# Integrated Mortgage Disclosures Under the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act (Regulation X) and the Truth In Lending Act(Regulation Z)

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/fr%3A2013-28210

## Record

- **Collection:** Federal Register
- **Document type:** Rule
- **Published:** December 31, 2013
- **Citation:** 78 FR 79730

## Text

BUREAU OF CONSUMER FINANCIAL PROTECTION
12 CFR Parts 1024 and 1026
[Docket No. CFPB-2012-0028]
RIN 3170-AA19
Integrated Mortgage Disclosures Under the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act (Regulation X) and the Truth In Lending Act(Regulation Z)

AGENCY:

Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection.

ACTION:

Final rule; official interpretation.

SUMMARY:

Sections 1098 and 1100A of the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act (Dodd-Frank Act) direct the Bureau to publish rules and forms that combine certain disclosures that consumers receive in connection with applying for and closing on a mortgage loan under the Truth in Lending Act and the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act. Consistent with this requirement, the Bureau is amending Regulation X (Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act) and Regulation Z (Truth in Lending) to establish new disclosure requirements and forms in Regulation Z for most closed-end consumer credit transactions secured by real property. In addition to combining the existing disclosure requirements and implementing new requirements imposed by the Dodd-Frank Act, the final rule provides extensive guidance regarding compliance with those requirements.

DATES:

The rule is effective August 1, 2015.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:

David Friend, Jane Gao, Eamonn K. Moran, Nora Rigby, Michael Scherzer, Priscilla Walton-Fein, Shiri Wolf, Counsels; Richard B. Horn, Senior Counsel & Special Advisor, Office of Regulations, Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, 1700 G Street NW., Washington, DC 20552 at (202) 435-7700.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

I. Summary of the Final Rule

A. Background

For more than 30 years, Federal law has required lenders to provide two different disclosure forms to consumers applying for a mortgage. The law also has generally required two different forms at or shortly before closing on the loan. Two different Federal agencies developed these forms separately, under two Federal statutes: the Truth in Lending Act (TILA) and the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act of 1974 (RESPA). The information on these forms is overlapping and the language is inconsistent. Not surprisingly, consumers often find the forms confusing. It is also not surprising that lenders and settlement agents find the forms burdensome to provide and explain.

The Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act (Dodd-Frank Act) directs the Bureau to integrate the mortgage loan disclosures under TILA and RESPA sections 4 and 5.
1

Section 1032(f) of the Dodd-Frank Act mandated that the Bureau propose for public comment rules and model disclosures that integrate the TILA and RESPA disclosures by July 21, 2012.
2

The Bureau satisfied this statutory mandate and issued a proposed rule and forms on July 9, 2012 (the TILA-RESPA Proposal or the proposal).
3

To accomplish this, the Bureau engaged in extensive consumer and industry research, analysis of public comment, and public outreach for more than a year. After issuing the proposal, the Bureau conducted a large-scale quantitative validation study of its integrated disclosures with 858 consumers, which concluded that the Bureau's integrated disclosures had on average statistically significant better performance than the current disclosures under TILA and RESPA. The Bureau is now finalizing a rule with new, integrated disclosures (the TILA-RESPA Final Rule or the final rule).
4

The final rule also provides a detailed explanation of how the forms should be filled out and used.

1
Dodd-Frank Act sections 1098 & 1100A, codified at 12 U.S.C. 2603(a) & 15 U.S.C. 1604(b), respectively.

2
12 U.S.C. 5532(f).

3

See
Press release, U.S. Bureau of Consumer Fin. Prot.,
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau proposes “Know Before You Owe” mortgage forms
(July 9, 2012), available at
http://www.consumerfinance.gov/pressreleases/consumer-financial-protection-bureau-proposes-know-before-you-owe-mortgage-forms/; see also
Blog post, U.S. Bureau of Consumer Fin. Prot.,
Know Before You Owe: Introducing our proposed mortgage disclosure forms
(July 9, 2012), available at
http://www.consumerfinance.gov/blog/know-before-you-owe-introducing-our-proposed-mortgage-disclosure-forms/
.

4
See part III below for a discussion of the Bureau's qualitative testing of prototypes of the forms with more than 100 consumers, lenders, mortgage brokers, and settlement agents before issuing the proposal and its quantitative testing of the forms with 858 consumers across the country. This part also describes the Bureau's outreach efforts, including the panel convened by the Bureau to examine ways to minimize the burden of the proposed rule on small businesses, as well as the Bureau's handling of the over 2,800 public comments the Bureau received during the public comment period that followed the issuance of the proposal and other information on the record.

The first new form (the Loan Estimate) is designed to provide disclosures that will be helpful to consumers in understanding the key features, costs, and risks of the mortgage for which they are applying. This form will be provided to consumers within three business days after they submit a loan application. The second form (the Closing Disclosure) is designed to provide disclosures that will be helpful to consumers in understanding all of the costs of the transaction. This form will be provided to consumers three business days before they close on the loan.

The forms use clear language and design to make it easier for consumers to locate key information, such as interest rate, monthly payments, and costs to close the loan. The forms also provide more information to help consumers decide whether they can afford the loan and to compare the cost of different loan offers, including the cost of the loans over time.

In developing the new Loan Estimate and Closing Disclosure forms, the Bureau has reconciled the differences between the existing forms and combined several other mandated disclosures, such as the appraisal notice under the Equal Credit Opportunity Act and the servicing application disclosure under RESPA. The Bureau also has responded to industry complaints of uncertainty about how to fill out the existing forms by providing detailed instructions on how to complete the new forms.
5

This should reduce the burden on lenders and others in preparing the forms in the future.

5
This guidance is provided in the regulations and the Official Interpretations, which are in Supplement I.

B. Scope of the Final Rule

The final rule applies to most closed-end consumer mortgages. It does not apply to home equity lines of credit, reverse mortgages, or mortgages secured by a mobile home or by a dwelling that is not attached to real property (in other words, land). The final rule also does not apply to loans made by a creditor who makes five or fewer mortgages in a year.
6

6
For additional discussion of the scope of the final rule, see part V below regarding § 1026.19, Coverage of Integrated Disclosure Requirements.

C. The Loan Estimate

The Loan Estimate form replaces two current Federal forms. It replaces the Good Faith Estimate designed by the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) under RESPA and

the “early” Truth in Lending disclosure designed by the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (the Board) under TILA.
7

The final rule and the Official Interpretations (on which creditors and other persons can rely) contain detailed instructions as to how each line on the Loan Estimate form should be completed.
8

There are sample forms for different types of loan products.
9

The Loan Estimate form also incorporates new disclosures required by Congress under the Dodd-Frank Act.
10

7
These disclosures are available at
http://www.hud.gov/offices/hsg/rmra/res/gfestimate.pdf
&
http://ecfr.gpoaccess.gov/graphics/pdfs/ec27se91.024.pdf
.

8
The requirements for the Loan Estimate are in § 1026.37. Additional discussion of this and other sections of the rule is provided in the relevant portion of part V below.

9
Appendix H to the final rule provides examples of how to fill out these forms for a variety of different loans, including loans with fixed or adjustable rates or features such as balloon payments and prepayment penalties.

10
For a discussion of these disclosures, see part V.B below.

Provision by mortgage broker.
Recognizing that consumers may work more closely with a mortgage broker, under the final rule and similar to the current rules, either a mortgage broker or creditor is required to provide the Loan Estimate form upon receipt of an application by a mortgage broker. However, even if the mortgage broker provides the Loan Estimate, the creditor remains responsible for complying with all requirements concerning provision of the form.
11

11
This provision is in § 1026.19(e)(1)(ii).

Timing.
The creditor or broker must give the form to the consumer no later than three business days after the consumer applies for a mortgage loan.
12

The final rule contains a definition of what constitutes an “application” for these purposes, which consists of the consumer's name, income, social security number to obtain a credit report, the property address, an estimate of the value of the property, and the mortgage loan amount sought.
13

12
This provision is in § 1026.19(e)(1)(iii).

13
The definition of “application” is in § 1026.2(a)(3).

Limitation on fees.
Consistent with current law, the creditor generally cannot charge consumers any fees until after the consumers have been given the Loan Estimate form and the consumers have communicated their intent to proceed with the transaction. There is an exception that allows creditors to charge fees to obtain consumers' credit reports.
14

14
This provision is in § 1026.19(e)(2)(i).

Disclaimer on early estimates.
Creditors and other persons may provide consumers with written estimates prior to application. The rule requires that any such written estimates contain a disclaimer to prevent confusion with the Loan Estimate form. This disclaimer is not required for advertisements.
15

15
This provision is in § 1026.19(e)(2)(ii).

D. The Closing Disclosure

The Closing Disclosure form replaces the current form used to close a loan, the HUD-1, which was designed by HUD under RESPA. It also replaces the revised Truth in Lending disclosure designed by the Board under TILA.
16

The rule and the Official Interpretations (on which creditors and other persons can rely) contain detailed instructions as to how each line on the Closing Disclosure form should be completed.
17

The Closing Disclosure form contains additional new disclosures required by the Dodd-Frank Act and a detailed accounting of the settlement transaction.

16
These disclosures are available at
http://www.hud.gov/offices/adm/hudclips/forms/files/1.pdf
&
http://ecfr.gpoaccess.gov/graphics/pdfs/ec27se91.024.pdf
.

17
The requirements for the Closing Disclosure are in § 1026.38(a)(3).

Timing.
The creditor must give consumers the Closing Disclosure form to consumers so that they receive it at least three business days before the consumer closes on the loan.
18

If the creditor makes certain significant changes between the time the Closing Disclosure form is given and the closing—specifically, if the creditor makes changes to the APR above
1/8
of a percent for most loans (and
1/4
of a percent for loans with irregular payments or periods), changes the loan product, or adds a prepayment penalty to the loan—the consumer must be provided a new form and an additional three-business-day waiting period after receipt of the new form. Less significant changes can be disclosed on a revised Closing Disclosure form provided to the consumer at or before closing, without delaying the closing.
19

This is a change from the proposal, which would have required that most changes cause an additional three-business-day waiting period before the consumer could close on the loan. The Bureau received extensive public comment raising concerns about this aspect of the proposal, especially about its impact to cause frequent closing delays in the residential real estate market. In response to the public comments received on this issue, the Bureau decided to limit the types of changes that will result in an additional three-business-day waiting period to the three changes described above. This requirement will provide the important protection to consumers of an additional three-day waiting period for these significant changes, but will not cause closing delays for less significant costs that may frequently change.

18
This provision is in § 1026.19(f)(1)(ii).

19
This provision is in § 1026.19(f)(2).

Provision of disclosures.
Currently, settlement agents are required to provide the HUD-1 under RESPA, while creditors are required to provide the revised Truth in Lending disclosure under TILA. Under the final rule, the creditor is responsible for delivering the Closing Disclosure form to the consumer, but creditors may use settlement agents to provide the Closing Disclosure, provided that they comply with the final rule's requirements for the Closing Disclosure.
20

The final rule acknowledges settlement agents' longstanding involvement in the closing of real estate and mortgage loan transactions, as well as their preparation and delivery of the HUD-1. The final rule avoids creating uncertainty regarding the role of settlement agents and also leaves sufficient flexibility for creditors and settlement agents to arrive at the most efficient means of preparation and delivery of the Closing Disclosure to consumers.

20
This provision is in § 1026.19(f)(1).

E. Limits on Closing Cost Increases

Similar to existing law, the final rule restricts the circumstances in which consumers can be required to pay more for settlement services—the various services required to complete a loan, such as appraisals, inspections, etc.—than the amount stated on their Loan Estimate form. Unless an exception applies, charges for the following services cannot increase: (1) The creditor's or mortgage broker's charges for its own services; (2) charges for services provided by an affiliate of the creditor or mortgage broker; and (3) charges for services for which the creditor or mortgage broker does not permit the consumer to shop. Charges for other services can increase, but generally not by more than 10 percent, unless an exception applies.
21

21
The limitations and the exceptions discussed below are in § 1026.19(e)(3) and (4).

The exceptions include, for example, situations when: (1) The consumer asks for a change; (2) the consumer chooses a service provider that was not identified by the creditor; (3) information provided at application was inaccurate or becomes inaccurate; or (4) the Loan Estimate expires. When an exception applies, the creditor generally

must provide an updated Loan Estimate form within three business days.

F. Proposals Not Adopted in the Final Rule

The proposed rule would have redefined the way the Annual Percentage Rate or “APR” is calculated. Under the proposal, the APR would have encompassed almost all of the up-front costs of the loan.
22

The Bureau explained in the proposal that it believed the change would make it easier for consumers to use the APR to compare loans and easier for industry to calculate the APR. The proposed rule also would have required creditors to keep records of the Loan Estimate and Closing Disclosure forms provided to consumers in an electronic, machine readable format to make it easier for regulators to monitor compliance.
23

22
These proposed revisions are discussed below in part V, in the section-by-section analysis of § 1026.4.

23
This proposed provision is discussed below in part V, in the section-by-section analysis of § 1026.25.

Based on public comments it received raising implementation and cost concerns regarding these two proposals, the Bureau has determined not to finalize these provisions in the final rule. The Bureau continues to believe these ideas may have benefits for consumers and industry, however, and intends to continue following up on both issues. For example, the Bureau intends to work closely with industry on private data standard initiatives to promote consistency in data transmission and storage. After additional study, the Bureau may propose rules on either or both topics.

The Bureau also decided not to require in the final rule a disclosure item that had been mandated by the Dodd-Frank Act, but that caused confusion at its consumer testing. Specifically, the Dodd-Frank Act requires creditors to disclose, in the case of residential mortgage loans, “the approximate amount of the wholesale rate of funds in connection with the loan.”
24

To implement this requirement, the proposal would have required creditors to disclose the approximate cost of funds used to make a loan on the Closing Disclosure.
25

Because consumer testing conducted by the Bureau prior to its issuance of the proposal suggested that consumers do not understand the disclosure and that it would not provide a meaningful benefit to consumers, the Bureau alternatively proposed to exempt creditors from the cost of funds disclosure requirement.

24
15 U.S.C. 1638(a)(17).

25
This proposed provision is discussed below in part V, in the section-by-section analysis of § 1026.38(o)(6).

The Bureau considered the comments it received on this disclosure in addition to the consumer testing results. The comments echoed the Bureau's concerns regarding consumer confusion from this disclosure, and also raised implementation, compliance, and cost concerns. The Bureau has decided to exempt creditors from the cost of funds disclosure requirement. The Bureau believes this approach will simplify the disclosure forms, making them more effective for consumers, and reduce compliance burden.
26

26
However, the Bureau is finalizing the Dodd-Frank Act requirement to include the total interest percentage disclosure on both the Loan Estimate and Closing Disclosure, because consumers at the Bureau's consumer testing were able to understand and use the total interest percentage disclosure on both the Loan Estimate and Closing Disclosure. This proposed provision is discussed below in part V, in the section-by-section analyses of §§ 1026.37(l)(3) and 1026.38(o)(5).

G. Effective Date

The final rule is effective on August 1, 2015. The final rule applies to transactions for which the creditor or mortgage broker receives an application on or after that date, except that new § 1026.19(e)(2) and the amendments of this final rule to § 1026.28(a)(1) and the commentary to § 1026.29 become effective on that date, without respect to whether an application has been received on that date.
27

27
For additional discussion regarding the effective date of the final rule, see part VI below.

II. Background

A. The Mortgage Market

Overview of the Market and the Mortgage Crisis

The mortgage market is the single largest market for consumer financial products and services in the United States, with approximately $9.4 trillion in loans outstanding.
28

During the last decade, the market went through an unprecedented cycle of expansion and contraction that was fueled in part by the securitization of mortgages and creation of increasingly sophisticated derivative products designed to mitigate accompanying risks to investors. So many other parts of the American financial system were drawn into mortgage-related activities that when the bubble collapsed in 2008, it sparked the most severe recession in the United States since the Great Depression.
29

In the last quarter of 2008 and early in 2009, GDP was falling at an annual rate of roughly 6 percent.
30

By the Fall of 2009, unemployment reached a peak of 10 percent.
31

The percentage of loans in the foreclosure process reached its peak of 4.63 in both the first and the fourth quarters of 2010.
32

From peak to trough, the fall in housing prices is estimated to have resulted in about $7 trillion in household wealth losses.
33

Further, five years after the collapse of Lehman Brothers and AIG, the United States continues to grapple with the fallout.

28
Bd. of Governors of the Fed. Reserve Sys.,
Flow of Funds, Balance Sheets, and Integrated Macroeconomic Accounts
(June 2013).

29
See Thomas F. Siems,
Branding the Great Recession,
Fin. Insights, May 13, 2012, Vol. 1 Issue 1 at 3, available at
http://www.dallasfed.org/assets/documents/banking/firm/fi/fi1201.pdf
(stating that the [great recession] “was the longest and deepest economic contraction, as measured by the drop in real GDP, since the Great Depression.”).

30
Bureau of Econ. Analysis, U.S. Dep't of Commerce,
Real Gross Domestic Product
(Nov. 7, 2013), available at
http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/GDPC1.

31
Bureau of Labor Statistics, U.S. Dep't of Labor,
Labor Force Statistics from the Current Population Survey
(Nov. 19, 2013), available at
http://data.bls.gov/timeseries/LNS14000000
(Labor Force Statistics from 2003 through 2013).

32
Press Release, Mortg. Bankers Ass'n,
Short-term Delinquencies Fall to Pre-Recession Levels, Loans in Foreclosure Tie All-Time Record in Latest MBA National Delinquency Survey
(Feb. 17, 2011), available at
http://www.mortgagebankers.org/NewsandMedia/PressCenter/75706.htm
.

33
Bd. Of Governors of the Fed. Reserve Sys.,
The U.S. Housing Market: Current Conditions and Policy Considerations,
at 3 (2012), available at
http://www.federalreserve.gov/publications/other-reports/files/housing-white-paper-20120104.pdf
.

The expansion in this market was accompanied by particular economic conditions (including an era of low interest rates and rising housing prices) and changes within the industry. Interest rates dropped significantly—by more than 20 percent—from 2000 through 2003.
34

Housing prices increased dramatically—about 152 percent—between 1997 and 2006.
35

Driven by the decrease in interest rates and the increase in housing prices, the volume of refinancings increased rapidly, from about 2.5 million loans in 2000 to more than 15 million in 2003.
36

34

See
U.S. Dep't. of Hous. and Urban Dev.,
An Analysis of Mortgage Refinancing, 2001-2003
(2004), available at
www.huduser.org/Publications/pdf/MortgageRefinance03.pdf;
Souphala Chomsisengphet & Anthony Pennington-Cross,
The Evolution of the Subprime Mortgage Market,
88, No. 1 Fed. Res. Bank of St. Louis Review, at 48 (Jan./Feb. 2006), available at
http://research.stlouisfed.org/publications/review/article/5019.

35
The Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission,
The Financial Crisis Inquiry Report
at 156 (2011) (FCIC Report), available at
http://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/GPO-FCIC/pdf/GPO-FCIC.pdf
.

36

An Analysis of Mortgage Refinancing, 2001-2003,
at 1.

In the mid-2000s, the market experienced a steady deterioration of credit standards in mortgage lending, with evidence that loans were made solely against collateral, or even against expected increases in the value of

collateral, and without consideration of ability to repay. This deterioration of credit standards was particularly evidenced by the growth of “subprime” and “Alt-A” products.
37

Subprime products were sold primarily to consumers with poor or no credit history, although there is evidence that some consumers who would have qualified for “prime” loans were steered into subprime loans as well.
38

The Alt-A category of loans permitted consumers to take out mortgage loans while providing little or no documentation of income or other evidence of repayment ability. Because these loans involved additional risk, they were typically more expensive to consumers than “prime” mortgages, although many of them had very low introductory interest rates. In 2003, subprime and Alt-A origination volume was about $400 billion; in 2006, it had reached $830 billion.
39

37
FCIC Report at 88. These products included most notably
2/28
and
3/27
hybrid adjustable rate mortgages (ARMs) and option ARM products.
Id.
at 106. A hybrid ARM is an adjustable rate mortgage loan that has a low fixed introductory rate for a certain period of time. An option ARM is an adjustable rate mortgage loan that has a scheduled loan payment that may result in negative amortization for a certain period of time, but that expressly permits specified larger payments in the contract or servicing documents, such as an interest-only payment or a fully amortizing payment. For these loans, the scheduled negatively amortizing payment was typically described in marketing and servicing materials as the “optional payment.” These products were often marketed to subprime customers.

38
For example, the Federal Reserve Board on July 18, 2011, issued a consent cease and desist order and assessed an $85 million civil money penalty against Wells Fargo & Company of San Francisco, a registered bank holding company, and Wells Fargo Financial, Inc., of Des Moines. The order addresses allegations that Wells Fargo Financial employees steered potential prime-eligible consumers into more costly subprime loans and separately falsified income information in mortgage applications. In addition to the civil money penalty, the order requires that Wells Fargo compensate affected consumers.
See
Press Release, Bd. Of Governors of the Fed. Reserve Sys. (July 20, 2011), available at
http://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/press/enforcement/20110720a.htm
.

39
Inside Mortgage Fin.,
2011 Mortgage Statistical Annual: Mortgage Originations by Product,
at 20 (2011).

So long as housing prices were continuing to increase, it was relatively easy for consumers to refinance their existing loans into more affordable products to avoid interest rate resets and other adjustments. When housing prices began to decline in 2005, however, refinancing became more difficult and delinquency rates on subprime and Alt-A products increased dramatically.
40

More and more consumers, especially those with subprime and Alt-A loans, were unable or unwilling to make their mortgage payments. An early sign of the mortgage crisis was an upswing in early payment defaults—generally defined as borrowers being 60 or more days delinquent within the first year. Prior to 2006, 1.1 percent of mortgages would end up 60 or more days delinquent within the first two years.
41

Taking a more expansive definition of early payment default to include 60 days delinquent within the first two years, this figure was double the historic average during 2006, 2007 and 2008.
42

First payment defaults—mortgages taken out by consumers who never made a single payment—exceeded 1.5 percent of loans in early 2007.
43

In addition, as the economy worsened, the rates of serious delinquency (90 or more days past due or in foreclosure) for the subprime and Alt-A products began a steep increase from approximately 10 percent in 2006, to 20 percent in 2007, to more than 40 percent in 2010.
44

40
FCIC Report at 215-217.

41
CoreLogic's TrueStandings Servicing (reflects first-lien mortgage loans) (data service accessible only through paid subscription).

42

Id.

43

Id.

44

Id.
at 217.

The impact of this level of delinquencies was severe on creditors who held loans on their books and on private investors who purchased loans directly or through securitized vehicles. Prior to and during the bubble, the evolution of the securitization of mortgages attracted increasing involvement from financial institutions that were not directly involved in the extension of credit to consumers and from investors worldwide. Securitization of mortgages allows originating creditors to sell off their loans (and reinvest the funds earned in making new ones) to investors who want an income stream over time. Securitization had been pioneered by what are now called government-sponsored enterprises (GSEs), including the Federal National Mortgage Association (Fannie Mae) and the Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation (Freddie Mac). But by the early 2000s, large numbers of private financial institutions were deeply involved in creating increasingly complex mortgage-related investment vehicles through securities and derivative products. The private securitization-backed subprime and Alt-A mortgage market ground to a halt in 2007 in the face of the rising delinquencies on subprime and Alt-A products.
45

45

Id.
at 124.

While there remains debate about which market issues definitively sparked this crisis, there were several mortgage origination issues that pervaded the mortgage lending system prior to the crisis and are generally accepted as having contributed to its collapse. First, the market experienced a steady deterioration of credit standards in mortgage lending, particularly evidenced by the growth of subprime and Alt-A loans, which consumers were often unable or unwilling to repay.
46

46
FCIC Report at 88.

Second, the mortgage market saw a proliferation of more complex mortgage products with terms that were often difficult for consumers to understand. These products included most notably
2/28
and
3/27
Hybrid Adjustable Rate Mortgages and Option ARM products.
47

These products were often marketed to subprime and Alt-A customers. The appetite on the part of mortgage investors for such products often created inappropriate incentives for mortgage originators to originate these more expensive and profitable mortgage products.
48

47

Id.
at 106. “Hybrid Adjustable Rate Mortgage” is a term frequently used to describe adjustable rate mortgage loans that have a low fixed introductory rate for a certain period of time. “Option ARM” is a term frequently used to describe adjustable rate mortgage loans that have a scheduled loan payment that may result in negative amortization for a certain period of time, but that expressly permit specified larger payments in the contract or servicing documents, such as an interest-only payment or a fully amortizing payment. For these loans, the scheduled negatively amortizing payment was typically described in marketing and servicing materials as the “optional payment.”

48

Id.
at 109.

Third, responsibility for the regulation of consumer financial protection laws was spread across seven regulators including the Board, HUD, the Office of Thrift Supervision, the Federal Trade Commission, the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency, and the National Credit Union Administration. Such a spread in responsibility may have hampered the government's ability to coordinate regulatory monitoring and response to such issues.
49

49

Id.
at 111.

In the wake of this financial crisis, Congress passed the Dodd-Frank Act to address many of these concerns. In this Act, among other things, Congress created the Bureau and consolidated the rulemaking authority for many consumer financial protection statutes, including the two primary Federal consumer protection statutes governing mortgage origination, the Truth in Lending Act (TILA) and the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act (RESPA), in the Bureau.
50

Congress also provided

the Bureau with supervision authority for certain consumer financial protection statutes over certain entities, including insured depository institutions with total assets of over $10 billion and their affiliates, and certain other non-depository entities, including all companies that offer or provide origination, brokerage, or servicing of consumer mortgages.
51

50
Sections 1011 and 1021 of the Dodd-Frank Act, 12 U.S.C. 5491, 5511. The Consumer Financial

Protection Act is substantially codified at 12 U.S.C. 5481-5603.

51
Sections 1024 through 1026 of title X of the Dodd-Frank Act, codified at 12 U.S.C. 5514-5516.

At the same time, Congress significantly amended the statutory requirements governing mortgage practices with the intent to restrict the practices that contributed to the crisis. For example, in response to concerns that some lenders made loans to consumers without sufficiently determining their ability to repay, section 1411 of the Dodd-Frank Act amended TILA to require that creditors make a reasonable and good faith determination, based on verified and documented information, that the consumer will have a reasonable ability to repay the loan.
52

Sections 1032(f), 1098, and 1100A of the Dodd-Frank Act address concerns that Federal mortgage disclosures did not adequately explain to consumers the terms of their loans (particularly complex adjustable rate or optional payment loans) by requiring new disclosure forms designed to improve consumer understanding of mortgage transactions (which is the subject of this final rule).
53

In addition, the Dodd-Frank Act established other new standards concerning a wide range of mortgage lending practices, including compensation for mortgage originators
54

and mortgage servicing.
55

For additional information, see the discussion below in part II.F.

52
Section 1411 of the Dodd-Frank Act, codified at 15 U.S.C. 1639c.

53
Section 1032(f) of the Dodd-Frank Act, codified at 12 U.S.C. 5532(f). Sections 1098 and 1100A of the Dodd-Frank Act amend RESPA and TILA, respectively.

54
Sections 1402 through 1405 of the Dodd-Frank Act, codified at 15 U.S.C. 1639b.

55
Sections 1418, 1420, 1463, and 1464 of the Dodd-Frank Act, codified at 12 U.S.C. 2605; 15 U.S.C. 1638, 1638a, 1639f, & 1639g.

Size of the Current Mortgage Origination Market

Even with the economic downturn and tightening of credit standards, approximately $1.9 trillion in mortgage loans were originated in 2012.
56

In exchange for an extension of mortgage credit, consumers promise to make regular mortgage payments and provide their home or real property as collateral. The overwhelming majority of homebuyers continue to use mortgage loans to finance at least some of the purchase price of their property. In 2012, 93.7 percent of all home purchases were financed with a mortgage credit transaction.
57

56
Moody's Analytics,
Credit Forecast 2013
(2013) (Credit Forecast 2013), available at
http://www.economy.com/default.asp
(reflects first-lien mortgage loans) (data service accessibly only through paid subscription).

57
Mortgage Markets Daily,
New Houses by Type of Financing,
available at
http://www.mortgagenewsdaily.com/data/financing-type.aspx
.

Consumers may obtain mortgage credit to purchase a home, to refinance an existing mortgage, to access home equity, or to finance home improvement. Purchase loans and refinancings together produced 8.6 million new first-lien mortgage loan originations in 2012.
58

The proportion of loans that are for purchases as opposed to refinances varies with the interest rate environment and other market factors. In 2012, 72 percent of the market was refinance transactions and 28 percent was purchase loans, by volume.
59

Historically the distribution has been more even. In 2000, refinances accounted for 44 percent of the market while purchase loans comprised 56 percent; in 2005, the two products were split evenly.
60

58
Credit Forecast 2013.

59
Inside Mortgage Fin.,
Mortgage Originations by Product, in
Inside Mortgage Finance Issue 2013:08 (Mar. 1, 2013) (Inside Mortgage Finance Newsletter).

60
Inside Mortgage Fin.,
2012 Mortgage Statistical Annual: Mortgage Originations by Product: 2000-2013 Data,
at 17 (2012). These percentages are based on the dollar amount of the loans.

With a home equity transaction, a homeowner uses his or her equity as collateral to secure consumer credit. The credit proceeds can be used, for example, to pay for home improvements. Home equity credit transactions and home equity lines of credit resulted in an additional $41 billion in mortgage loan originations in 2012.
61

61
Inside Mortgage Fin. Newsletter.

Shopping for Mortgage Loans

When shopping for a mortgage loan, research has shown that consumers are most concerned about the interest rate and their monthly payment.
62

Consumers may underestimate the possibility that interest rates and payments can increase later on, or they may not fully understand that this possibility exists. They also may not appreciate other costs that could arise later, such as prepayment penalties.
63

This focus on short term costs while underestimating long term costs may result in consumers taking out mortgage loans that are more costly than they realize.
64

62
ICF Macro Int'l,
Summary of Findings: Design and Testing of Truth in Lending Disclosures for Closed-End Mortgages,
at 6 (July 2009) (Macro 2009 Closed-End Report), available at
http://www.federalreserve.gov/boarddocs/meetings/2009/20090723/Full%20Macro%20CE%20Report.pdf
.;
see also
Kleimann Communication Group, Inc.,
Know Before You Owe: Evolution of the Integrated TILA-RESPA Disclosures
(July 2012), available at
http://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201207_cfpb_report_tila-respa-testing.pdf
.

63
James Lacko & Janis Pappalardo,
Improving Consumer Mortgage Disclosures: An Empirical Assessment of Current and Prototype Disclosure Forms,
at 26 (2007) (finding borrowers had misunderstood key loan features, including the overall cost of the loan, future payment amount, ability to refinance, payment of up-front points and fees, whether the monthly payment included escrow for taxes and insurance, any balloon payment, whether the interest rate had been locked, whether the rate was adjustable or fixed, and any prepayment penalty), available at
http://www.ftc.gov/os/2007/06/P025505MortgageDisclosureReport.pdf
.

64
Oren Bar-Gill,
The Law, Economics and Psychology of Subprime Mortgage Contracts,
94 Cornell L. Rev. 1073, 1079 (2009) (discussing how subprime borrowers may not fully understand the loan costs due to product complexity and deferral of loan costs into the future);
id.
at 1133 (explaining that borrower underestimation of mortgage loan cost distorts their decision to take out a loan, resulting in excessive borrowing), available at
http://legalworkshop.org/wp-content/uploads/2009/07/cornell-a20090727-bar-gill.pdf
.

Research points to a relationship between consumer confusion about loan terms and conditions and an increased likelihood of adopting higher-cost, higher-risk mortgage loans in the years leading up to the mortgage crisis. A study of data from the 2001 Survey of Consumer Finances found that some adjustable rate mortgage loan borrowers, particularly those with below median income, underestimated or did not realize how much their interest rates could change.
65

These findings are consistent with a 2006 Government Accountability Office study, which raised concerns that mortgage loan disclosure laws did not require specific disclosures for adjustable rate loans.
66

This evidence suggests that borrowers who are not presented with clear, understandable information about their mortgage loan offer may lack an accurate understanding of the loan costs and risks.

65
Brian K. Bucks & Karen M. Pence,
Do Borrowers Know their Mortgage Terms?,
J. of Urb. Econ. (2008), available at
http://works.bepress.com/karen_pence/5
.

66
U.S. Gov't Accountability Office, GAO-06-1112T,
Alternative Mortgage Products: Impact on Default Remains Unclear, but Disclosure of Risks to Borrowers Could Be Improved
(2006), available at
http://www.gao.gov/new.items/d061112t.pdf
.

The Mortgage Origination Process

Borrowers must go through a mortgage origination process to take out

a mortgage loan. During this process, borrowers have two significant factors to consider: the costs that they pay to close the loan, and the costs over the life of the loan. For a given consumer seeking a mortgage of a given size, both factors can vary significantly, making the home purchase or refinance especially complex. Furthermore, for purchase transactions and to a much lesser extent for refinances, there are many actors involved in a mortgage origination. In addition to the lender and the borrower, a single transaction may involve a seller, mortgage broker, real estate agent, settlement agent, appraiser, multiple insurance providers, and local government clerks' and tax offices. These actors typically charge fees or commissions for the services they provide. Borrowers learn about the loan costs and the sources of those costs through a variety of sources, including disclosures provided throughout the mortgage origination process.

Loan Terms.
The loan terms affect how the loan is to be repaid, including the type of loan product,
67

the interest rate, the payment amount, and the length of the loan term. Among other things, the type of loan product determines whether the interest rate can change and, if so, when and by how much. A fixed rate loan sets the interest rate at origination, and the rate stays the same until the borrower pays off the loan. However, the interest rate on an adjustable rate loan is periodically reset based on an interest rate index. This shifting rate could change the borrower's monthly payment. Typically, an adjustable rate loan will combine both types of rates, so that the interest rate is fixed for a certain period of time before adjusting. For example, a 5/1 adjustable rate loan would have a fixed interest rate for five years, and then adjust every year until the loan ends. Any changes in the interest rate after the first five years would change the borrower's payments. Adjustable rate mortgages accounted for 30 percent of mortgage loan volume in 2000, and reached a recent high of 50 percent in 2004.
68

By contrast, adjustable rate mortgages accounted for only 10 percent of the mortgage loan market in 2012 ;
69

however, there is some early indication that adjustable rate mortgages are gaining market share again as interest rates for fixed rate mortgages are on the rise: the share of new mortgage applications for adjustable rate mortgages rose by 75% (from 4% to 7%) from March to August of 2013.
70

67
Types of loan products include a fixed rate loan, adjustable rate loan, and interest-only loan.

68
Inside Mortgage Fin.,
2012 Mortgage Statistical Annual: Mortgage Originations by Product: 2000-2013 Data,
at 17 (2012). These percentages are based on the dollar amount of the loans.

69
Inside Mortgage Finance Newsletter.

70

Compare
Press Release, Mortgage Bankers Assoc.,
Mortgage Applications Decrease in Latest Weekly MBA Survey
(Mar. 6, 2013), available at
http://www.mbaa.org/NewsandMedia/PressCenter/83653.htm

with
Mortgage Bankers Assoc.,
Mortgage Applications Decrease in Latest Weekly MBA Survey
(Aug. 28, 2013), available at
http://www.mbaa.org/NewsandMedia/PressCenter/85466.htm
.

Borrowers are usually required to make payments on a monthly basis. These payments typically are calculated to pay off the entire loan balance by the time the loan term ends.
71

The way a borrower's payments affect the amount of the loan balance over time is called amortization. Most borrowers take out fully amortizing loans, meaning that their payments are applied to both principal and interest so that the loan's principal balance will gradually decrease until it is completely paid off. The typical 30-year fixed rate loan has fully amortizing monthly payments that are calculated to pay off the loan in full over 30 years. However, loan amortization can take other forms. An interest only loan would require the borrower to make regular payments that cover interest but not principal. In some cases, these interest only payments end after a period of time (such as five years) and the borrower must begin making significantly higher payments that cover both interest and principal to amortize the loan over the remaining loan term. In other cases, the entire principal balance must be paid when the loan becomes due. Similarly, in a balloon loan, monthly payments are not fully amortizing, requiring the borrower to pay off a portion of the principal balance or the remaining principal balance in a larger “balloon payment” at specific points in the loan term or at the end of the loan term, respectively.

71
Some loans may require a large final payment (or “balloon” payment) in addition to monthly payments.

The time period that the borrower has to repay the loan is known as the loan term, and is specified in the mortgage contract. Many loans are set for a term of 30 years. Depending on the amortization type of the loan, it will either be paid in full or have a balance due at the end of the term.

Closing Costs.
Closing costs are the costs of completing a mortgage transaction, including origination fees, appraisal fees, title insurance, taxes, settlement services, and homeowner's insurance. The borrower may pay an application or origination fee. Lenders generally also require an appraisal as part of the origination process in order to determine the value of the home. The appraisal helps the lender determine whether the home is valuable enough to act as collateral for the mortgage loan. The borrower is generally responsible for the appraisal fee, which may be paid at or before closing. Finally, lenders typically require borrowers to take out various insurance policies. Insurance protects the lender's collateral interest in the property. Homeowner's insurance protects against the risk that the home is damaged or destroyed, while title insurance protects the lender against the risk of claims against the borrower's legal right to the property. In addition, the borrower may be required to take out mortgage insurance which protects the lender in the event of default.

Application.
In order to obtain a mortgage loan, borrowers must first apply through a loan originator that accepts applications for mortgage loans. There are two different kinds of such loan originators. A retail originator works directly for a mortgage lender. A mortgage lender that employs retail originators could be a bank or credit union, or it could be a specialized mortgage finance company. Some of these mortgage lenders may sell the loan soon after it is originated to an investor, and they are referred to as correspondent lenders. The other kind of loan originator is a mortgage broker. Mortgage brokers work with many different lenders and facilitate the transaction for the borrower.

A loan originator may help borrowers determine what kind of loan best suits their needs, and will collect their completed loan application. The application includes borrower credit and income information, along with information about the home to be purchased. A mortgage broker will pass this information on to a lender that will evaluate the borrower's credit risk using various factors, as described below. Consumers can apply to multiple lenders directly or through a mortgage broker in order to compare the loans that they are being offered. Once he or she has decided to move forward with the loan, the applicant notifies the loan originator or lender. An applicant can decide to pursue loans at multiple lenders at one time, but could incur fees in connection with each application. The loan originator will wait to receive notification from the consumer before taking more information from the borrower and giving the consumer's application to a loan underwriter.

Mortgage Application Processing.
A loan underwriter reviews the application and additional information provided by the borrower, and verifies certain information in connection with regulatory requirements. The

underwriter will assess whether the lender should take on the risk of making the mortgage loan. In order to make this decision, the underwriter considers whether the borrower can repay the loan, and whether the home is worth enough to act as collateral for the loan. If the underwriter finds that the borrower and the home qualify, the underwriter will approve the borrower's mortgage application.

Depending on the loan terms, including the loan amount, as discussed above, lenders may require borrowers to obtain title insurance, homeowner's insurance, private mortgage insurance, and other services. The borrower may shop for certain closing services on his or her own.

Closing.
After being accepted for a mortgage loan, completing any closing requirements, and receiving necessary disclosures, the borrower can close on the loan. Multiple parties may participate at closing, including the borrower, the settlement agent or a notary, and attorneys for the borrower, the seller, and the lender.

The settlement agent ensures that all the closing requirements are met, that all closing documents are completed in full, and that all fees are collected. The settlement agent makes sure that the borrower signs these closing documents, including a promissory note and the security instrument. This promissory note is evidence of the loan debt, and documents the borrower's promise to pay back the loan. It states the terms of the loan, including the interest rate and length. The security instrument, in the form of a mortgage, provides the home as collateral for the loan. A deed of trust is similar to a mortgage, except that a trustee is named to hold title to the property as security for the loan. The borrower receives title to the property after the loan is paid in full. Both a mortgage and deed of trust allow the lender to foreclose and sell the home if the borrower does not repay the loan.

In the case of a purchase loan, the funds to purchase the home and pay closing costs are distributed at closing or shortly thereafter. In the case of a refinance loan, the funds from the new loan are used to pay off the old loan and, in some cases, to pay some or all of the closing costs, with any additional amount going to the borrower or to pay off other debts. Refinance loans also have closing costs, which may be paid by the borrower at closing or, in some cases, rolled into the loan amount. In home equity loans, the borrower's funds and the closing costs are provided upon closing. A settlement agent makes sure that all amounts are given to the appropriate parties. After the closing, the settlement agent records the deed at the local government registry.

B. RESPA and Regulation X

Congress enacted the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act of 1974 based on findings that significant reforms in the real estate settlement process were needed to ensure that consumers are provided with greater and more timely information on the nature and costs of the residential real estate settlement process and are protected from unnecessarily high settlement charges caused by certain abusive practices that Congress found to have developed. 12 U.S.C. 2601(a). With respect to RESPA's disclosure requirements, the Act's purpose is to provide “more effective advance disclosure to home buyers and sellers of settlement costs.” 12 U.S.C. 2601(b)(1). In addition to providing consumers with appropriate disclosures, the purposes of RESPA include, but are not limited to, effecting certain changes in the settlement process for residential real estate that will result in (1) the elimination of kickbacks or referral fees that Congress found to increase unnecessarily the costs of certain settlement services; and (2) a reduction in the amounts home buyers are required to place in escrow accounts established to insure the payment of real estate taxes and insurance. 12 U.S.C. 2601(b). In 1990, Congress amended RESPA by adding a new section 6 covering persons responsible for servicing mortgage loans and amending statutory provisions related to mortgage servicers' administration of borrowers' escrow accounts.
72

72
Public Law 101-625, 104 Stat. 4079 (1990), sections 941-42.

RESPA's disclosure requirements generally apply to “settlement services” for “federally related mortgage loans.” Under the statute, the term “settlement services” includes any service provided in connection with a real estate settlement. 12 U.S.C. 2602(3)(a). The term “federally related mortgage loan” is broadly defined to encompass virtually any purchase money or refinance loan, with the exception of temporary financing, that is “secured by a first or subordinate lien on residential real property (including individual units of condominiums and cooperatives) designed principally for the occupancy of from one to four families . . .” 12 U.S.C. 2602(1).

Section 4 of RESPA requires that, in connection with a “mortgage loan transaction,” a disclosure form that includes a “real estate settlement cost statement” be prepared and made available to the borrower for inspection at or before settlement.
73

12 U.S.C. 2603. The law further requires that the form “conspicuously and clearly itemize all charges imposed upon the borrower and all charges imposed upon the seller in connection with the settlement. . . .” 12 U.S.C. 2603(a). Section 5 of RESPA provides for a booklet to help consumers applying for federally related mortgage loans to understand the nature and costs of real estate settlement services. 12 U.S.C. 2604(a). Further, each lender must “include with the booklet a good faith estimate of the amount or range of charges for specific settlement services the borrower is likely to incur in connection with the settlement . . .” 12 U.S.C. 2604(c). The booklet and the good faith estimate must be provided not later than three business days after the lender receives an application, unless the lender denies the application for credit before the end of the three-business day period. 12 U.S.C. 2604(d).

73
Prior to the Dodd-Frank Act, section 4 of RESPA applied to “all transactions in the United States which involve federally related mortgage loans.” 12 U.S.C. 2603 (2009). However, section 1098 of the Dodd-Frank Act deleted the reference to “federally related mortgage loan” in this section and replaced it with “mortgage loan transactions.” The regulation implementing this statutory requirement has historically applied and continues to apply to “federally related mortgage loans.”
See
12 CFR 1024.8; 24 CFR 3500.8 (2010).

Historically, HUD's Regulation X, 24 CFR part 3500, has implemented RESPA. On March 14, 2008, after a 10-year investigatory process, HUD proposed extensive revisions to the good faith estimate and settlement forms required under Regulation X, as well as new accuracy standards with respect to the estimates provided to consumers. 73 FR 14030 (Mar. 14, 2008) (HUD's 2008 RESPA Proposal).
74

In November 2008, HUD finalized the proposed revisions in substantially the same form, including new standard good faith estimate and settlement forms, which lenders, mortgage brokers, and settlement agents were required to use beginning on January 1, 2010. 73 FR 68204 (Nov. 17, 2008) (HUD's 2008 RESPA Final Rule). HUD's 2008 RESPA Final Rule implemented significant changes to the rules regarding the accuracy of the estimates provided to consumers. The final rule required redisclosure of the good faith estimate form when the actual costs increased beyond a certain percentage of the estimated amounts, and permitted such increases only under certain specified circumstances.

73 FR 68240 (amending 24 CFR 3500.7). HUD's 2008 RESPA Final Rule also included significant changes to the RESPA disclosure requirements, including prohibiting itemization of certain amounts and instead requiring the disclosure of aggregate settlement costs; adding loan terms, such as whether there is a prepayment penalty and the borrower's interest rate and monthly payment; and requiring use of a standard form for the good faith estimate.
Id.
The standard form was developed through consumer testing conducted by HUD, which included qualitative testing consisting of one-on-one cognitive interviews.
75

HUD issued informal guidance regarding the final rule on its Web site, in the form of frequently asked questions
76

(HUD RESPA FAQs) and bulletins
77

(HUD RESPA Roundups).

74
During this 10-year period, in 2002, HUD published a proposed rule revising the good faith estimate forms and accuracy standards for cost estimates, which it never finalized. 67 FR 49134 (July 29, 2002).

75
U.S. Dep't. of Hous. and Urban Dev.,
Summary Report: Consumer Testing of the Good Faith Estimate Form (GFE),
prepared by Kleimann Communication Group, Inc. (2008), available at
http://www.huduser.org/publications/pdf/Summary_Report_GFE.pdf
.

76

New RESPA Rule FAQs,
available at
http://portal.hud.gov/hudportal/documents/huddoc?id=resparulefaqs422010.pdf
.

77

RESPA Roundup Archive,
available at
http://portal.hud.gov/hudportal/HUD?src=/program_offices/housing/rmra/res/resroundup
.

The Dodd-Frank Act (discussed further in part I.D, below) transferred rulemaking authority for RESPA to the Bureau, effective July 21, 2011.
See
sections 1061 and 1098 of the Dodd-Frank Act. Pursuant to the Dodd-Frank Act and RESPA, as amended, the Bureau published for public comment an interim final rule establishing a new Regulation X, 12 CFR part 1024, implementing RESPA. 76 FR 78978 (Dec. 20, 2011). This rule did not impose any new substantive obligations but did make certain technical, conforming, and stylistic changes to reflect the transfer of authority and certain other changes made by the Dodd-Frank Act. The Bureau's Regulation X took effect on December 30, 2011. RESPA section 5's requirements of an information booklet and good faith estimate of settlement costs (RESPA GFE) are implemented in Regulation X by §§ 1024.6 and 1024.7, respectively. RESPA section 4's requirement of a real estate settlement statement (RESPA settlement statement) is implemented by § 1024.8.

C. TILA and Regulation Z

Congress enacted the Truth in Lending Act based on findings that the informed use of credit resulting from consumers' awareness of the cost of credit would enhance economic stability and would strengthen competition among consumer credit providers. 15 U.S.C. 1601(a). One of the purposes of TILA is to provide meaningful disclosure of credit terms to enable consumers to compare credit terms available in the marketplace more readily and avoid the uninformed use of credit.
Id.
TILA's disclosures differ depending on whether credit is an open-end (revolving) plan or a closed-end (installment) loan. TILA also contains procedural and substantive protections for consumers.

TILA's disclosure requirements apply to a “consumer credit transaction” extended by a “creditor.” Under the statute, consumer credit means “the right granted by a creditor to a debtor to defer payment of debt or to incur debt and defer its payment,” where “the party to whom credit is offered or extended is a natural person, and the money, property, or services which are the subject of the transaction are primarily for personal, family, or household purposes.” 15 U.S.C. 1602(f), (i). A creditor generally is “a person who both (1) regularly extends . . . consumer credit which is payable by agreement in more than four installments or for which the payment of a finance charge is or may be required, and (2) is the person to whom the debt arising from the consumer credit transaction is initially payable on the face of the evidence of indebtedness or, if there is no such evidence of indebtedness, by agreement.” 15 U.S.C. 1602(g).

TILA section 128 requires that, for closed-end credit, the disclosures generally be made “before the credit is extended.” 15 U.S.C. 1638(b)(1). For closed-end transactions secured by a consumer's dwelling and subject to RESPA, good faith estimates of the disclosures are required “not later than three business days after the creditor receives the consumer's written application, which shall be at least 7 business days before consummation of the transaction.” 15 U.S.C. 1638(b)(2)(A). Finally, if the annual percentage rate (APR) disclosed in this early TILA disclosure statement becomes inaccurate, “the creditor shall furnish an additional, corrected statement to the borrower, not later than 3 business days before the date of consummation of the transaction.” 15 U.S.C. 1638(b)(2)(D).

Historically, the Board's Regulation Z has implemented TILA. Effective July 21, 2011, the Dodd-Frank Act generally transferred rulemaking authority for TILA to the Bureau.
78

See
Dodd-Frank Act sections 1061 and 1100A.

78
Section 1029 of the Dodd-Frank Act excludes from this transfer of authority, subject to certain exceptions, any rulemaking authority over a motor vehicle dealer that is predominantly engaged in the sale and servicing of motor vehicles, the leasing and servicing of motor vehicles, or both. 12 U.S.C. 5519.

TILA section 128's requirement that the disclosure statement be provided before the credit is extended (final TILA disclosure) is implemented in the Bureau's Regulation Z by § 1026.17(b). The requirements that a good faith estimate of the disclosure be provided within three business days after application and at least seven business days prior to consummation (early TILA disclosure) and that a corrected disclosure be provided at least three business days before consummation (corrected TILA disclosure), as applicable, are implemented by § 1026.19(a). The contents of the TILA disclosures, as required by TILA section 128, are implemented by § 1026.18.

On July 30, 2008, Congress enacted the Mortgage Disclosure Improvement Act of 2008 (MDIA).
79

MDIA, in part, amended the timing requirements for the early TILA disclosures, requiring that these TILA disclosures be provided within three business days after an application for a dwelling-secured closed-end mortgage loan also subject to RESPA is received and before the consumer has paid any fee (other than a fee for obtaining the consumer's credit history).
80

79
MDIA is contained in sections 2501 through 2503 of the Housing and Economic Recovery Act of 2008, Public Law 110-289, enacted on July 30, 2008. MDIA was later amended by the Emergency Economic Stabilization Act of 2008, Public Law 110-343, enacted on October 3, 2008.

80
MDIA codified some requirements previously adopted by the Board in a July 2008 final rule. 73 FR 44522 (July 30, 2008) (HOEPA Final Rule). To ease discussion, the description of MDIA's disclosure requirements includes the requirements of the 2008 HOEPA Final Rule.

Creditors also must mail or deliver these early TILA disclosures at least seven business days before consummation and provide corrected disclosures if the disclosed APR changes in excess of a specified tolerance. The consumer must receive the corrected disclosures no later than three business days before consummation. The Board implemented these MDIA requirements in final rules published May 19, 2009, which became effective July 30, 2009, as required by the statute. 74 FR 23289 (May 19, 2009) (MDIA Final Rule).

MDIA also requires disclosure of payment examples if the loan's interest rate or payments can change, along with a statement that there is no guarantee the consumer will be able to refinance

the transaction in the future. Under the statute, these provisions of MDIA became effective on January 30, 2011. The Board worked to implement these provisions of MDIA at the same time that it was completing work on a several year review of Regulation Z's provisions concerning home-secured credit. As a result, the Board issued two sets of proposals approximately one year apart. On August 26, 2009, the Board published proposed amendments to Regulation Z containing comprehensive changes to the disclosures for closed-end credit secured by real property or a consumer's dwelling, including revisions to the format and content of the disclosures implementing MDIA's payment examples and refinance statement requirements, and several new requirements. 74 FR 43232 (Aug. 26, 2009) (2009 Closed-End Proposal).

For the 2009 Closed-End Proposal, the Board developed several new model disclosure forms through consumer testing consisting of focus groups and one-on-one cognitive interviews.
81

In addition, the 2009 Closed-End Proposal proposed an extensive revision to the definition of “finance charge” that would replace the “some fees in, some fees out” approach for determining the finance charge with a simpler, more inclusive “all-in” approach. The proposed definition of “finance charge” would include a fee or charge if it is (1) “payable directly or indirectly by the consumer” to whom credit is extended, and (2) “imposed directly or indirectly by the creditor as an incident to or a condition of the extension of credit.” The finance charge would continue to exclude fees or charges paid in comparable cash transactions.
82

81
Bd. of Governors of the Fed. Reserve Sys.,
Summary of Findings: Design and Testing of Truth in Lending Disclosures for Closed-End Mortgages,
prepared by Macro International, Inc. (July 16, 2009) (Macro 2009 Closed-End Report), available at
http://www.federalreserve.gov/boarddocs/meetings/2009/20090723/Full%20Macro%20CE%20Report.pdf
.

82
As discussed in the section-by-section analysis of the proposed amendments to § 1026.4 in part VI, in response to concerns about the effect of an “all-in” finance charge on the higher-priced and HOEPA coverage thresholds in §§ 1026.35 and 1026.32, respectively, the Board proposed to implement a different “transaction coverage rate” for higher-priced coverage and to retain the existing “some fees in, some fees out” treatment of certain charges in the definition of points and fees for purposes of determining HOEPA coverage.
See
76 FR 27390, 27411-12 (May 11, 2011); 76 FR 11598, 11608-09 (Mar. 2, 2011); 75 FR 58539, 58636-38, 58660-61 (Sept. 24, 2010).

On September 24, 2010, the Board published an interim final rule to implement MDIA's payment example and refinance statement requirements. 75 FR 58470 (Sept. 24, 2010) (MDIA Interim Rule). The Board's MDIA Interim Rule effectively adopted those aspects of the 2009 Closed-End Proposal that implemented these MDIA requirements, without adopting that proposal's other provisions, which were not subject to the same January 30, 2011 statutory effective date. The Board later issued another interim final rule to make certain clarifying changes to the provisions of the MDIA Interim Rule. 75 FR 81836 (Dec. 29, 2010).

On September 24, 2010, the Board also proposed further amendments to Regulation Z regarding rescission rights, disclosure requirements in connection with modifications of existing mortgage loans, and disclosures and requirements for reverse mortgage loans. This proposal was the second stage of the comprehensive review conducted by the Board of TILA's rules for home-secured credit. 75 FR 58539 (Sept. 24, 2010) (2010 Mortgage Proposal).

The Board also began, on September 24, 2010, issuing proposals implementing the Dodd-Frank Act, which had been signed on July 21, 2010. The Board issued a proposed rule implementing section 1461 of the Dodd-Frank Act, which, in part, adjusts the rate threshold for determining whether escrow accounts are required for “jumbo loans,” whose principal amounts exceed the maximum eligible for purchase by Freddie Mac.
83

75 FR 58505 (Sept. 24, 2010). On March 2, 2011, the Board proposed amendments to Regulation Z implementing other requirements of sections 1461 and 1462 of the Dodd-Frank Act, which added new substantive and disclosure requirements regarding escrow accounts to TILA. 76 FR 11598 (March 2, 2011) (2011 Escrows Proposal). Sections 1461 and 1462 of the Dodd-Frank Act added section 129D to TILA, which substantially codifies requirements that the Board had previously adopted in Regulation Z regarding escrow requirements for higher-priced mortgage loans (including the revised rate threshold for “jumbo loans” described above), but also adds disclosure requirements, and lengthens the period for which escrow accounts are required.

83
The Board finalized this proposal effective April 1, 2011. 76 FR 11319 (Mar. 2, 2011).

On May 11, 2011, the Board proposed amendments to Regulation Z to implement section 1411 of the Dodd-Frank Act, which amends TILA to prohibit creditors from making mortgage loans without regard to the consumer's repayment ability. 76 FR 27390 (May 11, 2011) (2011 ATR Proposal). Section 1411 of the Dodd-Frank Act adds section 129C to TILA, codified at 15 U.S.C. 1639c, which prohibits a creditor from making a mortgage loan unless the creditor makes a reasonable and good faith determination, based on verified and documented information, that the consumer will have a reasonable ability to repay the loan, including any mortgage-related obligations (such as property taxes).

As noted above, effective July 21, 2011, the Dodd-Frank Act generally transferred rulemaking authority for TILA to the Bureau.
See
Dodd-Frank Act sections 1061 and 1100A. Along with this authority, the Bureau assumed responsibility for the proposed rules discussed above. Pursuant to the Dodd-Frank Act and TILA, as amended, the Bureau published for public comment an interim final rule establishing a new Regulation Z, 12 CFR part 1026, implementing TILA (except with respect to persons excluded from the Bureau's rulemaking authority by section 1029 of the Dodd-Frank Act). 76 FR 79768 (Dec. 22, 2011). This rule did not impose any new substantive obligations but did make certain technical, conforming, and stylistic changes to reflect the transfer of authority and certain other changes made by the Dodd-Frank Act. The Bureau's Regulation Z took effect on December 30, 2011.

D. The History of Integration Efforts

For more than 30 years, TILA and RESPA have required creditors and settlement agents to give consumers who apply for and obtain a mortgage loan different but overlapping disclosure forms regarding the loan's terms and costs. This duplication has long been recognized as inefficient and confusing for both consumers and industry.

Previous efforts to develop a combined TILA and RESPA disclosure form were fueled by the amount, complexity, and overlap of information in the disclosures. On September 30, 1996, Congress enacted the Economic Growth and Regulatory Paperwork Reduction Act of 1996,
84

which required the Board and HUD to “simplify and improve the disclosures applicable to the transactions under [TILA and RESPA], including the timing of the disclosures; and to provide a single format for such disclosures which will satisfy the requirements of each such Act with respect to such transactions.”
85

If the agencies found that legislative action might be necessary or appropriate to simplify and unify the disclosures, they were to submit a report to Congress containing recommendations for such action. In the

same legislation, Congress added exemption authority in TILA section 105(f) for classes of transactions for which, in the determination of the Board (now the Bureau), coverage under all or part of TILA does not provide a meaningful benefit to consumers in the form of useful information or protection.
86

84
Public Law 104-208, 110 Stat. 3009 (1996).

85

Id.,
section 2101.

86

Id.,
section 2102(b).

The Board and HUD did not propose an integrated disclosure pursuant to this legislation. Instead, in July 1998, the Board and HUD issued a “Joint Report to the Congress Concerning Reform to the Truth in Lending Act and the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act” (Board-HUD Joint Report).
87

The Board-HUD Joint Report concluded that “meaningful change could come only through legislation” and provided Congress with the Board's and HUD's recommendations for revising TILA and RESPA.

87
Bd. of Governors of the Fed. Reserve Sys. And U.S. Dep't of Hous. and Urban Dev.,
Joint Report to the Congress Concerning Reform to the Truth in Lending Act and the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act
(1998), available at
http://www.federalreserve.gov/boarddocs/rptcongress/tila.pdf
.

The agencies recommended a number of amendments to TILA and RESPA in the report, such as amendment of TILA's definition of “finance charge” to eliminate the “some fees in, some fees out” approach and instead include “all costs the consumer is required to pay in order to close the loan, with limited exceptions”; the amendment of RESPA to require either the guaranteeing of closing costs on the GFE or estimates that are subject to an accuracy standard; and provision of the final TILA disclosure and settlement statement three days before closing, so that consumers would be able to study the disclosures in an unpressured environment.

The Board-HUD Joint Report also recommended several additional changes to the TILA disclosures. In particular, the report recommended significant revisions to the “Fed Box,” which is the tabular disclosure provided to consumers in the early and final TILA disclosures under Regulation Z containing the APR, the finance charge (which is intended to be the cost of credit expressed as a dollar amount), the amount financed (which is intended to reflect the loan proceeds available to the consumer), and the total of payments (which is the dollar amount of the transaction over the loan term, including principal and finance charges).
88

The report recommended, among other things, eliminating the amount financed from the disclosure for mortgage loans because it probably was not useful to consumers in understanding mortgage loans. The report also recommended adding disclosure of the total closing costs in the Fed Box, citing focus groups conducted by the Board in which participants stated that disclosure of the amount needed to close the loan would be useful.

88

See, e.g.,
Regulation Z, 12 CFR part 1026 app. H-2 Loan Model Form.

The Board-HUD Joint Report did not result in legislative action. Eleven years later, and four months before the revised RESPA disclosures under HUD's 2008 RESPA Final Rule were to become mandatory, the Board published the 2009 Closed-End Proposal, which proposed significant revisions to the TILA disclosures and stated that the Board would work with HUD towards integrating the two disclosure regimes. The proposal stated that “the Board anticipates working with [HUD] to ensure that TILA and [RESPA] disclosures are compatible and complementary, including potentially developing a single disclosure form that creditors could use to combine the initial disclosures required under TILA and RESPA.”
89

The proposal stated that consumer testing would be used to ensure consumers could understand and use the combined disclosures. However, only ten months later in July 2010, the Dodd-Frank Act was enacted by Congress, which transferred rulemaking authority under both TILA and RESPA to the Bureau and, as described below in part II.E, under sections 1032(f), 1098, and 1100A, mandated that the Bureau establish a single disclosure scheme under TILA and RESPA and propose for public comment rules and model disclosures that integrate the TILA and RESPA disclosures by July 21, 2012. 12 U.S.C. 2603(a), 5532(f); 15 U.S.C. 1604(b).

89
74 FR 43232, 43233.

The Bureau issued proposed integrated disclosure forms and rules for public comment on July 9, 2012 (the TILA-RESPA Proposal or proposal).
90

The TILA-RESPA Proposal provided for a bifurcated comment process. Comments regarding the proposed amendments to § 1026.1(c) were required to have been received on or before September 7, 2012. For all other proposed amendments and comments pursuant to the Paperwork Reduction Act, comments were required to have been received on or before November 6, 2012.
91

Now, more than 17 years after Congress first directed the Board and HUD to integrate the disclosures under TILA and RESPA, the Bureau publishes this final rule.

90

See
the Bureau's press release
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau proposes “Know Before You Owe” mortgage forms
(July 9, 2012), available at
http://www.consumerfinance.gov/pressreleases/consumer-financial-protection-bureau-proposes-know-before-you-owe-mortgage-forms/
; the Bureau's blog post
Know Before You Owe: Introducing our proposed mortgage disclosure forms
(July 9, 2012), available at
http://www.consumerfinance.gov/blog/know-before-you-owe-introducing-our-proposed-mortgage-disclosure-forms/
.

91
In its initial
Federal Register
notice, the Bureau also applied the September 7, 2012 deadline to comments on the proposed amendments to the definition of finance charge in § 1026.4. On August 31, 2012, however, the Bureau issued a notice extending the deadline for such comments to November 6, 2012.
See
the Bureau's blog post,
More time for comments on proposed changes to the definition of the finance charge
(Aug. 31, 2012), available at
http://www.consumerfinance.gov/blog/more-time-for-comments-on-proposed-changes-to-the-definition-of-the-finance-charge/
. The extension was published in the
Federal Register
on September 6, 2012.
See
77 FR 54843 (Sept. 6, 2012). It did not change the comment period for any other aspects of the TILA-RESPA Proposal, which, as noted above, closed on November 6, 2012.

E. The Dodd-Frank Act

As noted above, RESPA and TILA historically have been implemented by regulations of HUD and the Board, respectively, and the Dodd-Frank Act consolidated most of this rulemaking authority in the Bureau. In addition, the Dodd-Frank Act amended both statutes to mandate that the Bureau establish a single disclosure scheme for use by lenders or creditors in complying comprehensively with the disclosure requirements discussed above. Section 1098(2) of the Dodd-Frank Act amended RESPA section 4(a) to require that the Bureau “publish a single, integrated disclosure for mortgage loan transactions (including real estate settlement cost statements) which includes the disclosure requirements of this section and section 5, in conjunction with the disclosure requirements of [TILA] that, taken together, may apply to a transaction that is subject to both or either provisions of law.” 12 U.S.C. 2603(a). Similarly, section 1100A(5) of the Dodd-Frank Act amended TILA section 105(b) to require that the Bureau “publish a single, integrated disclosure for mortgage loan transactions (including real estate settlement cost statements) which includes the disclosure requirements of this title in conjunction with the disclosure requirements of [RESPA] that, taken together, may apply to a transaction that is subject to both or either provisions of law.” 15 U.S.C. 1604(b).

The amendments to RESPA and TILA mandating a “single, integrated disclosure” are among numerous conforming amendments to existing

Federal laws found in subtitle H of the Consumer Financial Protection Act of 2010.
92

Subtitle C of the Consumer Financial Protection Act, “Specific Bureau Authorities,” codified at 12 U.S.C. chapter 53, subchapter V, part C, contains a similar provision. Specifically, section 1032(f) of the Dodd-Frank Act provides that, by July 21, 2012, the Bureau “shall propose for public comment rules and model disclosures that combine the disclosures required under [TILA] and sections 4 and 5 of [RESPA] into a single, integrated disclosure for mortgage loan transactions covered by those laws, unless the Bureau determines that any proposal issued by the [Board] and [HUD] carries out the same purpose.” 12 U.S.C. 5532(f). The Bureau issued the TILA-RESPA Proposal pursuant to that mandate and the parallel mandates established by the conforming amendments to RESPA and TILA, discussed above.

92
The Consumer Financial Protection Act is title X, “Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection,” of the Dodd-Frank Act, Public Law 111-203, 124 Stat. 1376 (2010), sections 1001-1100H. In the Consumer Financial Protection Act, Congress established the Bureau and its powers and authorities, transferred to the Bureau various existing functions of other agencies, mandated certain regulatory improvements, and prescribed other requirements and conforming amendments. Subtitle H, “Conforming Amendments,” is the last subtitle and consists of sections 1081-1100H. Certain titles of the Dodd-Frank Act are codified at 12 U.S.C. chapter 53. Subtitles A through G (but not H) of title X are codified at 12 U.S.C. chapter 53, subchapter V, parts A through G. Thus, the Consumer Financial Protection Act is substantially codified at 12 U.S.C. 5481-5603.

F. Other Rulemakings

In January 2013, the Bureau issued several other rulemakings relating to mortgage credit to implement requirements of the Dodd-Frank Act (the Title XIV Rulemakings), and throughout 2013 has issued proposed and final rules to amend the rulemakings based on public feedback:

HOEPA:
On January 10, 2013, the Bureau issued a final rule implementing certain Dodd-Frank Act requirements that expand protections for “high-cost” mortgage loans under HOEPA, pursuant to TILA sections 103(bb) and 129, as amended by Dodd-Frank Act sections 1431 through 1433 (2013 HOEPA Final Rule).
93

15 U.S.C. 1602(bb) and 1639. The rule implements certain Title XIV requirements concerning homeownership counseling, including a requirement that lenders provide lists of homeownership counselors to applicants for federally related mortgage loans, pursuant to RESPA section 5(c), as amended by Dodd-Frank Act section 1450. 12 U.S.C. 2604(c). On November 8, 2013, the Bureau issued a final interpretive rule providing lenders with additional instructions on complying with the 2013 HOEPA Final Rule requirements.
94

93
78 FR 6855 (Jan. 31, 2013), finalizing a proposal issued on July 9, 2012 (77 FR 54844 (Aug. 15, 2012) (2012 HOEPA Proposal)).

94
Homeownership Counseling Organizations Lists Interpretive Rule (Nov. 8, 2013), available at
http://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201311_cfpb_interpretive-rule_homeownership-counseling-organizations-lists.pdf;

see also
Homeownership Counseling list requirements, CFPB Bulletin 2013-13 (Nov. 8, 2013), available at
http://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201311_cfpb_bulletin_homeownership-counseling-list-requirements.pdf
.

Servicing:
On January 17, 2013, the Bureau issued the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act (Regulation X) and Truth in Lending Act (Regulation Z) Mortgage Servicing Final Rules (2013 Mortgage Servicing Final Rules).
95

These rules implement Dodd-Frank Act requirements regarding force-placed insurance, error resolution, information requests, and payment crediting, as well as requirements for mortgage loan periodic statements and adjustable rate mortgage reset disclosures, pursuant to sections 6 of RESPA and 128, 128A, 129F, and 129G of TILA, as amended or established by Dodd-Frank Act sections 1418, 1420, 1463, and 1464. 12 U.S.C. 2605; 15 U.S.C. 1638, 1638a, 1639f, and 1639g. These rules establish: (1) Early intervention for troubled and delinquent borrowers, and loss mitigation procedures, pursuant to the Bureau's authority under section 6 of RESPA, as amended by Dodd-Frank Act section 1463; (2) obligations for mortgage servicers that the Bureau found to be appropriate to carry out the consumer protection purposes of RESPA, as well as its authority under section 19(a) of RESPA to prescribe rules necessary to achieve the purposes of RESPA; and (3) requirements for general servicing standards, policies, and procedures and continuity of contact, pursuant to the Bureau's authority under section 19(a) of RESPA.

95
78 FR 10901 (Feb. 14, 2013), amending Regulation Z (2013 TILA Mortgage Servicing Final Rule), and 78 FR 10695 (Feb. 14, 2013), amending Regulation X (2013 RESPA Mortgage Servicing Final Rule). These rules finalized proposals issued on August 20, 2012 (77 FR 57317 (Sept. 17, 2012), proposing amendments to Regulation Z (2012 TILA Mortgage Servicing Proposal) and 77 FR 57200 (Sept. 17, 2012), proposing amendments to Regulation X (2012 RESPA Mortgage Servicing Proposal)).

Loan Originator Compensation:
On January 20, 2013, the Bureau issued a final rule to implement provisions of the Dodd-Frank Act requiring certain creditors and loan originators to meet certain duties of care, pursuant to TILA sections 129B and 129C as established by Dodd-Frank Act sections 1402, 1403, and 1414(a) (2013 Loan Originator Final Rule).
96

15 U.S.C. 1639b, 1639c. The rule sets forth certain qualification requirements; requires the establishment of certain compliance procedures by depository institutions; prohibits loan originators, creditors, and their affiliates from receiving compensation in various forms and from sources other than the consumer (with specified exceptions); and establishes restrictions on mandatory arbitration and the financing of single-premium credit insurance. On May 29, 2013, the Bureau issued a final rule delaying the effective date of a prohibition on creditors financing credit insurance premiums in connection with certain consumer credit transactions secured by a dwelling from its original effective date of June 1, 2013 to January 10, 2014.
97

The delay is meant to permit the Bureau to clarify the provision's applicability to transactions other than those in which a lump-sum premium is added to the loan amount at closing.

96
78 FR 11279 (Feb. 15, 2013), finalizing a proposal issued on August 17, 2012 (77 FR 55271 (Sept. 7, 2012) (2012 Loan Originator Proposal)).

97
78 FR 32547 (May 31, 2013), finalizing a proposal to delay the effective date of the prohibition issued May 7, 2013 (78 FR 27308 (May 10, 2013)).

Appraisals:
On January 18, 2013, the Bureau, jointly with Federal prudential regulators and other Federal agencies (the Agencies), issued a final rule to implement Dodd-Frank Act requirements concerning appraisals for higher-risk mortgages, pursuant to TILA section 129H as established by Dodd-Frank Act section 1471 (2013 Interagency Appraisals Final Rule).
98

15 U.S.C. 1639h. For mortgages with an annual percentage rate that exceeds the average prime offer rate by a specified percentage, the final rule requires creditors to obtain an appraisal or appraisals meeting certain specified standards, provide applicants with a notification regarding the use of the appraisals, and give applicants a copy of the written appraisals used. On July 10, 2013, the Agencies issued a proposal to amend the final rule to provide exemptions for: (1) Transactions secured by existing manufactured homes and not land; (2) certain “streamlined” refinancings; and (3) transactions of $25,000 or less.
99

98
78 FR 10637 (Feb. 13, 2013), finalizing a proposal issued on September 5, 2012 (77 FR 54721 (Sept. 9, 2012) (2012 Interagency Appraisals Proposal)).

99
78 FR 48548 (Aug. 8, 2013).

On the same day it issued the 2013 Interagency Appraisal Final Rule, the Bureau issued a final rule to implement section 701(e) of the Equal Credit Opportunity Act (ECOA), as amended

by Dodd-Frank Act section 1474 (2013 ECOA Appraisals Final Rule). 15 U.S.C. 1691(e). That rule requires that creditors provide applicants with a free copy of written appraisals and valuations developed in connection with applications for loans secured by a first lien on a dwelling and notify applicants in writing that copies of appraisals will be provided to them promptly.

Ability to Repay:
On January 10, 2013, the Bureau finalized a proposal issued by the Board to implement provisions of the Dodd-Frank Act (1) requiring creditors to determine that a consumer has a reasonable ability to repay covered mortgage loans and establishing standards for compliance, and (2) establishing certain limitations on prepayment penalties, pursuant to TILA sections 129C as established by Dodd-Frank Act sections 1411, 1412, and 1414 (2013 ATR Final Rule).
100

15 U.S.C. 1639c. Concurrent with the issuance of the 2013 ATR Final Rule, the Bureau issued a concurrent proposed rule amending certain aspects of the 2013 ATR Final Rule (2013 ATR Concurrent Proposal), which proposal was finalized on May 29, 2013 (May 2013 ATR Final Rule).
101

That rule provides exemptions for certain nonprofit creditors and certain homeownership stabilization programs, provides an additional definition of a “qualified mortgage” for certain loans made and held in portfolio by small creditors, and modifies the requirements regarding the inclusion of loan originator compensation in the points and fees calculation.

100
78 FR 6407 (Jan. 30, 2013), finalizing a proposal issued by the Board on May 11, 2011 (76 FR 27389 (May 11, 2011) (2011 Board Ability to Repay Proposal)).

101
78 FR 35429 (Jun. 12, 2013), finalizing the concurrent proposal issued on January 10, 2013 (78 FR 6622 (Jan. 30, 2013)).

Escrows:
On January 10, 2013, the Bureau finalized a proposal issued by the Board to implement provisions of the Dodd-Frank Act that require escrow accounts to be established for higher-priced mortgage loans and to create an exemption for certain loans held by creditors operating predominantly in rural or underserved areas, pursuant to TILA section 129D as established by Dodd-Frank Act section 1461 (2013 Escrows Final Rule).
102

15 U.S.C. 1639d. On April 18, 2013, the Bureau published a proposal setting forth certain clarifying and technical amendments to the 2013 Escrows Final Rule, including a clarification of how to determine whether a county is considered “rural” or “underserved.”
103

The final rule was published on May 23, 2013.
104

102
78 FR 4726 (Jan. 22, 2013), finalizing a proposal issued by the Board on March 2, 2011 (76 FR 11597 (Mar. 2, 2011)).

103
78 FR 23171 (Apr. 18, 2013).

104
78 FR 30739 (May 23, 2013).

In addition to the foregoing, the Bureau proposed and finalized three additional sets of amendments to the Title XIV Rulemakings. The first set of amendments, proposed in April 2013 and published on July 24, 2013, clarify, correct, or amend provisions on the relation to State law of Regulation X's servicing provisions; implementation dates for adjustable rate mortgage servicing; exclusions from requirements on higher-priced mortgage loans; the small servicer exemption from certain servicing rules; the use of government-sponsored enterprise and Federal agency purchase, guarantee or insurance eligibility for determining qualified mortgage status; and the determination of debt and income for purposes of originating qualified mortgages.
105

105
78 FR 44685 (July 24, 2013), finalizing a proposal issued on April 19, 2013 (78 FR 25638 (May 2, 2013)).

The second set of amendments, proposed on June 21, 2013, was published on October 1, 2013.
106

These amendments focus primarily on clarifying, revising, or amending provisions on loss mitigation procedures under Regulation X's servicing provisions; amounts counted as loan originator compensation to retailers of manufactured homes and their employees for purposes of applying points and fees thresholds under the Home Ownership and Equity Protection Act and the Ability-to-Repay rules in Regulation Z; exemptions available to creditors that operate predominantly in “rural or underserved” areas for various purposes under the mortgage regulations; application of the loan originator compensation rules to bank tellers and similar staff; and the prohibition on creditor-financed credit insurance. The amendments also adjusted the effective dates for certain provisions of the loan originator compensation rules, and incorporated technical and wording changes for clarification purposes to Regulations B, X, and Z.

106
78 FR 60382 (Oct. 1, 2013); 78 FR 39902 (Jul. 2, 2013).

The third set of amendments was published on October 23, 2013.
107

These amendments focus primarily on clarifying the specific disclosures that must be provided before counseling for high-cost mortgages can occur, and proper compliance regarding servicing requirements when a consumer is in bankruptcy or sends a cease communication request under the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act. The rule also makes technical corrections to provisions of the other Title XIV Rulemakings.

107
78 FR 62993 (Oct. 23, 2013).

The Bureau regards the foregoing rulemakings as components of a larger undertaking; many of them intersect with one or more of the others. Accordingly, the Bureau has carefully coordinated the development and implementation of the proposals and final rules identified above in an effort to facilitate compliance. As an example, in developing the TILA-RESPA Proposal and Final Rule, the Bureau took care to ensure common terms, such as “prepayment penalty” and “balloon payment” are defined consistent with the Title XIV Rulemakings, as described in more detail below. In addition, each rulemaking includes regulatory provisions to implement the various Dodd-Frank Act mandates and to ensure that the overall undertaking is accomplished efficiently and that it ultimately yields a regulatory scheme for mortgage credit that achieves the statutory purposes set forth by Congress, while avoiding unnecessary burdens on industry.

III. Summary of the Rulemaking Process

As noted above, the Dodd-Frank Act established two goals for this rulemaking: “to facilitate compliance with the disclosure requirements of [TILA and RESPA]” and “to aid the borrower or lessee in understanding the transaction by utilizing readily understandable language to simplify the technical nature of the disclosures.” Dodd-Frank Act sections 1098, 1100A; 12 U.S.C. 2603(a), 15 U.S.C. 1604(b). Further, the Bureau has a specific mandate and authority from Congress to promote consumer comprehension of financial transactions through clear disclosures. Section 1021(a) of the Dodd-Frank Act directs the Bureau to “implement . . . Federal consumer financial law consistently for the purpose of ensuring,” inter alia, that “markets for consumer financial products and services are fair, transparent, and competitive.” 12 U.S.C. 5511(a). Section 1021(b) of the Dodd-Frank Act, in turn, authorizes the Bureau as part of its core mission to exercise its authority to ensure that, with respect to consumer financial products and services, “consumers are provided with timely and understandable information to make responsible decisions about financial transactions.” 12 U.S.C. 5511(b). Consistent with these goals and in preparation for proposing integrated rules and forms, the Bureau conducted

a multifaceted information gathering campaign, including researching how consumers interact with and understand information, testing of prototype forms, developing interactive online tools to gather public feedback, and hosting roundtable discussions, teleconferences, and meetings with consumer advocacy groups, industry stakeholders, and other government agencies.

A. Early Stakeholder Outreach & Prototype Form Design

In September 2010, the Bureau began meeting with consumer advocates, other banking agencies, community banks, credit unions, settlement agents, and other industry representatives. This outreach helped the Bureau better understand the issues that consumers and industry face when they use the current TILA and RESPA disclosures. For example, as part of this outreach, in December 2010, the Bureau held a mortgage disclosure symposium that brought together consumer advocacy groups, industry representatives, marketing professionals, designers, and other interested parties to discuss various possible concepts and approaches for integrating the disclosures.

At the same time, the Bureau began to research how consumers interact with and understand information. Given the complexities and variability of mortgage loan transactions and their underlying real estate transactions, the Bureau understood that the integrated disclosures would have to convey a large amount of complex and technical information to consumers in a manner that they could use and understand. Considering that, in January 2011, the Bureau contracted with a communication, design, consumer testing, and research firm, Kleimann Communication Group, Inc. (Kleimann), which specializes in consumer financial disclosures. Kleimann has been hired by other Federal agencies to perform similar design and qualitative testing work in connection with other financial disclosure forms. For example, the Federal Trade Commission and the Federal banking agencies contracted with Kleimann to design and conduct consumer testing for revised model privacy disclosures.
108

Also, HUD contracted with Kleimann to assist in the design and consumer testing for its revised RESPA GFE and RESPA settlement statement forms.
109

108
72 FR 14940, 14944 (Mar. 29, 2007); 74 FR 62890, 62893 (Dec. 1, 2009).

109
73 FR 14030, 14043 (Mar. 14, 2008); 73 FR 68204, 68265 (Nov. 17, 2008).

The Bureau and Kleimann reviewed relevant research and the work of other Federal financial services regulatory agencies to inform the Bureau's design of the prototype integrated disclosures. One of the findings of this research was that there is a significant risk to consumers of experiencing “information overload” when the volume or complexity of information detracts from the consumer decision-making processes. “Information overload” has often been cited as a problem with financial disclosures.
110

Researchers suggest that there should be a balance between the types and amount of information in the disclosures, because too much information has the potential to detract from consumers' decision-making processes.
111

In its 2009 Closed-End Proposal, the Board cited a reduction in “information overload” as one of the potential benefits of its plan to harmonize the TILA and RESPA disclosures in collaboration with HUD.
112

The Board's consumer testing in connection with its 2009 Closed-End Proposal found that when participants were asked what was most difficult about their mortgage experience, the most frequent answer was the amount of paperwork.
113

HUD also stated that one of its guiding principles for HUD's 2008 RESPA Proposal was that “the [mortgage loan settlement process] can be improved with simplification of disclosures and better borrower information,” the complexity of which caused many problems with the process.
114

110

See e.g.,
Debra Pogrund Stark and Jessica M. Choplin,
A Cognitive and Social Psychological Analysis of Disclosure Laws and Call for Mortgage Counseling to Prevent Predatory Lending,
16 Psych. Pub. Pol. and L. 85, 96 (2010); Paula J. Dalley,
The Use and Misuse of Disclosure as a Regulatory System,
34 Fla. St. U.L. Rev. 1089, 1115 (2007); Patricia A. McCoy,
The Middle-Class Crunch: Rethinking Disclosure in a World of Risk-Based Pricing,
44 Harv. J. on Legis. 123, 133 (2007); Lauren E. Willis,
Decisionmaking and The Limits of Disclosure: The Problem of Predatory Lending: Price,
65 Md. L. Rev. 707, 766 (2006); Troy A. Paredes,
After the Sarbanes-Oxley Act: The Future Disclosure System: Blinded by the Light: Information Overload and its Consequences for Securities Regulation,
81 Wash. U. L. Q. 417 (2003); William N. Eskridge, Jr.,
One Hundred Years of Ineptitude: The Need for Mortgage Rules Consonant with the Economic and Psychological Dynamics of the Home Sale and Loan Transaction,
70 Va. L. Rev. 1083, 1133 (1984).

111
John Kozup & Jeanne M. Hogarth,
Financial Literacy, Public Policy, and Consumers' Self-Protection-More Questions, Fewer Answers,
42 Journal of Consumer Affairs 2, 127 (2008).

112
74 FR 43232, 43234.

113

See
Macro 2009 Closed-End Report at 19. For additional discussion regarding information overload, see the section-by-section analysis of proposed § 1026.37(l).

114
73 FR 14030, 14031.

The potential for “information overload” was also cited by Congress as one of the reasons it amended the TILA disclosures in the Truth-in-Lending Simplification and Reform Act of 1980.
115

According to the Senate Committee on Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs, this legislation arose in part because:

115
Public Law 96-221, 94 Stat 132 (1980).

During its hearings the Consumer Affairs Subcommittee heard testimony from a leading psychologist who has studied the problem of `informational overload.' The Subcommittee learned that judging from consumer tests in other areas, the typical disclosure statement utilized today by creditors is not an effective communication device. Most disclosure statements are lengthy, written in legalistic fine print, and have essential Truth in Lending disclosures scattered among various contractual terms. The result is a piece of paper which appears to be `just another legal document' instead of the simple, concise disclosure form Congress intended.
116

116
Public Law 96-221, Depository Institutions Deregulation and Monetary Control Act of 1980, Senate Report No. 96073 (Apr. 24, 1979).

Based on this research, the Bureau is particularly mindful of the risk of information overload, especially considering the large volume of other information and paperwork consumers are required to process throughout the mortgage loan and real estate transaction.

The Bureau began development of the integrated disclosures with certain design objectives. Considering that the quantity of information both on the disclosures and in other paperwork throughout the mortgage loan and real estate transaction may increase the risk of information overload, the Bureau began development of the integrated disclosures with the objective of creating a graphic design that used as few words as possible when presenting the key loan and cost information. The Bureau's purpose for such a design was to make the information readily visible so that consumers could quickly and easily find the information they were seeking, without being confronted with large amounts of text. Accordingly, the Bureau decided to limit the content of the disclosures to loan terms, cost information, and certain textual disclosures and to exclude educational material. The Bureau understood that consumers would receive educational materials required under applicable law, such as the Special Information Booklet required by section 5 of RESPA, through other means. In addition, the Bureau anticipated that it would provide additional educational information and tools on its Web site and place a Web site link on the integrated disclosures directing consumers to that site, which

would obviate the need to place educational material directly on the disclosures.

The Bureau believed and continues to believe that the design should highlight on the first page the most important loan information that consumers readily understand and use to evaluate and compare loans, placing more detailed and technical information later in the disclosure. With such a design, the first page could potentially be used by some consumers as a one-page mortgage shopping sheet. In addition, the Bureau believed the design should use plain language and limit the use of technical, statutory, or complex financial terms wherever possible.

The Bureau believes these design objectives best satisfy the purposes of the integrated disclosures set forth by Dodd-Frank Act sections 1098 and 1100A, as well as the Bureau's mandate under Dodd-Frank Act section 1021(b) to ensure that consumers are provided with “understandable information” to enable them to make responsible decisions about financial transactions.

From January through May 2011, the Bureau and Kleimann developed a plan to design integrated disclosure prototypes and conduct qualitative usability testing, consisting of one-on-one cognitive interviews. The Bureau and Kleimann worked collaboratively on developing the qualitative testing plan and several prototype forms for the disclosure to be provided in connection with a consumer's application integrating the RESPA GFE and the early TILA disclosure (the Loan Estimate). The Bureau planned to develop the disclosure provided in connection with the closing of the mortgage loan that integrates the RESPA settlement statement and the final TILA disclosure (the Closing Disclosure) after development and testing of the prototype design for the Loan Estimate. Although qualitative testing is commonly used by Federal agencies to evaluate the effectiveness of disclosures prior to issuing a proposal, the qualitative testing plan developed by the Bureau and Kleimann was unique in that the Bureau conducted qualitative testing with industry participants as well as consumers. Each round of qualitative testing included at least two industry participants, including lenders from several different types of depository institutions (including credit unions and community banks) and non-depository institutions (mortgage companies and mortgage brokers) and, for the Closing Disclosure, settlement agents.

B. Pre-Proposal Prototype Testing and the Know Before You Owe (KBYO) Project

In May 2011, the Bureau selected two initial prototype designs of the Loan Estimate, which were used in qualitative testing interviews in Baltimore, Maryland. In these interviews, consumers were asked to work through the prototype forms while conveying their impressions, and were also asked a series of questions designed to assess whether the forms presented information in a format that enabled them to understand and compare the mortgage loans presented to them. These questions ranged from the highly specific (
e.g.,
asking whether the consumer could identify the loan payment in year 10 of a 30-year, adjustable rate loan) to the highly general (
e.g.,
asking consumers to choose the loan that best met their needs).
117

Industry participants were asked to use the prototype forms to explain mortgage loans as they would to a consumer and to identify implementation issues and areas for improvement.

117
The consumers who participated in these interviews had varying levels of education (from consumers with less than a high school education to consumers with graduate degrees) and varying levels of experience with the home buying and mortgage loan process (from consumers who never owned a home to consumers who had been through the home buying and mortgage loan process before).

At the same time, to supplement its qualitative testing, the Bureau launched an initiative, which it titled “Know Before You Owe,” to obtain additional public feedback on the prototype disclosure forms.
118

The Bureau believed this would provide an opportunity to obtain a large amount of feedback from a broad base of consumers and industry respondents around the country. This initiative consisted of either publishing and obtaining feedback on the prototype designs through an interactive tool on the Bureau's Web site or posting the prototypes to the Bureau's blog on its Web site and providing an opportunity for the public to email feedback directly to the Bureau. Individual consumers, loan officers, mortgage brokers, settlement agents, and others provided feedback based on their own experiences with the mortgage loan process by commenting on specific sections of the form, prioritizing information presented on the form, and/or identifying additional information that should be included.
119

118

See

http://www.consumerfinance.gov/knowbeforeyouowe/.

119
Examples of consumer and industry responses to the prototypes of the disclosures can be seen in the CFPB blog, including at:
www.consumerfinance.gov/know-before-you-owe-go
;
www.consumerfinance.gov/13000-lessons-learned
; and
www.consumerfinance.gov/know-before-you-owe-its-closing-time
.

From May to October 2011, Kleimann and the Bureau conducted a series of five rounds of qualitative testing of different iterations of the Loan Estimate with consumer and industry participants. In addition to Baltimore, Maryland, this testing was conducted in Los Angeles, California; Chicago, Illinois; Springfield, Massachusetts; and Albuquerque, New Mexico. Each round focused on a different aspect of the integrated disclosure, such as the overall design, the disclosure of closing costs, and the disclosure of loan payments over the term of the loan. The overall goal of this qualitative testing was to ensure that the forms enabled consumers to understand and compare the terms and costs of the loan.

After each round of testing, Kleimann analyzed and reported to the Bureau on the results of the testing. Based on these results and the supplemental feedback received through the KBYO process, the Bureau would revise the prototype disclosure forms for the subsequent rounds of testing. This iterative process helped the Bureau develop forms that better enable consumers to understand and compare mortgage loans and assist industry in complying with the law. For a detailed discussion of this testing, see the report prepared by Kleimann,
Know Before You Owe: Evolution of the Integrated TILA-RESPA Disclosures
(Kleimann Testing Report), which the Bureau posted on its Web site and on Regulations.gov in connection with the TILA-RESPA Proposal.
120

120
Kleimann Communication Group, Inc.,
Know Before You Owe: Evolution of the Integrated TILA-RESPA Disclosures
(July 2012), available at
http://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201207_cfpb_report_tila-respa-testing.pdf
.

After completion of the qualitative testing that focused solely on the Loan Estimate, the Bureau and Kleimann began work on the prototype designs for the Closing Disclosure. From November 2011 through March 2012, the Bureau and Kleimann conducted five rounds of qualitative testing of different iterations of the Closing Disclosure with consumer and industry participants. This testing was conducted in five different cities across the country: Des Moines, Iowa; Birmingham, Alabama; Philadelphia, Pennsylvania; Austin, Texas; and Baltimore, Maryland.

Similar to the qualitative testing of the Loan Estimate, the Bureau revised the prototype Closing Disclosure forms after each round based on the results Kleimann provided to the Bureau and

the supplemental feedback received from the KBYO process. The Bureau focused on several aspects of the prototypes during each round, such as the settlement disclosures adapted from the HUD-1, new disclosure items required under title XIV of the Dodd-Frank Act, and tables to help identify changes in the information disclosed in the initial Loan Estimate. The overall goal of the qualitative testing of the Closing Disclosure was to ensure that the forms enabled consumers to understand their actual terms and costs, and to compare the Closing Disclosure with the Loan Estimate to identify changes. Accordingly, several rounds included testing of different iterations of the Loan Estimate with the Closing Disclosure.

Overall, the Bureau performed qualitative testing with 92 consumer participants and 22 industry participants, for a total of 114 participants. In addition, through the Bureau's KBYO initiative, the Bureau received over 150,000 visits to the KBYO Web site and over 27,000 public comments and emails about the prototype disclosures.

C. Proposal Stakeholder Outreach

While developing the proposed forms and rules to integrate the disclosures, and throughout its qualitative testing of the prototype disclosure forms, the Bureau continued to conduct extensive outreach to consumer advocacy groups, other regulatory agencies, and industry representatives and trade associations. The Bureau held meetings with individual stakeholders upon request, and also invited stakeholders to meetings in which individual views of each stakeholder could be heard. The Bureau conducted these meetings with a wide range of stakeholders that may be affected by the integrated disclosures, even if not directly regulated by the final rule. The meetings included community banks, credit unions, thrifts, mortgage companies, mortgage brokers, settlement agents, settlement service providers, software providers, appraisers, not-for-profit consumer and housing groups, and government and quasi-governmental agencies. Many of the persons attending these meetings represented small business entities from different parts of the country. In addition to these meetings, after each round of qualitative testing, in response to the Bureau's posting of the prototype integrated disclosures on the KBYO Web site, the Bureau received numerous letters from individuals, consumer advocates, financial services providers, and trade associations, which provided the Bureau with additional feedback on the prototype disclosure forms.

In preparing the TILA-RESPA Proposal, the Bureau also considered comments provided in response to its December 2011 request for information regarding streamlining of regulations for which rulemaking authority was inherited by the CFPB from other Federal agencies, including TILA and RESPA. 76 FR 75825 (Dec. 5, 2011) (2011 Streamlining RFI). That request for information specifically sought public comment on provisions of the inherited regulations that the Bureau should make the highest priority for updating, modifying, or eliminating because they are outdated, unduly burdensome, or unnecessary, and sought suggestions for practical measures to make compliance with the regulations easier. Several commenters requested that the Bureau reconcile inconsistencies in the terminology and requirements of Regulations X and Z. Wherever possible, the Bureau proposed to do so in the TILA-RESPA Proposal. In addition, other relevant comments received in response to the 2011 Streamlining RFI were addressed in the TILA-RESPA Proposal and are addressed below.

D. Small Business Review Panel

In February 2012, the Bureau convened a Small Business Review Panel with the Chief Counsel for Advocacy of the Small Business Administration (SBA) and the Administrator of the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs within the Office of Management and Budget (OMB).
121

As part of this process, the Bureau prepared an outline of the proposals then under consideration and the alternatives considered (Small Business Review Panel Outline), which it posted on its Web site for review by the general public as well as the small entities participating in the panel process.
122

The Small Business Review Panel gathered information from representatives of small lenders, mortgage brokers, settlement agents, and not-for-profit organizations and made findings and recommendations regarding the potential compliance costs and other impacts of the proposed rule on those entities. These findings and recommendations are set forth in the Small Business Review Panel Report, which will be made part of the administrative record in this rulemaking.
123

The Bureau considered these findings and recommendations in preparing the TILA-RESPA Proposal and addressed certain specific examples in the proposal, as well as below in this final rule.

121
The Small Business Regulatory Enforcement Fairness Act of 1996 (SBREFA) requires the Bureau to convene a Small Business Review Panel before proposing a rule that may have a substantial economic impact on a significant number of small entities.
See
Public Law. 104-121, tit. II, 110 Stat. 847, 857 (1996) (as amended by Public Law 110-28, sec. 8302 (2007)).

122
Available at
http://www.consumerfinance.gov/blog/sbrefa-small-providers-and-mortgage-disclosure/
.

123

Final Report of the Small Business Review Panel on CFPB's Proposals Under Consideration for Integration of TILA and RESPA Mortgage Disclosure Requirements
(Apr. 23, 2012), available at
http://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201207_cfpb_report_tila-respa-sbrefa-feedback.pdf
.

In addition, the Bureau held roundtable meetings with other Federal banking and housing regulators, consumer advocacy groups, and industry representatives regarding the Small Business Review Panel Outline. The Bureau considered feedback provided by roundtable participants in preparing the proposal.

E. The Bureau's Proposal

As described above in part II.D, in July 2012, the Bureau proposed for public comment a rule amending Regulation Z to implement sections 1032(f), 1098, and 1100A of the Dodd-Frank Act, which direct the Bureau to combine the mortgage disclosures required under TILA and RESPA.
See
77 FR 51116 (August 23, 2012). Consistent with those provisions, the proposed rule would have applied to most closed-end consumer mortgages. The proposed rule would not have applied to home-equity lines of credit, reverse mortgages, or mortgages secured by a mobile home or by a dwelling that is not attached to real property. The proposed rule also would not have applied to loans made by a creditor who makes five or fewer mortgages in a year. In addition, the proposed rule would have amended portions of Regulation X, for consistency with the proposed amendments to Regulation Z.

As discussed above, to accomplish the Dodd-Frank Act's mandate to combine the disclosures required under TILA and RESPA, the Bureau engaged in extensive consumer and industry research and public outreach for more than a year. Based on that input, the Bureau proposed a rule with new, combined forms. The proposed rule also would have provided a detailed explanation of how the forms should be filled out and used. In developing the proposed forms, the Bureau reconciled the differences between the existing forms and combined several other mandated disclosures.

The first proposed form (the Loan Estimate) was designed to provide disclosures that would be helpful to consumers in understanding the key features, costs, and risks of the mortgage for which they are applying. This form would have been provided to consumers within three business days after they submit a loan application. The Loan Estimate would have replaced two current Federal forms: the RESPA GFE and the early TILA disclosure. The proposed rule and commentary would have contained detailed instructions as to how each line on the Loan Estimate would be completed, and also would have contained sample forms for different types of loan products. In addition, the Loan Estimate would have incorporated new disclosures required under the Dodd-Frank Act. Under the proposed rule, the creditor would have been permitted to rely on a mortgage broker to provide the Loan Estimate, but the creditor also would have remained responsible for the accuracy of the form. The creditor or broker would have been required to give the form to the consumer within three business days after the consumer applies for a mortgage loan, and the proposed rule would have contained a specific definition of what constitutes an “application” for these purposes. The proposed rule would have permitted creditors and brokers to provide consumers with written estimates prior to application, but would have required that any such written estimates contain a disclaimer to prevent confusion with the Loan Estimate.

The second proposed form (the Closing Disclosure) was designed to provide disclosures that would be helpful to consumers in understanding all of the costs of the transaction. This form would have been provided to consumers three business days before they close on the loan. The form would have used clear language and design to make it easier for consumers to locate key information, such as interest rate, monthly payments, and costs to close the loan. The form also would have provided more information to help consumers decide whether they can afford the loan and to compare the cost of different loan offers, including the cost of the loans over time. The proposed Closing Disclosure would have replaced the RESPA settlement statement and the corrected TILA disclosure. The proposed rule and commentary would have contained detailed instructions as to how each line on the Closing Disclosure would be completed. In addition, the Closing Disclosure would have contained additional new disclosures required by the Dodd-Frank Act and a detailed accounting of the settlement transaction.

Under the proposed rule, the creditor would have been required to give consumers the Closing Disclosure at least three business days before the consumer closes on the loan. Generally, if changes occurred between the time the Closing Disclosure is given and the closing, the consumer would have been provided a new form and also would have been given three additional business days to review that form before closing. However, the proposed rule would have contained an exception from the three-business-day requirement for some common changes, such as changes resulting from negotiations between buyer and seller after the final walk-through and for minor changes which result in less than $100 in increased costs. The Bureau proposed two alternatives for who would be required to provide consumers with the Closing

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/fr%3A2013-28210. Public record. Not legal advice.
