# Appendix — United States v. Williams

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386417_2639%3A2

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Appendix
- **Published:** January 1, 1955
- **Citation:** 349 U.S. 938

## Text

Gu the Gnited States Court of Claims

No. 50403
(Decided January 11, 1955)

RUSSELL H. WILLIAMS, d/b/a WILLIAMS EQUIP-
MENT CO., AND REED & MARTIN, INC., A COR-
PORATION v. THE UNITED STATES

Mr. William H. Ferguson for the plaintiffs. Mr. Donald
McL. Davidson was on the briefs.

Mr. Kendall M. Barnes, with whom was Mr. Assistant
Attorney General Warren E. Burger, for the defendant.

OPINION

Jones, Chief Judge, delivered the opinion of the court:

This case involves a contract between the plaintiffs and
the defendant for the construction of a paved road at Fair-
banks, Alaska. The facts have been set out in detail in our
findings and will be referred to only to the extent necessary
for an understanding of the issues which gave rise to the suit.

The principal issue has to do with the amount of borrow
material which was excavated by the plaintiffs and put in
place on the road. The contract provided for payment for
the borrow material at $1.29 per cubic yard and the payment
for hauling the material beyond a certain distance at a unit
price of 32 cents per cubic-yard mile. The borrow material
yardage to be paid for was to be measured in its original
position in the borrow pit, which yardage was to be computed
by the average end area method, and the overhaul item was
to be paid upon the measurement of material in its original
position times the overhaul distance in miles and fractions
thereof. In other words, an important consideration in de-
termining the amount due the plaintiffs was a determination
of the amount of borrow material in its original position.

(1A)

NR ADHERE AP ARO EH ORY sl BE ATI TAD EE BY aces ARG MOTT BE eR IE Cy Pm of ate " AL Roeser aii

2A

The face of the quarry rose from a flat surface at a steep,
though not vertical, angle. The average end area method
contemplated that surveys be made of the vertical profile of
the quarry at frequent intervals along its face, both at the

beginning and at the end of the quarrying operations. The }
extent to which the profile upon final survey had receded
from its original position would then be the basis for meas-

uring the amount of material that had been removed from
the quarry. At or about the time the plaintiffs began work a t

survey was made of the quarry. After some 30 or 40 percent
of the excavation work had been completed, a slide occurred
at the quarry in which a large amount of material moved
downward and outward toward the base line where the plain-
tiffs were operating. The amount of material moved was esti-
mated by a witness for the defendant as from 30,000 to 50,000
cubic yards, and by witnesses for the plaintiffs as from 200,000
to 400,000 cubic yards.
:
>
j
be
7
.

“1g

NRHA Tht

#Y NPD

ASST,

ELIOT RST

338960—55——_3

x

*
RY
ee
NYO PRS TAT TEL ALAR RENTS COG ET SNR =|

8A

ings we have found that 84,471 cubic yards of borrow ma-
terial were excavated which is 15,121.3 cubic yards more than
that allowed by the defendant. Since the contract price was
$1.29 per cubic yard for the excavation of this borrow mate-
rial, the plaintiffs are entitled to recover $19,506.48 on this
item.

Since the amount allowable for the overhaul item varies in
direct proportion to the volume of borrow material removed,
the cubic-yard miles allowable on this item is 267,727.8 in-
stead of 217,032.4, that is, 50,695.4 cubic-yard miles more
than allowed by the defendant. At the contract price of 82
cents per cubic-yard mile, this amounts to $16,222.53, which
the plaintiff's are entitled to recover on this item.

The other issue in the case involves questions of law and
arises out of an entirely different set of facts from those just
discussed. One of the items involved in the contract was the
paving of the road with asphalt. In order to do this work,
the plaintiffs had considered renting or buying an asphalt
plant in the State of Washington. The rental cost of such
a plant would have been approximately $10,700. After the
job got under way, the plaintiffs learned that there was a
plant located at Ladd Air Force Base which was under the
jurisdiction of one Major Russell who was responsible for
the maintenance of the roads at the Air Force Base. One of
the plaintiffs made inquiry of Major Russell as to whether
arrangements could be made for the plaintiffs to use the
plant. Major Russell suggested that certain roads on the
Base needed seal coating and if plaintiffs would do this work
they could use the plant on the road job. After certain
negotiations during which Major Russell represented that
he had been given authority to enter into the agreement, the
plaintiffs submitted a written proposal which was accepted by
Major Russell as Air Installation Officer, whereby the plain-
tiffs agreed to seal coat the main paved roads on the base in
return for the use of the asphalt plant to produce asphalt for
the road job.

Upon the approval of that agreement by Major Russell,
the plaintiffs proceeded to carry out their part of the agree-
ment which they did by seal coating some nine or ten miles of
roads in a manner satisfactory to the Air Force Base author-
ities. The value of such work was in excess of $10,000.

9A

In the meantime, Major Russell had forwarded to his
superior officer copies of the agreement which he had ap-
proved for seal coating of the roads in return for the use
of the asphalt plant by the plaintiffs. Shortly after the
seal-coating job had been completed but prior to the time
when the asphalt plant had been delivered to the plaintiffs,
Major Russell’s superior officer advised him that there was
no authority for such an agreement and that work there-
under should be stopped immediately. Major Russell re-
plied that the work had already been completed and urged
that since the plaintiffs had carried out their part of the
agreement and since the agreement was in the best interests
of the Government, the plaintiffs should be permitted to use
the asphalt plant. However, Major Russell’s superior of-
ficer refused to change his position. Major Russell advised
the plaintiffs of his inability to carry out the agreement but
suggested that arrangements be made to have the plant bor-
rowed by the Alaska Road Commission and then rented by
the Commission to the plaintiffs. Major Russell stated that
if this could be arranged he would arrange for payment for
the work which had already been done by the plaintiffs at
Ladd Field. As a result the asphalt plant was turned over
by Major Russell to the Alaska Road Commission which, in
turn, made it available to the plaintiffs at a rental figure of
$1.30 per ton. In agreeing orally to that rental figure, the
plaintiffs relied upon the assurance previously given by
Major Russell that they would be paid for the work which
they had already performed at Ladd Field.

The plaintiffs used the asphalt plant in paving the roads
under their contract. At or about the time the paving was
completed, Major Russell advised the paintiffs that payment
could not be made by the defendant for the seal-coating work
which had been performed by them at Ladd Field. There-
upon the plaintiffs refused to sign a change order prepared
by the Alaska Road Commission reducing the unit price of
asphalt by $1.30 per ton. However, the contracting officer, in
the final settlement under the plaintiffs’ contract, directed
that the change order be considered a written order changing
the specifications and that the rental stipulated therein be
deemed to be an equitable adjustment of the contract price.

ee — a

10A

Upon completion of the contract, it was determined that
7,820.3 tons of asphalt had been actually used and accordingly
$10,166.39 was deducted from payments to the plaintiffs,
On appeal to the head of the department, the decision of the
contracting officer was affirmed. No amount has been paid
to the plaintiffs on account of the work which they did at
Ladd Field.

What the plaintiffs are suing for is the amount just re-
ferred to which was deducted from amounts otherwise due
them under the contract involved in this proceeding. No
question is raised by the defendant as to the fact that the
plaintiffs performed the services or that the services were
worth at least the amount now sued for. The sole defense
of the defendant is that since Major Russell was not a con-
tracting officer with full authority to bind the Government
in the fullest contractual sense, the plaintiffs cannot recover
on this item. Surely, compelling reasons would be required
to have any court sanction any such inequitable result and
we do not think such reasons exist. Whatever might be said
with respect to the lack of authority on the part of Major.
Russell to enter into a binding contract, it is certainy true
that the plaintiffs proceeded in an entirely appropriate and
proper manner in entering into the agreement and did so
only after they were assured by Major Russell that he had
authority to do so. Likewise, Major Russell had also pro-
ceeded in good faith in the entire matter and had been assured
by Washington that such an arrangement would be satisfac-
tory. The roads that were seal coated were wholly within
the base where the contracting officer was located. It seems
incredible that he did not know all about the agreement and
by his inaction ratify it. Certainly he did not repudiate the
agreement, and he did not appear as a witness. The plaintiffs
carried out their part of the agreement for which the Gov-
ernment received the benefit. We feel that there then arose
an implied contract under which the defendant was obligated
to pay the value of the services rendered by the plaintiffs.
Recovery is accordingly allowable for this item in the amount
deducted under the contract, $10,166.39. Cf. W. H. Arm-
strong and Company v. United States, 98 C. Cls. 519, 529;
Lewis Joseph Stiers, et al. v. United States, 121 C. Cls. 157,

11A

172; and Pacific Maritime Association v. United States, 123
C. Cls. 667, 676.

Judgment will accordingly be entered for $19,506.48 for
the material item, $16,222.53 for the overhaul item, and
$10,166.39 for the asphalt plant item, making a total of
$45,895.40.

It is so ordered.

Laramore, Judge; Mavpen, Judge; Wurtaxer, Judge;
and LirrteTon, Judge, concur.

FINDINGS OF FACT

The court, having considered the evidence, the report of
Commissioner Richard H. Akers, and the briefs and argu-
ment of counsel, makes findings of fact as follows:

1, At all times material to this proceeding the plaintiff,
Russell H. Williams, was engaged in the contracting busi-
ness in Alaska as an individual under the name of Williams
Equipment Company with his principal place of business
in Fairbanks, Alaska. For convenience, that plaintiff will
sometimes hereinafter be referred to as “Williams.”

At all times material to this proceeding the plaintiff,
Reed & Martin, Inc., was an Alaska corporation with its prin-
cipal place of business in Fairbanks. It was engaged in the
contracting business, normally business construction.

2. During the early part of 1950, the plaintiffs entered into
a joint venture agreement for the purpose of submitting a
bid to the defendant, acting through the Department of the
Interior, Alaska Road Commission, for the construction of a
highway from Fairbanks to College and a portion of the
Steese Highway, a total distance of approximately 5.74
miles. Williams was the manager of the operation and the
other plaintiff did not actively participate therein except
in connection with the securing of an asphalt mixing plant
hereinafter referred to.

3. The plaintiffs were advised on March 16, 1950, by John
R. Noyes, Commissioner of Roads for Alaska, that their bid
in the total amount of $389,713.10 based upon the estimated
quantities set out in the invitation for bids and the unit prices
bid by them had been accepted, that the formal contract was
being prepared for their signatures, and that that letter would

BLS ILO OF SLL ETS

12A

constitute notice to proceed within 15 calendar days after
its receipt.

4. Under date of March 28, 1950, the formal contract cover-
ing the work was signed. That contract bore the number
1-arc—4263 and was signed on behalf of the defendant by A. F.
Ghiglione, Chief Engineer, Alaska Road Commission, as
contracting oflicer. It provided that the plaintiffs would
furnish the materials and perform the work for constructing
the highway from Fairbanks to College and a portion of the
Steese Highway in consideration of payment of the unit
prices set forth in the bid schedule in strict accordance with
the specifications, schedules, and drawings specifically desig-
nated in the contract. The contract further provided that
the work was to be commenced within 15 calendar days
after receipt by the contractor of notice to proceed and be
completed by October 15, 1950, subject to such extensions
as might be authorized under the contract. The work was
started at or about the time required, namely, about April 4,
1950, and, as will hereinafter appear, was completed
September 30, 1950, and accepted October 9, 1950.

5. The bid schedule, copy of which was annexed to and
made part of the contract, read in part as follows:

OAR Pay names, with unit bid price written in Unit

Item words (pay name defined on page shown | bid Amount
quantity in parentheses) | price bid
. . s e s
26 (1) 57,000 | Cu. Yds. Unclassified Excavation for Borrow,
Case 1, at One dollar and twenty-nine cents
Sr DE Fe Cay PE swank batd veseevemnwan $1. 29 $73, 530

.
28 (2) 187,000 | Cu. Yd. Mi. Special Overhaul of Borrow
(1,000’ freehaul), at Thirty-two cents per

FE Cia BP nce caw bans an secnenaanses .32 59, 840
. . . . .
140 (1) 8,000 | Tons (Class F Pavement, Type F-1) Plant
Mixture, Grading A-1, at Twelve dollars |
and no cents per ton (274).................. 12.00 96, 000

|
. . . . .
|

6. The contract contained, among other provisions, the
following:

Articie 4. Changed conditions.—Should the contrac-
tor encounter, or the Government discover, during the
progress of the work, subsurface and/or latent condi-
tions at the site materially differing from those shown
on the drawings or indicated in the specifications, or

Se i els Eee Se Nee Ne Se ee ee Oe ona oS ee ee ee Pn) Lh oon see) Oe oie heel ee. ee

«
f
|
'
if
;
t

13A

unknown conditions of an unusual nature differing ma-
terially from those ordinarily encountered and generally
recognized as inhering in work of the character provided
for in the plans and specifications, the attention of the
contracting oflicer shall be called immediately to such
conditions before they are disturbed. The contracting
oflicer shall thereupon promptly investigate the condi-
tions, and if he finds that they do so materially differ
the contract shall, with the written approval of the head
of the department or his duly authorized representative
be modified to provide for any increase or decrease o
cost and/or difference in time resulting from such
conditions.

Anricie 15, Disputes—Except as otherwise specifi-
cally provided in this contract, all disputes concerning

uestions of fact arising under this contract shall be
decided by the contracting officer subject to written
appeal by the contractor within 80 days to the head of
the department concerned or his duly authorized repre-
sentative, whose decision shall be final and conclusive
upon the parties thereto. In the meantime the con-
tractor shall diligently proceed with the work as directed.

Arricte 16. Payments to contractors.—(a) Unless
otherwise provided in the specifications, partial pay-
ments will be made as the work progresses at the end of
each calendar month, or as soon herentber as practicable,
on estimates made and approved by the contracting offi-
cer. In preparing estimates the material delivered on
the site and preparatory work done may be taken into
consideration.

* * * * *

7. Specifications FP-41 issued by the Federal Works
Agency, Public Roads Administration, and incorporated in
the contract by reference, provided in part as follows:

Irem 26.—Borrow
DeEscriIPpTION

26-1.1 This item shall consist of excavating approved
material from borrow pits, when sufficient quantities of
suitable material are not available from other excava-
tions, and the disposing of all excavated material, all in
accordance with these specifications and in conformity
with the lines, grades, and dimensions shown on the plans
or as directed by the engineer.

26-1.2 Material to be used as topping for embank-
ments, as a cushion for rock embankments, or for rein-
forcing unsatisfactory subgrade soil or for backfilling

FR AE MEIER LOT TE OR 7 OE A BEON,

14A

cuts, where excavation below de is authorized, shall
be obtained under this item when satisfactory material
for the special purpose is not obtainable from other
excavations.

26-1.3 Se.ecrion or Sources.—Material for this item
shall be obtained under the terms of case 1 and/or case 2
described below.

Case 1.—When case 1 is called for in the bid schedule,
the sources of borrow material shall be indicated on the
plans and/or designated by the engineer, and the con-
tractor shall be relieved of the responsivility of obtain-
ing the right to take the material from such sources.

s

e * r *
MATERIALS

26-2.1 Material for this item shall be material se-
lected by the engineer as —— ee for the
particular embankment or backfili for which the mate-
rial is intended. The material shall be obtained from
the approved borrow sources.

MernHop oF MEASUREMENT

264.1 The yardage to be paid for shall be the num-
ber of cubic yards of material (including the yardage
of overburden stripped from pits) measured in original
position and computed by average end area method, ex-
cavated and acceptably disposed of in embankment,
backfill, or as otherwise ordered, except that when case 2
is called for in the bid schedule, the yardage of over-
burden stripped from pits (unless used as borrow ma-
terial) shall not be included in the yardage to be paid
for. The measurement shall not fechas the yardage of
any excavation performed prior to the taking of eleva-
tions and measurements of the undisturbed ground.

Basis or PAYMENT

26-5.1 The yardage, measured as provided above,
shall be paid for at the contract unit price per cubic
yard for “Unclassified Excavation for Borrow, Case 1,”
or “Unclassified Excavation for Borrow, Case 2,” as the
case may be, * * *.

Irem 28.—SpectaL OvERHAUL or Borrow

(Cubic-yard-mile basis)

DESCRIPTION

28-1.1 This item shall consist of authorized haulin
in excess of the free haul distance of any material pai

PRGA #

= aad GRADY TREE TOAD OO IRL TERETE LES AE BASLE Cee Hea ek AE ECP DARE ASAE ARTE —7

15A

for under BORROW (case 1) and disposed of as re-
quired under the various items prescribed for the dis-
posal of such material.

The free haul distance shall be 500 feet or 1,000 feet,
whichever is called for in the bid schedule. Only one
free haul distance shall be provided in any one contract.

Meruop oF MEASUREMENT

98-4.1 The number of cubic-yard-miles of special
overhaul of borrow to be paid for shall be the product
of the volume of the pina oe material, measured in
its original position, in cubic yards, by the overhaul dis-
tance in miles and fractions thereof. The overhauled
material shall be the material comprehended within the
terms of 1.1 above and hauled as directed more than
the free haul distance (as designated in the bid sched-
ule). The overhaul distance shall be the distance be-
tween the centers of volume of the overhauled material
in its original position and after placing, less the free
haul distance (as designated in the bid schedule).

+ ’ * * *

Basis or PAYMENT:

28-5.1 The cubic-yard miles, determined as provided
above, shall be paid for at the contract unit price per
cubic-yard mile for “Special Overhaul of Borrow (500
feet free haul)” or “Special Overhaul of Borrow (1,000
feet free haul),” as the case may be, which price and
payment shall constitute full compensation for all labor,
—* tools, and incidentals necessary to complete
the item.

Under general requirements in the same specifications ap-
peared the following provisions:

Art. 7.14 No Warver or Lreat Ricurs.—The Gov-
ernment shall not be precluded or estopped by any meas-
urement, estimate, or certificate made either before or
after the completion and acceptance of the work and pay-
ment therefor from showing the true amount and char-
acter of the work performed and materials furnished by
the contractor, nor from showing that any such measure-
ment, estimate, or certificate is untrue or is incorrectly
made, nor that the work or materials do not in fact con-
form to the contract. The Government shall not be
precluded or estopped, notwithstanding any such meas-
urement, estimate, or certificate and payment in accord-
ance therewith from recovering from the contractor or

16A

his sureties, or both, such damages as it may sustain by
reason of his failure to comply with the terms of the
contract. Neither the acceptance by the engineer or by
his representatives, nor wd haga for or acceptance
of the whole or any part of the work, nor any extension
of time, nor any possession taken by the engineer shall
operate as a waiver of any portion of the contract or of
any power herein reserved, or of any right to damages.
A waiver of any breach of the contract shall not be held
to be a waiver of any other or subsequent breach.

;
k

8. Special provisions which were also made a part of the
contract read as follows:

Control of Material
*

* *

Materials suitable for Borrow, Item 26 (1) may be
obtained from the following source :

Deposit B-1

1.5 Mi. from Sta. 73+00+ Steese Highway, via Steese

signs and Lazelle Road.
eposit A-1 is an existing stockpile, therefore, no
clearing or stripping will be required.

Deposit B-1 is known locally as the Birch Hill Quarry.
The Contractor will be required to secure material from
a fresh face. The cost of cleaning an approach to the
face, and the cost of any necessary clearing and strip-
ping, shall be considered as included in the unit bid
price for Itean 26 (1), Unclassified for Borrow.

If it becomes necessary to obtain such material from
other sources, allowance will be made for actual net
increased haul and will be paid for at the unit price set
forth for Item 28 (2) Cu. Yd. Mi., Special Overhaul of
Borrow, provided that the quantity shall be determined
by truck measurement at point of delivery. The dis-
tance shall not be subject to freehaul, but shall be the
actual mileage of haul occasioned by the changed loca-
tion of the material sources as compared to the haul
which would have been necessary had all the material
been acquired at the designated point. No change in
the location of the source of the material shall be made
without approval in writing by the Engineer, provided
that no reduction in the contract unit price shall be
made if consideration of the entire contract undertaking
should result in a net decrease in haul.

* *

2 ERR: IGE Miah 35 LEP

So a

17A

9, The following “general notes” appeared upon sheet 2 of
the contract plans for the highway :

1. Alignment and grades are subject to adjustment.

2. Depths of surfacing, base course and borrow are com-
pacted thicknesses.

3. Curves shall be widened and super-elevated as staked
by the Engineer.

4, Approaches shall be constructed to all existing side
roads with a minimum width for driveways of 12’.
Approach fills shall be constructed with Borrow.
Surfacing shall consist of 6’’ of Crushed Gravel Base
Course. Pipes shall be installed according to the
Pipe List on sheet 3 of these Plans.

5. An extra allowance of 1820 cu. yd. of Excavation and
5500 cu. yd. of Borrow has been included in the Esti-
mate of Quantities to cover possible stripping and
backfilling of poor material encountered during con-
struction.

6. Deposits for Borrow, Base and Surfacing are shown
on sheet No. 1 and described in the Special Provisions.

On the cross-sections for the road an estimated quantity
of approximately 51,000 cubic yards of borrow material was
shown as required. To that was added the 5,500 cubic yards
of borrow set out in note 5 above, and the total amount so
arrived at was further increased by a small yardage to make
the even figure of 57,000 cubic yards which was shown in the
bid schedule as the estimated amount of borrow required for
the project. It was also considered that the borrow material
under compaction would yield approximately 62,700 cubic
yards of embankment. The cross-sections do not show any
separate amount computed as required for driveways and
intersections. The original survey was deficient in that
it had not taken full cognizance of these driveways and
intersections.

The pipe list which appeared on sheet 3 of the contract
drawings listed 87 different pipe locations, 70 of which re-
quired the installation of pipe for the first time, 8 of which
required the extension of existing pipe, and 9 of which
required the removal of an existing pipe and the placement
of a new one. It was estimated that 1,726 linear feet of
15-inch culvert pipe, 30 linear feet of 21-inch culvert pipe,
436 linear feet of 24-inch culvert pipe, and 146 linear feet of

:
TA cece |

18A

36-inch culvert pipe would be required, of which 30 feet of
21-inch pipe, 14 feet of 24-inch pipe, and 36 feet of 36-inch
pipe were for extensions to existing culverts. In carrying
out the work, the plaintiffs installed a total of only 69 more
linear feet of pipe than were called for on the above pipe list.

10. At the time the contract involved in this proceeding
was entered into and carried out, Col. John R. Noyes was
Commissioner of Roads for Alaska. Colonel Noyes was
graduated from West Point with a degree of Bachelor of
Science in 1923, and from Cornell University with a degree
of Civil Engineering in 1926. He has been on active duty in
the Army since his graduation from West Point and most of
his work has been of an engineering nature. During the
period 1926 to 1933, he was assigned as an assistant at the
Alaska Road Commission. In 1946 he was placed on an inter-
departmental committee dealing with Alaskan affairs which
later, in 1948, indirectly led to his appointment as Commis-
sioner of Roads for Alaska.

The contracting officer was Angelo F. Ghiglione. He
received a bachelor’s degree from the University of Wash-
ington, and a master’s degree from the Massachusetts Insti-
tute of Technology—both in civil engineering. Immediately
after his graduation he started working permanently for the
Alaska Road Commission in 1933 and, except for a period of
military service when he was in the Civil Engineering Corps
of the Navy from 1941 to 1944, he has been continuously
employed by the Alaska Road Commission. He held various
positions with the Alaska Road Commission prior to 1947, in
which year he was promoted to assistant chief engineer, and
in April 1949 to chief engineer. As chief engineer he became
the contracting officer on the contract involved in this pro-
ceeding. In 1951 he was made Commissioner of Roads for
Alaska.

11. In 1948, the road-building program in Alaska expanded
greatly. Prior to 1948 appropriations had not been more
than $5,000,000 a year. Commencing in 1948, they were
about $25,000,000 a year. This was brought about by the
adoption of a program for hard surfacing as well as by the
extension of the normal work for new construction and
maintenance. The Alaska Road Commission had to be ex-

SSS

OLEAN kein Rite

rR et

—_

19A

panded very greatly in order to take care of the work. It
utilized the services of the United States Bureau of Public
Roads very largely in initiating the program. The United
States Bureau of Public Roads prepared specifications and
supervised the work in a number of cases. The Alaska Road
Commission had been building roads in Alaska since 1905,
but not paved roads. Since this work had been carried out
by its own hired crews and not by contractors, the experience
of the Alaska Road Commission with road contracts of the
type involved in this proceeding was somewhat limited.

The contract involved in this proceeding was the first con-
tract entered into by the Alaska Road Commission for the
construction of a hard-surface road in the Fairbanks district
which was to be supervised by that Commission. It had
entered into two other contracts for hard-surface roads in
that area at or about that time but their supervision was by
the Bureau of Public Roads. On June 1, 1949, the Alaska
Road Commission had executed a contract for the construc-
tion of Haynes Highway, a distance of forty miles, and on
March 15, 1950, had executed a contract for the construction
of a road three and one-half miles long at or near Anchorage.
Both were hard-surface roads and both were under the com-
plete supervision of the Alaska Road Commission. They
were outside the Fairbanks district.

12. At the time the contract was entered into, Colonel
Noyes recognized the lack of knowledge and experience of
the personnel in the Fairbanks area with contracts of the
type about to be carried out. The district engineer, Frank
Nash, had grown up with the road work in Alaska but he was
not adequately informed on a jobof that kind. The assistant
district engineer, Milton C. Zimmerman, while a well trained
engineer with some years experience in Alaska, was likewise
inexperienced on a job of this character. Because of this
situation, Colonel Noyes gave more than the usual attention
to the job. In addition, the Alaska Road Commission
obtained for resident engineer James L. Foster, a competent
engineer who had had considerable experience in work of
the character involved. Because of the weakness in the dis-
trict office, Foster was granted more authority than was
usually given to a resident engineer in carrying out a job of

20A

that kind. Since this was the Commission’s first paved road
job in the Fairbanks district and one of their first jobs of
that kind which was being carried out without assistance
from the United States Bureau of Public Roads, he (Noyes)
told Foster he was anxious that a good job be done. Noyes
also told Foster that in the event he was unable to secure
decisions from Nash, he (Foster) should communicate di-
rectly with him (Noyes). On two occasions when Williams
took up matters with Nash, Nash told Williams that Foster
was resident engineer and that matters pertaining to the job
should be taken up with him. While Foster was under
Nash and Zimmerman, most of the decisions which had to be
made on the job with respect to carrying out the work were
made by Foster without much assistance from them. How-
ever, Foster submitted his reports through the district office
and conferred with both Nash and Zimmerman from time
to time with respect to the manner in which the work should
be carried on.

13. The Birch Hill Quarry which was designated in the
contract as the source of borrow material was located approx-
imately one and one-half miles east of the eastern terminal
of the road construction on the Steese Highway. The length
of the face of the quarry on which the plaintiffs were working
was about 650 feet and it had a height of 100 to 125 feet.
When the plaintiffs started work, the quarry, which was vir-
gin material not previously excavated, lay on about a 45 per-
cent slope, that is, it rose 45 feet for each 100 feet in the face
of the slope. In taking material from the quarry, the lay of
the material was changed in substantial part to about a
60 percent slope which was the steepest at which the material
would remain in place.

The material was a micaceous schist lying in planes four
to six inches in width. The deposit was conic in shape and
the plaintiffs were working on one of the sloping faces. The
material was not a solid wall of rock, but was laminated and
had further disintegrated to some extent by the action of the
weather upon it. While the evidence does not clearly estab-
lish the extent to which voids may have existed in the virgin
material before it was disturbed in the plaintiffs’ operation,
whatever voids existed, except for broken material on the sur-

21A

face, were smaller in magnitude than the voids in the material
after it was removed by the plaintiffs. Small slides, in addi-
tion to the major slide hereinafter referred to, occurred from
time to time during the operation. ‘The excavation was per-
formed by power shovel which operated from the toe of the
slope and loaded the material into trucks. No blasting was
required or employed except two small shots to loosen the
frozen toe area at the beginning of the operation. The ma-
terial, loaded as just described, was delivered by the trucks
to the road and formed the base course for the road. It was
compacted on the road by traffic, including the plaintiffs’
vehicles, moving over it during the period of operations and
by the use of a caterpillar tractor.

14. No survey had been made of the part of Birch Hill
Quarry where the plaintiffs were required to secure the bor-
row material prior to the execution of the plaintiffs’ contract.
However, since the contract provided that borrow pit mate-
rial, referred to in the bid schedule as Item 26 (1), and spe-
cial overhaul of borrow, Item 28 (2), were to be paid for on
the basis of the number of cubic yards of material measured
in original position in the quarry and computed by the aver-
age end area method, the defendant caused a survey to be
made of the quarry immediately before the plaintiffs began
excavation work. This survey was done in large part by the
stadia method by making profiles of the face of the quarry
at 25-foot intervals from an established base line 1,000 feet
long and parallel with the main slope of the quarry. There
was a relatively flat plane at the top and extending back from
the quarry, and the profiles just referred to extended back on
this plane for distances ranging from 25 to 50 feet. Since
the face of the quarry was irregular, inaccuracies could result
by the use of the stadia method under such circumstances.
However, this method is often used and is usually found rea-
sonably accurate within a margin of error of 5 percent. The
chain method of survey which was used to a relatively small
extent takes much longer but produces results accurate within
a margin of error of 1 percent.

15. It iscustomary on contracts of this type, where the final
quantity is to be established by cross-sections, to make prog-
ress payments on the basis of a measurement of trucks, a

22A

determination of the load carried by each truck including
the heap on the truck and swell in the material, and a count
of the number of trips made by each truck. Prior to the
commencement of the hauling of borrow from the quarry,
defendant’s resident engineer, James T. Foster, and a repre-
sentative of the plaintiffs measured each of the trucks on the
job and calculated the dimensions of their gross load when
heaped full. Each of the trucks was numbered and the
number painted on its side. The volume of each truck as
measured was reduced by a swell factor to allow for voids
in the material in the trucks as compared with the material
in its undisturbed state in the quarry. A somewhat larger
swell factor was used in the smaller trucks because of the
greater compaction of the load in a large truck, the greater
likelihood of fine material filling voids that might arise dur-
ing loading, and the fact that the cab on the larger truck
held a larger heap at that end. However, that difference in
the factor on the smaller trucks became of relative unim-
portance on the job for the reason that the so-called smaller
trucks, seven cubic yards in capacity or less, were used for
only a short time during the operations.

The yardage for each truck, adjusted in the manner indi-
cated above to represent yardage in place, was recorded
against the number of each truck. Thereafter, throughout
the course of the job, a representative of the resident en-
gineer’s office checked each truck that left the borrow pit and
listed its number, yardage, and time of departure. Another
inspector from the resident engineer’s office on the job noted
the time of arrival of each truck, yardage, and the place where
delivered. A representative of the plaintiffs also checked
yardage and placement of the material on the road. These
three reports on yardage were reconciled each day and the
resident engineer furnished to the plaintiffs a weekly report
on the yardage hauled and the yard mile tabulation based
upon the method of calculation just described. Monthly
progress payments were made to the plaintiffs on the basis
of these tabulations. Likewise the plaintiffs paid their
hauling subcontractors on the same basis of calculation of
yardage.

16. As shown in finding 14, the base line of the quarry for
the survey made by defendant was 1,000 feet long and par-

8 RCIA NIE AISNE SL OAR te NOE EE Y , : vom.

23A

allel with the main slope of the quarry. The plaintiffs’
operations in the quarry covered only approximately 650
feet, that is, from station 3+50 to station 10+00. The toe
of the slope at station 3+50, which was the eastern limit
of the plaintiffs’ operations, commenced about 90 feet back
from the base line and the toe of the slope at other points
between station 3+50 and station 10+00 varied from that
distance back of the base line to a close proximity to the
base line at stations 8+25 and 8+75 and approximately 50
feet at station 10+00. The power shovel operated at the
toe of the slope and toward the steep embankment of the
quarry, that is, in a northerly direction. Approximately 92
percent of the material excavated by the plaintiffs during
their period of operations came from between stations 6+ 50
and 9+ 50.

17. Prior to May 11, 1950, the plaintiffs had excavated and
moved from the quarry 34,596 cubic yards of material com-
puted on the truck measurement basis heretofore described.
On May 11, 1950, a large slide occurred at the site where
excavation work was being carried on by the plaintiffs in
the quarry—partially burying the shovel and killing the
shovel operator. At the time of the slide, the power shovel
was operating about in the area of station 7+00 to station
8+50, that is, from 150 to 300 feet from the western end of
the borrow area. A large amount of material moved down-
ward and outward toward the base line where the plaintiffs
were operating. The slide covered approximately 500 feet
along the face of the slope encompassing the area about
between stations 4+75 to 10+00. A large amount of mate-
rial moved as a result of the slide though no accurate
determination of the quantity can be made from the evidence
in the record nor was any attempt made to determine the
extent of the slide when it occurred. A witness for defendant
estimated that not more than 30,000 to 50,000 cubic yards
of material were involved in the slide, whereas witnesses
for the plaintiffs estimated from 200,000 to 400,000 cubic
yards. Cracks, fissures, and crevasses were opened up north
of the face of the slope and on the slope itself. The biggest i
crevasse was immediately above the slide area and was about Hy
50 feet along, 10 feet wide, and at least 20 feet deep. At
least some of the cracks, fissures or crevasses were outside

838960—55———4

iF
:
‘
Hd
Pd
:
4
i
&
é
¥
ie
;
f

A RAGA 2 HE ESO EEE

POI PET FAN EMER ICA

al atid

26A

21. The work on the contract involved in this proceeding
was completed on September 30 and formally accepted by
the Alaska Road Commission on October 9, 1950. As here-
tofore shown, the work under Item 26 (1), Unclassified Ex-
cavation for Borrow, was completed on or shortly after June
30, 1950.

Foster remained on the job as resident engineer until about
September 16, 1950, at which time, because of his own illness
or illness in his family or some other reason, he returned to
California and did not thereafter return to his job in Alaska.
At the time he left, the Alaska Road Commission expected
that he would return within a few days and his job was not
filled on a permanent basis until some months later when
it appeared that he would not return to Alaska. No one else
connected with the Alaska Road Commission was as familiar
with the work as Foster, and his absence from the job made
it more difficult for the Alaska Road Commission to prepare
the final estimates and ultimately deal with the controversies
involved in this proceeding. However, during the period
July to September, the greater part of which time Foster
was on the job, the survey referred to in finding 22 was
made. What connection Foster had with this final survey
does not definitely appear, though in his weekly reports for
July 23 and August 6, 1950, there are notations to the effect
that the survey was being made.

22. Under the average end area method provided in the
contract for computing the amount of borrow material re-
moved, it was contemplated that a survey would be made of
the quarry after the excavation was completed for compari-
son with the original survey. The excavation was completed
about June 30, 1950, and during the period July, August, and
September, 1950, the office of the Alaska Road Commission
at Fairbanks caused such a survey to be made. The same
base line was used as in the original survey and cross-sections
were prepared, using the same stations as in the original
survey, that is, stations 25 feet apart. Since the original
survey did not cover the entire area from which material
had slid into the quarry, the original profiles were extended
by interpolations, under recognized engineering procedure,
to cover certain areas not covered by the original survey.

7 —

-
BEE APA SRP RE # WLI

274A

The use of interpolations is subject to certain inaccuracies
but usually provides a reasonable degree of accuracy.
The interval between the original survey and the final
survey as plotted was used as a basis for computing the ma-
terial removed from the quarry. No allowance was made
for swell or voids in the quarry which may have been created
in the material remaining in the quarry by reason of the slide.
That computation showed the total amount of borrow ma-
terial excavated as 68,888.32 cubic yards and the number of
cubic-yard miles of special overhaul for borrow as 202,582.
On that basis the final estimate was prepared by the resident
engineer and approved by the district office of the Alaska
Road Commission. This estimate was a reduction in the
borrow material item from 99,592 cubic yards, as reported on
the truck measurement basis, to 68,888.52, that is, a reduction
of 30,703.68 cubic yards which, at the contract price of $1.29
per cubic yard, amounted to a reduction in the amount to be
paid to the plaintiffs of $39,607.75. Similarly on the over-
haul item, it meant a reduction from 311,570 cubic-yard
miles to 202,532, that is, a reduction of 109,038 which, at 32
cents per cubic-yard mile, amounted to a reduction in the

amount to be paid to the plaintiffs of $34,892.16.

23. In computing the final yardage of borrow material
which had been removed from the quarry by the use of the
two surveys, 27 cross-sections taken 25 feet apart were used,
that is, from station 3+950 to station 10+00 which was
the area where the excavation was carried out. Four of
these sections were found wholly negative and six others
partly negative. A negative section is one in which the final
ground is above the original ground, that is, more material
than there was at the start of the excavation. A partly nega-
tive section is where some portion of the final ground is above
the original ground. The defendant deducted yardage to the
extent of the negative and partly negative sections. The
following tabulation shows the amount of material com-
puted for each section, including the sections shown as nega-
tive or partially negative:

28A

Btation Cubic yards
3-+50 653. 7
38+75 1, 306.9
4+00 1,519.9
4425 1, 133.3

°4+50 618.5
Partially Negative___ 4+75 145. 4
TG oi ita tthe stats wons oe a ie ene 5+00 —12.5
Partially Negative___ 5425 —25.5
Negative__- 5+50 —31.5
Partially Negative____ = meee 5+75 157.4
POSHGliy NGGRIVG. 36s n oe cansimenenees 6+00 —29. 4
Negative i este ean anise arian 6425 417.1
Partinity NGGRUV6. |

RRA SN CA

48A

to the Flood Soils Laboratory for analysis, and the table
of soils characteristics in the contract drawings was appar-
ently based upon the laboratory report. This fact was un-
known to plaintiffs. The defendant did not deliberately
misrepresent the materials it thought would be encountered
or hold back any information it had from plaintiffs.

There was a duty on the part of defendant, if it made bor-
ings, to fully disclose such facts as were found. Ranieri y,
United States, 96 C. Cls. 494, 506. This it did, and we can
find no reason to hold that the defendant misrepresented
the facts to such an extent as to cause a breach of contract
on its part.

The second, third, and fourth issues presented by this
claim are for the purposes of this opinion grouped.

The borings and data made and furnished by defendant
were inadequate, and plaintiffs encountered shale in locations
and amounts seriously in excess of those indicated by the
drawings. In these respects the contract drawings were not
approximately correct. Plaintiff Daugherty’s reasonably
careful inspection of the site gave no indication to him that
he would encounter materials any different from those repre-
sented on the contract drawings.

The total quantity of excavated materials moved was
2,056,262 cubic yards.

In July 1943 plaintiff Daugherty encountered hard shale
and concluded that it could best be removed by breaking it
up with a rooter. A rooter is a heavy blade which projects
into the ground and operates on the principle of a plow.
Daugherty’s rooter had three teeth, but after experimenta-
tion it was found that in some areas the hard shale could more
easily be rooted by removing two of the teeth, thus giving
increased power to the operation. The rooter was powered
by a crawler-type tractor having 110 drawbar horsepower.
The hard shale could not have been removed by pans used in
taking out clay without first rooting it. Considerable quan-
tities of soft shale were also encountered. This was “grad-
ing” and was handled with the same equipment, pans, and
tractors as used on dirt.

The defendant classified the material, now claimed by the
plaintiffs to have been hard shale and rock, as “grading” in
each of the 1943 monthly estimates, and plaintiff Daugherty

494

was paid upon that basis. Daugherty did, however, protest
orally in September 1943 to the resident engineer about such
payment. The following month in a letter to the engineer
in charge of design and construction, he stated that 200,000
cubic yards of hard shale had been encountered slowing
operations but did not claim a changed condition for purposes
of reclassification or payment. Previously Daugherty’s
engineer and two successive superintendents made strong
oral representations about a changed condition to defend-
ant’s resident engineer and his assistants and asked that pay-
ment be made for rock. This was refused upon the basis that
it was being rooted and therefore was grading within the
contract classifications. Plaintiffs’ engineer also told the
resident engineer that he was going to cross section the hard
materials and make claims for additional compensation
therefor. The resident engineer was requested to cross sec-
tion the materials but declined to do so. Plantiffs requested
the resident engineer to have representatives present while
plaintiffs took elevations, but he did not do so. The
resident engineer did not report to the contracting officer the
representations made by plaintiff Daugherty about the
changed conditions encountered until March 30, 1944. The
first such claim was made by the contractor in writing on
February 4, 1944, after counsel had been retained and was
for 193,000 cubic yards of rock alleged to have been excavated
in 1943. This claim was denied February 10, 1944.

Plaintiff Daugherty had not excavated a shale bank near
the runway intersection and when the work was resumed
in 1944 the cosureties contended that this shale constituted
rock within the contract definition. The pertinent specifi-
cations provided as follows:

3.1 General. * * *

All material encountered shall be considered as unclas-
sified excavation unless otherwise specified. The Con-
tractor shall inform and satisfy himself as to the
character, quantity and distribution of all material to be
excavated. No payment will be made for any excavated
material which is used for purposes other than those

designated, * * *
* * * * e

3.3-b Classification of Excavation. fy een

83A

equipment and supplies required for extensive drilling and
blasting.

39. Plaintiffs’ records are not sufficiently complete to make

sible an accurate audit of actual costs. Nevertheless, the

defendant attempted a calculation involving both audits of
records and estimates, concerning costs for excavation which,
for the total quantity excavated, resulted in a unit cost of
38.9 cents per cubic yard. If certain items which the de-
fendant disallowed and which are claimed in this suit are
included, the unit cost would appear to be about 44.56 cents
per cubic yard for excavation. Approximate over-all cost at
the rate of 39 cents per cubic yard was in no small measure
due to plaintiffs’ slack production, heretofore referred to and
which eventuated in the termination of his contract rights.

In the completion of the project, the co-sureties expended
the sum of $1,584,942.27, of which $487,882.90 was a loss.
The co-sureties have paid up to December 31, 1951, a total
of $493,991.64, which is the sum claimed by them of any
judgment rendered herein.

40. Plaintiffs filed a claim for rock and shale excavation
on February 17, 1945. The contracting officer denied the
claim on June 4, 1945, stating, in part, as follows:

In comparing the areas in which you claim to have en-
countered rock with the information shown on the
monthly progress reports, it is found that considerable
areas in which this more difficult excavation is claimed
to have been performed were excavated during the 1943
season. There is not sufficient evidence to give con-
sideration to any part of the claim bearing on the work
in 1943. From a daily inspection of the performance,
the Government did not at any time consider that the
conditions being encountered differed materially from
those shown on the plan. The evidence on file does not
indicate that the contractor was of the different opinion
as to the class of the material being excavated. While
on several occasions letters were directed to the Gov-
ernment’s project engineer concerning a controversy in
the interpretation of the specifications, in no instance
did the contractor take exception to the soil classifica-
tions as indicated by the plans and specifications. It
was not until February 4, 1944, several months after
his right to proceed had been terminated, that the prime
contractor came forth with a claim for the excavation
of rock. In view of his prior tacit acceptance of the

84A

terms of the contract, the accuracy of the claimed diffi-
culties could not at this late date be determined. If the
contractor intended to claim additional compensation,
these alleged changed conditions should have been made
a matter of record before these conditions were dis-
turbed as contemplated by the contract so that an in-
vestigation could then and there have been made.

The fact that the a a. officer was deprived of his
prerogative of examining the conditions prevents the
acceptance of your argument that the character of the
soil was entirely different from that represented by the
plans. After the receipt of the letter of February 4,
1944, and after work was resumed in 1944, an investi-
gation of the soil conditions was instituted so that it
could be determined whether, in the areas remaining to
be excavated during the 1944 season, the completing
sureties would encounter material falling within the
classification for rock in the specifications. As you are
aware, representatives of this office were present on
May 19 and 20, 1944, for an on-the-job demonstration
of the difficulties attendant to the prosecution of this
work. The primary purpose of this demonstration was
to determine whether the soil remaining to be excavated
would fall under the classification for grading or rock
excavation. * * *

For the purpose of this demonstration you provided a
three-fourths cubic yard power shovel and performed
some excavation in the face of a bank of shale which had
not previously been disturbed. The results of this show-
ing did not prove that the material encountered met the
provisions of the specifications with respect to rock exca-
vation since it was possible to remove the materials with-
out undue difficulty. Insofar as is known to this office
all of the material for which payment has been made
under item 1.21 of the contract was removed with equip-
ment which is generally used for unclassified excavation,
and with the exception of 689 cubie vards of rock
removed from a channel! 380 feet left of the centerline at
station 10+00 on the NW.-SE, runway, blasting was not
resorted to in any of the grading operations. Your
claim for compensation for the excavation of rock over
and above the quantity of 689 cubic yards for which pay-
ment has been made is, therefore, denied.

The statements made concerning your claims for rock
excavation in the areas graded during 1943 apply as well
to your claim of 65 cents per cubie yard for excavating
423.168 cubic yards of shale. Apparently the bulk of the
material you claim as shale encountered during 1944
construction was classified on drawings Nos, 3-X-1276-

85A

9A and 8-X-1276-9B as hard impervious silty clay and
occurred above the elevations whan shale was shown.
This material, to the knowledge of this office was all
excavated with ordinary grading equipment without
greater difficulty than should have been anticipated from
an analysis of the specifications and an investigation of
local conditions. The conditions encountered were
peculiar to the locality and were not so materially dif-
ferent from those shown on the plans as to justify a
further allowance for excavation.

41. Plaintitfs appealed to the head of the department who,
on August 22, 1945, reviewed the decision of the contracting
officer and denied the claim stating, in part, as follows:

On the basis of the evidence developed and after careful
consideration of the statements contained in your appeal,
I find that the decisions rendered by the contracting
oflicer in this case were proper and must therefore be
sustained. Accordingly, it is hereby determined that
there is no basis for the payment of any additional com-
ensation in connection with any item of your claim.
tem 1 of your claim deals with the excavation of rock
and shale and is based on your contention that the plans
and drawings forming a part of the contract did not
accurately describe the conditions actually encountered.
Notwithstanding the merit of your argument, I do not
believe that such contention has any bearing on the mat-
wane. * * *
* * * the contract provides for two types of excava-
tion—unclassified excavation at 25 cents per cubic yard,
and rock excavation at $1.35 per cubic yard. It is mu-
tually agreed that no drilling or blasting was resorted
to in performing the excavation with the exception of
689 cubic yards for which you have been or will be paid
at the contract price of $1.35 per cubic yard.

In effect, your argument with respect to this item of
the claim attempts to set forth a third classification for
excavation to provide for an intermediate price between
that provided for unclassified excavation and that pro-
vided for rock excavation to take care of the material
which you claim was removed under great difliculty
both in time and expense and delay in progress, although
such material did not require drilling or blasting.

I can see no basis for such a revision of the contract.
The contract is clear and specific with respect to the two
types of excavation and inasmuch as the material re-
moved did not fall within the definition of “Rock
Excavation” as set forth by the contract, there is no

ARE 4

86A

authority for classifying such material as rock or for
paying for its removal at any price in excess of the 9§
cents per cubic yard specified by the contract for
unclassified excavation.

42. When the contracting officer and the head of the de
partment denied and failed to recognize a changed condition
as described in these findings where plaintiff encountered
216,755 cubic yards of hard shale which was not indicated
in the borings and contract drawings, and which was more
difficult of removal than grading, and when said officers
failed to make an equitable adjustment for removal thereof,
the determination was arbitrary and was not supported by
substantial evidence.

DEFENDANT'S COUNTERCLAIM

43. Daugherty rented equipment and received property
from the Maxon Construction Company, becoming indebted
thereby in the sum of $875.32. The Maxon Construction
Company assigned its claim to defendant. Daugherty ig
indebted to defendant in the sum of $875.32.

CONCLUSION OF LAW*

Upon the foregoing findings of fact, which are made a part
of the judgment herein, the court concludes that as a matter
of law plaintiffs General Casualty Company of America and
Central Surety and Insurance Corporation are entitled to
recover, and it is therefore adjudged and ordered that they
recover of and from the United States as reimbursement for
sums expended for and in behalf of N. EK. Daugherty, d/b/a
N. E. Daugherty Construction Company, the sum of
$91,039.91 less $875.52, representing defendant’s counter-
claim, making a total of ninety thousand one hundred sixty-
four dollars and fifty-nine cents ($90,164.59).

*As amended by order of the court dated February 16, 1955.

4 S GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE: 1988

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386417_2639%3A2. Public record. Not legal advice.
