# Appendix — NLRB v. Textile Workers

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386414_0077%3A03

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Appendix
- **Published:** January 1, 1972
- **Citation:** 409 U.S. 213

## Text

, KOFZWIDOS

: wie ty iy Pewgs RS g*. +3 ‘ers
Sie HiGfS 56 ficou (TTT LOTIT BIOGZ Hollis

vr
‘
i

P Ver a 7A i ie :
£4.10 vata. .4 VVAaA

-?

1 ‘ .* : r
{34% ft “69 LSD SO AL

Beggs 30, SOLIS FRO LIS

SOBIOS an

S he ly bore ives fa
iow oe A
iz a frit bare Gite RENDIX
ae af} ti £f i0%S Yor. f Appeals
fosTio ii Bow. rigid: Bint ei taad
= Bee! BE -rodrivat

« 7a | mrtryct
eae Sag a Aiea Usrox
Scglheergpetrd hose eno; ‘APEL-CHO; RESPONDENT

“Ye irtet eid’ hl

SeiwooTenii jwoitesr off ; Boessis

ON. APPIEGATION FOR PORCH. OF. ax ORDRR, or THR
tiga) ori} PATIONAL LABOR, RELATIONS BRABR irae
rie Hite siew asta} Cases saskeuves titi

64 ti ocintug ne
ic ahs: 7 Ho vil st Ho 3 mn ai Wade 3 eta. ts
poi ei nope 29, mine ree ee
arom, Circuit Judge.’ ya case. ‘comes ee
A ion..for enforcement of; a, ;
respondent,

(babi ;
(1) to restrain or coerce (A) Sse anny mya fies liga
(1a)

2a

when it sought judicial enforcement of fines again!
thirty-one union members who, during the course of
a lawful, union-authorized strike, resigned from the
union and crossed thepicket;tine,to return to work,
The union represents the production and mainte.
nance @mplayees? df!'the+Interiationdl: Paper Box
Machine Companjy-izi’ Nashitia,s Mew: Hampshire. The
collective bargaining agreement which was in effect
between September 20, 1965, and September 20, 1968,
included a “mainteltee ‘of? “membership clause,”
which Re eisedlite lo Tees who belonged to the
unidn 6 F50:"4 or’ joined’ aee” the
onal ice would remain members i in good stand-
ing for-the :duYation “off the -eohtract!. Each: ‘employee
ccpleinastektlin dnaieiditn was, requined to sign
a “dues check-off” authorization form. This form ex-
pressly made the check-off atithorization irrevocable

éxcept diiring specified Annual ten-day pericds. |
Shortly before the ‘expiration area collective bar-
gaining agreement, Se Seg ey were still in

d in section 7 of this title:.. Provided, That
ein tg a cto
tion to ye sscetead its o haa to the acquisition or

rey Pn chanarty $s Hos ) garaciol

Maid re re

any or all ‘of such activities

: helt Piero tata cy of
this title.” (Emphasis added)

3 igo 11974 aly rt LGD Te ge jg ifr Yen. rian tea’:

¥ 3a

found Ap] racti yall the. members’
pre ve. re ig st one mem-

w days bef ore oe Pant
mn
‘the eee
aber. racioe Palla
“that jf heal fay il $8 5
‘irialovs hee

ibership.,.Th i.e thereupon pre
Aye a about eae — examiner’s deci-

or: ti ember that
2 : ne Fate toe Saieest wt iH e

ag ty ;
ou ele hited

s Wk rest ~

7 fe ne he union

8 i ‘the New .

ref “ Horn strik:
s ng ” ny '

Bie, a

Pye pra Shei add to svat sti

State court
hy..she.qnion, 40, ,seepver. money, advanced -to,.theeg: empleyees
during: the tzike,did ot rviolate: $ 8(b) (4)44)--Ta many in;

stances, the; union had paid: premigms to keep aon employes’ arene
ineuremee policies current. during: the. strike, and
scnivetaencnak sane 200 ste tags his bay ivctov

FREED SAY ETE oe aE Ce REECE RUE ete draw RR tee arn ae

Set Cua pats

@ 5a
= ip is ‘
Lie therefore a ase of first impression before. this

3
Wy
a ET"
‘ 3 ae 7% ie is 1 ¢ .
Fe ee t its inis ‘ } aS os Riot
eResa .
i aA OED igi £! ‘y= takes z
j i 3 ri ;
4 a

Tonmem M. Kamamous, Bog, ax oxo
Ptocmior «ae a? Pe

a Jane 4 4, 1900, Trial- Rxaminer Milton Janus
‘his Decision: in: the: above-entitled Cage 1-CB-

l4a

meaning of the National Labor Relations Act, as
amended, and recommending that the complaint be
dismissed in its PK ne forth in the attached
Trial bye Thereafter, the General
1 filed- Sada Oe Toe hen ae
cision and a brief in ‘support thereof. The Respondent
filed an answering brief.

-¢ On} Daly: 31969, the General Qounsel filed a motion
with: the ‘Board :to! reopen the reeerd in) Case’ 1-CB-
1460 (1-2), alleging that the Union had .undertaken to
implement itagthreat to fine the Charging Parties,
which the Trial Examiner found was not violative of
the Act, by filing formal charges against, Radziewicz
and Kimball fof crossing its picket line at their place
of employment ‘at mational Paper Box Machine
Company (herein called the Company,). The Respond-
ent filed a brief in opposition to the General Coun-.
sel’s motion. On ae es go mdand the Board issued an

Order grant Counsel’s , otion to re-
open ‘the ‘re st fonda ‘the: to the
Trial dinar ses Sa ose ‘Of permitting

the parties to present evidence, of conduct occurring
aftir the dose oF the kentitg and bearing directly

upon the conduct alleged im the complaint.”

In the interim, on June 24 and ber 3, 1969,
mene eh ts gm thio Oase1_CB—
1504(1—4) and 3 on the basis of
which a consolida zt pant eit ‘with notice of hear-
ing, was issued against ‘tia Galenee October 20, 1969.
The complaint alleged that the Union violated Section
pen snare Boe ere by threatuiiitig to fine!- impos-
dhig) fines," dni desking judicial ‘enforcement: fof such
fined azadinst certain nathed 'énipidyees of ithe Company
‘whic tisd resigned from the! Union ‘and had°retarhed to

work during the. Union's. strike against the. Company.
On November 10, = pursuant to motion made by

Aba

| Counsel, the Trial Examiner pe saan
hese cases and, on N oyember 20, 1969,
ng ‘the entire consolidated .

. adi ng g, finding that t
h and was engaging in certain unfair labor Grete
within the meaning of the National Labor Relations
as amended, and recommending that it cease and
s' _ therefrom as set forth in the attached Trial
miner’s Supplemental Decision. Thereafter, the
p ondent filed sition at's to the Trial Examiner’

3 5 Dein the ¢
pos record in 1

Peianiner found, and we ‘agree. that the
A: Parties, es, Having” hegre resign. from
the ‘Uition Chetore they crossed its picket: line at their
place of employment, were not subject to the Tnidh’s

4 ‘ " beipline for their: ion m éondet. The Trial
2 Pkarniner oareagrndih

tx 4

"a

nis ‘from té Unidn ‘and by seeking judi-
uforcement Of such filies, Violated Section Bob)
a Nitta ies at dinig, "however, eae rely

Pera iat sy C8 Mi bot: my ERLE 13199 ITF “ert!

TCH Lek! HALL beg? SORDER 6 «

Finest lay the’

‘ &% Sige) t hy. ,
orders that the Res My ent, Gr
f ¢. ger
: het & at Peg Dts tas
6 ES suse AG gts in
Oat of the, Ts ; 3
7! MESSE

he vely 5
5 Atk as, futne tie ek dusuriolius

fe mir nt Hn ner rn of uM
shits Weve ABO (The Bong =

ee

17a

Reimburse or refund to any employees named
pendix A who may have paid fines under the
nstances ibed . in paragraph 1(a) of the

f said fines plus interest
60! the: ‘percent per annum.” *

% In footnote 8 of the Trial Examiner’s Supple-

mtal Decision, substitute “20"’ for “10” days.
Substitute the ‘attached Appendix B for the Trial

xa aes ers Appendix B.

Dated, Washington, D.C. -
“(geaL) ~Epwarp B. Mitr, Chairman
_ Howarp Jenxins, Ir., Member

N. ATIONAL LaBor RELATIONS Boarp

“reasons stated. in ™my ‘separate opinion in
fer Lodge No. 405, International Association of
R cham sts and Aerospace Workers, AFL-CIO (The
Boein 7‘ Company), 18 NLRB: No. 23, 1 would ‘find |
“BM violation of Section 8(b)(1)(A) of the Act in these’
Aes and ould dismiss ‘the complaint in its entire ty.
a GERALD A. Brown, Member,
Gs» Nasvonat Lanon Retamjows, Boar,
or iis No. 40b, Ynlernational Assbelasioy op ig!
aud Masia Workers, AFL-CIO (The y Srna
), supra;fn. Bo | Hod net

4 >
3 ~~ ff
2
”, 1a

i 2 eM ,

POSTED BY ORDER OF THE: (NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS
BOARD, AN AGENCY OF THB UNITED STATPS GOVERN MENT

WE WILL NOT fine former members of this
Union for crossing our picket lines at International
Paper Box, Machine Company after they have re-
signed from the Union, nor will we try to collect such
fines by suing theni in the courts.

WE WILL: NOT restrain: or coerce our former
members in the’ exercise of rights-guaranteed to them
byi Seetion 7 ofthe National Lbor Relations Act, a
amended.

WE WHILE: trescina. the pars we ah imposed
againgti the perséns aiied télow, change our ‘records.
tovsliowi that we have rescinded tliese-fines, and take:
allnecessary action ‘in the courts. of New ‘Hampshire
to Meer = give up. all diniage for! collection of
sucks fins. see ROA FO astnaD

19a ° :
Robert Roy
Zennie Runowicz
Alfred Theriault

fines they. may have paid to us for working
ind our picket line at
hine Company plus interest at the rate of 6 per-

Granite Stare: Jour Boarp, Textie
..,,4 WORKERS UNIon or America, Loca 1029,

Mhis is an official notice and must not be defaced
anyone) 4 ie

is notice must remain posted for 60 consecutive

this notice or compliance
directed to the Board’s
Poe 2th Fid6r Tolm F Kennedy Federal Building
Sembridge & New Sudbury §

usetis 02203, Telephone 617-223-3330,

United Stites of America
_BErore THE ‘Nariowan Lazos RELATIons Boarp
' DIVISION OF TRIAL EXAMINERS
Washington, D.C.
Case. No. 1-0B-14600-1-2

Geanrre Stare Jomt Boarp, Texriz Worxers
Union OF Amentoa, Locat 1029, AFL-CIO (Intzr-
NATIONAL Paper Box Macuine CoMPANY)

and Loh ey

“Faux Rapamwice, Manon K. Krai 1,

SSRIDU AIR

| “Thomas P. Rennety, ties. for the, General Counsel.
foaegy Reapennne Teast gee iet Be

Duar Beane Dacrios
AE teak eto fed:

"STATEMENT. OF THE cas ot

MILTON JANUS, Trial Hecpninnes Viteees were
filed by Felix Radziewicz and Maurice K. Kimball II,
on December 9, 1968, against Granite State Joint
Board, Textile Workers Union of America, Local 1029,
AFL-CIO, referred to hereafter as the Respondent
or.the Union. A complaint based thereon was issued
by the Regional Director for Region 1 on January 29,
1969, and an amendment thereto on February 12. The

(200) /

2la

mint, as amended, alleges that the Union violated
m 6(b)(1)(A)’ of the Act’ by ‘threatening em-
sof International Paper Box Machine Com-
‘who ‘were claiming to be no longér members
the Union with exéessive fines if ‘they failed to
port its strike against the Company and/or at-
mpted to resign from the Union, and by threatening
nployees with bodily harm and property damage if
' failed to support its strike,’ Respondent’s answer
es. the material allegations of the complaint.

I conducted a hearing in this matter at Nashua,
-New Hampshire, on March 25, 1969. Briefs have been
“received from the General Counsel and the Union, and
“have been fully considered.

* Upon the entire record in the ease, and from my
4ebservation of the witnesses and their demeanor, I
ake the following:

FINDINGS OF FACTS

I, JURISDICTIONAL FACTS

+, International Paper Box Machine Company is a
New Hampshire corporation with its principal place
of business at Nashua, N.H., where it is engaged in
Phe. manufacture and sale of automatic paper box
| Making and gluing machines. During a representative
42-month period preceding the issuance of this com-
yplaint, the Company received material valued in ex-
® 4The pertinent language of the statute reads as follows:
“Sec. 8(b). It shall be an unfaif labor practice for a labor
_ PePeAnization or its agents—
§ (1) to. restrain or coerce (A) employees in the exercise of
‘@the rights guaranteed in section 7: Provided, that this para-
i graph shall not impair the right of a labor organization to
@ prescribe its own rules with respect to the acquisition or reten-

22a

‘,cese of $50,000; from points: directly outside New
_ Hampshire, and. shipped products directly: to. points
outside that,State valued in. excess of $50,000. I find
that.the.Company is an employer. engaged in com-
meree within:the meaning of the Act.

wu, THE LABOR ORGANIZATION INVOLVED

Granite State Joint Board, Textile Workers Union
of America, Local 1029, AFL-CIO, admits, and I find,

that ‘it is a labor organization within the meaning of
Section 2(5) of the Act. ©

Ill. THE ALLEGED UNFAIR LABOR PRACTICES
The Factual Background

The Union has fepresented the production and
maintenance employees of the Company for more than
20 years. Pursuant to a strike vote, the employees
went on strike September 20, 1968, over economic
issues upon the expiration of the latest agreement.
The strike was still current in late March 1969, when
this hearing was held. Although the plant remained
open, the only employees at work were supervisors,
_ Clerical, office and technical employees, and 3 or 4 em-
ployees in the bargaining unit who were not union
members. About 160 employees remained on strike,
honoring a token picket line which kept the main gate
of the plant undersurveillance. = ae

The. motion to strike the Company was voted on at
a duly called meeting of union members the Saturday
before expiration of the contract. Practically all the
‘members were in attendance, and they assented to the
strike by a standing vote, with only one member
dissenting. The following Saturday, a day or two after
the inception of the wis snotber union meeting was

23a

to discuss organization and tactics. A rank-and-
uber proposed a motion that anyone aiding or
the Company or its officials during the strike
Bubject to a $2000 fine. The motion was adopted
I in VUBSLY without debate.

adziewicz and Kimball decided independently in
mber that’they would abandon the strike and re-
firm to work for the Company. Knowing of the
Mnion’s vote that members who aided the Company
“dur each believed

~at the attempt to resign, that they were not familiar
With the provisions and procedures they were required
to adhere to when they chose to become members, and
“that they were still considered to be members in good
“gtandi required to abide by the Union’s rules and
: tions. Further, Pitarys’ letters went on to say,
Bee | the event you have any thought that your action

‘Two. witnesses for the Respondent, Pitarys, a vice-president
the International Union and manager of the Granite State
“Somt Board, and Arel, who was recording secretary of Local
9 in September 1968, testified that the motion as offered ‘and
pted was to the effect that the fine be $2000 or any amount
ermined by the Union. The official minutes of the meeting,
7 Rept by Arel, were not offered by Respondent. I note, more-
‘Gover, that the letters of Pitarys to Radziewicz_ and Kimball
‘a@ention only a $2000 fine, referring neither to the possibility
BF a larger or a smaller fine. I shall consider, in my later dis-
Geeion, that the amount of the fine which Radziewicz and
Genball thought the Union could impose on them was a flat

As

sone 770 from your obligation. asa union member,
or that, the right to cross. the picket, lines, let
aution }, that, you will be subject to a. fine of
mn Pare AID Fe Tog

i | te-his letter cautioning him
a. $2000 fine, Radziewiez decided not to work
behind the pieket line.’ The Union has taken no action
Radziewiez or Kimball by way of. charges or

prossotings for the purpose of fining them or impos-
any other type of discipline. It is clear that Kim-

i - agreement which expired Septem-
ber 20, 1968, had provided that employees who were
union members on its'effective date 3 years earlier, or
Wwhio joined the Union during its term, were to remain
members in good standing. The agreement had also
abide tha the Company. would deduct union dues

wz also testified that Pitarys threatened him in one of
PP apeomaa et fro ham phere meme
ing day, the pickets would be watching for him, and that Pitary
would not sible for what might be done to him or to his
car. Pit. a making any threat of physical harm or
hinge 9 adsiowis. I credit Pity

25a

intention to join by signing an application for
abership .which included an authorization to the
apany to deduct his initiation fees and dues. The
mabined application for membership and check-off

-

I, the undersigned hereby accept membership
in Textile Workers’ Union of America, AFL-
CIO, and do hereby authorize and direct

INTERNATIONAL PAPER BOX MA-
CHINE COMPANY, NASHUA which is my
employer, to deduct from my wages the mem-
bership dues including initiation fees, in the
amount fixed pursuant to the Constitution and

suant to the provisions of any current or future
collective agreement.

This authorization shall remain in effect until

revoked by me and shall be irrevocable for a

period of one year from the date hereof or until

the termination date of any applicable collec-

ae. tive agreement, whichever occurs sooner ; ‘un-

_* ‘less I revoke it by sending written notices to

i my Employer and the Local Union by regis-

tered mail, only during a period of ten days im-

> mediately Succeeding the termination date of

any applicable collective agreement or yearly

Period, it shall be automatically renewed as an

irrevocable checkoff from year to year, until

- duly revoked as herein provided.

26a

‘The eombined application and dues check-off au.
thorization card does not set out a procedure by which
& union member may resign. It does, of course, permit
revocation of the dues. check-off authorization within
the time periods specified in Sec. 302(c)(4) of the
Labor Management Relations Act, as amended, but
the language provides for no more than that—it is
completely silent on when or if the Union will recog-
nize a resignation as effective.‘ The authorization card
thereby mirrors what the constitutions and by-laws
of the Textile Workers Union of America, the Granite
State Joint Board, and Local 1029 already provide
for—that a member may not voluntarily withdraw
from the Union except by leaving the industry, in
which case he may obtain a withdrawal card. Death,
presumably, provides the only other means of exit
from the Union. |

The Union also attempted to show that Kimball had
in effect revoked his letter of resignation by accepting
a. Thanksgiving turkey from it after his letter to the
Union. The evidence as to whether Kimball accepted
one of the Union’s turkeys is unclear, but even if he
had, I would not consider it to be a meaningful retrac-
tion of his attempt to resign.

Analysis and Conclusions

The Supreme Court held in N.L.R.B. v. Allis-
Chalmers Manufacturing Company, 388 U.S. 175, 87

* Under the maintenance of membership provision of the last
i a union member who had revoked his check-

his anniversary of acquiring membership
Shed to remain a member in good standing
of the agreement. Failure to

payment, of his union dues could result

B gysepein ‘Tequest of the Company, under

go 2001, that the Union in that case had not vio-
id See. 8(b) (1) (A) of the Act by seeking judicial
cement for a fine of $100 imposed on a member

¥. NLRB. — US. ——, 89 S. Ct. 1154,
(April 1, 1969) the Court held that a union rule im-
sing a ceiling on payments for incentive work was
id and could be enforced through collection of rea-

‘he Court’s opinions in these two cases were obvi-
Antended to illuminate a broader area than that
“under direct consideration. A brief statement of the
“general principle involved is given in Allis-Chalmers,
_at 888 U.S. 195:
e Thus this history of congressional action does

not support a conclusion that the Taft-Hartley
prohibitions against restraint or coercion of an
employee to refrain from concerted activities
ineluded a prohibition against the imposition of
fines on members who decline to honor an
authorized strike and attempts to collect such
fines. Rather, the contrary inference is more
justified in light of the repeated refrain
throughout the debates on See. 8(b)(1)(A)
and other sections that Congress did not pro-
pose any limitations with respect to the internal
: affairs of unions, aside from barring enforge-
~.. ment of a union’s internal regulations to affect
_)s &@ member’s employment status.
are as yet no decisions of the Board in which
las worked out the implications of Allis-Chalmers
t Scofield. Specificall » among the unanswered ques-

g whether a union has violated Sec. 8(b)
(A) that the amount of the fine is “unreasonable”,
i under what circumstances does it become unrea-

sioniie; and (2) is it critical, for purposes of the
same determination, that membership in the union
was in some sense involuntary.

‘1, Reasonableness of the fine. It is clear from both
AllisChalmers and Scofield that the Court considered
the amount: of. the fines ‘for which judicial enforce-

are seattered. references throughout the two opinions
that the reasonableness of the fine, at least when judi-

cial enforcement was sought, was a factor in deciding
ie a violation would be found. But there are
other parts of the two opinions where the absence of
a reference to reasonable fines might lead one to con-
clude that the amount of the fine was beyond the scope
of the Board’s inquiry.’

However, since I assume that the Court did not
knowingly refer to the reasonableness of. a fine with-.
out intending it to have some significance, an attempt
must be made to fit the concept into the context of
the Court’s actual holdings. It must again be noted,
in preface, that the Court held the fines as enforced
by the state courts in Allis-Chalmers and Scofield as
reasonable, and that court enforcement of a fine is the
final stage of a fine proceeding, The preliminary
stages recognized by the opinions, through which a

* E.g.: Allis-Chalmers v. N.L.RB., 388 U.S. 175 at 191-192:
“Cogent support of an interpretation of the body of Sec. 8(b)

(1) (A) as not reaching the imposition of fines and ee at
court enforcement is the proviso to Sec. 8(b)(1) ... At the

amount of a “% for which thd may
‘3 ae atetial:

OF 2457

20a
1's fine motion may proceed, are as follows: @)

passage of the motion in an approved manner, or
me prior existence of a union rule with or without a
meseribed penalty; (2) notification to a member of
union action or existing rule; (3) imposition of a
» Im accordance with the procedure prescribed in
| Landrum-Griffin Act;* and (4) enforcement,
: judicially or through the union’s own internal
sachinery.

otification, meaning a cautionary announcement
strikebreakers that their offense might be punish-

by a fine, is found by the Court in Allis-Chal-
ee, ‘mers, supra, at

Union believed to be ready to engage in strikebreak-
ing would not be a violation, unless perhaps, court en-
forcement was also threatened. Although such a noti-
fication may be given before the imposition of a fine,
‘it is only the latter which is, assuming the Union’s
compliance with Sec. 411(a)(5) of the Landrum-
Griffin Act, efficacious. Until the prescribed procedure
has been followed, a cautionary announcement to a
- Possible offender that a fine may be imposed is not, it
‘iq. Pub. L. 86-267, 73 Stat. 522, 29 U.S.C. Seo. 411 et seq,
‘Be #11(a)(5) reads: “ against improper discipli-

se
=

forded » full and fair hearing. |

Oe

seems to me, any more an unfair labor practice thea?
the fine motion itself. There is no hint in either of the
Court’s opinions that promiulgation of a valid union
‘rule and a eribed penalty, even though “‘unrea
sonable”, would constitate a violation of Sec. 8(by(1 (1)
(A.

I need not therefore decide in this case whether the
imposition of a $2000 fine would have been unrea-
sonable per se; whether the surrounding ‘circumstances

_ might affect a determination as to the reagonableness
of a fine;" or whether court enforcement of an im-
posed’ fine in such amount ‘would ‘be an unfair labor
practice, I find here that the notification to the poten-
tial. strikebreakers, Kimball and Radziewicz, of the
Union's fine motion, of which they were already
aware, and the explicit warning that they would be
‘subject to a $2000 fine was not an unfair labor prac-
‘tice, This does not, however, necessarily dispose of the
case.

2. The Resignations. The General Counsel con-
tends that a a’s right to impose a reasonable fine

r fa to support its strike does not

extend to a threat to fine an employee who has re
his membership, without regard to. the reason-
ableness of the fine. The main thrust of the Respond-
ent’s argument is that Kimball and Radziewicz
eould not resign when they attempted to do so, that
they are still union members, and that the Board does
not ‘have the authority ‘‘to pass judgment on the

| "¥ Such surrounding ciroumstances might’ be the duration of
‘the strike and what the employee might have earned if he had
Zone back to work despite the imposition of the fine, as com-
hay oo edbee h ahaa

LONE FRR eS ASE, Ue) NIE ee en Per PANT one Roe er he a

RAG at,

3la

ties. a Union may impose on a member.’’* The
lon argues, however, that if Kimball and Rad-
wics had in faet resigned, and if the Pitarys letters
te a threat, they were nevertheless not coercive
hin the meaning of Sec. 8(b) (1) (A) because the
igations of membership, no matter how severe, sim-
-do not apply to nonmembers.

he Supreme Court’s opinions in Allis-Chalmers
‘Scofield make occasional references to “full mem-
ership”’ but they appear to relate to the problem of
m employee obligated under a union-security provi-
ion. to become a union member who chooses not to
sume the responsibilities of full membership but to
itisfy his financial obligations by paying the equiv-
ent of the initiation fee and the monthly dues. There
‘however, a statement in Scofield which speaks more
rectly on the issue of a union’s right to fine a mem-
ar who seeks to resign. It reads as follows (89 S.
1154 at 1158):

t Under this dual approach, Sec. 8(b) (1) leaves
a union free to enforce a properly adopted rule
which reflects a legitimate union interest, im-
pairs no policy Congress has imbedded in the
labor laws, and és reasonably enforced against
union members who are free to leave the unton
and escape the rule. (Underscoring not in orig-
inal).

2 quoted language does not refer to the conditions
verning resignations, such as whether a meniber
The quotation is from the Board’s decision in the Wiscon-
‘Motors case 145 NLRB 1097, 1104, enforced by the Su-
preme Court sub nom. Scofield v. N.L.R.B. supra.

32a

must comply ‘with internal union ‘regulations as to
their time and manner, or whether a resignation need
‘be accepted at all if the uriion makes no provision
for. voluntary cer aerereeme while - employed in the
industry; /

There are, howeter,; ositpih stiakaten'y and Board
principles which are of help in determining the rights
and obligations of unions toward employees who seek
to resign their union membership. There is first, of
course, the proviso to Sec. 8(b)(1)(A) which en-
joins impairment of a union’s right to prescribe its
own Tules asto the acquisition or retention of mem- .
bership; There are also those Board cases which hold
that a union violates See. 8(b)(2) if it seeks the dis-
charge for: nonpayment of dues of an employee who
has ‘resigned at a time when a union security, or
maintenance of membership, clause was not in effect,
or who has resigned at arly time from a union which
does not provide by its constitution or bylaws for any
effective method of resignation.’ These cases certainly
hold that a Union cannot prevail against an otherwise
‘valid charge of violating Sec. 8(b)(2) by invoking
the proviso to Sec. 8(b)(1)(A), Even the Paulding
case on which Respondent relies, (N.L.R.B. v. Inter-
national Union, Automobile Workers etc., 320 F. 2d.

* Aeronautical Industrial District Lodge 761 etc. (The Boeing
Company) 178 NLRB No. 71; Local Union No. 621, United
Rubber etc. Workers, (Adlantic Research Corporation) 167
NLRB No. 838, fn. 1; International Union, United Automobile
ete. Workers, (John I. Paulding, Inc.) 142 NLRB 296; 137
NLRB 901, set. aside in V.LAR.B. v. International Union, ete.
820 F.2d 12,(C.A,,1),; 180 NLRB 1085, enf'd N.L.B.B. v. In-
ternational Union,..cto, 297 'F. 9d 272, (C.A. 1); Newspaper
Guild of Buffalo, Local No. 96,118 NLRB 1471; Marlin Rock-
well Corporation, 114 NLRB 558; New Jersey Bell Telephone *
Company, 106 NLRB 1322, enf’d 215 F. 2d 835 (C.A. 2).

33a

OF. 2d , a8 we indicated
a p same parties; ‘it

be reasonableness be- ”
may not go’ in structuring its

“Proviso of Sec. 8(b) (1) (

_ 1 am led to conclude

“of the Union when Pi
Mers, can the Union

kind of blinkered
Cannot be coerced by a threat

34a

fine based. on failure to fulfill the obliga
only, of a member. It is true, however, only
nonmember can divine what the Board and the
in his particular case years later.
the immediate risk im having to decide
nion might be able to do, it is not. surpris-
Kimball ‘and Radziewicz decided to forego
See. 7. right to work. during the strike rather
gn hr guia
However, the issue of whether the Pitarys letters

Fs ge
ail

_I have previously concluded that the Pitarys letters
went no further, and ‘accomplished no more than the
fine motion did, and since a fine motion or other valid
union rule against strikebreaking is not in itself a
violation, further notification of its passage or ex-
istence either to members or nonmembers is also not
a violation. The Union did not impose fines on Kim-
ball or -y¢ssgp noth in compliance with the procedures
required by Sec. 411(a)(5) of the Landrum-Griffin
Act, nor did it. seek either internal or external en-
forcement of its valid fine motion. It is thus unneces-
sary for me to decide whether it is the imposition or
the. ne a an eerie fine which violates

AL, shall recommend dismiseal 0 of, the complaint in its

>

e 35a
E- m the basis of the foregoing findings and analysis
if the facts, I made the following :

Conclusions of Law

iy

1, International Paper Box Machine Company is
jaged in commerce and in activities affecting com-
rce within the meaning of Section 2(6) and (7)
ihe Act. ~
2. ite State Joint Board, Textile Workers
Jnion of America, Local 1029, AFL-CIO, is a labor
janization within the meaning of Section 2(5) of
Act.
The Respondent has not engaged in any unfair
wor practices as alleged in the complaint.
‘ RECOMMENDED ORDER
It is hereby recommended that the complaint be
, ‘dismissed in its entirety.
~ Dated at Washington, D.C.
xe Miton Janus,
P a f Trial Examiner,

_ GRANITE STATE JOINT BOARD, LOCAL 1029 (INTL, PAPER
a, _- “BOX MACHINE COMPANY) 1-CB~1460 (1~2)

a Please attach this Supplemental TXD to the orig-
~ ine Decision and Order issued on December 31,

187 NLRB No. 90.

f

United States of America
BEFORE THE Narion at Lapor RELATIONS Boarp
DIVISION OF TRIAL EXAMINERS
_.. , Washington, D.C.
Gnanrrs Srare Jomnt. Boarp, TEXTILE WorKERS UNION

or America, Looat 1029, AFL-CIO (INTERNATIONAL
Parser Box Macnine Company)

and
- Feu Rapztewicz, Maurice K. Kimaatt, II,
INDIVIDUALS

- Case No. 1-CB-1460(1-2)

: and
Paut R. Marquis, EvGene Cotiarp, Hazen R. Joun-
SON, PETER Maxnris, Sk., INDIVIDUALS

Case No. 1-CB-1504(1-4)

and
JosePH M. KEerriGan, EsQ., AN INDIVIDUAL
Case No. 1-CB—1534

Thomas P. Kennedy and Gerald P. Cobleigh, Esqs.,
for the General Counsel.

Harold B. Rottman, Esq., Boston, Mass., for Re-
spondent.

(36a)

: 37a
‘Tama Examiven’s Suprrementat Decision
STATEMENT OF THE CASE

_ MILTON JANUS, Trial Examiner: On June 4,
1969, I issued a Decision in Case No. 1-CB-1460(1-2)
recommending dismissal of the complaint against the
_ Bespondent, Granite State Joint Board ete. (referred
to hereafter as the Union). The reason for my recom-
mendation of dismissal was that, in my opinion, the
holdings of the Supreme Court in Allis-Chalmers v.
NLRB. 388 U.S. 175, and in Scofield v. N.L.R.B.,
394 U.S. 423, required a finding that Section 8(b) (1)
(A) was not violated by the Union’s warning the
charging parties, Radziewicz and Kimball, that they
would be subject to fines if they engaged in strike-
breaking. I also held in my Decision that Radziewicz
and Kimball could resign from the Union at any time
in the absence of provision in the Union’s constitution
or by-laws for resignation at specified intervals, and
that the resignations they had submitted to the Union
were effective.

The General Counsel filed exceptions to my Deci-
sion on June 26, 1969. Two days earlier, on June 24,
charges had been filed against the Union in Case No.
1-CB-1504(1-4) by the individuals named in the cap-
tion, charging a violation of Section 8(b)(1)(A) by
the Union’s threats to fine them if they crossed the
Union’s picket line at the International Paper, Box
Machine Company plant where the Union was on
strike. es

_ On July 3, 1969, the General Counsel filed a Motion
with the Board to reopen' the record in Case No.
~1-CB+1460(1-2), alleging that the Union had filed
¥ | charges against Radziewicz and Kimball for

t
§
i)

38a

crossing its picket line at the Company’s plant,
thereby going beyond its previous warnings to them
which I had found not to be violative of the Act.

On September 3, 1969, Peter Kerrigan, an attorney,
filed a charge in Case No. 1-CB-1534 on behalf of 23
named individuals, employees of the Company, alleg-
ing that. the Union had fined them for crossing its
picket lines and had brought suit in a State court to
collect the fines which it had imposed.

- On October 20, 1969, the General Counsel ordered
Case Nos. 1-CB-1504(1-4) and 1-CB~1534 con-
solidated for hearing, and issued his complaint in that
consolidated proceeding alleging that the Union had
violated Section 8(b) (1) (A) by threatening to impose
fines, by fining and by seeking judicial enforcement of
such fines against employees of the Company who had
resigned from the Union and had returned to work
daring the Union’s strike against the Company.

Two days later, on October 22, the Board granted
the General Counsel’s motion to reopen the record in
Case No. 1-CB-1460(1-2) and remanded it to me to
take evidence as to conduct which occurred after the
close of the hearing in that case and which bore di-
rectly on the conduct alleged in that complaint. There-
after, on October 24, the General Counsel filed a mo-
tion with me to consolidate the remanded case with the
two eases which he had previously consolidated and on
which he had issued a new complaint. I issued an
Order granting the General Counsel’s motion, on No-
vember 10, 1969, and reaffirmed it on November 14,
after the Uniori’s request for reconsideration. A hear-
ing was thereafter held on the entire consolidated pro-
ceeding on November 20, 1969, at Nashua, New Hamp-

} '

39a

re. The Union filed a brief after the hearing which
ave considered. I have also considered later com-
_Miuniecations from both the Union and the General
Counsel advising me of certain recently issued Trial
~ Examiner’s Decisions supporting their respective
~*~ Upon the entire record in the case and from my
_ observation of the witnesses, I make the following :
apt ADDITIONAL FINDINGS OF FACT
‘ - The essential facts here are not in dispute, and at
_ the risk of some repetition, I will summarize what is

already set out in my original Decision as a prelude

Sc

to a description of the events which have taken place
~The last bargaining agreement between the Company
and the Union expired September 20, 1968, and on that
“date the Union began an economic strike which was
_ ill in force on the date of the latest hearing, Novem-
ber 20, 1969. Almost the entire working force were
‘Members of the Union under a maintenance-of-mem-
bership provision in the last contract, and all of the

Union members went out on strike. The strike vote
had been unanimously adopted, and a motion to fine
'@yone who aided the employer during the strike in
“the amount of $2000 was adopted at a Union meeting
with only one dissenting vote. ef

' Radziewicz and Kimball sent letters of resignation

a

t the Union in November, 1968, and the Union quickly

xy By arrangement at the hearing an exhibit number, G.C. 11,

mas \ for later submission by Mr, Kerrigan, the at-
‘ trney| for charging parties. It is now part of the official
Bord of

aay

a
x
‘

40a

replied, advising them that, their purported resigna-
tions. were ineffective, that they were still members
subject to the Union’s rules, and cautioning them that
they were subject to a fine of $2000 if they insisted on
going back to work.during the strike. Kimball did not
attempt to return to work, while Radziewicz, who had
gone back to work fora few days, then decided not to
continue working behind the picket lines.

On these facts, I held in my original Decision that
neither the fine ‘motion, passed by the membership
at the inception of the strike, nor the Union’s letter
to Radziewicz and Kimball on receipt of their resig-
nations constituted imposition of a fine within the
-. meaning of Sec. 411(a)(5) of the Landrum-Griffin
Act, 29 U.S.C. 401 et seq., and that it was therefore
unnecessary for me to decide whether a $2000 fine, if
it had been imposed, would have been unreasonable. I
went on to find that since the Union’s constitution did
not provide for voluntary resignations under any cir-
cumstances or at any particular time, Radziewicz and
Kimball were free to resign whenever they chose.
Resignation from a Union was, I found, a right pro-
tected by Sec. 7 of the Act.* I recommended dismissal
of the complaint since I found no violation of Section
8(b) (1)(A) by the Union warning the two charging
parties that they might be fined for crossing its picket
line at the Company’s plant.

What follows is a recital of the events occurring
after June 4, 1969, the date of my Decision. As soon
as the Company was notified of that Decision, it sent
‘letters to all the striking employees (Respondent Ex-
hibit 3) advising them that my Decision meant that

. *My reason for considering the resignatién problem at all)

was in conpection with the arguments of both parties on whether
nonmemb can be restrained or coerced by a threat to fine him.

—_

\ 4la
resigned from the Union could not be

preme Court had up-

us anyone engaged in
_ Strikebreaking, and that charges would be brought
_-@gainst anyone doing so, It urged them not to be mis-
sled by the Com y. Fi

_ » Shortly before my: Decision was issued, a third em-
- ployee, Hazen J, ohnson, resigned. After the Decision,

ing on June 6, 1969, and for some months fol-
_ lowing, there were

returned to work for the
Company, crossing the picket lines to do so. While
-,they had been out on strike, many of these 31 had
_ obligated themselves in a written statement to the
Union, to reimburse it for the premiums which the
Union would pay to keep their group insurance poli-
Gies current. Many of them also accepted cash pay-
‘ ‘nents from the Union while thev were strikinc

}
1
i

paying his fine, and threatening him with legal action
to colleet-it: None of them paid the fine imposed, and
the. Union then filed a‘suit‘and writ of attachment
against each’in the New Hampshire state courts. The
suits claim’ a specific amount due the Union as a re-
sult of the defendant’s contract of membership in the
Union and, where applicable, a second count based on
its claim for moneys advanced on his behalf for in-
‘gutance premiums. However, the amount claimed is in
all cases’ greater than the specific sums alleged to be
dus porertie owing. For example, the action brought
against Hugene Collard is for' $1400 in the first count,
-and $195.14 ‘in the second, while the total amount
claimed is $2000.

CONTENTIONS, ANALYSIS AND CONCLUSIONS

‘The General Counsel has already filed exceptions to

my Decision in the original proceeding and stands by
the contentions raised then, that the Union’s letters
to Radziewicz and Kimball after their resignations in
November 1968, are threats to impose excessive fines
and are in themselves violative of Section 8(b) (1)
(A). As to the imposition of fines on the 31 charging
parties now involved in the consolidated proceeding,
and the suit for judicial enforcement of these fines,
the General Counsel argues, in the alternative: (1)
that the 31 all effectively resigned from the Union and
that a threat to fine, or the imposition of a fine in any
amount, on nonmembers of a Union is restraint or co-
ercion of their Section 7 right not to remain a mem-
ber; but assuming, however, that their resignations
may have been ineffective fir me reason, so
they were still members when the Union | fined th
vs in that event, the fine of a day’s pay for each

ed is excessive, since its effect is to force them to

|
it

© equitworking for the Company. This latter argument
Mis ‘based. on the General Counsel’s contention, already
sade inthe first proceeding, that the Allis-Chalmers

_ eviolation of Section 8(b) (1) (A).
_ & The Union’s basic arguments, like that of the Gen-
- tefal Counsel, center on the resignations. It argues

has a Tight to require satisfaction from them by the
_ imposition and collection of fines. :

“Ymecepted as effective. I find the argument unpersua-
combined membership application and authoriza-

fhis employer

44a

An. empleyee..might- well intend. to. remain: a Union
member but; ;choose.not-"to. have} his: Union dues
. checked . off: by ‘his -employer, so, that: revocation. of
the authorization does not imply. resignation from the
- Union., Also, an-employee-eoncerned about his right
to resign. would certainly expect to-be:-bound by what
the Union’s: hasic charter says or'does not say on the
- Subject, ‘and. should. not be required to guess at what
the. Union’s. intentions were from an ambiguously éx-
pressed. form designed ‘for other purposes altogether.
_ Other arguments advanced for the ineffectiveness
of the resignations.are also unpersuasive since they
are. based.on the proposition that the procedures to
be followed for resignation are the same as those to
be. followed for revocation of the dues check-off au-
thorization. They relate to the fact that some of the
"resignations were not sent by registered mail or were
sent. by. telegram. One resignation, that of employee
‘Desjardins, was unsigned. In fact, however, his letter
gives his name and-clearly expresses his intent to
resign. As for those employees who resigned by ordi-
nary} mail er by telegram, I find that their resigna-
tions became effective upon receipt of their commuti-
cations to the Union since no other form of communi-
cation was obli

to
resigning. In both. cases, it appears that the
benefits received accrued before the ions and

-are therefore not inconsistent with an effective resig-
nation. + fr 4

45a

ions. I find nothing improper
of June 5, 1969 (Respondent

the Union during the strike.’

JILL IL SS
*

8 inir g agreement; and

‘the: course of

‘Membership. although tHe

‘@arging withdraw from the

' avoid their obligations
racce membership and to con-

‘Bone supporting the strike. Each member was in-

‘Bieed to. strike by the mutual commitment of all the

Se
» -

Seo the cass’ cited in footnote 9 of the ‘or‘ginal ‘Decision.

46a

other ‘members to do: the same, and by returning to
work during the ‘strike the charging parties have,
breached their agreement with their fellow members,
Judicial enforcethent: ofa fine imposed for break-'
ing a: strike}: it is argued, is in harmony with the
national labor policy of: protecting the right to strike,
‘The: logic’ of the Union’s argument’ requires. the
conclusion’ that: a resignation of a union member has
only a prospective effect, so that: deeisions made by
the Union before the resignation continue to bind
the former member who now ‘seeks to repudiate the:
collective decision he:.once aceepted. It is an argu-
ment ‘that cannot: be lightly ‘brushed: aside, since it
is based on the proposition’ common ‘in ‘the law, that
one» cannot escape: one’s freely accepted ‘obligations
when the going gets tough. However, for more com-
pelling een T loaned ‘reject the iment

argument.

n Bection. T off ‘the Act: eels equally the right to
ehgage, andthe right not to engage, in coneerted ac-
tivities including ‘strikes. The same Section also pro-
tects the right! to resign ‘from:a ‘union ‘ just as it does
the right to join! one: When:an employee joins a union
he assumes: both rights and obligations with respect to.
it. To say that his obligation (in this case, to stay out
on: strike): continues even ‘after he has: effectively re-
signed; Would postpone to some indefinite date beyond:
his control/his right not;to strike: Further, since their
right to attend Union: meetings, to vote and to influ-
ence the Union’s future’ course of: action as to the!
vista ended with their resignations, I believe that

y y Bot Telephone Company, 106 NLRB 1892, 13%,
. Cor s Workers of Am CIO vv.
F,. 2 885, (C-A, 2)y and: Marlin Rook Cor-

553, 559-569.

This is not to say, however, that monetary obliga-
lions of a member to his union which are based on an
ress or implied contract between them, may not

vive the member’s resignation.’ In the category of
ible: monetary obligations due the Union by the
eharging parties are the premiums for group insur-
aheepolicies which the Union advanced on their be-

Charging ir resignations is, in my
‘pinion, not collectible. through resort to the State
courts, because the Union would thereby be in viola-
- the of Section 8(b) (1) (A) of the Act.

°P Scofield v. N.L.R.B., 804 U.S. 498 st 480: “Under this dual

th, Sec, 8(b)(1) leaves @ union
doptec rule which reflects. a |

"Dd 888, 888 (C.A. 2)
ai? ‘ 3

48a"

‘Dhe-rettaining: contentions which the Union makes’
can be disposed :of: briefly. First, it argues’ that the
charging parties: failed to exhaust their internal union
remedies ‘even to the extent of failing to appear at the
Union trialsin' order to ‘claim. that they had effectively
resigned. But: exhaustion of internal remedies would
only pe required of Union members, whereas here all
the ‘charging’ parties had’ resigned ‘before the Union
filed charges against them. Consequently, they were
under no obligation to explain or defend their resig-
nations at‘ Unionhearing. ©

‘Finally, the Union argues’ that the ra imposed,
a day’s: pay't ‘for each day worked, were not’ unreason-
able. I “no ‘opinion ‘on ‘whether ‘the “reason-
ableness of a union fine’ determines the legality of its
inigideition ‘oft méenibers‘ndr Gu‘ whether ‘the amounts
sought hére*are int fact reasonable; since in my opin-—
ion, the Union’s imposition ‘of a fitié in’ any amount on
nonmenibers atid ‘its attempt to-séek judicial enforce-
ment delet, are © Violations ‘of Section 8(b) (1) (A).

te

7 t' set forth above,
’ Re ana activities
dneribod in Seotion & of xy érignal Dicson, have a

se _mT have at
(b) (1) (
that it it and |

49a

mative wetion designed to effectuate the policies
semieally, I will recommend that the Union re-
‘the fines it has imposed on the 31 persons named
mix A, change its records to reflect such
we take all necessary action, in the New Hamp-
‘shire courts where it is secki judicial enforcement

ee
~té7 6.4)

“give up its claims for the fines it has imposed, and
“potify the said 31 persons that it has done all the

i» «+ *\ CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

The Respondent has restrained and coerced the
ersotis narned in Appendix A, all of whom had
‘ively resigned their memberships in the Re-
ndent, in the exercise of their right to resign said
Te mnbersh ips and of their right not to strike against
Beit émployer, by imposing fines on them through its
Tit rn il procedures, and by seeking judicial enforee-
ent of such fines,

@®. The aforesaid unfair labor practices affect com-
Weree within the meaning of Section 2 (6) and (7)
haga RECOMMENDED ORDER

#04 pursuant to Section 10(c) of the National Labor
ations Act, as amended, I recommend that Granite
ite Joint Board, Textile Workers Union of Amer-
Local 1029, AFL-CIO, its officers, agents and rep-

Y Cotse and desin reneregee | | |

Y me pars ep osu to reflett theiae
tion. taken to rescind such fines.

»ie(@): Lake all:necessary:action in’ the -eonrts of the
_ State of New Hampshire where -judicial-enforeement
. for collection of the fines imposed against the persons
named in Appendix . Avhas‘been- brought, to withdraw
4), Notify the persons. named -in Appendix A that
stag taken the actions which: haye .been ordezed
iQ). ‘Post. in, ,conspienous. places at. its; Gffices ahd
meeting. hells, :and other , places . where.notices to its
-members 2 y posted, copies of the attached
notice marked “Appendix ~ Doptga of api, notion, op

“ey
reof, and be.maip- |

signed by an
it, be re-

ed. forthwith to the Regional Diregtor, for disposi-
Notify the Regional Director for. Region 1, in
ing, within. 20 days from the date of receipt of
Supplemental Decision and Recommended Order
What steps it has taken to comply herewith."
Dated at Washington, D.C.

MILTON JANUS,
Trial Examiner.

-* In the event that this Recommended Order is adopted by the
board, this provision shall be modified to read: “Notify said
Regional Director, in writing, within 10 days from the date of

Order what steps Respondent has taken to comply
ith.” ae

bs MEELIS

ee Appendix B
Nortor: ro EMPLOYEES AND MEnBERS

BY ORDER OF THE NATIONAI, LABOR RELATIONS
ghana tix 7°? . BOARD:

ns coer aN #0)

nr Agency: of. thes United States Government

in or coerce our former

‘in the exercise of rights guaranteed to them
Tof the National Labor Relations Act, as

% WILI. rescind the fines we have imposed
3 inst, the Persons named below, change our records
iow that ‘we have rescinded ‘these fines, and take
pcessary action inthe courts of New Hampshire
idrgw and give up all’ claims for collection of

a eee
ck

Bee ET Adrian! Gagnon |

Clovis Gamache

Robert Guerrette
Hazen Johnson cae
Maurice Kimball
Armand Levesque

Peter Makris

Paul Marquis
is Ronald Maynard
(58a)

William Mayo Robert Roy
yn McAlister Zennie Runowicz

. Alfred Theriault
“Henry Tremblay

- Gerald Tyler.

Grantre State Jomnt Boarp, Tex-

TILE Workers UNION or AMERICA,

Locar 1029, AFL-CIO (Labor Or-
uj) ganization) -

Bhs Ts An Oficial Notice ‘And Mast Not Be Detaoed
: By Anyone : sth

alee Notie ‘viust Loess eek BY candien
‘five days from the date of posting and mist not be
alt tered, ‘defaced, or covered by any other material.

my 3 ions concerning this Notice or compliance
with its provisions, may be directed to the Board’s

Office, 20th Floor John F. Kennedy Federal Build-
ing, Cambridge &: New Sudbury Sts,; Boston,. Mag-
sachusetts 2203 elem No. siento ua oT aid

APPENDIX D

fit "United States of America

nro B'THE Natiowar, Lator Rezarioxs Boarp

ris Case 15-OB~779

_ cachenon No. 405, INTERNATIONAL ASSCCIATION

RMAC 4CE Workers, AFL—~CIO
and

_.THE Borne Company

he Decision, together with supporting
ghtiefia, ing ‘Party filed a reply brief. Sijh-’
| ently, :in response to an invitation of the Board,
wie Oharying ‘Party and ‘the ‘Respondent filed supple-
4 mente ~btiefs. In -response ‘to ‘the ‘same invitation,
Peiatements .of position. ‘were filed ‘by the ‘National
Selemlociatic 1.Of, Manufacturers, and by the American
(PPrteretion of Labor and Gongress of Industrial

y (85a)

.
ees
: AS
at ; . Eee A
56a Seige,
. ts 3-5
A

- yatiizations, joined by the International Brother-
hood ‘of ‘Teamsters and the: International Union,
UAW; as amici ouriag...)-:.;
"the Bodedteas reviewed tho fulings ofthe Trial
Examiner mad¢ at the hearing: and finds that no preju-
dicial error was committed. The Board has considered

ord in the case. The Board adopts the Trial Exam-
iner’s findings 6f fact, but adopts ‘this conclusions and
recommendations ‘only’ to’ thé ‘extent’ that’ they are
consistent with the decision herein.

Se ee ek ie S20 oat in dinpuln

* Booster Lodge No, 405, } peer onal Association of

Machinists and Aerospace W AFL-CIO, here-
inafter called TAM. ou: fhe Tipton, and Bocing were
parties to a collective-bargaining agreement effective
from May 16, 1963 throngh & maber 15;'1965.' Upon
the expiration of the contract, the Union commenced a
lawfal strike against, Boeing at its ;Michond plant in
Newt Gtisina Lockinta: mek ue nations other -loca-
tions. The strike lasted 18 days,.On October 2, 1968,
@ new contract. was signed. The, strikers returned to
work. on: the following day. ‘Both, contracts. eontained
maintenanes-of-membership, ‘clauses, , which., required
. "TA the time of the ‘execiition of ‘the'1963 resent, Booster

Tiilige 408 wild “itt, ins ‘eitidbetige: fochg’a tiitiond,"Lotleion,
iene [anu mi we Seat, Ren

57a

late early November 1965, the Union
edall strikebteaking employees that charges ‘had

1 pence
pS: 5. &) ‘3
ON PFE GP

i ‘

‘taeéepting nployment Saensaneanan eee
a strike . . . existe.” Employees:-were advised of the
dates of thd toi were “cpa exncrtmes
their absenea, ‘of the availability of union-member:
éotiisel; Prior tothe strike, the Union had not warned:
menibérs about the ‘possible imposition of disciplinary
measures. However, the LAM ‘constitution provides
that members found ‘guilty of misconduct after notice
atid «hearing ate‘pubject to ‘‘reprimand, fine, suspen-
sion,: oF :expubsion:: fron: membership; or any lesser
penagity ae! ee
a a,
‘ f
eae,
bis
¥

unnecessary to

? 8(b)(1) (A) as not
the imposition of fines and attempts at court
ament.7 ee ,

l€ signific of the
tit establishes the uni

= || ee
hag

a

ERY the proviso to Section 8(b) (1) (A).

_eorresponding ‘right to. discipline him for breach of
that duty are extinguished. ‘

In ‘the; case iat bar, the Union’s right to discipline
employees. terminated upon the employees’ submission
of, their’ letters of resignation." ‘The attempted
imposition of discipline for subsequent conduct was
‘beyond: the powers of the Union.” It was not consented
40 by. the employees. Nor, in our view, was it protected
Reg eect gy moat
~ ‘The holding, in Allis-Chalmers was. carefully re-
stricted to the facts of that case. The Court expressly
efused: to. pass on.the légality of the imposition of a
fine. upon, “limited members” of the union." It appears.
to.us.that in this reservation there was the implica-
tion that such a fine when levied against nonmembers

“#'The Union takes the position that’ voluntary resignation

from ‘its ranks is impossible of achievement because its consti-
tution. and bylaws set forth no procedure for such. resignations.
As this argument is contrary. to long-standing Board precedent,
We reject it here. Seo Comownioations Worker of Amerie
O10. (New Jersey Rell Tel. Go.), 106 NLRB 1322, enfd. 215
F.2d 885 (CLA: 2); Lobval Union No, 681, United Rubber, Cork,
Linoleum & Plastic Workers of Amnérioa, AFL-OIO (Atlantic
Research Corp.), 167 NLRB. 610; District Lodge 751, Inter-
national Association of Machinists & Aerospace Workers, AFL-
ClO (Boeing Co.),:178 NLRB No. 71. Moreover, as_ indicated
fra the Supreme Court in the Soofield case expressely sanc-

., oF Teaving the union to avoid disciplina

i Loops Erg dolla

f

63a

stitutes a form of restraint and coercion proscribed
F Bection 8(b)(1)(A).~The decisions in two sub-
Seiin’its recent Scofield opinion,“ the Supreme Court
3 jumm: ‘ized its construction of Section 8(b) (1) (A)
as follows:

=~ [The section] leaves a union free to enforce a
* properly-adopted rule which reflects a legiti-
mate union interest, impairs no policy Congress
has imbedded in the labor laws, and is rea-
sonably enforced against wnion members who
“are free to leave the union and escape the rule

[Emphasis supplied. ]

his suggests that the prohibitions of Section 8(b)

(A) encompass union rules which do not conform
th the enumerated qualifications. Included in this
ter category is a rule enforeed against nonunion
embers.. By observing that members could “leave
8 union and escape the rule,” the Court seems to
@Mave envisaged the possibility that union members
} could, indeed, resign membership and avoid discipline.
+) An the Shipbuilding Workers case," the Supreme

ee. oR

@trued Section 8(b) (1) (A) as assuring a union free
_} 40m. of self-regulation only “where its legitimate in-
#¥ernal affairs are concerned.” But the imposition: of
SMiscipline upon nonmembers can hardly be deemed

© “Boopela, et al. v. NLRB. 304 US 499.

3 UN LRB. v. Marine & Shipbuilding Workers, 391 US.

J a
> ~oey

>.
=

sihedalile sidneaty 3 we: find’ that the Re-
sidallncle telat ‘Section 8(b) (1) (A): of the Act by

imposing disciplinary ‘fines upon resigners: from its
for acts committed after their resignations.

pelos ee Maso) A apa aR

wihiniii inf oer oie
i Gilicbers Fanaing, Brown, and Jenkins),
fed at the gly omg tt Spend

f2 . 65a

. inc “that the Respondent did not violate Section
(2) (A) by fining the nonresignees. Nor, in our
Bion, does the Respondent’s failure to exercise its

uluating the Union’s conduct. The provisions of a
guntrac and @ cause of action can be
“brought. upon them, even after the expiration or ter-
‘Mination: agreement. The rights and duties

0 aion’s fut authority over them. tial
‘Accordingly, we further find that. the Respondent
hot violate Section 8(b)(1)(A) of the Act by
ing former members’ for miseonduct. engaged in
ablenes: the Board does f do the Lisi E; =i! ,

bn' to collect ‘ould in all other regpeots be lawful.
fe expulsion’ ‘from bership’ is ‘clearly the only avail-
& methox ‘of ‘enforcement, he' ‘would consider ‘the size of a

66a

prior to their resignations from among its ranks,
However, ‘this conclusion does not legitimize the im-
position of discipline for ‘conduct engaged in after
‘the resignations, We. shall order the Respondent to
cease and desist from such action, and to remit a pro-
rata portion of the fine, so-that what remains reflects
only preresignation conduct.
ORDER

Pursuant to Section 10(c) of the National Labor
Relations Act,'as amended, the National Labor Rela-
tions Board hereby orders that the Respondent,
Booster ‘Lodge No. 405, International Association of
Machinists ‘and~ Aerospace ‘Workers, AFL-CIO, its
officers, agents, suécessors, and assigns, shall:

1. Cease and desist from:*°
a) ‘Reimbertee: ‘or ‘refund to’ any erriployees, de-

3 of cout eakpetaes conduct <n rene at the plant

67a

ud, Louisiana plant of the Boeing Company, if

. de posted at the aforementioned locations, in
icuous places, including all places where notices

2 complaint as to which no violation has been
- be, and they hereby are, dismissed.
Dated, Washington, D.C.
5 eae (SEAL) Joun H. Fannina, Member.
Frank W. McCutLocn, Member.
Howarp J. ENKINS, Jr., Member.
NatrionaL Lapor ReLations Boarp.

a with my colleagues in dismissing the allega-
sof the complaint with respect to the imposition

68a

pon fn pen purported fro he

veep wsllbnafowtMlapenitibe af thin ‘questiie: is: pred:
icated upon the premise that an employee, faced with
the’ threat “ofa ‘union fine,’‘may well be impelled to
forego: his‘ statutory ‘right not‘ to honor the Union’s
picket line rather than risk involvement in a ‘lawsuit
‘whose outcome he cannot predict.” But this is what
‘Alis-Chalmers ‘was all about. There,a union fine, or
the threat of it, expressly designed to force employees

to “forego: [their] ‘statutory right not to honor the
Union's picket line’? was nevertheless held not to vio-

late Section 8(b)(1) (A) even though such a fine was
colléctible,or collected; in‘ court: The Supreme Court
reasoned that 8(b) (1)(A}-was not intended to apply to
this kind of coercion. If;as*is' the ease here, a Union
does not violate 8(b) (1) (A)- By: imposing or threaten-
ee eae ek cnteetiaete at
y “un*collectible fine can be violative of
that Gedtion. ‘Even if, 4s the majority reasons, the em-
ployee ¢oneerned: may not be sufficiently knowledge-
able to evaluate the Union’s fine as ‘‘un-collectible,”
and ‘thts feel completely frée to cross the pocket line
ti Mabe

| member.

ignored ‘by my colleagues,

Is mie of the employees in-

ve aaah in A Other sittations of which I
ain ‘aware; was: a: member of the Union: in: all senses
SERevard betehe he tine eae Thue the fealty
6d by: a: Soa wha ae sit aint be ‘ime into

action from the can las ds the Union and his

69a

low-members..Moreover, I cannot conceive of a
e/arising where a union would “‘fine’”’ someone who
a never been its member at all. It is only ‘because
} employees here were, in the eyes of thé Union,
{pursuant to the Union’s constitution and bylaws,
i Union members, that the fines would have any
act at all upon them. In this respect, whether
loyees. are still members of the. Union for pur-.
es of imposition of: a Union fine, the. proviso to
)(1).(A), im express terms, applies. to. a union’s
for acquisition or retention of membership.”
For all these -reasons,-I would find no violation of
ection 8(b) (1) (A) of the Act in a Union’s fining
}nonmember or a purported nonmember.

GzRatp A. ‘Brows, Member ‘
National Lasor RELATIONs Boarp

Notice TO MgmsBers
POSTED BY ORDER OF THE NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS
faye tL £07 PAAED Mt

"SS Ati “Ageney of the United States Government.”

WE WILL NOT restrain or coerce employees who
+ had resigned from the Union and who, in the exercise
» of their rights guaranteed in Section 7 of the Act,

orked at the Michoud plant during the September
55 strike, by imposing fines or by threatening to
sk or by seeking court enforcement of said fines as
‘such employees. e

+ * The cases cited by my colleagues in footnote 11 concern a

Union’s application of its membership rules to his job tenure,

and thus are inapposite to the instant situation, where the
§ pertain solely to another internal union matter.

70a

5 WE° WELL reimburse nonmembers abovementioned
fob. ‘any fines they ‘may have _— to us for working
during said strike. - :

SWE WILL NOT in: ine like or vetited manner re-
atrain or oetce employees in the exercise of rights
guaranteed to them in Section’7 of the National Labor

‘Boceeat sols No. 408, Lertesivariowa
| ARSOCTATION OF MACHINISTS AND AEROSPACE
site hose sro sa odeire Cabin Speen)

Deted. iii wa biel 5 'sBY

(Representative) (Title)

This Ts An Oficial Notioe And Must Not Be Detaced
By Anyone

This-Notice must remain posted for 60 consecutive —
days from the date of posting and must not be altered,
pyre cincenl thetenbe ew Seeeerhemeciogs

Any questions concerning this Notice or compliance
with its provisions, may be directed to the Board’s
Office 16024 Federal Building (Loyola) 701 Loyola
Ave.,; New Orleans, La; 70113. Telephone 504-527-
6361.

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386414_0077%3A03. Public record. Not legal advice.
