# Respondents Brief in Opposition — Air Line Pilots Ass'n, International v. Quesada

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386420_0999%3A3

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Respondents Brief in Opposition
- **Published:** January 1, 1961
- **Citation:** 366 U.S. 962

## Text

No PM

va the Supreme Court of the United: States

Ooreper Pinar. Pea

b :
: }? it~ \Ssocisy IN TEEN VL EO I tT a
Pew rie .
i
, re . .
at Qs ais [° t if s? | > ‘ -
i} { i‘.
Lik OF Thi 4 I a\\ \ N

' Fash. \ ; ‘ ;

b (ty, fe] by AK . i

BRIEF FOR THE RESPONDENT IN OPPOSITION:
‘ARCHIBALD COX

se ae! 4 . WILLIAM H- ORRICK. 7:

MORTON HOLY ANDER,
; ; EDWARD A. GROOBER?.,

INDEX

‘Opinion beiow._ ~~ -- -- --- Peete secon
Jurisdiction. __- Lead rou bes kik Sees
‘Question presented. ___ _ -

Sta‘utes and regulations involved.

Statement — ___ :
Argument.
Conelusion.__.
CITATIONS | a
Cases: /

Air Line Pilots - Ass'n, ‘Debt. Ciel . leronteties
Bodrd, 214 F.2d 122 -

American Trucking Assns. v. l ‘nited States,
344 U.S. 2982. _. py ts .

Bi-Metallic Investment Co. v. State Board of
Equalization, 289 U.s. 441. ae

Bowles v. Willingham, 321 U.S. . 303. —

Bretholz v. Board of Supervisors, 257 US.

Corer, £6 fe 100: 2. OB fe. ccc.

Chew v. Quesada, 182 F. Supp. 231_.._-. -_-.

Columbia Broadcasting System, Inc. v. Paden
States, 316 U.S. 407... ......-2--: 3%

Federal Communications Commission v. Ne-

tional Broadcasting Co., Inc., (KOA), 319 |

MG ca aCks codecs mac ca eae
L. Bi W tlson, Inc. v. Federal € ommunications
Commission, 170 F. 2d 793__.__...-----

_ Natyonal Broadcasting Co. v.. United States,
B19 USS. Sdutucrrcrs ohn eeaeces Sass

(1)

596984 — 61----1

ee

.

AEP eet

Norman vy. Baltimore & Ohio Railroad Co.,

294 U.S. 240. ._-
Philadelphia Co. v. Securities ikea

( Leas

mission, 164 F. 2d 889, Vacated and: dis-

missed as moot, 337 U S. 901, eter
State Railroad Tax Cases, 92 U.S. 575.

United States v.~ Storer Broad vasting Co., 351

Om. $06.. .. 2. vee aE ee =
Statutes: || a

Administrative Procedure Act, 60 Stat.

as amended, 5 U SC. 1001, vet seq.:
5 U.S.C. 1001 (0). eer
5 USC. 1001(d).._- eae
5 US.C.. 1003... .- ee

-s7-7

237,
4,10
R)
5-6, 8, 10

Pas Wn oe needs cee cones ies’ )

RS oR ee 4

5. B.SC. 1009. ....-.... ase 12

Federal Aviation Act of 1958, 72 Stat. 737,
49 U.S.C.-1801, et seq.: a

Sec. 601{a), 72 Stat. 775, 49 Us
OS RE pS AP ied og PTS Seek?) Wake

See. 601(b), 72 Stat. 775, 49 Us.c.
SOLO)... cee nnd SMS RO NE He os 0

Sec. 609, 72 Stat. 479, 49 USC. 1429. 3

Miscellaneous:
Civil Air Sicseishiaas’
Section 40.260___ -
Section 41.48. __.
Section 42.40... __-

Davis, Administrative Law Treatise (19: 58 e id ):

‘Section 5.01. -
Section 6.05. _

- Section 6.12... __:
Section 7.07 __.

II
Miscellaneous—Continued

Fuchs, Procedure in Administrative Rule-Mak-
ing, 52 Harv. L. Rev. 259, 265 (1938)____.
- Hearings Before the Sub-Committee on Avia-
_ tion ofthe Senate Committee on Interstate
and Foreign Commerce on 38: 3880, 85th

— Cong., 2d Sess.,-165-166_. —

Senate Report No. 1811, 85th C ong., 2d Sess.

(1958), 10-12_- v2 ae

- U.S. Code, Congressional & Administzative
News, 1958, 3741:

B3746-Ade_ —

ee + Se ae ee ca

o) : Nae fee OE

Page

10

12

12

12
12
11
12

”
A A I TR
. -

ze the Supreme Cour of the Binted Pintes

Oc TOBER TERM, 1960

No, 959

“Ain Ling Prors AssociaTION, INTERNATIONAL, ET AL.,

PETITIONERS
2 .

y : U. o ~

Etwoop R. Quesapa, INpIVIDUALLY AND-AS ADMINIS- _

TRATOR OF THE FepERAL AVIATION AGENCY
ps , &

oe

ON PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED ©
STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE SECOND CIRCUIT

BRIEF FOR THE RESPONDENT IN OPPOSITION.

‘ OPINIONS BELOW

The opinion ot the United States District Court
for the Southern District of New York denying the
petitionersg#é 1 motion for a preliminary injunction is
reported. at 182 ‘F. Supp. 595 (App. 315a-321a)}."
The opinion of the Court ef Appeals affirming the
denial of that moWon is reported at 276 F. 2d 892
(Pet. App. 65a-75a).? The decision of the District |
Court granting the respondent's motion for dismissal

‘App.—refers to .the appendix filed by the petitioners in the

Court of Appeals in Case No. 26174.

* Pet. App.—refers. .to petitioners’ appendix in their petition
for certiorari. ;

(1)

a)

of the complaint: is not reported (Pet. $). The

opinion » of the Court of Appeals affirming the dlis-
missal of the complaint is reported at 286 F. 2d
319 (Pet! App. 76a-78a). — ae eeenes See

JURISDICTION — «28

. The judgment of the Court of Appeals affirming
the dismissai of the.coinplaint was entered on Febre- |
ary 9,,1961. he petition for certiorari was filed
on ‘May 11, 1961, pursuant to an-extension granted
by Mr. Justice Harlan. The. jurisdiction of this
Court is invoked under 28 U.S.C. 1254(1).

QUESTION PRESENTED, _.

‘Whether the imposition of a 60 year age lint
for commercial air line pilots is a reasonable exercise
of the authority .of the Administrator of the Federal
Aviation Agency to issue regulations to promote
safety. ee ae .

STATUTES AND REGULATIONS INVOLVED

The Federal Aviation Act of 1958, 72 Stat. 737,
49 U.S.C. 1301, et seq.; provides in pertinent part:

Sec. 601 [72 Stat. 775, 49 U.S.C. 1421].

(a) Minimum standards; rules and reqila-
tions. aa | ;

The Administrator is empowered and it shall
be his duty to promote safety of flight of civil
aircraft in ‘air commerce by a ane
revising from time to time:

heer, ye ae * * * . i ee

“(5) Reasonable rules and: regulations ‘gov-
erning,. in the interest of safety, the maximum

g

t

3 ‘ °

hours or periods of “service of airmen, and
other employees, of air carriers; and .
(6) Such reasonable rules and regulations,
or minimum standards, governing other prac-
tices, methods, and procedure, as the Admin-
istrator may find necessary to provide ade-
‘quately for national seenrity and sifety in
air commerce,

*— * * *
Sev. 609 [72 Stat. 779, 49 ULS.C. 1429], ;
61429, Reins pection or recraminations.

anmcndment, NUS JM Rion, or revocation of cortif=
leatess notifications hearing; appeal to Board;
Judicial reviow. oe D
The Administrator may, from time tetime,
Terspect any civil aireraft, aireraft, engine,
propelier, appliauce, air navigation facilite, or
air ageney, or may reesfmine ay civil ajreian.
It, as alresnit of any such reinspection or re-
examination, or if, asa result of guy other ine
vestigation omatle by thé Adniinistrator, he
determines that safety ti air commerce or air
transportation and the publie-interest requires, -
the Administrator may isste an orde®.amend-
Ing meédifving, suspending.« or revoking, in’
Whole or iff purty any type certifieate,: pro-

‘ : ee ‘ f . om . -.
duction certificate, airworthiness certificate, air-

tian certificate, air-carrier operating gertifieate,
air navigation facility certificate, or dir ageney
certificate. Prior to amenditig, modifying, sts-
‘pending, or reveking any. of the foregoing cer-
*tififates, the Administrator shall advése the
holder thereof as toe any charges or other
reasons wlied upon by the Administrator for
his.-proposed action and, except’ in cases of

-
‘

s

>: a os
4
ee s ft.
emergency, shall previde the holder of such a
-certificate.an opportunity, to answer any charges
and be heard as to. why ‘Such ce ‘tifieate should
not. be amended, modified, suspended, or re-
. voked, Any person Whose certifizate is _s.
~— by such at order of the Administrator under
this section may appeal. the Adnmunistrator’s
order to fhe Board and the Board may, after
> notice and hearing, amerid, modify, or reverse
the Administrator’s order if it finds that safety.
in air commerce Or air transportation and the
pubhie interest do not require affirmation of the
Administrator's ordeg. *.* * i foe
Civil air regulations: © ? _ . :
14 C.F.R. 40.260, 41.48, and 42.40) effective on
March 15, 1960, provide .in pertinent art :

* * * No mdividual who Kas reached his 60th
birthday shall be ‘utilized or serve as a pilot on
wny aireraft® while engaged in aig carrier
operations. .

_ * * ipa eo. % a.

The Administrative Procedure Act, 60 Stat. 237,

as. amended, 5 US Cc. 1001, et seqg., provides in,’

“y

pertinent part: ~
§ 1001. Definitions.
As used in this chapter—
* * * * +

(ce) ‘Rule.and rule making. é

Rule’ means the whole or any part of any
agency statement of general or particular appll-
éability and future effect designed ‘to imple
ment, interpret, or preseribe law or policy: of
to describe the organization, procedure, of
practice requirements of any: agency and | in-

In Regulation 42.40 the’ words “large since ft” ‘are ne

i ‘
e, ;

5

eludes the approval or prescription for the fu-
ture of rates, wages, corporate or financial
structures or reorganizations thereof,. prices,
facilities, appliances, services or allow ances
therefor or of valuations, costs, or accounting,
or practices hearing upon any of the foregoing.
‘Rule making’’ means agency process for the
formulation, amendment, or repeal of a Tule.

(d) Order and adjudication,

“Order” means the whole or any Ss of the
final disposition (whether affirmative, negative,
injunctive, or declaratory in form) of any agen-

_¢y in any matter other than rule making but

including licensing. ‘*Adjudiéation’’ means

-agency process for the formulation’ of an order.

* ® "3 : | :
§ 1003. Rule making.

* * ; * * *
(a) Notice; publication, and contents.

General notice of proposed rule making shall
be published i in the Federal Register (unless all

_ persons subject thereto are named and either °

personally) served or” otherwise have actual
notice thereof in accordance with law) and
shall inelude (1) a statement of the time, place,
and nature of public. rule making proceedings; |
(2) reference to the authority under which the.

rule is proposed; and (3) either the terms or F
substance of the proposed rule or a description

of the subjects and issues involved. Except

Where notice or hearing is required by statute,
this subsection shall not apply to interpretative

..Tules, general statements . of policy, rules of

agency organization, procedure, or practice, or
in any situation in which the agency for good

cause finds (and ineorporates the finding and a

brief statement of the reasons therefor in the

" §96984--a1——_2

6.

rules inauad) that notice and public procedure.
_ thereon are impracticable, unnecessary, or con-
trary to the public interest.
' (b) Procedures.

After notice required by this section, the .
agency shall afford interested persons an op-
portunity to ‘participate in the rule making
through submission of written data, views, or
arguments with or without opportunity to pre- .
sent the same orally in any manner; and, after
consideration of all relevant matter presented,
the agency shall ineorporate in any rules
adopted a concise general statement ‘of their
basis and purpose. .Where rules are required
by statute to be made én the record after op
portunity for an agency hearing, the require--
ments of sections 1006 and 1007 of this title
shall apply in place of the prov x of this
subsection.

* _ * * * ' *.

fe .

STATEMENT

Seetion 601(a) of the Federal Aviation ‘Act of 1998..
supra, p. 2, requires the Administrator of the Federal
Aviation Agency to preseribe rules and regul: itions
promoting safe ai® travel. Pursuant to this authority.
the Administrator ‘ and his medical staff begam an ex-
tensive: study of the aging ‘process in order to ceter-
mine whether the older pilots were physicially reliable _
to operate aircraft “with the liighest possible degree
of safety’* (§ 601(b); Apps 254a). -The Administrator
*Najeeb Halaby was appointed Administrator of the Feder!
Aviation Agency on January 19, 1961. Mr. Hadaby wav =i!»

stituted as defendant in this action an February 25, 161, by.
the Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit.

e

OO eee Sear r—S—~S
.

7
regarded this problem of pressing importance because
for the first time in aviation history there were a num-
ber of pilots aged: sixty véars or more (App. 255a).
The study revealed a progressive deterioration of
many physiological and psychological functions as
.a person grows older, particularly a.greatly increased

#susveptibility to sudden strokes and heart attacks

(App. 256a). It also recognized that medical science
Is unable to predict with any degree of accuracy
whether an indiv: idual is likely to suffer such a sud-'
den ineapacitation. Thus, a study of a large group
of industrial empioyees showed that 85% of the em-
ployees who suffered a heart attack for the first time
did so Wi‘hin six months to one year after a thoreuch
physical examination in whiff the individual had

been found to be in a condition normal to his age

and without any evidence suggesting the imminence
of such an attack (App. 256a).

Therefore, the Administrator determined that the
existing regulations requiring rigorous periodic phys-
ical examinations of airmen did not adequately pro-
teet the public and that a maximum age limit for
pilots Was necéssary (App. 2o6a-257a). The maxi-
mum was set at sixty after the Administrator

learned that:

(1) statistical information compiled by the Na-
tional Office of Vital Statistics showed that the

nortality rate per one thousand white males from

heart disease was 50 per cent higher between the ayes .
of 60 to 64 than it was in the age group 55 to 59.

(App. 257a-258a). The incider nee of death from

strokes in the 60° to 64 year “old group Was almost

es
.

8

twice that for the age group 55. to 59, and more
than three times that for those in the 50 to 54 age
group (App. 258a) ;

- (2) a panel of. experts in the field of aviation
medicine and .safety had agreed that a maximum age
limitation of sixty should be ‘established, while some
even suggested that. the maximum should be lower
(App. 258a-259a) ; and :

(3) inquiry made of the practices of five major
foreign air carriers revealed that two had established
retirement ‘ages of 60 and two of 55 (App. 258a).

On June 27, 1959, the Administrator published in
the Federal Register his intention to amend the Civil
Air Regulations bv establishing a 60 year age limita-
tion for pilots (Pet, 4). In aecordance with the
rule making requirements of the Administrative Pro-
cedure Act, 5 U.S.C. 1003, supra> p. 5, interested
parties were invited to submit written data and briefs.
About.i90 comments were filed, including those of the
petitione r Pilots Association. The medical opinion
received, overw helmingly favored the regulation.’ Ae-
cordingl, the Administrator issued on December 1
1959, the 60 vear age regulation, supra, p. 4.

Petitioner Air Line Piiots Association, a union of
airline pilots, together with the individual petitioners.
who ‘are airline pilots, brought this suit in the District
Court for the Southern Distriet of New York seckins
an injunction and a deciaratory judgment that the
regulation was nuli and void. They claimed that tlie
rule was invalid because it allegedly ‘hau the effect of
modifying and revoking pilots’ certificates by limiting
- their duration without complying with the procedura!

9 :

requirements of § “§ 609% the Sein al Aviation Act of
1958 (App. Ya). The petitioners also asserted that.
the Administrator’s action was unconstitutional be-
eause It deprived them of their property rights in the

certificates without due process of daw, and alse be-

cause the aetion was arbitrary (App. 9a). Finally,

the -petitionérs contended that the pilots were entitled

tou hearing under the Administrative Procedure’ Act,

2 US.C. 1004 and 1008 (App. 9a).

The petitioners moved for a preliminary injunction.
The respondent moved for summary judgment. The
district court denied the motion for a preliniinary in-

- junetion. On appeal, the Court of Appeals for the

Second Cireuit, in an opinion written by Chief Judge
Lumbard and concurred in .by Judges Hand and
Hincks, rejected both of the petitioner's contentions,
sustained the validity of the regulation and aftirmed
the denial of the preliminary injunction. The Dis-
triet Court then granted the respondent’s motion for.
summary judgmeit, and disntissed the complaint. On
a second appeal, the Court. of Appeals, with Judges
Lumbard, Medina and Smith sitting, again affirmed.

ARGUMENT

The petitioners seek review by this Court on the
same grounds that they urged below. The decisions
by the Court of Appeals that the safety regulation. is |
hot unreasonable and that the Administrator was not
required by. the Constitution, the Federal Aviation
Act of 1958, or the Administrative Procedure Act to
afford the pilots a hearing before issuing the regula-
tion are correct. The petition shotild be denied.

10
1. There can be no serious challenge to the fact
that the promulgation of this safety. regulation con-
stituted rule making. -The Admuustrative Proce-

- dure Aet, 5 U.S.C. 1001 (¢), eupra, p. 4, defines a rule

as “any agency statement of general or particular
applicability and future effect designed to inyplement,:
interpret, or prescribe law or poliev * * *." See also .
Davis, Administrative Law Treatise § 9.01 (1953 ed):
Fuchs, Procedure in Administrative Rule-Maling, 52
Harv. L. Rev.’ 259, 265 (1938). As the court. below
held, the regulation involved is just such a Statement. .
it follows that the Administrator was not required
by: the Administrative Procedure Act to hold hear
ings before issuing the directive. Air Line Pilots
Ass’H, dnt’) vy. Civil Aeronautics Bourd, 215 F. 2d 122
(C.A, 2). A hesving is only, required In connection,
with rule tnaking wher the “rules are required hy
statute to be made on the record after opportunity
for an ageney hearing * * *°°5 U.S.C. 1o035¢b).
supra, p. 6 The Federal Aviation Aet of 195*° does
het contain such a requirement. .

2. The petitioners argue that the regulation is vou
because it -has the effect of amending, modifying,
suspending or revoking, pilots’ certificates by limit-
ing their duration © without eympliance with the pro-

*it should be noted -here that the petitioners’ argument! is

based on the-mistaken assumption that a pilot's ‘certificate

is of unlimited duration and that the 60 year age regulation
amends or revokes ihe certificate because it limits the dura-
tion. Each certificate itself provides that “This ‘vertiticate
is of such duration as is provided in the currently effective

Jl

eedural requirements of § 609 of the Federal Aviation |

Act of 1998, supra, pp. 3-4. It is: clear fréim the face
of the statute and its legislative history that © 609
has no bearing on the rule making procedure, but
applies only when an order of the Administrator is
directed at an individual airman and concerns, ¢on-
duet and other facts peculiar to that airman.

’ Thas, § 609 provides that ‘the Administrator may
** * reexamine anv civil airman’, avd if as a result
of such reexamination the Administrator “determines
that safety in air commerce * * * and the public

interest requires, [he] may issue an order amending
** #

or revoking * * * [any] aifman certificate * * *."
Further, the House Report states that the Adimiin-
istrator may, “after affording the person affected
#4 «

1 * * * amend

an opportunity to be heare
***the certifieate ino question.”” U.S. Code. Con-

cressional & Administrative News, 1958, 8741. 3756.

If $609 were applicd to a safety regulation whieh -

affected certificates, the 18.000) certificate . holders
would be entitled to a hearing before adoption, then to
anappeat to the Civil Acronauties Board, and, finally,
‘to Judicial review of the Board's order. However, it is
abundantly clear that Congress intended that the Ad-
——— eae

Civii Air Regulations, unless sooner suspended or *revoked.”
(App. 286a-2eTa.) - Therefore, it was ‘contemplated at the
time the certificate was issued that the holder's rights im the
certifieate are subject to limitation as to duration by.a duly
issued regulation, whether the regulation provided that the
certificate would expire after one year, five years, or when
the holder reached age 60. Since the pilots held the certifi-
cates at the will of the Administrator, the Administrator's

ation could not have deprived them of any substintiak property
: rights, .

&

12

ministratur was to “be given full safety rulemaking
authority without review by ‘the Civil Aeronautics
Board” in order to prevent division of responsibility
and duplication of effort, and to insure that there
‘ would be timely and effective safety rules. UlS. Corde,
Congressional & Administrative News, 1958, 3741,
3747. The constitutionality and validity of safety rules
was to be determined in aecordance with the judicial
review provisions of the Administrative. Procedure
Act, 5 U.S:Q_ 1009. U.S. Code, Congressional & Ad-
mes ATR 1958, 3741, 3746-47, 3761; Senate
Report No. 1811, 85th Cong., 2d Sess. (1958), 1W+12;"
Hearings before the Sub-Committee on Aviation of
the Senate Committee on Interstate and Foreign
Commerce on S. 3880, 85th Cong., 2d Sess., 16+ 166.-
Consequently, the application of § 609 to this situation
could not be squared with the Congressional intention
that the Civil Aeronautics Board: should not. have
power to review safety regulations. As the Court of .
Appeals said: :

The elaborate procedural requirements of © Ho
‘are_patently incompatible with the seen
with which Congress intended that the Admin-
istrator should act in the promulgation of
safety rules. The clear public interest in the
_ speedy adoption of rules relating to air safety
far outweighs any possible advantage in « multi
tude of piecemeal and time-consuming hearings
brought by each contesting airman. [ Pet. App.

73a. }
The petitioners’ assertion that the safety regulation -
is invalid because it amends their certifieates without

13
complying with § 609 is similar to the argument which

this Court rejected in United States v Storer Broad-
casting Co.; 351 U.S. 192. In Storer, the Federal

Communications Commission, aé¢ting within its au--” -

thority to pramulgate general rules in the public
interest, ruled that it would’ not grant broadcast

°
" licenses. to parties-who already ewned interésts in five

other stations. The “Federal Communications Act
provided that applications for a license could not be
" denied without a hearmg. This Court flatly rejected
theepyntention that the regulation was invalid because
-it had the effect of denying certificates without a
hearing.

3. The faet that pilots are affected hy the regula-

tion, because it results in the termination of some:

certificates and the limitation of the duration of
others, did not require the Admmistrater to grant

a each petitioner a hearing before adopting the regula->

ton. It is well settled that the exercise of a power to
issue general rules need not: be preceded by a hearing
. ¢ven though the rule limits or destroys property
‘nights, State Railroad Tar Cases, 92 U.S. 575, 609-

010; Br-Metallic Investment’ Co. vy. State Board of .

Equalization, 239 U.S. 441; Bretholz v. Board of
Supervisors, 257 U.S. 118; Bowles v. Willingham, 321
U.S. 503, 519-521; Davis, Administrative Law Treatise
(1958 ed.), §§ 6.05, 6.12, 7.07. The ageney is acting as
a legislative body, Bowles v. Willingham, supra, and
affording each affected individual a hearing would
often destroy the agency ’s rule making power, Bi-

Metallic Investment Co. v..State Board of Equaliza-

3%

14

tion, supra, This eertainly would be the case here if

the Administrator had to grant each certificate holder,

some 18,000 ‘airmen, a-hearing. The Court of Appeals

stated: .
Administrative regulations ‘often limit in the
public interest the use that persons may make

of their property withoyt affording each one

affected an opportunity to present eyidence
upon the fairness of the regulation. See United
States v. Storer Broadcasting Co., supra;
Bowles v.. Willingham, 321 U.S. 508, 519-420

(1944). Obviously, unles the inciden‘al limita-

tions upon the.wse of a¥rmen’s certificates were

subject to. modification! by general ules, the

conduct of the Administrator’s business would
be subject to intolerable burdens which might

well render it impossible for him effectively to

discharge his duties. All changes in cerfificates
would be subject. to adjudicative hearings, In-
cluding appeals to the courts, and each pilot
whose license was affected—here some 18,
000—might demand to be heard individually.
[Court's footnote omitte d.] [Pet. App. 7la.]

The cases ‘the petitiéners rely on are not pertinent
here. They involved orders directed at specific
parties rather than general policy decisions applica-
ble to unnamed and unspecified persons, F'edera!
Communications: Commissiow Vv. National Broadeast-
ing Co., Ine. (KOA ), 319 U.S. 239; L. B. Wilson, Lne.
v. Federal Communications Com mission, 170 F, 2d 793
(C.A.D.C.); Philade iphig Oo. v. Securities Barchany:
Commission, 164 FP. 2d sx9 (CLA. 1.€, , Vacated and

. as Rye. 5: .
dismissed as moot, 337 U.S. 901; In re Carter, 177 ¥F.
2d 75 (C.A.D.C.). | ate

4. The petitioners assert that the rule is uneonsti-_
tutional because the Administrator's action was arhi-
trary. They ask this Court, in effeet, to reverse the
Administrator’s judgment on the basis of a few items
of evidence which the Administrator and his s‘aff of
experts had already considered. However, In veview-
ing rule making, the courts. have traditionally limited
their inquiry to a determination as to whether the”
regulation has a reasonable relation to a legitimate
end. Norman ¥. Baltimore. ) Ohio Railroad Ci4'
294 US. 240; 311; National: Broadcasting Ce. Vv.
United States, 319 U.S. 190, 224: American T rucking
Assns. v. United States, 344 U.S. 298; Air Line Pilots
Ass’n, Int'l v. Civik Aeronautics Board, 215 F.2d 122
(C.A. 2). Clearly, the evidence that: the number of -
' pilots over 60 Years of age is increasing; that sudden
. ineapacitation heeatise of heart attack and stroke is
more frequent as men approach age 60; that medical
‘science is unable to determine ein advance which
individuals are likely te suffer such attacks so that
the periodic examinations: of the pilots are not a
sufficient protgetion; and that aviation safety and
medieal experts ‘advoe ‘ated a maximum age of 60 or

“This issue is quite distinet from the question of whether
a person affected by such a rule er regulation .is entitled to a
/teview of ite legality.e The {fet that the regulation may be
considered ar “order” for the purposes of review, Colum hai
Broadcasting Nystem, [ne. Vv. Minited Ntates, 316 U.S,° 407,
_ does not mean that every person’ affected is er titled to the type
_ofhearing provided for an adjadicative proceeding.

16

less, supports the Administrator’s judgment that the
regulation was necessary to’ protect the air travelling
public.’ 2 .
CONCLUSION ¢ x ;

For the reasons stated, it is respectfully submitted
that the petition for a‘writ of certiorari should t»
denied. sb
Arcufpatp Cox, -

Solicitor General.
Winiiam.H. Orrick, Jr.,

Assistant Attorney General.
Morton .HOLLANDER,,
Epwarp A. GRroopert,

> Attorne is.

x

eRe

‘

- JUNE 1961

7 The ‘regulation was held reasontble in Chew v. Quesada, 4
182 F. Supp. 231 (D.D.C.}. _ §

(

j *
. ’
US GOVERNMENT PRINT WE CRRICE 496:

©

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386420_0999%3A3. Public record. Not legal advice.
