# Transcript of Record — Maryland Ex Rel. Levin v. United States (No. 345)

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386411_0158%3A02

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Transcript of Record
- **Published:** January 1, 1964

## Text

% 2¢ Se
: Oia Pa oor ae ee
_. SYDNEY L. JOMNS, ET AL, PETITIONERS,

Y V8.
: =
a. x .. wr, 2B : ee) f
> "ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI 70 THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPRALS
FOR THE ‘cmacae! es
‘ ms ; 4 A
oS PETITION 3 FOR CERTIORARI FILED AUGUST 3, 1964 _— fj
_ CERTIORARI GRANTED OCTOBER 19, 1964 7
‘ ;

‘ . : ‘ : : °~% ] Es ART aoe
= aia” piecey
le ee Print
hice tins the United States District Court for ies
the Western District of Pennsylvania ae iE
Relevant docket entries in No. eens A +
Clerk’s note ; ‘EB. 61.7
ee tN ie ag
8. : eteea ee transcript and exhibits. pertaining. =a
to preliminary issue: Jie .
a. Transcript | of proceedings, May 29 and 31, 1961 ir
. Witmesses: .
Robert J. Skahan. op parepeescennnmnnven = 17
Captain Julius R. MeCoy cei cele 35 -
Lieutenant Colonel Victor F. rey +: 122
46 + John Tames Stasko ~ SLs - 186

Sp. . Plaintifi’s Exhibit 1, Local Flight Clearmiee .- S Ga
. Plaintiff’s Exhibit: 2, wight Order Number - |

ee. 209
- Plaintiff’s Exhibit 3, Civilian Persorinel New. yi
*. ual ilaiipacle .210 -
‘Plaintiff's Exhibit 4, AFR -60-2 ere
pfaintiff’s Exhibit 5,.File of Bureau of Em-
| ployee’s Compensation arene 224 -
Plaintiff’s’ Exhibit 6, Special Orders No: is, .
dated 13 Sept., 1955 :.....:; / ;
_ Plaintiff’s Exhibit.7, AFR 45-2. " 233
Plaintiff's . ‘Exhibit | 9, ° ~ Deposition of Col.
‘ | Ebaugh _ anion
© . Plaintiff's Exhibit : 10, Deposition cof Major - ms
Britton 253
Plaintift’s Exhibit 11; Deposition of en. Wil- -

_ son . 277°

ae
.

ee :

ot

VaR ee - Index Continued —

Plaintiff’s. Exhibit /12, Deposition of. Capt. ‘

~ MeCoy . met seaeenee B43, 416

Plaintiff's Exhibit 13, Senin e Major

Seott~ ..... zs 499

Plaintiff's Exhibit 14, Deposition of Col. Kil-

. kowski ........ 509

” Plaintiff's Exhibit. 15, N ational Guard Regula

Page ;

. tions No. 75-16 -.........-.. .. 634 . oe

* Plaintiff's Exhibit 16, National Guard Regula-

tions No. 75-16 ........ wie * 647 - ;
ee Plaintiff’s Exhibit 1 17, ANGR 40-01 a 652.
¢. Defendant's Exhibit. 1, General Orders secseele 660.

Defendant’s Exhibit 2,- ‘Special Order No. 98 .. ‘662

Defendant’s Exhipit 3 Local. Flying -Aréa,
a 0.P. No. 3 2.1: 6

Defendant’s Exhibit 4, Passengers’i in Aircraft,

S.0.P.. No.9 665 —
Defendant’s Exhibit 5, Local Clearance, S. 0. me
No, 18., .. 666
Defendant's Exhibit 7, AFR 45-2: ae iene CBT
_ |, Defendant’s Exhibit 9, ANGR 50-01 «671
6. Subicoigiitiatel and Answers of September 1959 677
Se Memorandem, filed Sept. 1, 1961 ed — a} 33 679
8. Findings of Fact, fifed October 27, 1961... voneesenennne 679 . : -
9. Conclusions of Law, filed October. 27, 1961 oa a 688
10. Order, filed. October 27, 1961 pet cS tam

/ ff ’

Cs 7, Re Original, Print."
Plaintiff's Exhibit No! 5— ah Zot.
Chalmers dated May 20, 1: 689 ~ 689. —
Fxeerpt from. interrogatories 690 690° *
Opinion, Gourley, C. J. 2 aera ae.

ings in United States Court -of Appeals oe ee
for the Third Circuit ore Fee” tes

- Opinion, Smith, J. Rie ecceecee ee 708
Ypinion concurring in resut,'Hastie, J... 2 6S
Dissenting ‘opinion, Staley, J, _’ a 728 _ 726

Judgment in Case No. 14,04] 2: Senex SLAW ae 734 731.
Judgment in Case No. 14.042 finer RG. TRS

“Order denying petition for rehearing... 736 . “733 :

‘certiorari -_ a nena ee 738 7. > é °
~ Order allowing ovetioreri 2 —--- 739 784° nan

c. pains a se. in e Pe
~ | .
“ i,
5 ;
\
.
o
..
* “
;
f 6 :
ay
s
a °
| a
* : :
|
e idS, | ;
(ee |
/ ” ’ |
of |
f j
ae !

Captain Julius R. McCoy |

416.

Was recalled as a witnéss and having ibeionills been duly’

ul

' sworn was examined and testified as follows :.

7 Examinatjon by Mr. Pettibone:
My. Pettibone: Will the Reporter mark this as United hy"

States Exhibit for identification No. 1.

(Genefal Orders referred. to marked U. S. Exhibit No. z

. for identification. D ak
Mr. Pettibone: Please hand United. States Exhibit for

identification No. 1, to the. witness.
328: Paper handed to witness. )

5 Q (By Mr. Pettibone) Captain McCoy, will you look
ce “at United States Exhibit for identification No. 1.
‘ "Were you commissioned as a second lieutenant in the

Maryland Air Nation
rank from January

Guard on 31 January 1952, with.
1952, pursuant to Gefefal Orders

No. 9, issued by the State of Maryland Military Depart-
ment, Fifth Regiment Armory, Baltimore, dated 31 Janu- -
ary.’52? A. This appears to be a General Order issued by
ttre State of Maryland, appointing me as a second lieutenant

ia the Maryland our rrannas Gon, yes, sir, on the dates

indicated.

Q. And that asppointzaeatt was pursuant to General Order
No. 9, an abstra¢t part: of which: appears in United States

‘Exhibit No? 1 for identification, i is that —— A. That

is correct.

ba

-Q. Now, were’) “you on: March 31, 1952, by tednaiaa Order

_ No. 24, issued by the State of ‘Maryland Military Depart-

ment, Fifth Regiment Armory, Baltimore, Maryland, given ~

| Federer #eognition as a second lieutenant in the Maryland

4 National Guard, with date of rank from 25

329° 3 sneer 1952? A. Again, a portion of the exhibit

; sears to bea reproduction of a General Order
me as a second lieutenant, with Federal recog- .

ot

: ap: > iggy
nit: fhe eT Air National Guard. |

. interest

ie S|

Q And doet the ‘ait ‘from emer Order No. wo. es
which’is shown in United States Exhibit ‘No. 1 for identi-
ficatio appear to be an extract copy of the orders 80 ex- .
- g Federal. recognition? "

/ %

- board, or, alii like that? A.-They were prepared i in

Q. ‘About how lorig a pertedowould be covered usually
“by training schedules of this e? ALI believe they are
published for a six months period. ~~

advance: tthe training pet yes.

Q. Would the -training schedule call for meetings | or

assemblies of members, of the: commissioned officers, mem-
bers of the unit? A. They would require the entire mem-

bership of the unit, both enlisted and commissioned, to per-

form. their particular functions.

Q: About how often. would. the ‘meetings take placet A.
Roughly twice a month. : »

Q. Did you | ever see any training schedules of this

352 type that. were issued by anyone other than your unit

: commander? Vari Ausdell—V-an A-u-s-d-e-l-l—and I believe in 1953 _

Lieutefant Colonel Dow-—D-o-w—and [| believe agajn in
1957 he waa replaced by Majo: _Britton—B-r-i-t-t-o-1.
Mr. Wolcott: What was his full name?
The Witness: “Major Britton?
Mr. Wolcott :. . oe
The Witness: Milton D.: Britton.
Q. (By Mr. Pettibone) Now, as a cities officdr your-

.. self, you are familiar, I assume, with the expre
. monly used in the Air Force and the Air Nati

and other military installations, ealled command thority, 4

is that correct? A. Iam, yes. ~
Q. Would any of these officers whom you have just

: named, who were attached'to your unit as Air Advisor, in ~

| your opinion have command authority at any tite 0 over you
as a commissioned officer in that unit? /
854 Mr. Mudd: Just a minute. Objectign. The’ ques-
tion ‘calls for a conclusion of law——+
Mr. Pettibone: It calls for his opinion. — .
Mr. Mudd: —by the witness, or, ds the question said,
his opinion. I therefore object to it.

I do not instruct this witness not to answer, ieee -

~ Mr. Wolcott: ‘Well, Iwant to join in the objection, and
on the further ground that the witness has not stated what
_he-unQerstands the term command authority to‘ be, and I
‘ think hé should be first asked -that in any event.

Mr. Pettibone: I think your point is well taken, Mr.
Wolcott, very well taken.

Q.. (By Mr. Pettibone) Captain McCoy, _ is your
understanding of the meaning of the term command. re-..
sponsibility in the military establishment?

Mr. Wolcott: Did you. say authority or responsibility?

Are ‘you.using the term command ey or com- ©

mand authority? ©
Mr. Pettibone: Command ‘saiiceaiie: Command au-
thority. If I. said responsibility, Mr. Reporter,
355. please correct my statement. It-should be command
authority. — os
&£, ;

?
ca all

Tae
| 431 ©

Q. (By Mr. Pettibone) Could you tell us what that means,
Captain McCoy? .A. There are established command lines
in my opinion that emanate from the president right on |
- down, right through the lowest officer, in a chain or in an
organization of a particular type. : - ,
Mr. Wolcott: You are talking about the President of the.
United States? agit, pee t
The Witness: That is correct, sir. AS
Mr. Wolcott: Yes. mn ie
~ Well, I still don’t understand*what is meant by it.
Mr. Mudd: Well, perhaps not what the witness has said
‘what he understands ‘by it. Pee x
_ Mr. Wolcott: Well, okay.| It certainly left me in the dark.
Mr. Pettibone: I will be glad to furnish you with the
Air Force publication, if there is one, I don’t know that
there is one. | Ais ss ,
- Mr. Wolcott: Does that mean a chain of command,
356 may I. ask? 0,
eee Mr. Pettibone: Is this off the record\now?
.. Mr. Wolcott: Yes. | ; aa
-(Discussion off the -record.) |
Q. (By Mr. Pettibone) Captain McCoy, did you ever
individually receive any direct orders from any of the offi-
cers whom you have just mentioned, who filled the position
of Air Advisor with your unit? A. None other than to-
respect the rank and the military position of a superior, -
to. my knowledge. *
“.*Q. Now, you have testified previdusly in this proceed-
ing that part of your duties with the 104th Fighter Squad-
‘ron was to perform what you called check-outs on planes .
: and instruments assigned.to the unit. — .
-* What is embraced in the termi check-out as you used it in
that connection? A. The term I believe was flight check.
Q. All right. A. I might be corrected on that.
° Q. All right. A. And the objective was to evalu-
357 ate the. equipment for its fitness for flight or for —
its air readiness in the case of instruments or radio

oy ee

equipment and to monitor the quality of maintenance per-
' formed at the installation.

Q. Did that sometimes involve your ae flying the
equipment? A.It did. —

Q. As pilot? A. That is eorrect.

Q. Now, when you performed such duties involving the -

»- flying of equipment for this purpose, was that done pur-
suant to soméone’s orders, some superior’s orders? A. It
is desirable that an aircraft maintenance -officer be able to
perform this duty, and I. believe that can be found in the
appropriate manuals.

Q. Yes, realize that, but when you actually did- per-
form the duty, was it performed: pursuant to orders of
anyone? A. In all eases flight orders were issued to per-
form these duties.

Q. Yes, and by whose authority, or.in whose name

358 - Y were the flight orders in those instances issued? A. -

_ The authority to operate the aircraft was issued by
the Department of Air Foree.

Q. I am referring now to flight orders to make a specific ©

flight for the purpose which you have just described. Were
those orders issted by the Department of Air Force? A.

® I assume the overall authority to operate the aircraft—— ,

Q. No, I am not referring to that, but——.
_ Mr. Wolcott: Please let the witness answer. You are
interrupting the witness.

Mr. Pettibone: All right IT sath not “wll to interrupt

him.

Mr. Wolcott: Now, clear up his answer. Let him finish
‘his answer. .

Q. (By Mr. Pettibone) Go ahead, state your answer. A.
aan} in that connection, authority specifically delegated to
the local Commander, who in turn issued the epee order
to perform a specific flight.

Q. All right, now, we are referring——

433

‘ii Wolcott: “Would you read that answer back? ¥ does
_ not sound very complete.
— 359 (Answer read by Reporter. 7

i, ( By Mr. Pettibone) Where the spécific orders
for the specific flight——

Mr. Mudd: I think we would all agree that there was some
| ‘part ‘of his statement or answer that wast out.

Mr. Wolcott: That is right, because he svarted to say

. by authority-——

Mr. Mudd: It is my understanding that he said they orig-

inally came down from the Air Force and they went to the .

local Commander.
Mr: Wolcott: That is the part that was left out. ;
Mr. Mudd: I wonder if we could clarify that on the ree-
ord, Mr. McDonald?

(Testimony read by tle Reporter.) |

Mr. Mudd: Do you wish to add anything? You said, “1
assume the overall authority’’, and then there was an in-
terruption by Mr. Pettibone, and if Mr. Pettibone has no
objection to letting him give his full answer.

Mr. Pettibone: Yes, let us supply the missing part, and —

I think he will probably be able to supply that, and then
take up the rest of that.

-360 The Witness: With the interruptions that have
been in there, I am losing words.

Can I just make the whole answer over again?

Mr. Mudd:.Go ahead.

Mr. Pettibone: Go ahead.

Mr. Wolcott: Go, ahead.

The Witness: I assume that the overall authority to oper-

ate the aircraft is issued by the Department of Air Force,.

. ‘and then authority is subsequently delegated to the local
Commanders to issue orders for a specific flight.

Q. (By Mr. Pettibone) Were the specific orders for the
om flight that you have described issued in each in-

:

stance by the Commander of your local unit, that is, the
* 104th Fights Squadron? A. To the best of my ability.

‘Q.. You mean to the best of your recollection? A.Tothe .

best of my belief. I don’t recall it.

Q. Yes. Yes. That would in other words be the base *'

detachment Commander of your unit, either Colonel Kilkow-
os _ski or Major Britton, or Majér Scott, excuse me. A. I
361 ‘believe this would be the Squadron Commander ra-
ther than the base detachment Commander.
Q. I see. And who would that.be? Can you recollect the

name of the Squadron Commander who issued those or- ..

ders? A. Any particular year or ‘flight?

Q. Oh, let us take the year 19581 A. Colonel Kilkowski
was Squadron Commander at that time. Yassume he would
_ issue the orders.

-Q. Were the other ion, the other Squadron officers”
. who would issue such orders, also commissioned officers in
the Air National Guard, assigned to your unit? A. Yes,
ae
Mr. Mudd: Objection, on the ground of materiality.

Go ahead and answer the question if you know.

A, I assume that they are in the Air National Guard,.
yes, sir. f

Q. (By Mr. Pettibone) Now, in your previous testimony
. you have mentioned the fact that’ you were from time to
- time given check flights to test your flying proficiency.

In general, what is the nature of such a flight, and in gen-
“eral how is it conducted, just briefly? A. Certain in- ©

diyiduals are assigned the duty annually to check

the proficiency of the pilots of the unit and the
standardization between the pilots with the unit, and they
are given a flight check, the pilots are given a flight check
by these individuals.

Q. Well, exactly what does that involvet Does that in-
volve making a flight in a plane accompanied by the person
giving the test? - A. That is correct.

Q. Did you actually cw J such — for such test pur-
poses? A. I did.

435

Q. Since the time of your commissioning in 1952, about
how many such flights did. »u make for tést’ purposes?
A. I don’t recall. ff . ee

Q. Well, about how often do you make these flights? Is:
it once a year or more frequently or less frequently than
that? A. I believe it is annually. |

Q. Were the individuals who gave you these tests mem-
bers .of the unit to which you were assigned? A. Prob-

_ ably. : : ;
363 Q. That is to say, were they commissioned, officers

'. - ‘asbigned’ to the same unit as yourself? A. To the
best of my recollection, yes.

Q. Do you remember the names of any of them? "A. I.
don’t at this moment. ,

Q: Were you ever given a check, a test flight for such
checking purposes, by anyorfe other than a member as-
signed_to the same unit as yourself? A. In-my original
answer in this line of questions I referred to the standardi-
zation for proficiency flight check. © es

Q. Yes. A. To my knowledge, I can’t recall any mem-
ber other than a member assigned or attached to the 104th
Fighter Squadron that performed such a check with me.
_ Q. Now; Captain McCoy, in addition to being commis-
sioned officer, a flight officer, a pilot in the 104th Fighter
Squadron, you were also a civilian “employee of that unit,
- is that correct? A. I am not quite sure what status I was. .
é Q. Well, you testified before, if I remember cor-

. 864 rectly, you said you had a dual status: You were
; a commissioned officer in the Air National Guard,
assigned to this unit, and we have just gone over the assign-
- ment, your assignment to this unit, and your service with
it from 1952 to the.present time. Now I am turning to
something else. You were also in addition to being a com-
missioned officer, you were also a civilian employee for a
particular purpose, whicli we will go, into in a moment, in
the unit, is that correct? ay

- Mr. Mudd: Go ahead and answer it if you can.

A. I cannot answer this question truthfully. I am re-
quired to wear the uniform that I presently have on during
my status as an Air Technician, and I cannot truthfully
answer -your cuestion.

Q. (By Mr. Pettibone) Well, aren’t you aware of the~
fact that you were and are a civilian employee of the 104th
Fighter Squadron as well as being a commissioned officer
in it? A. Again, I cannot be positive as to the status.

. Mr. Pettibone: Will the Reporter mark this document
as United States Exhibit No. 3 for identification?

(Special Orders referred to marked U. S. Exhibit 3 for
berms cad D* a

365 Mr. Pettibone: I would like to ask the witness to
look at Exhibit No. 3 for identification.

(Paper handed to and examined by witness. )

Mr. Wolcott: May Task you on the record, Mr. Pettibone,
: what PAC means?
Mr. Mudd: Similar to authority contained in——
Mr. W>leott: What does ANGR mean? :
b M: add: National Guard Regulations.

Mr. Pettibone: In case you have any question as to the
extract, the part excluded does not pertain to the witness
or having anything to do with this matter that we are deal-
ing with here. - :

_ Mr.. Wolcott: Yes. .

Mr. Pettibone: But I will be, glad to give you the whole
order.

Mr. Wolcott: Well, I assume the same comment applies.
to all of these.

Mr. Pettibone: Yes, that is right.

- Mr. Wolcott: May I ask you on the record, Mr. Petti-
bone, what assistant U.S. P. & F. O. means?
Mr. Pettibone: It is an —callaageaas for. ‘United
366 States Property & Fiscal ener
Mr. Wolcott: I see. —

Mr. Pettibone: As Iam : informed by competent Air —
» authority.,

Mr. Mudd: And put that in capitals, Mr. McDonald. Let
the record show he is referring to Major Prince.

Q. (By Mr. Pettibone) Captain McCoy, referring to
United States Exhibit No. 3 for identification, have you
seen this document before at any time? I don’t mean this
specific one. I mean the original of which this is a copy
or another copy of it. A. I have. -

Q. In the second line of United ‘Biates Exhibit No. 3 you
will see the term, ‘‘Air National Guard Civilian Personnel
-Program’’. Do you know what that means or what it refers —
to? A. I assume that it has reference to some Portion of
the: Air National Guard Regulation 40-01.

Q. Do you know whether or not it provides a program
or procedure for the employment. of civilian personnel by
the National Guard? °

Mr. Mudd: Objected to. “
367 Mr. Wolcott: All right, objected ‘“ . / :
Are you referring to the personal knowledge of
the witness? -.

Mr. Pettibone: Yes, I am edkion him whether he knows. .
Mr. Kieffer: Just a minute. For the ecord I would like
to have it stated, although formal objections are waived, I -
wish to concur ‘in all objections previously made and sub-

sequently. made that I did not individually object to.

And that goes on behalf of Mr. Galiher and his clients,
- ‘and Mr.:Davidson and his clients.

Mr. Pettibone: Well, I am sorry, Mr. Kieffer, but I
could not 'agree to let a statement of that _— pass without |
comment. \ ="
. you have an objection on form, in accordance with .

our procedure here, you will have to make your objection,
the same as the rest of us hays, I _ not agree to any
other procedure.

Mr. Kieffer: Well, I believe this is a: seme discovery:
. deposition, and under the Rules, of course, no © objections
are ‘waived at the trial. \

438°.

368 Do you prefer from now on that I concur in all
_ objections made with Mr. Wolcottt
Mr. Pettibone: At the beginning of this deposition of
the witness, you were not present at that time, I believe,
but it was agreed that any objection as to form would be
made here and now during the taking of the deposition of

the witness, and that was the basis upon which we agreed:

that we would conduct this deposition. At least that is my

understanding of it. And there are other people here who

can concur in that. So in accordance with that, so far.as
I am concerned, I cannot make any exception to what was
to be the procedure, and objections as to form have to be
made here and. now.

Mr. Kieffer: At this time I wish to concur in the objec-
tion which is made.

Q. (By Mr. Pettibone) Will. you answer the question? 7

| _ Mr. Wolcott: What is the question?
(Question read by the Reporter.)

Mr. Wolcott: Are you objecting, Mr. Muda?’
Mr. Mudd: Well, I made the original objection.
Mr. Wolcott: Yes.

369 Mr. Mudd: Of course, obviously this is a long

way from the best evidence, but if you are testing

_his knowledge. of the regulation, I will let him answer. Of —
course, what he says or what he \understands does not nec- .

essarily prove what the program provides.’

Mr. Pettibone: Well, we all realize that a lot of the things 3
- that he testified to here thus far have not — been the .

best evidence on the point.

Mr. Mudd: No, but presumably on some of these techni-
cal regulations, it may not be correct. The point I am mak-
ing is that to test this witness on the contents of various
regulations is extending the record really without any au-
thoritative source, you might say...

Mr. Pettibone: If I have been very technical, I would

certainly have to agree with you, but I really only asked ~

t

him very ‘broad general tentine. Now, maybe E., am in
error, but I assume that matters in the general knowledge
of a commissioned officer with his rank i in | the Air National
_ Guard would be admissible. |
I am trying very hard not to be. very technical about

the regulations, and naturally they will speak for
_ 370 ~- themselves anyhow. ©

' -Mr. Mudd: That is right, that is “right. .

Mr. Pettibone: I am asking him in a general way if he
is familiar with the general civilian employment program
of the National Guard.

Q. (By. Mr. Pettibone) Now, will you please answer the
question? A. I know that Air National Guard Regulation
‘40-01 pgovides certain information and certain -require-
ments for. the Air Technician Program. As to the status
of the individual, again I am not positive. * —~_

Q. Well, you testified previously that you took a course.
of instruction at the Chanute Air Force Base back in 1955
and 1956, a course of training for aepar maintenance
personnel.

Now, upon the completion of that course you stated that
you returned to your unit here in the Baltimore area. Were
you given any duties in connection with aircraft mainte-
‘nance upon yourreturn to your unit at that time? A. As |
e stated, I was assigned the duties of an aircraft mainte-
nance officer. e
$71. Q. And how were you sia for those duties?, A.
I was paid at the rate of pay commensurate with

-

the rank of aircraft maintenance officer in the Maryland a

Air National Guard. :
Q. What was your title? A. Aireraft maintenance officer.
Q. Now, I am referring to 1956. Well, what was the date

when ‘you first took over these duties as an officer in air-

eraft maintenance? It was in 1956, was it not? A. 1956, yes.
Q. Do you rementber the exact date? A. I do not.
Q: The month? A. June, I believe.
Q. All right, in June of 1956. What was your title at

. 440
- that time? A. I was aircraft maintenance officer of the |
' 104th Fighter Squadron,’ Maryland Air National Guard. —
Q. Did you have any other title? A. In.the Air National fe
Guard?
: Q. In the 104th Fighter. hice, your unit. af
372 _- Mr. Mudd: You mean other than rank, I presume. Fe
Mr. Pettibone: That is correct: |. }
Mr. Mudd: Do you mind if he consults with me?
_ Mr. Pettibone: No, go ahead.

(Mr. Mudd and witness in conference. )

A. I was ‘base maintenance supervisor for the 104th —

Fighter Squadron.as an Air Technician. .° ‘ l
Q. (By.Mr-: Pettibone) Is that a capacity other on your

“.. @apacity as a commissioned officer in the Air.- National
* " Guard at that time? A. T believe that the Regulation. re-

quires that the base maintenance supervisor be a commis-
sioned officer in the Air Natjonal Guard. That is my belief.
Q. What Regulation? — ‘are-you referring to? A.
ANGR 40-01. Se
Q. Yes, that is true, but Jet me go back to my question
-now, because my: question was a little different than that: ..
Is that status or position different from and in. addition
‘to let-me say being’a commissioned officer in the Air Na-
.tional Guard? I understand that you have to be a
375. commissioned officer to hold this position, but. what
- Tam getting at is, is this'a different position? A.
I think I have stated that,.Mr. Pettibone.
Q. No, you have not, not yet. A. I.was an aircraft main-
tenance officer in. the Air National Guard and held the job
title in addition as Base Maintenance Supervisor, and to
perform these duties, or to have this job description, I had
to be a commissioned officer in ‘the Air National Guard. If
they are separate, I don’t know. Q@XNc»
_ Q. Did you receive separate pay in each of these capaci-
ties? A. I did. .

\ °
& -
Q. From a different source? A. I think both pay dibdia
were drawn on the Treasury ‘of the United Statés. / |
Q. Were you paid at the same time or ‘different times?
A. Not necessarily at the same time.

ge Referring to United States Exhibit No. 3 for identi- *

fication, in the sixth line under the. words. “Base Main-

'. tenance Supervisor’’*the word maintenance being

_ 374 abbreviated as Maint; there appear the letters NGC-
* 11. Do you see those? A. I do. .

Q. Do you know what they stand for, or what a rep-

resent, or what they mean, or What they refer to? A. I

believe that is a rating issued by the National Guard Bu- |

_ reau for Air Technician Manning purposes.

- Q. And following those letters.and numbers, you see fur-
tes letters, $-2 and then eff, followed by a date, 16 Decem-
ber ’57, also abbreviated. Do you know what that stands
for, refers to our means, and if so, tell us. A. I believe
that refers to the step, in this case Step 2, and te smevtive
date that I attained that step. .

Q. All right. Prior to May 13, 1958, then, you were a
base maintenance supervisor in the 104th Fighter Squad-
ron, as indicated herein, is that correct A. That is correct.

Q. And then to the right of Base Maintenance Super-
visor you see the term Aircraft Maintenance Chief; the
word Aircraft being abbreviated, Acft. Is that another
technician’s position to which you were transferred on

May 13, 1959?
375. Mr. Wolcott:.’58. .
Mr. Pettibone: 1958, excuse me.

The Witness: 16 May ’58._ . x

Mr, Mudd: I think it says effective May 16th. i

Mr. Pettibone: Yes, you aré correct. The order appears

~ té be dated May 30th, but the effective date is May 16, by e

its own. terms. :
The Witness: That is correct.

Q. (By Mr. Pettibone) Now, tell as just briefly the gen-
~~ eral nature of your duties as air technician during the pe-°

. > °
4 fy

442 .

rigd you were employed : as base maintenance supervisor. A.

_ I had overall supervision of ‘vehicles, erash equipment,

ground support equipment in the various shops and other

_ support areas of aircraft maintenance ‘and “he responsi-
bility for airtraft maintenance.

Q. All right. Then after your transfer to the position
of aircraft maintenance chief on 16 May 1958, did -you
thereafter have different duties as air technician? A. I
had fewer duties. I relinquished a areas to another
individual. oe .

Q. Just describe briefly in a general way your

: 376 duties as air technical .after| you became aircraft

maintenance chief?. A. I was concerned with aircraft
maintenance and limited ‘support for it as opposed to the
‘overall base Maintenance supervision prior,to that date.
ae Did you enter upon and perform duties of that posi-
. tidn commencing on May 16, 1958? A-I did.
~ Q~Does that position require you to be a commissioned
officer in the Air National Guard? A. To the best of my
belief the Regulation says commissioned officer, warrant
officer or—I don’t recall if it is civilian or master. sergeant.
Maybe both. : ¥

Q. Did the. change of position on n May 16, 1958, which
you just described, involve an increase in pay or salary
for you? A. I believe the salary was the same or slightly
more. =e
Q. Who was your minedlat supervisor in your capacity
"as aircraft maintenance chief? A. Major Jesse D. Mitchell.

, Q. What was the nature or extent of his supervi-
377 sion of your work? A. He assumed the duties of

-base maintenance supervisor.

Q. Is that the position which you had held previous to
that time? A. That is correct. e
~ Q. You mean “the person who assumed your old posi-
tion became your supervisor in your new position? A.
That is correct. :

au

443

Would you nats the sinaeiad again, pleaes?
Mr. Pettibone: May F ask the ee. to read it to ee

- (Testimony read by Reporter. )-

a S Saar .
Q. (By Mr. Pettibone) Referring to the United

derneath the term aircraft maintenance chief, I see the
letters NCMS-9. Do you know what those letters and num-
ber mean or refer to? A. The. letters to the best of my

| belief and the related number designate a rate in

- 878. the air technician’s manning document. a"

Mr. Wolcott: In what doeument?
The Witness: In the air technician manning document:

Q. (By Mr: Pettibone) What does the S-3 mean follow- :
‘ing itt A. That would indicate the step in the rate,

Q. And the letters eff I take it mean effective date of
your entering into this position? A. That is right..

Q: May 16, 1958, is that correct? A. That is correct.

Q. Were you notified by anyone on or before May 16,

* 1958 that’ you were going to be transferred from the posi-
-tion.of base maintenance supervisor. to that of aircraft

maintenance chief? A.T was. — :
Q. By whom? A. I believe Colonel Killowski. -
Q. Do you recollect who notified’ you before your ap-
pointment as base maintenarice ‘supervisor? Who

379° informed you that you would be appointed to that

position? _A. Major Scott.
Q. That would be back in 1956? A. 1955.

Exhibit 3, in the seventh line of the’ test of this uke ae un- °

Q. Did yous pply to Major Scott for that yoann, either ~

verbally or in writing?
‘Mr. Pettibone: You have it ene.
: Mr. Wolcott: I mean is this where this comes trons, the
Civilian Personnel Manual? ae aban
Mr. Pettibone: That is right. a
_ — Mr. Wolcott: All right. Cm |
‘383. = Q. (By Mr. Pettibone) Is this document which
we have identified as United States Exhibit No. 4 for
identification the same as the description of your duties
as aircraft. maintenance chiefeon file with your tnit that.

_ ydu just referred to in’your testimony? .A. This is the .,
*. document I have reference to.

Q. This -is a copy of the same document, is _that what
you mean? A. Yes.

Q. That has happened? A: That has happened.

Q. And what would you do in those cases? Call up and.

tell anyone? ‘A. That is right. |
— Q. Who would you call? A. Two people: The Com- -
mander ‘and the person responsible for making the, appro-
_ priate entries in the attendance form.
Q. Now, were you entitled to a certain amount of sick
léave under certain conditions? A. That is correct.
Q. Do you know how much sick leave you were entitled
- to per year, or per week, or however it was, what-
393 ever the system was? Tell us what. it was. A. I be-
; ‘lieve at that time it was accrued at ~ Tate of 120
hours of sick leave per year.
Q. By that time, you are referring to 19581 A. May 1958, |
or at the time I took over the duties of aircraft maintenance.
Q. It was measured in terms of hours, is that correct?
~ That i is correct.

451

- Q. And were the hours credited if you were entitled to ©
eeniaiies pay over a. period of time? A. They were.

Q. Now, if you were absent for other reaséns other than
sickness, if you wanted to just have some absence to do
something of a personal nature, were you entitled to take
a certain amount of leave for that-purpose? A. We were.

Q. Do you remember how much or what the system was
on ‘that?. A. I believe that accrued at the same rate, i
hours a year:

Q. And if you wanted to have such leave, did you —
. 394 apply for it in advance? A. That is normal pro-
cedure, yes.

Q. To the same people that you notified in cases of sick-
ness? )

Mr. Pettibone: Well, now hold it just one moment, stein,
Captain McCoy, before you proceed.

Mr. Wolcott: He has a right to complete it. .

Mr. Pettibone: I didn’t say he didn’t. I - asked fora
moment’s pause.

Mr. Wolcott: Okay. I’m sorry.

Mr. Pettibone: Well, you have ‘oiiinn further you .

want to say, Captain MeCoy? :

The Witness: Yes, as an addition to the answer’to your
question, 'since I was in the capacity of aircraft maintenance
officer for the 104th Fighter Pauadcon—

464
é y

Mr. Pettiboie: Excuse me. You mean .as sirerait main-
tenance officer you ‘are..referring to your capacity at that
time as a Captain——_ -_

= The Witness: That’ s right.

419 Mr. Pettibone: in the Air National Guard, as
distinguished: from ‘your employment as aircraft
maintenance chief. Is that what you mean?

The Witness: That is correct...

Mr: Wolcott: No. Idon’t see what—— __

Mr. Pettibone: Well, he said officer, Mr. Wolcott, and the”
term here is ‘‘chief’’.

Mr. Wolcott: I understand then. va has three jobs. His
job as an Air National Guard Captain is, one. Then the
other job is, aircraft maintenance chief. :

Mr. Pettibone: That’s right, two jobs. :

Mr. Wolcott: But you are nae gal a third one, aircraft
- maintenance officer. _ a

‘Mr. Pettibone: He used the terns “ome”. Let the Re- |
porter read it back.

Mr. Woleott: Mavbe he used it, but T am + ine to get
it straight:

The Witness:.In my capacity as a Captain in the Air
’ National Guard, with the job description of an aircraft
maintenance Pfficer and being qualified to perform flight
checks on equ. ‘pment, and as I stated before there is

420 no requirement in the aircraft maintenance chief job.
deseription to make these flights, but since I was
there full time and had this dual responsibility then again
-with an eye for safety in the best operating equipment I felt
that it.was necessary that these flights be accomplished and
in the absence of the base maintenance supervisor, who
would normally make these flights, I did so. I asta careette
them. - .
~ Q. (By Mr. Pettibone) Well, I gather what you mean is
what yoy are saying is that you, in a dual capacity —
~Mr. Wolcott: I object to your summation, Mr. Pettibone.
-. Pettibone: Tam asking a en,

Ne.

Q. (By Mr. Pettibone) You had a dual capacity?

‘Mr. Wolcott: I think he has already answered and@ I
think you should put a question, not summarize. - .

Mr. Pettibone: Iam puttingaquestion. _ .

Q. (By Mr. Pettibone) You were in a dual capacity, is
_ that right? A. I had two job descriptions, yes.

Q. Now, in one job description you were an Air-

421 National Guard Captain, is that correct? A. It is my

understanding that I was an Air National Guard |
_ Captain all the time.

Q. Yes, I realize that all the time in one cael you.
were an Air National Guard Captain. In the other capacity .
_ you were an aircraft maintenance chief? A. I was an Air
- National Guard Captain and aircraft maintenance chief.

Q. Now, in the first capacity could you make maintenance, ©
-operating check flights? A. In the first capacity, yes.

Q. In the other capacity was that part of your job?

- Could you make them? A. I could make them, yes.

Q. Was it-part of your job to make them in that capacity?
A. I was still a Captain in the Air National Guard and——
Q. That is what we talked about first. Now I am talk-
ing about the other capacity. ? fea as
-Mr. Wolcott: Wait a minute. I think you have gotten.
it all the way around. I thought first was the air-
422 ‘craft maintenance chief. Is that the way you under-
. stood it, Captain, first capacity?
* The Witness: Well, let me answer.
Mr. Mudd: Justaminute. ~
Mr. Pettibone: Please, Mr. Wolcoit, will you let me
finish my questions and then object to them?
Mr. Mudd: Captain, answer the questions that are put
to you.
. .The Witness: Well, I want to.clarify this first ey -sec-
ond capacity that has been brought up. —
_ Mr. Mudd: It has been gone over. Mr. Pettibone hasa
question. Hear the question and then see what it i is. Let’s:
have or question.

Q. (By Mr. Pettibone) Now- in hopes we can keep this
‘cledr betweeu us, Captain, I will start again all over. In
one capacity you were a Captain in the Air National Guard
and were in that capacity acting as aircraft maintenance
officer? A. That’s Brrect.

Q. In another capacity you were employed by the 104th
___» . Fighter Squadron as an aircraft maintenance chief?

423 Mr. Mudd: Object. I don’t like the words ‘‘em-
: ployed by the 104th. ” It is posetny: misleadingly
_ Classified. It might be better——

Mr. Pettihone: I think your objection is well taken. Let .
me rephrase that question. :

.Q. (By Mr. Pettiborie) You were also at the same ia
employed in the capacity of aircraft maintenance chief,
is that correct? A. That’s correct.

Q. Now did your status as aircraft: “maintenance. officer,
the. duties of that assignment and position require you to
make maintenance. operational check flights of aircraft? A.
As a rated pilot and being required to perform certain:

-flights to satisfy’ the Department of the Air Force .and
having fulfilled the qualifications necessary to make me
capable of performing operational checks on aircraft, then

_part of my duties I agsume would be the responsibility for
the aircraft and: to By fly them or to flight check them.

Q. All right. Nowy in the other capacity in which you >
were employed as aircraft maintenance chief were you

either required or authorized in that capacity, dis- ,

424 ‘tinguished from this other orie, to make maintenance.

operational check flights of ‘aircraft? A. I don’t

believe any aircraft maintenance chief, per se, is authorized

to make aerial flights. The authorization comes from the
Department of the Air Force.

Q. Now turn specifically to May 20, 1958. Do you re-

3 member what time you reported to work that morning?

Mr. Mudd: I am going to. object again if we are getting

- into his minute by minute, hour by hour movements on

May 20th inasmuch as it was gone into in extensive detail

on the original. If you have some pertinent questions I

467
_don’t mind the“question on that, but if we are going to take
it from the beginning of the time he reported to work——.

Mr. Pettibone: No, I didn’t have that in mgd. I don’t
want to take up the time myself either to go all over every
little detail. I do have a few items that. J hope I can -
to properly and without any delay.

Mr. Mudd; Ali right.

Q. (By Mr. Pettibone) I. would like to start off with.
the question which I just asked Do you remember
| what time you eame to work that morning May 20th?

425

Regulations 66-D as they apply. >
Q. Yes. Now; what manuals were. used y Fe in con-

is the operation ¢manual, ) OF erat operat ‘fanual tech- |

7]

-Q. Does that also inclnde tiaintenstnee, or ae that the”

general’ operation? ' ‘aA. No, maintenance; the. general main:
tenance manual wanld’ be [T-33- A- ‘ and it shreds out for

all types of maintenance. Le ey ee UR, eae
sie ey ’ e : je ; ‘ oh [ee af _
217 . Q. Captain, who is the Air. Force liatson’ slhtie

|. 218°. -stationed at the’ sbyaet?’ A. Major Britton... ~

~. Q “Can you arn 3 me his full name? A. Milton D. aw

ao Britton.

“Q. Are. there any other Air Force personel stationed |

a at the-base? A. There Are.

: positive of the names.. Bs

'Q. Could you tell us “who they are, pleaset A. Iam ‘not | pf

Q. As best you can and also while you are at it saa give ;

“us their function, pleast. A. I can’t be positive. There is

ge Sergeant, Baldwin, Sergeant Storm, and one whose name

escapes me at this moment. . rag He ae ae
Q: What are-the functions df these sergeants? A. These. . ;
_ people are to assist Major Britton in advisory services in

‘the maintenanice afea, the adiniisiatratlostree, and weather

. in connection with that. function? A.‘We are gov-

f Sight. - Se ee pe a
oe: ot. ee eae : ee | az : *
219 Q. ‘Is there a manual, or are there manuals used — . “Ke

| wy
Major Scott, with Major Britton’s signature, ag then they

- 413

are forwarded to me for action to comply. with the discrep-
“ancy, or so forth, at the Martin Airport.

o:---. -~@ * | ea . @ a o * -

248 Q. (By Mr. Wolcott) Now, Captain, what dé you

commander through the operations officer,

Q. And is that a- particular area to which you are physi-
cally- limited in the operation of your aircraft? Ms
Mr. Mudd: Objection. eet Re .
aa ab yg ShallI amswert « - , Pa
Mr. Mudd: Sure. Goahead. oe .
.Mr. Woleott:. Yes. Go-ahead. Answer.

?

- ,The Witness: The only local flight clearance,-VFR local ~

flight clearance, the S.0.P. confines the operating—the oper.

ation of the aircraft to the local flying area, yes, sir... ‘

_ Q. (By Mr. Wolcott) Well,.now, on May 20th, 1958, were .

y is local flight area? A. I was limited by

S.0.P. with the type clearance I had to loeal flight area. =
Q. The local flight area that we have just discussed, is

' that right? A: As near as I can determine, yes, sir,

Q. Now, in the performance of your duties as main:
tenance officer what uniform did you Wear, Captain?
250 *

id
: &2 “Yon. Now, on this particular occasion who
6 conducted the pre-flight ie seman A. Maintenance? di

° ey

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386411_0158%3A02. Public record. Not legal advice.
