# Administrative Leave, Investigative Leave, and Notice Leave

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/fr%3A2024-29139

## Record

- **Collection:** Federal Register
- **Document type:** Rule
- **Published:** December 17, 2024
- **Citation:** 89 FR 102256

## Text

OFFICE OF PERSONNEL MANAGEMENT
5 CFR Parts 630 and 752
RIN 3206-AN59
Administrative Leave, Investigative Leave, and Notice Leave

AGENCY:

Office of Personnel Management.

ACTION:

Final rule.

SUMMARY:

The Office of Personnel Management is issuing a final rule on the acceptable uses and proper recording of administrative leave, investigative leave, and notice leave for covered Federal employees. The Administrative Leave Act of 2016 created these categories of statutorily authorized paid leave and set parameters for their use by Federal agencies. OPM prescribes this final rule to carry out the Act and guide agencies regarding these leave categories.

DATES:

Effective date:
This final rule is effective on January 16, 2025.

Compliance date:
Agencies must issue internal policies consistent with this rule and any applicable collective bargaining obligations no later than September 13, 2025.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:

For matters related to general administrative leave, Bryce Baker by email at
LeavePolicy@opm.gov
or by telephone at (202) 606-2858; for matters related to investigative leave or notice leave, Timothy Curry by email at
employeeaccountability@opm.gov
or by telephone at (202) 606-2930.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

I. Executive Summary

The Office of Personnel Management (OPM) is issuing a final rule regarding the administrative leave, investigative leave, and notice leave provisions of the Administrative Leave Act of 2016.
1

The Act added three new sections in title 5, U.S. Code, that provide for specific categories of paid leave and requirements that apply to each: section 6329a regarding administrative leave; section 6329b regarding investigative leave and notice leave; and section 6329c regarding weather and safety leave.
2

1
Enacted under section 1138 of the National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2017 (Pub. L. 114-328, 130 Stat. 2000, Dec. 23, 2016).

2
In this preamble, references to statutory provisions in title 5, U.S. Code, will generally be referred to by section number without restating the title 5 reference (
e.g.,
section 6329a instead of 5 U.S.C. 6329a). Also, references to regulatory provisions in title 5, Code of Federal Regulations, will generally be referred to by section number without restating the title 5 reference (
e.g.,
§ 630.1401 instead of 5 CFR 630.1401).

The Act charged OPM with prescribing regulations to carry out sections 6329a, 6329b, and 6329c and guide agencies regarding these new leave categories no later than 270 calendar days after the Act's enactment on December 23, 2016,
i.e.,
by September 19, 2017. OPM published proposed regulations for all three sections on July 13, 2017,
3

and issued regulations implementing § 6329c, weather and safety leave, on April 10, 2018.
4

3
82 FR 32263.

4
83 FR 15291.

OPM now prescribes a final rule regarding acceptable uses and proper recording of administrative leave to carry out section 6329a, as well as regulations regarding acceptable uses and proper recording of investigative leave and notice leave, baseline factors agencies must consider regarding investigative leave, and procedures for the approval and the extension of investigative leave to carry out section 6329b.

II. Background

Prior to passage of the Administrative Leave Act, there was no specific statutory authority for the use of administrative leave, which is an excused absence without loss of pay or charge to leave. Agencies granted paid excused absences (which they often called “administrative leave”) to employees based on statutes, like 5 U.S.C. 301-302, that provide heads of agencies broad authority to manage their workforces.

While sections 301-302 do not expressly address excused absence and do not set parameters on its use, some direction on agency discretion to use the excused absence authority was provided in Comptroller General decisions and in past OPM guidance via governmentwide memorandums, handbooks, fact-sheets, and frequently asked questions.
5

In that guidance, OPM provided that the use of administrative leave should be limited to those circumstances in which the employee's absence is not specifically prohibited by law and satisfies one or more of the following criteria: (1) it is directly related to the agency's mission, (2) it is officially sponsored or sanctioned by the agency, (3) it will clearly enhance professional development or skills of the employee in the employee's current position, or (4) it is determined to be in the interest of the agency or of the Government as a whole.

5

See, e.g.,
Off. of Pers. Mgmt., “Fact Sheet: Administrative Leave,” at
https://www.opm.gov/policy-data-oversight/pay-leave/leave-administration/fact-sheets/administrative-leave/.

In drafting the Administrative Leave Act, Congress considered an October 2014 report entitled “Federal Paid Administrative Leave,” prepared by the Government Accountability Office (GAO) at Congress' request.
6

GAO examined the paid administrative leave policies at five selected Federal agencies.
7

It reviewed practices in recording and reporting of paid administrative leave and described categories of purposes for which large amounts of paid administrative leave have been charged. GAO found that agency policies on administrative leave varied and that some employees were on administrative leave for long periods of time. These periods had significant cost implications. GAO found that the “predominant reason” for “large amounts of administrative leave was personnel matters, which was cited as a reason for paid administrative leave at all five of [the] selected agencies.” These personnel matters included “investigations into alleged misconduct, criminal matters, or security concerns as well as settlement agreements, pending adverse actions due to inappropriate behavior, and interim relief.” These matters concluded in a variety of ways, including “removal, retirement, resignation, reinstatement of [the] employee, and settlement agreement[s].” GAO also found variations in agencies' recording and reporting practices with respect to administrative leave and that there was no reliable data on the amount of administrative leave by type of use (
e.g.,
weather and safety reasons, personnel investigation reasons).

6

See
Gov't Accountability Off., “Federal Paid Administrative Leave,” Oct. 2014, at
https://www.gao.gov/assets/gao-15-79.pdf.

7
The five agencies GAO reviewed were the Departments of Defense, the Interior, and Veterans Affairs, the General Services Administration, and the U.S. Agency for International Development.

GAO concluded that “Federal agencies have the discretion to grant paid administrative leave to employees to help manage their workforces when it is in their best interest to do so. This discretion is important in ensuring that employees are not placed in dangerous circumstances, have access to professional development opportunities, and are able to participate in civic activities during work hours,” but that administrative leave should be managed effectively since it is a cost to the taxpayer. GAO made two recommendations: that OPM, in coordination with agencies, (1) develop guidance on which activities to enter, or

not enter, as paid administrative leave in agency time and attendance systems, and (2) provide updated and specific guidance to payroll service providers on which activities to report, or not report, to the paid administrative leave data element in the Enterprise Human Resources Integration database.

Congress extensively cited the GAO report in 2016 House and Senate committee reports regarding draft bills for Federal administrative leave.
8

Those committee reports also included background information on the development of the legislative text that eventually became the Administrative Leave Act. As discussed further, below, while Congress sought to address and better record all forms of paid administrative leave, its primary focus when enacting the Administrative Leave Act was on leave related to misconduct, performance, or other reasons prompting an investigation (as opposed to general administrative leave unrelated to an investigation).

8

See
House Report 114-520, (Aug. 25, 2016), accompanying H.R. 4359, at
https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CRPT-114hrpt520/html/CRPT-114hrpt520.htm;
Senate Report 114-292, (July 6, 2016), accompanying S. 2450, at
https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CRPT-114srpt292/html/CRPT-114srpt292.htm.

In the sense of Congress provisions in section 1138(b) of the Administrative Leave Act, Congress expressed the need for legislation to address concerns that usage of administrative leave had sometimes exceeded reasonable amounts and resulted in significant costs to the Government. Congress wanted agencies to (1) use administrative leave sparingly and reasonably, (2) consider alternatives to use of administrative leave when employees are under investigation, and (3) act expeditiously to conclude investigations and either return the employee to duty or take an appropriate personnel action. Congress also wanted agencies to keep accurate records regarding the use of administrative leave for various purposes.

As explained in the “Executive Summary,” the Act added three new sections in title 5, U.S. Code, that provide for specific categories of paid leave and requirements that apply to each:

• Section 6329a regarding administrative leave;

• Section 6329b regarding investigative leave and notice leave; and

• Section 6329c regarding weather and safety leave.

The Act directed OPM to prescribe regulations to carry out these three sections and guide agencies regarding these new leave categories. Specifically, under section 6329a, OPM is required to prescribe regulations that provide guidance to agencies regarding (1) acceptable uses of administrative leave and (2) the proper recording of administrative leave and other leave authorized by law. Under section 6329b, OPM is required to prescribe regulations regarding (1) the acceptable uses of investigative leave and notice leave, (2) the proper recording of investigative leave and notice leave, (3) baseline factors that an agency must consider when making a determination that the continued presence of an employee in the workplace may pose a threat to the employee or others, result in the destruction of evidence relevant to an investigation, result in loss of or damage to Government property, or otherwise jeopardize legitimate Government interests, and (4) procedures and criteria for the approval of an extension of a period of investigative leave. And section 6329c required OPM to prescribe regulations regarding (1) the appropriate purposes for providing weather and safety leave and (2) the proper recording of weather and safety leave.

The Administrative Leave Act provided that OPM prescribe these regulations no later than 270 calendar days after its enactment on December 23, 2016—
i.e.,
by September 19, 2017. OPM published proposed regulations on July 13, 2017.
9

OPM proposed to add three new subparts to 5 CFR part 630 that correspond to the three new statutory sections in 5 U.S.C. chapter 63: subpart N, Administrative Leave (implementing section 6329a); subpart O, Investigative Leave and Notice Leave (implementing section 6329b); and subpart P, Weather and Safety Leave (implementing section 6329c).

9

See
82 FR 32263.

The Act further directed that agencies “revise and implement the internal policies of the agency,” to meet the statutory requirements pertaining to administrative leave, investigative leave, and notice leave no later than 270 calendar days after the date on which OPM issues its regulations.
10

There was no similar agency implementation provision in the law governing weather and safety leave.

10

See
5 U.S.C. 6329a(c)(2), 6329b(h)(2).

The 30-day comment period for the proposed regulations ended on August 14, 2017. After consideration of the comments received, and in recognition of the different implementation dates for the new leave categories under the Act, OPM determined that it would better serve agencies if the regulations at subpart P, Weather and Safety Leave, were issued first, separately from the regulations addressing the other leave categories. The regulations on weather and safety leave were published on April 10, 2018, and became effective on May 10, 2018. In that final rule, OPM stated it would delay enforcement of the reporting requirements for weather and safety leave pending this final rule (see 83 FR 15291); accordingly, agencies must begin reporting weather and safety leave not later than 270 days after the date of publication.

The effective date for these regulations addressing administrative leave (subpart N) and investigative and notice leave (subpart O) is 30 days after the date of publication and the compliance date is set as 270 days after the date of publication. This compliance date is consistent with the provisions in sections 6329a(c)(2) and 6329b(h)(2), which require that agencies revise and implement their internal policies consistent with the Act within 270 calendar days from the date OPM prescribes the regulations. That same effective and compliance dates apply to OPM's amendments to §§ 752.404(b)(3) and 752.604(b)(2), which are conforming amendments related to subpart O. Agencies are responsible for compliance with time limits provided for in the Act, these OPM regulations, and any related guidance.

III. Regulatory Amendments and Related Comments

A. Summary of Regulatory Changes

In this final rule, OPM is adding two new subparts to 5 CFR part 630 that correspond to new statutory sections in 5 U.S.C. chapter 63: subpart N, Administrative Leave (implementing 5 U.S.C. 6329a), and subpart O, Investigative Leave and Notice Leave (implementing 5 U.S.C. 6329b).

Administrative leave is permitted—at an agency's discretion but subject to statutory and regulatory requirements—when an agency determines that no other paid leave is available under other law. Under section 6329a(b)(1), an agency “may place” an employee on administrative leave for no more than 10 total workdays in any given calendar year.

Investigative leave and notice leave are permitted—at an agency's discretion but subject to statutory and regulatory requirements—when an agency determines that an employee must be removed from the workplace while under investigation or during a notice period (
i.e.,
the period beginning on the date the employee is provided a notice of proposed adverse action and ending on either (1) the effective date of the

adverse action or (2) the date the agency notifies the employee that no adverse action will be taken). These two types of leave may be used only when an authorized agency official determines, through evaluation of baseline factors, that the continued presence of the employee in the workplace may pose a threat to the employee or others, result in the destruction of evidence relevant to an investigation, result in loss of or damage to Government property, or otherwise jeopardize legitimate Government interests. Before using these two types of leave, agencies must consider options to avoid or minimize the use of paid leave, such as changing the employee's duties or work location. Use of investigative leave is subject to time limitations and special approvals for extensions.

Both the law and these regulations also address recordkeeping and reporting requirements with which agencies must comply. Agencies must keep separate records on each type of leave provided under the Act: administrative leave,
11

investigative leave, notice leave, and weather and safety leave.

11
As described below, this final rule provides for two subcategories of administrative leave: (1) administrative leave for investigative purposes (related to employee conduct or performance) and (2) administrative leave for all other purposes.

OPM is also making several editorial changes from its proposed regulatory text. In § 630.1504(g), OPM has changed the reference to the Committee on Oversight and Government Reform to the Committee on Oversight and Accountability to reflect the change in the name of the relevant committee in the House of Representatives since the passage of the Act. OPM is also revising its proposed regulatory text to adopt gender neutral language. Finally, OPM is revising the Authority citations for part 752 to comply with 1 CFR part 21, subpart B, without substantive change.

B. Digest of Public Comments

OPM received 78 comments on the proposed regulations from agency representatives (18), unions (7), other organizations (6), and individuals (47).
12

In the next section, we address general or overarching comments on the proposed rule. In the sections that follow, we address comments related to specific proposals.

12
OPM received an additional 13 comments that contained personally identifiable information and were removed from
regulations.gov
but OPM still considered them in conjunction with this final rule. Four of the total comments received were neither posted to the docket on
regulations.gov
nor considered in this final rule because they are irrelevant to issues discussed in the proposed rule.

C. General Comments

Comment re Coding in Payroll System:
Multiple commenters requested guidance about how the new types of leave should be coded in the payroll system to accurately account for and track the use of these new leave provisions. An agency questioned the need for a separate category for administrative leave used for investigative purposes and suggested coding such leave as investigative leave.

OPM response:
The regulations specify that an agency must track the use of the new categories of leave using five categories: (1) administrative leave for investigative purposes (related to employee conduct, performance, or other reasons prompting an investigation), (2) administrative leave for other purposes, (3) investigative leave, (4) notice leave, and (5) weather and safety leave (published separately at 83 FR 15291).

The two categories related to investigations are necessary because the law bars use of investigative leave under section 6329b until the employee has reached the 10-workday annual limit for administrative leave for investigative purposes under section 6329a.
13

That means that agencies will use an initial period of administrative leave for investigative purposes unless and until that period is exhausted before the provisions of section 6329b apply. This is the reason the type of administrative leave must be separately tracked. The regulations do not address details regarding the coding of leave in agency payroll systems or in OPM's Government payroll databases. OPM will be providing payroll and shared service providers with instructions on how to properly code the various types of leave.

13

See infra
Section IV.(B.) regarding OPM's interpretation that the annual 10 workday limitation in section 6329a of the Administrative Leave Act was meant to apply to management-initiated actions to “place” an employee on administrative leave, with or without the employee's consent, for the purpose of investigating an employee's conduct or performance that could lead to an adverse personnel action.

Comment re Leave Reporting:
An organization expressed concern that the proposed regulations require agencies only to report on their use of administrative leave and not investigative leave or notice leave. The same organization also expressed concern that having reports prepared by the GAO submitted every 5 years is too infrequent. Instead, the organization stated that agencies should be required to maintain real-time, current tallies of all types of paid leave available on its public website, rather than “buried in obscure, long, after-the-fact reports.”

OPM response:
The commenter is incorrect that the regulations do not require reporting on the use of investigative leave and notice leave. The regulations at § 630.1506(c) require that data on usage of investigative leave and notice leave be included in data reports to OPM. Payroll providers submit payroll data to OPM every biweekly pay period. Thus, agencies and OPM will have greater visibility into administrative, investigative, and notice leave usage, which may be used to generate reports as necessary. The 5-year period for GAO's report is a statutory requirement, which OPM has no authority to change, nor does OPM have the authority to impose on GAO the obligation to submit additional reports to Congress.
14

14

See
section 1138(d)(2) of Public Law 114-328 (5 U.S.C. 6329a (Editorial Notes)).

Comments re Existing Collective Bargaining Agreements:
A union requested clarification that any OPM-issued “guidance” does not interfere with the union's bargaining rights or legal obligations in existing collective bargaining agreements. Also, an individual commented that excused absence provided under a negotiated collective bargaining agreement should be excluded from the limits in subpart N.

OPM Response:
Statutory and regulatory requirements affect collective bargaining agreements in different ways. To the extent that existing agency collective bargaining agreements contain provisions that are inconsistent with the statutory provisions of the Administrative Leave Act (including sections 6329a, 6329b, or 6329c), the Act supersedes conflicting provisions in agency collective bargaining agreements as a matter of law. Regulations issued pursuant to the Administrative Leave Act, however, cannot nullify the terms of an existing collective bargaining agreement for the duration of the agreement. If an agency collective bargaining agreement is in effect before the date these regulations are prescribed,
15

then any provisions in the regulations (other than those restating statutory requirements which are immediately enforceable) that conflict with the agreement may be enforced only when the current term of the collective bargaining agreement expires (whether or not the agreement is

officially reopened for negotiations or is automatically renewed through a rollover provision). But agency collective bargaining agreements that take effect on or after the date these regulations are prescribed must comport with the requirements of this regulation. Any conflicting provisions will be unlawful and may not be enforced. To the extent that provisions in agency collective bargaining agreements are consistent with the Act and accompanying regulations, those provisions remain in effect unless and until the provisions are renegotiated.

15

See
5 U.S.C. 7116(a)(7) (explaining it shall be an unfair labor practice for an agency to “enforce a rule or regulation . . . which is in conflict with any applicable collective bargaining agreement if the agreement was in effect before the date the rule or regulation was prescribed[.]”).

Moreover, OPM will issue interpretative guidance relating to these regulations. Any collective bargaining provision reached after the date these regulations are prescribed that conflicts with the regulations would be unlawful and non-negotiable, and, if included in a collective bargaining agreement, unenforceable by the Federal Labor Relations Authority (FLRA or the Authority) or an arbitrator.

Comment re Disciplining Managers:
An organization expressed concern that the proposed regulations would not prevent abuse in the form of excessive investigative leave and notice leave, since managers would not be held accountable in a meaningful way for inappropriate use of these types of leave—they do not subject managers who approve excessive leave to discipline and there is no “down side” for them in terms of adverse career consequences. The organization stated that such excessive leave affects both the taxpayer and the agency by allowing human resources to be wasted. The organization also expressed concern that excessive investigative leave damages the targeted employee's professional prospects and reputation. For instance, employees can be left in lengthy “leave-limbos” without due process protection where they are viewed by management as “inconvenient, an irritant, or a political threat.”

OPM response:
The statute governing investigative leave (section 6329b) established various accountability mechanisms to prevent use of investigative leave beyond specified limits and controls. Those mechanisms include standards on appropriate usage (supplemented by regulations), time limits, approval levels, reports to Congress, recordkeeping, and GAO reviews. OPM notes that, as required by law, these regulations deal with the granting of leave and do not regulate agency decisions regarding investigations or adverse actions.

Although the Administrative Leave Act did not establish time limits for notice leave, notice leave may be used only when an agency has issued a notice of proposed adverse action. Also, agencies must keep records regarding the use of notice leave and those records are subject to review by Congress, OPM, GAO, and other oversight or adjudicative bodies. Data on the use of notice leave can reveal any excessive use that warrants additional scrutiny.

Finally, the regulations are not intended to be a substitute for agencies' own compliance and remedial efforts relating to potential program abuse. But OPM notes that due process protections would not apply to an employee in a paid status because there would be no deprivation of property while on investigative leave or notice leave.

Comment re OPM's Oversight of Agency Practices:
An organization commented that OPM's proposed regulations would not place responsibility on OPM to police agency practices with respect to investigative leave and notice leave but would, instead, allow agencies to police themselves. The organization stated that the regulations make no provision for ensuring that agencies establish necessary agency rules or that agency rules are consistent with OPM regulations. The organization suggested that OPM exercise oversight over agency practices.

OPM response:
As described above, the Administrative Leave Act authorized OPM to issue regulations dealing with the appropriate uses and proper recording of the new types of leave. Although OPM has a general oversight function, Congress imposed no specific obligation on OPM to monitor or police agency practices with respect to the Act. OPM will take steps, however, to enforce the rules to the extent permitted by resources and consistent with other significant priorities. OPM can and will intervene, for example, if it becomes aware that an agency is not complying with the law and regulations for which OPM is responsible. At the same time, each agency, along with its Inspectors General, is responsible for evaluating agency personnel programs and the actions of its managers. The Act also gave GAO a specific responsibility to evaluate agencies' implementation of investigative leave and notice leave every 5 years.

Comment re Required Hours While Teleworking:
One commenter noted the telework-related provisions in the proposed regulations and expressed concern that Federal employees were not performing required hours of work while teleworking.

OPM response:
The Telework Enhancement Act of 2010, which built on earlier enactments, specifies roles, responsibilities, and expectations for all Federal executive agencies regarding telework policies, employee eligibility and participation, program implementation, and reporting. Under that statute, each agency is responsible for monitoring whether employees are performing required hours of work while teleworking. These regulations merely recognize the option of telework under authority of 5 U.S.C. chapter 65 and explain how telework relates to the new types of leave.

D. Comments Related to Specific Regulatory Amendments

OPM discusses the regulatory changes to part 630 before turning to conforming changes to part 752.

Amendment to § 630.206(a)

Comment:
Three unions, one professional association, and an individual objected to the removal of the provision at § 630.206(a) that agencies traditionally used to excuse employee absences of less than 1 hour. The union and the professional association said there are valid reasons for employee tardiness for which administrative leave should be granted. The union also mentioned the hardship on employees with children in daycare. The union said that agencies should continue to have their current discretion to grant excused absence in any such circumstances. A second union added that it was unfortunate that OPM believes it necessary to remove this provision without any firm data indicating some type of adverse impact. A third union expressed concern about the second approval level now required and believed that removal of the provision is outside the scope of what Congress intended to address with the legislation. The professional association and an individual objected to the change because of the administrative burden. An agency asked if this removes a supervisor's authority to grant 59 minutes of excused absence. Another agency asked if the removal of the provision meant that the authority was now under the new administrative leave regulations. An individual suggested that the administrative leave regulations allow for use of a 59-minute rule without second-level management approval (
e.g.,
to deal with employees who arrive late).

OPM response:
The new OPM regulation is not eliminating the possibility of an agency granting administrative leave in appropriate circumstances when an employee arrives late but is simply clarifying the authority under which the agency is

authorizing such administrative leave. There was never clear authority to grant excused absence for leave less than one hour under annual and sick leave statutes. As we explained in the preamble of the proposed rule, § 630.206(a) was not an authority for creating a type of paid time off, but merely recognized the existence of agency authority to provide brief periods of excused absence under Comptroller General decisions. Now that OPM has authority to regulate the use of administrative leave under section 6329a, it is appropriate for this application of administrative leave to be covered under these new regulations.

Since section 6329a is now the exclusive authority for administrative leave for employees covered by title 5, U.S. Code, any excused absence for tardiness should be documented as administrative leave and included in agency reports so that, among other reasons described in this preamble, Congress has complete information about administrative leave. Agencies have discretion under the section 6329a authority to continue to grant administrative leave for these brief periods, if determined to be appropriate.

The preferred action is to continue allowing employees to adjust their stop time under a flexible work schedule within the flexible time bands established by the agency or to use annual or other appropriate leave. OPM recognizes, however, that there may be occasions when an agency believes administrative leave is appropriate. Subject to the principles and prohibitions in § 630.1403, agencies have considerable discretion in granting such administrative leave.

As described further below, these regulations only require a second level of approval to grant administrative leave if an agency head or authorized delegee has not adopted policies that allow first-line supervisors to grant a specified amount of administrative leave in a specifically defined circumstance.

Regarding the administrative burden concern, agencies must account for all hours within an employee's tour of duty, regardless of whether the employee is at work, on leave or leave without pay, using compensatory time off or credit hours, or is absent for any other reason. A decision not to provide administrative leave for absences under 1 hour simply requires application of normal procedures.

Subpart N—Administrative Leave

Section 630.1401—Purpose and Applicability

Comment:
One agency asked if the Administrative Leave Act replaced agency authority under 5 U.S.C. 301-302 or if agencies still retain authority to grant administrative leave on matters not addressed in the regulations. An individual asked whether the Administrative Leave Act eliminated, superseded, or replaced the authority in sections 301-302. The individual noted that the limits imposed by the Act would nullify existing collective bargaining agreement provisions on the granting of administrative leave and that agencies may want to continue to use the sections 301-302 authority to preserve those provisions.

OPM response:
The statutory language of the Act does not specifically address agencies' preexisting authority in sections 301-302. Section 301 provides in pertinent part that the “head of an Executive department . . . may prescribe regulations for the government of his department, [and] the conduct of its employees . . . .” Section 302 authorizes an agency head to delegate the authority “to take final action on matters pertaining to the employment, direction, and general administration of personnel under his [or her] agency.” OPM does not regulate agencies' management authority under sections 301-302 (or other statutes that grant agencies similar management authority to grant particular types of leave), so in this final rule OPM does not opine as to what agencies can or cannot do under sections 301-302.

It is OPM's view, however, that section 6329a is the exclusive administrative leave authority for employees covered by title 5, U.S. Code. Section 6329a of the Act defines “administrative leave” as leave without loss of or reduction in (1) pay; (2) leave to which an employee is otherwise entitled under law; or (3) credit time for time or service; and “
that is not authorized under any other provision of law.
” [Emphasis supplied]. Investigative leave and notice leave are similarly defined, except that investigative leave may only be approved for an employee who is the subject of an investigation (section 6329b(a)(7)), and notice leave may only be approved for an employee who is in a notice period (section 6329b(a)(8)).

The Administrative Leave Act in section 6329a(c)(1) states that the “Director . . . shall prescribe regulations to carry out this section; and prescribe regulations that provide guidance to agencies regarding acceptable agency uses of administrative leave and the proper recording of administrative leave and other leave authorized by law.” Under section 6329b(h)(1) of the Act, the “Director shall prescribe regulations to carry out this section, including guidance to agencies regarding acceptable purposes for the use of investigative leave and notice leave.” This subsection also provides that OPM shall regulate “the proper recording” of investigative leave and notice leave, “and other leave authorized by law.” Section 6329c(d) provides similar language regarding appropriate purposes for, and proper recording of, weather and safety leave.

Thus, the Act gives OPM authority to regulate regarding acceptable purposes for using administrative leave, investigative leave, notice leave, and weather and safety leave, and requires OPM to regulate the “proper recording” of those types of leave, as well as other leave authorized by law.

As noted above, the specific issue of the continued vitality of other excused absences under sections 301-302 (
i.e.,
other excused absences not defined as a type of administrative leave under the Act) is beyond the scope of these regulations, and we do not address their use in this final rule.

Agencies should be mindful, though, that any such grants may also be subject to internal and external oversight, including scrutiny by the agency Office of the Inspector General, GAO, and Congress, and agencies may have to justify any extraneous uses.

Comment:
The individual also asked whether the Act currently impacts collective bargaining agreements and agency policies or if the impact will occur when agencies implement their policies in 270 days.

OPM response:
The provisions of the Administrative Leave Act supersede any conflicting provisions in agency policies or a collective bargaining agreement. Once this regulation is prescribed, any new collective bargaining agreement must be consistent with the regulation. Any conflicting provisions in a pre-existing collective bargaining agreement will prevail over regulatory requirements only until such time as the current term of the collective bargaining agreement expires (whether or not the agreement is officially reopened for negotiations or is automatically renewed through a rollover provision). As provided in the Act, agencies must “revise and implement the internal policies of the agency” no later than 270 days after related regulations are prescribed so that those policies

conform with the law and regulations.
16

There is no similar delayed agency implementation provision governing weather and safety leave, and thus the weather and safety leave regulations were implemented 30 days after the April 10, 2018, publication date.

16

See
sections 6329a(c)(2) and 6329b(h)(2). In the proposed rule, OPM stated that, for the final rule, OPM intended to specify that the regulations for subparts N and O (dealing with administrative leave and investigative/notice leave, respectively) “will take effect 270 days after publication by specifying a separate `implementation date.'” 82 FR 33263, 33264.To be clear, the effective date of this final rule is 30 days after publication and the date by which agencies must revise and implement their internal policies to meet the requirements of the Administrative Leave Act and these regulations is 270 days from the date these regulations are published.

Comment:
One individual commented that the statutory authority at section 6329a(d) conflicts with the statutory authority at 38 U.S.C. 7421 and asked how OPM would reconcile the two. The same individual asked how 38 U.S.C. 717 applied to proposed §§ 630.1404(a) and 630.1504(a).

OPM response:
Chapter 74 of title 38, U.S. Code, applies to personnel of the Veterans Health Administration (VHA), a component of the Department of Veterans Affairs. The statute at 38 U.S.C. 7421 applies exclusively to VHA physicians, dentists, podiatrists, optometrists, registered nurses, physician assistants, expanded-duty dental auxiliaries, and chiropractors. While these employees are, by default, covered by title 5, U.S. Code, leave provisions (since they are “employees” under 5 U.S.C. 2105), the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) may, generally, use the section 7421 authority to exclude them from title 5, U.S. Code, leave provisions and to create alternative leave rules for them. However, in each of the sections 6329a, 6329b, and 6329c, there are provisions requiring VA to apply those sections “notwithstanding” the section 7421 authority.
17

The Administrative Leave Act provisions, therefore, apply to VHA employees notwithstanding the section 7421 authority to prescribe leave benefits.

17

See
sections 6329a(d), 6329b(i), and 6329c(e).

The statute at 38 U.S.C. 717 was enacted via Public Law 114-315, title V, section 503(a)(1) on December 16, 2016, while the Administrative Leave Act was enacted a few days later on December 23, 2016. Under section 717, the Secretary of the VA may not place any covered individual (
i.e.,
those subject to an investigation or who are facing disciplinary action) on administrative leave, or any other type of paid non-duty status without charge to leave, for more than a total of 14 days during any 365-day period.
18

Section 717 also authorizes the Secretary of VA to waive the 14-day limit if the Secretary notifies Congress of the reasons for an extension. That VA employees are covered under a VA-specific administrative leave limitation does not except them from coverage under the Administrative Leave Act. We note that VA employees are covered under the Administrative Leave Act's definition of “agency” under sections 6329a(a)(2)(B), 6329b(a)(1)(B), and 6329c(a)(1)(B). Both laws can be applied simultaneously.

18
Notably, the 14-day annual limitation on the number of days the VA may “place” an employee on administrative leave or other paid non-duty status in 38 U.S.C. 717, enacted days before the Administrative Leave Act, applies only to VA employees who are subject to an investigation to determine whether they should be subject to any disciplinary action under title 38 or title 5 or against whom any disciplinary action is proposed or initiated under title 38 or title 5.
See
38 U.S.C. 717(c). This further supports OPM's reading that the 10-day annual period in section 6329a(b)(1), limiting the number of days an agency “may place” an employee on administrative leave under the Administrative Leave Act was meant to apply to agency-directed administrative leave for investigative purposes, as explained below.

Comment:
Nine individuals opposed the application of the administrative leave regulations, and particularly the 10-workday calendar year limit, to VA employees. These individuals cited several activities for which they maintained VA granted excused absences in the past, including research, teaching, training, medical education and certification, attending conferences and scientific meetings, travel to other VA stations or Federal agencies for support or educational purposes, conducting grant reviews or serving on panels at other agencies, reporting on VA research findings and models to stakeholders and professional societies, and sabbaticals. The individuals felt that the regulations would seriously impair VA patient care, education, and research efforts and would negatively affect recruitment and retention.

OPM response:
Congress specifically provided in the Administrative Leave Act that section 6329a “shall apply” to an employee covered by 38 U.S.C. 7421(b), “notwithstanding subsection (a) of section 7421.” Through this enactment, Congress required VA employees covered by leave programs established under section 7421(a) to be subject to section 6329a. While these VA employees are covered by the statute, as explained later in this preamble, the annual 10-workday period only applies to administrative leave for investigative purposes. Also, many of the activities cited by the commenters might more appropriately be classified as “on-duty” time, which does not require the granting of administrative leave. For instance, if VA determines that research, teaching, grant reviews or other support activities are components of an employee's duties and are justified under agency appropriations, these activities would not require the granting of administrative leave. Likewise, administrative leave is not needed for training, conferences, and meetings that are authorized under sections 4109 and 4110 and the regulations at § 410.404.

However, administrative leave is generally not appropriate for sabbaticals that would provide paid time off for lengthy periods of time. When Congress has sought to allow certain Federal employees to take sabbaticals, it has provided specific authority via legislation.
19

We note that VA may consider whether it can provide sabbaticals under its section 7421 authority to establish “conditions of employment.” VA may also consider whether certain sabbaticals qualify as special work assignments rather than as “leave” (as can be done with certain assignments made under 5 U.S.C. 3371-3376).

19

See, e.g.,
5 U.S.C. 3151(a)(7), 3396(c); 50 U.S.C. 3610(a)(1)(G).

Comment:
One commenter believed that VA activities for which excused absence had been granted in the past would no longer qualify because proposed § 630.1403(a)(3) limits the duration of administrative leave to “not more than 1 workday.”

OPM response:
OPM's final rule does not bar leave longer than 1 workday. While § 630.1403(a)(3) states that administrative leave “is appropriately used for brief or short periods of time—usually for not more than 1 workday” it specifies that “[a]n incidence of administrative leave lasting more than 1 workday may be approved when determined to be appropriate by an agency.”

Section 630.1402—Definitions

Comment:
The preamble discussion on the proposed § 630.1402 stated that the 5 days of excused absence for employees returning from active military duty granted by the Presidential memorandum of November 14, 2003, is not considered administrative leave. One commenter asked if this meant that the 5 days would no longer be granted or if the 5 days now belong to a separate leave category.

OPM response:
The 5 days of excused absence for employees returning from active military duty is authorized by a Presidential directive. As noted in the

definition of
administrative leave
in § 630.1402, administrative leave does not encompass leave authorized by Presidential directives. The President is acting under the President's authority under the Constitution; thus, excused absence provided by Presidential directive is leave that is authorized under another provision of law and is excluded from the statutory definition of
administrative leave
in section 6329a(a)(1). Also, section 6329a limits only actions by agencies, not actions by the President. Thus, the 5 days of excused absence authorized by the Presidential memorandum is not administrative leave under section 6329(a)(1) and, as such, these regulations do not affect this entitlement.

Comment:
An agency requested clarification on the proper use of administrative leave authorized by Congress or Presidential directive, which the agency said appears inconsistent with the regulatory provision at § 630.1403(a)(2) that administrative leave be granted sparingly. The agency also requested that OPM expressly address other potential uses of administrative leave to aid agencies that will need to renegotiate labor agreements in light of the statutory 10-workday calendar year limit in section 6329a.

OPM response:
The definition of
administrative leave
in § 630.1402 excludes paid leave authorized by statutes other than section 6329a and by Presidential directives issued under the President's authority. Therefore, the treatment of leave authorized by other statutes and Presidential directives is excluded from these subpart N regulations.

Comment:
One agency said that in sections of the proposed rule, OPM used the term
administrative leave
to refer to investigative leave, notice leave, and weather and safety leave. The agency recommended that OPM redefine
administrative leave
to exclude these other types of leave.

OPM response:
Following review of the proposed rule, OPM did not find any instances where the term was used incorrectly. The definition of
administrative leave
in § 630.1402 clearly provides that it applies only to leave authorized under section 6329a and subpart N.

Comment:
Three agencies and an individual asked about other paid leave in relation to the regulations—specifically, court leave, bone marrow and organ donation leave, funeral leave, disabled veteran leave, and the 4 hours of excused absence for preventive health screenings for employees with low sick leave balances under Presidential Memorandum of January 4, 2001. Commenters asked whether these types of leave were subject to the 10-workday annual limit under section 6329a.

OPM response:
Leave entitlements authorized under other statutes or Presidential directives are not subject to section 6329a and subpart N, so they are not considered administrative leave. Also, as explained below, the 10-day annual limit in section 6329a applies to administrative leave for investigative purposes, not the types of leaves identified in the comments above.

Comment:
An agency recommended adding a definition for “excused absence.”

OPM response:
The Act did not define “excused absence” and the regulations refer to “excused absence” only in the definition of
Presidential directive,
the meaning of which is self-evident. Therefore, OPM is not adding this definition as we do not consider it to be necessary.

Comment:
One agency recommended that the definition of
agency
conform to the definition of
agency
in the annual and sick leave regulations.

OPM response:
The term
agency
has differing definitions in five other subparts of 5 CFR part 630. Accordingly, OPM has defined
agency
in § 630.1402 based on the statutory definition at section 6329a(a)(2). The definition of “agency” specified in the Act must be applied in these regulations. OPM has also clarified the meaning of the term
agency
in the context of describing an authorized agency official empowered to make a determination and take action.

Section 630.1403—Principles and Prohibitions

Comment:
One agency commented that the regulations governing agency use of administrative leave are too restrictive and that, without a statutory basis, they specifically target collective bargaining agreements as well as administrative leave used for the benefit of a labor organization. A union objected to the general principles set out in § 630.1403(a)(1), which the union said OPM based on unspecified past OPM policy and guidance and unnamed Comptroller General decisions.

OPM response:
The regulations establish parameters for the granting of administrative leave in accordance with appropriations laws and for differentiating administrative leave from on-duty time and other authorized paid absences. The proposed rule at § 630.1403(a)(1) established three criteria where administrative leave is allowed: (1) the absence is directly related to the agency's mission, (2) the absence is officially sponsored or sanctioned by the agency, or (3) the absence is in the interest of the agency or of the Government as a whole. The proposed regulations reflected basic principles consistent with the sense of Congress section of the Administrative Leave Act, which references precedent by the Comptroller General and OPM guidance.
20

There are numerous Comptroller General decisions on administrative leave and excused absence.
21

OPM policy guidance on administrative leave is provided in reference materials by OPM
22

and historically in the former Federal Personnel Manual. The list of allowable criteria in the proposed § 630.1403(a)(1) largely mirrored OPM's longstanding guidance regarding the appropriate uses of administrative leave. OPM's guidance, however, includes a fourth category that was
excluded
from the proposed rule: “The absence will clearly enhance the professional development or skills of the employee in the employee's current position.” OPM has decided to add this criterion to the list of allowable uses of administrative leave in the final rule. Its inclusion allows agencies to act consistent with OPM's longstanding guidance and provides the flexibility with which agencies are familiar. OPM will be updating its guidance materials on administrative leave to reflect these regulations.

20

See
section 1138(b)(1) of the Act.

21

See e.g.,
Comptroller General decision B 156287, February 5, 1975, at
http://www.gao.gov/products/452029#mt=e-report.
Comptroller General decisions may be found at
http://www.gao.gov/search?advanced=1.

22

See infra
note 5.

Comment:
Two agencies, three unions, and a professional association commented on the provision at § 630.1403(a)(4) that prohibits agencies from establishing administrative leave as an ongoing or recurring entitlement. One agency said that the provision appeared to be aimed at banning all collective bargaining agreement language that provides for the granting of administrative leave in specified circumstances. Another agency asked if the provision prohibited agency policy from addressing administrative leave for blood donations and voting. Two unions objected on the basis that an employee who qualifies for the administrative leave should receive it regardless of whether the provision of the leave is recurring. One union said that this provision was not needed because birthdays and the day after a Thursday holiday could be listed as a specific prohibited use under paragraph (b) of the section. The union also felt that

requiring leave to be granted on an ad hoc basis would lead to uneven application. The professional association noted that, in its experience, administrative leave for recurring events, like birthdays and in conjunction with holidays, has not been granted to employees with any frequency. In addition, it said that § 630.1403(a)(4) as it pertains to administrative leave in conjunction with holidays is erroneous, in that these are generally granted under the administrative dismissal authority at 5 CFR part 610, subpart C. The association also believed that this section was contrary to the authority of the President to close the Federal government by executive order.

OPM response:
The proposed regulations at § 630.1403(a)(4) were not intended to bar recurring use of administrative leave; the intent was to bar establishing a recurring use as an
entitlement.
The plain language of the Act makes clear that the approval of administrative leave is at the agency's discretion, and that such leave is not an entitlement of the employee.
23

OPM's intent was to ensure that agencies retain control of administrative leave and are always able to grant or deny use of such leave based on mission needs. Otherwise, the authority could be used in a manner never contemplated by Congress—to create new open-ended entitlements to “holidays” or new types of paid leave entitlements with no agency discretion—an area over which Congress has traditionally asserted control.
24

23

See
section 6329a(b)(1), stating that an agency “may” approve administrative leave.

24
Congress has the authority to establish recurring entitlements to paid time off in law (
e.g.,
paid holidays under chapter 61 or various types of paid leave under chapter 63), and, thus, the creation of new recurring paid time off entitlements should be reserved to Congress.

OPM appreciates these comments and clarifies that this provision does not prohibit agencies from providing administrative leave on an ad hoc basis or limited basis for a recurring activity that otherwise meets one of the acceptable use criteria. For example, agencies may establish in policy, approved by the agency head, that authorized agency officials may make ad hoc determinations to grant administrative leave for a specified activity (
e.g.,
blood donations or voting). Such a policy might provide that a first-level supervisor can grant, on an ad hoc basis, up to 4 hours of administrative leave to an employee to donate blood in an agency-sponsored drive after determining that such leave is appropriate.

OPM has revised the regulatory language to ensure that it conveys the intended purpose—namely, that (1) administrative leave is not an entitlement, and an agency retains the discretion to grant or not grant administrative leave in any circumstance based on agency judgments regarding mission needs, (2) generally, administrative leave should be granted on an ad hoc, event-specific, or time-limited basis, and (3) there is no categorical prohibition on administrative leave being granted for a recurring event, but rather that it cannot be a recurring entitlement that eliminates agency discretion.

The regulatory language in § 630.1403(a)(4), moreover, does not include separate requirements for recurring events like employee birthdays or holidays. In the preamble to the proposed regulations, OPM stated that agencies should not provide administrative leave for employees' birthdays or the day following a Thursday holiday as a recurring entitlement (that is, with no agency discretion to consider mission needs). As explained above, OPM is clarifying in these regulations that agencies may not use administrative leave to establish recurring entitlements that eliminate agency discretion over granting the leave.

A commenter expressed the view that § 630.1403(a)(4) was contrary to the authority of the President to close the Federal Government by executive order. The President may establish a special holiday under 5 U.S.C. 6103(b). Such a holiday is not a use of administrative leave and is not governed by section 6329a or these regulations.
25

25

See
the definition of administrative leave under § 630.1402.

A commenter also misunderstands the application 5 CFR part 610, subpart C, which applies only to a very small segment of Federal employees paid at daily, hourly, or piecework rates who could not otherwise receive paid time off received by most employees (
e.g.,
on a holiday). It cannot be used as an authority to grant administrative dismissals to other employees.
26

26

See also
section 6104.

Comment:
Two agencies and a union asked for OPM to clarify whether administrative leave is used for union official time. One agency felt that the regulations specifically targeted administrative leave used for the benefit of a labor organization.

OPM response:
Union official time granted pursuant to 5 U.S.C. 7131 is a specific type of work time during which the employee otherwise would be performing the duties of the employee's assigned position, for which grants of administrative leave would not be necessary or appropriate. By definition,
administrative leave
does not include activities that qualify as hours of work (§ 630.1402). Under section 7131, official time is treated as work time for which employees receive basic pay. Section 7131(a) and (c) authorize official time for specific representational purposes. Section 7131(b) prohibits official time for internal union business. And section 7131(d) provides authority for an agency and exclusive representative to negotiate official time for any other matter covered by 5 U.S.C. chapter 71 and which they agree to be reasonable, necessary, and in the public interest. Finally, payroll systems already have separate payroll codes for the various categories of official time, which are not impacted by these regulations. Therefore, agencies have sufficient authority to provide official time for use by representatives of a labor organization.

Finally, these regulations do not target any particular use or use by any group. Rather, they are designed to comply with statutory requirements and to implement Congress' intent as to what comprises the acceptable uses of administrative leave.

Comment:
One agency and two individuals were concerned with the impact of the regulations on settlement agreements. The agency noted that it made extended administrative leave substitutions on timekeeping records pursuant to orders, settlements, and agency decisions. One individual stated that excused absence under a third-party settlement agreement should be excluded from the limits under subpart N.

OPM response:
As a general principle, settlements must comport with applicable law and regulation. They may not include provisions that provide aspects of relief that the agency is not free to grant under applicable law. If an agency determines, on a prospective basis, that it is appropriate to use administrative leave under section 6329a as part of a settlement agreement, such use will be subject to its statutory conditions and regulatory requirements. If other statutory authorities are relied on to grant paid nonduty status on a prospective basis as part of a settlement agreement, then the paid nonduty status is not considered to be administrative leave under section 6329a.

A retroactive period of paid nonduty status may be provided under the Back Pay Act (section 5596) or under a settlement under that law. Such a period of paid nonduty status does not

constitute administrative leave under section 6329a since it is not “leave” and is authorized by operation of another law. Retroactive salary payments to cover a period of erroneous separation are a correction of an erroneous personnel action that is authorized under the back pay law. These payments would be included under the definition of “pay, allowances, and differentials” in § 550.803 (pay, leave, and other monetary employment benefits to which an employee is entitled by statute or regulation). They are payments for nonwork periods authorized by the back pay law, not a use of discretionary administrative leave, and should not be designated as administrative leave in timekeeping records.

Comment:
One individual commenter argued that agencies should not grant administrative leave prior to a holiday.

OPM response:
Administrative leave is an agency discretionary authority; therefore, each agency makes determinations regarding when and for what purposes (including as a goodwill gesture to address employee morale) it provides administrative leave. The regulations at § 630.1403 set out certain principles and prohibitions on use of administrative leave but do not otherwise restrict agencies from exercising their discretionary authority in granting this leave. OPM is adding a new paragraph (6) in § 630.1403(a) that lists factors agencies are required to consider as they develop policies and make case-specific decisions regarding the use of administrative leave. Consideration of these factors, in combination with guiding principles, will help agencies exercise their discretion with respect to administrative leave in a prudent manner.

Comment:
Two unions opposed the provision at proposed § 630.1403(a)(3) that states administrative leave is appropriately used for brief or short periods of time. One of the unions stated that the duration should be at the agency's discretion or as provided under negotiated policies. Both unions recommended that OPM remove the provision so as not to mislead agencies on Congressional intent.

OPM response:
The “Sense of Congress” provisions at section 1138(b)(2) of the Administrative Leave Act explicitly state that “administrative leave should be used sparingly.” At section 1138(b)(1)(A), Congress recognized the “established precedent of the Comptroller General” and “guidance provided by the Office of Personnel Management” as having provided appropriate and reasonable standards for Governmentwide administrative leave policy. Numerous Comptroller General decisions have held that administrative leave should be granted only for brief periods of time. This has been OPM's longstanding policy as reflected in its historical guidance and its public fact sheet on administrative leave. OPM notes that while § 630.1403(a)(3) states that administrative leave is appropriately used for brief periods of time, it also permits agencies the ability to approve longer periods when appropriate, at their discretion. This caveat is described further, below, with regard to agency-specific policies established by the head of an agency.

Comment:
An individual recommended that employees be permitted to use administrative leave for voluntary community service.

OPM response:
OPM does not believe that the proposed § 630.1403(b)(4) would have barred administrative leave for voluntary community service. It provided that such administrative leave was permitted if it was officially sponsored or sanctioned by the head of the agency based on the agency's mission or Governmentwide interests, which ties these provisions with the general principles in § 630.1401(a)(1). As explained previously, however, OPM will include a fourth category to the general principles in § 630.1403(a)(1) that was excluded from the proposed rule: the absence will clearly enhance the professional development or skills of the employee in the employee's current position. The inclusion is consistent with OPM's longstanding guidance. OPM also is not adopting the proposed prohibition in § 630.1403(b)(4), since it is unnecessary; the requirements to satisfy one or more of the general principles in § 630.1401(a)(1) and to operate under approved agency policies is sufficient to prevent inappropriate use of administrative leave in community service situations.

Comment:
Another individual commented that the regulations should discuss scenarios where administrative leave is not needed because employees are considered to be on duty time. A second commenter recommended that OPM add guidance that sets parameters on the granting of administrative leave for holiday parties, employee recognition days, and similar infrequent social events. A union commented that OPM should note that on-duty activities such as award ceremonies and training can be voluntary in nature.

OPM response:
Certain activities occurring during an employee's work hours are generally considered on-duty events for which administrative leave does not apply. These include agency-sponsored events (
e.g.,
award ceremonies), employee human resources matters, management-approved team-building activities (
e.g.,
holiday social gatherings), and training, conferences, and meetings that are authorized under sections 4109 and 4110 and the regulations at § 410.404. At the agency's discretion, attendance at these on-duty activities can be voluntary. Other activities, although they occur during employee work hours, are generally not considered on-duty activities. For example, activities related to employee wellness and health generally are not considered as duty time; however, longstanding policy reflected in Comptroller General decisions is that the agency interest in employee health justifies use of brief periods of administrative leave for these activities. Agencies will retain discretion in determining whether certain activities are on-duty events for purposes of implementing the Administrative Leave Act and this final rule.

Comment:
A union believed that dual status employees should receive administrative leave for required military medical examinations and the diagnosis and treatment of medical conditions caused or aggravated by military service.

OPM response:
If the employing agency determines that this is an appropriate use under the general principles at § 630.1403(a), it has the discretion to grant administrative leave.

Comment:
One agency stated that the administrative leave definition should exclude leave for Federal employees stationed overseas when they observe foreign holidays. The same agency asked whether administrative leave may still be provided for rest and recuperation (R&R).

OPM response:
OPM has no authority under laws it administers to authorize paid time off for local holidays in foreign areas beyond the holidays provided under section 6103. An agency may, however, use the administrative leave authority in section 6329a if it determines the circumstances comply with the OPM regulations. For example, under § 630.1403(a)(4) in this final rule, an agency must retain the discretion to grant or not grant administrative leave in any particular circumstance based on agency judgments regarding mission needs. An agency cannot, therefore, create a paid holiday in a foreign area as an absolute entitlement. We expect that agencies with employees in foreign areas will determine whether to grant administrative leave in connection with a foreign holiday to some or all employees on a case-by-case basis. If

there is a safety-related basis for the time off, use of weather and safety leave may be appropriate. Agencies may also continue to provide administrative leave for R&R if the employing agency determines that this is an appropriate use under the general principles at § 630.1403(a).

Comment:
Three agencies and a union sought clarification on physical fitness activities during duty hours. One of the agencies and the union recommended that physical fitness be classified as an on-duty activity and not require the granting of administrative leave. One agency asked if long-term physical fitness activities would be prohibited as a recurring activity under § 630.1403(a)(4). Two of the agencies were concerned that the limitation on administrative leave would have a negative effect on wellness programs, with one agency stating that the limitation would significantly affect participation in agency-sanctioned and administered physical fitness activities. The same agency also requested that OPM clarify the application of this rulemaking on employees who have physical fitness requirements in connection to their position;
i.e.,
military technicians of the Reserves and National Guard who must maintain military membership as a condition of employment of their civilian position. The union recommended that these dual status employees be authorized to engage in voluntary physical training as official hours of work.

OPM response:
Agencies, at their discretion, may permit employees with job-related fitness requirements (such as law enforcement officers) to participate in physical fitness programs while on duty. For other employees, physical fitness activities should normally be performed outside of duty hours unless an employee is using annual leave. When covered by a flexible work schedule, an employee may be able to shift work hours to create mid-tour breaks during which physical fitness activities may be performed. If an agency determines it is appropriate to provide administrative leave for brief periods of physical fitness activities for a limited time, it may grant such administrative leave on an ad hoc basis.

The Comptroller General has found that “official duty time” for physical fitness activities is appropriate only for employees covered by a mandatory physical fitness program due to the strenuous nature of the position.
27

That decision indicated that administrative leave was inappropriate for other employees in the absence of supporting guidance from OPM. OPM later issued guidance to recognize that short periods of excused absence (by definition, not “duty” time) could be provided to employees in positions without mandatory physical fitness requirements.
28

All administrative leave granted under section 6329a, including that which is granted for fitness programs, would have to be recorded and reported, as described below.

27

See e.g.,
Comptroller General decision B-218840, Sept. 6, 1985, 64 Comp. Gen. 835 at
http://www.gao.gov/products/438969#mt=e-report.

28

See e.g.,
subchapter 11 of FPM Chapter 630, Sept. 23, 1991, and FPM Letters 792-15, April 14, 1986, and 792-23, June 25, 1992.

Comment:
An agency asked if the regulations will impact the 24 hours an agency grants for a Permanent Change of Station (PCS). The agency also asked if the 10-workday limit impacts administrative leave granted to new hires as a relocation incentive.

OPM response:
Employees on approved house-hunting trips under chapter 302, subpart C, of the Federal Travel Regulations are in duty status and do not require administrative leave.
29

Also, as explained below, the 10-workday limit in section 6329a does not apply to this type of leave.

29

See
41 CFR 302-5.17 and Comptroller General decision B-203196, Feb. 3, 1982.

Comment:
One union requested that OPM eliminate the requirement in proposed § 630.1403(a)(5)(i) that administrative leave be permitted under policies established by the head of the agency and instead require only that administrative leave be permitted under “written agency policies.” The union said that the definition of
head of the agency
is unclear and overly restrictive, noting its application to Department of Defense subordinate departments.

OPM response:
OPM does not consider the definition of
head of the agency
in § 630.1402 to be unclear.
Agency
is defined in that section as meaning an Executive agency as defined at 5 U.S.C. 105. Under the statute,
Executive agency
means an “Executive department, a Government corporation, and an independent establishment.” The Executive departments are set out at 5 U.S.C. 101 and include the DoD. Therefore, under the regulations, administrative leave policies for subordinate departments under the DoD, or any other agency, must remain within the discretion of the agency and must be established (or approved) by the head of the agency to help prevent abuse and to address Congressional concerns about inappropriate use of administrative leave. Agency heads are directly accountable for agency administrative leave policies. This regulation does not mandate how specific the agency top-level policy is and does not preclude subordinate organizations from making more specific policies under a delegation of authority. Those agency head policies may include general principles as well as specific rules. An agency head may delegate authority to lower-level officials to establish more specific policies if they are consistent with the agency head's overarching policies. To assist agencies in developing appropriate policies on use of administrative leave, OPM is adding a new paragraph (6) in § 630.1403(a) that lists factors agencies are required to consider.

Comment:
Five agencies, a union, and an individual expressed concerns with proposed § 630.1403(a)(5)(ii), which provides that a determination to grant administrative leave for an absence must be reviewed and approved by an agency official higher than the official making the determination (unless there is no higher-level official). The agencies felt that this requirement diminished the authority of first-level supervisors, who they believed should be able to grant administrative leave for specific situations, such as blood donations or for occasions where less than an hour is needed. Two agencies and the union said a second level of review should not be needed where administrative leave is provided under agency policy. One agency believed the second level of review to be an administrative burden and recommended that heads of agencies have the authority to delegate further, such as to the heads of installations. Another agency said that the requirement would be time consuming for second-level officials, particularly for routine events. The union expressed concern that the second level of approval would cause administrative delays to the detriment of the employee, especially when the second-level official is not in the same building or there is a time zone difference. The union also said it was unaware of any evidence showing administrative leave abuse not related to investigations and concluded that the requirement for second-level review was unnecessary and inefficient. The individual suggested allowing agencies to determine the appropriate procedures and level of review.

OPM response:
As explained above, agencies may establish policies, approved by the head of the agency (or the agency head's delegee), that provide specific circumstances (blood drives, voting, etc.) in which supervisors may grant a stated amount of administrative leave to employees without the need for

second-level review. OPM is revising the regulations to make clear that second-level approval is not necessary when a specific type of use and amount of administrative leave is permitted under agency head policies or supplemental policies issued by agency officials with specific delegated authority. At the same time, to support prudent use of administrative leave, OPM is adding a new paragraph (6) in § 630.1403(a) that lists factors agencies must consider in developing policies on use of administrative leave.

Comment:
An agency asked what the intent is for the prohibition on administrative leave use for personal benefits in proposed § 630.1403(b)(2) and whether it precluded agencies from providing administrative leave for other purposes.

OPM response:
The proposed § 630.1403(b)(2) would have barred administrative leave to participate in an event for the employee's personal benefit or the benefit of an outside organization; however, there was an exception to the bar based on a determination that the employee's participation would satisfy one or more of the general principles in § 630.1401(a)(1). As explained above, however, OPM is adding a fourth category to § 630.1403(a)(1) that is excluded from the proposed rule: the absence will clearly enhance the professional development or skills of the employee in the employee's current position. We are therefore not adopting the proposed prohibition in § 630.1403(b)(2), since it is unnecessary and arguably inconsistent with the additional acceptable use in § 630.1403(a)(1). The requirement to satisfy one or more of the general principles in § 630.1401(a)(1) and to operate under approved agency policies is sufficient to prevent inappropriate use of administrative leave in situations that provide a personal benefit to an employee or benefit an outside organization.

Comment:
One agency objected to the prohibition in proposed § 630.1403(b)(3) against granting administrative leave to recognize the performance or contributions of employees. The agency felt that this provision limited an agency's ability to recognize its high performers in a cost-effective manner.

OPM response:
The provision at proposed § 630.1403(b)(3) prohibits an agency from granting administrative leave as a reward to employees but does not limit the agency's ability to grant time off as a reward under other legal authority. As OPM noted in the preamble of the proposed rule, the proper personnel authorities for recognizing the performance or contributions of employees are cash awards and time-off awards (
e.g.,
under section 4502(e) and 5 CFR 451.104).

Comment:
Another agency commented that the regulations will necessitate a change in the timekeeping for 10-month faculty at an academy as their two non-working months were recorded as administrative leave.

OPM response:
OPM agrees; these employees are in an off-duty paid status, not on administrative leave. The agency will need to work with its payroll provider for the appropriate coding under the timekeeping system.

Section 630.1404—Calendar Year Limitation

Comment:
A union asked for clarification on whether the calendar year for purposes of applying the 10-workday limit for placement on administrative leave is January 1 to December 31 or is 12 consecutive months from any day during the year. Two agencies recommended that, for consistency, administrative leave be tracked by the year used for other leave purposes. An individual said that all other leave (except military leave) is based on the leave year and that using a calendar year for administrative leave would be difficult. The individual recommended using the leave year or payroll calendar year. The same individual asked if a period of administrative leave that continues into another year counts toward the 10-workday limit for the new year. Another individual asked that OPM consider using a rolling year instead of a calendar year. Another commenter suggested that OPM's proposed rule, applying the 10-workday limitation to all administrative leave was incorrect and that it should only apply to administrative leave for investigative purposes.

OPM response:
First, OPM agrees that the 10-workday limitation in section 6329a of the Administrative Leave Act does not apply to general uses of administrative leave, but instead was meant to apply to management-initiated actions to “place” an employee on administrative leave, with or without the employee's consent, for the purpose of investigating an employee's conduct, performance, or other reasons prompting an investigation that could lead to an adverse personnel outcome. OPM is therefore modifying this aspect of its proposed rule.

Section 6329a states that: “During any calendar year, an agency may place an employee in administrative leave for a period of not more than a total of 10 work days.”
30

The language—“an agency may place”—suggests that the action to put the employee in administrative leave status is initiated and controlled by management, with or without the employee's consent. Indeed, this is the same language that Congress used to describe an employee being in investigative leave or notice leave.
31

It is plainly not the language that Congress used throughout 5 U.S.C. chapter 63 to describe other types of leave. Instead, chapter 63 uses the more obvious “grant,” and it does so with respect to multiple types of leave.
32

Also, there is a direct connection to the 10-workday annual limit in the law governing investigative leave in section 6329b. Section 6329b(b)(3)(A) bars use of investigative leave until the “expiration of the 10 workday period described in section 6329a(b)(1).” This connection supports the conclusion that the 10-workday annual limit was intended to cover the same investigations as those described in section 6329b, not more general uses of administrative leave.

30
Section 6329a(b)(1) (emphasis added).

31
Section 6329b(b)(1) (“An agency may . . . place an employee in investigative leave if the employee is the subject of an investigation; [or] notice leave if the employee is in a notice period.); Section 6329b(b)(2) (“An agency may place an employee in [investigative leave or notice leave] only if the agency has [identifying conditions]”).

32

See, e.g.,
section 6302(d) (“The annual leave . . . may be granted at any time during the year”); section 6305 (“After 24 months of continuous service . . . an employee may be granted 24 months [of home leave]); section 6310 (“The head of the agency concerned may grant leave of absence . . . to alien employees”); section 6323 (“[Military leave] granted . . . shall not exceed 22 work days.”).

Moreover, interpreting the 10-workday annual limit as applicable to more general uses of administrative leave could lead to illogical results. Take, for example, an employee who in January is placed on 10 days of administrative leave for investigatory purposes. After those 10 days, the agency determines that there is no need to place the employee on investigative leave and the employee returns to her normal work status. If the 10-day annual limitation applies to general uses of administrative leave, then, for the remainder of the year, the employee would never be able to use administrative leave—not for voting, or a blood drive, or a COVID vaccine, or any other plainly acceptable and appropriate use—because the employee had already been placed on administrative leave for investigatory purposes. OPM does not believe that Congress intended such a nonsensical result.

This understanding of the 10-workday limitation on administrative leave—that

it only applies to agency-directed placement on administrative leave for investigative purposes—not only is firmly grounded in the statutory text and structure but is also consistent with and supported by the legislative history. The House and Senate Reports indicate that the Administrative Leave Act was primarily created in response to concerns about abuse related to disciplinary proceedings. Both Reports heavily cite the 2014 GAO report specifically focused on these types of abuses. The main impetus for the Act was to address (1) inconsistent use of administrative leave among agencies and excessive use of administrative leave while conducting misconduct and disciplinary proceedings and (2) inconsistent recordkeeping which made oversight of administrative leave difficult.

The legislative history evolved over time but remained focused on administrative leave relating to employee performance, conduct, and other reasons that would prompt an investigation.

The House Report stated that H.R. 4359 “creates a standard process for the use of administrative leave in cases of misconduct and poor performance, which will help curb the overuse of administrative leave within the federal government.” It explained that, under the bill, Federal employees could not be placed on administrative leave for more than 14 days during any year for misconduct or poor performance. The House bill's “rules of construction” emphasized this point, saying “nothing in the amendment shall be construed to . . . limit the number of days that an employee may be placed on administrative leave, or any other paid non-duty status without charge to leave, for reasons unrelated to misconduct or performance.”

The Senate Report on S. 2450 cited OPM administrative leave guidance, including the four acceptable factors for granting administrative leave, but did so as background and was not critical of this guidance or the factors. The Senate bill's time cap focused on limiting an agency from placing an employee on administrative leave for a period of more than 5
consecutive
days and addressed sections 301-302, but only to say that the authority could not be used to get around this consecutive-day limitation. It also stated that agencies should not circumvent the consecutive-day cap by putting an employee on leave, taking them off, and putting them back on again. Ultimately, the language regarding the 5-day consecutive period and the reference to sections 301-302 did not make it into the final statutory language of the Administrative Leave Act. But the Senate bill's 5-day (consecutive) cap was focused on investigation-related administrative leave.

The structure of the statutory language in section 6329a—“During any calendar year, an agency may place an employee in administrative leave for a period of not more than a total of 10 work days”—resembles the language in the Senate bill: “An agency may place an employee in administrative leave for a period of not more than 5 consecutive days.” As explained further, below, section 6329b(b)(3) references this 10-day period, stating “Upon the expiration of the 10 work day period described in section 6329a(b)(1) with respect to an employee, and if an agency determines that an extended investigation of the employee is necessary, the agency may place the employee in investigative leave for a period of not more than 30 work days.” The Senate bill, S. 2450, regarding “investigative leave and notice leave” proposed a similar clause relating to investigative leave titled “Duration of leave,” which states that, “Subject to extensions of a period of investigative leave for which an employee may be eligible . . ., the initial placement of an employee in investigative leave shall be for a period not longer than 10 days.” Under S. 2450, if additional time was necessary after the “initial placement,” the employee could then be placed on extended investigative leave. This parallel structure further supports the position that the 10-day period in section 6329a was meant to apply to administrative leave for investigative purposes and that, at the expiration of that “initial placement,” if necessary, the employee would be placed on a period of investigative leave.

In sum, the best reading of the relevant 10-day provision, based on the text, structure, and legislative history, is that it applies only to agency-directed placement on administrative leave for investigative purposes, including prior to placement on investigative leave, but excluding placement on general administrative leave related to other allowable uses. Accordingly, we are revising the proposed regulations in §§ 630.1404 and 630.1504(a). As part of the revisions, we are clarifying that the bar in section 6329b(b)(3)(A)—under which investigative leave may not be used unless the 10-workday annual limit has first been met—applies only to the placement of an employee on an
initial period
of investigative leave. The bar does not apply to an extension of investigative leave under section 6329b(c) (regulated in § 630.1504(f)) or a further extension of investigative leave under section 6329b(d) (regulated in § 630.1504(g)). Thus, for example, if a particular investigation of an employee begins in one calendar year and is extended or further extended in the next calendar year, there is no requirement to use 10 workdays of administrative leave for investigative purposes before approving an extension in the next calendar year.

Section 6329a(b)(1) also requires that the “calendar year” be used for this purpose, which in common usage is January 1 to December 31. OPM does not believe that any other period was intended by Congress. Because OPM has determined that the 10-workday annual limit applies only to administrative leave for investigative purpose, such administrative leave counts only against the 10-workday limit in the year it is used. For example, a six-day continuous period (excluding non-workdays) of administrative leave split evenly over the end of 2024 and the beginning of 2025 would have 3 days applied to each year's limit.

Comment:
Three agencies, one union, and one individual opposed the requirement in proposed § 630.1404(a) that administrative leave used in different agencies must be aggregated so that an employee can be placed on administrative leave for no more than 10 workdays across agencies. One agency and the union said that the requirement to aggregate is not contained in the law. The union believed that, if Congressional intent was that this leave should be aggregated, the law would have stated the requirement differently. The union said that Congress clearly wrote the law to cover only an individual agency. One agency commented that the regulation imposes an unnecessary reporting and tracking requirement. Another agency said the requirement places an administrative burden on the new agency. A third agency noted that employees who reached their administrative leave limit because of an investigation, even though cleared, could not be granted administrative leave at the new agency. The individual believed that OPM's interpretation places an undue restriction on agencies that hire an individual who already reached the 10-day cap at the individual's former agency.

OPM
response: As explained above, OPM reads section 6329a(b)(1) as applying the 10-workday annual limit only to administrative leave in which an employee is placed for investigative purposes. Because of this determination, OPM agrees that the annual limit applies on a per-agency basis.

Otherwise, the result would not track the intent of Congress and the purpose of the statute, as it would mean that one agency may place an employee on 10 days of leave pending an investigation; but, if the employee moves to another agency, then the second agency would not have the 10 days available within the same calendar year if needed. The 10-workday annual limit was intended to allow an agency to remove an employee from the workplace in the initial stages of an investigation without having to invoke the additional procedures in section 6329b. The annual count should therefore reset when an employee moves to another Federal agency. OPM is revising § 630.1404 to make clear that the 10-workday annual limit separately is applied to each agency that employs the employee during a calendar year. OPM is not adopting proposed paragraphs (c) through (e) of § 630.1404, since those paragraphs were based on the prior interpretation that the 10-workday annual limit applied to all types of administrative leave. Also, OPM is not adopting proposed § 630.1407, which would have imposed special recordkeeping and reporting requirements for employees who transferred or separated from an agency so that a gaining agency employing the employee in the same calendar year would be able to apply the 10-workday annual limit on administrative leave. With OPM's revised reading of the 10-workday limit and its application to employees transferring agencies within a calendar year, this section is no longer applicable.

Comment:
An individual asked, in relation to the conversion of days to hours in proposed § 630.1404(b), how to determine the limit if part-time employees change their schedule in the middle of a period of administrative leave. The commenter also asked how to calculate the limitation if the change is retroactive.

OPM response:
Under this final rule, the 10-workday annual limit applies only to administrative leave for investigative purposes. While that narrows the affected population of employees, there remains a need to address the calculation of days for employees in that population who have part-time or uncommon tours of duty. The proposed regulations on the 10-workday annual limit did address such employees but did not address the scenario of an employee switching to a different type of work schedule during the calendar year. OPM is adding a new paragraph (b)(4) in § 630.1404 to provide a methodology for addressing this scenario. In general, the methodology requires converting hours of administrative leave for employees on part-time or uncommon tours of duty to their equivalent value for an employee on a full-time tour. Then the actual hours of administrative leave used as a full-time employee and the converted hours of administrative leave used as a part-time or uncommon tour employee can be summed together and the resulting sum would be applied against the 80-hour limit for full-time employees. This can be done on a retroactive basis, where the result could mean that the employee's placement on administrative leave for investigative purposes has met or exceeded the limitation and any additional leave for investigative purposes would have to comply with the requirements of section 6329b.

OPM is also adding a new paragraph (j)(4) in § 630.1504 (dealing with the 30-workday and 70-workday limits associated with investigative leave) to address the same scenario of changing work schedules by incorporating the same methodology used in § 630.1404(b)(4).

Comment:
Two unions, four agencies, and two individuals opposed the requirement in proposed § 630.1404(d) that agencies must first exhaust an employee's 10-workday limit on administrative leave before placing the employee on investigative leave. One union commented that there is no requirement in the Administrative Leave Act to first exhaust the limit on administrative leave. Both unions and two agencies noted that an employee placed on investigative leave, even though cleared during the investigation, could no longer be granted administrative leave for the remainder of the calendar year. An individual similarly thought the requirement was unfair. Another individual said there was no explanation for why administrative leave must be exhausted before investigative leave is used but not before notice leave is used. An agency said that the requirement is confusing, will be difficult to administer, and has no added value.

Additionally, a professional association said that the Act only specifies a 10-day cap on administrative leave with regard to investigative leave. The association believed the imposition of a 10-day cap on all administrative leave by the regulations would inhibit meetings between agency leaders and professional associations. Another agency asked that OPM clarify how it is not enforced leave when an agency is required to place an employee in nonpay status when the 10-workday cap is exhausted and the employee is not able to work or use leave during new administrative leave events.

OPM response:
Section 6329a(b)(1) of the Administrative Leave Act specifies that an agency may not “place” an employee on administrative leave for more than 10 workdays per calendar year. Section 6329b(b)(3)(A) expressly requires that the 10-workday period of administrative leave be exhausted before an employee can be placed in investigative leave. (There is no similar requirement regarding notice leave.) In OPM's proposed regulations, we interpreted the 10-workday annual limit in section 6329a as applying to all types of administrative leave. Based on comments received and further analysis, we have revised our reading of this section, as explained elsewhere in this preamble. These regulations provide that the 10-workday annual limit applies only to administrative leave in which an employee is placed for purposes of an investigation of an employee's conduct, performance, or other reasons prompting an investigation. We conclude that the purpose of the 10-workday annual limit is to allow an agency to commence an investigation expeditiously without the additional requirements that follow in section 6329b. This revised reading addresses various concerns raised by the commenters. For example, and as explained above, this revised reading avoids situations where employees placed on administrative leave and later cleared of any wrongdoing following an investigation are deemed nevertheless to have exhausted their available annual allotment of administrative leave.

Comment:
An agency stated that the requirement to place an employee in a leave without pay (LWOP) status may be appealed by the employee as a “constructive suspension” if the employee did not request it.

OPM response:
As explained above, OPM has revised its interpretation of section 6329a to clarify that the 10-workday annual limit only applies to administrative leave for investigative purposes. This change should address the agency's concern regarding scenarios that could lead to LWOP status, since such a status will not be triggered by the effects of these regulations.
Comment:
An agency asked if there is an exception to the 10-workday limitation that would allow employees more time to participate in Employee Assistance Program (EAP) services.

OPM response:
As explained above, OPM has revised its interpretation of section 6329a to clarify that the 10-workday annual limit applies only to administrative leave for investigative

purposes. An employee's participation in EAP services would be at the agency's discretion based on the Administrative Leave Act, these regulations, the agency's policies, and any other authorities or guidance relating to administrative leave.

Section 630.1406—Records and Reporting

Comment:
Three agencies commented that ample time is needed to modify time and attendance systems because of the new reporting requirements. A fourth agency said that WebTA will need to be revised to include the new categories of leave. One of the agencies said that the systems should have the capability for alerts when leave limits are exceeded. An individual asked if the reporting will be in hours rather than days.

OPM response:
OPM is working with agency payroll and shared service providers to prepare for the modification of current recordkeeping systems to accommodate the new data reporting requirements. As provided by the statute, agencies have 270 calendar days from the date of publication of these regulations to make the necessary changes in their recordkeeping and reporting systems. Agencies should communicate any needs for special functionality, such as alerts, to their payroll and shared service providers. Reporting of administrative leave will be by hours (or fractional increments of hours) used, not days of use.

Comment:
One agency recommended eliminating the reporting of administrative leave that is used for investigative purposes, noting the extra burden involved and arguing that the law does not require reporting this category of leave.

OPM response:
Section 6329a(c)(1)(B)(ii) requires OPM to regulate the proper recording of administrative leave. There is no exclusion for administrative leave used for investigative purposes. It is important to identify this specific usage, just as it is important to track how the other types of leave under the Act are used, especially since this type of administrative leave counts towards the 10-workday annual limit in section 6329a. OPM also anticipates Congressional interest in data on leave used specifically for investigative purposes separate from data on administrative leave used for general purposes. Therefore, we are not removing the requirement for the reporting of administrative leave used for investigative purposes.

Comment:
The same agency recommended that OPM create two new timekeeping codes—one for back pay to preclude it from being recorded as administrative leave, and another for weather and safety leave to preclude individual agencies from developing their own specific code.

OPM response:
OPM does not set the timekeeping codes used by agencies and therefore does not create these codes. Payroll and shared service providers specify the timekeeping codes to be used by their client agencies. In terms of data reporting to OPM's central payroll data system, OPM will establish data categories for the new types of leave established under the Administrative Leave Act. OPM established a payroll data category for weather and safety leave in 2018. OPM anticipates establishing a catch-all data category for paid time off granted under any authority that is not covered by any other specific payroll data category. OPM also may consider establishing data categories for other types of paid time off.

Comment:
Two unions raised concerns about the protection of employees' rights under the Privacy Act (section 552a) with respect to agency records and reports on the use of administrative leave. The unions were concerned about the possible inappropriate dissemination of recorded details regarding the purpose of the leave (
e.g.,
medical concerns) or other sensitive information. They indicated a need for additional instructions for agencies to protect employees from inadvertent or improper disclosures. One of the unions recommended that OPM provide more detailed instructions in § 630.1406 regarding the reporting requirements.

OPM response:
Any records an agency keeps on the use of administrative leave are subject to regular Privacy Act requirements. Section 630.1406 requires that usage of administrative leave under section 6329a and subpart N be recorded and reported using two subcategories: (1) administrative leave used for investigative purposes and (2) administrative leave for all other purposes. Section 630.1406 does not require the recording or reporting of additional details regarding why administrative leave was granted. However, section 1138(d)(2) of the Administrative Leave Act requires GAO provide reports to Congress every 5 years that evaluate the use of the section 6329a authority to grant administrative leave. Therefore, it is conceivable that GAO could seek additional information to the extent it is available in agency records.

Section 630.1407—Separation or Transfer

Comment:
Four agencies commented on the certification and transmittal of administrative leave records for transferring employees. One agency stated that the new procedural requirements represent a significant administrative burden for agency compliance. The agency requested clarification on the manner of certification required and recommended that ample time be provided for agencies to make changes to their automated systems. The agency also recommended that OPM change the word “one” in the first sentence to “each.” Another agency asked if OPM will update Standard Form 1150 (Record of Leave Data) to accommodate the data reporting. Two other agencies expressed concern about the ability to transfer administrative leave records without modifications to the current system.

OPM response:
OPM is not adopting the proposed § 630.1407, which had required transmittal of administrative leave records for transferring or separating employees. This change was made because OPM is clarifying that the 10-workday annual limit in section 6329a resets if an employee is transferred to a new agency.

Comment:
An individual asked how the gaining agency will know the number of administrative leave days that have been used, especially for part-time employees, if the reporting is in hours. The individual also asked about situations where a part-time employee transfers to a full-time position with another agency or a full-time employee transfers to a part-time position and more hours are used under the full-time position than the part-time position allows.

OPM response:
Administrative leave, like other forms of leave, must necessarily be used and recorded in increments of hours (or appropriate fractions of an hour). Thus, OPM's regulations provide that administrative leave must be converted to hours, considering whether the employee had a full-time, part-time, or uncommon tour of duty (§ 630.1404(b)). The proposed regulations did not address the scenario of an employee changing the type of work schedule during a calendar year, but OPM is adding a provision in the issued regulations to address this scenario. (See the new paragraph (4) in § 630.1404(b).) Because the regulations apply the 10-workday annual limit only to administrative leave for investigative purposes, the need to track hours vis-a-vis the limit

and to convert hours for employees with part-time and uncommon tours of duty is confined to uses of administrative leave for investigative purposes. We note, as described above, that the 10-workday annual limit in section 6329a resets if an employee is transferred to a new agency.

Subpart O—Investigative Leave and Notice Leave

General Comments

Comment:
An agency observed that the proposed regulations did not address how to handle active investigation cases that are ongoing at the time the subpart O regulations become effective. The agency requested guidance regarding whether employees in ongoing cases on the implementation date would (1) be placed in an initial period of 30 workdays of investigative leave or (2) be placed first on administrative leave until the 10-workday limit is exhausted and then on investigative leave.

OPM response:
An agency must revise and implement its internal policies to comply with subparts N and O within 270 days after publication of these regulations. Afterwards, use of administrative leave for investigative purposes must comply with these regulations by, first, exhausting the use of administrative leave under subpart N, followed by placing the employee on investigative leave under subpart O. The agency should not count any time an employee spent in an administrative leave status, even for investigative purposes, prior to it revising and implementing its internal policies towards the limitations established in these regulations.

Comment:
An individual presented a scenario in which an employee who holds a non-critical sensitive position loses clearance eligibility and files an appeal over such loss. There are no non-critical sensitive positions in which to place the employee pending adjudication of the employee's appeal, and since an indefinite suspension is not permissible on grounds of clearance suspension, the commenter asked how this situation would fit under the proposed rules. An agency commented that the proposed regulations do not adequately address situations in which an employee's security clearance has been revoked or suspended and they are unable to perform work without proper security clearance. Employees are therefore placed on administrative leave in adherence with adjudicative requirements and to secure information pending final determination of their appeal of the revocation or suspension. The agency stated that the proposed regulations need to provide additional clarity regarding “alternative use of administrative leave.”

OPM response:
If an
investigation
is being conducted by an
investigative entity
(as those terms are defined under § 630.1502), in connection with the suspension or revocation of a security clearance, or an appeal from such an action, and the agency completes the required determinations of § 630.1503(b), then the agency may place the employee on administrative leave for investigative purposes until the 10-workday annual limit is exhausted, and then on investigative leave. The commenter's reference to “alternative use of administrative leave” appears to refer to what the statute calls investigative leave. Based on this comment, OPM will further amend the regulatory definition of the term
investigation
at § 630.1502 to make clear that periods of time during which an appeal of a security clearance revocation or suspension is pending should be considered part of an
investigation
within the meaning of this regulatory framework. Notice leave would not be applicable until such time as the employee receives notice of a proposed adverse action. To clarify that investigative leave may only be used when an investigation is being conducted by a person or persons meeting the definition of the term
investigative entity,
OPM is amending the definition of the term
investigation
to specifically refer to “an inquiry by an investigative entity.” Separately, under this hypothetical example, an agency may seek an indefinite suspension pending a final determination once it preliminarily determines to suspend or revoke an employee's access, or eligibility for access, to classified information, in the absence of contrary provisions found in an internal agency policy or collective bargaining agreement. Investigative leave under this scenario, therefore, is not the only available option.

Comment:
An agency commented that the proposed regulations should include an additional category of leave that allows an agency to use excused absence from duty when a petition for review is pending before the Merit Systems Protection Board (MSPB or Board). Currently, if an Administrative Judge reverses or mitigates a removal action, an agency is required to place the employee back in a pay status even if the decision is appealed to the full Board for review. The agency concluded that, under the proposed regulations, an agency would be limited to using the 10 workdays of general administrative leave under subpart N and then be required to return the employee to a duty status. The agency believes that this is problematic since the employee does not meet the criteria for investigative leave or notice leave, yet it would continue to be in the best interest of the government not to have this employee in a duty status.

OPM response:
By definition, the term
administrative leave
excludes leave that is authorized under any other provision of law (section 6329a(a)(1)(B) and § 630.1402). The agency comment is describing a situation in which an Administrative Judge is providing interim relief by restoring a separated employee to employment status pending the outcome of a petition for review, as authorized under section 7701(b)(2)(A)(ii)(II) and 7701(b)(2)(B). Under those statutory provisions, the agency may determine that the return or presence of the employee at the place of employment would be unduly disruptive to the work environment. If so, the employee is entitled to receive pay while in nonduty status during that interim period as if in duty status. Since another law authorizes pay for this type of nonduty status, it would not be appropriate to use administrative leave.

Comment:
An agency asked if investigative leave counts when considering an excessive absence charge.

OPM response:
Charges and penalties for attendance-related matters are outside the scope of this regulation. OPM notes, though, that in this scenario, the employee would be placed on investigative leave by action of an agency so we would not generally consider it appropriate to include investigative leave as a basis for an excessive absence charge. Additionally, it would not be appropriate to place an employee on investigative leave pending a potential adverse action if the employee is already absent from duty and, therefore, in a leave status.

Comment:
An agency asked if OPM will issue guidance or provide further clarification on actions that take place during the investigative process—specifically, whether it is appropriate to include time preparing the investigative report and recommendations as a part of the investigative process.

OPM response:
An agency may appropriately include time spent preparing an investigative report (including recommended actions) as part of the investigation period and thus continue investigative leave during that time. Similarly, as discussed in OPM's response to a comment concerning the definition of the term
notice period
and its potential impact on settlement

agreement negotiations, an agency may appropriately keep an employee in investigation status and investigative leave status while it is deciding whether to propose and/or preparing a notice of proposed adverse action. Based on these observations, OPM has amended the definition of the term
investigation
to include time spent preparing an investigative report and recommendation(s).

Section 630.1502—Definitions

Comment:
An agency commented that the definition of the term
investigation
is overbroad and subjective. The agency stated that “an investigation is defined as alleged misconduct that could result in adverse action.” The agency further stated that it is unclear why the definition only refers to adverse actions and that the language is contradictory because there is a subsequent reference to disciplinary action.

OPM response:
The term
investigation
encompasses a variety of inquiries that could eventually result in an adverse action as well as internal probes expressly focused on whether to commence an adverse action. Those actions could include, for example, an internal probe to determine the appropriateness of continued eligibility for access to classified information, or eligibility for logical or physical access to agency systems and facilities, as well as inquiries by the agency's Inspector General, the Office of Special Counsel, or the Attorney General—focused on their areas of jurisdiction—that could eventually produce information eventually leading to an action that is adverse to the employee. OPM has modified the definition of investigation in this final rule to remove the reference to disciplinary action. Finally, the modified language used to define the term
investigation
allows for an agency to fact-find and examine under a variety of circumstances and situations.

Comment:
An agency requested clarification on the meaning of certain terms within the definition of
investigation:
specifically, “similar authority,” “other matters that could lead to disciplinary action,” and “disciplinary action.” The agency believes these terms are key to the scope of the new investigative leave provisions and, therefore, important to clarify.

OPM response:
The phrase “or similar authority” in the definition of
investigation
refers to those agencies that operate under a different statutory authority that is equivalent to 5 U.S.C. chapter 75. Those agencies take adverse actions (or their equivalents) under authorities similar to 5 CFR part 752. The phrase “other matters that could lead to disciplinary action” may include a variety of circumstances and is intentionally broad to allow for agency discretion in such situations. The term “disciplinary action” in the proposed rule refers to an agency's administrative action taken to address an employee's misconduct. Nevertheless, OPM has revised the definition of “investigation” to eliminate the term “disciplinary action” and clarify that the regulation is intended to cover all types of matters that could lead to outcomes adverse to the employee—not only adverse actions taken under chapter 75 or similar authority.

Comment:
An agency suggested the words “logical” access be changed to “logistical” access, with respect to the definition of the term
investigation.

OPM response:
The term “logical access” comes from Homeland Security Presidential Directive-12 (HSPD-12), dated August 27, 2004, and is used with respect to use of information systems.
33

It is the correct terminology in this context.

33

See
HSPD-12, ¶ 12 (“As promptly as possible . . . the heads of executive department and agencies shall, to the maximum extent practicable, require the use of identification by Federal employees and contractors that meets the Standard in gaining . . . logical access to Federally controlled information systems.”).

Comment:
A union referenced the proposed regulatory definition of the term
investigation
—specifically, the third prong, “other matters that could lead to disciplinary action.” It asked if, in situations related to the investigation of an Equal Employment Opportunity (EEO) complaint, management could use the third prong of the definition of
investigation
to retaliate against the employee for filing an EEO complaint. The union stated that there should be explicit language that would not easily allow management to consider an employee who has filed an EEO complaint to be “under investigation” and be placed on investigative leave.

OPM response:
The definition of
investigation
adequately describes the scope of the matters that may result in an inquiry by an investigative entity and the specific requested language is unnecessary. An employee's EEO complaint may result in an EEO investigation; however, that employee is not “under investigation” as a result of filing a complaint. Filing an EEO complaint is a protected right under existing statutes and there are existing laws to protect an employee from reprisal. Accordingly, this regulation does not consider the mere filing of an EEO complaint to be an action that could bring the employee under investigation, require the use of investigative leave, and lead to an adverse action.

Comment:
An agency questioned whether the term
investigative entity
includes agency attorneys under the category “other agency representatives.”

OPM response:
The definition of the term
investigative entity
provides examples of what may be considered an internal investigative unit. It is not intended to be an exhaustive list. For example, agency counsel could be considered part of an investigative unit as an agency representative if they serve in that capacity.

Comment:
An agency commented that the definition of
investigative entity
should be expanded to include external investigative units of any agency outside the agency granting investigative leave that have a role in the investigation of an employee. Agencies or investigative units outside the initial agency conducting the inquiry may be responsible for delays, including civil, criminal, or judicial proceedings that are not controlled by, or the responsibility of, the investigating agency. The agency asserted that these delays would require additional requests and approval of investigative leave beyond the initial period of 30 workdays and subsequent extensions of 30 workdays not to exceed the 90-day limit. The agency recommended that definition of
investigative entity
be amended as follows: “(1) An external federal, international, state, or local investigative authority or internal investigative unit of an agency granting investigative leave under this subpart, which may be composed of one or more persons, such as supervisors, managers, human resources practitioners, personnel security staff, workplace violence prevention team members, or other agency representatives; . . . .”

OPM response:
Section 6329b(a)(6) defines the term
investigative entity
as a limited, enumerated list of entities within the federal government. Because the Act already defines
investigative entity
in a restrictive way, OPM has determined not to expand upon this language to include “external” authorities not countenanced under the statute.

Comment:
An agency commented that the proposed definition of the term
notice period
may inhibit the ability to use notice leave in circumstances where the parties engage in negotiation of a resignation/retirement agreement, after investigative leave but prior to the agency proposing an adverse action. The agency stated that, under the proposed regulation, agencies could not place an employee on notice leave (prior to

proposing removal) and that this may eliminate or adversely impact the ability of the parties to engage in settlement negotiations (
e.g.,
regarding resignation/retirement) or at least create a gap in coverage in some circumstances while an agreement is being negotiated.

OPM response:
The agency is correct in stating that use of notice leave is restricted to the notice period. The regulation is consistent with the Act, which expressly requires that the notice period begin on the date an employee is provided notice of a proposed adverse action (section

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/fr%3A2024-29139. Public record. Not legal advice.
