# Transcript of Record — Utah Pie Co. v. Continental Baking Co.

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386412_0013%3A03

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Transcript of Record
- **Published:** January 1, 1967
- **Citation:** 386 U.S. 685

## Text

1 “ ; * * . 27 =
. : : 75 „ : ö
S 2 1 ° ¢ e. 7
= . E n 3 a F 2
—

2

:

pe A

ree" Sa

~ SUPREME court ic ory THE UNITED ei

3 2 60 i se 12: ** . 7

| _ UTAH PIE COMPANY, renden
e n it 00 ene
. “ConmINENAL arne COMPANTE; ‘Ate ae
wae ; von THE TENTH mob Se quad ini Te 3

s * IDE a 2 *
7 e vor 3. 5 seo PETE,
° Berra from, Uni ited States District Court für the s
District of Utah, Central Division—Continued |
_ Excerpts from transcript of proceediziga, Febru-
, rr 4, 1963-February 23, 1968.—Oontinnecead 2
e aie ee ee NEN ig .
e eee —— b g 911 999

iL

— 315 > 1001

i or ‘Shel A. Kb Fez Ses ae 1
„ Sr e direct... r 1086-8:
cee cb Bee H. Ade een e
ts eee 1 45 a direct — 4 +970 1057 A
ee Voir dire examination — - 14 0O% lala" Peta

=
*
Pa
are
Pad

ang “4 mb: 5 8 A AD 272 A ke 53
5 2 f : Soy £0245 — A dien 1092 1185
5001 i gy Attell Biniosent 122 A OT
seas ip rte ~~ direct — 8 9
deen oS ie: . ee, 2

5 > *
BEE . 0 . r

hy

Record from United States District Court for the
District. of Utah, Central “Division—Continued |
' Excerpts from transcript of proceedings, Febru-
‘ary 4, 1963-February 23, ants +-Continned te
Testimony af Robert Meth: tne ap

» direct 7
Voir dive ephmination - ;
‘Motion iy: beat Yor Uk Pie Genpeny

amend the complaint and granting thereof 126

Argument on behalf of Utah Pie by Mr. Alioto
Argument on behalf of Continental by Mr.
Schafer
Argument on behalf of Pet by Mr. tau
Argument on behalf of Carnation by Mr. Bil-

lings
, "Additional argument on behalf of Utah Pie by
Mr. Alioto ——
-, Court’s instruction to jury —
Exceptions to certain inatruetion
Additional Court 'n e
5 exceptions — j
Verdicts —
— ——
Defendants’ proposed instructions to jury
Defendant, Pet Milk Company's requested ad-
ditional instructions
Defendants, Continental Baking Company's
e e eee
7 Note to Court from jury ack

Procedings in the United Stata Cour of Appeals
for the Tenth Circuit —
Order .granting motions to stay Ps and
ee stayed: pending, ee n eee

f R
ee eee a

1124 1225

1171 1282

1193 13100
1209 1329
1216 1337
1228 1348
1252 1373

1264 1386

1288 145

1284 1407
1800 1422

1818 1448

1820 1446

Clerk’s certificate (omitted: in printing) suey

1321 1448

i 10

ita tes Voir dire examination. sion :
By, Mr. A500 i ie

0. Tell ne again what the b. W... oe

A. The green represents fresh pie sales.

. The green are fresh pie sales? 7
A. And other income, all the ‘other rms of j income other —
0 pies. i
2. Ro thatthe yellow, then, as us fronen pes?

A. That is right. 527

Mr. Alioto: We have no objection, if your ‘Honor lease. re

The Court: Received. -

(The exhibit marked Defendant’s Exhibit A-48 for 2
tification was yeonived. | in evidence.) 5

0 58 * oad. eee „ ayes
© a .

col. 912] Q. Wil you please tell the juty wat an oper- ie

- ating statement is.

A. That is where we computed. ‘the net income of ‘the
company as though it were only in the. frozen pie business,
eliminating that capital gain feature that was not relevant
to the frozen pie business. And in the year 1961 the rate

of return was 30.6 per cent. r ‘ 5

per cent. In the year 1959 the company earned 27.8 pe r
cent of its net worth. And in the years 1958 and 1957 there :
J ape sash cml onic, tse

another loss in 57.

[fol. 9131 C. Now, nas, calculations have 8 to do oS

with salaries? f

A. That's — ot
2. These caleulations „
A. Well, the net inoome was adjusted, where we com-

_* pated the oberating income, ̃ have added back an amount .

to income where the bonuses exceeded ten centof the

bela Lamb: we have: an exhibit 3 440 a Sh
5 that will compare the Swiss Miss and apple
= pie for na arn California and Reno as against the Utah

“©

Pie price.
Mr. Alioto: The Utah price for. your company, 5a
0 ° e- 0 e .

Mr. Alioto: And is it stipulated that this exhibit i taken 5

8 pera what source? Invoices?

‘Mr, Lamb: No, these exhibits have been taken from the

. ‘price list, the off. invoice, and the advertising allowances.

What. we introduced this morning was the additional in-
formation of invoices. In order to make the record abso-

E. ey clear— —

Mr. Alioto: These exhibits, th port to be only what
is taken from the price lists, — do not represent any

55 advertising allowanes-that may have been paid back by

*

check; is that right? 8
- [£01914] Mr. Lamb: No, no. These represent the exact

„price, with all invoice allowances on the announcements
and all advertising allowances’ on the announcements. In 5

other ‘words, if a Swiss Miss pie was purchased at that 8

; time, it would ht cal purchased at that price.

Mr. Alioto: W dee May we
- stipulate’ that Phe represent your offering prices, rather

; than prices ‘factually paid by af wholesaler?

5 a e

“Mr. Lamb: That's N N
: „ ee * 6 é :
“(The e. exhibit marked Defendant Pet’s Bait No. A-49
tor iclentifteation was received in evidence.)

Itol. 915] Mr. Billings: Now, your Honor, I aii a aer
_exhihit, which i is Carnation's Exhibit Cd through CN,
“which was prepared by Mr. Zimmerman in the same man-
. wer and 1 wunder if we could have the'ssine stipulation, so
vs won't have to call Mr: Zimmerman back? |

Mr. Alioto: Thess,’ ‘again, are . prices, 5

42 4

8

J

| : : | | | 3 5 {00k
. Ir, Binge: I don’t know whether —— ier: 5
ence; but they were taken from the offering source.
Mr. Alioto: Okay. They were not taken from sourse

— anything actually paid by a wholesaler?’
Mr. Billings: That's correct.

‘Mr. Alito: — join agua, toto

weight, not to admissibility.
The Court: All right. Received, in evidence.

(The exhibit marked Defendant Carnation’s Exhibit No.

C- through CN for identification was en in evi-

°

' denee.) a. 3;
Mr. Lamb: “Your Honor, we haw no further questions

58 o this witness.

Cross exainiiiation.
By Mr. Alioto:

. Q Mr. Zimmerman, the very last N you . |
related to the ber: cent -of oraings to net worth. Was

that it?
A. Yes, sir.

Q. Wotld you be good enough to find the exact page that 5

thats? set out in your Exhibit A-461
(Witness indicates.) |

„. Now, did 1 ‘correctly understand you to say that in
that connection that this is the rate of return—that is, the
rate of earnings to net worth—hased-upon income as ad-
usted by you, rather than income as shown. by the books?

A. Yes, sir.

2. Now, in oonnection with that income adjustment, did - ‘

I farther understand you, did 1 correctly understand you
to say that you took some of the salaries paid to the Rigbys

VVV 0000

po ration?
[fol. 916] A. We reduced the salaries by i

e year 1961, in twelve er thirteen Bosa olay,

*

- and considered that to be part of the retumn on the net oe

worth of the

company.
Qs: “Why. did you réduce. the salatics,: ‘Mr. Zimmerman AS ies

Didn't vou figure that these folks were worth it?
A. This was discussed, and the position we tock was that

a normal Christmas bonus would amount to, at best, one

month's salary; and this ten per cent is even more than

that. The bonuses appeared to me, based up on the net
income as reported by the company, to have a rather direct

relationship to the net earnings of the company for Fed-
eral Income Tax purposes. And for that reason it seemed
fairer, in order to reflect a truer rate of retars, for the

| company to adjust their bonuses.
The Court: ‘T don’t understand that.

By Mr. Alioto:

. Isn't the substance of what you lidve * that these
people weren't worth che salaries they received Now,

isn't that the substance of what you Pare said?
“A. Absolutely Sse ate ms ty

Mr. Lamb: L object to that. That's a characterisation :
Mr. Alioto: Isn't the—- b

The Court: Overruled. ci
The Witness: No, sir, it is not.

By Mr. Alo:

mige saying in ue that he arin ak ee

' unreasonable?
AX No, sir, ‘I am not.

The Court: bet dn pow We dy d a est

relationship to the earnings of the company for Federal
Income Tax purposes “ I don't understand that.

The Witness: Well, your Honor, as the earnings of the {

a eee ee ee ee

ha resort

oa”.

— eT Se

eg 4 . :

The Court: well, sure. When they make more money, d
. they get more bonus. .
The Witness: Yes, sir. But at the dem taka. your

Honor, the increases were to all members of the fainily,
ee [fol. 917] regardless of their tenure with the company.

And they did not appear to be, based upon our examina-
tion of the books and records, upon a relationship between
+ the individual’s tenure or how long he'd been with the com-

pany. -And so—and it’s clearly spelled out, sir, that this is
one dan’ the een e exists in this study. ;

: By Mr. Alioto: aes
. Wal, 11. Per ed that it’s not normal to do
that? Is that it!
A. It is very normal in a closely held corporation, Mr.
Alioto, to adjust bonuses to Federal Tax net income.
Q. And that's what you did! et
A. That's what they did, sir. , 3
— 0 Well, would you be good enough to tell me der
or not it is normal for people to work sixty hours a 06%
as you understand normality? -

Mr. Lamb: I object to the question.

The Court: Overruled. - ‘

The Witness: Sir, who did you say was working sixty
hours a week? 4

By Mr. Alioto:
. 9 Did you make any determination before you arbitra-
rily decided that these folks weren’t worth the salaries

they gave themselves; did you make a ios amet to
determine— a *

Mr. Lamb: I object to that, your Honor,
„The Court: Overruled. p

„ : ‘ * — ,
ö RES 4
* 2 i ’ . *
5 2 ‘ g us 5 7 a Z
0% * a — 8 el oe : „

mene, Rule

9 Did vou make any tavestigation’ to dne how
many hours the members of this . worked in · this

plant: . N
A. As a *thiattar of fact, ais! we were precluded f ‘tins

; asking that type of question

Q. So you didn’t have the jifarmation? eo ae
X I was not allowed it, sir. 0 ee. eae.
Q. Now, were you here in Court whee this onyx

came out as to how many hours these folks worked!

A. I heard some general testimony, sir, about. their
working hours, but I heard nothing specifically directed to

the number of hours any individual worked.

. Now, let's take a look at these salaries and find out
. which one of them you think is excessive. 15 6
A. We had a schedule, sir, showing exactly whose

bonuses were adjusted in there. May I find it for you?

[fol. 918] O. Well, now, first of all, 1957, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7

+8 Rigby family members took. $52,000. That's approxi-

r en (fh Pores f ere years Did you make any

adjustment for that year? ©:

3 ‘A. Sir, the schedule is in chere. If I nity, refer to. it,

Id be glad to answer your question.

Q. Surely, you may refer to anything. And then fust.
‘answer the question as to whether or not you made any
adjustment for that year, when they took an average of
$4,000 a year, these folks sitting there, and their family

members.

. Well, sir, the average is not exactly reflected. Im

sure you understand that. Bryant Rigby took $13,800 that

Fear, and Varona Johnson, who is the daughter of the
family, om hee ie Aegon r re e e veg e

Al right, soos the year 1958 shows 651,000; bee 1,
3, 4, 5, 6, 8 8 88 worked for that yor and got the

Q

615 000, ranging krom the father—thé secchd 5
the

te
j\

Did you regard those salaries as being excessive for

eight people, and therefore make an adjustment!

A. We made no adjustment in the year 1958. :

Q. In 1959, according to your statement, there were 15 *
3 4, 5, 6, 7-8 Rigbys who received $56,000, or an average
of, let's see, that’s $7,000, isn’t it? An average df $7,000.
Did you regard that as excessive, and therefore. make an
adjustment : 115

A. Our total adjustment amounted to $1,785. SAE
LQ. All right. Now, 1959—1960, rather—eight of the

Rigbys received $59,000, a little more than $7,000 a year.
Did you regard that as excessive in connection with these
studies you made? :

Mr. Lamb: If your. 1 please, I object to this ‘ye :
of question, because counsel is averaging it. If he wants

s second generation—$51,000 for eight peo. 2

33 ˙᷑1ʃ eas

sion of this, I’ll have no objection.
The Court: The se owner ate is overruled:

3 By. Mr. Alioto: 75

. Did vou regard that as excessive ‘and make an ad-
justmelk

A. In the vear 1960, the amount of our adjustment was
83,746. cy
[fol. 919}. Q. ‘Now, i in the year 1961, eight of the Rigbys
received $81,000, or an average of approximately 610,000
a year. Did you regard that as excessive and make an
adjustment 1 9 5

A. The amount of our adjustment was $12,552.

Q.. Now, do you know that the president of tlie Pet Milk
Rice is approximately 38 years ‘old? |

No, sir. at

Q. Do you know that the president. of the Pet Milk Com- :
pany is a nephew. of the former president and chairman of
the —

Je

— 0 > oe
.
.
7 3 P 7 — °° 7 8
. , &

A Les. 5
A. How long 1 really don’t remember. I would estimate, eo.
four hours. . : 3

Q. Four hour conference? rites

A. Ten until lunch, and then all 15 —1 really don’t
remember. : :

Q. And then the next sentence is, and Ya like you ‘to
listen to this: “Young agreed to write a letter to each of

kol. 948] the Safeway Divisions requesting help in our
* behalf reemphasizing the advantages and freight 2
dy pooling Pet-Ritz with Bel-Air brand.“

Now, did Young make that. agreement, or didn’t he make
‘that agreement?

A. Young—in the sense of that, or tlie meaning of —.
word “agreed,” this was my hope, and any businessman’s °
hope, to maximize the effectiveness of his operation. And
in talking to Mr. Young, I pointed out to him the benefits
to the Safeway organization and to our company that if
he were to pool products—and I hoped and prayed that he .

. would. give us some support—whether he. gave us support
- * Lhave no way of knowing. He did not agree to write me a
A letter or cohtraet, no, not in the sense of the word “agreed”
there that I think you're trying to imply.
Q. Well, the letter reads the. words are: “Young |
agreed to write a letter.” Now, are yoy telling us now that 7
that really means ‘you hoped he wo Id write a letter? .
A. That's exactly. And I see no g wrong with that.
Q. “Young agreed to write a letter. ” That doesn’t: mean
he agreed to, write a letter! |
a A. Well, I think you are’ playing o on the word “agreed.”
Q. Yes, I surely am. a
A. I would say he “agreed”; I would hope that he would
5 do as I asked him to do. Now, that is his business. 5
ö Q. Then, to go on: “In other words, Young’ will act as
à door opener Ser our sales people, re in the case

„ ͤ ee ee ee

ee ee eee ee ee ee oes *

eee

1988

of. geinch fruit, creams, custards, and 8-inch. fruit, flavors
not produced finder the Safeway Bel Air label. In addition,
Young will encourage the Safeway Sales Division to stock
2 Pet-Ritz “flavors. eres a
Did he agree to encourage them to do that? N a
A. No; I don't think he-agreed. I asked him, and I hoped .
that he would: He might have said to me, I will do every-
thing I can,” I don't know. That wasn’t a contract. You |
don't see his name on there, do ou 9
Q. In addition, Young will encourage the Safeway Sales ,
- Division= *I am reading again. —to stock Pet-Ritz fla-
vors of Sinch fruit pies that are packed under the Bel Air
label, particularly with those divisions that are currently aoe
stocking a pie that competes. with Pet-Rits both i in quality
and price.” ee
Do yom’ ‘remember, having that discussion ‘with Mr.
„ Young
ft 9) i e and I certainly tse 5
Q. You told him you wanted him to use his best effort 5
8 to knock’ the competitive pies ont of Safeway? RT he

Mr. Lamb; I object to that, ‘your Honor.
The Court: Overruled. -
„Mr. Lamb: That isa characterization.
The Court: Overruled. . © ; ae

“By Mr. Alioto: SURE ee ; “ye

, @. vou tell him that, in 8 ani effect?
A. You use the word “knock” a little differently. than P
¥ would like to use it, to answer your nene 11 I may, your
Honor

L

Tube Court Sapa you answer oounsel’s question, and
I am sure he will be 1 252 to let you say anything vou 5
want.

A. All right. 1 asked Mr. 6
eist himself j jn those areas where it would be to our mutual
benefit to feature and to gtock Pet-Ritz pies. Now, whether

8 = reat 2 : J Rh 9

a —

=

5 f
: 5
3 - . ‘ ee A 5 .
* 7
atl = * £ .
: . G os ¢-

he did it is another question. I don’t know. I don’t thin
he did because subsequent to that we lost distribution in

somè areas. Aa | ; nie
Q. The next sentence is: “Young will send me se
’ “Young will send me a blind copy of the letter that goes to
each Safeway Division.“ : ier

Did he say he would, or were you hoping, in some fash-
ion, that he would send it to you? | So a Ne
A. I was hoping, and, in the fashion, I thinlg of an opti-
mistic sgles manager, but he never sent it. el
Mr. Harsha, do you mean to say that you and Young .
didn’t discuss the idea of. sending a blind copy? 3
A. No, we did not. I didn’t, and he didn’t with me. sae
2. How could you have written this thing, “Young will!
gend me, will,send me, a blind copy of the letter that goes
to each Safeway Division”? How could vou have written
— hat if there wasn't some discussion between you and
- . Young about it! 5 A ee
2. It is obvious that we didn’t receive a letter, so there
was nothing to—I got no copy from him, so there was no
agreement. I never received a letter from Mr. Young. Rs
[fol. 950} C. Why a blind copyt . — : Pee:
; A. I suspect Mr. Young doesn't even know.that that
‘memorandum was written to myself. In fact, I know he
doesnt. N . ;
2. I am sure he doesn
it have to be blind? : ;
A. I think this is prudent business. I don’t always send:
letters out in my operation to other people. I think I re-
serve the right to say whether I want to have a blind copy
or not as prudent business. om tes ae
. In other words, was it your hope, as distinguished
from whatever you agreed to, was it your hope that Mr.
Young would conceal from his own personnel: the fact that
he was currently informing you of ‘his efforts by letter?
A. I don't like your selection of the word “conceal,” no.
~ Q. It goes on to say, to complete that sentence, “Young
will send me a blind copy of the letter that goes to each

't. Why a blind copy? Why did
W * :

— r + W e 7 > *
D EE LS

sion on which we need support.“

- 1040
Safeway Division, with the understanding our men ere
‘hot to quote this letter.”
Did you or didnt you have that understanding with
Young? ,
A. We had no agreement as to a letter that was going
to be sent out, in the sense*that you are trying to portray.
Mr. Harsha, the next sentznoe is: „Schenk will ad-
vise as to the sizes and/or flavors by Safeway Sales Divi-
Schenk will advise whom?-
A. I would suspect he would advise Mr. Tobie: 5
Q. Of course. And that was the agreement that you,
Schenk, and Young made at that agreement, ween it?
A. N was no agreement. :

Mr. Lamb: I object.
The Court: The objection is overruled.

By Mr. Alioto:

Q. Now, then, on ‘the. e itself, your counsel asked
you whether or not the Safeway contract had in it an un-
derstanding that Safeway wouldn't deal with competitive
manufacturers on the same fruit flavors with which they
were dealing with you, so far as the Bel Air label was con-
cerned. Do you remember that testimony?

A. No. 4 f
[fo}.. 9511 Q. This morning

A. His discussion with se

Q. Yes. |

A. Yes, I . that. * at
2. You remember that. Is your answer true. that you
didn't have an understanding that Safeway would not deal,

in connection with Bel Air fruit flavors, with competitive
1 manufacturers! ü ee
A. We had no such deal. a
Q. Did you ever sti Sat such discussion? A
A. No.

rs)

— ° - >
. : f 5 .
0 : . * 0
*

1041.
Q. I want to point out in your letter—in your memoran- .
dum, Paragraph B under Discussion of the Contract“
incidentally, where you say, “under discussion of the con-

tract,“ “Young agreed to a renewal of the contract for a
‘period of one year,” I take it that he means he agreed to it:

A. Of renewal of the provisions of the contract.
Q. That doesn’t mean you hoped he .
A. This was the basic contract.
Q. So “agreed” there means what it says? 25
A. To the extent that we had discussed it, but ny the
time you sign a contract and when you agree or discuss,
there is a substantial amount of time. 4
Q. Then you ge on to say, “the,” “General agreement
was reached on all points of the present contract ; excep- -
tion: Modify or eliminate the ne points: No. 1, 3,

a 4,6,10,11.” .

7. Do you know what Point 4 that fed agreed to modify 0 or

‘ . eliminate—do you know what Point 4 was?

R ° *** „ 0 *

A. I don’t—these points, I think, refer to the numbered
points i in the contract, Mr. Alioto. .

By Mr. Alioto:

Q. And doesn’t that Point 4 specifically refer to the sub-
ject matter of whether or not competitive—Safeway. may.
use competitive pie manufacturers under certain: -circum-
stances?

A. I don’t remember the wording * the contract. I
didn’t write it verbatim. 155
[fol. 952] Q. The contract won't help you on that, babe .

‘ 1 is deleted. Let me show you in evidence in this case, as
Plaintiff's Exhibit 42, which is the Safeway contract, effee-
tive as df January 1, 1960, and with it a letter from Mr.
Schenk, | | | —
* * . 95 „

Q. Yes. Now, then, in his letter, which 15 is 17

r talks about Paragraph ‘ of the amended agree-

¢ 8

* fe
“+

1042
ment. Now, you remember that is one of the paragraphs -
on which you say you had general. agreement. se ts
“Paragraph 4 of the amended agreement ”

_ This is his letter to Alan an Young on the date of January
2 and he states : *

An Paragraph 4 of the amended contract we have de-
leted completely the sentence, if seller is unable to deliver
the two million-case quantity, buyer shall have the right.
to procure supplies from other packers i in the amount seller
is unable to deliver. a

Now, do you remember that you 5 that 3

a [fol. 953] A. Not in that conference.

O. With Mr. Schenk in this conference?
A. Not that specific point, I don’t think. I don’t recall
having done it. Maybe Mr. Schenk did.
Q. Do you know anything else No. 4 refers to apt
that same No. 4 in Mr. Schenk’s letter? :
A. No, I don’t.
. Do you remember the spbject matter at eee dis-
- cussed? 5
A. Of the conversation i in general?. 25
Q. The subject matter about other packers 1 able to
do it and the deletion of that particular clause? Be
A. I don’t remember that, no. 1
. You understood that your Safeway Bel Air contracts
on fruit flavors was a total- requirements contract, every-
thing they require you will ne for them ; he understand
that, ‘don’t you? © a a
A. That is not true. 1
Q. Do you know one ‘single packer—let_ me ask you this :

Done single packer during the time of your contract who

supplied Safeway with as much as one pie, a fruit pie, not
pumpkin or mince, with as much as one pie in any Safeway -
store in any part of the United * other than your-
selves? .

1043:

4. Ne, but that T mean that ues didn’t ary to.

C. Is the answer “ng,” that no other packer has during

the life of the contract?

tract with one single fruit pie, and I am excluding pump-

A. They supplied 1 mince, and I don't see
why you should separate them. : —

0 * “ * —— 0 . « *
0 2 N

[fol. 954] By Mr. Alioto:

Q. Mr. Harsha, so we can return to this andert .

and put it in some kind of focus, it is a fact, is it not, that
there has not been one single manufacturer of pies who,
under the Bel Air label, has supplied any Safeway Store
anywhere in the United States during the life of your con-

kin and mince. That is a fact, is it not? And ‘then you can

say anything you want after you state whether or not it
is a fact. ö

A. I don't know whathar that is a fact.

*
Q. Then you think maybe somebody else 70 have

done it, is that it!

A. N. o. As I said, I would be disposed there 125 ;
not been anybody, but you ask as a fact, and I do not know.

. In any event, it is your present testimony that you

don't even remember discussing with Mr. Young the dele- |

„tion of that paragraph that would haye permitted him
under certain circumstances to go, to ether .

A. He has always

Q. You don’t even remember the subject matter?

A. To best of my knowledge he has always—he,
representing Safeway—have always had the right to go

- anyplace to buy anything they want, and I think they

Gf

exercise that right.
[fol. 9551 Q. Why did von insist on deleting the para-
graph, then, which would have given him that right?
A. Iam not sure I. did that specific point. We discussed
it maybe. I don’t remember, Mr. Alioto. »
Q. That is what I am saying, you don’t remember it at
all, 3 is that it?

0 &

88 5
8

A. ‘That has been ailing’ ago, and that is another

reason why I make memos. a a
Q. Is the answer that you don’t remember it at. all:
A. Not the specific details, no.

a Q. Do you remember any discussion about competitive

pie manufacturers? ;

A. No, but if it e in, it came in on fruit requirements
probably. 2
Qi. Now, then, vou were head ou were the superior,

were you not, of a Mr. Dittman, who was here in the court- -
room on Saturday and testified? You were his superior, 7
weren't you!
1 what point in time? I have on several occasions.
Q. Were you his superior i in 19607
A. Yes; I was. ue 2
Q. And were you in 1900 —did you still have ene
jurisdiction in connection with the Safeway contract?
A. Not in the latter stages, no, sir, Mr. Alioto. If you
‘will recall, I was general product mapager of the corpora-
tion at that time: g
Q. At what time f
A. In June, 1960.
Q. Prior to June of 1960 you still had . to do
with the Safeway contract, didn’t yout ;
A. Yes. a
Q. You recognize, don’t you, that the Safeway contract
accounts for approximately 40 per cent 9 your total pie
- production? — .. |
A. I am not aware of that. >
.. Well, do you know what percentage it accounts fort
23 7 No, because I don't keep those figures in my mind.
Those are details that I don’t bother with. I know it rep-
resents a substantial portion of our business, yes.
Q. Did you know about the fact that Mr. Dittman dele-
* gated to Mr. Schenk the responsibility of mains out what
made the Utah Pie Company tick?
A. No, I do not Inow. that. *
. Q. Did he talk to you about it at the time?
A. No, he did not.

8 Me Ra :
-@ * Aa ee * sae ©

2

*

o .

[fol. 956] ray Did the People in “your oxghninnticn ever
discuss with you that your competitive threat o on the ree. —
Vvay contract— a

Mr. Lamb: I object to this, your 3 to ede
threat.” That is a characterization. The record _— that
there was competition for this contact.
The Court: Well, I am going to overrule that objection.
This i is cross-examination.

* „ „ „„ ch Qi

Q. Now, just a few other points I think we can cover

| hurriedly, When you were being asked about whether you

made money or whether you finally came into the black, or
when it was you last money, I want to call your attention

to the interrogatories filed in this case, which I will read,

so there won't be any . apout it, filed by your
company : o

N ational sales of frozen pies are as follows: 1957, two
million one cases; 1958, 2,500,000 cases; 1959, 4, 700, 000
cases; 1960, 4,000,000 cases; 1961, 5,200,000 cases. There
have been no net profits for these years. A gross profit
has been realized for the years in. question, but allocation
of home office expense has resulted f in a negative 8 profit
position.“ f a

4

. [fol 957] N ow, I take it—thiese are the sworn answers

of the Pet Milk Company. I take it that “negativé net
profit position” means loss, is that pierre 4.
A. I would think · so.

5 Q. Yes. And so this shows that even on your 1961, with

five million cases of Pies, that you. § lost money, that is cor-
* isn't it! 0 .

A. Net profit, I pregume. oot

Q. Now, in 1959, in yous annual stockholders report,

the rf statgment fppears:

“The rd sales volume of $190,000, 000 for thes year

- primarily reflected increased sales in the dairy division
and in the Pet-Rits frozen pie line.“ LP

es Bhan it goes on to say: nt ip a ey, ror
Completion of the national introductory program,
-. ‘started with the acquisition of Pet-Ritz in 1955, made pos-
- gible:a. significant reduction in operating expenses relating
tod our frozen pie business. THis,;,combined with increased
sales volume, brought us to the seat cone in our
: n business during 1959,” aie

That statement is not correct, is i, that you broke eben ae

on pies in 19597

A. I think it said “about break-even”, end I would imag-
ine if Price - Waterhouse — that, it would be substan-
tially correct. ii

= This, éuinbined wich increased sal 5 volume, tought.
us to the break-even Lam in: our sire pie business gar

‘ 8 b 5 : b 1
* „ *
Oe 3 9 Ni gh * bd

2 fol. 9581 18 that statement true, or were the interroga- a : :

Rete 5

5 A. think it is substantally true, both of ten.
. Both of the z
A. One is in act dollars and cents, and this is general

iging i in the sense öf the report to the stockholders. _
. Let's see, I think we have your 1959 loss here. |
A. There is your figure. i

ve -@ Presax profits in 1969 cami to a lose of $2000. That
is correct, is it not? tf
ce A That's right. Tt is substantially at a break-even point :

. 62% * * Oy PSS @ ir.
tel 5691 0 ‘You ders saked abont mis That is the rea-
Son I was trying to inquire. You really don’t know any-

thing about how i. —_ system came 1 5 8 . ö

Le Mur Harsha”

ay Ss Yeas Lknow how i xine sont,
22 ow did it come about?
. ee the: natural evolution of jobhing ine, the

: Reed 3 ih

‘A. Teeame bout through the nataral eration 2b
_ Mr. Lamb: Let him fist. =

Mr. Alioto: Im s sorry. I didn’t mean pies” a N

8 (Continuing) Through the normal course, if yon are

relating to any-of the one that was shown or any of these? ie

Fenit {ff Rormaliconrse of ‘business’ that: is: dons; and
freight, economic consideration.

*

[fol, 960 Q. It is a natural evolution, ia that the wey ie

develops t
A. No, it is—yes, it — as a ‘tesult of economic fac-

tors in the market place in terms of your plant in relation- 85

ship to ‘freight, in relationship to the market.

C. And in terms of just copying the Carnation zones, N :

whatever they might be?

A. We aren't interested in ene Oatnation's zones,
any more than I suspect they're interested in ours. Our.
problems are different.

9
Q. In other words, your problems are different. : ‘There.

fore, your zones should be different, shouldn’t they? is
A. Not necessarily. What we do 4 is our business. a

' they do I suspect is theirs.

Q. You copied the Carnation’s 8 rice ‘zones when you

5 started in 1957, didn’t vou

A: Im not 80 sure that that’s the case, no. Pet. Ritz

might have been in the early stages before we acquired
them, might have had his own zones. They might have ac-

Bs quired them. They, too, acquired the pany from Sim-

ple Simon. I don’t know, Mr. Aloto. Em sure we e oe
copy ours from. them. 10
Q. You're sure you didn’t copy ‘fret Carnation?

A. Well, I see no reason to, because our problem- are =

different.
Q. Well, I don’t; either. et me. show yon this letter.
Let me show you this letter. To Minas mane: Cox You

know who orem yout dntdt i
A. Tes. . „
„„ 6? Senacn es ee 5 Big Th e e

‘ Sor
i : 8 e 3 8 >. — * — ae 8 7 .
6. . . . 2 — 1 .
¢ . — ‘ ;
ee 2 5 Se ee ‘ a 4 o
: 2 *
N 3 rt — . 8 8
2 : . 2 N 8 ing 7 2
4 ‘ 7 * Rees

A. II Keil, forthrghty ell you agua, Kd think
our company copied their zones or pricing. -: Boh ae
The zone of che Carnstion in Oregon, Washi. .
ington, Utah, Idaho, Wyoming, West Nebraska, Colorado,

New Mexico, El. Paso, Texas. Your; second zone, as you 5

will see from Plaintiff's Exhibit 39, Oregon, Washington,
Idaho, Utah, west Nebraska, Colorado, New. Meaxieo, EI.
Paso, Texas. It's exactly. the: ane. isn’t, it? eS
A. On that point, Ves. 8
Qi. Their fourth zone is ne — El Paeasinad oth-
ers. Your zone: includes Kansas ity N * Bare a and 4
New Mexico.

A. Did it Wa en in dere toot
Q. Well, your Kansas City—Carnation Company wasn't
manufecturing in the cnstatthinitime,'was itt cat 3

A. I don’t know.

38, and 59 and during the period of time when you Were
head man in your organization, vou don't know that the fa

; Carnation Company’s: only pie manufacturing plant was

in Torranee, near Los Angeles, Oalifornia?: You don’t know
that? 8 ba
A. I didn't know. at that time, no. But it was my ne
standing that they were trying to set up an operation in
Indiana, if memory serves me right. Now, whether they
ever did, I don't know... a

Tou don't ‘now Mat the- CsTüstian C — 15 7 |

- [fol. 962}. 0. Now then, iwe heard a good deal shout in. 5 5
vestment spending. That's a term that Mr. Gamble is quite a

fond of using, isn’t it! Yea 3
4. It’s a term that all of us in our company who are in.
volved in monies and management use quite oft.
Q. And that’s a term, I take it, that you heard a ‘good
„%% A Gebel when pee, attendee
the Management class?
. Tos heard that a number of years, ven, ait art
5 ‘Q. Now, investment spending, as yon stated this morn. 5
ing, means that you're. prepared: to sell at a logs over 4
number of years in order to get a national franchise or
e e ee eee

t does it mann nk
ent in our company, T would never res-
a ee ory that our company would sell at a loss, out- of-
5 pocket loss, would never, because: then there's no hope
your investment spending to ever come back and
make a profit, because if you don't start out with a gross
+ profit, how can you ever hope to end up with one, when
BE Ao then have done your investment: spending? =.
L. I take it now that you’ re talking about gross profits,
aud not net profits?
A. That's exactly. That's what I said.
Q. Okay. And gross profits comprehends that sitions
salary; for example, who works in connection ‘with the com-
pany will be allocated. as an expense? Is that Fight? |
: right. :

„. Tes. For
J H it's . 5
. For example, your’ own er- and Im going to
refrain from asking you what your salary is, however
great the temptation+your own salary,-any work you did
on frozen pies, for’ example, would not be allocated to the
frezen. pie division in determining profits and losses:
That's what you mean nen profit, don't yout
mee exactly ri
Q. And the girls in office, for example, who typed up

hs Phat sould alt eee. eas

3 sha teal nel eee
spending to P

Selling at a wet ¢ loss: over * substantial number an

Pe Te 1
„ r
7 + 5 *

* *
E
e

** *

* e ? . i
—

gt — 1 11 —

. K

+

es the i invoices or worked on the i invoices with the ee cna a

4

4

4

e
That's correct?
A. Right.

[fol: 963] Q. Now, he Gand ‘act 0 way, Wer,

when the Carnation Company was involved, did you, when

you priced your 9. inch pies in connection with Carnation's

pricing, you didn’t have that philosophy then, did yout 3

A. Im not familiar with that.

Q. Well, this exhibit:reads, mis same exhibit bo Miss

Eunice Cox, the attorney in St. Louis, this exhibit reads:

“Since it appears from market studies that Simple Simon
is doing considerable pushing of 9-inch pies at institutional
and restaurant level, we feel that. in order to be competi-

tive and to make a.reasoneble profit on our item, we should
get our pricing along these lines..

Then it sets the pricing. Now, this idea of making 4 ea
* sonable profit right at the beginning with prices like 65.78

i ate: 1 2. which is a high. price compared with what we ve
- heard here 65.78 a dozen —that doesn’t involve invest-

7 ment spending in that sense, does it?

ay? a Total em bate sh Get ihn i, :

a year or two, 33 wet see 3

I says 1957. ee oY

A. Which is two vat; isn’t it?

Well, your investment spending, insofar a as this area

| is concerned, lasted: up until 1961, hasn’t it!

A I’m not sure when we Went in, Mr. Alioto. Twas no not

there when we introduced 9-inch. They varied by product

manufacture of g inch pies.” ?“

A. They might have had them before then. I don’t now.

. Okay. Did you participate in th
this business, conferences within y pect
vou e for

Ane is what Tm trying to say to you. I don’t know. T was |
4 The letter starts out by saying: “Now that us ‘have
production facilities, we feel it advisable to return to the

2

=

es 1052 8 . Bek 3 : : * ; * 75 ce : |
| 2 City? Did you have naying ¢ to do with that busie 2

ie

ness ? : * 5 3 i
- At what point i time? AEG IEE: e .
At any time. * eee scot

A. I have — —(— company in St. 27 .
whenever I vas involved. with my divisien or my job within
the company in all of our finaneial planning, as it pertamed
f do the division that I happen to have been in at that time.
. Then you have sat in on those sessions where on
projected these net losses for specific areas in advance of
actually suffering them? :

A. Planned—we always laid our plans ‘ob objectives, ;
what we wanted to do; the time that it would involve, and
the amount of money that it would cost, and the things

that we would have to do in order to do that, whether that
be four years; five years, two yea: And it Wald packed

by produet line. se 5
| 8 2 964 The Court: Tou une, answered the qnetion

Poe ‘ 55 By Mr. Atioto:

fe

0. No. The question i is, fee you eee .
in those sessions in which your company has directly pro-
5 “jected net losses in connection. with its frozen pie business
in areas throughout the United States, including Salt Lake
Crt er: 8 can . answer that Jes, or no, and then 2
. 1 i.
0. Okay.: You Atal And I take it that: you participated -
tho business decisions in 1958 and 59, which are set
„ testi
Plaintiffs Exhibit 7, 2 you had
nal losses gh | San Francisco sales division, i in your

8 New, 1 . 35353 eee. end te f
trike t it a minute. "You abe fis morning, you rca,

4 oA ger == rs A 7 EE 168. 5
oa eas Met he ae regi 2 r 9
5 r —— s
is the word yon used, - something ere a. poral: or re-

i gional about the frozen pie business: . a

— 0 It lends itselt, does it not, to local . a ie er local
a people entering the business without too much dient: 3
A. That's correct...

. And because of freight factors, if u local company is

‘within. a spécific region, it has an opportunity to prosper |
-. Just in normal business arrangements because of its Local

ity. That's correct, isn't it?

A. It not only has an opportunity, but.through national te
, companies doing what we did, investing money and spend* .
5 ing to build the market, they participate over and beyond ee

| their investment. We make the market, and we hope to
get more than our share, or our share.“ But the regional
always develops or participates i in that, becausg we have
made the market. This is one of the penaltics for national
distribution.
Do vou think that you: 2205 the krosen food market,
or did you get in on à market that was expanding and that
had, T think, in-your language, 8 growth at s dynamic rates
Which was it!
A. I don't think Wee any question about what we
helped substantially to develop it. 41 4 : 92
. In other words, you helped a wave that was already
in existence, but vou didn’t create the wave, did yout eee
A. I think there was very few pie companies at that
ae point, and I would | say we 8 e ee a
.

N
17
e
5
:
“cmb ®
5 0
N

Baie Sut .
* 3 7 cy .
* 8 2 — 8
8 sah *
0 a 5 . a

*

is area a at times than you sold in other areas at exactly
same time, that the natural result of that is to’ wach
the i . :
3 not. s 5
„ I take it nee ee aht the 2
of time when you have been head of this division
there have been different and lower prices in Salt
City than there were at your plants in California?
. Im not familiar with that, because I actually wasn’t
t close to the day to day operation. en e
be expected to be.

You ‘were pretty close to the uu ‘contract,
you? 2
That was a big factor. |
right. . . f
WW

292 0 je Ng 4 „ 2

45 By Alioto:
Q. It's this ne These are called, * “Price Differ-

2

17

-
=

1

7717

z
iit

38.

i

: | ences. Between Pet-Rits Pies, Full trucks, and Bel Air
Pies, dated January 1, 1960. Now, you will-notice that

their apple pie, for Pet-Ritz, the price in Salt Lake’ City
is set out at $2.15, the base price. ,
A. 62.16. 8 | 5
. Salt Laks City, $2.16, Were in Tos Angeles ‘and
San Francisco it's $2.32 a case, or sixteen cents more where

the ‘plant in ‘located, ‘or 42‘cents more a dozen. That's cor- . . 8

rect, is it not?
A. That's what it reads, yes, sir. hae
nd Mami 7m bed nah ta is Coat and

eT al i oy. |
ere and an independent is

dle Iie; hint: that: piles tend dees e bbs

eee front 04858 e b,
it, as distinguished from a $2.32 price? ' 684

[fol. 966] Mr. Lamb: 1 objeot. n calls for a con-

clusion— | ; :
The Witness: I ‘don’t think ‘so, e ee e e,
The Court: Overruled. What was the answer . 8 pea
The Reporter: e 5

By Mr. Alioto: pa

@ Kon ‘wisam thet ah‘ independent, ike the I Pia

} Company is better off with a $2.16 price as against a $2.32
price by, Pet-Ritz? ! i,
| A. I don’t know, what their costs. are.’ And they would

vary by area, would they not?

C Regardless of what the costs are, isn’t it.perfestly .
clear that the Utah Pie Company would be better off com- Se

petitively if it had to compete. against the Californias. price,

Wich was.82-cents a dosen higher than the Salt Lake City
price, which was 32 cents a dozen lower? Isn't it obvious—

A. There isn’t any question about that..

Q. Surely.
A. It would be better if it was 62.80.

. Obviously. So that that difference in price seu make
a competitive, difference, doesn’t it, to the en! lo-

cated in the area where the Price is lower?
A. Yes.

Just one last subject 3 You said, i in connection :

| with the Swiss Miss—now, Swiss Miss is an economy pie

. of 20-ounces that you Ce ee :

488

a as it the purPage of Swiss Miss to compete ag
the national pie labels, or was it the purpose of 8512
to compete against the regional pies?

A It i to com eee ue
Soe at at at wb 5

* 566 : aoe ey | : - | : :

— you this morning to say in your
. answer to Mr. Lamb's question, did I misunder-
bad you when I thought you said that Swiss Miss mainly :
"competes. with the regional pies ?!

‘A. It Talls in that, but it was not—it was designed to
reren S. pie market

dhat existed at that point in time when we made the deci-

dion, Which I think started in mid 59, when we determined

that we were going to go in. And then it took us that long

to move into it, which was in oh
3 GI don’t think, with deference, Mr. . .
an answer to my question. Did you testify this morning

under Mr. Lamb's questioning that Swiss Miss main,

competes with the regional pies?.- © ~
(fol. 967] A. It competes with the economy pride, which
generally speaking are the regional pies. F ee
Okay. 8
Av Kind T think thit’s exactly what 1. n

And 1 take it that the Utah Pie, er W pies" of the 5

tan Pie Company, would come under that definition of the

regional pie, as — from 4 ed cond for

ame? , |

| A. That's correct. Sb tie a. ,
8 Fi e ee bs behalf dr

Se fol-

; ows: 8 ai,

- Direotexamination. ae 5 ate
00 oye By Me Lambs :

ae en Pai ai Ne and.
= sian a

ao * ae a —
. * ur ies" gl 2 * * .

9 . . ‘ 9 y
. oe * 8 8

eee eee e pls
f market was from a period from July of 1958 through ©
August of 1959 and to assist in. determining whether we
; should go into a second brand of pi / baal |
Q. Did you de any ‘other research with regard to.
second brand of pie?. 8
A. Not formal research. We did a great deal of other
economic investigation, looking into the pie business, but
nothing of a formal nature. 8 a

aD Did don erer transmit a copy of this report io’ any
= employee in the Continental Raking: Company?

A. No, sir. re
“Q. Did. you ever LET, of copy of this report to any, :

employee of the Varnation Company! 8 8
5 A No, sir. Ie ; os 5 ee ;

‘ 7 A: : : *. 5 : ö
2 % * 280 . G » 9

- [fol. 969): Mr. Alioto: 123 was ane formally péoeived in fs
evidence. We ask it be received. at this time, that being

the Pet invoices for Utah and California between . =

and June of 1961 of the Swiss Miss label. 4
Mr. Lamb: No objeotion, your Honor.
The Court: Received. 5 th

(The document marked Plaintiff’s Exhibit . 193 for
8 identification was Re aaa eee Tee
[tol 970) H e bathed aa Gehan an!
‘ er spe nada dita ad ecco
| e > 2 5

birest examination.

„

rn e e Let.
coal H. . ARS, ade 8 = Logan,

i, Lamb: an you hae an you hear the witaaset

1 N
*
a3

* Sa Gi
nade 4 * 3 .
x ° : g . :
ee # 5 . aaa Kee , *
— — . ~ 0 . 3
ee outs 8 a : 3 8 .
. ~ o~ ; ie . . 1 *
8 5
r

*

The Court: Ine en tight The witness een

wake enough: noise. Will a lift your'v voice.”

1

5 By Mr. Laub: : 1 5

Dr. Anderson, will you give es Court and jury the

benefit of your chronological—the chronological order of
your educational background! a
A I received my Ph. D degree in Agrisulturel Weondintes

. in’ 1943, became assistant professor at the University of

Wyoming, doing research and teaching in ‘agriculture,
economics, and marketing; went into the Service for two
years, in the Navy; came out of the Navy in 1945 and went
back to the University of Wyoming—excuse me, that was

in 1946. Went back to the University af Wyoming for one

‘year, dnd then moved to Utah State University, in.

„September, 1947, and I have been there since that time in
the department "af. agriculture, economics and marketing,
doing primarily research: in the eld: of agricultural
marketing.

7

. Will you: give us some 4464 of your training and = Se Gy

‘experience in making marketing studies?

A. About two-thirds, @n an average, over this period of
_ time; about two-thirds.of my time has been spent in doing

research work, collecting data from marketing agencies,

in some cases from farmers, concerning marketing prob-

lem dealing primarily with agricultural products.
Q. And how long have you been doing this?

AL Well, since 1943, ve the nien of twa’ years

out for the Service.

Q. Will you identify for us Dr. .
A. Dr. Lambourne is a professor at the University of—
Utch State University. He also received his training in

*

degree from Cornell University. I

the year. was
15. if I. am not mistaken.

Aud he went directly from

een years when N ow © Michi-

.
8

economics and marketing, received his Ph. DP

4

nell te Utah ‘State University in that year, 1947, and
ne has been associated there with the exception 7

10

ben think at smal oollege ere fr about two pr.
time. 8
[fol. 971] Q. Dr: Anderson; ne De Lessbourne-
engaged by the deféndants in this case to make a market-
ing study of frozen pies in the neee arent

A. We were.

2 * U ae oe. 5 5 ow
4. We were asked
By Mr. Lamb: . | |
Q.: Was your ‘compensation: contingent upon the outcome
of what the study might show? ‘ o

A. No, it was not. f ay
. Were yon given full freedom to make this study ee
‘ without interference” by the defendants? = :
. Yes, we were. f a
Q. Were you given any instructions by the defendants
as to how to proceed!
4. No, except some general indications, since this is *
new field for us, the specific area; they indicated at the
outset some of: the manufacturing firms and the .whole-

- Balers in the market. We were concerned with how big a

job this was and about how many people involved, so some
indication of this was given before we started.

Q. ‘Will. you explain to the Court and the jury. the
männer in which you went about making this study?
A. We obtained information from the buyers of fruit
pies in the Intermountain market, wholesale buyers. We
discovered early that there were a relatively small number
of large buyers and that the purchases were rather large,
80 that we immediately decided that there was no point.
in sampling either the firms or the invoices or the data
Which we obtained, so we: set about to get 100 per cent.
compilation of the pie purchases in the Intermountain
market. Of course, we knew full well that there would be
some out of business, and so on, that ‘would. be impossible
to obtain, but this was our goal, to get 1 and

0 i

SE ee ee Be f : 77. 9 OD SCPE AIR FPA SRC ET nee a

z 4 —
— *

we did ‘at our information from thie buyers of the family apple pie flavor, by brands, for the four years.

Mr. Lamb: Mr. Alioto, do you want to see this?

Vr. Aloto: Is that also the same as the o one in the study. f
itself, but just blownup?> ;

Mr. Lamb: That's correct.

Mr. Alioto: We have no objection. *

Mr. Lamb: I offer it in evidence, rent Honor.

The Court: Received.

(The exhibit marked Defendent Pet's Exhibit No. 37
for identification was received in 5 9 85 0 ‘

69 „ 0 „
* *

[fol 9781 By Mr. Lamb:

pr. 19 ‘I show you Defendant Pet's Exhibit |
1.36 for identification and ask you to tell me what that is.

„ tpidiks These are the Pet prices as. obtained from our report,
these médian prices paid by wholesalers for 8-inch frozen

7 apple pie only— this is for . brand for the four-

se Voir dire examination.
ee By Mr. Alioto: . |
Tell me whiat prices are suposed to be represented

5 | [fol. 979] here for the Morton Company in July of 1961.

stead of the $1.28 price that yéu first had down there, and
you got off the books of the 1 is that

2. I got off the—yes.. I'm putting the corrected price,
o they will be comparable with the naher. unaio tan
Mr. Alioto: I’m going to object, if your Honor please,
to the introduction of so visual and graphic a book, which.
is against his very study and in which he finally winds up
putting a figure that a lawyer gives him, outside of his

study. sheet Peat ve: ;
Mr. Schafer: I. think that’s inaccurate.
The Court: I don't think it's inaccurate. * 5
Mr. Schafer: The facts will show that Dr. “Anderson :
checked all the invoices. ; | eee
The Court: Objection zustainetn. ene ß
Mr. Lamb: If your Honor please, may we offer this in
evidence with that exception? aes
Mr. Alioto: I don't know how you can offer that without
exception, unless you take it off. I have no objection— i
The Court: Well, let me excuse the jury for a few
minutes. You haven't been out sincé 2:00 anyway. So don't
talk about the case. * e e
. (Here the jury was dismissed from the courtroom.)
The Court: Now in the first place, Mr. Lamb, you're in
difficulty with that $1.28 and 61.43 price, But your offer
of the exhibit for the balance, excluding this, is bad, be-
cause your accountant who prepared this thing on Mr.
Schafer’s request said he didn’t know whether the others
were right, either. That's what he said. He said he didn't
fol. 980] Mr. Lamb: I didn’t recall that that statement.
had been made. May I ask Dr. Anderson a question, your .

; :

at
ORIEN

Honor? Seeks
The Court: ‘Sure. | RAE ROSE Ries AE
‘y te By Mr. Lamb: % tg 1 | bs of id 1
2. Dr. Anderson, will you state to the Court what this
study is // pits ex ethase aig 5

Ac Tht e de e te plein ue trv Ae 8
. invoices of the wholesale buyers of pies.

. Can you vouch för the accuracy of the abu, that
were taken from those invoices? ? sane |
A. Yes, I san vouch for the accuracy of the data taken,
. but I don’t have any—if I-may just add this explanation—
I don’t have any way of knowing whether they’re delivered
or f.o.b. plant. These are the invoice Prices paid by the
wholesalers. ?

If those invoice prices show delivered prices, that’s shat
we got. And it was only in this Morton’s cae that we made
any adjustment for delivered price, and 1 assumed the

other: prices were delivered prices, -but I can’t, ‘vouch a
- this a hundred per ent.

2 In the case 6f Pet Milk Company, Dr. . were
vou furnished certain invoices that you were unable to
obtain turcagh certain wholesalers - ‘in order to further *
check the acc of your stud}?

A. Yes. We: an LB. M. study from Pet Milk to check
our total sales a :

: 2222 \e mae & 2 *
~ Cotsoquy W ‘Court aND Covent,

‘fol. 983} “Mr. Alioto: Now, the only objection I have. to
this document, it doesn’t actually show the net of anything ;
and that difficulty is not so horrible as counsel says it is,
it they really wanted it done, with all the statistical help ~—
that they have. The difficulty I have is this. When I first:
got this, if your Honor please, we had attached to this study

a map which showed the Frost N' Flame as the lowest in

the market. And it shows Morton jumping in July of, A. sve

*

e eee

spe e

market is represented by your study?

A. Based on checks that we made from both the audit

_ made by Mr. Zimmerman and information supplied by
*. Carnation and by Pet Milk Company, our study includes

85 to 90 per cent of the total market during those four
years. =, 5 : 7. 8

e Anderson, will you give me your professional
opinion as to whether or not that is an adequate sample

from which you as an expert economist can draw certain
conclusions? d e ae

A. It is. 7 We det ee eee

2. Now, Dr. Anderson, will you give us your professional
opinion as to whether or not the frozen fruit pie market

in the Intermountain area was marked by competition? 7

5 A. Tes, sir. It was marked by competition.

Ur. Alioto: That's objected to—excuse me. III make a
& 294117

motion to strike the answer.

= [fol. 1003], The Court: The answer is stricken.

Mr. Alioto: That's objected to on the ground it calls for
the. ultishate conclusion to be made by the jury on a
competitive matter about. which this witness cannot pos-

_ sibly be advised. Now, there's one obvious reason that

counsel knows about. Certain prices are given here by Dr.

Anderson that don't represent the prices at all. As every-

body knows, they represent what's on the invoice. And f
whatever they got back by way of rebates, by way of

allowances or anything else, Dr. Anderson hag absolutely

no knowledge about.: Now, how could. a man be asked a
question of competition or competitive factors, when he

doesn't even know that simple matter? «0

Mr. Lamb:. If your Honor please, I can fully appreciate
Mr. Alioto’s trying to destroy this entire document by

_, constantly referring to prices. My question has not gone to
prices. It has gone to the market share. And I have quali-
. fied Dr. Anderson, with his opinion: that an 85 per cent

7

*

—

ö Sample! is an simost perfect one, and that he as an i expert .

can make some. observations with regard to competition
from the statistics of the total number of frozen pies a
by the three defendants and by the plaintiff in this

He has at no time in answer to the questions referred, to
price.

r. Alioto: Certainly, he can ask: about what documents
may. show, what certain speefie: documents may show; but
to ask the witness whether or not his study of invoices,
which don’t even show the real prices, whether or not the
study of invoices shows competition, competition in the.
market place, when. the witness doesn’t have the back-
ground in the market place other than the study of i invoices,

and Mr. Schafer's telegram these are his souroes—

Mr. Lamb: Let me try one more question.
M. Alioto: The telegram is 125 for identification. This
is the source of his information on Morton.
The Court: Let me see. Let me read this.
Mr. Schafer: Not all of his information.

The Court: Well, now, let's not get into any argument f

about this Now, all I want to dois feed this telegram.
“(The Court examines.) ; at
[fol. 1004] The Court: All right.

Mr. Lamb: oer ed l e 0
a _ the Court that the questions which I am directing toward -

this witness have nothing to do with prices. The questions
that I am limiting myself to, in view of this problem, are
the question of market chare. .

The Court: Well, now, the thing that’s troubling me

and maybe you can direct your questions to this—the thing

that’s troubling me is that Dr. Anderson’s qualifications—
the only qualification he has to speak about chis matter is

derived from the ‘material that vou lawyers supplied him. 8

‘Right? /
Mr. Lamb: Oh, no, your Honor: These data that I speak
of now are data which were res by Dr. Anderson and

Dr. Lambourne. .

*

4

&

e 5
: . ; 5
. 8 R > 8
. 5 :
. 5 . 0 1085
— 1 . 5 — *
5

„be Court: Al richt. Al right. Dr. Anderson and his
staff went around to Ad and to the other people here in
town, and he got some information from them, and he got

some invoices from you folks, and maybe some other in-
formation; but he didn't get all of it, he didn't get all of
it. Now, secondly, Dr. Anderson doesn’t have any personal

knowledge whatsoever about what went on in the market

no idea about that. 5 g
Now, to ask him to give a professional opinion this

. ~ place during the time in question in this lawsuit. He had

ga afternoo on what forces were working in the market place,
and how—and that's what you're getting at—what forces

were working in the market place and how, in the period in
question, in this lawsuit, when he doesn’t have all of the
data on it, is, it seems to. be an improper hypothetical

question. 14110 . :

Mr. Lamb: If your Honor please, may I speak first to
the adequacy of the study itself? The witness testified
that 85 percent is a near perfect sample—or, near perfect

a universe. Normally, economists and statisticiang will

develop a mathematical fo

mla for a random Sample by

5 _- whicl they will select ever so many invoices and reduce it

down to a relatively small number, which, in the |
of an economist, becomes a universe. They know precisely
how many they have tb sample in order to reach the best

conclusion. We didn’t use that sort of a sample here. We

went out and received information from all of the major
buyers in this market and got 85 per cent of the total; and
the reason we know we got 85 per cent of the total is the
fact that—and Im speaking now of the number of - pies
. [fol. 1005] The Court: Have you seen that telegram?.
Mr. Lamb: No. “Hs ath te :
Mr. Alioto: The only basis on which
Mr. Lamb: I’m not talking about prices now.
The Court: You ought to take a look at it.

2

8

A *

1086:

Mr. Alioto: Im talking about share. Im talking about
market share. Instead of getting the market share of
Morton from the invoices which he asked for, he gets them
in a telegram from Mr. Schafer addressed to your associ- |
ate, Mr. Thatcher. I don’t know how you didn’t see that.
II 's addressed to your people.
The Court: Well, now, let's not have any argument
about this. Let's not have any argument about it. I don'ʒt
Want to cut anybody off, particularly you, Mr. Lamb, be-
cause Im thinking about ruling against you, and I want
vou to have every épportunity to say anything you want.
You go right ahead.
Mr. Lamb: Tour Honor, I asked Dr. Anderson—and I
will ask him again, if nécessary—whether or not the
market share data that he had—and I’m not speaking about
prices, Im speaking about the number of dozens and
thousands -of dozens of frozen fruit pies sold in this
market—I asked him whether or not an 85 per cent uni-
verse was an almost perfect one, and he said yes. That
was his answer. Now, I qualified him as a professor, doctor
of philosophy from Utah State ‘University, who is. oompe-
tent to testify with regard to what is a proper universe
kor the determination of an answer to these questions.
Now, instead of using a formula sample, he went out
and surveyed the whole market; and he got 85 per cent of
it, and he was able to heck the accuracy of that 85 per cent
as against an IBM run which we furnished to him. And 1
say, your Honor, that in respect to the market shares as
Feflected by Defendant Pet's Exhibit: A-36, on which there
are no prices at all, that Dr. Anderson in his expert
capacity as an economist can testify as to whether or not
there was competition in this market in view of these
changes that took place in the market from 1958 through
1961. And the question on the Robinson-Patman side of
the subject, your. Honor, is to determine whether or not—
[fol. 1006] The Court: I know. You don't — to x it
out to the jury.

1087

Mr. Lamb: Therefore the element of competition in the
_ market place, as reflected by these data, is relevant, it is

25 material, and it is competent, for an expert to answer

whether or not that picture reflects competition.

Mr. Alioto: If your Honor please, first of all this perfect
universe is 85 per cent predicated upon a telegram sent by
Mr. Schafer—predicated in part upon a telegram sent by
Mr. Schafer. I think the record will show at.this point
that the telegram handed to the court was marked Plain-
tiff’s Exhibit 125 for identification, the telegram which the

court read. I would like to direct a very short voir dire
question to Dr. Anderson about this telegram, if your
_ Honor please. REE We ABS ae tage ;
The Court: Go ahead. |
Mr. Alioto: I don’t think the record shows it.

Voir dire examination.
| By Mr. Alioto: ° f

Q. Dr. Anderson, there came a point where you dis-
covered that the Morton, or the Continental, invoices were
not present at the Wholesale Grocers in Salt Lake City
when you examined their files, that is correct, is it not?

A. That's right. om 3 eure
Q. And as a result of that you made a request of Conti-
nental to produce their invoices to you, is that correct!
A. A request was made by Mr. Thatcher, who had
engaged me to make the study. I did not make the request
personally. 5 * . Ot

Q. Dr. Anderson, it is correct to say, is it not, that you
have been engaged by Continental, by Carnation, and by
Pete: ae es 2

A. That's right. e of e

. And that your compensation, whatever it is—and we
do not ask for it—is coming from all three sources? |
A. That’s right. : :

. So: that when you made the request of Mr. Thatcher 7
to get the Continental i invoices, vou were making a request
of your own elient to give you his own invoices? =

A. This is richt.
N ow, is it a fact that vou were told by Mr. 3

„

who acted asmyour agent, presumably, in contacting

Continental; that: Continental refused to turn their in-
voices over to yout Didn’t he tell you that! 4 f.

Mr. Schafer: ‘Ien’t this eross-examination ?
Lol. 1007 Mr. Alioto: No. This is voir dire.
Te. Court: No, I think we > ought to pursue it.

By Mr. Alioto:

; — turn the invoioe,over to yo, tha
is correct, is it not? f
A. He didn't tell me he had refused them. I don't re-
member him saying this. He aig say—or he sent this
telegram in lieu of it. :
. So that the basis lor the study and the charts that are |
in evidence, so. far as the market share of Continental is
— Fe een
identification 7
, a
2. That incorrect, i it mott
A. Yes. as desks A
„Mr. Alioto: We will offer this telegram, if your Honor
dae iu connection with this voir dire and as a further

ground for our objection.
The Court: Received in evidence.

[ xue document marked Plaintiff's Exhibit No. 125 for
identification was received in evidence.)
Mr. ‘Schafer: I cortaimly want the jury to seo that

telegram,
: Mr. Alioto: I will read the telegram.

23 a 3 : 5

The Court: These interruptions and arguments do not
advance the cause at all. There is no sense in them. We try
to maintain a little serenity in the courtroom here, a little
quiet, a little dignity; and maybe, as a result, there will be
a little light shed, on some of these things, instead of 80
much heat. 5 „ Pie pate |
Now, what do you want? 12 5 ye i 2
Mr. Schafer: Your Honor, I would like to ask the
witness one or two questions right now if I may to clear
up. this latest imputation on my calendar.
The Court: The court isn’t interested in that at this
Mr. Schafer: It goes, your Honor, to the accuracy of
the witness’ study. „%%% ͤ ͤ V
(fol. 1008] The Court: I am not interested a bit in ini-
putations around here. Nobody is concerned with · imputa -
„tions. We are just trying to find out what are the facts,
so we can proceed with the lawsuit. ee.
Mr. Schafer: May I ask then ait ee
The Court: If you are talking about clearing up an
imputation, I am not interested in hearing about it. If you
are talking about voir dire, why, you may proceed. .
Mr. Schafer: Just about two questions on the last
subject matter raised, your Honor. ete
The Court: You ask the question, and we will see where
we go from there = 1 e

Voir dire examination.
: By Mr. Schafer: 5 e onl
Q. First, Mr. Witness, isn’t it a fact that not. only
Morton’s invoices were missing from a couple of these

buyer organizations, but that the invoices of Pet and Car-
nation were also missing? Isn't that true? : ers

The Court: Well, that isn’t helping the cause.
Mr. Schafer: That's what he testified to earlier.

> 5

: ~~
‘By Mr. Schafer:

. Tsn’t that a fact, that the reason you had to get
Associated Grocers’ data from the defendants was that
Associated's invoices had been lost? Isp’t inet correct,
A. That is correct.
Q. Isn't it also a fact, Mr. Witness, that wide your study
was finally done, that it was checked for accuracy against
every single Morton invoice, checked * Mr. r,
isn't that a fact? 0

Mr. Alioto: How do s he ow! ;
The Court: Mr. Thatcher is shaking his head over thane
Maybe you folks ought to get together. I think it is about
time we let these men go to the hotel and-talk to each other.
Mr. Lamb: If your Honor please— f
The Court: In the first place, I am going to clear up the
{fol.1009} record at this juncture, and I am going to
sustain Mr. Alioto’s objection to your question up to date.
Now, after thinking it over overnight, if you want to
come back here and ask questions of your witness, why of
course, nobody is going to stop you. But at this juncture
I am systaining the eee to - questions dsked here

just now.

6 2 r ~*~ f + “rs
2 . * * 1 & .
SS OM eek

—

[fol. 1011] ‘Bois H. ee ‘resumed the stand aay,

testified further as follows:

ä of:
Direet Aline bm.

By Mr. Lamb (continued): " pi

Foa

training and ¢gperience in the field of economics and mar-
keting, both generally and also as relate to the prepa -
ration and use of studies such as the one you have made

4

n 0 ° a . *
° 4 5 8
’ 2 „

0

A. As I indicated, and perhaps ‘needn’t repeat in detail,
J have been trained in the field of economies, marketing,
and statistics, and have had experience in this area for the
last twenty years. 1943 was the time that I received my
Ph.D, degree. I had two years out in this time in the
Service, as I indicated. n thet Of ah k all.
My training consisted of taking courses in these three
areas of statistics, economics, that is, economic principles
and theory, and marketing principlés ‘and theory.
Mx experience has been along these same lines, in doing.
research work. At least two-thirds of my working time
has been spent in research activities where I have dealt
with many commodities, agricultural commodities in par-
ticular, some of these raw materials, some. of them have
been ready for the consumer, that is, processed agricul-
tural commodities. And my experience here has taken me
into the areas of collecting factual information, collecting
data, analyzing these data, to show trends, to show rela-
_ tionships between prices and quantities and such things,
and then, in addition to this, interpreting the data and
writing reports which have been published as Experiment
Station bulletins at Utah State University. .
I could indicate titles of such publications, which indi-
. eates the nature of the work and the products I have
worked with. I could just mention these briefly. Ihave —
worked primarily with poultry products, chickens, eggs,
turkeys, also worked on a project of wool marketing, one.
of alfalfa hay marketing. And these studies have permit-
ted me to collect the facts, to interpret the data, to analyze oe
the data, and to form opinions regarding the relationships,
and so on, involved, = : int
.. What is the nature of the conclusions you can draw -
as such an expert from such a study, without at this tim ‘
stating any conclusions. you may have drawn! * cE
A. Well, getting information on any commodity, deal-
ing with production or consumption or sales and prices, it
is possible to take these kind of data, to correlate them, to 3

1092 N 9
_ [¥ol. 1012] relate price changes with quantity changes, to
plot and measure trends in production and trends in prices
and draw conclusions with respect to causal relationships
between these kinds of statistical measurements.
Q. Have your studies and experience included study and
éxperience as to the nature and characteristics of a free
enterprise market economy as it spate to commodities i in
trade generally and pies in
A. Yes. erer
with some kind of criteria, some model, if you will—we
call it a model from which we hypothesize the problem
to be analyzed.
We start, of course, in our economy with the competitive
model. This is the kind of economy in which we operate,
so we begin with the economic model as a firm in competi-
tion, and then, as we.collect data about. the-market of any
particular commodity, we can fit it into the model and
draw conclusions as to whether the market for the particu-
lar commodity is competitive, whether it’s—there are ele-
ments of what we call imperfect competition which, leading
to the extreme, would be elements of monopoly involved.
| This is as it applies, it seems to me, to any commodity |
and it particularly could apply to frozen pie in the Inter-
mountain market. |
Q. Dr. Anderson, since you, left the court yesterday have
vou had an opportunity to inspect the invoices of the Mor-
ton Company? |
A. Yes, I have. Last nicht I went over all of the invoices
that they submitted on their sales in this market.
Q. Did you have an opportunity to check all of the prices |
as against the data which you collected? —
A. Les. I saw the prices on these invoices. I didn't
have time to incorporate the additional invoices on prices
into the price data that were submitted yesterday. The
only addition involved here would be some additional
ee when data were available. ‘
you recall, some of the months on the Morton Pie 5
Company did wis * price data until we saw these in-

1098

ee, —

voiees last night. We, with additional time, could pinpoint
some additional months, but the same general trends of
prices should prevail. 2 beeen] 1 de
Q. Now, I show you Pet's Exhibit A-35 for identification .
which is in evidence and turn to Page 15 and ask you
whether or not you would like to have changed that docu-
ment; J ask you if you have changed it as a result of the
inspection of the invoioes last night. a an
[fol. 1013] A. Yes. The one price that was of concern yes-
terday was this price of July, 1961 where he had an aver
age or a range in prices from $1.28 per case to $2.61 per
‘case. We had two observations only. Our method of get-
ting this general level of prices that I described yesterday
Was to take the number of observations that we had and to
statistically get at some measure of central tendency here
to indicate the level of price. Now, when it was called to
our attention that this price of $2.61 was unreasonable, .
we did take a look at the invoice. We got the particular
invoice that this was concerned with and found that an
error had been made. In any kind of statistical study
you're always looking for any possible errors and willing
to change errors, but not to change procedures and method.
But we found that-this was a price quotation for a per
dozen pies rather than per case of six. Morton’s pies come
in lots af a donen. Some others come in sixes, and this was
an error on our part. So we would change that price down
to instead of $2.61 it would be $1.31 or $1.30% for per
case of six. Ryd 83 7
_ Q. Well, then, what does the range show now? |
A. The range now shows $1.28 to $1.31 with a median as
we used in our procedures of 61.29. And this represents
then the invoice price, and we have changed my chart to
reflect the price of 61.29. m rah

Mr. Lamb: If your Honor please, we would like to have
permission to correct Pet’s Exhibit A-35 in evidence to

conform with the testimony of Dr. Anderson.

Mr. Alioto: No objection.
The Court: All right.

%%

*

ed plate nB ise ie SS noid
Q. Dr. Anderson, I now show you Pet's. Exhibit 4
8 identification and ask you whether or not you have

made corrections i in this.chart to reflect the error you mae
discovered f

A. Yes, I have. a +
_ ee Sni + adie 2 n
[fol. 1014] : Voir dire examination |
3 By Mr. Alioto: ’ e 8 :

Q. With respect to this exhibit which i is 4.38 for identi-
fication, Dr. Anderson —never mind your turning it around,
Mr. far as the. Pet-Ritz and the Simple Simon
and Air prices are concerned and even the Swiss
Miss prices, so far as they are concerned, Dr. Anderson, it
is a fact, is it not, that those do not represent actually
what these wholesalers paid, actually paid mipus any ad-
vertising allowances they may have been given at the time;
that's right, isn't it? 8

A. No. They do indlude the advertising allowances as
shown on the invoices in addition to—in addition tg. This

the wholesalers file with their invoices any credit. emos

which indicate advertising allowances, and these are usu-

_ ally—it’s their: practice to clip these right. on the invoice.
And when we took these data from the invoices the prices.
were corrected for all of the advertising and other off-

invoice allowances that were present in the file. We admit

chat in some cases the advertising—or the credit memo

„ Was not yet applied for or was not in there on some i invoices

and this accounts, for some of the variation that we found
in our average prices. But again, when we used the method
‘that we did to determine these average prices we were
eliminating these extremes both high and low, and we are
representing these prices as not the—necessarily these
highest or lowest prices in any 1 8 because we have an

| | 7 100%
average for a month. This is what we have submitted here

and represented these to be and not showing daily changes.

. In other words, it's perfectly clear, is it not, Dr.
Anderson, that any advertising allowances which were, in
fact, given but not clipped to the invoices are not reflected
on this chart at all © - >). 04,
A. They may not have been taken at all. ‘They may not
have been applied for so this would still represent what
the wholesaler paid for the pie. He possibly did not adver-
tise and, therefore, conform and get the allowance that he
could have had had he applied for it. And-in this case it
wouldn't be in there and wouldn't suggest the— N
Q. Well, on the assumption that he was the kind of a
wholesaler who if he had a chance · to get a rebate from
advertising or for any reason, on the assumption that che
was the kind of a wholesaler who would take: the money

that they were offering to him and he got that money, on
that assumption it wouldn't be on the chart, would it; on
the assumption that he was the kind who would take the .
money that was offered to him wouldn’t it be on the chart?
. A. It would be on the chart if he would take this money
he paid then an amount less the allowance that was sup-
plied him. hme oh 11

kol. 1015. Q. Dr. Anderson, weren’t you in court yester-

day when Mr. Harsha testified on the advertising allow-
Q. Do you remember his saying that it would be almost
impossible to trace the e allowances given to
specific invoices ? „ Bhar oy
A. These wholegalers happen to keep these in their files
along with, and attach them to, the very invoices to which
they do apply. It may be more difficult for the—I’m not
sure of it. It may be more difficult for the seller of pies, .

* 0
r

* 5 * ‘ ee
8 ‘ F 8 . 7 -
* e 2 . .
5 a 1097
: . G 4 f
o

Q. Then you are telling me that this thing is exact in -
' reflecting all of the advertising allowances that were given
‘to these wholesalers by Lae client, is that what you're

now saying? .
* [fol. 1016} A. I’m saying that to the extent that these

advertising allowan¢es were clipped to, in the case of the 2

wholesalers, and that were supplied by the clients indicat-
ing advertising allowances made available to the buyers.

- Q. Dr. Anderson, perhaps I’m not poopy baker very
cleat. First of all, let's start at this point I under-
stoed you to testify—now, maybe I’m mistaken—that this
chart of yours does not reflect all of the advertising allow-
anees that were in fact given by your client to these whole-

salers, is that correct?

A. They are all in there to the extent that it’s possible
to get them in there. f
_ , Q. All right. Now, regardless of possibilities or any-
ae thing else, can’t you tell us whether you know that that

chart in fact does not set out all of the advertising allow-

ances given by: your clients to these en do you
know that?

A. We took a count of every one that was given to us,

therefore, J don’t know of any that we did not account for.

I don’t know of any that were given that we didn't account
for in the chart.
Q. Well, did you determine whether there were any that

are not accounted for in the invoices? ,

A. ‘Trying to get all of them, I'd any that I tried to get
all of them if a—and if there were some that we didn’t get,
I didn’t know about because I didn’t see them.. Otherwise
I would have taken them into account. |
Q. Just one last thing. This Swiss Miss price, is this

somé kind of an, adjusted price, this Swiss Miss price?

A. The Swiss Miss price was calculated exactly the same

as the others and does not represent, as I indicated, any,

day to day fuctuations, but represents an average of the
5 * who — Swiss Miss for ay, month:

Q: Did zo bes that study that was d by Me Lamb
yesterday indicating that Swiss Miss was consistently be-

low the Utah--that is the Utah Pie label did you see that

study that was put in yesterday by Mr. Lamb?

A. I was not in the courtroom when that was pice
. Well, then, you didn’t see it? ent. 2
A. No. N 110

. * * Shek, * * *
. 7 \

5 fol 10 ~~ Voir dire examination.

2

By Mr. Schafer: . N

Q. Dr. Anderson, am 1 correct in ente that

now this purports to report what the prices were
for the various brands simply as . reflected on the, invoices
that you studied? —

A. That is correct.

Q. Am I correct in. understanding, Dr. Anderson, that
yesterday the chart that you offered the purpose of that
chart was to report what you understood to be the f. o. b.
Salt Lake City pricing on -these brands ,

‘A. This was what I purported them to be. I long ago
learned that you can't add peanuts to walnuts and come
out with peanuts, so I tried to make it comparable in terms

of point, and I was—had some information shown me which
indicated that there were some differences in the point of ©

pricing on the Morton pie, particularly
Q. Doctor, I am just asking—

A. (Continuing) —the last few years, = 80 1 did try

to represent this as f. o.b. Salt Lake in all cases.
Q. And now the chart that is being reoffered today does

not purport to take inte account whether it is f. o. b. Cali-
fornia or f. o. b. Salt Lake City, am 1 correct in that under- 7
standing: 32 =
A. That's right. It purports to ‘a what e invoice
a prices beanie: the prices paid by wholesalers.

Serre

Direct examination.
By Mr. Lamb (Continued): 4155
Q. Dr. Anderson, will you tell the Court and the jury
what criteria do you use to determine whether or not there
is competition in the market! “fe 555
A. Well, as an economist, there are several measures
which we consider in determining whether. a market is
competitive-or not, whether it meets the conditions of what .
we call perfect competition, or whether there are elements
of imperfect competition. 7 5 8
The first of these—I will just briefly list them ahd then
try to develop tiem further —the first of these would be a
criteria of the number of firms and brands of a product -
being sold in the market. This is an evidence of perfect
competition if you have a large number of sellers. © ~-
Another eriteria would be the relative importance of
these sellers in terms of how they share the market, how
fol. 1018] large is one in comparison with another. This .
tends to give equal bargaining power. So the economist
says that in a market where the sellers are relatively equal
in their bargaining power, then we have the characteristic
of a perfect competition. To the extent that there are some
firms that are larger than others or some firms that are
smaller, then we have some elements of imperfect com
petition. . "bite PO eet Sie LE
A third factor of measuring the nature of competition
in a market would be the ease of entry. A good deal has
been said about this already, but if the product is of a
nature that it's easy for firnis to come in and manufacture
this product, then this, in itself, implies a good deal of
‘competition in the market, because, if one firm leaves,
another can come in and pick up and produce the product.
A fourth factor in what I would call perfect competition,
or a high degree of competition, would be a tendency _
toward uniform price. Now, this one, is kind of a double.
edged factor, because a monopoly price is a single price,

*
*

*
4 ‘
2 —
—

33

1100

—

but a price in 0 e e which we have many -.
products in agriculture, -of raw materials, we only have

one price here, and yet it is very ‘competitive. Se this one

is a little bit of a problem unless you understand the na-
ture of the particular product, but a tendency toward uni-

form price is another measure of Fompetition.
And the fifth factor I would name would be the fact that

in a competitive market absence of conspiracy, collusion, -
on the part of any of the buyers or of any of the sellers’
would be an indication of a high degree of competition.

* would say those five factors.
0 2959 22 * o 8 2

ea [fol. 1019] (The document marked Defendant Pet's Ex-
. hibit A-38 for identification was received in evidemee.)

Mr. Lamb: Thank you, your Honor. 1
By Mr. Lamb: 5

2. Dr. Anderson, you are fully an der with Pet's Ex. N

hibits A-36, A-37; and A-38. I would like to ask you this

question: Do these data hade significance respecting the

activity of the Frozen pie market in this area:
A. Yes. I think that they do. g
. Can you then, as an expert, explain this significance,

~

illustrating your testimony from the charts that are in

evidence?

A. Lwould be happy to try to. I would like to see the—

ie both of the charts, the volume charts and the—particularly
the one on apple, because we do have just the apple prices.

„This should be noted, that these are prices only for apple

oor ETL Ge Or 222 2 *

A, I think there is no question that there are some evi-

dences here of changes in market shares that correlate .

very closely with the price changes year by year. Of

course, many of these price changes take places in mid

year, and so on, and we are e representing only the shares,

a

*
. 1
0
4
2 — ° 5
. 0 .
/ 4
5 F 8

—
7
. 8 ve

2
>. *
2 .
D ee b

1 0¹

5 or the sales for the whole period. This would make the
correlation less than perfect, but I think we can see what

has happened in the chse of following through some of these

individual price changes on this chart, oompared with the
volume changes on this exhibit. nn

We can take these brand by brand would be perhaps
way to do it: Let's start with the Pet-Ritz brand.
Pet-Ritz in the 1958 year was priced at about 2.50 per

six-pie case. In that year Pet-Ritz enjoyed this blue, 3.3
thousands of dozens out of a market of 17.6. ined

(fol. 1020] The next year, or just in the latter months of

that year, Pet-Ritz reduced its price to a little below 225, lLl

coming nearer to the other confpetitors in the market. And 5

in 1959 they enjoyed 4.9 thousands of dozens out of 41,000.

Now, that was not an inerease comparable with the mar-

ket or the of apple pie in the market, as you can
see. - That a very rapid total inerease.

Anothe evidence of the well, let's follow the Pet-Ritz

richt through, if you will. Coming over now the year
1960, Pet redueed priees for a short period and then in-

creased them to the end of the year, and you will

'. notiee that Pet-Ritz went down from 3.1, reducing

in actual ‘dozens sold and, of course, in per cent of the

ae market would have gone down very drastically.

1,

And the same was true for 1961 when Pet again retained |

a high price of 2.25, and the volume of sales dropped cler
to 1%.. They were practically, let's say, priced out of the
market. 5 i

Let's follow through Pet’s contract with Bel Air, Which f

came inte existence, as you know, in 1959 and was priced

just about equal with the Utah brand, beginning in that
year. And you see what a share of the market they en-
joyed that first year in the Bel Air brand manufactured

by ‘Pet. They got 9.7 thousand dozens out of 41. They

retained this same competitive price situation throughout

the period generally, but this was not to last consistently. It _
didn’t grow with the market, even though they were com-

petitive. They enjoyed some growth in 1960. They got up

* N N

*

gee eA |
R 9

to 14,000, and then went down to 8.7 thousand dozens,
which percentage wise would give them a smaller share.
Now, we can take other individual brands. Let's take
Simple Simon, for example. At the same time, or approxi-
mately the same time, that Pet-Ritz reduced its price,
Simple Simon reduced about the same amount, down to.
2.25, and they enjoyed an increase from this year to this
year (indiating 24 up to 3.2 thousands of dozens.
_ ‘Then the féllowing year they came down even further
than Pet had to a point within approximately 5 cents per
case, 5 to 6 cents, of the Utah brand, and this year their
sales increased to 842 thousand dozens out of 70,000. This
was a more than proportionate increase. They enjoyed, if
I recall, from about 8 per cent of the total market—now,
on the apple I would have-to check these figures, but on
total market from 8 up to about 12 per cent of the total
„ „ famwiot. i.
we & [kol. 1021 Then from that 8 on Simple Simon again,
the Carnation Company, maintained a relatively high price
and enjoyed a smaller share of the Market, 6.9 thousand
dozens out of approximately 100,000 dozens. |
Let's take the example of the Utah pie. Utah was priced
here at semething like 45 cents below thése other two, and
they enjoyed a big share of the market in 1958. They had
10.3 thousand dozens out of 17.6. On apple pie I don't
know how this figures out. On total share of the market it
was about two-thirds. The exact figure here could be
caleulated.
Then from then on they. they decreased the price
of this pie somewhat in 15 . They increased sales only
Slightly here, not 1 as much as the growth of the
ö market.
And the next year, maintaining this same price. level,
. they lost sales in spite of the rapid growth in the market.
They reduced prices again in 1961, and. their share in-
2 creased again in 1961. But some other factors have been
involved here withethe Utah Pie Company, because they .
introduced their Frost N' Flame brand in 1960. -It was

. i ’ . 1 P . 5 f late
ae aie „ e
Priced down around 61.50 per six-pie case, and that year
they enjoyed 15.1 thousand dozens, a very healthy portion
of this market. avec gu ”
They continued this price and even reduted it some in
1961, and their sales went up to 25.9 thousand dozens out
of 100,000, about one-fourth of the market. be; tints
I should mention Swiss Miss ang their introduction by
Pet in the summer of 1960. This, as you have already been
told, is. an economy pie, a 20-ounce pie, and this price rep-
resents the price of the 20-ounce pie. No adjustment has
been made for the size of pie. We felt that consumers buy
pie as pie, and not by the ounce. This is.a very unique.
. product perhaps in the fact that size is measured in both
diameter and ounces per pie, and thé consumer perhaps is
not fully aware-that when they buy an inch pie they
have the alternative of getting just a 20-ounce pie or a
24-ounce pie. But, in spite of thath Swiss Miss was priced
here at a price about midway between Frost N- Plame and
the Utah and Bel Air brand, and enjoyed a very substan-
tial part df the market. . a issn
[fol. 1022] The Swiss Miss is the. green, 6.4 per cent this
year, even though they didn’t start. until the latter half of
the year. They maintained thig general price level for 1
1961 and enjoyed 16.3 3 out of 100,000 in
1961. A very substantial growth due to the fact that they
were priced relatively low in the market. |
he other example I would like to point to would be the
Morton Pie Company, who, in the year 1958—bear in mind .
this is the company where we had limited wiimber of ob-
servations to indicate a trend in. price, but in 1958 r
were the highest priced pie and, by the way, it was a 21.
“ounce pie at that time. They enjoyed a very small per-
centagé of the market,. 2. This would be .2 of a thousand
_ dozens out of the 17.6. RE of beton
The- did reduce price somewhat in 59. They did in-
crease their share somewhat, up to 1.9 thousand dozens.’ _
They pri&ctically—didn’t have a large number of sales in,
1960 and really don't have very good prices until the last
2 ; 4

‘of 1060 and in 61, and it was: thin period de tins

. Gid: reduee quite drastically the prioes at, which ‘they. sold

their pie, and they did N their sales of apple ‘pie
to 147. i
Now, this: is n 0b. 0871 is more aqoctheginic really: han
their share of the total market, which comes to about 8

per cent, as I remember, of the market, ande I have for- |

. how many thousand dozens, but this is not Per cent.
a is 14,000 dozens: out of 100,000 dozens: :
8 e eee,
time, and te market shares are highly correlated with the 8

~ price changes that have taken place in the market as rep. i
5 weramted by tho average wholesale prices.

Dr. Anderson, based on your analysis, have ‘you
NS reathed any: ‘conclusions with respect to whether or not
‘ there has been any lessening of competit:. a in this market?
. Tes. Based on these general principles, these eco-
nomie me „ by which competition might be meas-
ort would say: measured, I have reached the
that in general, taking the general ‘first, that

degree of competition in the market, sh the latter years;

, 1960.61, as compared with 58.59

Mo ty-topinpaint thin ins to, av unas fete,
5 during the 1958 year there were seven: manufaoture in
kol. 1023] — — tod wer ineve’
on the chart plus some others that are included in “All
Others There were three additional: firms. They’ ‘had
CCC .
7 in 1960; ee Era, there were stil seven firms, bat one
———— —„—

8 —— to ba'iore-ootnpetitive, Have « higher 85

In 1960 the number of manufacturers had increased to oe

wre, and, the: sumber' of brands they were-selling had
. imereased to 12 gad BA 55
= E od/amantfucteirere tetnaliy declined |

benen the amber of brands neee 70 13 80 based’.
on this measure of number of brands competing in the

FF the market, wet

50
2

orale ai tink 6 debe ut obiljtitioe: ds Urte Bs
measure in 1960 and 1961 than is true in 1950 anf 1989.
Now, take the factor of relative tinportaned” of- these’.
firms and brands in the market. We havs already been
ay: through this in ‘some detail. Tou can see from the chart;
from: the erhibit, that these 18 brandz, 12 or 180 in the“

—

ears 60 and 61 de share the market rélatively:equally;? - —/_
although some of the other brands in there thut we havent
a that we put in this All Others“ category; had very small ae
volume of sales. But of the major brands involved, none ;

had mare than about—in the total market, I think it was
about 22 per cent. No brand enjoyed more thun this; and epee
on a firm basis, no firm enjoyed: more than 45 ent.
Loontend there ig a good deal of competiti n. between a
brands even of the same firm, because -customiérs gener. ae
ally, consumers, are not aware of who makes the 1 .

‘>

brands, Who makes Swiss Miss. This is available de them,

bot they don't: generally; T think, avail thenitelvewof tis!

or are not concerned with this. problem. Hoi iH N
On the matter of case of entry, much has bob Bald uhoht-
this, and. T would ‘like ‘to indieate ‘only one ‘additional: ob-

> -s@rvation: that was madé: in our ‘eollecting of chese data,

in trying to find who the buyer or who the sellers were 85
among: these wholesalers; who sells ‘pie. in the market, We

toundſi these other firms, for izist Land I could name
several of them—Libby’s, i n.8, Werner emden
2 F 5

In getting information about these Arme * 85
they did in fact sell pie to these wholesalers; we found that

5 these firme are selling other products to these ‘wholesalers!

(fol. 104 Ten are selling: meat pies, they ure selling all
kinds of, fond products. They are in the market. It is not
as:thongh they are just not around: They are here sod
ready to sell. 3 fs

ee ed deo are H at

„ am 8
Sree dar bares ber en dec tl

. * . . nia 0 8
* 5 2 ° ce Ap
¢ A ; - 4 ie „5 8
= ‘ * 0 4
8 7 . 4 e : 7 3 ae
*

a?

5 . d > x 8 . 5 N
a ; g 4
8 8 2 2 5 a Z 5
; — > N — 2 « a
2 . 0 °
* > =. - . ye 8 d 0
« l 5

. CCC ͤꝛK iRindudivebion ier
dan meetithe competition. So I would say this kind of ease
3 ol entry illustrates: high degree of competition.
. .. -giswonldn’t say that it was particularly greater in te

en than it was in 58 and 59, but this is a fat
‘a t. dais product, the nature of its production, the fact
ce that it is a product that can be manufactured without
large investment of capital; without particularly skilled
5 w.. ͤ e 0 5
N into Done 8
But ches — sy tendency. to. wniform price, L
. t deal about this. IJ think the chart speaks-
W tor dinalz, Perhaps yon say the price variation is
* “greater: in the latter years, and: would say that is what ~~
the chart shows, except again remember that the Simple
Simon and the Pet, Rita represent nom a very, or fairly):
3 ‘sraall percentage: of his. market, and 8 the bulk of sales
do lis down in this general ares of the say, an average of
Syiss Mise, from there up to Btah Pie) down 0 Morton’s

1 ost. N Flame! This is the bulk of sales inking plaee
N A ay weston) eg eee ult :
St ad i nnn

a based on weight
ppurmbé me indent toward a taiform pris which
nde indi 1 8 or W r in the: market.

a Dr. Kudersonn (tte; 10

ne e dibdtion 4-1

seg e e ee that is with respeet to

Folien in the ‘market-or Conspiracy on the part iof several
. 3 eee ont bythe: ‘timing: of

nee From the data — load you to conclude
on. oF. , CONBPITACY, 9% 5" REISE ls a 00 TR

aS : ME Ath 4 0 1 einai 1 10 ee i
: UTNE: mere sisi te ds A et, ash}, gi Fe A en 0”,

L 2 ¹ 842

1 A: (Continuing) . trom the; pet 1 —

i

2 ö s 2 e 8 . mere
27 . * . e

/ * . N : 0 2 3 5 ‘ 1
af 5 — F . = : 3 > ’
9 .

Mr. Auoto: Excuse me. ni Han MAURER
dhe Court: The motion is pen age n woah dale bi Ree tS
Ar- Alete: make amotio to irh...
She Coneks ‘The zer is ade to dur dane. 8 85
: it. i ee was r i. 398 7
A ‘Aliotas, ecient 46; ie 2 9 vain
Mr. Lamb: F i
‘The Court: know. ee The jury i —
| instructed rea ETE et it. ee l al

0 ‘Dr: Ril, 1 as one more e ge 14 . to.
ask you! ‘T’stiow you Plaintiff's Exhibit 96 in ‘evidence and on
ask you to take a Took at that. Have ‘you cai — oe
- tabulation?’ * side 55

X Les. Len repro en ge beute n.,

1 sited ae 5 Re 2 7 7 42 . e re „ st Pas.
‘ita 10250 By Mr. Lamb: rapes stag

0. Now, JC
the Utah Pie Company as, indicated,in the caption of every-

— thing, except private labeled business sold 70 per cent’ of
nl Pn le inane a nm apn ie Sed ‘The

| on bo on eatin ek
hypothesis consistent with the . — of competition?
„„ nn ee
labels? Is this only— g iS
. The private labels are not ine Pe

ok

A. Are not included: : Ta this the Bel Ar only or’ do
this include others that I urine’ ee —
8. shiag- study includes Carnation 3

. Continental Baking’ Company ' Morton, Pet un

der-

9

4 That did not include Frost he nang W hes |
nat does not inelude Frost N' Flame, does nb

"include Swiss Miss, does not inelude Bel Air or either of
the Utah brand or of the Pet brand.

PF e

; particular percentage of a market that it happens to enjoy

in any given year for any other period of time. he com- «

petitive system itself implies that firms producing ‘the .
product are engaged, in striving Se ig nye ee
with their merchandise. And the fact that

—_ percent of the ‘market in one vent implied’ that 4 ee
did please const ners, and that oe endl Cah py SRT
lis does not -Z ve ther 77 any right to a particular Pee N ö
Be ( this market at any other time.

W, Di Anderson, this ep. shows that 3
E 1 marke in 1956, 1957, 1958,
1959, 1960, nd 1961. The plaintiff has sought to select
1958 as n base Fear. Will you tell us as an expert statisti-

oe 227! Cc

a pro} eee 1 ah BEE ee

rf bes a!

é we ee zur Beer.
5 a 225 8 i 7

. 2 oto: 4 2 t 9
I J
‘ile: You're asking mei Sins soy aaf sree ;

. R ok du nid l
partake thet ‘year, didn't vou ayaa n ae
n year shonld he haves seledtedt: nid

A. 1 say, if, oun ering ret ora through’

fol. 1028 A. I'd have to say

.
s = *
*

.

Lae ed 8 . sot ought took ei

all the years and determine whether an average of the .

group would be a better representation of normialey or

whether some other individual year is more representativo

3
sold.

0 What year should he n eclectd t goon
A. 1 wonld say on u period of this short of t ns would

be inlined to 4 an-average of « group of years, not a 2

dinge rear, as a base: * f
. What ear should he h B tuen! Ae Ra
. You could average the whole period and say that this

~ represents what they enjoyed for the whole period. Now,

how do their year by year changes relate to the average

: for the whole period? ,

.Q. Dr, Anderson, do you know anything at all ubout the

proof,.of damages. in antitrust cases? f/
A. I think I know something about them. 7 ii
— ed Have you ever read on the Were, matter ve
A I have. ; 2
Q.: What have: you-readt:. 21 9

ee e all the bald, tharketig tite Pet out by f

Phillips and ‘Duncan, Converse and Hugey, and Maynard

Br a ee
principles of antitrust— 3
„Q. Specifieally with respect. to proof of damages |
A. The Robinson-Patmen amendment and this sort of
thing, and 1 don't pose as an expert in this field. I haven't
posed as an expert in the field of—

e er ond yoni. du na pep un hn Gpert in d,
e
under che antitrust laws, is that correct! |

Mr. Alioto: 1 make 4 ‘motion tt
. er cae to ie erry exhibit i 18

"gf idadesine:totbuilaan ‘Chiness-wall — 125 City,

Nobody is contending that. “Anybody was free at any time
r —— Hilt ‘Like Oy;
‘build a pie plant directly across the street from the Utah
Pie Company and merchandise his pies on a unified price
"system without diserimination and on the basis of efficiency
‘or anything else actually run the Utah Pie ‘Company: out

ot bed «Anybody has ‘always been free to do exactly ~~

mat. Auybody has always been free thrqughout this period

ktol, 1031) of time to reduce his price level uniformly ~
throughout the United States if he eee 0 enter a
great big portion of the Utah Pie market. A ‘was -
” absolutely Tres to-do that at any time during this li gation. _

What may not be done, of courte i to have's price dr.
7 elinainetbons bronght about in part by cooperative: activity

directed toward the Utah Pie — for the purpose of

— diminishing competition and, therefore, berge 2 N
olx. This, of course, may not be done.
Now, if saying that you can't do this ‘kind of thing i is

building a Qhinese wall around Salt Lake City, this is the
vnpehat the Congvess of the ‘United! States based upon:

the experience of the Standard Oil litigation’ thought it
eee eee Andp at dome it’s obvious’ that it should

be dens. zial bun u

Now, this} rst of all, is the first point Apr n
sel has missed entirely. Proof of damages will only be
determined hy this jury after the jury has determined that
_there's been a violation; and until the: jury determines there 5

eee eee am
F 8801

; 2
A * . ;
* * * . 9

eg ‘busihess orto inj the paint or to impair:
as ‘Me capital ven. N

oe

is talking about a $4.30 price alone. We have made a ealcu-
evidence shows zit. What the jury will then have to deter-

mine; and this is like ABC almost. I don't know why we

buave to keep repeating it here. What the jury will have to
CCC Dyerioers Cenignhe Say Ser

ket if these people hadn’t violated the antitrust laws.
Now, apparently, this $4.30 Price, Im going to tell yon

right. now what evidence I’m’ going to prove the 64.30

Price. Tm going to use Dr. Anderson’s study, He shows a

price up here, the Utah Pie Company starting over 4.30,
and he shows a Pet-Ritz and Simple Simon price’ of over
4.30, more than 4,30, This is the proof in damages I’m
going to use on the 4.30 price. Presumably when they put
it in the are vouching that that there is a reasonable price,
[fol. 1082) So once again that jury finds that ae has
: in fact, been a violation, only then does the jury go to the
question of what was a reasonable price, only, then does it
go to that question. 9
| Now, then, 1. want to point out ‘tenn ‘that Mr. Pt
chose in this instance to direct his questions on Exhibit
96, to direct his questions specifically to the point as to
whether or not this was a legitimate way to prove dam-

ages. And I tried to stop him, as your Honor recalls, but

he went right ahead 1 Then when we asked the
é dae, he knew anything at all about the proof

"ike a theo qaly. point T's making. Me Sak ére
5

pare ite 7
—

need Wesen
“situation in 1958, beginning in 1958, then the question
O 5

comes how much did the plaintiff lose. Now, here, nobody

5 e | dea ow saying. sh i it at

*

*
*

1 lation based on a number of prices.” That basic exhibit in pas

Oo
3

J lie cb be- bold tordiaregand::any opinions he has given

on Eixhibit' 96 as damage evidence,

3 ‘No farther argument, your Honor. 22

b d return to the rE

3 „Ihe Court Lb te have that exhibit. e
——— ——— to me.

Mx. Alioto's motion to strike this witness’s testimony

FFF
— Ten am: nee, se care bane a ia

- Crose-examination Continued).

0 1 Se Assi ra like, to o rect my attention
to Jour general dissertation on the matter of perfect or

And whether or not a declining price
tage with respect to name brands as

OU

2 A.
uf e krom private label evidenced a certain’ type

ue

“Do you recall that general testimony’ of yourat'"This te
Spars day one Now, you’ 41285

N From ybur readings the antitrust Ws
isl ep ta N |

5 I ie. not et so by section. You'd have

3 1 tet 1 Understand
or’ 6 here ffect is to
i Ot e

men 5
1 2 * *
- 4 0 5
a 1113
0
* *

2

A. We lerer SHEE tes .
Lou know it derived, I take it, from the. Standard.
. Oil. litigation | during the administration of bee

A. aer With thee cn ly by my ce Ate

and I can’t specifically pinpoint details about ree

Q. I take it you know that one of the « in the
Standard Oil case, as evidenced by the litera not the

cases have vou read Ida Tarbell's work, for example, on

the nature of monopoly in the oil industry that resulted in
the enactment of this section? Have you read Fra
1
. In any event, you have read. the 8 on this
matter, some of the literature on this matter? *
A. Some of the literature, in general Principles area,
; rather than detailed, specific cases, 3
Q. You recall, I take it, that the specific purpose for
" enacting this section of the Clayton ‘Act derived from the
historical sifuation in the Standard Oil Company where
interstate profits: would be used for the Rarer of dive

5 bombing ¢ on prices, or selling— _
Mr. Lamb: Your Honor, I object to thin, This is a

5 characterization. This is argument.

Mr. Alioto: This isn’t argument at all. He permitted
this witness to talk at great length as to. phat * a
The Court: Objection overruled. .
Mr. Lamb: There is no such word as “dive bam”
Mr. Alioto: I will change my word. f ¥
The Court: Objection overruled.
i Ur. Lamb: (Continuing) “in the ane run Act

(fol. 10341 By Mr. Alioto:

. You. know,: Ae en ‘io: Get fhe” matter E Pries
diseriminations where it affeots a local seller, as ‘against u |
national seller, derived from that Standard Oil situation
where interstate profits were used to, charge exceedingly’
low Bree where the local competitor existed ond keeping

“

Seq ok,
0 4

pꝛrides high where he didn’t have that dete. %s

local: competitor, for the purpose of injuring the business
of chat local competitor. 1 take it you know that that was

the background of this ‘Prive discrimination section.

85 g question.

X. This is correct.

Ir. Lamb: Bi your. Honor 1 i Sales, to the

Yh

2. (Continuing) l To that meet

Mr. Lamb: Because Mr. Alioto i is testifying,
eich trig No, he isn’t either. TOS

Rat

The Court!’ He is ‘abhi a question Objection over- 5

n ‘ ae .

*

ene ee

say, Section 1 or Section 2, which involves combinations

or gonspiragies in restraint of trade, this séction of the
antitrust laws objects on the ground that there i is indeed
competition in the market place, but unfair dn
isn’t that what it is predicated. upon?’ |

A. This is right. ai

5 °Q. . tor e an

erosien of the price of the Utah Pie Company from a level

of 4.30, we will say, down to & level of 1:75, if there is that

28 Bund of an erosion, it in not ‘impossible, is if, that that :

--@rogsion could have resulted from this Standard Oil type. of:
K. I think this lower pries is aide nedesdarily an i

a e This is—if ‘you had only one seller in this market,

a monopolist, it would be to His advantage to reducé his

Prise over this period of time in order to. Cain increased

taken piace in the market e hoch in le dard dee: :
re hae ieee teat ch cote woe

8 ‘2! 4 i> 4810
> =

3 8

pan Sas: * 2 . *
: a . 5
* N
8 . . — 11 8
2 : 5 ~ Me
5 :
.

de the period of time, of ll fms, aid partionlaly the
Utah Fi By :
Q: Dr. Anderson, witha yur: cis e pes
eroded; because that is ultimately the question for these
ladies and gentlemen here, without zour giving that, is it
not possible that this priee erosion could have occured: be-
cause of the intense type of competition evidenced in the
Standard Oil case about which I have talked to fg
Isn't that one of the possibilities é
A. It is one of the eee

* 9 © ow „ ‘e 88 5

[fol. 1085] By Mr. A .

Now, Men 1 take it hat throughout the Pert “oe

time you were making your studies you were aware of the
fact that the only pie manufacturer in the Intermountain
cs Pye wae eee tat Sa Ey Cay eee
Company.
A. This is correct. N 8
I take it it would be alta agel that the Utah Pie ,
Company would have most of its oe in the immediate
area of its plant. a :
A T would expect it to. 2
. And that is predicated upon the fact that: it is ‘the
. cheapest and most efficient producer in that area?

Sars

„efficient.
33 Well, they'are ofcient in the enge that it is located;
: its plant is located, in the marketing area. i
A. This depends on its location of raw materials, where
der come from, the relative prises or cost: of transporting
raw materials for pie, relative to finished p these

ae ‘wort of problems, 80 J bay it is likely they are che chsapest

because of these things, but not meoessnrily saying that
it ie tlie most efficient, 8

in the light af ts tact that it isthe only” plant
| - located in the Intermiountain area, it is Apparent, is it nat,
Dr. 0 that its marketing area not ed includes

SP a 2. *
1 888 8
4 2 a
5
5
2

* ad 5

21 would say the cheapest, niaybe not e most

ee

* *
5 1 * — — —

de bre arbnd Salt Lake City; the 2 around Salt
Lake City, but that marketing area, for example, includes
Denver, Colorado in a competitive situation with plants
dhat are loeated in California ? That is quite clear, isn’t it?
A. L. would think if they are interested in expanding
Pyr rt would push out in this manner: ,
Jou would agree with me, would you not, that the
relevant ‘competitive market between a plant located in
Salt Lake City and three plants located out in California,

dhat that relative competitive. market would obviously in-

‘ clude the Denver, Colorado area? You would agree with
1 wouldn't you? 9 8

A. Very likely woll. 11
tel. 1036] Q. Ton would pia ood you 1
Doctor, that a plant located i in Salt Lake City, as against
‘three plants -lochted below San Francisco, or in Southern
California, that the Washington market and the Oregon
market and the Montana and the e markets would
also be relevant competitive area? A |

A. Absolutely.

“Q. Now, it is & fact, is it not, that your entire ee oe

market «share, your entire study on market share, is

‘centered around Salt ‘Lake City and e Idaho =" 5

That is. ‘Tight, isn’t it!

A. This is right. er dip e aa hai Ge n 7
the Intermountain market, or the area within which whole- _
_ salers distribute product primarily from Boise, Idaho and
* Lake City. This would be the definition of our market.

Q. ‘And you made not attempt to make any study of the
market as it-would inyolve those relevant competitive areas,

C tt Ms OBI be felevamt. com

8, Co paliam 5 We 3 Idaho, Mon-

is correct. e e fhe
shares in the Intermountain, market and not to
ine] eee Ne e a toe
part of my, assign 52 8

. It would have been very easy to have done it had it .
heen part of your assignment!!!

A Just as easy as it was to get the data for the other

Q. Of course it was, But you were told not to do it?
A. No, I was just told to do this, and I didnt— i
‘Q. How did you actually do it? You took the ‘invoices of
the wholesalers located in Salt Lake City? /
A. And Boise, in this Intermountain area. A Hane +

Qi. Name for us for the record—I didn't think it.is here

{ei nO 5
The e Would you Tepeat the question. ai
1 7 at ee amy en ot suze nw

MUL B OT HL 9eBo Bit sit Pees * Hoe
@, a went you to 1 say an rots

1110 16: ete 5 Na e 15 o ie 455 95 540 g Bann

A. (Continuing) Yes or no. You try to put these ques-
oe in ternis of a yes-or-no answer, when they can’t be
oe ed = an ?

| By 6 7
% Tit i not bo. T em not asking you say yes or
riod. You can say, yes or no and then you can say. |
28 ‘you want and peak as long en want, Doctor.

T have no. objection to that, sir; :
8 I need ‘the’ Ae reread.

ae wild bi yea if you ‘could prove all ls 55
ey allegations that you have made about these companies. |
Thank you. Now, then, on this matter of competition "2

in this market place, ag you have discussed it, Dr, Ander-

{ so L tke it that fromm your reading of the antitrust laws
aud the. antitrust’ ‘literature, and from ‘the standpoint. of
5 ‘the economies of it, now, not the law of it, but the economics ,
. of it, that ‘you ‘dre ‘acquainted with the expression. enn.
dive dealing contracts” or t “Eramchisee”t 12

and vou er are ‘you
pi ape “requirements contracts”? .

ep ey Ses re faerie e Se Sea
Total gery contracts? /
2 ry % that it would be one frm supplying the
ment e ie Ri bth edt

1

* Paar ,

A Pari oa, Mt wet folk do 5107 40 wt
ae PAD i 1 e! ie 757 ing b ‘ V. i a 95 “eres

15 sate ‘the’

a

a ca ae gg or ii a The

5 5 “io fogt oxista, its anti-corhpetitive wice would,

unte) anticompetitive cronomio fot, isn’t it 11 would
be, wouldn't it? a es b bnd

A. Les Again assuming at ‘you could prove this
allegation:

bit 107 Ji nit See af 2 El! MEK

1. Yeas. all richt. eee, 0 proveT eas

assuming the fact is—the: ‘proof is a matter for this jury te ;
determine—assuming the fact is that such a contract‘is in

existence between, we will say, the Pet Milk Company and

Sateway for all‘bf the Bel Air business under private label
fruit me that he ce that fact to be sb vould yon agree’

bib vu Wi

7 pan fort 3
Spes 2 51 ‘ 0
sper mim ft) JA
: ce
f ivy N 1 125 ,
PAVE LEE. OMT eke fF
oi 8

3 law at an appropriate om T therefore ‘object. to the
n pe it calls for. a, legal reer . this

Ove 55 Mia 19 ay 121 1 s
0 mae Wien I would Tike the question . Kern, i
Tie ay oat lel he at 5

0% "By Mr Ali toe’ } 413 1 4 2218 ye 1 1045

Q. Let me rephrase. it 80 ani vill be no duese On
We e e is a fact, not saying that it is now,
the jury, will determine ‘it-—on the assumption that
„CF aomnecancn |

n Zot
;
E

‘on-4.national, basis betrsen the Pet Milk Compaiiy an he -

1 55 Stores for the Bel Air business in“ all f the

Stores in the United States en fruit flavore,

104 J exclnding excluding pumpkin. and minoe, n ine

ft

it sad er that it —) the N

: 8 01 am am not aractariety. 2 3
2. e er een ner
Mr. Lenz e about What it is as a matter

BST

from. dealing with Safeway on an area basis where the inde-
pendent has a freight advantage and an efficiency |
advantage Isn’t that the anti-competitive vioe of it?
A. In-this case it seems to me that it.would depend on
Whether or not the private label here is—it depends on
how it is marketed in this regional market and the pricing:
- policy, that. it uses. Now, if it-is—if this private label is
used to be a priee leader and to eliminate competition,
then I think your allegation would be so, But in my study
of this market, and based on the facts, the Bel Air brand
has been priced - competitive with Utah Pie, but above
others in the market. And as I saw it in operation, Safe-
way did, in fact, buy pie from other companies and did, in
fac Sell it in heir. stores and did, In fect, lose share of te
er the period oftime. |
nik it ‘depends ‘entirely on the action of the ‘private
us of whether they enforce—or require their,
the private label as against letting their re-
‘gional managers buywompetitively. i in the market.
. 1 other Sn did Satsway buy Bel Air fruit

“A: They didn’t bay Bel Air but they bought other brands
in competition with their o-.

.Q: I didn’t make my questions clear then. Tm talking ’
aloud Bel Air pies and I am ‘talking about the business
that a pie manufacturer would receive by manufacturing 5

2 ~ Air pies for Safeway. That's what Im talking about. 0

A. I see. i
a 0 Row, 1 would be correct would: 1 not, Doctor, and x
J agree with me in the light of your study of the
antitrust ‘literature, that the anti-competitive device of an
exclusive dealing ¢optract: between ‘Safeway and Pet-Ritz
_ “obvering. all of the ‘Safeway Stores in the United States
a on‘the Bel Air label for fruit pies, that the anti-competi-
one n ee would be that it would preclude the inde >.
from megotiating with Safeway covering just the pies, the
Bel Air pies; in eee area of the a rena pie
: manufacturer. ont Ahold N 5

N ;

ens. ne ae

Mr. Lamb: If your Honor please, I object to this ques-
tion. Mr. Alioto is characterizing the contract between the
Pet Milk Company and the Safeway Company as an
exclusive dealing arrangement when there is no such provi-
sion in the contract: and he knows it's not an exclusive

Mr. Alioto: I know just the opposite. Lc iti
The Court: The objection is overruled. I heard that
Tol. 1044] The Witness: It should be pointed out and the
chart show it— — ines Bol
Spy a anes AREY SESE AS gh
“2 . Would you mind answering my question first, itor, =.
and then point out anything you want, Doctor, anything
ou want, but answer my question first. Is that not the
anti-competitive device that a circuit deal or an exelusive: ~
dealing arrangement, assuming that to be the fact, and
assuming this jury finds it to be the fact, is it— 5
Mr. Lamb: Your Honor, I object to the characterization
of a circuit:deal. There is no such gee! aok OD:
The Court: I think it pretty bad courtroom practice to
interrupt Gh the middle of a question before it’s finished: °
because we don't know what the question is yet. Now, go
ahead, Mr. Alioto, and ask your question and when it's
completed, Mr. Witness, you withhold your answer, to give.
counsel an opportunity to make his objection d
r. Lamb: Thank vou, your Honor.
By Mr. Alioté: e eee
In the light of your. testimony, your'direct:testimony,
aud the licht of your study of the competitive features in
— 45 this market and in the light. of all of the things you have
would you not, taking the assumption that there is- an
erclusiye dealing oontract and that the jury finds there to

=
: U
2
*

~
*

— & 8 N 3 =

4

_

/ &

+ 8 ;
yes . bes
K x a * 0

de an exclusive dealing contract between the Safeway
Company and the Pet Milk Company on the Bel Air label
for all of the Safeway Stores in the United States, you
would agree with me, would you not, that the anti-competi-
tive device in the sense of our monopoly. statutes, the anti-
competitive device is that the independent manufacturer
in a particular region is thereby precluded from negotiating
and securing the right to manufacture the Bel Air label in
a regional area: Isn't that the anti-competitive device that
the ‘antitrust literature condemns in so-called exclusive
: dealing contracts? /

Mr. Lamb: Your Honor, I * Fae on the ground that it
berm for a. legal conclusion.

The Court; No, I don't think so. Objection overruled.

The Witness: Tes, but it is not a fact that the Utah Pie
‘Company did ‘not’ manufacture some Bel Air pies. The
chart. shows that they had the contract to erde mince
and ae eat in the market. a 5

‘fol, 1045) By Mr. Alioto;

Q. Les. Well, Im excluding mince 4d pumpkin from
the question. If I exclude*it from the question you would
agree with me, would you not, that in the literature you
have read the ‘anti-competitive device. of these exclusive
dealing: arrangements is that, the independent is precluded
from dealing in: the one area where he has owe and
better location?

MI. Lamb: Your i T eject again on the bonne
mat it calls for a legal conclusion. f
The Court: The objection is overruled. 3
The Witness: I can’t answer the question on the basis
15 that Tm not familiar enough nor do I pose #s an expert in
te fleld of antjtrust. I pose as an expert as an economist’
| ff ar arene

* 8
yt 2 Tey!

Ar- 3 ee

tion e Ee A
Q. No, I am not asking’ you to Pree, Psat 65

thing is in violation of anything, „Doctor. Bites

for an economic opinion as to whether or not the device

the exclusive dealing stint ee in a co

ra

negotiating a smaller contract e te Prete ‘which —
would maybe otherwise be made possible by reason of | is

er Lan; T object onthe gromds that it eae fora a
The Court: Overruled. 5578801
„ Miene ee tht wuld be, . Shane

By Mr, Alioto:

; Jou. Now, if that did exist . this Wmbrbet
and if the jury found it to exist in oy ob ently that 5

A. It would be * than Pek: It would be lets than pe. 8
fect; it would have some elements of imperfect.
Ifol. 1046] O. Do you know in the study of the Ge a
literature, I take it, you've heard of the expression the
“high leg” and the “low leg” of a Brice’ e or haye
vou / :
Rees Im not familiar wich this 8 pees
! know about two price systems? 1 0 [N01 401 I
i ay: din i fei cn bee Be)
eee,
a lower price in a more competitive ees

> answer?

zs not evid collusion, is that what you were saying?

A. a 20 wd. vol

Q.. Now, if it were the Pa ee if it were ihe fact,
that in a two-price system of these defendants, the high
leg of the price was right at their plant and the low leg of
‘the price was 750 miles away from the plant, would you
say that that indicated competitive pricing as against
predatory prising?.

A. Les. f

. Tut it indicated 8 pricing, is that your

X It indicated less than perfect: pricing.
Tes. It's an unnatural pricing, isn’t it!
“A. It would be unnatural for that company. | |
7 0. Sure. Now, suppose three companies, three com-
| panies, three national companies, having a dollar or sales
volume, we'll say, in 1961 on frozen pies of $12,800,000 for
one, $,600,000 for a second, and $15,100,000 for a third;
7 suppose three companies: at about the same’ time each had
a two-price system where the high leg of the price was
located right by the plant and the low leg of the price was
located. we'll say, in Salt Lake City, wouldn't you agree
with me that that is evidence of ween less fhap 92
fect competition?
A. I don’t think it means it's infinitely less. 225 means
it's less. 8
C. It eeertainly qvideniie of éollusion, isn’t: it? 0
4 A. No. Collusion is something entirely different, than
uniform action.
ee saying, that uniform unnatural-pri¢e action

%

A Raden rove collusion.
- Q, Init evidence of hien
A. Some evidence. , i
92 „ Foe. * „ Bs} e

[fol: 1047 O. In yoür study of the antitrust Uteretme,

the study about whith friend, Mr. Lamb, qualified you,
did 7 make ret ul ied an Intensive study of zone

2°

ih ain A

| 5 tare, as you, imply it. Ein an: sconosnist,;Bot sin-entitewst

No, no, no. a mapas Gdaeenes.. „ e ee
trust economist, are vou not; t are an e
economist? N

A. Thi ok ͤĩ ecnnéenied: EE . 3

. Let me put it this way. You were qualified, v were eee

oe not 4s an expert on the question of eeonomie competition? 3

A. Right.
Q. Well, that's what Im taking abont: Now, 1 your
studies of economic competition, your historical and cur-
rent studies on economic competition, I take it that ‘you:
have done some considerable study about pries zones by
national companies? n
A. My work has been more in the feld ofagridittara’
products, and I’ve been concerned with interregional: com-
petition of a product that is more nearly a compptitively
priced product. and not so: much in the manufactured ares’
in these zone prieings. n
Q. Well, then, you do not ider yourself an Mpert |
of the competitive effect or the’ competitive implications of ieee
zone pricing, is that it? tae

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386412_0013%3A03. Public record. Not legal advice.
