# Record and brief — William H. Plummer, Administrator of Hiram Tucker, Deceased, Appellant, vs. Sargent and Company

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Aper_scotus_1886_121%3A0

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Record and brief
- **Published:** January 1, 1886

## Text

*

COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.

ITED STATES FOR : “i

aa

tae

SUPREME. COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.

OCTOBER TERM, 1885.

No. 378.

WILLIAM H. PLUMMER, ADMINISTRATOR OF HIRAM
TUCKER, DECEASED, APPELLANT,

VS.

SARGENT AND COMPANY.

APPEAL FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES FOR
THE DISTRICT OF CONNECTICUT.

INDEX.

Original. Print.

IEE ciidin ditkele nde omnd ab onsale cimmanns oinniabait: sie diisan aeiahil nla nid omaiia wien 6
NONE cinidciitin Re eg aia * ee Bs) =
UN 4 eS Be OY. SRI Fe ae . @ we © > z+

y , ila tt 3 , ‘ ‘
’ Ril tp te oe oe . Si ai ORT eg a ign pairs i ally 6. B35 ee ae " : he "
Pe a ee Og EP: Ae eb ON A Se edt Pe A MAE ee AOL Ce! pn thc NOR TES, ek Ma ae al pio od F ss P <> mn ee ER ee ee,
Chi gm iat tant. Se Eee f FAR EP Los RRS Beg Gee oho ag, ee NE RS a ee TERE Sa eRe Se Le EN ET OE SE oe ee MEER CU SRS GEM ot RD eR aie Se ME er Saree es SR ce Pe, Ree, ok a eeee
ee ag Ss: . ; 7™~ Se Ge TRIAD ge Ray Aree hs Fv SEE PRE SO eee He. Wael ETRE A BN ee Ceiee Ae sole MBN pe Pa ey et’
y hover , . ; ea eee Re ‘ x Se ae
‘

2 WILLIAM H. PLUMMER, ADM’R, &C., VS.

process described in said reissued patents, and alleging that the de-
fendants had colored iron only by processes as were 1n_ public use
more than two years “aes to the application of Hiram Tucker for a
patent therefor, and that said Tucker was not the original inventor
thereof.
That the parties were at issue on said bill and answer; that proofs :
thereupon were taken and filed and a hearing had thereon before
said court, and thereafter, on the 20th day of September, A. D.
9 1881, did make its final judgment, order, and decree dismiss- }
ing said bill of complaint with costs. :
That on or about the day of , A. D. 188-, the said
Tucker died, and the said Plummer was, on the -day of
A. D. 188-, appsinted his administrator; and whereas, upon exam-
ination, he believes said decree to have been erroneous, and disas-
trous to the estate of said deceased, therefore the appellant was filed
a bill of revivor and obtained a decree reviving a lan and he
now appeals from the whole of said decree of said circuit court, and
respectfully prays that the decree thereof and the bill, answer, plead-
ings, depositions, evidence of proceedings, and the whole record and
evidence in the said cause may be sent to the Supreme Court of the
United States without delay, and that the said Supreme Court will
proceed to hear the said cause anew, and that the said decree of the
circuit court and every part thereof may be reversed by a decree
made in accordance with the prayer of said bill of complaint, or |

| | such other decree as to the said Supreme Court shall seem just.
WILLIAM H. PLUMMER,
Administrator Estate of Hiram Tucker. |

10 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, |... 7
District of Massachusetts, ads

| Boston, May 10, 1883.

| Then personally appeared the above-named William H. Plummer
| and subscribed the foregoing bill and made oath that the statements
therein made as of his own knowledge are true, and that those ~~
made upon information and belief he believes to be true.
Before me—
[NOTARIAL SEAL. } GEO. W. MORSE,
+ Notary Public.

,

11 Bond.

Know all men by these presents that we, William H. Plummer,
of Cambridge, county of Middlesex, and State of Massachusetts, prin-
cipal, and Geo. W. Morse, of Newton, county of Middlesex, and State
of Massachusetts, and Samuel P. Teele, of Cambridge, county of Mid-
dlesex, and State of Massachusetts, sureties, are held and firmly
bound unto i & Co. in the sum of three hundred dollars, to
be paid as liquidated damages; for the payment of which, well and
| truly to be made to the United States, we bind ourselves, our heirs,
executors, administrators, or assigns, jointly and severally, firmly by
these presents. |

*

their legal liabilities, at least.

. r - _ +4 a ey | 7 jAe' ho ru 7 . -
5 ee * ae SA tee m 5s » wee ee ye ee hae Seat - , eae SS
FA - bo Re we? le oy aes +> > — " ae a he PAA neat’ ona ae be Ostia eS, AE . 7 ¥ et OF aD nee ~ mn s %. 0
, ys aoe 5h ll aaa gi ae Sapte een. SP ae Pee WaT IES ek a é . c
Le RR ee TS er i ea te Nie rods See

Sealed with our seals and dated this 17th day of May, A. D. 1883.
The condition of the above obligation is such that whereas the
said William H. Plummer hath appealed to the Supreme Court of
the United States to reverse the jecamsent rendered in the case of
Hiram Tucker vs. Sargent & Co. by the United States circuit court

for the district of Connecticut.
Now, therefore, this condition of this obligation is such that

12 if the above-named William H. Plummer shall prosecute his

said appeal to effect and answer all costs if he shali fail to
inake good his plea, then this obligation is void; otherwise to remain
in full force and virtue.

In testimony whereof the said William H. Plummer, George W.
Morse, and Samuel P. Teele have hereunto subscribed their hands
and affixed their seals the day first above written.

WILLIAM H. PLUMMER, [1.8.]
45 Greene St., Cambridge, Mass.

GEO. W. MORSE, (x. 8.]
28 State St., Boston, Mass.

SAMUEL P. TEELE, [1. s.]
88 Washington St., Cambridge, Mass.

Signed, sealed, and delivered in presence of—
LEON F. CHAMELIN,

To W. H. P., G. W. M.,5S. P. T.
(Two seals to each signature.)

STATE OF sign agai
County of Middlesex,

Personally appeared before me, a justice of the peace in and for
said State of Massachusetts, the said George W. Morse and Samuel
P. Teele, who signed the above obligation, and who made solemn
oath that they are each worth five thousand dollars over and above

GEO. W. MORSE.
SAMUEL P. TEELE.

Sworn to and subscribed, as above written, before me this 17th day

of May, 1883.
LEON F. CHAMELIN,
Justice. of the Peace.

13 Orrice oF THE U.S. Crrevit Covrt,
District oF ConnecTICcUrT,
Hartroxp, May 18, A. D. 1883.

[ hereby certify that George W. Morse, one of the sureties who
have signed the foregoing bond, is known to me as a resident of
Newton, Massachusetis, and a citzen of the United States, and that
I believe them to be amp! Y sufficient security for the amount thereof,

and that the bond is gooc :
E. E. MARVIN, Clerk, ee.

WILLIAM H. PLUMMER, ADM’R, &C., VS.

DistTRIcT OF CONNECTICUT, HarrtrorD, May 18, 1883.

The above and foregoing bond is approved and the appeal allowed.
: N. SHIPMAN, |
Mstrict Judge.

14 United: States Circuit Court, District of Connecticut. In |
Equity.
Wi1t.1AM H. PLumMer, Administrator of Hiram Tucker, : |

v8.
SARGENT & CoMPANY. i

By the Honorable Nathaniel Shipman, one of the judges of the cir-
cuit court of the United States for the district of Connecticut, to
Sargent & Company, Greeting:
Whereas William H. Plummer, of Cambridge, in the district of = *

Massachusetts, as he is administrator of the estate of Hiram Tucker, ;

complainant of the original bill of complaint, now deceased, having

now appeared as a party plaintiff in the suit, by his bill of revivor
hereinbefore filed, hath lately appealed to the Supreme Court of the

United States from the final decree lately rendered and entered in

the above cause in favor of you, the said Sargent & Co., and hath

tiled the security required by law, you are therefore cited to appear
before the said Supreme Court of the United States, at the

15 city of Washington, in the District of Columbia on the second

Monday of October, A. D. 1883, to do and receive what may
appertain to justice to be done in the premises.
Given under my hand, at the city of Hartford, in the district of |
Connecticut, in the second circuit, this 18th day of May, A. D. 1883.
N. SHIPMAN, :
One of the Judges of the Circuit Court

for the District of Connecticut.

New Haven, May 18, 1883.
Service of the foregoing citation is hereby acknowledged.
JNO. S. BEACH,
Sol’r for Sargent & Co.

16 The Return of the Judges of the Circuit Court of:the United States
for the District of Connecticut to the foregoing Appeal.

The bill, answer, and pleadings, evidence and proceedings whereof
mnention is therein made, follow in these words, viz:

Hiram Tucker
v. >In Equity.
SARGENT & Company. J

Be it remembered that heretofore, on the 6th day of January, 1880,
there was filed in this court a bill of complaint;in the following :
words, viz: :

SARGENT & COMPANY.

17 Bill of Complaant.
Circuit Court of the United States, District of Connecticut. In Equity.
Hiram Tucker vs. SARGENT & ComPANy.

To the honorable the judges of the circuit court of the United States
for the district of Connecticut :

Hiram Tucker, of Boston, in the district of Massachusetts, brings
this his bill of complaint against Sargent & Company, a corporation
organized under the laws of the State of Connecticut and located
and doing business in the city of New Haven, in said State.

And thereupon your orator complains and says that he, being the
original and first inventor of a new and useful manufacture of iron
ornamented in imitation of bronze, and of the process for producing
the same, fully described in the letters patent hereinafter mentioned,
which manufacture and process had not been known or used before
his said invention thereof, and which had not been, at the time of
his application for letters patent therefor, as hereinafter set forth, in
in public use or on sale with his consent or allowance for the space
of two years, and being also a citizen of the United States, did, on
the fifteenth day of December, A. D. 1863, upon due application
therefor, obtain letters atent of the United States in due form of
law, under the seal of the Patent Office of the United States, bearing
date the day and year last above mentioned, signed by the Secretary

of the Interior and countersigned by the Commissioner of
18 Patents of the United States, whereby there was granted to

your orator, his executors, administrators, and assigns, for
the term of seventeen years from the date thereof, the full alenien
ive right and liberty of practising said process for ornamenting
iron in imitation of bronze as set forth in said letters patent.

And your orator further shows that said letters patent, and all
rights and interests in or pertaining to the same, were, on or about
the third day of March, A. D. 1865, by an instrument in writing of
that date, duly assigned by your orator to the firm of Tucker & Com-
pany, which firm then consisted of your orator and one Thomas J.
Fisher, and that thereafter, to wit, on or about the twenty-ninth day
of March, A. D. 1866, said letters patent were, by an instrument in
writing of that date, duly assigned by said firm of Tucker & Cotmn-

any to the Tucker Manufacturing Company, a corporation organ-
ized under the laws of the Commonwealth of Massaghusetts and
having its usual place of business in Boston, in said Commonwealth,
both of which instruments of assignminent were duly recorded in the
Patent Office of the United States, as by the saine or by certified
copies thereof in court to be produced will fully appear.

And your orator further shows that said letters patent being in-
operative by reason of a defective specification, through inadvertence,
accident, or mistake, the same were duly surrendered; and, upon
proper proceedings being bad, new letters patent for the same inven-
tion were issued by the Commissioner of Patents of the United States
to the said Tucker Manufacturing Company, as the assignee of your
orator, which said reissued letters patent were in two divisions, each

6 WILLIAM H. PLUMMER, ADM’R, &C., VS.

upon a separate amended specification, bearing date Sept. 11, A. D.
1866, and numbered respectively reissued letters patent No. 2355
and No. 2356, signed by the Secretary of the Interior and counter-
signed and sealed with the seal of the Patent Office of the United
States by the Commissioner of Patents, whereby there was granted
to the said Tucker Manufacturing Company, its successors and
assigns, for the residue of the term of seventeen years from the date
of said original and surrendered letters patent, the full and exclusive

right and liberty, not only of practicing said process, but of
19 making, using,and vending to others to be used, the said manu-

facture, as by said reissued letters patent or duly certified
copies thereof in court to be produced will fully appear.

And your orator further shows that on the twenty-seventh day of
August, A. D. 1872, the said Tucker Manufacturing Company, by
an instrument in writing of that date, reassigned to your orator said
reissued letter patent Nos. 2355 and 2356, and ail rights and privi-

leges thereby secured, which written assignment was duly recorded

in the Patent Office of the’ United States, as by said instrument or a
duly certified copy thereof in court to be produced will fully appear.

And your orator further shows that afterwards, to wit, on or
about June 20th, 1876, by an instrument in writing of that date, he
assigned both said reissued letters patent to Walter Curtis and
Charles M. Reed, both of said Boston, as collateral security for the
payment of certain indebtedness of your orator to them, and that on
or about Jan. 29th, A. D. 1877, the said Walter Curtis having in the
meantime deceased, and Benjamin R. Curtis having been duly
appointed adiministrator of his estate, the said reissued letters patent
and invention, and all rights of action and claims for damages and
profits arising out of infringements upon said letters patent accruing
after the said 27th day of August, 1872, were reassigned to your
orator by said Charles M. Reed and said Benjamin R. Curtis, the
latter acting as administrator as aforesaid, which instrument of
assignment was duly recorded in the Patent Office of the United
States, as by the same or a duly certified copy thereof in court to be
produced will fully appear. :

And your orator avers that, by reason of the above-mentioned
assignments, not only said reissued letters patent and invention, but
also ali rights of action and claims for damages and profits arising
out of infringements upon the same committed since the said twenty-
seventh day of August, 1872, have become and now are fully vested
in your orator. :

And your orator further shows that on or about the third day of
August, 1874, he filed his bill in equity in the clerk’s oftice of this
honorable court for the district of Massachusetts against the said

Tucker Manufacturing Company, alleging that said Company
1) had, since its assignment of said letters patent to him, in-

fringed upon the exclusive rights vested in him by said re-
issued letters patent No. 2355, by practicing the process for orna-
menting iron in imitation of bronze therein described ; that said
cotmpany appeared and answered, denying that your orator was the
original and first inventor of said patented process, denying the

SARGENT & COMPANY. 7

validity of said letters patent, and denying that it had infringed the
same; that a general replication having been filed, and a great
amount of testimony having been taken in support of the issues
raised by the pleadings, the said cause was fully argued by counsel
upon the pleadings and evidence before the Hon. Nathan Clifford,
associate justice of the Supreme Court of the United States, who
thereupon decreed that the said letters patent were good and valid,
and that the said Tucker Manufacturing Company had _ infringed
the same, and also that said company should be perpetually en-
joined from further practising said patented process, and should
account for and pay over to your orator the gains and _ profits re-
ceived by it through such infringements, as well as the costs of suit
by him incurred, which decree was not appealed from, and was
sutistied by the issuance and Service of the writ of injunction therein
granted, and the payment by said company to your orator of the
sum of five thousand dollars in cash, in satisfaction of said profits
and costs of suit, all of which will fully appear from the record in
said suit now upon the files of this honorable court ut said Boston.

And your orator further shows that afterwards, to wit, on or about
April 24th, 1877, he filed his bill in equity in the clerk’s office of the
circuit court of the United States for the district of Connecticut,
against P. & F. Corbin, a manufacturing corporation organized
under the laws of the State of Connecticut, alleging infringement by
said P. & F. Corbin of said reissued letters patent No. 2355, to which
said P. & F. Corbin pleaded that it had done the acts complained of
under and by virtue of a license granted to it by the owners of said
letters patent; that issue being joined upon this plea and testimony
taken, the cause was fully argued by counsel before the Hon.
Nathaniel Shipman, one of the judges of said court, who thereupon

decreed that said noaendied license was null and void, that
21 said letters patent were good and valid, and thatsaid P. & F.

Corbin had infringed the same, and that said P. & F. Corbin
be perpetually enjoined from practising said patented process, and
that it account for and pay over to your orator the gains and profits
received by it through such infringement and his costs of suit, which
decree is still in full force, and the accounting therein directed still
pending.

And your orator furtber shows that on the 5th day of July, 1879,
he fiied his bill in equity in the clerk’s office of this court for the
district of Massachusetts against Charles A. Burditt.and Joseph
Williains, of Boston, alleging infringement by them of both the
letters patent aforesaid, and, after full argument by counsel upon
the question of the validity of said letters patent reissue No. 2356
for said bronzed iron as a new article of manufacture, before Hon.
John Lowell, judge of said court, an injunction was granted against
said Burditt and Williams enjoining and restraining them from in-
fringing either of said letters patent until further order of court,
which injunction is still in full force and effect.

And your orator further shows that the new manufacture of iron,
ornamented in imitation of bronze, specifically described and claimed
as new in said reissued letters patent No. 23™, is the specific product

8 WILLIAM H. PLUMMER, ADM’R, &C., VS.

of the process therein described and specifically claimed as new in
said reissued letters patent No. 2355, and cannot, to the best of his
knowledge and belief, be produced by any process not substantially
thesame. He therefore submits that the effect of the above-mentioned
decrees against said Tucker Manufacturing Company and said P. &
F. Corbin and said Burditt & Williams is not only to establish the
novelty of said process and the validity of said reissued letters patent
No. 2355, but a to establish the fact that your orator was the origi-
nal and first inventor of said new manufacture of iron specifically
claimed in said reissued letters patent No. 2356 as aforesaid.
And your orator further shows that from and after the said twenty-
seventh day of August, 1872, he was and still is possessed of the ex-
clusive right and liberty of making, using, and vending to
22 others iron ornamented in imitation of bronze by the process
described in said reissued letters patent, which exclusive
right and liberty has been and still would be of great value to your
orator but for the tortuous acts of the defendant hereinafter specified ;
yet the defendant, the said Sargent & Co., well knowing the premises,
without your orator’s consent and in violation of the exclusive rights

conferred upon him by said reissued letters patent, has, since said —

last-mentioned date, not only used and sold large quantities of iron
ornamented in imitation of bronze by the process described in said
letters patent, but has practised said process extensively in the manu-
facture of various kinds of ironware, and still continues so to do,
whereby the said defendant has infringed and is still infringing the
exclusive rights intended to be secured to your orator by said re-
issued letters patent.

And your orator has requested the said defendant to acknowledge
his rights in the premises and desist and refrain from further in-
fringement upon said letters patent, and to account for and pay over
to your orator what is justly due him on account of such infringe-
ments; but the said defendant has refused and still refuses so to do.

All of which acts and doings of said defendant are contrary to
equity and good conscience and tend to the manifest injury of your
orator in the premises ; Gate.

To the end, therefore, that the said defendant may, if it can show
cause why your orator should not have the relief herein prayed, and
may, upon oath of its proper officers, and according to the best of
their knowledge, remembrance, information, or belief, full, true, and
perfect answer make to all and singular the premises. ye:

And that the said defendant may be decreed to account for and
pay over to your orator all gains and profits realized by it from the
unlawful use by it of said invention as aforesaid in the manufacture
and sale of iron ornamented in imitation of bronze by said patented
process ; :

And that said defendant, its agents, attorneys, clerks, servants,
and workmen, may be restrained by a writ of injunction, issuing out

of and under the seal of this honorable court, from using said
23 patented process or any substantial and material part thereof,
and from using or selling iron ornamented in imitation of
bronze by said process, and that it may also be restrained and en-

~

4
- | aii . > ”
of Ne Sta yee a. sete.

— pon = oe
; #

SARGENT & COMPANY. 9

joined during the pendency of this suit, and for such other and
further relief in the premises as the nature of the case may require,
and to your honors may seem meet.

May it please your honors to grant unto your orator not only
writs of injunction conformable to the prayer of this bill, but also a
a writ of subpoena, directed to the said defendant, Sargent and Com-
pany, commanding it at a certain penalty therin to be limited by
its pee officers, to be and appear before this honorable court, then
and there to answer unto this bill, and to do and receive what your
honors shall deem meet in the premises.

HIRAM TUCKER.
: : CHAS. M. REED.
Solicitor and of Counsel for Complainant, Boston, Mass.

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
District of } -
| Boston, Jan. 5, 1880.
Then personally appeared the above-named Hiram Tucker, and
subscribed the foregoing bill, and made oath that the statements
therein made as of his own knowledge are true, and that those made
upon information and believe he believes to be true.

Before me—
[NOTARIAL SEAL.] | J. A. L. WHITTIER,
Notary Public, Suffolk Co., Mass.

234 And on the same day a writ of subpcena issued out of

court, directed to the said defendant, which was duly served
and returned, and which, with the return of service endorsed thereon,
was and is in the words and figures following, viz:

24 The President of the United States of America to the marshal
[seaL.] of the district of Connecticut, sendeth Greeting:

You are hereby conmanded to summon Sargent & Company, a

corporation organized under the laws of the State of Connecticut,

and located and doing business in the city of New Haven, in the
State and district of Connecticut, to appear before the judges of the
crceuit court of the United States of America for the district of Con-
necticut, in the second circuit, in equity, on the first Monday of Feb-
ruary, 1880, wheresoever the said court shall then be, to answer a
bill of complaint exhibited against said Sargeht & Company in said
court by Hiram Tucker, of Boston, in the district of Massachusetts,
and then and there to answer the same,and todo and abide by
what said court may order and decree in the premises.

Make due service and return at least twenty days before said first
Monday of February, 1880. |

Witness the Hon. Morrison R. Waite, Chief Justice of the Su-
preme Court of the United States, at Hartford, this 6th day of Janu-

ary, A. D. 1880.
E. E. MARVIN, Clerk.

The defendant is required to enter its appearance in said cause
2—378

10 WILLIAM H. PLUMMER, ADM’R, &C., VS.

in the clerk’s office of said court, on or before the day at which this
writ is returnable, or, by the rules of said court, said bill will be

taken as confessed. :
E. E. MARVIN, Clerk.
WM. WALDO HYDE, Hartford, Conn., |

Complainant’s Solicitor.
25 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA.

DisTRICT OF CONNECTICUT, | .. .
New Haven County, — f **’
New Haven, Jan’y 8, 1880.
Then and there I served the within writ on Sargent & Company:
herein named, by delivering to and leaving with C. L. Baldwin, the
secretary of said company, a true and attested copy hereof.

Attest : JOS. D. BATES,
U. S. Marshal.

26 And on the same day Wm. Waldo Hyde, Esq., entered his

appearance for the complainant; and on the 26th day of Jan-—
uary, 1880, John S. Beach, Esq., entered his appearance for the re-
spondents; and on the 2d day of March, 1880, the respondents filed
in court their answer in the words and figures following, viz:

27 Defendants’ Answer. (Filed March 2, 1880.)

Circuit Court of the United States, District of Connecticut. In Equity.
Hrram Tucker v. SARGENT & Co.

The answer of Sargent & Company, defendants, to the bill of com-
plaint exhibited against them by Hiram Tucker.

To the honorable Judges of the circuit court of the United States for
the district of Connecticut:

The defendants, reserving all advantage and benefit of exception
to said bill of complaint, for answer thereto or to so much thereof
as they are advised it is material for them to answer unto, answer-
ing, say: .

Phat they are informed and admit that letters patents of the
United States were on the the 15th day of December, 1863, issued to
the complainant for an alleged invention in the art of coloring iron,
and that the same was afterwards surrendered and reissued in two
parts, as alleged in said bill, and numbered respectively 2355 and
2356; but the defendants have no knowledge, save as is imparted to
them by the allegations of said bill, of the assignments of said original

Poon SS

SARGENT & COMPANY. 11

letters patent, or of said reissues, or of either of them, and leave the
complainant to the proof thereof, and they have no knowledge, except
as derived from the allegations of said bill, of the institution, prog-
ress, or result of the several suits which said bill alleges have been
brought by the said complainant against “The Tucker Manufactur-
ing Company” and Burditt & Williams in the United States cir-

cuit court for the district of Massachusetts, and against P. F.
28 Corbin, in the United States circuit court for the district of

Connecticut, and leave the complainant to such proof thereof
as he may be advised; but, upon information and belief, they deny
the allegation of said bill that the coloring of iron, as described and
claimed in said reissued letters patent, cannot be produced by any
process other than that therein described; and they deny that the
effect of any decree in either of the above-mentioned cases was to
establish the validity of said letters patent as against these defend-
ants, or to abate their rights. |

And these defendants, further answering, admit that the said orig-
inal letters patent issued to the said complainant, and bearing date
December 15, 1863, were inoperative a void by reason of a defect-
ive specification, as set forth in said bill, in that the specification
was vague and uncertain and defined no limits as to quantity of oil
or the thickness of the coating to be applied, and gave no such clear
direction as to the application or use of the alleged new process as
to enable a person skilled in the art to which it relates to practise
the same; but, upon information and belief, they deny that the said
original letters patent were for that reason surrendered, but on the
contrary they allege that the said surrender was made and said _ re-
issue obtained for the purpose of covering, as the invention of the
complainant, what was not described or claimed in said original
letters patent as the invention of said complainant, and they aver
that said reissued letters patent are void:

Ist. As exhibiting the same vagueness and uncertainty of descrip-
tion which nullified said original letters patent.

2d. As being for a different invention from that described and
claimed in the said original letters patent.

3d. As purporting to secure exclusive rights which, in their
nature, are not patentable.

And the defendants, further answering, deny that they have used
the process described in said letters patent, or sold any articles of
iron colored thereby; and if it shall be claimed by the said com-
plainant that these defendants have, in the process of coloring iron
used by them, infringed upon any of the exclusive rights ‘tay vort-

ing to be secured by said letters patent, then the de badeieti
29 will maintain that upon any construction thereof covering
the process used by the defendants in coloring iron said let-

‘ters patent are void:

Ist. Because such process was in public use, and the articles col-
ored thereby were on sale in this country, with the knowledge and
consent of the said complainant, more than two years prior to his
application for said letters patent. 7
1. Because such process was in public use and the articles col-

nthe 0

12 WILLIAM H. PLUMMER, ADM’R, &C., VS.

prior to the application for said letters patent.

3d. Because the said Hiram Tucker was not the first and original
inventor of said process, but the alleged invention, including all
such portions thereof as the defendants are alleged to have infringed,

was at the date of the supposed invention an old process well known .

in the art of coloring metal, and long prior to any supposed invention
thereof by the said Tucker, and Jong prior to his application for
letters patent thereon, was known to and in use by persons other
than the said Tucker, whose names and residences and the piaces
where used by them respectively are set forth in schedules hereto
annexed, marked A and B, and forming part of this answer, and
was also fully described in certain public works and letters patent,
as set forth in schedule hereto annexed, marked C, and forming part
of this answer. 7 }

SCHEDULE A.

Name. Residence. Place where used.
Purmont & Bradford----- .--- New Haven, |
Peck & Walter M’fg Co._----- New Britain,
5 BO non ienivnin cn cnnn New Haven, New Brita;
J. B. Sargent & Co.......... vine, fh UC! CO
Sargent & Co. ...--.-...----. New Haven,
Fred’k W. Brockseipier -.-.-. North Haven, |
Misahet GE 6 cidic cacesnnn Wallingford, | Wallingford and
ee SR ae cisicin: sci e ieimaccon New Britain, § New Britain.
ou SCHEDULE Bb.

James G. Smith, J. C. Smith, Paul Schieltze, Edwin R. Augevine,
and Joseph Flyun, all of Middletown, Conn., at said Middletown and
Westfield, in said State; Frederick Mallory, of New Haven, in said
State, at said New Haven; W. Fitch and John Gusel, of and at said
New Haven; H. L. Judd, of Wallingford, at said New Haven and
Wallingford Conn.; Rodolphus L. Wett, Horace Eddy. Russell &
Erwin Manufacturing Company, and Landers, Frary & Clark, of
and at New Britain, Conn.; Henry Whitely, of Cambridge, Mass.;
Luther F. Whitney, of Charlestown, Mass.; Edmund W. Drake, of
Somerville; Robert Murphy, of Chelsea; Frederick Smith, of Somer-
ville, and John W. Talbot, of Charlestown, all in said district of
Massachusetts, at Boston, in said district; Nathaniel Bradlev, Walter
Hubbard, Lewis J. Roselins, Abel H. Snow, Elias K. Breckenridge,
and Hugh Mulvey, all of and at Meriden, in the State of Connecticut:
Joha M. Spring, Charles Peck, both of and ai New Britain, Conn.:
Burton Mallory, William Ronalds, William H. King, William Leboyd,
Samuel Barton, Daniel Wright, and Henry Talmadge, all of and at
New Haven, in the State of Connecticut; Charles M. Daboll, G. A.
W. Rogers, William Clark, B. F. Barker, E. H. Douglass, Increase
Wilson, and the Wilson Manufacturing Company, all of and at New
London, Conn.; Henry H. Elwell, of Sate Conn., at said Nor-
walk aud Meriden; Emory Parker, of New Britain at Meriden and

ored thereby were on sale in this country for more than two years

es
* ”

~OOMe @

SARGENT & COMPANY. 13

New Britain, and Daniel Fowler, of Meriden, Conn., at said Meriden;
Lemuel Morgan, of New York city, at said Meriden; Richard
Eatabrook, of and at Camden, in the State of New Jersey ; Horace
M. Hedden and George M. Hedden, both of and at Worcester, in
the State of Massachusetts, and Newark, New Jersey; Luther Grover,
J.& J. Berry, William Park, John E. Blakemore, all of and at Boston,
in said State of Massachusetts.

31 SCHEDULE C.

On pages 181 and 182 of a book entitled “A Narrative of the
Building, and a Description of the Construction of the Eddystone

| er yeh sag with Stone, * * * by John Smeaton,” etc., published
at Li

ndon, 1813; and also on pages 559 and 560, in an article headed
“Japanning,” beginning on page 7 and ending on pase 12 of vol-
ume II of a work in two volumes, entitled “The Engineers’ and

Mechanics’ Enclyclopedia, * * * by Luke Herbert,” etc., pub-

lished at London, 1842; and, also, on pages 467 to 474, inclusive, of
tle first volume of a work printed in the German language, entitled
“Handbuch der Mechanischen Technologie, * * * von Karl
Kammarsch,” which, being translated, is “Manuel of Mechanical
Technology, * * * by Karl Kammarsch,” published at Hanover,
1857 ; “ Enclyclopedia of Useful Arts, Mechanical and Chemical,”
edited by Charles Tomlinson, and published in two volumes at
London and New York, 1854. On page 384 of the second volume is
an article beginning on page 382 and headed “ Pens.”

The defendants reserve the right to add to and amend said
Schedules A, B, and C, within the period limited by law for that
purpose, and they pray that they may have the same advantage of
the facts hereinbefore stated, and the same benefit of the allegations
of this answer, as if the same had been specially pleaded ; and they
deny that any matter or thing in said complainant's bill contained,
and not herein and hereby well and sufficiently answered, is true to
the knowledge and belief of the defendants; and they pray to be
hence dismissed, with their reasonable costs and charges.
| SARGENT & CO.,

3 By J. B. SARGENT, President.
JNO. S. BEACH,
Solicitor and of Counsel.

32 Usirep States or AMERICA, |
District of Connecticut,
| New Haven.

On this first day of March, 1880, before me comes Joseph B. Sar-
gent, who, being duly sworn, dceposes and says that he is the presi-
dent of the corporation Sargent and Company ; that he knows the
contents of the foregoing answer, and that the matters therein set
forth, so far as they are stated to be within the knowledge of the
defendants, are true, and as to all other matters therein set forth he

believes them to be true.
JOHN B. MILLS,
Notary Public.

BSS >is

14 WILLIAM H. PLUMMER, ADM’R, &C., VS.

Anda on the 3rd day of April, 1880, the complainant filed in court
his replication to said answer in the words and figures following,
Viz:

33 Complainant’s Replication.

Circuit Court of the United States, District of Connecticut. In Equity.

aa Hiram TUCKER v8. SARGENT & Co.

aaa This repliant, saving and reserving to himself all and all manner
aw of advantage of exception which may be had and taken to the mani-
aa fest errors, uncertainties, and insufficiencies of the answer of the said
defendant, for replication thereunto say that he does and will aver,
maintain, and prove his said bill to be true, certain, and sufficient
in the law to be answered unto by the said defendant, and that the
at answer of the said defendant is uncertain, evasive, and insufficient
aa in the law to be replied unto by this repliant, without this, that any
ai other matter or thing in the said answer contained material or
effectual in the law to be replied unto, and not herein and hereby
well and sufficiently replied unto, confessed or avoided, traversed or |

denied, is true; all which matters and things this repliant is ready 4

———

| to aver, maintain, and prove as this honorable court shall direct,

and humbly prays, as in and by his said bill he has already prayed.

an By his solicitor, CHAS. M. REED.

a WM. WALDO HYDE,
Solicitor of Record.

334 And on the 20th day of November, 1880, the defendant
filed an amendment to his answer, in, the words and figures
following, viz: /

fh 34 Amendment of Answer. (Filed Nov. 20, 1880.)

United States Circuit Court, District of Connecticut. In Equity.

HrramM TucKERv. SARGENT & Co.

The defendants, in pursuance of leave of court for that purpose,
amend their answer as on file by inserting between the paragraph
of said answer (No. 3), which contains a reference to sahelialen A, B,
and C, and said schedules, as follows:

“4. Because that long prior to the supposed invention of said
Tucker articles of iron bronzed by process claimed in said patent
were manufactured by Wilhelm Graff, Gottich A. Erhardt, Otto
North, Heinrick Holsmuller, all of Berlin, in the Kingdom of Prus-
sia, at said Berlin: E. C. Zimmerman, of Frankfort-on-the-Rhine, at
said Frankfort, and at Hannan, in the Kingdom of Prussia, the Royal
of Berlin, in the Kingdom of Prussia, at said Berlin, and
were imported into the United States and known to and used and
sold by the following-named persons and firms at the city of New 4

Si

ech Oa oo a RM a BE MSI RN
at ie . :
haere See

York :

Se MEE IID a et tg ee te

SARGENT & COMPANY. 15

C. F. A. Henricks, of No. 367 Henry street, in the city of Brook-
lyn, New York. :

Hartley & Graham, and Schuyler, Hartley & Graham, of the city
of New York.

Stephen Pell, of 148 Main street, Brooklyn, New York.

John Wilcox, of No. 73 Christopher street, New York city.

L. I. Kalemberg, of 125 Fulton street, city of New York.

Dated at New Haven, November 19, 1880.”

SARGENT & CO.,
By J. B. SARGENT, President.
JNO. S. BEACH,
Solicitor and of Counsel.

35 Sworn to as being true to the best of his knowledge, infor-
mation, and belief, by Joseph B. Sargent, president of said

Sargent & Co. |
CHAS. L. BALDWIN,
Notary Public.

35} And on the 15th day of June, 1881, complainant’s and de-
_fendants’ evidence was filed in the words and figures follow-
ing, Viz:

36 In the Circuit Court of United States for the District of
Connecticut.

HrraM Tucker v. SARGENT, ce.

Evidence for complainant, taken pursuant to the sixty-seventh rule
of the Supreme Court of the United States, in equity, as amended,
before me, John C. Lane, special examiner.

Oct. 12, 1880,

(Hiram Tucker, being first duly sworn, in answer to direct ex-
amination by Elihu G. Loomis, Esq., of counsel for complainant,
saith as follows :)

Question 1. What is your name, age, residence, and occupation ?

Answer. Hiram Tucker; age 57; reside in Boston; manufacturer.

Q. 2. Are you the complainant in this case?

A. I am.

(Examination suspended.)

Complainant offers in evidence a certified copy of reissued

37 letters patent of the United States, number 2355, granted to
the Tucker Manufacturing Company, dated September
eleventh, 1866, for “ Improved Process of Bronzing or Coloring Iron,”
marked Tucker “Exhibit A A, John C. Lane, Spec. Ex'r;” also a
certified copy of reissued letters patent of the United States, number
2356, granted to the Tucker Manufacturing Company, dated Septem-
ber eleventh, 1866, for “ Improved Manufacture from Iron in Imita-
tion of Bronze,” marked “Tucker Exhibit B, John C Lane, Spec.
Ex’r;” also a certified copy of an assignment of said patents from

16 WILLIAM H. PLUMMER, ADM’R, &C., VS.

said Tucker Manufacturing Company to said Tucker, dated August
twenty-seventh, 1872, recorded libro A 18, page 454, of Transfers of
Patents in the Patent Office of the United States; also a certified
copy of an assignment of said patents from said Tucker to Walter
Curtis and Charles M. Reed, dated June twentieth, 1876, recorded
libro V 20, page 175 of said Transfers of Patents; also a certified
copy of an assignment of said patents from Benjamin R. Curtis, as
administrator of the estate of Walter Curtis and Charles M. Reed,
to said Tucker, dated January twenty-seventh, 1877, recorded libro
H 21, page 282 of said Transfers, marked “Tucker Exhibits C,
John C. Lane, Spec. Ex’r;” also three buts, marked “ Tucker Exhibit
A, Feb’y 25, 1880, Geo. L. Huntress, Notary Public” —* ‘Tucker Ex-
hibit D, John C. Lane, Spec. Ex’r;” and “Tucker Exhibit D D,
John C. Lane, Spec. Ex’r;” and said counsel for complainant states
that if the defendants do not admit that said Exhibits A and D and
D D are goods manufactured and sold by them, evidence of such
manufacture and sale will be hereafter offered.

(Examination resumed.)

Q. 3. Please state briefly what degree of familiarity you have
with the use of oils and varnishes and with the various processes
for ornamenting iron in common use.

A. I have had more than thirty years’ experience in using these
substances for the purpose of covering and ornamenting iron by
means of heat. I have also had large experience in the manufacture

of japans and varnishes. :
38 d 4. What practical experience have you had in the use
of the process described in the letters patent here in suit ?

A. I have had more or less experience in making Tucker bronze
for eighteen years and consider, myself thoroughly versed in every-
thing that relates to that process.

Q. 5. What practical experience have you had of the effects of
different degrees of heat on oils, varnishes, and japans, when spread
upon metallic surfaces?

A. More than thirty years’ experience in the use of those sub-
stances for covering iron by means of heat.

Q. 6. Will you examine these exhibits, marked Tucker Exhibits
“A,” “D” and “DD,” in this cause and state whether or not they
~ are substantially the same as the bronzed iron described and claimed
in your patents in suit?

A. I consider them to be substantially the same thing.

Q. 7. Will you give your reasons for such opinion ?

A. This pair of butts, Exhibit D, appear, after being fitted and
while in the rough state, to have been coated over with either a
strong boiled oil or a thin coating of brown japan and then sub-
mitted to a degree of heat sufficient to solidify the same and modify,
to some degree, its color. The face of the butts then appear to have
been ground and smoothed by a fine emery wheel. The butt was
then placed in a furnace heated sufficiently to raise a dark brown
color upon the surfaces so ground or smoothed The butt, after
being removed from the oven and cooled, appears to have had ap-

pm
es

ww

=

a

ca

he ns an, li

iis O "RIDA 2 oN ee ms Wage ¢:

SARGENT & COMPANY. 17

plied to it a thin coating of oi] copal varnish. After such coating
of varnish was applied it appears to have been replaced in the oven,
previously heated to a high degree of heat, and there remained
until the varnish became solidified and modified in color, after
which it was removed and was then completely finished, ready for
the market. Although this process consists of two stcps instead of

one, as deccribed in the patent, I consider it substantially the same

for the reason that it produces the same result, to wit, a surface on

-

ee the iron which is composed of oxidized or modified oil, or

; 39 oil varnish (which is the same thing for the purpose of prac-
a) ee tising this invention), and oxidized iron, both produced by
means of heat. The same remarks will apply to Exhibits D D and A.

Q. 8. Are you or not, from your knowledge of the art of ornament-

4 ing iron, enabled to say positively that the three exhibits just re-
4 ferred to were ornamented by substantially the process which you

# have described ?

A. Iam.
Fi Q. 9. Have you read that portion of the affidavit of Henry B.
/ Sargent before filed in this case which describes the process em-
| ployed by Sargent & Company in the finish and ornamentation of
| butts?

A. I have.
Q. 10. Whether or not said affidavit confirms your opinion that
y these goods were finished by substantially the same process as that
described and claimed in your patents in suit?

A. Yes, for the reason that the process he has described for color-
ing and covering the ground surfaces of his butts is substantially
the saine as I have described as being practised on Exhibits D, A,

and DD, and I have testified already that that process is substan-
: tially the same as is described in my patents here in suit.
VW Q. 11. Will you prepare a piece of Tucker bronze, following
F strictly the specifications of your patents, and produce it at the time
he? Som and se to which this examination shall be adjourned ?
A. I will.

(Examination suspended.)

Complainant offers in evidence a certificate of the appointment
of Benjamin R. Curtis as administrator of the estate of Walter
Curtis, under the seal of the probate court of Suffolk county, in the
Commonwealth of Massachusetts, marked “ Exhibit E, John C.
Lane, Spec. Ex’r.”

Oct. 13, 1880.
40 Complainant puts in evidence a speciinen of Tucker bronze,
as promised in his eleventh answer, marked “ Tucker Ex-
hibit F, John C. Lane, Spec. Ex.”

(Examination resumed.)

(And in answer to cross-examination by C. E. Mrrcnusy., Esq_., of
counsel for respondents, saith as follows :)

Cross-question 1. State whether the title exhibits placed in evi-
J—378

pied AYO OPS irae yy
is lan) sy See he

24. OS a hae ot Weg g.-"- _ entafii * a

Rg Sth UE IM AK Tp EBON. GRRE RNSY LI BORDA Lot

ON ee ad “

_ ee ee ae eer enn

oN eebiihahiitianisentied AONE ORIN ee AL ALD DR a atte erm PRE OEE TELA EM 5. oe Mla pio =

SPARES stag Py BB

18 / WILLIAM H. PLUMMER, ADM’R, &C., VS.

dence in connection with your testimony constitute all the contracts
to which you are a ie relating to the letters patent in contro-
versy, or to rights of recovery, or to moneys recovered under the
same.

A. To the best of my knowledge and belief, yes.

Cross-Q. 2. Have you not signed a contract of the kind referred
to in the last question since the date of the last deed contained in
‘Tucker “ Exhibit C”*’

A. I have.

Cross-Q. 3. Will you produce the same, or a copy thereof, for use
in this case?

A. I cannot say whether I will or not until I have consulted my
counsel, Mr. Reed. I understand by the question, however, that it
refers to a contract made between myself and the Tucker Manu-
facturing Company and William H. Plummer, which does not affect
my title to the patent, as I understand it. 3

Cross-Q. 4. Does not the contract that you referred to in your last
answer, and you are right in understanding it to be the one I re-
ferred to, vest in the Tucker Manufacturing Company and William
H. Plummer the whole or part of the title to any money that may
be recovered for alleged infringement in this case?

A. They are entitled to eighty per cent. of the proceeds which
may accrue from any litigation of said patent until their claims
against me are satisfied, said claims amounting, at the time the
contract was made, to some twenty-four or five thousand dollars.

(Counsel for respondent here calls upon counsel for complainant
to produce said instrument or a copy thereof.)

41 Cross-Q. 5. No reply being made to my request for said in-
strument, will you please state fully and in detail every par-
ticular of said instrument?

A. I decline to do so at this time, for the reason that my counsel,-

who has this case especially in charge, is ill and not able to be
present. I see no particular reason why I should not give the
details in regard to this contract, as I have already given the sub-
stance, but not knowing exactly what the effect of a full answer may
be to the last interrogatory, I prefer to wait for Mr. Reed’s advice.

(Counsel for respondent states that, in view of the last answer, he
will defer cross-examination upon this point for the present and
renews his demand for the production of said instrument, claiming
that the legal effect thereof is to vest a titie in equity in the persons
named in answer to cross-question 3.)

Cross-Q. 6. In the deed from the Tucker Manufacturing Company
to you, dated August twenty-seventh, 1872, I find enumerated among
the patents conveyed by said instrument not only the reissues in
controversy, but also letters patent, number 90891, dated June first,
1869, for an improvement in coating articles of ironware. What
was the improvement described in those letters patent?

(Objected to as incompetent and immaterial.)

>|

+ POA PREM >

SARGENT & COMPANY. 19

A. I am not able to state with accuracy just what that patent
related to or, more properly speaking, Just what the improvement
set forth in that patent consisted in. It is many years since I have
read it.

Cross-Q. 7. You were the patentee, I believe, of the last-named
patent, were you not?

(Objected to for same causes.)

A. I was.
‘ross-Q. 8. It related to the use of copal varnish for coating

articles of ironware, did it not? .

(Also objected to for same reasons.)

A. My memory of dates is so defective, and have taken out so

many patents for improvements in finishing iron, that I am

42 notable to state whether this patent under discussion was

the one that related to covering articles that had been

Tucker bronzed with varnish. I remember of taking a patent,
however, for that so-called “improvement.”

Cross-Q. 9. To the best of your knowledge, information and belief,
was not the patent of June first, 1869, the patent taken out by you
for coating with copal varnish articles previously ornamented in
imitation of bronze by oil and heat in accordance with your pre-
viously patented process ?

(Objected to as before.)

A. Ihave no reason to doubt but what that was the fact, but I
cannot swear to it at this moment.

Cross-Q. 10. Assuming that to be true, of which you say in your
last answer you have no reason to doubt its truth, please state
whether I am correct, substantially, in the following statement of
the three inventions referred to in the deed from the Tucker Manu-
facturing Company to you dated August twenty-seventh, 1872:

First. A process of ornamenting iron in imitation of bronze by oil
and heat by removing sand, scale, or other foreign matter, then ap-
plying to the cleansed surface such a thin film of linseed oil, or
equivalent oil, as is best attained by applying the oil with a brush
and then rubbing off the oiled surface thoroughly’ with a rag,
sponge, or other suitable implement, and then —— jt in an oven
where it is submitted toa daases of heat which may be measured
by an intensity sufficient to change a brightened surface of clean
vnoiled iron toa color varying from a light straw color to a deep
blue, then repeating the process if desired.

Second. Analleged new manufacture consisting of iron ornamented
in imitation of bronze by oil and heat in the manner described.

Third. A patent for outer coating with copal varnish articles
ornamented in imitation of bronze, treated by the process before
described.

(Objected to as before.)
A. Yes.

~ CER Mat A ee
"

$

PEALE! SPELL IE AEE NET SEP ELAN NOELIA ED ELMO. SNA LAY IAL LEN INS Hi
i itn ae ante agence so stcslonaet nbeat nore P.3

20 WILLIAM H. PLUMMER, ADM’R, &C., VS.

Cross-Q. 11. Was the third patent referred to in the last

43 question in evidence in the case of Tucker against the Tucker
Manufacturing Company tried before Judge Clifford in this
circuit ?

A. No; it was not.

Cross-Q. 12. Tucker Exhibit F, I understand, is a piece of iron
ornamented in accordance with the process described in your patent
numbered 2355, is it not?

A. It is.

Cross-Q. 13. Please describe in detail the way in which you pro-
duced the surface of Tucker Exhibit F.

A. This Exhibit was first polished on an emery wheel, then oiled
over with boiled linseed oil by rubbing the same on with the finger,
then afterwards rubbing it off with a rag, then placed in a regular
bronzing oven, one end of the exhibit resting upon the bottom of
the oven nearest the fire, and allowed to remain until the color ap-
peared as now seen on said exhibit, with the exception of it being
soinewhat lighter in shade. It was then removed from the oven,
allowed to cool, oiled again in the same manner by rubbing with
the finger, the surplus oil rubbed off with fine tissue paper; the piece
was then replaced in the oven, hung about the centre of the sume
by being suspended on a wire, and allowed to remain for an hour,
more or less, until it assumed the character and appearance now
seen.

Cross-Q. 14. What was the heat to which the oiled iron was sub-
— at each repetition of the process in producing Tucker Ex-

ubit F?

A. Iam _ not able to state specifically. I am sure that at the first
heating the heat used was over four hundred degrees Fahrenheit,
and, according to my best judgment, at the second heating was
about four hundred; might have been some less.

Cross-Q. 15. As I understand you, the heat at the second heating
was sutticient to deepen the color of the iron?

A. I should judge it was.

Cross-Q. 16. And it was sufficient to produce upon clean unoiled

iron the color prescribed by your patent as a test, was it not?
44. . hernia *
a tege ee a NR tN SCRE A TNS RAINE ARI AEG AISLE, ARH REN CRIN LH NE AB ENG Cte, LOGE ATALANTA AP ARR MTS RT AO ee ee eee re
oe
Rati
4 “

in

Fae met

22 WILLIAM H. PLUMMER, ADM'R, &C., VS.

Cross-Q. 24. You knew that it had been customary in the arts to
bake copal varnish onto metallic surfaces prior to the date of your
original invention, did you not?

A. If I understand your question to mean placing copal varnish
onto bright metallic surfaces directly and than baking the same,

I did not.
46 Cross-Q. 25. To give a single illustration, you knew that
copal varnish had been baked upon the bright surface of tin
long before the date of your process, as discovered by you, did you
not?

A. I did not.

Cross-Q. 26. Do you regard English brown varnish, applied in
the manner described in your patents in suit, and subjected to the
heat prescribed by said patents, as the equivalent for linseed oil ?

A. I doubt very much whether it would be practical to treat iron
with English brown varnish in the way specified in the patent for
treating the oil; if it could be, it would be within my patent un-
doubtedly.

Cross-Q. 27. If it could not be applied in the precise way pre-
scribed in your patent, would you regard it as an equivalent, say, if
it were applied by diluting it with turpentine or benzine ?

A. I should, for the reason that English brown varnish is com-
posed almost entirely of linseed oil which has been boiled to a paste
and diluted with spirits of turpentine. When a thin coat of this
material is placed over the surface of bright or polished iron, and
then submitted to such a heat as is deseribed in the patent here in
suit, and for a length of time sufficient to raise an oxide or change
of color on the surface of the iron, which shall combine in some de-
gree with the baked brown varnish which was placed upon the iron
previous to its being heated, it constitutes the new surface, or the
distinctive features of this invention.

(Examination suspended.)

(Examination resumed.)

Oct. 22, 1880.

Cross-Q. 28. You say, in reply to question 7, among other things,
“this pair of butts (Exhibit D) appear, after being fitted and while
in the rough state, to have been coated over with either a strong
boiled oil ora thin coating of brown japan.” Are you quite sure

that this first coat did not consist of black japan ?
47 A. I feel quite sure I was right in my statement that you
have just quoted, but I won't say that I am absolutely sure.

Cross-Q. 20. Whichever was the case the maker had a right to use
such coating, I suppose ?

A. He had not a right to use it if the sand and scale had been
removed from this groundwork before applying the coat of boiled
oil or thin brown japan, or a mixture of the two, and heating it in
such a heat as described in the patent. I do not claim it to be an
infringement of my patent if this brown color which appears on the
groundwork of this butt is produced by colored pigments alone.
Cross-Q. 30. Do you understand that more than one coat of either

hs sichaniniiiatliailiieice BE eee a a |

J sepcieniiiiicalisici AE eee iegtteagae eens | ‘

camel oo anew

SARGENT & COMPANY. 23

black japan, or brown japan, or strong boiled oil, as the case may
have been, was used in producing the groundwork of Exhibit D—
I call it black groundwork ?

A. I don’t think there was more than one coat used before the grind-
ing off the salient surfaces.

Cross-Q. 31. Inasmuch, then, as your patent prescribed several
repetitions of the process in order to produce a black, it follows,
does it not, that if a black color was produced on the groundwork
of Exhibit D by a single coat, at a single baking, your process was
certainly not used prior to the grinding of the salient faces ?

A. No, that does not follow. You state that you say that this
groundwork isa black; I do not see it to be so, but should call it
brown, and such a brown as is produced by first removing the sand
and scale by a pickle made from sulphuric acid and water. When a
thin coating of such a material as I have described as being used
on this groundwork in question is placed over a surface so treated,
from which the sand and scale has been removed by pickle, the
result is always the saine as appears on this groundwork in ques-
tion. | "e

_Cross-Q. 32. You understand, do you not, from the affidavit of

Henry B. Sargent, to which your attention was directed, in reply

to question 9, that according to his statement, butts of the

48 defendants’ manufacture are first covered with a black japan ?

A. I do so understand it, and I have not the slightest rae

but what the groundwork of the butt which he put in as an ex-

hibit was done with black japan. It appeared to me so when I

made an examination of said butt. The color and texture of that

groundwork appeared different altogethcer to me from the ground-
work on this Exhibit D. |

Cross-Q. 33. If Mr. Heury B. Sargent’s statement in his affidavit
referred to in question 9 as to the use of black japan for the ground-
work is correct, such use does not involve your process, does it?

A. It does not.

Cross-Q. 34. If, then, the process described by Henry B. Sargent as
to producing the ne does not involve your process, and if,
as you say In reply to question 10, “the process he (Henry B. Sar-
gent) has described fer coloring and covering the ground surfaces
of his butts is substantially the same as I have described as being
practised on Exhibits D A and D D,”—how can the process you have
described as the one by which the groundwork was applied be
within the patent? Can two processes for producing the groundwork
upon butts be substantially alike and one of those processes be
within your patent and the other without your patent?

A. To answer the latter part of your question first, I will say no,
they cannot be substantially alike and vet there be a patentable differ.
ence. As I understand these two groundworks, and I call them two,
because on inspection they appear to be so, the colur on one of them
is produced by the black japan, without regard to the heat, while
the color on the outta wk on these Exhibits D is produced by
the action of heat on the thin coating of boiled oil, or light brown
japan, or a mixture of both, as the case may be, combined with the

pee SE pi a erp SD RL te alae a
e ~ ~ hasten serommuegrntinn

a ‘deg 2 ON Di RAR. CER elie Doe Nee er ee sea eete ies Ss
y . Cog Tee

24 WILLIAM H. PLUMMER, ADM’R, &C., VS.

dark color of the iron left by the pickle. I do not say absolutely

that I am right in the supposition that this groundwork on
49 these Exhibits D is produced as I have supposed, but for the
purpose of this answer I take it for granted that it is so.

Cross-Q. 35. Inasmuch as in reply te question 9 of your direct
testimony you refer to no exhibit made or filed by Henry B. Sar-
gent, and inasmuch as in my cross-examination I have referred to
no such exhibit, and inasmuch as no such exhibit is before us for
inspection or comparison, and inasmuch as I don’t know to what
exhibit you allude and inasmuch as all such exhibits are, or
ought to be, in the clerk’s office at Hartford, you will please excuse
me if I don’t follow you in this digression. Now, to repeat in another
form what I have said, I understand you to say, in reply to question
9, that you have read the affidavit of Henry B. Sargent, before filed
in this case, which describes the process employed by Sargent &
Company in the finish and ornamentation of butts. I understand
you also to have said that, according to his description of that pro-
cess, the groundwork is produced by baking on black japan. I un-
derstand you also to have said that, if the groundwork 1s produced
as hedescribed it, [it] does not involve the use of your process. [ under-
stand you also to say that the process he has described is substan-
tially the same as you have described. How, then, can one be
within the patent and the other without ?

A. To answer the latter part of your question first, I will say
that I never have described or admitted that these two processes
now under discussion were substantially or at all alike. One isa
process for producing color and surface by means of oii and heat

used thinly over iron from which the sand and scale has been.

removed, as I understand it. The other process, to wit, that de-
scribed by Henry B. Sargent in his affidavit, on which you have ex-
amined me (and this exhibit of H. B. Sargent referred to in his
athidavit) consists in a groundword of thick black japan, the iron
underneath forming no part of the color. I have read H. B. Sar-
gent’s affidavit and think I understand the process therein described
fully, and I believe the black japan on ni exhibit is correctly de-
scribed in his affidavit.
50 Cross-Q. 36. You would not be willing to say, would you,
that the pigmenty looking opaque coating on Tticker Ex-
hibit D D where the words occur, Pat’d Nov. 21st, 1871, was produced
by a single application of an oily film and heat in the way described
in your patent, would you ?

A. I wouldn’t consider it of the slightest consequence whether it
was or not, as this surface is so rough and spongy as to be of no
value as an ornamental surface, only in contrast and as a ground-
work in connection with bright surfaces, as appears on this exhibit.
All such surfaces are very deceptive, and I am not willing to swear
whether it is or is not such a surface as is described in the patent.
To repeat, perhaps, what I have said before, such a surface is of no
possible value, taken by itself as an ornamental surface.

Cross-Q. 37. Inasmuch as you are not willing to swear whether it
is or is not such a surface as is described in the patent, may we not

a
ae
gp RR
c+

SARGENT & COMPANY. 95

agree in regarding the alleged infringing butts as not involving the
patented process up tothe time of tie grinding of their salient
faces ?

A. I decline to agree to any admission. My testimony already
given will be a sufficient reason for so declining.

Cross-Q. 38. Do you, as an expert, swear that the alleged infring-
ing butts were subjected to your process prior to the —s of
their salient faces, and do you, as an expert, swear that the dark
groundwork on the alleged infringing exhibits was not produced,
in whole or in part, by pigments?

A. If my suppositions in regard to this exhibit in question are
right, I should say my patented process had been practised, and I
should say if there were any pigments used in the solution they had
so slight an effect as not to affect the result to any material degree.

(Objected to as irresponsive.)

Cross-Q. 39. Inasmnch as, in reply to cross-question 36, you say
referring to such surface, “I am not willing to swear whether it is
or is not such a surface as is described in the patent,” I suppose you
are unwilling to swear whether your supposition is correct or

not?
51 A. In the answer from whica that quotation is taken I

was swearing as to one small particular spot, which for some
reason appears to be more heavily coated, [ presume with the outer
coat of varnish, and has a different appearance from what the other
matted groundwork in this butt has. That spot, taken by itself, us
I said before, is confusing, but taking the two long strips of matted
work on the outside of this butt, I should say, according to my best
judgment, they come within the patented process. |

Cross-Q. 40. Please answer whether or not the color of the ground-
work on the alleged infringing butts is produced wholly or in part
by pigments?

A. If there was any pigment in the oil, I don’t think it had any
substantial effect in producing the color.

Cross-Q. 41. Please state whether or not there were any pigments
in the coating by which the groundwork was produced on the
alleged infringing butts.

A. I do not know whether there was or was not.

Cruss-Q. 42. Are you able to say for a certainty that the dark
groundwork on Tucker Exhibits D D D, and A were produced
otherwise than by baking on a black japan, and if such japan were
employed, might not the difference in shade be owing to the varying
action of the yellow coat of baked varnish placed above it, or some
other cause consistent with its being a japan coat?

A. To the first question, I am ; to the second question, it would not.
I will state that this groundwork under discussion is precisely the
same in texture and appearance and in all its characteristics with
the groundworks on all Tucker bronzed goods that have ever been
made of which I have had knowledge and experience since the dis-
covery of this invention was first made by ime.

Cruss-Q. 43. If, then, Sargent & Company have never made any
4—375

cenithnieitenbiameeete lta atin i gated cena iE et Ee ve at eet mt

Larner y: poi
eine itinetiiiiie ae bel ee a, ee oe

Pe et So ten

on hrm am nds Lh

Bi Re a . ms Pee ae - F a :
5 re LFS ~> ete 7 >" tr R * en & ou ©
FR Ee Eg EMS UT EO ET” A SE EN OP APS ne ny pi aot os Lisp Se
> ive rm eae 7 S t r x ms ace rs

26 WILLIAM H. PLUMMER, ADM’R, &C., VS.

imitation bronze butt excepting those whose groundwork was pro-
duced by baking a black japan, you would be willing to swear that
these butts were not Sargent’s goods, would you?
52 A. I should like to know before I answer that question (if
it’s proper for me know as an expert) what you mean by a
coating of black japan. If it is meant ordinary coating of thin
black japan, baked on in the usual way, or by any degree of heat, I
shall say such a coating has nothing whatever to do with my patent
here in suit; but if counsel for the defendants mean a coating of
extremely thin dark-colored japan, which when placed over the
groundwork produces no substantial color, and then submitted to a
heat such as is described in my patent, such heat coloring the coat-
ing and modifying to some degree the iron in connection with it,
that would be an infringement on my patent, as I understand it.

(Objected to as irresponsive.)

Cross-Q. 44. You have testified that if Mr. Henry B. Sargent has
correctly described the process of producing the groundwork on
defendants’ butts, such application was not within your process. If
all the butts made by Sargent & Company having salient faces had
their groundwork produced as he describes, then would you be will-
ing to swear that the alleged infringing butts were not made by the
defendants ?

A. I shouldn’t want to swear anything about it.

(Examination suspended.)

(Examination resumed.)

Oct. 23, 1880.

Cross-Q. 45. If Mr. Henry B. Sargent is correct as to the ground-
work of the alleged infringing butts being made as he states and the
salient faces are then ground away, there is nothing up to that stage
that contains your process, even from your standpoint, I suppose ?

A. I answered that question particularly and fully. There is an
ambiguity in Mr. Sargent’s description, if I understand it and
remember it correctly—that is to say, he doesn’t say in his affidavit
how thick or thin he uses the japan, or whether the groundwork has
been treated by removing sand or scale before so treating. Those
are conditions I should wish to be informed about before giving a yes

or no answer to your interrogatory. Further than this, I do not

53 remember (although he may have done so) that he stated the

4 degrees of heat used in the process for producing said ground-
work.

Cross-Q. 46. I understood from your answer to questions 9 and 10
of your direct examination that you were conversant with Henry B.
Sargent’s description contained in his affidavit, which is that the
sunken parts of the butts were first covered with a black japan, that
this coat of blacking was baked in an oven at a temperature not ex-
ceeding 320°. Do you claim that process so described to be within
your patent?
A. I do not.

ep eee

ee ee ee ee ee ae

SARGENT & COMPANY. 97

Cross-Q. 47 And the grinding off of the salient faces afterward
would not involve your process up to that stage either, would it?

A. It would not. :

Cross-Q. 48. And the production of the color by heat alone upon
the unoiled ground faces would not involve your process, up to that
stage ?

A. It would not.

Cross-Q. 49. The next step, as I understand, is the application of
a copal varnish. What mineral ingredients, in your judgment, are
contained in the copal varnish upon Exhibits D and D D?

A. I should say, practically none.

Cross-Q. 50. What mineral ingredients, in vour judgment, are
contained in said varnish?

A. Practically none.

Cross-Q. 51. (Question repeated.)

A. Copal varnish, as I understand it, will not hold in solution a
mineral ingredient. All minerals that I know anything about
which are used in copal varnish are used for the purpose of weer 3
ing and imparting drying qualities, and the minerals invariably
settle to the bottom.

Cross-Q. 52. What minerals, in your judgment, does the copal
varnish on Exhibits D and D D contain?

| A. Practically none.

54 Cross-Q. 53. What minerals do you have in mind in mak-
ing the discrimination which you seem to make between
none and practically none ?

A. Red lead, umber, or manganese, or sugar of lead, which settle
to the bottom of the tanks.

(Examination suspended.)

(Examination resumed.)
3 Nov. 8, 1880.

Cross-Q. 54. Have you ever superintended the production of
Tucker bronze practically—you have, I believe?

A. Yes.

Cross-Q. 55. When you practised the process by applying linseed
oil and afterwards rubbing it off thoroughly, as preseribed in the
patent, you were accustomed to dilute the linseed oil with turpentine
or eo or naphtha before applying it, were you not?

A. eS.

(Examination suspended.)

Counsel for defendants admits that Exhibits “ A,” “ D.” and “ D D”
were manufactured by defendants.

(Examination resumed.)

(And, in answer to redirect questions by said counsel for com-
plainant, saith as follows:)

4 ’ . ” ‘
ia RA re thse eats sadn jh 4 cash igo riphicencs Seam nla iman damn mca aosasiiaan ubllcuiahens edaietis aiasdbusiuiliesioel baedinidae aids teins ch ee . , aan ae

WILLIAM H. PLUMMER, ADM’R, &C., VS.

imitation bronze butt excepting those whose groundwork was pro-
duced by baking a black japan, you would be willing to swear that
these butts were not Sargent’s goods, would you?
52 A. I should like to know before I answer that question (if
it’s proper for me know as an expert) what you mean by a
coating of black japan. If it is meant ordinary coating of thin
black japan, baked on in the usual way, or by any degree of heat, I
shall say such a coating has nothing whatever to do with my patent
here in suit; but if counsel for the defendants mean a coating of
extremely thin dark-colored japan, which when placed over the
groundwork produces no substantial color, and then submitted to a
heat such as is described in my patent, such heat coloring the coat-
ing and modifying to some degree the iron in connection with it,
that would be an infringement on my patent, as I understand it.

(Objected to as irresponsive.)

Cross-Q. 44. You have testified that if Mr. Henry B. Sargent has
correctly described the process of producing the groundwork on
defendants’ butts, such application was not within your process. If
all the butts made by Sargent & Company having salient faces had
their groundwork produced as he describes, then would you be will-
ing to swear that the alleged infringing butts were not made by the
defendants ?

A. I shouldn’t want to swear anything about it.

(Examination suspended.)

(Examination resumed.)
Oct. 23, 1880.

Cross-Q. 45. If Mr. Henry B. Sargent is correct as to the ground-
work of the alleged infringing butts being made as he states and the
salient faces are then ground away, there is nothing up to that stage
that contains your process, even from your standpoint, I suppose ?

A. I answered that question particularly and fully. There is an
ambiguity in Mr. Sargent’s description, if I understand it and
remember it correctly —that is to say, he doesn’t say in his affidavit
how thick or thin he uses the japan, or whether the groundwork has
been treated by removing sand or seale before so treating. Those
are conditions I should wish to be informed about before giving a yes

or no answer to your interrogatory. Further than this, I do not
53 remember (although he may have done so) that he stated the
: degrees of heat used in the process for producing said ground-
work. :

Cross-Q. 46. I understood from your answer to questions 9 and 10
of your direct examination that you were conversant with Henry B.
Sargent’s description contained in his affidavit, which is that the
sunken parts of the butts were first covered with a black japan, that
this coat of blacking was baked in an oven at a temperature not ex-
ceeding 320°. Do you claim that process so described to be within
your patent?
A. I do not.

SARGENT & COMPANY. 27

Cross-Q. 47 And the grinding off of the salient faces afterward
would not involve your process up to that stage either, would it?

A. It would not.

Cross-Q. 48. And the production of the color by heat alone upon
the unoiled ground faces would not involve your process, up to that
stage ?

A. It would not.

Cross-Q. 49. The next step, as I understand, is the application of
a copal varnish. What mineral ingredients, in your judgment, are
contained in the copal varnish upon Exhibits D and DD?

A. I should say, practically none.

Cross-Q. 50. What mineral ingredients, in your judgment, are
contained in said varnish?

A. Practically none.

Cross-Q. 51. (Question repeated.)

A. Copal varnish, as I understand it, will not bold in solution a
mineral ingredient. All minerals that I know anything about
which are used in copal varnish are used for the purpose of clarify-
ing and imparting drying qualities, and the minerals iivatlehle
settle to the bottom.

Cross-Q. 52. What minerals, in your judgment, does the copal
varnish on Exhibits D and D D contain?

A. Practically none.
54 Cross-Q. 53. What minerals do you have in mind in mak-
ing the discrimination which you seem to make between
none and practically none ?

A. Red lead, umber, or manganese, or sugar of lead, which settle

to the bottom of the tanks.

(Examination suspended.)

(Examination resumed.)

Novy. 8, 1880.

Cross-Q. 54. Have you ever superintended the production of
Tucker bronze practically—you have, I believe?

A. Yes.

Cross-Q. 55. When you practised the process by applying linseed
oil and afterwards rubbing it off thoroughly, as prescribed in the
patent, you were accustomed to dilute the linseed oil with turpentine
or nse or naphtha before applying it, were you not?

A. Yes.

(Examination suspended.)

Counsel for defendants admits that Exhibits “ A,” “ D.” and “ DD”
were manufactured by defendants.

(Examination resumed.)

(And, in answer to redirect questions by said counsel for com-
plainant, saith as follows:) 3

28 WILLIAM H. PLUMMER, ADM’R, &C., VS.

Q. 1. What difference is there between the appearance of the
groundwork of the butts which have been under discussion during
the cross-examination, except those referred to as described in the
affidavit of Henry B. Sargent, and the appearance of groundwork
of butts that have been treated with oil in strict accordance with the
specifications of the patent? If any, please explain it.

A. The groundwork of butts which have been under discussion,
except the Sargent butt described in his affidavit, have been treated
with thin oily solutions, without rubbing. The groundwork of such
butts have all been of an absorbent character, and the effect of
dipping groundwork of butts is to saturate such absorbent ground-
work without leaving any excess of oil to be rubbed off. On the

other hand, when such butts with the same character of
55 groundwork are dipped into a thin solution of oil which has

been diluted with benzine or spirits of turpentine, the effect
is simply to fill the absorbent groundwork. The salient surfaces of
the last-named butts being polished before the butt is treated with
oil at all, and in consequence of being polished losing their absorbent
character, has to be carefully rubbed with paper, efoth, rag, sponge
or other suitable implements, but the character of the groundworks
in the two kinds of butts under discussion will be substantially
alike in all their characteristics—that is to say, as regards color,
texture, and so forth.

Cross-Q. 2. In your answer to interrogatory tenth of the direct ex-
amination you say “the process he has described for coloring and
covering the ground surfaces of his butts.” By the words “ ground
surfaces” do you mean the polished salient faces or the sunken
groundwork of the butts in question ? |

A. I mean polished salient faces.

Cross-Q. 3. In regard to the agreement between yourself and the —

Tucker Manufacturing Company, Charles M. Reed, and William H.
Plummer referred to in your answer to cross-interrogatory fifth,
whether you are ready, after consultation with counsel, to submit
the same to the inspection of counsel for the respondent ?

A. I am, and produce a copy for that purpose.

(Counsel for respondents places the said copy in evidence, marked
“ Exhibit Tucker Agreement, John C. Lane, Spee. Ex’r,” counsel for
complainant objecting thereto as incompetent, irrelevant, and im-

material.) .
HIRAM TUCKER.
Subscribed and sworn to before me November eighth, A. D. 1880.

JOHN C. LANE,
Special Examiner.

a

SARGENT & UOMPANY.
Complainant’s Evidence in Reply.

56 United States Circuit Court, District of Connecticut: In
Equity.

Hiram TucKER v. SARGENT & Co.

Testimony taken on behalf of the complainant in reply, under and

uursuant to the sixty-seventh rule of the Supreme Court of the

nited States, in equity, as amended, before me, John B. Mills,
special examiner.

Examination resumed at New Britain, April 15, 1881, ten o’clock
a.m.

Present: E.G. Loomis, Esq., of counsel for complainant; C. E.
Mitchell, Esq., of counsel for defendant.

(Hiram Tucker, a witness heretofore produced and sworn on
behalf of the complainant, to interrogatories proposed by E. G.
Loomis, Esq., of counsel for the complainant, answered as follows :)

Question 1. You are the complainant in this case, and have
already been examined therein?
57 Answer 1. I am; I have.

Q. 2. In what does your experience in regard to the use of
oil and varnishes generally consist, and what has been your ex-
perience in the process of manufacturing Tucker bronze ?

A. I have been familiar with the use of varnishes and drying oils
for the past forty years. I have been familiar with the Tucker
bronze process ever since its first discovery by me, and have been a
manufacturer of the saine for many years, since the date of the
patent. :

Q. 3. What has been your observation in regard to the novelty
of the process of making Tucker bronze, and of the product thereof?

(Objected to as incompetent and irrelevant.)

A. I have never heard the novelty of the invention-denied except
by those who were engaged in infringing the patent. I mean, after
the invention and its novelty has been explained to parties who had
sufficient interest to inquire in regard to the same.

Q. 4. Have you examined the testimony given by the several
witnesses for the respondent in this case?

A. I have; very carefully.

Q. 5. Mr. John Ruff and Mr. Brocksieper and Mr. Purmont Brad-
ford and Mr. Joseph B. Sargent and others have described a process
by which they claim that Mr. Brocksieper and others have finished
certain articles in imitation of bronze. Please compare the process
thus described by them with that described in your patent, and state
whether they are substantially the same, and give your reasons.for
your opinion. Please take processes in the order in which they
were described, beginning with the the watch-stand described by
Mr. John Ruff as sicher by Brocksieper in his presence.

30 WILLIAM H. PLUMMER, ADM’R, &C., VS.

A. The process which Mr. John Ruff describes as being practised
in his presence by Mr. Brocksieper does not, in my opinion, describe
a process for making Tucker bronze, for the reason that one essen-
tial element described in the patent is left out of the operation. Mr.
Ruff says that he obtained a casting of a watch-stand, and that after

receiving said casting from the foundry he brushed it with a
58 wire broom-bush, which is the ordinary implement used in

«ll iron foundries for the purpose of removing the loose sand
from an ordinary iron casting, and in no case is now used for the
purpese of removing scale. He says that after brushing the casting
with this iron broom-brush Mr. Brocksieper brought in a cup some
linseed oil without admixture of spirits of turpentine or any other
dilutant, and with an ordinary brush applied a very thin coat, and
afterwards held the article so treated over a forge fire until he ob-
tained, as he expresses it, the desired color. No matter what other
way this casting was treated, if the scale had not been removed as
described in the patent, the result of such treatment would not have
been Tucker bronze. I will say further in regard to this piece of
work that if Mr. Brocksieper had removed the scale from this cast-
ing in question there would be no evidence that the product he ob-
tained by such treatment was Tucker bronze. The coating of oil
which he has described, as I should understand it from his des-
cription, is simply such a thin coating as those familiar with japan-
ning ordinarily describe as thin coats, and would be very many times
thicker than that described in the patent, and the fact that he
might get a color from holding a piece of iron over a forge fire so
treated would be no evidence whatever that a surface was obtained
consisting of oxidized oil and oxidized iron, which constitutes the
novelty of this bronze invention in question.

Mr. Ruff also testifies that after witnessing the experiment of

Mr. Brocksieper he did a cast-iron sewing-bird substantially in the
same way in which he had seen Mr. Brocksieper do the watch-stand,
with the addition of chasing the work, which wasn’t a process for
removing scale at all. What I have said about the Brocksieper
—_ on the watch-stand will apply fully to this sewing-bird.
Neither of them are such descriptions as would enable a workman
skilled in the art of japanning to produce Tucker bronze. Mr.
wer? subsequent descriptions vary from the original process
as described by Mr. Ruff and himself in the fact that he removed the
scale as well as the sand from the coat and hat hooks, which I will
take for samples and illustration; he also added copal varnish

and spirits of turpentine to the oil for the purpose of
59 coating these coat and hat hooks, jamb hooks, ete. From

his description of what he did with this composition, it ap-
pears to me to be an ordinary thin coat or coating, but many times
thicker than that described in the printed process, and such a cout-
ing as in my opinion would prevent the iron from oxidizing the sur-
face underneath, unless the coating (which would be very apt to
occur) should crawl up into small bunches and leave part of the sur-
face exposed to the action of the heat, in which case the surface would
be of no commercial value whatever. But from the fact that Mr.

SARGENT & COMPANY. $1

Brocksieper testified that these coat and hat hooks and other articles
were left to partially dry so that they could be handled, as he ex-
pressed it, Ishould presume that the crawling effect might be obviated,
which would leave upon thesurface of the iron a colored surface which
to inexperienced eyes would appear very like Tucker bronze, but
would really be a surface, the same in character as a very thin coat-

ing of boiled oil japan would be over a surface of bright iron after

being submitted to heat, and a color and surface which was univer-
sally known and practised by all japanners of skill and experience
long before the date of and after my invention of what is called
Tucker bronze. I understand Mr. J. B. Sargent’s testimony to be
substantially the same as that of Mr. Brocksieper and Mr. Ruff, and
as intended to corroborate their testimony as to prior use of this
said invention. Mr. Brocksieper has testified at considerable length
in regard to the way he first became acquainted with the prone for
producing the so-called Tucker bronze. He says before he came to
this country he had seen practised the same thing substantially in
the process for tempering screws and shovels. The description of
this process of tempering, which Mr. Brocksieper became familiar
with, the knowledge of which, as he says, enabled him to make what
is called Tucker bronze with such facility, is very accurately de-
scribed by him.

It is a process that I have been familiar with, and that all workers
of metal of any experience, I believe, are familiar with, and in fact
is a very old art, it is presumed many hundreds of years. He says

that after certain screws were put into a perforated box, a
60 quantity of rapeseed oil was poured in, and the box held over

a forge fire, or a proper fire, until the proper color and effect
was produced. The effect of such treatment as this upon steel is
simply to affect its temper, and incidentally to give the skin of the
steel orirun a darker color than it otherwise ala have. This rape-
seed oil mentioned by him is not a drying oil, and in no sense the
equivalent of linseed oil for the purpose of making Tucker bronze,
and is simply the equivalent of lard or sperm oil, and used for Jubri-
cating purposes, or for the purposes of tempering, as described. A
person situated as Mr. Brocksieper was when he first came to this
country, or first went to work for the Peck & Walter Company, and
having bis attention called to a piece of iron-work, as it was, by Mr.
Ruff, and not being acquainted with the art of japanning or its kin-
dred arts, it would be the most natural thing in the world for him
to take linseed oil, if more convenient to his hand, and go through
the saine operation that he had seen practised abroad. Now, to show
that Mr. Brocksieper hasn't a correct idea, even at this late day, of
what constitutes the new surface produced by the process described
in this bronze patent in suit, I an attention to that part of his testi-
mony where he says (without attempting to quote his exact language)
he considers this Tucker bronze to be the result of the tempering
process practised and well known by workers in metal, and the same
as that which he describes as seeing abroad, which is the same thing
as that universally used for tempering. Now, as a matter of fact,
those processes described by Mr. Brocksieper do not produce a sur-

Oo eee Nn eagle am at ant

32 WILLIAM H. PLUMMER, ADM’R, &C., VS.

face at all like Tucker bronze in character, for the reason that this
rapeseed or lard or sperm oil, used as he has described the rapeseed
oil was used, and I use them all as being the same in character, do
not change in character under the action of heat in such a way as
to leave the hard resinous substance which results from the use of
linseed oil, and which is one of the constituent elements of the com-
bination to make the new surface in question, but simply leave a
greasy surface that can be rubbed off by waste or paper, or washed
off by soap and water, as a greasy plate should be washed. Mr.
Brocksieper has testified to a process he used in producing a color on
Defendant’s Exhibit Brocksieper Picture Frame.
61 If I remember rightly, he says he first coated this with a
coating of size, made from varnish, oil, and spiritsof turpentine,
which is a very good composition for the purpose of sizing, if allowed
to remain a sufficient length of time to becone homogeneous—other-
wise the composition would act badly—but heavier in body than
the untreated linseed oil would be; that he did this picture-frame
ever with the solution, putting on, as he expresses it, equal parts,
after rubbing the prominent points of the frame with sand-paper,
and brushing the rest part of the frame (I will state here what I
omitted to state before, that the ingredients from which the size
was made were composed of — parts of linseed oil, copal varnish,
and spirits of turpentine.) Now, provided Mr. Brocksieper is not
mistaken in the slightest degree as to the process he practised on this
frame, there is no evidence that he produced Tucker bronze, for the
reason thatthe only part ofthis frame from which the scale was removed
presents the appearance of copper; and again, although this frame
appears to be colored, that is no evidence that there was a sufficient
amount of heat from the forge fire, or that a sufficient amount of
heat from a forge fire got to the surface of the iron which was cleaned
by sand-paper, to raise an oxide in conjunction with the oxidized
oil. Now. to my mind, one of two things is true in regard to the
process practised by Mr. Brocksieper on this frame in question; he
either did not apply sufficient heat to the size he placed upon this
frame by holding it over the forge fire to bring it to the ordinary
coler produced from practising the Tucker patented process (because
it does not have the appearance of any Tucker bronze that I ever saw
in my life), or he has rubbed on a thin coating of paint, composed
of pigment and oil—most likely umber, if I am correct—then dry-
ing that over the forge fire or hardening it; afterwards touching it;
afterwards touching it with bronze powder un the prominent points,
as he has described.

The character of the copper appearance on the prominent points
of this fraine I must say is a mystery to me, in view of the testimony
given by Mr. Brocksieper. If 1 was asked to give my judgment as

an expert in matters of this kind as to how this coating or
62 color on this frame was produced, I should say, after the cast-
ing came from the sand it was brushed and sand-papered as
Mr. Brocksieper has described it; that it was then submitted to a
battery process, and a blush of copper deposited on the bright por-
tions, and naturally to a very slight extent on the other portions of

SARGENT & COMPANY. 33

the frame; that afterward this very thin pigment was rubbed on
very thinly over the whole surface, and then the prominent, salient
points rubbed with a rag to remove the pigment from the bright
copper points. This process which I have described is old and well
known, not only practised on iron, but for many years on spelter for
chandelier work, and by following the description as I have given it,
just such appearing work as this would be the result; and for those
reasons, and from the long time which has elapsed since Mr. Brock-
sieper performed his operations on this frame, I think he has cer-
tainly forgotten just how he did it. Tucker bronze does not change
in color from the lapse of time unless exposed to the action of flies
and the weather. From my observation of work that was done as
far back as the date of the patent, there isn’t the slightest change
apparent to the eye in thecolor and characteristics of its surface, and
I propose, as the complainant in this case, to submit exhibits with
proof of their being done twenty years ago.

I have not scrutinized Mr. Purmont Bradford’s testimony with the
care I have devoted to Brocksieper’s, Ruff’s, and Sargent’s, for the
reason that his operations could not be considered as anticipating
the patent, if he had not made the slightest mistake in the descrip-
tion of what he did, as the result was a common japan surface. I
should not consider it at all sure, however, if he had omitted the
last coating which made practical japan, that he had done anything
that would anticipate my bronze invention, as there is no satisfactory
evidence in his description to show that he produced a surface of
oxidized iron and oil combined.

Q. 6. Mr. Sawyer and Mr. Angevine have described the processes
by which they dates to have finished certain check-canceller spears
in imitation of bronze. Have you examined their testimony, and

will you please compare the processes described by them with
63 that described in your patent? State whether they are sub-
stantially the same, and give your reasons for your opinion.

A. I have examined the testimony of the witnesses referred to
with a great deal of care, and I do not find such a description given
by them as would enable the person skilled in the art of japanning

’ to make the patented bronze. My reason is, first, that the descrip-

tion in regard to applying the oil with a brush and paper does not
describe within a degree of accuracy the thickness or thinness of
the coat of oil. The witness used the word- “ very thin;” but that
is a comparative term, and what would be an extremely thin coat-
ing in ordinary phrase, as applied to japanning would mean a coat-
ing many times too thick to produce merchantable Tucker bronze.
There is a portion of the testimony of Mr. Angevine, in regard to
one process used on these spear-heads, which Iam not able to recon-
cile in a way to appear reasonable to my mind. He says, without
quoting his exact sonic that after these spear-heads were pol-
ished and oiled he placed them on a thin iron plate, the spear-heads
standing on their base, about two inches from the iron plate, which
was about an inch anda half thick, more or less, and which was
placed directly over the fire which heated the kiln. Iam a little
too fast in my description. He says that this thin sheet-iron plate

5—378

34 WILLIAM H. PLUMMER, ADM’R, &C., VS.

was placed over the thick iron plate which covered the fire, and when
that thin sheet-iron plate became red hot, or a portion of it as bi
as a ten-cent piece became red hot, that then the spear-heads, oile
as he has described them, were placed on this thin sheet-iron so
heated and allowed to remain about an hour, and were then finished.
Now, this witness has certainly made a mistake in this description,
for the reason that small pieces of iron like the spear-heads in ques-
tion, placed in such a heat as they must have received under such
circumstances, would in a very few moments have attained the heat
of the red-hot plate on which they were placed, and the inevitable
consequence of such heating would be to utterly destroy any oil
coating which might have been placed thereon. There is not the
slightest evidence that these spear-heads, which were oiled and col-
ored over the forge, had on .their surface when finished anything
more than a thin coating of linseed oil, which had been colored by
heat.
64 Q. 7. Have you had any communication with J. B. Sar-
gent, of New Haven, who has testified in this suit, in regard
to your invention described in the letters patent now in suit; and,
if so, what? |

A. I have had. I saw Mr. Sargent, at his factory in New Haven,
the last of September or the first of October of the year 1876, soon
after the decision of Judge Clifford in my suit against the Tucker
Manufacturing Company for their infringement of my bronze. My
business with him at that time was to effect a settlement with him
for his past infringement of my bronzing patent. Mr. Sargent at
that time said that he had not infringed my patent, for the reason
that his work or bronzing was done by the old japanning process,
which was a matter of common knowledge among everybody familiar
with the patent ; and when [ explained to him the nature of my in-
vention, and explained to him the grounds on which the decision of
Judge Clifford was based, he denied that the process he used resulted
in any oxidation of the iron, but was simply a thin coating of Japan
over a bright surface. The result of this interview was Mr. Sargent’s
denial of infringement and my affirmation that he did infringe.

Q. 8. Whether or not Mr. Sargent said that he had made goods
that were like Tucker bronze previous to the date of your invention,
or claimed to have anticipated in any way your process patent ?

A. Mr. Sargent distinctly claimed at that interview that my pro-
cess differed in no essential particular from the old and well-known
japanning process, and the only way that I had attained notoriety
and success was by doing the work nicer—I mean by “the work ”
the japanning—than was practiced by the trade before the date of
— patent. He did not intimate in the slightest degree that him-
self or any one in his employ had ever donea similar fizish on iron
which differed from the old japan process.

Q. 9. Were the originals of the two letters already in evidence an:
agreed to be true copies of letters written by J. B. Sargent, and put
in evidence in case of Tucker v. Burditt and Williams, except that
the copy of letter No. 2 is undated, received by you from Mr. Sar-
gent ?

A. They were.

ee a

—

SARGENT & COMPANY. 35

65 Cross-examined by Mr. MiTcHELL:

Cross-Q. 10. Do you recognize Defendant’s Exhibits Cancellers A?
and A® and B? and B? as having the finish described and claimed in
reissued letters patent No. 2356 ?

A. I don’t know whether they are or not. If they have been oiled
the oil has been rubbed off with such extreme thoroughness as to
make it difficult for me to determine from simply looking at them.

Cross-Q. 11. Ii your opinion, are the exhibits referred to in the
last question Tucker bronze or are they not?

A. I have given as intelligible an answer to your question as I am
able. It is not one to which I can answer simply ves or no.

Cross-Q. 12. Can you not tell by inspection whether an article is
Tucker bronze or not?

A. Not certainly ; when exhibits are made for the purposes of de-
ception, I cannot.

Cross-Q. 13. Can you say whether Defendant’s Exhibits Canceller
A! and Canceller B! are or are not Tucker bronze ?

A. I should say with a good deal of confidence that the Exhibit
A! was simply a brightened piece of iron colored by heat, and not
Tucker bronze. Exhibit Cancellef B' presents an appearance slightly
different from Canceller A', and I am not able to say whether it is
Tucker bronze or not. If there is any oil, linseed, or its equivalent
oil, on this exhibit I am not able to distinguish it.

Cross-Q. 14. Well, is B' Tucker bronze?

A. I have answered as intelligibly as I can already, and I say
about that as I said before, it is not a question which I can say yes
or no to.

Cross-Q. 15. Is or is not A? Tucker bronze ?

A. Same answer to this question as to the last.

Cross-Q. 16. Is or is not Canceller A* Tucker bronze?

A. Yes; I should call that a poor specimen of Tucker bronze. On
close inspection, I think I see oil mixed with the oxide—not a good

specimen by any means, and I am not sure that the character of
t

ie oil, on looking at it, would be linseed oil and come within the
patent. I only guess at it. ,
66° Cross-Q. 17. Is or is rot Canceller B® Tucker bronze?
A. I don’t know whether it is or not; if it is, it is a worth-
less specimen. ,

Cross-Q. 18. Is or is not Canceller B® Tucker bronze ?

A. May be a very poor specimen ; cannot answer yes or no.

Cross-Q. 19. If made in the way testified to by Mr. W. R. Sawyer
and Mr. Angevine, are they Tucker bronze?

A. I paid very little attention to that part of the testimony of
these witnesses, because I didn’t consider it of the slightest moment
t my case what sert sc exhibits of Tucker bronze they may make

4¥, or wl? sort of experiments they may conduct. My evidence
4 * bears upon what these witnesses actually did, or
. did, before the date of my bronzing patent here

Et. ta

ve ot ai as Langa i otk ete ty 4, TEE ee SOE ees Seen ee eRe ‘ :
a a Gonghe; s EE ope YL eS Nike ste: EP, Oe ; Dee ee os ao 7 et oe eee ea
: Ge oe ee -. 2 LMS Cae ee ros : 5 a 2 -. Sa. 4" hy ov ae: ee
” wh Wins: s5'4 ea ete hes PO ee Ce ee ee i a ee of ot ie Bi
h
3 x Oe

86 WILLIAM H. PLUMMER, ADM’R, &C., VS.

Cross-Q. 20. You heard the testimony of Mr. Sawyer and Mr.
Angevine, did you not, when it was given ?

A. I heard a portion of it, and saw the other portion of it in writing.

Cross-Q. 21. peer) if Cancellers A? and B? and A® and B® were
made as described by Mr. Sawyer and Angevine, they are Tucker
bronze, are they not?

A. I can only say there were so much testimony given by those
gentlemen that was irrelevant that I didn’t think it worth while to
examine any more of it than related to this case. What they swore
they did before date of this invention or patent I examined with a
great deal of care and interest, but 1 consider this superabundance
of exhibits made for the purposes of this case were superflous and
a waste of time, and for that reason didn’t think it worth while to
go into it. :

Cross-Q. 22. Do you mean by your last answer that you do not
know how Mr. Sawyer and Mr. Angevine testified that Cancellers
A? and A® and B® and B* were made and finished ?

A. I do mean to say just that; I don’t mean to say that it was
not stated in my presence, or that I might not have heard some-
thing about them; but, knowing.that testimony of that character
would have no important bearing upon this case, I did not charge
my mind with it, and can’t state at this moment more definitely

than I have stated their testimony on that point.
67 Cross-Q. 23. You were present assisting your counsel dur-
ing the taking of Mr. Sawyer’s and Mr. Angevine’s testimony,
and were in constant consultation with your counsel during their
cross-examination by your counsel, were you not?

A. I was not present at the direct examination of Mr. Sawyer or
Mr. Angevine, but my counsel read over to me, before coming to
the office of the examiner, portionsof Mr. Angevine's direct exaini-
nation, and after full consultation, Mr. Loomis and myself concluded
that it was not worth while to cross-examine on Mr. Angevine’s tes-
timony, or at any length on either; but since that time my counsel
and myself have discussed the important points that I have stated
of the testimony of these two witnesses. anand

Cross-Q. 24. Did you not understand Mr. Sawyer to say, and Mr.
Angevine to corroborate him in saying, that Cancellers A? and A?
and B* and B® were made and finished in the same way as check-
cancellers were made and finished at Smith’s in Westfield before the
war of the rebellion ?

A. Of course I understood in a general way the significance of
these exhibits put in by these witnesses in question, that they were
put in for the purpose of showing priority of use of this process be-
fore the date of the patent in question; but, as I said before, I didn’t
consider that part of the testimony of the slightest importance, and
did not charge my mind with precisely what was said about them.

Cross-Q. 25. Pardon me for saying that you were not asked what
portion of the testimony referred to was important, nor whether
yeu charged your mind with precisely what was said. I simply
asked you whether you did not understand the witnesses to say that
the exhibits referred to in the last question were made and finished

ER ha Sa ea a ame sh Pe ae Re Ge ND ee ane CN OSE Oe LEME Be ST One Saeed
Cage an 2 Fg i : a ee ie Paty Us ees OMe py er ee ’ bie aes ben ¥ ET Pe een oe OS
pS oak AN a fete ty aed alk, UP ies Ae 5 ha ae SE Ns os BS Mey te ed lS i te es? iB i 5 és Sat
rs >

_ SARGENT & COMPANY. 37
in the saine way as check-cancellers were made and finished at
Smith’s in Westfield, before the war of the rebellion? Now, can
you not answer that question?
...A. I think I have said to you, in answer to a former interroga-
tory, that I could not, and I repeat that answer now.

Choa, 26. What did you understand Exhibits A? and A? and
B? and B® were intended to represent?

A. That those were done by the witnesses as specimens of

68 color they produced on goods before the date of my patent.

I had no trouble about understanding the signifieance. of
those exhibits at any time; I only meant to say, in former answers,
that I don’t remember specifically what they said about them, or
how they testified. |

(Counsel for defendant states that he will resume the cross-ex-
amination upon the foregoing subject-matter when the testimony
of Messrs. Sawyer and Angevine is present, it being now in the
_ hands of the printer.)

Cross-Q. 27. In your opinion, is Defendant’s Exhibit Ruif Art Ex-
hibit Tucker bronze ?

(Objected to.)

A. I should say it was a very good specimen.
Cross-Q. 28. Within letters patent No. 2356?

(Objected to.)

A. Undoubtedly.
Cross-Q. 29. And No. 2355?

(Objected to.)

Cross-Q. 30. Is Defendant’s Exhibit Art Casting No. 1 within re-
issued letters patent No. 2356, and finished by the process described
in No. 2355?

(Objected to.)

A. Undoubtedly this is Tucker bronze.

Cross-Q. 31. And is the same true of Defendant’s. Exhibit Art
Casting No. 2?

A. Yes.

Cross-Q. 32. And is the same true of Defendant’s Exhibit Art
Casting No. 37

A. I should say it was; the portions that appear to the eye are
not covered with the bronze powder. I have no doubt the surface
under the bronze powder is of the same character, but am not
absolutely certain.

Cross-Q. 33. And is the same true of Defendant’s Exhibit [?

A. Yes.

reg 34. And is the same true of Defendant’s Exhibit L?

A. Yes. |

helen met. ¢ = " ~~ n sation
pebanitaiapdiuiinatdtiimitaeebiniia a is ens labtits sc heablaaistn.oon SeecaeaeaamnenecuaeN
: ay tA ’ ee ‘

Pits) . ile palin te U4 »
PEA AE NAAT LYLE NEES AIR) Al Sata AB 'e ea73

anime ewes ep Aippnnsa renee tiene mapas tpemspinrrenntnit aia,

38 WILLIAM H. PLUMMER, ADM’R, &C., VS.

Cross-Q. 35. Is the same true of Defendant’s Exhibit Match-box ?
(The same being two match-boxes separtely tagged.)
69 Yes.
Cross-Q. 36. Is the same true of Defendant’s Exhibit G, H,
and H??

A. Yes.

Cross-Q. 37. And the same is true of Defendant’s Exhibit J, J?, sail
L, these, however, having had a further finish by tipping their ridges
with bronze powder ?

A. Yes; all that you have called my attention to in this question
have been through the Tucker process, in my opinion.

Cross-Q. 38. Is the same true of the six central knobs of Defendant’s
Exhibit A B?

A. Yes; although ihese seem to be a little coarser specimens.

Cross-Q. 39. Then, if I understand you, all the exhibits to which
your attention has been called since and including cross-Q. 27 con-
tain an exhibit both of the improvements (if they can be separated)
described in your two patents in suit?

(Each of the questions objected to, from the cross-Q. 31 down to
and including the above interrogatory, as incompetent, irrelevant,
and immaterial.)

A. Yes.
Cross-Q. 40. The same is true of Defendant’s Exhibit C D, is it not,

so fur as the six central knobs are concerned ?
(Objected to as above.)

A. These seem to be poor specimens of black knobs, neither bronze
in color nor good black. I have no doubt that the scale has been
removed, and these knobs are so treated that they contain the ele-
ments which I claim as constituting Tucker bronze; but the result
of such treatment is such that no valuable end has been attained
over the old japan process, as far as the appearance of the goods go.
That is about all I can say in relation to those exhibits in answer to
that question.

Cross-Q. 41. And E F are also within your patents in suit, are they
not—I mean the six middle knobs? I call your attention especially
to that part of your patent which says that the process may be re-
peated until a black color is produced, the fact being that C D repre-
sents the repetition of the process applied to A B, and E F represents
still another repetition of this same process.

70 (Same objection as before.)

A. Assuming that these knobs had the scale taken off, and were
then treated to a thin coating of oil, as described in the patent, as
they appear to be—some of them—and then heated until the oil
and the color of the iron appeared simultaneously, and then still
further treated with a thin coat of oil, and re-treated to the color of
black, as appears on these darkest-colored knobs, I consider would
=e the patented process and producing the patented re-
suit.

SARGENT & COMPANY. | 39

Cross-Q. 42. You say, referring to the watch-stand finished by
Brocksieper for Ruff (I refer to your reply to Q. 5), that Mr. Ruff
says, “that, after brushing the casting with this iron broom-brush,
Mr. Brocksieper brought, in a cup, some linseed oil without admix-
ture of spirits of turpentine or any other dilutant.”. Where does Mr.
Ruff say that the linseed oil was undiluted ? |

A. I don’t mean to be understood as saying that Mr. Ruff said
any such thing as that; but he said it was linseed oil, if I remember
rightly; that of course inferred that there was nothing with it.

Cross-Q. 43. Do not your patents prescribe the use of linseed oil,
and do they anywhere instruct the reader to dilute that linseed oil ?

A. The patent describes linseed oil to be used pure and simple,
either raw or boiled. They do notsay anything about spirits of tur-
pentine or any other dilutant being necessary.

Cross-Q. 44. Then vou cannot regard the fact that Mr. Ruff fails
to refer to any dilutant as in anyway material, can you?

A. I think so, in connection with his operation in regard to that
exhibit. It is very material, as it is the only office of spirits of tur-
pentine, when used with oil or varnish, to enuble the user to obtain
a thin coating with less trouble than he would without the spirits or
any other dilutant; and if Mr. Ruff had testified that he had diluted
his oil with three or four parts spirits of turpentine, more or less, to
one of oil, he would have got on a very much thinner coat by the
process he describes as using than he did.

~ Cross-Q. 45. You do not appear to understand me. Your
71 atents require the use of linseed oil, or its equivalent. Mr.
_ Ruff says Brocksieper used linseed oil; does he not then say

that Brocksieper used the material which your patent prescribes ?

A. Certainly. ,

Cross-Q. 46. If, as would appear from Int. 38 and its answer, of
Mr. Ruff’s deposition, Art Castings No. 1 and No. 2 were bronzed by
the same process as the watch-stand in question, you would have
no doubt of its being what you now call Tucker bronze, would you?

A. Not the slightest.

Cross-Q. 47. You find nothing in Mr. Ruff's testimony to indicate
that the castings were not smoothed in the sense of having the scale
removed by tumbling or otherwise before the brush was used, do
you?

A. First place, Mr. Ruff said nothing about tumbled casting ; in
the next place, an iron wire broom wouldn’t have been a suitable
tool at all to have treated a tumbled smooth casting with—it was
not made for that purpose; and, in the third place, it would be next
to impossible to tumble a delicate casting, such as he has described,
without either breaking or destrying its beauty of configuration. I
took it for granted he described the process as he a it.

Cross-Q. 48. I so understood also; your reply to Int. 5 also contains
this language: “ Mr. Ruff also testifies that after witnessing this ex-
periment of Mr. Brocksieper’s (the watch-stand) he did a cast-iron
sewing-bird substantialy in the same way in which he had seen Mr.
Brocksieper do the watch-stand, with the addition of chasing the
work, etc.” Now, Mr. Ruff in describing bow he made the sewing-

)
CREE LODE NSARM SERIE, SARS abi Pu a EM AE is Ce SI scl acne oi ha
. Te, Ri sige eee ee 5
4
nn -“ , BR oa
a. ~ ~ - ~ ~e a —— ~ ae omovies
- mya rye per tA rent
ae Rag wae S ne GSB nie Bree eS ~ —— x Seeeewose
ae abt = “ai re vee REST uy aS ~~ _—
phx

believe, entirely irrelevant to the case.

he regards as irrelevant to this case.

Sapte Ee

42 WILLIAM H. PLUMMER, ADM’R, &C., VS.

for the purpose of ornamentation ; his varnish was applied after the
iron had become cold. I don’t claim that as a Tucker process at all,
for the reason that the oil-varnish was not reheated.

Cross-Q. 63. Then there is some sense in applying oil or oil-varnish
to scythes or shovels apart from producing the operation of temper-
ing, 1s there not?

A. No, not the slightest if you are going to burn your oil
75 or varnish all off, and leave the iron as it was before, as Mr.
Brocksieper has described it.

Cross-Q. 64. Where has Mr. Brockseiper described the burning-
off of the oil?

A. In his description of the shovel process, where he describes
the change of color which took place on the iron under heat after
being oiled, to wit, the dark blue color of a portion of the shovel.

Cross-Q. 65. The oil would burn off in your process if the heat
became too great on a particular portion of the article heated, would
it not?

A. Yes, but in this case the process that Mr. Brocksieper has de-
scribed differs essentially from my patent process, putting aside the
kind of oil that he uses, in the fact that in this shovel process a
substantial coat was placed on the shovel before submitting the
same to heat, and that the only effect of heat on such a coating of
oil, provided it had been by linseed oil, would have been to make
it perfectly black, before the dark blue color which he describes the
operator as watching for should make it appearance. Mr. Brock-
sieper has described pure and simple the proper and weil-known
process for treating shovels tipped with steel for the purposes of
temper.

Cross-Q. 66. In reply to sixth interrogatory you said, “I have ex-
amined the testimony of the witnesses referred to (Sawyer and
Angevine) with a great deal of care.” Do you still adhere to that
statement ?

A. I do. :

Cross-Q. 67. Then will you tell me whether exhibits Canceller A?,
B?, A*, B® are Tucker bronze, if they were finished in the way testi-
tied to by those witnesses? é

A. I baven’t thought it advisable to give that part of their testi-
mony any considering whatever. When I testified that I had ex-
amined their testimony very carefully I meant that part of it which
I considered essential to this case, to wit, what the witnesses actually
did before the date of my invention. Whether these spear-heads
which they have put in for the purpose of illustration are Tucker

bronze or not hasn’t to me the slightest interest, as I view the

76 matter. In a over that testimony, or in having it read

over by my counsel to me, I found the great mass of it, as I

(Counsel for defendant states—

ist. That he did not ask the witness what part of the testimony

SARGENT & COMPANY. 43

2d. He did not ask the witness what part of the testimony has to
him the slightest interest, as he views the matter.

3d. Whether the witness thought it advisable to give that part of
the testimony any consideration whatever, and in view of the mani-
fest interest of the witness he declines to cross-examine him further
as an expert.)

(Counsel for complainant states that if any answer of any witness
is regarded by counsel for defendant as irresponsive, or as otherwise
objectionable, the usual remedy of objection is open to him.)

HIRAM TUCKER.

Sworn to this sixteenth day of April, 1881, before me—
JOHN B. MILLS,

Special Examiner.

anne adjourned until Monday, April 18, 1881, at Boston, at
eleven o'clock a. m.

Boston, April 18, 1881.
Examination resumed. Counsel present as before.

Examination adjourned to Tuesday, April 19, at 9.15 a. mn.

Boston, April 19, 1881.
Examination resumed. Counsel present as before.

Hrram TucKERr recalled:

Question 1. If you have procured any specimens of Tucker bronze,
showing the effect of time and of wear, alee produce the same.
Answer. I have; I hereby rroduce one lamp complete and
77 part of another; these lamps have been in use from fourteen
to fifteen years; the difference in color of these two lamps is
owing partly to the difference in character of oil used for the purpose
of producing the bronze, the amount of heat they were submitted to,
and the difference of the smoothness of surfaces. The grayish ap-
pearance of the ground-work on the incomplete lamp, whic 1 repre-
sents the acorn pattern, as we call it, is owing to a very thin pi ment,
composed of flake white, verdigris green, and linseed oil, which, after
being applied very thinly with a brush, was rubbed off with a rag
or tissue-paper, and is intended to represent the oxide that appears
on the ground-work of real bronze which are in the rear of salient
surfaces.
Q. 2. By whom were these exhibits, Tacker Lamp No. 1 and
Tucker Lamp No. 2, made; and when and where have they been
since they were made; and to what wear have they been subjected ?

i RTE puts in evidence Complainant’s Exhibit Tucker
Lamp No. 1, J. B. M., special examiner, and Complainant’s Exhibit
Tucker Lamp No. 2, J. B. M., special examiner.)

A. These lamps were made by the Tucker Manufacturing Com-
‘pany while I was superintendent, done under my supervision ; and

44 WILLIAM H. PLUMMER, ADM’R, &C., VS.

lamp No. 1 was given by me as a present to my brother, Edward O.
Tucker, and to my knowledge has been used by him as a kerosene-
oil lamp certainly as many as fourteen years; lamp No. 2 was given
as a present to Mrs. Mary H. Green, my sister-in-law, and has been
in use as a kerosene-lamp for about the same time as lamp No. 1 has
been used by my brother. :

Q. 3. Please state what has been your experience with reference
to the art of japanning.

‘A. I was taught the art of japanning about forty years (40 years)
ago, in Meriden, Conn.; about thirty-odd years ago I was engaged
in a manufacture which required the best skill of japanners. It was
in the manufacturer of mirror marble chimney-pieces, which were
composed of a frame-work of highly ornamental cast-iron and panels

of plate glass. As this cast-iron work was made to represent
78 black marble as near as possible, the japanning had to be

done with great care and skill. I found the japan so obscured
the fine lines of the castings as to be very objectionable, and it was
at that time that I first began to experiment with a view to making
a better finish for ornamental cast-iron work. I will say here that
cast-iron was the ftinest-flowing metal, when put into moulds
[in] the form of castings, known to the arts; but, for the want of a
suitable finish, it had never been used for work such as chandeliers,
lamps, and fine builders’ hardware was: required. At the time re-
ferred to, to wit, when I was engaged in manufacturing these chim-
ney-plieces, | made a long series of experiments with thin coatings
of japan in our regular japan oven for the. purpose of discovering
an improved finish, but without valuable ‘result until I had con-
structed a small oven where I could obtain a much higher degree
of heat, and where | began to apply extremely thin coatings of a
solution of ivory black and boiled linseed oil of commeree. I sue-
ceeded in producing a fine black coating by putting on this black
solution ina thin coating and then rubbing off the same with a
common shoe-brush thoroughly. In pursuing these experiments |
noticed on the prominent points of an ornamental casting, which
had been made bright before | began to treat it, which points had
been rubbed off more thoroughly than the other parts of the cast-
lug, Slight indications of a bronze color. This discovery led me to
think it might be possible, by leaving out

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Aper_scotus_1886_121%3A0. Public record. Not legal advice.
