 13.)
5 Inmate Galindo told other inmates that on the day prior to the assault, Quezada told
6 Defendant Nwachukwu “that he didn’t want to stay at ASP, and if he had to, he would assault
7 another inmate to get off the yard. Defendant Nwachukwu responded by telling Quezada he
8 couldn’t help him because he wasn’t his assigned counselor.” (Compl. at 13.) Inmate Galindo
9 also told other inmate witnesses that “Quezada approached the two Housing Unit 330 officers
10 named as Defendants in ¶(6) above (Defendants Alvarez and Szalai) and repeated his threat to
11 assault another inmate if he was not removed from the yard, but they told him to bring it up at his
12 UCC that morning.” (Compl. at 13-14.) Inmate Galindo also conveyed to other inmate
13 witnesses that when Quezada walked in to the committee conference room with the six
14 correctional counselors (Defendants Smith, G. Nwachukwu, Burell, Giannandrea, and Trujillo-
15 Villa), he repeated his threat again, and his assigned counselor told him to “do what [he had] to
16 do[.]” (Compl. at 14.)
17 It is further alleged that following the assault by inmate Quezada, Defendant Nwachukwu
18 asked Plaintiff, “why didn’t you even fight back, Perez? I would have at least tried to defend
19 myself.” (Compl. at 11.) Defendant Smith repeatedly mocked Plaintiff about being attacked by
20 telling him “[b]e careful, they’re cutting clerks out there,” or “Do you need someone to go with
21 you for protection.” (Id.) Defendant Burell asked if Plaintiff wanted to buy life insurance
22 because he was prone to assault. (Compl. at 12.)
23 After viewing all the evidence submitted in the light most favorable to Plaintiff, the Court
24 finds there exist genuine issues of material fact with respect to Plaintiff's claim that Defendants
25 A. Smith, D. Schuller, G. Nwachukwu, J. Burell, V. Giannandrea, J. Trujillo-Villa, J. Szalai, J.
26
4 Although Defendant Schuller declares that he was not present at inmate Quezada’s classification hearing on
27 December 18, 2018, Plaintiff claims that he was present. Furthermore, it is undisputed that Schuller was present on
December 18, 2018, prior to the assault on Plaintiff and was Quezada’s assigned counselor who specifically
1 Alvarez acted with deliberate indifference to his safety. Plaintiff’s version of events differs with
2 respect to Defendants prior knowledge and his version must be accepted as true for the purpose
3 of resolving Defendants’ motion. Comite de Jornaleros de Redondo Beach, 657 F.3d at 942;
4 Thomas v. Ponder, 611 F.3d 1144, 1149 (9th Cir. 2010). The Court may not weigh the parties’
5 evidence or assess their respective credibility, and here there is evidence from which a
6 reasonable jury could find that Defendants A. Smith, D. Schuller, G. Nwachukwu, J. Burell, V.
7 Giannandrea, J. Trujillo-Villa, J. Szalai, J. Alvarez were aware of inmate Quezada’s threat to
8 harm another inmate (Plaintiff) on December 18, 2018, if he was not place in handcuffs and
9 placed him in a holding cell, which presented a substantial risk of serious harm to Plaintiff’s
10 safety. See Farmer, 511 U.S. at 842; Lemire v. California Dept. of Corrections and
11 Rehabilitation, 726 F.3d 1062, 1078 (9th Cir. 2013); Foster v. Runnels, 554 F.3d 807, 814 (9th
12 Cir. 2009); Hearns v. Terhune, 413 F.3d at 1041. As previously stated, the inquiry is factual and
13 to the extent there circumstances which show the risk was not obvious to Defendants or they
14 acted reasonably despite the risk, that determination is left to the trier of fact. Farmer, 511 U.S.
15 at 842; Foster, 554 F.3d at 814
16 Accordingly, the Court finds that Defendants A. Smith, D. Schuller, G. Nwachukwu, J.
17 Burell, V. Giannandrea, J. Trujillo-Villa, J. Szalai, J. Alvarez are not entitled to summary
18 judgment and it recommends their motion be denied.
19 2. Qualified Immunity
20 The defense of qualified immunity protects “government officials ... from liability for
21 civil damages insofar as their conduct does not violate clearly established statutory or
22 constitutional rights of which a reasonable person would have known.” Harlow v. Fitzgerald, 457
23 U.S. 800, 818 (1982). The rule of qualified immunity protects “ ‘all but the plainly incompetent
24 or those who knowingly violate the law;’ ” defendants can have a reasonable, but mistaken,
25 belief about the facts or about what the law requires in any given situation. Saucier v. Katz, 533
26 U.S. 194, 202 (2001) (quoting Malley v. Briggs, 475 U.S. 335, 341 (1986)). “Therefore,
27 regardless of whether the constitutional violation occurred, the [official] should prevail if the
1
believed that his particular conduct was lawful.” Romero v. Kitsap County, 931 F.2d 624, 627
2
(9th Cir. 1991).
3
A right is clearly established if it were “sufficiently clear [at the time of the conduct at
4
issue] that every reasonable official would have understood that what he is doing violates that
5
right.” Taylor v. Barkes, 135 S. Ct. 2042, 2044 (2015). “The right must be settled law, meaning
6
that it must be clearly established by controlling authority or a robust consensus of cases of
7
persuasive authority.” Tuuamalemalo v. Greene, 946 F.3d 471, 477 (9th Cir. 2019). If the law
8
did not put the officer on notice that his conduct would be clearly unlawful, summary judgment
9
based on qualified immunity is appropriate. Saucier, 533 U.S. at 202.
10
A court considering a claim of qualified immunity must determine whether the plaintiff
11
has alleged the deprivation of an actual constitutional right and whether such right was clearly
12
established such that it would be clear to a reasonable officer that his conduct was unlawful in
13
the situation he confronted. See Pearson v. Callahan, 555 U.S. 223 (2009) (overruling the
14
sequence of the two-part test that required determination of a deprivation first and then whether
15
such right was clearly established, as required by Saucier, 533 U.S. at 194); Henry A. v. Willden,
16
678 F.3d 991, 1000 (9th Cir. 2012) (qualified immunity analysis requiring (1) determining the
17
contours of the clearly established right at the time of the challenged conduct and (2) examining
18
whether a reasonable official would have understood that the challenged conduct violated such
19
right). The court may exercise its discretion in deciding which prong to address first, in light of
20
the particular circumstances of each case. See Pearson, 555 U.S. at 236 (noting that while
21
the Saucier sequence is often appropriate and beneficial, it is no longer mandatory). “[U]nder
22
either prong, courts may not resolve genuine disputes of fact in favor of the party seeking
23
summary judgment,” and must, as in other cases, view the evidence in the light most favorable to
24
the non-movant. See Tolan v. Cotton, 134 S. Ct. 1861, 1866 (2014).
25
The qualified immunity inquiry is separate from the constitutional inquiry for a claim of
26
deliberate indifference under the Eighth Amendment. Estate of Ford v. Caden, 301 F.3d 1043,
27
1053 (9th Cir. 2002) (extending Saucier to Eighth Amendment claims). A determination that
1
there is a triable issue of fact as to whether defendants were deliberately indifferent does not
2
necessarily preclude a finding of qualified immunity. Id. For a qualified immunity analysis, the
3
court need not determine whether the facts alleged show that defendants acted with deliberate
4
indifference. See Osolinski v. Kane, 92 F.3d 934, 936 (9th Cir. 1996). Rather, the court need
5
only review the relevant law to determine whether, in light of clearly established principles at the
6
time of the incident, the officials could have reasonably believed their conduct was lawful. Id. at
7
939. It is possible for a prison official to know all of the facts alleged by plaintiff and to
8
understand that he cannot recklessly disregard a substantial risk of harm to a prisoner, and yet to
9
mistakenly, though reasonably, perceive that the risk of harm is not too high; such an official is
10
entitled to qualified immunity. Estate of Ford, 301 F.3d at 1049-50.
11
The plaintiff bears the burden of proving the existence of a “clearly established” right at
12
the time of the allegedly impermissible conduct. Maraziti v. First Interstate Bank, 953 F.2d 520,
13
523 (9th Cir. 1992). The defendant bears the burden of establishing that his actions were
14
reasonable, even if he violated the plaintiff's constitutional rights. White v. Pauly, 137 S. Ct. 548,
15
552 (2017).
16
Viewing the evidence in the light most favorable to Plaintiff, the Court finds Defendants
17
are not entitled to qualified immunity. First of all, Plaintiff has clearly alleged the deprivation of
18
an actual constitutional right, i.e., an Eighth Amendment right to be protected from violence at
19
the hand of others. See Valandingham v. Bojorquez, 866 F.2d 1135, 1138 (9th Cir. 1989).
20
Secondly, Defendants have failed to establish that their conduct was reasonable. Viewing the
21
evidence in the light most favorable to Plaintiff, Defendants are alleged to have received
22
knowledge from inmate Quezada that he intended to harm another inmate if he was not
23
transferred prior to Quezada’s assault on Plaintiff on December 18, 2018, and failed to acted
24
reasonably in response to such threat.
25
At the time of this alleged conduct, it was sufficiently clear that every reasonable official
26
would have understood that he has a duty to protect prisoners from the violence at the hands of
27
other prisoners. See Farmer, 511 U.S. at 833-34, 837. It thus would have been “clear to a
1
reasonable officer that [his] conduct [of increasing the threat of harm to Plaintiff] was unlawful
2
in the situation [Defendants] confronted.” Saucier, 533 U.S. at 202; see also Valandingham, 866
3
F.2d at 1138 (deliberately spreading rumor that prisoner is snitch may state claim for violation of
4
right to be protected from violence while in state custody). Therefore, it cannot be said that a
5
reasonable officer in Defendants’ position would have understood that it was lawful to not
6
segregate Quezada after he threatened to harm other inmates if he was not transferred. In other
7
words, in light of clearly established principles at the time of the incident, it cannot be said that
8
Defendants could have reasonably believed that his conduct was lawful. See Osolinski, 92 F.3d
9
at 939. Furthermore, Defendants deny having any alleged knowledge of the threats, so it cannot
10
even be argued that they acted with a mistaken belief that their conduct was
11
reasonable. See Estate of Ford, 301 F.3d at 1049-50. Accordingly, in light of the disputed issues
12
of material fact in this case, Defendants are not entitled to qualified immunity.
13
3. Dismissal of Defendant Doe
14
Pursuant to the Court’s July 22, 2020 screening order, the Court found that Plaintiff
15
stated a cognizable failure to protect claim against the Doe Defendant identified as “ASP
16
Designated Custody Supervisor.” (ECF No. 10.)
17
In the Court’s September 30, 2020 service order, it was explained that Defendant Doe
18
could not be served before being identified and noting that Plaintiff could amend his complaint if
19
the Defendant’s identity were ascertained during discovery. (ECF No. 15 at n.1.) Indeed,
20
Plaintiff’s complaint acknowledged that the actual identity of the Doe Defendant would be
21
sought during discovery. (Compl. at 8.)
22
The March 17, 2021 amended scheduling order provided that the parties could
23
conduct discovery until October 22, 2021. (ECF No. 37.) The deadline was subsequently
24
extended to December 22, 2021. (ECF No. 41.) Plaintiff has not moved to amend his complaint,
25
moved to substitute a Defendant, or otherwise notified the court of the identity of Defendant
26
Doe.
27
1
Pursuant to Rule 4 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, “[i]f a defendant is not served
2
within 90 days after the complaint is filed, the court—on motion or on its own after notice to the
3
plaintiff—must dismiss the action without prejudice against that defendant or order that service
4
be made within a specified time. But if the plaintiff shows good cause for the failure, the court
5
must extend the time for service for an appropriate period.” Fed. R. Civ. P. 4(m). This 90-day
6
deadline under Rule 4(m) applies to service on unnamed defendants. See Bulgara v. Cty. of
7
Stanislaus, No. 1:18-cv-00804-DAD-SAB, 2020 WL 5366306, at *5 (E.D. Cal. Sept. 8, 2020),
8
report and recommendation adopted, No. 1:18-cv-00804-DAD-SAB (PS), 2021 WL 1105255
9
(E.D. Cal. Mar. 23, 2021) (dismissing action against “Doe defendants” for failure to serve
10
within Rule 4(m)’s 90-day deadline). In this case, well over 90 days have elapsed since the
11
filing of plaintiff's signed complaint on June 15, 2020. (ECF No. 1.) Plaintiff has therefore failed
12
to serve the Defendant Doe in compliance with Rule 4(m).
13
In addition to Rule 4(m)’s requirements, “a court may dismiss a defendant, a claim[,] or
14
an action based on a party’s failure to prosecute an action[,] failure to obey a court order,
15
or failure to comply with local rules.” Bulgara, 2020 WL 5366306, at *5 (citing Ferdik v.
16
Bonzelet, 963 F.2d 1258, 1260-61 (9th Cir. 1992) (dismissal for failure to comply with an order
17
requiring amendment of complaint), Henderson v. Duncan, 779 F.2d 1421, 1424 (9th Cir.
18
1986) (dismissal for failure to prosecute and to comply with local rules)). Plaintiff received
19
advisement that he was required to amend his complaint to identify the Defendant Doe so that
20
the complaint could be served. (ECF No. 15.) Discovery has closed and the deadline to amend
21
the pleadings has passed without Plaintiff filing anything to indicate that he has identified
22
Defendant Doe.
23
Where plaintiff has failed to effect service in accordance with Rule 4(m) and has failed to
24
comply with the orders instructing him to identify the defendant before the close of discovery,
25
dismissal of a Doe defendant is warranted. See Williby v. California, 276 F. App'x 663, 665 (9th
26
Cir. 2008) (holding district court's sua sponte dismissal of Doe defendants was merited where
27
plaintiff had failed to identify defendants within allotted discovery period); Bulgara, 2020 WL
! 5366306, at *5 (recommending dismissal of Doe defendants, without additional notice, for
failure to effect service under Rule 4(m) where defendants were not identified within the
allotted discovery period). Accordingly, it is recommended that Defendant Doe dismissed from
‘ this action.
° IV.
6 RECOMMENDATIONS
7 Based on the foregoing, it is HEREBY RECOMMENDED that:
1. Defendants’ motion for summary judgment be denied; and
2. Defendant Doe be dismissed from the action pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil
10 Procedure 4(m).
These Findings and Recommendations will be submitted to the United States District
2 Judge assigned to the case, pursuant to the provisions of 28 U.S.C. § 636(b)(). Within twenty-
one (21) days after being served with these Findings and Recommendations, the parties may file
written objections with the Court. The document should be captioned “Objections to Magistrate
Judge’s Findings and Recommendations.” The parties are advised that failure to file objections
within the specified time may result in the waiver of rights on appeal. Wilkerson v. Wheeler,
"7 772 F.3d 834, 838-39 (9th Cir. 2014) (citing Baxter v. Sullivan, 923 F.2d 1391, 1394 (9th Cir.
1991)).
19
20 | IT IS SO ORDERED.
Al (re
71) Dated: _ October 3, 2022 IF
2 UNITED STATES MAGISTRATE JUDGE
23
24
25
26
27
28