# HOOPA INDIAN RESERVATION

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/tribal%3Ahoopa_valley%3A0c4c498b895491c3

## Record

- **Collection:** Tribal code
- **Document type:** Tribal code

## Text

HOOPA INDIAN RESERVATION
TITLE 71 ARSON
CHAPTER ONE- GENERAL PROVISIONS

69.1.01 Legislative Intent
The Hoopa Tribal Council acknowledges that arson fires and negligently set fires with the

reservation boundaries are a threat to public health and safety and cause devastating damage to
tribal and private resources, including but not limited to clean air, clean water, fish and wildlife
habitat, timber resources, forest soils, economic and employment opportunities, range lands,
structures, recreational areas and other improvements.

The purpose of this code is to:

(1) Provide standards by which the court can determine whether a fire that caused damage
within the reservation boundaries was either arson or negligently set; and

(2) Establish a damage formula so that the Tribe or private individuals harmed by arson fires
or negligently set fires may be made whole, and

(3) Establish civil penalties and court ordered consequences to be imposed against
individuals who are found by the court to have started an arson fire or negligently set a
fire which has caused damage within the reservation boundaries.

69.1.02 Annual Operating Plan

The Tribal Council, Tribal Office of Emergency Services, Hoopa Fire Department, Hoopa
Volunteer Fire Department, Tribal Environmental Protection Agency and the Tribal Police
Department shall meet annually no later than April with federal and state law enforcement
personnel to establish an operating plan for how to address and prosecute arson or negligently set
or spread fires within the Hoopa Valley.

Personal Jurisdiction
Arson fires and negligently set fires are such a threat to the health and safety of tribal members,

and tribal resources including trust land, that the Tribal court shall have jurisdiction over anyone
who violates the provisions of this code while within the boundaries of the Hoopa Valley

Reservation.

69.1.03 Definitions
As used in this Chapter, the following terms have the meanings indicated unless the context

clearly requires otherwise.

(a) “Allows” a land owner or assignee allows an individual to commit arson or negligently
start or spread a fire on property if the land owner is present on the property and aware of
the fire being started at the time the fire is started, and has taken no steps to prevent the
starting of the fire.

(b) “Arson” To willfully and maliciously set fire to, or to aid, encourage or request another
set fire to, any structure, vehicle, forested land, or any other real or personal property.

(c) “Burn Permit” means a formal authorization from, or approval by the Hoopa Fire
Department and the Hoopa Valley Tribal Environmental Protection Agency, Air Quality
Department to burn approved materials as defined under Title 49 section 49.3 (K); or
formal authorization from, or approval by the Hoopa Fire Department for a cultural burn.

Page 1 of 8
CHAPTER THREE- ENFORCEMENT MECHANISMS

69.3.01 Citations for Committing Prohibited Acts

Hoopa Tribal Law Enforcement, Hoopa Fire Department Personnel, Hoopa Volunteer Fire
Department Personnel, Hoopa Tribal Office of Emergency Service Personnel or any TEPA
Enforcement Officer shall have the authority to issue an individual a citation when there is
probable cause to believe the individual has committed either arson or has negligently set or
spread a fire within the reservation boundaries. The Tribe shall be the plaintiff in any court case
in which a citation under this code is the initial filing.

69.3.02 Civil Complaints
Any person or entity who has had property damaged by arson or a negligently set fire may file a

civil complaint seeking damages under this code. A civil complaint may be filed even when a
citation has not been issued.

CHAPTER FOUR- COURT PROCESS

69.3.01 Procedure to be Applied

Title 2 of Tribal code contains the court procedure applied in cases filed under this code, except
that the specific provisions contained in this chapter shall also apply. The court may set pretrial
conference hearings or motion hearings to resolve issues before trial, pursuant to the procedural
rules contained in Title 2 of Tribal Code.

69.3.02 Burden of Proof

(a) Citation Cases
In citation case the Tribe shall have the burden of proving beyond a reasonable doubt that the
defendant(s) conunitted arson, or negligently started or spread a fire.

(b) Civil Complaints
In civil complaint cases the plaintiff must prove the defendant(s) committed arson or

negligently set a fire by a preponderance of the evidence.

(c) Arson

in order to prove that arson occurred, the plaintiff must prove the following:
(J) Starting an Arson Fire
(i) The fire was started by human actions; and

(ii) The defendant’s actions started the fire; and
(iii) The defendant’s acted willfully and maliciously when starting the fire; or

(2) Encouraging, Aiding, or requesting Another Start an Arson Fire

(i)The defendant encouraged, aided, or requested another person to start a fire; and
(ii) The person who was encouraged, aided, or requested to start a fire started an arson fire.

Page 3 0f 8
(d) Negligently Set or Spread Fire

In order to prove that a fire was negligently set or spread the plaintiff must prove the following:
(1) The defendant did not use reasonable care; and
(2) As a result of the defendant’s oversight, a fire started or spread

69.3.03 Protective Orders for Witnesses

(a) Issuance of Protective Order

On the court’s own motion, or at the request of a party or a witness, the court may issue a
protective order that limits the other party’s contact with the witness and prohibits threats, harm
or harassment of the witness. The purpose of such an order is to prevent witness intimidation in

these cases.

(b) Effect of Protective Order on Discovery Process

The protective order will not prevent a deposition or other formal discovery process, unless the
person requesting the protective order can show that the deposition or other discovery process
will result in threats being made to the witness, harm being done to the witness, or harassment of
the witness. The court may issue a protective order setting parameters on the discovery to protect
the witness, and shall only issue an order denying formal discovery when it appears no lesser
restrictions will protect a witness from threats, harm or harassment.

69.3.04 Initial Hearing- Citation Cases

At the initial hearing in a citation case, the court shall do the following:

(1) Explain the defendant’s rights, including the right to go to trial if she or he denies the
allegations. The complete list of rights which must be explained is found in section 69.3.05
of this code; and

(2) Explain the reason for the citation, as listed in the citation; and

(3) Explain the consequences if the individual is found to have committed the act for which she
or he was cited; and

(4) Ask the person who has been issued a citation whether or they admit or deny having
committed the act for which they were cited; and

(5) Explain what will happen at the next hearing

69.3.05 Righis of the Cited Individual
A person who has been cited under this code for arson or negligently setting or spreading a fire
has the following rights during his or her court hearings:
(a) The right to not say anything incriminating; and
(b) The right to hire an attorney or spokesperson to represent him or her. The court must explain
that the Tribe will not provide an attorney or spokesperson and
(c) The right to see and hear any evidence which supports the citation. This includes the right to:
(i) a free copy of any report written by law enforcement or TEPA to support the citation;
and
(ii) the right to a pretrial examination of any physical evidence, though the examination must
be supervised by law enforcement, and
(d) The right to cross examine any witnesses who testify against him or her; and

Page 4o0f 8
(e) The right to present evidence in support of his or her defense. This right includes the
opportunity to have witnesses or records subpoenaed; and

(2) The right to ask questions about court procedures if she or he does not understand what is
happening.

CHAPTER FIVE- CONSEQUENCES FOR VIOLATION OF THIS CODE

69.5.01_ Consequences Available Under this Code

(a) Citation Cases
A person who is found to have violated this code in a citation case may be ordered to comply
with any of the consequences available under this code.

(b) Civil Complaints
A person who is found to have violated this code based on a civil complaint shall only be
ordered to pay money damages and shall be subject to the employment prohibitions in
section 69.5.09 as a result of the complaint. The Tribe may file a separate exclusion action
after a person has been found to have committed arson or negligently set or spread a fire.

69.5.02_Criminal Penalties Not Prohibited
The civil penalties imposed under this code do not prevent the state or federal government from
imposing criminal penalties for the same actions which have violated this code.

69.5.03 Right to Criminalize Violations of this Code
The Tribe reserves the right to pass a criminal code which addresses the same actions prohibited
by this code.

69.5.04 Damages
The plaintiff is responsible for proving by a preponderance of the evidence the amount of

damages owed by the defendant.

(a) Property Damage
A person who has been found to have violated this code is shall pay the plaintiff a sum at least

equal to twice the value of the property destroyed, damaged, or injured by the fire.

(b) Repayment of Tribal Costs to Respond to Fire

In addition to the property damages listed under subsection (a), a person who has been found to
have violated this code shall pay the Tribe an amount equal to all the costs incurred by the tribe
to respond to the fire. This includes personnel costs, equipment costs, cosis of water Gf any),
costs associated with evacuation and/or relocation of community members including gas, food
and temporary housing expenses; costs associated with providing air purifiers; and any other
costs that the Tribe proves were directly related to fire response.

(c) Injuries or Death - Persons
In addition to the property damages listed in subsection (a) and (b), any person who has been
found to have violated this code shall pay the following:

(1) Medical expenses for anyone injured or killed by the fire;

(2) Estimated future medical expenses for anyone injured by the fire;

(3) Lost wages for anyone injured or killed by the fire;

Page 5 of 8

(4) Estimated firture lost wages for anyone injured or killed by the fire; and
(5) Pain and suffering for anyone injured or killed by the fire (calculated by multiplying all
other amounts under this subsection by three)

(e) Injuries or Death- Animals & Livestock

In addition to the damages listed in subsections (a)-(c), any person who has been found to have

violated this code shall pay the following to the Plaintiff:

(1) Veterinary bills for any animal or livestock injured or killed in the fire; and

(2) Estimated future veterinary bills for any animals or livestock injured in the fire; and

(3) An amount of at least $500 per family pet or livestock injured or at least $1000 for each
family pet killed.

69.5.06 Fines
Tn addition to any damages ordered under section 69.5.04, a person who has been found to have

violated this code shall be ordered to pay the following fines:

(a) First Offense
(1) Land, no Buildings

@ 1 Offense: less than 1 acre bumed, no buildings: $500
(ii) 1“ Offense, more than 1 acre but less than 5 acres burned: $1000
(ii) 1% Offense, more than 5 acres burned: $2000
(2) Building partially or completely burned (per building) $5000
(b) Additional offenses

The fine amounts under subsection (a) shall be multiplied by the offense number. For
example, fines shall be twice as much for a second offense, three times as much for a third

offense, etc.

69.5.07 Enhancement for Cultural Site or Building Damaged or Destroyed

In addition to any other damages under this chapter, a person who is responsible for a fire that
damages or destroys a cultural site or building shall make amends to the community. A cultural
or dance leader who is the caretaker of the damaged site must consult with any families impacted
by damage to cultural or spiritual sites and, based on the families’ input, may make a
recommendation of consequences to the court. The court is not bound by the recommendation.

The court may, if it believes doing so will assist the community in healing, set a hearing at which
it allows the impacted families to address the court directly with their concerns and
recommendations for consequences of the arson.

69.5.08 Lien on Land

(a) Entry of Lien

If an individual owns fee land within the reservation boundaries, and has been found to have
committed arson or negligently started or spread a fire, the Tribe or an individual who is owed
restitution may place a lien against the judgment debtor’s property in the amount of the money
owed to the Tribe or individual 30 days after the date of the entry of judgment.

Page 6 of 8
(b) Delay of Entry of Lien

The lien process may be delayed, at the request of the judgment debtor, if that individual enters
into, and remains current on, a payment plan that will pay the judgment off in a reasonable time.
If the judgment debtor misses a payment, 30 days after the missed payment the tribe or
individual who is owed money may place a lien against the judgement debtor’s property.

69.5.09 Cancellation or Relinguishment of Land Assignment

(a) Cancellation

If an individual who has a land assignment through the Tribe is found to have violated this
ordinance, or allowed others to do so on their assignment, the court shall order the individual’s
land assignment cancelled if the restitution and fine amounts remain unpaid for more than 30
days after the entry of judgment unless the individual enters into, and remains current on, a
payment plan that will pay the judgment off in a reasonable time. If the judgment debtor misses a
payment, 30 days after the missed payment the court may order the cancellation of the
individual’s land assignment.

(b) Innocent Land Owner Exception

If a landowner was not aware of the presence of the individuals who violated this code, or was in
the process of removing those individuals from the land, or otherwise could not have reasonably
known of the risk of arson or a negligently set fire, the Court shall not cancel the innocent
landowner’s assignment.

(c) Voluntary Relinquishment of Land Assignment

(1) Option of Relinquishment to Offset Judgement

If an individual who has a land assignment through the Tribe is found to have violated this
ordinance, or allowed others to do so on their assignment, the individual may voluntarily
relinquish their assignment and receive an offset in restitution and fines based on the fair market
value of their relinquished interest in the land.

(2) Prohibition on Profiting from Land Relinquished Because of a Violation of this Code

No one convicted under this code, or any landowner who knowingly allowed someone to violate
this code while residing or visiting the assignment, may profit from the relinquishment. If the
value of the landowner’s interest is greater than the fines and restitution owed, the land owner
shall not be paid the difference.

69.5.10 Mandatory Exclusion

(a) Length of Exclusion
Any person who is found by the court to have committed arson shall be excluded from the

reservation for a period of:

(1) not less than 1 year if less than 1 acre burned, no buildings were damaged, and no people or
animals were injured or killed; or

(2) not less than 3 years if a building was damaged but no people or animals were killed; or

(3) not less than 5 years if any people or animals were injured or killed.

Page 7 of 8
(b) Calculation of Excluded Period
The exclusion period shall not start to run until the defendant leaves the reservation, and shail

start over if the defendant re-enters the reservation without the permission of the court before the
exclusion period ends.

(c) Issuance of Exclusion Order
The exclusion order shall issue at the same time as the order finding that the person committed

arson.

69.5.11 Prohibition on Employment

Any person who is found by the court to have committed arson shall be prohibited for life from

working for the Tribe (including contractual work) in any of the following positions:

qd) in any capacity as a responder to fire, or

(2) in any law enforcement capacity, or

(3) in any position where job duties include enforcement of tribal codes; or

(4) as a member of any board, paid or not, that has oversight authority over any tribal
department or entity; or

(5) Chairperson of the Tribe; or

(6) Member of the Tribal Council.

6.5.12 Referral to District Attorney or United States Attorney for Prosecution

The court may refer any violation of this code to either the Humboldt County District Attorney’s
office or the United States Attorney for the Northern District of California for criminal
prosecution. As part of this referral process, the court may order any Tribal office or Department
including but not limited to, Law Enforcement, the Environmental Protection Agency, the Office
of Emergency Services, the Fire or Volunteer Fire Departments, to forward all law enforcement
records related to the investigation to either prosecutor’s office.

CERTIFICATION

I, the undersigned, as Vice-Chairman of the Hoopa Valley Tribal Council do hereby certify that
the Hoopa Valley Tribal Council, composed of eight members; of which eight (8) were present
constituting a quorum at a Regular meeting thereof; duly and regularly called, noticed, and
convened and held this 8" day of August, 2016; and that this Ordinance was adopted by a vote
of seven (7) for, zero (0 ) against, and zero (0) abstaining, and that said Ordinance has not been
rescinded or amended in any way. DATED THIS 8" DAY OF AUGUST, 2016. Hoopa

California

7 oo . .
Vee pe ee OB

Oscar Billings, Vi¢e-Chairman

(\ deth bes Hoopa Valley Tribe
ATTEST:

Judith Surber
Executive Secretary

Page 8 of 8

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/tribal%3Ahoopa_valley%3A0c4c498b895491c3. Public record. Not legal advice.
