# Joint Appendix — Boeing Co., The v. United States, (2009) (No. 1302)

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA43085015_0591%3A08

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Joint Appendix
- **Published:** January 1, 2009

## Text

Nos. 09-1298 & 09-1302

™

LN THE

Supreme Court of the Ruiter Ste

‘areme Coun, U.S.

* ov 12 2010

OFFICE OF THE CLERK

GENERAL DYNAMICS CORPORATION.

Petitioner.
Vv.
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
Respondent.

THE BOEING COMPANY,

Petitioner,
Vv.
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
Respondent.

On Writ Of Certiorari To The
United States Court Of Appeals
For The Federal Circuit

JOINT APPENDIX
VOLUME I

CHARLES J. COOPER
Counsel of Record
MICHAEL W. KIRK

HOWARD C. NIELSON, JR.

DAVID LEHN

COOPER & KIRK, PLLC

1325 New Hampshire
Avenue, N.W.
Washington, DC 20036

(202) 220-9600
ccooper@cooperkirk.com

Counsel for The Boeing
Company

PETETIONS FOR CERTIORARI FILED APRIL 23, 2010
CERTIORARI GRANTED SEPTEMBER 238, 2010

PAUL M. SMITH

Counsel of Record
DAVID A. CHURCHILL
ELAINE J. GOLDENBERG
JENNER & BLOCK LLP
1099 New York Avenue. NW
Suite 900
Washington, DC 20001
(202) 639-6000
psmith@jenner.com

Counsel for General Dynamics
Corporation

59

J. MICHAEL LUTTIG

EXECUTIVE VICE PRESIDENT
& GENERAL COUNSEL

GRANT M. DIXTON

LYNDA GUILD SIMPSON

THE BOEING COMPANY

100 North Riverside

Chicago, Il. 60606

(312) 544-2800

Counsel for The Boeing
Company

NEAL KUMAR KATYAL
ACTING SOLICITOR GENERAL
Counsel of Record
TONY WEST
ASSISTANT ATTORNEY GENERAL
JEANNE E. DAVIDSON
BRYANT G. SNEE
KIRK TT. MANHARDT
PATRICIA M. MCCARTHY
ATTORNEYS
UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT
OF JUSTICE
950 Pennsylvania Avenue,
N.W.
Washington, DC 20530
(202) 514-2217
SupremeCtBriefs@usdoj.gov

PAUL L. OOSTBURG SANZ
GENERAL COUNSEL
THOMAS N. LEDVINA
WENDELL A. KJOS
ATTORNEYS

Department of the Navy
Washington, D.C. 20350

Counsel for The United States

INDEX

Volume 1

Relevant Docket Entries, McDonnell Douglas

Corp. v. United States, No. 1:91-cv-01204-
Et aR Sane aie See ae eT }

Relevant Docket Entries, McDonnel/ Douglas

Corp. v. United States, No. 1998-5096 (Fed.
+ 8 TEESE. SAPS te YER eho OES Ae ndd 2, Oe OEP 41

Relevant Docket Entries, McDonne/l/] Douglas

Corp. v. United States, No. 2002-5034 (Fed.
as, 42

Relevant Docket Entries, McDonnell] Douglas

Corp. v. United States, No. 2007-5111 (Fed.
ERSTE ive EE Oe Varo Pee eR Rr eI EEE 43

Memorandum From Eleanor Spector, Deputy

Assistant Secretary Of Defense
(Procurement), To Under Secretary Of
Defense For Acquisition (Jan. 5, 1988) ............... 44

A-12 Full Scale Engineering Development

Contract, excerpts (Jan. 13, 1998)

SET TITIEisssnhdiscicadrsehesomnnuniianlibaaiiiatianmewassdenamnionness 47
NER Te RTE ERI OEE 48
Section B — Supplies Or Services ........................ 49
Section C — Description Or Specifications
Io sctatiabeasenupmeswensougns 54
a a ee 73
ERIE a SA gre oe ena sar ON? 77
IL ceeuuiannsnnaseanpeseranenaenscens 82

Progress Payments Clause (Deviation)............. 111

Attachment 34° -- Contract Security
Classified Specification ...............cccccccceeeeeeees

Attachment 36 -— Government [Furnished
SII siccon- sch acionsideiadenta weaialediaauaunietdaiimenndeniiasseaies

Attachment 45 -— Security Implementation
SI adesieadicuhtiniietnainnapinbietbadunaiwudededamedenmtddanetinites

FAR 52.249-2 Termination For Convenience
Of The Government (Fixed-Price) (1984)..........

FAR 52.249-8 Default (Fixed-Price Supply And
NI ells

FAR 52.249-9 Default (Fixed-Price Kesearch
And Development) (1984) .0000....0..cccccccceececceees

A-12 Program Review (June 13, 1990)...................

Letter From John F. McDonnell, Chairman
And Chief Executive Officer, McDonnell
Douglas Corp., And Stanley CC. Pace,
Chairman And Chief Executive Officer,
Genera! Dynamics Corp. To H. Lawrence
Garrett, Secretary Of The Navy (June 27,
SARE ates Lk Berle SMA LON oe ARO OOmeD

The Navy's A-12 Alurcraft Program: Joint
Hearing Before Procurement & Military
Nuclear Sys. Subcomm., Research &
Development Subcomm., and
Investigations Subcomm. of the H. Comm.
on Armed Services, 10) Cong. 76°77 (Dec.
10, 1990) (Statement Of H. Lawrence
Garrett, Secretary Of The Navy).................0.....

Minutes Of A-12 Meeting With Contractors

ne tsa Sak dae se

223
227

237

TP

Minutes Of A-12 Meeting With Contractors

(Dec. 21, 1990) .....00000... OE area eee

Letter From Roger J. Witte, Vice President,
McDonnell Douglas Corp., And George
Kostohryz, Vice President, General
Dynamics Corp., To Rear Admiral W. R.

Morris, Dep't Of The Navy Wan. 2, 1991)...

Minutes Of A-12 Meeting With Contractors,

10:00 (Jan. 2. 1991)... ee. ee ee

Minutes Of A-12 Meeting With Contractors,

Ey 0, TD... cicsucveceevecescevcecguemmenssuss

Minutes Of A-12 Meeting With Contractors,
a NIL: Sil IIe cireracsiennesiuvineass meses asciaeeee

Minutes Of A-12 Meeting With Contractors,

UNNI: We IE eaitiivcs ceetscasiinnsnenanctsinscncasirwaeans

Minutes Of A-12 Meeting With Contractors,

CD Geis, BD BORD. vnicccsvcoccccveccoccccessvenccccsssssc:

Letter From Rear Admiral W. RK. Morris, Dept
Of The Navy, ‘To George Kostohryz, Vice
President, General Dynamics Corp., And
Roger J. Witte, Vice President, McDonnell

Douglas Corp. (Jan. 7, 1991) .....0000.0. ee, -

Memorandum For The Contract File, From
Rear Admiral W. R. Morris, Dep't Of The

ge a” ene ee

Memorandum From Herbert J. Lanese, Senior
Vice President, McDonnell! Douglas Corp.,
To Eleanor Spector, Deputy Assistant

Secretary Of Defense Wan. 29, 1991) 0000000...

209

272

279

240)

2YQH

301

306

313

319

ee

~*

1V
Letter From Rear Admiral W. R. Morris, Dep't
Of The Navy, To George Kostohryz, Vice

President, General Dynamics Corp., And
Roger J. Witte, Vice President, McDonnell

Douglas Corp. (Feb. 5, 1991) ...............00:cceeeeee. 339
Deferment Agreement (Feb. 5, 1991) ..........000cc00. 342
Opinion And Order (Fed. Cl. Feb. 20, 1992) .......... 349

Defendant’s Motion To Dismiss Plaintiffs’
Claims Related To “Superior Knowledge”
In Alleged Other Low Observable Weapons
Programs, excerpt page 6 (Fed. Cl. Apr. 1,

aaa mp 5 CAE REE Py Rech Ea RO A a 373
Declaration Of Peter C. Eames (Fed. Cl. Sept.

a et ne Ae Beat aR ie A ORAS One 376
Declaration Of Secretary Of The Air Force

Donald B. Rice (Fed. Cl. Nov. 20, 1992)............ 383
Order And Opinion (Fed. Cl. Nov. 23, 1992).......... 388

Volume II
Second Amended Unclassified Complaint (Fed.

Ce es ccptanusen 395
oo Se een 478
Transcript (Fed. Cl. Mar. 23, 1993).................c0008 480
OS EEO eS a nr ap ie Ee 503

Defendant’s Motion For A Protective Order
(Includes Declaration Of The Acting
Secretary Of The Air Force Michael B.
Donley) (Fed. Cl. Mar. 30, 1993) .........0.0.0....00. 504

Order (Fed. Ci. Apr. 16, 1909) ..............00....0000.02..... 524

Vv

In re United States, Order On Petition For
Writ Of Mandamus (Misc. No. 370) (Fed.

taal
Order (Fed. Cl. Apr. 30, 1903) ............0...-scccccseceseee

In re Unites States, Order On Petition For
Writ Of Mandamus (Misc. No. 374) (Fed.

I i oc sacscasassciasadesansasaiens
Order (Fed. Cl. May 7, 1993) ............ccccccccccceseeseees

Defendant’s Motion To Dismiss Plaintiffs’
“Superior Knowledge” Claims, Or In The
Alternative, For Partial Summary
Judgment, And Motion For A Protective

Order (Fed. Cl. May 27, 1993)............0.0.0.0.008.
Opinion & Order (Fed. Cl. June 21, 1993) ...........

Defendant's Supplement To Motion To
Dismiss Plaintiffs’ “Superior Knowledge”
Claims (Includes Declaration Of The
Acting Secretary Of The Air Force Merrill

A. McPeak) (Fed. Cl. July 23, 1993) 0000000000000...
Order (Fed. Cl. Aug. 11, 1993)...............ccccceeceeeees

Declaration Of Albert P. Farr III (Fed. Cl.

a

Declaration Of S. Keith Jackson, Jr. (Fed. Cl.

Ce dann

Defendant's Brief In Support Of Its Motion To
Dismiss Plaintiffs’ “Superior Knowledge”
Claims, And Response To The Court’s
Order Dated November 1, 1993, excerpt

pages 1-31 (Fed. Cl. Nov. 19, 1993) .........00000...

.. 026

.. 002

.. 022

..626

Vv)

Defendant's Opposition To Plaintiff's Motion
For Summary Judgment On Count IX, And
Motion To Dismiss Or In The Alternative
Cross Motion For Summary Judgment,
excerpt pages iii, 1-2, 12°35 (Fed. Cl. Dec.
RSIS REA IOE SDs dln preteen ts Mies Rn 735

oa Be ee ” eee meena 768

Defendant's Motion For Leave To File
Response To The Court’s Order To Show
Cause, And Response To Order To Show

Cause (Fed. Cl. Mar. 7, 1904)..............c.0...c0000 771

- Order (Fed. Cl. Apr. 28, 1994) o.ccccccccccccccscesesveseeeeee 787
ee re Ge, Tom, Te BOI oon Seciccsscssicasecodsacdasasseree 791
og ie ay Se | epee 793

Defendant's Response To Plaintiffs’ Status
Reports Concerning Superior Knowledge
And The Order Of Proof At Trial, excerpt
pages i, iv, 1-2, 12-21, and appendix (Fed.
Ra Se si iccocensscpaiaasiipllonivadeunsinercenvectia 797

Judgment (Fed. Cl. Mar. 31, 1998)...........0000....0005. 884
Volume III

Brief For Defendant-Appellant United States,
excerpt pages iil, 37-48 (Fed. Cir. June 15,
SSIS GARBER try er ve pry Oe 886

Reply/Cross-Appellee Brief For Defendant-
Appellant United States, excerpt pages 1,
18-30 (Fed. Cir. Sept. 28, 1998)......................... 904

Vil
Defendant's Statement Of Issues And Notice

Of Probable Testifying Experts For Trial,
excerpt pages 1, 15-25 (Fed. Cl. July 11,

NINN cis sealstiies hasenenntiansaunmteuscsearecapcacelmedaaaennenten

Plaintiffs’ Response To “Defendant's
Statement Of Issues And Notice Of
Probable Testifying Experts For Trial,”
excerpt pages 1-2, 14-16 (Fed. Cl. July 25,

I iasistat tieatsienhtnantidenlaenssedvereniiddudhapiaageldanceatiogns

Transcript, excerpt pages 1-2, 72:18°81:7 (Fed.

ee I os cis Seuaunsciluescseanens

Transcript excerpt pages 1-2, 53:1-58:17 (Fed.

IE Oe I hic. icine scncenesleennenipuicapientonsestens

Defendant's Notice Of An £y Parte Filing In
Connection With Plaintiffs’ 29" And 30%
Sets Of Discovery Requests (Includes
Declaration Of The Secretary Of The Air
Force F. Whitten Peters) (Fed. Cl. Feb. 7,

sR A SRST ee Aa ela acer Neko eee
Opinion And Order (Fed. C]. Mar. 1, 2001).........

Plaintiffs’ Statement Of Issues And Legal
Standards For Trial, excerpt pages 1-4

I I coe ec ecedeccacduensaens

Transcript, excerpt pages 1-2, 74:13-79:21

Sr Oe I I cca incenspsinssieceennpsenimicnauas

Defendant’s Brief Regarding Effects Of State
Secrets And Motion For Reconsideration,
excerpt pages iii, vii-viii, 1-39 (Fed. Cl.

occa sicasls sap csusncunaiaenianacmsseaticies

.. 938

..944

... 960

ooo OES
... 983

.. 994

Vill
Appendix To Defendant’s Brief Regarding
Effects Of State Secrets And Motion For
Reconsideration Volume I Of IV, excerpt
pages 2, 33-35, 37, 69, 73-74, 79 (Fed. Cl.
I a surnsnsbussandabinmnies 1063

Appendix To Defendant's Brief Regarding
Effects Of State Secrets And Motion For
Reconsideration Volume II Of IV, excerpt
pages 104-06, 172-76, 179 (Fed. Cl. Mar.
C2 5 cscpiiioumindslaitimeebasteinneennt 1079

Appendix To Defendant’s Brief Regarding
Effects Of State Secrets And Motion For
Reconsideration Volume III Of IV, excerpt
pages 208, 213-15, 217-18, 243-48, 251-53,

255, 291-95 (Fed. C). Mar. 28, 2001)............... 1095

Appendix To Defendant's Brief Regarding
Effects Of State Secrets And Motion For
Reconsideration Volume IV Of IV, excerpt
pages 307, 311, 317, 322, 336, 342-43, 351-
52, 353-64, 369-74, 685-86 (Fed. Cl. Mar.

Ne se oeak cemreuanuaeni 1124
Transcript, excerpt pages 1°3, 42:5-47:13,

54:21-63°6 (Fed. Cl. Apr. 23, 2001).........0000..... 1211
Order (Fed. Cl. Apr. 27, 2001) ...........00cccccceeeeeeeeee 1233
Transcript, excerpt pages 89, 92, 166, 191-92

SP ks NN Ws i sesicinisssveencincvsapeerescccereenss 1237
Transcript, excerpt pages 4848, 4851-59, 4868-

72 (Fed. Cl. June 15, 2001) ..........................000 1243
Judgment (Fed. Cl. Aug. 31, 2001)... 1262

Order (Fed. Cl. Oct. 4, 2001)... eee 1263

ix
Brief For Defendant-Appellee-Cross-

Appellant, excerpt pages i-1n, 16-21, 52-70
RIP, GU. I STD oo icceccscicesccevstscecsovseses 1265

Judgment (Fed. Cl. May 3, 2007) ..............cccceceeeee 1293

xX

NOTICE

The following documents have been omitted in the
printing of this Appendix. They may be found in the
No. 09-1298 Petitioner's Appendix at the following
pages:
Appendix A

McDonnell Douglas Corp. v. United States,

567 F.3d 1340 (Fed. Cir. 2009) .........000..:ccccecceeeeees la

Appendix B
McDonnell Douglas Corp. v. United States,
FO FOG. Ce. BE GD ovcictesesosnntnndcinvczecnunntananen 35a

Appendix C
McDonnell Douglas Corp. v. United States,
323 F.3d 1006 (Fed. Cir. 2003) ............cccseeeeees 178a

Appendix D
McDonnell Douglas Corp. v. United States,
OD Pee. Ga, DHE GEE vsccescvsnicsnsccconsssactanaaee 212a

Appendix E
McDonnell Douglas Corp. v. United States,
182 F.3d 1319 (Fed. Cir. 1999) ............ ce eeeeeees 250a

Appendix F
McDonnell Douglas Corp. v. United States,

4B Dad. Ch. GRD CIID vcs scvcrestiicnvmmseae 280a
Appendix G

McDonnell Douglas Corp. v. United States,

ST FOG, Co. BI CI vcevsiesesssissidinceecnee 343a

Appendix H
McDonneil Douglas Corp. v. United States,
35 Fed. Cl. 368 (1QBG) ............ccsecccccscesesecsccsesesss 382a

xl
Appendix I
McDonnell Douglas Corp. v. United States,

ES UE ID... .rccococcesovscevecorercesece 430a
Appendix J

Order denying rehearing, McDonnei/

Douglas Corp. v. United States, No. 2007-

5111 (Fed. Cir. Nov. 24, 2009) .............cccccccccce- 444a

Appendix K

Statutory and Regulatory Provisions
edo cidcnunecnncvnsccenivexevarecveceees 446a

1
Relevant Docket Entries

United States Court of Federal Claims

MCDONNELL DOUGLAS, et al v. USA
CIVIL DOCKET FOR CASE #: 1:91-cev-01204-RHH

DATE # DOCUMENT
06/07/1991 | 1 Complaint.
| 08/07/1991 Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss.

08/14/1991 Defendant's Motion for the
Designation of a Court Security
Officer and Alternate Court Security
Officers.

08/15/1991 Order.

08/22/1991 Notice of Filing of Classified
Supplement to Complaint.

09/06/1991 Hearing Transcript.

09/12/1991 Plaintiffs’ Motion for Leave to Amend
Complaint and Amended Complaint.

09/13/1991 Hearing Transcript.

09/16/1991 Plaintiffs’ Opposition to Defendant’s
Motion to Dismiss.

09/16/1991 Defendant’s Response to Plaintiffs
Motion for Leave to Amend
Complaint.

09/16/1991 Order.

DATE
10/07/1991

11/22/1991

12/04/1991

12/18/1991
12/18/1991
12/19/1991

12/20/1991

01/09/1992

01/10/1992

E:
|

2

DOCUMENT

Defendant's Reply to Plaintiffs’
Opposition to Motion to Dismiss and
Appendix.

Defendant’s Motion for Leave to File
a Supplemental Brief in Support of
Its Motion to Dismiss (Brief
Attached).

Plaintiffs’ Motion for a Protective
Order Regarding Classified
Information and Memorandum in
Support of Plaintiffs’ Motion for a
Protective Order Regarding
Classified Information.

Hearing Transcript.
Order.

Defendants’ Motion for Leave to File
Declaration of Peter Eames.

Defendant's Cross-Motion for a
Protective Order Regarding
Classified Information.

Plaintiffs’ Opposition to Defendant’s
Cross-Motion and Reply to
Defendant's Opposition to Plaintiffs’
Motion for a Protective Order
Regarding Classified Information.

Plaintiffs’ Response to Court’s Draft
of Joint Protective Order Governing
Classified Information.

3
DATE ca DOCUMENT

01/10/1992 Defendant’s Response to Court’s
Draft of Joint Protective Order
Governing Classified Information.

02/20/1992 Opinion and Order Denying
Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss.

03/20/1992 Defendant’s Answer and Affirmative
Defenses.

04/01/1992 Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss

Plaintiffs’ Claims Related to
“Superior Knowledge” in Alleged
Other Low Observable Weapons
Programs and Notice of Classified
Filing in Support Thereof.

04/09/1992 Plaintiffs’ Motion to Strike
Affirmative Defenses or for a More
Definite Statement of the Affirmative
Defense of Setoff.

04/22/1992 Defendant’s Response to Plaintiffs’
Motion to Strike Affirmative
Defenses or for a More Definite
Statement of the Affirmative Defense
of Setoff.

DATE
05/01/1992

05/01/1992

05/04/1992
03/08/1992
05/22/1992

03/22/1992

06/02/1992

06/03/1992

4
DOCUMENT

Plaintiffs Brief in Response to
Defendant's Motion to Dismiss
Plaintiffs’ Claims Related to
“Superior Knowledge” in Alleged
Other Low Observable Weapons
Programs and Notice of Filing of
Classified Appendix in Support
Thereof.

Plaintiffs Motion for Leave to
Commence Discovery on Superior

Knowledge Counts.

Hearing Transcript.

Notice of Filing of Classified Brief.

Defendant's Reply to Plaintiffs
Opposition to Defendant’s Motion to
Dismiss Plaintiffs’ Claims Related to
“Superior Knowledge” in Alleged
Other Low Observable Weapons

| Programs.

Defendant's Opposition to Plaintiff's
Motion for Leave to Commence
Discovery on Supenior Knowledge
Counts.

Plaintiffs’ Reply to Defendant’s
Opposition to Plaintiffs Motion for

Leave to Commence Discovery on
Superior Knowledge Counts.

Notice of Classified Filing.

DATE

06/08/1992
06/15/1992
06/16/1992
07/16/1992
07/24/1992

, 07/28/1992

08/06/1992

08/07/1992
08/10/1992
08/12/1992

09/08/1992

D
DOCUMENT
Hearing Transeript.
Hearing Transcript.
Order.
Order.
Defendant’s Motion for a Protective

Order Regarding Discovery on
“Superior Knowledge.”

Plaintiffs’ Motion for Entry of an
Order Governing Superior Knowledge
Discovery and Brief in Opposition to
Defendant's Motion for a Protective
Order Regarding Discovery on
“Superior Knowledge.”

Defendant's Reply to llaintiffs’
Opposition to Defendant's Motion for
a Protective Order Regarding
Discovery on “Superior Knowledge.”

Letter Regarding Count IX Hearing.
Hearing Transcript.

Plaintiffs’ Motion for Leave to File
Hearing Exhibits and Hearing

Exhibits.

Defendant’s First Amended Answer
and Affirmative Defenses

DATE
Q9/D9/1992

09/09/1992

09/14/1992

OY/16/1992

09/17/1992

09/17/1992

09/18/1992
09/29/1992

10/05/1992

10/08/1992

a

6
DOCUMENT
Defendants Motion for a Stay of

Discovery Regarding Superior
Knowledge.

Defendant's Motion for Leave to File |

and Defendants Supplemental Brief
Reparding Defendant's Motion for a
Protective Order

Order

Plamtiffs Opposition to Defendant ©
Motion for Leave to Pile and
Defendant’s Supplemental Brief
Reyvarding Defendants Motion for a
Protective Order.

Defendant's Motion to Certify Order
for Interlocutory Appeal.

Defendant's Motion for Leave to File
and Defendant's Supplement to
Defendant's Supplemental Brief
Regarding Defendant's Motion for a
Protective Order.

Hearing Transcript.

Plaintiff's Motion to Compel
Discovery.

Plaintiffs’ Brief in Opposition to
Government's Motion to Certify
Order for Interlocutory Appeal.

Hearing Transcript.

DATE
10/13/1992

10/14/1992
10/15/1992

10/29/1992

10/30/1992
| 11/05/1992
11/12/1992

11/13/1992
11/17/1992

| 11/20/1992

11/23/1992

11/22/1992

7
DOCUMENT

Plaintiffs’ Supplemental Brief in
Support of Motion to Compe!
Discovery.

Hearing Transcript (In Camera).

Defendant's Reply to Plaintiffs’
Opposition to Defendant's Motion to
Certify Order for Interlocutory
Appeal.

Defendant’s Response to Plaintiffs’
Supplemental! Brief in Support of
Motion to Compel Discovery.

Order.
Hearing Transcript.

Defendant’s Response to the Court s
Order of October 30, 1992.

Plaintiffs’ Motion to Compel
Discovery.
Notice of Filing of Classified
Appendix.

Plaintiffs’ Supplemental Brief
Regarding Plaintiffs’ Motion to
Compe] Discovery.

Defendant's Response to Plaintiffs
Motion to Compel of November 13,
1992.

Hearing Transcript.

DATE
11/23/1992

11/23/1992
11/23/1992
12/02/1992
01/23/1993

02/05/1993
02/08/1993

02/09/1998

02/09/1993

02/12/1993

8

DOCUMENT

Order and Opinion Denying Request
to Certify for Interlocutory Appeal.

Protective Order.
Order.
Order.

Hearing Transcript and Order that
Hearing Transcript Shall Not Be
Duplicated Except By Order of the
Court.

Stipulation and Protective Order.

' Defendant's Motion for a Protective

Order.

Plaintiffs’ Motion for Leave to File
Second Amended Unclassified

Complaint.

Defendant's Motion for a Protective
Order and Response to Plaintiffs’
Motion to Compel Responses to
Discovery Requests Withheld Under
Claim of Discovery Stay.

Plaintiffs’ Motion for an Order
Governing B-2 and F-117a Discovery.

DATE
02/17/1993

02/18/1993

02/25/1993

03/01/1993
03/03/1993
03/03/1993

03/05/1993
03/05/1993

03/08/1993

03/09/1993

02/26/1993 |

#

9
| DOCUMENT

| Plaintiffs’ Response to Defendant's

Motion for a Protective Order and

Reply to Defendant’s Response to

Plaintiffs’ Motion to Compel

Responses Withheld Under a Claim
of Discovery Stay.

Opinion and Order Denying Motion
to Dismiss and Vacating All Stays of
Discovery.

Defendant's Response to Plaintiffs’
Motion for an Order Governing B-2
and F-117a Discovery.

Hearing Transcript.
Order.
Order.

Defendant's Motion for Partial
Reconsideration of the Court’s Order
Dated March 1, 1993.

Order.

Plaintiffs’ Supplemental
Memorandum in Support of their
; Motion to Compel Production.

Defendant’s Motion for a Stay of
Court’s March 5, 1993 Order.

Order Denying Motion for a Stay.

DATE
03/09/1993

03/09/1993

A,
03/10/1993

03/10/1993

03/11/1993

03/12/1993

03/16/1993 |

03/17/1993

10
DOCUMENT

Petition for Writ of Mandamus and
Motion for a Stay Pending Resolution
of Petition for Writ of Mandamus.

Order of Court of Appeals for the
Federal Circuit.

Defendant's Second Amended
Unclassified Answer and Affirmative
Defenses.

Plaintiffs’-Respondents’ Opposition to
the Government's Motion for a Stay
Pending Resolution of the
Government's Petition for a Writ of
Mandamus.

Defendant: Petitioner's Reply to
Plaintiffs’-Respondents’ Opposition to
the Government's Motion to Stay.

Order of Court of Appeals for the
Federal Circuit.

Plaintifts’-Respondents’ Opposition to
Petition for Writ of Mandamus and
Appendix in Support Thereof {Misc.
No. 370].

Defendant-Petitioner’s Reply to
Plaintiffs’-Respondents’ Opposition to
Petition for Writ of Mandamus [Misc.
No. 370).

DATE
03/18/1993

03/18/1993
03/23/1993
03/23/1993
03/30/1993

03/30/1993

03/31/1993
04/01/1993

04/02/1993
04/03/1993

04/06/1993

04/06/1993

04/07/1993

11

DOCUMENT

Plaintiffs’-Respondents’ Sur-Reply to
Defendant-Petitioner’s Reply to
Petition for Writ of Mandamus [Misc.
No. 370].

Order.
Hearing Transcript.
Order.

Notice of Filing of Classified Ex Parte
In Camera Declaration.

Defendant's Motion for a Protective

Order.

| Order.

Defendant's Supplemental Brief in
Support of Motion for Protective
Order.

Hearing Transcript.

Defendant's Second Supplemental
Brief in Support of Motion for
Protective Order.

Defendant’s Second Supplemental
Brief in Support of Motion for a
Protective Order.

Defendant's Notice of Filing of
Classified In Camera Ex Parte
Declaration and Materials.

Order.

DATE
04/08/1993
04/09/1993

04/09/1993

04/09/1993

04/12/1993

04/13/1993

04/13/1993

04/14/1993
04/14/1993

04/15/1993

04/16/1993

12
DOCUMENT

Order.

Plaintiffs Opposition to Defendant’s
Motion for a Protective Order Barring
Access to Unnamed Classified
Programs and Notice of Filing of
Classified Appendix in Support
Thereof.

Plaintiff's Notice of Filing of
Classified Deposition Transcript.

Plaintiffs’ Motion for Leave to File an
In Camera Classified Declaration.

Order.

Defendant’s Reply to Plaintiffs
Opposition to Defendant's Motion for
a Protective Order.

Defendant's Motion for Stay of Order
Pending Interlocutory Appeal and
Motion to Certify Order for
Interlocutory Appeal.

Order Denying Motion to Stay.

Order Denying Motion to Certify for
Interlocutory Appeal.

Government's Petition for Mandamus
and Request for Stay to the Court of
Appeals for the Federa} Circuit.

Order.

DATE
04/16/1993

04/16/1993

04/20/1993

04/20/1993

04/21/1993

04/21/1993

04/22/1993

04/27/1993
04/30/1993
04/30/1993

05/05/1993

13

DOCUMENT

Plaintiffs’ Motion Requesting Record
of In Camera Proceedings.

Court of Appeals for the Federal
Circuit Order.

Court of Appeals for the Federal
Circuit Order.

Order.

Defendant's Response to the Court's
Order Dated April 16, 1993 [Mise.
No. 370].

Plaintiffs’-Respondents’ Opposition to
Petition for Writ of Mandamus and
Opposition to a Stay Pending
Resolution of Petition and Motion for
Leave to File Documents In Camera
[Mise. No. 370].

Defendant: Petitioner's Reply to
Plaintiffs’-Respondents’ Opposition to
Petition for Writ of Mandamus and
Opposition to a Stay {Misc. No. 370].

Order.

Order.

Court of Appeals for the Federal
Circuit Order.

Order.

DATE
05/07/1993

05/20/1993
05/26/1993

05/27/1993

05/27/1993

06/08/1993

06/10/1993
06/11/1993

06/11/1993

14

DOCUMENT

Order Staying Ali Discovery on Air
Force Programs.

Order.

| Plaintiffs’ Memorandum Concerning
' Continuation of Discovery on Count

IX and Notice of Filing of Classified

Appendix in Support Thereof.

Defendant's Motion to Dismiss
Plaintiffs Superior Knowledge
Claims, Or In the Alternative for
Partial Summary Judgment, and
Motion for a Protective Order and
Notice of Filing of Classified
Appendix in Support Thereof.

Defendant's Memorandum Regarding
“Superior Knowledge” Hearing on
May 28.

Plaintiffs Motion for Continuance of
Defendant’s Motion for Partial
Summary Judgment.

Hearing Transcript.

Defendant’s Response to Plaintiffs
Motion for a Continuance.

Defendant's Notice of Filing of
Classified, In Camera, Ex Parte
Appendix to Motion to Dismiss
Plaintiffs’ Superior Knowledge
Claims.

DATE
06/15/1993

06/21/1993
06/21/1993
06/23/2003

06/25/1993

07/08/1993
07/15/1993

07/19/1993

07/23/1993

07/26/1993

08/1 1/1993
10/22/1993

15
DOCUMENT

Notice of Filing of Classified
Appendix.

Order.
Opinion and Order.

Defendant’s Status Report
Concerning Count IX.

Plaintiffs Response to Status Report
re Count IX.

Order.

Defendant's Status Report
Concerning Count IX.

Order Vacating Stay of Discovery on
Superior Knowledge Claims.

Defendant’s Supplement to Motion to
Dismiss Plaintiffs Superior
Knowledge Claims.

Opinion and Order.
Order.

TRANSCRIPT of proceedings re: 28
volumes, taken at Washington, D.C.,
for dates of September 20-30, 1993,
and October 1, October 4, October 5,
and October 7, 1993.

DATE
11/01/1993

11/19/1993

11/19/1993

11/22/1993

11/29/1993

11/29/1993

11/29/1993

12/17/1993

13

14

16

21

23

16

DOCUMENT

PUBLISHED DECISION addressing
state secrets doctrine and discovery
issues, and setting concurrent Brief
deadline to November 19, 1993.

NOTICE of filing of classified, EX
PARTE materials by USA.

MEMORANDUM by USA re: motion
to dismiss “Superior Knowledge”

Claims, and response to 1I/I/93 order.

MEMORANDUM by MCDONNELL
DOUGLAS, GENERAL DYNAMICS
re: superior knowledge order by leave
of the Judge.

MOTION by MCDONNELL
DOUGLAS, GENERAL DYNAMICS
for Summary Judgment on Count IX.

PROPOSED FINDINGS of
Uncontroverted Fact by
MCDONNELL DOUGLAS,
GENERAL DYNAMICS.

Notice of filing a classified appendix
by MCDONNELL DOUGLAS,
GENERAL DYNAMICS.

RESPONSE by MCDONNELL
DOUGLAS, GENERAL DYNAMICS to
response by USA.

DATE
12/20/1993

12/23/1993

12/29/1993 |

01/03/1994

01/03/1994

01/03/1994

01/03/1994

58

64

68

17
DOCUMENT

RESPONSE by MCDONNELL
DOUGLAS, GENERAL DYNAMICS
to USA’s memorandum |i.c. motion to
dismiss “Superior Knowledge” claims}
by leave of the Judge.

ORDER entered directing the Clerk
to refuse to accept for filing any
pleadings signed by or for the current
attorney of record for the USA or the
Director of Commercial Litigation
until further direction from the court.

Attorney for defendant, Mary Sue
Mitchellson, terminated this date.

MOTION by USA For reconsideration
of order under Rule 83.2 , to Vacate
order, and for Expedited
Consideration.

Notice of filing classified materials by

USA.

CROSS MOTION to Dismiss by USA
and RESPONSE to motion for
Summary Judgment by GENERAL
DYNAMICS, MCDONNELL
DOUGLAS.

STATEMENT OF GENUINE
ISSUES by USA.

DATE
01/10/1994

01/10/1994

01/31/1994

02/01/1994

02/01/1994

02/02/1994

02/02/1994

79

57

89

90

94

18

DOCUMENT

REPLY by USA to plaintiffs’ 12/17/93
brief in response to USA'S motion to
dismiss plaintiffs’ Superior
Knowledge Claims.

ORDER granting motion to Extend
‘lime to respond to motion for
summary judgment.

Notice of filing classified appendix by
MCDONNELL DOUGLAS,
GENERAL DYNAMICS.

REPLY by MCDONNELL
DOUGLAS, GENERAL DYNAMICS
to response to cross motion.

MOTION by MCDONNELL
DOUGLAS, GENERAL DYNAMICS
for Leave to File a supplemental]
superior knowledge memorandum
regarding Northrop ATA proposal
documents.

ORDER granting [90-1] motion for
Leave to File a supplemental
superior knowledge memorandum.

SUPPLEMENTAL MEMORANDUM
by MCDONNELL DOUGLAS,
GENERAL DYNAMICS re: Northrop
ATA Proposal Documents PLACED
IN CAMERA.

DATE
02/04/1994

02/04/1994

02/10/1994
02/14/1994

02/16/1994

02/18/1994

03/07/1994
03/07/1994

118

97

102
109

113

122

14]

19

DOCUMENT

TRANSCRIPT of proceedings re: 1
volume, at Washington, D.C., for date
of February 8, 1994. Notice to parties.

ORDER entered that there is no
basis for finding that the Air Force
acted to help or hinder development
of the merits of this case, with the
Clerk directed to accept any
pleadings complying with the Rules
from the USA.

STATUS REPORT by USA.

RIEPLY by USA to response to cross:

motion.

ORDER scheduling Show Cause
Hearing for 10:00 a.m. on 3/7/94 for
USA to Show Cause why the Court
should not deem admitted plaintiffs’
superior knowledge claims, ete.

ORDER denying motion For
reconsideration of order under Rule
83.2. Order also states that the
December 23, 1993 order is now
MOO'.

Show Cause Hearing held.

MOTION by USA for Leave to File
response to order to show cause, and
response to order to show cause.

DATE
03/09/1994

03/23/1994

03/24/1994

03/28/1994

03/31/1994

(4/04/1994

04/05/1994

04/14/1994

04/18/1994

04/20/1994

163

167

189

195

20]

defendant's response to Show Cause

20)
DOCUMENT |
ORDER re: defendant's response to |
order to show cause. |
MOTION by MCDONNELL
DOUGLAS, GENERAL DYNAMICS

for Leave to File repiy, and reply to

Order on Superior Knowledpe.
ORDER entered directing plamtitfs
to designate representatives to
explore feasibility of proposal to
litigate portion of superior knowledge
case, etc.

MOTION by USA for Reconsideration
of order.

ORDER adding matters to avenda for
a show cause hearnig.

STATUS REPORT re. assertion of
privileges by USA

RESPONSE by MCDONNELI.
DOUGLAS, GENERAL DYNAMICS
to report by USA

ORDER entered re further
procedures.

STATUS REPORT regarding Count
IX by USA.

ORDER entered re’ security issues
related to Count %

|
}

DATE
04/28/1994
07/22/1994

07/28/1994

09/14/1994

09/23/1994

09/27/1994

09/26/1994

341

354

21

DOCUMENT
ORDER entered re discovery, etc.

MOTION by MCDONNELL
DOUGLAS, GENERAL DYNAMICS
for Leave to File to permit disclosure
of nonparty B-2 and F-117A
information to plaintiffs’ engineers
cleared into those programs.

| ORDER entered granting motion for
' Leave to File to permit disclosure of
| non-party B-2 and F-117A
information to plaintiffs' engineers
cleared into those programs.

MOTION by MCDONNELL
DOUGLAS, GENERAL DYNAMICS
to Compei discovery of documents
from the B-2 and F- 117A programs.

RESPONSE by USA to motion to
Compel.

TRANSCRIPT of proceedings re: ]
volume, at Washington, D.C., for date
| of September 26, 1994.

| ORDER entered that plaintiff's
motion to compel discovery is
suspended pending a review by
government counsel of the Air Force
response to plaintiff's interrogatories
and request for production.

22

—

DATE # | DOCUMENT |

10/04/1994 | 361 | STATUS REPORT by USA re: |
production of documents from the B-2 |
and F-117A programs.

10/04/1994 | 360 MOTION by MCDONNELL
DOUGLAS for entry of B-2 and F-
117A discovery order.

361 | STATUS REPORT by USA re:
| production of documents from the B-2
and F-117A programs.

10/04/1994

10/14/1994 | 364 ORDER set Evidentiary Hearing to
discuss B-2 and F-117A discovery:
10:00 a.m. on 10/17/94.

10/17/1994 | 365 TRANSCRIPT of proceedings re: 1
volume, at Washington, D.C. for date
of October 17, 1994.

11/01/1994 | 377 | (Preliminary) STATUS REPORT by
' USA re: production of documents
| from the B-2 program.

11/02/1994 | 380 ORDER entered re apparent

destruction of documents etc. (signed
| by Judge Robert H. Hodges).

11/03/1994 |

\
378 | ORDER granting motion for Leave to |
File revised preliminary status report
regarding production of B-2

, documents.

‘

DATE
11/03/1994

11/16/1994
11/16/1994
11/18/1994

12/01/1994

12/09/1994

12/16/1994

01/31/1998

385
403

400

424

‘
'

23
DOCUMENT

REVISED PRELIMINARY STATUS
REPORT regarding production of
documents from the B-2 program by
USA.

MOTION by MCDONNELL
DOUGLAS, GENERAL DYNAMICS
for Leave to File response to
defendant's status report re: the
production of B-2 documents.

STATUS REPORT by USA.
RESPONSE by MCDONNELL

DOUGLAS, GENERAL DYNAMICS
to report by USA.

ORDER granting motion for leave re:

production of B-2 documents. etc.

ORDER directing parties of Judge's

decision of agreement with Plaintiff

re: improper termination of A-12
contract for default in Count XVII.

ORDER granting motion for entry of
B-2 and F-117A discovery order.

ORDER entered that defendant will
have the opportunity at trial to
present evidence that contractor
performance was so deficient at the
time of termination.

DATE
02/07/1995

02/22/1995

03/07/1995

03/09/1998

04/07/1995 |

i
|

12/19/199%

Vi

ven
oy)
qi

449

te
or
jo

488

793

24
DOCUMENT

MOTION by MCDONNELL
DOUGLAS, GENERAL DYNAMICS
to Compel production of documents
related to classified supporting data

file UNDER SEAL IN CAMERA.

RESPONSE by USA to motion to
Compe! production of documents
related to classified supporting data.

FILED UNDER SEAL.

REPLY by MCDONNELL
DOUGLAS, GENERAL DYNAMICS
to response to motion to Compe}
production of documents related to
classified supporting data. FILED
UNDER SEAL.

ORDER directing parties of further
procedures to take if discovery cannot
be resolved.

ORDER Staying briefing schedule for
Plaintiffs summary judgment motion
and addressing other case
proceedings.

ORDER entered re further
proceedings.

ORDER set Brief [parties proposed
schedule for addressing damages)
deadline to 1/5/96.

DATE
01/05/1996

01/05/1996

01/05/1996

01/23/1996 |

01/23/1996

800

SO1

23

| DOCUMENT

MOTION by USA for entry of case
management order to address
damages aspects of this case.

MOTION by USA to Dismiss
Damages Allegations and for Entry of
a Partial Final Judgment or, in the
Alternative, for Certification for
Interlocutory Appeal.

STATUS REPORT (Proposed
Schedule for Addressing Damages) by
MCDONNELL DOUGLAS,
GENERAL DYNAMICS.

ORDER Response to motion to
Dismiss Damages Allegations and for
Entry of a Partial Final Judgment or,
in the Alternative, for Certification
for Interlocutory Appeal reset to
1/26/96 and Reply to Response to
Motion reset to 2/2/96 for motion to
Dismiss Damages Allegations and for
Entry of a Partial Final Judgment or,
in the Alternative, for Certification
for Interlocutory Appeal.

RESPONSE by USA to motion for

entry of case management order to
address damages aspects of this case.

DATE
01/26/1996

02/07/1996

02/07/1996

02/07/1996
02/29/1996

02/29/1996

803

808

809

828

26

DOCUMENT

RESPONSE by MCDONNELL
DOUGLAS, GENERAL DYNAMICS
to motion to Dismiss Damages
Allegations and for Entry of a Partial
Final Judgment or, in the
Alternative, for Certification for
Interlocutory Appeal.

REPLY by USA to response to motion
to Dismiss Damages Allegations and
for Entry of a Partial Final Judgment
or, in the Alternative, for
Certification for Interlocutory
Appeal.

| REPLY TO RESPONSE by

MCDONNELL DOUGLAS and
GENERAL DYNAMICS to response
bv USA.

ORDER re: further procedures.

MOTION by MCDONNELL
DOUGLAS for Leave to File under
seal its memorandum on superior
knowledge discovery in response to

‘ the court's 2/7/96 Order.

STATUS REPORT (Regarding
Superior Knowledge Discovery and
the Order of Proof at Trial), by
GENERAL DYNAMICS.

DATE
02/29/1996

03/01/1996

03/18/1996

03/20/1996

03/22/1996

03/25/1996

04/02/1996

831

os)
w
=~]

841

842

os)
neN
Qi

27
DOCUMENT

ORDER granting motion for Leave to
File under seal its memorandum on
superior knowledge discovery in
response to the court's 2/7/96 Order.

' MEMORANDUM by MCDONNELL
- DOUGLAS re: superior knowledge

discovery per order with one volume
appendix filed by leave of the Judge
AND PLACED IN CAMERA.

ORDER set Evidentiary Hearing for
discovery in the B-2 program: 10:00
a.m. on 3/22/96.

RESPONSE by USA to report by

| GENERAL DYNAMICS by leave of

the Judge.

ORDER set Additional Documents
issues of burden of proof and
sequence of procedures, etc. [brief]
due: 4/1/96 for USA, 4/8/96 [response
to brief] for GENERAL DYNAMICS
and MCDONNELL DOUGLAS.

TRANSCRIPT of proceedings re: 1
volume, at Washington, D.C., for date
of March 22, 1996.

RESPONSE (filed as defendant's
supplemental brief concerning the
burden of proof, the order for
presentation of evidence at trial, and
pretrial schedule) by USA to order.

=

DATE

04/08/1996
04/08/1996
04/09/1996

04/19/1996

04/19/1996
04/19/1996

04/19/1996

05/02/1996

05/06/1991

a

859

860
S61

28

| DOCUMENT

| Petition for a Writ of Mandamus.

PUBLISHED DECISION.

RESPONSE by MCDONNELL
DOUGLAS, GENERAL DYNAMICS
to response by USA.

Additional Documentation
[supplement to memorandum in
response to the order dated April 3,
1996] by USA and placed in camera.

MEMORANDUM by USA re: order.

MOTION by MCDONNELL
DOUGLAS, GENERAL DYNAMICS
for a pretrial determination that no
loss adjustment can apply, etc.

Additional Documentation
[supplemental appendix to plaintiffs
motion for a pretrial, etc.) by
MCDONNELL DOUGLAS and
GENERAL DYNAMICS and placed

in camera.

Answer to Petition for Writ of
Mandamus.

TRANSCRIPT of proceedings re: pre-
trial conference, 1 volume, at
Washington, D.C., for date of May 3,
1996.

DATE
05/13/1996

05/16/1996

05/17/1996

05/24/1996

05/31/1996

06/05/1996

06/08/1996

!

878

879

889

894

29
DOCUMENT

ORDER directing counsel to meet no
later than May 24, 1996 to perform
tasks as outlined in said order and
directing counsel to notify court of the
results of said meeting as soon as
possible.

ORDER Clarifying case status and
court's position.

ORDER addressing case proceedings
and upcoming trial and hearing.

RESPONSE by USA to motion for a
pretrial determination that no loss
adjustment can apply, etc.

Court of Appeals for the Federal]
Circuit Order Denying Petition for
Mandamus.

Oral Argument re: motion for a
pretrial determination that no loss
adjustment can apply, etc. by
GENERAL DYNAMICS,
MCDONNELL DOUGLAS.

TRANSCRIPT of proceedings re: 1
volume, at Washington, D.C., for date

of June 5, 1996 exhibits:

DATE
06/12/1996

06/13/1996

09/25/1996

10/09/1996

10/09/1996

10/22/1996

897

902

999

1003

1006

1012

30

DOCUMENT

ORDER directing parties the only
issue for determination of damages is
incurred costs, closing discovery that
is not related to incurred costs and
directing parties al! other discovery
deadlines remain in effect unless they
are changed by agreement of counsel
or order of court and set Trial or
hearing for 9/16/96.

TRANSCRIPT of proceedings re: 1
volume, at Washington, D.C., for date
of June 12, 1996.

MOTION by MCDONNELL
DOUGLAS for Leave to File UNDER
SEAL its proposed findings of fact
and conclusions of law supporting
non-imposition of a lost ratio.

ORDER granting motion for Leave to ;
File UNDER SEAL its proposed
findings of fact and conclusions of law
supporting non-imposition of a loss
ratio.

RESPONSE by USA to Motion for
Leave to File UNDER SEAL its
proposed findings of fact and
conclusions of law supporting non-
imposition of a lost ratio.

RESPONSE by GENERAL
DYNAMICS to order.

DATE
11/26/1996

12/09/1996

12/13/1996
01/22/1997

02/05/1997

07/23/1997

08/14/1997

08/14/1997

02/20/1998

1022

1026
104]

1044

1095

1098

1099

1128

31

DOCUMENT

MOTION by GENERAL DYNAMICS
regarding preservation of record for
appeal.

MOTION by MCDONNELL
DOUGLAS, GENERAL DYNAMICS
for a determination of the balance
due plaintiffs from the government.

PUBLISHED DECISION.

PUBLISHED DECISION granting in
part, denying in part motion to
Dismiss Damages Allegations and for
Entry of a Partial Final Judgment or,
in the Alternative, for Certification
for Interlocutory Appeal.

PUBLISHED DECISION denying

motion for Summary Judgment.

TRANSCRIPT of proceedings re: 25
volumes, taken at Washington, DC,
for date of June 17 through July 14,
1997, together with cumulative

index.

Post-trial (memorandum of
contentions of fact and law) by USA.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND
CONCLUSIONS OF LAW by
MCDONNELL DOUGLAS,
GENERAL DYNAMICS.

PUBLISHED DECISION.

DATE
03/30/1998

03/31/1998

04/02/1998
05/29/1998

05/29/1998

6/27/2000

7/18/2000

7/31/2000

08/11/2000

1145

1150
1154

1159

1160

1162

32

DOCUMENT

PUBLISHED DECISION vacating
the published Opinion and Order,
vacating the judgment, and directing
Clerk to enter judgment accordingly.

JUDGMENT entered pursuant to
Rule 58 awarding plaintiffs the sum
of $1,200.132.820.00, plus statutory
interest from June 26, 1991, unti!
paid. No costs.

NOTICE OF APPEAL by USA.
NOTICE OF CROSS-APPEAL by
GENERAL DYNAMICS.

NOTICE OF CROSS-APPEAL by
MCDONNELL DOUGLAS.

Status Conference held (no reporter
requested).

NOTICE of Statement of Issues and
Notice of Probable Testifying Experts
for Trial by USA.

RESPONSE by MCDONNELL
DOUGLAS and GENERAL
DYNAMICS to notice by USA.

ORDER set hearing for 10:00 a.m.,
9/6/00.

DATE
8/11/2000

9/29/2000

11/07/2000

12/15/2000
12/19/2000

12/21/2000

01/12/2001

01/31/200)

1169

1192

1197

33

DOCUMENT

TRANSCRIPT of proceedings re:
Status Conference, 1 volume, at
Washington, D.C., for date of August
10, 2000.

TRANSCRIPT of proceedings re:
Evidentiary Hearing, 1 volume, at
Washington, D.C., for date of
September 28, 2000.

ORDER set Status Conference for
10°00 a.m., 11/16/00.

STATUS REPORT by USA.

STATUS REPORT by MCDONNELL
DOUGLAS and GENERAL
DYNAMICS.

TRANSCRIPT of proceedings, 1
volume, at Washington, D.C., for date
of December 19, 2000.

MOTION by USA to Compe!
disclosure of plaintiff's case and brief
in support, (together with separate
appendix).

RESPONSE by MCDONNELL
DOUGLAS, GENERAL DYNAMICS
to motion to Compe] disclosure of
plaintiff's case and brief in support,
filed with a (1) one volume appendix.

DATE
02/07/2001

02/09/2001

02/12/2001

02/12/2001

02/12/2001

92/15/2001

Q2/21/200)

Ht
1210

1218

1218

1215

1219

34

DOCUMENT

NOTICE of an Ibex Parte filing in
connection with Plaintiffs 29th and
40th sets of discovery requests by

USA.

KEPLY by USA to response to motion
to Extend Time within which respond
to motion to compel disclosure of
plaintiff's case.

MOTION by MCDONNELL
DOUGLAS, GENERAL DYNAMICS
to Extend Time to file bricks re’
issues to be tried (pending
determination of government's
invocation of state secrets privilege)
and for a status conference.

RESPONSE by USA to motion to
Extend Time to file briefs re’ issues
to be tried.

Binef regarding issues to be
addressed and the appropriate trial
standards to be applied at the May 1,
2001, default trial filed by USA.

ORDER Status Conference for 10:00

am., 2/23/01.

TRANSCRIPT of proceedings J
volume, at Washington, D.C., for date
of February 20, 2001. Notice to

parties.

33
DATE ue DOCUMENT

03/01/2001 | 1229 | UNPUBLISHED DECISION
reaffirming the December 13, 199@
opinion and order; and concluding
that defendant may not obtain a lost
adjustment pursuant to FAR 49.203,
_and plaintiffs may not obtain profits
pursuant to FAR 49.202.

03/07/2001 | 1236 | STATEMENT OF ISSUES AND
LEGAL STANDARDS FOR TRIAL
by MCDONNELL DOUGLAS and
GENERAL DYNAMICS

03/28/2001 | 1264 | MOTION, together with four volumes
of appendix, by USA For
reconsideration of order under Rule
83.2 and brief regarding effect of
state secrets.

03/30/2001 | 1269 | TRANSCRIPT of proceedings re:
Evidentiary Hearing, 1 volume. at
Washington, D.C., for date of March
29, 2001. .

04/10/2001 | 1277 | NOTICE of Supplemental Authority
by USA.

DATE
4/27/2001

04/30/2001

07/10/2001
07/10/2001

07/10/2001

07/11/2001

a
1284

1333

36

DOCUMENT

ORDER denying motion For
reconsideration of order under Rule
83.2. Trial of this case begins at 10:00
a.m. on May 7 and 9:00 a.m.
thereafter until June 29. The court
will not meet on May 28 or June 4°8.
The time will be evenly divided
between plaintiffs and defendant. Mr.
Lewis is excluded as an expert
witness. See Transcript of hearing on
April 23, 2001. All-other motions that
were pending and not. listed on the

: April 23 proposed agenda and status

report are moot and thereafter
denied.

TRANSCRIPT of proceedings re: Pre-
Trial Conference, 1 volume (151

pages), at Washington, 1).C., for date
of April 23, 2001.

Post-trial brief filed by
MCDONNELL DOUGLAS.

PROPOSED FINDINGS OF FACT
filed by MCDONNELL DOUGLAS.

PROPOSED FINDINGS OF FACT
AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW filed
BY GENERAL DYNAMICS.

Post-trial brief by USA.

DATE

08/31/2001 | 1346

08/31/2001

09/17/2001

09/17/2001

10/04/2001

11/16/2001

11/21/2001

cod

1351

1353

1356

37
DOCUMENT
MOTION by MCDONNELL

~DOUGLAS, GENERAL DYNAMICS

_to Stay this Court's Judgment in

light of Defendant's recent collection
report.

JUDGMENT entered, pursuant to

| Rule 58, that the complaint is
| dismissed and judgment is entered in

favor of defendant. No costs.

MOTION by MCDONNELL
DOUGLAS (Service by hand: 9/17/01)
to Amend judgment order.

MOTION by GENERAL DYNAMICS

to Alter Judgment, and to Amend to
Court's findings.

ORDER denying motion to Alter
Judgment, motion to Amend to
Court's findings and motion to
Amend judgment order.

MOTION by MCDONNELL
DOUGLAS, GENERAL DYNAMICS

to Stay Government's collection

‘demand.
| RESPONSE by USA to motion to

Stay Government’s collection
demand.

DATE
11/26/2001

11/30/2001
11/30/2001
12/14/2001

01/09/2004

01/23/2004

1359

1360

1361

1382

may
od

DOCUMENT

ORDER re: Directing parties to agree
on a date and time to address the
Court's responsibilities in this matter
concerning the money judgment, if
the parties feel the Court has
additional responsibilities.

NOTICE OF APPEAL by GENERAL
DYNAMICS.

NOTICE OF APPEAL by

'MCDONNELL DOUGLAS

NOTICE OF CROSS-APPEAL by
USA.

MOTION tor Judgment Based Upon
Additional Findings Mandated by the
Court of Appeals and Memorandum
in Support, Together with Separately
Bound Supplemental Appendix
(Volume D by USA.

-CROSS MOTION and OPPOSITION

to Dft’s Motion for Judgment on
Partial Findings, Together with
Separately Bound Appendix Volume
by MCDONNELL DOUGLAS
CORPORATION.

DATE
1/26/2004

03/12/2004

04/16/2004

4/16/2004

1386

1393

1397

1398

——

39
DOCUMENT

REPONSE to Motion for Judgment
on Partial Findings and Motion for
Judgment on Partial Findings by
USA and CROSS MOTION for
conversion of default termination to
termination for convenience, together
with 5 separate volumes of appendix,
filed by GENERAL DYNAMICS
CORPORATION.

OPPOSITION to Plitfs’ CROSS
MOTION for Judgment and
Conversion of the Default
Termination to Termination for
Convenience and BRIEF IN REPLY
to Pitfs’ Responses to Dft’s Motion for
Judgment, Together with Four (4)
Separately Bound Appendix
Volumes, filed by USA.

REPLY to Response to Motion re
CROSS MOTION to Motion for
Judgment on Partial Findings filed
by USA filed by MCDONNELL
DOUGLAS CORPORATION.

Reply to Opposition to Motion for
Conversion of Default Termination to
Termination for Convenience, with a
(1) one volume appendix in support.

DATE
7/15/2004

7/15/2004

6/8/2006

7/6/2006

7/21/2006

03/03/2007

1408

1409

1431

1434

1438

1440

1441

40
DOCUMENT

SUPPLEMENTAL BRIEF and
PROPOSED ADDITIONAL
FINDINGS OF FACT by
MCDONNELL DOUGLAS
CORPORATION.

POINTS IN REBUTTAL to Pltfs’
Oral Argument, filed by USA.

POST ARGUMENT BRIEF, filed by
USA.

RESPONSE to MOTION to Amend
Schedule re: Order on Motion for
Extension of Time to File , filed by
MCDONNELL DOUGLAS
CORPORATION, GENERAL
DYNAMICS CORPORATION.

MOTION for Leave to File
Supplemental Brief in Reply To
Plaintiffs’ Response Brief, filed by
USA.

PUBLISHED ORDER and OPINION
granting 1382 Motion for Judgment
on Partial Findings: denying 1385
Cross Motion: denying 1386 Cross
Motion. The Clerk is directed to enter
judgment.

JUDGMENT entered, pursuant to
Rule 58, in favor of defendant. No
costs.

4]

Relevant Docket Entries

U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit
MCDONNELL DOUGLAS CORP vy. UNITED STATES

DATE

1998-5096

DOCUMENT

6/15/1998 ! Brief of Defendant-Appellant to the Federal

8/3/1998

9/28/1998

7/1/1999

Circuit.

Brief of Plaintiffs-Cross Appellants’ to the
Federal Circuit.

Reply and Cross-Appellee Brief of
Defendant-Appellant to the Federal Circuit.

Federal Circuit Opinion.

42
Relevant Docket Entries

U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit
MCDONNELL DOUGLAS CORP vy. UNITED STATES

DATE
3/6/2002

3/6/2002
5/24/2002
7/31/2002
8/15/2002
9/13/2002

3/17/2003

2002-5034

DOCUMENT

Brief for Plaintiff-Appellant General Dynamics
the Federal Circuit.

Brief for Plaintiff-Appe!llant McDonnell
Douglas in the Federal Circuit.

Brief for Defendant-Appellee-Cross-Appellant
United States in the Federal Circuit.

Reply/Cross-Appellee Brief for McDonnell
Douglas in the Federal Circuit.

Reply/Cross-Appellee Brief for General
Dynamics in the Federal Circuit.

Cross Reply Brief for Defendant-Appellee-Cros:
Appellant United States in the Federal Circuit!

-

Federal Circuit Opinion.

43
Relevant Docket Entries

U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit
MCDONNELL DOUGLAS CORP v. UNITED STATES
2007-5111

DATE DOCUMENT

10/23/2007 | Brief for Plaintiff-Appellant General
Dynamics in the Federal Circuit.

10/23/2007 | Brief for Plaintiff-Appellant McDonnell
Douglas in the Federal Circuit.

02/19/2008 | Brief for Defendant-Appellee United States in
the Federal Circuit.

04/17/2008 | Reply Brief for McDonnell Douglas in the
Federal] Circuit.

12/01/2009 | Federal Circuit Opinion.

44

ASSISTANT SECRETARY OF DEFENSE
Washington, D.C. 20301-8000

5 Jan. 1988

MEMORANDUM FOR UNDER SECRETARY OF
DEFENSE FOR ACQUISITION

SUBJECT: ATA Risk Management

Subject 8118 of the FY88 DoD appropriations
act requires that, before a fixed price type contract is
used for development of a major system, the USD(A)
make a written determination that risk has been
reduced to enable realistic pricing and that the
contract type permits an equitable and sensible
allocation of program risk between the contracting
parties.

I have had two hours to review the Navy ATA
program which is employing a fixed price FSD
contract and three years of not-to-exceed (NTE)
prices for production. I, therefore, cannot give you a
firm, well-reasoned recommendation regarding the
two elements on which you must make your
determination required by Section 8118 — that
program risk has been reduced to the extent that
realistic pricing can occur or whether program risk is
equitably shared, but 1 can express some of my
observations and reservations.

The Navy has selected a source and is very
eager to sign a contract, hence their briefing may
indicate that program risk is less than it actually is.
The Navy does not consider technical} risk to be high

45

with the exception of instability of the low observable
design which has not been prototyped in a flying
model. This will be the first carrier based low
observable aircraft. First flight is scheduled for FY
90. The Navy plans to maximize use of existing
avionics though the contractor will be required to
design a new radar and conformal antennas and will
have to modify F-404 engines. Software integration
of the avionics will also be required. I cannot
effectively evaluate the technical risk involved in
these efforts in the short time available. The ceiling
price of the FSD contract is $4.8B — the target cost is
20% below that at $4.0B with a 60%/40% share from
target to ceiling making this a tightly priced FPI
contract. The Navy appears to have adequately
priced all known development costs and the in-house
Government estimate is close to the proposed price.
There is not an amount included for contingencies or
for unforeseen technical problems that inevitably
arise on major R&D programs. There is an economic
adjustment clause to cover unusual inflation. The
winning McDonnell/General Dynamics (GD) team's
price was $800M lower than the Grumman/Northrop
team's proposal. Northrop has had experience with
low observables and McDonnell/GD have not so it
could be the Northrop estimate was more realistic.
McDonnell and GD are strongly interested in
becoming involved in stealth technology so they
might be prepared to accept some risks to do so.

The FSD contract includes 3 years of
production NTE’s amounting to $4.6B for 34 aircraft
(6, 8 and 20). There is considerable risk in these
NTE prices. The prices are fixed (downward

46

negotiable only) before the aircraft has been
designed, 3 years before it will be flown and by
contractors who have no experience with the
extremely high tolerances required in the production
of low observables. Production contract warranties
require all OPEVAL — discovered specification
deficiencies to be corrected at contractor expense
although production on the first three contracts will
be substantially complete before the conclusion of
OPEVAL. Based on the above observations, I cannot
unconditionally recommend that there is an
“equitable and sensible allocation” of program risk
between the contracting parties on the ATA program.

With respect to the second determination you
are required to make, the Navy believes that the
selected team of Genera] Dynamics and McDonnell
can absorb any losses though there has not been an
economic analysis of either contractor’s capacity to
absorb a loss. The Navy does not believe there will
be a major loss.

Attached are the questions I asked and the
Navy’s responses. Their earlier responses give rise
to the concerns I’ve expressed.

/s/ Eleanor Spector

Eleanor Spector

Deputy Assistant Secretary
of Defense (Procurement)

Attachment

47
N00019-88-C-0050

FULL SCALE ENGINEERING DEVELOPMENT
N00019-88-C-0050
FOR
ADVANCED TACTICAL AIRCRAFT (ATA)

201/BRR/1105-87
Page 1 of 338 Pages

Copy: Cy206Kh-6

201/0RR/0005-88

: ow : | pe | 8000! 9 141 @imee oa ft;

\EPARTMENT OF THE SAXY © 7 7 ™

aval Air Systees Command

Washingzorc, D.C. 20361 See Section G

Alb~ 214K Ms B, Jones

Telephone: Arcs Code 202, 692- 2020 Pre-Avaréd Survev Serial Ne.

til ane aUnutsy OF COmMPRACTOS Wan simel sn een seem ene 711 bua tT Ueto
McOonnel] Dougias/McDonnell Aircraft Company/ PP ca seals ae ;
General Dynamics/Ft Worth Division —- dn uittemn er © hw

P.O. Box 748
Ft Worth, TX 76101

—_——_—->, Sssrsi. Sh: DEST OT Im, 4584
PART t= Tul Some OUe | O28" +) = COMTBAC? = BLEUE

EF SEEN 4 MONIC ONT AL = Ban : x 0 cOnthaC? Claugt? “e]
EOS AOn tS OF SB Ovizts iin ewctea eet | i-? O60 7-11 = HBT OF DOTUMEN™S Be —18I7s ANG CT.TRSST 2OMu, Te F180 Sate — 6-| ; GOS Swe art TEN be Bog

o> SESS CONT WS =~ Pt agit ss =] Vive pati Sag eae! P78 anaes
— CONTAASTIN: OF 81:72 Sz 4 COL FTE Fa TOR ESS APM ICAL ~ j)¢ ee

. = -

3? z Conreacroay ESOT IerEG SSAEEMENT sC onwerin wa rT OWAED iCnerresie @ 90! reuird Im ne Ihe Goremrel, Ye
decums _ e

proved AY TS a! ond wriye We tm emg aller . ete: Om Secs! oe MemMOe

O° este" 00°00, 38 ‘yrdun O26 O0+.09- oun vigene wong > rod tae ° 2 err

. Oerlne mM Ot 1% serotes ve 12e OOG+1OO1 GF CN OFE8s MAES Os ver @FSS E6119) & E4em

teever-sran won cree Tee tne OF ORs ORIMue'1Om seen) te: Ime | ork ts teste ee ten CDOre. 2 SOON. CLECDIES G2 & MD OMS &O008 0OBD 0

somes! tne. St8e ~eroun The amy Ong Seegiinns ct Re BOF1Gd 10 Ihe | we omy OAR esIe WOM) TH C606 LOM WMMEIM ine GBRI1EG weer 14

ore thmirer tee tee ne ie ree eae BEGwm Ors 141 the | Vuln w! IMe terme Beauments jo) Ihe Geer nmen! 4 Mrenever ene oF

we, leoristeasimes, ow aehean ene, 076 16) wer Orr erwuny, "90ers OOM OPS (Ol 1S CEE COME! oes. ‘wr IME EMMI TEI es: BEtemen! 4 nm
~ a5. ov we ptteanes © Mee eretoe o, | roy

as J 1A Megamente ery ing
+4 Nae Se VC Cl S cnee Vim o Baal = erasers
. [2G— femme’ OF Clim PO al ime UF
Charles A, Anderson W. S. Ross oer“
President j : ,

oe =. & et.

5 Jan 88

St

49
SCHEDULE

SECTION B - SUPPLIES OR SERVICES

Item Supphes or Quantity Unit Total Price
Services Price

0001 ATA Aireraft XXXX XXXX $244,150,654
Initial Design
Review (IDR)

0002 ATA Aircraft XXXX XXXX $236.957,522
Preliminary
Design Review
(PDR)

0003 ATA Aircraft XNXX XXXX $504.160,441
Critical Design
Review (CDR)

0004 Data for Items NSP (See
0001. 0002, Exhibit A
0003, 0049 and and
0050 applicable

Exhibit B
Data Items)

0005 ATA Aircraft 8 XXXX XXXX

OOO5AA Same as Item ] XXXX $209.006,809
0005

0005AB Same as Item 7 3° $589.737,050
0005

0006 Special Tooling xxx XXXX $354,478,268

and Special Test

Equipment for
Items 0001

0007

0008

0009

0010

00}1

through 0005
and 0049 and
0050

DELETED

Data for Items
0005. 0006 and
0051 through
0056

DELETED
Data for Items
0051 through
0056

Project
Management

*$84,248,150

0044

0045

0046

Data for [tem
0043

Installation and
Maintenance of
High Response
40 Probe Inlet
Distortion Rakes
For Inlet
Compatibility
Measurements

Data for Item
0045

XXXX XXXX

XXXX XXXX
x*xnxee

XXXX XXAX

(1) Setof2 xxxx
rakes Rt &
Left Inlet

XXXX XXXX

NSP (See
Exhibit B)

NSP (See
Exhibit C)

NSP

NSP (See
Exhibit U)

NSP

NSP (See
Exhibit V)

rem

0047 CALS Technical xxxx XXXX $645.640
Manual Program

0048 Data for Item XXXX XNXX NSP (See
0047 Exhibit W)
0049 ATA Aircraft XXXX XXXX $286,214,572
Program
Management

Review (PMR)

0050 ATA Aircraft XXXX XXXX $182,325.015
Program
Management
Review (PMR)
0051 Phase I Test XXXX XXXX $427.683,277
0052 Phase II Test XXXX XXXX $308 .653,614
0053 Phase "Il Test XXXX XXXX $202,.462.819
0054 Phase IV Test XXXX XXXX $100.175,645
0055 Phase V Test XXXX XXXX $76,708,495
0056 Phase V1 Test XXNXX XXXN $514.271,392
0057 Training XXXX XXXX $33,422,845
Equipment for
Item 0005
0058 Interim XXXX XXXX $9,638,166
Contractor
Logistics

Support (1CLS)
for Item 0047

or
bo

‘Total Target price $4,379,219,436

*The prices shown above are the target prices. The
corresponding target cost and target profit for each item is

as follows.

Item Target Cost Target Profit
0001 $221,955,140 $22,195,514
0002 $215,415,929 21,541,593
0003 458,327,674 45,832,767
0005 726,130,782 42,613,077
0006 322,252,971 32,225,297
0022 71,388.374 7,138,838
0047 586,945 58,695
OO4A9 260,195,065 26,019,507
0050 165,730,014 16,575,001
0051 388,802,979 38,880,298
0052 280,594,195 28,059,419
0053 184.057,108 18,405,711
0054 91,068,768 9,106,877

53

0055 69,734,995 6,973,500
0056 467,519,447 46,751,945
0057 48,566,223 4,856,622
0058 8.761,969 876,197
Total $3,981,108,578 $398,110,858

The total price applicable to each item has been computed
by adding to the target cost for such Item, the
corresponding target profit set forth above for such item.

SCHEDULE

SECTION C - DESCRIPTION OR
SPECIFICATIONS OR WORK STATEMENT

Item 0001 Initial Design Review (IDR)

The IDR shall be held at the contractor’s
plant, or at other locations as he may designate, to
determine that the selected aircraft design approach
is compatible with the engineering requirements of
the contract. The IDR shal! be held within four
months after contract award to clarify and resolve
potential areas of misunderstanding, and is a means
of determining that the contractor has correctly
understood all aircraft design & test requirements.
The IDR shall be scheduled to be completed in one
session of approximately five working days.

Item 0002 Preliminary Design Review
(PDR)

The PDR shall be held at the contractor's
plant, or at other locations as may be mutually
agreed, to evaluate the progress, technical adequacy,
and risk resolution (on a technical, cost and schedule
basis of the selected design approach and determine
its compatibility with performance and engineering
requirements of the development specifications. The
PDR will be scheduled in more than one session
consistent with the completion schedule for the
individual preliminary design efforts. The length of
each individual review session’ shali be
approximately four working days. At the conclusion
of the incremental PDR’s, a_ final PDR of
approximately four working days will be held to

-_—

are)

summarize the results of the individual PDR’s.
Completion and approval by NAVAIR (AIR 05) of the
final PDR will result in authorization for the
Contractor to proceed with the design of the ATA.

Item 0008 Critical Design Review (CDR)

The CDR shall be held at the contractor's
plant or at other locations as he may designate to
determine the potential of the detailed design of the
ATA to satisfy the performance and engincering
requirements of the ATA development specifications.
The review shall be conducted when detail design
and analysis is essentially complete (90%). The CDR
will be scheduled in more than one session consistent
with the completion schedule for the individual
design efforts. The length of cach critical individual
review session shall be approximately four working
days. At the conclusion of the incremental CDR’s a
final CDR of approximately four working days will be
held to summarize the results of the individual
CDR’s. Completion and approval by NAVAIR (AIR
05) of the final CDR will result in authorization for
the Contractor to proceed with the design of the ATA
aircraft. The contractor shall furnish at CDR the
information set out in Clause “Establishment of Not-
to-Exceed prices for Option IV Items”.

REDACTED Item 0005- The
contractor shall design, develop, manufacture and
furnish eight (8) Full Scale’ Engineering
Development (FSED) aircraft and _ associated
mockups, models, and test articles in accordance
with the Detail Specification for ATA Aircraft
Weapon System, SD-574-1, including all Appendices.

56

Avionics Integration Laboratories shall also be
developed as needed to provide a_ technically
acceptable product within schedule constraints.

REDACTED The contractor shall (1) design
ATA aircraft including the F404-GE-F502 engine
through IDR, PDR and CDR in accordance with
Detail Specification, SD-574-1, including all
Appendices under Items 0001, 0002, 0003, 0049, and
0050 and (2) shall continue and complete the design
of ATA aircraft including the F404-GE-F502 engine
in accordance with Detail Specification, SD-574-1,
including all Appendices under Item 0005 to include
the design and development, fabrication and tests
necessary to:

(1) REDACTED Cause the aircraft, engine
and all other subsystems to conform to applicable
specifications required by this contract.

(2) REDACTED Develop and qualify the
F404-GE-F5D2 engine for incorporation into the ATA
aircraft weapon system.

(U) The aircraft to be furnished hereunder
shall be configured with the test instrumentation
required for tests and demonstrations to be
conducted in accordance with the requirements of
0051 through 0056. ‘Test articles shall comply with
the requirements of Detail Specification SD-574-1
and Addendum 648 to SD-8706C. The aircraft
provided hereunder are assigned BUNOs, xxxxx0
thru XxXxxx7.

57
(U) The contractor assumes the

responsibility for integrating and interfacing any
Government Furnished Equipment (GFE).

REDACTED The aircraft shall be equipped
with the F404-GE-F5D2 engines developed in
accordance with this contract. The contractor shall
perform all work necessary to integrate the engine
into the ATA aircraft and cause each to conform to
applicable specifications required by this contract.
The contractor shall perform all work necessary to
qualify the engine to:

1. REDACTED Complete Prototype
Preliminary Flight Qualification (PPFQ),
Preliminary Flight Qualification (PFQ), Limited
Production Qualification (LPQ) and Full Production
Qualification (FPQ) in accordance with the
requirements of Appendix E, Engine Model
Specification, to Detail Specification SD-574-1.

A. (JU) PPFO shall be considered
complete upon:

(1) (QU) _— Satisfactory completion of all the
tests, inspections and analysis required by Appendix
E, Engine Model Specification, to Detail Specification
SD-574-1.

(2) (U) Government approval of all

reports documenting the results of the above tests,
inspections and analysis.

(3) (U) Satisfactory Contractor
completion of corrective actions required to remedy
any safety of flight related items revealed during
development and testing of the engine.

58

(4) (U) Submittal and = approval of
corrective action plans to remedy any engine
specification non-conformance’ revealed during
development and testing of the engine.

(5) (U) Completion of at least 2100 total
hours of full scale engine running time prior to the
start of PPFQ endurance test.

B. (U) PFQ shall be considered complete
upon

(1). REDACTED Satisfactory completion of
all the tests, inspections and analysis required by
Appendix E, Engine Model Specification, to the ATA
Detail Specification, SD-574-1.

(2). (U) Government approval of all
reports documenting the results of the above test,
inspections and analysis.

(3). (U) Satisfactory Contractor
completion of corrective actions required by either
party to remedy any safety related nonconformance
revealed during development and testing of the
engine.

(4). (U) Submittal and = approval of
corrective action plans to remedy any engine
specification nonconformances’ revealed during
development and testing of the engine.

(5). (U) Completion of at least 3500 total
hours of full scale engine running time prior to the
start of PFQ endurance test.

C. (U) LPQ shall be considered complete
upon:

59
(1) REDACTED Satisfactory completion of
all the tests, inspections and analyses required by

Appendix E, Engine Model Specification, to Detail
Specification SD-574-1.

(2). (U) Government approval of all
reports documenting the results of the above tests,
inspections and analyses.

(3). (0) Submittal and = approval of
corrective action plans to remedy any engine
specification nonconformances revealed during
development and testing of the engine and full scale
development testing of the aircraft.

(4). (U) Completion of at least 4600 total
hours of full scale engine running time on a
minimum of 6 in-house test engines prior to the start
of LPQ endurance test.

D. (U) FPQ shall be considered complete
upon:

(1). (U) Notwithstanding inspection and
acceptance of aircraft containing engines hereunder,
the Contractor shall perform corrective actions
required to remedy any engine specification
nonconformance revealed by development and
testing of the engine and full scale development
flight testing of the aircraft.

(2). REDACTED Satisfactory completion of
all PFQ and LPQ requirements stated above.

(3). (U) Satisfactory completion of an
additional 1000 hours Accelerated Simulated
Mission Endurance Test (ASMET) conducted (1) in

60

accordance with paragraph 4.6.1.2 of the engine
model specification, and (2) on the same nameplate
engine used for the official LPQ ASMET with
changes only as necessary to perform routine
maintenance or update to the FPQ configuration.

(4). (U) Satisfactory completion of an
altitude performance and operability demonstration
conducted in accordance with paragraph 4.6.3 of the
engine mode) specification on an engine conforming
to the FPQ parts list.

(5). (U) Test verification (component
and/or engine) to 90% confidence of the minus three
sigma low cycle fatigue life or damage tolerance
inspection interval for each critical rotation
component and pressure vessel.

(6) (U) Accumulation of at least 9535
hours of full scale engine running time.

2. (U) Perform the work specified below. ‘The
following tasks shall be completed as a part of the
engine qualifications and integration of the engine
into the air vehicle:

(U) Task A -- The Contractor shall provide
engineering and material support at all Government
test facilities where the contractor proposes or
requires testing. The Contractor shall provide depot
and intermediate maintenance support for all
engines and exhaust systems being tested at the
government designated test facilities and the
contractor’s facility as well as provide organization
maintenance

61

wean

SCHEDULE

Final Assembly for Option Item 0301 aircraft. and
Second-Sourcing and Co-Production for the fifth lot
of production aircraft.

REDACTED Item 0006 - The
Contractor shall provide special tooling and test
equipment required hereunder, and it shall be of a
type, quantity and quality suitable for sustaining all
applicable requirements of the ATA Program under
Items 0001 through 0005 and 0049 and 0050.

REDACTED Item 001) - The Contractor
shall establish and maintain management activities
in accordance with the Project Management
Requirements for the ATA Aircraft Weapon System
to satisfactorily complete the tests required by this
contract. The program management effort shall be
established with authority delegated at appropriate
levels. Individual assignments’ within the
management organization shall facilitate single-
points-of-contact for interface with Government
Managers in a timely manner. The Contractor shall
commit such resources as are necessary to
accomplish the requirement stated herein. Program
Management shall be accomplished in accordance
with Attachment 24, the Program Management
Requirements for the ATA Aircraft Weapon System,
as revised and updated for FSD, SD-574:1,
Addendum 648 to SD-8706C, Addendum 116 to MIL-
D-8708B(AS), ILS-DS-30A-155 and Attachment 25.

62

REDACTED The contractor shall

participate in joint Navy/Contractor program level
conference and reviews as follows:

A.

1.

REDACTED Prograin Reviews

Program Reviews shall be reviews of the
current status of the contractor's overall ATTA
development program, and shall cover all
principal technical, =programinatic — and
contractual matters. Program Reviews will be
held quarterly through CDR and then three
times a year thereafter, at the prime
contractor's plant and each normally will be
three days in length. The agenda for cach
Program Review wall be jointly established by
the prime contractor and PMA-235. The first
Program Review will be held) within six
months after contract award.

REDACTED Post Award Orientation

Post Award Orientation Conferences of the
ATA shal! be conducted at) the prime
contractor's plant to clarify procedural and
administrative requirements and — resolve
potential areas of misunderstanding. The
length of the conference shall — be
approximately two working days. The first
post award orientation conference shall be
held within 45 days after contract award.

akanaeat

63

(U) Item 0045 - The Contractor shall design,
develop, install and maintain one set (eft and mght
hand inlet) of high response inlet distortion rakes for
one aircraft in order to validate and develop, if
necessary, engine/inlet compatibility. Rakes shall be
designed in accordance with Appendix E of the Detail
Specification, SD-574-1.

(U) Item 0047 - The Contractor shall
establish and provide a CALS Technical Manual
Program for Item 0005, in accordance with ILS-DS-
30A-155, Chapter 1, paragraphs 1.3.10 and 1.3.10.1.

REDACTED Item 0049 - The Program
Management Review (PMR) shall be held at the
Contractor's plant and shall review the current
status of the overall ATA development program,
addressing all principal technical, programmatic and
contractual matters. This PMR _ shall not be
considered complete until the Contractor provides
the following top level principal system installation
drawings and top level major component structural
assembly drawings evidencing 100% drawing
release:

Svstems:

(u) Fuel Subsystem
(u) —_ Electrical Subsystems

(u) Environmental Control
System

(u) Hydraulic/Pneumatic
Subsystem

Structural Assemblies:

64

{u) Forward Fuselage

(u) Centerbody

(u) Outboard Centerbody
(u) Aft Section

{u) Outer Wing

REDACTED Item 0050 - The Program
Management Review (PMR) shall be held at the
Contractor’s plant and shall review the current
status of the overall ATA development program,
addressing all principal technical, programmatic and
contractual matters. This PMR shall not be complete
until the following items are also completed:

(u) Software CDR, Build #3, as
defined in Paragraph 5.3.3 of
MIL-STD-2167.

(u) Detailed design and
analysis of FSD “0” Level Hydro-
mechanical support equipment
essentially complete (90%).

(u) LIAFTA core hardware and
software design for the initial six
(6) WRA’s.

REDACTED Item 0051 - The Contractor
shall perform Phase | of ATA design cxaminations,
tests and engineering to substantiate, assess and/or
effect compliance with design requirements in
accordance with Addendum 648 to SD-8706C. The
Contractor shall provide test articles, test hardware,
hardware support and test planning and _ shall
conduct the portion of testing in accordance with
Addendum 648 to SD-8706C required to conduct the
Critical Design Review (CDR). This includes the

65

initia] effort required to design and fabricate a full
size aircraft and cockpit mock-ups that will satisfy
the requirements for aircraft, lighting and aircrew
station mock-ups as specific in paragraph 3.3.2 of
Addendum 658 to SD-8706C. In addition, the
Contractor shall perform Phase | of ATA aircraft
demonstrations in accordance with Addendum 116 to
MIL-D-8708B (AS).

REDACTED Item 0052 - The Contractor
shall conduct Phase I! of testing in accordance with
Addendum 648 to SD-8706C and Addendum 116 to
MIL-D-8708B(AS) as required to effect the first flight
of the first ATA aircraft. The following tests shall be
completed:

(u) First major static condition

(u) - Fatigue/Static Strength
Pitch Flap

(u) Propulsion PPFQ

(u) Proof Test Control
Surfaces on Aircraft #1

(u) Crew Escape - Sled tests

(u) Canopy Pressure tests

(u) Cockpit controls/maximum
pilot effort

(u) Iron Bird Hydraulic
System Functional

(u) Static Strength MLG &
NLG

REDACTED Item 0053 - The Contractor
shall conduct Phase III of testing in accordance with
Addendum 648 to SD-8706C and Addendum 116 to
MIL-D-8708B(AS) as required for the Navy to

66
commence Sea Trials. Aircraft of Item 0005 and
certain production aircraft specified in Clause H-28
hereof shall be used for tests and demonstrations in

accordance with Addendum 116 to MIL-D-
8708B(AS). The following tests shall be completed:

(u) —_ Bird strike tests
(u) — Propulsion PFQ
(a) Clean aircraft drop tests

(u) 1G envelope (clean
aircraft)

(u) RCS Baseline static
measurement

(u) Emergency recovery device
proof test - Aircraft #8

{u) Closed loop/degraded
modes (iron bird)
REDACTED Item 0054 - The Contractor

shall conduct Phase IV of testing in accordance with
Addendum 648 to SD-8706C and Addendum 116 to
MIL-D-8708B{AS) as required through provisional
acceptance of the fourth production aircraft to be
used for tests and demonstrations in accordance with
Addendum 116 to MIL-D-8708B(AS). Aircraft of
Item 0005 and certain production aircraft specified
in Clause H-28 hereof shall be used for tests and
demonstrations in accordance with Addendum 116 to
MIL-D-8708B(AS). The following tests shall be
completed:

(u) Flight tests 100% loads

(u) Second Dynamic RCS
measurement

(u) Fatigue test - 2 lifetimes

67

(a) CBR intrusion test

(u) Drop tests Deck
Obstruction Test
REDACTED Item 0055 - The

Contrestor shall conduct Phase V of testing in
accordance with Addendum 648 to SD-8706C and
Addendum 116 to MIL-D-S8708B(AS) as required to
deliver the first ATA aircraft to the Navy for
commencement of TECHEVAL. Aijrcraft of Item
0005 and certain production aircraft specified in
Clause H-28 hereof shall be used for tests and
demonstrations in accordance with Addendum 116 to
MIL-D-8708B{AS). The following tests shall be
completed:

(u) Propulsion LPQ
(u) Repeated fatigue drops
(u) Fuel ingestion

(u) Laboratory armament
tests

(u) RCS airframe RAMS Spec
test

(u) Third Dynamic RCS
measurement

REDACTED Item 0056 - The Contractor

shall conduct Phase VI of testing in accordance with
Addendum 648 to SD-8706C and Addendum 116 to
MIL-D-8708B(AS) as required to the completion of
TECHEVAL on all TECHEVAL aircraft. Aircraft of
Item 0005 and certain production aircraft specified
in Clause H-28 hereof shall be used for tests and
demonstrations in accordance with Addendum 116 to

68

MIL-D-8708B(AS). The following tests shall be
completed:

(u) Flight Control System
Integration (iron bird)
(u) Aircraft No. 2 propulsion

tests
(u) Contractor flight tests
(u) Structural Dynamic

Service Life Effects
(u) Aireraft High Angle of
Attack

REDACTED Item 0057 - The Contractor
shall furnish Aircrew Training Devices for Item 0005
in accordance with Appendix C, (Appendix E) to ILS-
DS-30A-155, the Training System Specification,
Chapters 3.0 - 5.0, paragraphs 3.2, 4.2 and 5.2.

REDACTED The Contractor shall also
furnish a suite of Maintenance Training devices in
accordance with Appendix C (Appendix F) to ILS-DS-
30A-155, the Training System Specification,
Chapters 3.0 - 5.0, paragraphs 3.3, 4.3 and 5.3.

REDACTED The Contractor shall
continue to establish and conduct the Aircrew and
Maintenance Training Curricula, Design,
Development and Implementation programs and
Evaluation, Maintenance and Revision Programs
defined in Item 0022.

REDACTED Item 0058 - The Contractor
shall perform Interim Contractor Logistics Support
(ICLS) for {tem 0057 in accordance with paragraph

69

1.2.2 of Appendices C and D to Appendix C of ILS-
DS-30A-155.

REDACTED Option Items 0101, 0201,
0302, 0401. The Contractor shall fabricate, assemble
and delivery ATA aircraft in accordance with SD-
574-1 and Appendices thereto. Sustaining Tooling
Support for Production, such as the costs of
maintenance and refurbishment due to normal wear
and tear, methods improvements, quality assurance
and calibration, subcontractor production non-
recurring, establishment of dual final assembly and
co-production capability , and establishment and
qualification of vendor second sources shall be
included in the respective option prices. For Option
Item 0101 the contractor shall implement the process
described in the clause entitled “Dual Sourcing and
Co-Production Capability”. Under Option Item 0101,
the avionics system shall be tested in accordance
with paragraphs 4.1, 4.3, 4.4 and 4.5 of Appendix D
to Detail Specification, SD-574-1. Under Option
Items 0201 and 0301 the avionics systems shall be
tested in accordance with paragraphs 4.1, 4.4 and 4.5
of Appendix D to Detail Specification, SD-574-1.
Under Option Item 0401 the avionics system shall be
tested in accordance with paragraphs 4.1, 4.4 and 4.5
of Appendix D to Detail Specification, SD-574-1, for
all CI’s and paragraphs 4.3 and 4.5 (equivalent) of
Appendix D to Detail Specification, SD-574-1, for
second-sourced CI’s.

REDACTED Production aircraft shall
have the following alternate mission equipment
attached at delivery.

70

Per

Aircraft

Qty

6 BRU-32/A Bomb Rack

4 ALE-39 Chaff Dispenser
1 Fuel Probe (IFR) Tip

2 sets Survival Kit Components
1 Radar Altimeter

1 X-Band Beacon

2 LAU-127 Missile Launcher
6 Tandem Adapter

12 DAC 4010 Rack

REDACTED The following alternate mission
equipment shall be shipped separately:

Qty Per
Aircraft
1 1 BRU-32/A Bomb
Rack
1 1 Chal Adapter

1 l Lode 14 Rack

71

1 4 Primary Auxihary
Fuel Tank

1 4 Secondary
Auxiliary Fuel
Tank

1 12 Mod 28-200 Refuel
Store

1 12 D-704 (or
equivalent Refue)
Store)

1 1 External Pylon

1 l 400 Gallon Tank

l 2 BRU-41 Rack

l 2 BRU-42 Rack

12 10 ‘LAU-117 Missile
Launcher

2 5 Lau-115 Missile
Launcher

REDACTED The engines’ delivered

integrated with the ATA aircraft hereunder shall
conform to both (a) the requirements of Engine
model Specification Appendix E to SD-574-1 and b)
the drawings depicting the parts comprising the
parts list as modified by Class I and Class II changes
for the engine configuration which successfully

72

completes Limited Production Qualification (LPQ) or
Full model specification noncompliance found during
flight tests. If the obligation to conform to any such
drawing conflicts with the obligation to conform to
the specification requirements, the specification
requirements. shall prevail; however, a_ part
appearing on such parts list may not be changed in
any manner from the version depicted on its
applicable drawings in order to conform to
specification requirements unless the change is
approved under the Configuration Control Procedure
described in special provision H-36.

(U) The engines shall be acceptance tested
in accordance with the engine model specification
Appendix E to SD-574-1.

(U) The contractor shall maintain a quality
assurance program in accordance with MIL-Q-
9858A, Amendment 2. Additionally the contractor
shall provide and maintain a corrective action and
disposition system for nonconforming material in
accordance with MIL-STD-1520A with Notice 1 and
a supplier quality assurance program in accordance
with MIL-STD-1535A for all supplies and services
provided under this contract.

73
SCHEDULE

SPECIAL SECURITY REQUIREMENTS FOR
COMPARTMENTED CONTRACTS

1. [REDACTED] GENERAL. This
contract pertains to a program, part of which
is compartmented, and which contains
Sensitive Compartmented Information (SC])
and Special Access Program (SAP)
information. Access to SCI and SAP
information under this contract is limited to
those personnel who have been propcrly
briefed in accordance with the Program
Security Manual (PSM) and have executed a
Program Indoctrination Agreement. The
contractor shall provide and maintain a secure
control system within an approved program
facility in accordance with the requirements
and restrictions of (1) this clause: (2) the
Program Security Manual (PSM):

(3) attachment 34, Contract Security
Classification Specification (DD-254) and
attachment thereto: and (4) attachment 45:
Security Implementation Plan. Clarification
of security requirements and restrictions will
be provided upon request by the Program

Security Officer (PSO).

2. {REDACTED) PROGRAM
SECURITY OFFICER/ASSISTANT
PROGRAM SECURITY OFFICERS.
[REDACTED] responsibility has been
assigned to the PSO, NAVAL AIR SYSTEMS

74

COMMAND (NAVAIRSYSCOM). The PSO is
the US Navy official responsible for all aspects
of security for the BRAVERY program. The
PSO is aided by Assistant Program Security
Officers (APSO), who will enforce the security
policies and procedures of the program.

3. (U) PROGRAM SECURITY
COORDINATOR. The Contractor shall
designate with the approva! of the PSO, a
Program Security Coordinator (PSC) who,
assisted by a staff assigned for these functions,
shall be assigned the responsibility for
assuring compliance with the provisions of
this CLAUSE, the DD 254, and the PSM made
a part of this contract by reference, and with
any clarification of security requirements and
restrictions provided by the PSO.

4. (U) SECURITY VIOLATIONS.
Security is a material part of this contract. A
violation of any of the requirements and
restrictions of this clause, and of any PSM
which may be incorporated by reference in this
contract, may result in debriefing and removal
from access to the classified/compartmented
portion of the program, and may also be
grounds for termination of the contract for
default. Further, any unauthorized disclosure
of the classified information pertaining to this
contract or program could seriously affect the
national defense of the United States, and
such revelation would be subject to federal
prosecution under the Espionage Laws (Title

75

18, United States Code, Section 793, 794 and
798).

5. {REDACTED] CONTRACTOR
PROGRAM FACILITY. ‘The PSO shail, with
PSC, inspect the contractor's facility to ensure
compliance, storage capability, and adequate
safeguarding of all program material. Under
no circumstances will storage of, or work on
compartmented program materia) be
performed in other than the approved program
facility.

6. (U) PUBLIC DISCLOSURE. Public
disclosure or conformation of any subject
matter relative to this contract is not
authorized without first obtaining written
approval from the PSO and the PCO.

7 (U) INVOICE/VOUCHER
SUBMISSION. See Section G.

8. [REDACTED] DD 254. The DD 254
and the contract number for the BRAVERY
program are unclassified and may be shown to
DEFINVSERV inspectors when requested, but
inspectors are not to be allowed access to the
contract or the BRAVERY program facility. If
they insist, the DEFINVSERYV inspectors are
to be told to contact [REDACTED] PSO, on
(202) 692-2020. The PSO shall also be notified
immediately by telephone, 1n order that
appropriate action can be taken.

[{-2

76

7. (UW) WAIVER OF CONTRACT OR
SECURITY REQUIREMENTS. Any conflict
which may exist between this clause and the
VSM or instructions from the PSO or PCO
shall immediately be brought to the attention
of the PCO. Resolution shall be authorized by
the PCO in writing.

8. (U) CORRESPONDENCE. Mailing of
correspondence will be in accordance with the
yuidance contained in attachment 45, Security
lnplementation Plan.

(J) CERTIFICATION OF INDIRECT
COSTS (APR 1986) (DOD FAR SUP
52.942-7003)

(a) (U) The Contractor shall certify any
proposal to establish or modify billing rates or
to establish final indirect costs rates in the
form set forth in paragraph (b) of this clause.
The certificate shall be signed on behalf of the
Contractor by an individual of the Contractor's
organization at a level) no lower than a vice
president or chief financial offer of the
business segment of the Contractor that
submits the proposal. The Contractor
understands that if the Contractor fails to
submit a certificate as required herein,
payments on account of indirect cost shall be
at rates unilaterally established by the
Governinent.

H-7

77
SCHEDULE

(U) ALLOTMENT OF FUNDS
APPLICABLE TO FSED ITEMS

(a) (U) The supplies and services
to be furnished under the basic contract
FSED Items shall be funded by the
Government on an installment basis.
This financing arrangement is
necessitated by the unavailability for
obligation, at the outset of this contract,
of sufficient funds to cover the total
target values or ceiling price of the basic
FSED contract line items.

(b) (U) The Contractor agrees that
the Government’s obligation of funds in
the amounts and by the dates set forth
below will permit compliance with the
contract. The Contractor acknowledges
that the terms and conditions for the
performance of this contract have been
established on the basis that the
Contractor’s termination liability will
not exceed the amount set forth below
by the dates set forth opposite said
amounts. Nothing herein — shall
authorize nor require the Contractor to
incur costs, plus a reasonable allowance
for profit, in excess of the total amount
obligated at any given time. The
Contractor may request the
Government, but the Government shall

78

not be obligated, to provide funds at a
more rapid rate than described herein.
The Contractor shall not be entitled to
reimbursement of costs incurred by the
Contractor through progress payments
when the Contractor exceeds the
amount of obligation specified herein.
However, when amounts are obligated,
any costs incurred by the Contractor
prior to such obligation shall be
allowable to the same extent as if such
costs had been incurred after such
amounts had been obligated.

REDACTED
Date by Which
Installment Amt. of
Will be | Obligation (Not
Installment Obligated cumulative)
1 Date of | $150,000,000.00
Contract.
2 14 Jan 1988 $616,000,000.00
3 01 Nov 1988 | $286,000,000.00
|
4 | 07 Jan 1989 $861,300,000.00
5 01 Nov 1989 $350.000,000.00
6 07 Jan 1990 $1,050,000,000.00

~)

10

11

79
01 Nov 1990 $185,000,000.00

07 Jan 1991 $553,200,000.00
01 Nov 1991 $55.900,000.00
07 Jan 1992 $167,600,000.00

01 Nov 1992 $104,219,436.00

(c) (U) In the event the
Government fails to obligate any
specified installment by the time
specified, the Contractor will continue
performance of the contract only to the
extent that he shall not be required to
incur obligations (termination liability)
beyond that amount already obligated
by the Government. If the Government
fails to obligate any funds at the time
specified and there are not previously

obligated funds remaining, the
Contractor shall notify the Contracting
()fficer. After receipt of this

notification, the Contracting Officer has
thirty (30) days to provide additional
funds or must issue a stop work order
not to exceed a period of thirty (30)
days. If the Contracting Officer issues a
stop work order and then funds the
contract during the work stop period,
the target values and ceiling price,
delivery schedules, and terms and

80

conditions of this contract shall be
equitably adjusted, to the extent that it
can be demonstrated by the Contractor
that such failure to obligate funds
affected contract cost and/or
performance. The Government's total
obligation for payment (including
termination settlement expenses) under
this contract shall not exceed the total
amount obligated at the time of
termination.

(qd) (U) Change Orders issued
pursuant to the “Changes” clause of the
contract shall set forth funds estimated
at the time to be sufficient to perform
the change unless otherwise agreed to
by the parties. Pending any equitable
adjustment pursuant to said clause, the
funds set forth in the change order shall
be added to the then established
amount of installment funds set forth in
paragraph (b) above.

(c) (U) Nothing contained in this
clause shall affect the right of the
Government to terminate this contract
pursuant to either the “Default” or
“Termination for the Convenience of the
Government” clauses.

(f) (U) The Government may
obligate funds at a more rapid rate than
set forth above without affecting any
other term or condition of this contract.

$1

(g) (U) If Congress appropriates
funds which require’ incremental!
funding for all or any party of Option |,
a clause similar to this “Allotment of
Funds” clause will apply to that
incremental funding portion of Option I.

(END OF CLAUSE)

82
SCHEDULE

electronic systems with advanced technology, and
provide maximum commonality with the Advanced
Tactical Fighter (ATF) program. Therefore, any
features in accordance with the Joint Integrated
Avionics Working Group (JIAWIG) common avionics
baseline (CAB-1) definitions that can be incorporated
in the baseline design to ease or make less expensive
the transition during P3I should be emphasized. The
CAB-1 documents are available separately from the
Program Office.

(END OF CLAUSE)

H-28 (REDACTED) Government Property for the
Performance of this Contract (Fixed-Price)
(Apr 1985) (NAVAIR 52.245-9500)

(a) (U) Definition. Government production
and research property, as the term is used herein,
shall consist of special tooling to which the
Government has title or the right to acquire title,
Government-owned special test equipment and
Government-owned facilities as each term is defined
respectively in FAR 45.101 and 45.301.

83

(b) (U) Authorization to Use Government
Production and Research Property. Material. and
Agency Peculiar Property Currently Covered by
Government Contracts Without Rental Charge in
Performing this Contract. Government production
and research property, material, and agency peculiar
property covered by the following listed Government
contracts on the effective date of this contract is
hereby authorized for use on a rent-free, non-
interference basis in the performance of this contract
and sub-contracts of any tier issued hereunder
(except for Items identified as Foreign Military Sales
(FMS) Items in Section B):

(b)(1) (REDACTED) For McDonnell Aircraft

Company and Subcontractors

F33657-76-A-0053 N00383-84-G-4510

F33657-77-C-0027
F33657-78-C-0513
F33657-82-C-0067
F42600-80-C-5225
F42600-81-C-5482
F42600-82-D-4980
F42600-83-C-4577
N00019-82-G-0101
N00383-75-A-6333
N00383-77-A-7500
N00383-78-A-8504
N00383-81-G-1500
N00383-83-G-3500
F33657-78-C-0645

F09603-75-A-0164
F09603-76-A-1729
F09603-77-C-0743
F09603-78-G-1129
F09603-80-C-0229
F09603-80-C-1472
F09603-S0-G-0001
F09603-80-G-0285
F09603-81-G-1045
F33615-79-C-3627
F33615-84-C-3015
F33657-76-C-0464
F33657-78-C-0527
F33657-78-G-0007

F33657-79-C-0779

F33657-81-G-2168
F33657-83-C-0043

F33657-84-C-2002

F33657-84-C-2228

N00383-81-G-1500
N00019-78-C-0526
N00019-81-C-0157
N00019-81-G-0509
N00019-82-C-0501
N00019-83-C-0272
N00019-83-C-0336
N00019-83-G-0277
N00019-84-C-0063
N00019-84-C-0200
N00019-84-H-0418
N00019-85-C-0003
N00019-83-G-5300
N00019-76-C-0666
N00019-79-G-0008
N00019-80-G-0101
N00019-82-C-0359
N00019-83-C-0119
N00019-85-C-0109
N61339-82-C-0022
F33657-77-A-0001

84

F33657-80-C-0056
F33657-81-G-2169
¥33657-83-C-2133
F33657-84-C-2131
F33657-85-C-2086
N00383-83-G-3500
N00019-86-C-0173
N00019-8i-G 0455
N00019-82-C-0440
N00019-82-G-0475
N00019-83-C-0335
N00019-83-C-0431
N00019-83-G-0412
N00019-84-C-0116
N00019-84-C-0270
N00019-85-C-0002
N00019-85-G-0076
N62269-84-C-0111
N00019-79-C-0165
N00019-80-C-0655
N00019-81-C-0497
N00019-82-G-0460
N00019-83-C-0267
N00383-84-G-4510
F33615-78-C-3601
N61339-76-C-0063

85

(U) McDonnell Aircraft and Subcontractor Facilities

Contracts:

Vendor

Allied-Bendix Teterboro NJ
Brunswick Prod Marion VA
Cleveland Pn Co Cleveland
OH

Cleveland Pn Co Tullahoma
TN

GE Aircraft E] Binghamton
NY

GE Armament Sys
Burlington VT
Hamilton-Sta Windsor
Locks CT

Honeywell Ind St. Louis Pk
MN

Honeywell Ind St. Louis Pk
MN

Hughes Aircraft Culver
City CA

Hughes Aircraft Culver
City CA

Hughes Aircraft Culver
City CA

Hughes Aircraft Culver
City CA

Hughes Aircraft Tucson AZ
Martin Marietta Orlando
FL

Facility
Contract No.

DAAHO1-86-E-0001
F33657-72-C-0078
F33657-78-L-0113
N0Q0019-84-E-9017
F33657-80-E-0297
DAAA09-86-E-0007
N00019-86-E-9005
DAAAO9-76-E-0030
N00024-82-E-5429
DAAHO1-86-E-A001
N00030-85-E-0122
NAS3-19569-F

NAS5-26229

F33657-81-E-2096
DAAH01-85-E-A001

Exp.
Date

0191
0787
1088

0290

Martin Marietta Orlando

FL

86

MDAC Huntington Beach

CA

MDC St. Louis MO
MDC St. Louis MO
MDC Tulsa OK

Northrop Corp Hawthorne

CA

Pacific Clark-Aiken

E! Segundo CA
Sanders Associates
Manchester NH

Tico Titusville FL

F09306-83-C-3990
NAS7-527F

N00019-83-E-9030
N00019-83-L-9032
F33657-72-L-0647
N00030-85-E-0135

F33657-81-E-2181
N00019-84-E-9015

DAAHO1-74-C-2721

N00019-82-E-9013

World Aerospace
Minneapolis MN

F61546-80-C-0014

DAAH01-83-D-A006
DAAH01-85-C-A050
DAAH0O1-85-C-A095

P0111-4927-A101

F61546-83-C-0001
F41606-83-A-0002
F41608-76-A-0003
F33657-78-G-0004

DAAD07-85-C-0009

F41608-86-D-0023
F41608-81-G-0024
F41608-80-G-0028
F41608-78-G-0032

(b)(2) (REDACTED) For General Dynamics:

F33657-83-C-0340
F04606-78-C-0358
F08635-82-C-0366
F33657-81-C-0432
F04606-78-A-0541
F33657-74-C-0591
F'33657-78-C-0669
F04606-83-C-0795
F33615-83-C-1029
F04606-78-C-1042
AF33657-13403
F04606-82-C-1408
NAS 3-16080F
NAS 3-16090

87

F41608-84-G-0036
F41608-85-G-0044
F41608-81-G-0046
F19628-83-C-0054
1°04606-84-D-0065
DSA500-77-A-0069
F04606-85-D-0073
I'33657-82-D-0079
F26600-79-C-0098
F04606-80-C-0099
F08635-78-C-0103
F04606-80-D-0112
¥'04606-82-D-0125
F04606-83-C-0126
N00019-85-C-0146
F04606-82-C-0156
F41608-82-D-0157
F33657-80-D-0169
F33657-86-C-0171
F30602-83-C-0178
F33657-76-C-0191
F33657-84-C-0192
F33657-76-C-0197
F'33657-80-L-0242
F33657-84-C-0247
F33657-84-C-0249

DAAK40-79-C-0263

F30602-80-C-0270

Contract No.

F33657-81-C-2012
F33657-82-C-2034
33657-82-C-2038
F33657-82-G-2084
F33657-82-G-2085
F33657-82-C-2120
F33615-78-C-3022
F33615-83-C-3227
F33615-80-C-3239
F09603-83-D-3573
F'41608-86-M-3846
F42600-83-D-4006
F42600-83-D-4008
F42600-83-C-4010
F42600-83-C-4011
F42600-84-C-4196
F42600-82-C-4580
F42600-85-D-4599
I'42600-85-D-4600
F42600-85-D-4601
F42600-85-D-4910
F33615-83-C-5079
F33615°81-C-5122
F33615-73-C-5178
F'42600-82-C-5730
F'42600-82-C-7509
NAS 3-22337

F33657-75-C-0310

(REDACTED) General Dynamics Facilities Contract:

Exp. Date

88
F33657-82-E-2124 7/89

(b)(3) (REDACTED) For McDonnell! Aircraft
and General Dynamics: Subject to the provisions of
paragraphs b(i) and (2) above, any of the
aforementioned items of special tooling and/or
special test equipment presently in the possession of
the Contractor and/or subcontractors may be
modified as necessary for the performance of this
contract subject to the approval of the requiring
contract PCO. It is, however, hereby provided that
such modification shall not interfere with the proper
performance of work under the contract{s) for which
they were originally produced, acquired or furnished
and that the Contractor shall return the modified
equipment to its original configuration after use. .

In addition, each Contractor may use, on a
rent-free, non-interference basis, any of the other
Contractor's Government-furnished property under
this clause at the St. Louis, Missouri, Fort Worth
Texas or Tulsa, Oklahoma locations.

(b)(4) (REDACTED) For General Electric:

Evandale: F33657-73-L-0248
Lynn, Mass: N00019-76-C-0261
N00019-78-C-0063
N00019-79-C-0152
N00019-80-C-0021
N00019-81-C-0050
N00019-81-E-9003
N00019-82-C-0042
N00019-83-C-0086

89

N00019-83-C-0150
NOO0019-83-C-0156
N00019-84-C-0140
NO00019-84-C-0136
N00019°84°C-0137
N00019 85-C-0129
N00019 85 C0160
N00019-85-C-0162
N00019-86-C-0048
N00019-86-C-0195
N00019-86-C-0166
N00019°85-C-0459 and
successor contracts

(REDACTED) Kor General] electric

Subcontractors:

American Welding & Mfg. Co.,

Warren, OH P33657-71-C-0122
Arkwin Industries Inc. B33657-71-C-0625
Bendix Corp., Energy Controls

Div. F33657-79-C-0020
Chandler Evans Corp. F33657-68-C-1332
Kang Fifth Wheel co. P33657-70-C-0952
Reeder & Kline Machine 1° 33657-84--2157
TRW, Inc... Minerva OH 33657-70-C-0272
Sundstrand *33657-70-C-O0819

(b)(5) (U) Consideration has been provided for
all prime and subcontractor facilities usape, as
identified above, on a rent-free, non-interference
basis. However, notwithstanding paragraph (1)
hereof, complete definition of Government production

91)

and research property Gn particular, facilities)
cannot be determined until subcontracting decisions
have been completed by the Contractor. It is
understood and agreed that subcontractor
determinations for facilities use on a rent free, non
interference basis in the performance of this contract
will be rendered on the premise that if such
Government production and research property can
be made available on a rent free, non iunterfercnce
basis, it will be identified and added to this section at
the time of subcontract definitization without further
consideration being required.

(-) (U) Authorization to Use Government
Production and Research Property and Agenevy
Peculiar Property to be Provided Under this Contract
Without Rental Charge in Performing this Contract
(This paragraph does not cover such property in
possession of the Contractor or his subcontractors on
the date of award of this contract.)

(1) (U) Subject to the provisions of the
Government Property clause of this contract,
the Government hereby agrees to provide
hereunder the Government production and
research property and agency peculiar
property identified in (c)€2) through (¢)(5) to
the Contractor. The Contractor is hereby
authorized to use, on a rent-free basis, said
property im the performance of this contract
(except for Items identified as Foreasgn Military
Sales (MS) Items in Seetion B).

91

(2) (U) Special Tooling (as defined in FAR
45.101):

Special Tooling acquired under Item 0006
which may have becn upgraded under Option
Item 0102.

(3) (U) Special Test Equipment (as defined in
FAR 45.101):

Special Test Equipment acquired under Item
0006 which may have upgraded under Option
Item 0102.

(4) (U) Facilities (as defined in FAR 45.301):
NONE

(These facilities shall, when proven, become
accountable under and be subject to that facilities
contract, if anv, in effect between the Government
and the Contractor or any of his subcontractors at
the plant where they are to be located during
performance of this contract.)

(5) (U) Agenev Peculiar Property (as defined in
FAR 45.301 and DOD FAR (Supplement
45.301):

(a) (REDACTED)“For demonstrations under
Items 0051 through 0046. 0203, 0332, and
0405, the Government will furnish: eight (8)
ATA Aircraft, which have been provisionally
accepted under Item 0005, to perform flight
demonstrations; and four (4) ATA Aircraft

92

delivered under Item 0101. to perform

production flight demonstrations. These
aircraft shall be provided on the dates listed
below:

Aircraft Number Need Date

Item 0005: 1 July 1990
2 August 1990
3 September 1990
4 October 1990
5 November 1990
6 December 1990

January 1991

~]

8 February 1991
Item 0101: 1 Julv 1991

2 September 1991

3 November 1991

4 January 1992

For purpose of this paragraph (5)a) and
notwithstanding the provisions of FAR 52.245-2(a)
(4), if the aircraft listed above are not delhvered to
the Contractor by the “need dates” listed above and
such late delivery is attributable to the Contractor's
delav in tendering the aircraft for acceptance as set
out in Section F hereof, an equitable adjustment
shall not be made.

(REDACTED) Spare, repair and@/or replacement
parts for the aircraft designated above and for
support equipment may be drawn from current
production assets (for replacement of assets removed
from aircraft for repair, maintenance or testing

93

purposes) and returned on a “payback” basis (in the
same conditions as furnished, normal wear and tear
excepted, and in a timely manner). The Contractor
may use GFP assets 1n conjunction with, or mn place
of, production assets when authorized by the PCO. If
any of these production/GFP assets are used in the
designated aircraft. the Contractor shall provide a
brief written report stating parts employed,
circumstances necessitating use, and the status of
the “payback” part. This report shall be provided to
the ACO, PMA, and PCO within two (2) weeks of the
conclusion of demonstrations under Item 0001
through 0056 and 0203.

(>) (U) Aircrew protective and flight safety
equipment as necessary to support production
acceptance flights or test flights associated
with the performance of this contract as
itemized below:

Total Estimated
Qty per Qty for FSD

Pilot including
Equipment or B/N* 10% spares
Oxygen mask &
Regulator 1 26
Life Preserver Unit l 26
Parachute Harness 1 26
Anti-g suit } 26
Aviator’s gloves l pr 26 pr
Helmet | 26
Mask & attaching
pieces 1 26

94

Boots 1 pr 26 pr
Flight suits 2 52
Exposure suits 1 26
Sunglasses 1 pr 26 pr
Socks 1 pr 26 pr

* Per pilot quantities will remain unchanged
throughout the production program.

(c) (U) Chase and Target aircraft as required
in performance of this contract as follows:

Chase &
Target A/C Requirement
Location atv Dates
MDC Tulsa i 5/1990
throughout the
program

NATC, Pax River Average: 6** 5/1990 - 1/1993
Peak: _iie

NWC, China - i 11/1990 -

Lake 6/1993

* To be maintained and operated by the
Contractor: must be two seat configuration.

** To be maintained and operated by the
Government.

(REDACTED) Definition of Chase and Target
Aircraft: Aircraft can be subsonic, must be

95

compatible with the Model 21 in regard to
endurance, and must have secure voice
communication capability; target aircraft must
include a minimum of one each F/A-18, A-4, A-7 and
A°6.

(d) (U) All Support Equipment, Technical Data
or other Equipment listed in Attachment 36 to
this Contract.

(U) The following terms and conditions shall be
applicable to the agency peculiar property, if any,
identified above:

(A) (U) each item of agency peculiar property
shall be identified by its Federal Item
Identification number and Government
Nomenclature;

(B) (U) the agency peculiar property shall be
accounted for under this contract: and

(C) (U) upon completion or termination of this
contract, the Contractor shal] request and
comply with disposition instructions from the
Contracting Officer.

(d) (U) Government Material and Agencv Peculiar
Property to be Furnished Under this Contract. (This
paragraph covers Government-owned material and
agency peculiar property furnished to the Contractor
for (A) consumption in the course of manufacture,
testing, development. etc., or (B) incorporation in
items to be delivered under this contract, e.g.,

96

Master Government-Furnished Equipment List
(MGFEL)).

(1) (U) Subject to the provisions of the
Government Property clause of this contract, the
Government hereby agrees to provide hereunder
the Government-owned agency pecuhar Property
and material identified in (d) (2) and (d) (3) to the
Contractor. The Contractor is hereby authorized,
as appropriate, (A) to consume the material
identified in ‘d) (3) in performing this contract or
(B) to incorporate such material and agency
peculiar property in articles under this contract.

(2) (U) Material (as defined in FAR 45.301):

(a) (REDACTED) Fuel (Fleet Common) while
ATA is being supported under this contract.
See the clause entitled “Government
Furnished Petroleum, Oil and Lubricants.”

(b) (U) Material items identified in Appendix | to
Detail Specification SD-574-1. Delivery dates
to the Contractor shall be derived from the
aircraft delivery schedule in Section F hereof.
using Installation Lead Time C(ILT) contained
in the above identified document.

(U) Requisitioning Documentation. If material is
identified above, the requisitioning documentation
for the above material shall be prepared by the
Contractor in accordance with the “Military
Standard Requisitioning and Issue Procedure
(MILSTRIP) for Defense Contractors”, DOD FAR

97

Supplement Appendix H. Upon completion or
termination of this contract, the Contractor shall
request and comply with the disposition instructions
from the Contracting Officer.

(3) (U) Agenev Peculiar Property (as defined in
FAR 45.301 and DOD FAR Supplement
45.301: NONE

(U) The terms and conditions made applicable to
agency peculiar property in (c) (5) shall be applicable
to the agency peculiar property, if any. identified
above.

(e) (U) Government Installations to be Made
Available Under this Contract. (This paragraph
covers Government installations, or portions thereof,
to be made available to a contractor but not
transferred to his possession ~- for example, test
centers, wind tunnels, aircraft fields. as well as
buildings, furniture. or equipment. Instructions may
be needed to establish ground rules or plans
governing availability of installations.)

(1) (U) The Government hereby agrees to make
available hereunder on a_ rent-free, non-
interference basis for performing the contract
Items in Section B- the Government
installations, or portion thereof, identified in
(e) (2) in accordance with standard operating
procedures and priorities unless otherwise
specified in the Schedule. Although not
“Government-furnished property” under this
contract, the provisions of paragraph (a) of the

98

Government Property clause of this contract
shall apply to these installations.

(2) (REDACTED) Installations:

(a) (REDACTED) The Navel Air Test Center,
NAS Patuxent River Maryland shall be the
principal test site and the Naval Weapons
Center, China Lake, Cahfornia shall be the
secondary test site for the ATA FSD Flight
Test Program. The facilities and resources of
the principal and secondary test sites (the
host) shall be provided to the Contractor
within the existing capabilities and resources
available at the test sites during the FSD
program. The responsibility to provide
resources beyond those specified herein shall
be borne by the contractor (the tenant).
Detailed Host/Tenant Agreements and Site
Activation Plans between both the principal
and secondary test sites and the contractor
shall be prepared in accordance with
NAVAIRINST 4000.15A and will be utilized to
define the specific resources available to the
contractor at each test site.

(b) (REDACTED) The contractor shall have
use of work spaces at both the Naval Air Test
Center and Naval Weapons Center for which
the minimum square footage is_ specified
below. Program plans for ATA FSD effort
include construction of new hangar spaces at
both test sites. In the event that construction
of the hangar facilities is not complete by the

99

scheduled arrival dates, adequate interim
facilities will be provided to the contractor
until the new construction is completed at
which time the contractor will be moved into
the new spaces. The contractor shall plan for
and execute an orderly transition into the new
spaces at such time as they become available
such that no impact on the flight test program
shall occur. Host facilities and services will be
made available to support the move. The
contractor shall supply and install special!
laboratory and test equipment to be listed in
his Site Activation Plan for each of the test
sites. Physical security of all contractor
assigned spaces shall be the responsibility of
the contractor.

NATC (sq ft) NWC (sq ft

Office and Computer 9,000 2,000

Space

Warchouse and 5,000 1,100

Storage Space

Laboratory Space 12,000 3,800

Aircraft Shop Areas 7,500 3,500

Project Hangar Space 26.000 10.400
59,500 20,800

In addition, the Government will furnish at
the above installation:

(a) Necessary fuel trucks
(b) Electricity
(c) Water

(d) Gas

100

{e) Compressed Air

(f) Sewer

(zg) Fire Protection

(h) Security

(i) Telephone service, excluding toll calls
{}) Maintenance space and shop usage

{k) Hangar space
(1) Al) additional services, facilities and

equipment
Host/Tenant

usage

subsequent FRD’s.

Agreements

documented in

and

(c) (U) Additional Government installations to
be provided hereunder on a rent-free non
interference basis, along with requirement
dates for all installations are listed below:

NOMENCLA-
TURE

AMES
RESEARCH
CENTER (ARC)

NASA LANGLE ¥
RESEARCH
CENTER (LRC)
NTF

NEED DATES
FROM/TO

06-01-88/06-30-88
08-01-88/09- 15-88
01-01-89/02-15-89
05-01-89/06-15-S9
08-01-89/09-15-89
01-01-90/02-15-90
04-01-91/04-30-9)

01-01-90/02-14-90

UTILIZATION

WIND
TUNNEL

WIND
TUNNEL

(LRC) SPIN

(LRC) 30X60

(LRC) TDT

ARNOLD
ENGINEERING
DEVELOPMENT
CENTER

LEWIS
RESEARCH
CENTER (LERC)
(6x9 ft. icing
tunne]) NAEC

LAKEHURST, N-J.

101

10-01-§8/12-15°88
00-01-90/00-02-90
00-02-90/00-03-90
09-01-90/10-15- 90
08-01-88/09- 15°85
INTERMITTENT
TO 10-15°88

08-01-89/08-31-59
09-01-88/10-15-88
09-01-§9/09- 30-59
05-01-90/05- 31-90

02-01-88/03-15° 88
07-01-88/08-15-88
09-0) -88/} 1-30-88
3°01-89/G3°31-89
07-01-89/07-31-89
09-01-89/
INTERMITTENT
TO 01-31-90
10-01-90/10-31-90

09-01-88/10-31-88
10-01-90/03-31-91
02-01-91/10-31-91

PWT 16T
WIND
TUNNEL

WIND
TUNNEL
FLIGHT TEST
BARRICADE
IEENGAGE-
MENT

NATC (PAX)

NAVY WEAPON
CENTER (CHINA
LAKE)

NADC

TRENTON, NJ.
NAPC

102
01-01-93/06-01 93

06-01-90/04- 30-93

01-01-90/04-30°93

06-01-88/07-31-8S
06-01-89/07-31°89
03-01-91/03°31°91
01-01°92/03-31-°92
1 1-01-89/01-31-90
06-0) -90/10-31°95

Q7-01-89/07 31°59

Q7 U1-89/06- 30°90

STRUCTUR:
AL
DYNAMICS
FLIGHT TEST

SURV/
VUI iN :
BALLISTICS

SLED TEST
FLIGHT TEST
EJIECTION

TOWER
TESTS

PROPUL:
SION ‘TESTS

103

NOMENCLA-

TURE NEED DATES
US. ARMY 09-01-88/10-31-88
PROVIDING

GROUNDS

(MUBWAY. UT)

AF- EWES 06-0) -&8/05-31-89

RATSCAT RAMS | 12°-15-87/07-31-5#
05-01-88/08-3)-88

APPROPRIATE

SIGNATURE

TEST FACILITY AS REQUIRED

EDWARDS AFB 10-01-99/) 9-31-92

EGLIN AFB 10-01-°92/12°31-92

UTILIZATION

SURV/VULN
CR

SIMULATION

SIGNATURE
TEST

FLIGHT TEST
CROSS WINDS

CLIMATIC
TEST

(3) (U) All government-furnished Search and

Rescue Aireraft, test equipment,
stations, and Special Flight

ground

Test

Instrumentation (SFTI), as identified in

Addendum 116 to MIL-D-87088.

(4) (U) Aircrew and maintenance trainer facilities

including air conditioning, heating,

adequate electric power and = yrounding,

hyhting,

and

(f)

104

raised Noormny (aircrew only), on the dates
provided below.

Traimer Suite Need Date
Site #] duly 1992
Site #2 Mareh 1995
Site #3 duly 1995

(U) Bailed Property to be Used Under this

Contract. (This paragraph wall not obviate the need
to set forth om this contract the terms of the project
agreement as required by the pertinent bailment

agreement )

(1) (U) The bailed property identified in) ©2) is
hereby authorized for use on a rent free basis in
the performance of this contract. Although not
“Governmentfurnished property) under this
contract, the provisions of paragraph Gio) of the
Government Property clause of this contract shall
apply to this barled property

(2) (LI) Pailoent
Agreement
Under Which
Description Serial Number Accountable

NONE

(3) (0) The bailed property identified in () €2) 1s
furnished “as is” and the Government makes no
representations or warranties with respect to
such property, including the suitabibty of such
property for the intended use.

105

{g) (U) Notwithstanding any provision to the
contrary in any contract with the United States
Government and in order to ensure compliance with
22 U.S.C. 2761fe), rent-free use of any property
identified above (other than that property identified
in paragraph (d)) in the performance of work under
this contract to satisfy an obligation that implements
a sale of goods or services, or both, to a foreign
government or international organization (if called
for under this contract) is expressly prohibited.
Further, this contract shall in no event be construed
to authorize rent-free use of any property identified
above in the performance of direct commercial! sales
to a foreign government. or __ international
organization.

(h) (U) Installation Cost. The price of this contract
constitutes full compensation to the Contractor for
all costs to be incurred under this contract for the
adaptation and installation of the property identified
in this clause.

G) (U) Installation. Government production and
rescarch property. other than foundations and
similar improvements necessary for the installation
of special tooling, special test equipment, and plant
equipment, as defined in FAR 45.101, shall not be
installed or constructed on land not owned by the
government in such fashion as to be non-severabile
unless authority is granted by the Contracting
Officer cognizant of the contract under which the
property is provided in accordance with FAR 45.309.

106

(j) (U) Limitation. This clause does not authorize the
Contractor to acquire any property for the
Government.

(k) (U) The Contractor represents that the price and
delivery schedule of this contract have been
established in reliance on the Government granting
the authorization in (b), (c), (d), fe) and (f) and that
no charge has been included in this contract for use
of the property as authorized above.

(1) (U) Whenever the Contracting Officer authorizes
or makes available the use. on a rent-free basis, of
additional Government production and _ research
property or other Government property in_ the
performance of this contract or subcontracts of any
tier under this contract, the contract will be
equitably adjusted in accordance with the procedures
provided for in the Changes clause.

(m) (U) If the Government production and research
property or other Government property authorized or
made available above is decreased by the
Government, the Contractor will be entitled to an
equitable adjustment to the terms of this contract in
accordance with the procedures provided for in the
Changes clause hereof as a result of such decrease:
provided, however, that if any such decrease is due to
the failure of the Contractor or his subcontractors of
any tier under this contract to fulfill their respective
obligations either with respect to the Government
property or with respect to the work such property is
to be used to perform, the Contracting Officer will

107

take such circumstances into account in establishing
the equitable adjustment.

H-29

(END OF CLAUSE)

(U) GOVERNEMENT-FURNISHED
PETROLEUM. OIL. AND LUBRICANTS

(a) (REDACTED) The petroleum, oil and
lubricant items necessary for use in the
performance of this contract set forth below
and in SD-574-1, Appendix E, shall be
furnished by the Government to. the
Contractor subject to the provisions of this
clause and the “Government Property for the
Performance of this Contract” clause for use at
Contractor designated plants at Tulsa,
Oklahoma: St. Louis, Missouri; Forth Worth,
Texas: Lynn, Massachusetts: Evandale, Ohio;
or Trenton, New Jersey, as applicable, and for
use at the Government installations listed in
Clause H-28.

Aviation Turbine Fuel, commercial Grade JP-4
Type MIL-T-5624L, NSN 9130-00-256-8613

Aviation Turbine Fuel, Commercial Grade JI’
5 Type MIL-T-5624L,. NSN 9130-00-273-2379

Aviation Turbine Lubricating O11 Type MIL-L-
23699 NSN 9150-00-681-5999

Aviation Turbine Lubricating Oil, Grade 1010,
Type MIL-L-6081, NSN 9150-00-231-6676

108

(b) (U) In the event a situation or condition
arises whereby the Government is unable to
furnish the petroleum, oil, or lubricant items
in a timely manner so that a delay in the
performance of the contract is threatened, it is
agreed that the Contractor shall, with the
approval of the Administrative Contracting
Officer, procure the necessary petroleum, oil.
and lubricant items to prevent delay in
performance of the contract. The Contractor
may either receive reimbursement in kind, or
be entitled to an equitable adjustment to all
relevant terms of the contract in accordance
with the procedures provided for in the
“changes” clause to take into account the
contractors having provided such _ fuel,
petroleum or lubricant.

(REDACTED) Estimated quantities of
Aviation Turbine Fuel, MIL-T-5624L are as
follows:

Quantity in Barrel's

FSD 425.000*
Lot 1 2.640
Lot 2 3,520
Lot 3 8.800
Lot 4 15,840

(c) (U) The Contractor shall comply with MIL-
STD-1518A, dated ?0 February 1974.

(END OF CLAUSE)

109

H-30 (U) SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS PERTAINING
TO CERTAIN GOVERNMENT
FURNISHED PROPERTY

(U) The Government will furnish to the
Contractor for use in the performance of this
contract, subject to and in accordance with the
provisions of the clause entitled “Government
Property for the Performance of this
Contract,” the following:

AIRCRAFT LOG BOOK
BINDERS AND SEPARATION
PAGES

ENGINE LOG BOOK BINDERS
AND SEPARATION PAGES

(U) The Administrative Contracting Officer
(ACO) shall insure that aircraft and engine log
book binders and _ separation pages. are
available for at least ninety (90) days prior to
the delivery of the aircraft and/or engine for
which they are associated.

(REDACTED) In the event an aircraft or
engine log book binder and separation pages is
not available at that time, the ACO shall
contact Naval Weapons Engineering Support
Activity, Washington D.C. 20734. Attn ESA-
203 to furnish as required.

(END OF CLAUSE)

110

H-31 (REDACTED) PROCEDURE FOR
OBTAINING CONTROLLED MATERIALS
(MAY 1986) (NAVATR 52.212-9500)

(U) Increasing scarcity of production materials
demands that the following procedures be
adhered to in complying with the
requirements of the clause of this contract
entitled “Defense Priority and Allocation
Requirements”. Nonconformance with these
procedures may cause delays in obtaining
needed materials --

(a) (U)’ The priority rating must appear on
all subcontracts and purchase orders.

(b) (U) Adequate delivery Jead time must

be allowed in placing subcontracts and
purchase orders.

(c) (U) The Contractor shall use his best
efforts to obtain a satisfactory delivery
schedule from his subcontractors prior to
referral to the Government for assistance.
Such referral, if required, shall be made to
the Administrative Contracting Officer of
the cognizant contract administration
office.

11li
PART II - CONTRACT CLAUSES

PROGRESS PAYMENTS (APR 1984) (DEVIATION)
(FAR 52.232-16)

Progress payments shall be made to the
Contractor when requested as work progresses,
but not more frequently than monthly in amounts
approved by the Contracting Officer, under the
following conditions:

(a) Computation of amounts

(1) Unless the Contractor requests a
smaller amount, each progress payment
shall be computed as

(i) 75 percent of the Contractor's
cumulative total costs under. this
contract, as shown’ by _ records
maintained by the Contractor for the
purpose of obtaining payment under
Government contracts, plus

(ii) progress payments to
subcontractors (see paragraph ())
below), all less the sum of all previous
progress payments made by the
Government under this contract. Cost
of money that would be allowable unde

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA43085015_0591%3A08. Public record. Not legal advice.
