# Amendments Relating to Small Creditors and Rural or Underserved Areas Under the Truth in Lending Act (Regulation Z)

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/fr%3A2015-24362

## Record

- **Collection:** Federal Register
- **Document type:** Rule
- **Published:** October 2, 2015
- **Citation:** 80 FR 59944

## Text

BUREAU OF CONSUMER FINANCIAL PROTECTION
12 CFR Part 1026
[Docket No. CFPB-2015-0004]
RIN 3170-AA43
Amendments Relating to Small Creditors and Rural or Underserved Areas Under the Truth in Lending Act (Regulation Z)

AGENCY:

Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection.

ACTION:

Final rule; official interpretations.

SUMMARY:

The Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection (Bureau) is amending certain mortgage rules issued by the Bureau in 2013. This final rule revises the Bureau's regulatory definitions of small creditor, and rural and underserved areas, for purposes of certain special provisions and exemptions from various requirements provided to certain small creditors under the Bureau's mortgage rules.

DATES:

This final rule is effective on January 1, 2016. For additional discussion regarding the effective date of the rule see part VI of the
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION
below.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:

Jeffrey Haywood, Paralegal Specialist; Nicholas Hluchyj, Senior Counsel, or Paul Ceja, Senior Counsel and Special Advisor, Office of Regulations, at (202) 435-7700.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

I. Summary of the Final Rule

In January 2013, the Bureau issued several final rules concerning mortgage markets in the United States (2013 Title XIV Final Rules), pursuant to the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act (Dodd-Frank Act), Public Law 111-203, 124 Stat. 1376 (2010).
1

The Bureau has clarified and revised those rules over the past two years. The purpose of those updates was to address important questions raised by industry, consumer groups, or other stakeholders. The Bureau also indicated that it would revisit the Bureau's regulatory definitions of small creditor and rural and underserved areas, promulgated in those rules and related amendments, through study and possibly through additional rulemaking.

1
Specifically, on January 10, 2013, the Bureau issued Escrow Requirements Under the Truth in Lending Act (Regulation Z), 78 FR 4725 (Jan. 22, 2013) (January 2013 Escrows Final Rule), High-Cost Mortgage and Homeownership Counseling Amendments to the Truth in Lending Act (Regulation Z) and Homeownership Counseling Amendments to the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act (Regulation X), 78 FR 6855 (Jan. 31, 2013) (2013 HOEPA Final Rule), and Ability-to-Repay and Qualified Mortgage Standards Under the Truth in Lending Act (Regulation Z), 78 FR 6407 (Jan. 30, 2013) (January 2013 ATR Final Rule). The Bureau concurrently issued a proposal to amend the January 2013 ATR Final Rule, which was finalized on May 29, 2013.
See
78 FR 6621 (Jan. 30, 2013) (January 2013 ATR Proposal) and 78 FR 35429 (June 12, 2013) (May 2013 ATR Final Rule). On January 17, 2013, the Bureau issued the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act (Regulation X) and Truth in Lending Act (Regulation Z) Mortgage Servicing Final Rules, 78 FR 10901 (Feb. 14, 2013) (Regulation Z) and 78 FR 10695 (Feb. 14, 2013) (Regulation X). On January 18, 2013, the Bureau issued the Disclosure and Delivery Requirements for Copies of Appraisals and Other Written Valuations Under the Equal Credit Opportunity Act (Regulation B), 78 FR 7215 (Jan. 31, 2013) and, jointly with other agencies, issued Appraisals for Higher-Priced Mortgage Loans, 78 FR 10367 (Feb. 13, 2013) (January 2013 Interagency Appraisals Final Rule). On January 20, 2013, the Bureau issued the Loan Originator Compensation Requirements under the Truth in Lending Act (Regulation Z), 78 FR 11279 (Feb. 15, 2013).

To that end, on January 29, 2015, the Bureau proposed several amendments to its 2013 Title XIV Final Rules to revise Regulation Z provisions and official interpretations relating to escrow requirements for higher-priced mortgage loans under the Bureau's January 2013 Escrows Final Rule and ability-to-repay/qualified mortgage requirements under the Bureau's January 2013 ATR Final Rule and May 2013 ATR Final Rule. The Bureau's proposal would also affect requirements under the Bureau's 2013 HOEPA Final Rule.
2

The proposed rule was published in the
Federal Register
on February 11, 2015.
See
Amendments Relating to Small Creditors and Rural or Underserved Areas Under the Truth in Lending Act (Regulation Z), 80 FR 7769 (Feb. 11, 2015).

2
The January 2013 Interagency Appraisals Final Rule provides an exemption from the requirement to obtain a second appraisal for certain higher-priced mortgage loans if the loan is secured by a property in a “rural county.” This final rule will not affect the scope of that exemption because it will not change the counties that are defined as “rural” under § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(A).

This final rule adopts, with some additional clarifications and technical revisions, the Bureau's proposed rule. It reflects feedback received from stakeholders through this notice and comment rulemaking regarding the Bureau's definitions of small creditor, and rural and underserved areas, as those definitions relate to special provisions and certain exemptions to requirements provided to small creditors under the Bureau's 2013 Title XIV Final Rules and updates.

Specifically, the final rule makes the following changes with regard to the definitions of small creditor and rural and underserved areas as currently provided in the Bureau's mortgage rules:
3

3

See
§§ 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(A), (B), (C), and (D), and 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(A) and (B) and commentary, cross-referenced in §§ 1026.43(e)(5) and (e)(6), 1026.43(f)(1) and (f)(2) and commentary; and § 1026.32(d)(1)(ii)(C)).

• Raises the loan origination limit for determining eligibility for small-creditor status from 500 originations of covered transactions secured by a first lien, to 2,000 such originations (referred to in this rule as “extensions of covered transactions”), and excludes originated loans held in portfolio by the creditor and its affiliates from that limit. The final rule also establishes a grace period from calendar year to calendar year to allow a creditor that exceeded the origination limit in the preceding calendar year to operate, in certain circumstances, as a small creditor with respect to transactions with applications received before April 1 of the current calendar year.

• Includes in the calculation of the $2 billion asset limit for small-creditor status the assets of the creditor's affiliates that regularly extended covered transactions. The final rule also adds a grace period to the annual asset limit, to allow a creditor that exceeded the asset limit in the preceding calendar year to operate, in certain circumstances, as a small creditor with respect to transactions with applications received before April 1 of the current calendar year.

• Adjusts the time period used in determining whether a creditor is operating predominantly in rural or underserved areas from any of the three preceding calendar years to the preceding calendar year. As with the origination and asset limits for small-creditor status, the final rule adds a grace period to allow a creditor that fails to meet this threshold in the preceding calendar year, to continue operating, in certain circumstances, as if it had met this threshold with respect to transactions with applications received before April 1 of the current calendar year.

• Amends the current exemption under § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(D)(
1
) provided to small creditors that operate predominantly in rural or underserved areas from the requirement for the establishment of escrow accounts for higher-priced mortgage loans. The final rule ensures that creditors who established escrow accounts solely to comply with the current rule will be eligible for the exemption if they meet the expanded definitions of small creditors operating predominantly in rural or underserved areas under the final rule.

• Expands the definition of “rural” by adding census blocks that are not in an urban area as defined by the U.S. Census Bureau (Census Bureau) to the current county-based definition.

• Conforms the definition of “underserved” to the proposals discussed above. The substance of the “underserved” definition is not changed.

• Adds two new safe harbor provisions related to the rural or underserved definition for creditors that rely on automated tools provided: (1) On the Bureau's Web site to allow creditors to determine whether

properties are located in rural or underserved areas, or (2) on the Census Bureau's Web site to assess whether a particular property is located in an urban area according to the Census Bureau's definition. The final rule maintains the current safe harbor for lists of rural and underserved counties provided by the Bureau, with technical changes. The final rule also adds commentary clarifying the circumstances under which U.S. territories will be included on the lists.

• Extends the current two-year transition period, which allows certain small creditors to make balloon-payment qualified mortgages (§ 1026.43(e)(6)) and balloon-payment high-cost mortgages (§ 1026.32(d)(1)(ii)(C)), regardless of whether they operate predominantly in rural or underserved areas. The transition period will include covered transactions for which the application was received before April 1, 2016, rather than covered transactions consummated on or before January 10, 2016.

In addition to the changes discussed above to the definitions of small creditor and rural and underserved areas, this final rule is also making a technical correction to the commentary to § 1026.36(a). This non-substantive change is discussed in the section-by-section analysis of the supplementary information section below.

II. Background

In response to an unprecedented cycle of expansion and contraction in the mortgage market that sparked the most severe U.S. recession since the Great Depression, Congress passed the Dodd-Frank Act, which was signed into law on July 21, 2010. In the Dodd-Frank Act, Congress established the Bureau and generally consolidated the rulemaking authority for Federal consumer financial laws, including the Truth in Lending Act (TILA) and the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act, in the Bureau.
4

At the same time, Congress significantly amended the statutory requirements governing mortgage practices, with the intent to restrict the practices that contributed to and exacerbated the crisis.
5

4

See, e.g.,
sections 1011 and 1021 of the Dodd-Frank Act, 12 U.S.C. 5491 and 5511 (establishing and setting forth the purpose, objectives, and functions of the Bureau); section 1061 of the Dodd-Frank Act, 12 U.S.C. 5581 (consolidating certain rulemaking authority for Federal consumer financial laws in the Bureau); section 1100A of the Dodd-Frank Act (codified in scattered sections of 15 U.S.C.) (similarly consolidating certain rulemaking authority in the Bureau).
But see
Section 1029 of the Dodd-Frank Act, 12 U.S.C. 5519 (subject to certain exceptions, excluding from the Bureau's authority any rulemaking authority over a motor vehicle dealer that is predominantly engaged in the sale and servicing of motor vehicles, the leasing and servicing of motor vehicles, or both).

5

See
title XIV of the Dodd-Frank Act, Public Law 111-203, 124 Stat. 1376 (2010) (codified in scattered sections of 12 U.S.C., 15 U.S.C., and 42 U.S.C.).

Under the statute, most of these new requirements would have taken effect automatically on January 21, 2013 if the Bureau had not issued implementing regulations by that date.
6

To avoid uncertainty and potential disruption in the national mortgage market at a time of economic vulnerability, the Bureau issued several final rules (the 2013 Title XIV Final Rules) in a span of less than two weeks in January 2013 to implement these new statutory provisions and provide for an orderly transition. These final rules include the January 2013 ATR Final Rule, the January 2013 Escrows Final Rule, the 2013 HOEPA Final Rule, and the January 2013 Interagency Appraisals Final Rule. Most of the mortgage rules released in January 2013 became effective on January 10, 2014.

6

See
section 1400(c) of the Dodd-Frank Act, 15 U.S.C. 1601 note.

Concurrent with the January 2013 ATR Final Rule, on January 10, 2013, the Bureau issued the January 2013 ATR Proposal, which the Bureau adopted on May 29, 2013 in the May 2013 ATR Final Rule.
7

The Bureau has issued additional corrections, revisions, and clarifications to the provisions adopted by the Bureau in the 2013 Title XIV Final Rules and the May 2013 ATR Final Rule over the past two years.
8

This final rule concerns additional revisions to the 2013 Title XIV Final Rules related to provisions regarding small creditors and rural and underserved areas.

7
78 FR 6621 (Jan. 30, 2013); 78 FR 35429 (June 12, 2013) (providing a two-year transition period during which small creditors that do not operate predominantly in rural or underserved areas can offer balloon-payment qualified mortgages if they hold the loans in portfolio). In May 2013, the Bureau also finalized amendments to the January 2013 Escrows Final Rule. Amendments to the 2013 Escrows Final Rule under the Truth in Lending Act (Regulation Z), 78 FR 30739 (May 23, 2013) (May 2013 Escrows Final Rule).

8

See, e.g.,
78 FR 44685 (July 24, 2013) (clarifying, among other things, which mortgages to consider in determining small servicer status and the application of the small servicer exemption with regard to servicer/affiliate and master servicer/subservicer relationships); 78 FR 45842 (July 30, 2013); 78 FR 60382 (Oct. 1, 2013) (revising, among other things, two exceptions available to small creditors operating predominantly in “rural” or “underserved” areas, pending the Bureau's reexamination of the underlying definitions); 78 FR 62993 (Oct. 23, 2013) (clarifying the specific disclosures that must be provided before counseling for high cost mortgages can occur and proper compliance regarding servicing requirements when a consumer is in bankruptcy or sends a cease communication request under the Fair Debt Collection Practice Act). In the fall of 2014, the Bureau also made further amendments to the 2013 mortgage rules related to nonprofit entities and provided a cure mechanism for the points and fees limit that applies to qualified mortgages. 79 FR 65300 (Nov. 3, 2014).

III. Summary of the Rulemaking Process

On January 29, 2015, the Bureau issued, and on February 11, 2015, published in the
Federal Register
, its proposed rule entitled “Amendments Relating to Small Creditors and Rural or Underserved Areas Under the Truth in Lending Act (Regulation Z).”
9

The comment period closed on March 30, 2015. In response to the proposal, the Bureau received 90 comments from consumer groups, members of Congress, creditors, industry trade associations, and others. As discussed in more detail below, the Bureau has considered these comments in adopting this final rule.

9
80 FR 7769 (February 11, 2015).

IV. Legal Authority

The Bureau is issuing this final rule pursuant to its authority under TILA and the Dodd-Frank Act. Section 1061 of the Dodd-Frank Act transferred to the Bureau the “consumer financial protection functions” previously vested in certain other Federal agencies, including the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (Board). The term “consumer financial protection function” is defined to include “all authority to prescribe rules or issue orders or guidelines pursuant to any Federal consumer financial law, including performing appropriate functions to promulgate and review such rules, orders, and guidelines.”
10

Title X of the Dodd-Frank Act, including section 1061 of the Dodd-Frank Act, along with TILA and certain subtitles and provisions of title XIV of the Dodd-Frank Act, are Federal consumer financial laws.
11

10
Dodd-Frank Act section 1061(a)(1)(A), 12 U.S.C. 5581(a)(1)(A).

11
Dodd-Frank Act section 1002(14), 12 U.S.C. 5481(14) (defining “Federal consumer financial law” to include the “enumerated consumer laws,” the provisions of title X of the Dodd-Frank Act, and the laws for which authorities are transferred under title X subtitles F and H of the Dodd-Frank Act); Dodd-Frank Act section 1002(12), 12 U.S.C. 5481(12) (defining “enumerated consumer laws” to include TILA); Dodd-Frank section 1400(b), 12 U.S.C. 5481(12) note (defining “enumerated consumer laws” to include certain subtitles and provisions of Dodd-Frank Act title XIV).

A. TILA-Specific Statutory Grants of Authority

TILA as amended by the Dodd-Frank Act provides two specific statutory bases for the changes in the Bureau's final rule. TILA section 129D(c) authorizes the Bureau to exempt, by regulation, a creditor from the requirement (in section 129D(a)) that escrow accounts be established for higher-priced mortgage loans if the creditor operates predominantly in rural

or underserved areas, retains its mortgage loans in portfolio, does not exceed (together with all affiliates) a total annual mortgage loan origination limit set by the Bureau, and meets any asset size threshold, and any other criteria, the Bureau may establish. TILA section 129C(b)(2)(E) authorizes the Bureau to provide, by regulation, that certain balloon-payment mortgages originated by small creditors receive qualified mortgage status, even though qualified mortgages are otherwise prohibited from having balloon-payment features. The creditor qualifications under TILA section 129C(b)(2)(E)(iv) are essentially the same as those for the higher-priced mortgage loan escrow exemption, including operating predominantly in rural or underserved areas, together with all affiliates not exceeding a total annual mortgage loan origination limit set by the Bureau, retaining the balloon-payment loans in portfolio, and meeting any asset size threshold, and any other criteria, the Bureau may establish.

B. Other Rulemaking and Exception Authority

This final rule also relies on other rulemaking and exception authorities specifically granted to the Bureau by TILA and the Dodd-Frank Act, including the authorities discussed below.

Truth in Lending Act

As amended by the Dodd-Frank Act, section 105(a) of TILA authorizes the Bureau to prescribe regulations to carry out the purposes of TILA. 15 U.S.C. 1604(a). Under section 105(a), such regulations may contain such additional requirements, classifications, differentiations, or other provisions, and may provide for such adjustments and exceptions for all or any class of transactions, as in the judgment of the Bureau are necessary or proper to effectuate the purposes of TILA, to prevent circumvention or evasion thereof, or to facilitate compliance therewith. A purpose of TILA is “to assure a meaningful disclosure of credit terms so that the consumer will be able to compare more readily the various credit terms available to him and avoid the uninformed use of credit.” TILA section 102(a), 15 U.S.C. 1601(a). In particular, it is a purpose of TILA section 129C, as added by the Dodd-Frank Act, to assure that consumers are offered and receive residential mortgage loans on terms that reasonably reflect their ability to repay the loans and that are understandable and not unfair, deceptive, or abusive. 15 U.S.C. 1639b(a)(2).

Historically, TILA section 105(a) has served as a broad source of authority for rules that promote the informed use of credit through required disclosures and substantive regulation of certain practices. Dodd-Frank Act section 1100A clarified the Bureau's section 105(a) authority by amending that section to provide express authority to prescribe regulations that contain “additional requirements” that the Bureau finds are necessary or proper to effectuate the purposes of TILA, to prevent circumvention or evasion thereof, or to facilitate compliance therewith. This amendment clarified the Bureau's authority under TILA section 105(a) to prescribe requirements beyond those specifically listed in the statute that meet the standards outlined in section 105(a), which include effectuating all of TILA's purposes. Therefore, the Bureau believes that its authority under TILA section 105(a) to make exceptions, adjustments, and additional provisions that the Bureau finds are necessary or proper to effectuate the purposes of TILA applies with respect to the purpose of section 129D. That purpose is to ensure that consumers understand and appreciate the full cost of homeownership. The purpose of TILA section 129D is also informed by the findings articulated in section 129B(a) that economic stabilization would be enhanced by the protection, limitation, and regulation of the terms of residential mortgage credit and the practices related to such credit, while ensuring that responsible and affordable mortgage credit remains available to consumers.
See
15 U.S.C. 1639b(a).

TILA section 129C(b)(3)(B)(i) provides the Bureau with authority to prescribe regulations that revise, add to, or subtract from the criteria that define a qualified mortgage upon a finding that such regulations are necessary or proper to ensure that responsible, affordable mortgage credit remains available to consumers in a manner consistent with the purposes of the ability-to-repay requirements; are necessary and appropriate to effectuate the purposes of the ability-to-repay and residential mortgage loan origination requirements; prevent circumvention or evasion thereof; or facilitate compliance with TILA sections 129B and 129C. 15 U.S.C. 1639c(b)(3)(B)(i). In addition, TILA section 129C(b)(3)(A) requires the Bureau to prescribe regulations to carry out such purposes. 15 U.S.C. 1639c(b)(3)(A).

TILA section 105(a) grants the Bureau authority to make adjustments and exceptions to the requirements of TILA for all transactions subject to TILA, except with respect to the substantive provisions of TILA section 129 that apply to high-cost mortgages. With respect to the high-cost mortgage provisions of TILA section 129, TILA section 129(p), 15 U.S.C. 1639(p), as amended by the Dodd-Frank Act, grants the Bureau authority to create exemptions to the restrictions on high-cost mortgages and to expand the protections that apply to high-cost mortgages. Under TILA section 129(p)(1), the Bureau may exempt specific mortgage products or categories from any or all of the prohibitions specified in TILA section 129(c) through (i), if the Bureau finds that the exemption is in the interest of the borrowing public and will apply only to products that maintain and strengthen homeownership and equity protections. Among these referenced provisions of TILA is section 129(e), the prohibition on balloon payments for high-cost mortgages.

The Dodd-Frank Act

Section 1022(b)(1) of the Dodd-Frank Act authorizes the Bureau to prescribe rules “as may be necessary or appropriate to enable the Bureau to administer and carry out the purposes and objectives of the Federal consumer financial laws, and to prevent evasions thereof.” 12 U.S.C. 5512(b)(1). TILA and title X and certain enumerated subtitles and provisions of title XIV of the Dodd-Frank Act are Federal consumer financial laws. Accordingly, the Bureau is exercising its authority under Dodd-Frank Act section 1022(b) to issue rules that carry out the purposes and objectives of TILA, title X of the Dodd-Frank Act, and certain enumerated subtitles and provisions of title XIV of the Dodd-Frank Act, and to prevent evasion of those laws.

V. Section-by-Section Analysis of the Proposed Rule

Section 1026.35 Requirements for Higher-Priced Mortgage Loans

35(b) Escrow Accounts

35(b)(2) Exemptions

35(b)(2)(iii)

Section 1026.35(b)(2)(iii) currently provides that an escrow account need not be established for a higher-priced mortgage loan by small creditors who operate predominantly in rural or underserved areas if four conditions identified in § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(A) through (D) are satisfied at the time of consummation.
12

Section

1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(A) provides a test for determining whether a creditor operates predominantly in rural or underserved areas; § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(B) sets an origination limit for small creditor status; § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(C) sets an asset limit for small creditor status; and § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(D) does not allow an exemption from the escrow requirement for creditors with existing escrow accounts, with certain exceptions. The Bureau proposed to make amendments to all of these conditions and, as discussed below, is adopting these amendments with some clarifications in this final rule.

12
Section 1026.35(b)(2)(v) excludes from the § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii) exception any first-lien higher-

priced mortgage loan that, at consummation, is subject to a commitment to be acquired by a person that does not satisfy the § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii) conditions.

Because the predominantly-rural-or-underserved test and the origination and asset limits of § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii) are cross-referenced in the Bureau's January 2013 ATR Final Rule and its 2013 HOEPA Final Rule, and amendments to those rules, they also affect eligibility for special provisions and exemptions provided in those rules, including the following:

• A qualified mortgage definition for certain loans made and held in portfolio (small creditor portfolio loans), by small creditors regardless of whether they operate predominantly in rural or underserved areas. These loans are not subject to the 43 percent debt-to-income ratio limit (or to “appendix Q” requirements in determining the debt and income of consumers) that applies to general qualified mortgage loans under § 1026.43(e)(2) (§ 1026.43(e)(5)). A first-lien qualified mortgage under this category also provides a safe harbor from ability-to-repay claims, if the mortgage's annual percentage rate (APR) does not exceed the applicable Average Prime Offer Rate (APOR) by 3.5 or more percentage points. In contrast, general qualified mortgage loans under § 1026.43(e)(2) provide safe harbors if their APRs do not exceed the applicable APOR by 1.5 or more percentage points.
13

13
Specifically, for purposes of determining whether a loan has a safe harbor with regard to TILA's ability-to-repay requirements (or instead is categorized as “higher-priced” with only a rebuttable presumption of compliance with those requirements), for first-lien covered transactions, the special qualified mortgage definitions in § 1026.43(e)(5), (e)(6) and (f) receive an APR threshold of the applicable APOR plus 3.5 percentage points, rather than plus 1.5 percentage points.

• Two qualified mortgage definitions for small creditors making certain balloon-payment loans. One is a permanent definition for small creditors operating predominantly in rural or underserved areas. The other is a temporary definition for small creditors who do not operate predominantly in such areas. These definitions provide an exception from the limitation on balloon-payment features on general qualified mortgage loans (§ 1026.43(e)(6) and (f)).
14

These two qualified mortgage definitions are also subject to a higher APR threshold for defining a higher-priced covered transaction, allowing small creditors of such qualified mortgages to receive a safe harbor under the Bureau's ability-to-repay rule.

14
Specifically these provisions allow: (1) On a permanent basis, balloon-payment qualified mortgage loans made and held in portfolio by certain small creditors operating predominantly in rural or underserved areas ((§ 1026.43(f)); and (2) for a temporary two year transition period—from January 10, 2014 to January 10, 2016—balloon-payment qualified mortgages originated by small creditors even if they do not operate predominantly in rural or underserved areas (this period is being extended under this final rule to cover transactions with applications received before April 1, 2016—
see
the section-by-section analysis below on § 1026.43(e)(6))).

• An exception from the prohibition on balloon-payment features for certain high-cost mortgages (§ 1026.32(d)(1)(ii)(C))—also on a permanent basis for small creditors operating predominantly in rural or underserved areas and a temporary basis for small creditors who do not operate predominantly in such areas.
15

15
Specifically, this provision allows: (1) On a permanent basis, small creditors that operate predominantly in rural or underserved areas to originate high-cost loans with balloon-payment features; and (2) for loans made on or before January 10, 2016 (extended by this final rule to cover transactions with applications received before April 1, 2016), small creditors to originate high-cost mortgages with balloon-payment features even if they do not operate predominantly in rural or underserved areas, under certain conditions.
See
§ 1026.32(d)(1)(ii)(C).

The Bureau adopted these special provisions and exemptions for small creditors because of the important role that small creditors play in providing mortgage credit to consumers. The Bureau believes that many small creditors use a lending model based on maintaining ongoing relationships with their customers and often limit their lending activities to a single community. They therefore may have a more comprehensive understanding of the financial circumstances of their customers and of the economic and other circumstances of that community.
16

The special provisions and exemptions facilitate the ability of small creditors that operate predominantly in rural or underserved areas, as well as small creditors that operate in areas that are neither rural nor underserved, to provide access to mortgage credit for consumers they serve.

16
Lending activities of many creditors that currently qualify as small are generally limited to a single community. However, creditors that will qualify as small with the adoption of the changes in this final rule generally lend and have branches (in the case of depository institutions) in several communities and counties.

35(b)(2)(iii)(A)

As discussed in detail below, the Bureau is adopting § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(A) substantially as proposed, with certain minor changes to enhance clarity. Accordingly, this final rule restores the one-year lookback period for determining whether the creditor is operating predominantly in rural or underserved areas as originally adopted by the January 2013 Escrows Final Rule. This final rule also adopts the proposed grace period that allows a creditor making a higher-priced mortgage loan based on an application received before April 1 to rely on its transactions from either the preceding calendar year or the next-to-last calendar year to meet the condition in § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(A).

The Bureau's Proposal

The current test under § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(A) for determining whether a creditor operates predominantly in rural or underserved areas is that, during any of the three preceding calendar years, the creditor extended more than 50 percent of its total first-lien covered transactions, as defined by § 1026.43(b)(1),
17

on properties that are located in counties that are either “rural” or “underserved” (the more than 50 percent test). The Bureau proposed to amend § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(A) and comment 35(b)(2)(iii)-1 to eliminate the three-year lookback period in § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(A) and to establish the preceding calendar year as the relevant time period for assessing whether the more than 50 percent test is satisfied as a general matter. The Bureau also proposed a grace period to allow otherwise eligible creditors whose first-lien covered transactions in the preceding year failed to meet the more than 50 percent test to continue to operate with the benefit of the exemption for applications received before April 1 of the current calendar year if their first-lien covered transactions during the next-to-last calendar year met the test.

17
“Covered transaction” is defined in § 1026.43(b)(1) to mean a consumer credit transaction that is secured by a dwelling, as defined in § 1026.2(a)(19), including any real property attached to a dwelling, other than a transaction exempt from coverage under § 1026.43(a).

The Bureau also proposed conforming and technical changes to the rule and commentary. Proposed comment 35(b)(2)(iii)-1.i was amended for consistency with the changes that the Bureau proposed to the regulation text in §§ 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(A) and 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(A), and to provide guidance on the one-year lookback and grace periods. The Bureau also proposed to remove from comment 35(b)(2)(iii)-1.i all discussion of the lists that the

Bureau publishes of “rural” or “underserved” counties pursuant to § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv).

The Bureau invited comment on whether it should eliminate the three-year lookback period as proposed and whether it is appropriate to rely on the preceding calendar year in determining as a general matter whether the more than 50 percent test is met. The Bureau also sought feedback on whether it should provide a grace period to creditors that meet this test in one calendar year but fail to do so in the next calendar year and, if so, whether such a grace period should apply to all applications received before April 1 as proposed.

For the reasons discussed below, the Bureau is adopting § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(A) and the accompanying commentary as proposed, with minor technical revisions.

Comments

The Bureau received comments from national and state associations of credit unions, a national association of community banks, and state associations of banks on the proposal to use the preceding calendar year, rather than any of the three preceding calendar years, as the relevant time period for assessing whether the more than 50 percent test is satisfied and on the proposed April 1 grace period. No comments were received on the related proposed changes to the commentary.

Most of the commenters on the proposed lookback provision recommended that the Bureau maintain the three-year lookback. A national association of credit unions noted many credit unions develop their forward-looking strategies with a two- or three-year outlook and was concerned that the proposal will curtail a credit union's ability to do such planning. For the same reason, this commenter suggested extending the effective date of this rulemaking to January 1, 2017 if the three-year lookback is replaced with a one-year period. A national association and a state association of banks both noted some of their members operate close to the 50 percent threshold and that a three-year lookback would prevent these lenders from abruptly halting their loan originations should they come close to approaching the loan threshold or otherwise become concerned that they may not meet the more than 50 percent test in a given year. The state banking association recommended a six-month grace period if the Bureau adopts the one-year lookback period to allow community banks to make necessary product and system adjustments and train staff. Other commenters noted generally that the three-year lookback would provide creditors greater flexibility than a one-year period would, but provided no specific details or examples.

The majority of commenters on the proposed Apri1 1 grace period supported that provision, although a few commenters recommended extending the grace period to six months, and in one case, to one year. The commenters recommending an extension of the grace period generally cited the need for additional time to adjust systems and train staff.

Final Rule

The Bureau is finalizing § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(A) and its accompanying commentary generally as proposed but with minor changes to provide greater clarity.

The Bureau considered comments requesting the continuation of the three-year lookback but has not adopted this approach in the final rule. As originally adopted in the January 2013 Escrows Final Rule, § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(A) considered only the preceding year and established a one-year lookback period. The Bureau instituted the three-year lookback period to stabilize the escrow exemption during the period from 2013 to 2015 while the definitions were under review. 78 FR 60382, 60416 (Oct. 1, 2013). This change guaranteed eligibility for a creditor that was eligible during 2013 with respect to operating predominantly in rural or underserved areas and met the other applicable criteria through 2015. Stability in this specific period was a particular concern because during the definitional review the first year-to-year transition in the “rural” definition for purposes of this exemption was to coincide with the shift in the United States Department of Agriculture's Economic Research Service's (USDA-ERS) county Urban Influence Code (UIC) designations that occur once every decade.

Once the definitional review period ends, the Bureau believes that using a three-year lookback period on a permanent basis would allow creditors to maintain eligibility even if their first-lien covered transactions do not meet the more than 50 percent test in most calendar years. That result would be contrary to the goal of identifying creditors that focus their activity in rural or underserved areas.

Although the three-year lookback period provides creditors with certainty that they will be eligible for the exemption at least two years into the future, the Bureau does not believe that such extended notice will be necessary once the revisions to the definitions are effective. As explained in the section-by-section analysis of § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(A), below, the areas that are rural under the definition would only change once or twice a decade.
18

While the counties defined as underserved could change each year, such shifts are unlikely to affect many creditors' eligibility for the special provisions and exemptions because very few counties would be underserved but not rural under the Bureau's definitions. Furthermore, creditors can monitor the first-lien covered transactions that they originate throughout the year using the Bureau's automated tool and should generally be able to anticipate any change in their eligibility well before the end of the year. Any changes that would be made in the rural definition after each decennial census would be based on demographic shifts that have unfolded over the preceding decade and which may, in many instances, be evident to creditors serving those areas. The changes would be announced well before they become effective, allowing time for creditors to assess their status and make appropriate transitions. The Bureau therefore believes that the preceding calendar year is the appropriate time period to use as a general rule in assessing whether the more than 50 percent test is met.

18
As noted in the discussion of comment 35(b)(2)(iv)-2 below, the Census Bureau released its list of urban areas based on the 2010 decennial census in 2012, and the USDA-ERS released its UIC designations based on the 2010 decennial census in 2013. If the USDA-ERS continues to incorporate decennial census results into its UIC county designations in a different year than the Census Bureau finalizes its rural-urban classification, as in 2012 and 2013, the effects of each decennial census would be incorporated into the Bureau's proposed “rural” definition over the course of two years, which would afford additional transition time to some of the creditors affected by the changes.

The Bureau acknowledges that in some cases, a creditor could find out on or close to December 31st that it was not operating predominantly in rural or underserved areas during that calendar year. Such a creditor might have difficulty transitioning from balloon-payment loans to adjustable-rate mortgages and complying with the higher-priced mortgage loan escrow requirements by January 1 if eligibility for the special provisions and exemptions is based solely on transactions in the preceding calendar year. The Bureau therefore is adopting the proposed grace period that allows a creditor making a higher-priced mortgage loan based on an application received before April 1 to rely on its transactions from either the preceding calendar year or the next-to-last

calendar year to meet the more than 50 percent test in § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(A).

A creditor that is otherwise eligible and that met the more than 50 percent test in calendar year one but fails to meet it in calendar year two remains eligible with respect to applications received before April 1 of calendar year three. The Bureau considered comments requesting longer grace periods of six months or one year, but the Bureau is adopting this provision as proposed. Most of the comments received favored the grace period as proposed, and the Bureau believes that a grace period of this nature facilitates the transition of creditors that no longer operate predominantly in rural or underserved areas and properly balances the importance of the substantive consumer protections provided by the higher-priced mortgage loan escrows requirement, the ability-to-repay requirement, and the high-cost mortgage requirements with concerns that have been raised regarding their potential impact on access to credit.

35(b)(2)(iii)(B)

The Bureau is adopting § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(B) and the accompanying commentary, substantially as proposed, with certain technical changes and commentary additions to enhance clarity, as discussed in further detail below. Accordingly, this final rule raises the origination limit for small creditor status from 500 covered transactions secured by a first-lien originated by the creditor and its affiliates, to 2,000 such loans. The final rule also excludes originated loans held in portfolio by the creditor or its affiliates from the limit. The final rule also adds a grace period to allow an otherwise eligible creditor that exceeded the origination limit in the preceding calendar year (but not in the calendar year before the preceding year) to continue to operate as a small creditor with respect to transactions with applications received before April 1 of the current calendar year.

Background—Origination Limit

As part of its rulemakings implementing title XIV of the Dodd-Frank Act, in January 2013, the Bureau adopted an annual origination limit for small creditor status of 500 first-lien covered transactions in the preceding calendar year (§ 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(B).
19

Specifically, the origination limit in § 1026.35 (b)(2)(iii)(B) provides that, during the preceding calendar year, creditors, together with their affiliates, must have originated 500 or fewer covered transactions, as defined by § 1026.43(b)(1), secured by a first lien.

19
For a more detailed discussion of the Board's and the Bureau's past rulemaking efforts with regard to the small creditor origination limit, see the proposed rule. 80 FR 7769, 7776-7781.

In adopting this limit the Bureau believed that an origination limit, in combination with other requirements, was the most accurate means of confining the special provisions and exemptions to the class of small creditors that focus primarily on a relationship-lending model, a business model the Bureau believed would best facilitate consumers' access to responsible, affordable credit.

However, prior to and after the effective dates of the 2013 Title XIV Final Rules, the Bureau heard repeated expressions of concern that the Bureau's definition of small creditor was under-inclusive and did not cover a significant number of institutions that met the rationale underlying the special provisions and exemptions. Accordingly, on May 6, 2014, in a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking with proposals addressing other elements of the 2013 Title XIV Final Rules, the Bureau also sought comment on the 500 total first-lien origination limit—including whether that limit is sufficient to serve the purposes of the small creditor designation.
20

20
Amendments to the 2013 Mortgage Rules Under the Truth in Lending Act (Regulation Z), 79 FR 25730 (May 6, 2014).

In response to the Bureau's solicitation of comments regarding the origination limit in its May 6, 2014 proposal, industry commenters, including national and state associations of banks, and national and state associations of credit unions, generally supported an increase in the 500 loan origination limit. Consumer groups generally did not support an increase, absent clear evidence that the current limit was significantly harming consumers. These consumer-group commenters asserted that evidence of consumer harm does not exist.

The Bureau's Proposal

The Bureau's proposed rule reflected stakeholder feedback on the small creditor definition received during the period since the issuance of its 2013 Title XIV Final Rules. Specifically, the Bureau proposed to raise the origination limit in § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(B) from 500 covered transactions secured by a first-lien originated by the creditor and its affiliates to 2,000 such loans. The Bureau also proposed to exclude loans held in portfolio by the creditor or its affiliates from the limit, so that the limit would only apply to loans that were sold, assigned, or otherwise transferred by the creditor or its affiliates to another person, or subject to a commitment to be acquired by another person. The Bureau also proposed to add a grace period from calendar year to calendar year to allow an otherwise eligible creditor that exceeded the origination limit in the preceding calendar year to continue to operate as a small creditor with respect to transactions with applications received before April 1 of the current calendar year if the creditor had not exceeded it in the calendar year before the preceding calendar year.

Proposed comment 35(b)(2)(iii)-1.ii made clear that a loan transferred by a creditor to its affiliate is a loan not retained in portfolio (it is a loan transferred to “another person”) and therefore is counted toward the 2,000 origination limit. The proposed comment also explained and added examples on applying the grace period to the origination limit.

In issuing the proposed rule, the Bureau stated its belief that an adjustment of the current origination limit as proposed, given feedback received on the origination limit up to that point, is justified. The Bureau stated that small creditors serve a particularly critical function for consumers in rural and underserved areas, especially when these creditors make portfolio loans for which there may be no secondary market. At the same time, the Bureau recognized that an expansion of the origination limit could undermine the Bureau's title XIV regulatory protections. The Bureau stated that it wanted to ensure that the origination limit is not set at a level that will allow larger creditors to take advantage of small-creditor status to avoid important regulatory requirements that protect consumers—regulatory requirements that those larger creditors, unlike many smaller creditors, have the capacity to implement effectively.

For the reasons discussed below, the Bureau is adopting § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(B), and the accompanying commentary, as proposed, with several technical revisions, and commentary additions and clarifications.

Comments

Comments on the Bureau's proposal to raise the origination limit were divided between industry stakeholders and consumer groups. Industry commenters generally expressed appreciation and support for the proposed rule changes, while consumer representatives and organizations opposed or expressed concern with the proposals.

Increase limit to 2,000 loans.
Industry commenters supported the proposed increase in the origination limit for small creditor status from 500 loans to 2,000 non-portfolio loans. Banks, and their national and state trade associations, were particularly supportive of the 2,000 origination limit. One national trade association stated, for example, that its internal analysis suggested that the Bureau approximated a good target through the proposed 2,000 origination limit. It stated further that from informal polling of its smaller community bank members, 1,000 loan originations per year is a common volume at banks of asset sizes below $1 billion, and that many may originate more. A state banking association agreed, stating that the Bureau's proposal better aligned the origination limit with the asset limit. This commenter stated that the current rule limiting originations to 500 covered transactions for institutions with up to $2 billion in assets does not reflect the business models of most community banks. A national association of credit unions, in expressing support for increasing the origination limit to 2,000 loans, stated that, because a large number of its members with assets under $2 billion originate more than 500 first-lien mortgages, it had long sought an increase in the origination threshold. Another state banking association stated that the increased origination limit will qualify more institutions as small creditors and promote the availability of mortgage credit for their customers.

While national and state credit union trade association commenters were supportive of the Bureau's proposal to raise the limit, a number questioned how the Bureau arrived at 2,000 loans for the limit, and suggested the Bureau analyze increasing the proposed limit. One national association of credit unions, for example, encouraged the Bureau to provide impact analyses that demonstrate how communities, consumers, and creditors would be affected if the limit were raised to 2,500, 3,000, 3,500, or 4,000, as well as the proposed threshold of 2,000, so that stakeholders and the Bureau would have more informed comments regarding what the new limit should be. Some state associations of credit unions suggested that the Bureau raise the limit to 5,000 loans, stating that a threshold at that level is more in line with the reality of credit unions that continue to maintain the virtues of a small creditor, including an elevated level of service and personal attention to borrowers.

Some state associations of credit unions suggested that the Bureau allow institutions with default rates of, for example, less than 1 percent of covered transactions in the previous calendar year to make up to 4,000 mortgage loans per year and still qualify for the small creditor exemption.

Consumer groups opposed or expressed concern regarding the proposed increase in the origination limit. Some cited a lack of an evidentiary basis to support the expansion of the origination limit, asserting that the Bureau did not provide any evidence that the current limit unreasonably constrains small creditors.

Several consumer organizations in a joint comment expressed concern about the expansion of the origination limit to 2,000 loans, with a specific focus on past practices and lack of regulatory oversight with regard to non-depository institutions. They stated that, in the past, the absence of oversight by federal financial regulators, when combined with inconsistent or weaker state oversight, created an environment where non-depository institutions, in particular, had improper incentives to push consumers into mortgage loans with problematic features. The joint commenters encouraged the Bureau to limit the increase of the origination limit to depository institutions exclusively.

Exclusion of portfolio loans from the limit.
Industry commenters also supported the Bureau's proposal to exclude portfolio loans from the origination limit. A national association of banks stated that this exclusion is consistent with the rule's overall goals of ensuring safe lending while promoting credit accessibility. It stated that the success and livelihood of community banks are dependent upon repayment of their portfolio loans and that community banks carefully underwrite these loans based on knowledge of their communities and standards that meet local customer needs. It also noted the sound lending practices of “hometown banks” as demonstrated by their persistently low default and foreclosure rates, even through the recent mortgage crisis. These comments were echoed by several state banking associations.

An organization of state bank supervisors stated that the Bureau's proposal correctly acknowledges that portfolio lenders have strong incentives to consider a borrower's ability to repay a loan. It also stated that raising the small creditor origination limit from 500 to 2,000 loans, and more importantly, excluding loans originated and held in portfolio from that threshold, will provide effective and significant regulatory relief for community bank portfolio lenders.

A coalition of mid-size banks stated that this aspect of the proposal rests on the understanding that a creditor retains the risk associated with its portfolio loans and therefore has a natural incentive to underwrite such loans deliberately and under conservative standards. It stated further that this incentive is magnified for small and mid-size banks, which have substantially lower capital cushions than their larger counterparts to absorb losses in connection with default. A state association of banks stated that the Bureau is moving in the “right direction” with many of its proposals, but recommended that the Bureau exclude from the origination limit loans transferred by a creditor to a wholly-owned subsidiary.

Grace period for transactions with applications received before April 1st of current calendar year.
Industry commenters supported the Bureau's proposal to allow a creditor that exceeded the origination limit in the preceding calendar year to operate, in certain circumstances, as a small creditor with respect to transactions with applications received before April 1 of the current calendar year. Some commenters, however, suggested that the grace period be extended,
e.g.,
to 6 months. These commenters expressed concern that the proposed grace period was too brief for small banks and credit unions to track their originations and to change their operations in a timely manner.

Final Rule

Increase of origination limit to 2,000 loans.
As discussed above, the Bureau believes that small creditors serve a critical function for consumers in rural and underserved areas, especially when these creditors make portfolio loans for which there may be no secondary market and that larger creditors may not be willing to make. Industry comments on the current small creditor origination limit indicate that it may be restricting the ability of such creditors with relationship lending models to provide needed credit to qualified borrowers in rural and underserved areas. The intent of the small creditor test is to facilitate lending by those small creditors that provide responsible, affordable credit to consumers, and to enable consumers in rural and underserved areas to access creditors with a lending model, operations, and products that may meet their particular needs.

The Bureau has considered those industry comments that suggested raising the limit above 2,000 loans, or

raising the limit above 2,000 loans for institutions with lower default rates. The Bureau seeks to avoid setting the origination limit, however, at a level that will allow larger creditors to take advantage of small-creditor status. The Bureau's primary goal in setting the limit is to draw the appropriate line between small and large creditors, and to strike the right balance between preserving consumer access to credit and maintaining effective consumer protections. The Bureau believes that the 2,000 non-portfolio loan limit strikes that balance.

The Bureau is finalizing the origination limit as proposed, applying equally to depository institutions and non-depository institutions, as does the current rule. Excluding non-depository institutions from the changes to the origination limit, as suggested by some consumer groups, would require the Bureau to establish, and oversee, two different regulatory schemes for banks and non-banks. This introduction of complexity into the determination of small creditor status would subject similar regulated entities to different regulatory requirements, possibly creating creditor confusion regarding compliance, resulting in increased burden and compliance costs for such creditors. Moreover, the Dodd-Frank Act sets out as one of the objectives for the Bureau enforcing federal consumer financial law consistently without regard to charter type.
21

21

See
section 1021(b)(4) of the Dodd-Frank Act, 12 U.S.C. 5511(b)(4), requiring the Bureau to “to ensure that Federal consumer financial law is
enforced consistently, without regard to the status of a person as a depository institution, in order to promote fair competition.”
(emphasis added).

Exclusion of portfolio loans from the limit.
The Bureau's proposal to exclude loans held in portfolio by the creditor and its affiliates recognizes that the interests of small portfolio lenders are more likely to be aligned with the interests of consumers because small portfolio lenders retain the credit risk for loans held in portfolio. The Bureau has also recognized that many small creditors use a lending model based on maintaining ongoing relationships with their customers and therefore may have a more comprehensive understanding of the financial circumstances of their customers. The Bureau's exclusion of portfolio loans from the origination limit, therefore, is a recognition not only of the small creditor's community-based focus and commitment to relationship-based lending, but also of the inherent alignment of creditors' and consumers' interests associated with portfolio lending by smaller institutions. The Bureau is therefore adopting the exclusion of portfolio loans from the origination limit as proposed.

The Bureau believes the final rule provides a bright-line approach for determining what is included in the 2,000-origination limit. The Bureau also believes that the bright-line nature of this rule would be undermined by the commenter's recommendation described above that the Bureau not count toward the limit loans transferred by the creditor to its wholly-owned subsidiary. A transfer of a loan by a creditor to a subsidiary, or other affiliate, is not a loan held in the creditor's portfolio. Rather, it is a loan that is sold, assigned, or otherwise transferred by the creditor to another legal entity in this particular situation (
see
§ 1026.2(a)(22), the definition of “person” under Regulation Z). Making distinctions between wholly-owned subsidiaries and other affiliates for purposes of the origination limit would create compliance and oversight complications for creditors, their affiliates, and regulators, for example, because whether a subsidiary is “wholly-owned” could be a complicated analysis in some circumstances.

Grace period for transactions with applications received before April 1st of current calendar year.
The Bureau is adopting its proposed grace period to allow a creditor that exceeded the origination limit in the preceding calendar year to operate, in certain circumstances, as a small creditor with respect to transactions with applications received before April 1 of the current calendar year. The Bureau has considered commenters' suggestions for a longer grace period but believes the grace period should provide sufficient time for creditors to make any needed adjustments to come into compliance with the Bureau's regulatory requirements upon exceeding the origination limit. Further, the focus of the grace period on transactions with applications received before April 1, rather than transactions consummated before April 1, will mean that creditors will be able to consummate as small creditors not only transactions that were pending in their pipeline at the beginning of the calendar year but also transactions well into the current calendar year, as long as the application for a transaction was received before April 1 of the current calendar year. For example, if a creditor received a loan application in mid-March of the current calendar year, it could consummate that loan transaction as a small creditor 60 or 90 days later, in mid-June or July of the current calendar year.

This final rule is also making several additional technical and clarifying language changes to § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(B) from the proposed rule, for example, changing the phrase “originated . . . covered transactions” to “extended . . . covered transactions,” to make the language of that section consistent with the terminology generally used in Regulation Z. In addition, this final rule makes several technical and clarifying amendments to comment 35(b)(2)(iii)-1.ii, including, for example, technical changes for purposes of consistency between the regulatory text at § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(B) and the commentary, and additional guidance regarding the definition of “affiliate.” The comment states that, for purposes of § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(B), “affiliate” has the same meaning as in § 1026.32(b)(5), which defines “affiliate” as “any company that controls, is controlled by or is under common control with another company, as set forth in the Bank Holding Company Act of 1956 (12 U.S.C. 1841
et seq.
).” The commentary also sets out the definition of “control” under the Bank Holding Company Act.

The Bureau believes that this final rule sets the origination limit in an effective and responsible way. As discussed, the Bureau's intent in setting the origination limit is to include small creditors that can provide responsible, affordable credit to consumers and enable consumers, particularly those in rural and underserved areas, to access creditors with a lending model, operations, and products that may meet their particular needs. As further discussed in the section 1022(b) analysis in part VII below, the Bureau estimates that expanding the origination limit to 2,000 originations, and not including portfolio loans in that originations count, will increase the number of small creditors by 700, from approximately 9,700 to approximately 10,400. The Bureau believes that this increase will include creditors with the size and responsible lending models that fit the purpose of small-creditor status that the Bureau intends.

35(b)(2)(iii)(C)

As discussed in further detail below, the Bureau is adopting § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(C) and the accompanying commentary, substantially as proposed, with certain technical changes and commentary additions to enhance clarity. Accordingly, this final rule includes in the calculation of the asset limit for small-creditor status the assets of the creditor's affiliates that regularly extended covered transactions secured by first liens during the applicable period. The final rule also adds a grace

period from calendar year to calendar year to allow an otherwise eligible creditor that exceeded the asset limit in the preceding calendar year (but not in the calendar year before the preceding year) to continue to operate as a small creditor with respect to transactions with applications received before April 1 of the current calendar year.

The Bureau's Proposal

Currently, under § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(C), eligibility for small creditor status is limited to creditors with less than $2 billion in assets (or other current yearly adjusted limit) at the end of the preceding calendar year.

The Bureau did not propose a change to the current $2 billion asset limit in § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(C). The Bureau, however, did propose to amend § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(C) to include in the calculation of the $2 billion asset limit the assets of the creditor's affiliates that originate covered transactions secured by a first lien. Proposed comment 35(b)(2)(iii)-1.iii provided that, for purposes of § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(C), in addition to the creditor's assets, only the assets of a creditor's “affiliate” as defined in § 1026.32(b)(5) that originates covered transactions as defined by § 1026.43(b)(1) secured by a first lien would be counted toward the asset limit.

In proposing this change, the Bureau noted that counting both the creditor's assets and the assets of the creditor's affiliates that originate mortgage loans would make the tests for determining small-creditor status consistent as between the asset limit in § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(C) and the origination limit in § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(B), which currently includes the originations of the creditor's affiliates in determining whether the limit has been exceeded. The Bureau stated that this added consistency between the two tests could facilitate creditor compliance with the special provisions and exemptions for small creditors, including those that operate predominantly in rural or underserved areas.

The Bureau also stated its belief, that given the proposed change to the origination limit to exclude the creditor's and its affiliate's portfolio loans from counting toward that limit, the proposed change to the asset limit is necessary to ensure that small-creditor status does not become a means for larger creditors, through the development of affiliate relationships, to evade important consumer protections.

The Bureau stated that it was interested in receiving comments on the proposed change's potential impact on creditors and access to credit. The Bureau also sought comment on the potential for larger creditors to obtain small-creditor status without this change and the possible impact on consumers.

The Bureau also proposed to add a grace period to the $2 billion asset limit in § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(C), similar to the grace period proposed by the Bureau for the origination limit. This proposed grace period allowed an otherwise eligible creditor that exceeded the asset limit in the preceding calendar year to continue to operate as a small creditor with respect to transactions with applications received before April 1 of the current calendar year. This proposed grace period was available to creditors that exceeded the asset limit in the preceding calendar year but had not exceeded it in the calendar year before the preceding calendar year. The Bureau stated that it proposed the grace period to provide consistency in requirements for creditors seeking and maintaining small-creditor status.

Proposed comment 35(b)(2)(iii)-1.iii explained that creditors meet the asset limit during calendar year 2016 if the creditors' total assets (which include, in addition to the creditors' assets, the assets of the creditors' affiliates that originate mortgage loans) are under the applicable asset limit on December 31, 2015. The proposed comment explained further that creditors that did not satisfy the applicable asset limit on December 31, 2015 satisfy the asset limit during 2016 if the application for the loan was received before April 1, 2016 and the creditors had total assets under the applicable asset limit on December 31, 2014. The proposed comment also added the threshold for calendar year 2015 to the 2013 and 2014 asset limits currently listed in the comment.

For the reasons discussed below, the Bureau is adopting § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(C), and the accompanying commentary as proposed, with several technical revisions, and commentary additions and clarifications.

Comments

Include the assets of the creditor's mortgage affiliates in the asset limit calculation.
In general, consumer groups strongly supported the Bureau's proposal to include in the calculation of the asset limit for small creditor status the assets of the creditor's affiliates that originate mortgage loans, citing it as an important “anti-evasion” measure. Specifically, a joint comment from three consumer organizations stated that as a result of the current rule's exclusion of affiliated assets in calculating the small creditor asset limit, very large financial institutions can create unlimited smaller affiliates and have each of them qualify as a small creditor under the rule. The comment stated further that this is a significant loophole that undermines the consumer protections created by the ability-to-repay rule and the accompanying qualified mortgage designation. Another consumer organization commenter stated that aggregating the loans for all affiliated lenders is an important anti-evasion device that preserves the “valuable” small creditor exemption, while preventing its abuse.

Industry commenters opposed the change. Some stated that if the Bureau adopted the proposal, it needed to increase the asset limit correspondingly. Several commenters, including a national association of banks, recommended an increase in the asset limit to $10 billion. The proposal, these commenters asserted, effectively lowers the threshold limit for financial institutions with affiliates.

Credit union commenters were concerned with the impact of the proposal on the eligibility of credit unions for small creditor status. A particular concern was regarding those credit unions with affiliated credit union service organizations (CUSOs), with some credit union commenters suggesting that the Bureau exclude CUSOs from treatment as “affiliates” for purposes of the asset limit. In support of different treatment for CUSOs, a credit union trade association commenter distinguished CUSOs from other affiliates, stating that they are limited in scope and purpose. This commenter alternatively requested clarification on how to calculate the asset limit in the case of a CUSO that is owned by multiple credit unions, if the Bureau adopted the proposal. Some credit unions pointed to the Bank Holding Company Act, and the reference to that Act in the Regulation Z definition of “affiliate” that was cited in the proposed rule, as a basis for excluding CUSOs from the asset limit calculation, stating that the Act does not apply to credit unions.

A state association of banks recommended that the Bureau exclude from counting toward the asset limit loans originated by a creditor and/or its affiliates and held in portfolio—including loans held in portfolio by a wholly-owned subsidiary of either. This commenter stated that a “community-based institution should not lose `small creditor' status simply because it is successful with its portfolio-based

strategy and crosses the $2 billion” asset limit.

Add grace period for transactions with applications received before April 1st of current calendar year.
Industry commenters supported the Bureau's proposal to allow a creditor that exceeded the asset limit in the preceding calendar year to operate, in certain circumstances, as a small creditor with respect to transactions with applications received before April 1 of the current calendar year. As with the grace period for the origination limit, however, some commenters suggested that the grace period be extended,
e.g.,
to 6 months.

Final Rule

Include the assets of the creditor's mortgage affiliates in the asset limit calculation.
The Bureau believes this change is an important anti-evasion measure that would limit the ability of larger entities to structure arrangements such that one or more affiliates can enjoy the benefits of small creditor status. This change would also make the asset limit calculation more consistent with the origination limit calculation, which currently includes the originations of the creditor's affiliates.

Accordingly, the Bureau is finalizing § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(C) as proposed but with several technical revisions. The final rule changes from the proposed rule the phrase “the creditor and its affiliates that originate covered transactions” to “the creditor and its affiliates that regularly extended covered transactions” in § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(C) to make the language of that section more consistent with the terminology generally used in Regulation Z. This change also provides greater clarity that, as stated in the proposed rule,
22

only the assets of the creditor's affiliates that originate covered transactions, and not the assets of other affiliates of the creditor, count toward the limit. The change also indicates that there is a difference between how the covered transactions of affiliates are counted for purposes of the originations limit and how the assets of affiliates are counted for purposes of the asset limit. The originations limit requires a creditor to count each affiliate's first-lien covered transactions that were sold, assigned, or otherwise transferred to another person, or that were subject at the time of consummation to a commitment to be acquired by another person. For purposes of the asset limit, a creditor counts only the assets of those affiliates that regularly extended first-lien covered transactions and not the assets of other affiliates. This difference prevents the assets of an affiliate that does not regularly extend covered transactions from having a significant impact on the asset limit for a creditor.

22
80 FR 7769, 7781 (February 11, 2015).

To provide additional guidance, the final rule also makes several additions and clarifications to comment 35(b)(2)(iii)-1.iii. Comment 35(b)(2)(iii)-1.iii.A states that only the assets of a creditor's “affiliate” (as defined by § 1026.32(b)(5)) that regularly extended covered transactions (as defined by § 1026.43(b)(1)) secured by first liens, are counted toward the applicable annual asset threshold. Comment 35(b)(2)(iii)-1.iii.A also refers to comment 35(b)(2)(iii)-1.ii.C, which discusses the definition of affiliate under 1026.32(b)(5) and the definition of control under the Bank Holding Company Act referenced in that section. Comment 35(b)(2)(iii)-1.iii.B states that only the assets of creditors' affiliates that regularly extended first-lien covered transactions during the applicable period for determining whether the creditor met the asset limit are included in calculating the creditor's assets. Comment 35(b)(2)(iii)-1.iii.B then discusses the meaning of “regularly extended,” which is based on the number of times a person extends consumer credit for purposes of the definition of “creditor” in § 1026.2(a)(17), and provides examples on this point. Consistent with § 1026.2(a)(17)(v), because covered transactions are “transactions secured by a dwelling,” an affiliate “regularly extended” covered transactions if it extended more than five covered transactions in a calendar year. Also consistent with § 1026.2(a)(17)(v), because a covered transaction may be a high-cost mortgage subject to § 1026.32, an affiliate regularly extends covered transactions if, in any 12-month period, it extends more than one covered transaction that is subject to the requirements of § 1026.32 or one or more such transactions through a mortgage broker. Comment 35(b)(2)(iii)-1.iii.C states that if multiple creditors share ownership of a company that regularly extended first-lien covered transactions, the assets of the company count toward the asset limit for a co-owner creditor if the company is an “affiliate,” as defined in § 1026.32(b)(5), of the co-owner creditor. Comment 35(b)(2)(iii)-1.iii.C also states that if the co-owner creditor and the company are affiliates, the co-owner creditor counts all of the company's assets toward the asset limit, regardless of the co-owner creditor's ownership share. The comment also notes that because the co-owner and the company are mutual affiliates, the company also would count all of the co-owner's assets towards its own asset limit.

While credit unions in their comments expressed concern about the impact of the proposal on credit unions affiliated with CUSOs, under the proposal only the assets of affiliates that regularly extended covered transactions are counted toward the creditor's asset limit. As adopted under the Bureau's final rule, therefore, only the assets of CUSOs that meet the definition of affiliate in Regulation Z (meeting the “control” test under the Bank Holding Company Act) and that regularly extend covered transactions during the applicable period will be counted toward the asset limit. The Bureau is not excluding CUSOs from possible treatment as affiliates because it remains concerned that a credit union could, under the current asset limit calculation, enter into a relationship with a CUSO or CUSOs to create a large entity that would be eligible for the special provisions and exemptions accorded small creditor status. The Bureau also notes that § 1026.32(b)(5) and its definition of “affiliate” references the Bank Holding Company Act only for the purposes of how control is determined under that Act, which is applicable to the determination of affiliate under Regulation Z regardless of the applicability of the Act to credit unions.

As noted, the Bureau did not propose to change the current $2 billion asset limit. However, as discussed, some commenters suggested that the Bureau increase that limit to correspond with the Bureau's proposed inclusion of the assets of a creditor's affiliates in the asset limit calculation, with several commenters suggesting an increase to $10 billion. The Bureau established the current $2 billion asset limit based on its belief that an asset limit is important to preclude a very large creditor with relatively modest mortgage operations from taking advantage of provisions designed for much smaller creditors with much different characteristics and incentives and that lack the scale to make compliance less burdensome. The Bureau believes institutions that fall under the $2 billion asset limit are more likely to be engaged in relationship-based community lending than larger institutions, with such small entities having a more in-depth understanding of the economic and other circumstances of their customers and community. The Bureau believes that allowing entities of up to $10 billion in size to take advantage of the exemptions

and special provisions accorded to small creditors is inconsistent with the purposes of the special provisions and exemptions.

The Bureau did not propose to exclude from the asset limit loans originated by a creditor or its affiliates and held in portfolio, or loans held in portfolio by a wholly-owned subsidiary of either. Given the final rule's exclusion of portfolio loans from the origination limit, also excluding portfolio loans from the asset limit could potentially allow a large creditor with significantly more than $2 billion in assets due to the size of its loan portfolio, or the size of its affiliate's loan portfolio, to take advantage of the special provisions and exemptions designed for smaller creditors. Such a change would run counter to the Bureau's intent in establishing an asset limit and the Bureau's intent to limit the ability of creditors who become large creditors through the development of affiliate relationships to circumvent consumer protections by obtaining small creditor status.

Add grace period for transactions with applications received before April 1st of current calendar year:
The Bureau is finalizing as proposed the addition of a grace period for the determination of the asset limit. It allows a creditor that exceeded the asset limit in the preceding calendar year, but that did not exceed it in the year before the preceding calendar year, to operate as a small creditor with respect to transactions with applications received before April 1 of the current calendar year. The Bureau has considered comments suggesting a longer grace period but, as with the grace period for the origination limit, believes the grace period for the asset limit as proposed should provide the time for creditors to make any needed adjustments to come into compliance with the Bureau's regulatory requirements upon exceeding the asset limit in the previous year.

35(b)(2)(iii)(D)

As discussed in detail below, the Bureau is adopting § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(D) substantially as proposed, with a minor change to enhance clarity. Accordingly, this final rule substitutes January 1, 2016 for January 1, 2014 where it appears in § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(D)(
1
) and its commentary. This change prevents creditors from losing eligibility for the escrow exemption because of escrow accounts they established pursuant to requirements in effect before the effective date of this rule.

The Bureau's Proposal

In general, § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(D) prohibits any creditor from availing itself of the exemption from escrow requirements in § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii) if the creditor maintains escrow accounts for any extension of consumer credit secured by real property or a dwelling that it or its affiliate currently services. However, § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(D) currently also provides that a creditor may qualify for the exemption if such escrow accounts were established for first-lien higher-priced mortgage loans on or after April 1, 2010, and before January 1, 2014 or were established after consummation as an accommodation for distressed consumers.
23

In light of the proposed expansion of the “small” and “rural” definitions in §§ 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(B) and 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(A), the Bureau proposed to substitute January 1, 2016 for January 1, 2014 where it appears in § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(D)(
1
) and comment 35(b)(2)(iii)(D)(
1
)-1. This change was proposed to prevent any creditors that are currently ineligible for the escrow exemption, but that would qualify if the proposed definitional changes were adopted, from losing eligibility for the escrow exemption because of escrow accounts they established for first-lien higher-priced mortgage loans pursuant to requirements in the current rule.

23
Comment 35(b)(2)(iii)(D)(
1
)-1 clarifies that the date ranges provided in § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(D)(
1
) apply to transactions for which creditors received applications on or after April 1, 2010, and before January 1, 2014.

The Bureau solicited comment on the Bureau's proposed amendments to § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(D)(
1
) and comment 35(b)(2)(iii)(D)(
1
)-1, and specifically the exclusion of escrow accounts established on or after April 1, 2010 and before January 1, 2016 from the limitation in § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(D). In particular, the Bureau sought comment on the need for the proposed changes and the impact on consumers of extending the exemption to the escrow requirements in § 1026.35(b)(1).

The Bureau is finalizing § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(D)(
1
) and comment 35(b)(2)(iii)(D)(
1
)-1 generally as proposed but with a minor change to conform the regulatory and commentary language.

Comments

The commenters on this subject, including a national association of credit unions and state associations of banks and credit unions, supported the provision to disregard escrow accounts that were maintained during a period a creditor was not exempt from the escrow requirement.

Final Rule

The Bureau has considered the comments received on this provision and is finalizing § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(D)(
1
) and comment 35(b)(2)(iii)(D)(
1
)-1 generally as proposed but with a minor change to include in the regulation the same language currently in the comment stating that the exemption applies to loans “for which the application was received” on or after April 1, 2010, and before January 1, 2016.

The Bureau does not believe that creditors that maintain escrow accounts they were required to set up before the effective date of this rule should lose the exemption simply because they were required by applicable regulations to establish escrow accounts before January 1, 2016. As the Bureau discussed in the Supplementary Information to the January 2013 Escrows Final Rule and again in finalizing amendments to the January 2013 Escrows Final Rule made in the September 2013 Final Rule, the Bureau believes creditors should not be penalized for compliance with the current regulation.
24

This final rule makes creditors eligible for the exemption provided under § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii) if they otherwise meet the requirements of § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii) and they do not establish new escrow accounts for transactions for which they receive applications on or after January 1, 2016, other than those described in § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(D)(
2
).

24
January 2013 Escrows Final Rule, 78 FR 4725, 4739 (Jan. 22, 2013);
see also
September 2013 Final Rule, 78 FR 60382, 60416 (Oct. 01, 2013).

A small number of commenters recommended additional exemption provisions, including exempting from the escrow requirement all loans held in portfolio if the APR does not exceed APOR by 3.5 percentage points or more. The Bureau notes, however, that the proposal did not address additional exemptions and thus such exemptions are outside the scope of this rulemaking.

35(b)(2)(iv)(A)

As discussed in detail below, the Bureau is adopting § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(A) substantially as proposed, amending the current definition of “rural,” with certain minor changes to enhance clarity. Accordingly, this final rule adds census blocks that are not in an urban area as defined by the U.S. Census Bureau to the current county-based definition in

§ 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(A) and broadens the definition of rural to apply to “an area” rather than “a county.”

The Bureau's Proposal

Section 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(A) currently defines a county as “rural” during a calendar year if it is neither in a metropolitan statistical area (MSA) nor in a micropolitan statistical area that is adjacent to an MSA, as those terms are defined by the U.S. Office of Management and Budget and as they are applied under currently applicable UICs, established by the USDA-ERS. The current rule further provides that a creditor may rely as a safe harbor on the list of counties published by the Bureau to determine whether a county qualifies as “rural” for a particular calendar year. The Bureau proposed to expand the “rural” definition in § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(A) to capture additional areas classified as “rural” by the Census Bureau, without affecting the status of any counties that would be deemed rural under the current rule. For technical reasons, the Bureau also proposed to move the discussion of the safe harbor list of counties provided by the Bureau that is currently in § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(A) and comment 35(b)(2)(iv)(A)-1 to new § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(C) and proposed comment 35(b)(2)(iv)(A)-1.iii, which are discussed below.
25

25
This proposed move was consistent with a similar move that the Bureau proposed with respect to the safe harbor discussion that currently appears with the “underserved” definition in § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(B).

The proposal added to the definition of “rural” those census blocks that are not designated as “urban” by the Census Bureau in the urban-rural classification it completes after each decennial census to the county-based definition in § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(A). To implement this change, proposed § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(A) provided that an area is rural during a calendar year if it is (1) a county that meets the Bureau's current rural definition, or (2) a census block that is not in an urban area, as defined by the Census Bureau using the latest decennial census of the United States.

The Bureau also proposed revisions to comment 35(b)(2)(iv)-1 that: (1) Conform to the changes made to § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv); (2) add a cross-reference to comment 35(b)(2)(iii)-1; and (3) make technical changes for clarity. The Bureau further proposed to update the example provided in comment 35(b)(2)(iv)-2.i to reflect the Bureau's proposal to add rural census blocks to the definition of rural area. Proposed comment 35(b)(2)(iv)-2.i explains that an area is considered “rural” for a given calendar year based on the most recent available UIC designations by the USDA-ERS and the most recent available delineations of urban areas by the Census Bureau that are available at the beginning of the calendar year. As the proposed comment noted, these designations and delineations are updated by the USDA-ERS and the Census Bureau respectively once every ten years. The comment provides an illustrative example.

The Bureau solicited comment on whether it should add a second prong to the rural definition based on the Census Bureau's urban-rural classification and, if so, whether it should make any modifications to the Census Bureau's classification in doing so. Although the Bureau proposed to maintain the current county-based test as part of the new definition, the Bureau also solicited comment on whether the counties included in the current definition should be expanded, contracted, eliminated, or maintained as is. The Bureau also requested feedback on any alternative approaches to defining “rural” areas in § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(A) that commenters believe might be preferable to the Bureau's proposal.

For the reasons discussed below, the Bureau is adopting § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(A) and the accompanying commentary as proposed, with minor technical revisions.

Comments

Creditor commenters, including national and state associations of banks and credit unions and individual banks and credit unions, as well as non-creditor commenters, including national associations of home builders, realtors, and banking supervisors, generally supported the expanded definition of “rural.” For example, a national banking association stated that the Census Bureau's urban-rural classification appeared to be the most suitable for the purposes and objectives of the regulations, and a regional association of credit unions referred to the proposed definition as a “common sense approach” that it urged the Bureau to adopt. Some of the commenters supporting the proposed change also noted the need to have an effective automated tool for determining whether a covered transaction is made in an area that is rural because of the difficulties inherent in considering millions of census blocks. These concerns are addressed below in the discussion of the Bureau's automated tool.

Other commenters, generally consumer groups, noted that the current definition has not been in place long enough for the Bureau to discern its effects and questioned whether data supported the proposed changes. These commenters recommended caution before adopting any changes because consumers may be harmed by a broader definition. They also recommended narrowly tailoring any changes to the definition to prevent non-rural lenders from taking advantage of the special provisions and exemptions. These commenters and a few others also argued that high-cost mortgages should not be eligible for qualified mortgage status under any circumstances.

A few commenters also recommended alternative definitions. A state association of banks and a state association of credit unions recommended only excluding “urbanized areas” of 50,000 or more from the definition of rural. A national organization representing banking supervisors and one representing real estate brokers and agents both recommended the Bureau establish an application process under which a person who lives or does business in a state may apply to have an area designated as a rural area. A national nonprofit organization that supports affordable housing efforts in rural areas noted that a reliance on Census Bureau classifications for rural areas may allow rural area determinations for lending activity that is actually suburban in nature, which may have the unintended consequence of diverting credit away from truly rural communities and consumers. This commenter recommended using a sub-county designation of rural and small-town areas which incorporates measures of housing density and commuting at the Census tract level.

Final Rule

The Bureau is finalizing § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(A) generally as proposed with minor changes in the associated commentary to provide greater clarity and consistency with other changes made in this final rule.
26

In developing the proposal, the Bureau

considered a variety of possible approaches that could be used to identify areas that are smaller than counties and that may be rural in nature, and the Bureau considered the alternative definitions commenters recommended. Of these, the Bureau believes that the urban-rural classification completed by the Census Bureau every ten years is the most suitable for the Bureau's current purposes. This classification is done at the level of the census block, which is the smallest geographic area for which the Census Bureau collects and tabulates decennial census data. While there are only about 3,000 counties in the United States, there are approximately 11 million census blocks.
27

The Census Bureau delineates census blocks as “urban” or “rural” based on each decennial census and most recently released its list of urban areas based on the 2010 Census in 2012. For the 2010 Census, an urban area consists of “a densely settled core of census tracts and/or census blocks that meet minimum population density requirements, along with adjacent territory containing non-residential urban land uses as well as territory with low population density included to link outlying densely settled territory with the densely settled core.”
28

The Census Bureau identifies two types of urban areas: “urbanized areas” of 50,000 or more people, and “urban clusters” of at least 2,500 and less than 50,000 people. Under the Census Bureau's classification, “rural” encompasses all population, housing, and territory not included within either type of urban area.

26
The addition of a census block prong in § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(A)'s “rural” definition does not affect the scope of the exemption from a requirement to obtain a second appraisal for certain higher-priced mortgage loans adopted by the January 2013 Interagency Appraisals Final Rule, as that exemption applies to credit transactions made by a creditor in a “rural county” as defined in § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(A). This definition of “rural county” is retained in § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(A) as § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(A)(
1
) and the reference to comment 35(b)(2)(iv)-1 in comment 35(c)(4)(vii)(H) is retained in comment 35(b)(2)(iv)-1.iii.A.

27
Census Bureau,
2010 Census Tallies of Census Tracts, Block Groups & Blocks,

https://www.census.gov/geo/maps-data/data/tallies/tractblock.html
.

28
Census Bureau,
2010 Census Urban and Rural Classification and Urban Area Criteria,

https://www.census.gov/geo/reference/ua/urban-rural-2010.html
. To qualify as an urban area, the territory identified must encompass at least 2,500 people, of which at least 1,500 must reside outside institutional group quarters such as correctional facilities, group homes for juveniles, and mental (psychiatric) hospitals.

The definition of “rural” in this final rule maintains the bright-line, easy-to-apply county-based test from the current definition, while also bringing into the definition rural pockets within counties that are non-rural under the current rule.
29

Because the Census Bureau's classification is done at the census block level, it provides much more granularity than any county-based metric. To prepare the rural-urban classification, the Census Bureau uses measures based primarily on population counts and residential population density, but also considers a variety of criteria that account for nonresidential urban land uses, such as commercial, industrial, transportation, and open space that are part of the urban landscape.
30

Since the 1950 Census, the Census Bureau has reviewed and revised these criteria as necessary for each decennial census. The Census Bureau completes its rural-urban classification every ten years based on the results of the decennial census, on roughly the same schedule that the USDA-ERS uses in updating its UIC designations, which should provide a relatively stable but up-to-date measure.

29
For example, Culpeper County, Virginia is part of the Washington-Arlington-Alexandria, DC-VA-MD-WV MSA and does not currently qualify as “rural” under existing § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(A). Because the Census Bureau defined some census blocks within Culpeper County as rural in its most recent rural-urban classification, under this final rule, those portions of the county qualify as rural under § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(A) until the next Census Bureau rural-urban classification.

30

See Qualifying Urban Areas for the 2010 Census,
77 FR 18652 (March 27, 2012);
Urban Area Criteria for the 2010 Census,
76 FR 53030 (Aug. 24, 2011);
Proposed Urban Area Criteria for the 2010 Census,
75 FR 52174 (Aug. 24, 2010).

The Bureau believes that use of the Census Bureau's classifications provides consistency, certainty, stability, and objectivity to the “rural” definition. The Census Bureau's classifications generally change only every ten years and, once established, provide a bright-line test that is not subject to discretionary judgments and manipulation, which could result under some commenters' more complex classification procedures, including those to establish an application process to have an area designated as a rural area. Used in conjunction with automated address search tools, as discussed more fully below, the Census Bureau's classifications allow the use of an easy-to-apply test, as originally provided under the county-based definition, to continue, thereby avoiding regulatory and administrative complexity.

35(b)(2)(iv)(B)

As discussed below, the Bureau is adopting § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(B) and (C) and comments 35(b)(2)(iv)-1, 35(b)(2)(iv)-1.iii, and 35(b)(2)(iv)-2.ii substantially as proposed, with certain minor changes to enhance clarity. Accordingly, this final rule makes minor technical and conforming changes to the definition of “underserved” and the regulation text and commentary discussed below.

The Bureau's Proposal

Section 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(B) defines a county as “underserved” during a calendar year if, according to Home Mortgage Disclosure Act (HMDA) data for the preceding calendar year, no more than two creditors extended covered transactions, as defined in § 1026.43(b)(1), secured by a first lien, five or more times in the county. It further provides that a creditor may rely as a safe harbor on the list of rural or underserved counties published by the Bureau to determine whether a county qualifies as “underserved” for a particular calendar year.
31

31
The rural and rural or underserved safe harbor lists are published on the Bureau's Web site on the regulatory guidance page at
http://www.consumerfinance.gov/guidance/
.

For technical reasons, the Bureau proposed to move the discussion of the safe harbor county lists provided by the Bureau from § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(B) and comment 35(b)(2)(iv)-1 to § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(C) and comment 35(b)(2)(iv)-1.iii.A.
32

The Bureau also proposed other technical changes to § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(B) and comments 35(b)(2)(iv)-1 and 35(b)(2)(iv)-2.ii and proposed to add a reference in comment 35(b)(2)(iv)-2.ii to the new grace period under § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(A). The Bureau did not propose a substantive change to the definition of underserved.

32
This proposed move is consistent with a similar move that the Bureau proposed with respect to the safe harbor discussion that currently appears with the “rural” definition in § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(A).

Comments

The Bureau did not receive comments regarding the proposed technical and conforming changes to § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(B), § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(C), comments 35(b)(2)(iv)-1, 35(b)(2)(iv)-2.ii, and 35(b)(2)(iv)-1.iii.A. Although the Bureau did not solicit comment regarding the definition of “underserved,” the Bureau received four comments suggesting the Bureau consider an alternative definition of “underserved.” These commenters suggested that the Bureau's definition of “underserved” is under-inclusive. These commenters recommended that the Bureau consider expanding or changing the meaning of “underserved” to include the consideration of socio-economic factors to determine underserved status. Specifically, they recommended that underserved areas include low- and moderate-income communities with limited credit options.

Final Rule

For the reasons discussed below the Bureau is not substantively changing the definition of “underserved” in this final rule. The Bureau is adopting substantially as proposed the technical and conforming changes to § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(B) and comments 35(b)(2)(iv)-1 and 35(b)(2)(iv)-2.ii. In addition, the Bureau is adopting substantially as proposed § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(C) and comment 35(b)(2)(iv)-1.iii.A.

As stated in the preamble to the proposed rule the current definition of “underserved” appropriately identifies areas where the withdrawal of a creditor from the market could leave no meaningful competition within that market. The designation of an area as “underserved” under the Bureau's rules is intended to identify communities that have few creditors and, thus, may be subject to access to credit issues. The Bureau's definition focuses on whether there is access to credit by looking at the number of creditors competing for mortgage business in an area. The economic-and demographic-based definitions suggested by commenters would introduce factors unrelated to competition for consumers' mortgage business.

The changes to the “rural” definition discussed above expand the term “rural or underserved” for purposes of the exemption to the escrow requirement for higher-priced mortgage loans in § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii), the allowance for balloon-payment qualified mortgages in § 1026.43(f), and the exemption from the balloon-payment prohibition on high-cost mortgages in § 1026.32(d)(1)(ii)(C). Because these provisions reference “underserved” only in the alternative with “rural” (“rural or underserved”), the Bureau believes that the expansion of the “rural” definition in this final rule addresses concerns that have been raised by commenters about the overall coverage of “rural or underserved.”
33

33
As discussed in the section 1022(b) analysis in Part VII below, the Bureau estimates that the number of rural small creditors will increase from approximately 2,400 to approximately 4,100.

The Bureau also notes that it did not propose or seek comment on substantive revisions to the definition of “underserved,” and that such changes to that definition are outside the scope of this rulemaking.

The Bureau notes that comment 35(b)(2)(iv)-1.ii refers to several current HMDA provisions. The Bureau's HMDA rulemaking proposed to modify the referenced provisions.
34

The Bureau expects to issue a notice in the future making conforming changes to comment 35(b)(2)(iv)-1.ii, should such change be necessary after issuance of the HMDA final rule.

34
79 FR 51732 (Aug. 29, 2014).

35(b)(2)(iv)(C)

As discussed in detail below, the Bureau is adopting the revisions related to the safe harbors § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(A) and (B) and § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(C)(
1
), (
2
) and (
3
) and comment 35(b)(2)(iv)-1, 35(b)(2)(iv)-1.iii.A, .B, and .C substantially as proposed, with certain minor changes to enhance clarity. Accordingly, this final rule adds two new safe harbor tools and makes minor conforming changes to the regulation text and commentary discussed below.

The Bureau's Proposal

Section 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(A) and (B) and comment 35(b)(2)(iv)-1 currently provide that a creditor may rely as a safe harbor on the list of counties published by the Bureau to determine whether a county qualifies as “rural” or “underserved” for a particular calendar year.
35

As noted above, the Bureau proposed to move the discussion of these county lists to § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(C)(
1
) and comment 35(b)(2)(iv)-1.iii.A. To facilitate compliance under the expanded definition of “rural,” the Bureau also proposed to add two additional safe harbors in proposed §§ 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(C)(
2
) and (
3
), for an automated address search tool on the Census Bureau's Web site and an automated tool that may be provided on the Bureau's Web site.

35
A historical record of each year's lists is available at:
http://www.consumerfinance.gov/guidance/#ruralunderserved
.

The Bureau proposed technical changes to the safe harbor provision relating to its county lists and also proposed to publish its county lists in the
Federal Register
. Proposed comment 35(b)(2)(iv)-1.iii.A also stated that, to the extent that U.S. territories are treated by the Census Bureau as counties and are neither MSAs nor micropolitan statistical areas adjacent to MSAs, such territories will be included on these lists as rural areas in their entireties.

Because the proposed changes to § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv) created the possibility that some counties would include both rural and non-rural areas, the Bureau also adjusted the discussion of the county lists in proposed comment 35(b)(2)(iv)-1.iii.A. to § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(C)(
1
) to make it clear that the lists would not include counties that are partially rural and partially non-rural. The Bureau does not believe it would be practical to publish lists of the census blocks that would qualify as rural under proposed § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(A)(
2
) because there are approximately 11 million census blocks in the United States.

To assist creditors in implementing the proposed “rural” definition, the Bureau proposed to develop and maintain on its Web site a tool that allows creditors to enter property addresses, both individually and in batches, to determine whether a property is located in a “rural or underserved” area for the relevant calendar years. The Bureau stated in the preamble to the proposed rule that it did not anticipate that the Bureau's automated tool would be available before the proposed effective date of the final rule, but it proposed that such a tool could provide a safe harbor if and when it becomes available.

Specifically, proposed § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(C)(
2
) provided that a property shall be deemed to be in an area that is “rural or underserved” in a particular calendar year if the property is designated as rural or underserved for that calendar year by any automated tool that the Bureau provides on its Web site.

In the preamble to the proposed rule, the Bureau noted that, until any automated tool that the Bureau may develop becomes available, the Bureau anticipated that creditors would use resources provided by the Census Bureau to determine whether proposed § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(A)(
2
), the new second prong of the proposed rural definition, is satisfied. The Bureau noted that the Census Bureau publishes maps, lists, and other reference materials on its Web site.
36

The Bureau also discussed how the Census Bureau currently provides on its Web site an automated address search tool that allows users to enter a property address to obtain census information about the property, including a designation that the property is in an urban area if that is the case.
37

The Bureau proposed that this automated tool or any similar automated address search tool provided

by the Census Bureau could be relied on as a safe harbor. Specifically, proposed § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(C)(
3
) provided a safe harbor for a property not designated as located in an urban area as defined by the most recent delineation of urban areas announced by the Census Bureau through any automated address search tool that the Census Bureau provides on its public Web site for that purpose. Proposed comments 35(b)(2)(iv)-1.iii.B and .C discussed the safe harbors related to these online tools. Proposed comment 35(b)(2)(iv)-1.iii.C clarified the calendar years for which the Census Bureau's automated address search tool can be used by noting that, for any calendar year that begins after the date on which the Census Bureau announced its most recent delineation of urban areas, a property is deemed to be in a “rural” area if the search results provided for the property by any such tool available on the Census Bureau's public Web site do not designate the property as being in an urban area. This is consistent with proposed comment 35(b)(2)(iv)-2.i, which explains that an area is considered “rural” for a given calendar year based on the most recent available UIC designations by the USDA-ERS and the most recent available delineations of urban areas by the Census Bureau that are available at the beginning of the calendar year.

36
Census Bureau,
2010 Census Urban and Rural Classification and Urban Area Criteria, available at https://www.census.gov/geo/reference/ua/urban-rural-2010.html
.

37

See generally
Census Bureau,
Frequently Asked Questions: How can I determine if my address is urban or rural?, available at https://ask.census.gov/faq.php?id=5000&faqId=6405
(The 2010 Urban Areas can be viewed using Reference maps and the TIGERweb interactive web mapping system;
See also
Census Bureau, American FactFinder
available at http://factfinder.census.gov/faces/nav/jsf/pages/searchresults.xhtml?ref=addr&refresh=t
(providing a link to an address search function that allows users to find Census data by entering a street address)).

The Bureau solicited comment on whether Regulation Z should provide a safe harbor for automated tools of this nature. The Bureau also requested feedback relating to how it could make the automated tool it is considering developing most useful to industry and other stakeholders as they implement the rural and underserved definitions.

Comments

The Bureau did not receive comments regarding the publication of the county lists to the
Federal Register
; clarification regarding the determination of “rural or underserved” status of U.S. territories; or the changes to proposed comment 35(b)(2)(iv)-1.iii.A. to conform to the proposed changes to § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv). The comments received focused on the proposed safe harbor tools. Most comments were in support of the Bureau's proposed automated tool. Many commenters suggested the Bureau's proposed automated tool with a batch feature is necessary for compliance if the Bureau finalizes the definition of “rural” as proposed because small creditors do not have the capacity (or they need more time) to develop tools to integrate the new census block typology. One state banking association commenter suggested that the Bureau delay the effective date of the rule until the Bureau's proposed automated tool is available because identifying “rural” areas under the proposed definition of “rural” would be difficult for small institutions and presents a compliance risk that these institutions may not be willing to take. A national banking association and several state banking associations recommended an extension of the two year transition period, under § 1026.43(e)(6), allowing small creditors to issue balloon-payment qualified mortgages and high-cost mortgages regardless of whether they operate predominantly in rural or underserved areas, until banks can access the Bureau's automated tool. These commenters asserted that if the transition period is not extended until an automated tool is available, many small institutions would be incapable of ensuring compliance and may curtail or eliminate consumer mortgage financing.

The Bureau also received several comments about the current usability of the Census Bureau's automated address search tool. These commenters stated that the Census Bureau's automated address search tool is not efficient for business use. One commenter criticized the accuracy and usability of the Census Bureau's automated address search tool but did not provide examples of inaccuracies. The commenter suggested that the Bureau use housing density and commuter information on a census tract level to define rural areas because a scheme based on the census tract level is more accurate. The commenter believed the Bureau's proposed automated tool would only add to the complexity of the proposed census block scheme used to determine “rural” status.

The Bureau received one comment addressing the technical and conforming changes to the provisions discussing the safe harbors. The commenter was concerned about the change in language in § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(A) and (B) that states, “a creditor
may
rely as a safe harbor on * * *” to the conforming change in proposed § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(C) that states, “[a] property
shall
be deemed to be in an area that is “rural” or “underserved” in a particular calendar year . . . .” The commenter believed the Bureau's use of the word
shall
makes the use of the safe harbor tools mandatory.

Final Rule

The Bureau is adopting these provisions substantially as proposed, moving the discussion of the safe harbor lists in § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(A) and (B) and comment 35(b)(2)(iv)-1 to § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(C)(
1
) and comment 35(b)(2)(iv)-1.iii.A. The Bureau is revising § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(C)(
1
) and comment 35(b)(2)(iv)-1.iii.A to clarify that counties are rural or underserved under the Bureau's definitions although they may contain census blocks that are designated by the Census Bureau as urban. This revision provides greater clarity on the effect of the list of rural or underserved counties, which is that a property in a listed county is deemed to be in a rural area even if the property is located in a census block that the Census Bureau designates as urban. The Bureau is also finalizing as proposed the addition of the two new safe harbor tool provisions in § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(C)(
2
) and (
3
), and new comments 35(b)(2)(iv)-1.iii.B and .C, with minor changes to provide greater clarity.

The Bureau is clarifying new comment 35(b)(2)(iv)-1.iii.B and .C, to facilitate compliance. For both the Bureau's and the Census Bureau's automated tools, the comments state that a printout or electronic copy from an automated tool designating a particular property as being in a rural or underserved area may be used as “evidence of compliance” that a property is in a rural or underserved area for purposes of the Regulation Z record retention requirements in § 1026.25. The Bureau is also adding new comment 35(b)(2)(iv)-1.iii.D to clarify that a property is deemed to be in a rural or underserved area if that designation is provided by any one of the safe harbors, even if that designation is not provided by any of the other safe harbors, and regarding proof of compliance without the use of the enumerated safe harbor tools in § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(C)
(1)
through (
3
). New comment 35(b)(2)(iv)-1.iii.D states that the enumerated safe harbor tools are not the exclusive means by which a creditor can demonstrate that a property is in a “rural or underserved” area as defined in § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(A) and (B). The comment states however, that creditors are required to retain “evidence of compliance” in accordance with § 1026.25, including determinations of whether a property is in a rural or underserved area as defined in § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(A) and (B).

The Bureau considered the comment regarding the availability of the Bureau's proposed automated tool by the proposed effective date, the concern that small institutions could not benefit from the expanded definition of “rural” because they do not have the capacity to determine the rural status of a property under the new definition of “rural,” and the suggestion that small institutions would not be willing to risk

a compliance breach by trying to determine rural status without the Bureau's proposed automated tool. The Bureau also considered the comments recommending an extension of the two year transition period, under § 1026.43(e)(6), until creditors can access the Bureau's automated tool. The Bureau expects that its automated tool will be available by the effective date of this final rule, which should address the concerns of these commenters. Further, the Bureau intends to provide guidance to industry stakeholders through implementation materials on how to access and use the Bureau's automated tool. In addition, creditors may use the Census Bureau's automated tool, or other means
38

besides the designated safe harbor tools, to determine the “rural” status of a property as long as the creditor retains “evidence of compliance” in accordance with § 1026.25 of whether a property is in a rural or underserved area as defined in § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(A) and (B).
See
comment 35(b)(2)(iv)-1.iii.B, .C, and .D discussed above.

38
As discussed above, creditors may use Census Bureau maps, lists, and other reference materials to demonstrate compliance with § 1026.35(b)(d)(iv)(A), but alternative methods do not have the benefit of a safe harbor and a creditor must retain “evidence of compliance” in accordance with § 1025.25.

The Bureau also considered the commenters concerns about the Census Bureau's automated address search tool and their requests that the Bureau make available its automated tool before the effective date of this rule. As noted above, the Bureau expects its automated tool will be ready by the effective date of this rule, which should address the usability concerns about the Census Bureau's automated address search tool. Creditors are encouraged to use the Bureau's automated tool, which will have a user-friendly interface and a batch upload feature. One commenter questioned the use of the Census Bureau's automated address search tool and suggested the Bureau adopt a rural classification scheme based on the use of census tracts and factors such as housing density and commuting. The Bureau believes such a system would increase administrative burden and complexity and reduce the objectivity achieved by a definition of rural based on census blocks. Accordingly, the Bureau is not adopting such a classification scheme.

Finally, one commenter believed the use of the word “shall” in § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(C) makes the use of the safe harbor tools mandatory. Creditors are not required to use the safe harbor tools. “Shall” is used in § 1026.35(b)(2)(iv)(C) to convey that a creditor who uses one or both of the tools receives a conclusive presumption of compliance with the Bureau's definition of “rural or underserved.” Using the word
may
in this context would cause uncertainty with regard to the effect of the safe harbor tool's designation with respect to a particular property.

Section 1026.36 Prohibited Acts or Practices and Certain Requirements for Credit Secured by a Dwelling

36(a) Definitions

The commentary to § 1026.36(a) discusses the meaning of the term “loan originator.” The Bureau did not propose changes to this commentary. However, the Bureau discovered a technical error in comment 36(a)-1.i.A.
3
. This comment contains a reference to comment “36(a)z4.i.” The correct format for this reference is “36(a)-4.i.” Thus, the Bureau is adopting a technical amendment to comment 36(a)-1.i.A.
3
to revise the incorrect format. No substantive change is intended.

Section 1026.43 Minimum Standards for Transactions Secured by a Dwelling

43(e) Qualified Mortgages

43(e)(5) Qualified Mortgage Defined—Small Creditor Portfolio Loans

As discussed in detail below, the Bureau is adopting comments 43(e)(5)-4 and 43(e)(5)-8 substantially as proposed, with certain minor changes to enhance clarity. Accordingly, this final rule makes minor technical and conforming changes to this commentary to § 1026.43(e)(5) discussed below.

The Bureau's Proposal

Section 1026.43(e)(5) defines a category of qualified mortgages originated by certain small creditors that enjoy special treatment under the ability-to-repay rules. These mortgages must be originated by creditors that meet the origination limit and asset limit in § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(B) and (C), and the creditors must hold the loans in portfolio for at least three years after consummation, with certain exceptions. Such a small creditor portfolio loan can be a qualified mortgage even if the borrower's total debt-to-income ratio exceeds the 43 percent debt-to-income ratio limit that otherwise applies to general qualified mortgage loans under § 1026.43(e)(2). Qualified mortgages originated by small creditors are entitled to a safe harbor under the Bureau's ability-to-repay rule if the loan's APR does not exceed the applicable APOR by 3.5 or more percentage points—in contrast to the general qualified mortgage safe harbor which covers loans with APRs that do not exceed the applicable APOR by 1.5 or more percentage points.

The Bureau proposed several changes to the commentary to § 1026.43(e)(5) to conform to the Bureau's proposed changes to the origination limit and the asset limit in § 1026.35(b)(2)(iii)(B) and (C). Proposed comment 43(e)(5)-4 regarding c

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/fr%3A2015-24362. Public record. Not legal advice.
