# Appendix — Blue v. McKay

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386418_0764%3A2

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Appendix
- **Published:** January 1, 1956
- **Citation:** 352 U.S. 846

## Text

APPENDIX
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBLA CIRCUIT

No. 12,903
TERRY 1. BLUE, Appellant
v.
DOUGLAS MeWKAY, Secretary of the Interior,
Appellee.

Appeal from the United States District Court
for the District of Columbia

Decided April 12, 1956
Mr. Welburn Mayoch tor appellant.

Mr S. Billingsley Hill, Attorney, Department of
Justice, with whem Mr. Perry W. Morton, Assistant
Attorney Generai, was on the brief, for appellee. Mr.
Roger P. Marquis, Attorney, Department of Justice,
also entered an appearance for appellee.

Mr. Robert M. Vaughan tiled a brief on behalf of
California Land Title Association, as amicus curiae
ureing affirmanee.

Before Prettyman, Fahy and Bastian, Circuit
Judges,

ae adie Wn

2

Per Curiam: Plainisf (appellant) filed this pro-
ceeding praying for a Judgment declaring that the
United States is rightfully the owner of and has ace
cepted ownership by tr ‘aty and grant from the Re-
public of Mexico, of the minerals under certain lands
in California ceded by the Treaty of Guadalupe Hi-
dalgo, and that the Mineral Leasing Act of February
25, 1920, 41 Stat. 437, 30 U.S.C. 182 as amended. he
declared applicable to the right to develop the minerals
under said grant. Plaintiff further prayed that a
mandatory injunction or order be issued directing the
defendant (appellee), Secretary of the Interior, and
his agent or representative, to reprocess plaintiff's
application for an oil and eas lease filed pursuant to
the said Mineral Leasing Act and, as of the date of
said application, to erant plaintiff's application for
an oil and gas lease. From an adverse Judgement, alter
final hearing, plaintiff appeals,

The opinion of Judge MeGarraghy in the District
Court, 136 F. Supp. 315 (D.C.Cir. 1955), in our Judg-
ment, correctly disposes of the case,

The judement of the District Court is
Affirmed.

3

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA

Civil Action No. 1691-52

TERRY 1. BLUE, )
Plaintiff, )

Vs. )

DOUGLAS MeKAY, )
Secretary of the Interior, )

Defendant. )

MEMORANDUM

This is a proceeding for a judgment declaring (1)
that the United States is rightfully the owner of and
has accepted ownership by treaty and grant from the
Republic of Mexico of the minerals in certain lands
in California ceded by the Treaty of Guadalupe Hhi-
dalgo and later patented by the United States to par-
ties who elaimed title under a prior Mexican grant:
(2) that the Mineral Leasing Act of February 25, 1920,
41 Stat. 437, 441, 30 U.S.C. TST, 226, is applicable to
the right to develop the minerals under the said con-
firmed Mexican grant: and (3) for a mandatory in-
junction or order directing the Secretary of Interior
to reprocess plaintiff's application for an oil and gas
lease tiled pursuant to the Mineral Leasing Act and
to grant the plaintiff's application for such lease.

The defendant, while contending that the plaintiff
could not obtain a deeree directing Issuance of an oil
and gas lease since this involves a discretionary fune-

A gears: PETAR ar. 4

ass

4

tion of the Seeretary of lnterior, raised no objection
to the Court’s review of the Secretary's legal conela-
Sion that title to the minerals passed with the patent,
nor does the defendant claim that the owners of the
surface rights are necessary parties to this proceeding.

By the Treaty of Guadalupe Hildaleo of February
2, 1848, 9 Stat. 922, the Mexiean war was brought to
a close and, among other things, a large territory in-
cluding all of the present State of California was ceded
to the United States. Among other provisions, the
Treaty provided for the protection of property in the
ceded territories which was then held by many indi-
Viduals under prior grants from Mexico and Spain.

The Protocol of Queretaro dated May 26, 1848, con-
tained the following clarifying provision;

“The American Government by suppressing
the Ath Article of the Treaty of Guadalupe did
not In any way intend to annul the erants of land
made by Mexico in the ceded territories. These
grants, notwithstanding the suppression of. the
article of the Treaty, preserve the legal value
Which they may possess: and the grantees may
cause their legitimate titles te be acknowledved
before the American tribunals.

*Conformably to the law of the United States,
legitimate titles to every description of property
personal and real, existing in the ceded territories,
are those which were legitimate titles under the
Mexican law in California and New Mexico up to
the 15th day of May, 1.846 and in Texas up to the
2nd day of March 1.836."

4)

In order to establish the vaiidity and the boundaries
of the private claims and to set apart the lands private-
iv owned from those whic h would thereafter be owned
by the United States, Congress passed the Act of
Mareh 3, I851, 9 Stat. 631, entitled **An Act to Ascer-
tain and Nettle the pies’ Land Grants of the State
of California”’.

The Act established a Board of Commissioners to
hear all land claims with provision for appeal to the
District Court and to the Supreme Court of the United
States.

Sec. 8 of the Act provided that claimants should
present their claims to the Commissioners when sitting
as a Board and thereafter the Commission should
“proceed promptly to examine the same upon such
evidence and upon the evidence produced on behalf of
the United States and to decide upon the validity of
said claim’ and thereafter, within thirty days from the
date of the decision, to certify the same, with the rea-
sons on Which it was founded, to the District Attorney
of the United States in and for the District for which
the decision was rendered.

See. 9 provided for a court review in the District
Court of the United States and an appeal to the United
States Supreme Court.

See. 11 provided that the Commissioners and the
Distriet Court and Supreme Court in passing upon
the validity of any claim “shall be governed by the
Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo, the law of the Nations.
the laws, usages and customs of the government from

6

Which the claim is derived, the principles of equity,
and the decisions of the Supreme Court of the United
States, so far as they are applicable.”’

Sec. 13 of the Act, after providing that all lands,
the claims to which have been finally rejected by
the Commissioners or which are finally decided to be
invalid by the courts, and all lands the claims to which
shall not have been presented to the Commissioners
Within two years from the date of the Act, shall be
deemed held and considered as part of the public do-
main of the United States, further provided that ‘for
all claims finally confirmed by the said Commissioners,
or by the said District or Supreme Court, a patent
shall issue to the claimant upon his presenting to the
General Land Office an authentic certificate of such
confirmation, and a plat or survey of the said land,
duly certified and approved by the Surveyor General
of California, whose duty it shall be to cause all private
claims which shall be finally contirmed to be accurately
surveyed and to furnish plats of the same...”

See. 15 of the Act provided that “any patent to be
issued under this Act shall be conclusive between the
United States and the said claimants only and shall
not affect the interests of third persons.”

On October 19, 1852, various heirs of Christobel
Dominguez presented a petition to the Board of Com-
Inissioners appointed under the above Act claiming **in
fee simple a certain tract of land situate in the county
of Los Angeles, known by the name of ‘San Pedro’
containing ten square leagues, more or less.”

7

The claim went on to state Gaat the claimants **elaim
said tract of land, a portion of them by inheritance
from, and a portion by purchase Prom, the heirs of
Christobel Dominguez who died seized in fee thereof
and who inherited from his uncle, Juan Jose Domin-
euez, Who died also seized theretor in fee somewhere
about the year L809-10."°

After reciting the chain of title and their relation-
ship to Christobel Dominguez, the petition stated ‘and
your petitioners therefore aver they claim in See the
said Rancho of San Pedro as tenants in common in
the shares and proportions as aforesaid in virtue of
the aforesaid grants, of their long and specific posses-
sion and of the satisfaction, approval and acknowledg-
ment of their title by the Mexican Government.”

The petition prayed “the Honorable Board to take
their said claim into consideration and to declare their
title to the said Rancho San Pedro good and valid,
and to confirm the same, and as in duty bound, ete.,

e¢

ae

Thereafter, the Board of Commissioners sustained
the claim of the petitioners and, in an opinion reciting
the evidence in support of the claim, the Board held
that the case “falls within the rules and as such is en-
titled to a confirmation”, and ‘ta decree will be en-
tered in general terms confirming the title of the peti-
tioners to the premises to hold the same as tenants in
common in the proportion in which they are respec-
tively entitled under the rights derived from the
sources above mentioned.”

8

A decree of contiriiaiion was entered on October
17, 1854.

From the decision of the Board of Commissioners,
an appeal was prosecuted by the Government to the
District Court of the United States for the Southern
District of California, which Court on the 10th day of
February, 1857 entered its judgment affirmine the
decision of the Board of Land Commissioners. The
Judgment adjudged and decreed **that the claims of
the appellees to the land claimed in this case is good
and valid and the same are hereby confirmed in them
as follows: the lands of which confirmation is hereby
made are known as the ‘Rancho San Pedro’ situate in
Los Angeles County and bounded as follows: . . . ( De-
scription follows).”’

An appeai was taken from the decision of the Dis-
trict Court to the Supreme Court of the United States
but was subsequently withdrawn. Thereafter, the sur-
vey was approved by the U.S. Surveyor General and
a patent was issued on December 18, 1858.

After reciting the various procedural steps taken
under the Act of March 3, 1851, ineludine quotation
of the complete survey authenticated by the U.S. Sur-
veyor General, California, the patent concluded with
the following vrant:

“Now Know Ye, That the United States of
America, in consideration of the premises, and
pursuant to the provisions of the Act of Congress
aforesaid of 3rd March 1851, Have Given and
Granted, and by these Presents do Give and Grant,

9

unto the said Manuel dominguez, Concepcion
Roche. Bernardino Rocha, Jose Antonio Aguina,
Maria Jesus Cota de Dominguez, Madalina Do-
minguez, Andres Dominguez, Feliciana Domin-
guez, Estebane Dominguez, Maria Dominguez,
Pedro Dominguez, Jose Dominguez, Maria, widow
of Manuel Rocha, and Antonio Jacinto Rocha, and
to their heirs. the tract of land embraced and de-
scribed in the foregoing survey, ‘in the respective
shares and proportions which they hold in the
premises,” “by title deduced from Christobel Do-
minguez, deceased, by heirship or by mesne con-
veyances’; but with the stipulation that in virtue
of the 15th Seetion of the said Act, the contirmia-
tion of this said claim, and this patent, ‘shall not
affect the interests of third persons ;°

“To Have and To Hold the said tract, with the
appurtenances, in the respective shares and pro-
portion, and with the stipulation aforesaid, unto
the said Manuel Dominguez, Concepcion Rocha,
Bernardino Roeha, Jose Antonio Aguina, Marie
Jesus Cota de Dominguez, Madalina Dominguez,
Andres Dominguez, Feliciana Dominguez, Esten-
ban Dominguez, Maria Dominguez, Pedro Domin-
enez, Jose Dominguez, Maria, widow of Manuel
Rocha. and Antonio Jacinto Rocha, and to their
heirs and assigns forever.”

From the date the patent was issued in 1858 until

the present time, the United States has not asserted

claim to any mineral interest in the land described in

the

patent. Apparently the area has been used and

developed on the theory that the patentees obtained a
full fee title. An exhibit offered im evidence by the

10

defendant indicates that ihis particular area is in the
heart of one of California’s richest oil producing fields.

On February 27, 1937, the plaintiff applied to the
United States Land Office in Los Angeles for an oil
and gas lease on some of the lands included in the
Dominguez (or San Pedro) patent described as Sec. 4,
Township 5 South, Range 13 West Los Angeles County,
This application was rejected on April 2, 1937 by the
Commissioner of the General Land Office on the
ground that the land was “embraced in confirmed pri-
vate land claims title to whieh has long since passed
from the Government by patent. The Department has
no jurisdiction over such lands aud ho authority to
issue an oil and gas lease covering the same.’

A rehearing was granted on May 12, 1937 following
Which briefs were filed by parties in interest but no
decision was rendered for some twelve vears. This
delay was due primarily to the intervening “off shore
oil” litigation, On April 8, 1949, an opinion was issued
by the Solicitor of the Department of the Interior act-
ing for the Secretary, denying the rehearing applica-
tion. An application for reconsideration was filed on
July 5, 1949 which was rejected on July 12, 1949. This
suit followed on April 16, 1952.

ll
PLAINTIFF’S CONTENTIONS

Plaintiff contends that the United States patent
did not convey the minerals beneath the soil in the land
described to the patentees for the reason that the
Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo and the Protocol of
Queretaro provided for the contirmation by the United
States of legitimate titles under Mexican law in Cali-
fornia up to May, 1846; that under Mexican law the
ownership of agrarian land did not include the mines
or minerals below the surface, but that these belonged
to the sovereign; that the claim of Dominguez, et al,
which includes the land involved in these proceedings
was a claim of title to agricultural land and did not
constitute a claim to the minerals therein, which under
Mexican law belonged to the sovereign; that the Act
of March 3, 1851 provided only for confirmation of
eXisting titles to property under Mexican law and did
not include the power to convey to a claimant out of
the Publie Domain of the United States more property
than such claimant owned under Mexican law; that the
United States acquired by cession all the rights and
property of the Republic of Mexico and California in-
cluding the minerals beneath the surface of the Do-
minguez grant, and that since title thereto has never
been conveyed but remains in the United States, the
plaintiff acquired the right to a lease of the minerals
in the land described in his Application of February

26, 1937,

EH

ar

12

~_

DEFENDANT’S CONTENTIONS

The defendant contends that the patent issued un-
der the Act of March 3, 1951 and the proceedings which
were held incident to the issuance of said patent ear-
ried with it title to the oil, gas and minerals and that
the United States does not own any interest in the
land described in plaintiff's application which could
propertly be the subject of a Federal oil and gas lease;
that since the patent was issued the United States has
made no attempt to claim any mineral interest in the
land described and the area has been used and devel-
oped on the theory that the patentee obtained a full
fee title; that this particular area is in the heart of
one of California's richest producing oil fields and that
this suit would gravely interfere with title claims
Which have been in existence for a long period of time;
also, that as against the United States, or those ¢laim-
ing under it, a patent under the 1851 Act operates as
a quit claim, and that one holding a patent under the
1851 Act has unifornily been held to have a conclusive
title against the United States or anyone tracine his
claim to the United States; that the legislative history
of the 1851 Act confirms the conclusion that patents
issued thereunder conveved the minerals; and that
while there have been no earlier Interior Department
decisions on the precise subject, there seems to be no
question that the defendant's predecessors in title have
consistently concluded that the United States did not
own the minerals and lands patented under the 185]
Act; that earlier Secretaries of the Interior at no time

have suggested that action should be taken to assert a

a

13

claim of title to these minerals and, therefore, this case
is subject to the rule that courts should regard long
continued and uniform practice of the officers charged
with the duty of administering the law as persuasively
determinative of its construction.

OPINION

The question to be decided in this case is whether
or not the patent dated December 18, 1858 to Manuel
Dominguez, et al, and issued pursuant to the provisions
of the Act of March 3. 1851, conveyed title to the min-
erals beneath the soil in the land described in the
patent.

It seems clear that, as plaintiff contends, under
Spanish and Mexican law, no interest in the minerals
passed by grant from the Mexican Government of the
land in which they were contained, without express
words designating them. The United States vs. Andres
Custillero, 2. Black 17; Moore vs. Smaw, 17 Cal. 199.
In view of this fact. it may be argued in support of
the plaimtiff’s position that, since the claim of Domin-
euez, et al, was a claim of title to agricultural lands
and did not constitute a claim to the minerals therein,
the patent issued pursuant to the provisions of the Act
of Mareh 3. 1851 only confirmed the title of the elaim-
ants to the agricultural land and did not convey title
to the mines or minerals below the surface.

However, such a ruling would run counter to a long
line of authorities which either directly or indirectly
support a contrary view and would do violence to the

14

purpose of the Act of March 3, 1851, to settle private
land claims in the State of California based on Mexicny
and Spanish grants and not to leave such titles in their
former indefinite position,

The contentions made by the plaintiff in this suit
Were raised as lone avo as IS61L, and decided adversely
to the position here taken by the plaintiff, in the case
of Moore vs. Smaw, 17 Cal. J YY, Written by Chief Jns-
tice Field of that Court. later Mr. Justice Field of the
Supreme Court of the United States, in which the
Court held that consistent With the purposes of. the
Act of March 3, 1851, the effect of a patent under said
Act was to divest the United States of any and all in- — !
terest in the land, including the minerals Which it may
have acquired from Mexico under the Treaty,

While the precise issue raised in this pendine suit
appears not to have been raised in any prior litigation
in any Federal Court so as to be direetly passed pon,
the Moore decision has never been questioned and if
has been cited with approval in other cases, although
hot with respect to the issue involved in this proceed-
ing. Burke vs, Southern Pacific Railroad, 234 U.S,
669, 689, United States us. Teras, 339 U.S. 706, 709,

The Dominguez Claiin was the subject of an elaho-
rate opinion by the Supreme Court of the United States
in Domingues Di Grayer vs. Banning, 167 U.S. 723.
Written by Mr. Justice Harlan, in whieh the
of the claim: is recited in detail and, while the
in that case did not haye before it the issue
consideration, it did hold that the

history

Court
how under
description in the

15

patent controlled and from tis holding it is reason-
able to conelude that the patent issued on December
ik, 1858 embraced all of (ae land, including the min-
erals under the surface, to the patentees therein named.

In the case of Beard vs. Federy, 3 Wall. 478, the
Supreme Court held that a patent issued pursuant to
the provisions of the Act of March 3, 1851 is ‘ta con-
vevyance of such interest as the United States possessed
in the land, and it takes effect by relation at the time
when proceedings were istituted by the filing of the
petition before the Board of Land Commissioners,”

In Fremont vs. United States, 17 How, 542. the
Court also had the Act of Mareh 3, 185L under consid-
eration and pointed out that the Eighth Section of the
Act “embraces not only inchoate or equitable titles, but
legal titles also; and requires them all to undergo ex-
amination and to be passed upon by the Court. The
object of this provision appears to be, to place the titles
in land in Califorma upon a stable foundation, and to
vive the parties who possess them an opportunity of
placing them on the records of the country, in a man-
ner and form that will prevent future controversy.”’

In Juterstate Land Co, vs. Marwell Land Co., 139
U.S. 569, the Supreme Court again had before it the
question of the effect of a patent covering land ae-
quired from Mexico by the Treaty of Guadalupe Hi-
dalvo, and the Court said (page 580)

The confirmation and patenting of the grant

to Beaubien and Miranda operated to divest the
United States of all their rights to the land em-

16

braced in the grant which this country acquired
from Mexico by the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo.
And the only way that that grant ean be defeated
now is to show that the lands embraced in it had
been previously eranted by the Mexican Goyer.
ment to some other person.”’

In United States vs. O'Donnell, 303 U.S. DOL, S12,
in Which the history of the Act of March 3, 1851 is set
out in detail, the Court said:

“The primary purpose of the Mexican Claims
Act was the performance by the United States of
its treaty obligations to quiet the titles of the
claimants under Spanish and Mexican grants. But
a necessary consequence of proceeding before the
Commission, and one incidental to the determina-
tion of the validity of the titles of such claimants,
Was a determination whether, by the cession, the
lands in question had become a part of the public
domain of the United States, It is evident that
the treaty obligations to quiet the title of claimants
under the Mexican grants would be defeated and
the Mexican Claims Act would fai] of its purpose
if the finality of the Board's confirmation of claims
under Mexican grants could be challenged by per-
sons claiming under vrants of publie lands by the
United States. For that reason it has been eon-
sistently held that. claimants under the United
States, by virtue of statutes disposing of its pub-
lic lands in California, are not ‘third persons’
Within the meanine of the Mexican Clainis Act,
and that confirmation undep that Act of claims
under Mexican grants is conclusive Upon all those
claiming under the United States,"

17

In Adam vs. Norris, W056 U.S. 591, 593, the Court
sald:

.

Dut the United States, in dealing with parties
claiming, wider Mexican grants, lands within the
territory ceded by the treaty of Mexico, never
made pretense that it was the owner of thei.
When, therefore, guided by the action of the tri-
bunals established to pass upon the validity of
these alleged grants, the Government issued a pat-
entit Was in the nature of a quit claimj—an admis-
sion that the rightful ownership had never been
in the United States, but had passed at the tine
of the cession to the claimant, or to those under
Whom he claimed. This principle has been more
than once clearly announced in this Court. (Citing

cases, ) 7"

In the case of Aly Real Estate d& Tnvestinent Com-
pany es, Walls, of al, 202 F721. which related to the
Gadsden Treaty with Mexico of December 30, 1853,
under whieh the Cited States aequired that portion
of Arizona involved in the proceeding, required con-
sideration of the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo and the
Court dicussed at leneth the PLOVISTOUS of the Act of
Mareh 2, 1851, particularly Sec. 15 thereof. In the
opinion written by Circuit Judge Gilbert, after review-
Ing a number of authorities, the Court said:

“Tt has been held in numerous decisions that
the patent issued upon a confirmed Mexiean grant
is to he regarded in two aspects: First. it isa quit
claim deed from the United States, which takes
effect by relation at the time when proceedings

ere

18

Were instituted by Ue filing of the petition with
the Commission or Court created to adjudicate the
claim; Second, it is a record of the Government,
showing its judgment with respect to the title of
the patentee at the date of the cession.’ (Citing
cases)”

Other authorities which, while not directly in point,
lend support to the conclusions herein expressed, are
Botiller vs. Dominguez, 130 US. 238; United States
vs. San Jacinto Tin Co., 125 U.S. 273; United States
us. Coronado Beach Co,, 255 U.S. 472: Work vs. Mason,
6B. (2d) 474; Hogan vs. United States, 72 F. (2d) 799;
Los Angeles and Salt: Lake Railroad Company vs.
(nited States, 140 F. (2d) 436; Leese vs. Clark, 20 Cal.
388, 423.

The claim tiled by the heirs of Cheristobel Domin-
guez claimed “in fee simple a certain tract of land
situate in the County of Los Angeles, known by the
name of "San Pedro’ containine ten square leagues,
more or less*’, and went on to state that Christobel Do-
minguez “died seized in fee thereof’, and then the
petitioners “aver they claim in fee the said Rancho
San Pedro as tenants in common .. .° The patent
Issued gave and granted “the tract of land embraced
and described in the foregoing survey’,

In the light of the foregoing authorities, it is my
conclusionsthat the patent herein described and issued
pursuant to the provisions of the Act of March 3. TS5T,
did convey title to the minerals beneath the soil in the

land deseribed in. the patent; that the patentees ac-

19

quired a conelusive title agaiiist the United States or
anyone tracing his claim to: the United States; that
the defendant correctly ruled that the United States
Joes not own the minerals in the lands described in the
lease application and, therefore, the plaintiff isnot

entitled to the relief demanded,
Counsel for the defendant will submit an appre-

priate order in conformity with the foregoing.
s JOSEPH C. MeGARRAGHEY

Judge F

June 24, 1955

EXCERPT FROM PROTOCOL OF QUERETARO
CLARIFYING TREATY OF GUADALUPE HI-
DALGO.

The Protocol of Queretaro dated May 26, 1848, con-
tained the following clarifying provision:

“The American Government by suppressing
the Ath Article of the Treaty of Guadalupe did
not in any way intend to annul the grants of land
made by Mexico in the ceded territories. These
erants, notwithstanding the suppression of the
article of the Treaty, preserve the legal value
Which they may possess; and the grantees may
cause their legitimate titles to be acknowledged
before the American tribunals,

*“Conformably to the law of the United States,
legitimate titles to every description of property
personal and real, existing in the ceded territories,
are those which were legitimate titles under the

Seetacall cilia

20

Mexican law in California and New Mexico up to
the 13th day of Mav 1846 and in Texas up to the
2nd day of Mareh 1836."

PERTINENT SECTIONS OF ACT OF MARCH 3, 1851
Pa

Sections 1, 8, 9, 10, 11, 13, and 15 of the Act of
March 3, 1851, 9 Stat. G81, are as follows:

An Act to ascertain and settle the private Land
Claims in the State of California

Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Rep-
resentatives of the United States of America in
Congress assembled, That for the purpose of ascer-
taining and settling private land claims in the
State of California a commission shall be, and is
hereby, constituted, which shall consist of three
commissioners, to be appointed by the President
of the United States, by and with the advice and
consent of the Senate, Which commission shall cou-
tinue for three vears from the date of this act,
unless sooner discontinued by the President of the
United States.

* * ~ * *

Sec. 8. And he it further enacted, That each
and every person claiming lands in California by
virtue of any right or title derived from the Span-
ish or Mexican government, shall present the same
to the said commissioners when sitting as a board,
together with such documentary evidence and
testimony of witnesses as the said claimant velies
upon in support of such claims; and it shall be the
duty of the commissioners, when the case is ready

21

for hearing, to proceed promptly to examine the
same upon such evidence, and upon the evidence
produced in behalf of the United States, and to
decide upou the validity of the said claim, and,
within thirty days after such decision is rendered,
to certify the same, with the reasons on which it
is founded, to the district attorney of the United
States in and for the district in which such deci-
sion shall be rendered.

Sec. 9 And be it further enacted, That in all
cases of the rejection or confirmation of any claim
by the board of commissioners, it shall and may be
lawful for the claimant or the district attorney,
in behalf of the United States, to present a peti-
tion to the District Court of the distriet in which
the land claimed is situated, praying the said court
to review the decision of the said commissioners,
and to decide on the validity of such claim; and
such petition, if presented by the claimant, shall
set forth fully the nature of the claim and the
names of the original and present claimants, and
shall contain a deraignment of the claimant's title,
together with a transcript of the report of the
hoard of commissioners, and of the documentary
evidence and testimony of the witnesses on which
it was founded; and such petition, if presented by
the district attorney in behalf of the United States,
shall be accompanied by a transcript of the report
of the board of commissioners, and of the papers
and evidence on which it was founded, and shal!
fully and distinetly set forth the grounds on which
the said claim is alleged to be invalid, a copy of
which petition, if the same shall be presented by a
claimant, shall be served on the district attorney

22

of the United States, and, if presented in behalf
of the United States. shall be served on the claim-
ant or his attorney; and the party upon whom
such service shall be made shall be bound to answer
the same within a time to be prescribed by the
judge of the District Court: and the answer of the
claimant to such petition shall set forth fully the
nature of the claim, and the names of the original!
and present claimants, and shall contain a deraien-
ment of the claimant's title; and the answer of
the district attorney in behalf of the United States
shall fully and distinctly set forth the erounds on
Which the said claim is alleged to be invalid. copies
of which answers shall be served upon the adverse
party thirty days before the meeting of the court.
and thereupon, at the first term of the court there-
after, the said case shall stand for trial, unless on
cause shown, the same shall be continued bv the
court.

Sec. 10. And be it further enacted, That the
District Court shall proceed to render judement
upon the pleadings and evidence in the ease. and
upon such further evidence as may be taken by
order of the said court, and shall, on application
of the party against whom judgement is rendered,
grant an appeal to the Supreme Court of the
United States, on such security for costs in the
District and Supreme Court, in case the judement
of the District Court shall be affirmed. as the said
court shall prescribe; and if the court shall be sat-
isfied that the party desiring to appeal is unable
to give such security, the appeal may be allowed
without security.

Sec. 11. And be it further enacted, That the

23

commissioners herein-provided for, and the Dis-
trict and Supreme Courts, in deciding on the va-
lidity of any claim brought before them under the
provisions of this act, shall be governed by the
treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo, the law of nations,
the laws, usages, and customs of the government
from which claim is derived, the principles of
equity, and the decisions of the Supreme Court of
the United States, so far as they are applicable.

* * * * *

Sec. 13. And be it further enacted, That all
lands, the claims to which have been finally re-
jected by the commissioners in manner herein
provided, or which shall be finally decided to be
invalid by the Distriet or Supreme Court, and all
lands the claims te which shall not have been pre-
sented to the said commissioners within two years
after the date of this act, shall be deemed, held,
and considered as part of the public domaim of the
United States; and for all claims finally confirmed
by the said commissioners, or by the said District
or Supreme Court, a patent shall issue to the claim-
ant upon his presenting to the general land office
an authentic certifieate of such confirmation, and
a plat or survey of the said land, duly certified and
approved by the surveyor-general of California,
whose duty it shall be to cause all private claims
which shall be finally contirmed to be accurately
surveyed, and to furnish plats of the same; and in
the location of the said claims, the said surveyor-
general shall have the same power and authority
as are conferred on the register of the land office
and receiver of the public moneys of Louisiana,
by the sixth section of the act *‘to create the office

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386418_0764%3A2. Public record. Not legal advice.
