# Record and brief — The Northwestern Fertilizing Company, Plaintiff in Error, vs. The Village of Hyde Park, Chauncey M. Cady, W. E. Hale, A. D. Waldron, L. G. Fisher, E. G. Clarke, M. Doyle, J. M. Barney, L. Bradner, and H. Vanderbilt, Trustees of Said Village. 1878: V

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Aper_scotus_1878_5%3A0

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Record and brief
- **Published:** January 1, 1878

## Text

7 Cla f 019
BA. 7.1040

TRANSCRIPT OF RECORD.

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.

No. Mir FZ S

THE NORTHWESTERN FERTILIZING COMPANY, PLAINTIFF
IN ERROR,

V8.

THE VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK, CHAUNCEY M. CADY, W.-E.
HALE, A. D. WALDRON, L. G. FISHER, E. G. CLARKE, M.
DOYLE, J. M. BARNEY, L. BRADNER, AND H. VANDERBILT,
TRUSTEES OF SALD VILLAGE.

IN ERROR TO THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF ILLINOIS.

FILED NOVEMBER 27, 1874.

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.
No. 245.

THE NORTHWESTERN FERTILIZING COMPANY, PLAINTIFF
IN ERROR,

VS.

THE VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK, CHAUNCEY M. CADY, W. E.
HALE, A. D. WALDRON, L. G. FISHER, E. G. CLARKE, M.
DOYLE, J. M. BARNEY, L. BRADNER, AND H. VANDERBILT,
TRUSTEES OF SAID VILLAGE.

IN ERROR TO THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF ILLINOIS.

Bill of complaint

Exhibit A

BROWEE 0000 cc cccs coccces cco. c0ce cncces onccce seceee oneces sees osee sees °
Supplemental answer

Bill of exceptions

Clerk’s certificate

Opinion of supreme court

Decree of supreme court

Clerk’s certificate

Assignment of errors

Petition for writ of error

Writ of error

SNE ho.nc cons cccdcs 06004000 060s ends 00bs bandas eehedeeanee .

ali

N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL. 1

a At a supreme court begun and held at Ottawa, on Tuesday
the ninth day of September, in the year of our Lord one thou-
sand eight hundred and seventy-three, within and for the northern grand
division of the State of Lllinois :
Present: Sidney Breese, chief-justice ; Pinkney H. Walker, justice;
John M. Scott, justice; W. K. McAllister, justice ; Benjamin R. Sheldon,
justice; Johu Scholfield, justice; Alfred M. Craig, justice.

Appeal from the circuit court of Cook County.

THE NORTHWESTERN FERTILIZING COMPANY
v8. No. 457.
THE VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK.

b Be it remembered that heretofore, to wit, on the tenth day of

September, in the year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred
seventy-three, came the Northwestern Fertilizing Company, appellant
herein, by Sweat and Herrick, its attorneys, and filed in the supreme

_ court its certain transcript of record and proceedings in the circuit

court of Cook County, State of Illinois; which is in the words and figures
following, to wit:

c STATE OF ILLINOIS,
Cook County :

Uv

THE NORTWESTERN FERTILIZING re
THE VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK.

It is hereby stipulated that the following contains a true copy of the
record in the above cause, so far as the same becomes material for its
consideration by the appellate court.

LEONARD SWETT,
Solicitor for Complainant.
CHAS. HITCHCOUK,
Solicitor for Respondents.
CHICAGO, August, 1873.

1 Be it remembered that heretofore, to wit, on the 11th day of

January, A. D. 1873, the Northwestern Fertilizing Company, by
Bentley, Swett & Quigg, its solicitors, filed in said court its certain bill
of complaint, in the words and figures following, to wit:

In the circuit court, Januar; term, A. D. 1873.

STATE OF ILLINOIS,
Cook County:

To the honorable judges of the circuit court of Cook County, in chan-
cery sitting.

The Northwestern Fertilizing Company, a corporation created by
and organized under, the laws of the State of Illinois, and located and
transacting business in Cook County, in said State, brings this its bill
of complaint against the village of Hyde Park, a municipal corpora-
tion, also created by and organized under the laws of the State of Lli-
nois, and C. M. Cady, a trustee and president of the board of trustees

REc. 245—1

Fes a ee ee

2 N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL.

of said village, and W. E. Hale, A. D. Waldron, S. G. Fisher, E. G.
Clarke, M. Doyle, J. F. Barney, L. Bradner, jr., and H. Vanderbilt,
trustees of said village.

Whereupon the complainant savs:

SUMMARY OF THE CHARTER.—On the eighth day of March, A. D.
1867, an act was passed by the legislature of the State of Illinois, and
became a law, by which, among other things, Christian Wahl, Louis
Wahl, and John A. Lighthall, and their successors, associates, and

assigns, were constituted and appointed a body corporate and
2 politic, with power of continued succession, for the term of fifty

years, by the name of the Northwestern Fertilizing Company, and
empowered by that name to contract and be contracted with, sue and
be sued as a natural person, to have and use a common seal, and the
right to purchase and hold sufficient real-estate for the free enjoyment
ot all the privileges granted, and to make by-laws and rules for the gov-
ernment of said corporation.

The act also provided that the capital stock of the company should be
fifty thousand dollars, with power to increase the same to any sum not
exceeding two hundred and fifty thousand.

It also provided that the incorporators named might, any time after
the passage of the act, organize said company upon stock being sub-
scribed to the amount of fifty thousand dollars, issue certificates, and
elect officers created by the by-laws, and that said officers should hold
their offices for the period prescribed.

CHARACTER OF THE WORKS.—The corporation was also authorized
and empowered to establish and maintain chemical and other works at
the place designated, for the purpose of manufacturing and converting
dead animals and other animal matter into an agricultaral fertilizer and
other chemical products, by means of chemical, mechanical, and other
processes.

The charter also provided that said chemical works should be located
in Cook County, Illinois, south of the dividing-line between townships
thirty-seven and thirty-eight, and that the corporation might maintain

depots in the city of Chicago, in said county, for the purpose of
3 receiving and carrying off any and all offal, dead animals, and ani-

mal matter which it might buy or own, or which might be deliv-
ered to it by the city authorities and other persons, and that the act
creating these corporate rights and privileges should take effect and be
in force from and after its passage.

THE SLAUGHTERING AND THE OFFAL.—The complainant craves leave
to refer to the said act of incorporation as a part of this its bill of com-
plaint, with the same benefit as if it had been herein set forth at length.
A copy of the said act is hereunto attached, marked “ Exhibit A.”

The complainant would also say that since the introduction of rail-
road transportation to the Atlantic cities and the region east of the Al-
leghanies, the city of Chicago has been rapidly becoming, and has now
become, in reference to the slaughtering and packing of animals for
human consumption, the largest market in the world. It receives more
largely than any other city the snrplus productions of animals from
Minnesota to the Rio Grande, and west to the Rocky Mountains. Since
1850 the rapid growth and development of the country west, northwest,
and southwest has increased this business with marvelous rapidity.

The age me of animals slaughtered in Chicago between Jan. 1, 1872,
and Jan. 1, 1873, the complainant is informed by the official Union
Stock Yards reports, and believes, is as follows:

N. W. FERTILIZING CoO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL. 3

Hogs alaughtered .. 2... coc cc sccccc ces ccevcese iSiect nn 1, 417, 029
Cattle - ees cou dbs un - hee oe 500060 beeG renee 174, 050
Sheep DV gee ee eee as aes 6 ddneeneee ep rE 165, 099
1, 756, 178
4 The amount of offal and blood which the slaughtering of these
animals produces borders on the horrible.
ZO CREGMS-ONeOE 1B. 2. 0c cecenc cacccese+svetuaben 647,500 gallons.
Hogs os o 00608 ces neewun: SkOSepes enehes 1, 500, 000 “
Sheep DL yeeetr ine tne eeen sae ae eee 58, 333 “
i eh ad eae eerie oe ecseccncs ae
Cattle-tank offal .......... ésmee hha ko ceeeene 4,675 tons.
Hog RD ge nesee raed 4046eun been ee 15,000 *
ee SF libs ones cannbswakeeesaea eee 1,500 *
BOGE a ccncecctsatttenssehnapesnnoeaue 21,175 tons.

The offal included in the above statement is the heads, livers, lungs,
lights, entrails, and other trimmings of the animal. These parts, as
soon as separated, are rendered in tanks at the slaughter-houses, by the
application of steam to extract the grease, and the residuum is ealled
tank-offal. The blood is not utilized by the packers. This gives as a
refuse or discharge from the packing-houses 21,175 tons of tank-offal
and 2,205,833 gallons of blood every year, consisting of materials which,
until recently, considered in such immense quantities, were valueless,
and in reference to which, as yet, the only object of the packers is to
get rid of it.

This business, as complainant is informed and believes, employs di-
rectly in slaughtering and handling the animals in the city and at the
Union Stock Yards, about three miles therefrom, some five thousand
men; about twenty thousand are engaged in industries dependent upon
it; and it supports in and around Chicago not less than 100,000 people.

It is the largest interest in the city.

5 LOCAL DIFFICULTIES.—AsS bearing upon the question of public
policy and necessity in construing its act of incorporation, the
complainant also would show that there are local difficulties attending
the disposal of this offal in Chicago, growing out of its geographical .
and topographical location. At St. Louis, Council Bluffs, Dubuque,
Burlington, Peoria, Cincinnati, in the West; and Allentown, Gordons-
ville, Philadelphia, Baltimore, and Richmond, in the East; all have
large and rapidly-flowing rivers, and by the location of their slaughter-
houses upon the margins of such rivers, below the city, the difficulty is
at once solved. New York and Boston have the ocean, whose waters
are too vast to be corrupted, and tend to purify whatever they receive.
Chicago is absolutely without natural drainage.

The difficulty here is also enhanced by the suddenness with which
this material is produced and accumulates. The packing-season com-
mences the lst of November and ends the first day of March. Dur-
ing that time, of hogs alone, about 12,000 are slaughtered daily.
This, with the other slaughtering during the packing-season, produces,
every working-day between the first of November and the first day of
March, substantially 13533 tons of tank-offal and 14,697,3, gallons of
blood. Thus the sacrifice at the great Temple’s dedication was little
more than a common day’s work of our constant sacrifice to the re-
morseless appetites of modern times.

a 5 Pe ee a

4 N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL.

It is self-evident that this material cannot be deposited upon the sur-
face of the ground to decay in the sun. It is so enormous and bulky
it cannot be buried, and even if it could, the earth would not hold the

noxious gases it would generate. It cannot be cast into the Chi-
6 cago River or the lake, and nothing remains but to convert it

into agricultural fertilizers and other chemicals, thus utilizing
and consuming it, or to drive the packing-interest from the city.

The history of the difficulties heretofore enumerated demonstrate this
conclusion.

GROWTH OF THE PACKING BUSINESS.—In the infancy of this busi-
ness, the quantity, being small, was buried and otherwise properly dis-
pused of with ease, but in time the business and the amount ot offal
increased, until neither the water nor the earth could hide it.

The following is a summary, showing the growth of the packing busi-
ness in Chicago:

Cattle slaughtered for city consumption and packed within the last sixteen

years.
i iiibired wikhcunidceds | eos e 157, 107
hai hiatal pia RE ERS Pane Eres eer 90, 596
Tih delintipiaiinn 74,006 | 1866.......... iinet 130, 454
Sa eee 54,601 | 1867 ........... a
ee ee» 51,631 | 1868...... k eieaeeee ais 108, 547
Se Et I beens on curing weenie 108, 385
a eee $0 twa hae EE 7 EE ha sihsin-nin ems Oxmeenes 141, 255
DEE Bill for injunction.
Vanderbilt, A. D. Waldron, Michael Doyle,
and J. F. Barney, trustees of the village |
Hyde Park, and the village of Hyde Park.

And the defendants, Chauncey M. Cady, William E. Hale, L. G.
Fisher, E. G. Clark, L. Bradner, jr., H. Vanderbilt, A. D. Waldron,
Michael Doyle, and J. F. Bai ney, trustees of the village of Hyde Park,
now come, and by leave of the court, for supplemental answer to the
bill for injunction in this cause filed, say that on the 13th day of Feb-
ruary, 1873, last past, and after the filing of defendants’ answer in this
cause, the following amendments were duly made to chapter 2 of the

Revised Ordinances of the Village of Hyde Park:
55 Be it ordained by the president and board of trustees of the
village of Hyde Park, as follows, to wit:

SECTION 11. All establishments, places, or premises within the village
of Hyde Park so negligently conducted, managed, or used as to create
such offensive smells as to taint the air and render it unwholesome or
disagreeable to the public, or to the inhabitants of said village, are
hereby severally declared to be a nuisance, and every person or corpo-
ration who shall create or aid or assist in creating such nuisance, shall
be liable to a fine of not less than 850 and not exceeding $200, and to a
like fine for each twenty-four hours such nuisance shall be continued
and remain unabated.

SEc. 12. Any person or corporation engaged in the business of con-
verting dead animals or other animal matter into an agricultural fertil-
izer, or into other products within the limits of said village of Hyde
Park, and who or which shall so negligently conduct, or manage, or
aid or assist in so conducting or managing such business as to create
such nuisance as is described in section 11 of this ordinance, shall be
liable to a fine of not less than fifty and not exceeding two hundred
dollars, and to a like fine for each twenty-four hours such business shall
be in such manner continued by the procurement, aid, or assistance of
such person or corporation.

SEc. 13. No person or persons, or corporation, engaged in rendering,
reducing, or manufacturing animal matter or offal into an agricultaral
fertilizer or other product, shall accumulate at any one place within the
jurisdiction of said village, matter or offal exceeding one hundred tons
or of blood exceeding one thousand gallons. Any person or corpora-
tion who or which shall vivlate this section shall be deemed guilty of

28 N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL.

maintaining a nuisance, and, upon conviction thereof, shall be
56 . fined in a sum not less than fifty and not more than two hundred
dollars.

SEc. 14. Any person or persons who, or corporation which, shall cause
animal matter or offal to be brought into the village of Hyde Park for
the purpose of manufacturing the same into a fertilizer or other product,
or who shall aid or assist therein, shall transport the same in close,
tight, and covered vars or boxes, and shall deposit the same in close,
tight, and covered bins, so that no offensive or unwholesome odor shail
escape therefrom. Any person who shall violate this section shall be
subject to a fine of not less than fifty and not more than two hundred
dollars for each offense.

SEc. 15. Any person or persons, or corporations, engaged in render-
ing, reducing, or manufacturing animal matter or offal into a fertilizer
or other product, who or which shall deposit within the limits of Hyde
Park any such matter or offal in a putrid or offensive condition, or who
or which shall aid or assist therein, shall be deemed guilty of creat-
ing a nuisance, and, upon conviction thereof, shall be fined in a sum
not less than $50 and not more than $200,

SEc. 16. Any person or persons, or corporation, engaged in rendering,
reducing, or manufacturing animal matter or offal into a fertilizer or
other product, who or which shall permit or suffer any animal matter
or offal to remain on premises occupied or used by him, or them, or it,
within the limits of the village of Hyde Park for a longer period than
48 hours before the actual reduction or manufacture thereof, shall be
deemed guilty of maintaining a nuisance, and,on conviction thereof, shall
be subject to a fine of not less than $50 and not exceeding $200, and to
a like fine for every day he, she, or they shall fail to abate such nuis-

ance.
o7 Sec. 17. Every person or corporation engaged in manufactur’

ing animal matter or oftal into a fertilizer or other product with-
in the limits of the village of Hyde Park shall, before the reduction
thereof, thoroughly deodorize the same by the application of salt, acid,
or other chemicals, so that the same shall not be offensive. Any person
who shall violate this section of the ordinance shall be subject to a fine
of not less than $50 and not more than $200.

SEc. 18. Any person or corporation who or which shall operate or
use, or be employed in any factory or other place for the reduction,
rendering, or manufacturing of animal matter or offal into a fertilizer or
other product between the Ist day of April and the Ist day of Novem-
ber, within the limits of the village of Hyde Park, shall be guilty of
maintaining a nuisanee, and, on conviction thereof, shall be subject to
a fine of not less than $50 and not more than $200, and to a like fine
tor every day he, she, or they shall fail to abate such nuisance.

SEC. 19. Nothing contained in this ordinance shall be construed so
as to repeal any existing ordinance of the village of Hyde Park relating
to nuisances or the abatement thereof.

All which matters and things these defendants are ready and willing
to aver, ma’ntain, and prove, as this honorable court shall direct ; and
humbly pray to be hence dismissed, with their reasonable costs and
charges in this behalf most wrongfully sustained.

HITCHCOCK, DUPEE & EVARTS,
AND SIDNEY SMITH,
Defendants’ Solrs.

But said supplemental answer not to affect the injunction heretofore
allowed.

at AO RIE GRIN | SORT Sra

N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL. 29

58 And after hearing counsel for the respective parties, the hearing

of motion filed by defendants to modify the injunction in the
papers now filed by defendants, and upon such papers as may in oppo-
sition thereto be filed by complainant, is set for March 6th next.

And thereupon afterwards, to wit, on the sixth and nineteenth days
of March, A. D. 1873, the following proceedings were had aud entered
of record in said cause, to wit:

THE NORTHWESTERN FERTILIZING Co. )
v. Bill.
C. M. CADY:-ET AL. ¢

This day came the complainants by Leonard Swett, esq., one of their
solicitors, and the defendants by Messrs. Hitchcock & Smith, their so-
licitors; and thereupon came on to be heard the motion of the defend-
ants for the modification of the injunction heretofore granted in said
cause, which was heard on bill, answer, affidavits, and on certain affi-
davits filed in the case of Gaughan v. The Northwestern Fertilizing
Company, and read pursuant to stipulation. The court after hearing the
argument of counsel, and not being now fully advised in the premises,
doth take said motion under advisement.

THE NORTHWESTERN FERTILIZING COMPANY } 7
v. “ 5d45 857. Bill.
C. M. CaADY ET AL.

This day came again the said parties by their respective solicitors.
And thereupon the court having now on this day carefully considered
the motion of said defendants heretofore made in said cause, and being
now fully advised in the premises, doth overrule the motion of said de-
fendants, to wit, to modify the injunction heretofore granted in said
cause.

And on motion and by agreement of counsel, it is ordered that
59 the order heretofore entered setting said cause for hearing for
the 2ith day of March next, be, and it hereby is, set aside.

And that said cause be, and it hereby is, set for hearing for the 26th
day of March, instant.

And afterwards, to wit, on the Ist and 4th days of April, A. D. 1873,
the following among other proceedings were bad and entered of record
in said court, to wit:

THE NORTHWESTERN FERTILIZING COMPANY }
Us.
C. M. Capy, W. E. HALE, A. D. WALDRON, L.
G. Fisher, E. G. Clark, M. Doyle, J. F. Barney, > Bill.
L. Bradner, jr., and H. Vanderbelt, trustees of |
the village of Hyde Park, and Village of Hyde
Park.

On motion and by consent of counsel, leave is hereby granted said
defendants C. M. Cady, William E. Hale, L. G. Fisher, E..G. Clark, L.
Bradner, jr., and H. Vanderbelt, part of the above-named defendants,
to amend their answer filed January 30th, 1873, instanter.

30 N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL.

THE NORTHWESTERN FERTILIZING COMPANY )

v8.

C. M. Capy, W. E. HALE, A. D. WALDRON, L.
G. Fisher, E. G. Clark, M. Doyle, J. T. Barney, } 5545 857. Bill.
L. Bradner, jr., and H. Vanderbelt, trustees
of the village of Hyde Park, and Village of
Hyde Park.

60 This day came said parties by their respective solicitors, and

thereupon this cause came on to be heard upon the bill, answers,
and proofs adduced in open court. The court, after hearing the evidence
and arguments of counsel, and being fully advised in the premises, doth
find that the complainant is not entitled to the relief prayed for in its
said bill of complaint.

Whereupon it is ordered by the court that the complainant’s bill of
complaint be, and it hereby is, dismissed out of this court, at complain-
ant’s costs, for want of equity.

To all of which the complainant, by its solicitors now here, excepts, and
prays an appeal to the supreme court of the State of Lllinois, which is
granted on condition that said complainant doth within twenty days
from date execute and file an appeal-bond in said cause, in the penal sum
of five thousand dollars, (35,000,) with security thereto, to be approved
by the court.

And it is further ordered that said complainant be allowed thirty
days from date in which to prepare and file a certificate of evidence in
said cause.

It is hereby stipulated that all the conditions of the appeal have been
complied with, and that this case is now in accordance with said order
of appeal properly before the supreme court for the northern grand di-
vision of Illinois.

It is also stipulated that the following bill of exceptions is a full state-
ment of the evidence taken in said cause, the same having been con-
densed as follows by the agreement of the parties.

LEONARD SWETT,
Sol. for Complt.
CHAS. HITCHCOCK,
Sol. for Defts.

61 Circuit court, Cook County, March term, A. D. 1873.

SrATE OF ILLINOIS,
Cook County :

NORTHWESTERN FERTILIZING Co. )
v. » Bill of exceptions.
C. M. Capy ET AL. \

Be it remembered that on the trial of this cause, at the March term
of 1873, of the circuit court of Cook County, honorable W. W. Farwell,
presiding as the judge of the said court, the plaintiff, to maintain the
issue upon his part, introduced the following testimony:

Louis WAHL:
I am a manufacturer of glue from the refuse of hides and the feet
and bones of animals, and have been thus engaged, in Chicago and at
Milwaukee, for the last twenty-seven years. Our firm, composed of

SBN a eI MAI a2 YAR a AI RIES By RIMS

i
;
4
Ra
4
&
a
{
3
4

N. W. FERTILIZING CO. Vs. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL. 3]

Christian Wahl, myself, and John A. Lightall, commenced to manu-
facture an agricultural fertilizer from offal and animal matter in the
city of Chicago in 1864.

The establishment was about four miles from the court-house in a
southwesterly direction.

In the fall of 1866 we moved the business to Ainsworth, which is in a
southeasterly direction from Chicago, and about thirteen miles dis-
tant. The location is about half a mile from the mouth of the Calumet
River.

At the time Wahl Brothers and Lightall commenced the fertilizing
business at Ainsworth, that country, in the main, was unsettled.
Between the Hyde Park Hotel and the factory there was one little

saloon called The Half-way House. This was the only house,
62 and was about two miles south of the present Hyde Park Hotel.

There was also a little hut at Clark’s Point, and an old house at
the Calumet light-house, and also another house belonging to a man by
the name of Cain; otherwise there were no settlements from the Hyde
Park Hotel to the Calumet River. In fact there was not over two or
three houses south of where the reform-schools are. The Hyde Park
Hotel mentioned is about two miles south of the present city limits.
The distance from 22d street to the factory was about thirteen miles,
and the distance from the Hyde Park Hotel to it is about eight or nine
miles.

When we commenced the business of manufacturing a fertilizer in
1864, the material which we obtained in the city produced about five
thousand tons of dry product each year, which must have been fifteen
thousand tons in its natural state. The material thus received was
partly steamed by the packers and partly in its natural state. The
head, ribs, backbone, and some of the entrails were steamed by the
packers for lard, but the livers, lights, and lungs came to us in their
natural state.

We steamed out the livers and lungs ourselves. We tried to get
machinery to aid us in the manufacturing, but found it cost more than
the product was worth. We tried first piling the material up, in hopes
that it would dry by spontaneous combustion. But this failing, we had
to spread it out in the sun and air. Thespreading was about six inches
thick, and it would dry in different periods, according to the weather,
from three or four days to as many weeks. After the material was
thus dried, we gathered it up and sold it. This was our process while
we were doing business at Bridgeport, and before going to Ainsworth.

All efforts to use machinery proved useless.
63 The material used by us from 1864 to 1866 increased about

fifteen to twenty per cent. It was produced at the slaughter-
houses by the slaughtering of animals, and embraced all the refuse parts
of the animal, and blood. These slaughter-houses then, in the main,
were located upon the Chicago River and its branches, and within from
one to two miles of its mouth ; and at first much of the offal and blood
found its way to theriver. The water-works for city consumption were
at that time and are now located near the mouth of the Chicago River,
at the margin of the lake. The water was then pumped up from the
edge of the lake at a point about eight points north of the mouth of the
Chicago River, and in a central part of the city. The current of the
lake, opposite the city, makes towards the shore. The deposits of sand
brought from more northern regions make constantly, along the whole
line of the city, accretions of land. This is particularly so upon the
north side, where the water-works are. The location of the packing-

pie nase et uilte

SR a ns F , se oh! stil ga ak Sat sais 6s ln seals Sse Pee oa
re gg Sr ae epee is” PO IP PN nF SRS os g ok ag RATE aah el 4 ede ea . Ay ote ety
* Se Sit aie fete eb aes Sinica, we 8 NEES YE Nee Te ae AY Hite Pe sagt
. Z A Pore eee B 4 . z Ds. 2 ‘. or
a5 bd Bi it th ES ee I ea Be five ES contac Ae 3 ht atom Wh a aitgie er ees
: Se ee EMOTE Go ty ore Re Sa Sed NS eel a CIR ae a Gea

50 N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL.

GIDEON CLARKE’:

The following ordinance of the village of Hyde Park was proved to
have beea duly passed, and offered in evidence :

‘‘ No person shall transport, carry, haul, or convey any offal, dead
animal, or other offensive or unwholesome matter or material, into or
through the village of Hyde Park. Any person who shall be in charge
of, or employed on, any trainjor team carrying or conveying such matter
or material into or through the village of Hyde Park shall be subject
to a fine of not less than $5 nor more than $50 for each offense.”

Chapter II of the Revised Ordinances of the Villageof Hyde Park was
here offered in evidence by defendants :

‘¢ SEc. 1. Any person or persons who shall own, keep, or use any yard,
pen, place, or premises within the village of Hyde Park, in or upon
which cattle or swine shall be confined or kept, so as to be offensive to
those residing in the vicinity, or an annoyance to the public, shall be
deemed the author of a nuisance, and on conviction shall be subject to
a fine of not less than ten dollars, and not exceeding one hundred dol-
lars in every case, and to a like fine for every day he, she, or they shal!
neglect or refuse to abate such nuisance, when notified by any officer or
policeman of the village of Hyde Park to abate the same.

‘‘ SEc. 2. All places or premises within the village of Hyde Park kept,
occupied, used for the purposes of steaming, boiling, or rendering in any
manner of any offal, tainted or damaged lard or tallow, or the steaming

or rendering of any animal substances, when the same is or may
100 ~=be kept, oceupied, or used in such manner as to occasion any

offensive smell, or to so taint the air as to render it unwholesome
or offensive to the smell, and all places where any nauseous, offensive,
unwholesome business may be carried on, are hereby severally declared
to be nuisances. And any person or persons who shall own, keep,
occupy, or use any such place or premises in such manner as to occasion
any offensive smell, or to so taint the air as to render it unwholesome
or offensive to the smell, shall, on conviction, be subject to a fine of not
less than fifty dollars, nor more than two hundred dollars in every case,
and to a like fine for every day he, she, or they shall continue to suffer
such nuisance to continue after the first conviction, or after being noti-
fied by any officer or policeman of the village of Hyde Park to abate the
same.

“Sec. 3. Any person or persons who shall own, use, or oceupy any
packing-house, rendering-establishment, tallow-chandlery, bone-factory,
soap-factory, or tannery, who shall cause or suffer any offal, filth, re-
fuse, foul or nauseous liquor, or other offensive matter to be discharged
out of, or flow from, any such premises into Lake Michigan, or into any
lake lying in whole or in part within the village of Hyde Park, or the
Calumet River, or either of the branches thereof, or any of the slips or
canals connected therewith, orinto any slough within the jurisdiction of
the said village, or in or upon any street, alley, public square, vacant lot,
wharf, dock, river-bank, or lake shore, shall be subject to a fine not less
than twenty-five dollars and not exceeding two hundred dollars for
each offense.

“Src. 4. Any person or persons who shall permit or suffer any offal,
filth, refuse animal or vegetable matter, which is liable to become putrid
or offensive, or injurious to health, to remain on any premises, used or
occupied by him, for a longer period than four hours at any one time,

shall be subject to a fire of not less than three dollars and not
101 more than two hundred dollars, and to a further fine of ten dol-

- ee

N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ETAL. 51

lars for each day the same shall be allowed to remain after a convic-
tion for the first offense.

‘Sec. 5. The owner or owners of any grocery, cellar, soap or tallow
chandlery, tannery, stable, pig-sty, privy, or sewer found to be in a filthy,
nauseous, offensive, or unwholesome condition, or any other unwholesome
or nauseous house or place, shall immediately cleanse, abate, or remove
the same upon being notified so to do by any officer or policeman of the
village of Hyde Park; any soch owner or owners who shall fail or refuse
to comply with such notice shall be subject to a fine of not less than
three dollars nor more than fifty dollars for each and every day he, she,
or they shall so fail or refuse to cleanse, abate, or remove the same.

‘¢Srec. 6. All buildings, yards, grounds, premises, and places of any
and all description in the village of Hyde Park kept or suffered to be in
a foul, offensive, nauseous, or filthy condition are hereby declared to be
nuisances, and any person who shall own or keep or use any of such
places so declared to be nuisances shall be deemed the author of a
nuisance, and on conviction thereof shall be subject to a fine not exceed-
ing two hundred dollars and not less than five dollars in every case, and
to like fine for every day he, she, or they shall fail or refuse to abate
such nuisance when notified by an officer or policeman of the village of
Hyde Park to abate the same.

‘‘SEc. 7. No person shall transport, carry, haul, or convey any offal,
dead animals, or other offensive or unwholesome matter or material into
or through the village of Hyde Park. Any person who shall be in charge
of or employed upon any train or team carrying or conveying such
matter or material into or through the village of Hyde Park shall be
subject to a fine of not less than five dollars nor more than fifty dollars

for each offense.
102 ‘Sec. 8. No person shall establish, maintain, or carry on any

offensive or unwholesome business or establishment within the
limits of the village of Hyde Park, nor within one mile of the limits
thereof. Any person who shall violate any of the provisions of this
section shall be subject to a penalty of not less than fifty dollars nor
more than two hundred dollars for each and every offense, and to a like
fine for each day such business or establishment shall be continued after
the first conviction.

“SEC. 9. The depositing of any night-soil, dead animals, manure, or
other filthy, offensive, or nauseous substances upon any lot, street, alley,
highway, or other place in the village is hereby declared to be a nuisance,
and any person convicted thereof shall be fined not less than three
dollars nor exceeding twenty dollars.

‘Src. 10. Whenever any nuisance shall be found on any premises
within the village contrary to any ordinance of said village, the presi-
dent of the board of trustees is hereby authorized, in his discretion, to
cause the same to be summarily abated in such manner as he may direct.”

Defendant also introduced the charter of Hyde Park, from which the
following sections are taken from the enumeration of the powers of the
board of trustees:

‘* Kighth. To compel the owner or occupant of any grocery or cellar,
tallow-chandler shop, soap-factory, tannery, or other unwholesome or
nauseous houses or places to cleanse or remove or abate the same
from time to time, as often as may be necessary for the health, con-
venience, and comfort of the inhabitants of said town.

‘Ninth. No restrain, regulate, or prohibit the running at large of
cattle, horses, or other animals, or the driving or herding the same upon
the public highway or alleys or lands in said town, and to authorize the

Aye sada so eae bla te Cea
CP ARN ak A OORT ON

FPR ne Bee SG | EP. ON ME ee TD
See oe eee ea ey a ae, Ne Cat

52 N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL.

, distraining, impounding, and sale of the same for the penalty in-
103. curred and the costs of proceedings, and also to impose penalties

on the owners or drivers or herdsmen of any such animals for a
violation of any ordinances relative thereto.

‘‘ Fifteenth. To define and abate nuisances which are or may be injuri-
ous to the public health in any manner they may deem expedient

‘¢ Sixteenth. To regulate, restrain, prohibit, or license breweries, tan-
neries, packing-houses, distilleries, slaughter-houses, butcher-shops,
stock-yards, or the establishments for the steaming or rendering of
lard, tallow, offal, manure, or such other substances as may be rendered,
boiled, or steamed, and all establishments or places where any nause-
ous, offensive, unwholesome, or immoral business may be carried on:
Provided, however, that the sanitary and police powers conferred by
this act shall not be exercised by said board of trustees as against the
Northwestern Fertilizing Company, or the Union Rendering Company,
located at or near the Calumet River, in said town, until the full expira-
tion of two years from and after the passage of this act.

‘ Seventeenth. To restrain and prohibit the deposit of any night-soil,
dead animals, manure, or other filthy, offensive, or nauseous substances,
upon any lot, street, alley, highway, or other place in said town.

‘ Twenty-fifth. To make, publish, ordain, amend, or repeal all such or-
dinances, orders, by-laws, police and health regulations, for the good
government of the town and the public health as may be necessary and
expedient to carry into effect the power vested in said board, or any
ofticer or agent of said board, and to enforce observance of the same by
fine or imprisonment, in the discretion of the magistrate or court before
which conviction may be had, provided such fine shall not exceed one

hundred dollars, nor shall such imprisonment exceed thirty days.
104. Kvery ordinance, regulation, or by-law, imposing a penalty, fine,

imprisonment, or forfeiture, or a violation of its provisions, shall,
after the passage thereof, be posted in at least three of the most public
places in said town.”

Defendant proved by Gideon E. Clark the publication of the ordi-
nance passed February 13, 1873, set forth in supplemental answer and
offered in evidence.

It was admitted that Hyde Park had adopted village organization
under the general laws of the State.

This ordinance was passed the 2nd day of November, 1872.

Also it is admitted that the following are ordinances of the village of
Hyde Park, duly passed and published ;

‘*Ordained, By the president and board of trustees of the village of
Hyde Park, as follows, to wit:

‘Sec. 11. All establishments, places, or premises within the village
of Hyde Park so negligently conducted, managed, or used as to create
such offensive smells as to taint the air and render it unwholesome or
disagreeable to the public or to the inhabitants of said village are hereby
severally declared to be a nuisance, and every person or corporation
who shall create or aid or assist in creating such nuisance shall be liable
to a fine of not less than $50 and not exceeding $200, and to a like fine
for each twenty-four hours such nuisance shall be continued and remain
unabated.

‘¢SEc. 12. Any person or corporation engaged in the business of con-
verting dead animals or other animal matter into an agricultural fertil-
izer or into other products within the limits of said village of Hyde
Park, and who or which shall so negligently conduct, or manage, or aid,
or assist in so conducting or managing such business as to create such

’ “y iS 2 - _ 2. - oh . ena ae Pitas
ae es Eee RN ee tS igs tN Se SOO oe eR a a
sai Sa Rd ae a a eC ORE 25 ARAB SPP TEEN,

—————

SSE

N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL. 53

nuisance as is described in section 11 of this ordinance, shall be
105 __—iiliable to a fine of not less than fifty and not exceeding two hun-

dred dollars, and to a like fine for each twenty-four hours such
business shall be in such manner continued by the procurement, aid, or
assistance of such person or corporation.

‘Sec. 15. No person or persons or corporation engaged in rendering,
reducing, or manufacturing animal matter or offal into an agricultural
fertilizer or other product shall accumulate at any one place within the
jurisdiction of said village, animal matter or offal exceeding one hun-
dred tons, or of blood exceeding 1,000 gallons. Any person or corpora-
tion who or which shall violate this section shall be deemed guilty of
maintaining a nuisanee, ard, upon conviction thereof, shall be fined in
a sum not less than fifty and not more than two hundred dollars.

“Sro. 14. Any person or persons who, or corporation which, shall
cause animal matter or offal to be bronght into the village of Hyde Park
for the purpose of manufacturing the same into a fertilizer or other
product, or who shall aid or assist therein, shall transport the same in
close, tight, and covered cars or boxes, and shall deposit the same in
close, tight, and covered bins, so that no offensive or unwholesome odor
shall escape therefrom. Any person who shall violate this section shall
be subject to a fine of not less than fifty and not more than two hun-
dred dollars for each oftense.

‘Sec. 15. Any person or persons or corporations engaged in render-
ing, reducing, or manufacturing animal matter or offal into a fertilizer
or other product, who or which shall deposit within the limits of Hyde
Park any such matter or offal in a putrid or offensive condition, or who
or which shall aid or assist therein, shall be deemed guilty of creating
a nuisance, and, upon conviction thereof, shall be fined in a sum not less

than 50 and not more than $200.
106 “Sec. 16. Any person or persons or corporation engaged in

rendering, reducing, or manufacturing animal matter or offal into
a fertilizer or other product, who or which shall permit or suffer any
animal matter or offal to remain on premises occupied or used by him,
or them, or it, within the limits of the village of Hyde Park for a longer
period than 48 hours before the actual reduction or manufacture thereof,
shall be deemed guilty of maintaining a nuisance, and, on conviction
thereof, shall be subject to a fine of not less than $50 and not exceeding
$200, and to a like fine for every day he, she, or they shall fail to abate
such nuisance.

‘Sec. 17. Every person or corporation engaged in manufacturing
animal matter or offal into a fertilizer or other product within the limits
of the village of Hyde Park shall, before the reduction thereof, thor-
oughly deodorize the same by the application of salt, acid, or other
chemicals, so that the same shall not be offensive. Any person who
shall violate this section of the ordinance shall be subject to a fine of
not less than $50 and not more than $200.

‘Sec. 18. Any person or corporation who or which shall operate or
use, or be employed in any factory or other place for the reduction, ren-
dering, or manufacturing of animal matter or offal into a fertilizer or
other product between the Ist day of April and the lst day of Novem-
ber, within the limits of the village of Hyde Park, shali be guilty of
maintaining 4 nuisance, and, on conviction thereof, shall be subject to a
fine of not less than $50 and not more than $200, and to a like fine for
every day he, she, or they shall fail to abate such nuisance.

“Sec. 19. Nothing contained in this ordinance shall be construed so
as to repeal any existing ordinance of the village of Hyde Park relating
to nuisances or the abatement thereof.”

28 SELES ARR AG WADES WS SMCS ee ee an ita

54 N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL.

107 FREDERICK MAHLA:

I am a native of Bavaria, Germany, and by profession an an-
alytical and manufacturing chemist. I was educated at Munich and
Gottingen. I commenced the study of chemistry at the age of thirteen,
and am now forty-two years old. I studied until I acquired my profes-
sion, and have been practising it ever since. Twenty years of my pro-
fessional life have been spent in Chicago.

I visited the Northwestern Fertilizing Company about the first of
this present month. I know the process of manufacture adopted by
the it, and while I was at the factory examined the piles of animal mat-
ter there. The tank-stuff was mixed with salt and salt-cake. I also ex-
amined the blood. The blood was in a solid condition, produced by the
admixture of sulphuric acid. This is a proper material, and three hun-
dred pounds to the dry ton is sufficient quantity. The effect of salt-
cake being introduced into the tank-stuff is to pickle it, and to prevent
putrefaction. The salt-cake is the bisulphate of soda, and while these
ingredients act upon the material, preventing decomposition, they also
absorb the water, drying and desiccating the articles with which they
are mixed. Twenty-five per cent. of salt or salt-cake mixed with the
animal matter is a sufficient quantity. I should think it extraordina-
rily large.

The object sought in making a fertilizer is to prevent putrefaction as
much as possible and retain the nitrogen. The process consists in ex-
pelling the water and retaining all the solid constituents of the animal
body. They are the meaty parts, fibrous substances, bone, cuticle, and
so forth. The constituents of these organic masses are carbon, nitro-
gen, hydrogen, and oxygen; and those of the mineral substances are
lime and phosphoric acid. The object to be attained is to expel the

water and retain all the other compounds.
108 I have examined the tank-stnff as it comes from the tanks. I

went to a packing-house and obtained fresh material, such as dis-
charges from their tanks, in order to ascertain whether it had an odor,
and whether it was already in a state of putrefaction, and how long it
would take the material to assume a putrid condition. When I first
took the material from the tank it had little or no odor, but after com-
ing down town and taking it to a warm room I found it had already be-
come odorous. That, however, was not a putrefactive odor. But within
a very short time—say about two or three hours—it acquired a regular
putrefactive smell, which could not be mistaken. I found that the en-
trails uncleaned were put into the tanks and steamed, with the manure
in them. Putting the offal, in connection with the entrails, with the
manure in them, into the tanks, and applying pressed steam, causes the
manure to infuse itself all through the pulpy mass, and become a part of
it. The particular quantity which I took down town to observe reached
a state of complete putrefaction within four or five hours. The tempe-
1rature on that day was about at freezing-point.

The effect of putting three hundred pounds of sulphuric acid to the
dry ton of blood into the fresh blood is to immediately coagulate it, sep-
arating the coagulated parts from the water it originally contained.
The mass thus coagulated contains about eighty per cent. of water, and
if the coagulated mass is piled up, the water gradually passes off from
it. The tendency and effect of the acid is to exude the water. When
analyzed by a chemist in his laboratory, blood, in a fresh state, contains
fifteen parts of ammonia. I have analyzed blood for the Northwestern
Fertilizing Company, and what I analyzed contained eleven or twelve
per cent. of ammonia. I have analyzed the product of the tank stuff,

N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ETAL. 55

but not since they have got their cylinder process. Under the old
109 process, with some machinery which they had, it yielded five or

six per cent. After decomposition has begun, it is impossible
treating animal matter in large quantities to destroy the effects of such
decomposition. It may be done in a laboratory with a small quantity.
Considering the animal matter in such quantities as is produced by the
slaughter-houses of the city, it is practically impossible to destroy the
effects of decomposition already begun, and it is also practically impos-
sible to deodorize the material, so that offensive odors will not arise
from it. 1 think it would be a matter of impossibility. After decomposi-
tion has taken place, the best thing that can be done with the animal mat-
ter is to put it through the dryer as quickly as its condition will admit.
The only object of applying chemicals to animal matter is to prevent
decomposition.

Q. I will ask you if, having examined the Northwestern {Fertilizing
Company, you are able to suggest any improvements in handling the
material or reducing it toa fertilizer, whereby the business could be
rendered less offensive to the public, or are they doing it as well as it
can be done?

A. [could not suggest any improvement in the present mode of man-
ufacturing. I don’t think such business could be carried on without the
production of unpleasant odors. There are no scientific principles which
can be applied to the business to prevent it. When I first witnessed
the Fertilizing Company’s {business, as carried on in Chicago, it was
done in a very crude manner. The offal was simply dumped upon the
ground, and spread out in layers and removed again after it had ac-
quired sufficient dryness. During this drying process immense volumes
of putrid gases were evolved, of which I believe all Chicago had the
benefit. The difference in the degree of offensiveness growing out of

this business, between a process which produces three per cent.
110 of ammonia in the tank-stuff, after spreading out the material for

a long while upon the ground, and one which produces seven or
eight per cent. and at the same time consumes the material at the rate
of one hundred tons a day, and a process equally rapid which produces
fourteen or fifteen per cent. of ammonia from the blood, may properly
be measured by the difference in the quantities of ammonia produéed ;
for just in proportion as the material is disposed of and the ammonia]
passes into the air, just in that proportion is the offensiveness, and in
proportion as decomposition is prevented and the escape of ammonia
prevented the offensive smell is lessened. And the difference between
the three per cent. and the seven to eight per cent. in the tank-stuff,
and the three or four per cent. in the blood and fourteen to fifteen per
cent., is the result of the improvement in the drying process. The effect
of the introduction of salt-cake and salt into the tank-stuff, in connec-
tion with the steaming or tank process, destroys the original identity of
the parts and produces a product which would hardly be identified as
animal matter. The change is so great that a person looking at the
pile would not know of what it was composed, except that he would
find animal matter init. The pile assumes a lightish color and looks
considerably like a pile of snow or a pileof salt. The pile of blood after
the acid is mixed with it has the color and appearance of a very rich
brown or black earth, and looks very similar to it. I don’t think a pile
of blood like that represented in the photograph would exude water in
sufficient quantities to make any visible drainage from it, and upon ex-
amining the pile in question and the pile of tank-stuff, I could see no in-
dications of any drainage from it, except there were little pools of liquid

56 N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL.

blood or water with some small quantity of blood admixed, percolating
the earth around the edges of it.

111 Cross-examination :

The process by which the animal matter is reduced to a pulpy
state, is the steaming and the pressure of the steam. This necessarily in-
creases the quantity of water in the animal matter originally. I know of
no process by which the material could be heated in the tanks except by
steam. The soft tank-stuff, when it comes from the tanks, in my judg-
ment, contains from seventy to eighty per cent. of water, and if an attempt
was made to put it through the dryer it would bake to the sides of it. I
know of no process by which the water can be exuded from it except
by natural drainage. Wahl Brothers attempted to do this by pressing
the material, and then they produced a centrifugal machine to force it
out by centrifugal force ; but in all these experiments it was found that
the material itself would go through with the water. Nearly all the
material would thus pass out with the water and could not be re-
tained, excepting the bony substances or hard and solid constituents.

It seems to me the odor in the tank-stuff, immediately upon taking it
from the tanks, must arise from the admixture of manure contained in
the entrails, and the rapid advance to decomposition and generation of
animal life is attributable to the same cause. If the entrails could be
steamed separately from the other parts of the animals, I think decom-
position would be delayed, and I see no reason, except economic reasons,
why this separation could not be made. The effect of the admixture of
sulphuric acid with blood is, that coagulation immediately takes place,
and the water is separated. It remains admixed or intermixed with the
so separated substances, but chemically taken, it is separated. The

water thus separated passes off by natural drainage.
112 (). You say you cannot suggest any improvements in the pres-
ent mode of manufacture at the Fertilizing Company’s works.
Now, I ask what means, if any, you can suggest in any mode of manu-
facture which will save the public from offensive odors? We are enti-
tled to your best judgment in regard to the mode of their manufacture,
and upon any improvements which may devised.

A. Any mode that will effect the desiceation of the article more rap-
idly may be considered an improvement. In this benzole process the
company desire to introduce—or benzine process they call it—that, of
course, has a tendency to accelerate the desiccation, whereby, of course,
the process would be improved.

A. Supposing if this business of manafacturing was carried on in a
dozen different factories on a small scale, the putrefaction and offense
about the premises need not be as great as about these premises at Ains-
worth, need it?

A. it a factory of this kind has asuflicient number of dryers, it seems
to me it would be better to confine it to one place, as there is an abso-
lute consequence in every manufactory of this kind, that some odorous
principles are evolved, thus creating alway S$ a sort of unpleasant smell,
which cannot be avoided during the manufacture.

(). You would say that a number of these dryers, or, in other words, a
large number of these factories, would be better than a small number ?

A. Yes, of course.

(). But you would limit them to one neighborhood ?

A. Yes.

The natural drainage of the tank-stuff must be very slow, slower than
the blood, and I think, under any circumstances, it would take several
weeks to complete it.

_ *

_ |

N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL. 57

There have been attempts to diminish dense vapors which pass off

through the smoke-stack at the works of the Northwestern Fertil-

113. izing Company. They conducted the vapors through horizontal
brick flues, and then passed water through the flues.

The idea of condensing these vapors to avoid the offensive smell
would, of course, at once present itself; but this can only be done by
large masses of water-showers, as it were, and which, owing to the great
quantities of water required, render the attempt impracticable. I sug-
gested a mode of cooling the gases which, I understand, they will
attempt to try.

I know by reading, but not by personal observation, that in eastern
cities there are establishments applying water by filtering processes
through smoke-stacks. These experiments are, as I understand, only
partially successful in distroying the odorous principle. In the present
case, any attempts to shower the chimneys would probably have the
effect of destroying the draft of the furnaces. I have been consulted
by the Fertilizing Company as to whether they might not devise some
plan to prevent the escape of the gases into the atmosphere, and I have
given them the best advice upon the subject I could. As a rule, unless
on account of the weather, the higher the chimneys the more likely are
the gases and bad odors to pass away into the upper air.

I dowt know of any process by which the gases which escape by
means of the chimney ean be condensed, or the escape of the odors
fully prevented.

C. M. Capy:

Iam president of the board of trustees of the village of Hyde Park,
and have occupied that position for the last five years. I have exam-
ined the letter set forth in the bill of complaint in this cause, addressed
to John Cleeland. I wrote it, and it was published in the city papers.

I also wrote a letter which appeared about the same time in the
114 Chicago Times, stating that it was the intention of the village of
Hyde Park to prosecute the Northwestern Fertilizing Company,

and drive it out of the community.

It is true that as president of the village of Hyde Park it was our in-
tention, by arrests and prosecution, to eradicate and get rid of the insti-
tution. It was my intention, by the letter addressed to Mr. Cleeland,
and by executing the ordinance preventing the taking of offal into the
village of Hyde Park, to cut off the supplies of the institution, and pre-
vent its having any offal. And, if uninterrupted, I intended to persue
these arrests from time to time, till it would be compelled to stop from
pure strangulation. If this injunction is dissolved, I intend to renew
the war, if 1 live, the next day after it is dissolved, or as soon as practi-
cable.

Cross-examination :

I inaugurated this war against the Fertilizing Company, and made
the arrests, in good faith, as an officer of the town of Hyde Park. Find-
ing our efforts in this direction interrupted by the injunction, we passed
the ordinance attempting to regulate the institution, and our object was,
as far as possible, to abate the nuisance. After the arrest of the em-
ployees, who were brought before Justice Hoyne, I instructed the police
to go back again to the factory and make new arrests when the next
train should arrive. I instructed them to bring the men thus arrested
for trial to that portion of Hyde Park near the Hyde Park Hotel, which
is between five and six miles from the factory.

ene anil in tasting nw

Ck ee = ee WL LBM ES TE ee Se ea ee, PRRs 2 wy Nt Bebe Mieka 8 Londin, Bip Bp er Bix rem AE, ae ” snk a ‘ - —P . P 4 ee eT
rere Se Sse eitiositnceatérektin talensameereneaneinsthas sentient anes — ceuniiemanieianatn Rin Bisae ss Soi st AU Bd 2A tO Sa a a len Pa GAS ANN RG i SSN ata a gn

58 N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL.

JOSEPH HIRSCH:

I am achemist of sixteen years professional life, and reside in Chicago.

I was educated for my profession at the University and at the Poly-

technic Institution at Leipsic. After acquiring my profession, I
115 __— practiced a short time in Europe, and since have been in Amer-

ica, thirteen years of which time has been spent in Chicago. I
have twice visited the Northwestern Fertilizing Company—once a few
years ago, and once last fall, and spent about half a day at the factory.
The first time I was there they spread the material out and dried it in
the air andthe sun. The last time they mixed sulphuric acid with the
blood, and salt or salt-cake with the tank-stuff; and after being thus
mixed and dried or drained, it was put through dryers. The salt-cake
and salt, admixed with the tank-stuff, and the sulphuric acid with the
blood, are proper materials, and the quantity used is a proper one. My
impression, from an examination of their establishment, was that it was
carried on properly, but that material, when received by them, was so
decomposed that it made it very ditficult to prevent offensive odors. I
gave itas my opinion that the animal matter ought to be treated at the
packing-houses by the packers, and before it leaves the packing: houses.
So far as the treatment of it by the Northwestern Fertilizing Company,
after it is received by them, I was not able to make any material sug-
gestions. What I would suggest is that a small furnace should be put
up in some convenient corner of the packing- houses, in which chemi cals
should be vaporized and carried into the tanks in which the material is
steamed. There are different gases which, I think, might be used for
this purpose. Notwithstanding the treatment which I suggest at the
packing-houses, I think there would be some odor attending the manu-
facture of the animal matter, but it would, I think, be materially less-
ened.

I don’t think the greater elevation of the chimneys would prevent
offensive odors, even in the neighborhood, because the gases which are

thrown out rapidly condense, and they would fall to the ground.
116 These gases are the products of the destruction of the fatty

compounds in the animal matter, mixed with ammonia and com-
pounds of ammonia, mixed with sulphurated hydrogen and compounds
of sulphurated hydrogen. They are of a very complex nature.

I heard Dr. Mahla’s testimony suggesting the obstacles to throwing
water down the smoke-stack or showering it, and I consider that little
benefit would come from that in this case, because the gases arising in
this case are not such as would dissolve in water even if they could be
condensed by it. And besides, the water itself would be a source of
very disagreeable odor, because it would have to be carried somewhere.
The best thing I could suggest in relation to the gases passing up the
chimney would be to burn them. I don’t know, however, that they
could be burned in connection with as much moisture as they are satu-
rated with coming from the dryers. I think if that could be done it
would be the best way. In reference to my suggestion about deodoriz-
ing the material at the packing-house, I don’t know of such things ever
having been done practically.

There was a great improvement in the Northwestern Fertilizing Com-
pany between the two different times Iwas there. The character of the
improvements were that the old mode of drying was completely aban-
doned, and that dryers such as were used the first time were greatly im-
proved and simplified and rendered more eftticient. The establishment
was also greatly improved with regard to its offensiveness to the sur-
rounding neighborhood, and I found that the smell of putrefaction had,

RRR i ee yioin Y RT: Someta ; th Eas po 24g ae ea et

a.

se

@ >.

am |

0

N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL. 59

to a great extent, been destroyed by the use of chemicals, and the es-
tablishment was greatly improved in respect to the general air of clean-
liness and neatness. Now, the smell attached to the establishment is

what you might call a manufactured smell, or a result from the
117 chemicals mixed with the animal matter, rather than tbe smell of

putrefaction. About the Union Rendering Company’s establish-
ment, which is quite near, there was a large number of dead animals in
all the various stages of decomposition and putrefaction. These dead
animals, and the putrefaction arising from them, overwhelmed the smell
arising from the Northwestern Fertilizing Company.

Cross-examination :

I have suggested that the material be treated at the packing-house
to arrest decomposition. This could be done by carrying into the vats
sulphuric-acid gas, carbolic acid, or the products of combustion of sul-
phur and gas-tar. Decomposition in that way may be arrested for sev-
eral months. If the process was properly applied at the packing-
— _ odors arising from the drying process would be very greatly
reduced.

CHARLES E. REESE:

Iam a resident of Hyde Park, and live within about four miles of the
Northwestern Fertilizing Company. I am frequently about this estab-
lishment, and was there this week. I was there just before the fire, and
have been there since the fire. While Mr. Bennett, the former foreman,
was there I had frequently occasion to go down and see him. I should
think I was about the factory once in two weeks during the year. That
was the year before last. I am a justice of the peace. I have been
about there ever since the year 1854, and have lived in the neighbor-
hood ever since that time.

I also knew the establishment when Wahl was there. There has
been a great improvement since Wahl Brothers & Lightall had charge
of it. They used to dry their material upon planks, thus creating a ve

bad smell all around. The factory is in a great deal better condi-
118 _ tion than it was then, regarding smell in the vicinity, and as re-

gards cleanliness. I have known the Union Rendering Company
ever since it was built, which was six or eight years ago. It was prob-
ably twenty rods from the works of the Northwestern Fertilizing Com-
pany. Their business was to render dead animals, and extract the
grease from them, and the smell was very offensive from the sediment
which came from it. It also polluted the Calumet River. They did
this to such an extent that I was instructed to look after them in this
particular. °

Exhibit No. 7, shown to me, is a correct representation of the works
of the Union Rendering Company. The larger building shown on the
photograph is the establishment of the Northwestern Fertilizing Com-
pany. The drain shown in the picture is from the Union Rendering
Company. This is shown more fully in photograph No.1. Photograph
No. 3 also shows this drain.

The Union Rendering Company used to receive dead animals in all
stages of decomposition. They were brought there by the Pittsburgh
& Fort Wayne road from the stock-yards. After their arrival they were
put into tanks and steamed. After being steamed, and the grease ob-
tained, the water was drained off and flowed through these drains into
the Calumet River, and the sediment or animal matter left after the
water was drained off was thrown on the ground and decayed. It
smelled very badly. Whether it was the rendering company or the

60 N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL. |

fertilizing company which smelled I cannot say. I could smell the ~
establishments for miles—to my house. The Union Rendering Company
is now removed. The effect of the removal of this establishment is to
reduce the smell, and the fertilizing company itself is not nearly as
offensive as it used to be. While the Union Rendering Company was
there the marshes were filled with animal matter—the residuum after
tanking. This was the work of the Union Rendering Company, and
not of the fertilizing company.

119 MARC DELAFONTAINE :
I am a native of Switzerland, and by profession achemist. I have
been engaged in that business for about fifteen years. Was educated e

in France and Germany. I have practiced my profession for three years
in Chicago. I visited the Northwestern Fertilizing Company in No-
vember last, for the purpose of examining the establishment, and point-
ing out wherein it could be improved and made less offensive. The
premises were in a cleanly condition. We went through the entire
establishment and examined the process of manufacture. Wesaw the
piles of the offal after it had been admixed with chemicals, awaiting the
drying process, also piles of blood and the lungs and livers, or soft tank-
offal mixed with the salt-cake. I took pains to examine the animal
matter.

The smell from the piles was perceptible only a short distance—I can-
not tell how far exactly, perhaps twenty yards. But as you approach
the pile and come near it, there was a smell. I speak now of one par-
ticular pile. The balance had very little smell. The pile which I said
was offensive and could be smelt at twenty yards distance was a small és
pile, perhaps six feet high. The blood did not smell. It was there in
piles, and the men were shoveling it about. There is no smell of a
putrefying character attendant upon the manufacture of the blood. I
also examined the drying process, and the manner in which they han-
dled and put through the material. The material, when sufficiently dry,
is fed into the cylinders in very small quantities or shovelfuls, enough
to make two or three inches of thickness on the bottom of the cylinder.
The whole is kept constantly in motion throughout the cylinder by the
rakes and the revolutions of the cylinder.

What they put into the cylinder, in the condition in which they put

it in, has substantially the appearance of animal matter, but is a
120 =dry powdery substance. The material put into the cylinder could

not be recognized. The machinery was constructed upon the
most scientific principles, and I don’t think, taking the whole treatment
with the machinery, the problem could be solved in any better manner.
The object sought is to dry the material without burning it; and it
seems to me the machinery in the way it works is very well adapted to
this purpose.

The most objectionable part of the establishment is the soft tank-stuff,
or the livers, lights, and entrails. The admixture of the salt, or salt-
sake, combines with it—the water-—or absorbs the water, but elements
of decomposition have been introduced in the tanks. i

(). I will ask you whether the material used—whether the acids, and
the manner in which they are used—is treating this material as well as
it can be treated, in your judgment ?

A. Yes, sir. It is possible that some other methods could be devised
to treat the same material; but none, so far as [ can see, have received
the sanction of experience on a large seale. I don’t know of any that
would do better, and I have tried to post myself on this subject.

a

ceatienam in pt Rona

N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL. 6l

OLIVER W. HODGES:

I am a photographer by profession. I have examined the photographs
marked B to J inclusive. They are photographs of various views of the
factory and the surroundings. C is of the rendering company and
the fertilizing works. All of them from B to J are views of the place
and its immediate surroundings. Photograph number 2 shows a drain
from the rendering company to the river. The building is the ferti-
lizing company. Number 7 also shows the building of the Northwestern
Fertilizing Company.

EDWIN P. BAUGH:

121 I am president of the Northwestern Fertilizing Company, and

have been connected with it from its organization. Have been
engaged in nanutacturing a fertitizer from animal material nineteen or
twenty years in the city of Philadelphia and at Chicago.

The manufacture of superphosphates in the East has within the last
fifteen years grown to be a large and important interest. One of the
indispensable elements to this industry is the production of matter con-
taining ammonia. eee
———

-
ae
ew

N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL. 95

employed. This same charter authorizes this company to establish de-
pots in the city to receive the dead animals and animal matter to be
manutactured. Butthere is no specific provision that the company shall
so manage these receptacles as that they shall not become a nuisance.
And yet no one would contend that they have a contract with the State
by which they can permit such matter to lie there indefinately and
200 become putrid and a nuisance to the people in the vicinity. And
in what consists the difference? In the one they may receive the
matter; at the other they may manufacture it. But we see no greater
exemption in the onecase than in the other. The maxim applies: “Legis
constructio non facit injuriam.” Hence in construing statutes the pre-
sumption must be adhered to that it was not intended to injure any
one, much less the people generally. When such an intention is ex-
pressed in clear and explicit language that admits of no construction,
then courts can but carry out the legislative will, where that body has
not transcended the limits of their power. In the case of Ohio and
Miss. R. R. v. McClelland, (25 Ills., 140,)1t was held that in grant-
201 ing the charter to the railroad company, the legislature not having
in terms surrendered the right to subject it to the general police
regulations, in the absence of express language such an exemption would
not be inferred. That in the creation of these bodies it must be held to
be subordinate to and under the control of the government to the same
extent as individuals. That they had at all times been required to
conform to the general laws of the State precisely as if they were natural
and not artificial persons. To hold otherwise would be to create a
government within a government independent and free from its con-
trol.
202 And the case of Providence Bank v. Billings, (4 Pit. R., 514,)
was referred to where Chief.Justice Marshall says, in reference
to the State not having relinquished the power to tax the banks: “ But
as the whole community is interested in retaining it undiminished, that
community bas a right to insist that its abandonment ought not to be
presumed in a case in which the deliberate purpose of the State. to
abandon it does not appear.” So of the power to regulate the general
police of the State. The power to impose police-regulations operates
upon all alike. And this is a fundamental principle lying at the
203 very foundation of organized society. Itis yielded by each mem-
ber when he enters society for the good of the entire community.
That it is incident to and a part of government itself, and need not be
expressly reserved when it grants rights or property to individuals or
to corporate bodies; as they take subject to this right. (See Galena &
Chi. U. R. R. v. Appleby, 28 Il., 283, and Dingman v. The People, 51
Ill., 278, where the same rule is announced.) Had a citizen erected this
structure and created this nuisance, does any one suppose that such per-
son would not have been liable to prosecution and punishment? An
204 individual in pursuit of gain had the undoubted right to make such
an erection, aud use it too, provided it did not become a nuisance
and inflict injury upon others. And why or how does an artificial per-
son, created to promote private interest and incidentally promote the
general weltare, acquire any greater or more sacred rights than the in-
dividual citizen? Does any one suppose that the general assembly
could by enactment authorize irrevocably an individual for his private
gain to inflict injury to the life, health, peace, and property of the
community? And if the irrevocable power to do these things by an
individual cannot be granted, how can it be contended that
205 ~~ such irrevocable power can be confer’ed on a corporation ? Sach

96 N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL.

entities should be content to have the powers of natural persons, and
be subject to the same rules prescribed for the government of the
community in which they exist. We hazard nothing in saying that the
general assembly never supposed they were creating artificial bodies,
not subject to be controlled by the police power inherent in and insepe-
rable from the soverignty of the State. it would be impossible to sup-
pose the general assembly, or in fact any government, would or could

divest itself of all power, beyond recall, to prescribe what are crimes
206 and to punish them. And if such a grant may be made to cor-

porations, it may be to individuals. If with one person, it may
be with all in community, and the power of protection be lost and the
ends of government be defeated. Nor is it an answer to say that it is
conceeded by agreement or contract. The legislature has the same
power to say to an inuividual, if he will perform a particular act, or
pursue a specified calling, he shall be released trom the police-power of
the State as to say to a number of persons that if they will organ-

ize and perform that act, or pursue that occupation, that they
207 shall be free from its operation. The general assembly might as-

sist the performance of the duty resting upon them by failing to
prescribe what shall constitute crimes and in not providing for their
punishment. If so, then so long as a civil remedy should not be taken
away, each individual would be left to his action against the wrong-doer
for the injury inflicted upon him. But the exemption of an individual
or a class of individuals from punishment for crimes or misdemeanors

by an act of the general assembly would not prevent that body
208 = from the repeal of that law and bringing them under the general

law punishing crimes and misdemeanors. And why should they
exempt a body-corporate ? No reason is perceived why they should not
in this respect be governed as are natural persous. The formation of
government was to confer equal rights and protection to all persons. In
view of what we have said we must therefore hold that all persons
possess their rights, whether to things tangible or entangible, subject to
the general police-power of the State, and that corporate bodies are
not, nor van they be, held to be a privileged class in this regard. When

created they are ordained by provisions of theircharters to the extent
209 ~=—s of the grant, with the same rights, and are liable to the same duty

and obedience to government as individuals. They are created
persons, but not higher nor superior to natural persons. They are
endowed with rights and powers within the seope of their franchises to
the same, and only to the same, extent as natural persons. To hold
otherwise is to reverse the rules of construction, the theory and policy
of government; to change the principles on which it is based, to en-
croach upon the rights of the people, and to create a power in the State

beyond its control, and highly dangerous to the general we’fare.
210 Such immunity to these bodies was not intended by the fram-

ers of our Government, and we have no doubt would have been
expressly prohibited if they could have imagined that such privileges
would be granted or claimed by construction. Nor ean we believe the
legislature supposed such exemption for such bodies would ever be
claimed, or they would have expressly provided that they should be
subject to the general laws of the State, precisely as are individuals.
Nor did the inhibition in the village charter from exercising the police-
power in reference to this company for two years inure to this company

asa grant to them; it was only a_ police-regulation operating
211 upon and controlling the village government. Appellants were
not a party to that enactment, and have no right to elaim any

N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ETAL. 97

privilege under it after the expiration of the two years. It was not a
grant of an immunity to appellants, but it was a restriction on the vil-
lage preventing it from exercising the power for the specified period.
This was the fall scope of the enactment; and it, by implication, fully
authorized the village to enact appropriate ordinances to abate the
nuisance, and to enforce the same after the expiration of the two years
named in their charter. The grant of power was ample, and its
212 -—s exercise was only suspended for the limited period as to appel-
lants and the other company, and when the time expired all
impediments to its exercise was removed. Inasmuch, then, as the
charter of appellants did not authorize them to create a nuisance, but
only to exercise their franchise so as not to injure community, the
authorities refer’ed to are not applicable to the case. The cases re-
fered to in reference to the erection of mills may be regarded as
necessarily producing the nuisences of which complaint was made,
and as an implied authority by the legislature to maintain the
nuisance. But even if it were conceeded that the general assem-
bly has such power, those cases are not like this, as no
213. such power was granted by this charter; hence those cases
have no application. Had the legislative power been thus ex-
erted in the cases refer’ed to, and the courts had held that the owners
of the mills were nevertheless exempt, then the cases would have been
analogous, and would have demanded of us the determination whether
we would have yielded obedience to them as authority. It also follows
that the case of Dartmouth College v. Woodward, 4 Wheat., 518, and
the other cases announcing the same rule, have no application. We
have seen there was no contract between the State and appellants that
they might create and maintain this nuisance, and hence no rights
214. +=+derived by contract have been impaired. It is urged that rail-
roads in cities and towns are nuisances, but they are only exer-
cising their functions in thus operating them. If this be true—and we
doubt not they may be so operated as to make them such—still the gen-
eral assembly has in many instances, long after their charters were
granted and the roads were constructed, enacted laws regulating the
speed of trains in cities and towns, or confer’ed the power on such mu-
nicipalities to do thesame thing, and thus prevent the roads from becom-
ing a nuisance. Nor are we aware that this salutary exercise of the
police-power has ever been challenged. Its justnessand even
215 necessity has commended it to all, and it has not been questioned.
And this is a fair illustration of the exercise of the police-power
over bodies corporate. It ison the same principle that railroads are re-
quired to fence their tracks, sound a whistle or ring a bell at highway
crossings, and to come to a full stop before a train crosses another rail-
road. These and many other duties are imposed as being necessary for
the safety of the people and their property, and grow out of implied
power that the general assembly may restrain these bodies to promote
the safety of community as it may individuals.
After a careful examination of the record and an attentive con-
216 ___— sideration of the arguments filed in the case, we are unable to say
that the court below erred in rendering the decree it did, and it
must be affirmed.
Decree affirmed.

217 ~=And to wit: ;
In term-time after Sept. term, 1873.

REc. 245—7

98 N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL.

SEPT. 24th, A. D. 1874.
THE NORTHWESTERN ms aa COMPANY ) No. 457. Appeal from

; THE VILLAGE on tives Paux. Cook.

On this day came again the said parties, and the court having dili-
gently examined and inspected as well the record and proceedings afore-
said as the matters and things therein assigned for error, and being

now sufficiently advised of and concerning the premises, for that
218 it appears to the court now here that neither in the record and

proceedings aforesaid, nor in the rendition of the decree aforesaid,
is there anything erroneous, vicious, or defective, and that that record
is no error: Therefore, it is considered by the court that the decree
aforesaid be affirmed in all things and stand in full force and effect, not-
withstanding the said matters and things therein assigned for error.
And it is further considered by the court that the said appellee recover
of and from the said appellants its costs by it in this behalf expended,
and that it have execution therefor.

219 STATE OF ILLINOIS, ss:

I, Cairo D. Trimble, clerk of the supreme court in and for the
northern grand division ef the State of Illinois, do hereby certify the
above and foregoing to be a true, full, and complete copy of the record
and proceedings of a certain cause entitled in this court The North-
western Fertilizing Company against The Village of Hyde Park.

Witness my hand and the seal of said supreme court, at Ottawa, in
said State, this 3lst day of October, A. D. 1874.
[SEAL. | C. D. TRIMBLE.

220 Supreme Court of the United States.

THE NORTHWESTERN FERTILIZING COMPANY

v8.

THE VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK AND CHAUNCEY
M. Cady, W. E. Hale, A. D. Waldron, Lucius
G. Fisher, E. G. Clarke, M. Doyle, J. M. |
Barney, Lester Bradner, jr., and H. Vander- |
bilt, trustees of said village.

Of October term in the year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred
and seventy-four.

Afterwards, to wit, on the senend Monday of October, in this
221 same term, before the justices of the Supreme Court of the United
States, at the Capitol, in the city of Washington, comes the said
Northw estern Fertilizing Company, by Leonard Swett, its attorney, and
says that in the record and proceedings aforesaid there is manifest
error in this, to wit:
1. The said supreme court of the State of Illinois erred in affirming
the decree of the said circuit court of Cook County.
2. The said supreme court of the State of Lllinois erred in dismissing
wer bill of complaint of the plaintiff in error.
. The said supreme court of the State of Illinois erred in rendering
judgment in said cause for the defendants in error.
222 And the said Northwestern Fertilizing Company prays that

* + Pe Se ee

° Oe ee ee

N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL. 99

the judgment aforesaid may be reversed, annulled, and altogether held
for nought, and that it may be restored to all things it hath lost by

occasion of the said judgment.
LEONARD SWETT,
Attorney for Plaintiff in Error.
223 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA:
In the Supreme Court of the United States.

To the honorable David Davis, one of the judges of said court:

Your petitioner, the Northwestern Fertilizing Company, a corpora-
tion created and existing under the laws of the State of Illinois, respect-
fully represents that on the eleventh day of January, A. D. 1873, it filed
in the circuit court of Cook County and State aforesaid, on the chancery
side thereof, a bill of complaint setting forth, among other things, the
following, to wit:

That on the eighth day of March, A. D. 1867, an act passed by the leg-

islature of the State of Illinois became a law, by which, among
224 other things, the persons therein named, their successors, asso-
ciates, and assigns, were constituted a body corporate and politic,
with power of continual succession for the term of fifty years, by the
name of The Northwestern Fertilizing Company, and clothed with the
usual powers of corporate bodies. Said act also provided that the cap-
ital stock of the corporation should be fifty thousand dollars, with power
to increase the same to any sum not exceeding two hundred and fifty
thousand dollars. By said act also the corporation was authorized and
empowered to establish and maintain chemical and other works at the
place designated, for the purpose of manufacturing and converting dead
animals and other animal matter into an agricultural fertilizer
225 and other chemical products, by means of chemical, mechanical,
and other procesess.

It was further provided by this charter that the chemical works should
be located in Cook County, Illinois, within certain limits designated
therein, and that the corporation might maintain depots within the city
of Chicago for the purpose of receiving and carrying off any and all
offal, dead animals, and animal matter which it might buy or own, or
which might be delivered to it by the said authorities and other per-
sons. A copy of this charter was attached to the said bill of complaint
as an exhibit.

Your petitioner would farther show that it was also alleged that

on the thirteenth day of December, 1867, the corporate organ-
226 = ganization contemplated was perfected, and capital stock was
subscribed to the amount of fifty thousand dollars. A location
was selected within the limits designated by the charter for the purpose
of carrying on the business and carrying out the purposes of said cor-
portion. The site thus selected was within the limits of the village of
Hyde Park, in Cook County, Illinois. Buildings were erected upon said
site, and depots established in the city of Chicago, which depots were
for the purpose of receiving dead animals, oftal, and animal matter, and
the buildings were for the purpose of converting [such material] into
agricultural fertilizers.
Your petitioner would also show that said bill contained the
227 =~ averment that the capital stock was increased from fifty thousand
dollars to two hundred and fifty thousand dollars, which was

YR mn emp arena —

100 N. w. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET Al.

| fully paid up and invested by the corporation in land, buildings, depots,
: tracks, machinery, improvements in machinery and costly experiments
| for the purpose of carrying on the business authorized by said charter,
and carrying out the purpose of said corporate organization. That said
corporate organization had been continued and the business authorized
by the charter carried on by it at the site selected from the time the
corporation was organized as set forth therein.
It was further alleged in said bill that the immense packing inter-
ests of the city of Chicago, and the vast accumulation of offal
228 and animal matter incident to such business, rendered the forma-
tion of such a corporation a public necessity, and the only solu-
tion of the difficulty which had increased with the growth of the city
and its packing interests. That the site selected was the best suited
and the most appropriate for the carrying on of such business, and the
least offensive to the mass of the people of any which could be selected.
Said bill also avers that the complainant had carried on this business
in the best manner possible, and had made use of every tested improve-
ment for the purpose of lessening its offensive character.
The bill further alleged that your petitioner having become
229 duly organized under its charter, and having invested the full
sum of two hundred and fifty thousand dollars in the business
especially organized, and having enlarged its works so as to be able to
take off, utilize, and consume in a manner the most scientific known,
and with the least offensiveness to the publie, the offal and animal mat-
ter produced in the city of Chicago, it had a vested right, subject to
proper police-regulat’ons, to carry on said business for the period of
time named in said charter.

It was further alleged in said bill that the village of Hyde Park is a
municipal corporation created under the laws of the State of Illinois,

and embracing within its limits the establishment of your peti-

230 ~=tioner. That said municipal corporation and the trustees thereof,

named in said bill, colluding and combining with various parties

to your petitioner unknown, and pretending to exercise police authority

under the power given them by law to make all regulations that might

be necessary and expedient for the promotion of health and the sup-

pression of disease, had undertaken to interfere with, break up, and

utterly destroy your petitioner’s business, and prevent it from pursuing

the saine under its act of [in]corporation aforesaid, and had given out

and publicly declared that they would continue such interference until

~your petitioners should be driven out of the town and the privileges

guaranteed by its charter should be destroyed. That said unlaw-

231 ful combination and purpose was sought to be carried out and

enforced by said trustees and confederates under the pretence of

police regulations, and by virtue of such pretence said trustees had

passed, published, and were then trying to enforce the following ordi-
nance :

‘*No person shall transport, haul, or convey any offal, dead animals,.
or other unwholesome matter or material into or through the village of
Hyde Park, and any person who shall be in charge of or employed on
any train or team carrying or conveying any such matter or material
into or through the village of Hyde Park shall be subject to a fine of
not less than five or more than fifty dollars.”

It was further alleged in the said bill that your petitioner had

232 = established and maintained a depot [in the town of Lake} in the
city of Chicago for the reception of cffal and animal matter to be
conveyed to its factory at Hyde Park, and that it had been the custom

N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL. 101

of the petitioner to transport the offal and animal matter received at its
depot in tight box-cars, by the Pit’sburg & Fort Wayne Railroad, to the
place where the business was carried on as above set forth, and that the
route of said railroad passed through portions of the village compari-
tively without population.

It was also alleged in said petition | bill| that there was no way in which
the offal animal matter received by your petitioner at its depot could
be transported to its factory without hauling or transporting the same

into and through the village of Hyde Park, and that there was
233 noway in which the material could be hauled as aforesaid except

by the Pitsburg & Fort Wayne Railroad, and that there was no
way in which said business could be carried on without violating said
ordinanee; nor could said ordinance be obeyed without the utter aban-
donment of your petitioner’s business and the relinquishment of all its
rights conferred upon it by its charter.

Said bill also alleged that said ordinance had been passed by the
trustees of said village under the color of law, and was an unlawful at-
tempt, under the pretence of police-regulations, to prevent your peti-
tioner from receiving any supply of material at its factory, and to con-

vey away from your petitioner the privileges conferred by its
234 charter, and for no other purpose whatever.

It was further alleged in said bill that, pursuant to said com-
bination and conspiracy, the president of the board of trustees of said
village, on the 6th day of January, 1873, ofticially notified the assistant
general superintendant of said railroad in writing that he had been
direeted by said board of trustees rigidly to enforce the ordinances of
said village relating to nuisances, and that among the ordinances which
he had ordered the police-ofticers of said village to enforce was the ordi-
nance above quoted.

Said bill then stated that said board of trustees and its presi-
2355 dent and their confederates, immediately after giving the said

notice, caused the police of said village to be stationed near your
petitioner’s factory, with instructions to arrest under the ordinance any
and all employees of vour petitioner who should be found transporting
oftal by rail from its depots to its establishments; and on or about the
Sth day of January, 1873, while the engineer, conductor, and brakemen,
five in number, were engaged in running on said railroad and the side-
tracks to your petitioner’s works, a train of cars containing offal and
animal matter for your petitioner, for the purpose of being manufact-
ured in the manner aforesaid, and under the provisions of said charter, ,

said police-force arrested said employees and enforced them to leave
236 ~~ their train upon the side-track, and brought them under arrest

before a justice of the peace ot said village, about six miles dis-
tant from the train, for a pretended violation of said ordinance, by
whom they were fined for such pretended violation of the ordinance,
and that immediately upon the conclusion of such pretended trial said
police-force were ordered back to the side-track of your petitioner to
arrest the employees upon the next train which should arrive.

The bill further averred that your petitioner had permanent arrange-
ment/s| with said Pit’sburg & Fort Wayne Railroad, by which it furnished

cars and the railroad furnished engines and engineers, conduc-
237 tor-, and brakemen to run the same for the transportation of offal
and other material to its factory, and that said railroad would not
furnish engines and cars for that purpose if the men were constantly
arrested and their trains were to be left wherever the train arrest might
be made, and that the employees would not work upon said trains if

said ordinance was in [en}force/d].

102 N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL.

It was further alleged that the village of Hyde Park, through its
president and trustees, openly threatened to continue the said arrests
from day to day until they should utterly break up and destroy your
petitioner’s business; and the president and trustees openly avowed

that such was their object and determination; that such inter-
258 ference would break up its business, and it could not carry on
and continue the same unless said village of Hyde Park and its
officers should desist from or were restrained from making such arrests
and persisting in such interference; and that your petitioner feared
that said village would persist in and continue such arrests and inter-
ference unless restrained and prevented by judicial authority; and that
if such interference was persisted in it would result in an irremediable
injury and damage to your petitioner, and in effect would work a con-
fiseation of its property.
239 The bill also alleged & insisted that your petitioner’s rights,
privileges, & immunities herein set forth appertained & be-
longed to its shareholders as citizens of the United States, & that such
rights, privileges, & immunities were guaranteed to your petitioner &
its shareholders by the United States & the laws thereof. And that
the said village of Hyde Park & the trustees thereof were, by the means
above set forth, attempting to deprive your petitioner and its share-
holders of such rights, privileges, and immunities under and by virtue
of the ordinance hereinbefore set forth, contrary to the Constitution of
the United States and the laws thereof.

The bill prayed that the said village of Hyde Park, Chancey M. Cady,
a trustee and president of the board of trustees of the village. and his

associate trustees, W. E. Hale, A. D. Waldron, Lucius B. Fisher,

240 E.G. Clark, M. Doyle, J. M. Barny, Lester Bradner, jr., and H.

Vanderbuilt, and their confederates, might be made defendants to

said bill and required to answer the same; and that said village of Hyde

ark and its trustees and their agents might be restrained by an inju ne-

tion out of said circuit court from in any way or manner interfering

with, arresting, hindering, or disturbing your petitioner, or any person

by your petitioner employed, in carrying, hauling, or transporting, by

railroad or otherwise, any offal or animal matter from any of its depots

aforesaid to the locality of its works above described, or to said works,

or in manufacturing said material into an agricultural fertilizer or other

chemical product, or in any manner other prosecuting the business of

your petitioner under its act of incorporation; and that your peti-

241 tioner might have such other and further reiief in the premises

as might be agreeable to equity; and that the court would grant

to your petitioner the writ of summons and the writ of injunction, di-
rected to said defendants.

Your petitioner further shows that said bill having been filed, the said
circuit court thereupon ordered that a writ of injunction issue out of
said court, directed to said defendants, and commanding and enjoining
them in accordance with the prayer of said bill, and that sueh writ of
injunction was duly issued and served on said defendants.

Your petitioner further shows that afterwards, to wit, on the third
day of February, 1873, the said defendants filed their answer to said

bill, of which the tollowing is a summary:
242 Said answer admitted that your petitioner by said act of the
legislature became incorporated, and a copy of said act was at-
tached to said answer as an exhibit. The answer also admitted that
your petitioner had since been claiming to act under and by virtue of
its charter as a body-politic, and that depots and works were erected
and established by your petitioner as alleged in its bill.

N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL. 103

It was further alleged in the answer that the village of Hyde Park
succeeded to the police and sanitary powers conferred upon the town of
Hyde Park, and that by an act of the legislature of the State of Lilinois
entitled ‘‘An act to revise the charter of Hyde Park, 1n Cook County,” ap-

proved March 26th, 1869, giving full sanitary & police powers to the
243 ofticers of said town, in the 16th clause of the 18th section of said

act the following proviso was inserted: “ Provided, however, That
the sanitary and police powers conferred by this act shall not be exer-
cised by said board of trustees as against the Northwestern Fertilizing
Company or the Union Rendering Company, located at or near the Cal-
umet River, in said town, until the full expiration of two years from and
after the passage of this act.”

That pursuant to the powers and under the authority conferred by
said act, the board of trustees of said town did, on the 14th day of Feb-
ruary, 1870, adopt an ordinance declaring, among other things, that all
establishments for the steaming or rendering of lard, tallow, offal, or

such other substances as might be rendered, boiled, or steamed,
244 should be nuisances, and all establishments where any nauseous

or offensive business might be carried on were nuisances, and
providing that any person owning or using sach places should be sub-
ject to fine, and that any person who should deposit any dead animals
or offensive or nauseous substances upon any lot, street, or other place
in said town should also be subject to a fine.

It was further alleged that on the 29th day of November, 1872, an
ordinance was adopted by the president and board of trustees of the
village of Hyde Park, pursuant to the 75th, 78th, 83rd, & 96th clauses
of article 5th of an act entitled “An act to provide for the incorporation
of cities and villages,” approved April 10th, 1872, of the laws of the
State of Illinois, & in pursuance of which act it was alleged in the an-

swer, and by virtue thereof said village of Hyde Park had suc-
245 ceeded to and become vested with all the rights, powers, & priv-

ileges of the town of Hyde Park, and the powers and privileges
conferred by said last-mentioned act, which ordinance was set forth and
quoted at length in the answer, and contained, among other things, the
ordinance set forth in your petitioner’s bill, and also prohibited any per-
son from maintaining or carrying on any offensive business or establish-
ment within the limits of the village of Hyde Park, and for the sum-
inary abatement of any nuisance by the president of the board of trus-
tees.

The answer alleges and charges that your petitioner’s charter did not
exempt it from obedience to and compliance with the ordinances of the

village of Hyde Park, and that the police and sanitary powers
246 of said village extended to and included thereunder your peti-

tioner as well as citizens of said village, and that no exemption
from obedience to said ordinances was conferred upon your petitioner
by its charter, and that such ordinances were a proper exercise of the
powers conferred by the statutes of the State of Illinois upon the presi-
dent and trustees of the village of Hyde Park.

It is in their answer also denied that the said ordinances were in dero-
gation of the rights and privileges of your petitioner under its act of in-
corporation, or that your petitioner acquired any right to disregard the
regulations and ordinances of said village by virtue of its charter, and
insisted therein that the rights, privileges, and franchises conferred
upon your petitioner by its act of incorporation were no otheror greater
than existed by common law in every other inhabitant in the State of
Illinois.

104 N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL.

247 Your petitioner further shows that on the 30th day of January,
A. D. 1873, said cause was heard by said cireuit court upon the
bill, answer, and proofs taken therein, and the said circuit court denied to
the petitioner the relief prayed for in its bill of complaint, and dismissed
said bill out of said court ; and thereupon your petitioner prayed an ap-
peal in said cause from the order of said circuit court to the supreme
court of the State of Illinois, which was granted upon compliance by
your petitioner with the conditions of the order allowing such appeal.
Your petitioner further shows that afterwards said appeal to the su-
preme court of the State of Illinois was duly perfected, and on
248 =the 24th day of September, A. D. 1874, the said supreme court of
the State of Illinois rendered a judgment in said cause that the
| decree of said circuit court, denying to your petitioner the relief prayed
| for in its bill of complaint and dismissing the same, be affirmed.
| Your petitioner further shows that the supreme court of the State of
| Illinois is the highest court of law or equity in the State of Illinois in
| which a decision in said cause can be had; that the said judgement or
| decree of the said supreme court of Illinois is a final decree; that in
| said suit the validity of said act of incorporation of the town of
| Hyde Park, and of said act of incorporation of the village of
| Hyde Park, and of the said several ordinances adopted by the
i
|

town of Hyde Park and said village of Hyde Park by
249 virtue of said act of incorporation, and of the authority exer-
cised by the said village 9f Hyde Park under such acts of incor-
poration, were drawn in question on the ground that such acts of in-
corporation and said ordinances, and the authority exercised by the said
village of Hyde Park, and each of them, were repugnant to the Con-
stitution of the United States. And your petitioner avers that the said
decision of the said supreme court of the State of Illinois was in favor
of the validity of the said acts of incorporation, and of the said ordi-
nances, and of the said authority exercised by the said village of Hyde
Park.
Your petitioner further shows that in said suit rights, privileges,
and immunities under the Constitution of the United States were
250 ~=and are specially set up and claimed by your petitioner, and the
decision in said supreme court of the State of Illinois was against
the rights, privileges, and immunities so set up and claimed by your
petitioner.

Your petitioner further shows that the matters and things hereinbe-
fore set forth, and each and every of them, appear of record in said
cause in the supreme court of the State of Illinois, and a certitied copy
of such record is presented to your honor with this petition.

The premises considered, your petitioner prays that a writ of error
| may issue, directed to the supreme court of the State of Illinois, com-
| manding it to send the record and proceedings aforesaid, with
| 251 = all things concerning the same, to the Supreme Court of the

United States, at the next term thereof, and that the said de-
fendants to the said bili of complaint be cited to appear and answer to

said writ.

sarees

NORTHWESTERN FERTILIZING COMPANY,
ROBT. W. RALSTON, Vice-Pres.

252 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
Northern District of Illinois, 8s ;

Robert W. Ralston, being first duly sworn, on his oath says that he
is vice-president of the said petitioner, The Northwestern Fertilizing

ee E

+t sma

N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL. 105

Company, and hereto duly authorized ; that he has heard read the fore-
going petition, and knows the contents thereof, and that the same is
true in substance and in tact, except such matters as are therein stated
upon information and belief, and that as to those matters he believes it
to be true. -

ROBT. W. RALSTON.

Sworn and subscribed before me this 12th day of October, A. D. 1874.
WM. BRADDEY,
Clerk Cir. Court U. S., N. Dist. of Ills.

253 (Indorsed :) Supreme Court of the United States. The North-
western Fertilizing Company vs. The Village of Hyde Park et al.
Petition for writ of error.
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, 88:
On this petition writ of error is allowed, without supersedeas, on filing
bond for costs, &c., in penalty of [83,000] $500,
D. DAVY, Judge.

©. D. TRIMBLE, Clerk.

Filed Octr. 24, 1874.

9 o'clock a. m.

254 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, 88:

The United States of America to the honorable the judges of the
supreme court of the State of [llinois, greeting:

Because in the record and proceedings, and also in the rendition of
the judgment of a plea which is in the said supreme court of the State
of Illinois, before you, or some of you, being the highest court of law or
equity of the said State in which a decision could be had in the said
suit between The Northwestern Fertilizing Company and The Village of
Hyde Park, Chauncey M. Cady, W. E. Hale, A. D. Waldron, Lucius G,
Fisher, E. G. Clarke, M. Doyle, J. M. Barney, Lester Bradner, jr., and
H. Vanderbilt, wherein was drawn in question the validity of a statute
of, and the authority exercised under, said State of Illinois, on the
ground that they were repugnant to the Constitution or laws of the
United States, and the decision was in favor of such their validity, and

wherein rights, privileges, and immunities were claimed under the
255 Constitution of the United States, and the decision was against

the rights, privileges, and immunities specially set up and claimed
under such Constitution, and manifest error hath happened, to the great
damage of the said Northwestern Fertilizing Company, as by its com-
plaint appears, we, being willing that the error, if any hath been, should
be duly corrected, and full and speedy justice done to the parties afore-
said in this behalf, do command you, if judgment be therein given, that
then, under your seal, distinctly and openly, you send the record and
proceedings ‘aforesaid, with all things concerning the same, to the Su-
preme Court of the United States, together with the writ, so that you
may have the same at W ashington on the fourth Monday of October
instant, in the said Supreme Court to be then and there held, that, the
record of proceedings aforesaid being inspected, the said Supreme
Court may cause to be further done herein, to correct that error, what of
right and according to the laws and customs of the United States

should be done.
256 Witness the honorable Morrison R. Waite, Chief-Justice of the

ReEc. 245—8

106 N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL.

said Supreme Court, the fifteenth day of October, in the year of

our Lord one thousand eight hundred and seventy-four.
(SEAL. | WM. H. BRADLEY,
Clerk.

257 (Indorsed :) Supreme Court of the United States. The North-

western Fertilizing Company vs. The Village of Hyde Park et al.
Writ of error. Filed Octr. 24, 1874. C.D. Trimble, clerk. 9 o’clock
a. Mm.

257 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, 88:
To The Village of Hyde Park, Chauncey M. Cady, W. E. Hale, A.

D. Waldron, Lucius G. Fisher, E. G. Clarke, M. Doyle, J. M. Barney,

Lester Bradner, jr., and H. Vanderbilt, trustees of said village, greet-

ing:

You are hereby cited and admonished to be and appear at a Supreme
Court ofthe United States to be holden at Washington on the fourth
Monday of October instant, pursuant to a writ of error filed in the
clerk’s office of the supreme court of the State of [Illinois for the north-
ern grand division, wherein ° e Northwestern Fertilizing Company is
plaintiff in error and you are defendants in error, to show cause, if any
there be, why the judgment in the said writ of error mentioned should
not be corrected and speedy justice should not be done to the parties
in that behalf.

Witness the honorable David Davis, one of the justices of the Su-

preme Court of the United States, this sixteenth day of October,
258 ~—=sin the year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred and seventy-

four.
DAVID DAVIS,
One of the Justices of the Supreme Court of the United States.

259 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
Northern District of Illinois, ss :

John J. Herrick, being first duly sworn, on his oath says that he
served the within citation on the within-named defendants in error this
24th day of October, A. D. 1874, by delivering a true copy of the same
to Messrs. Hitchcock & Dupee, attorneys and solicitors of record for
said defendants in error in said supreme court of the State of Illinois,
and also by delivering a true copy of the same to Edmund E. Ryan, one
of the trustees of said village of Hyde Park.

JOHN J. HERRICK.

([Indorsed:) Sapreme Court of the United States. The North-
western Fertilizing Company vs. The Village of Hyde Park etal. Cita-
tion.

We hereby accept service of the within citation by a true copy of the

same delivered to us this 24th day of October, A. D. 1874.
Attorneys for Defendants in Error.

Filed Octr. 24, 1874.
©. D. TRIMBLE, Clerk.

2 o’clock p. m.

Subscribed & sworn to before me Oct. 24, 1874.
E. A. DRUMM, U. S. Com.

N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK ET AL. 107
260 Supreme Court of the United States.

THE NORTHWESTERN FERTILIZING COMPANY

v8.

THE VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK AND CHAUNCEY
M. Cady, W. E. Hale, A. D. Waldron, Lucius
G. Fisher, E. G. Clarke, M. Doyle, J. M. Barney,
Lester Bradner, jr., and H. Vanderbilt, trus-
tees of said village.

Know all men by these presents that we, The Northwestern Fertiliz-
ing Company and Richard C. Meldrum and Robert W. Ralston, are held
and firmly bound unto The Village of Hyde Park and Chauncey M.
Cady, W. E. Hale, A. D. Waldron, Lucius G. Fisher, E. G. Clarke, M.
Doyle, J. M. Barney, Lester Bradner, jr., and H. Vanderbilt in the sum
of five hundred dollars, to be paid to the said Village of Hyde Park,
Chauncey M. Cady, W. E. Hale, A. D. Waldron, Lucius G. Fisher, E.

G. Clarke, M. Doyle, J. M. Barney, Lester Bradner, jr., and H.
261 Vanderbilt, their executors or administrators, to which payment,

well and truly to be made, we bind ourselves, and each of us,
jointly and severally, by these presents, and each of our heirs, executors,
and administrators, firmly by these presents, sealed with our seals and
dated this sixteenth day of October, A. D. one thousand eight hundred
and seventy-four.

Whereas the above-named The Northwestern Fertilizing Company
late prosecuted a writ of error to the Supreme Court of the United
States to reverse the judgment rendered in the above-entitled action by
the supreme court of the State of Illinois:

Now, therefore, the condition of the above obligation is such, that if
the above bounden, the Northwestern Fertilizing Company, shall prose-
cute its said writ of error to effect, and answer all costs if it shall fail
to make good its plea, then this obligation shall be void; otherwise to

remain in fall force and virtue.

262 (Signed) NORTHWESTERN FERTILIZING Co., (SEAL.]
R. W. RALSTON, V. Pres.
SEAL OF THE RICHARD C. MELDRUM. [SEAL.
NORTHWESTERN ROBERT W. RALSTON. [SEAL.
FERTILIZING C’.
Attest:

(Signed) H. W. Raston, Sec’t’y.

Taken & approved by—
(Signed) DAVID DAVIS,
Judge, &c.

OCTOBER 16TH, 1874.

STATE OF ILLINOIS, ss:

I, Cairo D. Trimble, clerk of the supreme court in and for the northern
grand division of the State of Illinois, do hereby certify the above and
foregoing to be a true copy of a bond for costs in a certain cause en-
titled in this court The Northwestern Fertilizing Company vs. The Vil-
lage of Hyde Park, which bond aforesaid was filed in this office on the
24th day of September, A. D. 1874. ;

Witness my hand and the seal of said supreme court, at Ottawa, in

said State, this 3lst day of October, A. D. 1874.
[SEAL.] C. D. TRIMBLE, Clerk.

108 N. W. FERTILIZING CO. VS. VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK Ef AL.

(Indorsed:) Copy. Supreme Court of the United States. The North-
. western Fertilizing Company vs. The Village of Hyde Park et al. Bond
for costs. Filed Octr. 24,1874. ©. D. Trimble, clerk. 9 o’clock a. m.

(Indorsement on cover:) No. 245. The Northwestern Fertilizing
Company, plaintiff in error, vs. The Village of Hyde Park, Chaun-
cey M. Cady, W. E. Hale, A. D. Waldron, L. G. Fisher, E. G.
Clarke, M. Doyle, J. M. Barney, L. Bradner, & H. Vanderbilt, trustese
of said village. Illinois sup. ct. Filed 27th November, 1874.

oO

*)

SUPREME (Court OF THE [J ee

——--ofo - --—

THE NORTHWESTERN FERTILIZING CO.,

vs.

THE VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK.

POINTS, AUTHORITIES AND ARGUMENT

FOR APPELLANTS.

BY

LEONARD SWETT.

CHICAGO :
PRESS OF BEACH, BARNARD & CO. LEGAL PRINTERS, NO. 104 RANDOLPH STREET.

1878.

P iu PSR MRL EAE OSE ceiieaeiaa

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.

~~ of ———
THE NORTHWESTERN FERTILIZING COMPANY

THE VILLAGE OF HYDE PARK.

Points AND AUTHORITIES FOR APPFLLANT

The appellant was authorized by its charter:

1. To establish and mazntain works for the purpose of man-

into a fertilizer.

WHICH WOULD RENDER A REPEALING LAW INVALID, THERE
HAS IN FACT BEEN NO REPEAL OF ITS CHARTER. j
| 1. Lhe charter of the Town of Hyde Park, passed in 1869,
beine a grant of general power conferred in general terms did
i not repeal or abrogate the appellant's special charter.
The doctrine of repeal by implication is not favored by the
law, and is never resorted to except where the repugnance or
opposition is too clear and plain to be reconciled.
' : ae
Bruce v. Schuyler, 4 Gilm., 372.
Supervisor v. Campbell, 42 Uls., 492.
flume v. Gossett, 43 Ills., 299.
People v. Barr, 44 Ills., 201. .
A subsequent law which 1s general, does not repeal or abro- ;
gate a former one which its special. e@
_ State v. Minton, 3 Zab., 529.
State v. Fersey City, 5 Dutch, 179.
®

—-=*»

aes

3

Tracy v. Goodwin, 5 Allen, 409.
Town of Ottawa v. County of LaSalle, 12 Ms.,

339-

If without the proviso inserted in the charter of 1869, that
charter and appellant’s charter could be so construed as to be rec-
onciled ; the addition of that proviso does not in any way impair
the rights of appellant.

First. It was clearly inserted for appellant’s benefit, and will
nut be so construed as to operate to its injury.

7 yson v. Posthelwaite, 13 Mls., 727.
Raym., 397.
Hob., 215.

hroone v. Fultet, 1 Scam., 258.

Second. This proviso should be construed as a limitation
upon such powers as the Town of Hyde Park could lawfully
exercise as against appellant, notwithstanding its charter, and
not as a recognition of any right to entorce other powers.

° Third. This proviso is not an affirmative enactment, but is
merely a limitation, and such a limitation having expired, the
original act to which it is attached is to be construed in the

‘same light as though such limitation had never existed.

2. The rule of construction that a subsequent general law. does
not repeal a former special law, applies with even greater force
to the general law, under which the Village of Hyde Park ts

now organized.

ITT.

Ir THESE LAWS COULD BE SO CONSTRUED AS TO EXPRESS
AN INTENTION TO QUALIFY THE AUTHORITY CONFERRED BY
APPELLANT'S CHARTER, THEY ARE MERE GRANTS OF POWER

TO CHANGE THE LAW, AND DO NOT ipso facto WORK A REPEAL.

Eaton v. Graham, 1 Ills., 619.

"f

1

|

iV.

Ir THE LEGISLATURE HAS DELEGATED TO THE TOWN OR
VILLAGE OF HypE PARK THE POWER TO REPEAL THE APPEL-
LANT’S CHARTER, THERE HAS BEEN NO EXERCISE OF THAT
POWER.

1. The ordinances which the town or village of Hyde Park

have passed are general ordinances, and they will not be con-
strued as repealing uppellant’s special charter.

2. The particular ordinance in question is unreasonable, and
therefore void, and can not have the effect of repealing a law.

Austin v. Murray, 16 Pick., 121.

3. The ordinances passed by the town of Hyde Park were
passed at a time when tt was expressly prohibited by its charter

Jrom exercising ts sanitary or police powersas against the appel-

lant. F

V.

THE APPELLANT'S CHARTER IS A CONTRACT WITH THE
STATE, AND THE LEGISLATURE HAVE NO POWER TO REPEAL,
IMPAIR OR ALTER IT.

The general princtple that charters of incorporation are con-
tracts within the meaning of the Federal Constitution, is settled
beyond controversy.

Dartmouth College v. Woodward, 4 Wheat., 518.
Armstadt et al. v. Ill. Cen. R. R., 31 Mi.
Buffett et al.v. The Great West. R. R., 25 Il.,

355:

State Bank of Ohio v. Knoop, 6 How., 360.

o
Sef. Branch Bank v. Skelly, 1 Bl., 436.
Bridge Prop. v. Hoboken Co., 1 Wall., 116.
Binghamton Bridge Case, 3 Wall., 51.
Home of Friendless v. Rouse, 8 Wall., 430.
Wash. University v. Rouse, Ibid., 439.

The State, by adopting the Federal Constitution, voluntarily
tmposed certain limitations upon the exercise of its sovereign
powers, and cannot, in the exercise of the police power, or any
other power, pass a law which impairs the obligation of tts con-
tracts.

The appelant’s charter ts a contract.

1st. The Legislature has conferred upon it a charter, which,
under the principle of the Dartmouth College, clearly express
an intention to contract.

2d. It is a contract with mutual considerations.

3d. The Legislature had ample power to make such a con-
tract.

The Legislature possesses all of the powers of parliament,
and is sovereign, except so far as those powers are limited by
the National and State constitutions.

The power of parliament is absolute and uncontrolled, and it
can do everything that is not naturally impossible.
4 Co. Inst., 86.
1 Black. Com., 160.

The Legislature possesses the same power, except as it may
have been limited by the State or Federal constitutions, and a
legislative act cannot be declared void, unless its conflict with
one of these two instruments can be pointed out.

Cooley Const. Limit., 172.

Field v. People, 2 Scam., 81.
People v. Marshall, t Gilm., 572.
People ex rel.v. Salomon, 57 Ills., 50.

6 |

Courts can not declare a law void on general grounds, be-
caus

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Aper_scotus_1878_5%3A0. Public record. Not legal advice.
