# Veterans Community Care Program

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/fr%3A2019-11575

## Record

- **Collection:** Federal Register
- **Document type:** Rule
- **Published:** June 5, 2019
- **Citation:** 84 FR 26278

## Text

DEPARTMENT OF VETERANS AFFAIRS
38 CFR Part 17
RIN 2900-AQ46
Veterans Community Care Program

AGENCY:

Department of Veterans Affairs.

ACTION:

Final rule.

SUMMARY:

The Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) adopts as final a proposed rule amending its regulations that govern VA health care. This final rule implements its authority from the VA MISSION ACT of 2018 for covered veterans to receive necessary hospital care, medical services, and extended care services from non-VA entities or providers in the community.

DATES:

Effective Date:
This rule is effective on June 6, 2019.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:

Joseph Duran, Office of Community Care (10D), Veterans Health Administration, Department of Veterans Affairs, Ptarmigan at Cherry Creek, Denver, CO 80209;
Joseph.Duran2@va.gov,
(303) 370-1637. (This is not a toll-free number.)

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

On June 6, 2018, the President signed into law the John S. McCain III, Daniel K. Akaka, and Samuel R. Johnson VA Maintaining Internal Systems and Strengthening Integrated Outside Networks (MISSION) Act of 2018 (hereafter referred to as the “MISSION Act,” Pub. L. 115-182, 132 Stat. 1395, as amended). This final rule implements section 101 of the MISSION Act, which requires VA to implement a Veterans Community Care Program to furnish required care and services to covered veterans through eligible entities and providers. Section 101, which amends 38 U.S.C. 1703 upon the effective date of these final regulations, further establishes the conditions under which VA determines if covered veterans are eligible to elect to receive such care and services through eligible entities or providers, as well as other parameters of the Veterans Community Care Program. This final rule implements in a regulatory framework the requirements in amended section 1703, consistent with the mandate in section 101(c) of the MISSION Act that VA promulgate regulations to carry out the Veterans Community Care Program. For the sake of convenience and understanding, we will refer to provisions of section 1703 as it will be amended on June 6, 2019, the effective date of this final rule. We additionally clarify that throughout this final rule, the abbreviation U.S.C. or the term section will be used to indicate discussion of or reference to a statutory provision in the United States Code (
e.g.,
section 1703) or in another statute, while the abbreviation CFR or the section symbol § will be used to indicate discussion of or reference to an existing or proposed regulatory provision in the Code of Federal Regulations (
e.g.,
§ 17.4005 as proposed). There may be instances where the term section rather than the section symbol must be used at the beginning of a sentence to discuss or reference a regulatory provision, but it should be clear in the sentence that a regulatory provision is at issue. In general, any reference to a section that uses a period in it (
e.g.,
§ 17.55) is a reference to the CFR, while any reference without such a period (
e.g.,
section 1703) is a reference to the U.S.C.

VA published a proposed rule regarding the criteria for determining when covered veterans may elect to receive care and services through community health care entities or providers, as well as other parameters of the program, on February 22, 1019. 84 FR 5629. In response to this proposed rule, VA received 23,557 comments. Over 18,000 comments were duplicated form responses that expressed strong support for the overall rulemaking, with some suggestions for substantive revisions to provisions from the proposed rule. We received 1,297 comments that were unique in that they were not duplicated form responses in support of or in opposition to at least one portion of the proposed rule, although VA did consider substantive issues raised in such duplicated comments. More than 700 comments expressed support for the proposed rule, in whole or in part, without substantive comment on provisions in the proposed rule. We appreciate the support of such comments, and do not address them below. Other comments expressed support or disapproval, in whole or in part, with substantive provisions in the proposed rule, and we discuss those comments and applicable revisions from the proposed rule below. We note that the discussion below is organized by the sequential order of the provisions as presented in the proposed rule, from §§ 17.4000 through 17.4040. As many of the comments we received were related to the access standards as proposed, we alert readers that the discussion on access standards can be found under the last section header § 17.4040 in this final rule, near the end of the
Supplementary Information
section of this published document.

We make two technical corrections to the proposed revisions to §§ 17.46 and 17.55 to clarify the sunset date of these regulations as they apply to VA's community care program such that these will not apply to care furnished after June 6, 2019.

§ 17.4000, Purpose and Scope

We received over 200 comments that did not relate to specific provisions of the proposed rule, but that related to the overall effect that implementation of the Veterans Community Care Program (VCCP) would have on either: (1) The care and services that VA directly furnishes, or (2) the U.S. healthcare industry at large. We discuss these comments in the context of § 17.4000(a) as proposed, because § 17.4000(a) established that §§ 17.4000 through 17.4040 would generally implement the VCCP as authorized by 38 U.S.C. 1703.

With regard to the effects on the care and services that VA directly furnishes, commenters expressed concern that implementation of the VCCP would deplete VA's allotted budgetary resources and thereby negatively impact VA's ability to directly furnish care and services to veterans (some comments referred to this impact as the “privatization of VA”). Commenters offered multiple reasons why implementation of VCCP would negatively affect VA's direct provision of care, all stemming from the assumptions that more covered veterans would choose VA community care if access to such care were expanded, which would then create a decreased need to fund VA's direct provision of care (
i.e.,
provision of care in a VA facility). A few comments further stated that decreased funding of VA's direct provision of care would be unavoidable unless such care was funded separately from the VCCP (presumably, separately funded by Congress specifically through the Federal appropriation process). Many of these comments further argued that, rather than potentially expand the provision of non-VA care in the community through implementation of the VCCP, VA should focus on improving its own infrastructure, hiring practices, and quality of care and services it directly provides. Some of these comments additionally provided more specific suggestions for how VA could use resources required to implement the VCCP to instead improve VA's direct provision of care and services (
e.g.,
VA could hire additional specific types of providers or increase pay scales for its providers generally; or VA could open additional VA facilities, expand or improve its existing facilities, or expand sharing agreements with non-VA facilities).

We do not disagree with portions of these comments requesting that VA look

to improving its direct delivery of care and services; indeed, a portion of the proposed rule that was organized under a header titled improving VA (
see
84 FR 5629, 5645-5646) discussed how the MISSION Act will assist VA in doing so. We do not, however, make any changes to § 17.4000 or any other part of the rule as proposed based on these comments. Section 1703 requires VA to implement the VCCP and to establish the conditions under which VA would determine if covered veterans are eligible to elect to receive such care and services through eligible entities or providers (
see
sections 1703(a)(1) and (d)). Section 1703(a)(1) establishes a program to furnish hospital care, medical services, and extended care services to covered veterans through eligible entities and providers; it is VA's responsibility to implement the VCCP. Section 1703(d)(3) creates a key condition on the operation of the VCCP: that the covered veteran must elect to receive care in the community, versus through VA. This election was further identified and explained in §§ 17.4000(b), 17.4010, and 17.4020(a) as proposed. VA's obligation to implement the VCCP does not diminish VA's obligation to directly provide care and services to eligible individuals as otherwise required by title 38 U.S.C, particularly for covered veterans who are eligible for but do not elect to receive care through the VCCP or veterans who are not eligible to receive care through the VCCP. As Congress appropriates funding for VA, VA will use those resources to implement the requirements Congress has set forth. The regulatory impact analysis for this final rule and VA's budget requests identify our anticipated needs, and we will closely monitor utilization of our available resources.

With regard to the effects that implementation of the VCCP would have on the U.S. healthcare industry at large, we find such comments generally beyond the scope of the rule where they do not relate to VA's direct provision of care and services or VA's ability to maintain its other core missions. For instance, some comments asserted that covered veterans seeking non-VA care could displace non-veteran patients that rely on other Federal health care coverage (
i.e.,
Medicare or Medicaid), particularly if VA did not consider potential reductions to other Federal health care funding in developing the proposed rule. Conversely, other comments expressed concern that implementation of the VCCP could put covered veterans seeking non-VA care in the position to compete with non-veteran patients who have private insurance, because non-VA providers simply will not have the capacity to absorb covered veterans as additional patients. We do not make changes to the rule based on these comments that relate to the potential effects that VCCP implementation may have on capacity of non-VA providers to see patients, either to a covered veteran's advantage or disadvantage when compared with other patient cohorts as asserted by the comments. However, we believe that the contracts, agreements, or other arrangements VA enters with eligible entities and providers will help to ensure provider availability for covered veterans who elect to receive care through the VCCP; we have no reason to believe that the effect, if any, on non-veteran patients would be significant. We similarly do not make changes based on comments that generally argued that expansion of eligibility for VA community care could create increased consolidation of health care markets in a manner to require VA to pay higher rates for non-VA care. We do not believe our actions in implementing the VCCP will have that significant of an effect on the health care industry. According to the National Health Expenditure Data set, the United States spent $3.5 trillion on health care in 2017. By comparison, VA obligated $12.9 billion for community care in FY 2017 or 17.8 percent of total VA Medical Care spending. As for other comments that specifically noted that implementation of the VCCP could have detrimental effects on the U.S. health care industry at large because VA would not be able to maintain its core missions of research and health care provider and clinician training, VA's obligation to implement the VCCP does not diminish VA's obligation to fulfill any of its core missions as otherwise required by title 38 U.S.C.

§ 17.4005, Definitions

We received more than ten comments that either suggested revisions to or clarification of some terms defined in the proposed rule, or that requested VA define additional terms. We address these comments below as they relate to the terms in the order they were presented in § 17.4005 as proposed.

One comment requested revision of the definition of the term appointment to expressly include telehealth and same-day encounters. While we believe the definition of appointment as proposed did include telehealth and same-day encounters (by using the separately defined term schedule), we agree with the suggestion to revise the definition to expressly add these terms. The definition of appointment is therefore revised to include telehealth and same-day encounters.

A few comments requested revisions to the term covered veteran. The term covered veteran as proposed is identical to the statutory definition in section 1703(b), which is limited to veterans. We reiterate from the proposed rule that the regulations at §§ 17.4000-17.4040 do not affect other VA authorities to provide care or services for non-veterans. Therefore, VA's limited authority to furnish care or services for non-veterans is generally not affected by regulations that implement the VCCP. Other comments requested that VA add a regulatory citation to 38 CFR 17.37(c) to the definition of covered veteran, as this regulatory citation corresponds to the statutory citation 38 U.S.C. 1705(c)(2) in the definition that authorizes eligibility for certain veterans who do not have to enroll prior to receiving VA care. We agree with the commenter that providing a relevant regulatory citation for these certain veterans would make the definition more consistent, as the definition does include the regulatory citation for § 17.36 as it relates to those veterans who do have an affirmative requirement to enroll prior to receiving care. We therefore revise the definition of covered veteran to reference 38 CFR 17.37(a)-(c), which implement section 1705(c)(2) related to veterans who may receive VA care without first enrolling in VA's system of patient enrollment. We do not further revise the definition as requested to require enrollment for these certain veterans as a condition of receiving non-VA care under the VCCP, because that is not a requirement of section 1703 and believe such a revision could frustrate efforts to assist veterans transitioning from service in the Armed Forces.

One comment requested revision of the term eligible entity and provider to expressly include the standards by which VA will assess these entities and providers for adequacy, such as assessment for compliance with VA's access standards as proposed, or compliance with other Federal laws such as the Americans with Disabilities Act. We do not make changes to the definition based on this comment, as the definition itself references the relevant section related to entities and providers, § 17.4030 as proposed. We will discuss comments related to entities and providers in the section of the final rule related to § 17.4030.

In the definition of episode of care, VA's only substantive proposed change from the definition used in § 17.1505 regarding the Veterans Choice Program

was to remove the qualifying language that stated the one-year duration for the episode began from the date of the first appointment with a non-VA health care provider. We received one comment that requested we add this qualifying language back to the definition, to ensure it was clear that an episode of care included follow-up appointments and ancillary and specialty care as needed. We do not make any changes based on this comment, as the definition as proposed expressly included follow-up appointments and ancillary and specialty services.

A few comments requested revisions to the term extended care services. Some comments stated that defining the term extended care services by referencing its applicable authority at 38 U.S.C. 1710B was insufficient to indicate what services were covered under the VCCP, particularly to ensure coverage of certain extended care services that comments asserted were not covered by Medicare (such as adult day health care). Other comments more specifically stated that the definition should expressly list the types of extended care services that would be covered, with some comments further advocating for inclusion of particular services such as assisted living, or hourly nursing services provided by home health agencies. We do not make changes based on these comments. We believe the reference in the definition to section 1710B(a) is sufficient to indicate the types of extended care services covered because it does provide a specific listing of services that encompasses both institutional and non-institutional extended care services (section 1710B(a)(4), for example, references adult day health care directly). Moreover, we see two benefits to referencing the statutory authority instead of defining it further in this rule. First, such a change would allow for any amendments to the law (section 1710B) to have automatic effect on this rule, and second, VA's interpretation of that provision of law will also automatically carry over to this rule.

A few comments requested clarification of or revisions to the definition of full-service VA medical facility. One comment requested clarification of what a full-service VA medical facility was. We reiterate from the proposed rule that this term means a VA medical facility that provides hospital care, emergency medical services, and surgical care and having a surgical complexity designation of at least standard. This definition includes a note that states that VA maintains a website with a list of the facilities that have been designated with at least a surgical complexity of standard, which can be accessed on VA's website. One commenter indicated that this note was not adequately specific and should provide the exact hyperlink where this information can be found. We do not make changes based on this comment, as we do not want to create a gap in our regulations should VA's website locations change in the future. For the public's awareness, as of the publication of this final rule, this information can currently be found at
www.va.gov/health/surgery
. Another commenter stated that the definition should be revised to expressly include inpatient and outpatient mental health services to ensure that veterans (particularly in rural and remote areas) have access to such services. The definition of a full-service VA medical facility is only relevant for determinations of veteran eligibility under § 17.4010(a)(2) as proposed, which, consistent with section 1703(d)(1)(B), means that covered veterans are eligible for VCCP if they reside in a State where VA does not operate a full-service VA medical facility. Therefore, while we understand the comment's concern that not including a specific type of care in the definition would seem to affect eligibility for the VCCP, we note that veterans requiring inpatient or outpatient mental health services may be eligible under one of the other five eligibility criteria in § 17.4010(a)(1) and (a)(3) through (6) as proposed, should a facility meet the requirements of this definition for full-service medical facility but not have inpatient or outpatient mental health services. We also note that the exclusion of a listed service from the definition of full-service medical facility is not intended to indicate that such services are not available from these facilities—to the contrary, the existence of services that are included in the definition, such as surgical services, tends to indicate that such facilities are more complex medical facilities that offer many services such as mental health, primary care, and many forms of specialty care, etc.

One comment requested that VA add a new definition regarding the best medical interest of the covered veteran, to assist in clarifying this concept for the purposes of determining eligibility for the VCCP under § 17.4010(a)(5) as proposed. We do not make changes to the definitions section based on this comment, although we will address the comment's concern regarding clarification of the best medical interest eligibility criterion in our consideration of comments on § 17.4010, which discusses eligibility for the VCCP.

One comment requested clarification of the terms hospital care and medical services, specifically seeking clarification of the explanation for the terms that was provided in the preamble of the proposed rule. The preamble of the proposed rule explained these terms in part by referring to the medical benefits package at § 17.38(b), where hospital care and medical services will be provided only if determined by appropriate healthcare professionals that the care is needed to promote, preserve, or restore the health of the individual and is in accord with generally accepted standards of medical practice. We clarify, as requested by this comment, that appropriate healthcare professionals can mean both VA and non-VA providers but are not making any revisions to the regulations.

The definition of the term other health care plan contract as proposed included language that stated such contracts did not include a policy, contract, agreement, or similar arrangement pursuant to 10 U.S.C. chapter 55, which is the authority for the Department of Defense TRICARE healthcare and insurance program. One comment requested a revision to this definition to remove the exclusion related to 10 U.S.C. chapter 55, to permit VA to bill TRICARE for non service-connected care provided under the VCCP. This comment asserted that VA was not legally barred from treating TRICARE as a health care plan contract for purposes of collecting reasonable charges for care or services furnished under 38 U.S.C. 1729. We do not make changes based on this comment, because we do not agree that section 1729 permits this practice. The plain language of the statute does not support the conclusion that VA may seek recovery from another Federal entity under section 1729. Specifically, TRICARE is another Federal program and, as such, does not meet the definition of “health plan contract” under section 1729(i)(1)(A). Additionally, while the definition of “third party” in section 1729(i)(3) includes a “State or political subdivision of a State[,]” it does not include “a Federal entity.” Moreover, case law does not support the conclusion that VA may seek recovery from another Federal entity under section 1729. In
United States
v.
Capital Blue Cross,
the United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit found that by excluding other Federal programs, such as Medicare, from the reach of section 1729, Congress avoided the “inefficient procedure of having one

arm of the federal government reimburse the another.” 992 F.2d 1270, 1275 (3d Cir. 1993). Finally, the legislative history of 38 U.S.C. 1729 does not support the conclusion that VA may seek recovery from another Federal entity under section 1729. See,
e.g.,
H. Rep. 99-300, (finding that no reimbursement could be obtained from Medicare or Medicaid by VA). We note that this discussion of what is permissible under section 1729 does not prevent VA from billing DoD under agreements that control the exchange of services under 38 U.S.C. 8111.

One comment requested a revision to the term residence to add language that would clarify a residence as the place the covered veteran stays on the date of the appointment. We do not make changes based on this comment, as we believe the definition as proposed, which defines a residence as where the covered veteran is staying at the time they want to receive care or services, provides for the same outcome without requiring constant monitoring by VA or updates by covered veterans. A few comments communicated that individuals who maintain more than one residence (the most common example provided was maintaining a different residence in a warmer climate during winter months, to accommodate health issues) can experience difficulties with receiving non-VA care. These comments did not suggest changes to any of the criteria or provisions in the proposed rule, so we are not making any changes as a result. We believe it is sufficient to state that the term residence in § 17.4005 as proposed does not preclude covered veterans from maintaining more than one residence at a time, but a covered veteran may have one residence at a time. Such residence is assessed in accordance with where the individual is physically staying at the time the care or services are needed.

A few comments requested that VA add a definition of unusual or excessive burden, to clarify how this term is used in the assessment of whether the best medical interest eligibility criterion is met under § 17.4010(a)(5)(vii) as proposed. We do not make changes based on these comments. This term has qualifying language in § 17.4010(a)(5)(vii)(A)-(E) that we believe is sufficient to inform these determinations, and we will address this qualifying language as raised by comments more specifically in the section of this rule that discusses eligibility.

One comment requested that VA add a definition for the term VA care coordination team to provide examples of VA staff or clinicians who comprise such a team. This comment requested this definition be added because it was used in the preamble of the proposed rule to provide an example of assessing when a covered veteran might be eligible for VCCP under § 17.4010(a)(1) as proposed, or eligibility when no VA facility offers the care or services needed. We do not make changes based on this comment. This term was used in the preamble of the proposed rule to help provide background on the types of individuals who might assist a covered veteran with understanding whether VA facilities at large might not offer certain services (such as full obstetrics care), but this term is not material to determinations of eligibility under § 17.4010(a)(1) and is not used in the regulatory text, so its addition would be superfluous.

One comment stated that the term VA facility as defined in the proposed rule was too broad to be useful for veterans to distinguish between VA facilities, and suggested that VA should instead use: The term center for non-medical facilities; the term hospital for full-service facilities; and the term clinic for all medical service facilities that are not full-service. We reiterate from the proposed rule that the term VA facility references the types of care a facility provides (
i.e.,
hospital care, medical services, or extended care services), rather than designations of VA facilities (such as a VA medical center, or community-based outpatient clinic), to ensure that any future re-designations of VA facility types would not result in a gap in our regulations. If the public is interested in how VA currently defines the scope of services available at different facility types, Veterans Health Administration (VHA) Handbook 1006.02, VHA Site Classifications and Definitions, should be instructive and is available online. Additionally, we clarify that this term is relevant for determinations of eligibility under § 17.4010, and that such determinations can only be consistently made with a broad definition that references the types of care a facility provides rather than the designation of a facility.

Lastly, one comment requested that the term VA medical service line be revised to mean a clinic within a Department medical center, to ensure that entire clinics could be designated as underperforming as needed. While the commenter's suggestion would match the definition in section 1703(o)(2), it would not clarify the meaning of that phrase for purposes of this regulation, as we believe the proposed definition does. The term clinic, in the context of health care, can have several different meanings. Merriam-Webster, for example, defines a clinic in the context of health care as a facility (as of a hospital) for diagnosis and treatment of outpatients, as well as a group practice in which several physicians work cooperatively. Merriam-Webster online,
https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/clinic.
The Cambridge English Dictionary, alternatively, defines a clinic as a building or part of a hospital where people go for medical care or advice. Cambridge Dictionary online,
https://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/clinic.
We believe these definitions reflect the common understandings of the term clinic, as well as the ambiguity in that term. In some contexts, a clinic is a physical structure, and in others it is an organizational component of a larger institution. We believe in the context of section 1703(o)(2) that the latter interpretation is more reasonable, as it would be illogical for Congress to define the term VA medical service line to mean a physical structure within a larger physical structure. The very term service line also reinforces conceptually that this authority is limited to a group practice in which several physicians or clinicians work cooperatively. VA policy also repeatedly uses the term service line to refer to specific practice areas, such as cardiology, radiology, oncology, and others. Each service line has different applicable access standards or standards for quality for the purposes of assessing underperformance under § 17.4015 as proposed, which could serve as a basis for eligibility for a covered veteran to participate in VCCP under § 17.4010(a)(6) as proposed. In this context, the definition of VA medical service line as proposed, to be limited to a service or set of services within a Department medical center, is more consistent with the general meaning of the term, provides clarity as to the intended effect of this provision, and more appropriately captures those types of services that are actually underperforming and not other services that could in fact be excelling. We note that it is theoretically possible, however, for all VA medical service lines within a clinic to be designated (depending on the organization of that clinic, and the assessment of such medical service lines against VA's standards, etc.), although we believe it would be unlikely that this would actually happen.

§ 17.4010, Veteran Eligibility

We received over 18,000 comments concerning the criteria under which VA determines a covered veteran may elect

to receive care and services under the VCCP. We address these comments below in the order in which they raise issues related to provisions in paragraphs (a)(1) through (6) of § 17.4010 as proposed. We note at the outset that the comments we received related to eligibility based on designated access standards in § 17.4010(a)(4) as proposed we be addressed in the section of this document that discusses § 17.4040 where such comments raised particular substantive issues related to the access standards. We will only discuss access standards in relation to § 17.4010 below where comments raised broad versus specific concerns regarding VA's establishment of such standards. We also note that a majority of these comments are the result of a duplicated form letter, within which at least one of the eligibility criteria from § 17.4010 as proposed was discussed.

We did not receive any comments that suggested changes to § 17.4010(a)(1) as proposed, regarding a covered veteran being eligible to receive care and services under the VCCP if no VA facility offered such care or services. However, some comments seemed to assert that this criterion could be unduly limiting if it was interpreted in a manner that barred eligibility if a single VA facility offered such care or services. One comment further requested clarification as to whether the access-related eligibility criterion in § 17.4010(a)(4) as proposed would apply if the criterion in § 17.4010(a)(1) was not met. We clarify, by reiterating from the proposed rule, that the criterion in § 17.4010(a)(1) will not be used to limit access to community care in instances where a single VA facility offers the care or services required; in such a case, covered veterans will be assessed under one of the other five eligibility criteria in § 17.4010(a)(2) through (6), for instance, the access-related criterion in § 17.4010(a)(4). The criterion in § 17.4010(a)(1) will function as a unique qualifier for covered veterans that need certain types of care that VA simply does not provide in any of its facilities (such as full obstetrics care), and any covered veteran requiring such care or services would not have to be assessed any further under other proposed eligibility criteria for community care. We do not make any changes based on these comments.

We received some comments related to § 17.4010(a)(2), regarding a covered veteran being eligible to receive care and services under the VCCP if there is not a full-service VA medical facility in the State in which the veteran resides. One comment seemed to oppose this criterion, asserting that this eligibility criterion was inappropriate because it did not consider full-service facilities across state lines that may be accessible to veterans. Another comment seemed to support this criterion, but also asserted that it was not appropriate because it did not consider that in-state transit times vary by State. We clarify that the criterion in § 17.4010(a)(2) is an assessment of VA facility locations within States, and does not consider transit times to facilities, in accordance with section 1703(d)(1)(B). This criterion is consistent with the statute, as well as prior VA practice in the Veterans Choice Program. We do not make changes based on these comments.

A few comments asserted that VA should not eliminate the 40-mile distance eligibility criterion from the former Veterans Choice Program. We interpret these comments to be expressing concern with the limited grandfathering provision in § 17.4010(a)(3)(ii) as proposed, where the 40-mile criterion will be carried forward indefinitely for some, but not all, covered veterans. We reiterate from the proposed rule that the 40-mile grandfathering provision is consistent with 38 U.S.C. 1703(d)(1)(C), where such eligibility is carried forward indefinitely for only those covered veterans that reside in Alaska, Montana, North Dakota, South Dakota, or Wyoming and meet additional criteria. Any covered veterans who do not reside in one of these States can only be considered to have grandfathered eligibility related to the 40-mile criterion until June 6, 2020. We therefore do not make any changes based on these comments, although we note that other VCCP eligibility criteria may apply for covered veterans after June 6, 2020, even if they do not reside in the States identified for the indefinite grandfathering provision.

Some comments objected to VA establishing any eligibility based on access standards under § 17.4010(a)(4) as proposed, suggesting instead that VA community care should not have any qualifying limitations related to VA's assessment of access. We do not make any changes to § 17.4010(a)(4) based on these comments. Congress authorized veterans to elect to receive community care if VA was unable to furnish care or services in a manner that complies with VA's designated access standards under section 1703(d)(1)(D). Congress further authorized the Secretary to establish access standards under section 1703B. As explained in the proposed rule, as well as our report to Congress, the Secretary is exercising his authority to establish and designate access standards for purposes of eligibility. We reiterate that we will discuss comments related to the substantive criteria of the access standards themselves from in the section related to § 17.4040 later in this document.

We received many comments related to the best medical interest criterion in § 17.4010(a)(5) as proposed. While some comments merely sought clarification of this criterion, others asserted that the covered veteran and his or her non-VA provider did not have enough control in determining when the criterion could be met, and that a determination by a non-VA provider that the criterion was met should not be subject to VA's review or approval (specifically, over 18,000 comments received were duplicate form requests that VA should not administratively or clinically review such determinations from non-VA providers). Conversely, other comments asserted that VA must retain review and approval for best medical interest determinations, or even prevent such determinations from being made by non-VA providers. Other comments more specifically suggested that certain conditions should be found to create eligibility under this criterion. For instance, some comments argued generally that a covered veteran's dissatisfaction with care they received directly from VA in the past should meet the criterion of best medical interest. Other comments suggested that certain conditions or factors should be considered to constitute an unusual or excessive burden as assessed under the best medical interest criterion in § 17.4010(a)(5)(vii), such as a veteran requiring oxygen to travel, or a veteran having experienced military sexual trauma.

We first address the issue within the comments concerning the level of review or approval that may be required to find that a determination of best medical interest has been met for purposes of eligibility for VCCP. These comments offered opposing interpretations of whether VA review or approval would (or should) be required to find that a determination of best medical interest had been met. We believe these opposing interpretations in the comments are due to an inconsistency between the preamble explanation for § 17.4010(a)(5) as published in the proposed rule and the regulation text at § 17.4010(a)(5) as proposed. The preamble of the proposed rule contained language that qualified a determination of best medical interest in § 17.4010(a)(5), by stating that such a determination must be for the purpose of the veteran achieving improved clinical outcomes by receiving the care or services in the community versus

from a VA health care provider. In turn, the preamble of the proposed rule further explained that the factors in § 17.4010(a)(5)(i)-(vii) as proposed would be considered in the context of clinical decision making (where the referring clinician could be either a VA or a non-VA clinician) to assess whether improved clinical outcomes would likely be achieved by receiving care in the community.

Although the preamble explained that the qualifying language related to a veteran's improved clinical outcomes would be in § 17.4010(a)(5) as proposed, it was inadvertently omitted by VA in the regulation text for § 17.4010(a)(5). We clarify that VA intended for this qualifying language to be in § 17.4010(a)(5) as proposed to allow VA to retain the ability to conduct a review of a best medical interest determination made by a non-VA or a VA provider if such determination did not appear to meet the standard for achieving improved clinical outcomes. To clarify this intent, we revise § 17.4010(a)(5) to add the qualifying language as stated from the preamble of the proposed rule that best medical interest determinations are made for the purpose of the veteran achieving improved clinical outcomes. We believe this revision effectuates VA's intent as evidenced in the preamble of the proposed rule. While we realize that this revision does not establish an absolute VA review of best medical interest determinations, and does not remove VA's review of these decisions as suggested in some comments, we reiterate from the preamble of the proposed rule that an assessment of best medical interest under § 17.4010(a)(5) is a clinical decision, and as such is made on a case by case basis depending on the individual circumstances of a covered veteran, to be guided by the factors further established in § 17.4010(a)(5)(i)-(vii). We believe that it is neither veteran-centric nor administratively feasible for VA to regulate an absolute requirement to review all determinations of best medical interest from non-VA or VA providers. We do not make changes to add certain specific qualifying conditions to § 17.4010(a)(5) in response to comments that requested VA consider specific conditions as meeting the best medical interest criterion (as raised earlier, conditions such as a veteran requiring oxygen to travel, or a veteran having experienced military sexual trauma). We believe that the language in § 17.4010(a)(5)(i)-(vii) is comprehensive to permit appropriate clinical decisions on a case by case basis without being overly specific or restrictive.

We received a few comments that requested clarification of how VA would distinguish between a best medical interest determination that may simply be for the convenience of the veteran (which was not permitted under § 17.4010(a)(5) as proposed), and a determination of best medical interest based on an unusual or excessive travel burden (which was permitted under § 17.4010(a)(5)(vii)). One comment further requested clarification of whether the undue or excessive burden determination was clinical in nature, and whether it could relate to the drive time access standard. To address the request to clarify when the undue or excessive burden factors in § 17.4010(a)(5)(vii)(A)-(E) might be met, we will not make changes from the proposed rule, but we clarify that VA will work to develop guidance for VA staff (that can be made available to VA and non-VA providers) regarding how VA will interpret the factors to ensure there is a consistent understanding of how the undue or excessive burden considerations are assessed and applied. As a general example, a covered veteran who requires physical therapy multiple times a week in relation to a neck injury might be considered eligible under the criterion in § 17.4010(a)(5)(vii)(C), if the veteran's injured neck is a medical condition that affects his or her ability to travel even short distances. In such a case, it would not be for the mere convenience of this veteran to be seen in the community at a location that would be closer to their residence.

We further clarify, without making changes to § 17.4010(a)(5)(vii), that the unusual or excessive burden assessment would ultimately be a clinical determination, as we previously clarified that the overarching best medical interest criterion is met when it is clinically determined that a covered veteran could be expected to experience improved clinical outcomes. Lastly, we clarify without changes that the unusual and excessive burden factors in § 17.4010(a)(5)(vii)(A)-(E) are independent of the access standard eligibility in § 17.4010(a)(4) and the standards themselves in § 17.4040; the undue and excessive burden factors might qualify a veteran for VCCP, even if the access standard related to average drive time might not be met. For example, a covered veteran could require daily dialysis care that could be furnished at a VA facility that is 29 minutes away from the veteran's residence by average drive time. If VA could furnish the care within the wait-time standard in § 17.4040, this veteran would not qualify under § 17.4010(a)(4). However, given the need for daily travel and the effect of travel for nearly an hour in transit every day, the veteran and the provider could determine it is in the best medical interest of the veteran to receive this daily dialysis care through the VCCP at a non-VA facility that is only a five-minute average drive from the veteran's home.

We received one comment related to § 17.4010(a)(6) as proposed, regarding a covered veteran being eligible to receive care and services under the VCCP if VA determined that a VA medical service line that would furnish the care or services the veteran requires is not providing such care or services in a manner that complies with VA's standards for quality. This comment asserted that VA should revise this eligibility criterion to be discretionary and not mandatory, to be consistent with 38 U.S.C. 1703(e), which is the statutory provision related to discretionary eligibility based on a finding that a VA medical service line is not providing care that complies with the standards for quality VA further establishes under section 1703C. We agree section 1703(e) authorizes and does not mandate the furnishing of care when VA medical service lines are underperforming, but we do not read our regulations in §§ 17.4010(a)(6) and 17.4015 as proposed to collectively to eliminate that discretion. Section 17.4015 permits, but does not require, the Secretary to identify underperforming VA medical service lines. It further permits the Secretary to establish limitations or conditions on the ability of veterans to elect to receive care and services in the community. If the Secretary makes a determination under § 17.4015 and identifies underperforming VA medical service lines and the conditions under which covered veterans seeking care or services from such a medical service line can elect to receive care in the community, then § 17.4010(a)(6) would apply and covered veterans could elect to receive care or services in the community consistent with the Secretary's determination. Sections 17.4010(a)(6) and 17.4015 therefore effectively preserve the discretionary nature of section 1703(e). We will address comments related to the establishment of or notice procedures for VA's standards for quality in the portion of the final rule that discusses § 17.4015.

We received one comment that requested clarification of VA's rationale to require a covered veteran to submit to VA information related to a change in the veteran's address in § 17.4010(b) as

proposed, and information on any other health-care plan contract under which the veteran is covered prior to obtaining authorization for care and services the veteran requires. We reiterate from the proposed rule that this information is required so that VA may make accurate eligibility determinations under § 17.4010(a)(2)-(6) that rely on a veteran's place of residence, and so that VA can continue to recover or collect reasonable charges for care and services furnished in the community for a non-service connected disability from a health plan contract, consistent with section 1703(j). We further note that veterans are required to submit information regarding other health insurance under section 1705A. Related to this comment concerning the provision of information by the covered veteran, one comment asserted that VA should make VCCP use conditional on the covered veteran's acceptance of an automatic release of their medical information to non-VA providers. The commenter asserted that this was necessary because it was inefficient to require veterans to authorize individual releases of their medical information, or to rely on non-VA providers to attest that records were received. We do not make changes based on this comment. VA currently has the authority to release veteran medical information for treatment purposes without the written consent or authorization of the veteran under applicable statutes and their implementing regulations (see 38 U.S.C. 7332(b)(2)(H)). Therefore, there is no need to require veterans to authorize individual releases of their medical information if a veteran is receiving treatment using VCCP.

Section 17.4010(d) as proposed established that eligibility determinations for covered veterans to receive hospital care, medical services, or extended care services through the VCCP would be subject to VA's clinical appeals process, and not be appealable to the Board of Veterans Appeals. We received some comments that suggested these eligibility decisions should be appealable to the Board. We make no changes based on these comments, as section 1703(f) expressly provides that these eligibility decisions be subject to VA's clinical appeals process and not be appealable to the Board of Veterans' Appeals. Other comments did not request revisions to § 17.4010(d) per se, but did suggest that VA's appeals process should be comprehensive, and more specifically that VA should develop a unique process within its clinical appeals process, to ensure that individuals adjudicating the VCCP eligibility determinations are not the same VA facility or VISN staff that made the initial eligibility determinations. We clarify that VA's current clinical appeals process can be found in VHA Directive 1041, Appeal of VHA Clinical Decisions, which can be found on VA's website and provides for a comprehensive process of appealing clinical decisions that includes elevating disputes beyond initial staff-level determinations.

Lastly, one comment raised several concerns about different provisions discussed in the proposed rule that potentially related to eligibility, based on several assertions: First, the comment asserted that VA's proposed rule would limit eligibility for VA community care to only certain service-connected veterans, or veterans with only certain discharges from active service; second, the comment asserted that the rule would limit eligibility for care for a recently discharged veteran to 12 months; and third, the comment asserted that veterans should be treated for service connected disabilities regardless of their character of discharge. All of the provisions cited in this comment refer to other provisions of law unaffected by VA's rule, namely § 17.46 (concerning the first issue identified above), which we are making no longer effective; section 1705(c)(2), which authorizes VA to furnish care notwithstanding a veteran's failure to enroll (concerning the second issue identified above); and section 5303(a), which statutorily limits VA's ability to furnish benefits to certain persons. Because these authorities are either being made ineffective through this rule (in the case of § 17.46) or are statutes that were unaffected by this rule (in the case of section 1705(c)(2) and section 5303(a)), we do not make changes based on this comment.

§ 17.4015, Designated VA Medical Service Lines

We received over 25 comments concerning the process by which VA would designate those VA medical service lines that were not able to furnish care or services in a manner that complied with VA's standards for quality, so that covered veterans who would receive care or services through such VA medical service lines would be eligible for the VCCP. We address these comments below in the order in which they raise issues related to the provisions in paragraphs (a)-(e) of § 17.4015 as proposed.

As a general matter, one comment suggested that any proposal to eliminate entire service lines at VA facilities should not be implemented. We clarify that no provision in the proposed rule sought to eliminate VA medical service lines at VA facilities. Section 17.4015 as proposed sought to establish criteria by which VA would assess VA medical service lines within its facilities to determine if they were underperforming. If such medical service lines were so identified, then § 17.4010(a)(6) as proposed would allow covered veterans to elect to receive the care or services they would have received under those underperforming VA medical service lines through the VCCP. We do not make any changes to the proposed rule based on this comment. We note that section 1706A, as added by section 109 of the MISSION Act, expressly requires remediation of any VA medical service lines identified under this criterion, and as we discussed near the conclusion of the preamble to the proposed rule, VA's remediation efforts will not be limited to just those medical service lines designated under § 17.4015. These remediation efforts are intended to bolster and support VA's medical service lines.

We received multiple comments related to § 17.4015(a) as proposed, concerning VA's basic parameters for identifying its underperforming medical service lines. First and most generally, one comment requested that VA revise paragraph (a) to make this provision mandatory by using the word “shall” instead of “may”; in the alternative, the commenter suggested that VA must otherwise clarify if it interprets the quality monitoring mandates imposed by section 1703(e) and 1703C to be optional. We do not make changes based on this comment and clarify that not all provisions in the MISSION Act require VA to take action. VA used the term “may” in § 17.4015(a) as proposed because VA is not required, and may be practically unable, to identify any VA medical service line as underperforming, and consequently, it may be the case that no covered veterans qualify for community care under this criterion. We also, as noted above, allow the Secretary to place conditions or limitations on the ability of covered veterans to elect to receive care under this criterion.

One comment requested that VA revise § 17.4015(a) to provide for a comparison of timeliness between VA and non-VA medical service lines, as this comparison of timeliness is not expressly prevented by section 1703 or 1703C. We do not make changes based on this comment, as the comparison of timeliness between only VA medical services lines is consistent with section 1703(e)(1)(B)(i). We further note,

however, that § 17.4015(a) identifies timely care as the first domain of care, and hence the timeliness of care with non-VA service lines would be considered indirectly.

We received multiple comments related to VA's standards for quality themselves, a majority of which we interpret as beyond the scope of the proposed rule because such standards are to be established and announced via a separate process in the
Federal Register
, as stated in the proposed rule. However, we summarize those comments here as they could be interpreted to apply to § 17.4015(a) as proposed, and that paragraph's express statements of using VA's standards for quality to determine when VA medical service line are underperforming. Multiple comments argued that VA should not use VA's standards for quality, but rather should use existing industry standards related to quality monitoring (such as the National Committee for Quality Assurance's Healthcare Effectiveness Data and Information Set, or Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services Merit-Based Incentive Payment System), versus developing VA-based quality measures as indicated in § 17.4015(a) as proposed. One comment more specifically requested that VA revise § 17.4015(a) accordingly to reflect that VA will use industry standards for quality. Conversely, other comments suggested that there seemed to be a deficiency of reliable data available to VA that is related to quality measures or metrics concerning non-VA providers; one comment further stated that until non-VA providers are able to produce comparative data to be used in assessing VA medical service lines, VA should only use its data to identify and remediate its medical service lines. Other comments more specifically recommended that VA use its existing tools such as VA's Strategic Analytics for Improvement and Learning tool to identify its underperforming service lines. Some of these comments further stated that VA should consider unique veteran populations when developing standards, with one comment requesting that VA require vascular surgery quality outcomes to be assessed to ensure non-VA outcomes match VA outcomes. Other comments did not suggest a particular approach regarding the use of VA or non-VA quality measures, but rather requested clarification of what quality measures or metrics VA would use. We do not make changes to § 17.4015(a) based on these comments, but we reiterate from the proposed rule that VA's standards for quality will be announced through a separate document published in the
Federal Register
as set forth in § 17.4015(c) as proposed. We do note that VA's proposed standards for quality, as submitted to Congress in a report earlier this year, focused on the framework for quality identified by the National Academy of Medicine.

We did not receive any comments on § 17.4015(b) as proposed and are not making any changes from the language we proposed.

We received a few comments related to VA providing notice of its standards for quality once established, as well as comments on other provisions set forth in § 17.4015(c) as proposed. At the outset, we note that multiple comments urged VA to publicly release VA's report detailing its standards for quality that was submitted to Congress on March 4, 2019. We do not make changes to § 17.4015(c) based on this comment, as we believe § 17.4015(c) makes adequate provision for public notice of the standards of quality.

Section 17.4015(c) as proposed contained language to establish potential limitations of when and where covered veterans could receive qualifying non-VA care and services at their election based on VA's identification of its underperforming medical service lines. These possible limitations on receiving qualifying non-VA care included a limitation by defined geographic area. We received one comment that stated this language implied that VA will interpret its standards for quality based on a regional geographic standard versus a national standard and asked that VA clarify whether this is the case. We clarify that while VA will have national standards for quality, VA's quality comparisons will generally be based on care that is locally available and not on national averages. It would be of little use to patients in a particular area or region to have VA care that is locally available to them compared to care that is not locally available. The language in § 17.4015(c) related to limitations (including the limitation based on geographic area) therefore serves to alert covered veterans that the qualifying non-VA care they may elect to receive may be limited in its location, in the type of care that may be received, etc., as it would be offered as an option to the specific care that would be designated in the specific VA medical service line that VA would have identified as underperforming. We do not make changes based on this comment.

A few comments requested clarification of whether direct notice to covered veterans of underperforming VA medical service lines, as set forth in § 17.4015(c) as proposed, would include other than electronic communication (to include notification by mail, phone, etc., as well as a
Federal Register
document). A related comment requested that VA ensure non-VA providers are provided the direct notice VA would conduct when making determinations under § 17.4015(c) on VA medical service lines. We do not make changes based on these comments. We reiterate from the proposed rule that VA will take reasonable steps to provide direct notice to covered veterans affected under this section to include written correspondence, electronic messages, or direct contact (in person or by phone). We do not believe it necessary to regulate VA's notice to community providers.

A few comments requested that VA revise § 17.4015(d) as proposed to permit VA to identify more than three underperforming VA medical service lines and more than 36 underperforming VA medical service lines nationally. One comment stated that there should be no limit on the number of designated VA medical service lines per facility or the total number nationally that could be designated as underperforming, and one comment urged VA to seek a legislative fix to allow VA to designate more than 36 VA medical service lines nationally. We do not make changes based on these comments, as VA is limited by statute to designating no more than three service lines per facility and 36 service lines nationally, in accordance with section 1703(e)(1)(C). As the comment indicates, any resolution to allow more than the permitted number of VA medical service lines to be designated would require Congressional action and therefore is beyond the scope of the proposed rule.

Multiple comments raised issues related to the factors VA would consider when determining whether its medical services lines would be identified as underperforming, as set forth in § 17.4015(e) as proposed. One comment noted that VA should limit comparison of underperforming VA medical service lines against only similarly underperforming non-VA medical service lines (and further, only those non-VA underperforming medical service lines that are accessible to covered veterans), to ensure that a covered veteran would not have the option to choose to receive lower quality care from a non-VA medical service line than a VA medical service line. Another comment asserted that VA must consider whether non-VA medical

service lines would be able to provide the same type of care or better care before designating a VA medical service line as underperforming. We interpret these comments to be related to § 17.4015(e)(1) as proposed, as the general paragraph that would establish whether differences in performance between VA and non-VA medical service lines were clinically significant. We do not make any changes to § 17.4015(e)(1) based on these comments. The language in § 17.4015(e)(1) provides that VA will compare performance of its medical service lines against the performance of non-VA medical service lines to identify VA deficiencies. By the time VA is determining whether the differences in performance are clinically significant, it will have already assessed the quality of VA's medical service and non-VA medical service lines and identified that there is in fact a difference. We also reiterate from the proposed rule that the language related to clinical significance in § 17.4015(e)(1) would allow VA to appropriately discern differences in performance between VA and non-VA medical service lines to determine if VA medical service lines were underperforming. Determinations regarding performance will be made locally and should generally result in veterans being able to access better quality care in the community than they would receive from service lines designated as underperforming.

We received a few comments related to the factor in § 17.4015(e)(2) as proposed, that VA would consider the likelihood and ease of remediation of the medical service line within a short timeframe when determining whether it was underperforming. We reiterate from the proposed rule that the intent of this factor is to allow VA to designate as underperforming those medical service lines in need of the kind of intensive remediation envisioned by section 1706A, and not necessarily those medical services lines where a simple action (such as the purchase of new equipment) is likely to occur and would be sufficient to remediate underperformance. One comment requested that VA revise this factor in § 17.4015(e)(2) to permit a temporary designation of a VA medical service lines that may only require simple actions likely to occur in a short timeframe, to prevent scenarios in which veterans would receive what the comment asserted would be substandard care even if on a temporary basis. We do not make changes based on this comment. We do not agree with the comment's equating of potential temporary underperformance of a VA medical service line with delivery of substandard care. Further, we reiterate from the proposed rule that § 17.4015(e)(2) is necessary to allow VA to be selective in engaging in remediation that will require allocation of VA resources. We further note that, in such temporary situations, covered veterans might still be eligible to receive care in the community under the best medical interest criterion in § 17.4010(a)(5), which may provide more nimble and timely access to care than the designation of a VA medical service line under § 17.4015. A related comment requested clarification of the effect of the factor in § 17.4015(e)(2), more specifically whether VA intended this factor to be used to identify only those medical service lines that could be remediated easily. We clarify that this is not the intent of § 17.4015(e)(2); to the contrary, we reiterate from above that this factor should allow VA to designate as underperforming those VA medical service lines in need of the kind of intensive remediation envisioned by section 1706A, and not necessarily those services lines where a simple action is likely to occur and would be sufficient to remediate underperformance. As other commenters noted, VA is limited to the number of VA medical service lines it can designate nationally and at any particular facility. It would be a poor use of this authority to waste one of those limited opportunities to designate a VA medical service line that could be improved easily and quickly.

We received one comment that requested VA provide more information on why data that may be required to assess the performance of VA and non-VA medical service lines could take as long as 18-24 months to collect or analyze, particularly if such data may already be collected by VA related to the performance of its medical service lines. The comment further urged VA to take steps to shorten this timeframe, to prevent scenarios where a covered veteran may receive what the commenter deemed sub-standard care for an extended time while VA determines whether its medical service lines are underperforming. We believe this comment is referring to the portion of the proposed rule that explained § 17.4013(e)(3), which is the factor that would permit VA to consider recent trends concerning a VA or non-VA medical service line when determining if a VA medical service line is underperforming. The preamble of the proposed rule provided that the process to gather, analyze, and verify quality data could take as long as 18-24 months, and for this reason VA needed a factor that would permit it to consider more contemporaneous information to determine whether one of its medical service lines was underperforming. These data are inherently time-lagged, as much of the data we use is collected and reported by other entities (such as Medicare). Moreover, it may take months to collect enough data to support valid conclusions; small sample sizes are inherently unreliable, and if a particular VA medical service line simply does not furnish care to that many patients, it could take some time to generate enough cases to produce reliable results that would be actionable. We again reiterate, though, that covered veterans could still access care in the community under any of the five other eligibility criteria in § 17.4010, including the best medical interest criterion under § 17.4010(a)(5). We believe that § 17.4015(e)(3) as proposed actually resolves the concern in the comment, because it expressly allows VA to consider contemporaneous information, and we make no changes based on this comment.

We received one comment that urged VA to remove the designation factor in § 17.4015(e)(6) as proposed, related to considering the effect that designating a VA medical service lines would have on other VA medical service lines. The comment characterized this factor as a loophole that would allow underperforming VA medical service lines to avoid designation, due to the negative effects such designation would have on other medical services lines. We disagree with the comment's characterization of this factor. We do, however, maintain that this factor is critical to allow VA to be selective in its designations, particularly for medical service lines whose designation may be more vastly disruptive, both to other VA medical service lines and other programs, than we believe is the intent of identifying any underperforming VA medical service lines under section 1703(e) generally. We do not make changes based on this comment.

We received a few comments that did not seem clearly related to any of the factors in § 17.4015(e)(1)-(6) as proposed, but that suggested clarifications or potential changes to § 17.4015(e) based on particular services or particular veteran populations. One comment requested that VA clarify to what extent extended care services could be an underperforming medical service line, and another comment urged VA to consider the unique needs of women veterans in designating VA medical service lines as

underperforming. We do not make changes to § 17.4015(e) based on these comments but do clarify that the rule does not place any limitations on what type of VA medical service lines may be designated, so such VA medical service lines could be those that provide extended care services (
e.g.,
geriatrics) if VA finds them to be underperforming. Additionally, we believe that § 17.4015(e) as proposed gives VA the latitude to consider all veteran populations, including women veterans, and we agree that VA should consider the unique needs of veteran populations when determining whether its medical service lines are underperforming.

Lastly, we received a few comments that urged VA to develop and make public a dataset that compares providers, facilities, and practices based on VA's standards for quality, to provide covered veterans with additional information they may use when determining whether to elect to receive care in the community. We do not make any changes based on these comments but note that we address VA's communication of comparative information to inform health care decisions in the portion of this final rule that discusses miscellaneous comments.

§ 17.4020, Authorized Non-VA Care

We received over 100 comments concerning the process and requirements for authorizing non-VA care under the VCCP. We address these comments below in the order in which they raise issues related to the provisions in paragraphs (a)-(d) of § 17.4020 as proposed (including VA's supplemental notice of proposed rulemaking related to transplant care). We note that some of these comments did not suggest changes to the regulation text in § 17.4020 as proposed, and further raised issues that were related more to administrative process rather than the regulatory requirements under which VA will authorize care. We will address below only those issues raised in comments regarding VA's requirements and authorities to authorize non-VA care as proposed and will address other issues related to administrative process in another section of this final rule related to miscellaneous comments.

We did not receive comments to revise a covered veteran's election to receive care under the VCCP should they be so eligible, under § 17.4020(a) as proposed. We do reiterate, however, in response to many comments that expressed concerns related to the effects of expanding non-VA care on VA's direct provision of care, that § 17.4010(a) requires a veteran's election to receive non-VA care under the VCCP; VA does not force covered veterans to receive non-VA care.

Several comments did request clarification or revision of VA's authorization of care and services to be furnished through the VCCP if the covered veteran elects to receive such care, under § 17.4020(a) as proposed. Some of these comments broadly opposed VA's specific authorization of care and services, for instance, those comments that asserted that a veteran's VA identification card should be all that is required to present to obtain care without further review or authorization requirements. Other comments were more specific, for instance, that VA should reduce or eliminate the requirement for VA authorization of care or services from approved non-VA providers who have a record of effective and efficient care within the Veterans Choice program. Still other comments further advocated that VA should eliminate the requirements for additional authorizations that may be required within an episode of care (referred to as secondary authorizations) because they were concerned that these authorizations could unduly delay the provision of care or services, such as additional testing that may be found to be required. One comment more specifically requested that any authorization of an episode of care that includes a surgical procedure should automatically cover any other care furnished during that procedure, and a related comment even more specifically requested that VA should require that follow up care for vascular surgical procedures (particularly imaging) be provided by the same non-VA vascular surgeon who provided the initial care or services to the covered veteran. We do not make changes based on these comments.

We reiterate from the proposed rule that, in accordance with section 1703(a)(3), VA is required to authorize care or services that a covered veteran might elect to receive through the VCCP. This authorization of care and services covers an episode of care that may last up to one year, but only for care and services that are within the scope of the care or services initially authorized. VA has developed a process to facilitate access to necessary and ancillary services within an episode of care; we refer to these authorizations as standard episodes of care (SEOC). VA uses SEOCs to bundle services that are necessary and related so that referrals between different specialists are more easily facilitated and so that all specialty and ancillary services are included within the episode of care. For example, a veteran in need of knee replacement surgery would be authorized through a SEOC for pre- and post-operative examinations, the surgery itself, and physical therapy. The same would follow for a veteran in need of vascular surgery, as raised by the comment described above, for all specialty care and ancillary services that would reasonably be expected to be medically necessary after the surgery itself. However, the regulation will not prescribe at so granular a level, for instance, automatic approvals for particular follow-up care or for care to be provided by the same providers that initially performed surgical procedures. Requests for authorization of services outside the SEOC further allow VA to assess the need for care or services recommended by a non-VA provider, and whether these services fall within the approved episode of care or whether they constitute a new episode of care.

Several comments asserted that a covered veteran's selection of a provider in § 17.4020(b) as proposed did not actually ensure that a covered veteran could see his or her provider of choice. The primary reasons offered for why providers of choice were not available were that delays in VA's payment of claims, or other complications associated with VA's administration of its community care programs, created too many disincentives for non-VA providers to participate in such programs. We will address these comments, as well as other comments regarding VA's administration of its community care programs, in another section of this final rulemaking related to miscellaneous comments. However, we do note that even setting aside these operational concerns, VA cannot compel a private provider to furnish care and services to a covered veteran. If the covered veteran identifies a particular entity or provider as his or her preferred source of care, and if that provider or entity is within VA's network and accessible to the covered veteran, we would refer the veteran to that entity or provider. If the identified provider is not part of VA's network and does not wish to become part of VA's network (and VA cannot otherwise secure the care through a sharing agreement, other arrangement, or Veterans Care Agreement), VA cannot compel that provider to treat the covered veteran. We do not make any changes to § 17.4020(b) as proposed based on these comments.

A majority of the comments VA received related to § 17.4020 as proposed raised issues related to emergency care that may be authorized by VA as set forth in § 17.4020(c) as

proposed. We reiterate that we will address below only those issues raised in comments regarding VA's requirements and authorities to authorize emergency care as set forth in § 17.4020(c), and we will address issues related more to administrative process of VA approving emergency care in another section of this final rule related to miscellaneous comments.

We received a few comments that requested VA clarify any potential intersection or sharing of assessment criteria or other standards between emergency care furnished under the VCCP and emergency care separately furnished under 38 U.S.C. 1725 and 1728. We interpret these comments to be related to § 17.4020(c) as proposed, as paragraph (c) established that it did not affect eligibility for, or create any new rules or conditions affecting, reimbursement for emergency treatment under sections 1725 or 1728. These comments ranged in their primary concerns for identifying the relationships between emergency care offered under different VA authorities. For instance, one comment wanted clarification of the reasonableness standard that would be applied under the VCCP to determine whether care or services were emergent in nature, and further advocated that the prudent layperson standard should be applied (specifically, to include post-stabilization). Another comment requested clarification of the relationship between the varying emergency care authorities to ensure that covered veterans would understand when VA will likely authorize emergency care and reimburse for such care, versus the veteran possibly being liable. We do not make changes based on these comments.

We believe that § 17.4020(c) is sufficient to indicate that emergency care furnished through the VCCP is distinct from and does not affect emergency care provided under sections 1725 or 1728. We do clarify, however, that because paragraph (c)(1) of § 17.4020 does reference section 1725(f)(1) to define emergency treatment, VA will use the prudent layperson standard as interpreted through section 1725. We understand this clarification that VA will use its section 1725 prudent layperson for emergency treatment furnished through the VCCP is not what was requested by the comment, which asserted that this very standard permitted VA to review decisions of reasonableness instead of VA using what would perhaps be considered a broader industry standard (for instance, as referenced by the comment to a Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services standard of prudent layperson in 42 U.S.C. 300gg-19a(b)(2)(A)). However, we believe VA's prudent layperson standard is reasonable to administer the furnishing of emergency treatment through the VCCP. This same comment also requested that VA revise § 17.38(a)(1)(iv) to expressly provide that emergency care under VCCP is part of the medical benefits package. We agree and are revising § 17.38(a)(1)(iv) accordingly. We believe this change will assist individuals in understanding that emergency care provided under the VCCP is separate from that provided under sections 1725 and 1728 and is a covered benefit under the VCCP.

We received a comment that requested VA clarify that the term emergency treatment includes mental health care, which we interpret to be related to § 17.4020(c)(1) as proposed as this paragraph referenced the definition of emergency treatment in 38 U.S.C. 1725(f)(1). We do not make changes based on this comment, as we believe the reference to the definition of emergency treatment in section 1725(f)(1) is sufficient to indicate that mental health services are considered within the scope of emergency treatment. Section 1725(f)(1) refers to medical care or services furnished in an emergency. We have interpreted this to apply to any care or services within VA's medical benefits package, which includes mental health services, as identified in § 17.38(a)(1)-(2).

Comments generally stated that the 72-hour rule in § 17.4020(c)(2) as proposed was not reasonable. Primarily, these comments asserted that the 72-hour timeframe was too short or did not provide exceptions where it may be exceeded. There were multiple reasons provided in the comments to support that the 72-hour rule should have exceptions, which we summarize and respond to below. We note that some of these reasons raise issues related to requirements in § 17.4020(c)(3) and (4) as proposed, related to requirements for approval and notice to VA, respectively.

One comment stated that § 17.4020(c) as proposed did not reflect what the comment asserted was the current regulatory option for an exception to the 72-hour rule, to provide VA notice within a reasonable amount of time after the emergency care was furnished. We note that no such exception exists in current regulation under § 17.54, and we see no reason to add such an exception here, as this rule would only apply to covered veterans and eligible entities or providers.

Other comments offered reasons to establish exceptions to the 72-hour rule that were related to veterans or non-VA providers not understanding what VA facility should receive the notice or who to contact at such VA facility. Some of these comments more specifically noted that neither the appropriate VA official nor the nearest VA facility in § 17.4020(c)(4)(i) as proposed were clearly defined or characterized, particularly in instances where a veteran might be traveling and not be familiar with VA facility locations, or non-VA providers may not be familiar with VA facilities in their area. Some of these comments further requested clarification of who is considered an appropriate VA official, or requested that VA revise the requirement to allow notice to be delivered to any VA facility. As we explained in the proposed rule, only eligible entities or providers who have a contract or agreement to furnish care on VA's behalf may furnish care under § 17.4020(c). While veterans who are traveling may not know the local VA facility, we are confident that each community entity or provider in our network will know the right VA facility to contact.

Other comments offered reasons to establish exceptions to the 72-hour rule that were related to the nature of receiving emergency care or services. For instance, these comments asserted that in many cases a covered veteran seeking emergency care will be in a compromised medical state, and therefore should not be expected to understand whether they are seeking care from authorized entities or providers, or to understand whether all care offered might be covered by the medical benefits package.

Still other comments argued that exceptions are needed due to other circumstances, such as when the nearest VA facility might be closed after business hours or on holidays (to create delays in meeting the 72-hour rule), or when 72 hours may simply not be enough time for a non-VA provider to have obtained all information required under § 17.4020(c)(4) (for instance, if a covered veteran presents for emergency treatment without identification). One of these comments further requested that VA revise the rule so that the 72-hour period would not begin until the later of when the entity or provider began furnishing the care or the time when a reasonably diligent non-VA entity or provider would have the information necessary to submit a notice to VA in compliance with § 17.4020(c)(4).

We do not make any changes based on these comments to create exceptions to the 72-hour rule in § 17.4020(c)(2) as proposed. We reiterate from the

proposed rule that the 72-hour requirement is consistent with the window for approval under existing § 17.54(a), and we believe the 72-hour requirement continues to be a reasonable timeframe to allow notification upon stabilization of the patient or upon the next business day in the overwhelming majority of cases. VA will work to improve its communication materials for both veterans and eligible entities and providers concerning who may receive the notice and at what VA facility, without making changes to § 17.4020(c)(2) through (4). We believe this improved communication will assist with effective and timely provisions of notice within the 72-hour requirement. We also clarify that if the 72-hour window is not met, VA will consider any claims for reimbursement of the costs of the emergency treatment under other authorities, specifically sections 1725 and 1728, which authorize reimbursement of certain non-VA emergency treatment; there is no 72-hour requirement under either of these other authorities, but we do request notification under these authorities as soon as possible in the interest of coordination of care. We note that a veteran's personal financial liability, if any, could vary depending upon whether the care is authorized under section 1703 under the 72-hour rule or reimbursed under sections 1725 or 1728.

One comment requested that VA clarify if it will define someone acting on the covered veteran's behalf in § 17.4020(c)(2), or if VA will provide an exception to automatically approve care if a covered veteran is incapacitated (or, conversely, if VA will apply what the comment asserted was the current VA emergency room standard to non-VA emergency rooms). We do not make any changes based on this comment, as we believe the issues raised may be conflating the concept of a covered veteran's consent to receive emergency treatment with VA's approval of such treatment furnished through the VCCP.

One comment requested that VA revise § 17.4020(c) to permit that two emergency room visits be permitted through the VCCP at no charge to covered veterans. We interpreted this comment to be raising issues more related to VA's administration of its approval of emergency treatment, because it relayed concerns that covered veterans were unduly subject to cost liabilities for emergency treatment that the comment asserted VA failed to approve or pay timely. We will therefore address this comment in the section of this final rule that pertains to miscellaneous comments, although we do clarify here that § 17.4020(c) as proposed does not limit the number of visits to an emergency room for a covered veteran to receive emergency treatment through the VCCP.

Lastly, one commenter asserted that VA should add urgent care in addition to emergency treatment as available care and services under the VCCP. We do not make changes based on this comment but do clarify that VA is promulgating separate regulations, published elsewhere in this issue of the
Federal Register
, to furnish urgent care through non-VA providers (see RIN 2900-AQ47, published as a proposed rule on January 31, 2019 (84 FR 627)).

On April 5, 2019, VA published a Supplemental Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (SNPRM) to amend VA's proposed rule by proposing a minor revision to paragraph (a) and a new paragraph (d) to account for section 1703(l) and its language concerning organ and bone marrow transplants. 84 FR 13576. VA received 10 comments on this SNPRM. One comment was a request for case management assistance, which VA has addressed but which was beyond the scope of the rulemaking. We make no changes based on this comment. Four comments supported the changes proposed by the SNPRM. We make no changes based on these comments. One comment raised concerns regarding billing and payments for community providers. The commenter stated that clear definitions of how payments will be processed and paid between VA and the community providers is important to minimize any confusion in the billing process. The SNPRM did not address claims or billing issues because these were separately addressed in § 17.4035 of the proposed rule. We received comment on the proposed rule regarding billing and claims payment, which we address more fully below. In brief, however, we do not regulate VA's process for claims submissions or billing at this time. VA contracts and agreements will establish these requirements between the parties, and rules of general applicability, particularly regarding prompt payment, will be regulated at a later time. We make no changes based on this comment.

One commenter requested that VA provide examples of medically compelling reason for a veteran to seek transplant services outside of the Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network (OPTN) region in which the veteran resides. We do not make changes based on this comment but clarify that examples of medically compelling reasons were provided in § 17.4020(d)(2)(i) through (iv) as proposed and were discussed in the SNPRM. This same commenter requested for VA to clarify how OPTN regions and distance considerations in § 17.4020(d)(2)(iii) as proposed will interact in determining whether a transplant will be authorized. We do not make changes based on this comment but clarify that § 17.4020(d)(2)(iii) provides that VA will consider travel burden on covered veterans when deciding to authorize transplantation care at a transplant center outside the Veteran's OPTN region of residence. Geographical proximity of a qualified transplant center in an OPTN region adjacent to the patient's residence will be considered when burden of travel is meaningfully impacted. Availability of services in consideration for authorization of care in another OPTN region is cited in § 17.4020(d)(2)(iv) as timeliness of transplant center evaluations and management. Transplant program qualifications are further addressed by § 17.4020(d)(2)(i) and (ii). Transplant programs must meet standards for quality, and specific patient factors may include a disease process or transplantation procedure that warrants referral to selected transplantation centers, including those in a different OPTN region.

One commenter suggested that VA permit Veterans to be listed on more than one OPTN regional list if indicated, to increase their chance of being matched. We do not make changes based on this comment but clarify that the listing of Veterans on more than one OPTN regional list is not prohibited by the regulation. Related policy will specify that such listing is an appropriate consideration for authorization of care in an OPTN region other than that of the Veteran's residence.

One commenter asserted that the SNPRM failed to clarify the differences between solid organ transplant and bone marrow transplant. This commenter more specifically noted that bone marrow transplant falls outside of the scope of OPTNs, and that the proposed rule only indicated how VA Transplant Programs and VA Transplant Centers interact with OPTNs; hence, the commenter indicated that VA should clarify whether the rule captures bone marrow transplants. We do not make any changes based on this comment, as the MISSION Act includes provisions for both bone marrow transplantation and solid organ transplantation. VA understands that OPTN does not oversee bone marrow transplantation, but the rule does cover bone marrow transplants. This same commenter further suggested that the four factors in

§ 17.4020(d)(2) to be considered when determining a medically compelling reason to travel outside of the OPTN must be revised to include relevant details for bone marrow transplant. For instance, the commenter noted that the factor related to assessing facilities outside of an OPTN to determine whether they meet VA's standards for quality in § 17.4020(d)(2)(ii) as proposed was only explained in the preamble of the SNPRM in reference to Scientific Registry of Transplantation Recipients data, which is only applicable to solid organ. We do not make changes based on this further comment. VA understands that relevant patient factors may vary based upon the specific transplant both among solid organ types and bone marrow transplant, which is precisely why the SNPRM noted the four factors in § 17.4020(d)(2)(i)-(iv) were a non-exhaustive list. The Scientific Registry of Transplantation Recipients database is provided only as an example. Additional standards for solid organ transplantation programs and separate standards for bone marrow transplantation programs will be developed during policy and procurement processes.

We received one comment that requested that VA clarify that it is the veteran's choice whether to obtain a VA or non-VA transplant within the Veteran's OPTN (the commenter essentially asserted that the SNPRM was unclear that the veteran first has a choice of a non-VA transplant center within the OPTN prior to any consideration of travel outside of an OPTN). We do not make changes based on this comment. A covered veteran who is determined by VA to meet eligibility criteria for community care in proposed § 17.4010 has the ability to decide whether to receive transplantation care in the community within the OPTN region of residence. Veterans who meet eligibility criteria for community care may elect to receive care at a VA Transplant Center. This commenter also asserted that section 1703(l) requires only that a veteran be a covered veteran to be considered eligible for this expanded access to transplant care and does not require such a covered veteran to be separately assessed under any other criteria (
e.g.,
the criteria to receive community care generally under section 1703(d) or (e)). We believe this portion of the comment was prompted by VA's clarification in the SNPRM that this expanded access to transplant care only applies for a covered veteran (as defined in § 17.4005) who meets one or more of the eligibility criteria for community care generally under § 17.4010. We do not make changes based on this comment. We read section 1703(l) as qualifying the conditions of eligibility set forth in section 1703(d) and (e); there is nothing in section 1703(l) that suggests it is intended to establish an additional, independent basis of eligibility for community care. Moreover, the expanded access to transplant care under section 1703(l) is available only if there is a medically compelling reason to travel to receive such care. VA cannot envision any instance in which a covered veteran would be found to have a medically compelling reason to justify travel outside of an OPTN, but not be found to qualify separately for community care generally under § 17.4010(a), particularly considering that the factors to determine a medical compelling reason under § 17.4020(d)(2)(i)-(iv) are related to many of the eligibility factors in § 17.4010 (for instance, factors exist under §§ 17.4010(a) and 17.4020(d) that relate to the specific medical needs of a veteran, the travel burden for a veteran, and the timeliness of care to be received). This commenter further asserted that VA should ensure a veteran's primary care physician receives deference over the Secretary in the determination of whether a veteran is eligible to travel outside of the OPTN. We do not make changes based on this comment. Section 1703(l) requires that the Secretary make the determination of whether to authorize community care for covered veterans requiring an organ or bone marrow transplant and who have a medically compelling reason to travel outside of the OPTN region in which they reside to receive the transplant. The Secretary's determination is only made when the primary care provider has opined that there is a medically compelling reason to travel outside the OPTN region in which the veteran resides to receive such transplant; this opinion is a threshold question of when the Secretary makes a determination, and not a final resolution of the matter. Lastly, this commenter urged that VA should include in the final rule a specific timeframe within which VA is required to make a decision on requests to travel outside OPTN for non-VA transplant, as well as a means for expedited decision or waiver of such a decision. We do not make changes based on this comment. Timeframes may be influenced by factors such as the type of transplant, patient disease process, and patient acuity. It would not be practicable to define specific timeframes by regulation, given the variability of these factors. However, VA will develop policy that will address such timeframes.

§ 17.4025, Effect on Other Provisions

We received over 50 comments concerning the effects of §§ 17.4000 through 17.4040 as proposed upon provisions of VA law that establish other criteria for the receipt of care or services. We address these comments below in the order in which they raised issues related to the provisions in paragraphs (a)-(c) of § 17.4025 as proposed.

We did not receive any comments that requested revisions to or clarifications for § 17.4025(a) as proposed, although as a general matter we did receive some comments that seemed to call for expanding eligibility for certain care and services under the VCCP beyond that which is established in other specifically applicable provisions of VA law (for instance, multiple comments called for the expansion of eligibility for VA dental care). Other comments did not seek expanded eligibility for certain care or services under the VCCP but did assert that the rule as proposed did not provide adequate explanation of eligibility for certain benefits such as dental care. We do not make any changes based on these comments and reiterate from the proposed rule that consistent with section 1703(n)(2), no provision in the rule may be construed to alter or modify any other provision of law establishing specific eligibility criteria for hospital care, medical services, or extended care services (such as for dental care). If specific services such as dental care under §§ 17.160-17.169 have unique eligibility standards, only covered veterans who are eligible under proposed § 17.4010 and meet such eligibility standards can elect to receive them through the VCCP.

A majority of the comments we received on § 17.4025 as proposed related to § 17.4025(b), regarding VA's criteria under the VCCP to fill or pay for prescriptions issued by non-VA providers. Some of these comments did not suggest changes to or clarification of the regulation text in § 17.4025(b) as proposed, but rather seemed to present issues related to administrative process rather than regulatory requirements (primarily, VA's administrative practices in reviewing prescriptions issued by non-VA providers). We will address below only those issues raised in comments regarding VA's requirements in § 17.4025(b) as proposed, and will address other issues related to administrative process in another section of this final rule related to miscellaneous comments.

As proposed, § 17.4025(b)(1) established the rule that VA would pay for prescriptions written by eligible entities and providers for a course of treatment not to exceed 14 days, and paragraph (b)(2) established that VA would fill prescriptions written by eligible entities and providers without any accompanying 14-day limitation. As explained in the preamble of the proposed rule, the intent of § 17.4025(b)(1) and (2) was to establish in VA regulations the long-standing VA practice of limiting its payment for medications written by non-VA providers and filled through non-VA pharmacies, rather than limiting VA's direct filling of such prescriptions through VA's Consolidated Mail Order Pharmacy (CMOP) system. We first address a comment that revealed an inadvertent omission in the regulation text at § 17.4025(b)(1) as proposed, related to when VA will pay for non-VA prescriptions. This comment specifically urged VA to change its practice of requiring veterans to pay for urgent or emergent prescriptions filled outside of VA's CMOP and then seek reimbursement from VA. This comment correctly summarized VA's practice at the time the proposed rule published, although § 17.4025(b)(1) as proposed did not contain any qualifying language related to VA paying for prescriptions written by non-VA providers only when they were urgently or emergently needed. We therefore revise § 17.4025(b)(1) to include qualifying language that VA will pay for prescriptions no longer than 14 days written by eligible entities or providers for covered veterans, including over-the-counter drugs and medical and surgical supplies, available under the VA national formulary system to cover a course of treatment for an urgent or emergent condition. In response to the request in this same comment that VA correct its practice of reimbursing veterans, to instead pay directly for prescriptions urgently or emergently needed for a course of treatment not to exceed 14 days, we clarify that VA's use of the term “pay” versus “reimburse” in § 17.4025(b)(1) was intended to and does create the option for VA to pay directly for these prescriptions. VA expects that upon full implementation of the Community Care Network of eligible entities and providers, the pharmacy benefits management options under those contracts will provide for VA to pay non-VA pharmacies directly for prescriptions written by eligible entities and providers to cover a course of treatment for an urgent or emergent condition and not to exceed 14 days.

We received multiple comments that indicated a general dissatisfaction with VA's practice of limiting payment for prescriptions written by non-VA providers, as well as comments that more specifically asserted that the 14-day limitation in § 17.4025(b)(1) as proposed was unreasonable because VA did not establish any exceptions to this limitation, with one comment requesting a revision to § 17.4025(b)(1) to allow for payment of a course of treatment greater than 14 days if VA is unable to fill that greater course through its Consolidated Mail Order Pharmacy (CMOP) system. Other comments requested an expansion of the 14-day limitation, such as a broad expansion of the limitation to 30 days, with one comment noting that a 30-day supply of medication should be approved for outpatient surgery specifically (to reduce potential post-surgical injuries or complications). We received other comments that did not suggest revisions or exceptions to the 14-day limitation per se, but that requested clarifications regarding its application. For instance, one comment requested clarification of VA's practices in paying for medications that are prepackaged for durations exceeding 14 days and that cannot be divided. We do not make any changes based on these comments that expressed general dissatisfaction with the 14-day limitation, or comments that VA should establish exceptions to or expand the 14-day limitation. As explained above, VA's only pays for non-VA prescriptions that are filled through non-VA pharmacies if they are needed to cover a course of treatment for urgent or emergent conditions. The 14-day limitation is a function of the limitation related to urgent and emergent conditions, as courses of medication for longer periods of time are not typically prescribed to treat urgent or emergent conditions. VA also has a responsibility to monitor the prescription of medications to ensure appropriate prescribing practices and general patient care. Using the outpatient surgery example as provided in one of the comments, typical medications issued following surgery such as antibiotics and pain killers are particularly important for VA to review and fill via the CMOP because such medications create medical concerns (such as antibiotic resistance, potential opiate monitoring issues, or other adverse events) if they were to be issued for and taken longer than 14 days. We also reiterate from the proposed rule that the current practice to limit payment for non-VA prescriptions allows VA to ensure that any amount of medication exceeding 14 days would be filled through VA's CMOP system to ensure cost and quality controls. VA believes that the economies of scale related to bulk purchase of medications allow for the best use of Federal resources.

We received one comment that asserted non-VA providers must verify that prescribed medications are available through VA's formulary and comply with VA's practice guidelines, to avoid scenarios where covered veterans might receive prescriptions VA will not fill. We first note that we do not have anecdotal knowledge that there are widespread or recurring issues that non-VA providers are issuing prescriptions that VA cannot or will not fill because such medications are not on VA's formulary, or because the prescription contradicts VA's practices or guidelines. However, VA will review its administrative practices in reviewing and filling prescriptions issued by non-VA providers, to ensure it develops any necessary education or communication to non-VA providers to prevent those scenarios. We do not make any changes based on this comment but do note that § 17.4025(b)(1) and (2) as proposed generally requires that medications issued by non-VA providers must be available under the VA national formulary system. There are exceptions where VA may fill non-formulary prescriptions issued by non-VA providers, and such requests for exceptions are reviewed under specific procedures in VHA Directive 1108.08, VHA Formulary Management Process, which can be found on VA's website.

We received a few comments related to the prescribing of durable medical equipment (DME) by non-VA providers under § 17.4025(b)(3)-(4) as proposed. Some comments asserted that the rule should not require VA oversight or approval of prescriptions from non-VA providers for durable medical equipment (DME). Other comments were more specific, with one comment requesting clarification of who determines and what standards are used to determine when DME is immediately needed under § 17.4025(b)(3) as proposed, and further asserting that it should be determined by the prescribing clinician. Another comment requested that VA revise § 17.4025(b)(3) as proposed to specify that DME is an immediate need if it is required to safely discharge a patient from an urgent or emergent care setting, and that § 17.4025(b)(3) and (4) should be revised to expressly include home oxygen as covered under DME.

With regard to comments concerning general VA oversight and approval of DME that is prescribed by non-VA

providers, we reiterate from the proposed rule that because DME and medical devices prescribed by non-VA health care providers are specific to a particular clinical need and in most cases are further specifically tailored to fit or serve an individual, they require oversight and approval by VA (except when urgently or emergently needed) to ensure clinical appropriateness and the best use of Federal resources. We therefore do not make any changes based on those comments. With regard to comments concerning who determines and under what standards that DME is immediately needed, as well as the comments concerning the specific revisions related to immediate need, we first reiterate that DME to address an immediate need for urgent or emergent conditions does not require VA oversight or approval, and therefore would be issued by the treating or prescribing clinician without VA review. We next reiterate from the proposed rule that an immediate need for DME exists when a covered veteran has a medical condition of acute onset or exacerbation that manifests itself by severity of symptoms including pain, soft tissue symptomatology, bone injuries, etc. We believe the language in § 17.4025(b)(3) as proposed provides sufficient but non-exhaustive examples of the types of DME that are typically necessary to address such immediate needs (
i.e.,
splints, crutches, manual wheelchairs), and § 17.4025(b)(3) otherwise makes clear that urgent and emergent conditions meet the immediate need standards. We therefore do not make changes based on this comment. With regard to the comment concerning expressly adding home oxygen as covered DME, we clarify that home oxygen is considered DME for purposes of § 17.4025(b)(3) and (4) without further revisions to the proposed rule.

We received comments related to covered veterans' possible copayments in using community care under the VCCP, which we interpret to be related to § 17.4025(c) as proposed. Some comments urged that the rule should not change anything related to current copay structures and procedures. One comment asserted American Indian/Alaskan Native veterans should not be charged copayments for care received under the VCCP, as this was inconsistent with Federal trust obligations. We do not make any changes to the rule based on these comments and reiterate from the proposed rule that veterans will continue to be liable as applicable under §§ 17.108(b)(4) and (c)(4), 17.110(b)(4), and 17.111(b)(3) for copayments for community care that is furnished through the VCCP. The VCCP will not alter the current treatment of veteran copayments under VA's traditional community care program or the Veterans Choice Program. We also reiterate from the proposed rule that veterans who receive care from the Indian Health Service (IHS) and Tribal Health Programs (THP) under a sharing agreement with VA will not be affected by regulations that implement the VCCP; the existing VA reimbursement agreements between IHS, THPs and VA control all parameters of how that care is provided, including whether copayments are charged.

§ 17.4030, Eligible Entities and Providers

We received over 200 comments related to non-VA entities and providers that may furnish hospital care, medical services, or extended care services through the VCCP. We address these comments below in the order in which they raised issues related to the provisions in paragraphs (a)-(c) of § 17.4030 as proposed.

A majority of these comments asserted that VA should ensure non-VA providers are similarly qualified and competent as VA providers to furnish the same levels of care as VA providers. These comments more specifically urged that non-VA providers must: Be properly licensed/credentialed; use evidence-based treatment; and have specific training in clinical areas where VA has developed particular expertise (
e.g.,
post-traumatic stress disorder, traumatic brain injury, etc.). Some of these comments further stated that if non-VA providers cannot furnish care or services as well as VA providers, then those providers should not be an option that covered veterans may choose to furnish community care under the VCCP. Lastly, a few of these comments also asserted that if non-VA providers do not submit full medical documentation for care or services furnished under the VCCP (and not mere submission of invoices or bills), VA must not pay them. We interpret these comments to be related to § 17.4030(a) as proposed, as some of the comments specifically alluded to VA establishing more specific requirements for providers in the contracts, agreements, or other arrangements the providers enter into under § 17.4030(a).

Regarding the general need for VA to establish requirements for non-VA providers, we agree with the comments that it is critical for covered veterans to receive competent care from qualified non-VA providers should such veterans elect to receive care under the VCCP. However, we do not make any changes to § 17.4030 based on these comments. The rule at § 17.4030(c)(2) as proposed requires VA to assess the qualifications of the entity or provider to furnish the needed care or services in determining whether the provider is accessible to the covered veteran. These assessments can include licensing and credentialing information that VA collects under OMB control number 2900-0823. VA additionally requires submission of medical records as part of their claims for all non-VA care and services furnished under the rule (also under OMB control number 2900-0823) and as required by 38 U.S.C. 1703(a)(2)(A). VA reviews all licensing and credentialing information to ensure non-VA providers meet applicable standards for care needed, as well as medical records to ensure care was provided appropriately and within the scope of authorization. Although not part of the proposed rule, VA is establishing competency standards and requirements for the provision of care by non-VA providers in clinical areas where VA has developed special expertise, in accordance with section 133 of the MISSION Act. We are not regulating these standards to permit flexibility, as such standards are based on clinical practice and can be subject to change. VA's contracts, agreements, or other arrangements will impose requirements to meet these competency standards.

We received some comments that asserted VA should permit Medicare providers to participate in VCCP. We do not make changes based on these comments, as Medicare providers are a type of provider permitted under section 1703(c) to participate in VCCP, and are otherwise permitted to enter into contracts, agreements, or other arrangements with VA to furnish care and services under § 17.4030(a).

We received a few comments that requested clarification on whether or to what extent providers employed by VA could also participate in VCCP as eligible entities and providers to furnish care or services under § 17.4030(b) as proposed. We reiterate from the proposed rule, without changes to § 17.4030(b) as proposed, that providers who are employees of VA may not be acting within the scope of their employment while providing care or services through the VCCP. Essentially, VA providers may participate in VCCP as long as it is not during their VA-employed work hours.

We received a few comments that requested clarification of how VA would assess whether a non-VA provider is accessible to a covered

veteran under § 17.4030(c) as proposed. These comments generally seemed to inquire whether § 17.4030(c)(1) and (3) (related to VA assessing the length of time the veteran would have to wait to be seen by the non-VA provider, and the distance between the veteran's residence and that provider, respectively) were essentially VA's application of its access standards to non-VA providers, as such access standards were set forth in § 17.4040 as proposed. Those comments that assumed § 17.4030(c) did seek to apply VA's access standards to non-VA providers were primarily supportive of such an assumption. However, a few comments noted that applying such standards to non-VA providers was not feasible or advisable. One comment that opposed applying VA's access standards to non-VA providers more specifically asserted that non-VA providers would be discouraged from participating in the VCCP if they had to comply with VA's access standards, as this would amount to preferred treatment of veteran patients over non-veteran patients in terms of timeliness of appointments.

We clarify that VA did not intend for § 17.4030(c)(1) and (3) to establish a regulatory mechanism to apply VA's access standards as set forth in § 17.4040 to non-VA providers. This does not mean, however, that VA will not endeavor to ensure that community health care providers are able to comply with the applicable access standards established by VA, as VA is required to do so under section 1703B(f). To clarify VA's intentions, VA intends to establish access standards for non-VA providers in the contracts, agreements, or other arrangements that eligible entities or providers enter into under § 17.4030(a) as proposed, as opposed to establishing access standards for non-VA providers in regulation. We do not make changes to § 17.4030(c) as proposed based on these comments.

Although we do not make changes to § 17.4030(c) as proposed based on these comments, we do offer the following clarifications as requested by comments regarding how VA will use § 17.4030(c)(1) and (3) to assess whether a non-VA provider is accessible. By considering the length of time a veteran would have to wait to receive hospital care or medical services from a non-VA entity or provider under § 17.4030(c)(1) as proposed, VA can ensure that veterans receive care as quickly as possible. If a veteran selects a non-VA provider who cannot see the veteran for several months, VA would probably determine that provider was inaccessible, and could then provide the veteran with other options of non-VA providers to potentially schedule an appointment sooner. By considering the distance between the covered veteran's residence and the non-VA provider, VA can ensure that veterans receive care closer to their residence. If a veteran resides in New York and selects a provider in California (to receive care in California when they otherwise would not be residing in California at the time of the appointment), VA would probably determine that provider was inaccessible, and could then provide the veteran with other options of non-VA providers that would be closer to their residence at the expected time of the appointment. In either scenario (distance or time for an appointment), VA's decision regarding accessibility is not pre-determined; these will be case-by-case decisions. We believe these factors will be most relevant in situations where a covered veteran has not selected a particular non-VA provider, but is looking for VA to identify a non-VA provider that can furnish the care for them. In such cases, we would use these factors to determine which providers should be offered as possible options. If a covered veteran has selected a particular provider, we may determine in some cases that the provider is inaccessible (as in the New York/California example above), while in other cases, such cross-country travel might be approved (if, for example, there were only one or two providers in VA's network that furnished a specific type of service). In more typical cases, we anticipate that the veteran's selection of a particular provider will likely be approved, even if a particular provider might have a slightly longer wait time or be slightly further away from the veteran, as this would be the veteran's choice.

We also note that § 17.4030(c)(2) as proposed will consider the qualifications of the entity or provider to furnish the hospital care, medical services, or extended care services the veteran requires. If an entity or provider does not have the expertise or equipment necessary to provide the required care or services, the needed care is not accessible from that provider, and VA may not authorize a patient to receive care or services from that entity or provider. We raise this last factor in § 17.4030(c)(2) as proposed to reiterate as stated above that VA will consider these factors together to make accessibility determinations on a case-by-case basis, considering each veteran's specific needs. Sometimes, there may be several eligible entities or providers that could deliver care close to the veteran's residence, and in such a scenario, distance likely will not matter. In other situations, there may only be one provider near the veteran's residence, but this provider either has extended wait times or lacks the expertise or equipment to provide the necessary care. VA will need to balance these competing interests and the preference of the veteran to determine whether an entity or provider is accessible.

We are making minor changes to paragraph (c) to use the term covered veteran in lieu of the term eligible veteran in several places. The term eligible veteran is used in § 17.1530 because it is a defined term in § 17.1505. Under the VCCP regulations, we use the term covered veteran, as defined in § 17.4005. This change simply removes any ambiguity as to the term and does not alter the effect or meaning of the rule.

Lastly, we received a comment that requested VA specifically include in these regulations outreach, training, and other assistance to non-VA providers to expand the Patient-Centered Community Care (PC3) network, as the commenter asserted that such expansion is particularly critical to deliver community care in underserved areas. We do not make changes based on this comment, as this comment presents an operational request that is more appropriately addressed through contract or policy. We do clarify, however, efforts on VA's part to improve education of providers regarding the formation of contracts under section 1703(h) through the Community Care Network in the portion of this document that discusses miscellaneous comments.

§ 17.4035, Payment Rates

We received over 25 comments concerning the parameters under which VA establishes payment rates for care and services furnished through the VCCP, as set forth in § 17.4035 as proposed. We address these comments below in the order in which they raised issues related to provisions in paragraphs (a)-(e) of § 17.4035 as proposed. We note that some comments we received related more to

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/fr%3A2019-11575. Public record. Not legal advice.
