# Record and brief — The Lehigh Valley Railroad Company, Appellant, Francis Kearney and Mary F. Tronson

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Aper_scotus_1894_314%3A0

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Record and brief
- **Published:** January 1, 1894

## Text

"SUPREME COUR

+

i ;

OF THE

. OCTOBER TERM

“ar “he

: xy r
: i z :

a . - J

t - . . P a fe, 5 e
* i ’ ‘ * . a ; sam eer 4
« * ‘ye a?
: . j Tae : * f
; / Ps oO eg Pig
‘ ¥ : % Bs a a Sa
» 3 Z a s eg
Z x F : - ee SATS

. . ~ ‘ i
’ 3 : $ é 5

“THE LEHIGH VALLEY RAILRO:

ft

FRANCIS KEARNEY AND MARY.

"s a = ~* sa f ‘ ni
‘ = - 3 » - weg $
: ; ' ag 4 i

‘ i aa Ce 3a +

APPEAL FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF

” THE: DISTRICT OF NEW

¢y aoe
ee 4

we

>

; ee y
oa -

1 ae

C 4 4 aie i

_enens , — — ez

FILED OCTOBER 8, 1891

ie

ig eet 4
as)
ae

‘iia iat
Ye

(14,881.)

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.

OCTOBER TERM, I=S04.

No. 314.

THE LEHIGH VALLEY RAILROAD COMPANY,
APPELLANT,

Us,

FRANCIS KEARNEY AND MARY F. TRONSON.

APPEAL FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
THE DISTRICT OF NEW JERSEY.

INDEX.
Original. Print.
jond on appeal

Petition of appeal
Citation
Proof of service of citation
Bill of complaint
Plea in abatement
Replication. ......
Stipulation to take
Evidence for defendant on plea

Exhibits offered

Testimony of John H. Immen..

Exhibit No. 1—Kearney and Tronson’s acknowledgment

joint ownership and title
No. 2—Immen’s assigninent to Annan
No. 3—Reassignment to Immen...

Order denying motion of complainants to strike out testimony
Further evidence for defendant on plea

Exhibits offered

Jupp & DerwerLer, Prixrgrs, Wasnineton, D. C., Fepruary 16, 1899.

II INDEX.

Evidence for complainants on plea. .... 2.2.26. 0 ee eee ee ee ees
en I 5a. Sik wn Nin w Wine bo CA wa coe ee eee
7 Testimony of Francis Kearney. ............--- 2-02 ce sence ee ees
I:vidence for defendant in rebuttal on plea...............--.0+55--
| nC din ss Swiae eee eee
| Testimony of Andrew McCallum......... 50 derek aaa
Oninion of Judme Nixoti-Of PION ......... 2.2. cc cc cnceeeserbewees
Order overruling plea ....... (CiGde eens > KAk>v eee ee nee eee
ME cs S heicak een tie a. a WER a aaa aunt ple (Swe ae eh eS
Se er ro EO ae Fen erm Peer ty t
Evidence for complainants on bill and answer, «ce.
LRN MIE 6 oda as weet eb ss SS ee MN eck ole ee ae
sestumony of Robert FH. Quimn .. . . 2.6.5 ca ec cee e eset ees ces
PS SNE GS fois ces eect aw swseereneuwnaahes
SOR I, SPUN ib bk es Sek dos cance deh a eee
Francis Kearney ........ Hake saks Dees
Se Ss ek pb uo we eee chee REN eeke eel
Evidence for defendant on bill and answer, &ec. ...... ..........
Testhnony of Alexander Mitchell..........
ee F. TUMOR. os on ck i cecawn dee bes
ee a oi on 65s wha ss pane ee deka sn eneeen
BEOUTOO ©), PAUGICK. 25. cece ccc ek:
Sn re ie kbe hw bo been enh a eee eee
gg Se a eee reer ne
Andrew Reasoner..... . ....... ive nees
es ee as ine oi oe ee hc oa he a ee ee

letters patent No. 113,528, granted ered
and Tronson April 11, 1871.

i'—File-wrapper and contents in the matter of re-
issue letters patent No. 5184, granted Kearney

and Tronson December 10, 1872. ..... be iss
(a—Letters patent No. 2143, granted Wm. W. Hub-

ee es a a kk veh Cha eees
[1—Letters patent No. 17884, granted Ethelred Ma Lv
PR ey SE oir os Shine eee
I—Letters patent No. 33114, granted Jigaen L.
wea Due Oe IEE... coe ck xo xeee ess
K—Letters patent No. 110,315, granted We dane an,
Major & Sample December 20, 1870.........
l.—Letters patent No. 38992, granted Allen §.
murs, oF. Palme Be. PAO we ooo ks ok eke ck
M—Letters patent No. 106,515, granted James
bates Pe BO ONTO... ook Ss kaso eden
\N—Letters patent No. 112,506, granted James
ET SE FUE Lh oo aed wes
Compl'ts’ Exhibit No, 1—Letters patent No. 113,528, granted Kear-
ney and Tronson April 11, 1871........

Reissue letters patent No. 5184, granted
Kearney and Tronson Dec. 10, 1872....

Evidence for complainants in'rebutial .... 06 os kh cies
pestumony of Oscar Dutand ............5..... (vee eases
BO ee re Mires re
RO ts ND hi sb kc ie ee ea eee

Def’ts Exhibit hi —-File-wrapper and contents in the matter of

Original.

32

164

[87

Print.
20
20
21

26

LOS

4
z
¥
;

SRT AS Sat a oo

ats
PUR pear ae TaF

ee tage gS.
Ls yee

uge

ee: CN IT Smart - °
INDEX.
Opinion of Mr. Justice Bradley, September 30, 1887.......... ‘
PIM ROT 8 5 5 es ee i es

Evidence for complainants on accounting... .

Testimony of H. Stanley Goodwin

gonn {. Kimeey...-...2.- 5.

Reuben Van Horn...
Cems BeRee eo SX

William Osborne .........

Lewis J. Lyons......
.. «Pee a
James Turner ........
John Gomer..

William Martin ..........

James M. Jolinson..
Peter Tronson.......
Osceola Currier
Francis Kearney..
Evidence for defendant on accounting... ..

Testimony of Wm. P. Henszey..........
Philip Ae

David Clark

os -

Johy Campbell. ... pie cn

Alexander Mitchell.

“_*e 8 *

é¢, Oe 6 6 6 6. 6-6 OO Ge Oo 8 eee a2 es

Complainants’ Exhibit Kinsey’s Statement of Cost, 8. D. O., M’r,

kebruary 7,
Complainants’ Exhibit
7, 1888—Drawing .

re 6@e 24.2 8 eS

Original.

2}
Anes |
231

ee)
wt aw

245

TIT
Print.
142
146
147
147
153
174
1SO
189
198
200
205
209
212
215
216
222
22)
9097

mrt

yor
24

249
251
22
254
257
260
262
P63
264
270
2/1

‘pre
st 4 hed

274
274
279
275)
28]
289
290
292
297
297
297
298
301
302
303
305
306
306

B07

OO

oe tore

IV INDEX.

Complainants’ Exhibit Lyons Diagram, S. D. O., M’r, December

TE oe oe ae ae a ee ee eee bi
Complainants’ Exhibit Fagin Stack, 8. D. O., M’r, Dee.

Defendant’s Exhibit A—Joln S. Noble, notary cee Pc

No. 1, sworn to by H. Stanley Goodwin

og 2 Se |. err eee ;

B—John 8. Noble, notary public—P hotograph.

(—John 8S. Noble, notary public—P hotograph.

Db—John S. Noble, notary public — Photograph.

Defendant’s Exhibit ‘* Mitchell’s Improved smeared John

S. Noble, notary pane —Drawing........ ioe ea a eens
Defendant’s Exhibit ‘‘ Mitchell’s Spark-arrester, Drawing No. 3,”
John 8. Noble, notary public—Drawing...................22+6-

Defendant’s Exhibit ‘‘ Be Print Spark-arrester,’ S. D. O., M’r,
a A ee Aa a ee ree ree er

Defendant’s Exhibit ‘‘ Camplice,’’ March 22, 1889, S. D. O., M’r—

erg, Si, Chia aig to weal ae wea we wa ee ee ea ae
Defendant’s Exhibit ‘‘ Clark,’’? March 22, 1889, S. D. O., M’r—
es fos ea. ku 4 ws BOW e BAERS MERE COO NEN Oe REN Owen
Defendant's Exhiluit ‘ Mitchell No. 1,’’ March 22, 1889, 8S. D. O.,
5 re See eee eae a gpk ace cag
Defendant’s Exhibit ‘ Hotic ker,” Mareh 22, 1889, S. D. O., Mr—
a a ae eG ei ay bk ae a
Defendant’s Exhibit ‘‘ Klein’s Report,’’ March 22, 1889, 8S. D. O.,
M’r—Letter from Klein to Kinsey, NN Ss og
Defendant’s Exhibit ‘‘Statement of Cost of Diamond Stack,”
Ee a Pe ere re res ge
Defendant’s Exhibit “Statement of Cost of Straight Stack,”
aa, Bee, Peurmary 16, 1800... icc cece: Sper ar eey oy
Defendant's Exhibit ‘* Kinsey Statement of Cost No. 5 a ee

ee ee eee Pe Ee ea Ee
Defendant’s Exhibit ‘‘ Straight Stack,’’ S. D. O., Mr, February 18,
Se hei ne wie EDP ERE ENS ats eg RT eT
Defendant’s Exhibit ‘ Dis amond Stack,” S. D. O., M’r, February 18,
1I890—Drawing .. a a eR i Oe aa
Defendant’s Exhibit ‘‘ Cost of Tron,’’ June 25, IS90, 8S. D. O., M’r
slue-print drawings offered by defendant referred to in Strattan’s
co ae ee ee ee bi me
Blue print showing standard smi rer ace for “> and “Ee”

See Oy es Ge koe ch eee eees Noe Rea ga ORLUEp RAO tek abi OU IB a

Original.

A83
5S 4

500

oy]

SY 9

yd

HOD

O96

yO7

JUS

jy99

HOO

601
O00?

Print.

307
307.

307

307

307

307

307

307

307

307

307

307

ou,

DOT

SOS

»!

5

LEHIGH VALLEY RAILROAD CO. VS. FRANCIS FEARNEY ET AL. 1

| Know all men by these presents that we, The Lehigh Valley

Railroad Company, as principal, and Charles Hartshorne, of
Merion, Pennsylvania, and E. P. Wilbur, of South Bethlehem, Penn-
sylvania, as sureties, are held and firmly bound unto Francis Kear-
ney and Mary F. Trenson in the full and just sum of twelve thou-
sand and five hundred dollars ($12,500) and interest from the 25th
day of September, 1890, to be paid to the said Francis Kearney and
Mary F. Tronson, their certain attorney, executors, administrators,
or assigns; to which payment, well and truly to be made, we bind
ourselves, our successors, heirs, executors, and administrators, jointly
and severally, by these presents.

Sealed with our seals and dated this fourth day of November, in
the year of our Lord one thousand — hundred and ninety.

W hereas lately, at a regular term of the circuit court of the United
States for the district of New Jersey, in a suit depending in said
court between Francis Kearney and Mary F. Tronson, complainants,
and The Lehigh Valley Railroad Company, defendant, a decree was
rendered against the said Lehigh Valley Railroad Company in the
sum of six thousand two hundred and thirty-five dollars and fifty-
two cents ($6,255.52), and the said Lehigh Valley Railroad Com-
pany having obtained an order of appeal and filed a copy thereof
in the clerk’s office of the said court to reverse the decree in the
aforesaid suit, and a citation directed to the said Francis Kearney
and Mary F. Tronson, citing and admonishing them to be and ap-

pear at a Supreme Court of the United States to be holden
2 at Washington on the second Monday of October next:
Now, the condition of the above obligation is such that if
the said Lehigh Valley Railroad Company shall prosecute said ap-
peal to effect and answer all damages and costs if it fails to make
its plea good, then the above obligation to be void; else to remain
in full force and virtue.
LEHIGH VALLEY RAILROAD COMPANY,
By CHAS. HARTSHORNE, Vice-President. [1. s.]

Attest ~ JNO. R. FANSHAWE, Secretary. |
CHAS. HARTSHORNE. L. 8.
E. P. WILBUR. L. S. |

Sealed and delivered in presence of—
. G. BAIRD.
FP. H. JANVIER.

Approved by—
EDW. T. GREEN, Judge.

November 4th, 1890.

(Endorsed:) United States cireuit court, district of New Jersey.
In equity. The Lehigh Valley Railroad Company, appellant, vs.
Francis Kearney and Mary F. Tronson, appellees. Bond on appeal.
Filed November 4, 1890.

1—314 '

2 THE LEHIGH VALLEY RAILROAD CO. VS.

3 United States Circuit Court, District of New Jersey. In
Equity.

THe Lenigh VaLitey RartLroap Company, Appellant,
VS. >
Francis Kearney and Mary F. Tronson, Appellee-.

The petition of The Lehigh Valley Railroad Company, the appel-
lant in the above-stated cause, respectfully shows that your peti-
tioner finds itself aggrieved by a final decree made in the circuit
court of the United States for the third circuit and district of New
Jersey, bearing date the twenty-fifth day of September, A. D. eighteen
hundred and ninety,in a cause therein depending, wherein Francis
Kearney and Mary F. Tronson were complainants and the said
The L ehigh Valley Railroad Company: is defendant, and hereby
appeals therefrom to the Supreme Court of the United States.

Your petitioner therefore prays that the said final decree may be
reversed, set aside, and for nothing holden, and that your petitioner
may have such relief and decree in the premises as to your honora-
ble court may seem meet.

ANDREW McCALLUM,
Solicitor, &e.

(Endorsed :) United States circuit —, district of New Jersey. In
equity. The Lehigh Valley Railroad Company, appellant, vs.
Francis Kearney and Mary F. Tronson, appellees. Petition of ap-
peal. Andrew McCallum, solicitor. Allowed November 4, 1890.
Edw. T. Green, J. Service acknowledged Nov. 17, 1890, for Francis
Kearney & Mary F. Tronson. Elwood C. Harris, sol’r. Filed No-
vember 4, 1890. S. D. Oliphant, clerk.

| By the Honorable Edward T. Green, one of the judges of the
eireult court of the United States for the district of New
Jersey.

To Francis Kearney and Mary i’. Tronson:

Whereas the Lehigh Valley Railroad Company has lately ap-
peated to the Supreme Court of the United States from a decree
lately rendered in the cireuit court of the United States for the
district of New Jersey, made in favor of you, the said Francis Kear-
ney and Mary F. Tronson, and _ has filed the security required by
law, you are therefore hereby cited to appear before the said Su-
preme Court, at the city of Washington, on the second Monday of
October next, to do and receive what may appertain to justice to be
done in the premises.

Given under my hand, at Trenton, in said district, this fourth day
of November, A. D. 1890.

EDW. T. GREEN, J.

Vi-

Gi;

FRANCIS KEARNEY ET AL. 3

4} | Endorsed :] Supreme Court of the United States. The

Lehigh Valley Railroad Company, appellant, vs. Francis
Kearney and Mary F. Tronson, appellees. Citation. Service of
within citation acknowledged this November 17, 1890, for Francis
Kearney and Mary F. Tronson, appellees. Elwood C. Harris, sol’r.

5 United States Circuit Court, District of New Jersey.
FRANCIS KEARNEY and Mary F. TRoNson
vs. In Equity.
THe LeniGgH VALLEY RAILROAD COMPANY.
Bill of Complaint.
(Filed March 15, 1883.)

In the Circuit Court of the United States for the District of New
Jersey.

To the honorable the judges of the circuit court of the United States
for the district of New Jersey, sitting in equity:

francis Kearney and Mary F. Tronson, executrix of the last will
of Luke F. Tronson, deceased, both of the city of Newark, in the

State of New Jersey, and citizens of the State of New Jersey, bring

this their bill of complaint, against the Lehigh Valley Rail-
6 road Company, a corporation formed under the laws of Penn-
sylvania, and doing business in the State of New Jersey and
elsewhere; aiid thereupon, vour orators complain and say that here-
tofore Francis Kearney and Luke F. Tronson, being then citizens
of the United States, and residents of the State of New Jersey, were
the original and first and joint inventors of certain new and useful
improvements in spark-arresters for locomotives, fully described in
the letters patent hereinafter mentioned, and which had not been
known or used before their said invention thereof; and that the
said Francis Kearney and Luke F. Tronson did, on the 11th day
of April, 1871, upon due application therefor, obtain letters patent of
the United States for said invention, in due form of law, under the
seal of the Patent Office of the United States, signed by the Secre-
tary of the Interior and countersigned by the Commissioner of Pat-
ents of the United States, bearing date the 11th aay of April, 1871,
and numbered 113,528, whereby there was granted and secured to
the said Francis Kearney and Luke F. Tronson, their executors,
administrators or assigns, for the term of seventeen years from and
after the date of said letters patent, the full and exclusive nght and
liberty of making, using and vending to others, to be used, the said
invention and improvements, which said letters patent are now re-
maining of record in the Patent Office of the United States.

And your orators further show unto your honors that the said
l'rancis Kearney, one of your orators, atid the said Luke F. Tronson,
for good and lawful cause surrendered said letters patent to the
Commissioner of Patents; and having made due application there-

4 THE LEHIGH VALLEY RAILROAD CO. VS.

for and having in all things complied with the acts of Congress, in
such cases nade and previded for, did, on the 10th day of Decem-
ber, 1872, obtain new letters patent therefor, being for the same in-
vention, for the residue of said term; and which were marked “ re-
issue,” No. 5184, and dated the 10th day of December, 1872, and
were issued in due form of law, under the seal of the Patent Office

of the United States, signed by the Secretary of the Interior
7 and countersigned by the Commissioner of Patents, as will

appear by the last-mentioned letters patent now remaining
of record in the Patent Office; a duly certified copy whereof your
orators pray leave to refer to, as a part of this their bill.

And your orators further show unto your honors, that thereafter
and on the 9th day of November, 1877, the said Luke F. Tronson
departed this life, leaving a widow, your orator, Mary F. Tronson,
and three children, and leaving a will, and upon due and proper
application and proceeding of law said will was admitted to probate,
and your said orator, Mary F. Tronson, the executrix named in said
will, was duly authorized to take upon herself the administration of
the estate of the said Luke F. Tronson, under said will as will more
fally appear by the certificate of administration granted to your
orator, Mary T°. Tronson, and a copy of said will in court to be pro-
duced.

And your orators show unto your honors that by virtue of the
premises and said will they became, and now are, the sole and ex-
clusive owners of the said letters patent, hereinbefore recited, and of
the inventions therein described, and of all the rights and privileges
granted and secured thereby. And that your orator, Francis Kear-
ney, and the said Luke F. Tronson, before his death, were at great
expense and trouble in and about said invention, for the purpose of
having the same manufactured and tested, and used, and making
the same profitable to themselves and useful to the public, and that
said invention is of great benefit and advantage.

Yet the defendant, well knowing the premises and the rights se-
cured to your orators aforesaid, but continuing to injure your orators
and deprive them of their benefits and advantages, which might and
otherwise would accrue to them from said invention, after the issu-
ing of said letters patent, and before the commencement of this suit,
has made and used, and caused to be made and used, spark-arrest-

ers for locomotives, at Jersey City, in said district of New
8 Jersey, and at other places in the district of New Jersey, and

divers other parts of the United States. And that said man-
ufacture and use of spark-arresters for locomotives has been and is
without the license or consent, and against the will of your orators,
and in violation of their rights, and in infringement of the afore-
said letters patent; and that said unlawful acts and infringements
have been committed by the defendant with the full knowledge of
the rights of your orators, and in defiance of their rights; and that
said defendant, since the issuing and reissuing of said letters patent,
as aforesaid, and before the commencement of this suit. has manu-
factured spark-arresters for locomotives, or caused them to be man-
ufactured, under the direction of its officers and workmen, and has

ee eee Lt

tr

FRANCIS KEARNEY ET AL. 5

on hand now, and is using in the district of New Jersey, spark-
arresters for locomotives, made according to, and employing and
containing and embodying the invention and improvement, and
substantial and material parts of the invention deseribed and
claimed in said letters patent; and that said defendant is threaten-
ing to cause to be made and used the said spark-arresters, for loco-
motives, to the injury and damage of vour orators.

And your orators further show unto your honors, on information
and belief, that said defendant has made a large number of said
spark-arresters for locomotives, and used the same, and have a large
number on hand, which they are using, and have realized large
profits and advantages therefrom; but to what extent and how
much, exactly, your orators do not know, and pray a discovery
thereof; and your orators say that the use of said invention, by said
defendant, and its preparation for and avowed determination to
continue the same, and its other aforesaid unlawful acts, in disre-
gard and defiance of the rights of your orators, have the effect to
encourage and induce others to venture to infringe said patents, in
disregard of your orators’ rights.

And your orators further say, that they have caused notice to be

given to said defendant of said infringements, and the rights
9 of your orators in the premises, and requested it to desist

and refrain therefrom; but it has disregarded said notice
and request, and refused to desist from said infringement, in disre-
gard of vour orators’ aforesaid rights.

And forasmuch as your orators can have no adequate relief ex-
cept in this court, to the end, therefore, that the said defendant may,
if it can, show why your orators should not have the relief hereby
prayed, and may upon corporal oath and according to its best and
utmost knowledge, remembrance, information and belief, full, true,
direct and perfect answers make to the premises, and to all the sey-
eral matters hereinbefore stated and charged, as fully and particu-
larly as if severally and separately interrogated as to each and
every of said matters, and may be compelled to account for and pay
to your orators the profits by it acquired, and the damages suffered
by your orators from the aforesaid unlawful acts.

And your orators pray that said defendant, its officers, servants,
agents, attorneys and workmen, and each and every of them, may
be restrained and enjoined provisionally and perpetually by the
order and injunction of this honorable court from directly or indi-
rectly making, constructing, using, vending, delivering, working, or
putting into practice, operation or use, or in anywise counterfeiting
or imitating the said invention, or any part thereof,-or any spark-
arresters for locomotives made in accordance therewith, or like or
similar to those which it has heretofore made and used; and that
the said defendant may be decreed to pay the costs of this suit, and
that your orators may have such further relief, or such other relief,
as to this honorable court shall seem meet, and as shall be agreeable
to equity.

May it please your honors to grant unto your orators the writ of
injunction, as well provisional as perpetual, issuing out of and

nn
EL Lg a ee 4

TA We aie Ari actos 1c

6 THE LEHIGH VALLEY RAILROAD CO. VS.

under the seal of this honorable court, commanding, enjoining and
restraining the said defendant, The Lehigh Valley Railroad Com-
pany, and its officers, servants, agents, attorneys and workmen, and

each and every of them, as is hereinbefore in that behalf

prayed. |
10 May it please your honors to grant unto your orators the
writ of subpeena issuing out of and under the seal of this hon-
orable court, directed to the said defendant, The Lehigh Valley
Railroad Company, commanding it, by a certain day and under a
certain penalty, to be and appear in this honorable court, then and
there to answer the premises, and to stand to and abide such order
and decree as may be made against. it.
And your orators will ever pray, &e.
FRANCIS KEARNEY.
MARY F. TRONSON,
Krecutria, de.
COCHRANE & MALCOMSON,
Compls’ Sol’rs.
A. BELL MALCOMSON, Jr.,
Counsel for Compl ts.

Unitrep STrates OF AMERICA, }
. o . 1 SN
District of New Jersey, |

On this twenty-ninth day of January, 1883, before me personally
appeared J*rancis Kearney and Mary F. Tronson, the above-named
complainants, who, being by me first duly sworn, depose and say
that they have read the foregoing biil of complaint subscribed by
them and know the contents thereof, and that the same is true of
their own knowledge, except as to the matters therein stated on in-
formation and belief, and as to these matters they believe it to be
true.

FRANCIS KEARNEY.
MARY F. TRONSON.,

Subseribed and sworn to before me this twenty-ninth day of Jan-

uary, 1885.
ARAM G. SAYRE,
[u. s.] Notary Public, Newark, N. J.

1] Plea in Abatement.

(Filed June 1, 1883.)

The plea of the Lehigh Valley Railroad Company to the bill of

complaint of Francis Kearney and Mary F. Tronson, complain-
ants.

The defendant by protestation, not confessing or acknowledging

all or any of the matters and things in said complainants’ bill men-
tioned to be true, in such mannerand form as the same are therein

;

SR ETE sy

Mb =

FRANCIS KEARNEY ET At. 7

or thereby set forth and alleged, does plead thereunto, and for plea
says:

That at the time this suit was commenced, and prior thereto, the
said complainants, Francis Kearney and Mary F. Tronson, were not
the sole and exclusive owners of the letters patent set forth in the
bill of complaint, but that the said patent was then owned by the
complainants jointly with one John H. Immen, of Newark, in the
State of New Jersey, each of said parties having an equal undivided
one-third interest in said letters patent, and this the said defendant
is ready to verify.

W herefore, the defendant prays the judgment of the court whether
it ought to be compelled to make any answer to said bill of com-
plaint, and that it may be hence dismissed with its reasonable costs.

ANDREW McCALLUM,
Solicitor for Defendant.

[ certify that in my opinion the above plea is well founded in
point of law.

ANDREW McCALLUM.

STATE OF PENNSYLVANIA, | =
" . . . SS -
County of Philadelphia, |

H. Stanley Goodwin, being duly sworn, deposes and says that he
is the general superintendent of The Lehigh Valley Railroad

12 Company, defendant in the above suit; that the said plea is
not interposed for delay, and that it is true in point of fact,

H. STANLEY GOODWIN.

Sworn to and subscribed before me this twenty-ninth day of May,
1883.
WM. C. ALDERSON,
Notary Public.

Replication.
(Filed July 7, 1883.)

The replication of Francis Kearney and Mary F. Tronson, com-

we

plainants, to the plea of The Lehigh Valley Railroad, defendant.

These repliants, saving and reserving unto themselves all and all
manner of benefit and advantage of exception which may be had or
taken to the manifold insufficiencies of the said plea, for replication
thereto, say that they will aver, maintain, and prove their said bill
of complaint to be true, certain and sufficient in law to be answered
unto, and that the said plea of the said defendant is uncertain, un-
true and insufficient to be replied unto by these repliants. Without
this, that any other matter or thing whatsoever in the said plea con-
tained, material or effectual in the law to be replied unto, and not
herein and hereby well and sufficiently replied unto, confessed or
avoided, traversed or denied, is true. All which matters and things.
these repliants are and will be ready to aver, maintain, and prove,

§ THE LEHIGH VALLEY RAILROAD CO. YS.

as this honorable court shall direct, and humbly pray as in and by
their said bill they have already prayed.
COCHRANE & MALCOMSON,

( omplamants’ Nolicitors.

13 Stipulation to Take lestimony On Plea.

»

(Filed July 24, 1883.)
John Cochrane. A. Bell Maleomson. Jr.

Offices of Cochrane & Malcomson, counsellors-at-law and advocates
in patent causes (Vanderbilt building), 152 Nassau street.

NEW York, July 21, 1888.

KEARNEY et al.
PS

LEHIGH VALLEY R. R. }

It is hereby agreed that the testimony in this case, on issues joined,
be taken for both sides, at the office of MeCarter & Williamson, at
Newark, N. J.,on the Ist day of September, 1583, at 10 o’elock a. m.,
and that the cause shall go upon the calendar for the September

term.
A. McCALLUM, Solicitor for Def’d’t.
COCHRANE & MALCOMSON,
NSolicitor- for Comp ts.
; Testimony.

(Filed September 3, 1883.)

Testimony taken in the above-entitled cause, pursuant to an agree-
ment of counsel, a copy of which is hereto annexed, this first day
of September, in the vear eighteen hundred and eighty-three, be-
fore John R. Hardin, a notary public, of the State of New Jersey,
in the presence ot lf raneis Kearney, pe r pe rsonam., and Oliver

Drake, of counsel with complainants, and Andrew McCallum, of

eounsel with the defendant.

14 Counsel for defendant offers in evidence the following writ-
ten instruments: :

A power of attorney and acknowledgment of joint ownership in
letters patent number 115,558, granted to Francis Kearney and
Luke F. ‘Tronson, dated April 11, 1871, for improvements in spark-
arresters for locomotives, instrument being dated Newark, April 10,
LS73,and signed by F. Kearney and Luke F. Tronson, and recorded
in United States Patent Office, July 2, 1875, in Liber V 16, page
289. of Transters otf Patents. Said instrument is marked Detend-
ant’s Exhibit No. 1, Kearney & Tronson’s acknowledgment of John
H. Immen’s joint ownership and title. John R. Hardin, notary

publie, N. J.

~~

ae

FRANCIS KEARNEY ET AL. g

Assignment of Immen’s interest in said patent from John H. Im-
men to William G. Annan, dated April 28, 1874. Recorded April

30, 1874, in Liber V 17, page ant, of Transfers of Patents, and

marked Defendant’s Exhibit No. 2, of Immen’s assignment to Annan.
John R. Hardin, notary public, N. J.

Reassigument of said interest in said patent from William G.
Annan to John H. Immen, dated June 22,1875. Recorded in Liber
W 29, page 198, of Transfers of Patents, marked Defendant’s Ex-
hibit No. 3, of reassignment to Immen. John R. Hardin, notary
public, N. J.

Counsel for defendant, having asked Mr. Francis Kearney if that
was his signature to Exhibit No. 1, he acknowledged that it was.

JoHN H. IMMeEN, a witness for the defence, being sworn, saith—

That he is 52 years of age, and resides in Newark, N. J., and is in
the machinery business.

Quest. Do you know the complainants in this case, or either of
them ?

Ans. I do.

Quest. Did you know the late Mr. Luke F. Tronson ?

Ans. I did.

Quest. Are you familiar with his handwriting, and also with that

of Francis Kearney ?
15 Ans. I am with both.

Quest. Please examine Defendant’s Exhibit No. 1, now
shown you, and state if the signatures thereto are that of the said
I'rancis Kearney and Luke F. Tronson.

Ans. I saw them sign that instrument.

(Juest. Are you the John H. Immen mentioned in said instru-
ment?

Ans. I am.

(Juest. Was it signed in your presence on the date thereof?

Ans. It was.

Quest. Do you know Mr. William G. Annan, of the city of New
York?

Ans. I do.

(Quest. Please examine Defendant’s Exhibit No. 2, and state if the
signature of John H. Immen thereto is in your handwriting.

Ans. I acknowledge that to be my signature.

Quest. Please examine Defendant’s Exhibit No. 3, and state, if
you know, in whose handwriting it is, and if the signature thereto
is genuine.

Ans. That instrument is wholly in the handwriting of Mr. Wil-
liam G. Annan, and his signature is known to me to be genuine.

Cross-examined by Mr. DRAKE:

Quest. Have you any other paper or was any other paper executed
at the time or prior to the paper marked Defendant’s Exhibit No. 1,
conveying to you any interest in the patent in suit?

(Objected to by defendant’s counsel as immaterial.)

2—-314

10 THE LEHIGH VALLEY RAILROAD CO. Vs.

Ans. I have no other paper, and none, no one, conveying any in-
terest.

Quest. Was there any agreement, written or otherwise, entered
into between you and Messrs. Kear ney and Tronson other than that
marked Defendant’s Exhibit No. 1?

(Same objection by defendant’s counsel.)
Ans. There was an agreement or contract made by Kearney and

Tronson.
16 Quest. When was that agreement made and where is it?

(Same objection.)

Ans. The agreement was made the fifth of April, in the year
eighteen hundred and seventy-two.

At this time a telegram was received by counsel for defendant,
from A. Bell Maleolmson, attorney of record for complainants, stating
that he would be present in half an hour and to wait further pro-
ceedings.

Mr. Malcolmson appeared and declined to go on, stating that he
had been out of town and was under the impression that the exam-
ination was at eleven o'clock, instead of ten; that feeling he might
not be here promptly at eleven, he telegraphed asking that the ex-
amination should wait for his arrival: that he is now willing to
commence the examination in this case and offers counsel to do so,
and refuses to accept as a part of the record in this case anything
that has been written down before his arrival.

Counsel for defendant says that the testimony for defendant on
the issue Joined has been all taken, and if counsel for complainant
has no further questions to ask the record will be closed.

Counsel for complainant states that if the foregoing means that
counsel for defendant intends to attempt to use any matter written
down by the person now writing this as testimony in this case and
does not propose to now commence examination and begin a record
in the presence of counsel for both parties as stipulated between
counsel for respective parties, then he will disown the stipulation as
to the taking of testimony here today, and claim that such writing
is not in any sense testimony for either party taken in good faith
under and in pursuance of such stipulation.

Counsel for defendant states that he has got through with the tes-
timony-in-chief for defendant under the issue joined, and has asked
the counsel for complainant to cross-examine the witness if he desires
to do so. He now states that he is ready to attend the taking of any

testimony on behalf of the complainant, and asks ‘counsel

17 for complainant if he proposes taking any such testimony.
Counsel for complainant states that the counsel for defend-
ant has not answered his question, which is: “ Will you now com-
mence the examination and taking of testimony in this case, as
agreed between us at the time we personally conversed in relation
to the matter and made the arrangement to meet here and take
such testimony, or do you insist upon attempting to use matter

Ce eee

FRANCIS KEARNEY ET AL. ll

which has been written down in my absence under your individual
direction?” Until this question is answered I have nothing fur-
ther to say, and know nothing about any testimony or any wit-
nesses to cross-examine.

Counsel for defendant states that he has already taken the testi-
mony for the defendant as agreed upon, and does not propose to
take it a second time, and will submit the same to the court as the

hearing of the case.
JOHN H. IMMEN.

and subscribed before me this first day of September,

Sworn
A. D. 1883.
[L. s.] JOHN R. HARDIN,
Notary Public, N. J.

Copy of Telegram.
SEPTEMBER Ist, 1885.
Received at Earey’s, 180 and 182 Market street.
Dated New York 1.
To Andrew McCailum, care Williamson & McCarter:
I will be with you in half an hour; wait.

A. BELL MALCOMSON.

Oftices of Cochrane & Malcomson, counsellors-at-law and advocate’
in patent causes (Vanderbilt building), 132 Nassau street.

New York, July 21st, 1883.

KEARNEY ef al. )
\
Us

LEHIGH VALLEY R. R. J

It is hereby agreed that the testimony in this case, on
18 issue joined, be taken for both sides at the office of McCarter
& Williamson, at Newark, N. J.,on the Ist day of Septem-
ber, 1883, at 10 o’clock a. m., and that the cause shall go upon the

calendar for the September term.
(Signed) A. McCALLUM,
Solicitor for Defendant.

COCHRANE & MALCOMSON,
Solicitors for Complainants.
810 Broad St.

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, | _
wy woe = $8:
District of New Jersey,

[, John R. Hardin, a notary public of the State of New Jersey,
and duly qualified under the laws of the United States to take dep-
ositions for use in the courts of the United States, do hereby certify
that on the day named in the depositions hereto annexed, I was
attended at Newark, New Jersey, by the counsel and witness afore-

|

12 THE LEHIGH VALLEY RAILROAD CO. VS.

said. That the said witness was duly sworn and examined, and
the deposition was reduced to writing and read to the witness, and

by him subscribed in my presence; and that exhibits, on behalf of

the defendant, Nos. 1, 2 and 3 were introduced in evidence in said
cause.

In testimony whereof, I have hereto set my hand and notarial
seal, this first day of September, A. D. eighteen hundred and eighty-
three.

JOHN R. HARDIN,
[ SEAL. | | Notary Public, N. J.

DEFENDANTS EXHIBITS.

DEFENDANTS Exupitr No. 1. KEARNEY & TRONSON’s ACKNOWL-
EDGMENT OF JOINT OWNERSHIP AND TITLE.

To whom it may concern:
19 This certifies that John H. Immen is fully authorized and
empowered to make any contract with the Central Railroad

of New Jersey, that may be binding on our part, for the sale of the
patent right ou spark-arrester, as secured to us by letters patent No.
113,528, dated April 11th, 1871, and reissue No. 5184, dated Decem-
ber 10th, 1872, he having one-third equal interest with ourselves in
the said patent.

Fr. KEARNEY.

LUKE F. TRONSON.

Newark, April 10th, 1873.

Received for record July Ju/y 2d, 1873, and recorded in Liber
V 16, page 289, of Transfers of Patents.
In testimony whereof, I have caused the seal of the Patent Office
to be hereunto affixed.
[L. s.] J. M. THACHER,
Acting Commissioner.

Ex’d: R. H. E.

DEFENDANT'S Exuibit No. 2, or IMMEN’s ASSIGNMENT TO ANNAN.
Assignment.

Whereas, Francis Kearney and Luke F. Tronson, of Newark, New
Jersey, did obtain letters patent of the United States of America, for
certain improvements in spark-arresters for locomotives, which let-
ters patent bear date the tenth day of December, eighteen hundred
and seventy-two, and are numbered 5184, reissue; original patent
granted April 11, 1871, and surrendered ;

And whereas, on April 10, 1873, said Kearney and Tronson sold
and assigned one-third of said patent to me, which assignment is
recorded in Liber V 16, page 289, of Transfers of Patents; and
whereas, it is my Intention to transfer my interest to William G.
Annan, he being desirous of acquiring an interest therein :

:

2 TRE tgntP lace rg ay anak Sag ase»

Lie

FRANCIS KEARNEY ET AL. 13

20 Now, this indenture witnesseth, that for and in considera-

tion of the sum of one hundred and fifty dollars, to me, John
H. Immen, in hand paid. the receipt of which is hereby acknowl-
edged, I have assigned, sold, and set over, and do hereby assign,
sell, and set over, unto the said William G. Annan, of New York,
all the right, title, and interest which I have in and to the said in-
vention, as secured to us by said letters patent.

The same to be held and enjoyed by the said William G. Annan
for his own use and behoof, and for the use and behoof of his legal
representatives, to the full end of the term for which said letters
patent are granted, as fully and entirely as the same would have
been held and enjoyed by me if this assignment and sale had not
been made.

In testimony whereof, I hereunto set my hand and affix my seal
this 28th day of April, 1874.

JNO. H. IMMEN. [1.s.]

Sealed and delivered in the presence of—
CHAS. DE KAY TOWNSEND.

Received for record April 30, 1874, and recorded in Liber V 17,
page 246, of Transfers of Patents.
[In testimony whereof, I have caused the seal of the Patent Office
to be hereunto affixed.
[L. s.] J. M. THACHER,
Acting Commissioner.
Ex’d: M. A. L.

DEFENDANT’s Exuipir No. 3, oF REASSIGNMENT TO IMMEN.

Know all men by these presents:

That I, William G. Annan, of the city of New York, in consider-
ation of the sum of one dellar to me in hand paid by John H. Im-
men, of Newark, New Jersey, do hereby grant, bargain, sell, assign,

transfer and set over to him, his heirs or assigns, all my
21 right, title and interest of, in and to certain letters patent for
improvement in spark-arresters for locomotives, letters patent
No. 113,528, dated April 11th, 1871; reissue No. 5184, dated Decem-
ber 10th, 1872, granted to Francis Kearney and Luke F. Tronson.

Witness my hand June 22d, 1875.

WM. G. ANNAN.

[In presence of—

WM. C. CLIFFORD.

Received for record, May 16th, 1883, and recorded in Liber W 29,
page 198, of Transfers of Patents.
In testimony whereof I have caused the seal of the Patent Office
to be hereunto affixed.
kK. M. MARBLE,

[L. s.] Commissioner.

terre? Fed.

14 THE LEHIGH VALLEY RAILROAD CO. VS.
22 Circuit Court of the United States, District of New Jersey.
Francis KEARNEY ef al. )

Us. -In Equity.

Tue Lewigh VALLEY Rartroap Company. }

~ The complainant having this 17th day of September, 1883, moved
to strike from the record certain testimony taken at Newark on the
Ist day of September, 1883, said motion is denied, the said com-
plainant, however, to have the right to except to any part of the

record and to cross-examine the witnesses.
JNO. T. NIXON, J.

[Endorsed:] U.S. circuit court, district of New Jersey. Francis
Kearney et al. vs. Lehigh Valley R. Co. Order denying motion, Xe.
Andrew McCallum, sol’r for def’t. Filed Sept. 17, 1883. 8. D. Oli-
phant, clerk.

Examination of witness produced, sworn, and examined be-
fore S. D. Oliphant, Esq., commissioner, at his office, in the
Government building, Trenton, New Jersey, September
26th, 1883.

Present: Mr. S. D. Oliphant, commissioner; Mr. Malcolmson, for
complainant; Mr. McCallum, for defendant.

Counsel for the defendant reopens the record taken September Ist,
1885, for the purpose of affording counsel for complainant an op-
portunity to state objections to the same, if he has any to make, and
also recalls the witness, John H. Immens, for the purpose of afford-
ing counsel for the complainant an opportunity to cross-examine.

Counsel for complainant states that he has filed his objections to
an examination had by the defendant, before a notary public, on the
first of September; that he again repeats his objection to the same,
and states that he will insist at the hearing that no such examtna-
tion or statements, made before the notary public, can be used as
testimony in this case; that he is here now, under the notice from
defendant’s solicitor, that he would proceed to take testimony in
support of the plea in abatement in this case, and he is ready to
proceed with the taking of such testimony.

Counsel for defendant says that under the order of the court of
the 17th of September, 1885, he has opened the record therein re-
ferred to, for the purpose of counsel for complainant stating any ob-
jections, or taking any exceptions thereto, and he has also recalled
the witness, Immens, for the purpose of cross-examination. If
counsel for complainant has no exceptions to note, or questions to
put to the witness in cross-examination, the said record will be

again closed.
Counsel for the complainant states that he knows of no record in
this case to be reopened, unless the alleged examination and
24 proceedings before a notary public, as referred to, and as such
proceedings were excepted to at the time they were taken,

s

eh SABRI a, Aaa

Sapa, ike

~~

FRANCIS KEARNEY ET AL. 15

and all that was done before such notary public was done in the
absence of complainant’s counsel, he does not acknowledge any rec-
ord in this case up to the present time, or at least up to the opening
of the examination today. That the witness, Immens, being now
present, he is ready to cross-examine him on any subject counsel for
defendant may call upon him to testify in relation to.

(Defendant’s counsel offers in evidence a paper marked “ Francis
Kearney and Mary F. Tronson against The Lehigh Valley Rail-
road Company. Defendant’s Exhibit No. 1, Kearney and Tron-
son’s acknowledgement of joint ow nership and title. John R.
Harden, notary public, RF ag

(Also, a paper marked “ Francis Kearney and Mary F. Tronson
against The Lehigh Valley Railroad Company. Defendant’s Ex-
hibit No. 2, of Immens’ assignment to Amman. John R. Hardin,
notary public, N. J.”)

(Also, a paper m: ntl SP “Francis Kearney and Mary F. Trofison
fibres The Lehigh Valley Railroad Company. Defendant’s Ex-
hibit No. 3, reassignment to Immens. John R. Hardin, notary
public, N. J.”)

JoHn H. IMMENs, a witness produced on the part of the defence,
being duly sworn according to law deposeth and saith:

Direct examination by Mr. McCatium:

Quest. Please state your name, age, residence and occupation.

Ans. Age, fifty-two; machinery business; residence, Newark,
N. J.; name, John H. Immens.

Quest. Do you know the complainants in this case, or either of
them ”

Ans. I do, both of them.

Quest. Did you know the late Luke F. Tronson ?

Ans. I did.

Quest. Are you familiar with his handwriting, and also with that

of Francis Kearney ?

25 Ans. Lam.

Quest. Please examine Defendant’s Exhibit No. 1, now
shown you, and state if the signatures thereto are those of the said
Francis Kearney and Luke F. Tronson.

Ans. I saw them execute this instrument; the body of it is in
mv handwriting.

Quest. Are you the John H. Immens mentioned in said instru-
ment?

Ans. I am.

Quest. Was it signed in your presence on the date thereof ?

Ans. It was signed in my presence on the date named in the in-
strument.

Quest. Do you know Mr. William G. Annam of New York?

Ans. I do.

Quest. Please examine Defendant’s Exhibit No. 2, and state if the
signature of John H. Immens is your own signature.

16 THE LEHIGH VALLEY RAILROAD CO. VS.

Ans. I acknowledge that to be my signature. ;

Quest. Do you know Mr. Annam’s handwriting?

Ans. I do.

Quest. Please examine Defendant’s Exhibit No. 3 and state if that :
is signed by William G. Annam.

Ans. That is Mr. Annam’s signature, and the body is in his hand-
writing.

Quest. The whole instrument is written by him?

Ans. Yes, sir.

Quest. Except the witness’ signature?

Ans. Yes, sir.

Cross-examined by Mr. MALCOLMSON :

Quest. What is Mr. William G. Annam’s business?

Ans. His business is in connection with an eastern manufactur-
ing concern; it is in the granite business; he was formerly of the
firm of Nichols, Thurston & Annam.

Quest. What was their business?

Ans. Lawyers.

Quest. What was his business at the time of these Exhibits 2

and 3 being made out?
26 Ans. He was secretary, also, of the Eagle Slate Company,
of which Mr. Nichols was president.

Quest. Was he not a lawyer at that time?

Ans. Yes, sir.

Quest. How did you come to know about this suit?

(The question is objected to by defendant’s counsel on the ground
that it is irrelevant and immaterial.)

Ans. Mr. Kearney informed me during the month of April.
Quest. How soon after that did you see anybody connected with
or representing the defendant ?

(Same objection.)

Ans. That was after I returned.

Quest. Returned from where?

Ans. From my trip through Pennsylvania.

Quest. What time—what month ?

Ans. During the month of April.

Quest. This vear ?

Ans. This year.

Quest. Who was it you saw representing the defendant?

(Same objection.)

Ans. I ealled on Mr. Mitchell.
Quest. Who is Mr. Mitchell, and why did you call on him ?
Ans. He is superintendent of the Wyoming and the Delaware
and Lehigh Valley Railroad Company.
Quest. Whereabouts is he?
Ans. At Wilkes Barre. 2

FRANCIS KEARNEY ET AL. 17

Quest. State what took place between you and Mr. Mitchell in
relation to this suit.

(Same objection.)

Ans. I called on Mr. Mitchell and introduced myself; he took
me with him to the shops and showed to me the device that he was
using, and also stated to me that there was a suit in progress and a
hearing was then about to take place, or had taken place, at Tren-
ton; I stated to him that I was a one-third owner of the patent;
that is all.

Quest. Please state for what purpose you went to see Mr. Mitch-

ell.
(Same objection.)

27 Ans. Mr. Kearney, some time last fall, asked me to take a

trip up, and see what they were using up there, and he called

my attention to some of the engines that were in Jersey City as
having a device similar to this.

Quest. Have you made any writing or transfers in relation to this

0

patent since that time?
(Same objection.)

Ans. I have.

(Juest. State what interest or alleged interest, and who to?

Ans. I assigned my interest to the Lehigh Valley Railroad Com-
pany.

Quest. Had you any otber writing with Kearney and Tronson,
besides the writing, Exhibit No. 1?

(Same objection.)

Ans. I had a previous contract with them, but that had ex-
pired.

Quest. What was its date ?

Aus. The 5th of April, 1872; that expired on the 5th of April,
1873.

Quest. Is that the paper which you have just had in your hand ?

Ans. Yes, sir; the agreement or contract.

Quest. Is that the original copy, which you were just looking at,
and which Mr. McCallum has now?

Ans. That is the original document.

(Counsel for complainant asked counsel for defendant to permit
the commissioner to make a copy of said original document, so that
it may be a part of this record, and the commissioner to certify
that such copy is a true copy of the original now present and referred
to by the witness. )

(Counsel for defendant has no objections to a copy being made,
but objects to the admissibility of the document in evidence, as
being under cross-examination, entirely irrelevant and immaterial
to the present issue.)

3—314

18 : THE LEHIGH VALLEY RAILROAD CO. YS.

Quest. Please read to the commissioner the said writing referred
to by you in your last three answers.

(Same objection.)
Ans. Witness read as follows:

28 Articles of agreement had, made, concluded and agreed
upon, this fifth day of April, in the year of our Lord eighteen
hundred and seventy-two, between Francis Kearney and Luke F.
Tronson, of the city of Newark, in the county of Essex and State of
New Jersey, of the one part, and John H. Immens, of the city of
Newark, in the county of Essex and State of New Jersey ,of the other
part: Witnesseth, that whereas, the said Francis Kearney and Luke
F. Tronson are the inventors of a new and useful improvement in
‘spark-arresters for locomotives, which is secured to them by let-
ters patent of the United States, dated April 11th, A. D. 1871, and
which they are desirous of having brought into general use on the
railroads of the United States; and the said John H. Immens is
about to undertake the sale and introduction thereof into use as the
agent of the said patentees.

Now, it is agreed by and between the parties to this agreement,
that the said John H. Immens shall be,and he is hereby appointed the
sole agent of thesaid Francis Kearney and Luke F. Tronson, in the
United States, for the introduction and sale of the said improvement,
for the term of one year from the date hereof, but this appointment
is not to prevent the said patentees from personally making sales
of the right to use the said improvement, if they at any time desire
so todo. _ |

And it is agreed by and between the parties to this agreement,
that the price or royalty, to be paid for the use of the said improve-
ment, shall be fifty dollars for each engine to which the same may
be applied, but if any one party shall propose to purchase the right
to use the same upon a large number of engines, such moderate re-
duction, as in the judgment of the said Immen may be advisable,
may be made from the said price of fifty dollars.

And it is further agreed, that as compensation to the said Immens,
for his services in this behalf, he shall be entitled to retain twenty-
five per cent. of all sums received by him from the sales of the right

to use the said improvement, and that seventy-five per cent. of

the amount, so received by him, shall be paid over by the
29 said Immetis to the said Kearne ‘y and Tronson as royalty ;
and it is further agreed, that the said twenty-five per cent.
shall be the full compensation of the said Immens for any services
performed in executing the purposes of this agreement, and that
the said Kearney and Tronson shall not be liable to him for any
sum or sums of money for services, charges, expenses or otherwise,
under this agreement or otherwise. 3
And the said John H. Immens doth hereby covenant and agree
that he will make return monthly to the said Kearney and Tron-
son, their legal representatives and assigns, of all _ of the said
right to use the said improvement, and of all moneys received upon

abies ae
mee aN

SOR PS In Equity.
THe LenigH VALLEY RAILROAD COMPANY.

The consent in writing of Cochrane & Malcomson, solicitors of
the complainants in the above cause, that Elwood C. Harris be sub-
stituted as solicitor of said complainants having been filed—

It is, on this second day of November, A. D. "1885, on motion of
Elwood C. Harris, ordere .d that said Elwood C. Harris be substituted
as solicitor of the complainants in the place of Cochrane & Mal-

comson.
JNO. T. NIXON, J.

[ Endorsed :] U.S. circuit court, district of New Jersey. Francis
Kearney and Mary F. Tronson, adm’r, vs. The Lehigh Valley Rail-
road Company. Order substitution sol. compl’ts. Elwood C. Har-
ris, sol. compl’ts. Filed Nov. 2, 1885. $8. D. Oliphant, clerk.

to

U.S. Cireuit Court, District of New Jersey.

FRANCIS KEARNEY et al.
US. >On Bill in Equity.
Tue LeHIGH VALLEY RAILROAD COMPANY.

EXAMINER’S SESSION,
CLERK'S OFFICE, TRENTON, Feb’y 9th, 1886.

Present: S. D. Oliphant, examiner; Elwood C. Harris, sol. for
compl’t-; And’w M. Callum, sol. for det fendant.

Complainant- offers in evidence an agreement between Francis
Kearney and Luke F. ronson with John H. Inman, marked
Compl’ts’ Exhibit “A.’

Objected to by counsel for defendants as being inadmissable, ir-
relevant, and immaterial.

It was agreed between counsel that the testimony should be taken
by a stenographer, question and answer, and the signatures of the
witnesses thereto be waived. |

it

FRANCIS KEARNEY ET AL. 21

33 FRANCIS KEARNEY, one of the complainants, being duly
sworn according to law, testified as follows:

Direct examination.
(By Mr. Harris:)

@. You are one of the complainants in this suit?

A. Yes, sir.

(. Where do you reside ?

A. In Newark, N. J.

Q. Mr. Tronson, with whom you obtained this patent, is not
living ?

A. No, sir.

Q. And his wife, as executrix under his will, is a party with you
in this suit ?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. (Paper handed to witness.) Just look at this paper which has

just be- offered in evidence and marked Exhibit “A” and state

whose signatures are attached to it.

A. The signatures of Mr. Tronson and myself and John H. Imn-
man.

(). Under that agreement Mr. Immon made some efforts to intro-
duce your patent, did he not?

Objected to.

A. Yes, sir. 7
(). Was there ever any other agreement between you and Mr.
Tronson, on the one part, and Mr. Immon, on the other part,
34 respecting this patent ?
A. None but the agreement that had expired before that
paper was made.

(). There was another paper between you ?

A. No; only the one withthe agreement for one year. When that
expired Mr. Immon presented this paper. I don’t know whether I
am allowed to speak of it or not.

Q. Onemoment. (Witnessshown Defendant’s Exhibit No. 1.) The
question was whether any other paper than this agreement ever
existed between you and Mr. Immon.

A. No other.

Q. Except that’

A. Except this, which was after that one had expired.

Q. By whom was this paper you now hold, Defendant’s Exhibit
No. 1, signed ?

. It is signed by me and Mr. Tronson.

Q. What date does that bear ?

A. April 10th, 1873.

Q. In whose handwriting is that paper ?

A. I take it to be Mr. Immon’s handwriting.
@. Where did you first see that paper?

A. On Broad street.

®. In Newark ?

z THE LEHIGH VALLEY RAILROAD CO. VS.

to

A. In Newark, near the Morris an: Essex crossing, on the Dela-
ware, Lackawanna & Western road
35 Q. Who had it?
A. Mr. Immon had it.

(). Was it written in its present form when you first saw it?
\. I did not see the paper; it was read to me on Broad street.

Q. What do you mean when you say you did not see it—that
you did not bring it, read it, or what?

A. I did not read the paper. Mr. Immon read the paper fo*me
on Broad street.

Q. What conversation took place between Mr. [mmon and you,
or what did he say about the paper when he read it?

.

Counsel for the defendants objects to the question as inad missable—
calling for parole evidence to vary the legal effect of a written in-
strument.

A. Mr. Immon took from a satchel he had with him the paper
and read it to me on Broad street. When he came tothe latter part
of it—oh, he said that—he read it to me and said that he expected
to go and see the New Jersey Central railroad on that day, as they
had told him they were about ready to settle with him for the use
of this spark-arrester. He took this paper from his bag and read it
to me, saying that he had brought it for me and Mr. Tronson to
sign, that they might see that he had authority to settle with them—

with the Central railroad. When he came to the part that
36 reads “having a one-third interest therewith ” Mr. Immon

made the remark to me that this paper was merely to show
them that he had the right to settle. He put the paper in his bag
and asked me if Mr. Tronson would sign it. [ said, Mr. Tronson is
just here. Walking to the shop I called him. He turned around
and went into the bank—underneath the bank there—the first
floor—close to the Morris & Essex crossing—and signed this paper.
| took it from what he said when he came to the one-third interest—
[ paid no attention, as his last agreement was that he was to have
one-third of any moneys collected instead of 25 per cent. on account
of a reissue on the patent, which he agreed to pay $20 for the office

fees in Washington, and instead of 25 per cent. to have one-third of

the money which he would collect for the sale of the spark-arrester
or patent. No other paper was ever made out. This paper I never
saw afterwards. I asked Mr. Immons on one or two occasions if he
would not appoint a day and have an agreement drawn up for his
agreement on the new start—after he gave the $20. He said it was
all right; there was no need of it.

Counsel for the defendant makes the same objection to the answer
as to the question.

Q. Under the former agreement Mr. Immons was appointed your
agent ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. For one year, to try and sell this spark-arrester ?
37 A. Yes, sir.

1-

er

ur

EE i Sis OE an aaa "

& Ps as

FRANCIS KEARNEY ET AL. 93

Q. And he to receive 25 per cent. of all the sales he might make?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Is the statement you have just made the explanation why he
was to receive one-third instead of one-fourth ?

A. Yes, sir; to receive one-third.

(. Instead of one-fourth ?

A. Instead of one-fourth.

(). By reason of what?

A. By reason of paying $20 to me which I handed over to Mr.
Tronson for the reissue of the patent.

Q. Was that reissued during the time of the previous agreement?

A. Well, the agreement for the reissue was shortly after the first
agreement.

(. And before this paper was signed ?

A. And before that paper was signed.

(). Did Mr. Insmon make any arrangement for the sale of this
patent to the New Jersey Central railroad afterwards ?

A. Not until after that paper wassigned. Inever saw Mr. [mmon
or said that he had anything to do after that paper was signed. I
had told Mr. Immous on one or two occasions, after his time had
expired and he was unsuccessful in settling with the New Jersey

Central, that if he would goon and see the parties, the Lehigh
38 Valley, which he had been up to Easton, if he should come

to any arrangement, that I would see he would get his one-
third allowed to him for the sale.

Same objection to the question and answer.

(). Was there ever an agreement with Mr. Immons that he should
be the owner of one-third of the patent ? |

A. No, sir; there was no such agreement as that for one-third
ownership of the patent.

Same objection.

(). After the commencement of this suit did Mr. Immon ever come
to you with reference to this patent?

A. I met him one day at Market street. He was apparently wait-
ing until I got off the train, and [ walked with him from Market
street to Chestnut street. He had been talking about the suit and
he asked me if it was not going on in Trenton. I told him I could
not tell him, that I had not heard that—whether it wasor not. He
said, “ Yes, we must go away from home and hear what is going on.
They will have it up in the country somewhere.” I said, “ You
know more than I do, although I expect there is such to go on, but
whether it is going on or not at present is more than I know at
present.”

(). Did he say anything to you at that time about his being the
owner of one-third of the patent ?

A. No, sir.
39 @. Has he ever at any time said to you that he claimed to
take one-third of the patent?

A. No, sir; never.

94 THE LEHIGH VALLEY RAILROAD CO. Vs.

Same objection.

Witness: I found, when speaking to him about if he would go
on, if he would come to any agreement—TI told him that I would
say that he would be allowed as percentage a one-third of what he
might collect. Henever said that he owned one-third of the patent
or expected to own one-third, or anything about it.

Counsel for the defendant objects to the whole of the foregoing
evidence on the ground of its inadmissibility, on the ground that
the legal effect of the written instrument referred to as Defendant’s
Exhibit No. 1 cannot be varied by parole evidence, not showing
mutual mistake, and he gives notice that he will move to strike out
said evidence at the hearing 7f the cause.

40) Cross-examination (de bene esse).
(By Mr. McCatium:)

Q. You say that the application for the reissue was made before
you signed and Mr. Tronson signed this paper, Defendant’s Exhibit
No. 1?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. And that he paid you $20 on account of obtaining the re-
issue ?

A. Yes, sir. Could I explain (interrupted)

Q. Not now. And that was the consideration why he should get
a } interest in the proceeds of the patent instead of a}? That is
correct?

A. Yes, sir.

®. Mr. Imman read the whole of the instrument to you, did he?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. And you understood from him that he was to have a $rd in-
terest with yourself in the proceeds of the patent?

A. 4rd of what he would collect instead of }, as before; not a 4rd
interest 1n the patent.

Q. In the proceeds of the patent ?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. He was to receive a $rd interest in the proceeds of the patent.
Is that correct?

A. Yes, sir.
4] (. In consideration of his services and the $20 paid by
him. ‘That is correct, is it? :

A. Yes, sir; one-third of the proceeds, as remarked, instead of
one-quarter, with the New Jersey Central railroad.

Q. You added the last part after consideration, after finishing the
former answer. Do you mean now to say that he was to havea
one-third interest in any other proceeds of the patent?

A. His time had expired.

@. I am talking about one-third.

A. One-third on all that he would sell during the year. He
made no sale at all. We gave him this paper to give him a chance,
as he represented that he was going to settle with the New Jersey

rt.

it i ee ey

be in toa ae

FRANCIS KEARNEY RT AL. 25

Central railroad; that they had written they wanted to come down.
That is why that paper was signed.

(). But there was no paper giving him authority for a year, ex-
cepting the one offered in evidence as Complainants’ Exhibit A,
was there?

A. That is the only paper.

(). And that had expired before this other paper was executed,
was it not?

A. Yes,sir. He said that he had (interrupted)

Q. Well, holdon. ‘There is no restriction as to time in this paper,
Defendant’s Exhibit No. 1, is there?

A. No; no restriction as to time.
42 Q. And there is no reservation of your right to annul that
power thereby conveyed, is there ?

A. No reservation; no, sir.

Redirect examination:

(). Is this recital at the end of this paper, “he having one-third
equal interest with ourselves in the said patent,” true or false?

Objected to for the reasons before stated.

A. It is false of any one-third in the said patent other than a
one-third interest as to the proceed-, as I before explained.

Q. After Mr. Imman took this paper, Defendant’s Exhibit No. 1,
from his satchel and before you signed it, did he add anything to
it, or was it in the state that it now is, when you signed it?

A. Ido not remember him doing anything to it. He returned
the paper into his satchel again after he had read it to me.

(). And then where did you go?

A. He asked me if Mr. Tronson would sign it, and I said, “ Here
is Mr. Tronson; I will speak to him.” I explained to Mr. Tronson

that Mr. Imman’s time had expired—that is, his first agree-
45 ment—and he had a paper with him that he wanted me and

him to sign to give him a chance to settle with the New Jer-
sey Central railroad, as he had notice from them to call on them
that morning and had the paper prepared in his bag. Mr. Tronson
said, if I remember exactly, “ Most assuredly,” and he walked to the
bank and signed the paper. I could not say whether Mr. Tronson
read the paper. He looked at it, but whether he looked at it long
enough to read the paper I could not say. I don’t think he did.

Same objection.

Counsel for the complainant- desires to put in evidence a certified
copy of the assignment made by John H. Immans to the Lehigh
Valley Railroad Company, bearing date May 10, 1883, and recorded
in the Patent Office May 16, 1883, in W 29, page 198, Transfers of
Patents.

Counsel for the defendant objects to the same as being immaterial
in the present issue.

Adjourned to the day to be agreed upon.

[Endorsed :] No. 9.
4—314

26 THE LEHIGH VALLEY RAILROAD CO. YS.

44 United States Circuit Court, District of New Jersey.

FRANCIS KEARNEY é al. )
v. ?
THE LEHIGH VALLEY RAILROAD Company. }

MAsTrER’s SESSION AT TRENTON, N. J., Feb’y 24, 1886.

Present: S. D. Oliphant, Esq., examiner; Andrew McCallum,
Esq., sol’r for defendant; Elwood C. Harris, Esq., sol’r for com-
plainant-.

BK ramimation ot iW Ltnesses Produced, Swor it, and Be ramined on the Fi art
of the Defendant.

Counsel for defendant offers in evidence a letter dated February
13, 1886, signed by eegrered and Warden, marked Defendant’s Ex-
hibit No. “4;” also a letter dated Feb’y 17, 1886, and signed by
James F. O’Rourke, marked Defendant’s Exhibit No. 5.

The said letters were offered to show that the witness, John H.
[mmen, is dead.

(Counsel for compl: ainant- objects to the competency of these letters
to show that fact. This objection will be withdrawn on being sat-

isfied of the truth of this offer on the part of the defendant on iis
own inquiry.)

Counsel for defendant also offers in evidence a letter dated May
21, 1885—three pages—marked Defendant’s Exhibit No. 6, from
J. H. Immen to A. MeCallum.

(Counsel for complainant- objects to this letter as incompetent.)

Counsel for defendant offers letter dated June 1, 1883, same to be
marked Defendant’s Exhibit No. 7.

(Same objection by counsel for complainant-.)
15 Also letter dated July 31, 1873, M. D. Leggett to J. H.
[mmen, marked Defendant’s Exhibit No. 8.

Also a letter dated April 26, 1883, McCarter, Williamson, and
McCarter to A. McCallum, marked Defendant’s Exhibit No. 9.

Same objection by defendant to letters Nos. 8 and 9.

ANDREW McCaLtuM, sworn as a witness on the part of the de-
fendant:

[ am solicitor for the defendant in this ease. I knew John H.
[mmen, who has heretofore testified as a witness in this ease. Sinee
the last session, Feb’y 9, 1886, I have learned that he died at Belle-
vue hospital, New York city, Dec. 6, 1885. The letter, Defendant’s
Exhibit No. 5, I received from the warden of the hospital, and the
letter from Mec urdy and Warden, Defendant’s Exhibit No. 4, I re-
ceived from his lateemployer. I was first introduced to Mr. Immen
by a letter from McCarter, Williamson & McCarter, of Newark, New
Jersev, attorneys for the Lehigh Valiey Railroad C ompany, Defend-
ant’s Exhibit No.9. I am familiar with Mr. Immen’s handwriting.

ni,
fi-

FRANCIS KEARNEY ET AIL. 97

The two letters, Defendant’s Exhibits Nos. 6 and 7, are in his hand-
writing, and are addressed to me.

With respect. to the interest 1n the Kearney and Tronson patent,
for infringement of which this suit is brought, he informed me that
he first had a contract in writing with Kearney and Tronson to
continue for one year from the fifth day of April, 1872, by which he
was appointed sole agent to sell the right to use the patented im-
provement.

(Counsel for complainant- objects to the testimony as being in-
competent because hearsay, and to all testimony as to what Mr.
[mmen informed the witness.)

That during the continuance of that contract it was found that
the patent was not broad enough, and it was found advisable to re-
issue it with broader claims, and that upon his agreeing to pay the
cost of reissue, it was agreed by Kearney and Tronson that he,
Immen, was to receive one-third interest in the patent. That on
this understanding he paid $40. That the application for the re-

issue was made through Cochrane and Malcomson, of New
46 York city, and obtained December 10, 1872. That as soon

as the reissue was obtained, he set to work to introduce the
invention and sell the rights under the patent on the new arrange-
ment, but being so much away he had no time to reduce the new
contract to writing, and having an opportunity to dispose of the
right to the Central Railroad of New Jerse ‘y, and being in a great
hurry and desiring to make sure of his one-third interest, he drew
the power of attorney with Kearney and Tronson’s acknowledg-
ment of joint ownership, (Defendant’s Exhibit No. 1.)

That he read and explained the purport of the same to both Mr.
Kearney and Mr. Tronson before they signed the paper, and that
the same was to cover his right to one- third interest in the patent,
and all proceeds thereof as had been before agreed upon, when he
paid Mr. Kearney the $40 and agreed to reissue the patent.

That he afterwards discovered that the description of the device
in the reissued patent was erroneous and contained mistakes which
he understood rendered it of no value. That he thereupon applied
to the Commissioner of Patents to have the errors corrected, but was
informed in reply that they could be corrected only by another re-
issue of the patent.

That he had no money to pay for the second reissue, became dis-
couraged, and believing that the patent was of no account he gave
up all efforts to sell rights under it.

That he did not know of any suit having been commenced against
the Lehigh Valley Railroad Company until he learned it from one
of the officers of that road ; that when he did learn of it he informed
Mr. Maleomson of his interest in the patent, but receiving no satisfac-
tion from him in the matter, he communicated the fact of his having
one-third interest in the pate nt to the attorneys for the Lehigh
Valley Railroad Company, McCarter, Williamson, and McCarter,
and finally disposed of his interest to the defendant. Defendant’s
Exhibit No. 8 is the letter be received from the Commissioner of

Mle Spite hig Met

a en 2 pat teh
aide Ste, Bay at

bo
OC

THE LEHIGH VALLEY RAILROAD CO. VS.

Patents, and it was given to me by Mr. Immen along with
47 the original contract of April 5, 1872, and other papers re-
lating to the transaction.

Cross-examination by Mr. HarRIs:

Question. Your testimony as just given you have read froma
paper previously prepared by you?
Answer. Yes.

Adjourned.

48 United States Cireuit Court, District of New Jersey.

Francis KEARNEY and Mary F. Tronson, Executrix, &c.,
US

THe LenIGH VALLEY RAILROAD COMPANY.

By Nixon, J.:

The bill of complaint was filed in this case — and Mary F. Tronson,
as executrix of Luke F. Tronson, deceased, against the defendant
corporation for an injunction and for the recovery of profits and
damages for the alleged infringement of reissued letters patent No.
5184 for new and useful “improvements in spark-arresters for loco-
motives.”

The defendant has put in a plea in abatement of the suit for the
non-joinder of parties, alleging that at the time of the commence-
ment of the action and prior thereto the complainants were not the
sole and exclusive owners of said letters patent, and that one John
Ht. Immer, of Newark, New Jersey, had an equal undivided one-
third interest therein.

[n support of the plea the defendants offered in evidence the fol-
lowing written certificate executed on the day of its date, duly re-
ceived for record July 2, 1875, and recorded in Liber V 16, p. 289,
of Transfers of Patents:

“Po whom it may concern:

1) This certifies that John H. Immer is fully authorized and

empowered to make any contract with the Central Railroad
of New Jersey that may be binding on our part for the sale of the
patent right on spark-arrester, as secured to us by letters patent
113,528, dated April llth, 1871, and reissue 5184, dated December
10, 1872, he having one-third equal interest with ourselves in the
said patent.

(Signed) Kh. KEARNEY.

LUKE F. TRONSON.
Newark, April 10, 1873.”

Che counsel for the defendant insists that the paper constitutes
an equitable assignment of the one-third ownership in the reissue;
that it is a writing free from all ambiguity, and that the comvlain-

-

tee In Equity.
THe LenicgH VaLttEy RAaILroap Company. }

[t is agreed by the parties hereto that testimony may be taken
under the 67th rule, as amended, before any U.S. commissioner or
notary public on giving 10 days’ notice of the time and place, either
at the shops of the defendant or in New Jersey or New York city.

E. C. HARRIS, Sol. Compl’t-.
A. McCALLUM, Sol. for Def’t.

—

FRANCIS KEARNEY ET AL. 35

Testimony taken before me, A. B. C. Salmon, a notary public, at
my office, No. 802 Broad street, Newark, N. J., this sixth day of
October, A. D. 1886, at 10 o’clock a. m., in the presence of Elwood
C. Harris, of counsel with the complainants, and of Andrew Mc-
Callum, of counsel with the defendant, on behalf of the complain-
ants.

Complainant’s counsel offers in evidence certified copy of Kear-
ney & Tronson’s patent, reissue No. 5184, Dec. 10th, 1872, entitled
“ Improvement in spark-arresters for locomotive,” and the same is

marked Complainant’s Exhibit No. 1.
6] Complainants’ counsel offers in evidence certificate of the
surrogate of the county of Essex of proof of the last will of
Luke F. Tronson, deceased, and that Mary F. Tronson, one of the
complainants, is the executris thereof, and the same is marked
Complainants’ Exhibit No. 2.

tOBERT H. QuINN sworn on behalf of the complainants.

Direct examination by Mr. Harris:

(. Where do you live?

A. 1000 Newark avenue, Jersey City.

Q. What is your present employment and for how long have vou
been employed ?

A. I am an engine-trier. I was machinest in the Pennsylvania
Railroad Company this 14 years and employed on the Meadows
between here and Marion.

Q. How were you employed in the years 1881 and 1882?

A. Iam not positive, but I believe I was in the round-house at
night, doing the machinest work under Mr. Kearney.

Q. (Witness, being shown affidavits and exhibit filed in this cause
March 24, 1883, on motion for injunction, is asked:) Are you the
Robert H. Quinn that made oath to the first affidavit ?

A. That is my signature.
62 Q. There is annexed to said affidavit two drawings, marked
Exhibit 356 and Exgibit 363. Will you state whether you
ever saw those drawings before; and, if so, where they came from?

A. Those are my drawings. I made them.

Q. Do you know how long before that affidavit was made?

A. No; it was within a couple of weeks, anyhow. I didn’t think
this would occur, and I paid no attention and made no memoran-
dum.

Q. Where did you make those drawings ?

A. In the round-house of the Penn. Railroad Company, on the
Meadows.

Q. Will you state what the one marked Exhibit 356 represents”?

A. It represents the spark-refractor.

Q. Out of what ?

A. Out of a locomotive.

(. Did you see such a spark-refractor as that in a locomotive ;
and, if so, what locomotive ?

36 THE LEHIGH VALLEY RAILROAD CO. VS.

was 306.
Q. That is the number of the engine, you mean?
A. Yes, sir.

Q. Did you also make the drawing marked Exhibit 363?
A. Yes.
63 Q. From what did you draw that’?

A. From the engine 363, I believe; i can’t swear to that.

(). Of what railroad ?

A. Lehigh Valley.

Q. W here was this engine when you saw this part of it?

A. In the Meadow shops—round- house.

Q. Were both these engines used by the Lehigh Valley Railroad
Company ?

A. Yes.

. Do these two drawings represent the same device ?

A. Yes; the same.

(). They were alike?

A. ag sIr.

Q. What part of a locomotive engine is shown by Exhibit 363?

r he front end or smoke-arch.

Complainants’ counsel offers in evidence the two drawings above
referred to by the witness and annexed to the affidavits, and the
one called Exhibit 356 is now marked Complainants’ Exhibit No.
3, and the one referred to as Exhibit 356 is now marked Complain-
ants’ Exhibit No. 4.

i Q. Of what was the spark-refractor, as shown in these
drawings, constructed ”
A. It is my belief it was cast iron. It is so long since I didn’t
pay any attention to it.
Q. Did you make the figures on No. 3—,'5, occurring twice, and
Oo}, occurring once—at the time you made the ieee!
A. Yes, sir.
Q. What does the ;°; mean ?
A. The width of the bar; also the width of the opening.
(). And the 31, what does that mean ?
A. That is the length of the opening.
@ How did the openings ran—up and down?
\. Straight up and down.
a. What was the height of this grate ?
18 inches.
o And the diameter at the top and bottom respectively ?
A. 18 inches and 12 at the bottom.
Q. Does Exhibit 4 show how this grating was attached to the
petticoat pipe and about its location in the steam head ?

Objected to as leading and because the drawing is the best evi-
dence.
A. Yes, sir.
Q.. Where do the exhaust pipes enter this grating ?

A. I know that it was a Lehigh Valley engine, and I believe it

—"* typ ec el .o

ater

FRANCIS KEARNEY ET AL. 37

A. At the bottom.
65 Q. And do you know how far up the exhaust pipes ex-
tended ?

A. No; it is not marked here.

Q. Do you remember whether you saw this same grate on any
other than the two engines you have mentioned ?

A. I have seen it—I couldn’t just say it is the same, but I have
seen grating of that drawing in several of the other engines.

Q. Of what railroad ?

A. The Lehigh Valley.

Q. Did this grating form a circle around the petticoat pipe, or
how was it?

A. It is cone-shape—round.

(. Did the slots continue all the way around it?

A. Yes; but there is a joint where it is attached together in
pieces.

Q. You may refer to the affidavit as to the time when it was
sworn to, the 8th of February, 1583, and state whether these draw-
ings were made before or since that date.

A. Before that date.

Cross-examination by Mr. McCauium:

Q. Do you understand mechanical drawings sufficiently to say

what is represented by them ?
A. I believe I do.
66 Q. Please look at the drawing on blue print now shown
you and state if that is a correct representation of the spark

retarder or arrester you saw in use on engines 396 and 363 of the
Lehigh Valley railroad.

A. According to my drawing, this has got five slots, and accord-
ing to mine, has only got three.

Q. (Question read.)

A. This is the very same that I saw in the locomotive.

Counsel for defendant asks the notary to mark this blue-print
drawing for identification as Defendant’s Exhibit “A.’

Q. Please look at the photograph now shown you and state if
that is a correct representation of the spark-arrester you saw on said
engines.

A. I believe that is something like it. I don’t know whether
that is what I have drawn from, but it is the same idea—the same
construction. -

The photograph referred to is marked for identification Defend-
ant’s Exhibit “ B.”

Q. Please look at the photograph now shown you and state if you
ever saw a spark-arrester of that construction in use on the Lehigh

Valley railroad.
A. No;

I can’t say I did.

38 THE LEHIGH VALLEY RAILROAD CO. VS.

67 Last-mentioned photograph offered and marked for identi-
fication Defendant’s Exhibit “©.”

Q. Have you inade any examination since the time you made the
affidavit, February 8th, 1883?

A. No.

Q. Please look at the photograph now shown you and state if you
ever saw a spark-arrester of that construction in use on the Lehigh
Valley railroad.

A. No, sir.

Photograph referred to marked for identification and marked De-
fendant’s Exhibit * D.”

Q. Please look at drawing now shown you and state if you ever
saw a spark-arrester of that construction in use on the Lehigh Val-
ley railroad.

A. No; I don’t remember.

Drawing shown witness is the drawing accompanying the Kear-
ney & Tronson patent, Complainants’ Exhibit 1, having reference
to the last question and answer.

(. You made some reference in your direct testimony to a petti-
coat pipe. Is not a petticoat pipe one which resembles the garment
of that name—open at the top and bottom?

A. Yes, sir.
68 Q. What part of the spark-arrester do you refer to as having
seen on the engine- 563 and 356 as a petticoat pipe?

A. The same as what Is on drawing here, 356, Complainants’ Ex-
hibit No. 3.

Redirect examination -‘

Q. Will you point out in Exhibit 4 the petticoat pipe?
\. From the top of the grating on up to the top of the box.
Is the petticoat pipe shown on Exhibit No. 3?

No.

Reeross-exaimlnation :

(. What do you mean by saying in one answer that the drawing
396, Complainants’ Exhibit No. 5, is the petticoat pipe and another
answer saying that the petticoat pipe is not shown on said drawing?
Please explain.

A. Referring to this (No. 3), I did not understand you in regard
to the petticoat pipe. Now, we generally call this from the top of
the grate extending up to the smoke-arch the petticoat pipe. I
would eall it all as workmen eall it—alla petticoat pipe, as it is
generally called. ‘Those grates are not used in our department.

Q. Referring to drawing, Complainants’ Exhibit 4, is not the

pipe extending from the top of the grating a straight pipe,
G9 of the same diameter throughout ? |
A. It shows that in the drawing.

ee

.

>.

Cross-examination by Mr. McCaLiuM:

(. Have you ever examined any other engines belonging to the
Lehigh Valley Railroad Company than the one you refer to in
order to ascertain what kind of a spark-arrester was used ?

76 A. I don’t recollect I ever did.
Q. Do you not know how long the one you saw was used ?

A. No, sir.

Sworn — and subscribed before me this sixth day of Oct., 1886
LYMAN M. WAER,
Notary Public.

~]
~

FRANCIS KEARNEY, one of the complainants, sworn on his
own behalf.

Direct examination by Mr. Harris:

(). You are one of the complainants?
A. Yes, sir.
(). Where do you reside ?
A. 1244 Pacitic street, Newark, N. J.
. You are one of the patentees of letters patent for spark-arrest-
ers, No. 113,528, dated April 11, 1871, and reissue No. 5184, dated
December 1 Oth, 1872?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Is Mr. Tronson still living?

A. No, sir.

(). About when did he die”

A. He has been dead for some time, to my knowledge; at least
two years; probably more than that.

(. He died before the commencement of this suit ?:

A. Yes, sir.

Q. You and he were the inventors of this patent ?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. W here were you and Mr. Tronson employed, and at what, at

the time you made the application for this patent ?
78 A. Mr. Tronson was master mechanic on what was known
as the Morris & Essex railroad at that time, and I was round-

house foreman at Spring street, Newark, N. J.

FRANCIS KEARNEY ET AL. 43

Q. With reference to the time when you made application for the
patent, when had you perfected the invention patented—how long
before the application ?

A. I think we experimented a couple of years or more before the
application was made.

~¢i> Q. Just look at this grating and state what itis. (Witness shown
piece of grating.)

A. This is one section forming the circle of our spark-arrester.

3 Eight of those makes the circle. This is larger at the bottom than
at the top. This sets on a base plate like that (indicating). Those
projections allows it to have air at the bottom. The petticoat pipe
fastens around the top and extends to the top of the smoke-arch,
clean to the smoke-stack. Those openings lengthwise prevent the
escape of anything larger than will pass through openings. The
object in having the bar so long is to give a better natural draft for
the escape of the smoke and gasses and cinders.

Q. Is that grating cast in the same form as shown in your origi-
nal patent and in the reissue ?
Objected to.
79 Question objected to, it not being shown by either the orig-
inal or reissue patent that the grate is made by casting in
the manner referred to in the question reissue, but, on the contrary,
is referred to in the reissue as made with straight, vertical bars of
iron placed at small distances apart.

A. I think it is.
Q. Was a grating of this form tried in any locomotives by you

¢
and Mr. Tronson before your application for a patent ?
A. That Iam not able to answer, as to the date.

Y
-
Counsel for complainants offers in evidence grating last shown
witness, whicn is marked Exhibit 5 for complainants.
(). Did you ever, in company with Mr. Quinn, examine any loco-
motives of the Lehigh Valley Railroad Company ?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. State how many different ones.

A. We examined three.

Q. Did Mr. Quinn make the drawings that he has referred to at
the time of this examination ?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Referring to Complainants’ Exhibit 4, is there any pipe shown

\ on that exhibit that you would call a petticoat pipe ?

f 80 A. No; not that I would call a petticoat pipe. There isa

I pipe or a part of a pipe covering this grating. The grating

: could not be seen from the front without removing a slide door in

| this lower pipe surrounding the grating.

i Q. To what is the upper end of the grating attached in this ex-

| hibit ?

: A. It is fast to the grating pipe—secured to the grating—and
wWw that pipe extends up to the top of the smoke-arch.

Q. Into what does that pipe open at the top ?

44 THE LEHIGH VALLEY RAILROAD CO. VS.

A. Into the smoke-stack.

Q. Is that grating attached to the grating pipe, as you call it, in
the same form as the grating in your patent is attached to the petti-
coat pipe ?

A. It amounts to the same, but ours comes over the outside of
the grating.

Q. In what direction are the slots in this grating ”

A. Upright; up and down.

(). In size how do they compare with the slots shown in your
rating ?

A. They compare very near. [| think ours is a little wider open-
ing; our opening is longer.

Q. About how long before the commencement of this suit did

you first learn that the Lehigh Valley Railroad Company
8] were using such a grating as has been described ?

A. I ean’t give any positive date. I should say a year;
probably more than that; but they had been notified of inftringe-
ment. We got no answer from them.

Q. Do you know whether or not they continued to use this grate
after the commencement of the suit ?

A. That I couldn’t say.

Q. You spoke a little while ago of experimenting with other de-
vices before making your application for this patent. Did you use
or applv other devices to locomotives and try them ?

A. Yes, sir. |

Q. During what space of time, as near as you can recall, before
your application for a patent ?

A. Well, [ should think probably over two years; probably three
years; | couldn’t say positive.

Q. What did you find the advantage of a device with vertical
slots over other devices tried by you ?

A. We found a better draft; more uniform working the fire in
the fire box; dra‘t better regulated with the upright bar, and better
escape for the gasses and smoke.

Q. In what respect is the grate used by the defendants like your

cy
>

grate ¢ :
A. In the openings and placed at the base of the smoke-
arch.
82 (). Does the pipe you have spoken of, surrounding the

grate in the defendant’s engine, extend all the way wround
the grate; and, if not, around what part of it? |
A. ‘The front. I couldn’t say whether it went all the way around
or not, but it covered all the front.

(‘ross-examination by Mr. McCarter:

(). What like were the spark-arresters you experimented with
before you made the invention deseribed in the patent In issue ?

A. We placed upright bars in front of the flues in the smoke-
arch about six inches from the flue; also tried sheet irou in the
smoke-arch ; also tried cast-iron grating in the combustion chamber

age Be as ee 7 é ime wr * ~— “~~ °

’

sets

tt

sf

tl

FRANCIS KEARNEY ET AL. 45

in front of the fire-box ; tried wire netting inside; tried wrought-
iron bars in the combustion chamber, provided with slots for the
expansion of the same. I believe that is up to the present grating
in the smoke-arch.

We tried the block opening in this present grate at about § of
an inch openings in length with the same width. We found it
stopped up. When the engine was put in motion it drawed the
cinders into those openings and stopped it.

®. Whose suggestion was the long slot as shown by Ex-
83 hibit 5 for complainants?
A. Me and Mr. Tronson.

(). Both thought of the same thing, did you ?

A. Both worked jointly on it—exchanged ideas.

®. At what time was this suggestion made—changing the slot ?

A. It was during the time of our experiments. I couldn’t give
dates of that; it is too long ago.

Q. Was it the last form of the grating you tried ?

A. It was.

(. You applied for a patent as soon as you found it all right?

A. No; some little time elapsed.

Q. How long, do vou remember ?

A. As aear as I can place it, from nine months to a year.

Q. When was the first one of this style put into use on a locomo-
tive engine ?

A. That date I couldn’t give you, but shortly after the patent
was obtained; probably three or four months; it might be longer.
I couldn’t be positive.

@. Where was it put in use?

A. On what is known as the Morris & Essex division of the D.,
L. & W. railroad; that is the first 1 run over the road. It was
first tried on the helping engines used in helping trains up the

hill. )
S4 Q. Were they applied to any more locomotives on that
road than the one you refer to?

A. To three others; making five running over the road.

Q. Are they still in use?

A. I ecouldn’t say.

Q. Do you know Mr. William H. Lewis?

A. Yes, sir; that is, now master mechanic of that division.

Q. Do you not know that the spark-arresters that you put in use
on said road were found to be impracticable, and were ordered taken
off by Mr. Lewis because they would not work satisfactorily ?

A. I don’t know but of one that was ordered taken off, to my
knowledge.

Q. Doyou know Mr. Andrew Reasoner, connected with said Morris
& Essex Railroad Company ?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Did you sell the right to use your patented improvement to
the Morris & Essex railroad ?

Objected to as not cross-examination.

a

ip erates inaetingo~ter nase we
tut 4A esethakeebacnae ce

46 THE LEHIGH VALLEY RAILROAD CO. VS.

A. No, sir.

Q. Have you ever sold the right to use it to any railroad com-
pany ?

A. No, sir.
Q. Have you ever put it on any other engines than the five vou
referred to?
D A. Put one on the New Jersey Central railroad ; one on the
Troy & Whitehall road ; that is all, I believe.
(). Did you get any pay for these last referred to ?
A. No, sir.
Q. You put them on as a matter of experiment, I presume ?

A. Yes, sir; to try them, to see how they would like them.

Q. Please look at the photograph, Defendant’s Exhibit “ B” for
identification, and state if the spark-arrester there shown is the same
as those you saw in use on the Lehigh Valley road.

A. Yes; that resembles the same. The openings are the same as
in the blue-print drawing.

Q. Please look at the. photograph, Defendant’s Exhibit “C” for
identification, and state if you have ever seen a spark-arrester of
that construction.

A. I can’t say that I did.

(J. Same question as to Exhibit “* D.

A. No. |

Q. The last referred to, Exhibit D, showing a screen of wire net-
ting and Exhibit “C,” one having lateral openings. Do you con-
sider that there is any material ‘difference between them and the

screens shown by Exhibit “ B,” with the vertical openings ?
86 A. The openings are altogether different. They are all dif-

ferent. “B” has an upright opening; “ D,” a block opening
with wire netting, and “C,” a transverse or lateral opening, just the
opposite to “ B.’

Q. Do you consider that the difference in the shape of the open-
ing would make any difference in the operation of the device ?

A. Yes.

(). Please explain why you think so.

A. I think the upright opening is the best for draft, getting the
most draft in the same amount of space.

Q. You form this idea from theory, not from practice, I under-
stand ?

A. That is my belief from what practice I have had in the
matter.

@. When did you arrive at that conclusion ?

A. While experimenting with those spark-arresters.

Q. That was before you applied for the patent?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Then why, in your application for the patent, did you make
oath that the grate is “formed either with bars or of netting or

perforated plates. The shape is not material. We make
87 them circucar as being most convenient in ordinary cases ” ?
A. We showed the upright bar in the model, also in the

CD
“o

i

FRANCIS KEARNEY ET AL. 4?

drawings, and thinking we had a right to stop anything that might
be put in there.

Q. You thought at the time that you were the first inventors of a
screen of any kind, did you?

A. At that time, yes.

Q. And you were refused a patent on your originai claims because
you were not the first inventors of such a sereen ?

Objected to as not the best evidence, the contents of the file-
wrapper being the best evidence.

A. I hardly know. ‘The specifications were altered to the upright
bar.

Q. Then, is it not a fact that vou had to limit yourself to the par-
ticular construction of the grate with the longitudinal bars before
the patent was allowed, and that the discovery of the peculiar
effeciency of that form of grate was not made until after the rejec-
tiou, and was first inserted in the specification of the patent by
amendment after such objection ?

Objected to as not being the best evidence, as the record should
be produced.

A. Iam not aware that the model was altered. It showed the

upright bar, also the specification, [ think; but that was
88 altered to the upright bar.
Q. That was all the invention claimed by the original
patent, was it not?

A. The cireular grate with the upright bar.

Q. In what respect was said original patent of April 11, 1871, in-
operative? You can look at the specification of the patent and point
out any such defect, if any there may be, in it. (Witness is here
shown certified copy of the Patent Office file-wrapper and contents,
marked Defendant's Exhibit “ E” for identification.)

A. It was on account of the base plate, if I understand, that the
grating rested on.

Q. I do not understand your answer. What base plate do you
refer to?

A. The flat surface in the bottom of the boiler; that, I think, was
one of the causes.

(). There is no such plate described in the patent, is there, refer-
ring to the original patent ”

A. I don’t think there was. I couldn’t say positively, but I think
that is one of the reasons the reissue was gotten for—the flat sur-
face.

(). What were the other reasons, if any, that called for a reissue
of the patent?

A. I think that was one of the principal causes. I can’t recollect

any other reason.
89 (). Could not a skilled mechanic make and use a spark-
arrester such as is shown and described in the original patent,
in your opinion?
Objected to, as it is not shown that the witness is an expert.

Pehle Ran pathert pen tN th hen dilitinn

aes eR Be tat Perera Sa 8 aes

ee oy

48 | THE LEHIGH VALLEY RAILROAD CO. VS.

A. I don’t know what skilled mechanics might be able to do;
there are different classes of them. Wesawthe necessity of stopping
sparks and we worked on that line, to prevent escaping sparks from
setting fire.

Q. What I mean is, could not a mechanic, from reading your
patent, understand how to make and use your invention ?

A. I should think so.

@. Do you consider that the use of spark-arresters like those
shown by Defendant’s Exhibits “C” & “ D” would be an infringe-
ment of your patent?

A. In my opinion, [ think not.

Q. What makes you think that the use of a spark-arrester like
that shown by the blue print would be an infringement ?

A. Because of having the upright openings.

@. Is that all?

A. That is all.

(}. Then the combination set forth in the second claim of the re-

issue patent is not infringed by the defendant?

90 A. We don’t claim that it is.
Q. Then it is only the first claim that you think is in-
fringed?
A. The grate with the upright bars is what we think is In-
fringed.

Q. The claim is for a grating of vertical bars placed at the foot
of the spark or petticoat pipe “ FE” in the manner and for the pur-
pose described. Do you consider that your petticoat pipe marked
“FE” is the same as the downward extension of the smoke-stack
marked “A” in the blue-print drawing ?

A. There is a little difference—one is tapering and the other is
straight—but they answer the same purpose.

Q. Is not your petticoat pipe “ E” open at the upper end, witha
space between it and the smoke-stack which is protected by the
wire netting “ F,” and in that respect is it not different from de-
fendant’s pipe, as well as being different in its shape ?

A. Yes; there is a netting protecting around the top of the pipe
that is not shown in the blue-print drawing.

Q. Is there not this further difference, that the defendant’s grat-
ing is wider at the top than the bottom, while yours is wider at the
bottom ?

A. Yes; there is that difference.
91 Q. Is there not this further difference, that the openings
in defendant’s screen break joints so as to present a zigzag
arrangement of the openings in it, while in yours they are all ar-
ranged in the same circular line or parallel to each other?

A. Yes, sir.

(). Is there not this further difference in the two screens, that in
yours the openings are made by two sets of parallel rods one above
the other, while in the defendant’s screen there are some five or six
sets of openings arranged to break joints as before referred to?

A. There is a difference in the openings. Ours are much longer.

(). Is there not this further difference, that the defendant’s screen

q

q

Ma ee

{
‘

AV,

q

9

4 ne E a ee > ‘

Sere ele

rs

FRANCIS KEARNEY ET AT. 49

has projections from its outer side at points between the openings,
while yours has no such projections ?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Is there not this further difference in the arrangement of the
two devices, that your screen is located near the bottom of the
smoke-arch extending below the lowest flue tabe and only up to
the third flue tube from the bottom of the boiler, while the defend-

ant’s screen exteiids from about the highest flue to about the
92 second lowest flue? In other words, is not the defendant’s

screen located at a much higher point within the smoke-arch
than yours?

A. It is higher, but ours is not so low as the lower tube.

Q. Is not also the defendant’s screen supported by the exhaust
nozzles at one end and by the smoke-stack at the other, while your
screen, as described in the reissue patent, rests upon and is supported
by the sheet-iron plate “H”?

A. Yes; yours is supported by the exhause nozzles, a plate cast
around the nozzle, and ours rests on a flat surface.

Q. Then, as I understand you, your claim for infringement lays
solely upon the fact that the defendant’s screen is made with ver-
tical openings. Is that correct?

A. That 1s correct.

Q. When was Exhibit 5 made?

A. I couldn’t tell how long it has been made; it has been made
some time.

Q. How many years?

A. It has been made probably 10 years.

. Who made it?

A. We had some cast at Hews & Phillips’, some at Currier’s, some
on High street, and some at Roseville.

(). Were they all made with projecting lugs on the bottom ?

A. Yes, sir.
93 q. These lugsare not shown on the drawings of the patent
or described in the specifications, are they ?

A. I don’t know that they are. I couldn’t say. I haven’t read
it over carefully enough to see that.

(). Please read it now in answer to the question; and also state
if you find anything said in the specification about the screen being
made by casting or from casting. . |

A. I don’t see it here. I don’t find any description of the lugs
or anything relating to castings.

Q. Now, if it were not for the lugs no air could get into the bot-
tom or through the bottom of the screes, could it?

A. No.

(). And it would not operate well without the air getting in at the
bottom, would it?

A. It has operated very well without the lugs.

Q. Do you mean by the screen resting on a plate or without a
plate ?

A. It would have to rest on a plate.

Q. When did you first begin to use the plate at the bottom ?

7—314

#
OT aT

evancee anata, Aesahreaehl

inte (imamate eaieiemnenemnaimianainmenaemmmmimenneene
\

" Sadia Romer on Ake . eee

be eh leat GindiaieniasA dn ptensla ee

50 THE LEHIGH VALLEY RAILROAD CO. VS.

A. We have always used it, I think, but I don’t think it was
claimed in the first patent, but I think it was in the reissue, but we
have always used it at the bottom.

Q. Did you always use the lugs, too?

A. We cut them off some.
04 ©. I meanat first. Did you use them at the time you ap-
plied for the patent—the lugs?

A. I couldn’t say as to that, the base plate not being mentioned
in the first application, but it was in the second. I think those
lugs were used, some with and some without; they gave too much
draft at the boitom and drew large cinders up.

©. How is the bottom of defendant’s screen made, do you
know? Like the blue-print drawing—open or closed ?

A. Plates cast around the exhaust pipe. Those plates are perfo-
rated with round holes.

Redirect examination :

Q. You, in your cross-examination, spoke of your device being
used on several engines on the Morris & Essex railroad, and that
one was ordered taken off; do you know why? '

A. The master mechanic, Mr. Lewis, told the engineer running
the engine named “ Lyke F. Tronson ” when that engine come in
she would not come out with the grating in. Mr. Lewis claimed
the engineer running the engine told him that she didn’t steam
weil; the engineer claimed it to be a falsehood, and a dispute arise
between the two. When I was speaking to Mr. Bartlet, who was

running the engine, that he .told Mr. Lewis that the engine
95 didn’t steam, and he said it was a falsehood, myself and Mr.

Bartlett got into some words over the matter; he denied
ever saying anything of the kind, and said if I said so I was telling
a falsehood also. We had soine trouble. Mr. Bartlett reported me
to Mr. Lewis and Mr. Lewis dispensed with my services. That is
why I knew about the one being ordered taken off.

Q. Were there negotiations between Mr. Tronson and yourself on
the one side and the Morris & Essex railroad for the use of this
spark-arrester ?

A. They thought of adopting it at one time.

Q. Why didn’t they do it?

A. They thought that me and Mr. Tronson, being employed by
the company, ought to give if to them for nothing.

Q. Do you remember the grounds upon which the patent was re-
issued, or was that matter left to your attorney ?

A. That was left to my attorney; Mr. Maleolmson, I think, had
that in charge; he got the reissue.

Recross-examination:

@. Do I understand you to say in answer to the last question that
Mr. Malcomson prepared the application for reissue on his own re-
sponsibility ?

A. He had charge of it.

/

. FRANCIS KEARNEY ET AL. 51

96 Q. He prepared it and you and Mr. Tronson signed it?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And you left it to him to make the alterations that were con-
sidered necessary ”
A. Yes, sir; I think he made the alterations.

Sworn and examined before me this 6th day of Oct., 1886.

Notary Public.

97 OLIVER DRAKE sworn on behalf of complainants.
Direct examination by Mr. Harris:

. @. What is yourjage and occupation and where do you reside?
| A. My age will be 58 next birthday ; occupation, solicitor of pat-
ents; residence, Newark, N. J.

Q. For about how long have you been engaged as solicitor of
patents?

A. Twenty-odd years.

(Q. What was your empioyment before that ?

A. I was engaged in mechanical pursuits prior to that; some
portion of the time at the Erie car works, near the Bergen tunnel.

Q. Are you familiar with the construction of locomotives ?

A. In a general way; yes, sir.

(. Have you examined and are you acquainted with the draw-
ings, specifications, and claim in patent of Kearney & Tronson for
spark-arresters, reissue No. 5184?

A. Yes, sir; I examined that somewhat carefully several years
ago; upwards of three years, I think it was.

@. You may state what the device therein described is, its use,
and your reason therefor.

A. Tine device described in the claim in the patent is for arrest-

ing the sparks and preventing their passage through the
98 smoke-stack. It is termed in the patent “ spark-arrester for

locomotives.” It consists of a grating placed at the lower
part of the “ petticoat pipe,” composed of vertical bars with narrow
vertical spaces between them. The claim, first, 1s for a grating let-
tered “ D,” with vertical bars placed at the foot of the spark or pet-
ticoat pipe “ E” in the manner and for the purpose substantially as
described. I understand that claim to be generic in character, so
far as it relates to the bars and spaces between them being vertically
arranged. The second claim is for the combination of the grating
“D” with a wire netting lettered “F” in the drawing. This wire
netting is placed near the top of the petticoat pipe “EI” and at or
near the base of the smoke-pipe and is intended to intercept any
sparks that may by any possibility pass the lower grating outside,
not going through it, more especially when kindling the fire or
when the engine is not In motion.

Q. What do you consider the particular feature of the first claim
of the patent ?

THE LEHIGH VALLEY RAILROAD CO. VS.

A. I think that question was answered in my answer to the first

question—that is, it seems to be intended to cover broadly a grating,

composed of vertical bars with narrow spaces between them,

99 places at the foot of the spark or petticoat pipe of a locomo-
tive engine.

Q. You may examine Complainants’ Exhibits 3 & 4 and defend-
ant’s blue-print drawing “A” and state what they represent.

A. They represent a grating composed of vertical bars and open-
ings arranged in substantially the same positions as those described
and shown in complainants’ patent. The only differences that I
note are that the gratings appear to be arranged a little higher in
the blue-print drawing than in the complainants’ patent, and they
are wider at the top than at the bottom than in the patent. Those
in the blue print appear also to be supported by what I suppose to
be the exhaust pipe, also in Complainants’ Exhibit 4. I notice also
a difference in the construction of the grating. Those in the blue-
print drawing and Complainauts’ Exhibits 5 and 4 show ties ar-
ranged alternately between the bars, whilest in the patent there 1s
but one tie, about in the centre, extending all around horizontally.
These differences, however, do not seem to be material. I should
judge that the gratings shown in the blue print and Exhibits for
Complainants 3 and 4 might be cast iron, while those in the patent
may be made of wrought iron. However, I am not certain of that,
there being nothing said, as I notice, in the patent about it. I
haven't read it through, but I don’t notice any reference made to
that.

L00 At this time, 5 o’clock p. m., the further examination of
the witness on the stand was adjourned till tomorrow, Oct.
7th, at 10 o'clock a. m.
THURSDAY—10 o'clock a. m.
The parties appeared as before, and the witness was examined
further as follows:

Q. In your opinion, does the grating, in its construction and
arrangement as shown in defendant’s blue drawing, Exhibit “A”
for identification, and in Complainants’ Exhibits 3 and 4, embody
the same features as the first claim in the complainants’ patent ?

A. Yes, sir; there isno doubt in my mind on that point.

(). Have you ever before testified as an expert in patent causes
before the United States courts ?

A. I have; frequently.

Cross-examination by Mr. McCatiuw :

Q. Do you find the subject-matter of the second claim of com-
plainants’ patent in the drawings or machine represented by the
drawings referred to in your direct testimony ? |

A. I do not find the subject-matter of the second claim in the -

blue-print drawing, Exhibit “A,” nor in Exhibits 3 & 4, as
101 the petticoat pipe in the blue print and in Exhibit 4 for
complainants appears to telescope into the smoke-stack or

he APOC Men

4

FRANCIS KEARNEY ET AL. 53

pipe without leaving any opening between the two, in which case
there is no need of the wire netting which is shown in complainants’
patent and embraced in the combination in the second claim
thereof.

Q. Is not the pipe shown by the blue print and referred to in
your last answer as closely fitted or telescoping into tne smoke-stack
practically a downward extension of the stack into the smoke-
arch ?

A. It may be considered such, and that is true also of the petti-
coat pipe in complainants’ patent.

I might add here, I can see no reason why the petticoat pipe in
complainants’ patent might not be made to fill the smoke-stack or,
rather, that such a construction would make any difference in the
operation of the device.

Q. If the complainants’ petticoat pipe were made as you suggest,
to closely fit the smoke-stack, it wouldn’t be the same petticoat pipe
described in the patent, would it?

A. In one sense, no, but in another, yes—that is, the operation
would be the same in both cases; but the grating or netting “ F”

in the case of a close fit of the two pipes would not be needed.
102 Q. If the screen or grating “ F'” was omitted it would not
be the same device described in the patent, would it?

A If the netting were omitted the combination covered in the
second claim of the patent manifestly would not be present; but I
cannot see that that would affect the subject-matter of the first claim
in any respect.

Q. Is not the petticoat pipe “ EF” made an element of the combi-
nation covered by the first claim ?

A. Most assuredly. It is net a combination, however. The claim
reads thus: “ The grating ‘ D, with vertical bars placed at the foot
of the sprak or petticoat pipe ‘E’ in the manner and for the pur-
pose substantially as described.” Now, I do not regard the terms of
the claim to be limited in any manner by the shape of the petticoat
pipe or by its union or the manner of its union, rather, with the
smoke-pipe.

(). If it is not a combination claim, what sort of a claim is it, in
your opinion ?

A. Iam inclined to think your question involves a question of
law; still, I may say that the claim might be regarded, possibly, as
a combination claim and yet not be limited by the shape of the pet-
ticoat pipe or the manner of its union with the smoke-pipe.

@. You said in your direct examination that you had not

103. read the specification through. Please now do so and see if

you find therein any suggestion that the pipe “EF” may be

made to fit the smike-stack, or that the grating “FI” may be dis-
pensed with.

A. I meant that I had not read itthrough immediately preceding
my being placed upon the stand. I have, however, read it through
since. I find the following language in the specifications, to wit:

™ F” is a netting or grating placed around the top of the petticoat
pip. 2€, SO as to cover the annular opening caused by the difference in

54 THE LEHIGH VALLEY RAILROAD CO. VS.

size of the upper part of the petticoat pipe and the bottom of the
smoke-stack “G.” Now, whilest I fiud no reference made to omit-
ting the wire netting, it seems to me to be apparent that the in-
ventors intended to apply their invention—that Is, the grating “ D”
placed at the lower part of the petticoat pipe—to locomotives in gen-
eral; but, finding the construction of the locomotive in respect to
the petticoat pipe and smoke-stack to be such as is shown in the draw-
ing of the patent, they hit upon the device “ F”’—that is, the wire
netting—as a means for covering the opening between the two pipes
where they connect; hence the incorporation of a second claim in
the patent.
104 The latter part of the foregoing answer, in which the wit-
ness expresses his opinion of what he supposes the inventor
intended, is objected to as non-responsive and irrelevant.

Q. What do you understand by the term “ petticoat pipe” in
mechanics, and why do such pipes obtain that name ?

A. Why they obtain the name “ petticoat pipe” I am unable to
say, neither can I see the propriety of the name, but I find it in the
specification. I will quote the language as follows: “‘ E’ is a pipe
extending from within the base of the smoke-stack down into the
smoke-box, and commonly termed a ‘petticoat pipe.” I under-
stand this pipe to be a mere extension of the smoke-pipe, or the
smoke-pipe an extension of it, as vou please, and I see no reason
why they should not be closely joined or a space left between them,
particularly.

QQ. Would it not be a fair interpretation of the language to say
that a petticoat pipe obtained its name from its similarity to the
garment of such name, being wider at the bottom than at the top,
and open at both ends?

A. There is some force and significance in your suggestion.

QQ. Can you say why the petticoat pipe shown and deseribed in
complainants’ patent is made wide at the bottom and narrow at the

top ?
105 A. I cannot, as I have already intimated. I do not see by

the specification any indication that the inventors had any-
thing to do with the construction of a petticoat pipe or with a smoke-
pipe, or, indeed, with any other part of a locomotive, but simply took
them as they found them. I think that is manifest from the follow-
ing reading: “A represents a portion of a boiler of a locomotive. B
is & space commonly called the smoke-box. C C are the flues at the
point where they enter the smoke-box. E is a pipe extending from
within the base of the smoke-stack down into the smoke-box, and
commonly termed a petticoat pipe.” Now, I find no claim what-
ever to invention in respect of the construction of these parts. As
a matter of fact, [ should judge from the drawing that the locomo-
tive shown in the patent was an old one at that time, because of the
shape of the smoke-stack, which widens toward the top, as the old-
fashioned locomotive smoke-stacks used to, while that in the blue
print shows a smoke-stack of uniform diameter inside all the w;
up.

FRANCIS KEARNEY ET AL. 55

All of the foregoing answer after the words “I cannot” objected
to as non-responsive and irrelevant.

Q. The pipe “ E” of complainants’ patent does conform in shape
to the definition of “ petticoat pipe,’ as before stated, dues
106 it not?

A. Well, I think it does, somewhat.

Q. Suppose the definition of the term “petticoat pipe” be cor-
rect, do you find in the blue-print drawing, Defendant’s Exhibit
“A,” or in Complainants’ Exhibit 4 a petticoat pipe?

A. Well, yes; somewhat. The same pipe in the blue print and
in Exhibit 4 is larger at the bottom than at the top, but the taper
is not uniform ; but I don’t see anything material in that.

Q. You think the shape of the pipe as shown and described in
complainants’ patent is quite immaterial, do you?

A. Yes, sir. The specification, I think, is clear on that point
from the following: “ Eis a pipe extending from within the base of
the smoke-stack down into the smoke-box,” and then they add that
that particular pipe is commonly termed a “ petticoat pipe.” It is
clear to me that there is no intention there to limit themselves to
any particular shape or to any particular differences which may be
found in those pipes in different locomotives. In the claim this
pipe is termed “a spark ” or “ petticoat pipe.”

Q. Further on in the specification, after describing the difficulties

or objections to such contrivances before in use, the following
107 = statement of invention: “In order to overcome these diffi-
culties we place a grating, F (should be D), at or near the
ower end of the petticoat pipe E, so as to surround the exhaust pipe
: | and prevent any cinders or sparks entering the pipe E while

1»wing free passage for the smoke and gasses. We also plaee a
‘ting or netting, F, around the top of the petticoat pipe to cover
! , aperature left between it and the smoke-stack in order to arrest

.y sparks or cinders that may be drawn to that point.” Do you
,ot consider that the netting F is here referred to as an important
element of the invention described in the patent?

A. I certainly do, in connection with a locomotive of that con-
struction.

Q. Is there any more prominance given to the grating D than to
the netting F in this description of the invention ?

A. Well, I think there is ; but whatever prominance may be given
to the netting F, I don’t see that it detracts in any way from the
importance or from the function of the grating D, nor, in my judg-
ment, would the greater prominance of the grating D detract from
the importance or function of the netting F.

Q. Do you think that the inventors are entitled or warrented in

so changing the construction of the pipe E as to dispense
108 with the use of the grating F ?

A. Well, I can only infer that they had in contemplation
that there might be constructions in which the netting F might be
dispensed with, from the fact that they have made a specific claim
to the grating D independent of its relation to the netting F. If

56 THE LEHIGH VALLEY RAILROAD CO. VS.

the two claims had been combined in one, your reasoning would
undoubtedly be correct—that is, both the grating D and the net-
ting F would have to be used in combination in order to come

within the terms of such claim.
The latter part of the answer, referring to the reasoning of coun-
sel, is objected to.

Q. How do you understand the grating D to be constructed, from
the reading of the specification ? a

A. 1 should say it was a circular grating or at least conforming
to the shape of the petticoat pipe, the bars of which are arranged
vertically.

(). is it not stated that the grating D is to be made with straight
vertical bars of iron placed at small distances apart?

A. It isso stated in the specification.

Q. Is there any other form or method of construction of the grat-

ing described in the patent ?
109 A. I don’t see any other form specified. I see the term “a
grating ” used in several places in the specification.

Q. Please point out where any other grating than the grating D
is referred to as “a grating.”

A. I note in the fourth paragraph, commencing on the 7th line,
these words: “ D is a grating placed at the lower part of the petti-
coat pipe,’ &c. Then I find this language in the 5th paragraph :
“Our improvements relate to providing locomotives with a suitable
device for preventing live coals, cinders, sparks, and like sub- g@
stances,” &e. Here the words “suitable device” evidently refers to. she i grating having

9 way

; nov the bars and openings arranged
vertically, C shows the same with bars arranged horizontally. and
D shows the same with the openings square, composed of wire net-
ting.
Q. Do these photographs show sparks or particles of fuel sticking
or adhering to the grating ?
Law aan ~~ 9 : ; ;
A. ‘They each of them show specks which may desienate
~~ 6 ’ : » ° - . = ag > ’
115 particles of cinders or ashes clinging to the grating.
Q. In which of the three do the openings in the grating
appear most clogged or choked up by the sparks” :

FRANCIS KEARNEY ET AL. 59

A. Exhibit B appears to show the most, although it is badly
blurred. I should think Exhibit D shows the fewest.
Q. Presuming that you had madea test of the three several forms
of gratings shown by said photograph exhibits, and that the photo-
graphs had been taken immediately after the running of the same
. engine under the same conditions as to speed and length of run and

a used, would you still be of the opinion that a erating with ver-
) ical openings like Exhibit B was better for the purpose than either
» of the other gratings shown by Exhibits C and D?

A. If the conditions were in every respect the same, [ should be,
of course, forced to the conclusion that I expressed in my last an-
swer—that is, that Exhibit B was more clogged than either of the
other devices.

--* ee

Sworn — and subscribed before me this 7th day of Oct., 1886

Notary Public.
116 Testimony.

(Filed December 24th, 1886.)

Pi Evidence for defendant, taken pursuant to agreement of counsel,
before John S. Noble, notary public.

SoutH Easton, Pa., December 21st, 1886.

Met pursuant to agreement.
Present: Elwood C. Harris, counsel for complainant-; Andrew
McCallum, counsel for defe

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Aper_scotus_1894_314%3A0. Public record. Not legal advice.
