# Appendix — United States v. Grinnell Corp. > Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more. URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386411_0279%3A02 ## Record - **Collection:** Supreme Court brief - **Document type:** Appendix - **Published:** January 1, 1966 - **Citation:** 384 U.S. 563 ## Text eS: ie: ASA a ia SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES OctToBER TERM, 1965 No. 73 Unrrep Srates, Appellant, vs. GRINNELL CORPORATION, ET AL. No. 74 GRINNELL Corporation, Appellant, vs. UnitTep STATES No. 75 AMERICAN District TELEGRAPH Company, Appellant, vs. UniTep STATES No. 76 Houmes Execrric Protective Company, Appellant, vs. Unritep STATES No. 77 Automatic Fir—E ALARM CoMPANY OF DeLaware, Appellant, vs. UNITED STATES _ APPEALS FROM THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF RHODE ISLAND Volume II INDEX INDEX Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continud Transcript of trial held in USDC for the District of Massachusetts, Boston, June 15, 16, 17, 22, 23 and GR Ta ns BEF Ar SAE sowie kn Beko sep ohh ta eae Appearances ...... 1... ee eee eee eee ee Colloquy and offer in evidence of Government Exhibits 1 through 307 and objections thereto Offer in evidence of additional Government Ex- pe ROE CONC Ee Mien Oe Pee Colloquy between Court and counsel for defend- Colloquy between Court and counsel for defend- Me iid Fad pk ea rey a ee Ree OER ore? Testimony of Francis Guibert— —direct (by Mr. Fritz)........ —eross (by Mr. Story)........ —redirect (by Mr. Fritz)...... Ray Brechbill— —direct (by Mr. Fritz)...... Colloquy between Court and counsel off the reeord Testimony of Ray Brechbill— —resumed direct (by Mr. Fritz) —cross (by Mr. Story)........ —redirect (by Mr. Fritz)...... Howard B. Schultz— —direct (by Mr. Fritz)........ Edward Gaston— —direct (by Mr. Williams)..... George Simon— —direct (by Mr. Fritz, Jr.).... William Arthur Crichton— —direet (by Mr. Fritz, Jr.).... Paul C. Sherer— —direct (by Mr. Fritz, Jr.).... Edward Carrier— —direct (by Mr. Fritz, Jr.).... Lawrence M. De Shane— —direct (by Mr. Conkling).... Roy Elliott— —direct (by Mr. Williams).... George L. Martin— —direct (by Mr. Williams).... Henry Fitzgerald— —direct (by Mr. Williams).... Walter Hennessey— —direct (by Mr. Williams).... John Vincent Polio— —direct (by Mr. Williams).... Original Print 462 325 462 325 463 325 470 330 479 335 487 339 498 345 498 345 538 350 594 380 603 385 604 386 611 390 623 396 650 411 651 412 652 412 688 432 707 443 714 447 728 445 746 465 761 473 769 477 772 479 774 480 775 480 INDEX Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued Transcript of trial held in USDC for the District of Massachusetts, Buston, June 15, 16, 17, 22, 23 and 24, 1964—Continued Testimony of Ray Brechbill—Continued Robert E. Landick— —direct (by Mr. Williams)... Thomas Sherman— —direct (by Mr. Williams)... Testimony of James 0. Maxey— —direct (by Mr. Fritz)........ Offers in evidence of defendant ADT and objec- men: SPO Sais Sia F0 oS BE eee Offers in evidence of defendant Hulmes Electric Protective Company and objections thereto. ... Offers in evidence of defendant AFA and objec- Gielen WN Foss hash, eis ctiap teins. Offers in evidence of excerpts from depositions and objections thereto...................... Testimony of Dariel Francis Collins— —direct (by Mr. Williams).... Walter Joseph Swett, Jr.— —direct (by Mr. Williams).... Albert Earl Smith— —direct (by Mr. Fritz)........ —cross (by Mr. Story)........ —redirect (by Mr. Fritz)...... Walter Darl Simpson— —direct (by Mr. Fritz)........ William F. Hable— —direct (by Mr. Conkling).... —cross (by Mr. Story)........ Francis C. Evans— —direct (by Mr. Conkling).... Janes A. McDonald— —direct (by Mr. Fritz)........ —cross (by Mr. MeInerney).... —cross (by Mr. Story)........ Robert J. Fahey— —direct (by Mr. Fritz, Jr.).... —cross (by Mr. Story)........ Testimony of Andrew M. Ronse— —direct (by Mr. Fritz, Jr.).... Lawrence J. O’Brien— ~ lirect (by Mr. Fritz)........ —cross (by Mr. Story)........ —redirect (by Mr. Fritz)...... Thomas P. Drew— —direct (by Mr. Fritz)........ —cross (by Mr. Story)........ Original Print 776 481 778 482 783 485 804 496 805 496 805 497 806 497 807 498 811 500 815 502 827 509 836 514 838 515 839 516 885 541 892 544 900 549 952 576 961 581 963 582 982 592 991 596 1005 603 1041 623 1057 632 1059 633 640 iv INDEX Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued : Transcript of trial held in USDC for the District of Massachusetts, Boston, June 15, 16, 17, 22, 23 and 24, 1964—Continued Testimony of Andrew M. Rouse—Continued John A. Mahoney— —direct (by Mr. Fritz, Jr.).... Dr. Jessie William Markham— —direct (by Mr. Williams)..... James Douglas Fleming— —direct (by Mr. McInerney)... —cross (by Mr. Fritz)........ Defendant Grinnell’s motion to strike certain of plain- is QU 5s BGS OR KO BAGE Clerk’s note re Joint motion to correct transcript of Tame, BOs TRG es 5208 eka ya hare ei Transeript of post-trial argument, October 9, 1964... Statement by Mr. Fritz on behalf of defendants ADT, Holmes Electric Protective Company and BPR BoP OL a Ta Statement by Mr. McInerney on behalf of Grinnell Corpomnne 66. eg TE esi Statement by Mr. Story on behalf of the Govern- Been se ees ees . leas Bid I ee a vee es Two letters from Wyzanski, J. to Clerk, Neal D. Murphy, dated November 27, 1964 listing errors Web IR, Sl a es icra es Findings of fact, Conclusions of Law and Opin- Notice of appeal of plaintiff to the Supreme Court of the Unite Qtee. 6563s eee re. Notice of appeal of Defendant Grinnell Corpora- tion to the Supreme Court of the United States Notice of appeal of Defendant Holmes Eiectric Protective Company to the Supreme Court of in We NN os Fes aeons. Notice of appeal of Defendant Automatic Fire Alarm Company of Delaware to the Supreme Court of the United States.................. Notice of appeal of Defendant American District Telegraph Company to the Supreme Court of We Ceres aa oss hi i Sige ck Application of the United States for an enlargement of time for docketing case on appeal.................... Order extending time to file........................... Application of defendants for an extension of time for docketing case on appeal (excerpts)................. Order extending time to flle........................... Order noting probable jurisdiction..................... Original Print 1082 645 1090 650 1129 668 1180 695 1188 699 1194 702 1199 703 1200 703 1221 714 1253 731 1267 738 1270 741 1302 768 1304 770 1308 771 1317 774 1326 778 1335 781 1342 784 1344 785 1345 786 1349 787 INDEX v Exhibit Volume I Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued GOVERNMENT’s EXHIBITS No. 1—NBFU No. 71, Standard of the National Board of Fire Underwriters for the Installation, Maintenance and Use of Central Station Pro- tective Signaling Systems for Watchman, Fire Alarm and Supervisory Service as recommended by the National Fire Protection Association, July, 1958 and July, 1959 Amendments....... 1351 789 No. 2—NBFU No. 72—Standard of the National Board of Fire Underwriters for the Installation, Maintenance and Use of Proprietary, Auxiliary, Remote Station, and Local Protective Signaling Mpeteien, Fey THE ox vnss vas vo + 3 RR 1375 813 No. 3—Underwriters Laboratories, Inc. (UL 611), Standards for Safety, Central Station Burglar Alarm Systems, December, 1956.............. 1405 843 No. 4—Underwriters Laboratories, Inc., Accident, Automotive, and Burglary Protection Equip- ment Lists, September, 1961................. 1439 877 No. 5—Manual of Burglary Insurance, Pages 212- 215; 333-396; 417 and 418... .........35%.. 1574 1012 No. 6—Approved Equipment for Industrial Fire Protection, 1962-1963, Associated eisai Mu- tual Fire Insurance Companies..........:.. 1584 1022 Exhibit Volume II No. 7—Introductory letter from ADT General Commercial Manager, A. E. Smith to Commer- cial Superintendents and Representatives, dated March 30, 1953 transmitting proposed ADT Sales Manual, “Selling ADT Service” (ex- GM Ae A aes 1742 1179 No. 9—Agreement dated March 1, 1907 between ADT and the Brooklyn Telegraph and Messen- ger Company, Brooklyn, New York (excerpts) 1753 1187 No. 10—ADT acquisition agreement of the Mer- chants Fire & Dispatch Company, Los Angeles, California, dated August 1, 1907 (excerpts)... 1763 1189 No. 11—ADT acquisition agreement of the Bankers’ Eleetric Protective Company and American Bank Protection Company, dated Jane TE WO Saat AS 1769 1191 No. 12—ADT acquisition agreement of the Pink- erton National Detective Agency and Pinker- ton’s Protective Patrol, dated February 21, 1908 1194 vi INDEX Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued GovERNMENT’S Exxuisits—Continued Original Print No. 13—ADT acquisition agreement of The Still Alarm Company, dated September 6, 1913 (ex- I iis rnc fn Woe aks eo ya ite he oes vee 4 1777_—s «1195 No. 14—ADT acquisition agreement of the Man- hattan Fire Alarm Company, dated April 9, pi | Be eae coreg ane ee 1783 1196 No. 15—ADT acoaisition agreement of The Still Alarm Compauy, dated November 27, 1918 (ex- may a ig Pp Ge ARS Rae at 1787 = 1198 No. 16—ADT acquisition agreement of the Pacific Messenger Company, dated September 9, 1926 CUI. Foo er ee cree c Ee iv is habe. ve 1789 =: 11199 No. 17—ADT acquisition agreement of the Ameri- ean Still Alarm of Detroit, dated September 29, Re RUNING a secs Shen et rep ie siete: 1793 1200 No. 18—ADT acquisition agreement of the Balti- more National Automatic Fire Alarm Company of Baltimore City, dated April 26, 1928 (ex- CR a AG Se eae i eas 1798 1202 No. 19—ADT acquisition agreement of the Spo- kane Alarm Company of Spokane, Washington, dated August 30, 1928 (excerpts)............ 1808 1203 No. 20—ADT acquisition agreement of the Reli- ance Electric Protective Company, Chicago, Illi- nois, dated November 16, 1931 (excerpts)..... 1809 1204 No. 21—ADT acquisition agreement of the Los Fire Alarm Company, Los Angeles, California, dated January 13, 1933 (excerpts)......... . 1810 1205 No. 22—ADT acquisition agreement of the Lewis Signal and Alarm Corporation, Sioux City, Iowa, dated August 8, 1934 (excerpts)....... 1811 1206 No. 23—ADT acquisition agreement of the Signal Protective Service Company, St. Louis, Mis- souri, dated February 8, 1935 (excerpts)..... 1816 1208 No. 24—ADT acquisition agreement of the Auto- matie Alarms, Ltd., Los Angeles, California, dated July 15, 1936 (excerpts).............. 1824 1209 Ne 25—ADT acquisition agreement of the Los Angeles Central Station, Inc., Los Angeles, Cali- fornia, dated May 20, 1938 (excerpts) . 1829 1210 No. 26-1—ADT acquisition agreement of the Reli- ance Alarm Company, (R. Houghton) Detroit, Michigan, dated August 9,1946 ..... 1835 1211 26-2—ADT acquisition agreement of the Reli- ance Alarm Company, (Peter Bens) Detroit, Michigan, dated August 9,1946.............. 1837s «11213 INDEX Vii Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued GOVERNMENT’s ExHIBITs—Continued Original Print 26-3—Schedule Showing Computation of Pur- chase: PYIMB i 656 36 SEN Re ES as ed 1839 1216 No. 27—ADT acquisition agreement of the Ameri- can District Telegraph Company of Hamilton County, Ohio, dated October 28, 1946 (excerpts) 1840 1217 No. 28-1—ADT acquisition agreement of the Lud- low Automatic Fire Alarm Company, Cinein- nati, Ohio, dated October 28, 1946 (excerpts).. 1847 1220 28-2—Memorandum for J. A. MacDonald, Audi- tor Re: Purchase of Ludlow Companies, Cin- cinnati, Ohio, dated December 2, 1946 (ex- QE 2 G2 ie is DEES Es 1854 1223 No. 29—ADT acquisition agreement of the Crown Burglar Alarm Systems, Pasadena, California, dated May 13, 1954 (excerpts)............... 1857 1224 No. 30-1—ADT acquisition agreement of the Globe Electric Protection Company, Ocean City, New Jersey, dated June 8, 1954.............. 1863 1227 30-2—Letter from Ray Brechbill to Harold H. Gray, Globe Electric Protective, dated June 15, 1954 re amendments to agreement............ 1866 1231 No. 31—ADT acquisition agreement of the Gen- eral Alarm Corporation, Boston, Massachusetts, dated March 9, 1955 (excerpts).............. 1867 1232 No. 32—ADT acquisition agreement of the Fed- eral Automatic Alarm Co., Inc., Albuquerque, New Mexico, dated June 10, 1959 (excerpts).. 1869 1233 No. 37—Holmes acquisition agreement of the Mer- cantile Burglar Alarm Company, New York, New York, dated December 15, 1925 (excerpts) 1873 1236 No. 38—Holmes acquisition agreement of the Metropolitan Electric Protective Company, New York, New York, dated August 3, 1928 (ex- COND 2 i RAN A Ca nn Se Bea Es 1875 1237 No. 39—Holmes acquisition agreement of the Silent Electric Protective Corporation, New York, New York, dated December 14, 1928 (ex- CNN 55 68S OIG AE Fi a 1889 1249 No. 40—ADT acquisition agreement of the Los Angeles Central Station, Inc., Los Angeles, Cali- fornia, dated May 20, 1938 (excerpts)........ 1893 1251 No. 41—Memorandum from ADT President E. Ward to ADT Vice President J. A. MacDonald, captioned, Lewis System-Sioux City, Iowa, dated November 19, 1951................... 1901 1254 viii INDEX Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued GovERNMENT’S Exuisits—Continued Original Print No. 42—ADT acquisition agreement of the prop- erty interest of Automatic Fire Protection Com- pany in the 1907 allocation agreements, dated January 1, 1949 (excerpts).................. 1902 1255 No. 43—Memorandum by ADT Vice President A. E. Smith reporting on Meeting with owners of Central Watch Service (Stackler), Chicago, Illinois, dated February 10, 1960 (excerpts)... 1917 1267 No. 44—Memorandum from ADT Assistant to General Sales Manager L. B. Straus to ADT General Sales Manager L. J. O’Brien, cap- tioned, Tulsa, Oklahoma, dated April 14, 1960 1922 1270 No. 45—Memorandum from ADT Vice President A. E. Smith to ADT President E. Gaston, dated BF, TR RR ESE 1923 = 1271 No. 46—Memorandum by ADT Vice President A. E. Smith captioned, Report on Tampa Sig- nal Co., Ine. (Florida Corporation) dated Mai Si SIRO F i ES 1929 1275 No. 47—Memorandum from ADT Vice President A. E. Smith to ADT Vice President J. A. Mac- Donald, captioned, Tampa Signal Company, Ine., dated August 31, 1960................. 1936 1281 No. 48—Memorandum from ADT District Sales Manager E. O. Betscher to ADT General Sales Manager L. J. O’Brien, captioned, Tampa, Florida, dated March 20, 1961............... 1938 1282 No. 49—Memorandum from ADT Vice President A. E. Smith to President E. Gaston, captioned Tampa Signal Company, Inc., dated March 23, ye ee is 1940 1283 No. 50—Letter from ADT President E. Gaston to President H. G. Clark of the Rhode Island Elec- tric Protective Company, dated October 1, 1958 1942 1284 No. 51—Letter from President H. G. Clark of Rhode Island Electric Protective Company to ADT President E. Gaston, dated July 8,1955.. 1944 1286 No. 52—Letter from ADT President E. Gaston to President H. G. Clark of the Rhode Island Elec- tric Protective Co., dated June 16, 1955....... 1945 1287 No. 53—Memorandum from ADT President E. Gaston to First Vice President J. A. Mac- Donald, captioned, Rhode Island Electrie Pro- tective Company, dated July 28, 1958........ 1946 1288 No. 54—Letter from Holmes President H. C. Ward to The Stockholders of Newark District Telegraph Company, dated July 7, 1960...... 1948 1290 INDEX 1x Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued GovERNMENT’s Exuisits—Continued Origiaal Print No. 55—Unsigned handwritten notes entitled “Board of Directors Meeting, February 20, 1958”, obtained from the files of Holmes...... 1955 1295 No. 56—Letter from AFA President T. P. Drew to Grinnell President J. D. Fleming, dated May 20, TONG ah TAS as Bs: 1959 1296 No. 57—Letter from AFA President T. D. Drew to Central Station Signals, Inc., dated February 316, MRR BREA SRS 1962 1299 No. 58—Memorandum for File by ADT President E. Gaston, captioned, Central Station Signals, Ine., New York, N.Y., dated May 22, 1959.... 1967 1303 No. 59—Memorandum from ADT President E. Gaston, entitled, Appendix to President’s Re- port for Meeting of November 19, 1958, dated Noventber 30, A008 |. ..33..20 22 OAS 8, 1969 1305 No. 60—Letter agreement from AFA to The Stockholders of Central Station Signals, Inc., dated December, 1960....................... 1971 1306 No. 61—Agreement between ADT and Holmes, dated September 28, 1906................... 1979 1312 No. 62—Agreement between ADT and Holmes, dated Mareh 20, 1018... .:...2:.... 20.0008: 1983 1315 No. 63—Agreement between ADT and Holmes, Gated: Fame By WR as bi UR is 1992 1322 No. 64—Agreement between ADT and Holmes, dated Mauch 3; I00F ioc 83 tk oe 2000 1329 No. 65—Letter from Holmes President A. W. Allen to ADT President C. C. Johnson, dated Fame 1B; WR oi ewer ates. 2005 1335 No. 66—Letter from “President” to Holmes Presi- dent A. W. Allen, dated July 8, 1932........ 2006 1336 No. 67—Letter from ADT Vice President C. C. Johnson to Holmes President H. S. Stevens, dated January 31, 1924................... 2007 1337 No. 68—Letter from Holmes President H. s. Stevens to ADT Vice President C. C. Johnson, dated February 4, 1924..................... 2008 1338 No. 69—Agreement between ADT and Holmes, . dete Masel: 36, 1000: 2... 68503. eT x 2009 8 1338 No. 70—Letter from ADT Sales Representative J. A. Summers to Holmes Vice President W. F. Burress, dated June 11, 1956................ - 2012 1341 No. 71—Memorandum from ADT District Sales Manager E. J. Heisley to General Sales Man- ager L. J. O’Brien, captioned Gerard Trust Company, Philadelphia Area, dated March 31, 1343 x INDEX Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued GovERNMENT’S ExuHisirs—Continued No. 72—Letter from ADT President C. C. John- son to Holmes President A. W. Allen, dated No. 73—Letter from ADT General Commercial Manager A. E. Smith to ADT Commercial Superintendent D. R. Hall, captioned, Ford Motor Company, Parts Warehouse, Pittsburgh, Pa., dated May 12, 1953.................... No. 74—Letter from ADT Sales Representative No. 75—Letter from Holmes “President” to ADT President C. C. Johnson, dated June 28, 1939. . No. 76—Letter from ADT President C. C. John- son to Holmes President A. W. Allen, dated pe A eee ar One Por MT ae No. 77—Letter from ADT Special Representative H. E. May to L. E. Burke, Sears, Roebuck and Company, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, dated Gotebet: Si. 208s 8 tat. No. 78—Agreement dated February 18, 1904 be- tween Robert L. McElroy and ADT.......... No. 79—Agreement dated April 2), 1905 between Robert L. McElroy and Automatic Fire Pro- tenthen:: eae i sb Nee ais oi No. 80A, B, C—Three Agreements dated April 29, 1907 between Grinnell, ADT, AFA and the Automatic Fire Protection Company ........ No. 81—Agreement dated June 13, 1913 between ADT, Automatic Fire Protection Company and Fire Protection Development Company ...... No. 82—Letter agreement between ADT and Gen- eral Fire Extinguisher Company (Grinnell) dated June SD, 3008.5 ibs Fae No. 83—Letter agreement between ADT and Gen- eral Fire Extinguisher Company (Grinnell) Gnted: June 4; 1008.3... reek No. 84—Agreement dated February 18, 1954 be- tween ADT and AFA...................... No. 85—Memorandum for File, by ADT Vire President J. A. MacDonald, captioned, Grinnell Corporation Negotiation, dated October 8, 1951 No. 86—Memorandum from Grinnell Counsel R. T. Clapp to Grinnell President J. D. Flem- ing, captioned, ADT Matter, dated November We ree ta SS AEN ey Original 2018 Print 1345 1346 1348 1350 1351 1352 1353 1361 1362 1387 1396 1397 1398 1402 1421 INDEX x1 Record from the Uuited States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued GovernMENT’s Exxisits—Continued Original = Print No. 87—Memorandum from Grinnell Counsel R. T. Clapp to Grinnell President J. D. Flem- ing, captioned, ADT Matter, dated January 5, ORs Sete ee Hea 2100 8 1425 No. 88—Memorandum of Grinnell Secretary and Counsel R. T. Clapp entitled, Memorandum of Conference at Mr. Ward’s Office, American Dis- trict Telegraph Company, June 9, 1948, dated Same 3h, WOR. COS OR RK a. 2105 1430 No. 89—Agreement dated December 29, 1952, be- tween ADT and Grinnell.................... 2108 1434 No. 92—Letter from ADT President E. Gaston to Grinnell Treasurer C. H. Rison dated June 19, IO. otc bit eS ee ie as 2148 1471 No. 93—Letter from ADT President E. Gaston to AFA President T. P. Drew dated January 13, DO 525 BCEAO SRE. BI 2150 1473 No. 94—Letter from AFA President T. P. Drew to Grinnell President J. D. Fleming dated Feb- wpa Be, FI 5 55 ERE, ie 2160 1483 No. 95—Letter from ADT President E. Gaston to Grinnell President J. D. Fleming dated Feb- Want G, BORN oir 8 RAS 8 2163 1486 No. 96—Memorandum from ADT Controller C. G. Eicker to Vice President J. A. MacDonald, cap- tioned—Rate Development—dated June 29,1956 2165 1487 No. 97—Letter from AFA Sales Manager J. J. Heavey to Davis, Dorland & Co., New York, N.Y., dated October 5, 1956................. 2191 1518 No. 98—Letter from ADT Anditor J. A. Mac- Donald to AFA President T. P. Drew, cap- tioned—Solicitation of Industrial Process Ser- vice in Conjunction with Sales of 8.8. & W.F. Service—dated June 10, 1948................ 2192 #81519 No. 104—Letter from ADT Assistant Secretary E. A. Gaston to AFA President T. P. Drew, eaptioned—Albert H. Voight, Inc., Philadelphia, Pa.—dated July 7, 1961..................... 2194 1521 No. 107—Letter from Grinnell Secretary R. T. ; Clapp to AFA President T. P. Drew dated May SA OB oss ei GES, 6a Ok A Oa AeA 2195 1522 No. 1°.1—Agreement dated December 24, 1953 be- tween ADT, AFA and Grinnell.............. 2196 §©1523 No. 112—Letter from T. P. Drew, President of AFA to F. J. Lehner, L. W. Thomason, F. Dur- ward Chass and A. G. Seddon, dated December 21, 1954 re transmittal of Letter Agreement dated December 15, 1954 between ADT, AFA OE IN 03s carte a oy ec os Ke dale Faas 2200 1525 xii INDEX Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued GOVERNMENT’ Exuisits—Continued No. 128—Agreement dated March 29, 1954 be- tween ADT, Grinnell and the Rhode Island Electric Protective Company................ No. 129—Agreement dated March 29, 1954 be- tween ADT and the Rhode Island Electric Pro- Suan: Qe ie ES VR eS No. 130—Memorandum from ADT Vice President J. A. MaeDonald to ADT Secretary John Han- non dated December 10, 1953................ No. 131—Letter from ADT Vice President A. E. Smith to President H. G. Clark of the Rhode Island Electric Protective Company dated De- eenielh She Wis i si ESR a yes No. 132—Letter from Rhode Island Electrie Pro- tective Company President H. G. Clark to ADT, dated February 5,1963...............05..... No. 133—Letter from Rhode Island Electric Pro- tective Company President H. G. Clark to Grin- nell, dated January 19, 1961................. No. 139—Memorandum from ADT District Sales Manager E. J. Heisley to ADT General Sales Manager L. J. O’Brien, captioned, Competition- Washington District, dated September 14, 1956 No. 140—Memorandum from ADT Superintend- ent of Field Service R. T. Warner to ADT General Commercial Manager A. E. Smith, eaptioned, Competition-Milwaukee, dated May OF FR RE SON EL PEAS. No. 141—Memorandum from ADT District Sales Manager W. K. Francis to ADT General Sales Manager L. J. O’Brien, captioned, Competition- Paramount Pictures Corporation, Los Angeles, California, dated August 10,1956............ No. 142—Memorandum from ADT District Sales Manager W. K. Francis to ADT General Sales Manager L. J. O’Brien, captioned, Paramount Pictures Corporation, Los Angeles, California, eee eee. No. 143—Memorandum from ADT Assistant to General Sales Manager W. W. Dooley entitled, Report on Survey of Sales Potential, San Jose Peninsula, (Not dated)..................... No. 144—Memorandum from ADT District Man- agers to ADT General Managers, captioned, Competition-Peoria, Illinois, dated December 12, eae leo est ast es Original 2218 2220 2221 2227 2229 2230 2232 1534 1540 1542 1543 1545 1546 1549 1550 1552 1554 1556 INDEX xiii Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued GovERNMENT’s ExuisiTts—Continued Original Print No. 145—Handwritten confidential memoranda from ADT Representative W. Rohlfing cap- tioned Call’s Police Signal, Chelsea, Massachu- setts, dated July 16, 1956................... 2238 1559 No. 146—Memorandum from ADT District Sales Manager R. T. Warner to ADT Vice President A. E. Smith, captioned, Call’s Police Signal Corporation, Chelsea, Mass., dated September OA TON she tak kd AS cS 2242 1561 No. 147—Memorandum (unsigned) to ADT Dis- trict Sales Manager E. Turnbull, captioned, Competition; Merchants Police, Milwaukee, Wisconsin, dated July 30, 1955.............. 2243 1562 No. 148—Memorandum from ADT Sales Repre- sentative R. P. Lucy to ADT District Sales Manager W. K. Francis, captioned Competition- Bay Burglar Alarm Company, dated March 28, W008 Sa SOROS ERS 2245 1564 No. 149—Memorandum from ADT District Sales Manager W. K. Francis to ADT Commercial Superintendent E. B. White, captioned General Plant Protection Company, Los Angeles, Cali- fornia, dated May 15, 1952.................. 2246 1565 No. 150—Memorandum from ADT District Man- agers to ADT General Managers, captioned Proposed Central Station-Anaheim (Orange County) California, dated July 26, 1960..... 2247 1567 No. 151—Memorandum from ADT General Su- perintendent, Operating Department to ADT Vice President J. A. MacDonald, captioned, Proposed Central Station, San Jose, California, dated March 24, 1959....................... 2250 1570 No. 152—Memorandum from ADT General Su- perintendent of Plant W. Hable to ADT Gen- eral Sales Manager L. J. O’Brien, captioned, Proposed Central Station-San Jose, California, dated March 20, 1959....................... 2251 1571 No. 153—Memorandum from ADT District Man- agers to ADT General Managers, captioned Pro- posed Central Station-San Diego, California, dated March 4, 1959........................ 2252 1572 No. 154—Memorandum from ADT Vice President A. E. Smith to ADT Vice President J. A. Mac- Donald dated August 3,1960................ 2254 1575 xiv INDEX Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued GoveRNMENT’s Exuisits—Continued No. 155—Memorandum from ADT President E. Gaston to ADT Vice President J. A. Mae- Donald, captioned, Proposed New Central Sta- tion-San Fernando Valley-Los Angeles, Cali- fornia, dated July 12,1961.................. No. 156—Memorandum from ADT Vice President A. E. Smith to ADT Vice President J.A. Mac- Donald, captioned Proposed New Central Sta- tion, Huntington Park, Los Angeles, dated June Fe pee oe) Oo eee rs a No. 157—Memorandum from ADT District Man- agers to ADT General Managers, captioned Pro- posed Central Station, New Brunswick, New Jersey, dated July 13, 1959 (excerpts)....... No. 158—Memorandum from ADT Executive Ac- count Representative F. J. Concannon to ADT General Sales Manager L. J. O’Brien, cap- tioned, New Central Station, Nassau County, Long Island City, N.Y., dated August 17, 1955 No. 159—Memorandum from ADT Vice President J. A. MacDonald to ADT General Commercial Manager A. E. Smith, captioned, Possible Estab- lishment of Central Station at Jamaica, Long Island, dated April 14, 1952................. No. 160—Memorandum from ADT District Man- agers to ADT General Managers, captioned, Proposed New Central Station, San Fernando Valley, dated July 26,1960.................. No. 161—Memorandum from ADT District Plant Superintendent J. F. Burns to W. Hable, cap- tioned, Proposed sub-divisions of existing Cen- tral Stations-New York District, dated Decem- PE BARN ERR ee eines. No. 163—Memorandum from ADT Director of Diversification & Expansion J. J. Stephens to ADT Vice President A. E. Smith, captioned, Sales Potential, Westchester County, New York, dated December 20, 1957.................... No. 164—Memorandum from ADT Vice President to ADT President Gaston, captioned, Charlotte, North Carolina, dated July 6,1960........... No. 167—Memorandum from ADT First Vice President J. A. MacDonald to ADT Controller C. G. Hicker, captioned, Rate Development, dated July 12, 1956. No. 168—Memorandum by “ADT Vice President J. A. MacDonald, captioned, Rate Adjustment 1959, dated November 10, 1959.............. Original 2261 2264 2267 2268 1576 1578 1581 1583 1585 1587 1592 1594 1599 Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued GovERNMENT’s Exuisits—Continued No. 169—Memorandum from ADT First Vice President J. A. MacDonald to ADT Vice Presi- dent A. E. Smith, captioned, Minimum Basic Annual Service Charges, dated December 22, OUD isis ie as SR ee eee Men ss No. 170—Memorandum from ADT President E. Gaston to ADT First Vice President J. A. Mac- Donald, captioned Rate Development, dated Daly 1d, MAG chee 86 idk. PR EOEER No. 171—Memorandum by Holmes President H. C. Ward, entitled, Holmes Electric Protec- tive Company of Philadelphia, Proposed 1957 Electric Protective Service Rate Revision, dated February 18, 1957 (excerpts)................ No. 172—Memorandum by Holmes President H. C. Ward, entitled, Revision of Electric Pro- tective Service Rates Proposed for Adoption for Mercantile and Residence Services, May 1, 1953, and for Financial Institution Service June 1, 1953, dated February 25, 1953............. No. 173—Memorandum for File (unsigned) cap- tioned, Projected Cash Resources and their Ap- plication, Five year Period ending December 31, DOOD ik. inte sis Cap ed WIA, AG eee etek No. 174—Memorandum from ADT District Sales Manager E. Turnbull to ADT General Sales Manager L. J. O’Brien, captioned Sales Produc- tion-Integrity of Service Charges, dated Sep- tontben BF: BOOG .a'. céwiawh. das deasielie Exhibit Volume III No. 175—Contract Data Reports and Competition Reports for Albany, New York (excerpts) ... No. 176—Contract Data Reports for Atlanta, Georgia (excerpts).................000000ee No. 177—Contract Data Reports and Competition Reports for Boston, Massachusetts (excerpts) . . No. 178—Contract Data Reports for Buffalo, New York (excerpts) . No. 179—Contract Data Reports and Competition Reports for Chicago, Illinois (excerpts)...... No. 180—Contract Data Reports and Competition Reports tor Cincinnati, Ohio (excerpts). .... No. 181—Contract Data Reports and Competition Reports for Cleveland, Ohio (excerpts)...... Original 2302 2316 1608 1611 1612 1617 1619 1626 1629 1635 1642 1665 1677 1700 1716 xvi INDEX Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued GovernMENT’s Exuisits---Continued Original = Print No. 182—Contract Data Reports and Competition Reports for Dallas, Texas (excerpts)......... 2445 1738 No. 183—Contract Data Reports and Competition Reports for Dayton, Ohio (excerpts).... .... 2470 1755 No. 184—Contract Data Reports and Competition Reports for Denver, Colorado (excerpts)...... 2486 1766 No. 185—Contract Data Reports and Competition Reports for Detroit, Michigan (excerpts)..... 2500 1780 No. 186—Contract Data Reports and Competition Reports for Houston, Texas (excerpts)....... 2515 1790 No. 187—Contract Data Reports and Competition Reports for Indianapolis, Indiana (excerpts).. 2527 1801 No. 188—Contract Data Reports and Competition Reports for Los Angeles, California (excerpts) 2551 1813 No. 189—Contract Data Reports for Louisville, Kentucky (excerpts)...................... 2566 1823 No. 190—Contract Data Reports for Memphis, Tennessee (excerpts)....................... 2576 1831 No. 191—Contract Data Reports and Competition Reports for Milwaukee, Wisconsin (excerpts).. 2589 1839 No. 192—Contract Data Reports and Competition Reports for Minneapolis, Minnesota (excerpts) 2619 1855 No. 193--Contract Data Reports and Competition Reports for Newark, New Jersey (excerpts)... 2632 1864 No. 194—Contract Data Reports for New Orleans, Louisiana (excerpts).......... 2644 1872 No. 195—Contract Data Reports and Competition Reports for New York, New York (excerpts).. 2653 1879 No. 196—Contract Data Reports for Omaha, Ne- braska (excerpts)......... ........ 2670 1895 No. 197—Contract Data Reports and Competition Reports for Peoria, Illinois (excerpts)... .. 2678 1901 No. 198—Contract Data Reports and Competition Reports for Philadelphia, Pennsylvania (ex- a: 1 es ae KEE Eso CIN Sy ewes eT nh 2686 1906 No. 199—Contract Data Reports for Portland, Oregon (excerpts).................. 2696 §=1915 No. 200—Contract Data Reports and Competition Reports for San Francisco, California (ex- eae. ities, uy hc cca Woe A» 2704 1922 No. 201—Contract Data Reports for Seattle, Washington (exeerpts).............. 2710 1928 No. 202—Contract Data Reports and Competition Reports for St. Louis, Missouri (excerpts) . 2720 1935 No. 203—Contract Data Reports and Competition Reports for Washington, D. C. (excerpts)... 2731 1945 INDEX xvii Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued GoveRNMENT’s ExuipiTs—Continued Original Print No. 206—Report on ADT General Sales Meeting April 6, 7 and 8, 1955, at the New York Athletic Cea ia hk BES ORS Sis cto. Fai 2748 1961 No. 208—Memorandum from ADT Vice President to ADT President E. Gaston, captioned, Service Charges—Proposed Revision, dated November DA: ROR eR Phin aris 2778 2003 No. 209—Memorandum for File by ADT Vice President J. A. MacDonald, captioned, Rate Development, dated November 17, 1955....... 2780 2006 No. 210—Memorandum for File by ADT Vice President, J. A. MacDonald, captioned, Rate Adjustments 1959, dated November 10, 1959.. 2784 2012 No. 212—Directive issued by ADT Vice President A. E. Smith and Concurred in by ADT Presi- dent E. Gaston to ADT District Sales Managers, captioned, Delegation of Authority, with Sup- plement, issued on July 1,1960.............. 2785 2013 No. 213—Memorandum from ADT President E. Gaston to ADT General Sales Manager L. J. O’Brien, captioned R. H. Macy, Paramus, N. J., dated December 29, 1955.................... 2791 2020 No. 214—Memorandum from ADT Sales Repre- sentative D. M. Gates. to ADT Executive Ac- counts Representative Alex Gaston, captioned, McAlpin Company, Cincinnati, Ohio, dated Be FE BO ec es iA EOE ARs o 2792 2021 No. 215—Memorandum from ADT Commercial Superintendent J. B. Bodley to ADT General Sales Manager A. E. Smith, captioned, Federal Engineering Co., Inc., Washington, D. C., dated November 14, 1952...................... 2793 2022 No. 216—Memorancam from ADT General Sales Manager L. J. O’Brien to ADT District Sales Manager W. J. Robinson, captioned, Competi- tion, Fidelity Electronics Protective Service, Pittsburgh, Pensylvania, dated March 14, 1961 2794 2023 No. 217—Memorandum from ADT District Sales Manager E. J. Heisley to ADT General Sales Manager L. J. O’Brien, captioned, National Pro- tective Corporation, Baltimore, Maryland, dated Cubaian Bis) TOR a HI RH 2795 2024 No. 218—Memorandum from ADT District Sales Manager E. Turnbull to ADT General Sales Manager L. J. O’Brien, captioned, Competi- tion—Autocall and Automatic Alarm, Minne- apolis, Minnesota, dated March 13, 1959 2796 2025 xviii INDEX Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued GovERNMENT’s ExHisits—Continued No. 219—Memorandum from ADT District Sales Manager J. D. Patton to ADT General Sales Manager L. J. O’Brien, captioned, Competi- tion—Fort Worth, dated December 22, 1958... No. 220—Memorandum from ADT Sales Repre- sentative R. W. Rice to ADT District Sales Manager J. D. Patton, captioned, New District Account—Letellier-Phillips Paper. Co., New Orleans, La., dated January 14, 1960......... No. 221—Memorandum from ADT District Sales Manager E. J. Heisley to ADT Sales Repre- sentative L, F. Lytle, captioned, Reliable Stores Corp., Washington, D. C., dated November 22, MOOG SA CSA et oiees. No. 222—Comparative Summary of Percentages of Minimum Basic Charges Secured at each ADT central station in the United States for the years 1957 through 1961................. No. 223—Memorandum from ADT District Sales Mausger A. 8. Jacks to ADT General Sales Manager L. J. O’Brien, captioned, Competi- tion—Dayton, Ohio, Liberal — ine, dated August &, 10@1... .. 2. 66.5. eee. No. 224—Memorandum from ADT Commercial Superintendent J. B. re to ADT General Commercial Manager A. E. Smith, captioned, Federal Engineering Co., Washington, D.. C., dated Jane:0, 1008: 82. eee ce EE. No. 225—Memorandum from ADT General Sales Manager L. J. O’Brien to ADT District Saies Manager J. K. Scott, captioned, York Profes- sional Pharmacy, Los Angeles, California, dated Sele Th MGs Rei as No. -227—Memorandum from ADT District Sales Manager E. J. Heisley to ADT General Sales Manager L. J. O’Brien, captioned, Competition (rumored) Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, dated Cetebal: BRIO sis eciesiecien ens... No. 228—ADT central station protection service Contract Forms for Watchman’s Reporting and Manual Fire Alarm Service, Automatic Fire Alarm Service, Sprinkler Supervisory and Waterflow Alarm Service and Burglary and Ho!dup Protection Service............. No. 229—Memorandum from ADT District Sales Manager C. L. Chafee to ADT Vice President A. E. Smith, captioned, Regional Sales Confer- ences and District Sales Meeting 1955, dated DN TI OO ores fective Original 2799 2811 2813 2814 2815 2818 2033 2039 2041 2043 2047 INDEX xix Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued GOVERNMENT'S Exuisits—Continued Original § Print No. 230—Memorandum from ADT Controller C. G. Eieker to ADT First Vice President J. A. MacDonald, captioned, Tampa, Florida, dated Bepteiaber 11, oo A 2823 2057 No. 231—Memorandum from ADT Vice President J. A. MaeDonald to ADT Controller C. G. Kicker, captioned, Advance Service Charge for Sprinkler Supervisory and Waterflow Alarm Services, dated August 5, 1953.............. 2828 2063 No. 232—Memorandum (unsigned) entitled, Charges Proposed by Commercial Department for all types of Sprinkler Supervisory and Waterflow Alarm Service and Waterflow Only Gervies: Cast: Gitee) os es ea ea Sees. 2829 2064 No. 233—Memorandum from ADT Controller C. G. Eicker to ADT First Vice President J. A. MacDonald, captioned, Rate Development, dated Sab Wh TS: 2 SS RRS 2833 2069 No. 234—Memorandum from ADT Controller C. G. Kicker to ADT First Vice President J. A. MacDonald, captioned, Rate Development, dated Bees BRR: oo ESCA AES: 2835 2070 No. 235—ADT Tabulation (unsigned) entitled, Proposed Revision in Advance Service Charges SAB REE RE. 2837 2074 No. 236—Annual Report of the Holmes Electric Protective Company and Subsidiaries for the your 100) (eneerpe) oo eS SS 2840 2075 No. 237—Memorandum from ADT Commercial Superintendent E. O. Betscher to ADT General Commercial Manager A. E. Smith, dated May 6 WE 3 NR OR ES aa 2845 2076 No. 238—Memorandum from ADT President E. Gaston to ADT General Sales Manager R. Brechbill, captioned, Owl Protective Company, Long Island City, N.Y., dated November 7, 1962 2847 2079 No. 239—Memorandum for File by ADT Vice President AES, captioned, Competition, Call’s Police Signal Co., Chelsea, Massachusetts, dated July 26, 1956 -........... OES ge ae 2080 No. 240—Memorandum from ADT General Sales Manager L. J. O’Brien to ADT District Sales Manager A. S. Jacks, captioned, Competition, Buffalo, New York, dated September 8, 1959.. 2850 2082 xx INDEX Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued GOVERNMENTS ExuisiTts—Continued Original Print No. 241—Memorandum from ADT District Sales Manager R. T. Warner to ADT General Sales Manager L. J. O’Brien, captioned, Cole-Hersee Company, South Boston, Massachusetts, dated Dae GTN? 5. ce isi ese sks 2851 2082 No. 242—Memorandum from ADT Sales Repre- sentative G. V. Roach to ADT Assistant to General Sales Manager R. Brechbill, captioned, Quality Wool Quilting Corp., Astoria, New York, dated August 8, 1961................. 2853 2084 No. 243—Memorandum from ADT District Sales Manager E. J. Heisley to ADT Special Repre- sentative H. E. May, captioned, Bellevue Strat- ford Hotel and Benjamin Franklin Hotel, Phila- delphia, Pa., dated September 23, 1960........ 2854 2085 No. 244—Memorandum from ADT Sales Repre- sentative R. F. Michiel, Sr., to ADT District Sales Manager E. Turnbull, captioned, Request for Competitive Quotation to Secure Agreement for SS & WFA with a new Subscriber, Mil- waukee Forge and Machine Company, dated Jali GWM 5s, tts 26 os 2855 2086 No. 245—Memorandum from ADT District Sales Manager R. T. Warner to ADT General Sales Manager L. J. O’Brien, captioned, Raymond’s, Inc., South Boston, Mass., dated August 9, 1958 2857 2088 No. 246—Memorandum from AFA Commercial Representative J. J. Way to AFA Vice Presi- dent L. W. Thomason, captioned, Morris Fish- man & Sons, Ine., Philadelphia, Pa., dated No- We TE ION oS OS ew 2859 2090 No. 247—Memorandum from ADT Special Repre- sentative F. E. Miller to ADT District Sales Manager E. Turnbull, captioned, Continental Can Company, Milwaukee, Wisconsin, dated Same Mi MOM coos 5 oe etn nis e0's 2860 2091 No. 248—Memorandum from ADT Sales Repre- sentative A. A. Balestrino to ADT District Sales Manager A. 8S. Jacks, captioned, Hyde Park Lumber Co., Cincinnati, Ohio, dated July 28, WO ei 82 eee wa geek Li 2862 2092 No. 250—Memorandum from ADT District Sales Manager E. J. Heisley to ADT General Man- ager L. J. O’Brien, captioned, Nationwide Safti Brake Co., Falls Church, Virginia, dated April Bi Rs soo Re es ce Fk eRe Ss 2863 2094 No. 251—Memorandum from ADT Sales Repre- sentative C. J. Lawson to ADT Disirict Sales Manager D. R. Hall, dated January 14, 1958.. 2865 2096 INDEX Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued GovERNMENT’S ExHIBITs—Continued No. 252—Memorandum from ADT First Vice President J. A. MacDonald to ADT President E. Gaston, captioned, Maleolm Goldstone, Owl Protective Co., dated February 9, 1962........ No. 253—Memorandum from ADT District Sales Manager J. K. Swanson to ADT General Sales Manager L. J. O’Brien, captioned, Wright- Bachman, Ine., Indianapolis, Indiana, dated Goplembes 33, 2008 5. 2 Te No. 254—Memorandum from ADT Sales Repre- sentative W. J. King to ADT Special Repre- sentative H. E. May, captioned, Phileo Dis- tributors, Ine., Milwaukee, Wisconsin, dated Weboumny 16, 3008 6 oe OS. No. 255—Memorandum from ADT Sales Repre- sentative B. W. Henke to ADT Executive Ac- counts Representative F. J. Concannon, cap- tioned, American Brass Company, Cleveland, Ohio, dated April 19, 1956.................. No. 256—ADT General Instructions No. 77, en- titled, Contract Procedures, issued July 11, 1960 No. 257—Memorandum from ADT Special Repre- sentative J. R. Norris to ADT Commercial Su- perintendent C. L. Chafee, captioned, National Can Corp., Cleveland, Ohio, dated July 23, 1954 No. 258—Memorandum from ADT Sales Repre- sentative S. J. Sievers to ADT Executive Ac- counts Representative H. Schultz, captioned, Foley’s, Houston, Texas, dated September 22, No. 259—Memorandum from ADT Sales Repre- sentative J. P. Dunn to ADT National Accounts Representative F. J. Concannon, captioned, Johns-Manville Corp., Los Angeles, California, Gated Jens 16, OOO. ok eS eae. No. 260—Letter from A. F. Greenwood of Gov- ernment Employees Exchange, Inc., to D. R. White, Albany Protective Service, Albany, New York, dated August 7, 1961................. Exhibit Volume IV No. 261—Memorandum from ADT Manager, Field Service Division, R. Brechbill to ADT General Manager of Sales Production L. J. O’Brien, captioned, Procter & Gamble Com- pany, Cincinnati, Ohio, Cleveland District Na- tional Account, dated September 1, 1955 __. Original 2870 2872 2874 2878 2879 2880 2100 2101 2103 2110 2112 2113 2114 xxii INDEX Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued GOvERNMENT’s Exuisits—Continued Original Print No, 264—Memorandum from ADT Sales Repre- sentative J. D. Patton to ADT Executive Ac- counts Representative F. J. Concannon, cap- tioned, Franklin’s, Dallas, Texas, dated Decem- WR I he eis redeea ned ioc: 2884 2117 No. 265—Memorandum by ADT Vice President A. E. Smith to File, captioned, Renewal Agree- ment, R.K.O. Pictures, Los Angeles, California, Gobet Set Te, We: i ee co 2885 2118 No. 266—Memorandum from ADT District Sales Manager R. T. Warner to ADT General Sales Manager L. J. O’Brien, captioned, The Van Heusen Charles Co., Albany, New York, dated Pens Wi OR oss os a ei 2886 2119 No. 267—Memorandum from ADT Special Repre- sentative H. E. May to ADT Executive Ac- counts Representative F. Concannon, captioned, American Sugar Refining Company, Phila- delphia, Pennsylvania, dated December 12, 1961 2887 2120 No. 268—Contract agreement for Alarm Engi- neering Service of the Dayton Electronics Alarm and Signal Co., 530 West Second Street, TR i he BS i in Ree SE eS 2889 2121 No. 269—Memorandum from ADT Special Repre- sentative H. E. May to ADT Executive Ac- counts Representative F. J. Concannon, dated January 18, 1960 (excerpts)................ 2891 2123 No. 270—Memorandum from ADT Special Repre- sentative H. E. May to ADT Sales Representa- tive F. Shadell, captioned, Swern & Company- Lit Brothers, Trenton, dated January 5, 1962.. 2897 2124 No. 271—Memorandum from ADT District Sales Manager E. J. Heisley to ADT General Sales Maaager L. J. O’Brien, captioned, City Stores, Ine., Philadelphia, Pa., dated January 19, 1960 2898 2125 No. 275—Memorandum from ADT District Sales Manager L. M. De Shane to ADT General Sales Manager L. J. O’Brien, captioned, Ralston Purina Company, Various Locations, U.S.A., dated March 4, 1957....................... 2901 2128 No. 276—Annual Report of the American District Telegraph Company for Fiscal Year 1953 (ex- rn ORE Dally 7 Cena (7 Hee ens Se Py a 2903 2129 INDEX Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued GovERNMENT’s Exuisits—Continued No. 277—Letter from ADT Vice President J. A. MacDonald to Grinnell Secretary and Counsel R. T. Clapp, dated July 2,1953.............. No. 278—ADT General Circular No. 222, entitled, Direct-Connected Fire and Burglar Alarm Ser- vice, signed by ADT Vice President A. E. Smith, dated April 27, 1955................. No. 279—Memorandum from ADT General Com- mercial Manager A. E. Smith to ADT Commer- cial Superintendent C. L. Chafee, captioned, Competition—Automatic Fire Alarm Systems, Columbus, Ohio, dated March 9, 1953........ No. 280—Memorandum from ADT Assistant Di- rector of Public Relations R. M. Bugbee to ADT Director of Public Relations A. W. Sulli- van, captioned, Proposed Ordinance—City of Newark, dated December 20, 1962............ No. 281—Memorandum from ADT District Sales Manager E. J. Heisley to ADT General Sales Manager L. J. O’Brien, captioned, Competition, Atlanta, Georgia, dated September 15, 1955... No. 282—Memorandum from ADT Assistant Commercial Superintendent, W. K. Francis to ADT General Commercial Manager A. E. Smith, captioned, Regional Conferences, June 4-6 and 18-20, 1953, Competition District No. 9, dated June 9, 1953 (excerpts)............... No. 283—Memorandum by Holmes Sales Man- ager, C. K. Empringham to File, captioned, Malcolm Goldstone, Central Office Alarm Com- pany, dated April 5, 1962................... No. 284—Letter from Holmes President H. C. Ward to Grinnell Secretary and Counsel R. T. Clapp, dated September 25, 1952............ No. 285—Memorandum from ADT General Com- mercial Manager A. E. Smith to ADT Com- mercial Superintendents, captioned, Proprietary Systems, dated October 5, 1963 (excerpts)... No. 286—ADT Pamphlet reporting on ADT Pro- tection Service for 1960 (excerpts).......... No. 287—Memorandum from ADT First Vice President J. A. MacDonald to ADT President E. Gaston, dated June 6, 1957............... 2918 2928 2934 2936 2135 2149 2153 2157 2159 2163 2164 2171 2173 2178 Xxiv INDEX Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued GovERNMENT’S ExnHisits—Continued Original Print No. 288—Minutes of Meeting of the Burglary Rating Committee of the National Bureau of Casualty Underwriters, April 25, 26, 27,1950.. 2972 2181 No. 289—Letter from Holmes President H. C. Ward to Grinnell Secretary & Counsel R. T. Clapp, dated October 10, 1952............... 2974 862184 i. 291—ADT Leaflet entitled, Astute Business Executives are Constantly Proving that it Pays 2 Ways to Protect Property Automatically, Better Protection and Lower Cost........... 2977 =: 2187 No. 292—Memorandum from ADT Associate Di- rector of Diversification & Expansion G. E. Friedli to ADT Director of Diversification & Expansion J. J. Stephens, captioned, San Jose Peninsula Survey, dated November 28, 1956... 2973 2189 No. 294—Memorandum from ADT Commercial Superintendent C. L. Chafee to ADT General Commercial Manager A. E. Smith, captioned, Competition—Cincinnati, Ohio, dated Septem- We Ra sks ick esis eR i ee 2981 2191 No. 295—Memorandum from ADT President E. Gaston to ADT Vice President A. E. Smith, captioned San Diego, California, dated October OE eS a I ee ss. 2982 2192 No. 296—ADT Acquisition Agreement of the United Electric Service Company, New York, New York, dated July 21, 1931 (excerpts).... 2983 2193 No. 297—ADT Acquisition Agreement of the Acxiliary Fire Alarm & Telegraph Co., Phila- delphia, Pennsylvania, dated March 26, 1930 CNM oid BE Wh SS. 2986 2194 No. 298—AFA central station protection Service Cenieite Wie os oar ei re SS 2995 2199 No. 299—Memorandum from AFA Vice President F. D. Chase to AFA President T. P. Drew, cap- tioned, Competition, dated September 4, 1958.. 2998 2203 No. 300—Memorandum from ADT Sales Repre- sentative J. J. Viscarde to ADT Assistant to General Sales Manager J. B. Rodley, captioned, Ivers-Lee, Newark, New Jersey, dated June 16, POs eR a eas is 3000 ©2205 No. 302—Memorandum from ADT Government and Special Sales Division Manager J. 0. Maxey to ADT General Sales Manager L. J. O’Brien, captioned, Competition, Owl Protec- tive Company, New York, New York, dated ST Se NOS 3 tee hin ish ee eRe ce ds 3001 2206 INDEX xXXV Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued GovERNMENT’s Exuisits—Continued Original’ Print No. 303—ADT Leaflet, entitled, Municipalities Served by ADT Central Stations............ 3003 2208 No. 304—List of Approved Central Station Pro-. tection Service Companies which were listed by Underwriters Laboratories, Ine., on December i asc ens ses gta ee ea phoresis 3007 2216 No. 305—Underwriters Laboratories, Inc. list of approved central station protection companies with the effective listing date................ 3011 2222 No. 306—Letter from A & P Transport, Inc., President E. G. Snow to Joseph Forman, Call’s Police Signal Corporation, Chelsea, Massachu- setts, dated July 9, 1950.................... 3018 2228 No. 307—Holmes central station protection ser- vice contract forms......................525 3019 2229 No. 308—Stipulation No. 1, Stipulation as to the authority of the documents offered into evidence yy PR eS aS 3022 2235 No. 309—Stipulation No. 2, Stipulation as to the volume of commerce across State and District of Colsebia Tises. .. 205625.) WRK, 3058 2260 No. 310—Stipulation No. 3, Relative market posi- tion of central station protection service com- panies in Underwriters Laboratories, Inc., Cer- tifieated central. station burglar alarm service.. 3062 2263 No. 311—Stipulation No. 4, Relative market posi- tion of alarm companies in Underwriters Lab- oratories, Ine., certificated local burglar alarm SG oS ee eee 3064 2264 No. 312—Stipulation No. 5, Relative market posi- tion of central station protection service com- panies in the approved station protection service business in the United States................ 3067 2266 No. 313—Designation of answers of the American District Telegraph Company to interrogatories propounded by Plaintiff (excerpts).......... 3082 2279 No. 314—Designation of answers of the Holmes Electric Protective Company to interrogatories propounded by Plaintiff..................... 3110 2301 No. 315—Designation of answers of the Auto- matic Fire Alarm Company of Delaware to interrogatories propounded by Plaintiff....... 3129 2318 No. 316—Designation of answers of the Grinnell Corporation to interrogatories propounded by PR 5 ES Pe 3149 2337 No. 317—Excerpts of deposition testimony of George F. Allebach, Sr., Insurance Rating Bu- reau of the District of Columbia............ 31.67 2353 xxvil Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued GoverNMENT’s Exuipits—Continued Original No. 318—Excerpts of ae ae testimony of No. sap Pent of deposition testimony of James H. Bray, Alarm Signal Company of Texas No. 320—Excerpts of deposition testimony of John D. —— Federal Engineering Com- pany, Ine No. 323—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Eugene Curran, Robinson Protective Alarm Company No. 324—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Clarence 8. Damon, Damon Alarm Corporation No. 325—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Clifford T. Davis, Protection Engineering Corp. No. 326—Excerpts of deposition testimony of James W. Flotron, Potter Electric Signal Co... No. 328—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Joseph Forman, Owl Protective Company, Gen- eral Burglar Alarm Company Exhibit Volume V No. 329—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Malcolm Goldstone, Central Office Alarm Com- No. 330—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Malcolm Goldstone, Owl Protective Company, General Burglar Alarm Company No. 331—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Harold W. Gray, American Burglar Alarm Co. (Pacific Extinguisher Co.)................... No. 333—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Sarah E. Jackson, Denver Burglar Alarm Com- pany No. 334—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Edward J. Lavino, Sentinel Alarm Corporation No. 336—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Thomas M. Lewin, Automatic Alarm Corpora- tion No. 337—Excerpts of deposition ‘testimony of Gerald J. Linder, American Fire Dispatch, Inc. No. 338—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Thomas L. Lugen, Fidelity Electronic Protective Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued GovERNMENT’s Exxisits—Continued Original Print No. 339—Excerpts of deposition testimony of James H. McDowell, Central Station Signals, p RE eC e MES pre te re CN ee 4280 2897 No. 340—Excerpts of deposition testimony of : Kenneth S. MecFarlan, Jr., Republic Alarm CORNING 8 600 oan sae ee a eS 4341 2919 No. 341—Exeerpts of deposition testimony of Peter J. Neumann, Albany Protective Service.. 4389 2933 No. 342—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Ephraim B. Oberlander, Protection Alarms, Inc. 4414 2943 No. 343—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Arthur T. Orner, Morse Signal Devices, Inc... 4461 2961 No. 345—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Shelton Phillips, Potter Electric Signal Com- pomp 00 Clee i ics Foes aK ied 4501 2974 No. 346—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Donald D. Pillsbury, National Bureau of Casualty Underwriters...................... 4527 2980 No. 347—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Henry J. Poile, Kedzie-Kane Alarm Co....... 4558 3604 No. 348—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Charles C. Porch, Factory Mutual Rating Dera ss Sis i es ei es 8 4599 3019 No. 349—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Walter W. Richardson, American Alarm Com- QO UR F268 5 cd NLRC ea CRT aR ore No. 351—Excerpts of deposition testimony of James E. Rose, Michigan Still Alarm Co...... No. 352—Excerpts of deposition testimony of George W. Saunders, Underwriters Laboratories 4730 3069 No. 355—-Excerpts of deposition testimony of George A. Smith, Smith Detective Agency & Nightwatch Service......................5.. 4755 3079 No. 356—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Maurice G. Sondock, MeCane-Sondock Detective IE i SSG AY es BUR OS * Ge No. 357—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Sidney Stackler, Central Wateh Service....... No. 358—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Lee C. Underdown, Central Alarm Company.. 4924 3152 No. 359—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Lyle and Joe Underdown, Central Alarm Com- PON he OE en ew SE Ae oe 4934 3159 No. 360—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Alex Venners, Federal Engineering Compariy, Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued GovERNMENT’s Exuipits—Continued INDEX No. 361—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Ira E. Warlick, Reliance Protective, Inc....... No. 362—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Morris F. Weinstock, Morse Signal Devices of I HL AA PENTECOST No. 363—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Samuel G. Wight, Central Alarm Company, BF RRE RA re ye AUT UTR ay DEFENDANTS’ EXHIBITS A—Schedule of Defendant alarm companies pro- posed objections to plaintiff’s documents—For MIME a Sec dca blr ievsceckecdeucey B—Defendant Grinnell objections to Government documents—For identification................ E-1—Minimum basic service charges effective Jan- MN es See aie a Whe Races ss a des ewe E-2—Minimum basic advance service ae effective April 1, 1962.. ie F—Form 701 dated August CeO Se _G—Form 400 dated February 1963... H-1—Summary in tabular form of contents. of Exhibit H—Vocational Listing of Subscribers Exhibit Volume VI I—Letter from L. J. O’Brien to C. L. Chafee, dated September 12, 1955 re: Procter & Gamble Company, Cincinnati, Ohio.................. F—68-80—Twelve tabulated exhibits and one list of book cities dated October 1, 1962 admitted at completion of testimony of Edward Gaston ... J—Summary statement of local alarm accounts in five cities, based on Form 400................ K—List of city of Everett, Massachusetts master L—List of city of Lynn, Massachusetts Police Department connections, (acting Chief George W. Donnelly), dated June 16, 1964.......... M—List of Everett, Massachusetts Police Station connections (Bradford V. Elliott, Chief of Police), dated June 16, 1964................ N—List of master boxes and heat detection con- nections, Braintree, Massachusetts, Fire Depart- ment Headquarters. ........................ O—List of Braintree, Massachusetts, Police De- partment connections....................... Original 4984 5004 5077 3242 3632 3633 INDEX Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued Derenpants’ Exnisirs—Continued P—List of auxiliary connections in the Fire De- partment, Lynn City, Massachusetts.......... Q—List of Weymouth Fire Department direct connected and auxiliary alarm connections... . R—List of Brockton Municipal connections, dated December 81, 1068. ...........0cc cscs tee S—List of Boston Municipal connections, dated Sana Ti DOO |. i: das i ode geen. T—List of Salem Municipal connections, dated Soamasd GTA | ik. 8 SOAs cea aces U—List of U.S. Government contracts (not se- curity classified), December 31, 1963......... V—Area list of Government installations, Conti- nental United States, January 1, 1964........ W(a)—List of ADT central station SS&WF sub- seribers in Natick, Needham and Newton, Massa- enete oR R OR Rea ee Widde sles , tective signalling service.................... Z-3—ADT contract form for central station bur- glary and holdup protestion service.......... Z-4—ADT contract form for direct connected ser- WO gods GeO cases . dake TRE owes Z-5—ADT contract form for local alarm service. . K-1—ADT contract form for local alarm service (customer owned system)................... L-1—List of representative installations made by ADT using systems and equipment made by CNN si a at ORR i eS M-1—List of representative systems installed by others, and sold outright to subscriber, where ADT was called in to restore service, and/or to provide a central station connection.......... U-1—Letter from Stanley N. Barnes, Assistant Attorney General, Antitrust Division to Frank A. Fritz, dated July 14, 1955................ V-1—Statement of (ADT) Company’s Revenues, gross and net balance sheet assets and indicated ratios, 1950. to 1063... ......... cece ee eee W-1—Ratio of net earnings to gross assets, net assets and net worth (ADT), 1947 to 1963.... X-1—Commercial Circular No. 197, supplement No. 21, dated July 25, 1960, from L. J. O’Brien regarding outright sales prices marked “Confi- CP oF Bis CREB Sea Original 5561 3685 3686 3687 3688 3689 INDEX Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued Derenpants’ Exnipits—Continued Y-1—List of offices showing annual and advance service charges secured in excess of minimum basie rates, 1957 to 1962.................... Z-1—Letter from L. J. O’Brien to J. A. Mae- Donald, dated August 16, 1960 re Pricing Policy Memorandum from ADT Special Representa- tive J. R. Norris to ADT Commercial Superin- tendent C. L. Chafee, captioned National Can Corp., Cleveland, Ohio, dated July 23, 1954 (copy) (omitted in printing)................ LL—Price Waterhouse & Company letter dated May 27, 1964 to The Board of Directors of ADT with Appendices A, B&C.................. MM(1-20)—Table of detailed financial data on a city-to-city basis regarding divestiture........ NN—Statement of revenue and expenses—1963, New Orleans central station (ADT).......... OO—Statement of revenue and expenses—1963, Richmond central station (ADT)............ PP—Summary of ADT deficit offices in 1963. ... QQ—Analysis of advance service charges, city by Gy; SO BAT Es RR—List of advance service charges amortized on a city-to-city basis. Detail of Reply to Govern- ment Interrogatory No. 17.................. SS—Memorandum of J. A. MacDonald dated June 17, 1952 regarding discussions with Grinnell Corporation on June 16, 1952............... UU—ADT Board of Directors minutes of June 11, 1952 (exeerpts).....................4... VV—Excerpts of ADT Board of Directors min- wees for Jails 0, 1008: 2. ei ei. WW-—Arthur D. Little, Ine. report on U.S. Mar- ket for electric protection services, 1961 to 1962 WW-1—Biographical summaries of Messrs. Gott- lieb, Frankel & Peters...................... Exhibit Volume VII XX—Interview guide used in conjunction with Arthur D. Little, Inc. survey................ YY—Two Sanborn maps of Dubuque, Iowa... . ZZ—Interviewer’s materials relating to survey of of Dubuque, Iowa—Anudit & Surveys, Inc., Forms 1, 2, 3, 4 & 5, Job #1232........... AB—Q4 by Q23, amount of square feet oecupied— this tabulation is related to Exhibit ZZ. Job EE ce Un ccle Rie «Rie eens weed Te ba 5809 5813 5815 INDEX Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued Devenpants’ Exxisits—Continued AC—Q4 by Q24, number of employees—this tabu- lation is related to Exhibit ZZ. Job #1232... AD—Q4 by type of business establishment, types of establisbments—this tabulation is related to Exhibit ZZ. Job #12382.................... AE—Letters from L. J. O’Brien to District Sales Managers, dated April 4, 1956; December 2, 1957; August 7, 1959; August 29, 1960; Novem- ber 23, 1960; re Form 701.................. AF—General Services Administration correspond- ence from September 20, 1962 to January 2, C-1—C-5—Defendant Alarm Companies objec- tions to plaintiff’s designations of deposition COMED 55080 oie CAEP DgvenpDaNnt GRINNELL CORPORATION’S EXHIBITS J-2—1950 Annual Report of the Grinnell Corpo- ee eee retains Pe ra Peer or J-5—1953 Annual Report of the Grinnell Corpo- WE COV TSR l eT AERC can now kta CO BO i RIN LA aS Oc eae outs Th, BONE 8 02 EBA SS J-43—Agreement dated February 28, 1949 be- tween Grinnell Corp. end Marine Midland Trust Ce. OF ae TO RE EES... J-44—Minutes of the Executive Committee of the Board of Directors, Grinnell Corp., March 23, TOP CONNOR) SS i Pee" J-45-—Letter from W. G. Hampton, Assistant Vice President, New York Telephone Co. to J. D. Fleming, President Grinnell Corp., dated Feb- CE Gy PO eos ea NeS as ea Lao Income statements of Holmes Electric Protee- tive Company for the years 1921-1949........ J-47—Agreement dated April 14, 1950 between New York Telephone Co. and Grinnell Corp... J-48—Closing Memorandum (undated) ........ J-49—Letter from W. J. Klickhauf, Apple-Cole Co., to J. D. Fleming, dated May 4, 1953 _.. J-50—Agreement dated June 16, 1953 between Western Union Telegraph Co. and Grinnell Corp. with Exhibits A-E.............. J-51—Loan Agreement, dated July 27, 1953 be- tween Grinnell Corp. and the Equitable Life Assurance Society (excerpts)................ 6001 6002 4110 4111 4113 4114 4117 4120 4158 4163 4164 4199 xxxii INDEX Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued DEFENDANT GRINNELL CorPoRATION’S ExHisrts—Con- tinued Original J-52—Letter from rr ee & N. Barnes, Assistant Attorney General to J. D. Fleming, dated June J-53-—Letter from Roger T. Clapp to W. D. Gail- lard, Jr., Milbank, Tweed, Hope & Hadley, dated July 2, 1953 J-54—Letter from Roger T. Clapp to M. J. Bloomer, Jr., Wickes, Riddell, Bloomer, Jacobi & McGuire, dated July 2, 1953 J-55--Letter from Stanley N. Barnes, Assistant Attorney General to Frank A. Fritz, dated July J-5f—Letter from Frank A. Fritz to Ephraim Jacobs, Department of Justice, Antitrust Divi- sion, dated July 13, 1953 J-59—Memo dated July 24, 1950 from Roger T. Clapp to Department Managers, Fire Protection Division J-60—Memo dated June 10, 1963 from Roger T. Clapp to Department Managers, Fire Protection Division J-62—Memo dated February 20, 1954 from O. L. Swats, Manager, Fire Protection Division to Department Managers, Contracting Engineers, J-65—Memo dated April 21, 1950 from H. C. Ward to All Holmes Employees ........... 6066 4216 J-66—Letter from J. A. MacDonald to Roger T. Clapp dated June 24,1953.................. 6068 4218 J-69—Memorandum of Material for Discussion with Messrs. Gaston and MacDonald on June 16 6070 4219 J-70—Letter from Bleakley, Platt, et al. to the Equitable Life Assurance Society, dated July BN hen A ae Shes IRS 6076 4226 J-74—Minutes of a special meeting of the Board of Directors of the Grinnell Corporation dated pe ERE er eee ee ee 6077 4227 J-75—Statement showing “1928-1937 Earnings Data”—Grinnell Corporation................ 6079 4229 J-75(1)—General Fire Extinguisher Co.—Report of the Treasurer To The Board of Directors for Twelve Months Ended December 31, 1928 ae CN ak. RE Ota EONS hs 6080 4230 J-75(2)—Ended December 31, 1929 (excerpts). 6087 4238 J-75(3)—Ended December 31, 1930 (excerpts). 6094 4246 J-75(4)—Ended December 31, 1931 (excerpts).. 6101 4254 INDEX Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued DEFENDANT GRINNELL CorPoRATION’sS Exuisits—Con- tinued J-75(5)—Ended Deeember 31, 1932 (excerpts) . . J-75(6)—-Ended December 31, 1933 (excerpts) . . J-75(7)—Ended December 31, 1934 (excerpts). . J-75(8)-——Ended December 31, 1935 (excerpts). . J-75(9)—Ended December 31, 1936 (excerpts). . J-75(10)—Ended December 31, 1937 (excerpts) . J-76—Plaintiff’s Answers to Certain Interroga- tories of Alarm Company Defendants........ Appendix A—Letter from Stanley N. Barnes, Assistant Attorney General to Frank A. Fritz, dated July 23, 1953 (copy) (omitted in print- EEE Ue Laer yn ta ora © aime Pans Be ge) gre Appendix B—Letter from Stanley N. Barnes, Assistant Attorney General to J. D. Fleming, dated June 29, 1953 (copy) (omitted in print- DOR) cininidin dv shdes Pid eweNeehe + ISIC Sab eee Appendix C—Letter from Frank A. Fritz to Ephraim Jacobs, Department of Justice, Anti- trust Division, dated July 13, 1953 (copy) (omitted in printing)....................... J-77—Balance sheet and income statements of AFA as of June 30, 1948.................. Derenpant ADT’s Exursirs A9—Memo dated December 15, 1952 from J. L. Hardesty to H. R. Eakin, Plant Superintendent, captioned Competition—W ashi m, D.C..... —Memo dated December 22, 1952 from J. B. Bodley to A. E. Smith captioned “Federal En- A13—Memo dated September 29, 1953 from A. E. Smith to J. A. MacDonald captioned Westches- ter County —Memo dated September 14, 1951 from W. J. Doyle, Commercial Superintendent, to A. E. Smith, captioned Modified Central Station Bur- A31—Letter dated March 23, 1959 from Jamie Bray, Alarm Signal Company of Texas to ae Be CI shi es eo ih i 8 aS A36—Handwritten letter dated June 2, 1962 from T. E. Smith to Mr. Haberman captioned Com- petition, San Antonio, Texas—Texas Industrial 6201 4318 4318 4331 XXxiv INDEX Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued Derenpant ADT’s Exuisirs—Continued Original A37—Letter dated October 18, 1955 from J. K. Seott to A. S. Cook, Manager, captioned River- side Protective Association, Houston 9, Texas. . A38—Letter dated October 1, 1959 from R. F. Ethridge to R. T. Warner, captioned The Polaroid Company, Dallas, Texas A39—Letter dated June 22, 1959 from 8S. W. Christian to J. B. Rustic, captioned Competi- A40—Letter dated March 15, 1960 from J. D. Patton to L. J. O’Brien, captioned Competition A4i—Letter dated December 11, 1956 from C. A. Southard to J. K. Scott, captioned Scobey Fire- proof Storage Company, San Antonio, Texas. . A47—Memo dated November 2, 1959 from J. B. Bodley to E. J. Heisley, captioned Competitive A49—Memo dated November 20, 1962 from Jake Kowalyk to W. J. Robinson, captioned Compe- tition—Pittsburgh A51—Memo dated March 12, 1956 from W. J. Dahl to L. J. O’Brien captioned Boeing Air- plane Company, Seattle, Washington, Conver- A52—Letter dated March 14, 1956 from T. I. Young to W. J. Dahl, re: Boeing Airplane Company, Seattle, Washington, Conversion. .. . A53—Memo dated January 30, 1956 from J. J. Stephens to J. A. MacDonald, captioned Direct Connected Services, Competition and Compen- sation A54—Memo dated February 15, 1956 from R. M. Bugbee to A. W. Sullivan, captioned Gamewell A55—Memo dated October 10, 1955 from A. W. Sullivan to L. J. O’Brien, captioned Competi- A57—Memo dated July 30, 1955 from R. V. Haight to H. B. Schultz A6i—Letter dated January 4, 1954 from E. J. Heisly to A. E. Smith, re: Wurzburg Bros., Memphis, Tenn. (Factory Mutuals) __. 6232 A62—Memo dated September 24, 1953 from J. Heath, Jr., to E. B. White, re Les Angeles and Salt Lake ‘Railways, Los Angeles 23, California 6233 INDEX xxxXV Record from the United States Distriet Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued Derenpant ADT’s Exuisrtrs—Continued Original Print A63—Memo dated March 20, 1953 from W. B. O’Hara to D. E. Kloster, re: Erie Resistor Cam, Male, Bae). Fs tetas os GES. 6234 435% A64—Memo dated February 12, 1953 trom O. T. Blank to F, J. Concannon, re: Benjamin Moore Co., Denver, Colorado...................... 6235 4356 A66—Memo dated March 6, 1952 from E. A. Rogers, Jr. to A. S. Cook, re: Competition, Wild & Stevens, Inc., Needham Street, Newton- Ville; ee Se STS BASRA aia 6236 4357 A67—Memo dated October 2, 1952 from N. Slavin to A. 8S. Cook, re: Hotels Statler Company, Hartford, Connecticut....................... 6237 4359 A68—Memo dated April 7, 1952 from D. R. Hall to A. 8. Cook, re: Ford Motor Company, Natick, Mass.—Compulsory Tour Service..... 6238 4359 A70—Memo dated January 18, 1952 from D. R. Hall to W. R. Boos, re: Ford Motor Company, Edgewater, New Jersey...................... 6239 4361 A71—Memo dated September 5, 1951 from E. J. Heisley to A. E. Smith, re: Union Bag and Paper Company, Savannah, Georgia......... 6240 4362 A77—Memo dated August 11, 1955 from J. B. Bodley to L. J. O’Brien captioned Competi- tion—Richmond, Virginia................... 6241 4363 —Memo dated August 8, 1955 from R. O. Beck- ham to J. B. Bodley entitled Competition— Wisma Ve eee A 6242 4364 A78—Memo dated June 1, 1953 from T. J. Yocom to E. B. White entitled Competition Report... 6244 4365 A79—Memo dated July 1, 1959 from Ray Brech- bill to Lyle Straus entitled Competition—Fort WN ASS PRETO i 6246 4366 A82—Memo dated March 18, 1955 from W. J. Doyle to J. A. Webb, re: The Jamison Plastic — Corporation, North Bellmore, Long Island, N.Y. 6245 4367 A84—Memo dated October 10, 1952 from G. J. Simon to John Hannon entitled Beth Israel Hospital, New York City.................. 6247 4368 A85—Memo dated December 9, 1952 from W. J. Doyle to C. S. Hammergren re: Beth Israel Hospital, New York, N.Y. pe 6248 4369 A86—Memo dated April 8, 1957 from. Ww. R. ‘Boos to W. J. Doyle re: Duro-Test Corp., Secaucus, ANNES Fe euy sac e cys Co LUeCR Ree y ces 6249 4370 INDEX Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued Derenpant ADT’s Exuisirs—Continued A89—Memo dated July 29, 1958 from C. H. San- ders to W. J. Doyle re: Globe Products Co., Inc., Webro Road, Clifton, New Jersey....... A95—Memo dated August 6, 1951 from A. E. Smith to John Hannon captioned Auxiliary Fire Alarm Service, Trenton, New Jersey... . A98—Memo dated January 5, 1952 from M. E. Hubert to W. W. Dooley, captioned First Na- tional Bank, Omaha, Nebraska.............. B8—Memo dated March 21, 1961 from A. S. Jacks to L. J. O’Brien capticued Competition, Erie, Pennsylvania ..... le SUEAGH Coe voneak ad ce B9—Memo dated November 21, 1960 from J. J. Caffrey to L. J. (* Srien captioned Competitive BMS © G5 Sib AAG. Fe tea te ao Bli—Memo dated May 19, 1959 from R. J. Del- linger to A. 8S. Jacks re: Gamewell Competi- tion—Erie, Pennsylvania.................... B12—Memo dated March 7, 1959 from R. J. Del- linger to A. S. Jacks re: Gamewell Company. . B13—Memo dated May 17, 1959 from R. M. Bug- bee to A. S. Jacks re: Gamewell Competition— Erie, Pennsylvania ...... Gi POCE oP CRN B17—Memo dated May 5, 1958 from F. T. Turner _to J. B. Rustic captioned “Auxiliary Fire Alarm Systems—City of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania”. . . B18—Memo dated April 11, 1958 from R. T. War- ner to L. J. O’Brien captioned “Olin Mathieson Chemical Corp., New Haven, Conn.”.......... B19—Memo dated March 28, 1958 from W. J. Dahl to A. W. Sullivan captioned Competi- tion—Fire Alarm Service, City of Portland, Oregon, Auxiliary Fire Alarm Systems con- nected to Municipal Cireuits................ B20—Memo dated March 25, 1958 from H. E. Peters to A. 8. Jacks captioned Competition. . B21—Memo dated October 15, 1957 from “District Sales Manager” (RTW) to L. J. O’Brien, cap- tioned Insurance Relations—FIA and FM.... B24—Memo dated June 7, 1956 from G. B. Fos- mire to C. L. Chafee, captioned Competition— SS MRS Si ei a cos hey AP ny oa a5 B30—Memo dated September 24, 1954 from D. M. Gates te C. I. Chafee... soe). coe. Original 6250 6252 6264 6266 6269 INDEX Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—C ntinued Derenpant ADT’s Exassits—Continued B33—Memo dated September 15, 1954 from J. A. MacDonald to A. W. Sullivan entitled Notifier Mfgs. B34—Memo dated September 10, 1954 from L. J. O’Brien to J. A. MacDonald re Competition— Notifier Alarm Co.—Spurling Automatie Fire B38—Memo dated August 30, 1954 from R. L. Hopf to C. L. Chafee re Competition—Spurling O Wetiller i... obits ASAE B40—Memo dated June 8, 1954 from Oper. Supt. (DHB) to J. B. Rustic, re Competition—Lin- then; ON 5.6. SOB RE Ca AES B92—Memo dated September 18, 1952 from R. M. Bugbee to A. E. Smith, re Atmo Competition— B94—Letter from “Koos Bros.” signed by George O. Klemp to B. W. Fox, Anchor Motor Freight- New York Corp., Linden, New Jersey, dated Hemp BE, NOG iio i ees B95—Memo dated September 24, 1952 from A. F. Clunan to W. J. Doyle, re Competition—Atmo, Linden Investment Co., Linden, New Jersey... Cl—Memo dated May 14, 1951 from R. M. Bug- bee to A. S. Cook re Atmo Competition, New Haven, Connecticut.............0..00-24.4-- C3—Memo dated July 22, 1957 from J. B. Bodley to O. E. Betscher, captioned M. H. Connell As- sociates, Miami, Florida..................... C4—Memo dated July 27, 1962 from C. C. Ras- mussen, Jr. to W. J. Robinson, re “United States v. Grinnell Corp. et al.”.............. C8—Memo dated July 11, 1952 from R. M. Pinio to B. H. Sofge re Ace Burglar Alarm Company, Hartford, Connecticut ...................... C10—Memo dated July 7, 1952 from K. E. Berrett to R. M. Pineo, re Ace Burglar Alarm Com- pany, Hartford, Connecticut................. C13—Memo dated July 1, 1960 from D. H. Bar- nett to L. J. O’Brien re “Proposed Councilmen’s Bill, Denver, Colorado”..................... C14—Memo dated November 29, 1954 from “Vice President” to L. J. O’Brien re Denver Ordinance C15—Copy of Ordinance allowing Denver Banks to install direct connect alarms, Series of 1954 Original 6278 6293 6296 6298 E . 68 8 € 2 8 8 XXXViii INDEX Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued Derenpant ADT’s Exuisits—Continued C21—Memo dated December 18, 1952 from W. K. Francis to E. B. White re Competition—Tele- Fire of California, Pasadena, California...... C22—Memo dated April 17, 1953 from J. Heath, Jr. to E. B. White re competition—Fullerton Mutual Orange Ass’n., Inc., Fullerton, Cali- SEARS RR Gp ie GR oe ae eae C26—Memo dated April 11, 1958 from W. K. Francis to L. J. O’Brien, entitled Competition— Sacramento, California...................... C31—Memo dated August 28, 1962 from W. J. Kupper to Ray Brechbill, re District #13— Sales Integrity and Competition............. C32—Memo dated June 16, 1954 from W. K. Francis to E. B. White re Sears, Roebuck & Company, Tucson, Arizona.................. C33—Memo dated April 29, 1957 from J. A. Mac- Donald to J. B. Rustic, re Competition—Spur- ling Fire Alarm & Indicator Co., Louisville, REE I ePIC Oe C34—Memo dated December 21, 1956 from W. J. O’Meara to E. 0. Betscher, re Yellowstone Dis- tillery, Ine., Shively, Kentucky.............. C35—Memo dated November 30, 1956 from E. O. Betscher to L. J. O’Brien, re Competition— Spurling Fire Alarm & Indicator Company, Louisville, Kentucky........................ C36—Memo dated September 12, 1956 from J. B. Bodley to E. O. Betscher, re Competition— Spurling Fire Alarm & Indicator Company, Louisville, Kentucky........................ C40—Memo dated September 7, 1955 from A. A. Balestrino to C. C. Chafee re Competition— CONE a iio bs ik a Sk kw wees ok. C41—Memo dated September 10, 1954 from R. L. Hopf to C. L. Chafee re Competition—Direct Connect to Fire Tower...................... Agreement between the City of Cincinnati and Spurling granting direct connect permission, dated August 6,1954.................. C42—Memo dated September 17, 1953 from E. J. Heisley to A. W. Sullivan, re Auxiliary & Direct Connect Competition, Charleston, South Caro- Ne ee ier ick. Sah Vids ke WEE Ca es E45 9s C49—Memo dated March 4, 1960 from D. R. Hall to R. T. Warner, re GMC, New Departure Divi- sion, Bristol, Connecticut.................... Original 6301 6319 6321 6323 6324 6325 6326 4422 4423 4439 INDEX xxxix Record from ‘he United States District Court for the Dis- triet of Rhoae Island—Continued Devenpant ADT’s Exuisits—Continued Original = Print C53—Memo dated May 6, 1958 from R. G. Dodd to L. M. DeSchane re: Mid-West Conveyor Company, Inc., Kansas City, Kans........... 6329 4449 C55—Memo dated April 4, 1958 from R. G. Dodd oo Ei BE en iS 6331 4451 C59—Memo dated March 14, 1957 from L. M. DeSchane to L. J. O’Brien re: Competition— Omaha and Lincoln, Nebraska............... 6332 4452 C60—Memo dated February 11, 1957 from H. E. Elster to D. H. Barnett re: Competition— Omaha, Notifier and Dictograph Corp........ 6333 4453 C61—Memo dated January 9, 1957 from Ray Brechbill to E. Turnbull captioned Competi- tion—Oshkosh, Wisconsin................... 6336 4456 C66—Memo dated May 27, 1955 from “E.0.B.” to L. J. O’Brien captioned Banks, Direct Con- moet Pubes Fi I Cis 6337 4457 C67—Memo dated May 23, 1955 from “District Operating Superintendent” to J. B. Rustic cap- tioned B. A. System By Diebold, Inc., Canton, Che 3058 ER. BG BISEG 6338 4458 —Newspaper clipping describing the ultrasonic device used by Diebold in local and direct con- nect vault alarm service..................... 6339 4459 C76—Memo dated August 13, 1954 from R. L. Beckwith to D. R. Hall..................... 6340 4460 C81—Memo dated November 11, 1953 from L. J. O’Brien to E. P. Hagan re Competition—Die- bold, Police Headquarters, Milwaukee, Wiscon- WN i CEE PIR SE VASE i en Pee 6341 4461 C87—Memo dated January 5, 1952 from M. E. Hubert to Mr. Dooley, Re: First National Bank, Gabe, Webeite 6 oR es 6343 4463 C89—Memo dated January 13, 1958 from R. A. Bewes to R. T. Warner, Re: State of New York Executive Department, Division of Military and Naval Affairs, Albany, N.Y.................. 6344 4464 C91—Memo dated June 27, 1962 from W. K. Francis to Ray Brechbill, Re: Golden Gateway, Redevelopment Project, San Francisev, Cali- en i. eS BEE eS TES FRE 6346 4466 C97—Memo dated February 27, 1957 from D. R. Hall to L. J. O’Brien, Re: Proprietary Systems, GMC, Chevrolet Division, Ford Motor Company, Chrysler Motors Corporation................ 6347 4467 INDEX xl Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued Derenpant ADT’s Exuisrrs—Continued Original Print D1—Memo dated August 19, 1952 from Commer- cial Superintendent to A. E. Smith re Aero Dll—Memo dated December 7, 1962 from W. A. Clark to W. C. Marin re The John Shillito Co., Cineinnati, D15—Memo dated August 1, 1961 from F. J. Coneannon to L. J. O’Brien captioned Julius Kessler Distilling Company, Calvert Distilling Company, Jeffersonville, Indiana (Louisville).. 6352 4472 D18-1—Memo dated February 2, 1961 from R. L. Beckwith to J. K. Swanson re: Jacobsen’s, Jackson, Michigan......................45.. 6354 4474 D18-2—Memo dated December 26, 1960 from Ray Brechbill to L. J..O’Brien re: American Hard Rubber Company, Akron, Ohio.............. 6356 4476 D20—Memo dated August 31, 1960 from L. J. O’Brien to District Sales Managers and Repre- sentatives, captioned Competition—Minneapolis- WINE. 8 ie PORN BA ia ih. 6357 4477 D21—Memo dated January 20, 1959 from M. H. A. Lindsay to J. A. MacDonald captioned Min- neapolis-Honeywell Regulator Co., Minneapolis, Minnesota D22—Memo dated August 16, 1960 from N. R. Brady to J. B. Bodley re Travelers Broadcast House, Hartford, Conn...................... 6361 4482 D24—Memo dated July 8, 1960 from J. B. Bodley to all ADT executive officers, re “Competition— Minneapolis-Honeywell Company” ........... 6362 4484 D26—Memo dated April 29, 1960 from A. 8. Jacks to H. B. Schultz re Tri-County Shopping Center—Shillito’s, Federated Department Store 6364 4486 D27—Memo dated February 3, 1960 from M. H. A. Lindsay to J. A. MacDonald re Minneapolis Honeywell Regulator Company and Competi- Se Os NE kas 6 er eh ins. 6365 4487 D28—Competition Report—November 20, 1962— West Orange, New Jersey. Job lost to Kidde ME SEE AGE FERRI: OSE ES 6368 4491 D30—Memo dated August 9, 1961 from M. H. A. Lindsay to L. J. O’Brien re New CIA Head- quarters, Washington, D. C, area............ 6369 4493 D32—Memo dated June 13, 1960 from A. Gaston to L. J. O’Brien re L. Bamberger & Company, Wem; Bae POM i or A ie. 6370 4494 E INDEX Record from the United States Distriet Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued Derenpant ADT’s Exuisitrs—Continued ’ Original D33—Memo dated January 26, 1960 from F. D. Shadell to W. J. Doyle re Competition........ 6371 D36—Memo dated January 31, 1956 from J. R. Hough to E. O. Betscher re Spurling and Kidde, Minusl, Phebe 6 656 REI 3 6373 D40—Memo dated January 14, 1954 from A. W. Sullivan to A. E. Smith captioned Atmo Com- ON Bo A ERIE TS 6375 D41—Memo dated April 2, 1953 from “General Superintendent” to R. M. Pineo captioned Atmo Fire Alarm Company, Bridgeport, Conn....:.. 6376 D42—Memo dated May 27, 1953 from R. M. Bug- bee to A. E. Smith captioned Atmo Competi- tion—New Haven, Conn..................... 6377 D45—Memo dated October 22, 1952 from W. J. Doyle to A. E. Smith re: Automatic Fire Alarm Competition, State of New Jersey............ 6378 D46—Memo dated October 14, 1952 from F. H. Langille to W. J. Doyle re: Automatic Fire Alarm Competition, State of New Jersey..... 6380 D51—Memo dated September 2, 1954 from E. J. Kaiser to King Young re: Competition....... 6381 D59—Memo dated April 8, 1959 from J. T. Lynch to R. T. Warner re: The New Haven Board and Carton Co., New Haven, Conn.........:..... 6382 D62—Memo dated March 12, 1957 from L. B. Straus to L. J. O’Brien re: Marshall Field & Co., Park Forest, Illinois....... saad fa ee Eee 6384 D75-B—Underwriters’ Laboratories, lea: Acad ited Central Stations by date of approval since 2 & & & FE E B& are _ a D75-E—Manual of Burglary Insurance (excerpts) 6387 Exhibit Volume VIII D89—Memo dated July 28, 1960 from Ray Brech- bill to R. J. Highstone re: Highland Park Police Department, Highland Park, Illinois... 6391 4523 D92—Memo dated January 5, 1960 from R. P. Lucy to W. K. Francis re: Bemis Bag Co., Newark, Califormia....... 2.26.6 6s cheer ee ess 6392 4524 D93—Memo dated October 5, 1954 from L. J. O’Brien to A. E. Smith re: Direct Connected Competition—Diebold Company and Gamewell Go, Chom Cltp, Tommie. cis es eee 6393 4525 xlii Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued Devenpant ADT’s Exnisits—Continued Original Print D97—Memo dated June 30, 1955 from C. L. Chafee to A. E. Smith re: Competition—Cin- cinnati, Ohio tions No. 3, dated November 24, 1953 from C. 8. Hammergren to All ADT Subsidiaries........ 6396 4528 E3—Letter from W. J. Dahl to A. W. Sullivan dated February 11, 1959, captioned Competi- tion—Tacoma, Washington RUS MAG see rR 6398 4530 E4—Letter from 8. H. Filipkowski to W. B. Flammer, dated August 6, 1956, captioned ADT Competition, Birmingham, Alabama.......... 6400 4532 E6—Memorandum from the Service Superintend- ent of ADT, Detroit, Michigan to Mr. Swanson, District Manager, dated October 10, 1960, cap- tioned Competition—Detroit, Michigan . 6401 4533 E7—Memorandum from W. K. Francis to L. J. O’Brien, entitled Competition, San Francisco, CI sii ie Sia ei IN os Ree ve bs 6402 4534 E8—Memorandum from R. T. Warner to L. J. O’Brien, dated April 6, 1960, captioned Com- eM i tdi hii iaiald PUL BRE SA ON V5 a 08 6405 4538 E9—Memorandum from E. J. Heisley to L. J. O'Brien captioned Competition—Washington, D. C., dated April 15, 1960................. 6407 4541 E10—Memorandum from A. 8. Jacks to L. J. O’Brien dated April 25, 1960, captioned Com- petition—Cleveland District................. 6410 4543 E-13—Letter from C. L. Chafee to L. J. O’Brien, dated June 7, 1957, captioned Competition— O’Brien, dated May 13, 1957 captioned Com- petition—Cleveland, Ohio.................... 6413 4548 E15—Memorandum from E. J. Heisley to L. J. O’Brien, dated April 17, 1957, captioned Com- petition Radar-Eye......................... 6414 4549 E16—Memorandum from R. T. Warner to L. J. O’Brien, dated March 8, 1957, captioned Com- petition—Radar-Eye ..................... 6415 4550 E18—Memorandum from E. J. Heisley to L. J. O’Brien, dated March 6, 1957, captioned Com- petition—Radar-Eye ..... 6416 46551 E19—Photostatic copy of an advertisement for the Radar-Eye Protection System as published in the Buffalo Carrier Express Newspaper, I Bs Hr oo 5.8 hic coe Sek. vin vee ee res 6417 4553 INDEX xliii Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued Derenpant ADT’s Exxisits—Continued Original Print E22—Memorandum from A. L. Kauffman to W. W. Dooley, dated August 12, 1954, captioned Competition—Denver, Colo................... 6418 4555 E28—Memorandum from W. E. Mauroschadt to Mr. John Stephens, dated ‘Angust 30, 1955. . 6421 4558 E48—Memorandum from Lynne Stora to E. B. White, dated August 9, 1954, captioned Conti- nental Can Company, Sacramento, California.. 6422 4559 E52—Letter from the President of ADT to the President of Holmes Electrie Protective Com- pany, dated March 27, 1947................. 6424 4561 E53—Letter from H. C. Ward, President, Holmes Electric Protective Company to E. A. Ward, President, ADT, dated March 26, 1947........ 6425 4561 E55—Memorandum from E. Turnbull to L. J. O’Brien, dated November 27, 1956, eaptioned “Certificate—Holdup Alarm, Minneapolis Dis- os ci iniinn hiceBiaiedn teed tees 6426 4562 E56—Memorandum from M. H. A. Lindsay to J. A. MacDonald, dated January 20, 1959, cap- tioned Southdale Shopping Center, Minneapolis, pe Pen ame ae het a ee 6427 4563 E57—Memorandum from L. H. Pryor to E. Turn- bull, dated June 20, 1956, captioned Electro- Watchman, BOR. inks cho dhe emavveen 6430 4566 E58—Memorandum from L. H. Pryor to E. Turn- bull, dated May 29, 1956, captioned Electro- Watchman, Inc., St. Paul, Minnesota......... 6432 4569 E60—Memorandum from D. R. Hall to L. J. O’Brien, dated September 2, 1958, captioned McConnell Kerr Company, Detroit, Michigan.. 6434 4571 E61—Contract competition report form 701 in- volving a prospect in Grand Rapids, Michigan 6435 4573 E69—Memorandum from R. T. Warner to L. J. O’Brien, dated April 12, 1957, captioned Com- petition—The Federal Burglar Alarm Company, Boston, Massachusetts........ .............. 6436. 4575 E70—Memorandum from R. T. Warner to L. J. O’Brien, dated January 8, 1958.............. 6437 4575 xliv INDEX Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued Derexpant ADT’s Exuisirs—Continued Original Print E71—-Memorandum from R. T. Warner to L. J. O’Brien, dated September 12, 1956, captioned MS Wes oo ce 6438 4577 E72—Memorandum from N. R. Brady to R. T. Warner, dated July 25, 1956................ 6439 4578 E82—Memorandum from E. J. Pueci to W. Hable, dated January 18, 1963, captioned Legislation— Laws and Ordinances Passed by City Councils and State Legislatures in the Minneapolis Dis- trict—Davenport—Moline .................. 6440 4579 —Attachments—Newspaper clippings......... 6441 4579 E84—Memorandum from E. Turnbull to L. J. O’Brien, dated July 27, 1960, captioned Com- petition—Cedar Rapids, Iowa................ 6445 4581 E86—Memorandum from D. R. Hall to L. J. O’Brien, dated September 2, 1958, captioned The Columbia-Western Corporation, South empl: Wn as 5 as 5 A ERGY: 6447 4583 E89-1—Letter from C. A. Wiborg, Lumbermen’s Mutual Casualty Company to the Holmes Elec- trie Protective Company, dated January 30, 1956, captioned Stewart Warner, Inc......... 6448 4584 E-89-2—Letter from E. J. Heisley to A. E. Smith, dated December 7, 1954, captioned Police De- partment Competition, Atlanta, Georgia...... 6449 4585 F16—Memorandum from the Secretary of ADT to J. A. MacDonald, dated June 24, 1963, cap- tioned The Citizens & Southern National Bank, PR DO 6B EO EES 6451 4589 F20—Memorandum from W. J. Dahl to Ray Brechbill, dated March 5, 1964, captioned Public Relations, Fire Department, Salt Lake City, We Fk ee re ay Fee CA RT SEX . 6458 4597 F42—Memorandum from J. J. Hayden to J. K. Scott, dated September 23, 1963, captioned Southern Burglar Alarm Co., Atlanta, Georgia 6463 4603 F43—Memorandum from P. K. Labadie to W. C. Martin, dated April 23, 1964, captioned Com- Pee Rees ha Bib ene se he ie 6464 4604 Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued Derenpant Hoimes Evecrric Prorecrive Compan y’s EXHIBITS H4—Pamphlet of the Autocall-Howe Plant Pro- tection Systems ................ 0.002 e cess H5—Letter from C. K. Empringham to Howard Stores, Inc., Brooklyn, N.Y., dated August 31, BOE a ES Banister pS H11—Report by J. G. Healey, Superintendent of Shops and Supplies, on the Local Alarm Con- ference, held November 4, 1960 in the Presi- dent’s Office, dated November 4, 1960 (excerpts) H16—Leaflet called “Protective Bulletin” issued hy the Insurance and Protective Department, American Bankers Association, for March, 1960 H18-1—cLetter from H. C. Ward to P. R. Webb dated April 16, 1952........................ H18-2—Memorandum from V. Wierman, Diebold, Kno. Ant: G2OGB oe ce es scapes. H-23—Competition report of Holmes, dated June 9, 1961, Pittsburgh, Pa. for the protection ac- count of the Keystone Iron & Metal Company H-26—Holmes Business Form No. 640 states that Holmes was bidding against a local alarm com- pany for the protection account of Citra Trad- her ai iis 6a a Shek Kadinncec ey nis H.30-1-—Competition Report of the Holmes Elec- trie Protective Company, dated January 3, 1963 in Philadelphia for the protection account of the Strait Advertising Company, Incorporated H30-2—Letter from T. L. Weber to Bruce D. Crockett, dated August 7, 1962, captioned Com- | ee eer ee ee re ree Derenpants’ Exursits (Depositions) W2a—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Joseph E. Cunningham, A. P. F. Company. . W4a—Excerpts of deposition testimony of M. I. Brod, Accurate Burglar Alarm Service. ..... W5a—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Gerson Zimmerman, Ace of Spades Burglar Alarm REE ee a POS SE SR Sn? SoG ee ae —Exhibits and handwritten correctiors....... W6a—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Thomas J. Smith, Alarm Engineering Company, Inc... . ro. 6491 6523 —Exhibits A thra E...................... 6660xxx W7a—Excerpts of deposition testimony of John W. Callaghan, Alarm Systems, Inc......... * 6660cece W8a—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Joseph Siegel, Alert Alarm Company................ 4619 4630 4633 xlvi INDEX Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued Derenpants’ Exuisits (Depositions)—Continued Original Print W29a—Excerpts of deposition testimony of George J. Kusta, Arrow Electric Protection Company 6713 4807 W10a—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Eric David, Tattle-Tale Alarms................... 6813 4843 Wlla—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Roy W12a—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Frank W. Houghton, Automatic Alarms............. 6907 4881 —Exhibits 7, 8,13 and 14................... 7006 ©4921 W13a—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Eve- rett A. Westphal, Bay Alarm Company....... 7012 4925 W14a—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Mor- ton Baizer, Bell Burglar Alarms and Eagle Pro- teatawe “Cem SS A. 7073 = 4951 W16a—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Jo- seph G. Wilson, Central Burglar Alarm Service and Surety Alarm Company................. 7166 4987 wr EB ATS. FERS 7255 5026 W17a—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Ar- thur A. Schwartz, Certified Burglar Alarm Sys- W18a—Exeerpts of deposition testimony of Clar- ence W. Novak, Chicago Mercantile Police inet BN i Se SE. 7437 = «4115 W19a—Excerpts of deposition testimony of James H. Coffey, Cirele Alarm Corporation......... 7455a 5122 W2la—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Ken- neth M. Holmes, Dallas Burglar Alarm Com- nhs EE DE UP ale oe ee oD Ta kas Dats 7458 5152 W22a—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Claude L. Carpenter, Dawn Patrol Burglar Re Ce i 8 Ee Ae 7490 =. 166 eS Ge Br. ies Fina os 7565 5192 W23a—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Grant Richard Hamilton, Day & Night Burglar Alarm COE NBs CSE tees - Ode Weds 7570 = 5196 Exhibit Volume IX W24a—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Al- fred Wayne Jackson, Diebold, Incorporated... 7626 5215 W25a—Excerpts of deposition testimony of R. Stafford Edwards, Edwards Company. . . F7R2 56255 W26a—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Lyle A. Vadnais, Electro Watchman, Inc. INDEX xlvii Record from the United States District Court for the Dis- trict of Rhode Island—Continued Devenpants’ Exuisirs (Depositions)—Continued OFi¢inel Print W27a—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Gerald R. DeLue, Frortier Guard and DeLue, WR Sis had weds Ho FL a 7845 5308 W28a—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Ar- thur William Fruh, A. W. Fruh & Company... 7°16 5344 W29a—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Harry Gerber, Gerber & Company.................. 7935 6354 W30a—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Loys C. Bridges, Greenville Avenue Patrol......... 7998 5378 W3la—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Mil- ton Pierce, Guardian Alarm Company........ 8035 5395 W32a—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Julian C. Cohn, Robert Hall Clothes, Inc............ 8097 65418 W33a—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Ken- neth V. McCluskey, Howard Stores Corporation 8113 5423 W34a—Excerpts of deposition testimony of John S. Nacey, Howe Electrie Company............ 8128 5429 W36a—Excerpts of deposition testimony of John H. Trout, International Business Machines Cor- MORNING Sy ccs cs oh c caves Kodss exeean ee ea ions 8219 5459 W37a—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Gor- don Dillard, Magnetic Alarm Inc............. 8244 5469 W38a—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Clar- ence Irvin Baker, Merchants Alarm Service... 8314 5491 W39a—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Rus- sell W. Laxson, Minneapolis Honeywell Regu- Nabe SN 6 ES SEI ERG mena 8399 5530 W40a—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Wil- liam Baggett, Mossie Burglar Alarm Company and Mossie Electric Protection Company...... 8438a 5554 W41la—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Oliver Tyrrell Joy, Notifier Corporation........... 8438ppp 5584 NUE MI 205 Like peers Mca eevee ws 8438} jj33) 5627 W42a—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Michael Singel, Security Alarm ............. 8440 5631 W43a—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Mary 3 B. Nordsiek, Nordsiek Protection Service .... 8474 5647 W44a—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Mor- ris J. Amsrud, Suburban Patrol Service Cor- NN 6 5.0 Shs teh eae SARA 68 Sv ies . 8491 5652 W45a—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Rob- ert E. Leeper, United States Burglar Alarm Company, Incorporated..................... 8501 5656 W46a—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Victor R. Zahn, Victor Burglar Alarm Company ... 8569 5684 W47a—Excerpts of deposition testimony of Henry A. Walters, WECO and Ace Alarm Company... 8648 5722 325 [fol. 462] Ins roe Unrren Srates District Court or THE District or MassacHUSETTS [Title omitted] Civil Action No. 2785 Transcript of Trial—Boston, Mass., June 15, 1964. APPEARANCES: Noel E. Story, Esq. and Hugh F. Morrison, Jr., Esq., Anti-trust Division, counsel for the plaintiff. Denis G. McInerney, Esq., Roger T. Clapp, Esq. and Gerald C. Van Cise, E'sq., counsel for the defendant Grn- nell Corporation, Frank A. Fritz, Esq., Frank A. Fritz, Jr., Esq., Matthew W. Goring, Esq., Robert L. Conkling, Esq. and Averill M. Williams, Esq., counsel for the defendants American Dis- trict Telegraph Company, Holmes Electric Protective Company and Automatic Fire Alarm Company of Dela- ware. [fol. 463] CoLLoquy anp Orrer In EVIDENCE oF GovERNMENY EXHIBITS 1 THrover 307 anv Ossections THERETO Mr. Story: Shall I proceed, your Honor? The Court. Yes. Mr. Story: Your Honor, the Government waives an opening statement in this matter, but I would request your Honor to allow me a very short rebuttal in the event that the defendants make an opening statement. The Court: All right. No opening will be made until the defendants begin, in accordance with the usual practice in this court. Mr. Story: Very well, your Honor. Well, your Honor, at this time the Government would like to proceed with the introduction of its documentary evidence. The Court: You may proceed. Mr. Story: Your Honor, I have one suggestion, if it is agreeable to all parties here, that will save some time, your 326 Honor. As your Honor knows, by order of this Court the Government filed with the Court designation of the docu- ments that it intended to use in its case-in-chief back in February, I think it was February Ist. In that document, the Government listed documentary material numbered from 1 to 307. Now it is my intention here this morning, your Honor, to describe only—— The Court: You need not describe them. They have al- ready been described. [fol. 464] Mr. Story: That is what I was going to suggest, your Honor. The Court: You may offer them in bulk. Mr. Story: Very well, your Honor. There is just one point that I would like to bring out to your Honor. There are some six documents where the Government introduced only a portion of the document. Now we have received ob- jections from the defendants to the admissibility of these documents. They have not objected so far to the introduc tion by the Government of only a portion. But I want to point out that to your Honor, so that in the event, as to those six documents, the defendants would like to offer any other portions, this will give them that opportunity. With that, your Honor, and to be of assistance to all of us in handling the exhibits in the record, I would suggest that the Government’s memorandum be given to the Court Reporter and have him type in the record of this hearing, just as I have here, the documents which have been, inci- dentally, your Honor, marked for identification by your Clerk, in the same numerical order as they appear in my memorandum. The Court: There is no reason ror the Court Reporter to undertake that labor. I will receive that — has it been marked? Mr. Story: This has not been marked. [fol. 465] The Court: I will receive that merely as a mat- ter for identification. It is not an exhibit. It is a classifica- tion of exhibits. It is not received as an exhibit. It is, how- ever. to be given a number, as though it were an exhibit, but to be marked an exhibit for identification only. What - is the next number? The Clerk: 364. The Court: It is 364 for identification only. 327 (Document entitled Designation of Documents upon which Plaintiff Will Rely in its Case-in-Chief and a state- ment of the main issues to which each document primarily relates, marked Exhibit 364 for Identification.) The Court: Now you offer the 363 preceding exhibits? Mr. Story: The Government now offers what have been marked Government Exhibits 1 through 307 for identifica- tion into evidence. The Court: Is there any objection? Mr. Fritz: I have two matters, your Honor. Mr. Story: Wait a minute. The Court: Wait a minute. I thought Mr. Story had con- cluded. Mr. Fritz: I am sorry. [fol. 466] Mr. Story: I am sorry, your Honor. I have fin- ished. The Court: Mr. Fritz? Mr. Fritz: First of all, if your Honor please, I object to the receipt of these documents in bulk. The Court: They will not be considered of course in bulk. But all have been before you, all of them have been ana- lyzed, and it is a matter of convenience to have them pres- ented in bulk. I will of course regard them individually. Mr. Fritz: Yes, I understand that. I wish to make the point, however, and I want to do it at the outset, that with such a bulk presentation, we have here a claim by the Gov- ernment for conspiracy between or among the four defend- ants, and I represent three of those defendants, and I sup- pose it is fundamental that no document relating to any alleged act or episode that may be referred to in any doc- ument on the part of one can possibly bind any other per- son until the so-called conspiracy is proved as an inde- pendent fact. The Court: I am satisfied from my examination of the documents that a prima facie case has been made for the admissibility on the conspiracy theory. Mr. Fritz: Well, I respectfully urge my reasons, as a preliminary objection. Secondly, as counsel for the Govern- ment has said, and as your Honor has noted, we have been furnished with a list of these documents, and we also have [fol. 467] furnished the Government with the designation of the objections that we have to those documents. There 328 are some of course to which we made no objection. Frankly, I am in a bit of a quandary as to what the situation is with regard and will be with regard to those objections. The Court: I am going to rule upon them this morning or as soon thereafter as you have finished your argument. Mr. Fritz: Well, I don’t think the document I have here will fully acquaint your Honor with the detail bases for the objections. The Court: You have my permission to speak orally as long as you like, to the Greek Calends, if you please. Mr. Fritz: Well, I haven’t any intention, if your Honor please, of arguing the objections to each of these three hundred and some odd documents individually, but I have noted to the Government the nature of our objections to those to which we do object. I have a statement here set- ting forth the nature of those objections in very cryptic form, however. I would be glad to hand those to the Court as part of the record in this case—— The Court: You may do so. Mr. Fritz: —as a basis for your Honor’s consideration. [fol. 468] The Court: You may do so. I have told you I am ruling as soon as you have finished. Anything you wish to say by way of elaboration you are free to say. No cloture will be imposed. Mr. Fritz: Well, I don’t think I wish to say anything fur- ther than to simply call your Honor’s attention to the na- ture of the objections we have to the various documents listed on this exhibit. The Court: It is received as Exhibit A for Identification on the part of the defendants, not for admission but for identification. (Schedule of defendant Alarm Companies’ Proposed Ob- jections marked Defendants’ Exhibit A for Identification.) Mr. Story: May I proceed, your Honor? The Court: I don’t know whether somebody else wants to say something. Mr. McInerney: If your Honor please, rather than du- plicate the statements of co-counsel, I would adopt his ob- jections insofar as they pertain to this defendant, and I would like to further note, your Honor, one other difference 329 in our position, perhaps not a difference but perhaps not one brought out and emphasized by co-counsel. Grinnell not only objects to these documents, or certain of them, but I have a list here—— {fol. 469] The Court. You may hand that up, if you wish, and it may be marked Exhibit B for Identification. (Defendant Grinnell Objections (to Government docu- ments) marked Defendants Exhibit B for Identification.) Mr. McInerney. In addition to the grounds stated on that list, your Honor, your Honor has stated that a prima facie case has been made out for a conspiracy and, therefore, the documents of the alleged co-conspirators should be admis- sible as against all of the defendants. This defendant has had a controlling interest in the other three defendants since 1953 and we respectfully submit, your Honor, that insofar as the documents between these defendants, exclud- ing those, but just taking the intra-corporate affairs of each defendant, even though those documents may relate to rela- tions with the other defendants but did not pass between the defendants, that is to stay any document that is not from, to or about Grinnell, since the period of its common ownership of these subsidiaries, we submit that as of that time there is no conspiracy recognizable in law with respect to the intra-corporate affairs of these people. Your Honor, I am not going to argue at great length. Mr. Story: Your Honor [fol.470] The Court: I know the Supreme Court cases. Do sit down, Mr. Story. Mr. Story: Your Honor, I had not finished my evidenti- ary presentation as to—— The Court: Please sit down, Mr. Story. Mr. McInerney: This is a very substantive point with us, your Honor. The Court: I understand that. And it is one which, of course, you are free to try to get the Supreme Court of the United States to change its views upon. Mr. McInerney: All I am saying, your Honor, is that I do not intend to expound on it at great length at this time. I simply wanted to note that objection, for the record, and have your Honor’s ruling on it at the close of the plaintiff’s case. The Court: The 307 exhibits, Exhibits 1 through 307 for 330 Identification, inclusive, are admitted in toto, in accordance with the proffer. All objections are overruled. (Documents formerly marked Government’s Exhibits 1 through 307 for Identification received in evidence.) OrFer In Evipence or AppirrionaL GOVERNMENT EXHIBITS Mr. Story: Now, your Honor, the next five exhibits which have been marked for identification are duly executed stipu- lations between the parties. I would like now to identify them on the record. Government Exhibit for Identification No. 308 is stipula- {fol. 471] tion No. 1 between the parties, which is a stipula- tion as to the authenticity of the documents offered into evi- dence by the plaintiff, that is, Government Exhibits 1 through 307. The Court: Is there any objection? I hear none. Ad- mitted. (Stipulation No. 1 between the parties marked Govern- ment’s Exhibit 308 and received in evidence.) Mr. Story: The next document, which has been marked Government Exhibit 309 for Identification, is designated as Stipulation No. 2, which is a stipulation as to the volume of customers across State lines in the United States and the District of Columbia. The Court: Mr. Story, if these are all stipulations, there is no need for you to describe them. You will just run up a bill with the Court Reporter. How many stipulations are there? Mr. Story: There are five. The Court: Is there any objection to any of them? Mr. Fritz: No, sir, we have stipulated. The Court: They are all admitted. Mr. Fritz: I am assuming that we are talking about the same ones he is. [fol. 472] The Court: Obviously if there is a mistake with respect to that, I will reopen the matter. Mr. Story: Just for the record, your Honor, the stipula- tions have been numbered Government Mxhibits 308, 309— The Court: You are not buying this transcript but the defendants are. Why charge them for your words? 331 Mr. Story: Well, your Honor, this will only take a few minutes, and I would like the record to be straight. The Court: All right. Mr. Story: Government’s Exhibits 311 and 312. (Stipulations Nos. 2, 3 and 4 and 5 between the parties marked Government’s Exhibits 309, 310, 311 and 312, re- spectively, and received in evidence.) Mr. Story : Now, your Honor, the next four exhibits which have been marked for identification are the Government’s extracts of answers by the defendants to interrogatories propounded by the Government. The Court: 313 through what? Mr. Story: 313, 314, 315 and 316. The Court: Is there any objection? I hear none. Ad- {fol. 473] mitted. (Designation of Answers of ADT, Holmes Electric Pro- tective Co., Automatic Fire Alarm Co. of Delaware and Grinnell Corporation to Interrogatories propounded by Plaintiff, marked Government’s Exhibits 313, 314, 315 and 316, respectively, and received in evidence.) Mr. Story: Now, your Honor, the next exhibits which have been marked by your Clerk for Identification are ex- cerpts from the transcripts of depositions taken in this matter. The Court: What are their numbers please? Beginning with 317? Mr. Story: 317 through 363. The Court: These are all extracts from depositions? Mr. Story: Yes, your Honor. The Court: And you are offering them in toto. And there is no objection to them, I assume? Mr. Story: No, your Honor, there is not. The Court: No objection? Mr. Fritz: Well—— Mr. Story: I—— The Court: Just a moment. There appears to be an ob- ' jection by Mr. Fritz. (fol. 474] Mr. Story: Well, your Honor, I am not offering all of them into evidence. The Court: What are you doing? 332 Mr. Story: Some of the extracts, your Honor, I am not offering into evidence. The Court: Which ones did you have marked you do not intend to offer? . Mr. Story: I can state those in the record right quickly. The Court: I hope so. Mr. Story: Government Exhibit 321, which is a deposi- tion of Benjamin H. Call of the Call Police Signal Corpora- tion, Chelsea, Massachusetts. The Government does not plan to offer into evidence this deposition because we found in the late stages that it would be cumulative. The Court: I am not ruling on matters not offered. Just give me the numbers of the ones you are not offering. Mr. Story: I am not offering Government Exhibit for Identification 321, 322—— Mr. Fritz: Excuse me. What was that number? The Court: 321 and 322. Mr. Story: Yes, sir. Mr. Fritz: Could you give us the name please? The Court: Yes, do that. The first one was Call. [fol. 475] Mr. Story: All right. The Court: The second one? Mr. Story: Exhibit 322 for Identification is a deposition of Henry G. Clark, Providence, Rhode Island. Mr. Fritz: Who is 321? The Court: Call. Mr. Fritz: Thank you. Mr. Story: Government Exhibit 327 is the deposition of Joe Forman of the Call Police Signal Corporation, Chelsea, Massachusetts. Government Exhibition for Identification 332 is the depo- sition of Francois Guibert, District Telegraph Company, Newark, New Jersey. Government Exhibit for Identification 344 is the deposi- tion of Ralph C. Peabody, Granite State Alarm Company, Manchester, New Hampshire. Government Exhibit for Identification 350 are excerpts from the deposition of Herman E. Robinson, Protective Alarm Company, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Government Exhibit for Identification 353 is the deposi- tion of Freddie Schnell, Electro-Protective Corporation, Newark, New Jérsey. 333 Government Exhibit for Identification 354, extracts of the deposition of Jack Silverman, National Protective Corpora- tion, Baltimore, Maryland. [fol.476] The Government is not offering the exhibits I have just related. The Court: The Government’s offer is of Exhibits 317 through 320, 323 through 326, 328 through 331, 333 through 343, 345 through 349, 351, 352, 355 through 363. Is there any objection? Mr. Fritz: Well, there are two others I would like to make inquiry about because I think they fall in the same category of reasons for which the others have been excluded. I may be in error. The deposition of Mr. Rosenberg of the Hyde Park Alarm, which is within 100 miles of this court, may I ask the Government whether that deposition is to be offered or not? Mr. Story: The Government—Mr. Who, sir? Mr. Fritz: Mr. Rosenberg, Hyde Park Alarm, in this area. Mr. Story: The Government has not designated any por- tion of that deposition and at the moment we do not intend to offer any of it. Mr. Fritz: Very well. May I also inquire whether or not the deposition of Harold S. Leich, Milwaukee, Wisconsin, is intended to be offered by the Government? Mr. Story: It was offered, your Honor, and I intended to offer it. [fol.477] The Court: The number please? Mr. Story: Your Honor, that is Exhibit 355—335, rather. The Court: 355. Mr. Story: Well, your Honor—— The Court: Hold on for a moment. I don’t want any- thing on the record or off the record until I have read this communication which has just been handed to me. I have just been handed a communication, received this morning in the office of the Clerk, from Harold S. Leich, who, I assume, is the person to whom reference has just been made in the preceding colloquy. This is addressed to Neale D. Murphy, Clerk. It is addressed to the United States District Court, United States Court House and Post Office Building, Boston, Mass. 334 It reads as follows: ‘‘Dear Mr. Murphy” and it is signed ‘‘Harold 8. Leich.”’ ‘Would you please hand the Judge the enclosed let- ter. The enclosed subpoena was not served on me until 7:30 A.M. June 13, 1964. ‘‘T also contacted at 12:42 A.M. June 14, 1964 it, Ralph Schulke of the local A.D.T. office so that he could inform their attorneys.’’ [fol.478] And the enclosed letter is from a Dr. Francis F. Rosenbaum, 425 East Wisconsin Avenue, Milwaukee, Wisconsin. It is dated June 13, 1963. It is addressed to this Court and says: ‘‘This is to certify that I have attended Mr. Harold S. Leich of 8860 No. Tenneyson Dr., Milwaukee, Wis., 53217, since November 1960. Mr. Leich has extensive coronary artery disease. ‘*T have been informed that Mr. Leich has been asked to appear at a trial in Boston on the morning of June 15, 1964. It is my opinion that Mr. Leich should not appear at a trial without adequate medical preparation and that the time allotted since his notification is not sufficient to permit this.’’ Mr. Duffey, in copying this in the record, there are a number of typographical errors. It is to be copied exactly as it is, please. In view of this plausible, at any rate, excuse, do you want to persist with the offer of exhibit 355 for Identification? Mr. Story: Yes, your Honor. The Court: All right. I just did not know whether in view of the fact it is quite obvious we may have to have a postponement, if you introduce 355 for indentification, [fol. 479] you want, yourself, to invite that postponement. Mr. Story: In just a moment—— The Court: That is all I am asking you. Nothing more. Think about it. Mr. Story: Your Honor, the Government will withdraw its offer. The Court: All right. That is enough. You don’t have to tell me why. Mr. Story: I want to straighten the number out, your 335 Honor. I called it 355. It should be 335. I would like to get that straightened out on the record. The Court: All right. Mr. Story: The Government will withdraw its offer of this deposition into evidence. The Court: All right. It is withdrawn. That makes it 333, 334 and 336 through 343. Mr. Fritz: Mr. Story, have you finished with your offer? Mr. Story: Yes. CotLoquy Between Court anp CounsEL For DEFENDANTS Mr. Fritz: If your Honor please, some time back—— The Court: Excuse me. Before you do proceed, would Mr. Story or somebody on the United States Government’s side inform Mr. Leici that the subpoena—no, I guess the defendants issued the subpoena. [fol.480] Mr. Fritz: That is correct, yes, sir. The Court: Will the defendants inform him that the sub- poena is withdrawn? Mr. Fritz: Yes. The Court: With the corisent of the Court it is quashed. Now you may proceed. Mr. Fritz: As your Honor will note, and probably has not had an opportunity to note, counsel for the Govern- ment and ourselves have cooperated to have printed almost as a running text the -xcerpts from all of these depositions that have been offered. The Court: You would be surprised at how much I have noted, although in your arguments you have sometimes assumed that I do not note what is filed. Mr. Fritz: I really would not assume that, sir. It is just bulk that I thought—— The Court: You had better make no assumptions as to the rate or quantity of work that I have done. Mr. Fritz: I hope your Honor will take my statement that I meant not the slightest offense or reflection. The Court: I do regard your stiéiements as both an offense and a reflection at an earlier stage because they are based upon the assumption that I gained information from some other source or other circumstances than by [fol.481] your demand that I should read these docu- ments. Mr. Fritz: May I—— 336 The Court: You yourselves put on me the burden of forming an opinion and I did form one. Mr. Fritz: May I respectfully say that I had no such intention in any comment I made to this Court. The Court: You have sometimes given the Court the impression that I acquired some idea of this case except from you and opposing counsel. I have no other idea. Mr. Fritz: I have purposely never intended to convey the slightest intimation of that to your Honor nor has it been in my mind at any time, and if I did so it was certainly an inadvertence, which I regret very. much. The Court: You have made it quite plain io the country at large, or at least to this community, that you regarded me as having formed an opinion from some othe [Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.] --- Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386411_0279%3A02. Public record. Not legal advice.