# FDIC FIL-29-2017: Appraisal Threshold for Commercial Real Estate Transactions

> Federal · Agency guidance · Superseded

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/statutes/FDIC_FIL17029

## Section

- **Citation:** FDIC FIL-29-2017
- **Heading:** Appraisal Threshold for Commercial Real Estate Transactions
- **Jurisdiction:** Federal
- **Kind:** Agency guidance
- **Status:** Superseded
- **Text as of:** August 14, 2026
- **Source:** Compiled text
- **Location:** FDIC Financial Institution Letters / Appraisal Threshold for Commercial Real Estate Transactions

## Text

35478
Federal Register / Vol. 82, No. 145 / Monday, July 31, 2017 / Proposed Rules
technical difficulties and cannot contact
you for clarification, DOE may not be
able to consider your comment.
However, your contact information
will be publicly viewable if you include
it in the comment or in any documents
attached to your comment. Any
information that you do not want to be
publicly viewable should not be
included in your comment, nor in any
document attached to your comment.
Persons viewing comments will see only
first and last names, organization
names, correspondence containing
comments, and any documents
submitted with the comments.
Do not submit to http://
www.regulations.gov information for
which disclosure is restricted by statute,
such as trade secrets and commercial or
financial information (hereinafter
referred to as Confidential Business
Information (CBI)). Comments
submitted through http://
www.regulations.gov cannot be claimed
as CBI. Comments received through the
Web site will waive any CBI claims for
the information submitted. For
information on submitting CBI, see the
Confidential Business Information
section.
DOE processes submissions made
through http://www.regulations.gov
before posting. Normally, comments
will be posted within a few days of
being submitted. However, if large
volumes of comments are being
processed simultaneously, your
comment may not be viewable for up to
several weeks. Please keep the comment
tracking number that http://
www.regulations.gov provides after you
have successfully uploaded your
comment.
Submitting comments via email, hand
delivery, or mail. Comments and
documents submitted via email, hand
delivery, or mail also will be posted to
http://www.regulations.gov. If you do
not want your personal contact
information to be publicly viewable, do
not include it in your comment or any
accompanying documents. Instead,
provide your contact information on a
cover letter
our
comment.
Submitting comments via email, hand
delivery, or mail. Comments and
documents submitted via email, hand
delivery, or mail also will be posted to
http://www.regulations.gov. If you do
not want your personal contact
information to be publicly viewable, do
not include it in your comment or any
accompanying documents. Instead,
provide your contact information on a
cover letter. Include your first and last
names, email address, telephone
number, and optional mailing address.
The cover letter will not be publicly
viewable as long as it does not include
any comments.
Include contact information each time
you submit comments, data, documents,
and other information to DOE. If you
submit via mail or hand delivery, please
provide all items on a CD, if feasible. It
is not necessary to submit printed
copies. No facsimiles (faxes) will be
accepted.
Comments, data, and other
information submitted to DOE
electronically should be provided in
PDF (preferred), Microsoft Word or
Excel, WordPerfect, or text (ASCII) file
format. Provide documents that are not
secured, written in English and free of
any defects or viruses. Documents
should not contain special characters or
any form of encryption and, if possible,
they should carry the electronic
signature of the author.
Campaign form letters. Please submit
campaign form letters by the originating
organization in batches of between 50 to
500 form letters per PDF or as one form
letter with a list of supporters’ names
compiled into one or more PDFs. This
reduces comment processing and
posting time.
Confidential Business Information
nd, if possible,
they should carry the electronic
signature of the author.
Campaign form letters. Please submit
campaign form letters by the originating
organization in batches of between 50 to
500 form letters per PDF or as one form
letter with a list of supporters’ names
compiled into one or more PDFs. This
reduces comment processing and
posting time.
Confidential Business Information.
According to 10 CFR 1004.11, any
person submitting information that he
or she believes to be confidential and
exempt by law from public disclosure
should submit via email, postal mail, or
hand delivery two well-marked copies:
one copy of the document marked
confidential including all the
information believed to be confidential,
and one copy of the document marked
‘‘non-confidential’’ with the information
believed to be confidential deleted.
Submit these documents via email or on
a CD, if feasible. DOE will make its own
determination about the confidential
status of the information and treat it
according to its determination.
Factors of interest to DOE when
evaluating requests to treat submitted
information as confidential include (1) a
description of the items, (2) whether
and why such items are customarily
treated as confidential within the
industry, (3) whether the information is
generally known by or available from
other sources, (4) whether the
information has previously been made
available to others without obligation
concerning its confidentiality, (5) an
explanation of the competitive injury to
the submitting person which would
result from public disclosure, (6) when
such information might lose its
confidential character due to the
passage of time, and (7) why disclosure
of the information would be contrary to
the public interest.
It is DOE’s policy that all comments
may be included in the public docket,
without change and as received,
including any personal information
provided in the comments (except
information deemed to be exempt from
public disclosure)
ormation might lose its
confidential character due to the
passage of time, and (7) why disclosure
of the information would be contrary to
the public interest.
It is DOE’s policy that all comments
may be included in the public docket,
without change and as received,
including any personal information
provided in the comments (except
information deemed to be exempt from
public disclosure).
DOE considers public participation to
be a very important part of the process
for developing test procedures. DOE
actively encourages the participation
and interaction of the public during the
comment period in each stage of the
rulemaking process. Interactions with
and between members of the public
provide a balanced discussion of the
issues and assist DOE in the rulemaking
process. Anyone who wishes to be
added to the DOE mailing list to receive
future notices and information about
this rulemaking should contact
Appliance and Equipment Standards
Program staff at (202) 586–6636 or via
email at
ApplianceStandardsQuestions@
ee.doe.gov.
Issued in Washington, DC, on July 14,
2017.
Kathleen B. Hogan,
Deputy Assistant Secretary for Energy
Efficiency, Energy Efficiency and Renewable
Energy.
[FR Doc. 2017–15848 Filed 7–28–17; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 6450–01–P
DEPARTMENT OF THE TREASURY
Office of the Comptroller of the
Currency
12 CFR Part 34
[Docket No. OCC–2017–0011]
RIN 1557–AE18
FEDERAL RESERVE SYSTEM
12 CFR Part 225
[Docket No. R–1568; RIN 7100 AE–81]
FEDERAL DEPOSIT INSURANCE
CORPORATION
12 CFR Part 323
RIN 3064 AE–56
Real Estate Appraisals
AGENCY: Office of the Comptroller of the
Currency, Treasury (OCC); Board of
Governors of the Federal Reserve
System (Board); and Federal Deposit
Insurance Corporation (FDIC).
ACTION: Notice of proposed rulemaking
and request for comment.
SUMMARY: The OCC, Board, and FDIC
(collectively, the agencies) are inviting
comment on a proposed rule to amend
the agencies’ regulations requiring
appraisals of real estate for certain
transactions
cy, Treasury (OCC); Board of
Governors of the Federal Reserve
System (Board); and Federal Deposit
Insurance Corporation (FDIC).
ACTION: Notice of proposed rulemaking
and request for comment.
SUMMARY: The OCC, Board, and FDIC
(collectively, the agencies) are inviting
comment on a proposed rule to amend
the agencies’ regulations requiring
appraisals of real estate for certain
transactions. The proposal would
increase the threshold level at or below
which appraisals would not be required
for commercial real estate transactions
from $250,000 to $400,000. This
proposed change to the appraisal
threshold reflects comments the
VerDate Sep<11>2014
16:29 Jul 28, 2017
Jkt 241001
PO 00000
Frm 00011
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
E:\FR\FM\31JYP1.SGM
31JYP1
sradovich on DSKBCFCHB2PROD with PROPOSALS

35479
Federal Register / Vol. 82, No. 145 / Monday, July 31, 2017 / Proposed Rules
agencies received through the regulatory
review process required by the
Economic Growth and Regulatory
Paperwork Reduction Act (EGRPRA)
and completed in early 2017. For
commercial real estate transactions with
a value at or below the proposed
threshold, the amended rule would
require institutions to obtain an
evaluation of the real property collateral
that is consistent with safe and sound
banking practices if the institution does
not obtain an appraisal by a state
certified or licensed appraiser.
DATES: Comments must be received by
September 29, 2017.
ADDRESSES: Interested parties are
encouraged to submit written comments
jointly to all of the agencies.
Commenters should use the title ‘‘Real
Estate Appraisals’’ to facilitate the
organization and distribution of
comments among the agencies.
Interested parties are invited to submit
written comments to:
Office of the Comptroller of the
Currency: Because paper mail in the
Washington, DC area and at the OCC is
subject to delay, commenters are
encouraged to submit comments by the
Federal eRulemaking Portal or email, if
possible
Estate Appraisals’’ to facilitate the
organization and distribution of
comments among the agencies.
Interested parties are invited to submit
written comments to:
Office of the Comptroller of the
Currency: Because paper mail in the
Washington, DC area and at the OCC is
subject to delay, commenters are
encouraged to submit comments by the
Federal eRulemaking Portal or email, if
possible. Please use the title ‘‘Real
Estate Appraisals’’ to facilitate the
organization and distribution of the
comments. You may submit comments
by any of the following methods:
• Federal eRulemaking Portal—
Regulations.gov: Go to
www.regulations.gov. Enter ‘‘Docket ID
OCC–2017–0011’’ in the Search Box and
click ‘‘Search.’’ Click on ‘‘Comment
Now’’ to submit public comments.
• Click on the ‘‘Help’’ tab on the
Regulations.gov home page to get
information on using Regulations.gov,
including instructions for submitting
public comments.
• Email: regs.comments@
occ.treas.gov.
• Mail: Legislative and Regulatory
Activities Division, Office of the
Comptroller of the Currency, 400 7th
Street SW., Suite 3E–218, Mail Stop
9W–11, Washington, DC 20219.
• Fax: (571) 465–4326.
• Hand Delivery/Courier: 400 7th
Street SW., Suite 3E–218, Mail Stop
9W–11, Washington, DC 20219.
Instructions: You must include
‘‘OCC’’ as the agency name and ‘‘Docket
ID OCC–2017–0011’’ in your comment.
In general, OCC will enter all comments
received into the docket and publish
them on the Regulations.gov Web site
without change, including any business
or personal information that you
provide such as name and address
information, email addresses, or phone
numbers. Comments received, including
attachments and other supporting
materials, are part of the public record
and subject to public disclosure. Do not
enclose any information in your
comment or supporting materials that
you consider confidential or
inappropriate for public disclosure
r personal information that you
provide such as name and address
information, email addresses, or phone
numbers. Comments received, including
attachments and other supporting
materials, are part of the public record
and subject to public disclosure. Do not
enclose any information in your
comment or supporting materials that
you consider confidential or
inappropriate for public disclosure.
You may review comments and other
related materials that pertain to this
proposed rule by any of the following
methods:
• Viewing Comments Electronically:
Go to www.regulations.gov. Enter
‘‘Docket ID OCC–2017–0011’’ in the
Search box and click ‘‘Search.’’ Click on
‘‘Open Docket Folder’’ on the right side
of the screen and then ‘‘Comments.’’
Comments can be filtered by clicking on
‘‘View All’’ and then using the filtering
tools on the left side of the screen.
• Click on the ‘‘Help’’ tab on the
Regulations.gov home page to get
information on using Regulations.gov.
Supporting materials may be viewed by
clicking on ‘‘Open Docket Folder’’ and
then clicking on ‘‘Supporting
Documents.’’ The docket may be viewed
after the close of the comment period in
the same manner as during the comment
period.
• Viewing Comments Personally: You
may personally inspect and photocopy
comments at the OCC, 400 7th Street
SW., Washington, DC. For security
reasons, the OCC requires that visitors
make an appointment to inspect
comments. You may do so by calling
on ‘‘Supporting
Documents.’’ The docket may be viewed
after the close of the comment period in
the same manner as during the comment
period.
• Viewing Comments Personally: You
may personally inspect and photocopy
comments at the OCC, 400 7th Street
SW., Washington, DC. For security
reasons, the OCC requires that visitors
make an appointment to inspect
comments. You may do so by calling
(202) 649–6700 or, for persons who are
deaf or hard of hearing, TTY, (202) 649–
5597. Upon arrival, visitors will be
required to present valid government-
issued photo identification and to
submit to security screening in order to
inspect and photocopy comments.
Board of Governors of the Federal
Reserve System: You may submit
comments, identified by [Docket No. R–
1568 and RIN 7100 AE–81], by any of
the following methods:
• Agency Web site: http://
www.federalreserve.gov. Follow the
instructions for submitting comments at
http://www.federalreserve.gov/
generalinfo/foia/ProposedRegs.cfm.
• Federal eRulemaking Portal: http://
www.regulations.gov. Follow the
instructions for submitting comments.
• Email: regs.comments@
federalreserve.gov. Include the docket
number and RIN number in the subject
line of the message.
• Fax: (202) 452–3819 or (202) 452–
3102.
• Mail: Address to Ann E. Misback,
Secretary, Board of Governors of the
Federal Reserve System, 20th Street and
Constitution Avenue NW., Washington,
DC 20551.
All public comments will be made
available on the Board’s Web site at
http://www.federalreserve.gov/
generalinfo/foia/ProposedRegs.cfm as
submitted, unless modified for technical
reasons. Accordingly, comments will
not be edited to remove any identifying
or contact information. Public
comments may also be viewed
electronically or in paper form in Room
3515, 1801 K Street NW. (between 18th
and 19th Streets NW.), Washington, DC
20006 between 9:00 a.m. and 5:00 p.m.
on weekdays
serve.gov/
generalinfo/foia/ProposedRegs.cfm as
submitted, unless modified for technical
reasons. Accordingly, comments will
not be edited to remove any identifying
or contact information. Public
comments may also be viewed
electronically or in paper form in Room
3515, 1801 K Street NW. (between 18th
and 19th Streets NW.), Washington, DC
20006 between 9:00 a.m. and 5:00 p.m.
on weekdays.
Federal Deposit Insurance
Corporation: You may submit
comments, identified by RIN 3064–
AE56, by any of the following methods:
• Federal eRulemaking Portal: http://
www.regulations.gov. Follow the
instructions for submitting comments.
• Agency Web site: http://
www.FDIC.gov/regulations/laws/
federal/propose.html.
• Mail: Robert E. Feldman, Executive
Secretary, Attention: Comments/Legal
ESS, Federal Deposit Insurance
Corporation, 550 17th Street NW.,
Washington, DC 20429.
• Hand Delivered/Courier: The guard
station at the rear of the 550 17th Street
Building (located on F Street) on
business days between 7:00 a.m. and
5:00 p.m.
• Email: Comments@FDIC.gov.
Comments submitted must include
‘‘FDIC’’ and ‘‘Real Estate Appraisals.’’
Comments received will be posted
without change to http://www.fdic.gov/
regulations/laws/federal/propose.html
including any personal information
provided.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:
OCC: G. Kevin Lawton, Appraiser
(Real Estate Specialist), (202) 649–7152,
Mitchell E. Plave, Special Counsel,
Legislative and Regulatory Activities
Division, (202) 649–5490, for persons
who are deaf or hard of hearing, TTY,
be posted
without change to http://www.fdic.gov/
regulations/laws/federal/propose.html
including any personal information
provided.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:
OCC: G. Kevin Lawton, Appraiser
(Real Estate Specialist), (202) 649–7152,
Mitchell E. Plave, Special Counsel,
Legislative and Regulatory Activities
Division, (202) 649–5490, for persons
who are deaf or hard of hearing, TTY,
(202) 649–5597, or Christopher
Manthey, Special Counsel, or Joanne
Phillips, Attorney, Bank Activities and
Structure Division, (202) 649–5500,
Office of the Comptroller of the
Currency, 400 7th Street SW.,
Washington, DC 20219.
Board: Anna Lee Hewko, Associate
Director, (202) 530–6260, or Carmen
Holly, Senior Supervisory Financial
Analyst, (202) 973–6122, Division of
Supervision and Regulation; or Gillian
Burgess, Senior Counsel, (202) 736–
5564, Matthew Suntag, Senior Attorney,
(202) 452–3694, or Kirin Walsh,
Attorney, (202) 452–3058, Legal
Division, Board of Governors of the
Federal Reserve System, 20th and C
Streets NW., Washington, DC 20551.
VerDate Sep<11>2014
16:29 Jul 28, 2017
Jkt 241001
PO 00000
Frm 00012
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
E:\FR\FM\31JYP1.SGM
31JYP1
sradovich on DSKBCFCHB2PROD with PROPOSALS

35480
Federal Register / Vol. 82, No. 145 / Monday, July 31, 2017 / Proposed Rules
1 12 U.S.C. 3331 et seq.
2 ‘‘Federal financial institutions regulatory
agency’’ means the Board, the FDIC, the OCC, the
National Credit Union Association (NCUA), and,
formerly, the Office of Thrift Supervision. 12 U.S.C.
3350(6).
3 These interests include those stemming from the
federal government’s roles as regulator and deposit
insurer of financial institutions that engage in real
estate lending and investment, guarantor or lender
on mortgage loans, and as a direct party in real
estate-related financial transactions. These federal
financial and public policy interests have been
described in predecessor legislation and
accompanying Congressional reports
from the
federal government’s roles as regulator and deposit
insurer of financial institutions that engage in real
estate lending and investment, guarantor or lender
on mortgage loans, and as a direct party in real
estate-related financial transactions. These federal
financial and public policy interests have been
described in predecessor legislation and
accompanying Congressional reports. See Real
Estate Appraisal Reform Act of 1988, H.R. Rep. No.
100–1001, pt. 1, at 19 (1988); 133 Cong. Rec. 33047–
33048 (1987).
4 12 U.S.C. 3331.
5 12 U.S.C. 3339. The agencies’ Title XI appraisal
regulations apply to transactions entered into by the
agencies or by institutions regulated by the agencies
that are depository institutions or bank holding
companies or subsidiaries of depository institutions
or bank holding companies. OCC: 12 CFR part 34,
subpart C; Board: 12 CFR 225.61(b); 12 CFR part
208, subpart E; FDIC: 12 CFR part 323.
6 USPAP is written and interpreted by the
Appraisal Standards Board of the Appraisal
Foundation. Adopted by Congress in 1989, USPAP
contains generally recognized ethical and
performance standards for the appraisal profession
in the United States, including real estate, personal
property, and business appraisals. See http://
www.appraisalfoundation.org/imis/TAF/Standards/
Appraisal_Standards/Uniform_Standards_of_
Professional_Appraisal_Practice/TAF/
USPAP.aspx?hkey=a6420a67-dbfa-41b3-9878-
fac35923d2af.
7 12 U.S.C. 3350(4) (defining ‘‘federally related
transaction’’).
8 12 U.S.C. 3350(5).
9 See 59 FR 29482 (June 7, 1994).
10 See OCC: 12 CFR 34.43(a); Board: 12 CFR
225.63(a); FDIC: 12 CFR 323.3(a).
11 Housing and Community Development Act of
1992, Public Law 102–550, sec. 954, 106 Stat. 3894
(amending 12 U.S.C. 3341).
12 Public Law 111–203, 124 Stat.1376.
13 Dodd-Frank Act, sec. 1473, 124 Stat. 2190
(amending 12 U.S.C. 3341(b)).
14 See 59 FR 29482 (June 7, 1994). The NCUA
promulgated a similar rule with similar thresholds
in 1995
(a); Board: 12 CFR
225.63(a); FDIC: 12 CFR 323.3(a).
11 Housing and Community Development Act of
1992, Public Law 102–550, sec. 954, 106 Stat. 3894
(amending 12 U.S.C. 3341).
12 Public Law 111–203, 124 Stat.1376.
13 Dodd-Frank Act, sec. 1473, 124 Stat. 2190
(amending 12 U.S.C. 3341(b)).
14 See 59 FR 29482 (June 7, 1994). The NCUA
promulgated a similar rule with similar thresholds
in 1995. 60 FR 51889 (October 4, 1995).
15 For loans and extensions of credit, the
transaction value is the amount of the loan or
extension of credit. For sales, leases, purchases,
investments in or exchanges of real property, the
transaction value is the market value of the real
property. For the pooling of loans or interests in
real property for resale or purchase, the transaction
value is the amount of each such loan or the market
value of each such real property, respectively. See
OCC: 12 CFR 34.42(m); Board: 12 CFR 225.62(m);
FDIC: CFR 323.2(m).
16 See OCC: 12 CFR 34.43(a)(1) and (5); Board: 12
CFR 225.63(a)(1) and (5); FDIC: 12 CFR 323.3(a)(1)
and (5).
17 OCC: 12 CFR 34.43(a)(5); Board: 12 CFR
225.63(a)(5); FDIC: 12 CFR 323.3(a)(5).
18 Transactions that involve an existing extension
of credit at the lending institution are exempt from
the Title XI appraisal requirements, but are required
to have evaluations, provided that there has been
no obvious and material change in market
conditions or physical aspects of the property that
threatens the adequacy of the institution’s real
estate collateral protection after the transaction,
even with the advancement of new monies; or there
is no advancement of new monies, other than funds
necessary to cover reasonable closing costs. See
OCC: 12 CFR 34.43(a)(7) and (b); Board: 12 CFR
225.63(a)(7) and (b); FDIC: 12 CFR 323.3(a)(7) and
ons or physical aspects of the property that
threatens the adequacy of the institution’s real
estate collateral protection after the transaction,
even with the advancement of new monies; or there
is no advancement of new monies, other than funds
necessary to cover reasonable closing costs. See
OCC: 12 CFR 34.43(a)(7) and (b); Board: 12 CFR
225.63(a)(7) and (b); FDIC: 12 CFR 323.3(a)(7) and
(b).
FDIC: Beverlea S. Gardner, Senior
Examination Specialist, Division of Risk
Management and Supervision, at (202)
898–3640, Mark Mellon, Counsel, Legal
Division, at (202) 898–3884, Kimberly
Stock, Counsel, Legal Division, at (202)
898–3815, Benjamin K. Gibbs, Counsel,
at (202) 898–6726, or Lauren Whitaker,
Senior Attorney, at (202) 898–3872,
Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation,
550 17th Street NW., Washington, DC
20429.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
I. Introduction
A. Background
Title XI of the Financial Institutions
Reform, Recovery, and Enforcement Act
of 1989 (Title XI) 1 directs each federal
financial institutions regulatory agency 2
to publish appraisal regulations for
federally related transactions within its
jurisdiction. The purpose of Title XI is
to protect federal financial and public
policy interests 3 in real estate-related
transactions by requiring that real estate
appraisals used in connection with
federally related transactions (Title XI
appraisals) be performed in accordance
with uniform standards, by individuals
whose competency has been
demonstrated and whose professional
conduct will be subject to effective
supervision.4
Title XI directs the agencies to
prescribe appropriate standards for Title
XI appraisals under the agencies’
respective jurisdictions,5 including, at a
minimum, that Title XI appraisals be:
itle XI
appraisals) be performed in accordance
with uniform standards, by individuals
whose competency has been
demonstrated and whose professional
conduct will be subject to effective
supervision.4
Title XI directs the agencies to
prescribe appropriate standards for Title
XI appraisals under the agencies’
respective jurisdictions,5 including, at a
minimum, that Title XI appraisals be:
(1) Performed in accordance with the
Uniform Standards of Professional
Appraisal Practice (USPAP); 6 (2)
written appraisals, as defined by the
statute; and (3) subject to appropriate
review for compliance with USPAP. All
federally related transactions must have
Title XI appraisals.
Title XI defines a ‘‘federally related
transaction’’ as a real estate-related
financial transaction that is regulated or
engaged in by a federal financial
institutions regulatory agency and
requires the services of an appraiser.7 A
real estate-related financial transaction
is defined as any transaction that
involves: (i) The sale, lease, purchase,
investment in or exchange of real
property, including interests in
property, or financing thereof; (ii) the
refinancing of real property or interests
in real property; and (iii) the use of real
property or interests in real property as
security for a loan or investment,
including mortgage-backed securities.8
The agencies have authority to
determine those real estate-related
financial transactions that do not
require the services of a certified or
licensed appraiser and are therefore
exempt from the appraisal requirements
of Title XI
in real property; and (iii) the use of real
property or interests in real property as
security for a loan or investment,
including mortgage-backed securities.8
The agencies have authority to
determine those real estate-related
financial transactions that do not
require the services of a certified or
licensed appraiser and are therefore
exempt from the appraisal requirements
of Title XI. These real estate-related
financial transactions are not federally
related transactions under the statutory
or regulatory definitions because they
are not required to have Title XI
appraisals.9
The agencies have exercised this
authority by exempting several
categories of real estate-related financial
transactions from the appraisal
requirements.10 The agencies have
determined that these categories of
transactions do not require appraisals by
state certified or licensed appraisers in
order to protect federal financial and
public policy interests or to satisfy
principles of safe and sound banking.
In 1992, Congress amended Title XI,
expressly authorizing the agencies to
establish a threshold level at or below
which an appraisal by a state certified
or licensed appraiser is not required in
connection with federally related
transactions if the agencies determine in
writing that the threshold does not
represent a threat to the safety and
soundness of financial institutions.11 In
the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and
Consumer Protection Act (the Dodd-
Frank Act),12 Congress amended the
threshold provision to require
concurrence ‘‘from the Bureau of
Consumer Financial Protection that
such threshold level provides
reasonable protection for consumers
who purchase 1–4 unit single-family
residences.’’ 13 As noted above,
transactions at or below the threshold
level are exempt from the Title XI
appraisal requirements and thus are not
federally related transactions
mended the
threshold provision to require
concurrence ‘‘from the Bureau of
Consumer Financial Protection that
such threshold level provides
reasonable protection for consumers
who purchase 1–4 unit single-family
residences.’’ 13 As noted above,
transactions at or below the threshold
level are exempt from the Title XI
appraisal requirements and thus are not
federally related transactions.
Under the current thresholds, which
were established by rulemaking in
1994,14 all real estate-related financial
transactions with a transaction value 15
of $250,000 or less, as well as certain
real estate-secured business loans
(qualifying business loans) with a
transaction value of $1 million or less,
do not require appraisals.16 Qualifying
business loans are business loans that
are real estate-related financial
transactions and that are not dependent
on the sale of, or rental income derived
from, real estate as the primary source
of repayment.17
For real estate-related financial
transactions that are exempt from the
appraisal requirement because they are
within the applicable thresholds or
qualify for the exemption for certain
existing extensions of credit,18 the
VerDate Sep<11>2014
16:29 Jul 28, 2017
Jkt 241001
PO 00000
Frm 00013
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
E:\FR\FM\31JYP1.SGM
31JYP1
sradovich on DSKBCFCHB2PROD with PROPOSALS

35481
Federal Register / Vol. 82, No. 145 / Monday, July 31, 2017 / Proposed Rules
19 See OCC: 12 CFR 34.43(b); Board: 12 CFR
225.63(b); FDIC: 12 CFR 323.3(b).
20 75 FR 77450 (Dec. 10, 2010). See also
Interagency Advisory on the Use of Evaluations in
Real Estate-Related Financial Transactions, OCC
Bulletin 2016–8 (March 4, 2016); Board SR Letter
16–5 (March 4, 2016); Supervisory Expectations for
Evaluations, FDIC FIL–16–2016 (March 4, 2016).
21 Public Law 104–208, Div. A, Title II, sec. 2222,
110 Stat. 3009–414, (1996) (codified at 12 U.S.C.
3311)
0 75 FR 77450 (Dec. 10, 2010). See also
Interagency Advisory on the Use of Evaluations in
Real Estate-Related Financial Transactions, OCC
Bulletin 2016–8 (March 4, 2016); Board SR Letter
16–5 (March 4, 2016); Supervisory Expectations for
Evaluations, FDIC FIL–16–2016 (March 4, 2016).
21 Public Law 104–208, Div. A, Title II, sec. 2222,
110 Stat. 3009–414, (1996) (codified at 12 U.S.C.
3311). The FFIEC is an interagency body comprised
of the Board, OCC, FDIC, NCUA, Bureau of
Consumer Financial Protection (CFPB) and State
Liaison Committee. Of these, only the Board, OCC
and FDIC are statutorily required to undertake the
EGRPRA review. The FFIEC does not issue
regulations that impose burden on financial
institutions and therefore its regulations were not
included in the EGRPRA review. The NCUA is not
required to participate in the EGRPRA review, but
elected to review its regulations pursuant to the
goals of EGRPRA, as it did during the agencies’ first
EGRPRA review 10 years ago. Accordingly, the
NCUA participated in the recent EGRPRA review
process with the Board, OCC and FDIC. The results
of the NCUA’s review are included in Part II of the
EGRPRA Report, described below. The CFPB is
required to review its significant rules and publish
a report of its review no later than five years after
the rules takes effect. See 12 U.S.C. 5512(d).
22 Earlier this year, the agencies and the NCUA
issued an advisory on appraiser availability that
points to alternatives that may help in areas facing
a shortage of appraisers. Interagency Advisory on
the Availability of Appraisers. See OCC Bulletin
2017–19 (May 31, 2017); Board SR Letter 17–4 (May
31, 2017); FDIC FIL–19–2017 (May 31, 2017).
23 FFIEC, Joint Report to Congress: Economic
Growth and Regulatory Paperwork Reduction Act,
(March 2017), (EGRPRA Report), available at
https://www.ffiec.gov/pdf/2017_FFIEC_EGRPRA_
Joint-Report_to_Congress.pdf
e of appraisers. Interagency Advisory on
the Availability of Appraisers. See OCC Bulletin
2017–19 (May 31, 2017); Board SR Letter 17–4 (May
31, 2017); FDIC FIL–19–2017 (May 31, 2017).
23 FFIEC, Joint Report to Congress: Economic
Growth and Regulatory Paperwork Reduction Act,
(March 2017), (EGRPRA Report), available at
https://www.ffiec.gov/pdf/2017_FFIEC_EGRPRA_
Joint-Report_to_Congress.pdf.
24 The $250,000 threshold in the current Title XI
appraisal regulations applies, by its terms, to all real
estate-related financial transactions, whether or not
the borrower is a consumer.
25 Other Federal Government agencies involved
in the residential mortgage market include the U.S.
Department of Housing and Urban Development
(HUD), the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs, and
the Rural Housing Service of the U.S. Department
of Agriculture. These agencies, along with the GSEs
(which are regulated by the Federal Housing
Finance Agency (FHFA)), have the authority to set
separate appraisal requirements for loans they
originate, acquire, or guarantee, and generally
require an appraisal by a certified or licensed
appraiser for residential mortgages regardless of the
loan amount.
26 See FFIEC, Home Mortgage Disclosure Act,
www.ffiec.gov/hmda/.
27 The agencies posited in the 1994 amendments
to the Title XI appraisal regulations that the timing
of the appraisal may provide limited consumer
protection. Changes to consumer protection
regulations since 1994 now ensure that a consumer
receives a copy of appraisals and other valuations
used by a creditor to make a credit decision at least
three business days before consummation of the
transaction (for closed-end credit) or account
opening (for open-end credit). See 12 CFR 1002.14
(for business or consumer credit secured by a first
lien on a dwelling).
28 15 U.S.C. 1601 et seq.
29 Dodd-Frank Act, Public Law 111–203, Title
XIV, sec. 1473(a), 124 Stat. 2190 (2010), (codified
at 12 U.S.C
itor to make a credit decision at least
three business days before consummation of the
transaction (for closed-end credit) or account
opening (for open-end credit). See 12 CFR 1002.14
(for business or consumer credit secured by a first
lien on a dwelling).
28 15 U.S.C. 1601 et seq.
29 Dodd-Frank Act, Public Law 111–203, Title
XIV, sec. 1473(a), 124 Stat. 2190 (2010), (codified
at 12 U.S.C. 3341(b)), as discussed earlier in this
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION.
30 ‘‘Higher-risk mortgages’’ are certain mortgages
with an annual percentage rate that exceeds the
average prime offer rate by a specified percentage.
See Dodd-Frank Act, Public Law 111–203, Title
XIV, sec. 1471, 124 Stat. 2185 (2010), which added
section 129H to TILA, (codified at 15 U.S.C. 1639h).
Continued
appraisal regulations require financial
institutions to obtain an evaluation of
the real property collateral that is
consistent with safe and sound banking
practices.19 An evaluation should
contain sufficient information and
analysis to support the financial
institution’s decision to engage in the
transaction. However, evaluations need
not be performed in accordance with
USPAP or by certified or licensed
appraisers. The agencies have provided
supervisory guidance for conducting
evaluations in a safe and sound manner
in the Interagency Appraisal and
Evaluation Guidelines (Guidelines).20
B. The EGRPRA Process
In early 2017, the agencies completed
a review of their regulations pursuant to
EGRPRA, which requires that, not less
than once every 10 years, the Federal
Financial Institutions Examination
Council (FFIEC), Board, OCC, and FDIC
conduct a review of their regulations to
identify outdated or otherwise
unnecessary regulatory requirements
imposed on insured depository
institutions (IDIs).21
As part of the EGRPRA review, the
agencies received numerous comments
from bankers, banking trade
associations, associations of appraisers,
and other commenters related to the
Title XI appraisal regulations
Board, OCC, and FDIC
conduct a review of their regulations to
identify outdated or otherwise
unnecessary regulatory requirements
imposed on insured depository
institutions (IDIs).21
As part of the EGRPRA review, the
agencies received numerous comments
from bankers, banking trade
associations, associations of appraisers,
and other commenters related to the
Title XI appraisal regulations. These
comments included recommendations
to increase the thresholds at or below
which real estate-related financial
transactions are exempt from the Title
XI appraisal requirements. Some
commenters noted that the current
thresholds have not been adjusted since
they were established in 1994, even
though property values have increased,
and that the time and cost associated
with the appraisal process impose an
unnecessary burden in the completion
of smaller-dollar amount real estate-
related transactions. Some commenters
also argued that the time and financial
costs attributed to meeting the appraisal
requirements at the current threshold
levels particularly affect banks in rural
markets. These commenters contended
that it is often difficult to find state
certified and licensed appraisers to
complete assignments for properties in
rural areas.22
In March 2017, the agencies
submitted a joint EGRPRA report to
Congress (EGRPRA Report) that
identified potential initiatives to reduce
regulatory burden.23 In the EGRPRA
Report, the agencies addressed
comments received concerning the
appraisal thresholds and stated that the
agencies would propose an increase to
the threshold for commercial real estate
transactions from $250,000 to
$400,000.24 Section II of this
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION invites
comments on this proposed increase
dentified potential initiatives to reduce
regulatory burden.23 In the EGRPRA
Report, the agencies addressed
comments received concerning the
appraisal thresholds and stated that the
agencies would propose an increase to
the threshold for commercial real estate
transactions from $250,000 to
$400,000.24 Section II of this
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION invites
comments on this proposed increase.
The agencies also stated their intention
to gather more information about the
appropriateness of increasing the $1
million threshold for qualifying
business loans, which is being done
through a request for comment in
Section III of the SUPPLEMENTARY
INFORMATION.
In the EGRPRA Report, the agencies
also addressed whether it would be
appropriate to increase the current
$250,000 threshold for transactions
secured by residential real estate. The
agencies determined that it would not
be appropriate to increase the threshold
for this category of transactions at this
time based on three considerations.
First, the agencies observed that any
increase in the threshold for residential
transactions would have a limited
impact on burden, as appraisals would
still be required for the vast majority of
these transactions pursuant to rules of
other federal government agencies and
the government-sponsored enterprises
(GSEs).25 As reflected in the 2015 Home
Mortgage Disclosure Act (HMDA)
data,26 at least 90 percent of residential
mortgage loan originations had loan
amounts at or below the threshold, were
eligible for sale to GSEs, or were insured
by the Federal Housing Administration
or the United States Department of
Veterans Affairs. Those transactions are
not subject to the Title XI appraisal
regulations, but the majority of those
transactions are subject to the appraisal
requirements of other government
agencies or the GSEs. Therefore, raising
the appraisal threshold for residential
transactions in the Title XI appraisal
regulations would have limited impact
on burden
e United States Department of
Veterans Affairs. Those transactions are
not subject to the Title XI appraisal
regulations, but the majority of those
transactions are subject to the appraisal
requirements of other government
agencies or the GSEs. Therefore, raising
the appraisal threshold for residential
transactions in the Title XI appraisal
regulations would have limited impact
on burden.
Second, appraisals can provide
protection to consumers by helping to
assure the residential purchaser that the
value of the property supports the
purchase price and the mortgage
amount.27 The consumer protection role
of appraisals is reflected in amendments
made to Title XI and the Truth in
Lending Act (TILA) 28 through the
Dodd-Frank Act governing the scope of
transactions requiring the services of a
certified or licensed appraiser. These
include the addition of the CFPB to the
group of agencies assigned a role in the
appraisal threshold-setting process for
Title XI,29 and a new TILA provision
requiring appraisals for loans involving
‘‘higher-risk mortgages.’’ 30
VerDate Sep<11>2014
16:29 Jul 28, 2017
Jkt 241001
PO 00000
Frm 00014
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
E:\FR\FM\31JYP1.SGM
31JYP1
sradovich on DSKBCFCHB2PROD with PROPOSALS

35482
Federal Register / Vol. 82, No. 145 / Monday, July 31, 2017 / Proposed Rules
See also Appraisals for Higher-Priced Mortgage
Loans, 78 FR 78520 (December 26, 2013)
(interagency rule implementing appraisal
requirements for higher-priced mortgage loans).
31 The agencies have coordinated with the NCUA
in developing this proposal. The agencies
understand that the NCUA is evaluating options to
develop a separate proposal to provide comparable
relief for federally insured credit unions.
32 The Riegle Community Development and
Regulatory Improvement Act of 1994, Public Law
103–325, 108 Stat
aisal
requirements for higher-priced mortgage loans).
31 The agencies have coordinated with the NCUA
in developing this proposal. The agencies
understand that the NCUA is evaluating options to
develop a separate proposal to provide comparable
relief for federally insured credit unions.
32 The Riegle Community Development and
Regulatory Improvement Act of 1994, Public Law
103–325, 108 Stat. 2163 (Riegle Act) provides that
rules imposing additional reporting, disclosures, or
other new requirements on IDIs generally must take
effect on the first day of a calendar quarter that
begins on or after the date on which the regulations
are published in final form. 12 U.S.C. 4802(b). As
discussed further in the Section IV of the
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION, the proposed rule
does not impose any new requirements on IDIs,
and, as such, the effective date requirement of the
Riegle Act is inapplicable. Additionally, the 30-day
delayed effective date required under the
Administrative Procedure Act (APA) is waived
pursuant to 5 U.S.C. 553(d)(1), which provides a
waiver when a substantive rule grants or recognizes
an exception or relieves a restriction. The proposed
rule would exempt certain transactions from the
Title XI appraisal requirements. Consequently, the
proposed rule meets the requirements for waiver set
forth in the APA.
33 A 1-to-4 family residential property is a
property containing one, two, three, or four
individual dwelling units, including manufactured
homes permanently affixed to the underlying land
(when deemed to be real property under state law).
See OCC: 12 CFR part 34, subpart D, appendix A;
Board: 12 CFR part 208, appendix C; FDIC: 12 CFR
part 365, subpart A, appendix A.
34 The second part of the definition is intended
to clarify, not be an exception to, the first part.
35 ‘‘Initial construction’’ refers to construction of
a new dwelling, as opposed to improvements on an
existing dwelling
ed to be real property under state law).
See OCC: 12 CFR part 34, subpart D, appendix A;
Board: 12 CFR part 208, appendix C; FDIC: 12 CFR
part 365, subpart A, appendix A.
34 The second part of the definition is intended
to clarify, not be an exception to, the first part.
35 ‘‘Initial construction’’ refers to construction of
a new dwelling, as opposed to improvements on an
existing dwelling. This is intended to be consistent
with the meaning of this phrase in provisions of
TILA and its implementing regulation, Regulation
Z. See, e.g., 15 U.S.C. 1602(x); 12 CFR 1026.2(a)(24).
36 The agencies propose to exclude consumer
‘‘construction-to-permanent’’ loans because these
loans are, in effect, for the purchase of 1-to-4 family
residential property, which would otherwise be
subject to the $250,000 threshold. This carve-out for
construction-to-permanent financing would avoid
the anomaly of requiring appraisals for permanent
financing of 1-to-4 family residential properties
above $250,000 while allowing an evaluation for
permanent financing (at or below $400,000) that is
preceded by a construction phrase.
37 See https://www.ffiec.gov/pdf/FFIEC_forms/
FFIEC031_201703_f.pdf.
During the EGRPRA process, the staff
of the agencies conferred with the CFPB
regarding comments the agencies
received supporting an increase in the
threshold for 1-to-4 family residential
transactions. CFPB staff shared the view
that appraisals can provide consumer
protection benefits and their concern
about potential risks to consumers
resulting from an expansion of the
number of residential mortgage
transactions that would be exempt from
the Title XI appraisal requirement.
Third, the agencies considered safety
and soundness concerns that could
result from a threshold increase for
residential transactions. As the EGRPRA
Report noted, the 2008 financial crisis
showed that, like other asset classes,
imprudent residential mortgage lending
can pose significant risks to financial
institutions
sactions that would be exempt from
the Title XI appraisal requirement.
Third, the agencies considered safety
and soundness concerns that could
result from a threshold increase for
residential transactions. As the EGRPRA
Report noted, the 2008 financial crisis
showed that, like other asset classes,
imprudent residential mortgage lending
can pose significant risks to financial
institutions.
For these reasons, the agencies
concluded in the EGRPRA Report that a
change to the current $250,000
threshold for residential mortgage loans
would not be appropriate at the present
time. The agencies are interested in
comment on whether there are other
factors that should be considered in
evaluating the current threshold for 1-
to-4 family residential transactions and
whether the threshold can and should
be raised, consistent with consumer
protection, safety and soundness, and
reduction of unnecessary regulatory
burden. The agencies will also continue
to consider possibilities for relieving
burden related to appraisals for
residential mortgage loans, such as
coordination of the agencies’ Title XI
appraisal regulations with the practices
of HUD, the GSEs, and other federal
participants in the residential real estate
market.
II. Revisions to the Title XI Appraisal
Regulations
A. Threshold Increase for Commercial
Real Estate Transactions
Overview of Proposal
The agencies propose to amend the
Title XI appraisal regulations to increase
the monetary threshold for commercial
real estate transactions at or below
which a Title XI appraisal would not be
required.31 The proposal would
establish a separate threshold for
commercial real estate transactions of
$400,000, which represents an increase
from the current threshold of $250,000
for all real estate-related financial
transactions
itle XI appraisal regulations to increase
the monetary threshold for commercial
real estate transactions at or below
which a Title XI appraisal would not be
required.31 The proposal would
establish a separate threshold for
commercial real estate transactions of
$400,000, which represents an increase
from the current threshold of $250,000
for all real estate-related financial
transactions.
In considering whether to propose an
increased threshold for commercial real
estate transactions, the agencies
considered the comments received
through the EGRPRA process, and took
into account whether changes to the
threshold would be appropriate to
reduce regulatory burden consistent
with the federal financial and public
policy interests in real estate-related
financial transactions and the safety and
soundness of regulated institutions.
As stated, the threshold for exempt
transactions was last modified in 1994.
Given increases in commercial property
values since that time, the current
threshold requires institutions to obtain
Title XI appraisals on a larger
proportion of commercial real estate
transactions than in 1994. This increase
in the number of appraisals required
may contribute to the increased burden
in time and cost described by the
EGRPRA commenters.
Based on supervisory experience and
available data, the agencies propose to
increase the threshold for commercial
real estate transactions, as defined
below, to $400,000. This proposal
would reduce burden for both rural and
non-rural institutions and, as discussed
below, would not pose a threat to the
safety and soundness of financial
institutions. The agencies are consulting
with the CFPB regarding this proposal
and will continue this consultation in
developing a final rule.
The agencies propose to make the
proposal, if adopted, effective on
publication of the final rule in the
Federal Register.32
Question 1
-rural institutions and, as discussed
below, would not pose a threat to the
safety and soundness of financial
institutions. The agencies are consulting
with the CFPB regarding this proposal
and will continue this consultation in
developing a final rule.
The agencies propose to make the
proposal, if adopted, effective on
publication of the final rule in the
Federal Register.32
Question 1. The agencies invite
comment on the proposed effective date,
including whether this time period is
appropriate and, if not, why.
Definition of Commercial Real Estate
Transaction
The proposed $400,000 threshold
would apply only to transactions
defined as ‘‘commercial real estate
transactions.’’ Under the proposed
definition, a commercial real estate
transaction would include any ‘‘real
estate-related financial transaction,’’ as
defined in the Title XI appraisal
regulations, excluding any loans
secured by a 1-to-4 family residential
property,33 but including loans that
finance the construction of buildings
with 1-to-4 dwelling units and that do
not include permanent financing.34
Accordingly, the definition would
include a loan extended to a consumer
to finance the initial construction 35 of
the consumer’s dwelling, but exclude
loans that provide both initial
construction funding and permanent
financing.36
The proposed definition would
largely capture the following four
categories of loans secured by real estate
in the Consolidated Reports of
Condition and Income (Call Report) 37
(FFIEC 031; RCFD 1410), namely loans
that are: (1) For construction, land
development, and other land loans; (2)
secured by farmland; (3) secured by
residential properties with five or more
units; or (4) secured by nonfarm
nonresidential properties. However,
loans that provide both initial
construction funding and permanent
financing and are reported as
construction, land development, and
other land loans during the construction
phase would be excluded from the
definition
and other land loans; (2)
secured by farmland; (3) secured by
residential properties with five or more
units; or (4) secured by nonfarm
nonresidential properties. However,
loans that provide both initial
construction funding and permanent
financing and are reported as
construction, land development, and
other land loans during the construction
phase would be excluded from the
definition.
The definition generally aligns with
the categories of transactions to which
VerDate Sep<11>2014
16:29 Jul 28, 2017
Jkt 241001
PO 00000
Frm 00015
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
E:\FR\FM\31JYP1.SGM
31JYP1
sradovich on DSKBCFCHB2PROD with PROPOSALS

35483
Federal Register / Vol. 82, No. 145 / Monday, July 31, 2017 / Proposed Rules
38 Real Estate Lending: Interagency Statement on
Prudent Risk Management for Commercial Real
Estate Lending, OCC Bulletin 2015–51 (December
18, 2015); Statement on Prudent Risk Management
for Commercial Real Estate Lending, Board SR
Letter 15–17 (December 18, 2015); Statement on
Prudent Risk Management for CRE Lending, FDIC
FIL–62–2015 (December 18, 2015); Guidance on
Prudent Loan Workouts, OCC Bulletin 2009–32
(October 30, 2009); Policy Statement on Prudent
Commercial Real Estate Loan Workouts, Board SR
Letter 09–07 (October 30, 2009); Policy Statement
on Prudent Commercial Real Estate Loan Workouts,
FDIC FIL–61–2009 (October 30, 2009);
Concentrations in Commercial Real Estate Lending,
Sound Risk Management Practices, 71 FR 74580
(December 12, 2006)
n
Prudent Loan Workouts, OCC Bulletin 2009–32
(October 30, 2009); Policy Statement on Prudent
Commercial Real Estate Loan Workouts, Board SR
Letter 09–07 (October 30, 2009); Policy Statement
on Prudent Commercial Real Estate Loan Workouts,
FDIC FIL–61–2009 (October 30, 2009);
Concentrations in Commercial Real Estate Lending,
Sound Risk Management Practices, 71 FR 74580
(December 12, 2006).
39 78 FR 10368 (February 13, 2013) (exempting
transactions to finance the initial construction of a
dwelling from the higher-priced mortgage appraisal
rule); 78 FR 4725 (January 22, 2013) (exempting
transactions to finance the initial construction of a
dwelling from the higher-priced mortgage escrow
requirements); 78 FR 6408 (January 30, 2013)
(exempting transactions to finance the initial
construction of a dwelling from the ability-to-repay
requirements); 78 FR 6856 (January 31, 2013)
(exempting transactions to finance the initial
construction of a dwelling from the high-cost
mortgage loan term restrictions and disclosure
requirements in the Home Ownership and Equity
Protections Act); 76 FR 79772 (December 22, 2011)
(exempting loans with maturity of 12 months or less
for the construction primary dwelling from the
balloon payment limitations).
40 See OCC: 12 CFR 34.43(d); Board: 12 CFR
225.63(d)(2); FDIC: 12 CFR 323.3(d)(2). The
agencies have long subjected such loans to this
requirement, as opposed to permitting licensed
appraisers, which is the case for typical 1-to-4
family residential properties.
41 See series RCFD F158 and F159.
42 The Board publishes data on the flow of funds
and levels of financial assets and liabilities, by
sector and financial instrument; full balance sheets,
including net worth, for households and nonprofit
organizations, nonfinancial corporate businesses,
and nonfinancial noncorporate businesses;
Integrated Macroeconomic Accounts; and
additional supplemental detail
series RCFD F158 and F159.
42 The Board publishes data on the flow of funds
and levels of financial assets and liabilities, by
sector and financial instrument; full balance sheets,
including net worth, for households and nonprofit
organizations, nonfinancial corporate businesses,
and nonfinancial noncorporate businesses;
Integrated Macroeconomic Accounts; and
additional supplemental detail. See, Board of
Governors of the Federal Reserve System, Financial
Accounts of the United States, https://
www.federalreserve.gov/releases/z1/current/
default.htm.
43 The CRE Index is quarterly and not seasonally
adjusted. See Board of Governors of the Federal
Reserve System, Series analyzer for
FL075035503.Q, https://www.federalreserve.gov/
apps/fof/SeriesAnalyzer
.aspx?s=FL075035503&t=&bc=:FI075035503,
FL075035503&suf=Q; Board of Governors of the
Federal Reserve System, Series Structure, https://
www.federalreserve.gov/apps/fof/
SeriesStructure.aspx.
44 Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve
System, Series analyzer for FL075035503.Q, https://
www.federalreserve.gov/apps/fof/SeriesAnalyzer
.aspx?s=FL075035503&t=&bc=:FI075035503,
FL075035503&suf=Q. Data for years prior to 1996
are comprised of a weighted average of three
appraisal-based commercial property series from
National Real Estate Investor. Id.
45 CoStar, Federal Reserve’s Flow of Funds to
Incorporate CoStar Group’s Price Indices, CoStar
(June 4, 2012), http://www.costar.com/News/
Article/Federal-Reserves-Flow-of-Funds-To-
Incorporate-CoStar-Groups-Price-Indices/138998.
46 See id.
agency guidance on commercial real
estate lending applies.38 The agencies
are treating construction-only loans to
consumers as commercial real estate
transactions to maintain consistency
with other regulations and guidance that
address construction loans to consumers
in other contexts
/
Article/Federal-Reserves-Flow-of-Funds-To-
Incorporate-CoStar-Groups-Price-Indices/138998.
46 See id.
agency guidance on commercial real
estate lending applies.38 The agencies
are treating construction-only loans to
consumers as commercial real estate
transactions to maintain consistency
with other regulations and guidance that
address construction loans to consumers
in other contexts.
Supervisory experience indicates that
financial institutions generally
administer construction loans to
consumers in a way similar to
construction loans to businesses.
Therefore, subjecting most construction
loans to the same threshold would
minimize regulatory burden. This
treatment would also be consistent with
other mortgage-related rules, which
exempt consumer construction loans
from various consumer protection
requirements.39 The agencies believe
that promoting consistency in
definitions and structure across
different regulations can reduce
confusion and regulatory burden for
financial institutions.
Moreover, including all 1-to-4 family
residential construction-only loans in
the proposed definition of commercial
real estate transactions is consistent
with the agencies’ longstanding practice
under the Title XI appraisal regulations
of treating construction loans for 1-to-4
family residential properties as
‘‘nonresidential’’ for purposes of the
requirement that certified appraisers be
used for ‘‘nonresidential’’ federally
related transactions.40
As discussed further below, financial
institutions report information about
consumer construction loans aggregated
with other construction loans through
the Call Report.41 Thus, much of the
supervisory information that the
agencies receive, including the basis for
the analysis presented below, aggregates
consumer construction loans with other
construction loans secured by 1-to-4
residential properties.
Question 2. The agencies invite
comment on the proposed definition of
commercial real estate transaction.
Question 3
ction loans through
the Call Report.41 Thus, much of the
supervisory information that the
agencies receive, including the basis for
the analysis presented below, aggregates
consumer construction loans with other
construction loans secured by 1-to-4
residential properties.
Question 2. The agencies invite
comment on the proposed definition of
commercial real estate transaction.
Question 3. The proposed definition
of commercial real estate transaction
would include loans to consumers for
the initial construction of their dwelling
or transactions financing the
construction of any building with 1-to-
4 dwelling units, so long as the loan
does not include permanent financing,
with the effect of permitting these loans
to qualify for the higher $400,000
threshold. The agencies invite comment
on the consumer, regulatory burden,
and other implications of the proposal.
What would be the implications of not
including these loans in the definition,
which would leave the current $250,000
threshold in place?
Question 4. The agencies invite
comment on the consumer, regulatory
burden, and other implications of the
proposed exclusion of construction-to-
permanent loans from the definition of
commercial real estate transaction,
meaning that the current $250,000
threshold would apply. What would be
the implications of including
construction-to-permanent loans in the
definition of commercial real estate
transaction, thus allowing these loans to
qualify for the higher $400,000
threshold?
Threshold Increase
The agencies propose to increase the
threshold in the Title XI appraisal
regulations for commercial real estate
transactions from $250,000 to $400,000.
In determining the level of increase, the
agencies considered the change in
prices for commercial real estate
measured by the Federal Reserve
Commercial Real Estate Price Index
(‘‘CRE Index’’)
gher $400,000
threshold?
Threshold Increase
The agencies propose to increase the
threshold in the Title XI appraisal
regulations for commercial real estate
transactions from $250,000 to $400,000.
In determining the level of increase, the
agencies considered the change in
prices for commercial real estate
measured by the Federal Reserve
Commercial Real Estate Price Index
(‘‘CRE Index’’). The CRE Index 42 is a
direct measure of the changes in
commercial real estate prices in the
United States.43 The CRE Index is
comprised of data from the CoStar
Commercial Repeat Sale Index,44 which
uses repeat sale regression analysis of
1.7 million commercial property sales
records to compare the change in price
for the same property between its most
recent and previous sale transactions.45
The data incorporated into this index
covers properties across the country and
across all price ranges,46 from before
1994 through the present.
Based on a review of the CRE Index,
prices for commercial real estate have
increased since 1994, resulting in an
increased proportion of commercial real
estate transactions exceeding the
threshold level today compared to 1994.
Based on the change in the CRE Index,
a commercial property that sold for
$250,000 as of June 30, 1994 would be
expected to sell for approximately
$830,000 as of December 2016.
However, as shown below in Table 1,
the price of commercial real estate can
be particularly volatile. For example,
the CRE Index indicates a commercial
property that sold for $250,000 in 1994
would be expected to sell for
approximately $412,000 in December
2003, $711,000 in December 2007, and
$423,000 in March 2010, when
commercial real estate prices were at
their lowest point in the most recent
downturn.
In proposing to raise the commercial
real estate threshold to $400,000 the
agencies are approximating prices at the
low point of the most recent cycle,
which occurred in 2010
uld be expected to sell for
approximately $412,000 in December
2003, $711,000 in December 2007, and
$423,000 in March 2010, when
commercial real estate prices were at
their lowest point in the most recent
downturn.
In proposing to raise the commercial
real estate threshold to $400,000 the
agencies are approximating prices at the
low point of the most recent cycle,
which occurred in 2010. This more
conservative approach is appropriate
because it takes into consideration the
VerDate Sep<11>2014
16:29 Jul 28, 2017
Jkt 241001
PO 00000
Frm 00016
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
E:\FR\FM\31JYP1.SGM
31JYP1
sradovich on DSKBCFCHB2PROD with PROPOSALS

35484
Federal Register / Vol. 82, No. 145 / Monday, July 31, 2017 / Proposed Rules
47 The CPI, which is published by the Bureau of
Labor Statistics (BLS), is a measure of the average
change over time in the prices paid by urban
consumers for a market basket of goods and
services. This series is published monthly and is
not seasonally adjusted. See U.S. Dept. of Labor
Statistics, Consumer Price Index, https://
www.bls.gov/cpi/.
48 The PCE, which is published by the Bureau of
Economic Analysis within the U.S. Department of
Commerce, is the broadest measure of the average
change over time of the price of consumer goods
and services. This series is published monthly and
is seasonally adjusted. See U.S. Department of
Commerce, Bureau of Economic Analysis,
Consumer Spending, https://www.bea.gov/national/
consumer_spending.htm; Federal Reserve Bank of
San Francisco, PCE Inflation Dispersion, http://
www.frbsf.org/economic-research/indicators-data/
pce-personal-consumption-expenditure-price-
index-pcepi/.
49 12 U.S.C. 3341(b)
is series is published monthly and
is seasonally adjusted. See U.S. Department of
Commerce, Bureau of Economic Analysis,
Consumer Spending, https://www.bea.gov/national/
consumer_spending.htm; Federal Reserve Bank of
San Francisco, PCE Inflation Dispersion, http://
www.frbsf.org/economic-research/indicators-data/
pce-personal-consumption-expenditure-price-
index-pcepi/.
49 12 U.S.C. 3341(b).
50 See, e.g., FDIC, History of the Eighties—Lessons
for the Future, Chapter 3: Commercial Real Estate
and the Banking Crises of the 1980s and Early
1990s, available at https://www.fdic.gov/bank/
historical/history/137_165.pdf; FDIC, Office of the
Inspector General, EVAL–13–002, Comprehensive
Study on the Impact of the Failure of Insured
Depository Institutions 50, Table 6 (January 2013),
available at https://www.fdicig.gov/reports13/13-
002EV.pdf.
51 Section 38(k) of the FDI Act, as amended,
provides that if the Deposit Insurance Fund incurs
a ‘‘material loss’’ with respect to an IDI, the
Inspector General of the appropriate regulator
(which for the OCC is the Inspector General of the
Department of the Treasury) shall prepare a report
to that agency, identifying the cause of failure and
reviewing the agency’s supervision of the
institution. 12 U.S.C. 1831o(k).
52 Acquisition, development and construction
refers to transactions that finance construction
projects including land, site development, and
vertical construction. This type of financing is
typically recorded in the land or construction
categories of the Call Report.
53 The agencies have examined data from a
number of different sources to evaluate the impact
of the proposed change in the appraisal threshold
on the safety and soundness of financial
institutions, as no single data source is sufficient
alone to fully analyze the impact.
volatility in actual prices of commercial
real estate over time
the land or construction
categories of the Call Report.
53 The agencies have examined data from a
number of different sources to evaluate the impact
of the proposed change in the appraisal threshold
on the safety and soundness of financial
institutions, as no single data source is sufficient
alone to fully analyze the impact.
volatility in actual prices of commercial
real estate over time.
This figure is also consistent with
general measures of inflation across the
economy since 1994, when the current
threshold of $250,000 was set. The
agencies considered general inflation
indices, including the Consumer Price
Index (CPI) 47 and the Personal
Consumption Expenditures Price Index
(PCE).48 Certain price changes tracked
by these general indices indirectly affect
commercial real estate values. For
example, the change in rents for
multifamily housing affects the value of
underlying properties, and the change
in prices of consumer products affects
the value of retail and warehouse space.
While these indices are not directly
based on changes in commercial real
estate prices, general inflation is a
component of the change in commercial
real estate values.
As indicated in the table below, when
adjusting a $250,000 basket of goods
under the CPI and PCE from 1994
dollars to 2017 dollars and using a
lowest point in the cycle adjustment for
the prices for commercial real estate
under the CRE Index, each of the
indices considered approximately tracks
the $400,000 proposed threshold.
TABLE 1—INFLATION ADJUSTMENTS OF $250,000 AT JUNE 30, 1994, FOR THE CRE INDEX; JULY 1994 FOR THE CPI
INDEX AND JULY 1, 1994, FOR THE PCE INDEX
Index source:
Index series:
Dated adjusted to
Adjusted
amount
CRE Index ..................................
Flow of Funds ................................................
December 2016 .............................................
$830,674
March 2010 ...................................................
, 1994, FOR THE CRE INDEX; JULY 1994 FOR THE CPI
INDEX AND JULY 1, 1994, FOR THE PCE INDEX
Index source:
Index series:
Dated adjusted to
Adjusted
amount
CRE Index ..................................
Flow of Funds ................................................
December 2016 .............................................
$830,674
March 2010 ....................................................
423,659
December 2007 .............................................
711,367
December 2003 .............................................
412,194
CPI ..............................................
All items, US ..................................................
March 2017 ....................................................
401,166
PCE ............................................
All products ....................................................
March 2017 ....................................................
373,706
Question 5. The agencies invite
comment on the proposed level of
$400,000 for the threshold at or below
which regulated institutions would not
be required to obtain appraisals for
commercial real estate transactions.
Question 6. How would having three
threshold levels ($250,000 for all
transactions, $400,000 for commercial
real estate transactions, and $1 million
for qualifying business loans) rather
than two threshold levels applicable to
Title XI appraisals within the appraisal
regulations affect burden to applicable
institutions?
Safety and Soundness Considerations
for Increasing the Threshold for
Commercial Real Estate Transactions
Under Title XI, the agencies may set
a threshold at or below which an
appraisal performed by a state certified
or licensed appraiser is not required if
they determine in writing that such a
threshold level does not pose a threat to
the safety and soundness of financial
institutions.49 Analysis of supervisory
experience and available data indicates
that the proposed threshold level of
$400,000 for commercial real estate
transactions would not pos
w which an
appraisal performed by a state certified
or licensed appraiser is not required if
they determine in writing that such a
threshold level does not pose a threat to
the safety and soundness of financial
institutions.49 Analysis of supervisory
experience and available data indicates
that the proposed threshold level of
$400,000 for commercial real estate
transactions would not pose a threat to
the safety and soundness of financial
institutions.
Many variables, including changing
market conditions and various loan
underwriting practices, may affect an
institution’s loss experience. The
$250,000 threshold has been applicable
to commercial real estate transactions
since 1994. Analysis of supervisory
information concerning losses on
commercial real estate transactions
suggests that faulty valuations of the
underlying real estate collateral have
not been a material cause of losses in
connection with transactions at or
below $250,000. In the last three
decades, the banking industry suffered
two crises in which poorly underwritten
and administered commercial real estate
loans were a key feature in elevated
levels of loan losses and bank failures.50
Supervisory experience and a review of
material loss reviews 51 covering those
decades suggest that larger acquisition,
construction, and development 52
transactions were more likely to be
troublesome due to the lack of
appropriate underwriting and
administration of issues unique to larger
properties, such as longer construction
periods, extended ‘‘lease up’’ periods
(the time required to lease a building
after construction), and the more
complex nature of the construction of
such properties. The agencies have no
evidence that increasing the appraisal
threshold to $400,000 for commercial
real estate transactions would materially
increase the risk of loss on such
transactions
operties, such as longer construction
periods, extended ‘‘lease up’’ periods
(the time required to lease a building
after construction), and the more
complex nature of the construction of
such properties. The agencies have no
evidence that increasing the appraisal
threshold to $400,000 for commercial
real estate transactions would materially
increase the risk of loss on such
transactions.
Coverage of the Threshold
The agencies’ analysis of available
data 53 related to commercial real estate
lending at financial institutions suggests
that an increase in the threshold would
not pose a safety and soundness risk to
financial institutions.
In order to consider the potential
impact of the proposed threshold
VerDate Sep<11>2014
16:29 Jul 28, 2017
Jkt 241001
PO 00000
Frm 00017
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
E:\FR\FM\31JYP1.SGM
31JYP1
sradovich on DSKBCFCHB2PROD with PROPOSALS

35485
Federal Register / Vol. 82, No. 145 / Monday, July 31, 2017 / Proposed Rules
54 The agencies used data reported on Schedule
RC–C and RC–C Part II of the Call Report. Schedule
RC–C includes the dollar volume of all loans
secured by real estate, reported in the five
categories: (1) For construction, land development,
and other land loans (RCFD F158 and F159); (2)
secured by farmland (RCFD 1420); (3) secured by
residential properties with five or more units (RCFD
1460); or (4) secured by nonfarm nonresidential
properties (RCFD F160 and F161); and (5) secured
by residential properties with fewer than five
dwelling units (RCFD 1797, 5367, and 5368). As
discussed earlier in this SUPPLEMENTARY
INFORMATION, the fifth category would not be
included in the definition of commercial real estate
transaction
esidential properties with five or more units (RCFD
1460); or (4) secured by nonfarm nonresidential
properties (RCFD F160 and F161); and (5) secured
by residential properties with fewer than five
dwelling units (RCFD 1797, 5367, and 5368). As
discussed earlier in this SUPPLEMENTARY
INFORMATION, the fifth category would not be
included in the definition of commercial real estate
transaction. Schedule RC–C Part II, Loans to Small
Businesses and Farms, includes the number and
amount currently outstanding in each case reported
in groupings by loan amount of loans secured by
nonfarm, nonresidential real estate (NFNR), with
original amounts of $1,000,000 or less and loans
secured by farmland with original amounts of
$500,000 or less. Institutions do not report
information on the size of land and construction or
multifamily loans. See FFIEC, Consolidated Reports
of Condition and Income for a Bank with Domestic
and Foreign Offices—FFIEC 031, https://
www.ffiec.gov/pdf/FFIEC_forms/FFIEC031_201703_
f.pdf.
55 See FDIC, Bank Financial Reports,
Consolidated Reports of Condition and Income,
https://www.fdic.gov/regulations/resources/call/
index.html. (‘‘Every national bank, state member
bank, insured state nonmember bank, and savings
association (‘institution’) is required to file a Call
Report as of the close of business on the last day
of each calendar quarter, i.e., the report date. The
specific reporting requirements depend upon the
size of the institution, the nature of its activities,
and whether it has any foreign offices.’’).
56 Although farmland is reported by size of loan,
such loans were also excluded from the analysis,
because they comprise a very small percent of
overall commercial real estate transactions and are
unlikely to materially affect the analysis. Moreover,
the majority of farmland loans are considered
qualifying business loans and are eligible for the
higher $1,000,000 threshold
ign offices.’’).
56 Although farmland is reported by size of loan,
such loans were also excluded from the analysis,
because they comprise a very small percent of
overall commercial real estate transactions and are
unlikely to materially affect the analysis. Moreover,
the majority of farmland loans are considered
qualifying business loans and are eligible for the
higher $1,000,000 threshold.
57 The CoStar Comps database is comprised of
sales data involving commercial real estate
properties. The agencies have limited their analysis
to arms-length completed sales, where the price is
provided. The agencies have also limited the
sample to properties that were financed. Owner-
occupied properties and sales of coops and
condominiums were excluded. The sample was also
limited to existing buildings. Land includes only
raw land defined as land held for development or
held for investment.
change on safety and soundness, the
agencies considered how the coverage of
transactions exempted by the threshold
would change, both in terms of number
of transactions and aggregate value. The
agencies considered three different
metrics to estimate the overall coverage
of the existing threshold and the
proposed threshold: The number of
commercial real estate transactions at or
under the threshold as a share of the
number of all commercial real estate
transactions; the dollar volume of
commercial real estate transactions at or
under the threshold as a share of the
total dollar volume of all commercial
real estate transactions; and the dollar
volume of commercial real estate
transactions at or under the threshold
relative to IDIs’ capital and the
allowance for loan and lease losses,
which act as a buffer to absorb losses,
as explained below. The agencies
examined data reported on the Call
Report 54 and data from the CoStar
Comps database to estimate the volume
of commercial real estate transactions
covered by the existing threshold and
increased thresholds
transactions at or under the threshold
relative to IDIs’ capital and the
allowance for loan and lease losses,
which act as a buffer to absorb losses,
as explained below. The agencies
examined data reported on the Call
Report 54 and data from the CoStar
Comps database to estimate the volume
of commercial real estate transactions
covered by the existing threshold and
increased thresholds.
Analysis of Call Report Data
The agencies’ analysis of data
reported on the Call Report suggests that
the threshold for commercial real estate
transactions could be raised without
exceeding the risk that these
transactions posed when the thresholds
were established in 1994.
All FDIC-insured depository
institutions report information about
loans on their balance sheets by
category of loan,55 but because IDIs do
not report on loans in all of the
categories that would be included in the
definition of commercial real estate
transaction by loan size, the agencies
used loans secured by NFNR as a proxy
for commercial real estate transactions
in this analysis.56 Data on NFNR loans
are an effective proxy because the vast
majority of commercial real estate
transactions are in the NFNR category.
NFNR loans should mirror trends across
all categories of commercial real estate
transactions.
IDIs report information on NFNR
loans in the Call Report by three
separate size categories: (1) Loans with
original amounts of $100,000 or less; (2)
loans with original amounts of more
than $100,000, but $250,000 or less; and
rity of commercial real estate
transactions are in the NFNR category.
NFNR loans should mirror trends across
all categories of commercial real estate
transactions.
IDIs report information on NFNR
loans in the Call Report by three
separate size categories: (1) Loans with
original amounts of $100,000 or less; (2)
loans with original amounts of more
than $100,000, but $250,000 or less; and
(3) loans with original amounts of more
than $250,000, but $1,000,000 or less.
They separately report the dollar
amount of all NFNR loans, including
those over $1,000,000. Using this data,
the agencies calculated the dollar
amount of NFNR loans at or under the
current $250,000 threshold as a
percentage of the dollar amount of all
NFNR loans.
According to Call Report data, when
the threshold for real-estate related
financial transactions was raised from
$100,000 to $250,000 in 1994,
approximately 18 percent of the dollar
volume of all NFNR loans reported by
IDIs had original loan amounts of
$250,000 or less. As of the fourth
quarter of 2016, approximately 4
percent of the dollar volume of such
loans had original loan amounts of
$250,000 or less. This analysis suggests
that a larger proportion of commercial
real estate transactions now require
appraisals than when the threshold was
last raised.
In contemplating an increase in the
threshold for commercial real estate
transactions, the agencies also used Call
Report data to consider the transactions
exempted from the appraisal threshold
as a share of equity capital plus the
allowance for loan and lease losses (the
allowance), which is a measure of the
potential concentration risk that these
transactions could pose to the financial
well-being of institutions as a whole. In
1994, NFNR loans with original loan
amounts of $250,000 or less represented
in the aggregate approximately 14
percent of IDIs’ equity capital plus the
allowance
of equity capital plus the
allowance for loan and lease losses (the
allowance), which is a measure of the
potential concentration risk that these
transactions could pose to the financial
well-being of institutions as a whole. In
1994, NFNR loans with original loan
amounts of $250,000 or less represented
in the aggregate approximately 14
percent of IDIs’ equity capital plus the
allowance. By the fourth quarter of
2016, such loans represented only about
3 percent of IDIs’ equity capital plus the
allowance.
To determine whether concentration
risk would be similar for small
institutions, the agencies separately
considered the percentage of NFNR
transactions exempted from the
appraisal threshold as a share of equity
capital plus the allowance for IDIs with
assets of less than $1 billion. This
analysis produced similar results.
Approximately 30 percent of the dollar
volume of all NFNR loans in such
smaller institutions had original loan
amounts of $250,000 or less in 1994. By
the fourth quarter of 2016, however,
only about 11 percent of the dollar
volume of such loans had original loan
amounts of $250,000 or less. In 1994,
the dollar volume of smaller IDIs’ NFNR
loans with original loan amounts of
$250,000 or less represented
approximately 33 percent of equity
capital plus the allowance. These loans
represented only about 18 percent of
IDIs’ equity capital plus the allowance
by the fourth quarter of 2016.
Because IDIs report loans on the Call
Report aggregated into only the three
categories mentioned above (less than
$100,000, $100,000 to $250,000, and
$250,000 to $1,000,000), the agencies
cannot use Call Report data to
determine the precise percentage or
number of transactions that would be
exempted by the proposed $400,000
threshold or the precise impact of a
$400,000 threshold on equity capital
plus the allowance.
Analysis of CoStar Comps Data
As described below, the agencies have
used the CoStar Comps database to
estimate this impact
0,000 to $1,000,000), the agencies
cannot use Call Report data to
determine the precise percentage or
number of transactions that would be
exempted by the proposed $400,000
threshold or the precise impact of a
$400,000 threshold on equity capital
plus the allowance.
Analysis of CoStar Comps Data
As described below, the agencies have
used the CoStar Comps database to
estimate this impact. The CoStar Comps
database 57 provides sales value data on
specific commercial real estate
transactions. While there are some
limitations regarding use of the CoStar
Comps database, as detailed below, the
database contains information on sales
values for individual transactions, so it
can be used to estimate the number and
VerDate Sep<11>2014
16:29 Jul 28, 2017
Jkt 241001
PO 00000
Frm 00018
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
E:\FR\FM\31JYP1.SGM
31JYP1
sradovich on DSKBCFCHB2PROD with PROPOSALS

35486
Federal Register / Vol. 82, No. 145 / Monday, July 31, 2017 / Proposed Rules
58 This same analysis could not be performed
using Call Report data because, as described above,
transactions reported for purposes of the Call
Report are either reported in groupings of large
value ranges or not reported by size at all.
59 The Interagency Guidelines for Real Estate
Lending provides that institutions’ loan-to-value
limits should not exceed 85 percent for loans
secured by improved property and 65 percent for
loans secured by raw land. See OCC: 12 CFR part
34, subpart D, appendix A; Board: 12 CFR part 208,
appendix C; FDIC: 12 CFR part 365, subpart A,
appendix A.
60 For example, the database tends to
underrepresent sales of smaller properties and
transactions in rural markets, and includes
transactions that are not financed by depository
institutions.
61 Net charge-offs are charge-offs minus
recoveries.
62 Net charge-offs represent losses to financial
institutions, which, in the aggregate, can pose a
threat to safety and soundness
A,
appendix A.
60 For example, the database tends to
underrepresent sales of smaller properties and
transactions in rural markets, and includes
transactions that are not financed by depository
institutions.
61 Net charge-offs are charge-offs minus
recoveries.
62 Net charge-offs represent losses to financial
institutions, which, in the aggregate, can pose a
threat to safety and soundness.
63 When a below-threshold transaction also
qualifies for an exemption from the appraisal
requirements for a reason other than being below
one of the thresholds or a qualifying existing
extension of credit, no evaluation is required.
percentage of transactions that would
become exempt under the proposed
threshold change (i.e., those above
$250,000, but less than $400,000).58
The CoStar Comps database contains
data for transactions involving
nonresidential commercial mortgages,
multifamily and land. The CoStar
Comps database is derived from sales
data and reflects the total transaction
amount, as opposed to the loan amount.
For purposes of this analysis, the
agencies included only financed
transactions and assumed a loan-to-
value ratio of 85 percent for
nonresidential and multifamily
commercial mortgages and a loan-to-
value ratio of 65 percent for raw land
transactions 59 to arrive at an estimated
loan amount which would be equivalent
to the ‘‘transaction value’’ under the
Title XI appraisal regulations. While the
CoStar Comps database has some
limitations for the purposes of
evaluating the proposed increase,60 it
provides information that can be used to
estimate the dollar volume and number
of commercial real estate transactions
that would potentially be exempted by
the proposed threshold increase
would be equivalent
to the ‘‘transaction value’’ under the
Title XI appraisal regulations. While the
CoStar Comps database has some
limitations for the purposes of
evaluating the proposed increase,60 it
provides information that can be used to
estimate the dollar volume and number
of commercial real estate transactions
that would potentially be exempted by
the proposed threshold increase.
An analysis of the CoStar Comps
database suggests that increasing the
threshold to $400,000 would
significantly increase the number of
commercial real estate transactions
exempted from the Title XI appraisal
requirements, but the portion of the
total dollar size of commercial real
estate transactions that would remain
exempted by the threshold would be
minimal. The percentage of commercial
properties with loans in the CoStar
Comps database that would be
exempted from the Title XI appraisal
regulations by the threshold would
increase from 17 percent to 28 percent
if the threshold were raised from
$250,000 to $400,000. However, the
total dollar volume of loans for
commercial properties in the CoStar
Comps database would only increase
from 0.7 percent to 1.5 percent.
Exempting an additional 11 percent of
commercial real estate transactions
would provide burden relief as sought
by some of the EGRPRA commenters.
The 0.8 percentage point increase in the
dollar volume of commercial real estate
transactions that the CoStar data
suggests would be exempted from the
appraisal requirements under the
proposed threshold is unlikely to
expose financial institutions to
increased safety and soundness risk.
Analysis of Charge-Off Rates
In addition to assessing changes in the
magnitude of transactions covered by
the appraisal threshold, the agencies
assessed trends in the loss rate
experience of commercial real estate
transactions
ould be exempted from the
appraisal requirements under the
proposed threshold is unlikely to
expose financial institutions to
increased safety and soundness risk.
Analysis of Charge-Off Rates
In addition to assessing changes in the
magnitude of transactions covered by
the appraisal threshold, the agencies
assessed trends in the loss rate
experience of commercial real estate
transactions.
While the agencies do not regularly
collect data on rates of loss for
commercial real estate by the size of
loans, they do collect net charge-off 61
data for commercial real estate loans on
the Call Report. The agencies
considered aggregate net charge-off rates
for commercial real estate loans in
determining whether the threshold
would pose a threat to the safety and
soundness of financial institutions.62
In order to evaluate the impact of
commercial real estate lending on the
safety and soundness of the banking
system generally, the agencies compared
peak net charge-off rates for two
periods: 1991 to 1994 and 2007 to 2012.
These periods represent two distress
cycles when aggregate net charge-offs
rose to their highest levels. The agencies
separately examined charge-off rates on
lending for all commercial real estate
categories covering construction,
multifamily, nonfarm, nonresidential,
and farmland. In order to evaluate
whether commercial real estate lending
may have a disparate impact on the
safety and soundness of IDIs of varying
sizes, the agencies examined peak
charge-off rates on loans for all IDIs, IDIs
under one billion dollars in total assets,
IDIs with total assets between one
billion dollars and ten billion dollars,
and IDIs with total assets of more than
ten billion dollars.
The analysis showed that aggregate
peak net charge-off rates for the most
recent cycle were generally no worse
than those recorded for the prior cycle,
with the exception of construction
loans
r all IDIs, IDIs
under one billion dollars in total assets,
IDIs with total assets between one
billion dollars and ten billion dollars,
and IDIs with total assets of more than
ten billion dollars.
The analysis showed that aggregate
peak net charge-off rates for the most
recent cycle were generally no worse
than those recorded for the prior cycle,
with the exception of construction
loans. Moreover, aggregate commercial
real estate loan loss rates for banks less
than $1 billion (which would
reasonably be expected to have a larger
proportion of small loans, given their
lower legal lending limits due to their
smaller size) were lower than for larger
banks as a group.
This data suggests that the loss
experience associated with commercial
real estate loans for the banking system
as a whole has stayed at a relatively
consistent rate through multiple credit
cycles. Thus, banking system safety and
soundness concerns associated with the
commercial real estate loan loss rates
have not increased. However,
commercial real estate loan charge-off
rates during periods of economic stress
have and will continue to vary across
individual IDIs based on location,
collateral, quality of underwriting and
risk management, and other factors.
Thus commercial real estate loan
concentration risk at individual
institutions remains a focus for the
banking agencies.
Question 7. The agencies invite
comment on the safety and soundness
impact of the proposed $400,000
threshold for commercial real estate
transactions.
Question 8. The agencies invite
comment on the data used in this
analysis, and what alternative sources of
data would be appropriate for this
analysis.
B
ntration risk at individual
institutions remains a focus for the
banking agencies.
Question 7. The agencies invite
comment on the safety and soundness
impact of the proposed $400,000
threshold for commercial real estate
transactions.
Question 8. The agencies invite
comment on the data used in this
analysis, and what alternative sources of
data would be appropriate for this
analysis.
B. Use of Evaluations
The Title XI appraisal regulations
require regulated institutions to obtain
evaluations for three categories of real
estate-related financial transactions that
the agencies have determined do not
require a Title XI appraisal, including
real-estate related financial transactions
at or below the $250,000 threshold and
qualifying business loans at or below
the $1,000,000 threshold. Similarly, the
agencies propose to require that
institutions entering into commercial
real estate transactions at or below the
proposed $400,000 threshold obtain
evaluations that are consistent with safe
and sound banking practices for such
transactions.63
An evaluation provides a general
estimate of the value of real estate, but
is not subject to the same requirements
as a Title XI appraisal. An evaluation
should provide appropriate information
to enable the institution to make a
prudent decision regarding the
transaction. Through the Guidelines, the
agencies have provided guidance to
regulated institutions on their
expectations regarding when and how
evaluations should be used. The
VerDate Sep<11>2014
16:29 Jul 28, 2017
Jkt 241001
PO 00000
Frm 00019
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
E:\FR\FM\31JYP1.SGM
31JYP1
sradovich on DSKBCFCHB2PROD with PROPOSALS
e the institution to make a
prudent decision regarding the
transaction. Through the Guidelines, the
agencies have provided guidance to
regulated institutions on their
expectations regarding when and how
evaluations should be used. The
VerDate Sep<11>2014
16:29 Jul 28, 2017
Jkt 241001
PO 00000
Frm 00019
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
E:\FR\FM\31JYP1.SGM
31JYP1
sradovich on DSKBCFCHB2PROD with PROPOSALS

35487
Federal Register / Vol. 82, No. 145 / Monday, July 31, 2017 / Proposed Rules
64 Guidelines at 75 FR 77461.
65 Interagency Appraisal and Evaluations
Guidelines, 75 FR 77450, at 77458 (December 10,
2010).
66 Interagency Advisory on Use of Evaluations in
Real Estate-Related Financial Transactions, OCC
Bulletin 2016–8 (March 4, 2016); Board SR Letter
16–05 (March 4, 2016); Supervisory Expectations
for Evaluations, FDIC FIL–16–2016 (March 4, 2016).
67 Guidelines at 75 FR 77457–58. See also
Valuation Independence rules in Regulation Z,
which apply to all creditors and cover extensions
of consumer credit that are or will be secured by
a consumer’s principal dwelling: Board: 12 CFR
226.42; CFPB: 12 CFR 1026.42.
68 OCC: 12 CFR 34.43(d); Board: 12 CFR
225.63(d)(2); FDIC: 12 CFR 323.3(d)(2).
Guidelines describe the transactions for
which financial institutions are required
to obtain an evaluation, and recommend
that institutions develop policies and
procedures for identifying when to
obtain appraisals for such transactions
a consumer’s principal dwelling: Board: 12 CFR
226.42; CFPB: 12 CFR 1026.42.
68 OCC: 12 CFR 34.43(d); Board: 12 CFR
225.63(d)(2); FDIC: 12 CFR 323.3(d)(2).
Guidelines describe the transactions for
which financial institutions are required
to obtain an evaluation, and recommend
that institutions develop policies and
procedures for identifying when to
obtain appraisals for such transactions.
Institutions should conduct
evaluations consistent with the
provisions in the Guidelines.64 As
described in the Guidelines, evaluations
should be performed by persons who
are competent and have the relevant
experience and knowledge of the
market, location, and type of real
property being valued.65 Evaluations
may be completed by a bank employee
or by a third party, as explained by the
Interagency Advisory on Use of
Evaluations in Real Estate-Related
Financial Transactions.66 Guidance on
achieving independence in the
collateral valuation program can be
found in the Guidelines, among other
sources.67 The Guidelines state that an
evaluation should provide an estimate
of the property’s market value or
sufficient information and analysis to
support the credit decision. The
Guidelines also describe the minimum
content that an evaluation should
contain.
In evaluating this proposal, the
agencies considered the impact to the
financial system of the proposal, and
specifically the impact to financial
institutions and borrowers of obtaining
evaluations instead of Title XI
appraisals. Based on information from
industry participants, the cost of third-
party evaluations of commercial real
estate generally ranges from $500 to
over $1,500, whereas the cost of
appraisals of such properties generally
ranges from $1,000 to over $3,000
of the proposal, and
specifically the impact to financial
institutions and borrowers of obtaining
evaluations instead of Title XI
appraisals. Based on information from
industry participants, the cost of third-
party evaluations of commercial real
estate generally ranges from $500 to
over $1,500, whereas the cost of
appraisals of such properties generally
ranges from $1,000 to over $3,000.
Commercial real estate transactions with
transaction values above $250,000 but at
or below $400,000 (affected
transactions), are likely to involve
smaller and less complex properties,
and appraisals and evaluations on such
properties would likely be at the lower
end of the cost range. This third-party
pricing information suggests a savings of
several hundred dollars per affected
transaction.
The agencies also considered the costs
in terms of time to obtain and process
appraisals and evaluations. There may
be less delay in finding appropriate
personnel to perform an evaluation than
to perform a Title XI appraisal,
particularly in rural areas. As described
in the Guidelines, financial institutions
should review the property valuation
prior to entering into the transaction.
Financial institutions require less time
to review evaluations than to review
appraisals, because evaluations contain
less detailed information. The agencies
estimate that, on average, the review
process for an appraisal would take
approximately forty minutes and the
review process for an evaluation would
take approximately ten minutes. Thus,
for affected transactions, the proposed
rule would alleviate approximately
thirty minutes of employee time per
transaction, in addition to the reduced
delay and the cost savings of obtaining
an evaluation instead of an appraisal.
In considering the aggregate effect of
this proposal, the agencies considered
the number of affected transactions
on would
take approximately ten minutes. Thus,
for affected transactions, the proposed
rule would alleviate approximately
thirty minutes of employee time per
transaction, in addition to the reduced
delay and the cost savings of obtaining
an evaluation instead of an appraisal.
In considering the aggregate effect of
this proposal, the agencies considered
the number of affected transactions. As
previously discussed, the agencies
estimate that the number of commercial
real estate transactions that would be
exempted by the threshold is expected
to increase by approximately 11 percent
under the proposed rule. Thus, while
the precise number of affected
transactions and the precise cost
reduction per transaction cannot be
determined, the proposed rule is
expected to lead to significant cost
savings for institutions that engage in
commercial real estate lending.
Question 9. The agencies invite
comment on the proposed requirement
that regulated institutions obtain
evaluations for commercial real estate
transactions at or below the $400,000
threshold.
Question 10. What type of additional
guidance, if any, do institutions need to
support the increased use of
evaluations?
Question 11. To what extent does the
use of evaluations reduce burden and
cost over the use of appraisals? To what
extent are evaluations currently done by
in-house staff versus outsourced to
appraisers or other qualified
professionals?
C
low the $400,000
threshold.
Question 10. What type of additional
guidance, if any, do institutions need to
support the increased use of
evaluations?
Question 11. To what extent does the
use of evaluations reduce burden and
cost over the use of appraisals? To what
extent are evaluations currently done by
in-house staff versus outsourced to
appraisers or other qualified
professionals?
C. State Certified Appraiser Required
The current Title XI appraisal
regulations, require that ‘‘[a]ll federally
related transactions having a transaction
value of $250,000 or more, other than
those involving appraisals of 1-to-4
family residential properties, shall
require an appraisal prepared by a State
certified appraiser.’’ 68 In order to make
this paragraph consistent with the other
proposed changes to the appraisal
regulations, the agencies are proposing
a change to its wording to introduce the
$400,000 threshold and use the term
‘‘commercial real estate transaction.’’
The amendment to this provision would
be a technical change that would not
alter any substantive requirement.
III. Appraisal Threshold for Qualifying
Business Loans
As noted above, in the 2017 EGRPRA
Report to Congress, the agencies stated
their intention to gather more
information about the appropriateness
of increasing the $1 million threshold
for qualifying business loans. The
agencies are not proposing an increase
in the business loan threshold at this
time, but the agencies invite comment
on the following questions concerning
the qualifying business loan exemption:
Question 12. The agencies invite
comment and supporting data on the
appropriateness of raising the current
$1,000,000 threshold for qualifying
business loans and the associated
implications for safety and soundness.
Question 13. What unique risks do
institutions associate with qualifying
business loans?
Question 14
e following questions concerning
the qualifying business loan exemption:
Question 12. The agencies invite
comment and supporting data on the
appropriateness of raising the current
$1,000,000 threshold for qualifying
business loans and the associated
implications for safety and soundness.
Question 13. What unique risks do
institutions associate with qualifying
business loans?
Question 14. What percentage of total
real estate lending at financial
institutions, by number of loans and
dollar volume of lending, are qualifying
business loans?
Question 15. What is the average size
of a qualifying business loan at financial
institutions? What are the incidences of
default on qualifying business loans
compared to other commercial real
estate transactions that institutions have
observed over time?
Question 16. The agencies invite
comment on the clarity of the
application of the current threshold for
qualifying business loans, and on any
difficulty that financial institutions have
experienced in interpreting the
limitation on source of repayment.
IV. Request for Comments
The Agencies invite comment on all
aspects of the proposed rulemaking.
Question 17. As discussed earlier, the
agencies have articulated several bases
for declining to propose an increase in
the residential threshold. The agencies
request comment on whether there are
other factors that should be considered
in evaluating the current appraisal
threshold for 1-to-4 family residential
properties.
VerDate Sep<11>2014
16:29 Jul 28, 2017
Jkt 241001
PO 00000
Frm 00020
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
E:\FR\FM\31JYP1.SGM
31JYP1
sradovich on DSKBCFCHB2PROD with PROPOSALS
ing to propose an increase in
the residential threshold. The agencies
request comment on whether there are
other factors that should be considered
in evaluating the current appraisal
threshold for 1-to-4 family residential
properties.
VerDate Sep<11>2014
16:29 Jul 28, 2017
Jkt 241001
PO 00000
Frm 00020
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
E:\FR\FM\31JYP1.SGM
31JYP1
sradovich on DSKBCFCHB2PROD with PROPOSALS

35488
Federal Register / Vol. 82, No. 145 / Monday, July 31, 2017 / Proposed Rules
69 5 U.S.C. 601 et seq.
70 For its RFA analysis, the Board considered all
Board-regulated creditors to which the proposed
rule would apply.
71 U.S. SBA, Table of Small Business Size
Standards Matched to North American Industry
Classification System Codes, available at https://
www.sba.gov/sites/default/files/files/Size_
Standards_Table.pdf.
72 Asset size and annual revenues are calculated
according to SBA regulations. See 13 CFR 121 et
seq.
73 12 U.S.C. 3341(b).
V. Regulatory Analysis
A. Regulatory Flexibility Act
OCC: The Regulatory Flexibility Act
(RFA), 5 U.S.C. 601 et seq., generally
requires that, in connection with a
rulemaking, an agency prepare and
make available for public comment a
regulatory flexibility analysis that
describes the impact of the rule on small
entities. However, the regulatory
flexibility analysis otherwise required
under the RFA is not required if an
agency certifies that the rule will not
have a significant economic impact on
a substantial number of small entities
(defined in regulations promulgated by
the Small Business Administration
(SBA) to include commercial banks and
savings institutions, and trust
companies, with assets of $550 million
or less and $38.5 million or less,
respectively) and publishes its
certification and a brief explanatory
statement in the Federal Register
together with the rule.
The OCC currently supervises
approximately 956 small entities
ations promulgated by
the Small Business Administration
(SBA) to include commercial banks and
savings institutions, and trust
companies, with assets of $550 million
or less and $38.5 million or less,
respectively) and publishes its
certification and a brief explanatory
statement in the Federal Register
together with the rule.
The OCC currently supervises
approximately 956 small entities. Data
currently available to the OCC are not
sufficient to estimate how many OCC-
supervised small entities make CRE
loans in amounts that fall between the
current and proposed thresholds.
Therefore, we cannot estimate how
many small entities may be affected by
the increase threshold. However,
because the proposal does not contain
any new recordkeeping, reporting, or
compliance requirements, the proposal
will not impose costs on any OCC-
supervised institutions. Accordingly,
the OCC certifies that the proposed rule
will not have a significant economic
impact on a substantial number of small
entities.
Board: The RFA,69 requires an agency
either to provide an initial regulatory
flexibility analysis with a proposed rule
or certify that the proposed rule will not
have a significant economic impact on
a substantial number of small entities.
The proposed threshold increase applies
to certain IDIs and non-bank entities
that make loans secured by commercial
real estate.70 The SBA establishes size
standards that define which entities are
small businesses for purposes of the
RFA.71 The size standard to be
considered a small business is: $550
million or less in assets for banks and
other depository institutions; and $38.5
million or less in annual revenues for
the majority of non-bank entities that
are likely to be subject to the proposed
regulation.72 Based on the Board’s
analysis, and for the reasons stated
below, the proposed rule may have a
significant positive economic impact on
a substantial number of small entities
550
million or less in assets for banks and
other depository institutions; and $38.5
million or less in annual revenues for
the majority of non-bank entities that
are likely to be subject to the proposed
regulation.72 Based on the Board’s
analysis, and for the reasons stated
below, the proposed rule may have a
significant positive economic impact on
a substantial number of small entities.
Accordingly, the Board is publishing an
initial regulatory flexibility analysis.
The Board will conduct a final
regulatory flexibility analysis after
consideration of comments received
during the public comment period.
The Board requests public comment
on all aspects of this analysis.
1. Reasons for the Proposed Rule
In response to comments received in
the EGRPRA process, the agencies are
proposing to increase the threshold from
$250,000 to $400,000 at or below which
a Title XI appraisal is not required for
commercial real estate transactions.
Because commercial real estate prices
have increased since 1994, when the
current $250,000 threshold was
established, a smaller percentage of
commercial real estate transactions are
currently exempted from the Title XI
appraisal requirements than when the
threshold was established. This
threshold adjustment is intended to
reduce the regulatory burden associated
with extending credit secured by
commercial real estate in a manner that
is consistent with the safety and
soundness of financial institutions.
2. Statement of Objectives and Legal
Basis
As discussed above, the agencies’
objective in proposing this threshold
increase is to reduce the regulatory
burden associated with extending credit
in a safe and sound manner by reducing
the number of commercial real estate
transactions that are subject to the Title
XI appraisal requirements
the safety and
soundness of financial institutions.
2. Statement of Objectives and Legal
Basis
As discussed above, the agencies’
objective in proposing this threshold
increase is to reduce the regulatory
burden associated with extending credit
in a safe and sound manner by reducing
the number of commercial real estate
transactions that are subject to the Title
XI appraisal requirements.
Title XI explicitly authorizes the
agencies to establish a threshold level at
or below which a Title XI appraisal is
not required if the agencies determine in
writing that the threshold does not
represent a threat to the safety and
soundness of financial institutions and
receive concurrence from the CFPB that
such threshold level provides
reasonable protection for consumers
who purchase 1-to-4 unit single-family
homes.73 Based on available data and
supervisory experience, the agencies
tailored the size and scope of the
proposed threshold increase to ensure
that it would not pose a threat to the
safety and soundness of financial
institutions or erode protections for
consumers who purchase 1-to-4 unit
single-family homes.
The Board’s proposed rule would
apply to state chartered banks that are
members of the Federal Reserve System
(state member banks), as well as bank
holding companies and nonbank
subsidiaries of bank holding companies
that engage in lending. There are
approximately 601 state member banks
and 35 nonbank lenders regulated by
the Board that meet the SBA definition
of small entities and would be subject
to the proposed rule. Data currently
available to the Board do not allow for
a precise estimate of the number of
small entities that would be affected by
the proposed rule because the number
of small entities that will engage in
commercial real estate transactions
within the proposed threshold is
unknown.
3
y
the Board that meet the SBA definition
of small entities and would be subject
to the proposed rule. Data currently
available to the Board do not allow for
a precise estimate of the number of
small entities that would be affected by
the proposed rule because the number
of small entities that will engage in
commercial real estate transactions
within the proposed threshold is
unknown.
3. Projected Reporting, Recordkeeping
and Other Compliance Requirements
The proposed rule would reduce
reporting, recordkeeping, and other
compliance requirements for small
entities. For transactions at or below the
proposed threshold, regulated
institutions would be given the option
to obtain an evaluation of the property
instead of an appraisal. Unlike
appraisals, evaluations may be
performed by a lender’s own employees
and are not required to comply with
USPAP. As discussed in detail in
Section II.B of the SUPPLEMENTARY
INFORMATION, the cost of obtaining
appraisals and evaluations can vary
widely depending on the size and
complexity of the property, the party
performing the valuation, and market
conditions where the property is
located. Additionally, the costs of
obtaining appraisals and evaluations
may be passed on to borrowers. Because
of this variation in cost and practice, it
is not possible to precisely determine
the cost savings that regulated
institutions will experience due to the
decreased cost of obtaining an
evaluation rather than an appraisal.
However, based on information
available to the Board, it is likely that
small entities and borrowers engaging in
commercial real estate transactions
could experience significant cost
reductions.
In addition to costing less to obtain
than appraisals, evaluations also require
less time to review than appraisals
because they contain less detailed
information
ation rather than an appraisal.
However, based on information
available to the Board, it is likely that
small entities and borrowers engaging in
commercial real estate transactions
could experience significant cost
reductions.
In addition to costing less to obtain
than appraisals, evaluations also require
less time to review than appraisals
because they contain less detailed
information. As discussed further in
Section II.B of the SUPPLEMENTARY
VerDate Sep<11>2014
16:29 Jul 28, 2017
Jkt 241001
PO 00000
Frm 00021
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
E:\FR\FM\31JYP1.SGM
31JYP1
sradovich on DSKBCFCHB2PROD with PROPOSALS

35489
Federal Register / Vol. 82, No. 145 / Monday, July 31, 2017 / Proposed Rules
74 5 U.S.C. 601 et seq.
75 13 CFR 121.201 (as amended, effective
December 2, 2014).
76 FDIC-supervised institutions are set forth in 12
U.S.C. 1813(q)(2).
77 FDIC Call Report, March 31, 2017.
78 The proposed definition of ‘‘Commercial Real
Estate Transaction’’ would largely capture the
following four categories of loans secured by real
estate in the Call Report (FFIEC 031; RCFD 1410),
namely loans that are: (1) For construction, land
development, and other land loans; (2) secured by
farmland; (3) secured by residential properties with
five or more units; or (4) secured by nonfarm
nonresidential properties. However, loans that
provide both initial construction funding and
permanent financing and are reported as
construction, land development, and other land
loans during the construction phase would be
excluded from the definition.
79 FDIC Call Report data, March 31, 2017.
80 Multiplying $31.9 billion by 1.53 percent then
dividing the product by an average loan amount of
$325,000 equals 1,504 loans and multiplying $31.9
billion by 4.10 percent then dividing the product
by an average loan amount of $325,000 equals 4,040
loans.
INFORMATION, an appraisal takes
approximately forty minutes to review
and an evaluation takes approximately
ten minutes to review
7.
80 Multiplying $31.9 billion by 1.53 percent then
dividing the product by an average loan amount of
$325,000 equals 1,504 loans and multiplying $31.9
billion by 4.10 percent then dividing the product
by an average loan amount of $325,000 equals 4,040
loans.
INFORMATION, an appraisal takes
approximately forty minutes to review
and an evaluation takes approximately
ten minutes to review. Thus, the
proposed rule would alleviate
approximately thirty minutes of
employee time per affected transaction
for which the lender obtains an
evaluation instead of an appraisal.
As previously discussed, the Board
estimates that the percentage of
commercial real estate transactions that
would be exempted by the threshold is
expected to increase by approximately
11 percent under the proposed rule. The
Board expects this percentage to be
higher for small entities, because a
higher percentage of their loan
portfolios are likely to be made up of
small, below-threshold loans than those
of larger entities. Thus, while the
precise number of transactions that will
be affected and the precise cost
reduction per transaction cannot be
determined, the proposed rule is
expected to have a significant positive
economic impact on small entities that
engage in commercial real estate
lending.
4. Identification of Duplicative,
Overlapping, or Conflicting Federal
Regulations
The Board has not identified any
federal statutes or regulations that
would duplicate, overlap, or conflict
with the proposed revisions.
5. Discussion of Significant Alternatives
The agencies considered additional
burden-reducing measures, such as
increasing the commercial threshold to
a higher dollar amount and increasing
the residential and business loan
thresholds, but have not proposed such
measures at this time for the safety and
soundness and consumer protection
reasons previously discussed
h the proposed revisions.
5. Discussion of Significant Alternatives
The agencies considered additional
burden-reducing measures, such as
increasing the commercial threshold to
a higher dollar amount and increasing
the residential and business loan
thresholds, but have not proposed such
measures at this time for the safety and
soundness and consumer protection
reasons previously discussed. For
transactions exempted from the Title XI
appraisal requirements, the proposed
rule would require regulated
institutions to get an evaluation if they
do not get an appraisal. The agencies
believe this requirement is necessary to
protect the safety and soundness of
financial institutions, which is a legal
prerequisite to the establishment of any
threshold. The Board is not aware of any
other significant alternatives that would
reduce burden on small entities without
sacrificing the safety and soundness of
financial institutions or consumer
protections.
FDIC: The RFA generally requires
that, in connection with a notice of
proposed rulemaking, an agency prepare
and make available for public comment
an initial regulatory flexibility analysis
describing the impact of the proposed
rule on small entities.74 A regulatory
flexibility analysis is not required,
however, if the agency certifies that the
rule will not have a significant
economic impact on a substantial
number of small entities. The SBA has
defined ‘‘small entities’’ to include
banking organizations with total assets
less than or equal to $550 million.75 For
the reasons described below and
pursuant to section 605(b) of the RFA,
the FDIC certifies that the final rule will
not have a significant economic impact
on a substantial number of small
entities
nt
economic impact on a substantial
number of small entities. The SBA has
defined ‘‘small entities’’ to include
banking organizations with total assets
less than or equal to $550 million.75 For
the reasons described below and
pursuant to section 605(b) of the RFA,
the FDIC certifies that the final rule will
not have a significant economic impact
on a substantial number of small
entities.
The FDIC supervises 3,744 depository
institutions,76 of which, 3,028 are
defined as small banking entities by the
terms of the RFA.77 According to the
Call Report, 3,010 small entities
reported holding some volume of real
estate related financial transactions that
meet the proposed rule’s definition of a
commercial real estate transaction.78
Therefore, 3,010 small entities could be
affected by the proposed rule.
The proposed rule will raise the
appraisal threshold for commercial real
estate transactions from $250,000 to
$400,000. Any commercial real estate
transaction with a value in excess of the
$400,000 threshold is required to have
an appraisal by a state licensed or state
certified appraiser. Any commercial real
estate transaction at or below the
$400,000 threshold requires an
evaluation.
To estimate the dollar volume of
commercial real estate transactions the
proposed change could potentially
affect, the FDIC used information on the
dollar volume and number of loans in
the Call Report for small institutions
from two categories of loans included in
the definition of a commercial real
estate transaction. The Call Report data
reflect that 4.55 percent of the dollar
volume of nonfarm, nonresidential
loans secured by real estate has an
original loan amount between $1 and
$250,000, while 11.81 percent have an
original loan amount between $250,000
and $1,000,000
Call Report for small institutions
from two categories of loans included in
the definition of a commercial real
estate transaction. The Call Report data
reflect that 4.55 percent of the dollar
volume of nonfarm, nonresidential
loans secured by real estate has an
original loan amount between $1 and
$250,000, while 11.81 percent have an
original loan amount between $250,000
and $1,000,000. The Call Report data
also reflects that 8.85 percent of the
dollar volume of agricultural loans
secured by farmland has an original
loan amount between $1 and $250,000,
while 7.49 percent have an original loan
amount between $250,000 and
$500,000.79 Assuming that the original
amount of nonfarm, nonresidential
loans secured by real estate and the
original amount of agricultural loans
secured by farmland are normally
distributed, the FDIC estimates that
between 6.08 percent and 12.95 percent
of loan volume is at or below the
$400,000 threshold for these categories,
respectively.
Therefore, raising the appraisal
threshold from $250,000 to $400,000 for
commercial real estate transactions
could affect an estimated 1.53 percent to
4.10 percent of the dollar volume of all
commercial real estate transactions
originated each year. This estimate
assumes that the distribution of loans
for the other loan categories within the
proposed definition of commercial real
estate transactions is similar to those
loans secured by nonfarm,
nonresidential properties or farmland.
The proposed rule is likely to reduce
valuation review costs for covered
institutions. The FDIC estimates that it
takes a loan officer an average of 40
minutes to review an appraisal to ensure
that it meets that standards set forth in
Title XI, bu

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

## Nearby sections

- [FDIC FIL-1-2002 FOREIGN ASSETS CONTROL ACT](https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/statutes/FDIC_FIL02001.md)
- [FDIC FIL-1-2010 Employee Compensation Advance Notice of Proposed Rulemaking](https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/statutes/FDIC_FIL10001.md)
- [FDIC FIL-1-2015 DEPOSITORY INSTITUTION REPORTS](https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/statutes/FDIC_FIL15001.md)
- [FDIC FIL-1-2018 DEPOSITORY INSTITUTION REPORTS](https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/statutes/FDIC_FIL18001.md)
- [FDIC FIL-1-2024 Consolidated Reports of Condition and Income for Fourth Quarter 2023](https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/statutes/FDIC_FIL24001.md)
- [FDIC FIL-2-2019 DEPOSITORY INSTITUTION REPORTS](https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/statutes/FDIC_FIL19002.md)
- [FDIC FIL-2-2020 Consolidated Reports of Condition and Income for Fourth Quarter 2019](https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/statutes/FDIC_FIL20002.md)
- [FDIC FIL-3-2017 Community Banking Conference 2016 Highlights](https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/statutes/FDIC_FIL17003.md)
- [FDIC FIL-4-2015 The FDIC Launches Web Page to Support Marketing of Failing Financial Institutions](https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/statutes/FDIC_FIL15004.md)
- [FDIC FIL-4-2018 Revisions to the Consolidated Reports of Condition and Income (Call Report) for March and June 2018](https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/statutes/FDIC_FIL18004.md)
- [FDIC FIL-4-2019 Banker Webinar: Update on the Standardized Export of Imaged Loan Documents Initiative](https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/statutes/FDIC_FIL19004.md)
- [FDIC FIL-4-2021 Revised Guidelines for Appeals of Material Supervisory Determinations](https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/statutes/FDIC_FIL21004.md)
- [FDIC FIL-4-2023 Guidance to Help Financial Institutions and Facilitate Recovery in Areas of California Affected by Severe Winter Storms, Flooding, Landslides and Mudslides](https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/statutes/FDIC_FIL23004.md)
- [FDIC FIL-4-2025 FDIC Statement of Policy on Bank Merger Transactions](https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/statutes/FDIC_FIL25004.md)

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/statutes/FDIC_FIL17029. Check the current official text before relying on it. Not legal advice.
