# Petition for A Writ of Certiorari — Seaboard & Western Airlines, Inc. v. Civil Aeronautics Board

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386419_0665%3A3

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Petition for A Writ of Certiorari
- **Published:** January 1, 1959
- **Citation:** 359 U.S. 912

## Text

Uttice-Supreme Court, U.S.

; a Page
Opinions*below 1
Jurisdiction... J 1
Question presented > -
Statute involved... ......:.-..... axta psn tien tesewh's 2
Statement _...____. eteww cen sene-eBeecasae eae ae 3
Reasons for granting the writ._______ he uae Sees 6

~ Conclusion: eee aweeceseneccccbkenn Ppl Ee anit aes nk 16
. Ot eWaeedshnanendtanshdun ey &
oe mins Lsukanwuaahtbamonanen waka ee

32
Q

13

14
4.

Eastern Airlines v. Civil Aeronautics ‘Board, 185 F. “od :
426, vacated as moot, 341 U.S. 901_....._._.....\ 3,14
_ Eastern Airlines v. Civil Aeronautics Board, No.10, 671,
C.A.D.C., ccriiorari denied, 341 U.S. 951_...._.-_. 14
Eastern A.L. Grandfather Certificates, 1 C’A.A. 173... « 13
Statutes:
Civil Aeronautics Act of 1938, 52 Stat. 973, as amend-
' ed, 49 U.S.C. 401, et seq.:

ne on a ack sulroiing x 32
se i a. hws kalo ees 14
Section 401(a)—(d)5_-....._____... 1 gwieahees Su a
"Section 416(b). -..----------, viwsaentas 2, 3,7, 9, 34
a oy a ge ie 8 5
Federal Aviation Act of 1958, 72 Stat. 731, Section .
1501 (c)___- SS eee Pe ee ee ee O--gih- -- - - -+'- 2
Miscellaneous:. ) . e Ry .
Civil Aeronautics Board: Yh ti
aoe A ee ee 13
4 ES eS. Pe aae eee nae 13
Order FE. 12520 Rae ar mn cee 13
(2) . :
493383 59 —1 , '
e — 2 7

a the Supreme Court of the ited Sat

2 No — :
CiviL AERONAUTICS Boarp, PETITIONER
*. . ¥
Pan’ AMERICAN Worip Arrways, Inc., ann. Trans,
Wor_p AIRLINES, Ive.

o .
PETITION For A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE.USITE D STATES
COURT ‘OF APPEALS FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA
CIRCUIT

The Solicitor General, on behalf of the Civil Aero-

‘tautics Board, prays that a writ’ of certiorari issue

fo review ‘the judgment’ entered in this case by the

pa TERM, 1958 * \

N

Chited States Court of Appeals for the re! es:

Columbia Circuit on November 14, 19: 58.
| oPinrons. BELOW af

The 0 opinion of the court. of appeals’ (App. ‘A, ‘infra,
Wi. 17-23) is not yet-re ported. The findings and order
ofthe Civil Aeronautics Bdard (R. 109; App. C, —
i. 25-31) are not vet reported. ;

JURISDICTION

The failabine ‘nt ofthe court of appeals (App. B,
“fra, po, 24) was entered on November 14, 1958, The’
Mmsdiction of this Court is invoke d under 28 U.S.C.
ACL). , s ji. . “i

af
(1)

. a
nt, QUESTION PRESENTED

\ "Section 416(b) of the Civil .Aeronauties Act of 18
» \ authorizes the Civil Aeronautics Board to exempt z
- air carrier from the certification requirements of th
Act\if enforcement of those requirements “‘would }
_an ‘undue burden” on _the carrier “by -reason of. ti
limited extent off or unusual circumstances ‘affectinz
‘the opexations.of” the carrier and would not, be “i;
the. fee ps Ah
theless held that the Board was powerless to afford the.

:Telief thought to -be necessary for the carrier’s sur-

vival. : Whether the Board has such power to amelio-.
rate the hardship to carriers and the damage to the

" publie interest arising from the inevitable delays in

certification proceedings is a question of substantial

_ importance in the administration of the Act.

é

vs

a

7
The only provision of the Act which empowers the
Board to permit air transportation other than uporf the

conclusion of formal certific ‘ation proceedings—after

notice and full hearings often” taking years ‘to com-

~ plete—is the exemption provision contained in § 416

-(b). The power to authorize interim operations pend-

ing certification therefore depends upon the Scope to -

be given that provision. ;
Section 416(b)° provides ak that the ‘Board
may exempt a carrier from any provision of the Act
the enforcement of which “would be an undue bur- .
den’’ on the carrier ‘‘by reason of the limited extent

of,-or unusual circumstances affecting, the operations

of” the carrier ‘‘and is not in the public interest.”
One of the provision’. from which exemption is thus
authorized ig § 401, which provides procedures for es

"certification of carriers and prohibits transportation

not authorized by a certificate, and it is from.the:
certification requirement (or, more accurately, from

the prohibition against uncertificated transportation)

that exemptions are, as here, most commonly. granted.
Thus there is no question that the section empowers

‘the Board, by exemption, to permit uncertificated ‘

transportation if the stated\conditions are imet,. and°
the sole question here is the interpretai. 1 of those

: conditions. oo

There are two. eideniiiies interpretations | of

§ 416(b), -both rejected by the court of appeals, upon

which the order of the Board in this ease ean be

- Sustained. The first turns on whether the acute finan-
cial distress of a carrier is, within the meaning of the - :

"493283502

8

Act, an “unusual circugistance’’-upon which an ex-

emption can be based.. The second turns on whether

the necessarily temporary character of interim opera-
tions pending certification makes. them ‘of such
‘limited extent”’ that enforcement of the réquirement
of certification, which would prevent the operations
altogether, would-be unduly burdensome. We will
consider the two questions.in order.

1. The court of appeals held that Seaboard’s findn-_
cial crisis Was not an ‘unusual circumstance”’ affect-

ing its operations that made the prohibition 6f the

interim operations pending certification an “undue -
burden.’”’ The only reason it. gave was that “If

i Congress had wanted to exclude economically Mar-

ginal carriers from certification requirements, it
would have done so in more explicit terms than those
of § 416(b)” (infra, p. 21). The Board, however, did

not exempt Seaboard from the certification require-

ments altogether. but only granted it an interim
exeniptiol to tide it over and assure its continued |
ability to operate under. the certificate should it be
granted; the power was used in aid of, not in lion
of, the certification procedure. Whether or not finan-
cial distress might be such an “unusual circum-
stance’’ as ‘to justify complete exemption from cer-
tification requirements, the acute possibility. of.
financial disaster even before the application for a -
certificate can be 4uled Uupol seems clearly sufficiently
“‘unusual”’ to justify interim retief pending com-
pletion of the certification proceeding.
The argument that Congress, had it’ intended to
authorize such exemptions, “would have done so in:

on

4

va

9

= more explicit terms”’ would reduce § 416(b) to a

nullity, for none of the possible kinds of exemptions

is authorized in any, more ‘‘explicit terms”? than that
granted here. The very reason for the general lan-

guage of §416(b) was that Congress could: not fore-
see all the possible circumstances in which enforce-
ment q a particular provision of the Act would
frustrate, rather than promote, the overall purposes

q For the Act. It therefore gave to the Board the power

‘

to decide whether such circumstances existed in the
particular cases coming before it, providing no more

than general standards to guide it. We think the

Board has properly applied those standards in this

case, ete y 5

2. The eourt of appeals also rejected, although on

, oe : bes .
grounds that are somewhat unclear,’ the alternative -
basis for the Board's order that the interim upera-
tions sought to be performed: were of such ‘limited.

extent” that enforcement of the Act’s certification re-

an
we?

quirements with respect to those operations would ‘be -

unduly burdensome. The operation Seaboard sought °

to have exempted was ‘the temporary traffsportation

of mail pending action on its application for a ver-

tificate amendment. ‘Such transportation could theo-
tetically have been authorized by-a ‘temporary certif-
leate"’ ($401(d)(2)) isstted for | that purpose, but

temporary certificates require the same Kind of notice

and hearing as do permanent certificates. The ques-
q

. . . . ah . .
- ton is Whether, beeause of the limited duration of the
- interim operations, compliance with the procedures

“See note 6, infra. -
o

o

10
for Attaining a temporary certificate: would bave le. }
unduly burdensome, - SEL

a. The Board has granted innumerable exemption
from the certifieation requirements of the Act in eis

_ Where the limited extent of the. proposed opera

tions Was such that subjecting them to certification
requirements would be, an undue burden. upon th.
applicant, One use of the autho

bis to exempt

long-term or continuing operations which are «

limited in size or extent (¢.9., air-taxi services). that

‘compliance with the requircments of the Act (certi-

fication, reports, tariffs, ete.) would impose burdens

disproportionate to the nature of the operations. ‘The
_ Most frequent use of the power, however, is to exempt .

short-term or temporary operations. - ‘Such operations
often could not be undertaken at all, or at least would
not be economically feasible, if the carrier were re-

quired to comply with certification pr cedures before’

undertaking them. Clear ‘examples are individual

charter flights or short-term operations for which
there is an immediate need—such as traisportation

- of military personnel or equipment on a particular

movement ‘or the handling yf Christmas mail—but
the. principle applies equahy to any. operations sut-
ficiently limited in time. nap

‘The operations which Seaboard sought to perform

pending certification were no Jess “lingited in extent’

than any other temporary operations: by definition,
the pe lod. during which they were to Be performed
was such that requiring their certification would pre-

/

/

' ee BAN
vent them altogether. Preventing Senboard f rom per-

forming the operations, in turn, would, without ques-
tion, impose an “undue burden’ upon it. However

strict the “undue burden” Fequirement might be, it

was certainly. satisfied by the finding that Seaboard
Was in such financial distress that preventing such
oper. Lions would threaten its very &jstence.

The ottly possible basis for distinguishing this case

from any other case of temporary operations is that
Seaboard was’ simultaneoug¥ seeking a permanent
certificate to perform the sam kind - of -operations

"> after lita of the ieee a 7. ope rations. * That
difference, however, would seem immaterial. The loss
beth to Seaboard and .to the public interest from its
inabyfity to perform the interim operations will be the
spate whether or not subsequent operations are later

as-much a inatter of concern .as are the subsequent

ones,- and there is no Teason why they cannot be
~~

-*In addition, the interim operations here ‘were li ited’ not

only elas of time but also to the carriage of salle ea-
board's existing cargo routes. In substance, Seaboard sought to

. Undertake not a ‘general expansion of operations but only the in-
terin: utilization of its excess cargo space, on its existing flights, to
carry an additional commodity., The “limited” extent of the addi-
tional operations is establiched, moreover, by the Board's ex-

| press findings ‘that Seaboard’s operations would divert “only a
small portion of the maid revenues” of the other two carr iers
ard wuld result in “no substantial adverse effect upon” them,
during the short ’ period pending determination of the certificate
application Cinfra, p. 29). Under any test, theasefore, the In
rin. ope rations were cle: “arly af “limited extent”

F

; authorized. The immediate operations, therefore, are’

at

12

treated a ee unit of operations for purposes

of exemption.‘ .

* A ‘contrary view on this issue seenis to have been the basis
for the court of appeals’ decision. The only reference to the
“limited extent” issue in the court’s opinion is the following

. footnote, which was appended to a statement that “the Board

concluded ‘that the authority conferred’ by exemption is limited _

in extent and in the public interest’” (infra, p. 21) :

The Board seems to have misunderstood: the “limited ex.
tent” requirement. The stitute does not refer to the limited
extent of the exemption itself; instead it refers to a pre
existing condition of the carrier's operations, that qualities
it for an exempticn. ' Se

- The meaning of the footnote -is- not entirely clear, . It CANO

‘ “limitation’
_tion. That is, the phrase “pre-existing condition” was meant té

mean that the test is to-be applied to the operations already
being performed by the carrier, as distinguished from those pro:
posed to be performed, since the very purpose of the exenip-
tion® power is to (permit proposed operation? - [t would
seem to mean rather that the test must be niet by the na-
ture of the operations in themselves: if they: are not of such’
“limited extent” as to satisfy the requirement, the necessary
cannot be supplied by simply limiting the exentp-

connote-only a condition existing independently of any limita-
tions imposed by the-tegms of the exemption. If that be so,
however, it amounts to Q° more than a criticism of the’ short.
hand form of the Board's statement—which literally described
the exemption, rather than the operations, as being limited—
unless: it reflects an unarticnlated premise that the interim op-
erations cannot -be treated as a unit of operations separate from

_ the subsequent operations sought to be certificated. That is the

question deat with in the text, and if, as we there show, the
interim operations are properly to be viewed as a matter of sep: *

_ arate convern, it follows that the test is met by the nature of

those Gpgrations in themselves (iv. “the pre-existing conditian”™

which guatifies them for exemption )-and not-by the limitation
impostd by the exemption order, :

i

:
°
2 .
‘ rae

) :
oes

7
.
; heed gent z a , .
re : (gs . - Victor R. HANSEN,

ie ee _ Assistant Attorney General, —
" s* PRANKLIN M: Stone, ; eee |
| General Counsel,
, 0. D. Ozmenr, Neer
SO" "Assistant General Con nsel,

Morris CuErtkovy,
~ Attorney,
Civil Aeron autics Board, .
Janvany 1959. ;

\ J SPPENDIX A
tii
‘ ne

> -Uxerep Stares Court or Appeais.
FoR THE District oF CoLtumbia Cinecrt
1 “Me 140...

Pay AMERICAN’ Wortp -Arnways, INC., PETITIONER |

ey

Besse
.° Civit AERONAUTICS BOARD, RESPONDENT ~
SEABOARD AND ‘Wesrery AIRLINES, .INC., INTERVENOR

No. 14506 °

“Trans. WorLd AIRLINES, INC., PETITIONER
. : fo \ t

- ~

: 6 . vs :
Ps CiviL AERONAUTICS BOARD, RESPONDENT
SEABOSRD AND: WESTERN AIRLINES, INC., INTERVENOR
PETITIONS FOR REVIEW Of ORDER OF THE CIVIL | y-
AERONAUTICS BOARD

* vide . . ae
“Filed November 1 1958

$416(b) of the Civil: Aeronautics Act, 52 Stat. L004
(1938), 49 U.S.C. § 496(b). This gant: permits Sea-
"board to carry United States mail across the Atlantic
While the Board considers and determines Seaboard ‘s
application for .certificate authority to carry suef}

: ' Hereinafter called Seaboard. “ay nic
# , 417) |

+

o

Y

wn,

f 4

~

?

18

Hh
mail Pan American World Airways, Tne.” sid:
Trans: World Airlines, Inc.’ the only United States -
airlines presently certified for ‘transatlantic mail ctr.
riage, separately petitioned this court for review of
the exemption grant, Civil Aeronauties Act, .§ 1006,
52 Stat. 1024 (1938), 49 U.S.C. § 646. . The case? wer

consolidated and came on for hearing. —
~ Both petitioners contend that this exemption grant
contravenes the certification requirements of * Hereinafter catled TWA. ;

. Chicago & Southern Air Lines, Ine. v. Waterman SS. ~
Corp. B33 U, S108 (1948) |

é

é

a :
, 19

petitions must be dismissed for lack of jurisdiction.

We aré not persuaded, however, that an ercemption .

which ior ,a limited period authorizes a carrier to
transport overseas mail between points already re-

ceiving certified cargo service from ghe same carrier °

is subject to, the restrictions of § 801. Section 801
contains no reference to exemptions although it re-
cites explicitly a whole series of Board actions rela-
tive:to certificates ‘affected by the statute. True, the
exemption dias operative effetts not unlike an amend-

ment of a certificate, but the extraordinary power .

tested in the Executive by this statute should not be
capanded beyond the needs of the’ foreign relatitns

considerations which have been -relied .on to justify |

the grant. Chicago d: ’! Southern Air Lines, Inc v.
Walerman S, S. Corp., note 4 stpra at 111.

These factors—the uniqueness of the statutory pro-
atision, its drastic impact, the precise definition of the
statute, and the Board’s interpretations fortify the
‘ conclusion that Congress did not intend to: include
exemptions in § 801. The enduring and continuing
character of the operations under a certificate as con-
_trasted with the temporary. and limited character of
the exemption sapply the most important basis for
distinction. faves, ; } q

II VALIDITY OF THE EXEMPTION

Section 416(b) of the Act" permits the Board to -

exempt’ an air carrier from the certificate require-

““e Been" * * wey © 9 * exempt from the ‘require-"
ments of thjg subchapter or any provision thereof * * * any
‘ait carrier * * * if it finds that the enforcement of this sub-
chapter or such provision * * * is or would be an undue
burden on such air catrier * * * by reason of the limited.
extent of, or unusual circumstanees atfecting, the operations of
Sich air earcier * * © yd is not in the public interest.” 52
Stat. 1004 (1938), 49 TS.C. § 496(b) (1).

oe

- 20

ments of § 401 if, but only if it first finds that enfor:
ment of those requirements would have certain speq.
‘fied results because of the existence of eertdi,
specified conditions. The Board must find that th:
‘‘operations” of the air carrier seeking the exemptiar
are either (1) of “limited extent” or (2) affected br
“unusual cireumstances.”” Aside from finding tha:
fe of. these conditions is present, the Board mu:
also find that that: condition causes. enforcement o-
the certificate requirements’ to work “an undue bur.
den” on the ‘carrier, Finally, the. Board must fini
that enforcement of ‘the ‘Tequirements “is not in th
publie interest.’ In the absence of any one of thes
findings the Board..is_ not authorized to suspend the
normal statutory requirements of notice, hearing and
requisite findings for issuance of a certificate of public
‘convenience and necessity. *
__ Nor .may these findings be merely a -recital. of
__ | $416(b). The Board “must find what the statute
“requires it to find, not in conclusory fashion in the:
; statutory language but in such fashion that a review-
ing court can test the validity of the finding.” Amer.
tcan Airlines, Inc. Vv. C.A.B., 98 US. App. D&C. 348,
396, 235 F. 2d 845, 853 (1956). Oates
The Board's findings in this cazeffte short and some-.
what cursory, consisting of but thfee paragraphs, It
found that ‘*Scaboard’s financial situation is ‘acute,”
and that ‘“‘Seaboard’s existence is in jeopardy.” With’
nv further préliminaries it found that -

+s To deprive the carrier of the opportunity te
‘Ain these revenues (from. mail earriage] §
pending decision. on, its certificate application ‘
would. impose. an undue burden on it and would
not bein the public interest.

a . \ P
It found that the diversion of mail revenues “rom
. Pan Ametiean and TWA Would be slight but that

af

exemption will be “deprived” of an

21

“the beriefit to Seaboard will be relatively substan- -
tial.” From these premises the Board . concluded '
“that the authority conferred by ‘exemption is limited
in extent and in the public interest.”* Finally the |

_ Board’s order recited the language “of §416(b) in’
concluding that the exemption should he granted.

Without, considering the problem of whether these
findings are supported by the record, we hold them
inadequate to meet the statutory requirements. The

‘undue burden” the Board has found is deprivation

of revenues during the course of certification | 1
ceedings. This “burden”. is found to be ‘‘uridue’”
‘Decause of the*financial straits in which. Se: eee
finds itself. Obviously, any carrier not: eranted an

earn. revenues from a particular carriage until it is
awarded a certificate therefor. Board has found
only one circumstance here that is tiot present in

every certification proceeding: Seaboard’s financial -

distress. This is insufficient. If Congress had
wanted to. exclude economically marginal carriers

‘from certification requirements, it would have done
‘so in more explicit terms than those of § 416 (b)." Of

3 The Board seems to have misunderstood the “limited extent”
requirement. The statute- does not refer to the limited extent

of the exemption itself; instead it refers to a preexisting condi- ~

tion of the carrier’s operations that qualifies ‘it for an exemption.

"It is pertinent that,.when Seaboard was initially given a
transatlantic cargo certificate, the Board said: .

“Since the service will not be subsidized, it becomes a matter

for the new carrier aud its.shareholders to determine whether

as a matter of business - judgment, it’ desires to ventiire its
capital in this enterprise * * * [sic] All of the applicants

are fully awar. of the attendant risks, and. all are actively -
. weking the opportunity to, prove the economic : feasibility’ “4

this venture.” 7'rensatlantie- Cargo ‘Case,. Order No, E-931
CCH AV. L. REP. (C AB Cas. beveiaietss G21,845.02 at 14, nt
(1955).

e

vortunity*to

3

course, an unusual cire tance which. causes finan- . }
cial distress may be such eircumstance as to watrant .f
reliefYunder this exemption provision. But financial
distress ‘in and of itself, unrelated to circumstances
which would. render-the carrier eligible, is not enouch,

In the Surface Mail Experiment Case* we upheld
an exemption grant, but even there the decision ws ~
clase. under ‘circumstances far more -ecompelling than
those here. That exemption Permitted certain all.
‘eargo air carriers to participate in a Post Offiee ex.

” periment to determine whether it would be economia!
| and feasible to send some surface mail by air. .\It

-" experiment. The court plainly relied heavily on. this _
finding, and Jud Prettyman ‘in coneurring said:

° “Tn such event denial of an exemption would he a ~
total and fin eprivation of Participation. That is. l
not the case if the usual application for exemption.”’’ *

- _ Additionally, in the Surface Mail Ex riment b'ase
» the Post Office recommended an exempfion, reasoninc .

; that (a) additional*mail volume was anNgj ted; (h)
the cargo carriers would provide protection against:
Service interruptions ; and (c) by Participation in *

_ It has \said. that ‘there is more capacity than: cur-
rently needed for the transportation of airmail fro

.

the New York Gateway - to Kurop~t#m—paints and

Consequently there is not the Peculiar need for ex."

emption . which existed’ because of the airlift ey-
“American Aiérlinea, Ine. v. CAB, 97 US. App. D.C 324.

231 F. 2d 483 (1956), eae et

rQ97 U.S. App. Da ', at 329, 231 F- 2d at 488.

~

” sas

warwwowsww~w~ ‘2 «= \ w

ce —”

periment * * *."" These comments by the Post Office
Iepartment tend to weaken the. Board's conclusory
finding in this case that enforcement of the certificate
requirements would not be in the publie interest. It
ix not necessary to hold, however, that this finding
has “no rational basis.” We hold only that financial
distress is not @ circumstance which, standing alone,
mects the requirements of § 416(b). Accordingly, we
set aside the order granting an exemption to Sea-
board. ' | :

. ae ° \
. je ° .
~ -
J f 4
.

Order Set Aside

pk ;
& |
‘ x
4 = ,
ae ~
qs
{
Aa wipes
2
|
4

APPENDIX B- i :

3
United States uns of Appeals for the District 0
Columbia Cireuit

ae : September Term, 1958 ~
. | | No. 14497. ;
CP ax AMERICAN Wortp Airways, Inc. +) PETITIONER,

Ae sat
CIVIL AERONAUTICS Boarp, RESPON DENT
———- & Westen AIRLINES, Inc. y ANTERVENOR
“ _ September Term, 1958 |
a No. 14506.

TRaNs Wor.p AIRLINES, INc., PETITIONER,

v 7
owt AFRONAUTICS @oarn, RESPONDENT ,
Seayoann & Western AIRLINES, INc., INTERVENOR

Before. ‘PRETTYMAN, Chief: dudge, and Witarr K.
MILLER and Burcer, ‘Circuit Judges ;

| OnbER

The shove titled cases came onto be heard on
the record from the Civil- Acronauties Board and
were argued by counsel,
$ON CONSIDERATION WHEREOF, it is ORDERED by the
.court that the order of the Civil Aeronauties ‘Board:
on review in these eases is hereby set aside. An
opinion wil] be filed later. :

It is FURTHER ORDERED by the court that a cqrtitied

% ¢ aoe copy of this order issue forthwith to the Civil’ Aero-
nauties Board, ce Rs: ° eras.
ay

Iv THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION OF SEABOAm® &
WESTERN AIRLINES, ENC. FOR AMENDMENT OF ITS
CERTIFICATE OF PuBiic ConvES{ENCE AND NECESSITY.
. Uxver Section 401 oF tHE CIvi ‘AERONAUTICS ACT |
OF 1938, AS AMENDEDY + ; | C ;

Docket No. 9264 >

IX THE MATTER OF TIMKAPPLICATION” OF SEaBoaRD &
-* s Western Arruines, Ixc. ror AN ExtPtTiox ORDER
‘RSUANT TO. SECTION 416(B) ‘oF THE CrvuL AERO-’
NAUTICS ACT OF 1938, 4s AMENDED.
ORDER 0 ee Teta
Seaboard and Western Airlines, Inc. ( Seaboard) is |
the holder of a temporary certificafe of publie con-
veniencé and necessity authorizing it to engage wm the
foreign air transportation of. property, ‘inter alia,
. between New York and the following European cities :
_ Mhannon, London, Glasgow, Hamburg, Brusséls, Am*" =.
sterdam, Dusseldorf, Cologne, Frankfurt, Nuremberg,
- Stuttgart, Munich, Paris, Geneva, and yi J ?

(25)

.
.

is which |
'* At the time of filing its application for amendmen

>

26 .

By applicatiorie dated eFebruary 13, 1958 (Dock
No. 9264), Seaboard requested exemption from sectii
401 of the Act so.as to authorize it to carry United
States and foreign transit mail on a non-subsidy serv.
ice rate basis, pending action by the Board on the
appltaion for such amendment of its certificate

at filed on Februgrf 7, 1958 (Docket Noz 9252)

of its certificate, Séaboard also filed a motion for ¢s-
_pedited hearing. «Pan American World Airways, Inc
(Pan . Americar. and Trans World Airlines, Ine.

'- (TWA) have: filed answers in opposition to the

motion, and Seaboard has filed replies.

In support of its motion, Seaboard states, jnter alia,
that its cargo schedules have available substant'.!
‘capacity which-could be utilized to carry mail and
thus improve mail deliveries to European points: that
diversion wf revenues from other U.S. earriers would
be minor; and that since it is not requesting subsidy
it would appear the ceftificate ‘proceeding could’ be

- limited and brief: In their answers; TWA and Pan
_ American state that diversion of mgil revenues would
. be substantial. TWA points out that its international

division’s operating profit for the twelve months ended
September 30, 1957 -was less than $500,000.- Pan
American asserts that the proceeding. probably - would
not be a simple one since a review of Seaboard ’s basic

. certificate would be required should Seaboard contend

that it needs mail authority to continue the trans .
atlantic «ll-eargo experiment, : a

In support of its exemption application, Seaboard
states, inter alia, that the Board has adopted the Post

. Office Department’s policy of favoring authorization

of new carriers, particularly cargo carriers, to trans-
port mail at. mon-subsidy rates; that in the area of |

- mail certification, the very availability of the proposed

aa

XY

a

@

service is in the public interest even though existing
mail service is fully.adequate; that it’ has a need for
maximum revenues to develop air freight on an
-economie and profitable basis; that the present dif-

" ficulties in developing air transportation on an eco“

nomie basis are unusual circumstances affecting all
eargo operators ; that the additional schedules and serv-
lees may prove of benefit to the Post Office Depart-

ment ; that any mail revenues it may secure would have :

no substantial adverse impact on Pan American or

_TWA; that. the public interest will require ultimate:

_ issuance to Seaboard of the requested certificate; and

that it is presently authorized to carry mail of all coun-

tries except the United States.

Pan American and TWA have filed answers and |

Pan American a petition for leave to intervene with
the Board, seeking denial or setting down of the
' application herein for hearing. In support thereof,
inter alia, these carrierg ‘allege as follows: (1) the
applicant has not mad showing’ of undue burden;
_ (2) Seaboard alleges no more than that it would like
~ to have the additional revenue; (3) any U:S. mail
_ arried by Seaboard would be diverted and thus rise
, the possibility of returning Pan American and TWA
_ toa subsidy status or of increasing their service mail
' Tate; (4) the existing mail service is excellent- and
: there is no need for additional ‘service; (5) the Post
Office Department did “not support Seaboard for
exemption authority to carry the mail during the last
holiday season (Docket No. 9163); (6) ‘enforcement
of Section 401 is in the publie interest; and (7), that
Seaboard’s authority-to carry foreign air mail results
from the statute ‘tself rather than from any authority
granted it by the Board.

cae ¢
Seaboard replied to these answers on March 14,

1958, stating that there is no evidentiary question in-
volved in this case and that the Board decision should

“

~ to having available the services of all scheduled ¢ertif.

“2. mues for the transportation of mail may be of as

aoe . 23 4
turn entirely ¢ on’a matter of Post Office Depart:
. and Board policy. |
*~ > (he Post Office - Dhjartment informed the \Boan
that it¢‘basié policy remains the same with nespect

_ cated air carriers for use in, the event the need Would
arise. There is currently more capacity than n¢eded
for ‘the transportation of air mail from New York §
to’ the European points, but” the Department states
that if the exemption: is grant@@ it. will use — serv:
ice if it expedites mail delivery. 3 :
The Board, upon considerg aforesaid
matters and of financial repor}s ‘on file; finds that the
motion of Seaboard for expe ted action_fn. Docket
. 9252 should be granted. If*is quite evident that
Seat ird’s financial] situation is acute, and that. reve

_ sistance to the carrier during its present crisis. It is
therefore, important that: the Board determine, a
promptly as possible, whether the certificate amend-
“ment sougiit ,by. Seaboard -should be granted. The
issues in "thé proceeding . are limited and. expeditet
treatment will permit an early decision. :

Pending — of the certificate proceeding iP
Docket No. 9252 we find that Le should - be
granted inimediate rélief, by*exemptiof authority to
earry mail on a non-subsidy: basis. For the eight
month period-ending February 28, 1958, the carrier
had an operating loss of $3.2 million ofpwhich $2.9.

-. million oecurred from October, 1, 1957. Further, it

has a negative working capital position. . This has
occurred despite an increase in revente ton miles and
operating revenue’ during 1957 over .the correspond
ing 1956 . period. ' It.is ev ident that Seaboard’ s ex*

1 Seaboard inaugurated service under its certificate on April

_— as

be

ssi

/
29

_ istenve is jn jeopardy. While no one can question the |
importanee of the ¢ertificate provisions of the’ statu-. .
tory plan embodied in the Act, the Board’s exemp-
tion powers are designed to afford it the flexibility
‘ needed to meet changing conditions for the over-all .

velopment and good of the air transportation: sys-
tem.- While the ‘additional revenue accruing to Sea- ©
hard through this exemption cannot, be precisely

timated,.it is apparent, on the basis of the schedules
currently offered, that the amounts of mail revenue:
will be of .zfiaterial assistance to tM carrer in im-.
» proving its working capital position in support-
ing its-cargo operations. To deprive the carrier of
_ the opportunity to earn these revenues pending de-
“ eision on its certificate application would impose an |

- undue burden on it and would not be in ‘the public

interest. We have'a duty to give ‘the carrier as much
aid and ‘encouragement. for economic survival as we
ean within the ‘provisions of the Act. Such aid can
be given in this instance without delay and without
_ burdening the’ Federal: Treasury. On. the basis of
-. the comparative scliedules offered by Seaboard, ~Pan.
American and TWA, only. a small portion of the
mail revenues of the latter two carriers will be sub-

"os Jeet to- diversion and. accordingly there: will be no

substantialfaverse- effect upon these carriers pending
-a formai .detérmination of the issues raised by the
certificate application. | ‘Whereas: ‘the diversionary
effect on the existing carriers will be slight, the bene-
fit to Seaboard will be relatively substantial. | Fur-
ther, to the extent that Seaboard’s. services are uti-
lized by, the Post: Office Department to expedite mail —

"deliv ery, as pointed out in. the Post Office filing, the .
ee publie interest will be benefited. | 3

~ It is evident from the faciegoing that the authority
conferred by exemption i is tunitet 1 in 1 extent and in the

aT) S i
Bt

‘public interest. Accordingly, the Board finds that
the enforcement of the provisions of Section 40Y of |
the Act insofar as they would prevent the operations
: hereinafter authorized, would be an undue burden on.
Seaboard by reason of the. limited extent of, and
unusual circumstances affecting its operation and is |
not in the publié interest; and |

IT 18 ORDERED: |

"1: That Seaboard’s motion for. expedited action in
Docket No. 9252 be and hereby is granted, and that
the answers of TWA and Pan Americarr be and they
; hereby are denied; .

2. That Seaboard be and” 18 hereby temporarily .
exempted from the. enforcement .of Sectifjh 401 of. -
the Act insofar as Seaboard would otherwise he
prevented from carrying United States and foreign
transit mail on a non-subsidy, service rate basis;

- 3. That the exemption authority granted. herein

* shall be effective from the date of this. order and shall

continue in effect until final. disposition by the Board

of .Seaboard’s application in Docket No. 9252;
4. That the answers of TWA and Pan American, ;

and Pan American’s petition for leave to intervene

and to set the application in Docket No. 9264. down

for hearing be and. they hereby are- ‘denied ;

5: That this order may be-amended or revoked in

- ‘the discretion of the Board without hearing.

By the Civil Aeronautics Board ; |
[sEav] — fs/ M. Oe Mutuday, Secretary.

Vice Chairman GURNEY. dissenting: ase
_ J-am opposed” to granting this carrier the right to
‘carry mail for the following reasons:

1. No need has been shown for: additional capacity
across the North Atlantic. ee

3 tears :
2. Any diversion of mail from the all-purpose car-

"riers qn_the North Atlantic route may seriously im-

pair the financial condition of these carriers.
3. It is doubtful whether additional schedules will
_ be utilized by the Post Office Department for carry-
ing the mail and therefore the carrier will receive
very little benefit from this authority. ! |
4 I am not convinced that the Board has the au-

thority under Section 416 of the Act ‘to grant an. |

exemption. (See Chicago’ and Southern Air Lines,
Inc., Hot Springs Exemption, 7 C.A.B. a
ae | /s/ CHAN GURNEY.

o

ae APPENDIX D

- The relevant ‘provisions of the Civil Aeronautics _
Act of 1938 (52 Stat. 973, as amended, 49 U.S. c 401,
et seq.) are:

SEc. In he: exercise and performance of
its sowers end duties urfder this Act, the Au-
thority. shall consider the following, among’
‘other things, as being in the public | interest,
‘and in accordance with the public convenie nee
and necessity—

“*{a) The encouragement and development of -

an qir-transportation system properly adapted —°

to the present and future needs of the foreign.
and domestic commerce of the United States...
of the Postal Service, and of the national
defense ;
(b) The regulation of air transportation in
~sueh manner as to recognize.and preserve the
inherent advantages. of, assure the highest de-
gree of safety in, and foster sound economic
conditions in, such transportation, and to im-
prove the relations, between, and coordinate.
transportation by, air carriers;
(c) The promotion of adequate, apononnionl,
and efficient service by air carriers at reason-
able. eharges, without unjust discrimination,

undue .preferences or advantages, or unfair or |

destructive competitive ‘practices ;

(d) Competition to the extent. necessary to
assure the sound devélopment of an air-transpor-
tation system properly adapted to the needs of
the: foreign and domestic ecommerce of the
United States, of the Postal Service, and of the

national defense ;

(e) The regulation of air commerce in such ©
manner as to best promote its dev elopment and

safety ; and
(82)

_ ae

( f)’ The eneouragement and development of
civil aeronautics. - ee

‘~*~ a + SEP * °

Sec. 401(a),3W6-air carrier shall engage in-——~ ~-
any air transpéMation unless there is in force a
certificate issued by the Board authorizing such
air carrier to engage in such, transportation -
*#2e @: . =

* Se s + 2 s
(c) Upon the filing of any such application,
the Board shall give due notice thereof to the ©
. public by posting a notice of such application
in the office of the secretary of the Board and
to such other persons as the Board may by reg-
ulation determine. Any interested person may
file with the Board a protest or memorandum of | -
opposition to or in support of the issuance of a
certificate. Such application shall be set for
“public hearing, and, the Board shall dispose of
such application as speedily as possible.
- | ~~ (d)(1) The Board shall issue a certificate au-
thorizing the- whole or. any part of the transpor-
‘tation. covered by the application;.if it finds
_ - that the applicant is fit, willing, and able to
_ perform such transportation properly, and
_.to conform to the provisions of this chapter
' and the rules, regulations, and requirements
' of the Board hereunder, and that such ‘trans-
portation is required by the public convenience
and necessity; otherwise such application shall
be denied. ; |
(2) In the’case of an application for a cer-
tificate,to engage in temporary air transporta-
tion, the Board may ‘issue a certificate authoriz-
ing the whole: or any -part thereof for such lim-
ited periods as may be required by the public
convenience and necessity, if it finds that the
_ applicant is fit, willing, and able properly to
‘perform such transportation and to conform to
the provisions of this chapter and the rules,

regulations, and eainiiaiiali ot tho.
‘hereunder.

- Sxo.: 416(b)(1) ‘The Board, from ‘time t
. time and to the extent necessary, may, (

__as_provided_in “‘paragraph—

tion) exempt from the requirements of this
or any provision thereof, or any rule,
tion, term, ¢ondition, or limitation pre
thereunder, any air carrier or class of air as
riers, if it. finds that the enforcement of thi
_ title or such provision, or such rule, ;
term, condition, or limitation-is or would
an undue burden on such air carrier or
- 6f air carriers by reason of the limited e
_ of, or unusual circumstances affecting, the
erations of such air carrier or class of air
riers and is not in the public interest.

Py

GS SOCCRNMENT PRINTING OFFICE 1989

‘IN THE

Supe Court. of the Hunited States

OCTOBER TERM, 1958

“2° No. 639° 3 .
SEABOARD & WESTERN ‘AIRLIN ES, INC,,
es Petitioner,

“CIVIL AERONAUTICS BOARD, i
and ° :° Respondent,

_ PAN AMERICAN WORLD AIRWAYS, INC., and
', TRANS WORLD AIRLINES, INC.,
os es, Respondents.

"No. 645 wares

CIVIL AERONAUTICS BOARD,
v. Petitioner,

%
_— AMERICAN WORLD sr INC., ;
and .

TRANS WORLD AIRLINES, INC.,
Le Respondents. .

_
—_—

' BRIEF OF PAN AMERICAN WORLD - AIRWAYS, INC.
. IN OPPOSITION TO PETITIONS FOR WRITS OF
_ CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF

_ APPEALS FOR THE DI CT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT

ov Henn J. FRIENDLY,
aw Ropert G. Barnarn,
Attorneys for Respondent,
Pan American World Airways, Inc.,

ee See,
ee sae
p Ant EASY

a ——. ‘
=, as Sy

r we

TABLICg CONTENTS ©
og ee

¥ : AGE
. y PA .
STATEMENT OF THE @ase ......... eerie Arr MT ee i

. : at
STATUTE ....... rewroen RENT AR et RO Oie Sete Pee os lida 4
“u-

fa

s

RN So liieinesconsdaeceatonanckicaned juanipetiags suing iedpial naeaes ately y

° CoxcLusion

CITATIONS’ . us,

Cases: .

American Airlines x. Civil Aeronautics Board, 2%
F, 2A S45 CIGD) ....0-cccccetecce--e

I

as Pacific Railroad Co, J4 wee Ft) so) eee 10
United States v. Pierce Auta Fre ight Lines, 327 U.S...

Sem CHORP cs c: Re ceteal Sa We eae aE a a

mt Sark ® Statutes:
Civil Aeronautics Act of -1938:

UO Oe oa BP cusclas ee

at, & CC, 6 Gil) ~~. et. RAGES

;

U
_

THE QUESTION PRESENTED ........00200202000-,--0000 ETN ETO stew ’

Florida v. United States, 282.8. 194 bis ais ¥
' * United States ee Chicago. Miliauite, St. Paul f ,

e

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386419_0665%3A3. Public record. Not legal advice.
