# Record and brief — The Crescent Brewing Company, Appellant. vs. Matthew Gottfried

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Aper_scotus_1887_35%3A0

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Record and brief
- **Published:** January 1, 1887

## Text

‘TRANSCRIPT OF RECORD.

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.

2

OCTOBER TERM, 1887.

No.odememe 53!)
oe

THE CRESCENT BREWING COMPANY, APPELLANT.
US.

MATTHEW GOTTFRIED.

APPEAL FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES FOR
THE DISTRICT OF INDIANA.

FILED SEPTEMBER 19, 1885.

te

Ceeraarev,. SCE

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.

OCTOBER TERM, 1887.

No. 294.

THE CRESCENT BREWING COMPANY, APPELLANT.

US.

MATTHEW GOTTFRIED.

APPEAL FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES FOR
THE DISTRICT OF INDIANA.

Original. Print.
Caption maine 1
Ee I iin beck stk ns wan, sania, seein seems aight ce » plain ppieipaaianes 2
Exhibit Letters Patent No. 42580, granted Holbeck & Gottfried,
‘ May 3, 1864
Appearance 2 eee
Stipulation as to testimony -_-_-
Answer... ........
Stipulation as to testimony
Replication ovine slack decile. ibaa ots eila Saami ihe
. Decree for complainant and reference to master_..---. ..-. --.-~. -.--
AT TE NTI i a. emcee ech 8 os hw ew sen wi een pimiaianaa aenin pa
ee Rpts fy © SSope ae rern ease hater iene aeseiea et ye a iene
. Decree affirming decree of September 23 s
NNN ONE NN ak iis ip cite oe alan Seenseinne Mahon anise chan ll oa
PR MNOr’S. TOROT nk oink hee sss oe
Motion to strike master’s report from files ..-._.
Order overruling motion to strike master’s report .... .-..---. .------
; mxpentions to master’s report 2... 5, 8.5 5 es ht en en see
| Final decree

‘—— nem li aE Eee ee ee ee ee ee ee

_————e wee oer ee re ee ee en ee a ee ae ee ee 6 ae ee oe

= _——eeoe o = ee eee ee es

ee
:
on BE heen ene enemy ’

aa _
ee.
Sear er”

Oe ee ee ee

Jupp & DeTwkEILER, Printers, WasHineton, Avuaust 16, 1887.

~~
we

y v

|

II : INDEX.

Original. Print.
88 42
89 42
89 42

EN SD cis Wie cc amicin. mi cals arin tame sees adeiiet
eer srantine appeal... oo... 2) Se ee Rts anata S
EE gina Cinliitiie awe tna Sneed onsreicdkerswebbe hues sacmee
i os int seen cenit, mia) caaiarinw did new whee 90 43
ppepemuen Of James K. Vailo. ww 6. nic sl. se 43
Complainant’s exhibit—Gottfried assignments’’_.__.---.--..--. 94 47
Complainant’s exhibit—‘‘Stromberg assignment’’ __------ -----. 57
Complainant’s exhibit—‘‘Holbeck assigment’’ ___..-....--- ---. 95
Deposition of Alvaro B. Graham_--_-- ...-— 60
Matthew Gottfried, (1) ....-.. ..2... -. s2 68
NN, cee IN is i inate wed oe tek eee y 78
Te: RD sos deg estes ged Wis Kathi testa oy 97
Complainant’s exhibit—“‘Gottfried’s circular”’ i 131 an
On thaw seid time jwecd do Ge unlne 133 | aia
Deposition of Conrad Seibel-_-.-. -.-- 133
RE TONNE Sinica cnc nas bes Suns ode enme
William J. Lemp--.--
Re TRAE ks itiliiee 35 Geis Sense
oe NE clic aba ccehceneaheah cine, winenirik: ih ne ele iteintesp- dani vs
Ns es IE ee eee: ve cS cence aoe Sn oe
MUOUOURRD: DMOIO oi ine oe Sees be ee
NT Aa i ie Ses OLS 1 BED Ste
pe A Se PEO nn ne Hees ies Lee
John H. Timmerman .-_-.-_--
is I a nen eee ceniviiwas bono iee
Exhibit—‘‘Blettner Sketch Vogt Machine’’.__.-__~ -.-. Saloon
Exhibit—“Blettner Sketch Blast Furnace No. 1’’____..---:
Exhibit—“‘Blettner Sketch Blast Furnace No. 2’’___. ---...
Deposition of Hermann Reutti is ier cen Silene
John Kauffman
Exhibit—“‘Sketch of Kauffman’s Pitching Machine’’- ._... -
Exhibit—“‘Cochrane & Slate English Patent’’ ._..--.. ----_-
Exhibit—“‘Davison & Symington English Patent’’.______.~
Exhibit—“‘C. P. DeVaux English Patent’’. ~~... -_- on
Exhibit—“Extract from Tomlinson’s Cyclopedia of Useful
CU, MIP tects Mathbcees Seine pakennic
Exhibit—“‘Extract from Handbuch fir Bier-Brauer, 1854’ __
Exhibit—“‘ Extract from Der Bier-Brauer, 18617’... _2-
Deposition ik: REG AORN ie cs a ce ee Se
Carsten 2800rlein .... en ence PER anes
CORRRRON.. SEMITONES ek hints wns Sain a be
Exhibit—“‘Translation from Handbuch fiir Bier-Brauer

ky Sates dtatmadmeste.

a eae
aa

eee

ote cul .
a

BNE oiEk Sins ak neha nnaien: eee Gea cdo
Exhibit—“‘Translation from Der Bier-Brauer, 1861’’._.. -__-
Bxninit—‘BRheinbolt Sketch” ... oe ne wo ce wn oe cee

Deposition of George H. Knight --- Basak Wilden is
Albert Schwill bs ceuliies selene tabaci a

Herman Lackman- uae ae ea

RE SK SS i ng iin oes ntti ins

Evidence before master -. ~~ -..- Selaihad Toisas alias ghvaraaecigics
Deposition of Matthew Gottfried, (2) -..... .__. ‘
pom deavek: (2) .o2- 55s 1.

Master’s opinion -.:.. .-_- sols ps Speeipies asks the labial

er iene

———
5 nh Banca mn nina

INDEX.

Exhibit—“Cireular A—Circular of Reutte e¢ al., October 17, ’73_
Exhibit—“Circular B—Circular of Brewers’ Association, October
mA: 3600 2. secestl

Deposition of William J. Seib..-- Rts, KIB mobi Cr
Anton Schuerle

Clements Uhleman-._ ...__-_.

Bawa TROMAR oo os ae a

SG We OIRO e ces So as a es

George Stupp

William Roessler_- ~~

August Olinger -_-. -.-- ere aa

Fe EE, BRD incidences Keine hd smi cannons

Joseph Meier PEED Stow on ND SME ePIC mee

CRIN I sites: cevsicttntetsi- eminence website

Ferdinand Steiner sala

SRN Bs one sh a a

RE AE IE iciscaiicccccitins saci bh Rin He hea

Matthew: Gottfried, (8)... 0. cic ia

Jacob Frech, Jr. (1)

otstie®: Bem Were io oo ii oi Ss a a

Bo Ay eo OE OR Sitio kd shin Gee Sega

Re ae ; Senn GeO Pier pete eer eit nen ha oe ae

William Gerst ors STS sober oy as Ae. ea

SFRICUIES SIO rrrine sand tadiids Sees

EG TE ici sen its tvs insta v ett es

Jacob Frech, Jr. (2)

John Brenner_----

2nomes: A. DORMS Soi cic Wass cc Gaegae. .

Report of Henry W. Bishop, master to C. C. U. S. N. D. Ills.
Report of Ezra H. Prince, master to C. C. U.S. 8. D. Ills.,
and orders thereon tat ch a
Report of Wm. C. Hillis, master to C. C. U. 5. C. D. Iowa_-
Report of Chas. A. Winslow, master to C. C. U. S. E. D. of
Mo., &c. .-.-
Report of Wm. C. Hillis, master to C. C. U.S. C. D. of Iowa-
Report of Joseph Gutman, Jr., master to C. C. U. S. D.. of N.
Y., &e.
Agreement between Gottfried & Febeek nn ih ee oe
Agreement between Gottfried & Jung & Borchert
Jung & Borchert statement
Agreement between Gottfried & Hill & Pilz. ---
" " " Genesee Brewing Co.----- ~-----
Jacobi, Coghlin & Co._.-- ---.-
SehemerWAan 5. 5 pi iniieiecein
PROUD OE > carina 5th Sek isl eile a
Apianinent of Holbeck to Gottfried
Complainant’s Exhibit—Letter of Banning & Banning, to Wood
& Boyd, December 5, 1882
Letter of Parkinson & Parkinson, to
Banning & Banning, Jan. 21, 1882-._-
Defendant’s Exhibit—Letter No. 1—Letter of Banning & Bann-
ing, to Parkinson & Park-
inson, Jan. 18, 1882.._-.

Original.

850

352
357
364
382
392
411
419
433
437
445
448
455
462
469
473
480
487
515
522
525
539
551
562
575
579
593
595

603
608

613
620

625
633
635
637
638
639
642
644
647
650

651

Tift
Print.
254
255
261

276

INDEX.

Deiendant’s Exhibit—Letter No. 2—Letter of Banning & Bann-
ing, to Parkinson & Park-
inson, Jan 20, 1882
Letter No. 3—Letter of Parkinson & Park-
inson, to Banning, Dec.
18, 1882 .--
Letter No. 4—Letter of Parkinson & Park-
inson to Banning & Bann-
ing, Jan. 20, 1883

I OI ici ictemisihiietinin shies nuhsdiiw iideibdlinegy wees “bialiel: iilieblan
I iar: Sian each sean nent sy Si nee pitay same

Original.

Print.

THE CRESCENT BREWING CO. VS. MATTHEW GOTTFRIED. 1

Pleas of the circuit court of the United States within and for

the district of Indiana, begun and holden at the United

States court-house, in the city of Indianapolis, on the first Tues-

day of November, in the year of our Lord one thousand eight

hundred and eighty-four, before the Honorable William A. Woods,

judge of the district court of the United States for the district of
Indiana and ez officio judge of said circuit court.

MATTHEW GOTTFRIED
vs. 7152. Chancery.
THE CRESCENT BREWING COMPANY.

Be it remember- that heretofore, to wit, at the November term,
1880, of said court, on the 21st day of March, 1881, before the Hon-
orable Walter Q. Gresham, one of the judges of said court, the fol-
lowing proceedings in the above-entitled cause were had, to wit:

Comes now the complainant, by Banning and Banning, and files
his bill herein in the words following, to wit:

2 Bill.

To the honorable the judges of the circuit court of the United States
for the district of Indiana:

Matthew Gottfried, of the city of Chicago, in the State of Illinois,
and a citizen of the State of [llinois, brings this his bill of complaint
against the Crescent Brewing Company, a corporation duly organized
and existing under and by virtue of the laws of the State of Indiana,
of the city of Aurora, in the State of Indiana, and a citizen of the
State of Indiana, defendants; and thereupon your orator complains
and says:

I. That prior to the third day of May, 1864, your orator and one
John F. T. Holbeck were the origina! and first inventors and dis-
coverers of a new and useful improvement in pitching barrels not
known or used by others before their invention thereof, and which
had not, at the time of their application for a patent therefor, been
in public use or on sale for more than two years, as your orator
verily believes; and that, upon due application, letters patent of
the United States No. 42580, in due form, were issued to your
orator and the said Holbeck, dated the said third day of May, 1864,
granting to them, their heirs, administrators, or assigns, for the
term of seventeen years, the full and exclusive right of making,
using, and vending to others to be used the said invention—as by
reference to the said letters patent here in court to be produced,
and a copy of which is hereto attached and made a part of this bill,
will more fully appear.

II. That by virtue of the premises and written assignments
given for good and valuable considerations, and duly executed and
recorded, your orator became and now is the sole and exclusive
owner of the entire right, title, and interest in and to said letters
patent and in and to all claims for damages occasioned by infringe-

1—294

9 THE CRESCENT BREWING CO. VS. MATTHEW GOTTFRIED.

ments thereof, and for gains, profits, savings, and advantages made
or received by others by reason of such infringements, and is by law
entitled to sue for and receive said claims to his own use.

III. That on the fourth day of October, 1877, your orator and the
said Holbeck filed their bills of complaint against Frank Bartholomae
and Bernard Roesing, Peter Fortune and John Fortune, and Peter
Schoenhofen, respectively, in the circuit court of the United States
for the northern district of Illinois, setting forth the said letters patent
and the infringement thereof by said defendants, and praying an
account and injunction against them, respectively; that the said de-
fendants afterwards filed their respective answers to said bills, deny-
ing, among other things, the validity of said letters patent, and setting
up that your orator and the said Holbeck were not the first and
original inventors and discoverers of the said invention, but that the
same had been patented in England and known and publicly used
by others in this country long prior to the date of their invention ;
that, issues being joined and proofs taken at length and for a long time,
all of said causes were brought to a hearing on their merits on the

eighth day of May, 1878, before his honor Judge Henry W.
3 Blodgett, and were argued before him by the counsel for your

orator and said parties, respectively, and were afterwards held
under advisement by said judge until the 24th day of June, 1878, when
judgment was duly pronounced; and that said court then decided,
among other things, that the said letters patents were good and valid
in law, and that your orator and the said Holbeck were the original
and first inventors and discoverers of said invention, patented as
aforesaid, and, by decrees entered of record in two of said causes (a
special arrangement being made by counsel as to the other perpet-
ually enjoined the said defendants, Batholomae and Roesing and
Fortune Bros., from using the said patented invention, and ordered
accounts to be taken of the profits and damages due by reason of
their infringements already committed ; that on the 6th day of Jan-
uary, 1879, on the application of the defendants, said decrees were
set aside and all of said defendants allowed to make further de-
fense; and that amended answers were afterwards filed setting up
_ additional defenses, and new proofs taken at length and for a long
time, in each of said causes.

That on the 3d day of June, 1878, your orator and the said Hol-
beck filed their bill of complaint against Valentine Blatz, and on
the 9th day of August, 1878, their bills of complaint against the
Philip Best Brewing Company, the Joseph Schlitz Brewing Com-
pany, and Jacob Obermann and Max Fueger, respectively, in the
circuit court of the United States for the eastern district of Wiscon-
sin, setting forth the said letters patent and the infringement thereof
by the said defendants, and praying an account and injunction
against them, respectively ; that the said defendants afterwards filed
their respective auswers to said bills, denying, among other things,
the validity of said letter patent, and setting up that your orator
and the said Holbeck were not the first and original inventors and
discoverers of the said invention, but that the same had been pat-
ented in England and known and used -by others in this country.

THE CRESCENT BREWING CO. VS. MATTHEW GOTTFRIED. 3

long prior to the date of their invention ; that, issues being joined
and proofs taken at length and for a long time, all of said seven
causes above named were brought to a hearing on their merits on
the 12th day of June, 1879, and were heard and argued together
before his honor Judge Charles E. Dyer; that the said hearing and
arguments were very full and exhaustive and lasted five days; that
said causes were afterwards held under advisement by said judge
until the first day of December, 1879, when judgment was duly
pronounced, and that said court, in a very long and full opinion,
then decided, among other things, that said letters patent were good
and valid in law, and that your orator and the said Holbeck were
the original and first inventors and discoverers of the said inven-
tion, patented as aforesaid, and, by decrees entered of record, perpet-
ually enjoined all of: said defendants from using the said patented
invention, and ordered accounts to be taken of the prufits and dam-
ages due by reason of their infringements already committed; all
which will more fully appear by a reference to the opinions of said
judges and the record of the proceedings in said suits, the first of
which opinion is published in vol. 13 of the Official Gazette of the
Patent Office, page 1128, and the second in vol. 17 of said Official
Gazette, page 67

That after said decisions the said The Philip Best Brewing Com-
pany, The Joseph Shlitz Brewing Company, Valentine Blatz, and
Jacob Obermann and Max Fueger acquiescing therein and in the

validity of said patent, settled with your orator for their past
4 infringement, and purchased licenses for the future use of

said patented invention, end paid your orator therefor a large
sum of money, amounting to many thousands of dollars; and that
thereupon final decrees were entered in the suits against them, re-
spectively, from which no appeals have ever been taken.

IV. That since the granting of said letters patent and at divers
times and occasions between that time and the filing of this your
orator’s bill the said Crescent Brewing Company, well knowing the
premises, and in infringement of said letters patent, and in violation
of the exclusive rights of your orator thereunder, and without the
license of your orator or the said Holbeck or any one ever inter-
ested in said patent, at Aurora, Indiana, to wit, at the district afore-
said, have used and still continue to use thesaid invention patented
as aforesaid, whereby great injury has resulted to your orator and
great gains and profits have accrued to the said defendants, the full
amount of which is unknown to your orator, but which in equity
belong to him and should be accounted for by the said defendants
and paid over to your orator as the avails of his exclusive rights
aforesaid and the profits and gains which he would have derived
therefrom but for the unlawful acts of the said defendants.

V. That your orator has no adequate remedy in the premises
save in a court of equity, where matters of this nature are properly
cognizable.

Where ore your orator prays—

1. That the defendants may answer the premises and may fully
disclose the number of pitching machines they are using and have

4 THE CRESCENT BREWING CO. VS. MATTHEW GOTTFRIED.

used, how long they have used such machines, the names thereof, by
whom the same were manufactured, and by whom and when pat-
ented, and whether in such machines the air is heated by its being
forced through or in contact with the fire on its passage from the
blower to the cask or barrel to be pitched; and, if not, how it is
heated, stating fully the construction and operation of the machine.

2. That the defendant, its agents, attorneys, servants, and work-
men, and each and every of them may be restrained and enjoined,
as well preliminary and provisionally as perpetually, from such in-
fringement of said letters patent.

3. That the defendant may render to your orator a true ac-
count of the number of casks, barrels, or kegs which it has pitched
or heated for pitching by the use of a blast of heated air forced into
such casks, barrels, or kegs and of the gains, ‘profits, and benefits
derived therefrom, and may be decreed to pay over to your orator
any and all of the gains, profits, savings, and advantages, to be duly
determined, made, derived, or received by the said defendant from
the use of said patented invention and in violation of your orator’s
rights as aforesaid and all damages resulting to your orator from the
use by the said defendant of the said patented invention, together
with such increase over the actual damages suffered as is warranted

by law and may seem to your honors just and proper.
5 4. And that your orator may have such other and further
relief in the premises as may be agreeable to equity and good
conscience, and'as to your honors shall seem to meet.

Lo this end may it please your honors to grant unto your orator—

1. The writ of subpoena issued out of and under the seal of this
honorable court, directed to the said defendants, The Crescent Brew-
ing Company, commanding it by a certain day and under a certain
penalty to be and appear in this honorable court, and then and
there to answer the premises and stand to and abide by such order
and decree as may be made against them.

2. The writ of injunction, as well preliminary and provisional as
perpetual, issuing out of and under the seal of this honorable court,
enjoining and restraining the said defendants, The Crescent Brew-
ing Company, its agents, attorneys, servants, and workmen, and
each and every of them, as is heretofore in that behalf pray ed.

And your orator will ever pray, ete.

MATTHEW GOTTFRIED.
BANNING & BANNING,
Solicitors for Complainant.
THOMAS A. BANNING,
Of Counsel.
Copy of Patent Mentioned in Foregoing Bill.
No. 42580.

The United States of America to all whom these letters patent shall
come:
Whereas J. F. T. Holbeck and Matthew Gottfried, of Chicago,
Illinois, have alleged that they have invented a new and useful im-

THE CRESCENT BREWING CO. VS. MATTHEW GOTTFRIED. 5

proved mode of pitching barrels, which, they state, has not been
known or used before their application; have made oath that they
are citizens of the United States; that they do verily believe that
they are the original and first inventors or discoverers of the said
invention, and that the same hath not, to the best of their knowl-
edge and belief, been previously known or used; have paid into the
Treasury of the United States the sum of thirty-five dollars, and
presented a petition to the Commissioner of Patents signifying a
desire of obtaining an exclusive property in the said invention, and
praying that a patent may be granted for that purpose:

These are, therefore, to grant according to law to the said Holbeck
and Gottfried, their heirs, administrators, or assigns, for the term of
seventeen years from the third day of May, one thousand eight
hundred and sixty-four, the full and exclusive right and liberty of
making, constructing, using, and vending to others to be used, the
said invention, a description whereof is given in the words of said
Holbeck and Gottfried in the schedule hereunto annexed, and is

made a part of these presents.
6 In testimony whereof I have caused these letters to be made
patent and the seal of the Patent Office has been hereunto
affixed.

Given under my hand, at the city of Washington, this third day
of May, in the year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred and
sixty-four, and of the Independence of the United States of America

the eighty-eighth.
[r. s.] J. P. USHER,
Secretary of the Interior.

Countersigned and sealed with the seal of the Patent Office.
D. P. HOLLOWAY,

Commissioner of Patents.

The Schedule Referred to in These Letters and Making Part of the Same.

To whom it may concern:

Be it known that we, J. F. Th. Holbeck and Matthew Gottfried,
both of Chicago, county of Cook, and State of Illinois, have in-
vented a new and useful improvement in pitching barrels, etc.; and
we do hereby declare that the following is a full, clear, and exact de-
scription thereof, reference being had to the accompanying drawings,
making a part of this specification, in which—

Figure 1 is a longitudinal section taken in a vertical plane through
the center of the apparatus which we employ in the operation of
pitching barrels, etc. Figure 2 is a horizontal section taken in the
course Indicated by red line 2 x in figure 1. Figures 3 and 4 are
views of the tabular-closing guard which is applied to the barrels or
casks in the operation of heating them. Similar letters of reference
indicate corresponding parts in the several figures.

Before filling casks with spirituous or volatile liquids it is neces-
sary to render the casks impervious to air, the most common and
probably the cheapest method of doing which has been to flow
melted pitch or other substance into the pores and joints of the

6 THE CRESCENT BREWING CO. VS. MATTHEW GOTTFRIED.

casks while they are in a heated state, but the difficulties hitherto
attending this process arise in consequence of a want of some eco-
nomical means of heating the casks without burning or seriously
charring their inside surfaces.

My invention has for its object the preparation of casks for re-
ceiving pitch or other melted substance suited to the object in view by
subjecting said casks to blasts of highly heated air by means of an
apparatus which will be hereinafter described. To enable others
skilled in the art to understand our invention we will describe its
construction and operation.

In the accompanying drawings we have represented one mode of
carrying our invention into effect, which consists of a furnace con-
structed of masonry as represented by A, figures land 2. This fur-
nace is of a rectangular form and has a vertical central opening, A’,
through it. Near the base of the furnace is a grate, a, beneath which
is the ash pit 6, and above which is a fire chamber, c, which 1s cov-
ered by a lid, c’, as shown in figure 1.

An opening, d, is made through the side of furnace A, which forms
an external communication with an internal chamber, A’, either
below the grate or above this grate, as shown in Figure 1. This
opening, d, communicates with a fan case, B, arranged outside of the
furnace and furnished with a series of rotary wings or fans, ee, which

may be rotated by any convenient motive power.
7 The fans e e create a blast of air through the furnace
chamber A’; this air, rushing through the opening d and
through the fire which is built upon the grate a, is allowed to escape
through the passage d’ near the top of the furnace.

Between this passage d’ and the cask which it is desired to heat
I form a communication by means of a detachable pipe, E, which
connects with a short pipe, E’, that is secured around the passage d’,
as shown in figures 1 and 2. ;

The removable pipe E may be made conical as represented, so
that the opening through the head of the cask D need not be very
large, and this pipe is provided with a bow handle, g, by means of
which the pipe can be removed or adjusted in place without liability
of burning the hands. The contracted end of pipe E enters a short
tube, A, which passes through and is suitably affixed to a covering
plate, 7, that is used to close or partially close the opening 7 which is
made through the head of the cask. This plate 7 should be some-
what larger than the opening through the head of the cask, and
this opening should be of such form as to admit plate 7, and to allow
of this plate being adjusted, as represented in figure 1. When this
plate 7 is adjusted on the inner side of the cask head, opposite the
openings there through, it may be confined in place by means of a
key, &, which is passed between a flange formed on. the projecting
outer portion of the short pipe h and the head of the cask, as repre-
sented in figures 1 and 2.

When a cask which it is desired to render impervious to air is ad-
justed in proper position, and a communication formed between it
and the furnace A, as above described, a fire is made upon the grate
a, and by means of the blast fan applied to the furnace the heated

THE CRESCENT BREWING Co. VS. MATTHEW GOTTFRIED. . 7

products of combustion are forced into the cask and allowed to
esvape therefrom through an opening at the bottom of covering
plate 2, as indicated by the arrows in figure 1.

When the cask thus subjected has become properly heated so
that the resin substance within it will readily flow into the pores
and cracks or joints in the wood, the parts 7 and E are removed, the
opening through the head of the cask properly closed, and the cask
rolled about until the melted resin has permeated every pore and
interstice in its inside surface.

(Here follows diagram marked p. 8.)

Having thus described our invention, what we claim as
new and desire to secure by letters patent is—
ist. The application of heated air under blast to the interior of
casks by means substantially as described, and for the purposes set
forth.
2nd. The use of a removable conductor, E, in combination with a
furnace and blowing apparatus, arranged and operated substantially
as described.
3rd. The tube-holding plate 2, in combination with the removable
pipe E and blast furnace A, substantially as and for the purposes

described.
J. F. TH. HOLBECK.
MATH. GOTTFRIED.
Witnesses;
CHAS. H. BARMM.
M. FLEMING.

And at the same time the defendant, by Parkinson & Parkinson,
enters appearance herein.

And the parties, by their respective solicitors, file stipulation
herein in the words following, to wit:

It is hereby agreed between the attorneys for complainant and
defendant, respectively, in the above-entitled cause, as follows:

First. That within ten days after notice to said attorneys for de-
fendants that complainant has commenced in the same court a suit
on the same patent against the Crescent Brewing Company of Aurora,
Indiana, appearance shall be entered and answer filed in behalf of
said company without service.

Second. That complainant may use the deposition of James R.
Vail, already taken in cause No. 6454, pending in said court between

this complainant and Samuel D. Langtree ¢ al., in this cause,
10 as well for the prima facie case as on account, if any account

shall hereafter be ordered; the said deposition to have the
same effect and with the same right of objection to relevancy and
competency as if said deposition had been duly taken after the issues
had been made up in said cause.

Third. Defendant shall close its proofs within seventy days after
the complainant’s prima facie case is clused, and complainant shall
have twenty days in which to take rebutting evidence after defend-
ant has closed its evidence.

ae (yr Hal beck ¥ Cott fred

Mode of Fitching Barrels
S1* 42,580. Fatented May s 1804.

}

¢

“RISEN TIE, jc yporaes)

a FOREN SO E RAE IEE als ARIS NG: NE eS LENA MRO O ARI HG

Send OM ot
ew ee il

:
;
:
|
;
4

#
Bh eeettoonenars 7

on

THE CRESCENT BREWING CO. VS. MATTHEW GOTTFRIED. 9

IV. It denies that it has at any time violated any right of the
complainants; denies that it has used or is using any invention em-
braced in said patent or any invention patented as alleged in said
bill of complaint; denies that any injury has resulted to the com-
plainants or any gain or profit accrued to this defendant which be-
longs to the complainants or which they have been prevented from
deriving by any wrongful act of this defendant.

V. It denies that the alleged improvement in pitching barrels,
described and claimed in said patent, involved patentable invention.

VI. It denies that said Gottfried and Holbeck were joint inventors
of the same or any part thereof.

VII. It says, on information and belief, that said Gottfried and
Holoeck were not the original or first inventors of the alleged im-
provement in pitching barrels, for which said letters patent are or
purport to be granted, or of any material or substantial part thereof;
that the same had been shown and described in letters patent and
printed publications and works, and had been in public use and on

sale in this country prior to their supposed invention and
12 discovery thereof; that the same has been abandoned to the

public; that for many years since the issue of said patent to
the complainants machines similar in construction and in mode of
operation to those now and heretofore used by these defendants, and
by the use of which it is charged with infringement in said bill of
complaint, have been commonly manufactured, used, and sold
throughout this country by many different persons with the full
knowledge of the complainants and without their asserting or pre-
tending to have any exclusive right thereto, though having the
same title then as now under said letters patent; that this defendant
and the public generally have thereby been led to suppose and have,
up to about the time the bill of complainants herein was filed, sup-
posed that they had the right to make, use, and sell said machines,
and that these complainants fully recognized and accorded said right
and made no claims to any exclusive right therein; that said com-
plainants have thereby become estopped from asserting ary exclu-
sive right in or to any of said machines or the processes for which
they are and have been used, and all title thereto would thus be
abandoned to the public if any such title had ever been vested in
them by said letters patent.

VIII. That said alleged improvements were, prior to the alleged
invention thereof by complainants, described and shown in the fol-
lowing letters patent and printed publications, to wit:

English letters patent, No. 12918, to Cochrane and Slate, granted
and dated January 3d, 1850.

English letters patent, No. 9924, to Robert Davison and William
Symington, granted and dated November 2d, 1843.

English letters patent, No. 6901, to Charles Pierre Deveaux,
granted and dated October 8th, 1835.

English letters patent, No. 5701, to James Beaumont Nelson,
granted and dated September 11th, 1828.

English letters patent, No. 11067, to George Hinton Bovill, granted
and dated January 31st, 1846.

2—294

THE CRESCENT BREWING CO. VS. MATTHEW GOTTFRIED.

Fourth. That both sides shall unite in asking Judge Gresham or
Judge Drummond to hear the said cause in twenty days after com-
plainant has closed his evidence in rebuttal.

Dated March 17, 1881.
BANNING & BANNING,
Sol’rs for Compl’nt.
PARKINSON & PARKINSON,
Sol’rs for Def’t.

And afterwards, to wit, at the November term, 1880, of said court,
on the 29th day of March, 1881, before the Honorable Walter Q.
Gresham, one of the judges of said court, the following further pro-
ceedings in the above-entitled cause were had, to wit:

Comes now the defendant, by Mess. Parkinson & Parkinson, its
solicitors, and files its answer herein in the words following, to wit:

11 Answer.

The answer of The Crescent Brewing Company, defendant, to the
bill of complaint herein.

This defendant, reserving to itself all right of exception and ob-
jection to said bill of complaint, for answer thereto says as follows:

I. It denies that the said Gottfried and Holbeck were the original
or first inventors of any improvement in pitching barrels, as set
forth in said bill of complaint; denies that the alleged improvement
had not been in public use and on sale for more than two years
prior to the application for a patent therefor, and denies that the
alleged improvement or any exclusive right therein was secured to
them by or under the patent set forth in said bill, or by any assign-
ment of or under said letters patent.

II. It is informed and believes and therefore alleges that these
complainants have, since the issue of said patent, divested them-
selves, by lawful assignmenis, of all title thereunder, but is not in-
formed whether the same has been reassigned to them or whether
they are now vested with said title, and therefore denies the same;
and further denies that they are entitled to any damages occasioned
by infringement of said patent, or any gains, profits, savings, or ad-
vantages made or received by reason thereof, or are entitled to sue
for or receive the same.

III. It denies that said patent is good or valid; denies that the
public generally acquiesced in the validity thereof; denies that any
money, profit, or advantage has beeu lawfully realized by licenses,
settlements, recoveries, or otherwise under said patent, and alleges
that all money and profit which has been obtained thereby has been
wrongfully extorted by threats of expensive and vexatious litigation
and by misrepresentations as to the validity of said patent.

As to the several suits against other parties, recited in said bill
of complaint, it has no specific information, and leaves the com-
plainants to make such proof thereof as they may be able, denying,
however, that it is affected thereby, and denying that the defences
available against said patent were fully exhibited or passed upon in
either of said suits.

THE CRESCENT BREWING CO. VS. MATTHEW GOTTFRIED. 9

IV. It denies that it has at any time violated any right of the
complainants; denies that it has used or is using any invention em-
braced in said patent or any invention patented as alleged in said
bill of complaint; denies that any injury has resulted to the com-
plainants or any gain or profit accrued to this defendant which be-
longs to the complainants or which they have been prevented from
deriving by any wrongful act of this defendant.

V. It denies that the alleged improvement in pitching barrels,
described and claimed in said patent, involved patentable invention.

VI. It denies that said Gottfried and Holbeck were joint inventors
of the same or any part thereof.

VII. It says, on information and belief, that said Gottfried and
Holoeck were not the original or first inventors of the alleged im-
provement in pitching barrels, for which said letters patent are or
purport to be granted, or of any material or substantial part thereof;
that the same had been shown and described in letters patent and
printed publications and works, and had been in public use and on

sale in this country prior to their supposed invention and
12 discovery thereof; that the same has been abandoned to the

public; that for many years since the issue of said patent to
the complainants machines similar in construction and in mode of
operation to those now and heretofore used by these defendants, and
by the use of which it is charged with infringement in said bill of
complaint, have been commonly manufactured, used, and sold
throughout this country by many different persons with the full
knowledge of the complainants and without their asserting or pre-
tending to have any exclusive right thereto, though having the
same title then as now under said letters patent; that this defendant
and the public generally have thereby been led to suppose and have,
up to about the time the bill of complainants herein was filed, sup-
posed that they had the right to make, use, and sell said machines,
and that these complainants fully recognized and accorded said right
and made no claims to any exclusive right therein; that said com-
plainants have thereby become estopped from asserting any exclu-
sive right in or to any of said machines or the processes for which
they are and have been used, and all title thereto would thus be
abandoned to the public if any such title had ever been vested in
them by said letters patent.

VII. That said alleged improvements were, prior to the alleged
invention thereof by complainants, described and shown in the fol-
lowing letters patent and printed publications, to wit:

English letters patent, No. 12918, to Cochrane and Slate, granted
and dated January 3d, 1850.

English letters patent, No. 9924, to Robert Davison and William
Symington, granted and dated November 2d, 1843.

English letters patent, No. 6901, to Charles Pierre Deveaux,
granted and dated October 8th, 1835.

English letters patent, No. 5701, to James Beaumont Nelson,
granted and dated September 11th, 1828.

English letters patent, No. 11067, to George Hinton Bovill, granted
and dated January 31st, 1846.

2—294

10 THE CRESCENT BREWING CO. VS. MATTHEW GOTTFRIED.

English letters patent, No. 4253, to Sir Thomas Coleman and
Alexander Galloway, granted and dated May 4th, 1818.

English letters patent, No. 83, of 1854, to Bellford, granted and
dated January 12th, 1854; sealed May 26th, 1854.

English letters patent, No. 435, of 1859, to John J. Russel, granted
and dated February 16th, 1859.

English letters patent, No. 183, of 1860, to Isaac L. Bell, granted
and dated January 24th, 1860.

English letters patent, No. 71, of 1857, to John J. Russel, granted
and dated March 28th, 1857.

Tomlinson’s Cyclopedia of Useful Arts, published by George Virtue
and Company, London and New York, 1854, volume 2, page 665,
figure 2015.

Handbuch fur Bierbrauer, von P. Muller, Druch und Verlag, von
Friedrich Vieweg und Sohn, Braunschweig, 1854 (received in the
library of the United States Patent Office at W ashington, D. C.,
March 12th, 1855), page 116 to foot of page 118.

IX. That said alleged improvements were, prior to the

13 alleged invention thereof by the complainants, known to and

publicly made, used, and sold in the United States by the fol-
lowing persons, to wit:

Known and publicly used at the Eureka Iron Company’s works,
in Wyandotte, Michigan, and at the Richmond Iron Furnace, Berk-
shire county, Massachusetts, by the following persons, among others,
to wit:

Warren Brinton, now residing at Bay View, Wisconsin; J. J.
Hagerman and 8. D. Arnold, both now residing at Milwaukee, Wis-
consin; George Coffin and Walter Lovelace, both now residing at
Richmond aforesaid, and Charles Lovelace, now residing at Depere,
Wisconsin.

Known and publicly used at the Rockland brewery and elsewhere
in New City, Rockland county, New York, and in Charleston, in said
county and State, by Joseph Beck, who now resides in the city of
New York, in said State, and by Albrecht Becker, who now resides
in the city of Brooklyn, in said State.

Known and publicly made, used, and sold in the city of St. Louis,
Missouri, by Conrad Seibel, who now resides and may be found at
No. 810 South Second St., in said city of St. Louis.

Known and publicly used in said St. Louis by Christian Stahlin,
Julius Winklemeyer, Julius Winklemeyer & Co., Joseph Schneider,
John G. Zoller, John G. Zoller & Co., the Star brewery, William J.
Lem, Schuer’s brewery, and many others, which said persons and
companies now reside in said St. Louis.

X. It says that said patent does not describe or show a useful or
successful operative machine and that said machine has never been
made, used, or sold by the complainants or others as there shown,
and that the machines and all the machines that have been made,
sold, or used by complainants and others purporting to be made
under said patent and marked thereunder and now sought to be
covered thereby were first introduced to the market by other parties

THE CRESCENT BREWING CO. VS. MATTHEW GOTTFRIED. 11

and are only valuable, useful, and salable by reason of features not
shown or described in said patent.

All of which things this defendant is ready to maintain and prove
as this honorable court shall direct, and it prays to be hence dis-
missed with its costs in this behalf maintained.

THE CRESCENT BREWING COMPANY,
By JAS. W. GAFF,
P resident Crescent Brewing Company.

PARKINSON & PARKINSON,
Sol’rs & Counsel for Def’ts.

And afterwards, to wit, in recess of said court, on the 17th day of
June, 1881, the following further proceedings in the above-entitled
cause were had, to wit:

Come the parties and file their stipulation herein in the
14 words following, to wit:

It is hereby agreed by counsel that tracings of the sketches
introduced by witnesses in testimony taken before Dan’! Kell
notary public and acting special examiner, in above-entitled causes,
may be made and certified in connection with a duplicate of the
testimony and filed therewith in either of above cases, with like
effect as the original—ihe original being filed in the other case.

Dated Chicago, May 31, 1881.

BANNING & BANNING,
Solicitors for Complainants.
PARKINSON & PARKINSON,
For Def ’ts.

And afterwards, to wit, at the May term of said court, on the
17th day of October, 1881, before the Honorable Thomas Drum-
mond and the Honorable Walter Q. Gresham, judges of said court,
the following further proceedings in the above-entitled cause were
had, to wit:

Come now the complainants, by Mess. Banning & Banning, their
solicitors, and 4ile their replication herein, in the words following,

to wit:

The Replication of Matthew Gottfried, Complainant, to the Answer of
The Crescent Brewing Company, Defendant.

This repliant, saving and reserving unto himself, now and at all
time hereafter, all and all manner of benefit and advantage of ex-
ception which may be had or taken to the manifold insufficiencies
of the said answer, for replication thereunto, says that he will aver,
maintain, and prove his said bill of complaint to be true, certain,
and sufficient in law to be answered unio, and that the said answer
of the defendants is uncertain, untrue, and insufficient to be replied

unto by this repliant; without this, that any other matter
15 or thing whatsoever in said answer contained material or
effectual in the law to be replied unto, confessed or avoided,
traversed or denied, is true; all which matters and things this re-

12 THE CRESCENT BREWING CO. VS. MATTHEW GOTTFRIED.

pliant is and will be ready to aver, maintain, and prove as this
honorable court shall direct, and humbly prays as in and by his

said bill he has already prayed.
BANNING & BANNING,
Solicitors for Complainants.

And afterwards, to wit, at the May term of said court, on the 23d
day of September, 1882, before the Honorable Walter Q. Gresham,
one of the judges of said court, the following further proceedings in
the above-entitled cause were had, to wit:

This cause came on to be heard at this term and was argued by
counsel, and thereupon, upon consideration thereof, it was ordered,
adjudged, and decreed as follows, viz: That said complainant and
one John F. Holveck, were the original and first inventors and dis-
coveries of the invention described and claimed in letters patent of
the United States, No. 42580, issued to them on the third of May,
A. D. 1864, for an improved mode of pitching barrels; that said
letters patent are in all respects good and valid in law, and that
the complainant is the exclusive owner thereof and entitled to sue
for and receive all damages and profits arising out of and accruing
from infringements thereof, as alleged in the bill of complaint
herein.

That the Crescent Brewing Company, the defendant herein,

16 has infringed upon the said letters patent and upon the ex-
clusive rights of the complainant under the same by using

the invention therein described and claimed, as alleged in said bill.

That the complainant- recover of said defendant the profits, gains,
and advantages which the defendant has received or made or which
have arisen or accrued to it from its infringement of said letters
patent by the use of said patented invention as aforesaid, and also
the damages which the complainants have sustained thereby.

That this cause be referred to William P. Fishback, Esq., one of
the masters of this court, to take proofs and to ascertain and take
and state and report to the court an account of the number of kegs,
barrels, casks, and other vessels which the defendant has pitched or
heated for pitching by the use of said patented invention, and of
the gains, profits, and advantages which the defendant has received,
or which have arisen or accrued to it from said infringement of
said letters patent and use of said patented invention as aforesaid,
and also of the damages which the complainant has sustained
thereby ; that on such accounting the complainant has the right to

cause an examination of the officers of the defendant ore tenus

17 or otherwise, and also the production of the books, vouchers,
and documents of the defendant, and that the defendant at-
tend for such purpose before said master from time to time as said

master shall direct.

THE CRESCENT BREWING CO. VS. MATTHEW GOTTFRIED. 13

And the defendants, by their solicitors, now file their motion and
reasons for a rehearing herein in the words following, to wit:

Motion of the Defendant, The Crescent Brewing Company, for a Rehearing.

Now.comes the defendant herein and moves the court for a re-
hearing and reversal of its order for a final decree last made herein
for the reason—

First. That the court erred in ordering a final decree upon ex
parte affidavits.

Second. That the court erred in reversing its order heretofore
made for a decree dismissing the bill.

Third. That the court erred in finding that there was any patent-
able novelty in the Gottfried machine.

Fourth. That the court erred in overlooking the machine known
in evidence as the “ Pewterer’s blast,” the “ De Vaux machine,” and
other auterior machines, in misconstruing the Cochran and Slate
patent, and in finding that the machine shown and claimed in com-
plainant’s patent possessed any patentable novelty as compared with

these earlier machines.
18 Fifth. That the court erred in that it did not find that the
first claim of complainant’s patent, being for the process, was
invalid, the court having found that the process was not novel.

Sixth. That the court erred in that it did not find that there was
no infringement of either the second or third claims.

Seventh. That the court erred in ordering a decree for injunction
and account upon a patent long since expired.

Eighth. That the court erred in that it did not find that the patent
having expired before the submission of the cause it had no juris-
diction as a court of equity to award either an injunction or account
or other relief.

Ninth. That the court erred in that it did not find that the pat-
entee having unreasonably neglected and delayed to disclaim the
process claim of his patent was not entitled to any relief whatsoever
in this case.

Tenth. That the court erred in that it did not find that the com-
plainant had no sufficient title under the patent sued upon to main-

tain this suit.
PARKINSON & PARKINSON,
For Defendant.

Which motion is overruled.

19 And afterwards, to wit, in recess of said court, on the 28th
day of September, 1882, the following further proceedings in
the above-entitled cause were had, to wit:

Comes now the defendant in the above-entitled cause, by Mess.
Parkinson & Parkinson, its solicitors, and files its motion for rehear-
ing in above cause in the words following, to wit:

Now comes the defendant herein and moves the court to set aside
the decree heretofore entered, for the reason—

First. That the same was entered without notice to defendant and
without opportunity to object to the form and substance thereof.

14 THE CRESCENT BREWING CO. VS. MATTHEW GOTTFRIED.

Second. That the same finds infringement of complainants’ pat-
ent generally, without specifying any particular claims thereof,
whereas there was no evidence which upon the broadest construction
of the patent tended to prove the infringement of any other than
the “ process” claim, which said claim was held in the opinion of
the court to be incapable of being sustained as a process claim.

Third. For that if the patent is construed as a patent for a machine,
as the court now construes it, the record shows that there is no in-
fringement.

Fourth. For that the decree recites the case to have been argued

by counsel during the present term, whereas there has been
20 no argument by counsel during the term, unless it be by

the counsel directly or indirectly representing complainant,
without notice to defendant.

Fifth. For that the court erred in hearing ex parte affidavits upon
an issue raised by demurrer to the complainant’s petition for rehear-
ing, and in entering a final decree upon a finding based upon such
ex parte affidavits, and in overlooking other defences in the case than
those to which said ex parte affidavits particularly related.

Sixth. For that the court entered said decree in disregard of a
motion already filed in behalf of defendant for rehearing upon points
alleged to have been overlooked by the court in its opinion and re-
fused to hear defendant upon said motion.

Seventh. For the several reasons specifically set forth in the mo-

tion for rehearing heretofore filed by the defendant herein.
PARKINSON & PARKINSON,
‘or Defendant.

21 And afterwards, to wit, at the May term of said court, on the

7th day of October, 1882, before the Honorable Walter Q.
Gresham, one of the judges of said court, the following further pro-
ceedings in the above-entitled cause were had, to wit:

This cause baving been heretofore argued by the counsel of the
respective parties and an opinion delivered by the court finding the
equities in favor of the defendant, and a petition for rehearing hav-
ing been filed by the plaintiff and demurred to by the defendant
and argued by the counsel of the respective parties, and another
opinion delivered by the court finding the equities this time in favor
of the plaintiff, and a petition for a rehearing having been filed by
the defendant and overruled by the court and a decree entered in
favor of the plaintiff, and another motion for a rehearing and to
set aside said decree having been filed by the defendant and argued
by its counsel, the court declining to hear arguments for the plain-
tiff, and the court being sufficiently advised thereon, doth now
order, adjudge, and decree that said motion for a rehearing and to
set aside said decree, filed by the defendant, be, and the same is

hereby, overruled, and that said decree stand affirmed ; and,
22 further, that said decree be, and is hereby, amended so as to

adjudge and decree that the plaintiff's patent, No. 42580, is
good and valid in law as to its first and second claims, and that the
defendant has only infringed said first and second claims, the third
claim of said patent not being now in controversy.

|

THE CRESCENT BREWING CO. VS. MATTHEW GOTTFRIED. 15

Opinion of the Court.
GRESHAM, J. :

I have considered the proofs and arguments on a motion for a
rehearing and am convinced that in holding the complainant’s
patent invalid undue importance was attached to the German pub-
lications, the Cochran and Slate patent, and the Siebel device as
anticipating defenses. See 9 Fed. Rep., No. 13, p. 762.

The German publications are vague and uncertain and describe
no machine capable of practical and successful use by brewers for
pitching casks and kegs.

It is sufficient to say of the Cochran and Slate device, without
again stopping to describe it, that without material changes in its
construction or arrangement it cannot be made to produce the same
useful results as are produced by the complainants’ device.

I am still of opinion, however, that the complainants’ patent can-
not be sustained on the theory that they were the first to use a hot

blast, from which the oxygen had been removed, in heating
23 the interior of casks for the purpose of pitching them.

Siebel, we have already seen, heated the cask with his ma-
chine for the same purpose by the application of a hot blast, which
he deprived of its combustible properties by forcing it through and
in actual contact with the fire in the furnace.

This furnace he inserted into the cask through the man-hole, and
there operated it. Of course this machine could not be used in
pitching kegs or other small receptacles into which it could not be
inserted.

In this and other respects the Siebel device was crude and imper-
fect compared with the complainants’ machine, which was located
and operated outside the receptacle to be heated and pitched, and
which was adapted to pitching barrels and small kegs as well as
casks. The complainants’ device was the first, and the proof shows
that it is to-day the only, means by which brewers are enabled to
pitch barrels and kegs without removing the heads. This device
also forces into the receptacle to be heated a much hotter blast than
Siebel can apply with his machine, and with it brewers are enabled

to do their pitching more expeditiously and economically.
24 The method or means which the complainants employed

in forcing into the cask a hot blast consisting of the same
elements as the Siebel] blast produced, if not a new result, certainly
a much better one than could be produced by any other method or
means then known to persons engaged in the business of brewing.
Compared with other means for heating the interior of casks and
receptacles, the complainants produced a new mechanism or thing
which enabled them to pitch casks and kegs more rapidly and eco-
nomically than they had ever been pitched before. I think the
complainants were entitled to a patent, not for the improved or
better result or effect, but for the mechanism or means by which the
result was accomplished.

It is the policy of the law to encourage useful improvements, and
I am unwilling to hold that the complainants’ device, consisting of

16 THE CRESCENT BREWING CO. VS. MATTHEW GOTTFRIED.

old elements combined and operated, as stated in the specification,

practically superseding, as it does, all other known means of pitching

kegs and other small receptacles and greatly superior, as it confess-

edly is, to Siebel’s machine for pitching large casks, is the mere me-

chanical equivalent of the latter or of any other device. These are
briefly my reasons for withdrawing my former ruling and for

25 now entering a decree in favor of the complainants, with an
order for an account of profits.

And afterwards, to wit, at the November term of said court, on the
16th day of November, 1583, before the Honorable William A. Woods,
one of the judges of said court, the following further proceedings in
the above-entitled cause were had, to wit:

Comes now William P. Fishback, master in chancery, and files
his report and evidence in the above-entitled cause, and said mas-
ter’s report is in the words following, to wit:

Master’s Report.

MATTHEW GOTTFRIED
vs. No. 7252.
THE CRESCENT BREWING Co.

MATTHEW GOTTFRIED

v -

’ ¥ 3 No. 6454.
RacHakEv 8S. Garr, Executrix, etc., and Samuet LAne- [
TREE. )

MATTHEW GOTTFRIED
v. No. 6840.
EvuGENE Hacu and Anton SIMON.

To the honorable the judges of the circuit court of the United States
for the district of Indiana:
26 I, William P. Fishback, to whom the causes above entitled
were referred, under interlocutory decrees therein, to ascertain,
state, and report to the court an account of the gains, profits, and
advantages which the defendants have received or which have ac-
crued to them, respectively, from their infringement of the Gott-
fried-Holbeck patent, No. 42580, mentioned in said decrees and the
damages which the complainant has suffered thereby, do respectfully
report as follows:

There being a number of cases of like character pending in the
United States circuit court for the southern district of Ohio, which
have been referred to J. C. Harper, Esq., special master, under simi-
lar interlocutory decrees, it was agreed that the cases above-entitled
and the cases pending in Ohio should be heard jointly by the un-
dersigned and Mr. Harper. We were attended on the hearing of
said cause by Messrs. Banning & Banning, counsel for complain-
ant, and Messrs. Parkinson & Parkinson, counsel for the defendants ;
have taken in evidence on the part of the complainant, in addition
to the stipulations or admission as to the amount of pitching done
by defendants in each case, the depositions of the following wit-

THE CRESCENT BREWING CO. VS. MATTHEW GOTTFRIED. 17

nesses and the documents and exhibits therein mentioned and referred

to,namely: William J.Seib, Anton Schuerle, Clements UhIman,
27 Edward Thorman, Emil Wilke, George Stupp, William Ros-

seter August Olinger, William Koehle, Joseph Maier, Casimer
Theinger, Ferdinand Steiner, August Goefile, Frank Walther, and
Matthew Gottfried, recalled ; and on the part of defendants the depo-
sitions of the following witnesses and the documents and exhibits
therein mentioned and referred to, namely : John Hauck, Christian
Moerlien, Emil Schmidt, C. W. Boss, Henry Schmidt, Henry Mul-
hauser, Louis Herancourt, William Gerst, Jacob Frecht, Jr., Gottlieb
Schwartz, J. M. F. Windish, John Hauck, Christoph Siebel, Henry
Scharf, and John Brenner. I herewith return all said testimony
and exhibits to be filed with this report.

The record is substantially the same in all cases pending here and
in Ohio.

The result of consultations and correspondence had between the
undersigned and Mr. Harper is a difference of opinion, and for that
reason [ state my views and reasons at greater length than is usual
in reports of this kind.

The Facts.

The complainant’s patent was issued in May, 1864, and the pat-
entees shortly afterwards attempted to introduce the inventicn to
the brewing public, and to this end they sent out circulars and ex-

hibited machines at one or two brewers’ conventions. Their
28 efforts to introduce the invention failed, and they never suc-

ceeded in esiablishing and building up a manufacturing
business. After a few years the patent was transferred to the Barrel
Pitching Machine Company of Baltimore, but this company proved
a failure and after four or five years went out of existence. At the
time it was organized a personal arrangement was made between
the patentees by which Holbeck became the owner of Gottfried’s in-
terest in the patent conditionally, and Gottfried was to receive a
royalty of ten dollars a machine. Little, if anything, was ever done
under this arrangement, and it was subsequently revoked. The
title and patent afterwards—partly in 1875 and partly in 1876—be-
came reinvested in the patentees.

In the meantime brewers and others regarded and treated the
patent as invalid and engaged extensively in making and using 1n-
fringing machines. The patentees commenced a number of suits
soon after getting the title back. The first decision reached 1n any
of these suits was by Judge Blodgett in June, 1878 (Gottfried v. Bar-
tholomuae, 3 Banning & Arden, 308), but this decision was afterwards
set aside and a rehearing granted. The next decision, and the first

one that was allowed to stand, was by Judge Dyer, of this
29 circuit, December .1, 1879 (Gottfried v. Phillip Best Brewing
Company, 5 Banning & Arden, 4). Up to the date of this
last decision the brewers generally considered the patent as invalid,
or, at least, there was such a doubt of its validity that they were un-
willing to recognize the patentees’ rights, and many brewers, includ-

o—294

18 THE CRESCENT BREWING CO. VS. MATTHEW GOTTFRIED.

ing the defendants in this suit, still refuse to recognize its validity,
notwithstanding this and other decisions.

In May, 1879, Gottfried bought out Holbeck’s interest in the pat-
ent for ten thousand dollars and a limited license authorizing Hol-
beck to manufacture machines and sell them to brewers who had
never infringed the patent or who had settled for their infringe-
ments.

This license was given asa part of the consideration for Hol-
beck’s interest in the patent, and was a personal arrangement be-
tween the patentees limiting Holbeck’s operations to one class of
brewers and Gottfried’s to another class. Gottfried says in his depo-
sition it was granted “asa part of the purchase price” and “ because
he, Holbeck, was an old acquaintance of mine, and because he was
in very poor circumstances at that time.”

After Judge Dyer’s decision Gottfried made a number of settle-

ments and granted licenses to brewers in different parts of
30 the country. These settlements were made in two ways—

some of them at a lump figure determined by the capacity of
the brewery and others at a regular, uniform rate of fifteen cents per
keg and one dollar per cask holding 80 barrels and one dollar and
a half per cask holding over 30 barrels for each pitching.

While there is some conflict in the evidence, I consider that this
rate per keg and cask was fair and reasonable and not above the
actual value of the invention or the benefits derived from its use in
ordinary pitchings, and I am fortified in this by the fact that, in
the several master’s reports and decrees hereinafter mentioned that
is the rate upon which damages have been estimated.

This is a brief statement of the material facts, and the evidence
in support of it will be referred to more in detail hereafter.

The complainant, waiving profits, now contends that he is entitled
to recover, first, for an established royalty or license fee per keg and
eask, and. if not, that he is entitled to.recover whatever rate per keg
and cask the general evidence shows to have been fair and reason-
able. Defendants contend that the complainant is limited by

amounts received by him and his co-patentee in their early

dL efforts to introduce their invention, and particularly from the

. sale of machines and Gottfield’s agreement made at the time

of the transfer to the Barrel Pitching Company. ‘The main ques-

tion to be determined, then, is, At what rate is the complainant en-
titled to recover”

Before proceeding to consider this question it is proper I should
stute, in view of the evidence, that the invention is a very impor-
tant and valuable one.

Before this invention was known kegs were pitched as follows:
The hoops were knocked off and staves loosened ; the heads taken
out; the hoops put on and tightened ; the pitch and wood heated by
fire built inside the keg; the hoops knocked off and staves loosened
again; the head put in; the hoops put on again, and staves tight-
ened up again. By using the complainant’s invention the pitching
is done without this trouble. I am convinced that, notwithstanding
the efforts of some of the witnesses to desparage the value of the

ghee gen PO Me . ?

a oe

en aad ‘~ >

THE CRESCENT BREWING CO. VS. MATTHEW GOTTFRIED. 19

invention, the use of complainant’s machine saves time, labor and
pitch ; the vessels are better pitched and, not being injured by the
taking out of the heads and displacing the staves, will last much
longer than when pitched in the old way. Its value is further de-
monstrated by the fact that the defendants in this suit, who have

tried both methods, have preferred to use the complainant’s
d2 invention, and they certainly would not persist in it if it did

not possess great advantages over the old pitching process,
the use of which would subject them to no liability.

Counsel on both sides insist that the complainant has an estab-
lished royalty or license fee which should be adopted as the basis of
the finding in these cases. Were I to adopt the rate insisted on by
the defendants the amount of complainant’s damages would be little
more than nominal.

As to the sale of machines by Holbeck, Mr. Gottfried testifies as
follows; reference is made to the pages of his printed deposition.
He says:

“My co-patentee, Holbeck, manufactured machines and occasion-
ally succeeded in selling a few. We put the price low, making for
ourselves only a profit of about $100.00 per machine. We expected
in this way to be able to supply the trade with our invention and to
build up a large business in manufacturing machines, but after a
time we discovered that the brewers would not respect our rights.
A great many of them were using our invention, but to our claims

they would make no answers or dispute the validity of our

Oo patent. From one pretext or another they kept refusing to
pay us anything, although they all admitted the great value

of our invention. Finally, as our patent was fast expiring, we saw
no other way than to commence suits, which we did against a num-
ber of the largest brewers in the West. These suits resulted in de-
cisions in our favor. Since the decisions the brewers for the first
time began to respect our rights and many of them have settled
with us.” (Page 4.)

“We have sold about 20 machines between the time the patent
was issued and 1876 and 1877,’—the time the suits were com-
menced. (Page 11.)

“The first time the brewers commenced to recognize my rights
was after Judge Dyer’s decision, December Ist, 1879.” (Page 12.)

“Our patented invention has been used in about 3,000 breweries
without having paid for the right to use it.” (Page 12.)

“When we first sold the machines we had $100.00 profit per ma-
chine, but after a time, when they commenced making machines In
most every time, the price was cut down to $80.00 and afterwards to
$50.00 and $60.00—the profits, [ mean. Then came a number of

years when we could not sell any machines at all, on account
o4t of the prices being cut down to the manufacturer’s price.”
(Page 14.)

On cross-examination he says that the profits were reduced
from one hundred dollars to eighty dollars about 1866 and to sixty
dollars “ the next year after that;” that this was the profit on “the
furnace only;” that “the price was first two hundred dollars, then

4
Bi
a |
.
i
Bi

t

eb 5 SRS akin ORE So et OES Sf
Se St a

20 THE CRESCENT BREWING CO. VS. MATTHEW GOTTFRIED.

came down gradually to one hundred and fifty dollars;” that Hol-
beck “has been selling very few,” because “there has been a great
many infringing machines in the market” (pages 33-34); that in-
fringing machines came into use from 1867 to 1870, and that “after
that they were made very generally, and up to the expiration of the
patent some forty or fifty different manufacturers, and then some
brewers also, made their own machines.” (Page 43.)

The question is whether these transactions, these sales of a few
machines under the circumstances stated, while the patent was con-
sidered invalid, establishes any royalty or rate of recovery, and,
particularly, whether it now prevents the complainant from recover-
ing at another and higher rate. ‘The amount received by the com-
plainant since Judge Dyer’s decision in the settlements he has made

under the decrees that he has obtained have been large,
oO aggregating over $100,000.00.

The fact that brewers, prior to Judge Dyer’s decision, were
unwilling to recognize the validity of the patent placed the patentees
at a great disadvantage and rendered it impossible for them to deal
upon equal terms with brewers in selling the machines. The effect
of this disregard of the patentees’ rights was to cut down their
profits, and, as Mr. Gottfried says, then came a number of years
when they could not sell any machines at all, and they were able to
sell only about 20 machines, although it is in evidence that 5,000
brewers adopted and used the invention within the 12 or 13 years
after the patent was issued.

In the case of Campbell vs. Barclay (5 Bissel, 180), Judge Blodgett
said :

“Inventors are frequently compelled by stress of poverty or
force of circumstances to dispose of some part of their rights in
the thing invented at much lower rates than they and others know
them to be worth. The fact that the inventor has sold or given
away some portion of a patented right is no justification to another
who has wrongfully infringed upon the rights retained.”

In “Sickles v. Borden” (38 Blatchford, 544), in Judge Nelson’s

charge to the jury, the following language is used:

36 ‘He (the patentee) says that his object in selling at such

prices was to get the invention into publie use, and that, on
that account, he made sacrifices of what he deemed its real value so
that the public might see the successful working of his improvement.
Undoubtedly this circumstance is not peculiar to this patentee. His
account is, perhaps, the history of most inventions on their first in-
troduction to public notice. It requires effort, influence, and sacrifice
to introduce them into notice so that they may acquire the confidence
of the community. The public are distrustful of new inventions, and
rightly so. Notone out of one hundred patents issued at the present
day is worth, in my judgment, the parchment on which itis written.
It is only now and then that a valuable improvement is produced,
and it soon becomes the subject of litigation and contest; and even
the most meritorious requires time, effort, influence, and the sacri-
fice of money to bring them into use. It is quite proper that these
views should be taken into account upon the question of the patent

aaah ai eee = OE heer eer nw ey

THE CRESCENT BREWING CO. VS. MATTHEW GOTTFRIED. 21

fee. If you are satisfied that the improvement was sold for less than
its real value, for the reason stated by the patentee, and that sacri-

fices were made for the sake of introducing it into public
ov use, it is quite proper that these views should be taken into

account upon the question of the patent fee. If you are satis-
fied that the improvement was sold for less than its real value, for
the reason stated by the patentee, and that sacrifices were made for
the sake of introducing it into public use, these considerations
should be taken into account in fixing a patent fee as a measure of
damages.”

While the patent was considered invalid it is improbable that the
purchasers of any machines made by Holbeck gave him any more
than the price of the laborand material represented in the machine,
with manufacturer’s profits, and it is not likely that the inventor’s
royalty entered into the selling price of the machine. The fact that
the sales made by Holbeck were very few and at variable rates for
the purpose of introducing the invention is to be considered. He
seems to have offered his machine at almust any price, but the
brewers, disregarding the patent, preferred to manufacture their own
machines, and he was not able to sell to more than one out of every
one hundred and fifty that presently adopted the invention, and
then came a number of years in which no machines could be sold

at all.
08 I am unwilling to adopt what I consider a narrow and
illiberal rule, which would limit the patentee of an important
invention in thé amount of his recovery to rates which he was com-
pelled to accept under such circumstances.

The owner of a valuable patent should be encouraged to intro-
duce and put his invention into public use; and to hold that this
patentee should be now punished for his early efforts to introduce
his invention would, in my judgment, be very unjust.

Judge Dyer, of this circuit, in an unreported case—‘ Graham v.
Geneva Lake Crawford Manufacturing Company ”—used this lan-
guage: “J am inclined to look upon all of these agreements made
with Waterman and,Waterman & Bloom as rather partaking of the
nature of efforts to secure the manufacture of the machine and its
introduction into public use than as unqualified licenses fixing a
license fee which could be accepted as establishing, within the lan-
guage of the court in Seymour v. McCormick, the average of actual
damages sustained by the patentee when his invention should be
used without his license.”

The evidence does not show that the defendants in these

oo suits knew of the sales by Gottfried and Holbeck or that they

were In any way injured or misled by them. It appears in

the evidence of the Cincinnati brewers who were examined as wit-

nesses that the greater part of the infringement was committed in
ignorance of the existence of the patent.

Admitting that under certain circumstances the sale of machines
by Holbeck might be considered as fixing the rate of recovery, the
complainant is not necessarily bound thereby. While the courts
have held that the price that the invention commands between those

|

22 THE CRESCENT BREWING CO. VS. MATTHEW GOTTFRIED.

who sell and purchase it is the best criterion of value, they have also
recognized the propriety of allowing a higher rate or fixing a lower
one. InSeyimour v. McCormick (16th Howard, 490), the court say:
“If a patentee claims anything above that amount (his license fee)
he is bound to substantiate his claim by clear and distinct evidence ;”
and in Birdsell v. Coolidge (93 U. S., 70), the court say: “It is ad-
mitted in several cases that the circumstances may be such that the
finding should be larger than the royalty.” See upon the same point
Phillip v. Nock (17 Wallace, 462).

I do not think the arrangement between Gottfried and Holbeck

made at the time the Baltimore company was organized, by which
Gottfried was to receive ten dollars for each machine, has
40 any application in determining or fixing the rate of recovery ;
that was a personal agreement between two patentees, them-
selves old friends and joint inventors, and one which did not affect
their rights as against the public. This arrangement was made for
the purpose of assisting Holbeck in his efforts to introduce the in-
vention. Besides this nothing was ever done under it, and it was
revoked in 1875. It was held in Bussey v. Excelsior Manufacturing
Company (5 Banning & Arden, 135,) that the rescinded license or
contract cannot be allowed a controlling influence in fixing or de-
termining the patentee’s right of recovery, nor do I think that the
license given back to Holbeck, at the time of the sale to Gottfried of
his interest in the patent, was different in its effect. It was made
while the patent still was considered invalid, and it was expressly lim-
ited to operations with brewers who had never infringed the patent
or who had settled for their infringements, nor does it appear how
many, if any, machines were sold under it or at what price, or that
Gottfried was in any way connected with the sale of them. Gott-
fried says that he supposed, but did not know and could not tell at
what price they were sold after the title came back from the Barrel
Pitching Machine Company. (Page 35.)
41 I pass now to the consideration of the complainant’s deal-
ings with infringers after Judge Dyer’s decision sustaining
the patent. These consisted in,making lump settlements and in the
granting of licenses at so much per keg and cask for all pitching
done. As has already been said the lump settlements were based
upon the estimates of the capacity of the different breweries, but as
I do not consider them in estimating the complainant’s damages I
shall not refer to them any further.

After Judge Dyer’s decision the complainant granted licenses
under it at the rate heretofore mentioned. Gottfried names 13
licenses which he gave and says there are others. These licenses
were. in the master’s opinion, sufficient in number and extent to
establish a royalty or license fee under the patent within the mean-
ing of Seymour v. McCormick ; that the settlements were made after
suits were begun is not sufficient, in my opinion, to break their force.
I am not inclined to assume that the infringers paid more than they
believed they were liable for and would have been obliged to pay at the
end of litigation. It is enough to say that no evidence has been
introduced showing that these settlements were not fair or that they

SRE re ne

SR er ne

THE CRESCENT BREWING Co. VS. MATTHEW GOTTFRIED. 93

resulted from coercion or were the result of collusion, although, while

the evidence was being introduced, it was hinted by counsel for
42 the defendants that some of these settlements were collusive.

No effort was made to establish that to be the case, and, in
the absence of any such testimony, I am unwilling to infer it. The
rate being reasonable, in my opinion, I do not consider it important
that the licences were granted late in the life of the patent. In fact
it comes with a poor grace from these defendants, who have been
violating the complainant’s rights and forcing him to expensive and
protracted litigation, to insist that because they had deprived him
of the enjoyment of his rights for 10 or 12 years he was therefore
not entitled to enjoy them for the few years that remained of the life
of the patent. Never until Judge Dyer’s decision in 1879 were the
complainants in a condition or a position that enabled them to en-
force their rights against those who had been wantonly disregarding
them.

It is objected that these licenses involved settlements for past use
as well as for future use of the invention.

It has been frequently held that gross settlements are incompetent
to prove a royalty or license fee (Black v. Munson, 2 Banning &
Arden, 626; Mathews v. Spangenberg, 14 Fed. Rep., 850), but in the

licenses proved in this case the uniform rate has been charged
45 per keg and cask upon sworn reports, and this rate was ap-

plied to pitching done before the licenses were granted and
afterwards. I do not think that the rule applied to lump settlements
applies to the licenses proved in this case. If my conclusion that
the complainant has an established royalty or license fee per keg
and cask be incorrect it seems to me clear that the complainant is
entitied to recover at the rate claimed on another ground. If com-
plainants are not bound, as J think they are not, by the profits re-
ceived on their machines by the so-called royalty or license fee when
the brewing public denied the validity of their invention, and if the
licenses involved in the last settlement named, at which the rate of

15 cents per keg and $1.00 and $1.50 per cask is not established by

sufficient evidence to make them a uniform royalty, I still think the
complainants entitled to recover on another ground—namely, the
general evidence offered as to the value of the invention. In
Suffolk v. Hayden (3d Wallace, 320), the court say: “ There
being no established patent or license fee in the case, in order
to get at a fair measure of damage, or evel an approxima-
tion to it, general evidence must necessarily be resorted to,
and what evidence could be more appropriate and_ pertinent

than that of the utility and advantage of the invention
44 over the old modes or devices that had been used for working

out similar results.” Upon the question as to the value of
the complainant’s invention to those who use it there seems to be no
doubt. The fact that the old method of pitching kegs has given
place to this in most of the breweries of the country is conclusive
evidence that in the estimation of brewers it is valuable. As here-
tofore stated in this report, the hand-pitching process is expensive,
and must, in the nature of things, be wasteful as to material used

o%

7 RII LE «0
cai ET RR Me, ta + .

a a

24 THE CRESCENT BREWING CO. VS. MATTHEW GOTTFRIED.
and destructive to the casks that are subjected to the treatment. A
few witnesses, it is true, have attempted to belittle the importance of
the invention and the advantages it possesses over the old method
of pitching. Fifteen witnesses have been examined by the com-
plainant and fourteen by the defendants on this point. Of those
examined by the complainant nine are disinterested, four work in
his brewery, one is his foreman, and the other is himself. Of the
fourteen examined by the defendants, four are defendants at Cin-
cinnati in these cases, nine are in the employ of defendants, and
one—a former partner of defendants—is now apparently disinter-
ested.
There is a square conflict in the evidence of the plaintiff
45 and defendant as to the value of the invention, witnesses on
the one hand speaking of its great utility, while the witnesses
for the defendant belittle it and claim that it is unimportant and of
little or no value in the practical work of pitching, but the fact re-
mains that they are all using the invention and have been using it
for years, and that it was the first way ever devised for pitching
kegs without taking the heads out, and that it has really superseded
the old method of pitching.

In my judgment the evidence of the complainant on this point is
entitled to the greater weight, and, irrespective of any supposed li-
cense fee or royalty, I regard fifteen cents per keg and one dollarand
fifty cents per cask for each pitching a fair and reasonable rate for
estimating complainant’s damages; but this is no new question in
this circuit. Cases arising under the same patent have been heard
and determined in both districts in Illinois, and some of the masters
who have considered and ruled on the question in controversy there
are men of great experience, particularly Mr. Bishop,of Chicago. Mr.
Bishop’s report in the case referred to him in Chicago and Mr. Prinee’s

report in the case referred to him in Springfield and the reports
46 of the masters in other cases in Iowa and New York have
been exhibited to us. Mr. Bishop, in asimilar case, ruling in
the plaintiff’s favor, said in his report: “ It isclaimed upon the part
of the defendants that the only license fee which can be enforced
against them is that which was paid by others during the time of
the infringement, not the fee which was arbitrarily charged and
forcibly collected after the decision of December Ist, 1879, establish-
ing the patent of the complainants ; and evidence is adduced show-
ing sales made during that period, which, it is claimed, should be
applied in these cases; but during all this time it appears that the
patent was regarded by those using it as invalid, and it does not
seem fair that the right of the complainant to fix his license fees
should be influenced by the state of facts which then existed or by
anything done by him before his patent was established, but that he
should have the full benefit of the result of that litigation through
the uniform settlements which are shown to have been made upon
the strength of it.” In the Iowa case the master, after reciting the
facts, says: “It does not seem just that the complainant’s right to fix
license fees should be affected by sales made or license granted
47 under such circumstances, and whiJe the brewers generally
denied the validity of the patent sued on.”

THE CRESCENT BREWING CO. VS. MATTHEW GOTTFRIED. 25

In a case in the southern district of [llinois exceptions were taken
to the master’s reports, which found in favor of the complainant at
the rate I have adopted. Judge Treat sustained complainant’s posi-
tion and confirmed the report after exceptions were filed and en-
tered a decree ratifying and confirming the report. The reports by
Mr. Bishop and the other masters were confirmed without opposi-
tion, but I have examined the record at Chicago, and the evidence
taken before the master there and upon which Mr. Bishop’s report
was based show- that the defendants contested the complainant’s right
to recover upon much the same grounds as those insisted upon by
the defendants here, and Holbeck’s and Gottfried’s transactions as to
the sale of machines were proved in most, if not all, of those
cases.

The plaintiff is entitled to recover actual damages. My conclu-
sion is that he is entitled to recover such damages at the rate of fif-
teen cents per keg, one dollar per cask holding under thirty barrels,
and one dollar and fifty cents per cask holding over thirty barrels

for each pitching, and this conclusion is based on two facts :
48 First, that he has an established royalty or license fee at these

rates, and that such royalty is fair and reasonable and appli-
cable to these cases; and, second, that if he does not have such estab-
lished royalty or license fee the rate mentioned is reasonable and
not above the fair actual value of the invention as appropriated by
deiendants. I state the amounts on this basis.

In the case of the Crescent Brewing Company the defendants
admit having pitched twenty-eight thousand one hundred and thir-
teen (28,115) kegs before the patent expired, and allowing damages
at the rate of fifteen cents per keg the complainant is entitled to re-
cover four thousand two hundred and fifteen dollars and ninety-five
cents ($4,215.95), and I so report his damages.

In the case against Rachael S. Gaff, administratrix, &e, and
Samuel D. Langtree the defendants admit having pitched thirty-six
thousand four hundred and three (86,403) kegs before the patent
expired, and allowing damages at the rate of fifteen cents per keg
the complainant is entitled to recover in this case five thousand four
hundred and sixty dollars and forty-five cents ($5,460.45), and I so
report his damages.

In the case of Hack and Simon the defendants admit hav-

49 ing pitched three thousand kegs (5,000) and two hundred and

fifty casks (250) holding under thirty barrels before the pat-

ent expired, and allowing damages at the rate of fifteen cents per

keg and one dollar per cask the complainant is entitled to recover

in this case seven hundred dollars ($700.00), and I so report his
damages.

All of which is respectfully submitted.

November 16, 1883.
WILLIAM P. FISHBACK, Master.

4—294

9°96 THE CRESCENT BREWING CO. VS. MATTHEW GOTTFRIED.

And afterwards, to wit, at the November term of said court, on
the 21st day of November, 1883, before the Honorable William A.
Woods, judge as aforesaid of said court, the following further pro-
ceedings in the above-entitled cause were had, to wit:

Comes now the defendant, by Mess. Parkinson and Parkinson, its
solicitors, and files its motion to strike the master’s report herein
from the files, and said motion is in the words following, to wit :

Now come the defendants herein, respectively, and move the court
to strike from the files and set aside the master’s report herein and
to refer the said cause back to the master for reasons as follows, to
wit:
First. That the said report was irregularly and improperly filed
without submitting a draft thereof to defendants or their solic-

itors.
50 Second. That the master did not, before filing said report,

as he was in duty bound to do, submit the same or a draft
thereof to defendants or their solicitors, or notify them that the said
report was ready or about to be filed, or of the tenor, effect, or sub-
stance thereof, or issue or serve upon them any warrant advising
them that the said report was prepared and about to be filed, or
allow them any opportunity of inspecting it or ascertaining the
nature or purport of said report or of obtaining a draft thereof; but,
on the contrary, the same was filed before defendants or their solic-
itors were advised that the master was ready to submit the same or
had prepared a draft thereof, and without affording them any means
of ascertaining the purport thereof or of offering or noting objec-
tions or exceptions thereto, whereby defendants were deprived of the
opportunity to object to the manifold errors therein and the unjust,
illegal, and wrongful recitals and findings thereof, to their great in-

jury and damage.
PARKINSON & PARKINSON,
For Def’ts.

I, Robert H. Parkinson, being duly sworn, depose and say that I
have been, throughout the pendency of said cause before the master,
solicitor fur defendants, in charge thereof, and that the grounds

assigned in the foregoing motion are, to iny personal knowl-

51 edge, founded in fact.
ROBT H. PARKINSON.
Sworn to in my presence and signed before me this 20th day of

November, 1883.
FRANK W. BURNHAM,
Notary Public in and for Ham. Co., O.

And afterwards, to wit, at the November term of said court, on
the 3d day of December, 1883, before the Honorable William A.
Woods, judge as aforesaid of said court, the following further pro-
ceedings in the above-entitled cause were had, to wit:

Comes now the complainant, by Messrs. Banning and Banning,
his solicitors, and the defendant, by Messrs. Parkinson & Parkin-
son, its solicitors, and thereupon the court, being sufficiently ad-

be ea

MR.

THE CRESCENT BREWING CO. VS. MATTHEW GOTTFRIED. 27

vised, doth now overrule the motion of the defendant, filed herein
on the 21st day of November, 1883, to strike the master’s report
herein from the files; to which ruling of the court in overruling
suid motion the defendant, by its solicitors, now here excepts.

And afterwards, to wit, at the November term of said court, on
the 14th day of December, 1883, before the Honorable William A.
Woods, judge as aforesaid of said court, the following further pro-
ceedings in the above-entitled cause were had, to wit:

Comes now the defendant, by Messrs. Parkinson & Parkinson, its

solicitors, and files its exceptions to the report of the master
52 herein in the words following, to wit:
Circuit Court of the United States for the District of Indiana.
MATTHEW GOTTFRIED
VS. 7152. In Equity.
THE CRESCENT BREWING Co.
MATTHEW GOTTFRIED
vs. : - .
~ . . - 6454. In Equity.
RACHAEL 8S. Garr, Executrix, &c., and SAMUEL 5 aes
D,. LANGTREE.

MATTHEW GOTTFRIED )
US. 6840. In Equity.
EuGENE Hack and ANTON SIMON. ;

Exceptions taken by defendants to the report made in the above-en-
titled cause- by W. P. Fishback, master, to whom these causes were
referred by an order of this court made in the interlocutory de-
crees herein, and being the report dated November 16th, 1888,
and filed about said date.

Now come the defendants herein, respectively,and except to the
said report of said master for reasons as follows, viz:

First. For that the said report disregards in its findings the fact
appearing in evidence, as well by the admissions of complainant in

his cross-examination before the master as by the assignments
53 and other proofs, that complainant has not suffered any actual

damage by reason of the infringement complained of beyond
the loss of the sale of the machines used by the several defendants,
which, at the rate of royalty established by himself and his associates
and predecessors in title under the patent, would not exceed twenty
dollars, and has erroneously substituted for such measure of recovery
a speculative royalty never actually established, and never proposed
as a royalty to be exacted from any person voluntarily purchasing
and putting into use said machine, and not representing any actual
damage suffered by complainant by reason of defendants’ infringe-
ment.

Second. For that the said report disregards the fact established in
evidence that no person has ever voluntarily put one of the infring-
ing nfachines in use in the ordinary course of business under any
conditions that involved the payment of more than the ordinary

28 THE CRESCENT BREWING CO. V8. MATTHEW GOTTFRIED.

selling price of the machine, and the further fact that complainant
or his predecessors or associates in title under the patent have never
at any time exacted from persons voluntarily dealing with them in
introducing the machine into use any tribute beyond the profit in
the sale of the machine, and fails to find, as the fact is, that there

is no proof nor presumption that complainant could or
54 would, but for the infringement of defendants, have obtained

more than the said profit on the sale of a machine, including
therein manufacturer’s profits as well as royalty under the franchise,
and no proof nor presumption that he has been damnified in any
way beyond the loss of said amount, and substitutes as the measure
of recovery herein vague speculations of witnesses as to the value of
the invention, unsupported by data and inconsistant with the con-
duct of the witnesses themselves and the facts shown in the cause.

Third. For that the said report fails to find, as the evidence shows,
and especially the depositions of Boss, Brenner, Frech, Gerst, Hauck,
Herancourt, Liebel, Moerlein, Mullhauser, Scharf, Schmidt, Schmitt,
Schreiber, Schwarz, and Windisch, taken before the master, that the
entire cost of pitching by hand, if all the employees engaged in the
work were specially employed for that purpose, would be less than
one-tenth part of the royalty of 15c. per keg, $1.00 per cask of less
than 30 bbl. capacity, and $1.50 per cask of more than 30 bbl. ca-
pacity, awarded as damages herein.

Fourth. For that the said report fails to find, as is fully estab-
lished in evidence, as well in the depositions recited in the last pre-

ceding exception as in the depositions in behalf of complain-
55 ant and the evidence in the original record in this cause, that

pitching by hand, as usually conducted, did not itivolve the
employment of any additional hands in the breweries, but was car-
ried on in the otherwise leisure time of the regular employees; that
the breweries could not economically introduce complainant’s ma-
chine at a cost for its use exceeding the purchase price thereof, and
that, while it has been in the market throughout the term of the
patent and open to use free from royalty by all who were willing to
purchase it, many brewers have continued to pitch by hand in
preference to the use of it, and of those who have had it some have
by preference continued to pitch their casks by the old methods,
while others have, under similar circumstances, by preference con-
tinued to pitch their kegs by the old methods.

Fifth. For that the said report fails to find, as is established in ev-
idence, and especially in the cross-examination of complainant’s wit-
nesses, Hoehle, Loeffel, Meir, Roessler, Seib, Schuerle, F. A. Steiner,
F. Steiner, Thienzer, Thorman, Uhleman, Walther, and Welker, that
the witnesses who estimated the value of complainant’s invention
at 15c. per keg, $1.00 per cask of less than 30 bbl. capacity, and

$1.50 per cask of more than 30 bbl. capacity for each pitch-
56 ing, give no data to support their estimate, but, on the con-
trary, were shown to have returned to pitching by hand, or
to the use of means for heating their casks and kegs common for
that purpose long prior to complainant’s invention, notwithstanding
the use of complainant’s-machine without license and upon the pay-

THE CRESCENT BREWING CO. VS. MATTHEW GOTTFRIED. 29

meut of the cost of the machine was open to them and known to be
open to them at the time.

Sixth. For that the said report fails to show the fact established
in evidence by the depositions above named in behalf of defendants,
and by the depositions in the original record herein, and by the
depositions in behalf of complainant herein; that the Seibel ma-
chine here in evidence, and shown to long antedate complainant’s
invention, is still generally used for the purpose of pitching casks
by brewers who have the machine here in controversy in their
breweries with the right to use it without royalty.

Seventh. For that the said report erroneously finds complainant’s
damages to be 15c. per keg, $1.00 per cask of less than 30 bbl.
capacity, and $1.50 per cask of more than 50 bbl. capacity for each
pitching, whereas it should find that complainant has failed to show

any damage beyond the loss of the sale of the machines used
o7 by defendants at a royalty not exceeding twenty dollars.
Eighth. For that the said report fails to find, as the fact is,
that complainant has failed to show himself to have sustained any
actual damage by reason of the infringement complained of and
to award nominal damages.

Ninth. For that the said report fails to find, as the fact is, that
said complainant has not shown himself to be entitled to recover
damages by reason of any infringement occurring prior to the title
of Holbeck, the co-patentee, zr May 1, 1879.

Tenth. Forthat the said report fails to find, as the fact is, that
complainant, having granted to said Holbeck, May 1, 1879, the right
to sell said machines at a royalty of ten per cent. on the price of the
machine, has suffered no damage by reason of any infringement oc-
curring since said date beyond the loss of said royalty of ten per
cent. on the price of the machine.

Eleventh. For that the said report fails to find, as the fact is, that
the said complainant, having released said doyalty and all claims
thereto, has not, by reason of any infringement occurring since said
release, suffered any damage whatsoever.

Twelfth. For that the said report erroneously finds that complain-

ant has an established royalty or license fee at the rate of 15c.
58 per keg, $1.00 per cask of less than 30 bbl. capacity, and $1.50

per cask of more than 380 bbl. capacity, whereas it should find,
as the evidence shows and especially the cross-examination of com-
plainant himself before the master, that no such royalty or license fee
was established.

Thirteenth. For that the said report errcneously finds that the
royalty or license fee of 15c. per keg, $1.00 per cask of less than 30
bbl. capacity, and $1.50 per cask of more than 30 bbl. capacity for
each pitching, is fair and reasonable, whereas it should find that
said royalty 1s neither fair nor reasonable, but grossly unfair, un-
reasonable, and extortionate.

Fourteenth. For that the said report erroneously finds said royalty
or license fee of 15c. per keg, $1.00 per cask of less than 30 bbl. ca-
pacity, and $1.50 per eask of more than 30 bbl. capacity is applica-
ble as a measure of damages in these causes, whereas it should find

30 THE CRESCENT BREWING CO. VS. MATTHEW GOTTFRIED.

that it has no application or relevancy to said causes and does not
furnish or tend to furnish any measure of the damages sustained by
complainant by reason of the infringement of these defendants.

Fifteenth. For that the said report erroneously finds that the said
royalty last above mentioned is not above the fair value of the in-

vention, whereas it should find, as is established by evidence
59 here, especially depositions in behalf of defendant herein be-

fore the master, that said sums were many fold the entire
cost of pitching by hand and grossly in excess of the value of com-
plainant’s invention and furnish no measure of damages to be re-
covered in this cause.

Sixteenth. For that the said report erroneously finds that the
measure of damages in this cause is the value of complainant’s in-
vention, whereas it should find that the measure of recovery herein
is the actual damage shown to have been inflicted upon complainant
by reason of defendant’s infringement.

Seventeenth. For that the said report erroneously adopts as the
measure of the value of said invention and of complainant’s dam-
ages herein a speculative estimate, not computed from any data
appearing in evidence or shown to be possessed or relied upon by
the witnesses and inconsistant with the conduct and admissions of
the witnesses making such estimates and with the facts established
in evidence.

Eighteenth. For that the said report erroneously finds that settle-
ments to which defendants are strangers afford the measure of re-

covery against defendants, whereas it should find, as the
60 evidence shows, that the said settlements were, if made at all,

made under pending or threatened litigation and to avoid
prosecution and afford no measure of damages herein.

Nineteenth. For that the said report erroneously finds that the
settlements made by complainant were made on the basis of a uni-
form royalty or license fee, whereas it should find, as the evidence
shows, that the said settlements were not made on any uniform roy-
alty or license fee, but for such varying amounts as complainant
was able to extort.

Twentieth. For that the said report erroneously recites that Gott-
fried “names thirteen licenses which he gave, and says there are
others,” and represents the same to have been licenses at a fixed
‘ate of royalty, whereas it should find, as the fact is, that Gottfried
names or refers to but-six so-called licenses of any kind as having
been granted, and admits expressly that these all included settle-
ments for past infringements ; that of these six one was never acted
upon ; that the remainder were paid-up licenses upon estimates
claimed to have been made in advance, instead of upon reports at
stated periods during the remainder of their term, as provided in
them, with the exception of one, upon which one report oniy is rep-

resented to have been made, showing no kegs pitched and
61 only twenty-two casks; that they were all made or effected
through the intervention of complainant’s attorneys, for sums
less than the expense of litigation, and, with one exception, litigation

: Pe a oes POE oe ee PELL SE FAS ss aR ORNATE 7s Cnr ae

Lees

THE CRESCENT BREWING CO. VS. MATTHEW GOTTFRIED. 31

had been commenced and was heing pushed prior to the time of
effecting such settlements.

Twenty-first. For that the said master erroneously finds that the
same questions involved in this controversy have been heard and
determined jn other courts, whereas he should find, as the fact is, that
there is no evidence showing the said questions to have been pre-
sented or passed upon by any master or court whatsoever, other
than as the courts have in causes arising under other patents de-
cided the law to be contrary to that administered by the master
herein.

‘T'wenty-second. For that the master erred in examining and con-
sidering evidence in other causes to which these defendants are
strangers, which evidence was not exhibited to defendants or their
counsel or in any way introduced into this cause. :

Twenty-third. For that said report erroneously finds that “ little,
if anything, was ever done” under the license from Gottfried to Hol-
beck, granted in 1870, and that it was subsequently revoked, whereas
it should find, as appears from the assignments in evidence and

from the testimony of Gottfried and others, both before the
62 master and in the original record, that the said license con-

tinued in force at least until Marck, 1875; that it does not
appear that the same was legally revoked at that time, and that a
company was organized and the patented machine with subsequent
improvements put on sale without restriction as to its use, and con-
tinued thus on sale under authority of the patent until the title was
reacquired by the patentees not earlier than 1879, and subsequently
to the last-named date was continued on sale by Holbeck, with ex-
press authorization of complainant, to the expiration of the term of
the patent.

Twenty-fourth. For that the said report erroneously finds that the
title to the patent became revested in the patentee partly in 1875
and partly in 1876, whereas it should find, as fully appears from the
records, that it did not become so revested until 1879 or subsequent
thereto.

Twenty-fifth. For that the said report erroneously finds that “in
the meantime brewers and others regarded and treated the patent as
invalid and engaged extensively in making and using infringing
machines,” whereas it should find, as the fact is, that there is no evi-
dence showing that the validity of the patent was under considera-

tion or any opinion formed with reference thereto by the
63 brewers at said time, or that infringing machines were made

or used in sufficient numbers to affect or did affect the sale
of tle complainant’s machines.

Twenty-sixth. For that the said report erroneously finds that up
to the decision of Gottfried vs. Philip Best Brewing Co. the brewers
generally considered the patent as invalid and were unwilling to
recognize patentee’s rights, whereas it should find, as the fact is, that
there is no evidence to show that at or prior to said date the ques-
tion of the validity of said patent had ever been brought before the
said brewers or considered by them, or that any brewer to whom the
patentee or those authorized under the patent had offered to sell a

32 THE CRESCENT BREWING CO. VS. MATTHEW GOTTFRIED.

machine or to deal with, as they were dealing with others in the
ordinary course of business, had refused to recognize any right exist-
ing under said patent.

Twenty-seventh. For that the said report erroneously finds that
the license given to Holbeck in May, 1879, was part of the consid-
eration for Holbeck’s interest in the patent, whereas it should find
that the same was granted for the consideration of the license fee
retained.

Twenty-eighth. For that the master erroneously finds that the

franchise held under the patent could be and was divided
64 between the patentees, so that one was to enjoy the monopoly

of the introduction of the machine to lawful uses while the
other recovered from infringers upon the basis of a speculative esti-
mate not based on any business actually carried on under the fran-
chise and exceeding many fold the profit made or capable of being
made by any method ever adopted for its lawful introduction and
use.
Twenty-ninth. For that the said report erroneously finds that
“there is a square conflict in the evidence between plaintiff and de-
fendant as to the value of the invention,” whereas it should find that
the facts established in evidence, as well by complainant’s as by de-
fendants’ evidence, prove that it had no sufficient value over old
methods to render its introduction probable on any terms more ex-
pensive to the user than the payment of the purchase price of the
machine.

Thirtieth. For that the said report erroneously represents that the
sale of machines at a royalty not exceeding twenty dollars was only
employed as a mode of enjoying the franchise in the early efforts to
introduce the invention, whereas it should find, as is established by
admissions of complainant in his cross-examination before the mas-
ter, by the assignments in evidence, and otherwise, that the roy-

alty of twenty dollars per machine is the maximum royalty
65 that has ever been asked under the patent in any efforts ever
made to introduce the lawful use of the machine, and that
machines have been on sale under authority of the patent through-
out its eutire term at a royalty not exceeding twenty dollars per
machine, and that the aggregate profit on the sale of such machines,

. as fixed by the patentees, prior to and throughout the infringements

herein, did not exceed fifty dollars, including in the said fifty dollars
all manufacturers’ profits and all profits on added improvements.

Thirty-first. For that the said report erroneously finds that the
said invention is a very important and valuable one, whereas it
should find the contrary. |

Thirty-second. For that the said report erroneously describes and
misrepresents the process of pitching as carried on before complain-
ant’s invention was known, in this, that it recites the same as fol-
lows, to wit:

“The hoops were knocked off and staves loosened, the head taken
out, the hoops put on and tightened, the pitch and wood heated by
fire built inside the keg, the hoops knocked off and staves loosened

THE CRESCENT BREWING CO. VS. MATTHEW GOTTFRIED. 30

again, the head put in, the hoops put on again, and the staves
tightened up again;”

66 Whereas it should find, as the evidence shows, that the pro-
cess most commonly in use prior to the date of said invention

was as follows, to wit: The hoops at one end were removed, the head

taken out, the pitch then ignited by passing a heated iron rapidly

over the mouths of a series of kegs placed in a row, the pitch poured

in, the heads replaced, the hoops tightened, and the kegs rolled.

Thirty-third. For that the said report erroneously finds that by
using the complainants’ invention the pitching is done without the
trouble of taking the steps taken in pitching by hand, whereas it
should find, as the evidence shows, especially the depositions, before
the master, of Windisch, Schwarz, Schrieber, Schmidt, Schmitt,
Scharf, Muhlhauser, Moerlein, Siebel, Herancourt, Hauck, Gerst,
Frech, Brenner, and Boss, that where the pitching was done by ma-
chine it was necessary, in the first instance, to go over the kegs with
a torch specially provided therefor and inspect the interiors of the
kegs, to remove therefrom, by implements specially provided for the
purpose, any refuse matter found therein; to then apply them to the
pipe of the furnace in which fire had been kindled for the purpose

and to which a blast was applied by means of a mechanical
67 fan put in operation with motive power obtained from the

boiler heated by another furnace; to then remove the kegs; to
then introduce pitch which had been heated by another fire through
the bung or spigot hole of the keg; to then roll the keg, and subse-
quently tighten the hoops thereof to compensate for the shrinkage
caused by the heat, and that it was further necessary, if injury to
the bung hole was to be prevented, to introduce into the bung hole
of each keg so pitched a metallic bushing to protect said bung hole
from being burned or rendered irregular by the heat of the pipe
from the furnace inserted into it.

Thirty-fourth. For that the said report erroneously fails to find, as
the evidence shows, especially the depositions last above cited, that
the inspection and removal of impurities from the inside of the keg,
made necessary where the pitching is by machine, consumes more
time and involves more labor than the removal of the heads of the
kegs and is less thorough in its purification of the kegs.

Thirty-fifth. For that the said report erroneously finds that com-
plainant’s machine saves time and labor, whereas it should find the
contrary, as the evidence shows, and especially that last above re-
cited.

Thirty-sixth. For that the said report erroneously finds
68 that complainant’s machine saves pitch, whereas it should find
the contrary.

Thirty-seventh. For that the said report erroneously finds that
the vessels are better pitched by machines, whereas it should find
that the evidence shows that the pitching is more thoroughly and
better done by the old methods, and that the same fully appears as
well in the depositions last above recited as by the depositions in
behalf of defendants in the original record.

5—294

34 THE CRESCENT BREWING CO. VS. MATTHEW GOTTFRIED.

Thirty-eighth. For that the said report erroneously finds that the
taking out of the heads and displacing the staves injures the kegs,
and that they will last much longer when pitched by machine than
when pitched in the old way, whereas it should find that the injury
to the keg by reason of the warping from constant heat when using

the machines is much greater than any injury from the removal of

ihe heads; that the kegs are destroyed more rapidly thereby, and
that the burning of the bung holes, incident to the use of the machine,
was so destructive as to render it impossible for the machine to com-
pete with the nand-pitching with economy without the use of means
of preventing such injury invented and introduced subsequent to
the date of complainant’s patent.
Thirty-ninth. For that the said report erroneously finds
69 the fact of defendants’ use of machines for pitching proves it
“to possess great advantages over the old pitching process,”
whereas it should find that such use, if it involved the use of no
other improvements, would not be evidence of more than a nominal
advantage; that defendants have never used said machine except
with improvements not found in complainant’s patent; that they
continued during the larger part of the term of the patent and until
further improvements had been introduced to pitch by old methods,
and that the defendants, The Crescent Brewing Co. and Rachael S.
Gaff et al., have continued throughout by vreference to use old
methods in a large part of their pitching, including all their casks.

Fortieth. For that the said report erroneously recites defendants
to concede that complainant is entitled to recover a royalty of twenty
dollars per machine, whereas it should find, as the fact is, that de-
fendants have insisted that the actual damage suffered by com-
plainant by reason of infringement and to be recovered herein can-
not exceed the said sum, and that complainant was not entitled to
that or any recovery until he should affirmatively show that he had
used such diligence in introducing his invention and keeping it

before the public, and that it was of such merit as originally
70 exhibited in his patent and without further improvements as

to establish the presumption that defendants would have
purchased complainant’s machine, paying the royalty thereon asa
part of the price thereof, if they had not purchased an infringing
machine.

Forty-first. For that the said report erroneously recites extracts
from the direct examination of complainant, and fails to recite his
cross-examination releyant thereto, and the evidence of defendant’s
witnesses by which his direct examination so recited is materially
modified and contradicted.

Forty-second. For that the said report erroneously finds that com-
plainant’s invention was adopted and used in three thousand brew-
erles within the twelve or thirteen years after the patent was issued,
whereas it should find, as the fact is, that it is not shown to have
been introduced and used in more than thirty breweries during said
time; that in these it was coupled with additional improvements,
and that complainant, being the only witness who undertook to state
the number of breweries in which said machine had been used, ad-

ated st. eee

Pe aie

THE CRESCENT BREWING CO. VS. MATTHEW GOTTFRIED. 35

mits, on cross-examination, that he was not, during or subsequent
to the term of said patent, seen any machines that he claims to be
within his invention in use in more than two hundred to two
hundred and fifty breweries.
71 Forty-third. For that the said report erroneously finds that
the question for the master to determine is, whether the sales
of the few machines under the circumstances stated, while the patent
was considered invalid, establishes any royalty which would prevent
the complainant from recovering at another and higher rate, whereas
it should find that the question is, whether the complainant has
shown himself to have suffered, by reason of defendant’s infringe-
ment, any damage beyond the loss of said royalty; and should fur-
ther find that there is no evidence showing or tending to show that
complainant has lost, by reason of said infringement, any benefit or
advantage or suffered any injury beyond said royalty.

Forty-fourth. For that the said report erroneously assumes and
represents that said sales were few in number and due to and affected
by infringements, the patent being considered as invalid, whereas
it should fi:d that this method of enjoying the franchise, by the sales
of machines with right of unrestricted use, was adopted by the pat-
entee and his associates in title at the outset and before they had
been affected by infringements, and continued throughout the entire

term of the patent as the only means employed by them of in-
72 troducing said invention or enjoying said franchise, and that

it does not appear that it was adopted in view of or in any-
wise due to any infringements or any adverse opinion entertained
as to the validity of the patent.

Forty-fifth. For that the said report erroneously finds that the
unwillingness to recognize the validity of the patent placed the pat-
entees to great disadvantage and rendered it impossible for them to
deal on equal terms with brewers in selling the machines, and that
the effect of this disregard of the patentees’ rights was to cut down
the profits, whereas it should find, as the fact is, that it does not ap-
pear that the profit on machines was ever reduced in view of any
infringement, or that any‘brewer to whom a machine manufactured
under authority of the patent was offered ever elected to take in
place thereof an unauthorized machine, or that any user of an in-
fringing machine ever refused, when asked to pay complainant or
his associates or predecessors in title to the patent, any royalty or
profit that he would have made by the sale to them of the number
of machines used by them at any rate ever obiained or asked in the
authorized sale of the machines.

Forty-sixth. For that the said master erroneously finds that there

was a time after the sale of said machines commenced when
73 complainant or his associates or predecessors in title could

not sell any machines at all, and represents the same to have
been due to infringements, whereas he should find, as the evidence
shows, that the failure to sell machines was due to mismanagement,
lack of business enterprize, and dissensions among the holders of
the title to the patent and their licensees, and to the fact that the
said invention without additional improvements was not found

ag ep a _

36 THE CRESCENT BREWING CO. VS. MATTHEW GOTTFRIED.

profitable by the brewers and was in nowise due to any infringe-
ment.

Forty-seventh. For that the said report erroneously finds that
while said patent “ was considered invalid it is improbable that the
purchase of any machines made by Holbeck gave him any more
than the price of labor and material represented in the machines
with manufacturer’s profits, and it is not likely that the inventor's
royalty entered into the selling price of the machines,” whereas it
should find that there is no evidence showing or tending to show
that the price at which said machines were sold throughout the en-
tire term of the patent was not adequate to pay both royalty under
the franchise and manufacturer’s profits, and that the evidence does
affirmatively show that the said price was fixed with the view to
payment of said royalty and the realizing of profits in addition

thereto.
74 Forty-eighth. For that the said report erroneously finds

“that the fact that sales made by Holbeck were few and at
variable rates for the purpose of introducing the invention is to be
considered,” whereas it should find, as the evidence shows, that the
said sales were adopted voluntarily as the mode of making profit
out of the franchise and at rates fixed before the same had been
affected by infringement, and that the small number of sales was due
to the fact that the machines offered were not regarded as sufficiently
desirable to compensate for the price demanded therefor and to lack
of business efficiency in introducing the same and creating a market
therefor.

Forty-ninth. For that the said report erroneously finds that said
Holbeck seems to have offered his machines at almost any price,
whereas there is no evidence showing or tending to show the same.

Fiftieth. For that the said report erroneously finds that Holbeck
was not able to sell to more than one out of one hundred and fifty
brewers that adopted the invention, whereas there is no evidence
showing or tending to show such fact or approximation thereto.

Fifty-first. Forthat the said reporterroneously findsthat there came

a number of vears in which no machines authorized under
7d the patent could be’sold at all, whereas there is no evidedce
to such effect, but the contrary.

Fifty-second. For that the said report erroneously recites and rep-
resents that the license fee for sale of machines adopted by complain-
ant.was one which he was compelled to accept by reason of infringe-
ment, whereas there is no evidence showing or tending to show that
compl

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Aper_scotus_1887_35%3A0. Public record. Not legal advice.
