# Setting and Adjusting Patent Fees During Fiscal Year 2017

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/fr%3A2017-24390

## Record

- **Collection:** Federal Register
- **Document type:** Rule
- **Published:** November 14, 2017
- **Citation:** 82 FR 52780

## Text

DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE
Patent and Trademark Office
37 CFR Parts 1, 41, and 42
[Docket No. PTO-P-2015-0056]
RIN 0651-AD02
Setting and Adjusting Patent Fees During Fiscal Year 2017

AGENCY:

United States Patent and Trademark Office, Department of Commerce.

ACTION:

Final rule.

SUMMARY:

The United States Patent and Trademark Office (Office or USPTO) sets or adjusts patent fees as authorized by the Leahy-Smith America Invents Act (Act or AIA). The USPTO operates like a business in that external and internal factors affect the demand for patent products and services. The fee adjustments are needed to provide the Office with a sufficient amount of aggregate revenue to recover its aggregate cost of patent operations (based on current projections), while maintaining momentum towards achieving strategic goals.

DATES:

This rule is effective on January 16, 2018. The changes to § 1.18(b)(1) shall apply to those international design applications under the Hague Agreement having a date of international registration on or after January 16, 2018.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:

Brendan Hourigan, Director of the Office of Planning and Budget, by telephone at (571) 272-8966; or Dianne Buie, Office of Planning and Budget, by telephone at (571) 272-6301.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

This rule was proposed in a notice of proposed rulemaking published at 81 FR 68150 (Oct. 3, 2016) (hereinafter NPRM).

Table of Contents

I. Executive Summary

II. Legal Framework

III. Rulemaking Goals and Strategies

IV. Fee Setting Methodology

V. Individual Fee Rationale

VI. Discussion of Comments

VII. Discussion of Specific Rule

VIII. Rulemaking Considerations

I. Executive Summary

A. Purpose of This Action

The Office issues this final rule under Section 10 of the AIA (Section 10), which authorizes the Director of the USPTO to set or adjust by rule any patent fee established, authorized, or charged under title 35 of the United States Code (U.S.C.) for any services performed, or materials furnished, by the Office. Section 10 prescribes that fees may be set or adjusted only to recover the aggregate estimated costs to the Office for processing, activities, services, and materials relating to patents, including administrative costs of the Office with respect to such patent fees. Section 10 authority includes flexibility to set individual fees in a way that furthers key policy factors, while taking into account the cost of the respective services. Section 10 also establishes certain procedural requirements for implementing or revising fee regulations, such as public hearings and input from the Patent Public Advisory Committee (PPAC) and Congressional oversight.

This rulemaking represents the second iteration of patent fee rulemaking by the USPTO to set fees under the authority of the AIA; the first AIA patent fee setting rule was published in January 2013. This current rulemaking is a result of the USPTO assessing its costs and fees, as is consistent with federal fee setting standards. Following a biennial review of fees, costs, and revenues that began in 2015, the Office concluded that targeted fee adjustments were necessary to continue to fund patent operations, enhance patent quality, continue to work toward patent pendency goals, support the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB)'s continued efforts to deliver high quality and timely decisions, fund general support costs necessary for patent operations (
e.g.,
rent, utilities, legal, financial, human resources, and other administrative services), invest in strengthening the Office's information technology (IT) capability and infrastructure, and achieve operating reserve targets. Further, in several instances, the fee change proposals offered during the biennial fee review process were enhanced by the availability of cost and workload data (
e.g.,
the number of requests for a service) that was not available in 2013. As a result, the 202 fee adjustments outlined in this rule align directly with the Office's strategic goals and four key fee setting policy factors, discussed in detail in Part III.

B. Summary of Provisions Impacted by This Action

This final rule sets or adjusts 202 patent fees for large, small, and micro entities (any reference herein to “large entity” includes all entities other than those that have established entitlement to either a small or micro entity fee discount). The fees for small and micro entity rates are tiered, with small entities at a 50 percent discount and micro entities at a 75 percent discount. Small entity fee eligibility is based on the size or certain non-profit status of the applicant's business. Micro entity fee eligibility is described in Section 10(g) of the Act. There are also 42 new fees being introduced or replacing one of the 14 fees that are being discontinued. This final rule applies small entity discounts to two additional fees and applies micro entity discounts to six additional fees.

In summary, the routine fees to obtain a patent (
i.e.,
filing, search, examination, and issue fees) increase slightly under this final rule relative to the current fee schedule. Applicants who meet the definition for small or micro entity discounts will continue to pay a reduced fee for the fees eligible for a discount under Section 10(b) of the Act. Additional information describing the fee adjustments is included in Part V. Individual Fee Rationale section of this rulemaking and in the “
Table of Patent Fees—Current, Final Rule and Unit Cost”
(hereinafter “
Table of Patent Fees”
) available at
http://www.uspto.gov/about-us/performance-and-planning/fee-setting-and-adjusting.

C. Summary of Costs and Benefits of This Action

The final rule is significant and results in a need for a Regulatory Impact Analysis (RIA) under Executive Order 12866 Regulatory Planning and Review, 58 FR 51735 (Oct. 4, 1993). The Office prepared a RIA to analyze the costs, benefits, and transfer payments of the final rule over a five-year period, FY 2017-FY 2021. The RIA includes a comparison of the final rule fee schedule to the current fee schedule (baseline) and to two other alternatives.

The Office of Management and Budget (OMB) has determined that this rule involves a transfer payment from one group to another that does not affect the total resources available to society. The costs and benefits that the Office identifies and analyzes in the RIA are strictly qualitative. Qualitative costs and benefits have effects that are difficult to express in either dollar or numerical values. Monetized costs and benefits, on the other hand, have effects that can be expressed in dollar values. The Office did not identify any monetized costs and benefits of the rulemaking, but found that the final rule has significant qualitative benefits with no identified costs.

The qualitative costs and benefits that the RIA assesses are: (1) Fee schedule design—a measure of how well the fee schedule aligns to the Office's key fee setting policy factors—and (2) securing aggregate revenue to cover aggregate

cost—a measure of whether the alternative provides adequate revenue to support the core mission and strategic priorities described in the final rule and FY 2018 Budget. For these costs and benefits, the fee schedule in this final rule offers the highest benefits, with no costs identified. As described throughout this document, the final rule fee schedule maintains the existing balance of setting entry fees (
e.g.,
filing, search, and examination) below the costs to the Office to perform those services and setting maintenance fees above the cost to the Office, as one approach to foster innovation. Further, as detailed in Part V, the fee changes are targeted in support of one or more fee setting policy factors. Lastly, the final rule secures the aggregate revenue needed to achieve the strategic priorities encompassed in the rulemaking goals and strategies (
see
Part III). In summary, the benefits of the final rule clearly outweigh those of the baseline and the other alternatives considered in the RIA. Table 1 summarizes the RIA results.

Table 1—Final Patent Fee Schedule Costs and Benefits, Cumulative FY 2017-FY 2021

Qualitative costs and benefits

Costs:

None identified
Neutral.

Benefits:

Secure Aggregate Revenue to Cover Aggregate Cost
Significant.

Fee Schedule Design
Significant.

Net Benefit/Cost

Significant Benefit.

Additional details describing the costs and benefits are available at
http://www.uspto.gov/about-us/performance-and-planning/fee-setting-and-adjusting.

II. Legal Framework

A. Leahy-Smith America Invents Act—Section 10

The Leahy-Smith America Invents Act was enacted into law on September 16, 2011.
See
Public Law 112-29, 125 Stat. 284. Section 10(a) of the Act authorizes the Director of the Office to set or adjust by rule any patent fee established, authorized, or charged under title 35, U.S.C., for any services performed by, or materials furnished by, the Office. Fees under 35 U.S.C. may be set or adjusted only to recover the aggregate estimated cost to the Office for processing, activities, services, and materials related to patents, including administrative costs to the Office with respect to such patent operations.
See
125 Stat. at 316. Provided that the fees in the aggregate achieve overall aggregate cost recovery, the Director may set individual fees under Section 10 at, below, or above their respective cost. Section 10(e) of the Act requires the Director to publish the final fee rule in the
Federal Register
and the Official Gazette of the Patent and Trademark Office at least 45 days before the final fees become effective. Section 10(i) terminates the Director's authority to set or adjust any fee under Section 10(a) upon the expiration of the seven-year period that began on September 16, 2011.

B. Small Entity Fee Reduction

Section 10(b) of the AIA requires the Office to reduce by 50 percent the fees for small entities that are set or adjusted under Section 10(a) for filing, searching, examining, issuing, appealing, and maintaining patent applications and patents.

C. Micro Entity Fee Reduction

Section 10(g) of the AIA amended chapter 11 of title 35, U.S.C., to add Section 123 concerning micro entities. The Act provides that the Office must reduce by 75 percent the fees for micro entities for filing, searching, examining, issuing, appealing, and maintaining patent applications and patents. Micro entity fees were implemented through the previous patent fee rule, and the Office will maintain this 75 percent micro entity discount for the appropriate fees and implement micro entity fees for additional services as appropriate.

D. Patent Public Advisory Committee Role

The Secretary of Commerce established the PPAC under the American Inventors Protection Act of 1999. 35 U.S.C. 5. The PPAC advises the Under Secretary of Commerce for Intellectual Property and Director of the USPTO on the management, policies, goals, performance, budget, and user fees of patent operations.

When adopting fees under Section 10 of the Act, the Director must provide the PPAC with the proposed fees at least 45 days prior to publishing the proposed fees in the
Federal Register
. The PPAC then has at least 30 days within which to deliberate, consider, and comment on the proposal, as well as hold public hearing(s) on the proposed fees. The PPAC must make a written report available to the public of the comments, advice, and recommendations of the committee regarding the proposed fees before the Office issues any final fees. The Office considers and analyzes any comments, advice, or recommendations received from the PPAC before finally setting or adjusting fees.

Consistent with this framework, on October 20, 2015, the Director notified the PPAC of the Office's intent to set or adjust patent fees and submitted a preliminary patent fee proposal with supporting materials. The preliminary patent fee proposal and associated materials are available at
http://www.uspto.gov/about-us/performance-and-planning/fee-setting-and-adjusting.
The PPAC held a public hearing in Alexandria, Virginia, on November 19, 2015. Transcripts of the hearing are available at
http://www.uspto.gov/sites/default/files/documents/PPAC_Hearing_Transcript_20151119.pdf.
Members of the public were invited to the hearing and given the opportunity to submit written and/or oral testimony for the PPAC to consider. The PPAC considered such public comments from this hearing and published all comments on the Fee Setting Web site, available at
http://www.uspto.gov/about-us/performance-and-planning/fee-setting-and-adjusting.
The PPAC also provided a written report setting forth in detail the comments, advice, and recommendations of the committee regarding the preliminary proposed fees. The report regarding the preliminary proposed fees was released on February 29, 2016, and is available at
http://www.uspto.gov/sites/default/files/documents/PPAC_Fee%20_Setting_Report_2016%20%28Final%29.pdf.
The Office considered and analyzed all comments, advice, and recommendations received from the PPAC before publishing the NPRM. Likewise, before issuing this final rule, the Office considered and analyzed all comments, advice, and recommendations received from the public during the 60-day comment period. The Office's response to comments received is available in Part VI. Discussion of Comments.

III. Rulemaking Goals and Strategies

A. Fee Setting Strategy

The overall strategy of this final rule is to establish a fee schedule that generates sufficient multi-year revenue to recover the aggregate cost to maintain USPTO operations and accomplish the USPTO's strategic goals in accordance with the authority granted to the USPTO by AIA Section 10. A similar strategy guided the initial AIA patent fee setting in 2013. The overriding principles behind this strategy are to operate within a sustainable funding model to avoid disruptions caused by fluctuations in available financial resources, and to continue strategic

improvements, such as progress on patent quality initiatives, continued reduction of the patent application backlog and pendency, continued delivery of high quality and timely PTAB decisions, and continued investment in modernization of IT systems and infrastructure.

In addition to the overriding principles outlined above, the Office also assesses alignment with the four key fee setting policy factors: Foster innovation, align fees with the full cost of products and services, set fees to facilitate the effective administration of the patent and trademark systems, and offer application processing options for applicants. Each factor promotes a particular aspect of the U.S. patent system. Fostering innovation is an important policy factor to ensure that applicants can access the U.S. patent system without significant barriers to entry, and innovation is incentivized by granting inventors certain short-term exclusive rights to stimulate additional inventive activity. Aligning fees with the full cost of products and services recognizes that as a fully fee-funded entity, the Office must account for all of its costs even as it elects to set some fees below, at, or above cost. This factor also recognizes that some applicants may use particular services in a much more costly manner than other applicants (
e.g.,
patent applications cost more to process when more claims are filed). Facilitating effective administration of the patent system is important to influence efficient patent prosecution, resulting in compact prosecution and reduction in the time it takes to obtain a patent. Finally, the Office recognizes that patent prosecution is not a one-size-fits-all process and therefore, where feasible, the Office endeavors to fulfill its fourth policy factor of offering patent processing options to applicants.

B. Fee Setting Considerations

The balance of this sub-section presents the specific fee setting considerations the Office reviewed in developing the final patent fee schedule. Specific considerations are: (1) Historical costs of patent operations and investments to date in meeting the Office's strategic goals; (2) projected costs to meet the Office's operational needs and strategic goals; and (3) sustainable funding. Additionally, the Office carefully considered the comments, advice, and recommendations offered by the public and PPAC during the public comment period for the NPRM. Collectively, these considerations informed the Office's chosen rulemaking strategy.

(1)
Historical Cost.
To ascertain how to best align fees with the full cost of products and services, the Office considers Activity Based Information. Using historical cost data and forecasted application demands, the Office can align fees to the costs of specific patent products and services. The document entitled
USPTO Setting and Adjusting Patent Fees during Fiscal Year 2017—Activity Based Information and Patent Fee Unit Expense Methodology,
available at
http://www.uspto.gov/about-us/performance-and-planning/fee-setting-and-adjusting,
provides detail on the Office's costing methodology in addition to historical cost data. Part IV of this rulemaking details the Office's methodology for establishing fees. Finally, Part V describes the reasoning for setting some fees at cost, below cost, or above cost such that the Office recovers the aggregate cost of providing services through fees.

The Office has made significant progress towards its strategic priorities for patent quality, backlog, pendency, and IT system modernization for several years now. For more information about the Office's performance record and progress towards its strategic goals,
see
the
FY 2016 Performance and Accountability Report,
available at
http://www.uspto.gov/sites/default/files/documents/USPTOFY16PAR.pdf.

(2)
Projected Costs.
The costs projected to meet the Office's strategic goals can be found in the FY 2018 President's Budget, which provides additional detail about the following performance and modernization efforts, among others: (a) Quality, backlog, and pendency for Patents and PTAB and (b) investing in modernizing the USPTO IT systems and infrastructure.

(a) Quality, Backlog, and Pendency. The Office developed the strategic goal of optimizing patent quality and timeliness in response to feedback from the intellectual property community and in recognition that a sound, efficient, and effective intellectual property system is essential for technological innovation and for patent holders to reap the benefits of patent protection. In addition to timeliness of patent protection, the quality of application review is critical to the value of an issued patent. Issuance of quality patents provides certainty in the market and allows businesses and innovators to make informed and timely decisions on product and service development. Under this final rule, the Office will continue to improve patent quality through ongoing efforts related to the three quality pillars: (1) Excellence in work products; (2) excellence in measuring patent quality; and (3) excellence in customer service.

In addition to quality, the USPTO continues to focus on backlog and pendency reduction. First action and average total pendency in FY 2016 were 16.2 months and 25.3 months respectively compared to 21.9 months and 32.4 months in FY 2012. The patent application backlog was reduced from 608,283 in FY 2012 to 537,655 at the end of FY 2016. This rulemaking aims to produce revenues adequate to continue the USPTO's progress towards attaining its strategic goals for patent backlog and pendency.

Similarly, the PTAB manages pendency and inventory for appeals. In the past few years, the Office has made great strides in reducing the backlog and pendency for
ex parte
appeals. Appeal inventory reached over 27,000 (in 2012) and by the end of FY 2016 was about 17,000. As of the end of fiscal year 2016, the average pendency for decided
ex parte
appeals was 25.5 months (as measured from appeal number assignment to decision date). The Office aspires to reach an appeals pendency goal of 12 months by the end of FY 2018 and to further reduce the existing inventory. This rulemaking will help the PTAB to maintain the appropriate level of judicial, legal, and administrative staff needed to provide high quality and timely decisions for reexamination appeals; and
ex parte
appeals.

(b) Information Technology. Revenue generated from the final fee structure will enable the USPTO to continue investing in modernizing the USPTO IT systems and infrastructure. Some current systems remain obsolete and difficult to maintain, leaving the USPTO vulnerable to potential disruptions in patent operations. However, the Office's efforts on PE2E, the large-scale patent IT improvement and modernization program, have already delivered value to examiners and customers alike. To date, the Docket & Application Viewer (DAV), a case management tool for examiners, was first released in March 2015. By the end of FY 2016, 100 percent of patent examiners were using DAV. The eDAN legacy system was retired in December 2016, as its full functionality was replaced by DAV. Other PE2E releases include pilots for Official Correspondence (replaces Office Action Correspondence System (OACS)), an authoring and workflow solution that offers DAV integration, and Examiner Search (replaces Examiner's Automated Search Tool (EAST)), which supports modern, scalable enterprise searches; both represent significant advances in how

the Office manages workload and delivers results to customers. PE2E relies on flexible, scalable, modern technology that is optimized to eliminate repetitive tasks and support analytics and automated processing. In April 2016, the USPTO released Financial Manager, its new online fee payment management tool. Financial Manager allows USPTO customers to store and manage payment methods online and generate custom transaction reports at any time. Modern IT tools benefit both USPTO employees and stakeholders by facilitating the effective administration of the patent system through effective application processing, better examination quality, and the ability to provide greater services via a nationwide workforce.

(3)
Sustainable Funding.
A major component of sustainable funding is the creation and maintenance of a viable patent operating reserve that allows for effective management of the U.S. patent system and responsiveness to changes in the economy, unanticipated production workload, and revenue changes. As a fee-funded agency, spending levels and revenue streams create volatility in patent operations and threaten the Office's ability to meet its designated performance levels (
e.g.,
quality, backlog, and pendency for Patents and PTAB).

The USPTO's annual budget delineates prospective spending levels (aggregate cost) to execute core mission activities and strategic initiatives. In the FY 2018 President's Budget, the USPTO estimated that its aggregate patent operating cost for FY 2017, including administrative costs, would be $2.986 billion. After evaluating relevant risk factors, the Office determined that a minimum balance of $300 million in the operating reserve was adequate for FY 2017 and FY 2018, which is below the optimal balance of three months operating expenses, or about $746 million in FY 2017. Based on the latest estimates as shown in the FY 2018 President's Budget, the spending requirement would exceed projected fee collections and other income of $2.876 billion and draw $110 million from the patent operating reserve, leaving a $245 million balance in the patent operating reserve, or $55 million less than the desired minimum of $300 million. This is partially due to the fact that these fee adjustments will only be in place for the last month of FY 2017. In FY 2018, when the fee adjustments will be fully implemented, the operating reserve is projected to rise above the desired minimum, with an end-of-year balance of $343 million. In FY 2019, budgetary requirements are projected to exceed income, taking the operating reserve down to $341 million. Then the operating reserve is projected to continue growing, to $418 million at the end of FY 2020 and $501 million at the end of FY 2021. This exceeds the desired minimum, but falls short of the optimal level of $841 million in FY 2021. The operating reserve is not projected to reach its optimal level within the next five years.

Fee setting authority allows the Office to align the fee schedule with the four fee setting policy factors discussed earlier in this document (
i.e.,
foster innovation, align fees to full cost, set fees to facilitate the effective administration of the patent and trademark system, and offer application processing options). This rule assumes that the USPTO will retain the important business tool of fee setting authority to respond to environmental and operational factors in the out-years. The USPTO will continue to assess the patent operating reserve balance against its target balance annually, and at least every two years, the Office will evaluate whether the target balance continues to be sufficient to provide the funding stability needed by the Office. Per the Office's operating reserve policy, if the operating reserve balance is projected to exceed the optimal level by 10 percent for two consecutive years, the Office will consider fee reductions. The ability to implement such fee adjustments is based on the assumption that the USPTO's fee setting authority under the AIA will be renewed or made permanent after it expires in 2018. Under the new fee structure, as in the past, the Office will continue to regularly review its operating budgets and long-range plans to ensure the USPTO uses patent fees prudently.

C. Summary of Rationale and Purpose of the Final Rule

The Office estimates that the final patent fee schedule will produce aggregate revenue to recover the aggregate cost of the USPTO, including for the implementation of its strategic and management goals, objectives, and initiatives in FY 2017 and beyond.

Using the strategic goals (optimizing patent quality and timeliness and providing domestic and global leadership to improve intellectual property policy, protection, and enforcement worldwide) and the management goal of organizational excellence as a foundation, the final rule should provide sufficient aggregate revenue to recover the aggregate cost of patent operations, including improving patent quality, reducing the patent application backlog, decreasing patent application pendency, delivering high quality and timely PTAB decisions, investing in modernizing the patent business IT capability and infrastructure, and implementing a sustainable funding model.

IV. Fee Setting Methodology

The Office carried out three primary steps in developing the final fee schedule:

Step 1:
Determine the prospective aggregate cost of patent operations over the five-year period, including the cost of implementing new initiatives to achieve strategic goals and objectives.

Step 2:
Calculate the prospective revenue streams derived from the individual fee amounts (from Step 3) that will collectively recover the prospective aggregate cost over the five-year period.

Step 3:
Set or adjust individual fee amounts to collectively (through executing Step 2) recover projected aggregate cost over the five-year period, while furthering key policy factors.

These three steps are iterative and interrelated. The following is a description of how the USPTO carries out these three steps.

Step 1: Determine Prospective Aggregate Cost

Calculating prospective aggregate cost is accomplished primarily through the annual USPTO budget formulation process. The Budget is a five-year plan (that the Office prepares annually) for carrying out base programs and new initiatives to implement the strategic goals and objectives.

The first activity performed to determine prospective aggregate cost is to project the level of demand for patent products and services. Demand for products and services depend on many factors, including domestic and global economic activity. The USPTO also takes into account overseas patenting activities, policies and legislation, and known process efficiencies. Because filing, search, and examination costs are the largest share of the total patent operating cost, a primary production workload driver is the number of patent application filings (
i.e.,
incoming work to the Office). The Office looks at indicators such as the expected growth in Real Gross Domestic Product (RGDP), the leading indicator to incoming patent applications, to estimate prospective workload. RGDP is reported by the Bureau of Economic Analysis (
www.bea.gov
) and is forecasted each February by the OMB (
www.omb.gov
) in the Economic and Budget Analyses section of the Analytical Perspectives and each January by the Congressional

Budget Office (CBO) (
www.cbo.gov
) in the Budget and Economic Outlook. A description of the Office's methodology for using RGDP can be found in Appendix I—Multi-year Planning by Business Line and Cost Containment of the FY 2018 President's Budget (Congressional Justification). The expected change in the required production workload must then be compared to the current examination production capacity to determine any required staffing and operating cost (
e.g.,
salaries, workload processing contracts, and publication) adjustments. The Office uses a patent pendency model that estimates patent production output based on actual historical data and input assumptions, such as incoming patent applications and overtime hours. An overview of the model, including a description of inputs, outputs, key data relationships, and a simulation tool is available at
http://www.uspto.gov/patents/stats/patent_pend_model.jsp.

The second activity is to calculate the aggregate cost to execute the requirements. In developing its Budget, the Office first looks at the cost of status quo operations (the base requirements). The base requirements are adjusted for anticipated pay raises and inflationary increases for the budget year and four out years (detailed calculations and assumptions for this adjustment can be found in the FY 2018 President's Budget). The Office then estimates the prospective cost for expected changes in production workload and new initiatives over the same period of time (refer to “Program Changes by Sub-Program” sections of the Budget). The Office reduces cost estimates for completed initiatives and known cost savings expected over the same five-year horizon. Finally, the Office estimates its three-month target operating reserve level based on this aggregate cost calculation for the year to determine if operating reserve adjustments are necessary.

The FY 2018 President's Budget identifies that, during FY 2017, patent operations will cost $2.986 billion, including $2.002 billion for patent examination activities; $180 million for IT systems and support contributing to direct patent operations; $87 million for activities related to patent appeals and AIA trial proceedings; $27 million for activities related to intellectual property protection, policy, and enforcement; and $688 million for general support costs necessary for patent operations (
e.g.,
rent, utilities, legal, financial, human resources, other administrative services, and Office-wide IT infrastructure and IT support costs). In addition, the Office transfers $2 million to the DOC Inspector General to conduct audits of USPTO programs. The Office also estimates collecting $24 million in other income associated with recoveries and reimbursable agreements (offsets to spending). Since operations costs are projected to exceed collections, the Office estimates that $110 million will be withdrawn from the operating reserve during FY 2017.

Table 2 below provides key underlying production workload projections and assumptions from the Budget used to calculate aggregate cost. Table 3 presents the total budgetary requirements (prospective aggregate cost) for FY 2017 through FY 2021 and the estimated collections and operating reserve balances that would result from the adjustments contained in this final rule.

Table 2—Patent Production Workload Projections—FY 2017-FY 2021

Utility, plant, and reissue (UPR)
FY 2017
FY 2018
FY 2019
FY 2020
FY 2021

Applications *
614,253
627,274
634,934
639,878
636,580

Growth Rate
0.7%
2.1%
1.2%
0.8%
−0.5%

Production Units
647,700
663,200
667,700
660,700
626,100

Unexamined Patent Application Backlog
485,300
430,000
378,200
338,200
329,600

Examination Capacity **
8,375
8,300
8,097
7,812
7,540

Performance Measures (UPR):

Avg. First Action Pendency (Months)
14.8
15.1
11.0
10.7
9.9

Avg. Total Pendency (Months)
24.8
23.0
22.7
19.5
19.0

* In this table, the patent application filing data includes requests for continued examination (RCEs).
** In this table, Examination Capacity is the UPR Examiners On-Board at End-of-Year, as described in the FY 2018 President's Budget.

The USPTO continuously updates both patent fee collections projections and workload projections based on the latest data. Patent production workload projections have been updated since the NPRM was published in October 2016. The most recent projections are shown in Table 2. UPR filings growth projections were revised downward during the FY 2018 budget formulation process due to revised RGDP estimates and more conservative estimates of out year growth.

Over the five year planning horizon budgetary requirements increased compared to the prior NPRM outlook projections. The primary drivers of the requirements variance are investments to modernize IT systems and infrastructure and updated assumptions about the resources necessary to meet production commitments in the Patent Pendency Model and PTAB models. The FY 2018 Budget is based on a framework of continuous and comprehensive budget reviews designed to ensure that all operational and administrative costs are reviewed and funds are reallocated when necessary to focus on high-priority and effective programs—primarily core mission activities—and mitigate risk by retaining minimum operating reserve balances. In addition, the USPTO operates similarly to a business in that the Office makes a determined effort to monitor and adjust spending in response to changes in workload, income, and operating reserve balances. These activities are carried out as regular parts of the budget execution and budget formulation processes.

Table 3—Planned Operating Requirements—FY 2017-FY 2021

Patent aggregate cost estimate
Dollars in millions
FY 2017
FY 2018
FY 2019
FY 2020
FY 2021

Patent Planned Operating Requirements
2,986
3,176
3,231
3,273
3,365

Less: Planned Patent Fee Collections
2,852
3,250
3,205
3,326
3,423

Less: Other Income
24
24
24
24
24

To (−)/From (+) Operating Reserve
−110
98
−2
77
82

EOY Operating Reserve Balance
245
343
341
418
501

Step 2: Calculate Prospective Aggregate Revenue

As described in “
Step 1,”
the USPTO's FY 2017 requirements in the FY 2018 President's Budget include the aggregate prospective cost of planned production, anticipated new initiatives, and a contribution to the patent operating reserve required for the Office to realize its strategic goals and objectives for the next five years. The aggregate prospective cost becomes the target aggregate revenue level that the new fee schedule must generate in a given year and over the five-year planning horizon.

To calculate the aggregate revenue estimates, the Office first analyzes relevant factors and indicators to calculate or determine prospective fee workload (
e.g.,
number of applications and requests for services and products), growth, and resulting fee workload volumes (quantities) for the five-year planning horizon. Economic activity is an important consideration when developing workload and revenue forecasts for the USPTO's products and services because economic conditions affect patenting activity, as most recently exhibited in the recession of 2009 when incoming workloads and renewal rates declined.

The Office considers economic activity when developing fee workloads and aggregate revenue forecasts for its products and services. Major economic indicators include the overall condition of the U.S. and global economies, spending on research and development activities, and investments that lead to the commercialization of new products and services. The most relevant economic indicator that the Office uses is the RGDP, which is the broadest measure of economic activity and is anticipated to grow approximately two percent for FY 2017 based on OMB and CBO estimates.

These indicators correlate with patent application filings, which are a key driver of patent fees. Economic indicators also provide insight into market conditions and the management of intellectual property portfolios, which influence application processing requests and post-issuance decisions to maintain patent protection. When developing fee workload forecasts, the Office considers other influential factors, including overseas activity, policies and legislation, court decisions, process efficiencies, and anticipated applicant behavior.

Anticipated applicant behavior in response to fee changes is measured using an economic principle known as elasticity, which for the purpose of this action measures how sensitive applicants and patentees are to changes in fee amounts. The higher the elasticity measure (in absolute value), the greater the applicant response to the relevant fee change. If elasticity is low enough (
i.e.,
demand is
inelastic
or the elasticity measure is less than one in absolute value), a fees increase will lead to only a relatively small decrease in patent activities, and overall revenues will still increase. Conversely, if elasticity is high enough (
i.e.,
demand is
elastic
or the elasticity measure is greater than one in absolute value), a fee increase will lead to a large enough decrease in patenting activities that overall revenues will decrease. When developing fee forecasts, the Office accounts for how applicant behavior will change at different fee amounts for the various patent services. Additional detail about the Office's elasticity estimates is available in “
USPTO Setting and Adjusting Patent Fees during Fiscal Year 2017—Description of Elasticity Estimates,”
available at
http://www.uspto.gov/about-us/performance-and-planning/fee-setting-and-adjusting.

Aggregate Revenue Estimate Ranges

When estimating aggregate revenue, the USPTO prepares a high and a low range of fee collection estimates. This range accounts for the inherent uncertainty, sensitivity, and volatility of predicting fluctuations in the economy and market environment; interpreting policy and process efficiencies; and developing fee workload and fee collection estimates from assumptions. The Office estimates a range for all its major workload categories including application filings, extensions of time, PTAB fees, maintenance fees, PCT filings, and trademark filings. Additional detail about how the Office calculates aggregate revenue is discussed in the document entitled, “Setting and Adjusting Patent Fees during FY 2017—Aggregate Revenue Estimating Methodology.” Details about projected workloads for each of the fee setting alternatives considered are available in the aggregate revenue tables for each alternative. All of these documents are available at
http://www.uspto.gov/about-us/performance-and-planning/fee-setting-and-adjusting.

Summary

Patent fees are collected for patent-related services and products at different points in time within the patent application examination process and over the life of the pending patent application and granted patent. Approximately half of all patent fee collections are from issue and maintenance fees, which subsidize the cost of filing, search, and examination activities. Changes in application filing levels immediately impact current year fee collections, because fewer patent application filings means the Office collects fewer fees to devote to production-related costs, such as additional examining staff and overtime. The resulting reduction in production activities creates an out year revenue impact because less production output in one year results in fewer issue and maintenance fee payments in future years.

The USPTO's five-year estimated aggregate patent fee revenue (
see
Table 3) is based on the number of patent applications it expects to receive for a given fiscal year, work it expects to process in a given fiscal year (an indicator for workload of patent issue fees), expected examination and process requests for the fiscal year, and the expected number of post-issuance decisions to maintain patent protection over that same fiscal year. Within the iterative process for estimating aggregate revenue, the Office adjusts individual fees up or down based on cost and policy decisions (
see
Step 3: Set

Specific Fee Amounts), estimates the effective dates of new fee rates, and then multiplies the resulting fees by appropriate workload volumes to calculate a revenue estimate for each fee. To calculate the aggregate revenue, the Office assumes that all fee rates will become effective on September 1, 2017. Using these figures, the USPTO sums the individual fee revenue estimates, and the result is a total aggregate revenue estimate for a given year (
see
Table 3).

Step 3: Set Specific Fee Amounts

Once the Office finalizes the annual requirements and aggregate prospective cost for a given year during the budget formulation process, the Office sets specific fee amounts that, together, will derive the aggregate revenue required to recover the estimated aggregate prospective cost during that time frame. Calculating individual fees is an iterative process that encompasses many variables. One variable that the USPTO considers to inform fee setting is the historical cost estimates associated with individual fees. The Office's Activity-Based Information (ABI) provides historical cost for an organization's activities and outputs by individual fee using the activity-based costing (ABC) methodology. ABC is commonly used for fee setting throughout the Federal government. Additional information about the methodology, including the cost components related to respective fees, is available in the document entitled “
USPTO Setting and Adjusting Patent Fees during Fiscal Year 2017—Activity-Based Information and Patent Fee Unit Expense Methodology”
available at
http://www.uspto.gov/about-us/performance-and-planning/fee-setting-and-adjusting.
The USPTO provides data for FY 2013-FY 2015 because the Office finds that reviewing the trend of ABI historical cost information is the most useful way to inform fee setting. The underlying ABI data are available for public inspection at the USPTO.

When the Office implements a new process or service, historical ABI data is typically not available. However, the Office will use the historical cost of a similar process or procedure as a starting point to estimate the full cost of a new activity or service.

V. Individual Fee Rationale

The Office projects that the aggregate revenue generated from the new patent fees will recover the prospective aggregate cost of its patent operations including contributions to the operating reserve per the strategic objective of implementing a sustainable funding model. As detailed previously, the PPAC supports this approach, stating that it “agrees that the Office should set its fees to establish an adequate revenue stream over a sustained period to fund the people and infrastructure essential for a high quality, low pendency examination process, and to fund its operating reserve.” It is important to recognize that each individual fee is not necessarily set equal to the estimated cost of performing the activities related to the fee. Instead, as described in Part III. Rulemaking Goals and Strategies, some of the fees are set at, above, and below their unit costs to balance the four key fee setting policy factors
discussed in Part III.

For some fees in this final rule, the USPTO does not maintain individual historical cost data for the service provided, such as maintenance fees. Instead, the Office evaluates the policy factors described in Part III to inform fee setting. By setting fees at particular levels, the USPTO aims to: (1) Foster an environment where examiners can provide and applicants can receive prompt, quality interim and final decisions; (2) encourage the prompt conclusion of prosecuting an application, resulting in pendency reduction and the faster dissemination of patented information; and (3) help recover costs for activities that strain the patent system.

The rationale for the fee changes are grouped into three major categories, discussed below: (A) Fees where large entity amounts stayed the same or did
not
change by greater than plus or minus 10 percent or 20 dollars; (B) fees where large entity amounts changed from the current amount by greater than plus or minus 10 percent and 20 dollars; and (C) fees that are discontinued or replaced. The purpose of the categorization is to identify large fee changes for the reader and provide an individual fee rationale for such changes. The categorization is based on changes in large entity fee amounts because percentage changes for small and micro entity fees that are in place today would be the same as the percentage change for the large entity, and the dollar change would be half or one quarter of the large entity change. Therefore, the only time there will be a small or micro entity fee change that meets the greater than plus or minus 10 percent or 20 dollars criteria without a similar change for the large entity fee will be for those instances when the Office is introducing new small and micro entity fees where there was previously only a large entity fee. These types of changes are discussed separately.

The
Table of Patent Fees
includes the current and final rule fees for large, small, and micro entities as well as unit costs for the last three fiscal years. Part VII. Discussion of Specific Rule contains a complete listing of fees that are set or adjusted in the final rule patent fee schedule.

A. Fees With Changes Less Than Plus or Minus 10 Percent or 20 Dollars

The Office is adjusting slightly (
i.e.,
less than plus or minus 10 percent or 20 dollars) several fees not discussed in sections B or C below. The
Table of Patent Fees
demarcates which fees meet the dollar change and percent change thresholds. Fees are rounded to the nearest five dollars by applying standard arithmetic rules. For fees that have small and micro entity fee reductions, the large entity fee will be rounded to the nearest 20 dollars by applying standard arithmetic rules. The resulting fee amounts will be convenient to patent users and permit the Office to set small and micro entity fees at whole dollar amounts when applying the applicable fee reduction. The slight increase in these fees helps the Office to recover higher costs of performing such services due to increased aggregate cost of doing business. The fee adjustments in this category are listed in the
Table of Patent Fees.

B. Fees With Changes of Greater Than Plus or Minus 10 Percent and 20 Dollars

For those fees changing by greater than plus or minus 10 percent and 20 dollars, the individual fee rationale discussion is divided into three categories, including: (1) New and significant fees; (2) patent enrollment fees; and (3) fees adjusted and amended to include discounts for small and micro entities. Note: Three fees in this section have fee changes less than 10 percent but are included here because they met this criteria in either the NPRM (
i.e.,
Plant Issue and
Inter Partes
Review Post-Institution Fee—Up to 15 Claims) or preliminary proposed fees (
i.e.,
Request for Continued Examination (RCE)—1st Request).

New and significant fees are further divided into subcategories according to the function of the fees, including: (a) Mega-sequence listing filing; (b) design and plant search, examination, and issue; (c) request for continued examination (RCE); (d) information disclosure statements; (e) certificate of correction; (f) request for
ex parte
reexamination; (g) appeals; (h) AIA trials; (i) PCT—International Stage; and (j) reissue patent maintenance rule.

As discussed above, for purposes of comparing amounts in the individual fee rationale discussion, the Office has included the current fees as the baseline to calculate the dollar change and percent change for new fees.

(1) New and Significant Fees

The following fees fall under the category of new and significant. A discussion of the rationale for each fee follows.

a)
Mega-Sequence Listing Filing

Table 4—Mega-Sequence Listing Filing—Fee Changes and Unit Cost

Fee description
Current fees
Large (Small) [Micro] Entity
Final rule fees
Large (Small) [Micro] Entity
Dollar change
Large (Small) [Micro] Entity
Percent change
Large (Small) [Micro] Entity
FY 2015 unit cost

Submission of sequence listings of 300 MB to 800 MB
new

$1,000
($500)
[$250]

+$1,000
(+$500)
[+$250]

n/a
(n/a)
[n/a]

n/a

Submission of sequence listings of more than 800 MB
new

$10,000
($5,000)
[$2,500]

+$10,000
(+$5,000)
[+$2,500]

n/a
(n/a)
[n/a]

n/a

The Office sets two new fees to manage handling of sequence listings of 300 MB or more. Pricing for this fee is divided into two tiers with Tier 1 for file sizes 300 MB to 800 MB and Tier 2 for file sizes greater than 800 MB.

The level of effort associated with the handling of mega-sequence listings is significant, because the Office's systems require extra storage and special handling for files beyond 300 MB. The Office has not yet collected actual cost data for sequence listings with file sizes of 300 MB or greater. However, based on historical data, on average, less than 10 applications per year contained sequence listing files greater than 300 MB. Based on previously filed applications with lengthy sequence listings, the Office determined that some applications disclosed sequence data that met the length thresholds for being included in the sequence listing but that was neither invented by the applicants nor claimed. Mega-sequence listings, in particular, often included sequences that were available in the prior art, were not essential material, and could have been described instead, for example, by name and a publication or accession reference. Further, claims accompanying such applications were frequently directed to the manipulation of sequence data rather than the substance of the sequences themselves. Submission of a mega-sequence listing in these applications would not have been necessary to complete the application if applicants limited the number of sequences that were described in such a way as to be required in a sequence listing. The fee should encourage applicants to draft their specifications such that sequence data that is not essential material is not required to be included in a sequence listing. The fee would also apply to the submission of mega-sequence listings received in national stage applications under 35 U.S.C. 371, including mega-sequence listings received by the Office pursuant to PCT Article 20. A reduced number of mega-sequence listings will benefit the Office and the public by reducing the strain on Office resources, thus facilitating the effective administration of the patent system.

(b)
Design and Plant Search, Examination, and Issue

Table 5—Design Search, Examination, and Issue and Plant Search and Issue Fees—Fee Changes

Fee description
Current fees

Large (Small)
[Micro] Entity

Final rule fees

Large (Small)
[Micro] Entity

Dollar change

Large (Small)
[Micro] Entity

Percent change

Large (Small)
[Micro] Entity

FY 2015
unit cost

Design Search Fee

$120
($60)
[$30]

$160
($80)
[$40]

+$40
(+$20)
[+$10]

+33%
(+33)
[+33]

$397

Plant Search Fee

$380
($190)
[$95]

$420
($210)
[$105]

+$40
(+$20)
[+$10]

+11
(+11)
[+11]

1,773

Design Examination Fee

$460
($230)
[$115]

$600
($300)
[$150]

+$140
(+$70)
[+$35]

+30
(+30)
[+30]

608

Design Issue Fee

$560
($280)
[$140]

$700
($350)
[$175]

+$140
(+$70
[+$35]

+25
(+25)
[+25]

314

Plant Issue Fee

$760
($380)
[$190]

$800
($400)
[$200]

+$40
(+$20)
[+$10]

+5
(+5)
[+5]

314

In the NPRM, the Office proposed a design issue fee of $800 and a plant issue fee of $1,000. In this final rule, after carefully considering comments from the PPAC and the public, the Office sets the design issue fee to $700 and the plant issue fee to $800, 13 percent and 20 percent less than the fees proposed in the NPRM respectively. Design and plant patents are unlike utility patents in that they do not pay maintenance fees after the patent has been granted. Under the current utility fee structure, entry costs (filing, search, and examination fees) are intentionally

set below the full cost of performing this service as a means to foster innovation. Then, the full cost of examination is recovered through the payment of issue and maintenance fees. Given the lack of maintenance fees and the fact that the majority of design applicants are small and micro entities who are eligible to pay reduced fees, the Office currently does not recover the costs to examine design and plant patent applications solely from design and plant application fees. Instead, these costs are being subsidized by other application types (
e.g.,
utility) and processes. The revised fees better align the fees with costs by bringing both application types closer to aggregate cost recovery while maintaining some subsidization.

(c)
Request for Continued Examination (RCE)—First and Second and Subsequent Request

Table 6—Request for Continued Examination (RCE) Fee Changes

Fee description
Current fees

Large (Small)
[Micro] Entity

Final rule fees

Large (Small)
[Micro] Entity

Dollar change

Large (Small)
[Micro] Entity

Percent change

Large (Small)
[Micro] Entity

FY 2015
unit cost

Request for Continued Examination (RCE)—1st Request (
see
37 CFR 1.114)

$1,200
($600)
[$300]

$1,300
($650)
[$325]

+$100
(+$50)
[+$25]

+8
(+8)
[+8]

$2,187

Request for Continued Examination (RCE)—2nd and Subsequent Request (
see
37 CFR 1.114)

$1,700
($850)
[$425]

$1,900
($950)
[$475]

+$200
(+$100)
[+$50]

+12
(+12)
[+12]

1,540

The moderate increases to RCE fees support the fee setting policy factor to align fees with costs. The increase would more closely align the fee rates with the cost of processing RCEs, as calculated using the most recently available cost data (FY 2015). Specifically, the Office is increasing the first RCE fee rate from $1,200 to $1,300 for large entities, a $100 increase (8 percent). The FY 2015 cost to examine a first RCE was $2,187 with the increase in the first RCE fee rate significantly below FY 2015 unit cost, this service will continue to recover only a portion of the total cost in the future.

The Office is increasing the second and subsequent RCE fee rate from $1,700 to $1,900 for large entities, a $200 increase (12 percent). The FY 2015 cost to examine a second and subsequent RCE was $1,540. When combined, first and second and subsequent RCE fees collected 62.5 percent of the examination costs. In order to approach cost recovery and limit the increase to the first RCE fee rate, the Office sets the second and subsequent RCE fee rate with a slightly larger increase. Had this fee structure been in place in FY 2015, the Office would have recovered 68.6 percent of RCE costs as opposed to the 62.5 percent that was realized. In FY 2015, the Office collected fees for 112,634 first RCEs and for 57,931 second and subsequent RCEs.

While this fee structure will not achieve full cost recovery for RCEs, it will bring collections closer to cost and therefore reduce the subsidy for RCE filings currently provided by other patent fees. In addition to the fee adjustments, the USPTO is committed to focusing on initiatives that will reduce the need for RCEs. Examples of initiatives the Office has already implemented to reduce the need for RCEs include the Quick Path Information Disclosure Statement (QPIDS) pilot program (
http://www.uspto.gov/patent/initiatives/quick-path-information-disclosure-statement-qpids
) and the After Final Consideration Pilot 2.0 (AFCP 2.0) (
http://www.uspto.gov/patent/initiatives/after-final-consideration-pilot-20
). Additionally, the Enhanced Patent Quality Initiative (
http://www.uspto.gov/patent/initiatives/enhanced-patent-quality-initiative-0
) evaluates and strengthens work products, processes, and services at all stages of the patent process.

(d) Information Disclosure Statements (IDS)

Table 7—DS—Fee Changes and Unit Costs

Fee description
Current fees

Large (Small)
[Micro] Entity

Final rule fees

Large (Small)
[Micro] Entity

Dollar change

Large (Small)
[Micro] Entity

Percent change

Large (Small)
[Micro] Entity

FY 2015
unit cost

Submission of an Information Disclosure Statement

$180
($90)
[$45]

$240
($120)
[$60]

+$60
(+$30)
[+$15]

+33
(+33)
[+33]

n/a

The Office is increasing the submission fee for an Information Disclosure Statement (IDS) from $180 to $240. The adjustment is an effort to set the fee optimally to encourage early submission of an IDS when possible while keeping the fee low enough to encourage timely filings during the time period (and under the conditions) when the fee would be required.

(e) Certificate of Correction Fees

Table 8—Certificate of Correction Fees—Fee Changes and Unit Costs

Fee description
Current fees

Large (Small)
[Micro] Entity

Final rule fees

Large (Small)
[Micro] Entity

Dollar change

Large (Small)
[Micro] Entity

Percent change

Large (Small)
[Micro] Entity

FY 2015
unit cost

Certificate of Correction
$100
$150
+$50
+50
$93

The Office is increasing the fee for a certificate of correction by $50 to $150. This adjustment will encourage applicants to submit accurate information initially, while at the same time not increasing the rate too much above unit cost recovery, which could discourage disclosure of needed corrections when an error has been identified. Whenever a mistake of a clerical or typographical nature, or of minor character, which was not the fault of the USPTO, appears in a patent and a showing has been made that such mistake occurred in good faith, the Director may, upon payment of this fee, issue a certificate of correction, if the correction does not involve such changes in the patent as would constitute new matter or would require reexamination.

(f) Request for Ex Parte Reexamination Fees

Table 9—Request for Ex Parte Reexamination Fees—Fee Changes and Unit Costs

Fee description
Current fees
Large (Small) [Micro] Entity
Final rule fees
Large (Small) [Micro] Entity
Dollar change
Large (Small) [Micro] Entity
Percent change
Large (Small) [Micro] Entity
FY 2015 unit cost

Ex Parte
Reexamination (§ 1.510(a)) Streamlined

new

$6,000
($3,000)
[$1,500]

+$6,000
(+$3,000)
[+$1,500]

n/a
n/a

The Office is establishing a new fee for smaller, streamlined reexamination filings. The streamlined filings will reduce the cost to the USPTO, allowing the Office to pass on the cost savings to applicants. This fee will apply to
ex parte
reexamination requests having: (i) 40 pages or less; (ii) lines that are double-spaced or one-and-a-half spaced; (iii) text written in a non-script type font such as Arial, Times New Roman, or Courier; (iv) a font size no smaller than 12 point; (v) margins which conform to the requirements of 37 CFR 1.52(a)(1)(ii); and (vi) sufficient clarity and contrast to permit direct reproduction and electronic capture by use of digital imaging and optical character recognition. The following parts of an
ex parte
reexamination request are excluded from (i) through (v) above: (a) The copies of every patent or printed publication relied upon in the request pursuant to 37 CFR 1.510(b)(3); (b) the copy of the entire patent for which reexamination is requested pursuant to 37 CFR 1.510(b)(4); and (c) the certifications required pursuant to 37 CFR 1.510(b)(5) and (6). Completed forms such as the Request for
Ex Parte
Reexamination Transmittal Form (PTO/SB/57) or the information disclosure statement form (PTO/SB/08), or their equivalents, will also be excluded from (i) through (v). Claim charts will be considered part of the request and will be included in the page limit. Any paper containing argument directed to the patentability or unpatentability of the claims, such as an affidavit or declaration, will be included in the page limit and subject to the above requirements. If only a portion of the paper contains argument, the entire paper will be included in the page limit. The Office deems conclusions and/or definitions to be argumentative. For example, a request that includes 40 pages of argument and a 41st page that includes conclusions or definitions would be deemed to be a request having greater than 40 pages. A page that consists solely of a signature will not be included in the page limit. The determination of whether a paper contains argument will be within the sole discretion of the Office.

Note that micro entity status is only available to patent owner requesters, not to third party requesters. The change is consistent with the USPTO's fee setting policy factors to align fees to costs, offer additional processing options, and facilitate the effective administration of the patent system, and is also consistent with the requirements of 35 U.S.C. 123.

(g) Appeal Fees

Table 10—Appeal—Fee Changes and Unit Costs

Fee description
Current fees
Large (Small) [Micro] Entity
Final rule fees
Large (Small) [Micro] Entity
Dollar change
Large (Small) [Micro] Entity
Percent change
Large (Small) [Micro] Entity
FY 2015 unit cost

Forwarding an Appeal in an Application or
Ex parte
Reexamination Proceeding to the Board.

$2,000
($1000)
[$500]

$2,240 ($1,120) [$560]
+$240 (+$120) [+$60]
+12% (+12%) [+12%]
$4,815

Based on feedback on the NPRM, the Office has eliminated the proposed increase to the notice of appeal fee. The Notice of Appeal fees will remain at current rates (
e.g.,
$800 for a large entity), and the Office has lowered the appeal forwarding fee from the proposed $2,500 (large entity) in the NPRM to $2,240 (large entity). At the current fee rate, the fees paid for an
ex parte
Notice of Appeal and Forwarding an Appeal only cover 58 percent of the

Office's cost for an appeal. The fee increase for Forwarding an Appeal will result in the combined
ex parte
appeal fees covering 63 percent of the Office's cost to conduct an
ex parte
appeal.

In the past few years, the Office has made great strides in reducing the backlog and pendency for
ex parte
appeals. The Office aspires to reach an appeals pendency goal of 12 months by the end of FY 2018 and to further reduce the existing inventory. As mentioned in Part III, the PTAB is working to reduce inventory via two pilot programs, EPAP and the Small Entity Pilot Program. The adjustment would allow the Office to better align fees to costs by reducing the gap between the amount paid by an appellant and the fully burdened cost of reviewing appeals by the Board. The additional revenue supports continued improvements to pendency and inventory via enhanced technology.

(h) AIA Trials

Table 11—AIA Trials—Fee Changes and Unit Costs

Fee description
Current fees
Large (Small) [Micro] Entity
Final rule fees
Large (Small) [Micro] Entity
Dollar change
Large (Small) [Micro] Entity
Percent change
Large (Small) [Micro] Entity
FY 2015 unit cost

Inter Partes
Review Request Fee—Up to 20 Claims.

$9,000
$15,500
+$6,500
+72%
$22,165

Inter Partes
Review Post-Institution Fee—Up to 15 Claims.

14,000
15,000
+1,000
+7%
12,674

Inter Partes
Review Request of Each Claim in Excess of 20.

200
300
+100
+50%
n/a

Inter Partes
Post-Institution Request of Each Claim in Excess of 15.

400
600
+200
+50%
n/a

Post-Grant or Covered Business Method Review Request Fee—Up to 20 Claims.
12,000
16,000
+4,000
+33%
16,213

Post-Grant or Covered Business Method Review Post-Institution Fee—Up to 15 Claims.
18,000
22,000
+4,000
+22%
23,060

Post-Grant or Covered Business Method Review Request of Each Claim in Excess of 20.
250
375
+125
+50%
n/a

Post-Grant or Covered Business Method Review Post-Institution Request of Each Claim in Excess of 15.
550
825
+275
+50%
n/a

The AIA established two new trial proceedings:
inter partes
review and post-grant review.
Inter partes
review is a trial proceeding created by the AIA that allows the Office to review the patentability of one or more claims in a patent only on a ground that could be raised under 35 U.S.C. 102 or 103, and only on the basis of prior art consisting of patents or printed publications. The
inter partes
review process begins with a third party filing a petition. An
inter partes
review may be instituted upon a showing that there is a reasonable likelihood that the petitioner would prevail with respect to at least one claim challenged. If the proceeding is instituted and not dismissed, a final determination by the Board will be issued within one year (extendable for good cause by six months). The Office is adjusting all four separate fees for
inter partes
review, which are due upon the filing of a petition. The USPTO will refund the post-institution fee if the
inter partes
review proceeding is not instituted by the PTAB.

Post-grant review is a trial proceeding created by the AIA that allows the Office to review the patentability of one or more claims in a patent on any ground that could be raised under 35 U.S.C. 282(b)(2) and (b)(3) in effect on September 16, 2012. The post-grant review process begins when a third party files a petition within nine months of the grant of the patent. A post-grant review may be instituted upon a showing that it is more likely than not that at least one challenged claim is unpatentable or that the petition raises an unsettled legal question that is important to other patents or patent applications. If the trial is instituted and not dismissed, the Board will issue a final determination within one year of institution. This period can be extended for good cause for up to six months from the date of one year after instituting the review.

In FY 2016, the PTAB received nearly 1,700 AIA trial filings and the Office expects that number to grow in the coming fiscal years. In order to keep up with demand and continue to provide high quality decisions within the statutory time limits, the Office needs to close the gap between the cost and the fees for performing these services. When the fees for these services were initially set, the Office had to estimate what the costs would be without the benefit of historical cost information. Now that the trials have been in place for three fiscal years, the Office has actual historical cost data available to more accurately set these fees and recover costs. In this final rule, the Office is setting the
Inter Partes
Review Request Fee—Up to 20 Claims at $15,500 and the
Inter Partes
Review Post-Institution Fee—Up to 15 Claims at $15,000. The total for the
inter partes
review (request and post-institution) fees is $30,500. These individual fee rates have changed from the rates proposed in the NPRM, although the total remains the same. The fee rates proposed in the NPRM were $14,000 for the
Inter Partes
Review Request Fee—Up to 20 Claims and $16,500 for the
Inter Partes
Review Post-Institution Fee—Up to 15 Claims. The Office is revising the fee levels to more closely align fees and costs to the Office for performing these services. Unit costs for
inter partes
review requests have consistently outpaced the unit costs for
inter partes
review post-institutions.
See
the
Table of Patent Fees.

(i) Patent Cooperation Treaty (PCT)—International Stage

Table 12—Patent Cooperation Treaty (PCT)—International Stage—Fee Changes and Unit Costs

Fee description
Current fees
Large (Small) [Micro] Entity
Final rule fees
Large (Small) [Micro] Entity
Dollar change
Large (Small) [Micro] Entity
Percent change
Large (Small) [Micro] Entity
FY 2015 unit cost

Late Furnishing Fee for Providing a Sequence Listing in Response to an Invitation Under PCT Rule 13
ter

new

$300
($150)
[$75]

+$300
(+$150)
[+$75]

n/a
n/a

The Office sets a new fee to encourage timely filing of sequence listings in international applications as another way to facilitate the effective administration of the patent system. When an applicant does not provide a sequence listing in searchable format with the international application or provides a defective sequence listing, the United States, acting as International Searching Authority (ISA/US) or as International Preliminary Examining Authority (IPEA/US), must issue an invitation to the applicant to provide the missing or corrected sequence listing. This additional process creates a delay in the issuance of the International Search Report (ISR) or International Preliminary Report on Patentability (Chapter II). The most recent data shows that the ISA/US issues ISRs within 16 months of the priority date for 75 percent of all international applications searched by the ISA/US. However, when the ISA/US issues an invitation to provide a sequence listing, the ISA/US issues ISRs within 16 months in only 28 percent of those international applications. The time limit for issuance of the ISR under PCT Rule 42 in most circumstances is 16 months from the priority date. This new fee will help compensate the Office for the extra work associated with issuing the invitation and handling the response, while better positioning the Office to meet applicable treaty timeframes. The fee is similar in size and scope to fees charged by other international intellectual property offices.

(j) Maintenance Fee Payments—Reissue Patent Rule

For each issued patent, the Office may grant one or more reissue patents. However, current practice dictates that only one maintenance fee is required for all of the possible reissue patents granted from a single patent. This change of practice would require payment of maintenance fees for each reissue patent, instead of a single maintenance fee payment for the group of reissue patents. The large majority of reissue patents are granted after the first stage maintenance fee payment has already been paid on the initial patent. Over the last six years, approximately 150 reissue patents per year would have been subject to additional fees due to this rule change. This is a significantly higher level than the Office experienced prior to FY 2010. For example, between FY 2003 and FY 2009, the average was 27 per year. The Office expects this change in practice to encourage patent owners to prioritize which reissue patents they want to maintain. If an owner wishes to maintain all reissue patents in force, he or she may do so by paying the appropriate maintenance fees. For reissue patents that are not maintained, subject matter previously covered by the patent would become available in the public domain to improve upon and further foster innovation.

(2) Office of Enrollment and Discipline Fees and Patent Practitioner Enrollment Fees

The following fee adjustments are comprised of Office of Enrollment and Discipline (OED) fees and other patent practitioner enrollment fees. In addition to the fee rate changes, there are four new fees introduced in this section. The purpose of amending the fees in this section is to better align fees with actual costs. During the previous patent fee setting effort, historical cost information for these activities was not available. Since then, the Office has developed cost information to more appropriately make these fee adjustments. No enrollment or disciplinary fees have been increased since 2008, and only two fees were adjusted that year. All other enrollment and discipline fees were last changed much earlier, specifically, between 1991 and 2004. In fact, one OED fee has been unchanged since 1982. As time passes, the difference between the fee charged by the Office and the cost to the Office to perform the service increases, resulting in greater subsidies by other patent fees. The increases to these fees will help to close the gap between the fee charged and the cost to perform the service. A discussion of the rationale for each fee change follows.

Table 13—OED and Patent Practitioner Enrollment—Fee Changes and Unit Costs

Fee description
Current fees

Large (small)
[micro] entity

Final rule fees

Large (small)
[micro] entity

Dollar change

Large (small)
[micro] entity

Percent change

Large (small)
[micro] entity

FY 2015
unit cost

Application Fee (Non-Refundable)
$40
$100
+$60
+150%
$225

On Registration to Practice Under § 11.6
100
200
+$100
+100%
493

Certificate of Good Standing as an Attorney or Agent, Standard
10
40
+$30
+300%
39

Certificate of Good Standing as an Attorney or Agent, Suitable for Framing
20
50
+$30
+150%
49

Review of Decision by the Director of Enrollment and Discipline Under § 11.2(c)
130
400
+$270
+208%
2,044

Review of Decision of the Director of Enrollment and Discipline Under § 11.2(d)
130
400
+$270
+208%
1,827

Administrative Reinstatement Fee
100
200
+$100
+100%
940

On Grant of Limited Recognition Under § 11.9(b)
new
$200
+$200
n/a
n/a

For USPTO-Assisted Recovery of ID or Reset of Password for the Office of Enrollment and Discipline Information System
new
70
+$70
n/a
n/a

For USPTO-Assisted Change of Address Within the Office of Enrollment and Discipline Information System
new
70
+$70
n/a
n/a

For USPTO-Administered Review of Registration Examination
new
450
+$450
n/a
515

The Office increases the application fee for admission to the examination for registration to practice from $40 to $100, about half of the historical cost of this service.

The fee for registration to practice or for a grant of limited recognition under § 11.9(b) or (c) is currently set at $100, and both transactions have the same fee code. This rule creates a new fee code for On Grant of Limited Recognition, allowing for a separate accounting of registration to practice or for a grant of limited recognition. Both Registration to Practice and Grant of Limited Recognition are increasing to $200, which is still below the estimated cost of performing these services. The Office is eliminating the reference to § 11.9(c) in the current provision. The Office does not presently impose a fee for an unregistered individual to prosecute an international patent application in the manner described in § 11.9(c). The Office is using the existing fee code for Registration to Practice fees and creating a new fee code for Grant of Limited Registration.

The Office is increasing the fee for the delivery of a certificate of good standing. A practitioner may also request a certificate of good standing as an attorney or agent that has been authentically signed by the Director of OED and crafted for framing. The Office is increasing the fee for both of these services to cost recovery, $40 and $50, respectively.

The Office is increasing the fees for petitions to the OED Director regarding enrollment or recognition. However, the new fees are still significantly below cost recovery. Any petition from any action or requirement of the staff of OED reporting to the OED Director shall be taken to the OED Director accompanied by payment of the $400 fee.

The Office is adjusting the fees for a review of the OED Director's decision regarding enrollment or recognition. A party dissatisfied with a final decision of the OED Director regarding enrollment or recognition may seek review of the decision upon petition to the USPTO Director accompanied by payment of the new $400 fee. This is an increase from the current fee but is still set significantly below cost recovery.

The Office is setting the fee for administrative reinstatement at $200. Reinstatement fees are imposed on practitioners seeking to be reinstated to active status. Raising the fee, while still set far below cost recovery, helps to close the gap between the fee and the cost for performing this service.

The Office is creating a fee for USPTO-assisted reset of user IDs and passwords for an OED Information System—Customer Interface (OEDIS-CI) account set at $70. The enhancement of the OEDIS-CI was implemented in FY 2015. With this enhancement, customers are now able to perform this process on-line as a self-service option free of charge. This fee would only be charged if it was requested that the USPTO perform this task instead of the self-service option.

The Office is creating and setting the fee for USPTO-assisted roster maintenance (change of address) in an OEDIS-CI account at $70. With the OEDIS-CI enhancement, customers are now able to perform this process on-line as a self-service method free of charge. This fee would only be charged if it was requested that the USPTO perform this task instead of the self-service option.

The Office is setting the fee for a registration examination review session at $450. Setting this fee at cost recovery relieves the administrative and cost burden of providing the review sessions. A private commercial entity currently provides this service to the public at a lower cost than the USPTO. The availability of the private-sector option has reduced demand for the USPTO-provided sessions and therefore increased the cost per registrant of USPTO-provided sessions.

The Office is setting the fee for changing a practitioner's registration status from agent to attorney. The Office currently charges $100 for this service. The fee would remain unchanged; however, 37 CFR 1.21(a)(2)(iii) would specifically provide for this fee.

(3) Fees Amended To Include Discounts for Small and Micro Entities

Within this section, where new micro entity fees are set, it is expected that an applicant or patent holder would have paid the current small entity fee (or large entity in the event there is not a small entity fee) and dollar and percent changes are calculated from the current small entity fee amount (or large entity fee, where applicable). The following table lists fees where new small and/or micro entity fees are provided. Providing these fee reductions for small and micro entity innovators continues the Office's efforts to foster innovation across all patent system users.

Table 14—Amended Fees To Include Discounts for Small and Micro Entities—Fee Changes and Unit Costs

Fee description
Current fees

Large (small)
[micro] entity

Final rule fees

Large (small)
[micro] entity

Dollar change

Large (small)
[micro] entity

Percent change

Large (small)
[micro] entity

FY 2015
unit cost

Petition for the Delayed Payment of the Fee for Maintaining a Patent in Force

$1,700
($850)
[$850]

$2,000
($1,000)
[$500]

+$300
(+$150)
[−$350]

+18
(+18)
[−41]

$121

Petition for Revival of an Abandoned Application for a Patent, for the Delayed Payment of the Fee for Issuing Each Patent, or for the Delayed Response by the Patent Owner in any Reexamination Proceeding

$1,700
($850)
[$850]

$2,000
($1,000)
[$500]

+$300
(+$150)
[−$350]

+18
(+18)
[−41]

244

Petition for the Delayed Submission of a Priority or Benefit Claim

$1,700
($850)
[$850]

$2,000
($1,000)
[$500]

+$300
(+$150)
[−$350]

+18
(+18)
[−41]

244

Petition to Excuse Applicant's Failure to Act Within Prescribed Time Limits in an International Design Application

$1,700
($850)
[$850]

$2,000
($1,000)
[$500]

+$300
(+$150)
[−$350]

+18
(+18)
[−41]

n/a

Petition to Convert an International Design Application to a Design Application Under 35 U.S.C. Chapter 16

$180
($180)
[$180]

$180
($90)
[$45]

$0
(−$90)
[−$135]

0
(−50)
[−75]

n/a

Hague International Design Application Fees—Transmittal Fee

$120
($120)
[$120]

$120
($60)
[$30]

$0
(−$60)
[−$90]

0
−50
−75

n/a

C. Discontinued or Replaced Fees

This section describes fees that are being discontinued and replaced with new fees. The purpose of this action is to simplify the fee schedule, more clearly inform customers of costs upfront, and align with the Office's new financial software for which fixed fee rates, not variable (
e.g.,
at cost) are preferred. This section also includes fees that are being discontinued because of disuse. The Office does not capture historical cost information for these discontinued or new fees.

(a) Discontinued and Replaced

Table 15—Discontinued Fees With New Fee Replacements

Fee description
Current fees

Large (small)
[micro] entity

Final rule fees

Large (small)
[micro] entity

Dollar change

Large (small)
[micro] entity

Percent change

Large (small)
[micro] entity

FY 2015
unit cost

Copy of Patent-Related File Wrapper and Contents of 400 or Fewer Pages, if Provided on Paper
$200
discontinue
−$200
n/a
n/a

Additional Fee for Each Additional 100 Pages of Patent-Related File Wrapper and (Paper) Contents, or Portion Thereof
$40
discontinue
−$40
n/a
n/a

Copy Patent File Wrapper, Paper Medium, Any Number of Sheets
new
$280
+$280
n/a
n/a

Copy of Patent-Related File Wrapper and Contents if Provided on a Physical Electronic Medium as Specified in § 1.19(b)(1)(ii)
$55
discontinue
−$55
n/a
n/a

Copy of Patent-Related File Wrapper and Contents if Provided Electronically
$55
discontinue
−$55
n/a
n/a

Additional Fee for Each Continuing Physical Electronic Medium in Single Order of § 1.19(b)(1)(ii)(B)
$15
discontinue
−$15
n/a
n/a

Copy Patent File Wrapper, Electronic Medium, Any Size or Provided Electronically
new
$55
+$55
n/a
n/a

Computer Records
at cost
discontinue
at cost
n/a
n/a

Copy of Patent Grant Single-Page TIFF Images (52 week subscription)
new
$10,400
+$10,400
n/a
n/a

Copy of Patent Grant Full-Text W/Embedded Images, Patent Application Publication Single-Page TIFF Images, or Patent Application Publication Full-Text W/Embedded Images (52 week subscription)
new
$5,200
+$5,200
n/a
n/a

Copy of PTMT Patent Bibliographic Extract and Other DVD (Optical Disc) Products
new
$50
+$50
n/a
n/a

Copy of U.S. Patent Custom Data Extracts
new
$100
+$100
n/a
n/a

Copy of Selected Technology Reports, Miscellaneous Technology Areas
new
$30
+$30
n/a
n/a

Labor Charges for Services, per Hour or Fraction Thereof
$40
discontinue
−$40
n/a
n/a

Additional Fee for Overnight Delivery
new
$40
+$40
n/a
n/a

Additional Fee for Expedited Service
new
$160
+$160
n/a
n/a

There are currently pairs of fees for copying patent-related file wrappers: a base fee and an excess fee. For both paper copies and electronic copies, these pairs are replaced with a single fee irrespective of size. A single fee allows customers to more easily budget and plan expenses for this service.

The catch-all fee of “Computer Records” currently priced “at cost” is being replaced by five fees that encompass the work currently performed using this code: Copy of Patent Grant Single-Page TIFF Images (52 week subscription); Copy of Patent Grant Full-Text W/Embedded Images, Patent Application Publication Single-Page TIFF Images, or Patent Application Publication Full-Text W/Embedded Images (52 week subscription); Copy of Patent Technology Monitoring Team (PTMT) Patent Bibliographic Extract and Other DVD (Optical Disc); Copy of U.S. Patent Custom Data Extracts; and Copy of Selected Technology Reports, Miscellaneous Technology Areas. Explicitly stating the service and fee at the start provides customers clearer information to aid decision making.

These specific fees recover the USPTO's costs for processing, validating, packaging, and shipping of these products to customers worldwide. For the copy of Patent Grant Single-Page TIFF Images, when a customer orders this service, the customer is sent expedited weekly packages (one for each Tuesday in the Calendar Year) via United Parcel Service. Each package contains at a minimum one Blu-ray and one DVD optical disc. For the other three services listed for $5,200, the expedited weekly packages (one for each Tuesday or Thursday in the Calendar Year) typically contain either a single Blu-ray or DVD optical disc. As an alternative to requesting and paying for these services, the USPTO has provided customers the ability to download this information at no cost since June 2010. This information is currently provided in the two locations referenced earlier, BDSS and PDD since October 2015 and June 2013 respectively.

Similar to the single fee for copying Patent-Related File Wrappers, the “Labor Charge” per hour with its variable charges is replaced with a single fee for “Expedited Service.” Following the same theme, shorter than standard shipping is currently billed under a catch-all code but is now replaced with a set fee for “Overnight Delivery.”

(b) Discontinued

Table 16—Discontinued Fees

Fee description
Current fees

Large (small)
[micro] entity

Final rule fees

Large (small)
[micro] entity

Dollar change

Large (small)
[micro] entity

Percent change

Large (small)
[micro] entity

FY 2015
unit cost

Self-Service Copy Charge, per Page
$0.25
discontinue
−$0.25
n/a
n/a

Establish Deposit Account
$10
discontinue
−$10
n/a
n/a

Uncertified Statement Re: Status of Maintenance Fee Payments
$10
discontinue
−$10
n/a
n/a
$10

Petitions for documents in form other than that provided by this part, or in form other than that generally provided by Director, to be decided in accordance with merits
at cost
discontinue
at cost
n/a
n/a

Copy of Patent-Related File Wrapper Contents That Were Submitted and are Stored on Compact Disk or Other Electronic Form (e.g., Compact Disks Stored in Artifact Folder), Other Than as Available in § 1.19(b)(1); First Physical Electronic Medium in a Single Order
$55
discontinue
−$55
n/a
n/a

Additional Fee for Each Continuing Copy of Patent-Related File Wrapper Contents as Specified in § 1.19(b)(2)(i)(A)
$15
discontinue
−$15
n/a
n/a

Copy of Patent-Related File Wrapper Contents That Were Submitted and are Stored on Compact Disk, or Other Electronic Form, Other Than as Available in § 1.19(b)(1); if Provided Electronically Other Than on a Physical Electronic Medium, per Order
$55
discontinue
−$55
n/a
n/a

To comply with Presidential Executive Order 13681, Improving the Security of Consumer Financial Transactions, current self-service copiers will be discontinued and the USPTO will enter into a “No Cost” contract with a vendor who will keep all payments collected in exchange for providing this service.

The USPTO's new Financial Manager system allows users to create their own deposit accounts so the Office is retiring the “Establish Deposit Account” fee. The fee associated with “Uncertified Statement Re Status of Maintenance Fee Payments” is discontinued due to lack of use. Customers have had the ability to do this online for more than 10 years. The fee associated with “Petitions for documents in form other than that provided by this part, or in form other than that generally provided by Director, to be decided in accordance with merits” is also discontinued due to lack of use.

The remaining fees pertaining to Patent-Related File Wrapper copies have never been used since their inception many years ago and therefore are being discontinued.

VI. Discussion of Comments

Comments and Responses

The USPTO published a proposed rule on October 3, 2016 soliciting comments on the proposed fee schedule. In response, the USPTO received comments from five intellectual property organizations, one federal agency, and nineteen individual commenters representing law firms, corporations, or themselves. These comments are posted on the USPTO's Web site at
https://www.uspto.gov/about-us/performance-and-planning/fee-setting-and-adjusting.

General Fee Setting Approach

Comment 1:
Two commenters expressed general support for the increases, and another expressed understanding of the fee increases and asked how a change will affect his particular patenting situation.

Response:
The USPTO appreciates the endorsement from the commenters, and is committed to achieving the goals developed in consultation with the stakeholder community as set forth in the Strategic Plan.

Comment 2:
Three commenters objected to any increase in fees, as they believed such increases placed hardships on individual filers, small-business owners, and federal agencies or, due to the resulting growing operating reserve, makes the USPTO an easy target for fee diversion. A United States Federal agency objects to the proposed fee increases citing a direct and negative impact on its ability to apply for, obtain, and maintain patents on its inventions due to flat annual budgets. In the opinion of the Federal agency, the proposed fee increases will limit its patenting activity thus making it more difficult to attract commercial licensees.

Response:
The USPTO appreciates the concern about rising fees, but points out the necessity of adjusting fees to recover the aggregate estimated cost to the Office for processing, activities, services, and materials relating to patents, including administrative costs of the Office with respect to such patent fees. As noted in the NPRM, FY 2018 President's Budget, and the FY 2016 Performance and Accountability Report (PAR) among other publications, the USPTO has made significant progress towards financial sustainability as a result of the initial AIA fee setting effort, including building towards a three-month optimal operating reserve for patents. The Office acutely recognizes that fees cannot simply increase for every improvement the Office deems desirable. Instead, for this rulemaking effort, the Office focused on prioritizing spending and gradually building the operating reserve in order to build resiliency against financial shocks. For small businesses and individual filers, the fees for small and micro entity rates are tiered, with small entities at a 50 percent discount and micro entities at a 75 percent discount. This final rule applies small entity discounts to two additional fees and applies micro entity discounts to six additional fees.

Comment 3:
One commenter cites operating reserve level estimates from the FY 2017 President's Budget, as referred to in the NPRM, noting that the operating reserve level is estimated to exceed the optimal level in out years and that overfunding the operating reserve is unfair to applicants and could be a target for fee diversion.

Response:
In the intervening months since the FY 2017 President's Budget, the Office's budgetary requirements and fee collection estimates have evolved. The USPTO continuously updates both patent fee collections projections and workload projections based on the latest data. Since the NPRM publication in October 2016 there is a revised understanding of expected incoming fees and projected spending.

Over the five year planning horizon budgetary requirements increased compared to the prior NPRM outlook projections. The primary drivers of the requirements variance are investments to modernize IT systems and infrastructure and updated assumptions about the resources necessary to meet production commitments in the Patent Pendency Model and PTAB model. In addition, UPR filings growth projections were revised downward during the FY 2018 budget formulation process due to revised RGDP estimates and more conservative estimates of out year growth. With the FY 2018 President's Budget, and under the fee rates included in this final rule, the operating reserve level estimates do not reach the optimal level of three months of expenses in the five year budget horizon.

As described in Part III. B. of the final rule, which summarizes the USPTO's operating reserve policy, the USPTO will continue to assess the patent operating reserve balance against its target balance annually, and at least every two years, the Office will evaluate whether the target balance continues to be sufficient to provide the funding stability needed by the Office. A key assumption is that the USPTO will

retain fee setting authority to adjust fee rates in the future as assumptions about the out years might change. For example, if the operating reserve balance is projected to exceed the optimal level by 10 percent for two consecutive years, the Office would consider using fee setting authority to reduce fees, per the operating reserve policy. Under the new fee structure, as in the past, the Office will remain a prudent steward of patent fees.

The USPTO continues to communicate the importance of continued access to all fees collected as a critical component of sustainable funding strategy to the public, lawmakers, and the executive branch. While fee diversion remains a possibility without an explicit law eliminating the possibility, the Office will continue its educational efforts in this area.

The financial outlook presented in this final rule reduces the trajectory of the estimated optimal operating reserve level because of changes in fees made in response to stakeholder feedback and in recognition of a changing outlook for Office operations and finances.

PTAB Fees

The Office received five comments regarding the proposed increases in PTAB fees, including two comments about fees for AIA trial proceedings.

Comment 4:
One commenter noted that the work performed by the PTAB in AIA trial proceedings is time consuming, and the commenter supports the increase in fee rates in those proceedings to ensure high quality decisions continue.

Response:
The Office appreciates the commenter's general support for fee increases in AIA trial proceedings. The USPTO is committed to maintaining the PTAB's ability to provide timely and high quality decisions. The AIA significantly affected the operations of the PTAB by establishing new types of trial proceedings. The AIA trial proceedings in the PTAB have been immensely popular (over 5,500 AIA trial proceedings filed through FY 2016) because they provide a less expensive and faster alternative to district court litigation. As a result, the PTAB workload has increased significantly. To accommodate the sudden growth in workload, the PTAB expanded its workforce and has continued to enhance its resources to meet the 12-month statutory requirement for completing each AIA trial proceeding. The fee rates in this final rule are the result of considering and analyzing historical data on the aggregate cost for conducting AIA trial proceedings, now that the proceedings have been in place for three fiscal years. The increase in AIA trial proceeding fees will help the PTAB maintain the level of judicial, legal, and administrative staff necessary to sustain the quality and timeliness of PTAB decisions, and close the gap between the costs and the fees associated with AIA trial proceedings.

Comment 5:
One commenter sought small and micro entity discounts for AIA trial proceeding fees, and requested expansion of pro bono representation to small entities in AIA trial proceedings.

Response:
The authority to reduce fees or to charge additional fees for small and micro entities under the USPTO's rulemaking authority is limited by the AIA to providing discounts to the six categories under Section 10(b) of the Act. AIA trial proceeding fees are outside of the six categories; therefore, absent a change in statutory authority, those fees are not eligible for discounts. The Office further notes that, in many cases, AIA trial proceedings serve as an alternative to more expensive litigation in the district court.

The patent pro bono programs are individually run as regional programs available to assist inventors and small businesses in their state or region. Each program sets the standards for participation, performs the intake function, screens potential clients, screens potential volunteer patent attorneys, and attempts to match the client with the volunteer attorney. These programs may be comprised of bar associations, non-profits, universities, or others. The USPTO, as a federal agency, does not direct the pro bono activities of these programs, but rather, provides resources and expertise to help establish and expand the reach of the programs.

Comment 6:
Three commenters opposed the increase to appeal fees. One commenter specifically expressed concern over passing a large portion of the appeal unit costs as increased fee rates borne by an appellant. Thus, the commenter suggested eliminating, or substantially reducing, the notice of appeal fee. Another commenter questioned whether increasing appeal fees would discourage meritorious appeals, noting that, the reversal rate by the PTAB indicates that a large number of appeals are pursued to correct invalid rejections.

Response:
The Office appreciates the commenters' concerns and, based on that feedback, has eliminated the proposed increase to the notice of appeal fee and reduced the proposed increase to the appeal forwarding fee. Thus, in this final rule, the Notice of Appeal fees will remain at current rates (
e.g.,
$800 for a large entity), and the Office has lowered the appeal forwarding fee from the proposed $2,500 (large entity) in the NPRM to $2,240 (large entity). The Office believes that those fees strike the appropriate balance between the expressed concerns and the Office's need to recover the costs for conducting an appeal. The Office notes that, even with the increase to the appeals forwarding fee, the true cost of an appeal is subsidized significantly. At the current rate, fees paid for an appeal cover 58 percent of the Office's cost for conducting the appeal. The increase to the appeal forwarding fee, which occurs after an examiner's answer, will result in total appeal fees covering approximately 63 percent of the cost for an appeal. Given the high cost of the appeals process to the Office, the appeal forwarding fee adjustment is necessary to decrease the gap between the total fees charged and the total costs in the aggregate for the appeals process.

The Office recognizes that applicants may in some cases need to appeal an examiner's decision. The appeal process, however, results in a high cost to the Office irrespective of whether the PTAB affirms or reverses the rejected claims on appeal because the PTAB must process, review, and decide the appeal on the merits. In addition, Office data show that more than 65 percent of the appeals decided on the merits by the PTAB result in an affirmance of at least some of the rejected claims (September 2016 Appeals and Interferences Statistics). The data demonstrate that the PTAB is affirming a larger percentage of rejected claims than it reverses.

The fee increase also will allow the PTAB to continue to reduce the appeals inventory and improve pendency for appeals. Additionally, the Office notes that the notice of appeal fee provides an appellant two months to file a brief, and to have that brief reviewed by two examiners and a supervisor with a subsequent conference regarding the rejection, the brief, and whether the appellant will forward the case to the PTAB for consideration of the appeal on the merits. If the examiner decides to reopen the case or allow it, the cost to an appellant for filing the notice of appeal would be less than the appellant would incur in filing an RCE, which is the other option available when facing rejection. The Office considered the relationship between the options of an appeal, on the one hand, and requesting an RCE, on the other, when determining the appropriate fee rates in this rulemaking.

Comment 7:
A commenter suggested that the Office consider suspending the appeal forwarding fee until an application is taken up for review by PTAB, given the appeal backlog and the current state of flux of patent subject matter eligibility.

Response:
In the future, the USPTO may consider changes to the timing of appeal fee payments. However, the general rule is that fees payable to the USPTO are required to be paid in advance; that is, at the time of requesting any action by the Office (37 CFR 1.22).

Comment 8:
One commenter proposed a refund to an applicant for reversals by the PTAB.

Response:
At this time, the USPTO does not have the statutory authority to issue refunds on the basis of
ex parte
appeal outcome.

Comment 9:
One commenter expressed interest in seeing the increased fee data versus decrease in response time to determine if the fee increase resulted in increased productivity of the USPTO and PTAB.

Response:
The Office appreciates the suggestion to compare data regarding increases in fee versus decrease in response time. The Office will continue to explore whether and how such comparative data fit within the overall fee setting strategy of allowing the Office to recover the aggregate cost of patent operations, while implementing key strategic initiatives, including decreasing pendency. The Office notes that the PTAB has made significant strides in reducing the appeals inventory and pendency of appeals over the past several years. Appeal inventory reached over 27,000 in 2012 (prior to the last fee setting rule), and the PTAB reduced that inventory to about 17,000 by the end of FY 2016. Thus, the PTAB has maintained a high level of productivity despite an increase in workload. The additional fees set forth in this rule will provide funds necessary to allow the PTAB to continue to maintain the appropriate level of judicial and administrative resources needed to provide high quality and timely decisions for
ex parte
appeals.

Between 2012 and 2016 the PTAB also received more than 5,500 petitions for AIA trial proceedings, and met all statutory deadlines in those proceedings. Despite the high demand for these services, the PTAB has continued to meet all AIA statutory deadlines. By targeting a fee increase to the AIA trial fees, the Office is addressing the subsidization of these proceedings in order to allow the PTAB to continue to maintain the appropriate level of judicial and administrative resources to provide high quality and timely decisions for AIA trial proceedings.

Examination Fees

Comment 10:
A commenter questions the USPTO's statement that pendency has improved, noting that in the opinion of the commenter, at least a portion of the improvement is due to reduced quality. Specifically, the commenter questions whether examiners are properly incentivized to conduct adequate examinations; the comment describes several examples of rejections that allegedly illustrate poor quality examinations. The commenter closes by proposing that if the PTAB or the Court of Appeals reverses an examiner rejection, the fees paid or a multiple thereof would be refunded to the applicant and deducted from the bonus payments of the examiners who signed off on the rejection.

Response:
As part of its current strategic plan, the Office has a goal to optimize patent quality and timeliness. The aim of the Office's processes for examiner oversight, review, and rewards, including the bonus payment program, is to provide high quality and timely examination at a reasonable cost. The Office continually assesses its operational strategies with respect to these processes to take into account changing circumstances, and the Office's efforts to reduce pendency have resulted in first action and average total pendency dropping from a high of 21.9 months and 32.4 months, respectively, in FY 2012 to 16.2 months and 25.3 months today. As pendency continues to decline, the Office's ability to test programs that may further enhance quality grows stronger, as demonstrated by the establishment of the Enhanced Patent Quality Initiative (EPQI) (
https://www.uspto.gov/patent/initiatives/enhanced-patent-quality-initiative-0
) in FY 2015.

As part of the EPQI, the USPTO solicited stakeholder feedback through various outreach efforts and used this feedback to develop and refine multiple programs to improve quality. One of these programs is the Increasing Clarity and Reasoning in Office Action program in which the Office included tips and techniques for drafting clear Office actions as part of examiner training. For example, as part of the Office's training on 35 U.S.C. 101, the USPTO not only taught the relevant changes in the law, but also included examples on how to write clear rejections as well as tips for responding to arguments. As a result of this training, there was a statistically significant improvement in the correctness and clarity of 35 U.S.C. 101 rejections. As part of the Quality Metrics program, the Office overhauled its quality metrics for work products and for examination processes. With respect to work products, the Office used data from the new Master Review Form to create clarity and correctness metrics on a per statute basis, which will allow the Office to better assess how to improve Office action quality. With respect to examination processes, the Office is evaluating certain types of transactions, such as rework and reopenings, to identify trends and examiner behaviors indicative of either best practices or potential quality concerns. Rather than setting targets for the particular transactions, the Office is conducting a root-cause analysis to allow for reopenings and rework where appropriate while providing training to ensure examiners have the necessary skills and resources to be as efficient as possible. These programs highlight only a couple of the programs that the Office is currently implementing to improve quality.

While providing refunds or deducting base or bonus pay from examiners is beyond the scope of this rulemaking, the Office continues to review new and revised approaches to determine what approaches may better incentivize the patent workforce to achieve its strategic goals.

Comment 11:
One commenter expressed concerns regarding the proposed increased fee rates for excess claims in reexaminations.

Response:
The large entity fee for a reexamination with unlimited pages is set at $12,000. The unit cost for performing this service was $23,288 in FY 2015. When fewer claims are filed, the time required for the assigned reexamination specialist to review the request and examine the requested claims is reduced, which translates to a reduced overall cost of conducting the proceeding. The excess claims fees charges help to subsidize the overall cost for performing a reexamination.

Comment 12:
One commenter suggested that the Office should consider expanding the situations for which a portion of reexamination fees may be refunded. For example, a partial refund of the reexamination fees may be merited where a reexamination is ordered, but an examiner does not make any new art-based rejections.

Response:
The USPTO is required to go through the entire reexamination process and the costs are calculated on the time an examiner spends on the reexamination. Whether the examiner makes a new rejection or not does not factor into how the Office calculates the cost of a reexamination proceeding. The

addition of claims by patent owner during an
ex parte
reexamination ordered pursuant to 35 U.S.C. 303 require the examiner to examine those claims during the proceeding, which includes making decisions which may be either adverse or favorable to patentability. Thus, even when the examiner does not make new art based rejections to new claims (
e.g.
makes a decision favorable to patentability with respect to the new claims to newly added claims), the addition of new claims by patent owner during the proceeding necessarily requires additional time by the examiner to fully search and examine those new claims. Further, even when the art cited by requester under 35 U.S.C. 301 is applicable to the newly added claims presented by the patent owner during the proceeding, the examiner will still need to search and examine the new claims to ensure the best art is presented with respect to those new claims. Thus, the time and cost of completing a reexamination proceeding is not necessarily predicated on whether or not new art based rejections are made by the examiner during the proceeding, but rather the amount of time needed to make decisions as to patentability. Accordingly, relating a fee refund to whether additional art rejections are made during the proceeding is not necessarily merited.

Design Fees

Comment 13:
The Office received three comments concerning the increase in design patent issue fee rates. Commenters noted that design patent issue fees were being increased by a large percentage and significantly more than utility patent issue fees were being increased.

Response:
As discussed in Part V. B., the increase to the design patent issue fee has been lowered twice from the initial proposal made in October 2015 based on stakeholder feedback. The final design patent issue fee is $700, an increase of $140 (25 percent) for large entities. The minimum required fees to obtain a design patent (filing, search, examination and issue) are set to increase slightly beyond cost recovery for large entities ($1,660 versus $1,596 in FY 2015) to subsidize the substantial number (almost half in FY 2015) of small and micro entity applicants who pay lower fee rates despite similar costs to the Office.

Further, given the lack of maintenance fees to subsidize front-end costs for design patents, the new fee rates aim to more closely align design-related fees with their costs. Even with the increased fee rates, design application processing costs will continue to be subsidized by non-design specific fee revenues. Still, the Office believes the moderate fee rate increases in filing, search, examination, and issue are more appropriately aligned to costs and support the policy factor to foster innovation.

Comment 14:
Two commenters suggest that the increase of design patent fee rates are comparatively greater than similar fees charged by other national/regional IP offices.

Response:
Substantive examination of design patent applications are conducted at the USPTO whereas most other national/regional IP offices do not conduct substantive examination of design patent applications. Substantive examination of design patent applications requires significant time from a highly trained patent examiner. Additionally, most other national/regional IP offices require design patent holders to pay renewal fees to maintain their property rights. As previously noted, in the United States, design patents are not subject to renewal fees.

Comment 15:
Two commenters suggested allowing applicants to submit design patent applications with multiple designs per application instead of a single design per application, as required under current practice.

Response:
Changes to design application practice are beyond the scope of the Office's fee setting authority. Currently, more than one embodiment of a design may be claimed so long as such embodiments involve a single inventive concept according to the obviousness-type double patenting practice for designs.

Comment 16:
Three commenters questioned the calculation of the costs of filing, search, examination, and issuance of design patents.

Response:
For detailed information about how the Office calculates these costs please
see
the appendix entitled “Activity Based Information and Patent Fee Unit Expense Methodology,” available at
https://www.uspto.gov/sites/default/files/documents/ABI%20Cost%20Supplement.docx.

Comment 17:
Three commenters pointed out that the costs of filing and issuance are the same for design patent applications as they are for utility, plant, and reissue patent applications.

Response:
The pre-examination and issuance processing for all of these patent application types are similar, and vary little between types. Therefore, the costs for these services are the same among the different patent types.

Comment 18:
Two commenters noted that the cost of search and examination of design patent applications is relatively high compared to other national/regional IP offices.

Response:
As mentioned previously, this is because a substantive examination is required under U.S. statute, which is a costly process. Substantive examination of design patents is not common in other national/regional IP offices.

Plant Fees

Comment 19:
The Office received ten comments from persons concerned with the increase in plant patent issue fee rates. These comments generally touched on the many years of development that go into new plant varieties, and noted that the resulting products are not sold in high volumes nor at high costs per unit, and therefore it can be difficult to recuperate costs.

Response:
As first discussed in Part V. B., the increase to the plant patent issue fee has been lowered from the rate proposed in the NPRM based on stakeholder feedback. The final plant patent issue fee is $800, an increase of $40 (5 percent) for large entities. In both the current and final rule fee structure, front-end fees are set below the Office's costs to foster innovation, per the fee setting policy factor. In the case of utility patents, the Office recovers these costs at the end of the process through maintenance fees. Similar to design patents (discussed earlier), plant patent holders are not required to pay maintenance fees. Additionally, similar to design patents, a significant proportion of applicants are provided small or micro entity discounts. While the fee rates in this rule will allow plant patent fees to recover a greater share of plant patent related costs, the balance will continue to be subsidized by other types of patent fees. However, in response to stakeholder concerns, specifically those regarding the potential impacts on small entities and individual inventors, the Office determined that a smaller fee rate increase was acceptable. For more information on costs please
see
the Regulatory Impact Analysis, Table of Patent Fees, and Activity Based Information and Patent Fee Unit Expense Methodology, all available at
https://www.uspto.gov/about-us/performance-and-planning/fee-setting-and-adjusting.

Request for Continued Examination (RCE) Fees

Comment 20:
Four commenters had concerns about the proposed increased fees for RCEs, though two of these commenters did express appreciation that the proposed rates were lower than the original October 2015 proposal. One

commenter believed that an examiner should be familiar with the application, prior art, and issues when handling an RCE, and interpreted the increase of RCE fee rates as an attempt to dissuade applicants from filing RCEs, rather than a means to recoup costs.

Response:
The Office appreciates the comments related to RCE costs. In setting the fee rates, the Office's goal is not to dissuade RCE filings, but to more closely align the fee rates with the cost of processing RCEs, as calculated using the most recently available cost data (FY 2015). The first RCE fee ($1,300 for large entities) has been set at a rate lower than both the cost of performing the services associated with an RCE ($2,187) and the fees for filing a continuing application ($1,720 for large entities), as well as much lower than the average historic cost of services associated with examining a new patent application ($4,255). Because the Office set the fee for the first RCE below the cost to process, the Office must recoup the costs elsewhere. Since most applicants that file one or more RCE resolve all remaining issues with a first RCE, the Office determined that applicants that file more than one RCE are using the patent system more extensively than those who file none or only one RCE. The fee set for the second and subsequent RCE ($1,900 for large entities) is above the cost of the Office processing those RCEs ($1,540). However, this does not fully recoup the costs associated with the first RCE, and the Office still must recoup the costs elsewhere for large entity applicants filing more than one RCE ($3,200 in RCE fees, $3,727 in costs).

Comment 21:
Another commenter believed the process used to arrive at the unit cost estimates for RCE processing is opaque and unreliable, citing inconsistencies in reported data. This commenter also questioned the use of a survey to allocate expenses. The commenter believed that a more focused look at the unit cost estimates is necessary before increasing fee rates.

Response:
The differences in the reported RCE costs from the initial proposal to PPAC and the NPRM are due to an improvement in the costing methodology. The approach was updated in FY 2015, and the data in more recent documents reflect the improved methodology, including updated historical data. Previously, the RCE cost was determined using the Total Activity Unit Expense Adjusted for Frequency of Occurrence approach, which based the cost of the RCE on activities performed only during the RCE process and summed the unit costs to obtain a final unit cost of an RCE. The updated methodology, the Incremental Expense approach, improves upon this by also capturing the increased cost of search and exam activities that occur prior to RCE filings. For those applications that reach an RCE, the initial cost of getting to that stage is greater than for an application that does not reach an RCE. When calculating the historical cost of standard search and examination fees, the Office uses the cost of only applications that do not undergo an RCE. By using the incremental costing approach, the increased initial cost for applications that reach an RCE is captured within the RCE fee expense number. The patent examiner survey captures an average level of effort for the various examination activities. However, the survey does not isolate RCEs and therefore does not capture the level of effort specific to an RCE. Year-to-year variations in results have been small, but because survey data is applied to approximately $2 billion worth of expense, very small changes in the survey responses could result in large dollar changes to various activity costs. The survey instrument and the associated burdening and factoring of workloads is the Office's best estimate for costs given available information.

The $411 increase in the RCE expense shown from FY 2014 to FY 2015 comes from an increase in cost for RCE specific work. Total Adjusted Activity expense for the activities `Prepare All Subsequent Actions' and `Perform Subsequent Search' increased the most for applications with RCE activities both before and during the RCE itself. No material changes were made in overhead allocations; however, overhead costs increased, specifically related to investment in Information Technology associated with the Patent End to End System.

Comment 22:
A commenter expressed appreciation for the Office's efforts to reduce the need for RCEs, but noted that many RCE filings are due to the current final rejection and after final practices, and urged the Office to eliminate these policies. The commenter argued that allowing every response to be entered will improve quality and lower pendency. The commenter believes that, before increasing RCE fee rates, the Office should determine the cost of after final responses and advisory actions.

Response:
The Office appreciates the comments on the various efforts to reduce the need for RCEs. These comments are outside the scope of this rulemaking, however, the Office looks forward to working with stakeholders as it continues efforts related to the Enhanced Patent Quality Initiative and any potential revisions to final rejection and after final policies. The AFCP 2.0—extended through September 30, 2017—is part of the USPTO's on-going efforts towards compact prosecution and increased collaboration between examiners and stakeholders. Regarding the cost of after final responses and advisory actions, the estimated the cost of these activities are calculated and included in the unit cost of other associated activities provided by the Office. For detailed information about how the Office calculates these costs please
see
the appendix entitled “Activity Based Information and Patent Fee Unit Expense Methodology” available a

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/fr%3A2017-24390. Public record. Not legal advice.
