# State Vocational Rehabilitation Services Program; State Supported Employment Services Program; Limitations on Use of Subminimum Wage

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/fr%3A2016-15980

## Record

- **Collection:** Federal Register
- **Document type:** Rule
- **Published:** August 19, 2016
- **Citation:** 81 FR 55630

## Text

DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION
34 CFR Parts 361, 363, and 397
[ED-2015-OSERS-0001]
RIN 1820-AB70
State Vocational Rehabilitation Services Program; State Supported Employment Services Program; Limitations on Use of Subminimum Wage

AGENCY:

Office of Special Education and Rehabilitative Services, Department of Education.

ACTION:

Final regulations.

SUMMARY:

The Secretary amends the regulations governing the State Vocational Rehabilitation Services program and the State Supported Employment Services program to implement changes to the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, as amended by the Workforce Innovation and Opportunity Act (WIOA) signed into law on July 22, 2014. The Secretary also updates, clarifies, and improves the prior regulations.

Finally, the Secretary issues new regulations regarding limitations on the use of subminimum wages that are added by WIOA and under the purview of the Department.

DATES:

These regulations are effective on September 19, 2016, except for amendatory instructions 2, 3, and 4 amending 34 CFR 361.10, 361.23, and 361.40, which are effective October 18, 2016.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:

Ed Anthony, U.S. Department of Education, 400 Maryland Avenue SW., Room 5086, Potomac Center Plaza (PCP), Washington, DC 20202-2800. Telephone: (202) 245-7488 or by email:
Edward.Anthony@ed.gov
.

If you use a telecommunications device for the deaf (TDD) or a text telephone (TTY), call the Federal Relay Service (FRS), toll free, at 1-800-877-8339.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

Executive Summary

Purpose of This Regulatory Action: Individuals with disabilities represent a vital and integral part of our society, and we are committed to ensuring that individuals with disabilities have opportunities to compete for and enjoy high quality employment in the 21st century global economy. Some individuals with disabilities face particular barriers to employment in integrated settings that pays competitive wages, provides opportunities for advancement, and leads to economic self-sufficiency. Ensuring workers with disabilities have the supports and the opportunities to acquire the skills that they need to pursue in-demand jobs and careers is critical to growing our economy, assuring that everyone who works hard is rewarded, and building a strong middle class. To help achieve this priority for individuals with disabilities, the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 (Act), as amended by the Workforce Innovation and Opportunity Act (WIOA) (P.L. 113-128), signed into law on July 22, 2014, seeks to empower individuals with disabilities to maximize employment, economic self-sufficiency, independence, and inclusion in and integration into society.

To implement the changes to the Act made by WIOA, the Secretary amends the regulations governing the State Vocational Rehabilitation Services program (VR program) (34 CFR part 361) and State Supported Employment Services program (Supported Employment program) (34 CFR part 363), administered by the Rehabilitation Services Administration (RSA), within the Office of Special Education and Rehabilitative Services. In addition, the Secretary updates and clarifies prior regulations to improve the operation of the program. Finally, the Secretary promulgates regulations in new 34 CFR part 397 that implement the limitations on the payment of subminimum wages to individuals with disabilities in section 511 of the Act that fall under the purview of the Secretary.

Summary of the Major Provisions of This Regulatory Action:
We summarize here those regulatory changes needed to implement the amendments to the Act made by WIOA for each part in the order it appears in the Code of Federal Regulations (CFR).

State Vocational Rehabilitation Services Program

WIOA makes significant changes to title I of the Act that affect the VR program. First, WIOA strengthens the alignment of the VR program with other core components of the workforce development system by imposing requirements governing unified strategic planning, common performance accountability measures, and the one-stop delivery system. This alignment brings together entities responsible for administering separate workforce and employment, educational, and other human resource programs to collaborate in the creation of a seamless customer-focused service delivery network that integrates service delivery across programs, enhances access to the programs' services, and improves long-term employment outcomes for individuals receiving assistance. In so doing, WIOA places heightened emphasis on coordination and collaboration at the Federal, State, and local levels to ensure a streamlined and coordinated service delivery system for job-seekers, including those with disabilities, and employers. Therefore, the Departments of Education and Labor are issuing joint final regulations to implement jointly administered activities under title I of WIOA (
e.g.,
those related to Unified or Combined State Plans, performance accountability, and the one-stop delivery system), applicable to the workforce development system's core programs (Adult, Dislocated Worker, and Youth programs; Adult Education and Family Literacy Act programs; Wagner-Peyser Employment Services program; and the VR program). The joint final regulations, along with the
Analysis of Comments and Changes
to those regulations, are set forth in a separate regulatory action published elsewhere in this issue of the
Federal Register
.

To implement WIOA's corresponding major changes to title I of the Act, we:

• Amend § 361.10 to require that all assurances and descriptive information previously submitted through the stand-alone VR State Plan and supported employment supplement be submitted through the VR services portion of the Unified or Combined State Plan under section 102 or section 103, respectively, of WIOA.

• Clarify in § 361.29 that States report to the Secretary updates to the statewide needs assessment and goals and priorities, estimates of the numbers of individuals with disabilities served through the VR program and the costs of serving them, and reports of progress on goals and priorities at such time and in such manner determined by the Secretary to align the reporting of this information with the submission of the Unified or Combined State Plans and their modifications.

• Clarify in § 361.20 when designated State agencies must conduct public hearings to obtain comment on substantive changes to policies and procedures governing the VR program.

• Remove § 361.80 through § 361.89 and replace with § 361.40 to cross-reference the joint regulations for the common performance accountability measures for the core programs of the workforce development system.

• Provide a cross-reference in § 361.23, regarding the roles and responsibilities of the VR program in the one-stop delivery system to the joint regulations implementing requirements for the one-stop delivery system.

Second, the Act, as amended by WIOA, emphasizes the achievement of competitive integrated employment. The foundation of the VR program is the principle that individuals with disabilities, including those with the most significant disabilities, are capable of achieving high quality, competitive integrated employment when provided the necessary services and supports. To increase the employment of individuals with disabilities in the competitive integrated labor market, the workforce system must provide individuals with disabilities opportunities to participate in job-driven training and to pursue high quality employment outcomes. The amendments to the Act—from the stated purpose of the Act, to the expansion of services designed to maximize the potential of individuals with disabilities, including those with the most significant disabilities, to achieve competitive integrated employment, and, finally, to the inclusion of limitations on the payment of subminimum wages to individuals with disabilities—reinforce the congressional intent that individuals with disabilities, with appropriate supports and services, are able to achieve the same kinds of competitive integrated employment as non-disabled individuals. Consequently, we make extensive changes to part 361, including:

• The inclusion of a new definition of “competitive integrated employment” in § 361.5(c)(9) that combines, clarifies, and enhances the two separate definitions of “competitive employment” and “integrated setting” for the purpose of employment under the VR program in prior § 361.5(b)(11) and (b)(33)(ii).

• The incorporation of the principle that individuals with disabilities, including those with the most significant disabilities, are capable of achieving high quality competitive integrated employment, when provided the necessary services and support, throughout part 361, from the statement of program purpose in § 361.1 to the requirement in § 361.46(a) that the individualized plan for employment include a specific employment goal consistent with the general goal of competitive integrated employment.

• The revision of the definition of “employment outcome” in § 361.5(c)(15) that specifically identifies customized employment as an employment outcome under the VR program, and requires that all employment outcomes achieved through the VR program be in competitive integrated employment or supported employment, thereby eliminating uncompensated outcomes, such as homemakers and unpaid family workers, from the scope of the definition for purposes of the VR program.

To assist designated State units (DSUs) to implement the change in the definition of “employment outcome” and to ensure that individuals with disabilities did not experience a disruption in services, the Department proposed in the Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (NPRM) published on April 16, 2015 (80 FR 21059), a transition period of six months following the effective date of the final regulations, during which period DSUs would complete the provision of vocational rehabilitation services to, and close the service records of, individuals pursuing uncompensated outcomes, such as homemakers and unpaid family workers, in accordance with individualized plans for employment that were approved prior to the effective date of these final regulations. In consideration of the comments received, the Secretary has extended the transition period in these final regulations. DSUs may continue to provide services to individuals with uncompensated employment goals on their individualized plans for employment, approved prior to the effective date of these final regulations, until June 30, 2017, unless a longer period of time is required based on the needs of the individual with the disability as determined by the vocational rehabilitation counselor and the individual with a disability, as documented in the individual's service record.

We also amend numerous other provisions throughout part 361 to address the expansion of available services, requirements related to the development of the individualized plan for employment, and order of selection for services, all of which are intended to maximize the potential for individuals with disabilities to prepare for, obtain, retain, and advance in the same high quality jobs and high-demand careers as persons without disabilities.

Third, WIOA emphasizes the provision of services to students and youth with disabilities to ensure that they have meaningful opportunities to receive the services, including training and other supports, they need to achieve employment outcomes in competitive integrated employment. The Act, as amended by WIOA, expands not only the population of students with disabilities who may receive vocational rehabilitation services but also the breadth of services that the VR agencies may provide to youth and students with disabilities who are transitioning from school to postsecondary education and employment. We implement the emphasis on serving students and youth with disabilities contained in the amendments to the Act made by WIOA in many regulatory changes to part 361 by:

• Including in § 361.5(c)(51) and (c)(58), respectively, new definitions of “student with a disability” and “youth with a disability.” After further analysis of the comments received, the Department has determined that the definition of “student with a disability” applies to all students enrolled in educational programs, including postsecondary education programs, so long as they satisfy the age requirements set forth in final § 361.5(c)(51). The definition is also inclusive of secondary students who are homeschooled, as well as students in other non-traditional secondary educational programs. We have incorporated this broader interpretation of the definition in final § 361.5(c)(51), which we believe will increase the potential for DSUs to maximize the use of funds reserved for the provision of pre-employment transition services by increasing the number of students who may receive these services.

• Implementing in § 361.48(a) the requirements of new sections 110(d) and 113 of the Act requiring States to reserve at least 15 percent of their Federal allotment to provide and arrange for, in coordination with local educational agencies, the provision of pre-employment transition services to students with disabilities. We have maintained our interpretation of “potentially eligible,” for purposes of pre-employment transition services, as meaning all students with disabilities, regardless of whether they have applied for or been determined eligible for the VR program. The Department believes this is the broadest legally supportable interpretation and is consistent with the congressional intent.

• Amending § 361.29(a) to require that the comprehensive statewide needs assessment include an assessment of the needs of students and youth with disabilities for vocational rehabilitation services, including the needs of students with disabilities for pre-employment transition services.

• Clarifying in § 361.49 the technical assistance DSUs may provide to educational agencies and permitting the provision of transition services for the benefit of groups of students and youth with disabilities.

• Clarifying in § 361.22(c) that nothing in this part is to be construed as reducing the responsibility of the local educational agencies or any other

agencies under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) to provide or pay for transition services that are also considered to be special education or related services under the IDEA necessary for the provision of a free appropriate public education to students with disabilities.

In addition to the preceding changes implementing the three major goals of the Act, as amended by WIOA, we have made changes to the regulations governing the comprehensive system of personnel development and the fiscal administration of the VR program. In order for DSUs to recruit qualified personnel to provide services to individuals with disabilities, including students and youth with disabilities, and carry out their responsibilities under the Act, we have made changes by:

• Amending § 361.18 governing the comprehensive system of personnel development by establishing minimum educational and experience requirements and eliminating the requirement to retrain staff not meeting the DSU's personnel standard for qualified staff.

• Revising proposed § 361.18(c)(2)(ii) in these final regulations to provide a more complete list of the skills and knowledge needed to meet the needs of employers and individuals with disabilities in the 21st century evolving labor market.

Finally, we make changes to part 361 to improve the fiscal administration of the VR program by:

• Clarifying in § 361.5(b) the applicability to the VR program of the definitions contained in 2 CFR part 200, Uniform Administrative Requirements, Cost Principles, and Audit Requirements and making numerous other conforming changes to align this part with 2 CFR part 200 to ensure consistency.

• Adding a new paragraph (a)(3) to § 361.65 requiring the State to reserve not less than 15 percent of its allotment for the provision of pre-employment transition services.

• Amending § 361.65(b)(2) to clarify that reallotment occurs in the fiscal year the funds were appropriated and the funds may be obligated or expended during the period of performance, provided that matching requirements are met.

• Adding a new paragraph (b)(3) to § 361.65 establishing the Secretary's authority to determine the criteria to be used to reallot funds when the amount requested exceeds the amount of funds available for reallotment.

Since publication of the NPRM, as a result of further Departmental review, we clarify in § 361.63 the requirements for the use of program income.

State Supported Employment Services Program

Under the State Supported Employment Services program (Supported Employment program) authorized under title VI of the Act (29 U.S.C. 795g
et seq.
), the Secretary provides grants to assist States in developing and implementing collaborative programs with appropriate entities to provide supported employment services for individuals with the most significant disabilities, including youth with the most significant disabilities, to enable them to achieve supported employment outcomes in competitive integrated employment. Grants made under the Supported Employment program supplement grants issued to States under the VR program (34 CFR part 361).

WIOA makes several significant changes to title VI of the Act, which governs the Supported Employment program. All of the amendments to title VI are consistent with those made throughout the Act, namely to maximize the potential of individuals with disabilities, especially those with the most significant disabilities, to achieve competitive integrated employment and to expand services for youth with the most significant disabilities. We implement the changes made to the Supported Employment program by WIOA in these final regulations by:

• Requiring in § 363.1 that supported employment be in competitive integrated employment or, if not, in an integrated setting in which the individual is working toward competitive integrated employment on a short-term basis. As a result of comments received, we revised the proposed short-term basis period to allow for an extension of the six-month period for up to a total of 12 months based on the needs of the individual, and the individual has demonstrated progress toward competitive earnings based on information contained in the service record.

• Extending in § 363.50(b)(1) the time from 18 months to 24 months for the provision of supported employment services.

• Requiring in § 363.22 a reservation of 50 percent of a State's allotment under this part for the provision of supported employment services, including extended services, to youth with the most significant disabilities.

• Requiring in § 363.23 not less than a 10 percent match for the amount of funds reserved to serve youth with the most significant disabilities.

• Reducing in § 363.51 the amount of funds that may be spent on administrative costs.

In response to comments received, we revised §§ 363.53, 363.54, and 363.55 to clarify the requirements for the transition of individuals with the most significant disabilities from supported employment services to extended services, the achievement of a supported employment outcome, and the closure of service records. We have redesignated proposed § 363.55 as final § 363.56.

Limitations on the Use of Subminimum Wage

Section 511 of the Act, as added by WIOA, imposes requirements on employers who hold special wage certificates under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) that must be satisfied before the employers may hire youth with disabilities at subminimum wages or continue to employ individuals with disabilities of any age at the subminimum wage level. Section 511 also establishes the roles and responsibilities of the DSUs for the VR program and State and local educational agencies in assisting individuals with disabilities, including youth with disabilities, to maximize opportunities to achieve competitive integrated employment through services provided by VR and local educational agencies.

The addition of section 511 to the Act is consistent with all other amendments to the Act made by WIOA. Throughout the Act, Congress emphasizes that individuals with disabilities, including those with the most significant disabilities, can achieve competitive integrated employment if provided the necessary supports and services. The limitations imposed by section 511 reinforce this belief by requiring individuals with disabilities, including youth with disabilities, to satisfy certain service-related requirements in order to start or maintain, as applicable, subminimum wage employment. To implement the requirements of section 511 that fall under the purview of the Department, we are issuing new regulations in part 397, including:

• Section 397.1, describing the purpose of this part and § 397.2 setting forth the Department's jurisdiction.

• Section 397.10, requiring the DSU, in consultation with the State educational agency, to develop a process that ensures students and youth with disabilities receive documentation demonstrating completion of the various activities required by section 511 of the Act, such as, to name a few, the receipt of transition services under the IDEA

and pre-employment transition services under section 113 of the Act, as appropriate.

• Sections 397.20 and 397.30, establishing the activities that must be completed by youth with disabilities prior to obtaining employment at subminimum wage and the documentation that the DSUs and local educational agencies, as appropriate, must provide to demonstrate completion of those activities, required by section 511(a)(2) of the Act. These include completing pre-employment transition services in final § 361.48(a) and the determination of eligibility or ineligibility for vocational rehabilitation services in final §§ 361.42 and 361.43.

• Section 397.40, establishing the documentation that DSUs must provide to individuals with disabilities of any age who are employed at a subminimum wage upon the completion of certain information and career counseling-related services, as required by section 511(c) of the Act.

• Section 397.31, prohibiting a local educational agency or a State educational agency from entering into a contract with an entity that employs individuals at subminimum wages for the purpose of operating a program under which a youth with a disability is engaged in work compensated at a subminimum wage.

• Section 397.50 authorizing a DSU to review individual documentation, required by this part, for all individuals with disabilities who are employed at the subminimum wage level, that is maintained by employers who hold special wage certificates under the FLSA.

In response to comments received, we made revisions to the final regulations to specify that intervals for providing career counseling and information and referral services to individuals of any age employed by section 14(c) entities will be calculated based upon the date the individual becomes known to the DSU starting July 22, 2016. Additionally, we included a time frame in the final regulations of 45 days but, in the case of extenuating circumstances, no later than 90 days, for the DSU to provide documentation of completed activities to individuals with disabilities. We also added provisions that establish minimal information that must be contained in the documentation required by part 397, as well as other administrative requirements related to the documentation process. Finally, we determined that section 14(c) entities have a potential financial interest in providing some of the services and activities required in the final regulations. Consequently, we inserted language prohibiting the use of these entities in providing these required services or activities, stating that a contractor may not be an entity holding a special wage certificate under section 14(c) of the FLSA and that a DSU's contractor, for the purpose of conducting the review of documentation authorized under the final regulations, may not be an entity holding a special wage certificate under section 14(c) of the FLSA.

We fully explain the regulations described in this
Executive Summary,
along with all other significant changes to parts 361, 363, and 397 following the publication of the NPRM, in the
Analysis of Comments and Changes
section of this preamble.

Costs and Benefits:
The potential costs associated with this regulatory action are those resulting from statutory requirements and those we have determined as necessary for administering the Department's programs and activities. Further information related to costs and benefits may be found in the
Regulatory Impact Analysis
section later in this preamble.

Public Comment:
In response to our invitation in the NPRM, more than 1,100 parties submitted comments on the proposed regulations amending the VR program (part 361), amending the Supported Employment program (part 363), and adding part 397 implementing the new provisions in section 511 of the Act, as amended by WIOA. We discuss substantive issues within each part, by section or subject. Generally, we do not address technical and other minor changes.

Analysis of Comments and Changes:

Part 361 State Vocational Rehabilitation Services Program

Following a description of the organizational changes to part 361 in these final regulations, we present the
Analysis of Comments and Changes
in three sections. In section A, we discuss provisions in part 361 that apply generally to the administration of the VR program and to the provision of vocational rehabilitation services to individuals with disabilities. In section B, we discuss provisions related to the transition of students and youth with disabilities from school to postsecondary education and employment. Finally, in section C, we discuss the fiscal administration of the VR program.

Due to extensive changes, we published the entire part 361 in the NPRM, which included conforming and technical changes. We did not propose substantive changes to all sections of this part. Thus, we did not intend to make all regulations within this part available for public comment. Consequently, we do not address the comments we received on the following sections: §§ 361.5(c)(18), 361.5(c)(24), 361.5(c)(27), 361.5(c)(28), 361.5(c)(29), 361.5(c)(30), 361.5(c)(34), 361.5(c)(40), 361.5(c)(43), 361.5(c)(57), 361.47, 361.52, 361.56, and 361.57. Finally, we generally do not discuss differences between the NPRM and these final regulations that are technical or conforming in nature.

Organizational Changes

Although the regulations maintain subparts A, B, and C of part 361, we make organizational changes to other subparts within this part. First, we incorporate new subparts D, E, and F, where we place the three subparts discussed in a separate, but related, regulatory action (the joint regulations issued by the Departments of Education and Labor implementing jointly administered requirements governing all six core programs of the workforce development system, including the VR program, contained in title I of WIOA) published elsewhere in this issue of the
Federal Register
. Please see that regulatory action for more information about how these subparts are incorporated into part 361. Second, we remove prior §§ 361.80 through 361.89, since the VR program-specific standards and indicators are no longer applicable. Finally, we eliminate Appendix A to prior part 361—Questions and Responses. The Department intends to issue guidance on various areas covered in the final regulations, including some that had been covered by prior Appendix A, in the near future.

A. Provisions of General Applicability

Section A includes the
Analysis of Comments and Changes
to the regulations in subparts A and B of part 361 that pertain to the administration of the VR program generally and to the provision of vocational rehabilitation services to individuals with disabilities of any age. The analysis is presented by topical headings relevant to sections of the regulations in the order they appear in part 361 as listed. We discuss some of these same regulations in section B of the
Analysis of Comments and Changes
as they relate specifically to the transition of students and youth with disabilities from school to post-school activities, including final §§ 361.24, 361.46, 361.48(b), and 361.49.

Topical Headings

Purpose (§ 361.1)

Authorized Activities (§ 361.3)

Applicable Regulations (§ 361.4)

Training on 2 CFR part 200 Requirements

Third-Party In-Kind Contributions

Applicable Definitions (§ 361.5)

Administrative Cost (§ 361.5(c)(2))

Supervisory Personnel

Travel Costs

Depreciation

Infrastructure Costs for the Workforce Development System and Capital Expenditures

Assessment for Determining Eligibility and Vocational Rehabilitation Needs (§ 361.5(c)(5))

Competitive Integrated Employment (§ 361.5(c)(9))

Competitive Integrated Employment

Subminimum Wage and Sheltered Employment

Public Benefits

Full- and Part-Time Employment

Minimum Wage Rates

Customary Wages

Comparable Training, Skills, and Experience

Self-Employment

Documentation of Competitive Earnings

Subsistence Occupations

Integrated Location—General

Typically Found in the Community

Level of Interaction Among Individuals With and Without Disabilities

Work Unit

Interaction During Performance of Job Duties

Opportunities for Advancement

Construction of a Facility for a Public or Nonprofit Community Rehabilitation Program (§ 361.5(c)(10))

Customized Employment (§ 361.5(c)(11))

Employment Outcome (§ 361.5(c)(15))

Statutory Basis

Informed Choice

Legitimacy of Homemaker Outcomes

Availability of Services

Disproportionate Impact

Resources for Service Provision

Feasibility Studies

Transition Period

Indian; American Indian; Indian American; Indian Tribe (§ 361.5(c)(25))

Informed Choice

Supported Employment Definitions

Transition-Related Definitions

Submission, Approval, and Disapproval of the State Plan (§ 361.10)

Content and Submission of the VR Services Portion of the Unified or Combined State Plan

Time Estimated for Submission

Alignment of Program and Fiscal Years

Other Comments

Requirements for a State Rehabilitation Council (§ 361.17)

Establishment of a State Rehabilitation Council

Additional Members

Terms of Appointment

Coordination With One-Stop Centers

Comprehensive System of Personnel Development (§ 361.18)

Data Report for Comprehensive System of Personnel Development (§ 361.18(a))

Applicability of Educational and Experiential Requirements to Vocational Rehabilitation Counselors (§ 361.18(c)(1))

Applicability of Standards to Other Personnel

De-Professionalization and Diminution of Vocational Rehabilitation Counseling

State Job Classification Minimum Qualifications

Additional or Substitute Qualifications

Interplay Between National or State-Approved Certification or Licensure Standards and Minimal Educational and Experiential Requirements

Succession Planning

Re-Training of Staff Not Meeting Personnel Standards

Standards of Personnel Development—Other Comparable Requirements (§ 361.18(c)(1))

Meaning of “A 21st Century Understanding of the Evolving Labor Force and the Needs of Individuals with Disabilities”

Staff Development (§ 361.18(d))

Training Areas for Staff Development

Public Participation Requirements (§ 361.20)

Public Hearings for Changes in an Order of Selection

Public Meetings of the State Rehabilitation Council

Substantive and Administrative Changes

Public Comment Through Electronic Means

Requirements Related to the Statewide Workforce Development System (§ 361.23)

Cooperation and Coordination With Other Entities (§ 361.24)

General

Cooperation and Collaboration With Other Agencies and Entities

Non-Educational Agencies

Federal Agreements

Guidance on the Braiding of Funds

Requirements for Training

Notification of the Client Assistance Program

Requirements for Third-Party Cooperative Arrangements (§ 361.28)

In-Kind Contributions

Students Who Are Eligible or Potentially Eligible for Services

Statewide Assessment; Annual Estimates; Annual State Goals and Priorities; Strategies; and Reports of Progress (§ 361.29)

Comprehensive Statewide Needs Assessment

Annual Estimates and Reports of Progress

Provision of Training and Services for Employers (§ 361.32)

Innovation and Expansion Activities (§ 361.35)

Resource Plans for Statewide Independent Living Councils

Innovative Approaches With Components of the Workforce Development System

Ability To Serve All Eligible Individuals; Order of Selection for Services (§ 361.36)

Individuals Who Require Specific Services and Equipment To Maintain Employment

Information and Referral

Monitoring by the State Rehabilitation Council

Order of Selection Criteria

Prohibited Factors

Pre-Employment Transition Services

Information and Referral Programs (§ 361.37)

Benefits Planning

Referral Options

Follow-Up

Independent Living Services

Protection, Use, and Release of Personal Information (§ 361.38)

Reports; Evaluation Standards and Performance Indicators (§ 361.40)

Pre-Employment Transition Services

Standards and Indicators

Program Year

Performance Accountability Regulations

Cumulative Caseload Report (RSA-113)

States With Two VR Agencies

Reporting Burden

RSA-911 Case Service Report

Assessment for Determining Eligibility and Priority for Services (§ 361.42)

Advancing in Employment and Other Eligibility Criteria

Substantial Impediment to Employment

Prohibited Factors

Residency

Compliance Threshold

Entities Holding Special Wage Certificates

Extended Evaluation and Trial Work Experiences

Development of the Individualized Plan for Employment (§ 361.45)

Time Frame for Developing the Individualized Plan for Employment

Options for Developing the Individualized Plan for Employment

Data for Preparing the Individualized Plan for Employment

Content of the Individualized Plan for Employment (§ 361.46)

Scope of Vocational Rehabilitation Services for Individuals With Disabilities

Services for Individuals Who Have Applied or Been Determined Eligible for Vocational Rehabilitation Services (§ 361.48(b))

Advanced Training

Other Services

Scope of Vocational Rehabilitation Services for Groups of Individuals With Disabilities (§ 361.49(a))

Establishment, Development, or Improvement of Community Rehabilitation Programs

Technical Assistance to Businesses

Establishment, Development, or Improvement of Assistive Technology Programs

Advanced Training

Comparable Services and Benefits (§ 361.53)

Accommodations and Auxiliary Aids and Services

Pre-Employment Transition Services and Personally Prescribed Devices

Interagency Agreements

Semi-Annual and Annual Review of Individuals in Extended Employment and Other Employment Under Special Certificate Provisions of the Fair Labor Standards Act (§ 361.55)

Effective Date

Who is subject to the requirements?

Documentation

Costs of Conducting the Reviews

Informed Choice

Retroactive Reviews

Cross-Reference With 34 CFR 397.40

Individuals With a Record of Service

Purpose (§ 361.1)

Comments:
A few commenters supported the replacement of the term “gainful employment” with the term “competitive integrated employment” and the inclusion of the term “economic self-sufficiency” in proposed § 361.1. In addition, many commenters sought clarification of the term “economic self-sufficiency” as used in this regulation and requested that we define it in § 361.5(c). Of these commenters, most suggested that the term “economic self-sufficiency” may deter individuals with disabilities who are receiving public benefits from applying for vocational rehabilitation services. Additionally, some commenters suggested that DSUs may use economic self-sufficiency to determine that individuals with disabilities who wish to maintain their public benefits are ineligible for vocational rehabilitation services. Some commenters indicated that individuals with intellectual or developmental disabilities may never achieve earnings, through competitive integrated employment, sufficient to cease receiving public benefits. Two commenters viewed “economic self-sufficiency” as a criterion within both the definitions of “employment outcome” and “competitive integrated employment,” and requested that we identify criteria that DSUs may use to determine when individuals achieve this level of employment and are rehabilitated enough to no longer need vocational rehabilitation services.

Discussion:
We appreciate comments supporting inclusion of the terms “competitive integrated employment” and “economic self-sufficiency” in final § 361.1. We agree that inclusion of these terms in the regulation reflects the spirit of the Act in general, and is consistent with specific amendments to section 100(a) of the Act made by WIOA. While we understand commenters' requests for a definition of “economic self-sufficiency,” the Act, as amended by WIOA, does not define the term. We believe that the use of the term in final § 361.1(b) is consistent with its common understanding and refers to the situation in which an individual can support him- or herself financially with minimal or no reliance on public benefits or assistance from other persons. Therefore, we do not define the term “economic self-sufficiency.” In addition, use of the term “economic self-sufficiency” in section 100(a)(2)(B) of the Act, as amended by WIOA, and in final § 361.1(b) does not require the individual to achieve economic self-sufficiency—either as a prerequisite for receipt of services or as an outcome resulting from vocational rehabilitation services provided. Rather, the term as used in the Act, as amended by WIOA, and in these final regulations merely requires that the vocational rehabilitation services provided to an individual be consistent with the individual's strengths, resources, priorities, concerns, abilities, capabilities, interests, informed choice, and economic self-sufficiency. Vocational rehabilitation services ideally should assist an individual to achieve a competitive integrated employment outcome that will enable the individual to become economically self-sufficient, but there is no requirement in either the Act or these final regulations that an individual achieve economic self-sufficiency or a specific level of financial independence.

Section 102(a) of the Act, as amended by WIOA, does not include economic self-sufficiency among the eligibility criteria. Inclusion of the term in final § 361.1(b) does not alter the eligibility criteria for the program in final § 361.42(a)(1). We encourage DSUs to conduct outreach to individuals with disabilities and service providers to clarify any misperception that the use of this term implies that individuals with disabilities may no longer receive vocational rehabilitation services for the purpose of achieving an employment outcome in competitive integrated employment or supported employment if they wish to maintain their public benefits. We also encourage DSUs to provide vocational counseling and guidance and benefits planning services to these individuals to assist them in better understanding the impact of participation in the VR program and employment on their public benefits.

Economic self-sufficiency is not a component of the definitions of “competitive integrated employment” and “employment outcome” in sections 7(5) and 7(11), respectively, of the Act, as amended by WIOA. We disagree that the implementing regulations for the definitions of these terms in final §§ 361.5(c)(9) and 361.5(c)(15) should be revised to incorporate criteria related to the achievement of economic self-sufficiency as suggested by the commenter. We believe the wages and benefits criteria, especially as contained in the definition for “competitive integrated employment” in final § 361.5(c)(9), are consistent with those set forth in the statutory definition in section 7(5) of the Act.

Changes:
None.

Authorized Activities (§ 361.3)

Comments:
None.

Discussion:
Upon further review of § 361.3, we have determined a change is needed to clarify that the use of VR program funds to pay for the infrastructure costs of the one-stop delivery system established by title I of WIOA is an authorized activity under the VR program. Section 121(h) of title I of WIOA requires one-stop partners, including the VR program, to pay a proportional share of the one-stop system's infrastructure costs. These costs satisfy the definition of “administrative costs” in final § 361.5(c)(2) because such expenditures constitute operating and maintenance costs, which are permissible administrative costs under the VR program. We have revised final § 361.3(b) to specify that one-stop infrastructure costs are considered administrative costs under the VR services portion of the Unified or Combined State Plan and, therefore, are authorized activities under the VR program. In making this change, we ensure consistency with final § 361.5(c)(2)(viii), as well as jointly administered requirements governing the one-stop delivery system contained in joint regulations published elsewhere in this issue of the
Federal Register
.

Changes:
We have revised final § 361.3(b) to specify that the use of VR program funds to pay for one-stop system infrastructure costs is an authorized activity of the program as an administrative cost.

Applicable Regulations (§ 361.4)

Training on 2 CFR Part 200 Requirements

Comments:
Two commenters requested the Department provide training on 2 CFR part 200 requirements, focusing on definitions and general applicability.

Discussion:
The Department has conducted a number of Webinars and developed technical assistance materials to assist grantees in implementing 2 CFR part 200 requirements and will continue to do so as needed. The Department maintains a technical assistance Web page for grantees regarding the requirements set forth in 2 CFR part 200, which may be accessed at
www.ed.gov
. The Department will consider future Webinars, as appropriate.

Changes:
None.

Third-Party In-Kind Contributions

Comments:
None.

Discussion:
As specified under final § 361.60(b)(2), third-party in-kind contributions may not be used to meet the non-Federal share for match

purposes under the VR program. This prohibition against the use of third-party in-kind contributions under the VR program has been in place since 1997. Upon further Departmental review regarding this long-standing prohibition, we have determined it necessary to revise final § 361.4(d). In so doing, the Secretary clarifies that 2 CFR 200.306(b), which allows third party in-kind contributions to be used as part of a non-Federal entity's cost sharing or matching when such contributions meet certain criteria, does not apply to the VR program. The Secretary believes this technical change will eliminate any confusion expressed by commenters in relation to final § 361.60(b)(2).

Changes:
We have amended the applicable regulations in final § 361.4(d) to specify that 2 CFR 200.306(b), as it pertains to the acceptance of third-party in-kind contributions, is not applicable to the VR program.

Applicable Definitions (§ 361.5)

Administrative Cost (§ 361.5(c)(2))

Supervisory Personnel

Comments:
One commenter recommended that we consider costs for local level supervisors who do not perform counseling duties, but who directly supervise counselors, to be direct service costs rather than administrative costs.

Discussion:
We disagree with the recommendation to consider the costs for local level supervisors who do not perform counseling duties, but who directly supervise counselors, to be direct service costs, rather than “administrative costs.” Final § 361.5(c)(2)(xi) specifies that administrative salaries constitute “administrative costs.” Administrative salaries are those personnel costs paid to individuals who are not providing direct services to VR program applicants and consumers, and may include clerical and managerial salaries. Therefore, we consider costs for supervisors who do not provide direct services to be administrative costs in support of vocational rehabilitation services, rather than costs for the actual provision of such services.

Changes:
None.

Travel Costs

Comments:
Two commenters indicated that the instructions for completing the Annual Vocational Rehabilitation Program/Cost Report (RSA-2) in Policy Directive (PD) 14-02 requiring DSUs to report staff travel costs as “administrative costs” appear to conflict with proposed § 361.5(c)(2)(xii), which specifically excludes travel costs related to the provision of services from “administrative costs.”

One commenter recommended we clarify that grantees may consider travel costs incurred in the provision of vocational rehabilitation services as a service-related cost, rather than an administrative cost. Specifically, the commenter requested that the final regulations clarify that travel costs incurred in the provision of pre-employment transition services may be paid from the funds reserved for that purpose. This commenter also suggested that the Department update reporting instructions accordingly.

Discussion:
We appreciate the commenters' observation that the definition of “administrative costs” in proposed § 361.5(c)(2)(xii) appears to conflict with the instructions for completing the RSA-2 with regard to staff travel costs. The Department will review and update previously issued guidance as necessary to ensure consistency with these final regulations.

We agree that travel costs incurred directly as a result of providing vocational rehabilitation services constitute service-related costs, not “administrative costs” for purposes of the VR program. Therefore, DSUs may pay for travel costs incurred as a direct result of providing pre-employment transition services to students with disabilities, including travel to individualized education program meetings, from the funds reserved for the provision of those services. Travel costs incurred as a result of providing other vocational rehabilitation services to students with disabilities may not be paid from the funds reserved for the provision of pre-employment transition services because such travel would be beyond the scope of section 113 of the Act, as amended by WIOA, and final § 361.48(a). While travel costs incurred as a result of providing other vocational rehabilitation services to students with disabilities who have been determined eligible for vocational rehabilitation services may not be paid from the funds reserved for the provision of pre-employment transition services, they still would be service-related, not administrative, costs. Staff travel costs incurred for other purposes, such as attending regional meetings or trainings, satisfy the definition of “administrative costs” and must be reported as such on the RSA-2. DSUs must have an established system of internal controls sufficient to record and track administrative expenditures associated with authorized activities so they can be distinguished from authorized service-related costs. In this way, DSUs are able to satisfy accounting and reporting requirements set forth in final § 361.12 and Uniform Guidance on financial management in 2 CFR 200.302.

Changes:
None.

Depreciation

Comments:
One commenter requested that we clarify whether DSUs must classify depreciation for administrative facilities as administrative costs.

Discussion:
Final § 361.5(c)(2) provides several examples of administrative costs; however, the examples provided are not exhaustive. DSUs must treat depreciation in accordance with the Uniform Guidance requirements, as set forth in 2 CFR 200.436, and report it accordingly. Therefore, DSUs must report depreciation for facilities used for the administration of the VR program as administrative costs.

Changes:
None.

Infrastructure Costs for the Workforce Development System and Capital Expenditures

Comments:
None.

Discussion:
After further analysis of proposed § 361.5(c)(2), we made a technical change in final § 361.5(c)(2)(viii) to specify that costs to support the infrastructure of the one-stop delivery system established under title I of WIOA are “administrative costs” for purposes of the VR program. Section 121(h) of WIOA requires one-stop partners, including the VR program, to pay a proportional share of the one-stop system's infrastructure costs. We believe these costs satisfy the definition of “administrative costs” in final § 361.5(c)(2)(viii) because these expenditures constitute operational and maintenance costs. We have revised final § 361.5(c)(2)(viii) to specify operational and maintenance costs, for purposes of the definition of “administrative costs” under the VR program, include one-stop system infrastructure costs. This technical change ensures consistency with final § 361.3(b) and the jointly administered requirements governing the one-stop system, as set forth in the joint regulations published elsewhere in this issue of the
Federal Register
.

Additionally, we made a change to final § 361.5(c)(2)(viii) to conform to the Uniform Guidance in 2 CFR part 200. In accordance with 2 CFR 200.439(b)(3), capital expenditures for improvements to land, buildings, or equipment which materially increase their value or useful life are unallowable as a direct cost, except with the prior written approval of the Department. Therefore, we have revised final § 361.5(c)(2)(viii) to delete a clause that had excluded capital

expenditures from the definition of “administrative costs” for purposes of the VR program. Pursuant to this change, DSUs must treat capital expenditures as “administrative costs” for purposes of the VR program. This technical change enables grantees to report these costs more accurately as an administrative cost on the RSA-2 VR Program Cost Report.

Changes:
We have revised final § 361.5(c)(2)(viii) to specify that the definition of “administrative costs” includes those costs associated with operating and maintaining the infrastructure of the one-stop system.

In addition, we have deleted the reference to “not including capital expenditures as defined in 2 CFR 200.13” from final § 361.5(c)(2)(viii).

Assessment for Determining Eligibility and Vocational Rehabilitation Needs (§ 361.5(c)(5))

Comments:
A few commenters supported the definition of “assessment for determining eligibility and vocational rehabilitation needs” in proposed § 361.5(c)(5). Some commenters disagreed with the requirement in the definition that, if additional data are needed to determine the employment outcome and the vocational rehabilitation services to be included in the individualized plan for employment, the DSU can conduct a comprehensive assessment that, in part, relies to the maximum extent possible on information obtained from experiences in integrated employment and other settings in the community. Another commenter requested clarification as to whether the use of information obtained from prior experiences within integrated employment settings or other integrated community settings could include internships or other unpaid work experiences.

Discussion:
We appreciate the support for proposed § 361.5(c)(5), as well as the concerns and requests for clarification. Section 7(2)(B)(v) of the Act, as amended by WIOA, and final § 361.5(c)(5)(ii)(E) allow a DSU, when conducting the comprehensive assessment to determine the vocational rehabilitation needs and employment outcome for inclusion in the individualized plan for employment, to rely, in part, on the applicant's participation in integrated employment settings to the maximum extent possible. However, neither the Act nor the final regulations require that the individual be paid during these experiences. Therefore, section 7(2) of the Act and final § 361.5(c)(5)(ii) do not prohibit DSUs from using unpaid internships or work experiences during the assessment process. We received other comments concerning a perceived conflict between this definition and proposed § 361.42(c)(2), which prohibits a DSU from considering an individual's work history when determining an applicant's eligibility for vocational rehabilitation services, and contracting with community rehabilitation programs that hold subminimum wage certificates issued by the Department of Labor under section 14(c) of the FLSA when conducting assessments. We address these comments in the
Analysis of Comments and Changes
of the
Assessment for Determining Eligibility and Priority for Services
section.

Changes:
None.

Competitive Integrated Employment (§ 361.5(c)(9))

Competitive Integrated Employment

The overarching principle of the Act, as amended by WIOA, that individuals with disabilities are capable of achieving full integration into all aspects of life, including employment, is most evident in the definition of “competitive integrated employment” in section 7(5) of the Act and the interweaving of the term throughout the many provisions of the statute. Because of its central importance to the purpose of the VR program, we received extensive comments on the definition in proposed § 361.5(c)(9), expressing both strong support for, and opposition to, the proposed definition. The vast majority of public comment on the definition focused on the criteria that an employment location must satisfy if it is to be considered integrated. Some commenters expressed support for the definition in general, and the criteria for an integrated location specifically, for several reasons, including the definition's specificity that the commenters believe will ensure individuals with disabilities are working in integrated employment settings, and the impact the definition can have in curtailing the low expectations for individuals with disabilities who are relegated to segregated employment with little opportunity for advancement. However, many commenters opposed the definition, expressing concern that it would restrict or eliminate subminimum wage and sheltered employment for individuals with disabilities, or limit the ability of these individuals to choose among these options. We appreciate the support for the definition, and discuss the detailed comments in opposition to, and requests for clarification of, the proposed definition under the topical headings that follow.

Subminimum Wage and Sheltered Employment

Comments:
Many commenters urged us to protect or not to eliminate the payment of subminimum wages to individuals with disabilities and sheltered employment. One of these commenters stated that not all individuals can be paid minimum wages, and that the employment must be profitable for both parties. Similarly, another commenter stated that if entities holding subminimum wage certificates were forced to pay less productive individuals with disabilities minimum wages, they would lose business to companies overseas. Likewise, some commenters stated that sheltered employment is needed to protect individuals with intellectual disabilities and other significant disabilities from abuse. A few commenters expressed their concern that the integrated location criteria of the definition devalue the employment of individuals with disabilities who cannot work in these settings.

Many commenters opposed the definition because it would limit an individual's choice of subminimum wage and sheltered employment options. Some of these commenters asked that we create an exception from the criteria for individuals who choose to work in a segregated or sheltered setting if all other criteria regarding competitive earnings and opportunities for advancement are satisfied.

Discussion:
We acknowledge that many commenters on part 361 in general, and the definition of “competitive integrated employment” specifically, are concerned that these final regulations will eliminate or restrict the ability of individuals with disabilities, particularly those with the most significant disabilities, to be paid subminimum wages by entities holding certificates issued by the Department of Labor under section 14(c) of the FLSA, as well as sheltered employment. Although we recognize the concerns expressed by these commenters, we emphasize that the definition of “competitive integrated employment” and its use throughout final part 361 are intended to ensure that all individuals with disabilities served through the VR program are provided every opportunity to achieve employment with earnings comparable to those paid to individuals without disabilities in a setting that allows them to interact with individuals who do not have disabilities. Nonetheless, nothing in title I of the Act, as amended by WIOA, or the

regulations in final part 361 affects the FLSA in any manner. Later in this
Analysis of Comments and Changes,
we address limitations on the use of subminimum wage in section 511 of the Act and final 34 CFR part 397. In addition, the definition “competitive integrated employment” in final § 361.5(c)(9) does not prohibit or eliminate sheltered employment. As explained in final regulations published on January 21, 2001, we agree that extended employment programs have traditionally served as a safety net for individuals with significant disabilities who cannot perform work in an integrated setting in the community or who choose to work only among their disabled peers (66 FR 7250). The Secretary does not devalue the dignity or the worth of extended employment programs or the individuals who work in those settings. Rather, the definition of “competitive integrated employment” reflects the heightened emphasis throughout the Act, as amended by WIOA, that individuals with disabilities, including those with the most significant disabilities, can achieve employment in the community and economic self-sufficiency if provided appropriate services and supports. Because DSUs have been unable to assist individuals with disabilities to obtain sheltered employment through the VR program since October 2001, the vast majority of individuals have accessed sheltered employment through other sources or on their own initiative. Therefore, the Secretary believes the definition in final § 361.5(c)(9) will not affect the availability of sheltered employment for individuals who choose this form of employment, or for whom it is a legitimate and necessary option.

Furthermore, while the Act, as amended by WIOA, places a premium on the ability of individuals with disabilities to exercise informed choice throughout the vocational rehabilitation process, we do not agree that the final regulations in part 361 generally and the definition specifically are inconsistent with that emphasis. In fact, an individual with a disability may pursue any form of employment he or she chooses. However, if the individual wishes to receive vocational rehabilitation services, he or she must intend to achieve an “employment outcome,” which is defined in final § 361.5(c)(15) for purposes of the VR program as employment in competitive integrated employment or supported employment. If the individual chooses to pursue work that does not satisfy the definition of “employment outcome” for purposes of the VR program, such as sheltered employment, the individual must seek services from another agency or provider. In such circumstances, these final regulations require the DSU to refer that individual to local extended employment providers or other Federal, State, or local programs (
e.g.,
community rehabilitation programs, State Use programs, and centers for independent living) that can meet the individual's needs. The referral requirements in final § 361.37 also ensure that individuals receive sufficient information concerning the scope of the VR program and opportunities for individuals with disabilities to pursue competitive integrated employment. This information enables individuals to make a fully informed choice regarding whether to pursue competitive integrated employment through the VR program or subminimum wage and extended employment through other sources.

The Secretary believes these final regulations ensure that the VR program promotes to the maximum extent possible opportunities for individuals with disabilities, particularly those with significant disabilities, to pursue competitive integrated employment options. Moreover, final § 361.52 requires each DSU to preserve individual choice in the manner in which the Act intends for individuals who choose to pursue employment outcomes within the scope of the VR program.

Finally, section 7(5) of the Act, as amended by WIOA, does not permit an exception to the definition's requirements for individuals who choose subminimum wage and or sheltered employment. In fact, such an exception would be inconsistent with the plain meaning of the criteria contained in the statutory definition in section 7(5) of the Act. Therefore, we lack the statutory authority to create such an exception in final § 361.5(c)(9).

Changes:
None.

Public Benefits

Comments:
One commenter requested that we clarify the effect of the definition of “competitive integrated employment” on the eligibility of individuals with disabilities for Social Security benefits. One commenter expressed concern that the criteria would cause individuals to lose needed benefits provided through Medicaid and other sources.

Discussion:
We recognize that some individuals are reluctant to pursue employment through the VR program due to their perceptions of the negative impact employment may have on the public benefits, including Medicaid and other sources, on which they rely for financial and medical support. To enable individuals with disabilities to better understand the effects of employment on Social Security and other benefits and make well-informed decisions about the employment goals that best suit their needs, section 102(b)(2) of the Act, as amended by WIOA, and final § 361.45(c)(2) require DSUs to provide benefits planning information, including information about work incentives provided through the Social Security Administration (SSA), to these individuals during the process for developing the individualized plan for employment. For further information, see the
Development of the Individualized Plan for Employment
section later in this
Analysis of Comments and Changes.

Changes:
None.

Full- and Part-Time Employment

Comments:
A few commenters requested that we define or clarify the terms “full-time” and “part-time” employment as they are used in the definition of “competitive integrated employment.” These commenters asked whether there is a minimum number of hours that an individual must work for the employment to satisfy the requirements of the definition, as well as the definition of an “employment outcome.” A few commenters expressed concern that on-call or temporary employment is not within the scope of the definition because it is not considered full- or part-time scheduled employment. They stated that many entry-level individuals are employed in on-call positions and that permitting this form of employment could enable individuals with intellectual disabilities to maintain employment.

Discussion:
The reference to full- and part-time work in the definitions for the terms “employment outcome” and “competitive integrated employment,” for purposes of the VR program, is not new. The definition for “employment outcome” has remained consistent since the 1992 Amendments to the Act and the 1997 VR program regulations (62 FR 6334 (Feb. 11, 1997)). Although “competitive integrated employment” is a new term in the Act, as amended by WIOA, and these final regulations, the term and its definition are consistent with that for “competitive employment” in prior § 361.5(b)(11), which dates back to the 1997 VR program regulations. Because these definitions have existed for approximately 20 years without substantial change, we do not believe it necessary to define “full-time” or “part-time” in final part 361. “Full-time” and

“part-time” have their common meanings and may vary across sectors of the economy. Generally, individuals are considered to be employed full-time if they work 40 hours per week. However, it is not uncommon for full-time employees to work fewer hours, such as 35 hours per week, depending on the terms of employment established by the employer. “Part-time” employment is employment for any number of hours less than that of full-time employment for the particular work performed. Nowhere in the statutory definitions of “competitive integrated employment” or “employment outcome,” or any other provision of the Act, as amended by WIOA, is a minimum number of hours that an individual must work for the employment to be considered full- or part-time specified, and we decline to do so in these final regulations, relying on the terms' common understanding. Finally, we clarify in this discussion that the definitions of “competitive integrated employment” and “employment outcome,” as set forth in the Act and these final regulations, do not require that the individual's employment be regularly scheduled, as suggested by the commenter. Thus, DSUs may assist individuals to obtain temporary or on-call employment so long as all the criteria of the definitions are satisfied.

Changes:
None.

Minimum Wage Rates

Comments:
Some commenters expressed strong support for the competitive earnings criteria in proposed § 361.5(c)(9)(i). We also received comments recommending changes to the criteria or requesting clarification. One commenter stated that the requirement that the individual's wages equal or exceed the higher of the Federal, or applicable State or local minimum wage rates adds unnecessary complexity to the vocational rehabilitation process. This commenter recommended that we apply a single standard of the Federal minimum wage rate to all employment outcomes achieved through the VR program, or that we apply the minimum wage rate in effect in the place of the individual's employment, and not the individual's place of residence.

Discussion:
We appreciate the strong support for the competitive earnings criteria and respond here to the requests for clarification. We disagree with the request to avoid complexity by using only the Federal minimum wage as the measure of competitive earnings. Section 7(5)(A)(i)(I)(aa) of the Act, as amended by WIOA, requires that the individual's earnings equal or exceed the Federal, State, or applicable local minimum wage rate, whichever is higher, for the employment to satisfy the definition of “competitive integrated employment.” Final § 361.5(c)(9)(i)(A) mirrors the statutory definition in this respect. Given the specific statutory requirement, we lack the statutory authority to restrict this requirement in the final regulation. In addition, the definition focuses on the wages paid by the employer, who is subject to the minimum wage laws applicable to the place of employment. Consequently, we agree with the commenter that the determination of whether the individual's earnings satisfy the definition's criteria should be based on the minimum wage rate applicable to the individual's place of employment, and not his or her place of residence.

Changes:
We have revised final § 361.5(c)(9)(i)(A) to clarify that the applicable State and local minimum wage laws are those that apply to the place of employment.

Customary Wages

Comments:
One commenter recommended that we revise the definition to emphasize that the intent of the law and the regulations is to ensure that wages and benefits paid to individuals with disabilities are comparable to the prevailing wage and benefits of individuals without disabilities.

Discussion:
Section 7(5)(A)(i)(I)(bb) of the Act, as amended by WIOA, and final § 361.5(c)(9)(i)(B) require that the individual with the disability be compensated at a rate comparable to the customary rate paid by the employer for the same or similar work performed by individuals without disabilities for the employment to be considered competitive integrated employment. The Secretary emphasizes that this provision in both the Act and the final regulations mirrors the definition of “competitive employment” in prior § 361.5(b)(11)(ii) (see 66 FR 4379 (Jan. 17, 2001)), which formed the basis for the definition in the Act. We also note that the commenter's recommendation would not limit the criterion to the wages paid by the employer, as do the statutory and final regulatory definition, but would appear to extend the criterion to the prevailing wages paid to individuals without disabilities in similar positions generally. For these reasons the recommendation is not consistent with the criterion in the statutory definition and, thus, we do not have the authority to expand the regulatory definition in final § 361.5(c)(9)(i)(B) as the commenter suggests.

Changes:
None.

Comparable Training, Skills, and Experience

Comments:
Two commenters requested that we clarify the meaning of “comparable training, skills, and experience” as used in the definition, and how this concept could be quantified.

Discussion:
Section 7(5)(A)(i)(I)(bb) of the Act, as amended by WIOA, and final § 361.5(c)(9)(i)(B) require the DSU to take into account the training, experience, and level of skills possessed by employees without disabilities in similar positions when determining whether the earnings of the individual with a disability are comparable. We do not believe that it is possible to quantify this comparison. Instead, the determination is based on the vocational rehabilitation counselor's knowledge of the training, skills, and experience needed to perform the job generally and required by the employer specifically. In this way, the DSU can ensure that the individual with the disability is compensated in a manner comparable to that of employees without disabilities in all critical respects, and is not paid at a lower rate simply on the basis of his or her disability.

Changes:
None.

Self-Employment

Comments:
One commenter noted the proposed definition recognizes that individuals, with or without disabilities, in self-employment may not receive an income from the business equal to or exceeding applicable minimum wage rates, particularly in the early stages of operation. The commenter requested clarification regarding the reason the definition proscribes an individual with a disability in self-employment from what other successful entrepreneurs have the option to practice. Another commenter asked if individuals who achieve self-employment are included in the calculations of the performance accountability measures assessing employment in the second and fourth quarters after exit from the VR program, since their employment and wages are not captured in Unemployment Insurance wage systems.

Discussion:
We want to clarify that section 7(5)(A)(i)(II) of the Act, as amended by WIOA, and final § 361.5(c)(9)(i)(C) do not prevent, as the commenter indicates, an individual with a disability who is self-employed from receiving earnings comparable to those achieved by individuals without disabilities in similar occupations. As explained in the preamble to the NPRM, the statutory and regulatory definitions

recognize that individuals with disabilities, as well as individuals without disabilities, may experience difficulty in generating sufficient income from their self-employment ventures, that will enable them to achieve earnings equal to or exceeding the applicable minimum wage rate, especially in the early stages of the business operations. Thus, final § 361.5(c)(9)(i)(C) provides that a self-employed individual with a disability in the start-up phase of a business venture who is making less than the applicable minimum wage can meet the definition of “competitive integrated employment.”

Furthermore, individuals who receive services through the VR program to assist with the achievement of self-employment outcomes are considered “participants” as that term is defined under the joint final regulations implementing the jointly administered performance accountability system requirements of section 116 of title I of WIOA, published elsewhere in this issue of the
Federal Register
, and must be taken into account when calculating a DSU's performance on those measures. Since the employment status and earnings of self-employed individuals are not captured through the unemployment insurance wage system, a DSU may use supplemental wage information to obtain the data necessary for the calculation of its performance. For further information concerning the definition of “participant” for purposes of the performance accountability measures under section 116 of WIOA and the data needed to calculate these measures, particularly data related to supplemental information when quarterly wage records are not available, see the analysis of comments on the joint performance final regulations published elsewhere in this issue of the
Federal Register
.

Changes:
None.

Documentation of Competitive Earnings

Comments:
One commenter asked what documentation a DSU is required to use when verifying the criteria for competitive earnings, including that the wages are equal to, or exceed, the applicable wage rate for the locality; that the individual's wages and benefits are comparable to those earned by individuals without disabilities in similar positions and who possess the same level of training, skills, and experience; that the individual has the same opportunities for advancement as do persons without disabilities in similar positions; and the income level of an individual who has achieved self-employment.

Discussion:
Final § 361.47(a)(9) requires the DSU to maintain a record of services for each individual served through the VR program that includes documentation verifying if the individual has achieved competitive integrated employment, including whether the individual has obtained employment with competitive earnings. Final § 361.47(b) does not prescribe the necessary documentation, but directs the DSU, in consultation with the State Rehabilitation Council, to determine the type of documentation needed to meet the requirements of § 361.47(a). However, examples of documentation that a DSU may use include, as appropriate for the type of employment, unemployment insurance wage records, tax returns, earnings statements from the employer, and self-reported information.

Changes:
None.

Subsistence Occupations

Comments:
Some commenters responded to the statement in the NPRM's preamble indicating that we interpret subsistence employment as a form of self-employment common to cultures of many American Indian tribes, or to the definition of “subsistence” under 34 CFR part 371 governing the American Indian Vocational Rehabilitation Services (AIVRS) program (see NPRM, Workforce Innovation and Opportunity Act, Miscellaneous Program Changes, 80 FR 20988, 20994-20998 (April 16, 2015)). Several commenters asked whether the interpretation of the self-employment criteria within the definition of “competitive integrated employment” in proposed § 361.5(c)(9) that includes subsistence activities is limited to individuals served through the AIVRS program under 34 CFR part 371 or to American Indians and Alaska Natives. Of these, one commenter noted that subsistence activities are not only culturally relevant for American Indians and Alaska Natives, but that they are also vital to many individuals who live in rural areas with limited competitive employment options. One commenter requested that we clarify the meaning of “culturally appropriate” as used in the definition of “subsistence” and the preamble to the NPRM by providing examples. Another commenter asked what limits would be placed on hobbies as self-employment outcomes if subsistence outcomes were available to all individuals served through the VR program. In addition, several commenters requested that we revise the definition of “employment outcome” for purposes of the VR program to include within its scope subsistence activities.

Discussion:
In the NPRM covering amendments made by WIOA to the miscellaneous programs authorized by the Act, the Secretary proposed a definition of “subsistence” in 34 CFR 371.6 for purposes of the AIVRS program (80 FR 20988, 20995). Under that definition, “subsistence” means a form of self-employment in which individuals use culturally relevant or traditional methods to produce goods or services for household consumption or non-commercial barter and trade that constitute an important basis for the individual's livelihood. To ensure consistency in the interpretation of the definition of “competitive integrated employment” for the purposes of the VR program and the AIVRS program, and in light of the definition of “subsistence” in final 34 CFR 371.6, the Secretary stated in the preamble to the NPRM to the VR regulations that the Department interprets subsistence employment as a form of self-employment common to cultures of many American Indian tribes. The Secretary believes that consistency in interpretation and implementation of the regulations governing the VR and AIVRS programs is essential given the large number of American Indians and Alaska Natives with disabilities who are eligible for services from both programs, some of whom may be served by the programs sequentially or even simultaneously.

The Secretary does not intend the statement in the NPRM covering the proposed regulations in part 361, or the inclusion of the definition of “subsistence” only in 34 CFR 371.6, to limit the provision of services designed to assist individuals to achieve subsistence occupations to those served through the AIVRS program. DSUs may assist American Indians and Alaska Natives served through the VR program to achieve subsistence occupations as a form of self-employment under the limited circumstances set forth in the definition in 34 CFR 371.6, which the Department applies in the same manner to the VR program.

While the Secretary believes that, as the statement in the NPRM indicates, subsistence occupations are most culturally relevant to American Indian and Alaska Native tribes, the Secretary recognizes that they may also be culturally relevant to other small groups of individuals who may traditionally engage in these occupations, such as those in the outlying areas. Thus, DSUs may find it appropriate to assist individuals from cultures other than American Indian and Alaska Native tribes to achieve self-employment in

subsistence occupations that meet the definition of 34 CFR 371.6. However, because the definition of “subsistence” in 34 CFR 371.6 requires that the subsistence occupation be culturally relevant to the individual, the Secretary declines to extend the applicability of subsistence occupations to other individuals with disabilities served through the VR and AIVRS programs solely on the basis of their location in rural areas.

Examples of subsistence occupations that are culturally relevant to American Indians or Alaska Natives include the exchange of fish caught, or grain raised, by the individual with the disability for other goods produced by other members of the tribe that are needed by the individual to live and maintain his or her home. Given, however, the large number of American Indian tribes, including Alaska Native villages and regional corporations, and their widely varying cultural practices, any list of further examples of culturally relevant practices would also be incomplete and may exclude cultural practices that are unique to some tribes. Since the definition of “subsistence” in final 34 CFR 371.6 requires that the activity constitute an important basis of the individual's livelihood, DSUs cannot provide vocational rehabilitation services to individuals to enable them to engage in mere hobbies that do not serve this same purpose.

Finally, the definition of “employment outcome” in final § 361.5(c)(15) encompasses all forms of competitive integrated employment, including self-employment. Because we consider subsistence occupations to be a form of self-employment, these occupations are already within the scope of the definition of “employment outcome” and it is not necessary to revise the definition to include a specific reference to subsistence.

Changes:
None.

Integrated Location—General

Comments:
As stated in the introduction to this section, the majority of commenters who commented on the definition of “competitive integrated employment” focused on the integrated location component of the definition in proposed § 361.5(c)(9)(ii), which requires that the individual perform work in a location that meets two distinct criteria. The location must be a setting: (1) Typically found in the community; and (2) where the employee with a disability interacts for the purpose of performing the duties of the position with other employees within the particular work unit and the entire work site, and, as appropriate to the work performed, other persons (
e.g.,
customers and vendors), who are not individuals with disabilities (not including supervisory personnel or individuals who are providing services to the employee) to the same extent that employees who are not individuals with disabilities and who are in comparable positions interact with these persons.

Of the commenters who strongly supported the criteria, several requested that we make additional changes to this particular component of the definition by: (1) Adding language that the criteria should not be used to exclude individuals from the VR program due to concerns about their ability to meet the standard, and emphasizing that individuals with disabilities, including those with the most significant disabilities, are capable of achieving high quality competitive integrated employment when provided the necessary skills and supports; (2) specifically excluding from the scope of the definition employment in businesses owned by community rehabilitation providers, group or enclave settings, affirmative industries, social enterprises, or any other form of non-traditional work unit; and (3) changing the term “competitive integrated employment” to “competitive integrated individualized employment” to be clear that employment through the VR program is individualized.

Many of the commenters who opposed the integrated location criteria in proposed § 361.5(c)(9)(ii) requested that we replace them with those in the statutory definition because they believe that: (1) Some of the proposed criteria are not mandated by WIOA; (2) some of the proposed criteria are too strict and would result in the loss of employment opportunities that pay good wages and benefits; and (3) the statutory language would maintain work options and choice for consumers.

Some commenters inquired about the impact of the definition on the employment, by community rehabilitation programs, of individuals with disabilities, particularly those who are blind and visually impaired, in managerial and other positions. These commenters stated that employment in these positions was in an integrated location under prior guidance issued by the Department, specifically technical assistance circular 06-01 entitled “Factors State Vocational Rehabilitation Agencies Should Consider When Determining Whether a Job Position Within a Community Rehabilitation Program is Deemed to be in an Integrated Setting for Purposes of the Vocational Rehabilitation Program” and dated November 21, 2005. One commenter requested that we clarify whether the employment of individuals with disabilities in call centers operated by community rehabilitation providers occurs in an integrated location.

Another commenter requested that we clarify the impact of the criteria on employment in the business enterprise (vending) program for individuals who are blind under the Randolph-Sheppard Act, as well as State industries programs for the blind.

Discussion:
We appreciate the strong support for § 361.5(c)(9)(ii). We also recognize those comments opposing, and requesting clarification of, the criteria. Before addressing the specific comments, the Secretary believes, as stated in the NPRM, that the definition of “competitive integrated employment” in section 7(5) of the Act, as amended by WIOA, for the most part incorporates the definition of “integrated setting” in prior § 361.5(b)(33)(ii). Therefore, the substance of the definitions of “competitive integrated employment” in final § 361.5(c)(9)(ii) and “integrated setting” in final § 361.5(c)(32)(ii), for purposes of the VR program, with respect to the integrated nature of the employment location is familiar to DSUs and does not diverge from prior regulations, long-standing Department policy, practice, and the heightened emphasis on competitive integrated employment throughout the Act, as amended by WIOA.

The Secretary believes that final § 361.5(c)(9)(ii) and the explanation in the following paragraphs provide sufficient guidance to enable DSUs to determine whether a particular work location satisfies the definition of “competitive integrated employment.” The Secretary does not believe it necessary to revise the definition by adding language emphasizing that individuals with disabilities, including those with the most significant disabilities, are capable of achieving high quality competitive integrated employment when provided the necessary services and supports. This principle is clearly expressed in final § 361.1 describing the purpose of the VR program, thereby forming the foundation for all provisions of final part 361, including the definition of “competitive integrated employment.” Therefore, there is no need to restate the principle in the definition.

We do not believe that it is possible to identify all types of non-integrated employment settings in the definition, as the specific exclusion of one type of non-integrated employment setting from the definition could result in a misperception that settings not mentioned are within the scope of the

definition. Instead, we explain in the following paragraphs the application of the integrated location criteria to these types of work settings. When the criteria are properly applied by DSUs, group and enclave employment settings operated by businesses formed for the purpose of employing individuals with disabilities will not satisfy the definition of “competitive integrated employment.” Therefore, the Secretary disagrees with the recommendation to add language to the definition expressly excluding from the scope of the definition employment in businesses owned by community rehabilitation providers, group and enclave settings, affirmative industries, social enterprises, and other forms of non-traditional work settings.

In addition, we disagree with the recommendation to change the term “competitive integrated employment” to “competitive integrated individualized employment.” Section 7(5) of the Act, as amended by WIOA, defines “competitive integrated employment,” and that definition forms the basis for the definition in final § 361.5(c)(9). Moreover, the many provisions of the Act and the final regulations in final part 361, including those governing the selection of an employment outcome, the vocational rehabilitation services provided, the exercise of informed choice, and the closure of an individual's service record, underscore the individualized nature of the VR program, thereby making it unnecessary to add the word “individualized” to the term “competitive integrated employment” in these final regulations.

Furthermore, the Secretary disagrees with the commenters' recommendation that we replace the regulatory criteria in proposed § 361.5(c)(9)(ii) with the statutory criteria, verbatim, in section 7(5)(B) of the Act, as amended by WIOA. As stated in the NPRM, the integrated setting criteria in proposed § 361.5(c)(9)(ii), although not verbatim, are nevertheless consistent with the statutory definition in section 7(5)(B) of the Act, as amended by WIOA, with respect to the integrated nature of the employment setting, and, in turn, are consistent with the definition of “integrated setting” in prior § 361.5(b)(33)(ii). Also in light of the consistency of section 7(5)(B) of the Act with the prior regulatory definition of “integrated setting,” as well as the Department's long-standing interpretation of that definition, the Secretary does not believe that the criteria in the statutory definition of “competitive integrated employment” would permit within its scope work options that would not have satisfied the criteria in prior § 361.5(b)(32)(ii). There is no indication in the Act, as amended by WIOA, or the limited legislative history, that Congress intended to narrow the scope of the integrated setting criterion of the definition of “competitive integrated employment.” Therefore, the Secretary believes the definition of “competitive integrated employment” in final § 361.5(c)(9)(ii), while not verbatim, is nonetheless consistent with the Act, prior regulations, and long-standing Department policy. This means employment that would have satisfied the definition of “integrated settings” in prior regulations and Department guidance would satisfy the definition of “competitive integrated employment” in these final regulations.

We emphasize that it is the DSU's responsibility to apply final § 361.5(c)(9)(ii) in a manner consistent with long-standing Departmental policy. The DSU must apply the criteria equally to any position, whether it involves the management or administration of, or the production and delivery of goods and services by, the organization, and without regard to the type of business operation, such as, but not limited to, a call center within a community rehabilitation program, the manufacture of office supplies by a State industries program for individuals who are blind, or a contract for landscaping services. The criteria contained in final §§ 361.5(c)(9)(ii) and 361.5(c)(32)(ii) provide important clarifications that are necessary to better enable a DSU to determine, on a case-by-case basis, whether a particular position in an organization's specific work unit is in an integrated location.

The Randolph-Sheppard Act provides opportunities for self-employment and entrepreneurship in the community to individuals who are blind. As a form of self-employment and business ownership, the outcomes of individuals in the vending facilities established under the Randolph-Sheppard Act are deemed to be in integrated settings and specifically within the definition of “employment outcome” in final § 361.5(c)(15).

Changes:
None.

Typically Found in the Community

Comments:
One commenter stated that work opportunities established by community rehabilitation programs specifically for the purpose of employing individuals with disabilities in the community constitute an integrated setting, and that these jobs enable people to become more self-sufficient and live a more rewarding life.

A few commenters asked whether the criteria would prohibit the employment of individuals with disabilities in work settings operated by community rehabilitation providers that exclusively serve other persons with disabilities (
e.g.,
group homes, inclusive child care centers, adult day programs, or peer support programs), because these locations are not typically found in the community or do not afford the level of interaction among individuals with and without disabilities required by the definition.

One commenter specifically addressed the criterion requiring the work location to be a setting typically found in the community, stating that the criterion does not exist in the statutory definition and it would limit opportunities for individuals with disabilities to participate in new and innovative employment models and businesses that are not yet typical. The commenter recommended that we remove this requirement.

Discussion:
The Secretary has incorporated language contained in the prior regulatory definition of “integrated setting” requiring that the work location be in “a setting typically found in the community,” meaning that an integrated setting must be one that is typically found in the competitive labor market. This long-standing Departmental interpretation is consistent with the Act, as amended by WIOA, as well as with express congressional intent as set forth in prior legislative history. Specifically, integrated setting “is intended to mean a work setting in a typical labor market site where people with disabilities engage in typical daily work patterns with co-workers who do not have disabilities; and where workers with disabilities are not congregated . . .” (Senate Report 105-166, page 10, March 2, 1998). Nothing in the Act suggests that Congress intended a different interpretation of the integrated setting criterion in the amendments made by WIOA. Rather, Congress demonstrated a continuation of this interpretation by incorporating into the statute, almost verbatim, a criterion from prior § 361.5(b)(33)(ii) into the definition of “competitive integrated employment” in section 7(5)(B) of the Act. Therefore, the Secretary maintains the long-standing Departmental policy that settings established by community rehabilitation programs specifically for the purpose of employing individuals with disabilities (
e.g.,
sheltered workshops) do not constitute integrated settings because these settings are not typically found in the competitive labor market—the first of two criteria that must be satisfied if a DSU is to

determine that a work setting is an integrated location under final § 361.5(c)(9).

As we made clear in the discussion of
Integrated Location—General
previously and have stated in long-standing Departmental policy, DSUs must apply the integrated location criteria in a consistent manner and on a case-by-case basis to any work setting, including settings operated by community rehabilitation providers that exclusively serve other persons with disabilities (
e.g.,
group homes, inclusive child care centers, adult day programs, or peer support programs). Nonetheless, we note that the settings described in the comments, though formed for the unique purpose of serving individuals with disabilities, have not been established for the purpose of employing them. Thus, the settings in question in the comments would appear to satisfy the first criterion that the setting is typically found in the community. If this is the case, it would remain for the DSU to determine if the setting is one in which the employee with the disability interacts with employees without disabilities in the work unit and across the work site to the degree that employees without disabilities in similar positions interact with these same persons.

With respect to the comment specifically about proposed § 361.5(c)(9)(ii)(A), which requires that the location be a setting typically found in the community, the Secretary disagrees with the commenter's request to remove the criterion from the definition. The criterion does not exclude from competitive integrated employment any innovative or unique business models that otherwise satisfy the definition's criteria. Instead, the Secretary interprets the criterion to be more narrowly focused on the purpose for which the business is formed. As explained earlier, businesses established by community rehabilitation programs or any other entity for the primary purpose of employing individuals with disabilities do not satisfy this criterion, and, therefore, are not considered integrated settings, because these settings are not within the competitive labor market. The Department has long considered several factors to typically distinguish positions in these types of businesses from those that satisfy the criterion. The factors that generally would result in a business being considered “not typically found in the community,” include: (1) The funding of positions through Javits-Wagner-O'Day Act (JWOD) contracts; (2) allowances under the FLSA for compensatory subminimum wages; and (3) compliance with a mandated direct labor-hour ratio of persons with disabilities. It is the responsibility of the DSU to take these factors into account when determining if a position in a particular work location is an integrated setting.

Changes:
None.

Level of Interaction Among Individuals With and Without Disabilities

Comments:
Of those commenters who commented specifically on the level of interaction among individuals with and without disabilities, one commenter asked that we include language to require individuals with disabilities to interact with other employees and individuals without disabilities to the same extent that employees without disabilities paid directly by the employer interact with these persons. The commenter stated that the additional language would help to emphasize that individuals can exercise informed choice in the selection of service providers under the VR program.

One commenter suggested that we define “integrated location” as a ratio of individuals with disabilities and individuals without disabilities, stating that true integrated employment consists of a mix of workers with and without disabilities.

Another commenter recommended that we adopt the prior Departmental guidance in technical assistance circular 06-01 mentioned in the
Integrated Location—General
discussion. The commenter believed that the guidance required DSUs to give equal weight to the interaction of individuals with disabilities with other individuals without disabilities, including employees in the work unit and across the work site, and customers as well as vendors.

Discussion:
In response to those comments addressing proposed § 361.5(c)(9)(ii)(B), the second criterion of integrated location, section 102(d) of the Act and final § 361.52 require that individuals be able to exercise informed choice in the selection of service providers. Therefore, it is not necessary to amend the definition to require that individuals with disabilities interact with employees and other persons without disabilities to the same extent that employees without disabilities paid directly by the employer interact with these persons. We do not believe that including the additional language in final § 361.5(c)(9)(ii)(B) would further protect the ability of individuals to choose among service providers.

The Secretary appreciates the commenter's recommendation that we revise this criterion and define an integrated setting as being comprised of a ratio (not specified by the commenter) of employees with disabilities in comparison to individuals without disabilities. Since “integrated setting” was first defined in VR program regulations, we have considered how best to capture the intent of Congress and long-standing Department policy in its criteria. In doing so, we considered whether to establish a numerical ratio and have rejected this as impractical and unworkable. Given the many and varied types of employment settings in today's economy, we cannot determine a single ratio that could be used to satisfactorily determine the level of interaction required to meet the intent underlying the definition. Rather than using a numerical standard, we believe that an “integrated setting” is best viewed in light of the quality of the interaction among employees with disabilities and persons without disabilities when compared to that of employees without disabilities in similar positions, and have not added a numerical ratio to final § 361.5(c)(9).

The Secretary disagrees with the commenter's interpretation of the prior guidance provided in technical assistance circular 06-01 and the assertion that factors such as the level of interaction of employees with disabilities with other employees in the work unit and across the work site, as well as with customers and vendors, should be weighted equally. As stated in the NPRM, the Secretary believes the focus of whether the setting is integrated should be on the interaction between employees with and without disabilities, and not solely on the interaction of employees with disabilities with people outside of the work unit. For example, the interaction of individuals with disabilities employed in a customer service center with other persons over the telephone, regardless of whether these persons have disabilities, would be insufficient by itself to satisfy the definition. Instead, the interaction of primary consideration should be that between the employee with the disability and his or her colleagues without disabilities in similar positions.

Changes:
None.

Work Unit

Comments:
Commenters supporting and opposing the integrated location criteria commented specifically on the use of “work unit” in final § 361.5(c)(9)(ii)(B). Some in support requested that we clarify the meaning of the term with respect to the numbers of individuals with disabilities as compared to those without disabilities

to ensure that the standard is consistently applied to work units of different sizes, and the effect of the term on the ability of individuals to choose to work alone. One commenter suggested that we clarify that the employment of individuals with disabilities in non-traditional work units who perform their duties of the position in isolation or separate from other employees in the work unit satisfies the definition of “competitive integrated employment” as long as all other criteria are met.

A few commenters asked whether “work unit” refers to all employees in a certain job category or program, or to groups of employees working together to accomplish tasks. These commenters stated that certain categories of employees (such as temporary office workers and certain kinds of contract workers) regularly interact with others within the work site (including other employees, customers, or vendors), but do not work side by side or in collaboration with others within the same job category. Similarly, a few commenters requested that we clarify the effect of the criteria on employment in scattered work sites.

Of those in opposition, some requested that we remove “work unit” from the definition because they were concerned that its use prohibits mobile work crews and enclaves unless very restrictive criteria are met, and that if Congress had intended to eliminate group work opportunities, it would have done so in the law. Other commenters requested clarification of the effect of the term on group employment under the JWOD Act commonly used in Ability One and long-term commercial contracts, stating that these settings provide well-paying jobs for persons with the most significant disabilities.

Discussion:
In response to those comments that address the use of the term “work unit,” the Secretary disagrees with the recommendation to remove the term from the definition because it properly focuses the consideration of the interaction of the individual with the disability with employees without disabilities within the environment in which the work is performed. As used in the definition, “work unit” may refer to all employees in a particular job category or to a group of employees working together to accomplish tasks, depending on the employer's organizational structure. In addition, its use is consistent with prior guidance issued by the Department. The Secretary emphasizes that the Department has long maintained that the interaction required between employees with disabilities and employees without disabilities is not dependent on the number of individuals in the work unit and that the criterion must be applied consistently to work units of any size. The Department also has long-held that the interaction between employees with and without disabilities need not be face to face. Nor do we interpret the criterion as necessarily excluding employment settings in which individuals work alone, such as telecommuting, temporary employment, and work in mobile or scattered locations, from the scope of the definition of “competitive integrated employment,” so long as the employee with the disability interacts with employees of the employer in similar positions and interacts with other persons without disabilities to the same extent that employees without disabilities interact with others.

As stated earlier in this section, the Department has long considered the funding of positions through JWOD contracts to be a distinguishing characteristic when determining if a business is typically found in the community. Likewise, the use of the term “work unit” in the definition does not change its application with respect to the required interaction among employees with and without disabilities in the work setting. Entities that are set up specifically for the purpose of providing employment to individuals with disabilities will likely not satisfy the definition's criteria. The high percentage of individuals with disabilities employed with these entities most likely would result in little to no opportunities for interaction between individuals with disabilities and non-disabled individuals. These entities, therefore, likely would be considered sheltered or non-integrated employment sites. Nonetheless, DSUs must apply these criteria on a case-by-case basis when determining if an individual's employment is in an integrated location and satisfies the definition of “competitive integrated employment.”

Changes:
None.

Interaction During Performance of Job Duties

Comments:
One commenter stated that to define “integrated location” as only “the interaction between employees with disabilities and those without disabilities that is specific to the performance of the employee's job duties, and not the casual, conversational, and social interaction that takes place in the workplace” is too narrow and may not reflect many workers' interaction patterns in typical work settings.

Discussion:
Under the definition of “competitive integrated employment” and consistent with the general principles contained in the prior definition of “integrated setting,” the DSU is to consider the interaction between employees with disabilities and those without disabilities that is specific to the performance of the employee's job duties, and not the casual, conversational, and social interaction that takes place in the workplace. As a result, it would not be pertinent to its determination of an integrated setting for a DSU to consider interactions in the lunchrooms and other common areas of the work site in which employees with disabilities and those without disabilities are not engaged in performing work responsibilities.

The Secretary recognizes that the application of the integrated location criteria in the manner explained in the preceding paragraphs will restrict the types of employment options available to individuals with disabilities through the VR program. However, these restrictions have been in effect since the definition of “employment outcome” was last revised in 2001 and, therefore, do not reflect new Departmental policy. Specifically, through application of the criteria, individuals with disabilities hired by community rehabilitation programs to perform work under service contracts, either alone, in mobile work crews, or in other group settings (
e.g.,
landscaping or janitorial crews), whose interaction with persons without disabilities (other than their supervisors and service providers), while performing job responsibilities, is with persons working in or visiting the work locations (and not with employees of the community rehabilitation programs without disabilities in similar positions) would not be performing work in an integrated setting. The Secretary believes that, even if such group employment in a community rehabilitation program provides for competitively paid wages, this fact does not change the non-integrated nature of the employment and may result in a less desirable level of integration (
e.g.,
interaction with non-disabled co-workers) than individual employment, which supports the autonomy and self-sufficiency of individuals with disabilities.

In summary, the DSU must determine, on a case-by-case basis, that a work location is in an integrated setting, meaning it is typically found in the community, and it is one in which the employee with the disability interacts with employees and other persons, as appropriate to the position, who do not

have disabilities to the same extent that employees without disabilities interact with these persons. Finally, the DSU is to consider the interaction between the employee with the disabilities and these other persons that takes place for the purpose of performing his or her job duties, not mere casual and social interaction. We firmly believe that the integrated location criteria within final § 361.5(c)(9)(ii), when properly applied, ensure that participants in the VR program, including individuals with the most significant disabilities, are afforded a full opportunity to integrate in their communities and to achieve employment available to the general public.

Changes:
None.

Opportunities for Advancement

Comments:
One commenter asked whether employment in which individuals with disabilities truly do not have the opportunity to advance in their jobs satisfies the definition of “competitive integrated employment,” if the criteria regarding competitive earnings and integrated locations are met. This commenter gave the example of a small business.

Discussion:
To ensure that the employment of persons with disabilities is equivalent in all respects to that of persons without disabilities, section 7(5)(C) of the Act, as amended by WIOA, and final § 361.5(c)(9)(iii) require that the employee with the disability have the same opportunities for advancement as employees without disabilities in similar positions, regardless of the size of the business. This new criterion is consistent with the prior definitions of “competitive employment” and “integrated settings.” If employees in positions similar to that of the employee with the disability have the opportunity to advance in their employment, the individual with the disability must be afforded the same opportunity for this criterion of the definition to be satisfied.

Changes:
None.

Construction of a Facility for a Public or Nonprofit Community Rehabilitation Program (§ 361.5(c)(10))

Comment:
One commenter requested that “construction” and “ongoing maintenance” be clearly defined in the regulations.

Discussion:
The term “construction of a facility for a public or nonprofit community rehabilitation program” remains unchanged in section 7(6) of the Act, as amended by WIOA, and final § 361.5(c)(10).

We disagree with the recommendation that we define “ongoing maintenance” in part 361. Final § 361.5(c)(2)(viii) specifies such costs, when incurred for operating and maintaining DSU facilities, may be allowable administrative costs under the VR program. However, ongoing costs of any kind, including ongoing maintenance costs, are not allowable expenditures when establishing, developing, or improving a community rehabilitation program (see final § 361.5(c)(16)(iii)).

Changes:
None.

Customized Employment (§ 361.5(c)(11))

Comments:
Most commenters supported the new definition of “customized employment” in proposed § 361.5(c)(11). A few commenters requested that the definition include the “discovery phase” of the customized employment model. A few commenters suggested that the definition address when it is appropriate for the DSU to consider customized employment for individuals with disabilities. Further, these commenters stated that DSUs should use customized employment as the last option in assisting an individual with a disability to achieve competitive integrated employment. Another commenter questioned whether customized employment means “job carving.” Furthermore, one commenter requested that we clarify how individuals with disabilities, who are working in customized employment, could advance in their careers. One commenter questioned whether an employer would want to support an individual with a significant disability in customized employment. Another commenter stated that customized employment should not be an unfunded mandate. Finally, one commenter asked that we clarify the impact customized employment might have on the performance accountability measure for the core programs, including the VR program, in the workforce development system under section 116 of WIOA that measures the median wage of participants during the second quarter after they exit from these programs. This commenter suggested that earnings from customized employment would deflate this measure.

Discussion:
We appreciate the comments supporting the new definition of “customized employment” in final § 361.5(c)(11). However, we disagree with commenters who recommended that the definition be modified to include additional requirements, such as the inclusion of the discovery phase of the model or when a DSU must consider customized employment for an individual. Section 7(7) of the Act, as amended by WIOA, which defines the term “customized employment,” does not include this information. Therefore, we believe final § 361.5(c)(11) is consistent with the statute and further regulatory change is not necessary.

We disagree with the commenter that DSUs should use customized employment as a last resort when assisting an individual with a disability to achieve an employment outcome. We believe that customized employment may be an option for some individuals with significant disabilities, while, for other individuals, it may not be a viable path to competitive integrated employment. We strongly encourage DSUs to tailor customized employment services, like all of the services in final § 361.48(b) provided to eligible individuals under an individualized plan for employment, to meet the unique strengths, needs, interests, and informed choice of the individual, so that he or she can achieve an employment outcome in competitive integrated employment. We understand that some may have referred to customized employment in the past as “job carving;” however, the Act, as amended by WIOA, does not use that term. Therefore, we have not incorporated the term “job carving” into these final regulations.

We believe it is possible for individuals with disabilities in customized employment to advance in their careers. Individuals who achieve competitive integrated employment through customized employment could advance in their career with their original employers or by seeking advancement with other employers. The definition of “customized employment” in section 7(7) of the Act, as amended by WIOA, and final § 361.5(c)(11) do not include any criteria requiring an individual with a significant disability to remain in customized employment; rather, these individuals may seek additional vocational rehabilitation services for the purpose of advancing in their careers through other forms of competitive integrated employment. Customized employment is an alternative that enables individuals with disabilities and employers the opportunity to negotiate job tasks and/or reassign basic job duties to improve overall production in the workplace. For employers, customized employment allows an employer to examine its specific workforce needs and fulfill those needs with a well-matched employee. We encourage DSUs to work with employers, particularly those employers that have not been open to employing individuals with significant

disabilities, to enable them to hire these individuals through customized employment when appropriate.

We disagree with the commenter that customized employment is an unfunded mandate. Customized employment services are included in the list of allowable vocational rehabilitation services in final § 361.48(b). DSUs may expend their resources, including program funds, on supporting individuals in customized employment when appropriate.

Customized employment, as we have discussed, must lead to competitive integrated employment. Section 116(b)(2)(A)(i)(III) of title I of WIOA establishes a primary performance accountability indicator for all core programs of the workforce development system, including the VR program, that measures the median earnings of all participants who have exited the program in the second quarter after exit. As such, earnings from customized employment will affect the VR program's performance, in the same manner that other earnings will do so. We cannot assume, as the commenter suggests, that individuals in customized employment will earn low wages.

Changes:
None.

Employment Outcome (§ 361.5(c)(15))

Some commenters supported the definition of “employment outcome” in proposed § 361.5(c)(15) because it is consistent with the overall purpose of the Act, as amended by WIOA, to promote the achievement of competitive integrated employment and self-sufficiency by individuals with disabilities. As proposed, an “employment outcome” would mean full- or part-time employment in competitive integrated employment, or supported employment. As such, uncompensated employment outcomes (
e.g.,
homemakers and unpaid family workers) would be removed from the scope of the definition for purposes of the VR program. However, most commenters strongly opposed removing “uncompensated employment outcomes,” and recommended revisions or clarifications to the proposed definition.

Statutory Basis

Comments:
Most of the commenters on the proposed definition of “employment outcome” in § 361.5(c)(15) stated that the proposed change is contrary to congressional intent and not mandated by the Act, as amended by WIOA. Many of these commenters requested that the Secretary use the discretion permitted under section 7(11)(C) of the Act to not limit the definition to compensated employment, thereby permitting uncompensated outcomes of homemaker and unpaid family worker to continue to count as an employment outcome under the VR program.

In addition, recognizing that WIOA amends section 102(b)(4) of the Act to require that the individualized plan for employment contain a specific employment goal consistent with competitive integrated employment, a few commenters presented two arguments to support the retention of uncompensated outcomes as an employment outcome. First, the commenters argued that the phrase “consistent with the Act,” as used in the statutory definition, does not require that all components of the term “competitive integrated employment” be satisfied. In the alternative, these commenters suggested that homemaker and unpaid family worker outcomes satisfy the criteria for competitive integrated employment because they are typically found in the community and the earnings of individuals with disabilities who obtain these outcomes are commensurate with those of non-disabled persons in similar positions.

Discussion:
We appreciate the commenters' concerns and recognize that the definition of “employment outcome” in proposed and final § 361.5(c)(15) will end a long-standing Department policy. We gave considerable thought to all aspects of the issue and seriously considered the definition in light of the comments received.

We agree with commenters that the change eliminating uncompensated outcomes was not explicitly required on the basis of an amendment to the statutory definition in section 7(11) of the Act, which remained unchanged, in pertinent part, by WIOA. Nonetheless, we believe that the Act as amended by WIOA, when read in its entirety, provides a strong justification for the change.

We agree with the commenters that section 7(11)(C) of the Act permits the Secretary to use his discretion to include other vocational outcomes within the scope of the definition of “employmen

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/fr%3A2016-15980. Public record. Not legal advice.
