# Transcript of Record — Pan American World Airways, Inc. v. United States

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386410_0138%3A01

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Transcript of Record
- **Published:** January 1, 1963
- **Citation:** 371 U.S. 296

## Text

TRANSCRIPT OF RECORD

Supreme Court of the United States
OCTOBER TERM, 1962

No. 23

+

¢ PAN AMERICAN WORLD ~aheceamaine INC.,
: APPELLANT,

vs.

UNITED STATES.

No. 47 —

UNITED STATES, APPELLANT,

“
vs.

VAN AMERICAN WORLD AIRWAYS, INC., ET AL.

APPEALS FROM THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK

_ NO. 23 FILED JULY 25, 1961 : °
NO. 47 FILED DECEMBER 1, 1961
JURISDICTION POSTPONED JANUARY 15, 1962

.
Pi
7@ *
Rihl. dated August: 13, 1931 - is, | oe 535
84—Letter to J. D- MacGregor from een L.-
Rihl, dated October 8, : 221 - -536
85—Letter to George L. Rihl from J. D. Mae- ys
_ Gregor. dated November 11,1931. 222, |_:538
88—Letter to H. J. Roig from D. S. ‘glehart, ee
dated June 27, 1932... - .. 227: 539.
&9—Letter to J. T. Trippe from’ J. D. “Mae.
Gregor, dated .July 12, 1932 ses 228.” 540
90—Letter to H. J. Roig from D. S. Igichart, y
. dated July M1, a2 2... 299 541
$1-~ Seemnoradiium to R. H. Patchin Seon: y D. .
MacGregor. dated November 16. 1932... 230° = 542
92_Letter to H. R. Harris from J.°D. Mae :
Gregor, dated February .11, 1933 ... | 231 544

pl

= ae INDEX 1h
. ‘ a ;
= = Original Print
Record from the United States District. Court for
the Southern Distriet of New York—Contigued a

Government’s Exhibits—C ontinned i,
‘94-——Memorandum for. Mr. Garni, Mr. Patchin
and Mr. Cogswell, from D. 8. Iglehart,

dated August 23, 1934 00000. |) 283) B45
; 95—A letter to J. D. MacGregor from Harold
J. Roig, dated’ January 9, 1935 235 ° 546
96— A‘letter to Mr. Garni, dated January 10, |
PUI cieital bo dian cuatiaidmicnite 236. 547 ,

97—-A letter to Harold J. Role from Douglas
Campbell. dated April 13, 1935, with an

= attachment, a proposed letfer to J.T. -
Trippe from Pan American-Grace |
Roig. dated September 23.1936 | ‘7 959 AGS
.110—Cablegrani te Roi¢e from Garni, dated. No-
: vember 16. 1936 ; / 261 567
%11—Cableeram to Roie¢ from Garni, dated No-
vember 17, 1936 _..... | + ee 262 568

«a

@ re )
’ = %

'

ts. 2 ‘ INDEX
‘ : Original
Record froni the United States ‘TDistrict Court fof :
.the Southern District of New “York—Coutinued . 2
* Government's Exhibits—Continued
112—Cablegram to Garni from Roig, dated No-

vember | ee * 203
“~ JI3I—-C ablegrani to Garni from Roig, dated No-
vember 19, 1936 ‘264
114—Memorandum by William F. Cogswell,
dated November 19, 1936 267
115—Letter to John D. MacGregor from
lombia” from Harold. J. Roig and A.
Garni, dated April 12. 1987 I>
128—Cablegram from Zalles to Grace, New

43

York, dated April 15, 1937 v 295 -

xii INDEX

Record from the United: States District Court fo.

‘the Southern District of New York—Continued
Government's Exhibits—Continued
129—Memprandum of telephone conversation
re between Mr. Garni and’ Mr. Rihl on
the morning of Monday, April 19,
1937, by George L. Rihl .
130—Memorandum of conversation held be-
tween Trippe, Garni, Roig and Rihl in
Mr. Trippe’s office on the morning of
ae April 22, 1937, by George L. Rihl |.
131—Letter to G. Vidal from Harold J, Roig,
dated April 30, 1937; attached thereto
are executive committee minutes dated

April 21,1937 and November 16, 1937,

_* aff a minute of the meeting of a board

of directors of June 28,1938 ss

132—Letter to H. R. Harris from J. D. Mae-

Gregor, dated May 5, "1937 nies

133—Letter to Garni from Harold J. Roig,
dated October 28, 1937 ~

- 135—Merhorandum for A. Garni Perr D.

MacGregor, dated April 29. 1938
396.—-Semorsndum by Harold: J. Roig, dated
September 7, 1938 .

137—Minutes of adjourned special meeting of

board of directors of Pan American-
Grace Airways hefd on.October 18, 1938
138—Letter to C. V. Whitney from D. 8. Igle-
hart, dated November 15, 1938 ;

139—Letter to D. 8. Iglehart from C. V. Whit-

ney, dated November 19, 1938 |
140—Cablegram to Pan American Airways at
Miami, Florida, from Young, dated
April 24, 1941 | e i
143—-Memorandunrto J. T: Triepe from H. B.
Denn, dated October 20. 1943
144—Memorandum ty Henry J. Friendiv from
H. B. Dean, dated October 20, 1943 |

Original Print
297 600 -
299 602
301 605
303. 607
304 «608
308 610

~

312 614
315 «616
317-617
319. 619
321-621
"394 = «699

326

624

“

INDEX . Xie

Original Print
Record from the United States District Court for
the Southern District of New York—Continued
Government's Exhibits—Continued- : -
145—Minutes of adjourned regular meeting of
the beard of directors of Pan Amer- |
ican-Grace Airways, Inc. held on No-

vember 8, 1943 . 326° 625
146—Minutes of adjourned regular » moeting ‘of

the board of directors of Pan Amer-

ican-Grace Airways, Ine, . held on April .

i ae 333. 630
147—Letter to H. B. Dean. from. E. Balluder,

dated January 11, 1945, 335 632 —
148—Memorandum to Henry J. . Friendly from -

-H. B. Dean, dated January 22,1946 ... 336 633
150—Letter to Douglas Campbell from G._ a

Vidal, dated February 1, 1946. - 338 634
.151—Cablegram to Garri from Roig, dated

3 Renee eee 329 = - 635
152—Letter to H. J. Roig from J. P. Grace, Jr. iy

dated November 1, 1948 —..... ..* fl 638
155—Memorandum to J. P. Grace. rs from

A. B.Shea, dated May 19, 1950 349. 639

157—Memorandum to J. P. Grace, Jr. from

Howard L. Clark. dated November 6,

1950 . on ‘353s G4
158—Me morandum: Notes on, telephone. con-

versation with Mr. Andrew Shiea and

Mr. Balluder on December 19, 1950 357+ 644
161—Letter to J. Peter GraceQJr. from Juan
T. Trippe. dated December 29, 1950 367 ~=© 649
162—Letter to Juan T. Trippe from J. P.

Grace, dated January 9, 1951 we 369° ~=—s «651 —

THRU- PLIGHT—PART I
163—Letter to D. S. Iglehart, unsigned, dated ;

; “?
February 25, 1936 371 653
164—Letter to Robert -H. Patchin from A. ~

Garni, dated August 21, 1936 372s G54
- 4

xiv INDEX

.Record from the United States District Court for ¢
the Southern District of New York—Continued
- Government’s Exhibits—Continued
165—Letter to Harllee Branch from A. Garni,
dated September 9, 1936 .°. .
166—Letter to A. Garni from Harllee Branch,
dated October 3, 1936 iG
167—-Letter to G. Vidal from J. D. MacGregor,
* dated October 15, 1936 . "
168—Memorandum for file entitled “Miami/
Cristobal in One Day,” dated March
.15; 1937, by Harold J. Roig
169-+Memoréndum of- a cablegram to ‘D. Ss.
Iglehart from Harold J. Roig, dated
October 15, 1937 — moe
170—Letter to Harold J. Roig from D. S. Igle-
. hart, dated October 18, 1937 . She
171—Letter to Harold J. Roig from D. s. Tele.
. hart, dated October 21, 1937 __
172—Letter to Harold J. Roig from A. Garni,
dated October 27, 1937 __ So
173—Letter to Harold J. Roig from A. Garni,
dated Octobér 28, 1937 - pS
174—Letter to A. Garni from Harold J. Roig,
dated November 5, 1937
175—Letter to Harold J. Roig from A. Garui.
dated November 8, 1937.
176—-Letter to Mr. Iclehart © from Harold’ -
Rofg, dattd. December 24, 1937, and
‘attached thereto are two drafts of a
letter to C. V. Whitney from D. S. Tale.
hart and a memorandum entitled “Sug-
gested Plan for Reorganization of Pan
American-Grace Airways, Ine.” :
177—Letter to C. V. Whitney from D. S. Igle-
hart, dated January 7, 1938 a
178—Letter to A. Garni from Harold J. Roig,
dated April 6, 1938
179—Letter to A. Garni from Harold a Rote.
_ dated April 21! 1938. and the attach-
ment of a letter to H. R. Harris from
T. B. Rodenbangh, dated April 12, 1938

Original Print

373

375

376

377

399
411

413

416

655
657

658

659 ,

. 696

INDEX

Record from the United States District Court for

\ the Southern District of New York—Continued *

Government’ s Exhibits—Confinued
_ 180—Letter to Harold J. Roig from A. Garni,

rons

dated April 29, 1938
181—Memorandum dated September 12, 1938
by Harold J. Roig
182—Series of minutes of Executive Committee
meetings and Buard of Directors meet-

ing of Pan American, dated September -

8, 1938, September 20, 1938, October 4,
1938 and December 28, 1938
183—Letter to Adolf Garni from. Juan T.
Trippe, dated September 24, 1938
185—Letter to C. V. W hitney from D. 8S. Igle-
. hart, dated November 15, 193%
186—Letter to Sonny Whitney from D. S. Igle-
hart, dated November 29, 1938, and
att tached thereto a memorandum to Mr.
Iglehart from Harold J. Roig, dated’
November 29, 1938 |
187—Letter to D. S. Iglehart from Harold J.
Roig, dated’ December 31, 1938
188—Letter to Iglehart from (. V. Whitney,
dated January 17, 1939
189—Letter to C. V. Whitney from D. S. Igle-
hart, dated -Jannary 19, 1939
190—-Memorandum of agreement between Pan
American and Grace, dated February
14, 1939 .

. 191—Memorandum dated Dee ‘ember 28, 1940

by A. Garni
192—Series of Executive and Board aeleting
minutes of Pan American dated Deceia-

ber 30, 1940, January 6, 1941, January :

7. 1941, January 14, 1941 and January:
8, 1941

193-——Letter to Civil Aeronauties Board from
D. S. Iglehart. dated May 2. 1941 and
_an attachment dated May 2 . 1941 from
D. S. Iglehart

Original

419

* 453

© 44

460

XV

Print

(29

rr

xvi . INDEX
° _ - Original Pri
Record from the United: States District Court for .
the. Southern District of New York—Continued
Government's Exhibits—Continued | be
-194—Minutes of special. meeting of the board
: of “irectors of Pan American-Grace gan
Airways, Ine. held on June 18, 1941. 462 73

195—Minutes of adjourned special meeting of ™
» . board of directors of Pan American- .
Grace Airways, Tne. held on June 20,
14 ; 467 74

196—Minutes of executive committee held. on
June 24, 1941, and board of directors :
on July 1,194. 00 a + 468 74)
197—Minutes of special meeting of board of
directors of Pan American-Grace Air:
ways, Inc. held on June 26,1941 470 743
198—Minutes of adjourned. special meeting of
. the board of directors of Pan, Amer.
ican-Grace Airways, Ine. held on June
fa _ oneal ae ivacnapeaaelc 471 744
199—Minutes of adjourned special meeting of
board of directors of Pan American- :
Grace Airways held on June 39,1941 -* 4792 745
-200—Letter dated June 30, 1941, from George
L. Rihl to Harold J. Roig apie 473 746
201—Minutes of adjourned special meeting of ‘
board of directors of Pan American-
Grace Airways, Inec., held on July 1,
tien Ee, 474747
202—-Minutes of adjourned special meeting of
board of directors of Par American-
Grace Airways, Inc. held on ‘July 2,
PE deg Patel als 479 752
203—Special stockholders’ meeting ‘of Pan | ‘
_American-Grace Airways, Inc., July 2,

thangs ae ae
204— Letter dated July 2. 1941, from ‘George
4. Rihl to Harold J. Roig 482 754

205—Letter dated July 3. 1941. from Harold
J. Roig to George I. Rihl : 483 = 755

: -*

INDEX

Record from the Unite de States District Court for
the Southern District of New York--Continued
Government's Exhibits—Continued |

206—Letter dated July 22, 1941, from’ ‘H.
Preston Morris to W. R. Grace & Com-
pany +...

207—Letter dated July 24, 1941, from D. S.
Iglehart to Pan American Airways
Corporation

208—Memorandum dated August 9, 1941, by
Iglehart . .

209—Letter to J. T. Trippe from A. Garni,

dated Ovtober 2, 1941 | —

210—Memorandum entitled - “Panagra, Miami /
New Orleans connection,’ by Harold
‘- J. Roig, dated October 6.1941, and an
attachment of a note to (. V. Whit-

ney, undateds

. 211—Letter to J. T. Trippe from Harold J.

Roig, ‘dated October 9. 1941

oat
““"~212—Letter,to W. R. Grace & Company from

Evén E: Young, dated October 22. 1941
213—Letter to Pan ‘American Airways Cor-
poration from A. Garni, dated Octo-
ber 27, 1941
214—Letter to Pan American Airways Cor-
poration from Harold J. Roig, dated
. October 27, 1941

215—Letter. to H. J. ‘Roig from Evan E_

Young. dated November 4. 1941

_+216—Letter. to H.-J. Roig from Evan E.

Young, dated Noyember 4, 1941°

217--Letter to Pan Americar Airways Cor-
poration from Harolde J. Roig, dated
Noyember 7, 1941

—-218—Letter to T. J. Kirkland from H.R.

Harris, dated January .5, 1942. and
attached thereto a memorandum to
Roig from H. R. Harris, dated —-
3,. 1942

xvii
Ory inal Print
486 » 757
458 759
491762
492 762
493 763
496-766
498 767
500 . 770
503 772
F 7
508 776
513 780
515 782
516 783°

_ xviii ~ - INDEX =

a eee

a ; Original. Print
a Record from ee United: States District Court for
the Southern District of New York—C ontinued
Government's Exhibits—C ontinued .
.219—Memorandum to J. T. Trippe from Evan

E. Young, dated January 6, 1942. 519 787
THRU-FLIGHT—PART II
220—Letter to Civil Aeronautics ye from ane
pe 3 D. 8S. Iglehart, dated April 27, 1942 520 788
* 221—Letter to George L. Rthl from Harold J. ,
Roig, dated May 29. 1542 §22 790
222--Letter to Harold J: Roig from George L.
Rihl, dated June 5, 1942 ae . §23- .791
293—Letter to George. L. Rihl from Harold J.
Roig, dated June 1K 1942 "524 792

294—Memorandum entitled “Miami - Balboa
Service,” by George L. Rihl, dated .
June 13, 1942 , aes 52d 793
225—Memorandum’ entitled “Miami - Balboa | : |
Delays,” by George L. Rik, dated June cree
18, 1942 ° " . 526 = 794
226 — -Memorandum ‘entitled “Status of arri- :
-vals Balboa 307° s,” by W. Q. Snyder,
to E. E. Young. dated July 7.71942 527. 196°
227—Memorandum entitled “Status of arri-
vals Balboa 307’s,” by W. O. Snyder
to E. E. Young, dated Angust 4.1942 - 528 798
5 298—Memorandum entitled “Status.-of arri-
~ vals Balboa 307’s.” by Evan E. Young,
dated August 7, 1942 ~ 529 199
229—Minutes of adjourned regular meeting of
, board of directors of Pan American-
Grace Airways, Inc. held on September

22, 1942 530 800 .
230—Letter to L. Welch Poste from A. Garni, try
‘dated October -28, 1942 342 811

931-—Minutes of annual meeting’ of the ial
of directors of Pan Ameriean Grace
= Inc. held on April 27, 1945 - 543 812.

a a

INDEX : xix

: Original Print
Record from the United States District’ Court for
the - Southern, District of New Yerk—Continued
Government’s Exh®its—Continued
. 232—Cablegram to Howard B. -Dean from .
Harold J. Roig, dated January 6, 1944 547 815
233—Letter to Harold J. Roig from Evan E.

Young, dated January 7, 1944 _. 548 816
234—Letter‘ to Evan Young from Harold J. |.
Roig, dated January 10,1944... = 550 ~ «818
235—-Letter to Harold J. Roig from Howard
_ B..Dean, dated March 13, 1944 551 ~—s« 819
236—Letter to Howard B. Dean from Harold J. -
Roig, dated March 21, 1944 552 820
238---Letter to Harold J. Roig from Howard
B. Dean, dated. June 29, 1944 655 621
239—Letter to Howard B. Dean from Harold ; ;
J. Roig, dated July 5, 1944 557. = 823
* 240—Letter to Harold J. Roig from Howard aot
pea B. Dean, dated July 20, 1944 - 558 824.
241—Letter to Howard B. Dean from Harold
J. Roig, dated July 25, 1944 — 560 827

942--Letter to Harold J. Roig from Howard
_B. Dean and Erwin Balluder, dated | :
July 27, 1944 : 562 828

VOLUME III

243—-Minutes of special meeting of the board
of directors of ‘Pan American-Grace

Airways, Ine. held on July 31, 1944 — 564 831
244—Letter to W. R. Grace & Company from ;
. J. T, Trippe, dated April 3, 1945 : 572 838

245—Minutes of regular meeting of the board
of directors of -Pan American-Grace .-
Airways, Inc., held on April 4, 1945 573 840
246—Letter to the president of Pan American
‘Airways Corporation from D. S. Igle-

hart, dated April 10,1945. 586 ~=—s- 851
247—Letter to W. R. Grace & Company from ;
J. T. Trippe, dated April 14,1945. 587- = 852

“.

3 |

—

fan.

INDEX

94

*

Record from the United States District Court for
the Southern District of New York—Continued
Government’s Exhibits—Continued

248—Telephone conversation between Mr.
Dean and Mr. Roig on July 11, 1945,
as recorded by Howard B. Dean _......

249—Letter to Harold J. Roig from Howard
B. Dean, dated August 13, 1940 —.....

_250—Letter to Howard B. Dean from Harold
J. Roig, dated August 27, 1945

251—Letter to Howard B. Dean from Harold

, J. Roig, dated January 17, 1946 .
252—Letter to Harold J. Roig from "Howard
'. * B. Dean, dated February 21, 1946..
254—Letter to Howard B. Dean from Harold

J. Roig, dated April 11, 19467. 0...

Origins!

255—Letter to Harold J. Roig from Henry J. —

. Friendly, dated April 15, 1946 —
256—Letter to John C. Cooper from. Harold
J. Roig, dated May 24, 1946, enclosing
a memorandum entitled “Pan Amer-
“iean-Grace Airways, Inc.,. notice of
special meeting of board of directors,

May 28, 1946,” dated May 24, 1946, » by

W. F. Cogswell — — ....
257—Letter to J. T. Trippe ‘from rt P. iis,
Jr., dated’ May 31, 1946
258—Memorandum of extracts from minutes
of Pan American Airways Corporation,

board of directors meeting, June 4, 1946 —

259—Minutes of adjourned special meeting of
board of directors of Pan American-
Grace Airways, Inc. held on June 35,
1946 -
260—Minutes of a an shiouravh special meeting
of the board of directors of Pan Amer-
ican-Grace Airways, Ine. ‘held on June
: 11, 1946 -
" 261—Minutes of board of dieee tons of Pan
American dated July 2, 1946

603

- 605

608

~ 609”

Print

. 854

855
858
860
861
863

864

866

869

873

Record from the United States District Court for
the Southern District of New York-—Continued
Government’s Exhibits—-Continued.

262—Excerpts from minutes of meeting of
board of directors of W. R. Grace &
Company, dated July 3, 1946

-963—Letter to Howard B. Dean from Prescott

S. Bush, dated July 8, 1946, and at-

tached thereto a memorandum entitled

-“Subjeet: P.A.A.Grace”
264—Excerpts from minutes of executive com-
mittee meetings of ~Pah American,
dated July 9, 1946, July 16, 1946, July
23, 1946, July 30, 1946; and’ a meeting
of the board of directors of Pan Amer-
ican. dated August 6, 1946
265—Extracts from the minutes of Pan Amer-
ican Airways, Inc., dated July 30, jos,
and August 6, 1946
- 266—Agreement between Pan Jimericén hie-
ways, Ine. and Pan American-Grace
Airways, Ine., dated July 30, 1946
(commonly referred to as the through-
flight agreement )

267—Agreement between W. R. Grace & Ren.

pany and Pan American Airways

Corporation dated July 30, 1946,

(commonly referred to as the parent
company agreement )

- 268—Letter to James M. Landis, Chairman, .
Civil Aeronautics Board, from Henry .

J. Friendly, Cahill, Gordon, Bailey &
‘Reissel, and Gerhard A. Gesell, dated
_ August 19, 1946
- .269—Excerpts from memorandum agreement
regarding services rendered:and to be
rendered to Panagra by the parent com-

panies and compensation _ therefor, °

dated July 14, 1948, and signed by

Harold J. Roig for Panagra: E. Bal- -
luder for Pan _American, and Andrew:

B. Shea for W.R. Grace & Company

Original

619

623

625

626

629

636

633 _

XXi

Print

888

889

892

899

-Xxil INDEX

* Original Print
Record from the United States District Court for
the Southern District of. New York—Continued
Governnent’s Exhibits—Continued

PAN AMERICAN:PANAGRA COMPETITION
270—Letter to R. H. Patchin from Harold J.

‘Roig, dated October 30, 1930 —......... - 645 906 .
271—Letter to D. S. Iglehart from Harold J. ;
Roig, dated December 9, 1930 _....... 647 907

272—Memorandum entitled “Pan American-
Grace Airways,” dated March 2, 1931,

by Harold J. Roig -.............-....--......-- 648 909
273—Letter to J. D. MacGregor from G. Vidal, nS,

dated October 23, 193] -.:.....-..-..-..... 651 ~~ 911
276—Letter to J. D. MacGregor from H. R.

Harris, dated October 27, 1933 _.......... 656 912

277—Letter to H. R: Harris from J. D. Mac-

Gregor, dated November 6, 1933... 657 a"
278—Letter to J. D. MacGregor from H. R. .
914

Harris, dated November 20, 1933 ...... 659 — |
279—Letter to Harold J. Roig from A. Garni, Gt ga
dated February 22, 1934 _............ ass -660 915 .
280—Letter to Harold J. Roig frum D. S. Igle-
hart, dated August 6,:1934 662 917 -
281—Létter to Harold J. Roig from D. S. Igle-
hart, dated August 13, 1934 2... 663 918
282—Memorandum of conversation with J. T. Lee
Trippe, September 14, 1934 . ee 666 . 920°
_ 284—Letter to A. Garni from DS. ‘Iglehart,
dated March 26, 1935... abe 670 =: 921
286—Letter to A. Garni from Harold J. Roig, . ;
dated May 11, 1935 0 ee. 673 922:
287—Letter to A. Garni from J. D. MacGregor, 0 hy
dated January 24, 1936 _ ah 679 926
_ 288—Letter to C. V. Whitney from D. S. Igle- ry :
hart, dated August 4,°1936 —............... 681 927

289—Pan American intercompany memorani-
dum entitled “BUE Sales Folder,” by >,
Ernest L. Foss, dated February 8,°1947 684 929

INDEX

Record from the United States District Court for
the Southern District of New York-—Continued
Government’s Exhibits—Continued

wa

' 294—Intercomy ny Pan American memoran-

dum by Amos Hiatt, dated June 19,
Be oe

.295—Pan American intere ompanw, memoran-

dum entitled “Panagra Through Flight
Agreement” by R. G: sens dated

June 24, 1947 ., - Saas
296—Pan. American-Grace intercompany mem-
orandum addressed to J. T. Shannon
* from James W. Walker, Jr., dated eid
21, 1948 . ae, ie Hie
298-—Pan Amadiens intercompany ‘memoran-
.dum entitled “Buenos Aires Sales to
the United States,” by F. H. Sheldon,

dated August 47, 1948 °

299--Pan American intercompany memoran-

dum entitled “Buenos Aires Sales to
the United States.” by Mario J. Mar-
tinez. dated August 25, 1948 —

300—Memorandum to A..B. Shea. from J. P.
Grace, Jr.. dated April 22.1949 a

301-—Pan American _intereomp»ny memoran-
dum entitled © “MIA-BUE Tourist
Fares” hy Willis G. Lipscomb, dated
May 26, 1949 bose
302—T.etter to J. W. Walker. Jr.. from Doug-
las Campbell, daged June 23. 1949.
303-—Letter to Porter Norris from Juan Homs,
Jr.. dated September 1, 1949
304—Pan American intercompany’ .memoran,
‘dum entitled “Panagra_ Representa-

tion-Buenos Aires.” by Porter Norris. |

dated September 7. 1949
306—Pan American intercompany, memoran-

‘dum by John FE. Muhlfeld, dated No.,

vember 29, 1949
307—I. etter to Donglas Camnbell from An-

drew B.-Shea, dated January 10, 1950 :

Ur iginal

689

691

693 |

696

697 —

XXill

' Print

930
931
933.
934

935 -

936

938 .
938

939

942

943

945

we

XXl1V INDEX.

Record from the United States District Court for
- the Southern District of New York—Continued
_Gdvernment’s Exhibits—Continued
* §B08—-Memorandum to A..B. Shea from J. P.
, Grace, Jr., dated. January 13, 1950 -
eee to Andrew B.“Shea from

J. P. Grace, Jr., dated January 18,

\. TD scstcilnet ETE ae,
311—Pan American intercompany memoran-
dum entitled “Panagra” by E. Bal-

luder, dated July 28, 1950 —...-........

313—Memorandum to Andrew B. Shea from

J. P. Grace, Jr., dated Auguit 13,
1950 sie ibaaienddabieisancinmasoemaeeiapeaaane
314~-Note to Admiral Towers, by R. W. B.,
dated January 29, 1951 - “
316—Memorandum entitled “Report ‘of Call
Covering Several Meetings on Pan
American Airways,” dated March 30,
1951 ‘ sicsuis esi boaaapeeenntenelineatee
317—Pan American intercompany memoran-
dum by Juan Homs, Jr., dated April 4,
1951 fe a aisles
318—Pan American intercompany memoran-

bd | dum entitled “Panagra Promotion” by

+ Porter Norris, dated April 4, 1951 .
320--Memorandum to Andrew B. Shea from
| J. P. Grace, Jr., dated April 28, 1951
394—Letter to Porter Norris from Juan Homs,
: Jr., dated May 18, 1951 - one
325— Memorandum by Howard L. Clark, dated
‘ May Oe a reenter
328—Pan American intercompany _ memoran-
dum entitled “Panagra Sales Force,”
_ by Erwin Balluder, dated une 26,
1953 ..........-,-
_- $29—Letter ‘to Edward G. Bern from ‘Roger
cx: - Vi Rowe. dated August 13, 1953
'332—Pan American intercompany .memoran-
’ dum entitled “Monthly Sales Report—
Buenos Aires, September 1953,” by
Fred F. Plimpton + alta oe teaihaidetatennboicaas

711

713

740

741

745

‘Original Print

960

961

962

963

INDEX

Record from the United States District Court for
i the Southern District of “New York-—Continued
. Government’s Exkibits—Continued be.

GRACE LINE-PANAGRA COMPETITION

333—Letter to Harold J. Roig from D. 8S. Igle:
hart, dated March 13, 1930

334— Memorandum for Mr. Garni from D. S.
Iglehart, dated, April 21, 1930

335—Memorandum to Roig, Patchin and Cogs-,

. well from D. 8. Iglehart, dated Octo-

ber 15, 1931 —. . ae ii

336—Memorandum for Mr. Zalles from W. F.
Cogswell, dated March 29, 1982

337—Letter to G. Vidal from J. ‘D. Mae-,

Gregor, dated May 17, 1932
338—Letter to Grace Line, Ine.. from W. R.
Grace & Co. at Lima, dated January 20.
, | Se
6 339—Letter to J. D. MacG regor from Harold
; R. Harris, dated February 17, 1933
340—Letter to J. M. Van Law from J. -D.
MacGregor, dated March 18, 1933

341—-Memorandum to Mr. Mann from W. F.,

Cogswell? dated: March 21, 1933
342—-Letter to A. Garni from D. S. Iglehart,
dated April 26, 1933
343—Memorandum for Mr. Garni from W. F.
Cogswell, dated May 24, 1933
344—-Letter to J. D. MacGregor from T. J.
- Kirkland. dated September 26, 1933
345—Letter to H. H. G. Redshaw from A.
Garni, dated October 27, 1933 a
346—Memorandum by G.. P. Smith, dated De-
eember 17, 1934

- 347—Letter to G. Vidal from H. R. Harris,
. . dated Angust 26. 1935
a rt 348——Pan American-Grace intercompany mem-

Sales-C. W.

Moore from W. H. R.,

dated November 19, 1951... --
392—Pan American inter-company memoran-
dum entitled “Pepsi-Cola Company—
Colon Free Zone,” by J. A. Soto, dated

May 27,

1952 -

Original

Print

1043

INDEX

Record from the United States District Court for ~
the Southern District of New York—Coutinued ~

Government's, Exhibits—Continued

393—-Letter to Louis A. Person from R: C.
Lounsbury, dated September 4, 1952

394—Pan Amerivan inter-cempany memoran-
dum entitled “Monthly sales report—

‘Buenos Aires, January, 1953,” by Fred °

_F. Plimpton, dated February 11, 1953
395—Cablegram to Valverde from Harold J.
Roig, dated July 23, 1985 —..-

GRACE CONTROL

400—Memorandum for Patchin and Cogswell,
unsigned, dated April 18, 1929 between ,

United States. or Eastern United States,
and Western South America using U. S.
flag carriers, March and September, 1957

1297

Original Print
;

1288 1359
1290 1360
1291 1361
1292 1362
1293 1363
1294 1364
1295 1365
"1296 1366 .

1367

invex’”

Record from the United States District Court -for
the Southern District of New York--Continued
Government's Statistical Exhibits—Contipued

11—Passengers traveling by air _ between

United States, or Eastern United States,

and Western South America vsing U. S.

flag carriers, March and —
1956 ..

19—Pahengers. “(gareeling w ae between

. United States, or Eastern United States,

« , and Western South America using U. S.

flag carriers, March and September,

1955 . J AE
19—Paseengers * pavelinn by air between
United States, or Eastern United States,
and Western South America using U. S.
flag carriers, March and September, 1954
14—Passengers traveling by air between
United States, or Eastern United States,
and Western Souh America using U. S.
flag carriers. March and September, 1953
Passengers traveling by air between
United States, or Eastern United States,
and Western feat America using U.S
flag carriers. March and September, 1952
16—Passengers traveling by air between
United States. or Eastern United States,
and Western South America using U.S.
flag carriers. March and September, 1950
17—Passengers traveling by. air hetween
- United States. or Eastern United States,
and Eastern South America using U. S.
flag carriers, March and September, 1957
18—Passengers traveling by air between
United States. or Eastern United States,
And Eastern South America using U. S.

flag carriers. March and September, 1956
19—Passengers traveling by air between
United Stites. or Eastern United States,
and Eastern Sonth America using U. S.
flag carriers, March and September, 1955

xli
Original Print
1998 1368
1299 1369
P00 1330
1301 =—:1371
1302' 13%2
4303 1373
1304 1374
1305° 1375
1306 =: 1376

7?

xlii_. , INDEX

Record from the United States District Court for
the Southern District of New York— Continued
Government’s Statistical’ Exhibits—Continued

20—Passengers travtling by’ air between.

United States, or Eastern United States,

and Eastern South America using U. S.

. flag carriers, March and September, 1954
21—Passengers traveling’ by air. between
United States, or E®&tern United States,

and Eastern South America using U. S.

flag carriers, March and September, 1953
29--Passengers traveling by air between
United States, or, Eastern United States,

and Eastern South America using U. S.

flag carriers, March and September, 1952
23—Passengers traveling by air between
United States, or Eastern United States,

-and Eastern South America using U. S.

flag carriers, March and September, 1950

24Passéngers traveling by air between .

* United States. or Eastern United States,
and Buenos Aires using @. S. .flag car-
riers, Mazggh and September, 1957 -
25—Preenserfrvelin by air between
United.Sftes. or Eastern United States,
and Buenos Aires using U. S. flag car-

riers. March and September. 1956
* 26—Passengers traveling by air between
United States. or Eastern United States,

and Buenos Aires using 1. S. flag car-.

riers, March and September, 1955
27—Passengers traveling by air between
Tnited States. or Eastern Tnited States,

riers. March and September. 1954
28—Passengers traveling by air “hetween
United States. or Eastern T'nited States,
end Bnenos Aires nsing TU. S.‘flae car-
riers. March and September, 1953 .

and Buenos Aires using 17. S. flag care

_ Original

1307

1308

1309

e
1310:

1311

1312

1313

1314

1315

Print —

1378

1379

1380

1381

* 1382

~ 1383

1384

1385

_ INDEX xiii
a) . ’ Original Print
Record from the United States District Court’ for
the Southern District of New York — Continued
Government's ‘Statistical “Exhibits—Continued
29-—Pasker pers traveling by air between
United States, or Eastern United States,
and Buenos Aires fusing U. S. flag car- .
riers, March and September, 1952 1316 = =1386
30—Passengers traveling by air between
United States, or Eastern. United States, -
and Buenos fires using U. S. flag car-
riers, March aiid September, 1950 1317-1387
32-—Passengers traveling by air between United —
States, or Eastern United States, and ’
South America’ using U.S. flag and for-
eign flag carriers, 1957 ~ 13819 = 1388
33—Passéengers traveling by air between United.
States, or Eastern United States, and
South Ameriga using V7. S. flag and for- .
eign flag carriers, 1956, 1320 =—-1389
34—Passengers traveling by air between U nited
States. or Eastern United States. and x
South Amertea using U.S. flag and for- ;
eign flag carriers, 1955 1321. 1390
35— Passengers traveling by air between U nied
States. or Eastern United States, and
South. America using U.S. flag and for-

eign flag carriers 1954 "1322, . 1391
36—Passengers traveling by air between Upited

States, or Eastern Unites] States. and. - ,

South America using T.S. flag end for- ) :

eign flag carriers. 1953 - - 4323 . 1392

37— Passengers traveling bv air between United 5.
States. or Eastern United States, and
South America using-. S. flag and-for.
‘ eign flag carriers, 1952 1324 1393
38—Passengers traveling bv air hetween United .
States. or Eastern Unjted States. and
South America usine T S. flag and for. ee
eign flag — 1950. 1325-1394

eS.

. xliv - INDEX |

Original Print
Record from the United States District Coyrt for
the Southern Districa, of New York—-Continued *
Government's Statistical Exhibits—Continued ,
39—Passengers traveling by air between United
States, or Eastern United States, and
4 Western South American Countries’
using U. Sotlag’and foreign flag ear:
riers, 1957 . SED 1326 =: 13895
40—Passengers traveling’ bye air » hetwe een U nited
4@:States, or Eastern United States, and «
4 bag age South American Countries
using U. — and foreign fag car.
_ Tiers, na ae 132% = «1396
41—Passengers travelife by air between United
States, or Eastern’ United States, and .
4 Western South American Countries
using U.S. flag and foreign flay car-
riers, 1955. ......:..°' 13281397
42-—Passengers traveling by air berwens United re oa Al
States, or Eastern United States. and
4 Western South American Countries
using U. S. flag and foreign flay carriers, ;
1954 . eleasiiae * 1329 «1398
49 Passsngets tray eling by air between United ,
States, or Eastern United States, and
4 Western South American Countries
using U. S. ‘flag and foreign flag ear-
riers, 1953 ws. .+..... | 13377 1399
44-— Passengers traveling by air between United
States, or Eastern’ United States, and

s

4 Western South American Countries - @
using U.S. ioe and. foreign flag car- iS
riers, 1952 1331 1400

45— Passengers ceavdine by air between U nited
States, or Eastern United States. and
4 riage South: American Countries
using U. S. flag and foreign flag car- é
riérs, pled ae sais ae 1332 = 1401

INDEX

. 4 e -

Record from the United States Distriet Court for
the Southern District of New York Continued
Government's Statistical Exhibit ‘ontinued .

a0— Passengers traveling by air becween United
Mates,-or Eastern United Syates. and

wa 7 Eastern South American Countries

” using U.S. tlag amd toreign tag ear
riers, 1957 0... _
47—Puassengers traveling bv air between United
States, or Rastern United States, and

7 Eastern: South American Countries
using U. S.-tlag. and foreign flay ear-

8 riers, 1956) , |

48- Passengers traveling by air between United
Stafes. or Eastern United States. and
© Eastern South Anierean Countries

* using US. dar and foreign tlag can

riers, 1955
4%-~ Passenyers traveling by air between United
States. or Eastern Umited Bates. and

7 Eastern South Amertean Countries’ ”

using U.S. tlas and foreign Udy ear
Tiers, 1854 .
. Me Passengers Praying by air between United
States, or Easterti United States. and
7 Eastern South Amerwan Countries
_ using I. Ss. flag and foreign flag car-
. riers, 19534 ' ‘

_ 51—Passengers trateling by air between United

States. or Eastern. United States. and
7 Eastern South Ameriyan Countries
using U.S. flag and foreign flay car-
riers, *1942 :

52— Passengers traveling * y sir between United
States. or Eastern United States. and

7 Eastern Sonti: American Countries
using I. S. flay and, foreign flag ear-
- riers, 1950 cena

x!v

Original, . frint
,

1333 1402
Inna” 1402
1835-1404
1436 © -1405°
1337 1406

1338 1407.
.

xlvi INDEX

. Original , Print
Record from the United States District Court for
‘the Southern Distriet of New York —Confinued
Government's Statistical Exhibits—Continued
53—Passengers traveling by air between United ¢
States, or Eastern United States, and
Argentina using U. 8S. flag and foreign
flag carriers, 1957... ss... 1340 1409
‘54—Passengers traveling by air betwien U nited .
- §tates, or Eastern United States, and
Argentina using U. S. flag and —

flag carriers, 1956 _. . 1341 1410
55— Passengers traveling by air between U nite. ,
° ——s- States, or Eastern United ‘States, and

Argeyptina using U. S. flag and foreign’

flag carriers, 1955° . . 1342 1411

56— Passengers. traveling by air between U nited
States, or Eastern A nited States, and
/Argentina using U.S. flag and forcign
flag carriers, 1954 ' 1343 1412
57—Passengers traveling by air between United ;
States; or Eastern United States, and
Argentina using U. S. flag and foreign
flag carriers, 1953 - 1344 1413
58—-Passengers traveling by airfetween United = =—s*
States, dr Eastern United, States. and
Argentina using U. S. flag and foreign
flag carriers, 1952 * 1345 1414
59— Passengers traveling by air between U nited
. States, or: Eastern United States, and
Argentina using U.,S. flag and foreign —
flag carriers, 1950 © (1346 0 1415
60-—Passengers traveling by air between United . |
States, or Eastern United States, and
Colombia using U. S. flag and foreign .
flag carriers, 1957 - a 1347 - 1416
- 61—Passengers traveling by air hetween i. nited
States, or Eastern United States. and
Colombia using U. S. flag and foreign
flag carriers. 1956 Bs, 1348 . 1417

Ps]

e

on INDEX

Record from the United States’ District Court for

- the Southern District of New York—Continued
Government's Statistic d
62—Passengers traveling by air between United

States, or Eastern hires States, and
Colombia using U. S. flag and foreign
flag carriers, 1955 |
63—Passengers traveling by air bermcen. U nited
States, or Eastern pipes States, and
Colombia using U. S. flag and foseign
- flag carriers, 1954 *.:
Pa eens traveling by airsbetween United
States, or’ Eastern United States, and
- Colombia using U. 8 flag and foreign

. flag carriers, 1953

65—Passengers traveling by air between United

: States, or Eastern United States. and
“Colombia using U. S. flag and foreign
flag carriers, 1952

66—Passengers traveling by air between United:

States, or Eastern United States. and
Colombia using U. S. flag and foreign
‘flag. carriers, 1950
68—Passengers carried hy sea in liner | service
between United States Coastal Areas
* and the West Coast of: South America,
: nee '
_ 69—Passengers carried by sea in liner service

between United “States Coastal Areas °

and ,the West Coast of South America.
1956.

- ay . . . © . 4
70-—-Passengers carried by sea in liner service
between United States Coastal Areas.

_ and the West Coast of South America,
1955 :

71—Passengers carried by sea in liner service |

between Thited States Coastal Areas
* and the West Coast of South America,
1954 —

A

Original

, 1349.

1353

1336

x}vil

Print

1415

1419
1420
1421
1422
128
1424

1425

1426

xviii * . INDEX

Record from the United States District Court for

the Southern District of New York—Continued
Government's Statistical Exhibits-—-Continued

72—Passengers carried by. sea in liner service

between the Atlantic Coast of the United

States and the West Coast of South
America, 1951-1953 (Trade Route 2) ..

. COMPARISON OF Pa&NaGRA AND GRACE PASSEN-
GER TRAFFIC:

74—Passengers carried by air with Panagra

. participation between certain Eastern
a Sections of the United States and Coun-

tries on the West Coast of South Amer..
iea, March and Boptember, 1956 and .

SEE, ihscinalinin cnthhaneetatiasinbishe
75—Passengers carried by air with Panagra

participation between certain Eastern —

_ Sections of the United States and Coun-

tries on the West Coast of South Amer-

ica, March and September, 1954 and
UIE sects itiahelecpakciei dips eeasaabutahentainaie

i-Bigtneus carried by air with Panagra

participation between certain Eastern
' Sections.of the United States and Coun-
tries on the West Coast of South Amer-
ica,, March and September, 1952 and
1953 Saguttibaletal Meaceiatensbetaaias

77-—Passengers carried by the Grace Line be- .

tween the Atlantic Coast of the United
States and the West Coast of South
America, 1955-1957 - 5
78—Passengers carried. by the Grace ‘Line be-
tween the Atlantic Coast of the United
_ States and the West Coast seg South
America, 1952-1954 - J
79—Comparison of average monthly passenger
traffic carried by air with Panagra par-
ticipation and by sea on Grace Line be-
tween Northeasteyn United States and
West. ge Countries of South Amer-
ica, 19 6 and 1957 - rae iy re

“

1359 1427
1361 1428 ©
1362 1429
1363 1430
1364 1431
1365 1432
1366 1433

Original Print

_ INDEX,

Record from the. United States District Court for
the Southern District of New York—Continued
-Government’s Statistical Exhibits—Continued -

80—Comparison of average monthly passenger
traffic carried by air with Panagra par-
ticipation and by sea on Grace Line be-
tween Northeastern United States and
West Coast Countries of South Amer-

ica, 1954 and 1955 - :
81—Comparison of average monthly passenger
_ traffic carried by air with Panagra par-
ticipation and by sea on Grace Line be-
tween Northeastern United States and
‘West Coast Countries of South Amer-

ica, 1952 ang 1958 ..

utd CARGO. AND MAIL STATISTICS

ie CARRIERS :

82—Overseas cargo carried by air into and out

° of New York, by ‘years, 1953-1957.
83—Cargo and mail carried by air between
‘Miami and points outside Continental

United States, by years, 1951-1957
84—Freight, express and mail carried by. air
on U. §. flag airlines serving Latin

\ America, 1957... eee

-85—Freight, express and mail ‘loaded o on 1 U:. s.
‘flag airlines serving South America, 1957

,

Sea CARRIERS:
86—Cargo carried by sea in liner service be-
tween the United States and Latin Amer-
ica, by years, 1951-1957 ~ * 2
-87—Cargo imports carried by sea in liner ser-
vice to United States Coastal Areas from
the West Coast of South America, 1957
* 88—Cargo. imports carried by sea in liner ser-
vice to United States Coastal Areas from

the West Coast of South America, 1956

Original

1367

1368 |

1369

1370

1371

1372

1373

1374

1375

xlix

Print

1434

1435

1436

1437

1438.

1439

\?

] . INDEX

Record from the United States District Court for
the Southern District of New York—Continued
Government’s Statistical Exhibits—Continued

89—Cargo imports carried by sea in liner ser--

vice to United States Cuastal Areas from
the West Coast of South America, 1955
90—Cargo imports carried by sea in liner ser-
vice to United States Coastal Areas from
the West Coast of South America, 1954
91—Cargo imports carried by sea in liner ser-
vice to the Atlantic Coast of the United
States from the West Coast of South
America, 1951-1953 (Trade Route 2)
92—-Cargo exports carried by sea in liner ser-
vice from United States Coastal Areas
to the West Coast of South America,
1957 —
93—Cargo vapents pa br sea in ; eae ser-
vice fram United States Coastal Areas
to the West Coast of South America,
1956 - Sets es
94—-Cargu exports carried ‘Sor sea in : liner ser-
vice from [United States Coastal Areas to
the West. Coast of South America, 1955
95—Cargo exports carried by sea in liner ser-

vice from United States Coastal ,Areas -

to the West Coast of South America,
1954 | ga aR fae

96—Cargo exports carried w sea in liner ser-"

vice from the Atlantic Coast of the
United States ‘to the West Coast of
‘South America, 1951-1953 (Trade Route

COMPARISON OF Paxacra AND GRACE arco
TRAFFIC :

97—-Freight, express, and mail loaded on Pie-
agra planes, by cities, 1957 ,

98—Cargo carried by Panagra planes between

Miami or the Canal Zone and five cities

in West Coast Countries of South Amer-

RC TMS rt Ree DOAN LOT Ee aR

Original

1378\

_ 1379

1380

1381

1382.

1383

1384-

1385

Print

1445.

1446

1447

1448

1449 -

1450

1452

INDEX

Record from the United States District Court for
- the Southern District of New York—Continued
Government’s Statistical Exhibits—Continued
99—Cargo carried by the Grace Line between

the Atlantic, Coast of the United States
and the West: Coast of South America,
by cities (Trade Route 2), 1957 -
100—Comparison of cargo traffic corsa by
Panagra planes and by Grace Line be-
tween indicated United States. Atlantic
Coast Points and specified cities in

West Coast. Countries of South Amer- -
ica, 1957 Feat saoe Eieabsteee ren caisantvadaionee

- Government’s Exhibits:

1119—Excerpts from the testimony of Juan |

Trippe in CAB docket 779

1120—Excerpts from the testimony of Harold |

Roig in CAB docket 779 - e
1121--Excerpts from the foedmony of i. C.
Dobbs, ‘A. E. Sinclair, Robert H.
oe Patchin, Adolph Garni and W. F.
Cogswell’ in CAB docket 779..
-1122—Excerpts from the testimony. of’ Juan
Trippe in CAB docket 3389 .
1123—Stipulation between Pan American, W.
R. Grace and Pariagra with respect to
various personnel of the three com-
I oie raceecs aon
1124—Stipalation between the United States
and Pan American with respect. to
various acquisitions: of airlines in

South America by Pan American ... .

Original

1386

1387

1387a

1424a

(1445a

1471
1485

1490

1128—CAB opinion in docket»No: 4882 et al. —

dated March 26, 1954 (No. E-8189) .
- 1129—CAB opinion in docket No. 4882 et al.

dated November 23, 1954 (Nos. E-9109

and E-9110) and appendices :

_ 1131—Letter to Board: of Directors, Pan Amer-
jean-Grace Airways, Inc. from An-

drew B. Shea dated November 26, 1956

1493.

1502

Print

1453

1454

1455

1491

1512

1535 -

1547

© eee

«

INDEX

Record from the United. States District Court for

the Southern District of New York- —Contimued
Gov ernment’s Exhibits—Continued-

-1132—Letter to.Andrew B. Shea from nau
LéWwis dated November 30, 1956. —._..
1134—Letter to Andrew B. Shea from Bowie
Ralluder, Henry J. Friendly, Roger
Lewis, Wilbur L. Morrison, Directors
of ‘Pan American- Grace Airways, Inc.,
dated January 10, WII avass cceeasiasenaics
1135—Minhutes of adjourned regular nieeting
| of Board of Directors of Pan Amer-
ican- Grace Airways, Ine. held Jan-
uary 10,-1957 .. P
1139--Pan American- Grace Aiew ays, a Route
_ Extension Study Geted November 1956
General Statement . decile iecsnue otek cats
NR oe eee ee
~Miami-New York. ,
Balboa—Mexico eel “Les Angeles, San Fran-
cisco - i lesa chaasesiganeadeosssie-ietenen dice ame ae
Annexes. eet ;

| ‘VOLUME V

Pan American World Airway s, Ine, Exhibits:

~DocUMENTARY EVIDENCE:

1—Letter to Wilbur L. Morrison hous R. c
Shrader dated October 11, 1946

' 2—Agreement .between Pan American Air-
ways, Inc. and Pan.American-Grace Air- _
_. » ways, Ine. dated July 30, 1946 Diaaods

NE caneueete

3—Letter agreement betwees Pan “American
Airways, Inc. and Pan ‘American- -Grace
Airways, Inc. dated May 28, 1947

4—Letter agreement between W. R. Grace and

Co. and Pan American Airways Corpora-
tion -dated May 28, 1947 -

Original

1560

“1562.

Print

1668

1669

1673

1677
1677

1680

1719

1760
1789

1851

1856

1859
1879

1884

1885

_ INDEX

Record from the United States District Court for

the Southern District of New York -Continued |

Pan American World Airways, Inc. Exhibits—

Continued
— §—Supplement No. 2 to Through Flight Agree-
Ment between Pan Amerivan Airways,

‘Ine. and Pan American-Grace’ Airways, -

Inc.’ dated January 9, 1948.
6—Supplement No. 3 to Through Flight Agree-

ment between Pan American. Airways,-
Inc. and Pan American-Grace Airways, |

Inc. dated January 28, 1949
7—Supplement No. 4 to Through Flight Agree-
ment between Pan American Airways,
Inc. and Pan American-Grace Airways,
Inc. dated February 9, 1949
8—Supplement:No. 5 to Through Flight Agree-
ment between Pan American Airways,
Inc. and Pan Ar.erivan-Grace Airways,
Inc. dated May 11, 1949
9—Antendment No. 1 to application of Pan
‘American World Airways, Inc. for ap-
proval of Supplement No. 5 to the
Through Flight Agreement dated ee
25, 1951 .
10—Supplement No. § to Through Flight
Agreement between Pan American Air-
ways, Ine. and Pan American-Grace
Airways, Inc. dated October 18, 1949
11—Supplement No. 7 to Through Flight
Agreement between Pan American

World Airways, Inc. and Pan American- .

Grace Airwaysine. dated January 31,
_—~—1950 ..... wm ee eet.

‘ 12—Supplement No. 8 to Through Flight
Agreement between Pan American

World Airways, Inc. and Pan American-

Grace Airways, Inc. dated December 26,

1950

>

Original -

1805

1831

1859

1847

1849

lili

Priut

1908

1910

1911

1919

1923

1925

1927

liv INDEX

Record from the United States District Court for
the Southern District of New York—Continued
Pan American World Airways, Inc. Exhibits—

Continued ©

13—Supplement No. 9 to Through Flight .

Agreement between Pan American
World Airways, Inc. and Pan American-
Grace Airways, Inc. dated January 24,
eee

-14—Supplement No. 10 1 to . Through Flight

, Agreement between Pan American
World Airways, Inc. and Pan American-
Grace Airways, Inc. dated June 29. 1951

15—Supplement No. 11 to Through Flight —

Agreement between .Pan American
World Airways, Inc. and Pan American-
Grace Airways, Inc. dated January 1,
RD

16—Supplement No. 12 to Through Flight
Agreement between Pan American
World Airways, Inc. and Pan American-
Grace Airways, Ine. dated April. 10,
1952 .. wr

17--Supplement No. 13 to Through ‘Flight

Agreement between Pan American

World Airways, Ing. and Pan American-

Grace — Inc. dated September 25,
1952 ..

18—Supplemen: Ne. 4 to Through Flight
Agreement between Pan American
World Airways, Inc. and Pan American-
Grace Airways, Inc. dated May 8, 1953

19-Supplement No. 15 to Through Flight

Agreement between Pan American

World Airways, Inc: and Pan American-
Grace Airways, Inc. dated January 20,

1954 _ nil
20—Supplement “No. 16 to Through Flight
_ Agreement between Pan American
World Airways, Inc. and Pan American-
. Grace Airways, Inc. dated June -29, 1954

”

1872

1875

1883

1891

1902

1903

1918

1934

Print

1952

1964

1971

1986 |

1987

INDEX

Record from the United States District Court for
the Southern Distriet of New York Continued
Pan American World Airways, ‘Ine. Exhibits —

Continued :

21—Supplement No. 17 to Through Flight

Agreement between Pan American
World Airways, lic. and Pan American-
Grace Airways, Ine. dated Septe.cber 7,
1955 :
22—Supplement No. 18 to Through Flight
Agreement between © Pan American
World Airways, Ine. and Pan Ametican-
Grace Airways. Inc. dated » August 4.
1955 e (
23—Supplement No. 19 to Through Flight
Agreenent between Pan American
World Airways; Inc. and Pan American-
Grace Airways, Ine. dated August 7,
1957
24—Supplement No. 20 to Through Flight
Agreement between Pan American
World Airways, Inc. and Pan American
Grace Airways. Ine dated duly 11, 15s
5—Supplement No» 21 to Through Flight
Agreement between Pan American
World Airways Ine and Pan American-
Grace Airways, Inc. dated December 25.
1958 :
26—Equipment Interchange Agreement be-
tween National Airlines, Incorporated,
Pan Americon World Airways. Ine, and
Pan American-Grace Airways. Ine.
dated August 4, 1955
27—Supplement No. 1 te Feiipment® Inter-
* change Agreement between National
Airl nes, Incerperated, Pen American
World Airwars, Ine. and Pan Amer.
jean Groce Airways, Ine. dated Angust

9, 1955 Pa

Original

1935

1%,2

14

1966

1978 °

lv

Print

2032

2126

lvi -, INDEX
- ee a Original Print
Record from the United States District Coart for
the Southern District of New York—Continued
Pan American’ World aa. Ine. Exhibite—
Continued
28—Application as wisieabia by Amendment
No. 1 of National Airlines, Incorporated,
Pan American World Airways, Inc., and
Pan American-Grace Airways, Inc. for
approval .of Equipment Interchange
Agreement and. amendment to Through
Flight Agreement under Section 412 of
.the Civil Aeronautics Act and; if
deemed necessary, for approval under
-or exemption from Section 408, of the
said Act dated August 4, 1955 _. 2033 «2138
29—Amendmen* No. 1 to applicatic”. of Na.
tional Airlines, Incorporated. Pan Amer-
‘ican World Airways, Inc., and Pan
_ American-Grace Airways, Inc’ for ap-
-- proval of Equipment Interchange Agree-
ment and amendment to Through Flight
- Agreement -under Section 412 of the
Civil Aeronautics Act and, if deemed —
necessary, for approval under or ¢xemp-
tion from Section 408. of the said Act .4
dated August 10, 1955 a se 2079 38382177

30—Letter to Civil Aeronauties Board frees
K. A. Lawder dated August 29.1955 2084 + 2181

mallbage ment No. 2 to Equipment Inter-

change Agreement betwéer National

Airlines. Incorporatcd, Pan American

World Airways, ag ing Pan Amer-

ican-Grace Airways. . dated August

22, 1955. oe ‘ 2085 2182
32—Letter ‘egrectsent between Pan American-

Grace Airways, Inc. and National Air-

lines. Inc. dated August 24.1955 - 2089 2185
33—Letter agreement between Pan America:-

Grace Airways, Inc. «nd National Air-’

lines, Inc dated November 28, 1955 2091 2186

INDEX

Record from the v nited States D: strict Court for
the Southern District 6{f New York - Continued”

Pan American World Airways. luce. Exhibits— -

Continued
34—Supplement No. 3 to Equipment Inter-
change Agreement between National
Airlines, Incorporated, Pan American
World Airways, Inc., and Pan Ampr-
ican-Grace Airways, Inc. dated Novem-
‘ber 28, 1955 ; .
= 35—Letter agreement between Pan ‘American-
| Grace Airways. Inc., National Airlines,
Incorporated, and Pan American World
* Airways, Inc. dated April 16 1957
36—Statement of references and cos, deter-

*

mination set forth in financial ‘supple

’ © ment dated August 9, 1955, to the Equip-

vem ment Interchange Agreement dated Au-
gust 4, 1955, between National Airlines,
Incorporated, Pan American World Air-
ways, Inc. and -Pan American-Grace
Airways, Tne.

Pan Ame-ican iauias ntary Evidence —Agree-
ments filed with the CAB ,
37—Agreements on Interline tickets between

Pan American Airways. Inc. and Pan.
American-Grace Airways, Inc, dated
from January 20, i932. 10 October 1,

ED tiene ¢ :
38— Letter agreement between Pan Amer'van
“Airway 5. Ine. and Pan American-Grace

_ Airways, Inc. dated June 11, 1937
39— Letter. agreement between Pan American-
Grace Airways. Inc. and Pan Amer:can’

Airways. Tite.’ uated May 13.1942
40—Ltter agreement between Pan Am» rieat-
Grace Airways. Inc. and Pat) American’

) © Airways.\Inc. dated October 28, 1942

Original

2093

2102

2113

2126

ri lvl

Print

2188

2196

2900

a _ INDEX -
7

Record from the United States District Court for
the Southern District of New York — Continued.

Pan American World Airways, Ine» Exhibits—
Continued
41— Agreement ‘enbinies Pan American- Grace
Airways, Inc.,and Pan American Air-
ways, Inc. dated May 25, 1944 ;
42—Contract between Pan Amerwan Airways,
Ine. and Pan Americen-Grace Airways,
Inc. dated August 23, 1945 é ,
8 43—Agreement between Pan American, Pan-
agra and Grace dated March 3, 1948
44—Letter agreementNetween Pan American
Airways. ‘Inc. Pan American-Grace
_ Ainways Ine July 14. 1948
2 45—Memorandum agreem jt regarding ser-
vica® rendered and

compensation therefor between Pan
American-Grace Airways. Inc., *Pan
American Airways,
Grace and Co., dat uly 14, 1948
46—General Traffic ard “Sales Ageney Agree.
ment between Pan American Airways,
“ Inc. and Pan American-Grace Airways.
Inc. dated September 10, 1948

47—Letter agreement between Pan American -

; _ Grace Airwavs, Inc. and Pan ‘American
World ‘Airways, Inc. dated December 10,
1951 ‘ |
cionales de Colombia. =A. dated Decem- *
ber 3.1954 209] *. 2371
56---Interline Traffic Agreem it signed by Pan
American Airways, Inc. dated Pirvom.

.

ber 3. 1954 9949 979
‘ c « ; ‘
Fane | VoLUME VI
57-~Amendment No, 1 to Genera! ‘Traffie and - 3 «2

Sales Aganev Agreement between. Pan
American World) Airways. Ine. anf

Aerovias Nacionales de «Colombia, S.A. Cra
dated June 18 1957 . = 2300 2383 °
® .
&
. _ . .
. -s e e

s
“y
.

lx . INDEX

Record from the United States District Court for
the Southern District of.New York—Continued
Pan: American World Airways, Ine. Exhibits—

Continued

58—_Amendment ‘No. 2 to General Traffic and

3 Sales Agency Agreement between Pan
7 American. World Airways, Inc aud
- Aerovias Nacionales de Colombia, S.A.

dated January BN: MR adasssiciaibtnccsiinrccnnc®

59—Amendment No. 3 to General Traffie and

‘Sales Agency Agreements between Pan ~

A: erican World Airways, Inc. and
-Ae.vvias Nacionales de Colombia, S.A.
> .. dated March 31; 1958 0

60—Amendment No. 4 to General Traffic and .

e - Sales Agency Agreement Between Pan

American World Airways, Inc. and’

‘ »* Aerovias Nacionales de Colombia, S.A.
“dated October 30, 1958 0
.61—Agreement for ground services and use of
ground facilities by scheduled operators
between Pan American Airways, Ine.
uz ‘ ‘and Braniff Airways, Inc. dated April
27, 1948 C5. ES eA OED
.62—Amendment No. I to Ground Facilities

t and Services Agreement ‘between Pan ~

American Airways, Inc. and Braniff Air-
ways, Inc. dated September 27, 1948 _..
63—Amcendment ‘II to Ground Facilities and

Servicts Agreement between Pan Amer-

ican Airways, Inc. and Braniff —
Ine. dated October 31, 1949 .. ca
64— Amendment No. III to Ground Facilities

and Services Agreeme.. t between-Pan .

American Airways, Inc. and Braniff
Airways, Ine, dated December 7, 1949 _.

65—Amendment IV to Ground Facilities and
-Services Agreement between Pan Amer-
ican World Airways, Inc. and Braniff
Airways, Inc. dated July 20, 1950 _...
‘

»

Original

2304 -

” 2306

'
.

2321

2324

’ Print

~ 2385

2389

2391

2407

INDEX

Record from the United States District Court for
‘ the Southern District of New York—Continued
’ Pan American World Airways, Inc. lan coal
Continued . :
- 66—Assignment agreement between Pan Amer-
ican World Airways, Inc. and - Aero-
puertos Unidos, “S.A. “dated April 30,
. 1952 . ds
67—Letter egrermens between ‘Pap’ Ai
World Airways, ine. ‘and Braniff Air-
ways, Ine. dated November 18, 1954 _.
68—Amendment No. V to Ground - Facilities

‘and Services Agreement between Pan —
6 American World Airways, Ine. and

. Braniff Airways, Ine. dated June 20,
A
69—Amendment VI to Gronnd Facilities ‘ana

Services Agreement between Pan Amer-

pera

Original

2327

2328 .

2331

ican World Airways, Inc. and Braniff _ -

= 74—Letter agreement between Pan Awerican
Airways, Ine. and Parfair Do Beasil, S. A.
accepted October 21, 1947 «

75-—Letter agreement hetween Panair Do Bra-

sil, $.A. and Pan American Airways, |

_Ine. accepted January 13, 1947

2332

lxi

Print

9412

2413

2416.

lxil INDEX

Record from the’ United States District Court for -

the Southern. District of New York Continued
Pan American. World Airways, Ine. Exhibits—
Continued
76—Letter agreement between Pan American
World “Airways,.Inc. and Panair Do

Brasil, S.A. accepted May 14, 1952 _... -
77—General Traffic and Sales Agency Agree--
ment between Pan American World Air- .

ways, Inc. and Panair Do Brasil, S.A,
‘dated January 1, 1955 nS
78—Letter agreement between Pan American
World Airways] Ine, and Panair Do
Brasil, S.A. accepted Deeémber 28, 1955
719— Amendment No. 1 to General Traffic and
Sales Agency Agreement between Pan
American World Airways, Inc. and Pan-

air Do Brasil, S.A. deted July 1. 1957 _

80—Amendment No. 2 to General Traffic and

Sales Agency Agreement between Pan

American World Airways, Ine, and Pan-
air Do Brasil, S.A. dated December li,
. 1957 .. eats
81—Letter iesia, -R. H. Pp. 6 c. x ‘Bilwiliee
dated August 30, 1927 .

82—Letter from R. H. Patchin te > Mr. ¢ Carter’

dated August 31, 1927 . ae
83—Letter trom J. T. Trippe. t to “Harold R.

_ Harris dated December 23, 1927 -
84—Leiier frons J: T. Trippe to Harold R.
| Harris dated December 30, 1927 __........
85—Letter from Huff Daland Dusters, Inc. to

Original

2355

2357

2379 .

2380

2382

2384:

2385

2386

2389

_ Juan Trippe dated January 3, 1928 2390

‘86—Memorandum of conversation with Dr.
vou Bauer by.R. H: Patehin dated Jan-
uary 3, 1928 Sahai aii anata eigenen :

’ 87—Letter from J. T. Trippe to Harold R.

Harris dated January 13, 1928 .

. §8—Letter from J. T. .Trippe to Edgar N.
. Gott dated February 21, 1928

2392

2395

2397

Print

2440

2441

"2460

2474

2476

INDEX

Record from the United States District Court for
the Southern District of New York—Continued
Pan American. World Airways, Inc. Exhibits—

Continued .

89—Letter from Juan Trippe to Richard F.
Hoyt dated February 23, 1928

90—Letter from Atlantic, Gulf and ¢: aribbean
Airways. Ine. to Edgar N. Gott dated
April 10, 1928

91—Infermal memorandum report. by ITT
dated April 27, 1928

92—- Memorandum by JTT dated May 7, 1928

93— Supreme Resolution of Peru regarding, the
Hui Daland Dusters, Inc. dated May
29. 1928 -

‘94— Agreement hekiees the General hdaiaie-

tration of: Posts and Telegraphs of Peru .
and the Huff Daland Dusters, Ine. dated

June 27, 1928

95—Advertisement for foreign siveail service’

by Post Office enn dated May
31, 1928 -

‘96—Memorandum from C. E. to. U. & a: dated

2 June 5, 1928

-97—Memorandum, to J.T. Teippe from r. E.

D. Nagle dated June 26, 1928

- 98— Airmail route proposak bond and oath ~ .

Pin American Airw ays, Ine. dated July

' 2, 1928 .

‘ 90-—Memorandam to letchart ‘from Patehin
Gajed July 11, 1978 _.

Original

2530

. 2532

2536

2537

2540:

2600

Print

2623

2625

2633

2680

INDEX . _ ixvii

>

Original Print
Record from the United States District Court for’ e
the Southern District of New York—Continued
- -»Pan American World Airways, “Ine. Exhibits—
Continued
’ 137—Post Office Department press release re
award of mail contract to Pan Amer-
scan-Graee ee Ine. dated May 3,
1929 . . 2601 2680
138—Letter to RR. Er ‘Hort from J. D. Me-
. Gregor dated’ May 9, 1929 ' 2602 2681
- 139—Memorandum to the directors of -Pan
* American-Grace Airways, Inc. from_J.

D. MacGregor attached to letter ms
Hoyt from MacGregor ated May 9,
1929 Sa 2 2603 2682
140—Order slaued by Ww. techie Glover, See-
ond Assistant Postmaster General, reas
. dated August 20, 1929 2614 2692
141—Letter to Walter F. Brown, Postmaster
General, from Pan American Airways,
ine. dated October 24, 192900 2615. 2692
142—Letter to Pan American Airways. Ine.
from W. Irving Glover, Second As-
sistant Postmaster General, dated Oc-
ober 28, 1929 2619 2695
143—Traffic agreement between Pan American
Airways, Inc.. Pan American-Grace
Airways, Inc. and SCADTA dated = -
February 28. 1930 . 2620 2696

144—-Letter to J. T. Trippe from E. E. W
dated May 2.1930 | 2628 2701
~ 145—Cable-to MacCracken, O'Neill from Bunge
Bilbao dated May 14, 1930 632 2705
146—Letter te Pan Aniericon Airways, Ine. |
from James D. Summers dated June 4, eT be
1930 : - 2636 ©2707

147—Memo to J. T Trippe from Pan Amer.”
iean-Grace Airways, Inc. dated June :
12, 1930 . 2639 2710

Ixvill_ ; _ INDEX. — ,

- Record from the United ‘States District Court for

the Southern District of New, York-—Continued .

Pan American World Airways,. Ing. Exhibits—
Continued

148—Letter to Walter F. Brown from Pan -

American-Grace Airways, Ine. dated
June 18, 1930

149—Méemorandum by MacCracken, ~ and J. |

T. Trippe dated July 22, 1930

.150—Memorandum in regard to the proposed -

acquisition by Aviation Corporation of
the Americas of the assets of New York,
Rio & Buenos Aires Line, Inc. pre-
pared by Root, Clark, Buckner & Bal-
lantine, -counsel for. Pan American,
dated July 28, 1930
151—-Letter to Root, Clark, Buckner & ‘Bal
lantine from John Lord ©’Brian, As-
sistant Attorney General, dated Au-
gust 1, 1930 - i
152—Post Office advertisement for. Selon: air-
mail seryice between Paramaribo and
Santos dated August 20, 1930 §
153—Contract for foreign airmail service route
No..10 between United States of Amer.
ican and Pan American Airways, Ince.
dated September 24. 1930

154— Extension of service and agreements. for- -

eign: airmail route No. 10, agreement
between. the Uaited States of Ameriva
‘and Pan American Airways, Ine.,
dated October 15, 1931 >:
155—Memorandum .to “directors, Pan Amer-
ican-Grace Airways. Inc. from J. D.
MacGregor dated September 26, 1930
156—Letter to Pan. American Airways. Ine.
from .E: R. White. Director. Post Of-
lice Department. dated December 13,

1930

Original

‘2641

2645

2646

2687

2696

2709 «

OT15

Print

2749

a

INDEX *) im

. y, -_ Original Print

Record from the United States District Court for
the Southern District of New York-—Continted
Pan American World Airways, Ince. Exhibits——

Continued > ‘
157—Law No, 8 of 193) of Colombia dated
, January 9, 1931 . Ziza)«=— 2788
1874 Memorandum to Trippe from ‘Evan E.
. Young dated March 6, 1931 ‘2733 © - 2797 -
158—Letter tu thé Postmaster General from °
- J. T. Trippe dated April-7, 1931 2735. 2799
159— —Letter to the Postmaster General from
¢ J. T. Trippé ditted April 7, 1931 2737 » 2800
160—Letter to the Postmaster General from .
© J.T. Tripipe dated April 7, 1931 ° 2739 = 28093
161—Lettér to J. T. Trippe from Francis i,
* White dated April 9, 193] ‘2740 =©62804

162—Letter to President of Pan American
from Washington Representative (Na-

gle) dated June 17, 1931 2741 =2805°
163—Letter to Walter F. wer n from. Thomas + _ |
| B. Dee-datéd: duly.2. 1931 2744 © 2808
164—Letter to Thomas B. Dow from Walter F. ; :
_ “Brown dated July 7, 1931 2746 2810
165—Cable to J. P. Trippe from Tietjen dated
July 10,1931 2748 = 2811
166—Telegram ae Tietjen ‘from. Trippe mee ‘ ,
July 11, 1931 9749-2812
167--Letter to gta ite ‘from J. T. ‘Trippe
dated September 4. 1931 - ‘ 2750 92813

168—Avreement between Uraba. Medellin &
Central. Airwuys. Ine; and Gonzalo :
Mejia, dated ‘Sepretnber 10.. 1931 ; 9753 9815

169--Clip; ing\from the New York Times dated
December 12.1934 ; 2739 ° 2819

17 ()-- Translation of deed of assignment of the
Mejia Concession.to Vraha. Me@ellin &
Central Airways. Ine. ed Se

11, 1932 ; t . 2760 2421
171— Letter to Harold R. Harris from Geo. L. ;
ne Rih] dated December 24, 1933 2770 = =2830 .

e

Ixx .

+ INDEX

Record from the United States District, Court for
‘ the Southern District of New York—Continued
Pan American World Airways, Inc. Exhibits—

174—Letter to A. Garni ‘from ‘Harold ‘Roig

Continued _ -

* 172—Letter to Geo- L. Rih! from H. R. Harris
. dated December 30, 1933

173—Memorandum of conference with Francis
White by H. J. F. dated February 23,

dated March 18, 1935 . 5s
175—Letter* tc Chief of hisedeia at New
York from Pan American Operations
Manager, Caribbean, Miami, dated
June 19, 1935 - ae
176—Letter to J. D. MacGregor. from ‘i. R.
Harris dated November 28, 1936...
177—Confidential memorandum re airmail ser-
vice U.S.A. to Buenos Aires vi® west
coast of South America by Garni at.
tached to letter from Harris ty Mac-
. w Gregor dated November 28, 1986
178—Memorandum re extension of FAM 9
- through Bolivia to the Argentine at-
tached, to letter from Harris to Mac-
Gregor dated November 28, 1936 _..
179—Letter tc J. D. MacGregcr from H. R.
Harris dated December 7, 1936

VOLIUME VII

180—Memorandum to Vice President Young
from M. J. Rice dated June 3, 1937

181—Letter from M. J. Rice to Evan E. Young
dated June 16, 1937

182—Letter to Evan E. Young from M. J.
‘Rice dated June 17, 1937

183—Letter to J. D. MacGregor from H. R.
Harris dated August 7, 1937

9772 9833
2774 2836
2780 2840
2785 2844
2787 2848
2792 2855.
2796 2861
2803 2867
2805 2869
2506 2870
9207 2872
2811 2877

Original Print

INDEX :

Record from the United States District Court for

- the Southern District of New York—-Coutinued

Pan American World Airways. Tne. Exhibits—
Con.inued

—-1$4--Agree ment between Pan American Grace—

‘Airways. Ine. and Compania de Avia-
cion Pan American Argentine. S.A.
dated September 1, 1937

2

1$5—Cable to, Roig from-Garni dated October ;

14, 1937 ~
186—Minutes of adjourne “special meeting of
board of directors of Pan American-
Grace Airways. Inc. held January 27,
re Wo) :
187—Exhibit B me ajorundain “ Rihl dated
January 27, 1938
188—Memorandum for ‘A. Garni from J. D.
MacGregor dated April 29. 192s,
189—Letter to A. Garni from Harllee Braneh,
Second Assistant Postmaster General,
dated June 30. 1938
190—Lettér to Evan E. Young from M. J. Rive
~ dated November 11, 1938
191—Letter to Trippe — von Bauer un-
“dated | 7
192—Memorandum of. contdrethe relating to
proposed agreement between ~ Pan
American Airways Corporation and W.
R. Grace and Company on February
14. 1939. by Henry, J. Priendly
193—Translation of confdential memorandum
bv A. Villegas Restrepo dated June 13,
. 1939 .
104 emevendusn of telephone onversation

between Mr. Latchford and Mr. Young:

by E. E. Y. dated Jnly 15.1939
195-—-Letter to P. P. von Bauer from Evan
E. Young dated August 7, 1939
196—Letter. to President. Exeentive, New
York. from Evan E. Young dated

September 6. 1939

Ixxi
Original Print
9813 - 2880:
9817, 2884
2x22 2890
9295 2893

-

9230 2895
2833 2899
2834 2900
9838 2905
9240 2908 |
9842 9910
9844 2913
845 - 2914
“2846 9915

lxxii INDEX

Original Print

Record from the United States District Court for
the Southern District of New York—Continued ,
.Pan American World Airways, Ine. Exhibits—
_ Coatinued. _-: ;
~ 197—Letter to Evan E. =e ian F. Powers
dated September 28, 1939 _.... _.. 2848 2917 .
" 198—-Letter to Thomas Burke from George “a ;
: Rihl dated November 13, 1939 _.-... 2852 = 2923 ©
-'199—Letter to Rih) from Thomas Burke dated ;
- , November 18, 1939. . nes * 2853 2923
200—Letter to Ellis O. Briggs from George L. eee
| Rih] dated December 16, 1939 - =~ 2854 2924
-201—Letter to Martin dei Corral from Georg
L. Rihl dated January 18; 1940 __..... 2859 2931

202—Letter to George L. Rihl from Jose ie :
quin Castro M. dated January 23, 1940: 2861 2933
_ 203—Letter to Juan T. Trippe from = L. ae

Rihl dated January 25, 1940 .. 2862 2934
204—Memorandum by J. T. Trippe dated dee

Rr Re 2870 2948
205-—Minutes of regular meeting of executive _..
committee of Pan American Airways, :
Inc. dated May 14, 1940 2872 2945
‘ 206— Minutes of regular meeting of executive . :
| committee of Pan American Airways, |
Inc. dated May 24, 1940 2877 2948
207—Minutes of regular meeting ‘of executive :
- committee of Pan American Airways, toon,
Inc. dated.May 28, 1940... 2878 2948 ©

_208+-Letter to J.T. Trippe from M. J. Rice
; dated June 8, 1940 2879 2949

_209—-Memorandum of conference with the
Civil Aeronautics Anthority reference
SCADTA by Cooper.of Pan American,
; dated June 13,1940 . __... 2880 2950
210—Minutes of adjourned regular inestiies ‘of
executive committee of. Pan American
Airways. Inc. dated November 12,1940 2883° 2953
211—Minutes of regular. meeting of executive
_ committee of Pan American Airways, Cae,
‘Ine. dated November 19, 1940 (2884. 2954

— INDEX

Record from the U nited States District’ Court for
the Southern Distriet of New York-—-Continued
Pan American World Airways, Inc. Exhibits—

Continued *

212—Memorandum- of telephone conversation
between Messrs. Rihl and Harding by
G. L. R. dated July 10, 1941, -

* 213—Memorandum. to President, Executive,

New York, from Evan E. Young dated
July 15, 1941 . Perea ae

214—Telegram to Panair.. Youae. New York:
- from Cauby dated July 15. 1941

215—Letter to C. V. Whitney from D. Stewart
* _Tglehart dated July 18, 1941

216—Letter to Civil Aeronautics Board from
W. R. Gracc ‘and Co. dated July 21,
1941 . peas ;

217-_Memorandam of points to. \ he. hocaiveel

in connection with charter of equip--

ment by Henry J.. Friendly, dated
August 2 a ;

. 218—Letter to Harold J. Roig from J. T. r.

“ dated October 29. 1941... >
219—Letter to W. R. Grace and Company
_ + from Pan Am»rican Airways Corpora-

* \ + tion dated November 4, 1941
990-—Letter to Pan American Airways Cor-

poration from W. R. Grace & Co. dated

November 12. 1941.
221—Letter ‘to ‘Ran Ameri: ath Ajrways ftom
Pan American-Grare Airways, Ine.
dated December 16, 1941 7... 2.
222—Letter to the Postmaster General from

Pan American Airways, Inc. dated

January 97, 1942 | 5.
293-_Letter to-FEvan E. Young from Smith W.

Purdum. Second Assistant Postmaster’

- General dated Jannarv 28. 1942 -
994. Letter to Smith W. Purdum from: John
C. Cooper dated Mirch 12, 1942 ¥

’

Original

2890

2892

2894

9899

. 2902

2903

xxiii ,

Print

2960
2962
2965
2966
2970
2973

2974,

. /

Ixxiv INDEX ~ .

Record from the United States District Court for
the Southern District of New York—Conttinued |
Pan American: World Airways, Inc. Exhibite—

,*

‘Continued

. 225—Letter to John C. Cooper from Smith W.

Purdum dated June 11, 1942 -
\ 226—Petition of the Department of J ustiee for
leave to intervene in CAB docket No.
779, dated September 24, 1942

ae 227—Confidential summary of agreement and’

action taken regarding reimbursement:
for costs of De-Germanization services
in Brazil? Pan American internal
memorandum dated December. 21, 1942
228—Letter to Harold J. Roig from Howard B,
: Dean. dated February 4, 1944
229-Memorandum of conference by H. J. F.
dated May 16,1944 ss
230—Memorandum of conference by H. 4 F.
‘dated May 18, 1944 sige
231—M¢ morandum of luncheon oriecenes by
H. J. F. dated May 19, 1944 _
232—Memorandum of conference by Henty J.
Friendly dated July 12, 1944 .

- _233—Memorandum to Mr. Friendly by HL B.

D. dated July 19, 1944 . &
234—Letter to Harold J. Roig fre. Howard
: B. Dean dated February 21, 1946 .
235—Memorandum by H. B. Dean dated Feb-

ruary 21, 1946 Pobrteess
236—Letter to Messrs. Dean, (iNegible), “Mor-
ris and Friendly from H. J. FP. dated
March 13, 1946 . ae
- 237-—Letter to Harold J. 7 we iecen. foward
B. Dean dated April 8, 1946
238—Letter to Harold J. Roig from E. Bal-
luder dated April 15, 1946 .
239—Memorandum to Marshall ‘Skadden from
David E. Grant dated May 31, 1946

Original Print

2906

~ 2907

2979

2980

2984

2988

' 2989

2993

2998

3001

3006

3007

- 3009

3012

3015
3016

3018

INDEX

Record from the United States’ District Court for

- the Southern District of New York—Continued
Pan American World Airwars. Ine. Exhibits—
Continued
240—Petition of Pan American Airways, Inf.
before the Civil Aeronautics Bourd
dated August 1, 1946
241—Letter to. James M. Landis froin He nry
J. Friendly, counsel for Pan American
Airways Corporation and Pan Amer:
iean Airways, Ine.; Cahill. Gordon,
Zachry & Reindel, counsel for W. R.
- Grace and Co.; and Gerhard A. Gesell,
eounsel for Pan American-Grace Air-
ways, Inc.. dated August 19, 1946
242—Reply brief for Pan American-Grace Air-

ways, Ine. in CAB docket No. 2423,

dated November 25, 1946
-243—Reply brief for Pan American Airways,

Orizinal

* 2952

2956

2958

Inc. in CAB docket No. 2423. dated

November 25, 1946
- 244—Memorandum to Vice President Balluder
from W. L. Morrison dated February
27, 1947
245—Summary of distribution of Argentine
Company expense attached to memo-
randum to Vice President Balluder

from W. L. Morrison, dated February

ae, Beet ok.

246—Memorandum ‘to Vice President Mor-
rison from ‘H. Brock dated March 25,
1947 _ :

247-——Memorandum. to Thee. President ‘Lips
comb from J. F. Muhlfeld, dated Au-
gust 26, 1947 .

248—Adv ertising and sales policy for Ateen-
tina attached to memorandum to Vice

‘ President Lipscomb from J. E. Muhl-
feld, dated August 26, 1947 .

2965

2968

2977

2978

Ixxv

Print

>.

3032

3051
3057

3058

3059

Ixxvi : ca INDEX :

Record from the United States District Court for

. the Southern District of New York—Continued:

Pan American World Airways, Ine. Exkibits—
Continued

249—Memorandum to Pan American District

Sales Managers, Sales, United States,

from John E: Muhlfeld, dated Sep-

tember 26, 1947

250—Memorandum to Regional. Saies Man-

agers, United States, Central, Eastern,

Western from a - Muhlfeld, dated
October 9, 1947 . Be
251—Letter agreement between Pan’ Aiton

Airways, Inc. and Gonzalo Mejia ac-

cepted November 0; SPOT 29, 1942 . 3425 ~ 3512
372—Letter to South American General Office, a
Lima, Peru. from Grace & Ci ia.. (Chile)
S.A. dated September 24, 1942 3426 3514

Ae to Pan American-Grace Airways.

Ixxxvi : INDEX
; ; Original Print
‘Record from the United States District Court for ~
the Southern District of New York—Continued ~»°
Pan American World Airways, Inc. Exhibits—
Continued
373—Letter to Grace & Cia., (Chile); agents
_ for Panagra, from J. E. Muhlfeld, - - .
- dated December 15, 1942 . eas 3428 - 3517

- 374—Memorandum to O. G. Balz tron @
Vida] dated January 27,1943 _........ 3429 3518 ©
375—Letter to Harold J. Roig from Howard
; B. Dean dated February 21, 1946 _ s- 3433— 3522
376—Letter to Charles E. Beard from.W. L. *
Morrison dated September 2, 1946 _.... 3434. 3523
377—Letter to Andrew B. Shea from J. T. T. -

dated July 8, 1954 .. ee 3435 . 3525
378—Memorardum to files. re : eos “Angeles/ sa
West Coast through flight by John C:

Leslie dated July 21, 1954 -. ... 8436 3526
379—Letter to Andrew B. Shea from hae

J. Friendly dated July 23, 1954 +. 34388 3528
380—Memorandum to Douglas Campbell from carn

A. B.S. dated August 20, 1954. = .. 3439 3528
- 381—-Memorandum to J. C. Leslie from Doug- z
* . las Campbell deted August 20,1954... 3440 3529
382—Letter to A. B. Shea from Douglas Camp-

bell dated August 18, 1954 =. =——ssié‘

4650

4651

4696

4658

Print

4601 -
4602
4603

4605

P INDEX‘

,

: - @

Record from the United’ States District Court’ for
the Southern District of New York—-Continued
Pan American World Airways, Ine. Statistical

, Exhibits—Continued »
“ 124—Changes in income and expenses under
. alternative three carriér route patterns
. between the U. S. and South America,
Pan American (LAD), 1952 _
125—Changes in income and expenses under
alternative three carrier route patterns
between the U. S. and South America,
Pan American (LAD), 1957 -

126—Changes in income and expenses under

"6 alternative oe" carrier route patterns

between the U. S. and South America,
Panagra, 1952

127—Changes in income and expenses ander
alternative three carrier foute patterns
between the U. S. and South America,
Panagra, 1957 . ue

128—Increases and decreases in investment
requirements under alternative three
carrier route patterns between the F. S.
and South America, 1952 and 1957

129—Increases or (detreases) in rate of-re-_

turn requirements under alternative
three carrier route patterns between
the U. S. and South America, 1952
and 1957 -
130—Comparison of Ps. 114 licen 129 and
GX-1139 estimated financial results of
Panagra extension to Miami, 1957-.
131—Comparison of PS-114 through 129 and
GX-1139 with actual Panagra system
experience, 1957 °.........
W. R. Grace and Company Exhibits: ;
1—Announcement of Postmaster General,
dated March 2. 1929 ;
2—Foreign air mail contract, Routg No. 9,
dated March 4, 1929 -

—

il

Original

4659.

4661

4663

. 4665

4667

4668

~ 4669

4670
4671

4672

4675

xevil

Print

4606

4612

4614

4615
4616 .

4617
4618
4618

4621

xeVill - INDEX

Record from the United States District Court for —

the Southern District of New York—Continued
W.-R. Grace and Company Exhibits—Continued
3—Memorandum of conversation with von
Bauer, dated January 3, 1928 . ie
4—Letter to Iglehart from Patchin, “dated
March 13, 1928 .................... "eR ere ate
5——Memorandum. on aviation, dated March 22,
1928 _ = oe
6—Memorandum | on av ition j insurance, . dated
; March 22, 1928 .
+ Prgemorandun of conversation s heleeea en Rear
Admiral Cone, Patchin and Cogswell,
dated March 22, 1928 0.
.8—Letter to Patchin from Major Dargue,

dated April 20, 1928 . ele
-9—Letter to Patchin from “Major Dargue,
dated May 26, 1928 . ©.

10—Letter to Valverde from Nitrate Agencies
Ltd., dated April 12, 1928 200000...
T—Letter, to Cogswell from Trippe, dated
August 14, 1928 - Re Se Coe a
-12—Letter to. Eaternational. Perches. Co. Ltd.
from Grace-Lima, dated November 7,
13—Letter to Patchin from ‘Hambleton, dated
October 22, 1928 .
‘14—Cable from Metzner t to ‘Valverde, Patchin
and Cogswejl, dated November 14, 1928
15—Cable from Metzner to Valverde, Patchin
#2 and Cogswell, dated November 16, 1928
16—Cable from Grace-Santiago to Patchin and
Cogswell, dated December 19, 1928
17—Cable to Metzner from Patchin and Cogs-
well, dated December 24, 1928 .
18—Cable to Santiago from Iglehart, Valv erde
and Patchin, dated February 7, 1929
19—Cable to Santiago from Valverde and
j Patchin, dated February 8, 1929...
20—Cable from Santiago to Valverde and

* Patchin, dated February 27, 1929 _

Original rint *
4683 4627
4686 4629
4687 4630
4690™ 4633
4691 4633
“4695 4637
4697 4639
4698 4640
4699 4641
4700 4642
4702 «4644
4703 4645.
4704 4646
4705 4647
4706. 4648:
4707 4648
4710 4651
4711 4652 .

INDEX
‘
Record from, the United States District Court for

the Southern District of New York—Continued
W. R. Grace and Company Exhibits—Continued

" 21—Translation of cable from Santiago, dated
February 28. 1929 °
22—Cable from Metzner to Patchin, dated’
- reh.2, 1929 ~ P
_ 23—Cable from Patchin and Valverde to San-
tiago, dated March 12, 1929-- _
24—Letter to Patchin from Second Maidan
Postmaster General, dated May 6, 1929
25—Felegram to Second Assistant Postmaster .
General from Patchin, dated May ?
1929
26—Cable foemn Geece- Lima to Pate¢hin, dated
January 25. 1929
27—Cable from Patchin to Grace-Lima, Gage
January 26, 1929
28—Letter to Patchin ‘from White, dated
Match 16. 1929 .«
29—Letter to Patchin from om, dated’
. * March 20, 1929 .
30—Newspaper clippings on Junius B. Wood's
« -record air flight, dated October 18, 1929.
31—Letter to Directors, Pan American-Grace
Airways, Inc. from J. D. MacGregor, *
dated September 26, 1930
32--Letter to Patchin from Roig, dated Oc-
tobe 4. 1930
33—Cable to Graes-Lima from Cogswell, dated
July 26, 1929
34—Memorandum. dated July 80, 1929 .
35—Cable from Metzner to Roig and Cogswell.
dated July 10, 1929
36—Letter to Grace-New York from “Grace-
. La Paz, dated August L5, 1929

37—Cable from Grace-La Paz to Cogswell,
dated December 4, 1929

38—Telegram to Roig from Patchin, dated
December 6, 1929

Oriainal

xcix

Print

4653
4654
4655

4656

ce: Ss ae ‘INDEX

Record from the United States District Court for
the Southern District of New York—Continued
W. R. Grace and Company Exhibits—Continued

39—Letter from Patchin to Roig, dated Oc-
tober 15, 1930 - eee
40—Letter from Roig t to | Pichia, yor} Oe.
' tober 24, 1930

41—Letter to Iglehart from Roig, dated May

~ 6, 1935 ER RL a
107—Letter to Iglehart from “MacGregor,
dated July 10, 1933 _

108—Letter to Patchin from. ‘Iglehart, dated

May 21, 1936 TOS

109—Letter to Iglehart from Patchin, . dated —

I al hl ehsnatinaicnsnk
110—Letter to Iglehart from Patchin, dated
I a. RN cic cca nniannienncsinninn
111—Letter to Iglehart from Patchin, dated
RIE DES en Retna een
112—Letter to Shea from Roig, dated ——
Py 8 Rae ee

113—Letter to Iglehart from Roig, dated:

March ER SRR ace hina ne Reem
114—Letter to "ig from Garni, dated March
so a a eae ee tee
113—Letter to Hels vuin from Zatles, dated No-
vember 3, 1933 SalI Fano SS PRCA

116—Letter to Harper from Zalles, dated No--

ies ee...
117—Letter to Zalles; dated December 4, 1930

118—Letter to Thommen from Stimmann,

dated December 5, 1930
119—Letter to Stimmann, dated December 97,
1930 .. fi
120—Letter to Garni from’ “Roig, dated “April
SRR SESE aan oe ee RCO
121—Letter to — from Roig. dated — 31,

Print

INDEX

Record from the United States District Court. for .

the Southern District of New, York—Continued
W. R. Grace and Company Exhibits—Continued
122—Letter to Iglehart from. Garni, dated
March 9, 1938... -
123—Memorandum by Iglehart, dated Decem-
ber 30, 1937 .
124—Letter to Roig from idchart, dated Jan
_ uary 11, 1938 -
125—Letter to Roig from igichart, po Feb-
ruary 19. 1938 . a ne
126—Letter to Roig eas teichart dated
- March 2, 1938. -
127—Letter to Roig from Garni, dated ‘Apeit
22, 1938 .
. 128—Letter to Reig from Patchin, dated Sep:
tember 5, 1938 - a
129—Letter to Iglehart from a dated Oe.
tober 18, 1938 - '
130—Memorandum by Roig, dated ‘hawt ma
May 1941 _.............

131—Letter to Morris from Grace, ane’ July

23, 1941 © ,

132—Letter to Whitney tote Iglehart, dated
June 20, 1941 -

133—Letter to Pan American trem Grace
(sgd) by Garni, dated November 12,
1941 . :

134—Pleadings from CA. B. Docket 707, dated
December 16, 1941 - Skee

135—Request to the Civil Levondetic os Board’

from Grace by Iglehart, dated April
er ctrisoriasssliene :
-136—Statement of face in eanport of letter of
W. R. Grace & Co. to the Civil Aero-
nautics Board, dated April 27, 1942,

relating to Pan-American-Grace Air- ,

ways, Ine. in CAB Docket 744 .........
137—Letter to Jglehart from the Civil Aero-
| nauties Board.-datcd June 26, 1942 ....

CV
Original Print .
5012 4932
5014 4933
+5015 4934
5016 4935
5018 4936
5019 4937 |
5024 4940
5027 4943
5038 «°4951
5040 4954
5043 © 4957
:5045 4958
5050 4961
5066 ©4977
50694979
5084 4993

evi |

171—Testimony of Harold J. Roig in CAB
\ Docket 779 (excerpts)
172—Testimony of Arthur E. Sinclair in CAB
Docket 779 (excerpts)
-173—Testimony of Juan T. Trippe in CAB
i Eanes
174—Growth in Air Traffic between the v nited
States and South America (including
Canal Zone), fiseal years 1951, 1957
and 1958
175—Growth in Revenue Passenger Miles on
Pan American ‘Miami-Balboa Sector,
1945, 1952 and 1957 ..
176—Comparative “Density of Air- ‘Traffic
Flow”—}57 (Professor Cherington’s
Criterion PS-101) .

177—Increase in “Density of Air Traffic Flow”

(Professor Cherington’s Criterion PS-
101) 1945-1987 2.2...
178—Growth of Average Passenger Lead | per
Plane Mile Flown on Pan American’s
Miami-Balboa Sector (Mr. Ferguson's
Criterion—PS-9), 1945 and 1957 _ __.
179—Comparative Development of Air Pas-
senger Traffic Between the U. S. and
South America and Between the U. S.
and Other Major Geographic Areas of
the World—Based on’ Comparison of
. Export and Import’ Trade with the
United States ..
180—Comparative Operating Ratios ( Conipate
_ with PS-107) ~ as

5505
5506
5507

5508

5509

5510

(5514 -

; Original , Print
Record from the United States District Court for |.

5353

5354

5358

INDEX

s

Record from the United States District Court ‘for
_ the Southern District of New York—Continued
W. R. Grace and Company Exhibits—Continued
181—Comparative Rates of Return (Compare
“ @ with PS-108)
1§2— —Comparison of Local and Thro gh Traf-
fic Carritd ‘by Pan American over
* Miami-Balboa Sector—1957 |.
194—Table showing the compefitive services
available in April, 1959, from various
cities in South América to the United
States sae Keung
195—Table showing the competitive services
available in April, 1959, between va-
rious cities within South Agnerica ;
196—Comparison of fares charged by @mpet-
ing airlines in April, 1959 between the
United States and South America
ST I, a oct icine sacnidinhaciinienecceietptnn
Final, judgment o ‘
Letter dated April 20. 1961 from Assistant At-
’ torney General Lee Loevinger to Honorable
Thomas F. Murphy
Notice of motion and motion to suspend injune-
tion pending appeal

Affidavit in support of motion to suspe nd in- |

junction —~
Exhibit A to affidavit—Copy of final judg-
ment cnd letter dated April 20, 1961
from Assistant Attorney General Lee
Loevinger to Honorable Thomas F. Mur-
Sapna remy
Memorandum cn motion to ‘suspend judgment,
Murphy, J. ix
Stipulation of W. R. ‘Grace and Company

Notice of appeal by Pan American World Air- .

ways, Inc.
Notice of appeal by the v nited States .
Orders postponing jurisdiction

cix

Original Print
5515 5969
“316 5360.
5517 536)
5518 5362
5519 5363
5521 5365
5591 5435
5592 5436
5593 5437
5595 5438
5599 5441
5604 5443
5606 5444
5611 5446
5615 5447
5618 5449

al

id

* " . % bd . - 7
[fol. 1] . © [File endorsement omitted |

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK |
Civil Action No. WYd2259 »

- © Unsirey States or AMentca, Plaintetf,
“¥,
Pax AMERICAN Wortn Aimways, bai W. OR. Grace ann,
Coupaxy, and Pax AmeEnican-Grack Aimways, INxc.,
Defendants. °

Cd Sa ee

>
COMPLAIN T— Kiled January 11, 1954

The United States of America, by its attorne ys, acting
under the direction of the Jttornes v General of the United
States, brings this action against the defendants and com-
plains and alleges as fo lows;

;

Jurisdiction and Venue 7

¢

1. This complaint is filed and the jurisdiction of this’
Court is invoked ander Section 4 of the Act of Congress of
July 2, 1S90 (ce. G47, 26 Stat. 209 15 ULS.C24), as amended,
entitled “An Aet to Proteét Trade and Commerce Against
Unlawful Restraints and Monopolies,” ccenmonly, Known
as thé Shyrman Act, te obtain civil relief against said de-
fendants preemies of thei violations, as hereinafter alleged,
of Sections 1, 2, and 5 of s aid: Act.

2. > Each of the defendants transacts business and is‘found
within the Southern District of Newyork.

b Il . s , ’
Description of Detendants —*

3. Defendant Pan American World ‘Airways, Inc. is a
.¢orporation organized im 1927 under the laws of the State’

_2

of ‘New York as the Pan American Airways, Ine. Its

(fol. 2] corporate name was changed to the present one in >

1950. From 1928 until December, 149, this defendant was
‘a wholly owned subsidiary of a corporation, organized in
1928-under the,laws of the State of Delaware as the Avia-
tion Corporation gf the Americas, which name was changed
in 1931 to Pan American Airways Corporation. Pan Ameri-
ean Airways Corporation was a holding company having
various subsidiaries, including foreign corporations, © en-
gaged in. the transportation by. afir of persons, property,
and mail throughout the world. ‘Ly December, 149, Pan
American Airways, Inc. acquired all of the assets and as-
sumed all of the liabilities of Pan. American Airways Cor-
poration. Defendant Pan Amv rican World Airways, Ine.
directly operates routes in air transportation of persons,
property, and mail between the United: States and various
points in Europe, Asia, Africa, Australia, and South Amer-

ica. The term-*Pan' American” is hereinafter used in this,

complaint to refer to defendant Pan Ayierican World Aiv-
ways, Inc., and to Pan American Airways, Inc., Pan Ameti-
can’ Airways Corporation, and. Aviation Corporation of the

Americas as the meaning may require. Defendant Paw

_Ameriean has its principal offices at 135 East 42nd Street,
New York, New York.

4. Defendant W. R. Grace and Company, hereinafter

called Grace; is a corporation organized in 1899 under the
laws of the State of Connecticut. Defendant Grace is a
holding corporation having subsidiaries which engage in

‘numerous aspects of industry, trade and commerce, inchad-.-

ing steamship transportation between the United States
and Latip America. Defendant Grace owns all of the capital

stock of Grace Line, Inc., which opérates steamship lines:

for the transportation gf persons, property and mail be-
tween ports of the United States and the west coast of
South America. Defendant Grace hig, its principal office
at 7 Hanover Square, New York, New York. ¢

fol. 3) 5. Defendant Pan American-G tace irways, lee. ’
hereinafter ‘called Panagra, is a corporation organized in
1929 under the laws of the State of Delaware. * Defend’int
Panagra is engaged in air transportation of persons, prop-

‘\
-

eal

- ‘[ . ae 3
erty and mail over routes between the Canal Zone and
Buenos Aires, .¥fgentina, vias the constries on the west
coast of South: America, [tis whelly ow ned by defendants
Pan American and Grace, each of which owns 30 per eent
of the stock thereot. ‘The principal efies of detenilant
Panagra is located) at 18d East 4znd Street. New York.
New York. |

@ Hl
iy The Trade and Commerce Lnvelved

6. Prior te L2s virtii uly all trans ~pertition between the
United States andthe tations of Latin Amerion was weal
ducted by steams ship. Giraee Line. Tne. the whelly dawned
subsialiary of aletetidant Grace, was at that time and has
remained wntil the tiling of this complcing the @argest come,
pany engaged im steams hip transportation le tween the
United States and countries loeated on the weet coast of

South Amenca. firace Line. Ine. operates steame=hip routes

from “New York City south: erred along the Atlantie coast
of North Ainerica through the Caribbean Sea to ports. le-
seated on the nerth coust of aba Amerie a. ated through |

—the Panama Canal te ports located on the west coast of

South America, In 160 Grace Ling, bie. transported about
90 per contuof the pits neers tragelling by liner service over
the stemishipe trade rete be ‘tween E nite “lb States Atlantic
ports and the west coust of South Amerie PY ec
per cent of the total comynéereial carge carfied in all liner
serviewover said route. Ower this trade rente, Grace Line.
Inc. transports virtually all of the passengers and com
wercial carge carried in United States tlag ships. In addi.
tion to its dominant position through Grace Line, Ine.‘ in
transportation between the countries on the west coast of
South America and betweer those countries.and the United
| fol. 4) States, defendarit Grace oee pies an imipertant posi.
tion in Latin American trade through a banking -ubsidjary

‘and numerous other subsidiaries located principally in

South America. For nearly 100 vears defendant Grace and
its predecessors have been engaged in rumerous phases
of industry, trade sand comme rey in the countries loe: ited on
the west coast of South America.

e?

4 ; ?

7. In 1928 air transportation service over local awa’
limited trunk line routes was being furnished in a fiumber
of South American countries by carriers other than United

.

_ States flag amr carriers. Such service, was fragmentary

and did not, reach north of South America. The potentiali-
ties of air transportation between the United States and
Latin America had for some years attracted groups and
individuals interested in the developme nt of aviation. ly
1928 Pan American Airways Corporation (then called the
Aviation Corporation of the Americ: is) was formed to ef-

fectuate the acquisition of a number of aviation companies
for the purpose of acquiring, developing and operating air
-routes from the United Shites to the Caribbean, Central
America, the Canal Zone, and down the east coast of South
America to Rio de Janeiro and Buenos Aires; Pan Ameri-
ean rapidly acquired a dominant position in air transporta-
tion between the United States and Latin America by the
development of new routes and, by the acquisition of com-
peting trunk and local air Jine companies serving countries
on the east coast of South America? 4

’

8.. The extensive system of Latin American. air trans-
portation operated by defendant Pan American ¢¢ mprixes
over 60,000 route miles certificated by the Civil Aeronau-
tics Board. It extends from points in the United States to

Latin America, “nclading ‘the Caribbean Sea, Mexico, and

Central America to the Canal Zone, and by way of the north
and east coasts of Sonth America to Rio de Janeiro and.

* Bueyos Aires, linking the. United States with the principal |

| fol. 5]-.traffie centers in. Latin America. , Aside from its
o9 per cent ownership in Panagra, and its ow nership of:
stock in Aerovias Nacionales de’ ¢ ‘olombia, which operates
primarily in Colombia, Pan American does not engage in
air transportation between countries located on the west
coast of South America. :

9. In 1928 Pan. Ame ‘rican aequired an option on a.Peru-
vian air mail contract and conéession whieh had been se*
eured by an American transportation company operating in
Peru.- Operating rights in Peru were essential to the es-
tablishment of a’ west coast air route paralleling and com-
petitive with the established west coast steamship routes

e:

.

a ra oe 5

of Grace’s subsidiary, Grace Line, Ine. whose ste amships
at that time provided most ol, if ne: virtually “all, {he
transportation. connectiag the countries on the west coast

of South America with ench other -and with ‘the United

States, In 1929 Pan American and Grace, purgnant to
agreement hereinafter allege formed Panagra and: have
since participated eqnaliy in its control Panagra’s line
comprises over 10000 route nile ‘s certificated’ by the Cival
Aeronautics Board. Ht extends from its terminal at the
Canal Zone southward through’the principal trafic centers
of countries docated on the west coast of South Amerie:
cand across the Andes to Buenos Aires, Argentina.

10. Until about MH6, Pan Afne rie: en owas the only hy ee

States flag air carrier operating se sheduled service between.

the United States and the countries on the north and east
coasts of Souths Aimervica. For many vears it has dominated
and at the piresent time continues to dominate air trans-
portation between the | United States and South America.

About nine-tenths of all passengers travelling by U hited.

States flag air carriers between points inthe Mastern coastal
states of thee United States and countries:on the north and
east cousts of South America are car ried by Pan Aime rican.
Defendants Pan American aud. Pans era, connecting at the

Canal Zone, carry about four-fiftiis ol the passengers tray-

‘fol. 6) elling by United States fag air carriers between
points in the astern costal states of the United States

, and countries on the west coaust.of South Atmerien, Including:
passengers travelling over the west coast reute to, Buenos

Aires. Foreign flag carriers, during the twelve-month pe-
riod ending June 151, transported less than one-fourth of
the air passenger trafic between the United States and the

Canal Zone and between the Cuited, States and South

ao

‘ ywor te .

‘Pursuant to contracts, agrecnienas, and understand:
ings, hereinatter ale ged, Panagra does not serve any points
served by Pan American on. its cast coast route, except
that Pan American and Panagra have common terminals
at the Canal Zone aid at Buenos Aires. A substantial part
of the traffie of both Pan American and Panagra handled
at Buenos Aires is through traffic.to or, from he United

States. The distance from United States teefnals to

;

od

ra)

6 4 :

Buenos Aires is substantially less by way of Panagra's west
coast routeshan by way. of Pan American's cast coast route.
Prior, to the passage of the Civil Aeronautics Act in 19338,
Panagra never operated its Own air .transportation service
north of the Canal Zone, and since that time Panagra ‘has
never sought from the Civil Aeronautics Board authority
for the operation by it of such transportation service. Most
of the traffic which Panagra liandles .at the Canal Zone
originates in or is‘destined:to the United States. This tratlic
is‘dependent for through United States -serviee upon op-
erations furnished by Pan American between the United
States and the Canal Zone. :

12. Panagra’s route along the west coast of South Ame Te
ica serves many of the ports and the principal cities in the °

countries served by the steamship routes of Grace Line,
Ine., which link the Atlantic coast of the United States to
ports on the west coast-of South America. Both Panagra
[fol. 7]. and Grace Line, Inc. carry a substantial number of
intermediate passengers travelling within or between the
countries served by Panagras Defendant. Panagra and
Grace Line, Inc. are potentially competitive with each
other in the transportation of passengers, property and
mail. ,

13. The growth. of air transportation of persons, prop-
erty and mail in competition With water transportation to
‘Latin America has been extremely rapid. During the twelve
months ending June 30, 1951, air trans portation accounted
for about 70 per cent of the total Yea and air passenger
traffic between the United States and the Canal Zone and
between the United States and South America. In that year
air transpgrtation accounted for about one-half of the pas-
senger travel between the United States and the Canal
Zone, about 8d per cent between the United States and
Colombia, about. 75 per cent between the United States and

Venezuela, about 70 per cent between the United States ‘and |
- Brazil, about 70 per cent sie United States and -

Argentina, end about 70. per cent between the United States
and other countries of South America. The total ton miles

of express and freight carried by United States flag air -
. ¢arriers between the United States and South America

2

he

increased from approximately 1Q,800,000 ton miles in 1946
‘to approximately 29,000,000 ton miles in 1957,

14. During the year 1949, Pan American carried ap-
proximately 700,Q00 air. passengers over its Latin American
routes, Its total oper: ating revenue Tor that year from its
Latin American air: line operations amounted to about
$65,000,000, of which about S40.500,000 was revenue from
passengers, rbout $15,800,000 revenue from United States
and foreign air mail, and about S0,200,0004 rom -carge. and

‘other sources, During the same ‘period Panagra- carried -

about 90,000 passengers Cinehiding intermediate trafic be-
{ween and within tountries in South America as well
[fol S{ as passengers travelling to and from the United
States) and its total operating revenue amounted to About
#16,800,0000 of Which about SLOS00,060 was revenue from
passengerseabout $4.400000 was revenue from foreign and

United States air majloand about $1,600,000 from: cargo ™

and other sources. During the year 1950, Grace Line, Ine.
carried a total of abéut 4,000 passengers on its steamship
line operating on the through route between, the United
States Atlantic port~ and the west cofst of South America

- (exeluding intermediate South Smerican traffic). During

the same vear Grace Line, Ine. carriegh about 600,000 tons
of cargo over this route, yy,

ri aoe :
Offenses ( harged ’
‘esinaing’’ incor about DIYS a: e vontiduind ji to the
ae of the filing ef this complaint, the defendants lave

een parties to and’ have operated under contricts, and
have been engaged in-a combination and conspiracy to

-restrain the aforesaid trade and commerce in the trans-
portation of passengers, property and mail, and to monop-.

olize the aforesaid transportation, by air of passengers,

- property and mail, and during said period have attempted:

to” monopolize and have monopolized the aforesaid: trans-
portation by ayer of pend ei rs, property and mail, in viola-
tion of Section ~1, 2 and 3 of ot a of Congress of July 2,

“1890 (ce. G47. at Strat. 200, 1A ELS GC. 4). as ane nded, entitled

"An Act to DP reteet Tr: vic and i oOMMeErce Against U nlawful

8

Restraints and Monopolies,” commonly known as the Sher-
man Act. Defendants threaten to continue and will con-
tinue such offenses unless the relief hereinafter prayed
for is granted. The aforesaid contracts, combination, con-
spiracy, attempt to monopolize and monopolization, and
certain of the acts, agreements and understandings which \
formed a part thereof and were used in their effectuation,
are hereinafter more fully set forth and described.

[fol.9) 16. For the purpose of obtaining and maintaining *
domination and control by Grace and Pan American of air
transportation between the United States and countries
along the west coast‘of South America and to exclude the
establishment of an independent air line which would be
competitive: with the parallel steamship route of Grace
Line, Inc., or with Pan American, Pan American and Grace
in 1928 entered into an agreement for the establishment of
Panagra. Under the agreement defendant Panagra was
to establish and operate an air_line on the west coast of,
South Ameriea and was to be jointly owned and costrolled
in equal shares by Pan American and Grace.

17. Defendant Panagra was established thereafter in
January 1929 and 50 per cent of its stock was transferred
to Pan American and 950 per cent to Girace. Panagra- ac-
quired the Peruvian rights and concessions described i
Paragraph 9 above from Pan American pursuant to the
agreement described, in Paragraph 16 above, and in 1929
began opérations ax an ir carrier on the west coast of.
South America. In May, 1929 Patiagra commenced opera-
tions between the Canal Zone and Mollendo, Peru. In QOec-
tober, 1929 its operations were extended to Buenos Aires,
Argentina, and Panagra hax since that time operated an
air line from the Canal Zone, along the west coast of South
America, and across the. Andes:to Buenos Aires, Argentina.

18. As a part of the understanding between Pan Ameri-
ean and Grace in the formation of Panagra, it was agreed’
that the sphere of operations of Panagra would be confined
to the-West coast of South America and that Pan American
would operate air routes on the east coast of South Ameriea
and between, the United Siates and the Carial Zone. Pur-
suant to this’ unlawful agreement and understanding,

9

pb rncing has refrained from acquiring or applying for Op-
rating rights or concessions and from: gperating an air
line on the east coast of South America and Pan American
[fol 10] has refrained from. applying for operating rights
and from operating an air line along the West coast of.
South America. For its connections atthe Canal Zone and.
for the transportation of its traffic’ between the United
States and the Canal Zone, defendants niade and have kept
Panagra dependent on Pan Americ¢an. ,

19. The eeneral purpose to maintain Panagra under the
joint ownership and control of Pan American and Grace.
has been continuously adhered to. Defendants Pan Ameri
ceun and Grace have entered into. iercements and under-
standings for the management and ¢anduet of the affairs
of -Panagra. Pursuant to such agreements and understand-
Ings, the management and operation of Panagra have been
kept under the control of Pan American and Grace,

20. Pursuant to such agreements jand understandings
and by virtue of the ‘control exe reised Jey “defendants Pan
Ameriean and Grace, defendant Puntagr wt has been pre:
vented from establishing and ntaifitaining. research, pro-
curement, advertising, sales and commercial serviees in the
* United States independently of Pan American, and has been
prevented from establishing and maintaining facilities,
sales, and commercial representation in South Nmerica
independently of Grace, |

21. Pursuant to their unlawful agresments and: under-
standings, Pan American and Grace each has retained own-
ership of 56 per cent of the voting steck of Panagra, and
each has. retained an equal number of representatives on
Panagra’s Board of Dirtetors. Because of this control,
-anagra has been-and is required to adhere and has ad-
hered to the unlawfal agreements between Pan American
and Grace and to the unlawful purposes and objectives of
Pan American and Grace, or either of them. :

(fol. 11] 22. By virtue of their equal division of control,
Pan American and Grace each has had and now has the
power of preventing the exercise of. Panagra’s corporate
powers and functions and cach has exercised this power to

10

block and prevent any action by Panagra considered by
Grace or Pan-American to be contrary or detrimental to
its own particular interests. As a consequence, the develop-

.ment of Panagra’s routes and operations in South America

jand their extension to the United States have been blocked,

the acquisition of. flight equipment andthe development of

. ground facilities. by Panagra have been retarded and pre-

vented, and Panagra has been impeded and restrained from -

developing and expanding competitively, from rendering
“tmproved and competitive transportation service and from

otherwise independently .exercising lawful competitive
practices. | * we

23. Throughout the period covered. by this’ complaint,

Pan American, in accordance with its unlawful agreements

and understandings with Grace to form Panagra ‘and to
divide and allocate. the areas of air transportation, has

used its 90 per cent control over Panagra to block and

prevent Panagra from securing requisite authority from
the-Civil Aeronautics. Board fo extend its route from the
Canal Zone to the United States. Pan American has also
used -its 50 per cent control over Panagra to block and
vent Panagra from effectuating any agreement with

any air line other than Pan-American-or a designee of

Pan American to establish, extend, or improve through
air ‘transportation service between the United States and

- South America. Such restraining action has been persisted

in by Pan American despite repeated’ expressions by the
Civil Aeronautics Board that it would be in the interest |
of the proper deve lopment of air transportation — “d-fen-

~.dant Panagra to be freed from such restraints. Sv long

as Pan American and Grace retain the power to “eontro}
{fol. 12] action by Panagra through their respective 50 per
cent. stock ownership, Panagra’s development and opera-
tions’ will be substantiaHy and unreasonably restrained...

24. During the period covered by this complaint, ‘de-

-fendants Pan American and Panagra, in furtherance of the
‘unlawful purposes hereinbefore alleged, have acquired the

stock or’ assets of, or othér interests in, competing. lines
operating in Latin American countries. Pan American and

Panagra (controlled by Pan American and Grace) have
used: the dominant position and power attajned by the

ry
| °
| : . . ‘

: ‘

a

defendauts in air transportation to impede and restrain the
establishment and development of competition in air trans-
portation between the United States and Latin America
by United States flag air lines.authorized in and after 1946
bythe Civil Aeronautics Board to develop and engage in
such transportation. Pan American and Panagra have
engaged in restrictive practices to restrain and impede
such air lines from utilizing established airports, terminals,

communications and other facilities in’ Latin Ame rican,
countries necessary to the inauguration and development of

such air transportation,

7 a
Effects of the Violations

” i

25. The aforesaid acts, combination, conspiracy, con.
tracts, agreements, understandings, and’ concert of ‘action
hereinabove alleged have had, as intended by the di-fen-
dants, the following effects among others :

(a) Defendants unlawfully acquired the power to mo-
nopolize and restrain air transportation between the United
States and Latin Amprica;

{fol. 18) > (b) competition in air transportation | between
the United States and‘Latin America has been restrained,
suppressed and prevented ; |

(¢) competition in transportation by air with transporta-
tion by water between the United States and Latin America
has been restrained, suppressed and prevented ;

(d) defendants have ar bitrarily divided and allocated

— between and among themselves air transportation: between
-. the United States and South America:

(e) trade and commerce with foreign nations has been
dominated, controlled and monopolized.

7

Prayer

Wherefore the Plaintiff Prays:
—1.¢That the Court aajudge and decree that the defen-
dants hate contracted.-combined and conspied in restraint

12

of the trade and commerce hereinabove described, have
combined and conspired to monopolize, have attempted to
monopolize and have monopolized that trade and commerce,
.in violation of Sections 1, 2 and 3 of the Sherman Act.

2. That the Court adjudge and decree that the stock.
holdings in und control of defendant Panagra by defen-
dants Pan American and Grace have operated so as to
restrain and to monopolize trade and commerce, as here-
inabove described, in violation of Sections 1, 2 and 3 of
the Sherman Act.

3. That the Court order and direct defendants lan
American and Grace to divest themselves of all stoekhold-
ings and other interests in defendant Panagra, held di-
rectly or through subsidiarie.. under terms and conditions
| fol. 14] which will accomplish effective divorcement and
complete elimination of~control of the operation and man-

agement of defendant Panagra from defendants Pan
American and Grace.

4. That the defendants, and each of them, be perpetually
enjoined from combining and conspiring to restrain or
monopolize, or from monopolizing or attegapting to monop-
olize the trade and commerce hereinbefore alleged, and
from engaging in any practice, relation hip, contract. .gree-
ment or course of conduct having the purpose or effect of
continuing or renewing any of the violations hereinbefore
alleged. ,

3. That the plaintiff hints such other and further relief
as the nature of the Case may require and the Court may
deew just and propes.

6. That plaintiff recover the costs of this suit.

Herbert Brownell, Jr., Attorney General, Stanley -N.
Barnes, Assistaat Attorney General, James E.
_ Kilday, Special Assistant to the Attorney General,
Frank F. Vesper, Special Assistant to the Attorney
General, J. Edward Lumhard, United States At-
- torney, John Guandolo, Trial Attorney.

. ro 5 i
conducted by steamship; that Grace Line, Inc. in 1928 and
thereafter was and continues to be onerof the largest com-
panies engaged in steamship transportation between the
United States and the west coast of South America; that
Grace Line, Inc. operates a steamship route, among others,
from New York City southward along the Atlantic Coast
of North America through the Caribbean Sea to ports
located on the north coast of South Ameried and through
the Panama Canal to ports located on the west coast of
South America; that in 1950 Grace Line, Inc. transported
approximately 90% of the passengers traveling by liner
service between the United States Atlantic ports and thd
west coast of South America: and approximately 605° of
the total commercial cargo in liner serviee -between said
points and transporis substantially all of the passengers
and commercial cargo-in United States. flag ships between
these points that Grace occupies an important position in
_Latin Ameriéan trade through its various subsidiaries some
‘of which are located: in South America; that for many
years Grae» has been engaged in various phases of indus-
try, trade and commerce in countries located on the west
coast of South America; except as hereinabove admitted,
[| fol. 17] denies each and every allegation of Paragraph “6”
of the complaint.

7. Admits upon information and belief the aflegations
contained in Paragraph “7” of the complaint. °

8. Admits upon information and belief the allegations
contained in Paragraph “8” of the complaint; exeept de-
nies knowledge or information suflicient to form a belief
as to the truth of the allegation that the extensive system
of Latin American air transportation operated by Pan

American comprises over 60,000 route miles ce rtifieated by

the Civil Aeronautics Board (the term “Pan-American”

is used in this answer. to refer to Pan Az:nerican World .

Airways, Ine., Pan American Airways, Inc., Pan American
Airways Corporation and Aviation Corporation. of the
Americas as the meaning may require).

9, Avers that the Peruvian Governme mt by Supreme
Resolution on May 28, 1928 granted Huff-Daland Dusters,

j

15

“Tne., a corporation organized under the laws of the State 6f-
Louisiana, permission to engage in transportation by air of
mail, cargo and passengers between Peru and the United
States; that thereafter Huff-Daland Dusters, Ine. pursuant
to permission granted by the Peruvian Government jn
November, 1928, transferred the rights granted to it under
said Supreme Resolution to Peruvian Airways Carporation,
an American corporation owned by Grace and Pan Ameri-
ean each holding 50% of its outstanding capital stock; _
_ that Grace and Pan American each owned a one-half inter-
est in Peruvian Airways Corporation; that Grace and Pan
American organized Pan American-Grace Airways, Ince.
(hereinafter “Pawagrit™) in Janidary, 1929 under the laws
of the State of Delaware: that Grace ond Pan American
. each subseribed to 50¢¢ of Panagra’s stock which they have
held to date and each had and continues to have equal rep-
resentation on the Board of Directors of Panagra:-that
Panagra succeeded to all the rights assigned to Peruviar
Airways Corporation by Huff-Daland Dusters, Ine.: that
{fol. 18] Panagra’s unduplicated weighted average route
mileage certified by the Civil Aeronauties Board ‘is upproxi-
mately 6,000 miles and extends from its terminal at the
Canal Zone southward through the principal traffie centers
of countries located 6n the west coast of South America and
across the Andes to Buenos Aires, Argentina; that said
routes were duly certificated .in 1940) by the Civil Aero-
naufies Board issuing a certificate of public convenience and
necessity under the werdnd! father” clause of the Civil AXero-
nautices Act of 1938 (49 EO S.C. See. 401(e)); that under a
Through Flight Agreement with Pan American dated July”
31, 1946,approved by the Civil Aeranauties Board on May
5, 1947 (Order Serial No, E-570) dnd again on May 4, 1950 -
"(Order Serial No. K-41: 30) P anagra’s.aircraft operate over
Pan American's route between the Canal Zone and Miami
to provide direct. one- plane . service between Buenos Aires
and Miami: except as hereinabove admitted, denies . each
and every allegation contained in Paragraph “O" of the |

complaint.

10. Kaaiits apon “information and belies the allegations
contained in Paragraph "10" of the complaint.
4 , e

16 ‘ :
a sane : 7"

11. Avers that. -anagra’s certificated routes do not du-
plicate those of Pan American in any part exce pt that both
have common terminals at the Canal Zone and at Buenos
Aires; Ufat a part of the trafic of bath Panagra and Pan
American handled at Buenos. Aires is through traflie to
or fron: the United States; that the distagee from United
State® terminals ‘to Buenos Aires is less by way. of
Panagra’s west coast route than by way of Pan American's
cast Coast route. as: presently operated that. most of the
-traffi¢ which Panagra hand|A.at the Canal Zone originates
in or is destined to nit& States; that prior to 1958
P anagra did not engage in air ansportation north of the
Canal Zone; that: anagra has n@t filed an application with
the Civil Aeronautics Board for authority to operate -air
transportétion north ‘of the. Canal Zone; that under the
Through Flight Agreement re tTerred tocin Paragraph °°"
[fol. 19] hereof and with the a wal of the Civil Aero-
nauties Board, Panagra’s aire —. over Pan Ameri-
can’s route between the Canal Zone and Miami to provide
direct -one-plane service between Buenos Aires and Miami:
except asshereinabove admitted, denies each and every allé-—
gation contained in Paragraph “11” of the complaint. :

°* 12. Denies each and every allegation contained in Para-.
graph'"12” of the complaint exce pt admits that Panagra
serves some of the ports and prine ipal cities served by
Grace Line, Inc. and that both Panagra And Grace Line, -
Ine. carry intermediate passengers traveling within’ or
between some of the countries served by Panagra. :

13. Admits upen information and belief. ihe allegations
pester est aragraph “13” of the complaint except de-
nies each and every allegation contained in the first and
last sentence of said paragraph “.

14. Admits upon information and belief the allegations
99 ~

contained in Paragraph “14” of the complaint except de-
nies upon information and belief that Panagra’s total op-
erating revenue for the year 1949 amounted to $16,800,000
and that of this amount $4,400,000 was revenue from foreign
and United States air mail and avers that such revenues
amounted to: $15,035,000 and $2,645,000, respectively.

17

_ 19. Denies each and every allegation-eontained in Para-
graph “15” of the complaint. |

16. Denies each and every allegation tontained in Para-
graph “16” of the complaint except admits.that Grace and
Pan American in 1928 agreed to establish a pioneer United
States flag carrier which was to be owned in equal shares
by Grace and Pan American. =

a 3 fc @)
17. Averg that Panagra was duly organized under the

z laws of the State of Delaware. in January, 1929 by Grace
° (fol. 30J|-and Pan American each of which purchased ‘and
hat at all times sinee then owned 50¢c of Panagra’s. out-
"standing capital stock; that Panagra acquired all the rights
assigned to Peruvian Airways Corporation by Huffgaland
Dusters, Inc, as alleged in Paragraph "9" of thik answer;
that Panagra was awarded a mail contract by the Post-
master General of the United States, with the approval of
the Attorney General, for the transportation of mail be-
tween.the Canal Zone and Santiago, Chile with. the option
in the Postmaster General to require extension of the ser-
»vice to Buenos ‘Aires, Argentina and Montevideo, Uruguay ;
that in May, 1929 Panagra commenced. operations under
the said contract between the Canal Zone and Mollendo,
“Peru; that in October, 1929, its operations were extended to
Buenos Aires, Argentina and sine Hat time Panagra’ has
transported persons, property. and mail over its entire
‘route between the Canal Zone and Buenos Airts, Argentina;
2." except as hereinabove admitted, denies each and every
““* allegation contained,in Paragraph "17" of the Complaint. -

-

18. Denies each and every allegation contained in Para-
graph “18” of the complaint.

19. Admits that Grace and. Pan American at all times:
since the incorporation of Panagra have-each owned 50%
of its stock and elected an‘equal number of its directors ;
that Grace'and Pan American and Panagra have entered.
into agreements with respeet to the management and opera-
tion of Panagra; except as hereinabove admitted, ‘denies
each’ and every allegation conta ntd- in Paragraph -“19"
of. the complaint. 3 IBS,

a all

18 a." . 5

20. Avets that te rtain of the adve rtising, sales and cem-
mercial services of Panagra are handled? by Grace and
Pan American; ‘except as icavinaliova admitted, denies
vach and every allegation contained in Paragraph "20"

of the complaint. om .

{ fol. 21), 21. Dems each and every allegation contained
in Paragraph “21" of the complaint. ;

22. Denies each and every allegation contained in Para,
graph “22” of the complaint. . .

a ha

23. Denies eacheand every ‘allegation contained in Para-
gifaph “23” of the complaint except admits that Pan Amerie
can has opposed the extension of Panagras route to the
1 nited States; that in 1951 Pan American opposed approval
by ‘the Citil Aeronautics Board of an interqhange of equip-
meat agreemen

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386410_0138%3A01. Public record. Not legal advice.
