# Petition for Writ of Certiorari — United States v. Silk

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386450_0240%3A2

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Petition for Writ of Certiorari
- **Published:** January 1, 1946
- **Citation:** 329 U.S. 702

## Text

¢ -
g .
je MA Pie i34
ma 2
oe ib LE MRE QEEP
™%
~
. . 4
% NO, -—- ‘

; the Sree the nied Sites

OcroBeR TERM, 1946

——————

“UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, PETITIONER

a: ° | -
~ i
Avpert Sirk, Doing Business aS ALBERT SILK
am , Coat CoMPaNy

PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED

STATES CIRCUIT COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE TENTH
CIRCUIT .

. ~

-_--——.-

Opinions below. * oer rs eat Reva air . ]
Jurisdiction. —__. 5 ae ee ae mee 2
Questions presented...” eee ek« 2
‘Statites aid re gulations involved Ce Re ene see er -f- 2
Statement. - : : ae i - 2
Specification of errors to be urged inden z 5
Reasons for granting the writ es 6
Conelusion..- =... ean ie ee re Ls ©
Appendix S utes eee 13
‘CITATIONS |. .

Cases: ings ’
American Oil Co. v. Fly, J 35 ee & | Se a

- Bedford Pulp & Paper @. v. Early, decided April 6, 1944,

Dp. C., E. D: Va ne gscthsgnnasede es V1
Deecy Products Co. v. We Ich, 124 KF. 2d! 592__: re eee 9
For Park Timber Co. v. Baker, 53 Wyo. 467 : —S 11
Conn v. Beard, 141 V. 24-376, certiorari denied, seh Ss. :

724, rehearing denicd, 324 USS. 889... : , 8,9
Glenn ves tandurd Oil Co., 148 F. 2d ~ —

é Greet Vv. Magruder, 148 F. 2d 679, certiorari denieg October
8 1945, No. 102, October 1945 Term, : P & 7:3-9
Poke Rapids ~~ Co. v. United State#, decided March

30, 1942, D.C. Dy, Balen. : ra Na 11
Hiner, Matter oj; pea d Se pte mber 2. 1941, D. C.8. D.,

Ind. : . Siok , 11
Industrial Com, v. “Bonfils, 78 Golo, 306... = a... s 11
Jones v. Goodson, 121 F. 2d. 176 ior )
National Labtr Refffions Board:y. Hearst P ublieations, 322

Ure, bes eee age ; 7,10, 11

Nevins, Inc. ¥: Rothersies, 151 F. 2d 189, affirining 58 F.
— Supp. 460___- 2 a
Perkins Bros., Inc. v. Dicninslen: decided October 19, 1944,

;D.C. N. D., Iowa_.--- 5 a ee wits lt
Texas Co. v. Higgins, 118 F. 24 636— ‘ ae
United States y. Aberdeen Aerie No ae & F. 2d 655" Q

, United States v. Vogue, Imé., 145 Fo 2d 0Q9 j7 8,9
\ Willard Sugar Co. v. Gentsch, 59 F. Sapp 1}
Statutes: ; ete
Internal Reyenue Code: :
- See. 1400 (26 U.S.C. 1940 ed., See, 1400) — 14.
Sec, 1401 (26 U.S. C. 1940.ed., See. 1401) 2 14
TOL002 ; tg (f)
; A
WV

e

7
Statutes——Continnued -
See. 1410 (26 U. GI Bee, 1410:
See, 1426 (26 U. ab , See, 1426)

Pn te oP ; hap:
a
. : St,
yt See. 1600 (26 UL S.C. 1940 ed., See. 1600) =
i SO
31,

a

See. 1607 (26.0, IMO ed, See. 1607)”

Social Security Aet, ¢ . gol, 49 Stat. 620: “
' See, $01 (442 UL SL 1940 od, pee. LOL)
i See, 802 (42 Us8. C. M0 ed., See, 10025 cas
See, 804 (42 U8. C. 1940 ed, See. 1004) ye
See. $11 42 US. . 1940 ed., See. LOM).
See. 9O1 (42 — . C. 1940 ed, See. 11015 Ame
¥ See, 907 (42 U.S. CL 1940 ed., See. 1107) :

Miscellaneous: , ors
~ Restatement of the Law of Agency, See. 2207, p. 486 Py :
Treasury. Regulations 90, Art: 205. __

Treasury Regulations 91, Am. G2... jak th ae eens
; 5 : ; : ’
3 Bae
bd 2
?
a
&
ee ; . | | fei “s ‘
: ry
ise ; Ae .
8
‘ ; a A
atek pe he.
\ &

| Inthe Supreme Court of the United States

OcroBer Term, 1946

Unirep States or AMERICA, PETITIONER

; e sin
_ALBerr Sink, Domina Business AS

o> ak OAL COMPANY

.
. »

PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED

ALBERT SILK

STATES CIRCUIT COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE TENTH —

“

; : JURISDICTION

The judgment of the Cireuit, Court -of Apyeals

ras entered on April 19, 1946. Fe 113-114.) The

jurisdiction of this: Court. is invoBed .under See-
tion 240 (a) of the Judicial} Code, as amended by
= Actwf February 13, 1925 .

' QUESTIONS PRESENTED 2

1. Whether certain persons when unloading
coal from freight cars into the bins of the tax-
payer, a retail eoak dealer*™ were performing serv-
ices as his employees within the me ang of See-
tions 811 (b) and 907 (e) of the’ Social Security
- “Act and Sections 1426 (b) and 1607 («)* of the
iow Revenue Code; as amended. eae

» Whether certain other persons when. engaged:
in ties coal ae taxpaye r were performing
services as -his employees within the me: ning of
Sections 811 (b) and 907 (c) of the Soci al Seea-
rity Act and Sections 1 1426 (b) and: 1607 (e)° of.
the Internal Pevenue Code, as amended

STATUTES AND REGULATIONS INVOLVED |
The statutes and regulations Anvolved .are set
_forth in the Appe ndix, infra, pp. 13-17... =

dake a asst resaaie
. . .

Roopaniiny nit brought this action’ for re fund f
taxes levied and collected by the petitioner wm es
Titles VIIL and IX of the’ Social Security ct
"and subchapters A and € of Chapter. 9 of the

-
Pe RS A stem cy
*% . ; ah

bes

oe : -
Internal Revenue Code, for the years 1936 through
1939. The tax was levied with respect to amounts
paid by respondent to. certain persons known sas

; “unloaders”) whe anloaded tlie respondent's coal .
from ‘freight cars, into his storagg, bins and
‘“trickers who‘ later hauled -the ‘coal to the re;
spondent’s cistomers:” The sole” Rgfie ‘hetween
the parties in the court below: was whether or
not these persons were engaged in performing the
tinloading and hauling services as employees of.
- the respondent within the meaning of the tax-
ing provisions. ~ (RB. 16-17.). aes

The facts are-net in dispute.’ : aN
OA The unloaders.—Qeshondent ix a’ retail coal
dealer ur¥ Topeka,. Kansas. He has‘ latee and
extensive retail coal business. The unloaders are
men Who.come to respondents’ coal yard and un-
load coal’ trom railroad: cars into the -bins. If
When they come. there its coal to_unlo ; they are
assigned a car and told.in what bin they are to put.
the coal. They furnish their’ own tools—shovels’
and sometimes picks (R. 84, 88)—and are paid
. an agreed price per ton, They come and go as
they please. They likewise: work forvothers at
“tas; without Knowledge or conser of “respond-

ent. he only unloader who testified’ as respond. _

ent’s witness, declared that he worked ‘two-thirds’
: : i Migs ;

of the time in the’ winter season ‘as: an unloader

‘Except. where otherwise idicated the facts are taken
from the findings of. the Districf Court’ (R. 7-12)° and the
opiniga of the Circuit Court of/Appeals (R. 110-112).

7

an respondent yard (R. 9uy, Respondent testi-

fied that the unloaders did what the vard fore-

man ‘told them to do”, that although i did not

direct, them in their duties, “he Supervised” ai 3
98). The court below interpreted this’ as meaning

that he mere ly designated the ear and the bin inte
which they were to unload? Siu. testified °

thatthe men are told ‘‘not'to break the coal more
= un Hipseaean help it”” (R55).

The true kers.—Respondent does not own the:

sia ‘ks or other vehiéles used -for the purpose of
delivering the: ‘eoal le sells. He contraets: with

individual owners of trucks for the delivery of

coal at an agreed’ price pe r ton. They provide
their own equipment dnd supplies. ‘He pays the m,
usually JOE a We ek, out of the. price received
from: his custome ‘es. They make C. O. D, collec-
tiofis for him when, requested CR, 41, 86).

The tritckers assemble iin a desiznated hiiildine

.on respondent’s premises; and, by - their’ own

arrangement? answer in retation tally front re-

coal. A trucker is not required to make any de-. -
‘ | |

livery: he May reject the order. If he aeceysts
it he drives his truck to the proper bin in re-

spondent’ s yard, Joads the truck hinixelf, \and -

spondent When he receives an order to déliver:

delivers the coal to the customer's bin. He fixes.

* "There is wso testimony that unloaders: worked under the

direction of the yard foreman with respect to miscellaneous

yard work such‘as screening and cleaning mp the yard, w here
they were cme by the hour. (R. 59) 89-90.)

>.
‘

a

oh

> °

. Lad
lis own hours, can come and go as he pleases,

ahd is, not supervised vin his agtivittes. Cus-.

tomers’ compli nts as rs dncne are made to
respondent, who tells the trucke ry (R. 48, 95).
Respondent: sends SOMONE to clean up, when
necessary, and pays for. ‘any damage (R. js—40,
95-06 ).

The truckers also haul: for other * persons whe ny
ys so desire. “But during the winter seasorf

they usually stick to responde nt ¢R: 52). Many

of the same men would show up: regularly day

after day for years (R. 69, 30, 84, 94). Those

who testified * all indicated that by far the largest
pgen. of their Income—m some Instances prac-

ally all of. it—was derived from working® for
respondeait (CR. 78-79, 84,: 96, 100),

Upon the faets just ‘Summarized the District.
Court held that both the truckers and tlie cox! un-

loaders were not employees, of fhe respondent Ipet,

instead, were independe ‘it contractors, “and that
the remuneration whieh -he. pail ta the an for their
services did not come within the scone of the tax-
ing provisibns of thie Social Si enrity Act) and

corresponding sections of the -Tntermak Revenne

Code. (CR. 13, 104-108). . The Cireuis Court of
Appeals affirmed *R, 110-113).

SPECIFICATION SF ERRORS TO BE URGED

The Gireuit Court of Appe “als erred in fail-

zine te hold that the persens in que stion were oe

—_—_-—_—

~At the urging of the court the number of witnesses Was

; limited | in order to avoid clmutative testimony CR, @1, 103).

is ,
3 pe ra
i ’

° ees aa Poa
i . °

4
ieee ieee

plovees of the 2 respondent and that he, Was liable

for the social security taxes in question. .
: ‘The Cireuit Court of Appeals erred in fail
ing to look-to the pugposes of the Social See urity”
Act and to consider the. economic facts of the -

>)

relations hip in holdifg that the persons engaged

i unléading and hauling coal for the respondent
were not. bis: employees within the meaning: of

sat Act. : F 111.

The divergence in approach among the circuit

courts of’ appeals emphasizes the desirability and~

importance of*an authoritative disposition of the
| question.. °

3. We also urge that if the Court is of the view
that the question as to the status.of the unloaders
should be reviewed for the reasons set out above,

the status of the truckers also be considered in

order that theewhole case may be disposed. of in
adcordance with what this Court decides to be the
_ correct test. The primary afference between the

truckers and the unloaders is that the former own

* See Revtat ment of the Law of Agency, Sec. 220, p. 486 |

(subsectio ument €) in which it is stated: “Unskilled
bor is usually performed by those customarily regarded as
servants, and. a laborer is almost conclusively a serv rant? in

spite of the fact that he may nominally contract to do a -

"specified job for a specified price”,

x

ad

a .
ore -

Ba = oor ee

APPENDIX
‘ Sotial Security’ Act, ¢. 531, 49 Stat. 620;
Tire VITT—Tares With Respect “To
Employment oF pe

.
Ke * * : ¥* *

, ee is o
© SkctTION SOL. In addition to, other taxes,
there: shall? be levied, collected, ard pak
upon the income of every individual a.ta
equal to the following percentages of
wages (as defined in section ST1) recelye
“by him atter Pegember 31, 1936, with re-
— spect to. employment (as defined in section
811) after todo so. The righ? to discharge is alse nan
Important factor indicating tliat the. person
possessing that right is an employer. Other
*£ factors characteristicesef an employer are.
the furnishing of topls and the furnishing
_. of a place to work, to the individual who
performs the: services. Tn general, if an.
Individual is subject-to the control or diree:
tion of another merely %s to the result to be
accomplished by the work and not as to: the
means and methods for accomplishing thé
result, he isan rndependenc contractor, not
an employee, 3 ee - ,
a If the relationship of employer .and em-.
ployee exists, the designation or deserip- | +
tion of the relationship hy the parties as
anything other than. that of employer and
employee is immaterjal. Thus,’ if two ipd
dividuals in fact stafid in the relation of
employgr and employee to each other, it: is
of noJconsequenee ‘that the employee. is +
_ designaged -as a partner, coadventurery —
agent, or independent contractor. ee
~ The measurement, method, or designation
of compensation is also immaterial. if the
relationship of employer and Employee in
fact exists, arene ge =
Tuelividuals* performing services as. in-
dependént contractors gare not employees,
‘Generally, physicians, lawyers,.» dentists,

veterinarians, contractors, subcontractors,

public stenographers, auctioneers, and
_ others who follow an ‘Independent trade,
business, or profession, in which they offer
thei services to: the public, are inde pe nde nt

contractors aitd not employees.
* See * * eax

ARTICLE 3, Treasury Regulations 91, promul-
fate d-under ‘Title Viib of the Sociat Security
Act, in so far as pertinent here, is substantially:

the same as Article 205 of Treasury Regulations
9 set out abbve,

t

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386450_0240%3A2. Public record. Not legal advice.
