# Transcript of Record — Continental ore Company et al v. Union Carbibe and Carbon Corp.

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386410_0122%3A08

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Transcript of Record
- **Published:** January 1, 1961
- **Citation:** 370 U.S. 690

## Text

EXHIBIT VOLUME—VIII
TRANSCRIPT OF RECORD

Supreme Court of the United States

OCTOBER TERM, 1961

No. 304

CONTINENTAL ORE COMPANY, ET AL.,
PETITIONERS,

v8.

UNION CARBIDE AND CARBON
CORPORATION, ET AL.

ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT

PETITION FOR CERTIORARI FILED AUGUST 11, 1961
CERTIORARI GRANTED OCTOBER 23, 1961

SUPREME COURT. OF THE UNITED STATES

CONTINENTAL ORE COMPANY, ET AL,

OCTOBER TERM, 1961
No. 304

PETITIONERS,

vs.

UNION CARBIDE ANT) CARBON

CORPORATION, ET AL.

ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

Plaintiffs’

; Exhibit No.

1.

10.

FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT

INDEX

Answers to interrogatories showing
production of vanadium oxidesby de-
fendants, 1933 to 1947

Answers to interrogatories showing
production of ferrovanadium, 1932
to 1947, by defendants

Answers to interrogatories showing
sales of vanadium oxide and ferrova-
nadium by defendants. 1933 to 1944
Union Carbide price sheets of vana
dium products, 1953 to 1944

Price sheets of vanadium products
distributed by Vanadium Corporation
of America, 1933 to 1945

Contracts dated November 18, 193s
and June 30, 1939 between Electromet
Sales and Vanadium Corporation of
America for the sale of vanadium ox-
ide to V.C.A.

riginal

46

Print

1]

49

Recorp Press, Printers, New York, N. Y., JANUARY

29, 1962

DD

Plaintiffs’
Exhibit No.:

14.

16.

17.

18.

19.

21.

33.

INDEX

Purchases of vanadium ore concen-
trates and vanadium source materials
made by the Vanadium Corporation of
America, 1933 to 1944
Vanadium-bearing materials pur-
chased by Union Carbide subsidiaries
from others, excluding vanadium-
bearing ore, 1933 to 1945

List of purchasers of vanadium prod-
ucts sold by subsidiaries of Union
Carbide, 1933 to 1944 ;

List of purchasers of vanadium prod
ucts sold by Vanadium Corporation
of America, 1933 to 1944

Chart showing production of vana-
dium oxide from 1927 to 1945, entitled
“Compilation of United States Vana-
dium Corporation, Total Production,
United States Imports and Compari-
son of Same With Electro-Met. Sales”
Schedule showing total number of re-
quirement contracts of each of the de-
fendants with purchasers of vanadium
products __ So eee ee
Answers to interrogatories setting
forth the vanadium-bearing ores
mined by each of the defendants and
purchased by each, 1933 to 1947
Answers to interrogatories setting
forth the quantity of vanadium oxide
and vanadium-bearing ore, and in the
ease of V.C.A. of ferrovanadium as

“well, which the defendants purchased

from the Metals Reserve Company,
1943 and 1944 oD Pe hr

Letter dated 9/14 ‘38 from Van Fleet.
Vice President of U.S.V., to B. Bur-
RE tian a el

Original Print

45

50

13]

132

135

139

14]

134

135

138

142

144

Plaintiffs’
Exhibit No.:

34.

36

40.

41.

43.

57.

59A.

62.

63.

76.

INDEX

Letter dated 9 19 38 fromm Van Fleet
to Gormely, Swain and Sneath

Letter dated 12 24 41-from W. G
Haldane, Assistant to Blair Burwell,
to J. E. Weston, Burwell, and Cole-
man of USV.

Telegram dated 2 24 44 from B. Bur-
well to W. G. Haldene

Letter from Continental Ore Company
to Vanadium Corporation of America,
Mr. G. Laub, dated 11 16 43

Letter of G. Laub dated 11 19 43.
Vanadium Corporation of America, to
Continental Ore

Letter of Continental Ore Company
to Electro Metallurgical Sales Corpo-
ration dated 11/17 43, together with
reply of Electro Metallurgical Sales
Corporation dated 11 30 43

Minutes of Vanadium Corporation of
America in 1939

Document entitled “Vanadium Rear-
ing Raw Material” 1935-1939

A portion of press release of A.E.C.
dated 12 17 48 |

Report of Gustav Laub to Bransome.
President of V.C.A. dated 3 14 42:
reports of Gustav Laub dated 2 20 42
and 4/14 42: and letter dated 4 22/42
from R. Sterling to F. F. Kett — ”
Letters dated 3.11 40 and 4/8 40
from Lippa of Apex Smelting to
V.C.A., and reply of G. Laub of
V.C.A. to Apex dated 4 20 40
Telegram dated 1] 13 44 from Nisley
& Wilson to Continental Ore

Letter dated 1/31/44 from Frank
Nisley to Continental Ore

iil

Original Print

145

147

14s

14°

150

146

162

163

iv

Plaintiffs’
Exhibit No.:

77.

78.

111.

113.
114.
116.
127.
128.
a.

142.

INDEX

Letters from Leir to Roser dated
6/14/41, from Leir to Gormely dated
6/16/41, and from Gormely to Leir
Oe Tae

V.C.A. inter-office memevenduss dated
2/14/47, P. J. Gibbons to J. B. Gird-
ler; letter dated 2/24/47, Girdler to
Continental Ore Company; letter
dated 3/7/47, Continental Ore Com-
pany, by J. A. Mirel, to Vanadium
Corporation of America; letter dated
3/13/47, Girdler to Continental Ore
I nitacestscceccanactcaudincenonamadeewes
Letter senectnah ‘betwen Climax
Molybdenum Company of Pennsyl-
vania and Continental Ore Company
dated February 10, 1943 aa
Letter dated 11/10/43 from E. F.
Hatch of War Production Board to
W. G. Haldane of U.S.V.
Letter dated 12/5/44 from Brown,
General Manager of [mperial Paper
& Color Corporation to Continental
Ore Company . rar REN eta Ne
Memorandum of Martin Wolf, Conti-
nental Ore Company, dated 2/19/43
Letter dated 1/13/42 from Continen-
tal Ore Corporation to Apex Smelting
Company

Telegram from Continental te Apa
dated 10/17 ‘40 and letter from Apex
to Continental of the same date
Exchange of letters between Vitro
Manufacturing Co. and Continental
Ore Corporation in August 1942 ___
Letter dated 5/25/38 from Apex
Smelting Company to Robert E.
HII: -sibdanitipeiarhitosotittedbeldatuncinnnatitcabiobanisas

Original Print
172 176
175 178
179 182
180 184
181 185
182 187
183 188
184 189
186 191
188 193

Plaintiffs’
Exhibit No.:

145.

163.

164.

165.

166.

171

INDEX

Defense Plant Corporation letter to
Mr. Lippa, Apex Smelting Co., dated
12/20/41 __..... ;

Letter dated 9/17/43, J. W. Hill to
Page grants

Memo dated ‘ 24 fering Page Kduards
to J. W. Hill -
Agreement listininne: Mesa Vaneiion
Company and United States Vana-
dium Corporation, dated May 7, 1940
Letter dated 10/13/43 from Remmers
to J. D. Swain - ;

Letter dated Nov onlier 19, 1941 from
Milenski to Apex Smelting Company
Letter from Blanding Mines to Apex
Smelting dated 2/23/42 - Z
Telegram, Jaoul Electrochimie to Ve-
nadium Corporation of America,
dated 10/4/39 ,

Cablegram, 11/8/39, from Vanadium
Corpcration of America to Trochim,
I odeaterdenciser na eeseeuene
Letter, V.CA. to Societe d’Electro
Chimie, dated 11/9/39 __................
Cablegram, 12/14/39, Vanadium Cor-
peration of America to Trochim
Letter, 3/28/40, Bransome to Painvin
Letter, Bransome to Viles, V.C.A.
dated 5/23/43 ..........--.------.-

Original

189

190

192

193

199

201

202

203

Vv

Print

194

195

207

208

vl

Plaintiffs’
Exhibit No.
for
Identification
only

20.

25.

47.

48.

49.

50.

INDEX

Union Carbide’s Answers to Inter-
rogatory No. 33 showing net sales,
total costs of net sales and profits
before federal taxes pertaining to
vanadium and uranium together with
Vanadium Corporation of America’s
answer setting forth yearly total costs
of all vanadium and uranium prod-
ucts and their respective compounds
and sales value, years 1933 to 1947 _..
Memorandum of Sale of vanadium ox-
ide by Electromet Sales to Vana-
dium Corporation of America, dated
9/15/33 together with correspondence
pertaining to said memorandum of
sale; Memorandum of Sale of oxide
by Electromet Sales to Vanadium
Corporation of America, dated 1/3/36
Report on Vanadium dated June
1935 by C. E. MacQuigg of Union
Carbide Research Laboratories (ex-
I chore tiyaaneociw as
Series of letters between personnel
of Union Carbide or its subsidiaries
dated from July 29, 1935 to December
3, 1935, entitled “Vanadium Situa-
tion” or “Vanadium Report” —..
Inter-office communications from Van
Fleet to F. P. Gormely of Electro-
met dating from 3/9/36 to 11/3/37
and letter from Van Fleet to Burwell
GG AIR po he
Memoranda of V.C.A. Ore Confer-
ence Meeting held in New York dated
13/6/36 and 2/9/37

Original

211

213

224

281

304

314

Print

217

219

230

286

316

326

Plaintiffs’
Exhibit No.

for

Identification

only

51.

53.

60.

61.

INDEX

Report by Mr. Van Fleet to F. P.
Gormely, F. H. Haggerson, W. H.
Sneath, J. M. Price, dated March 25,
1936 . wae
Inter-office reports ef V.C.A. and let-
ters between Electromet Sales or
U.S.V® and V.C.A. dated in 1934,
1935, and 1936. Sales agreements be-
tween Electromet Sales and V.C.A.
of 9/15/33 and 1/3/36

Inter-office memorandum from Blair
=p to J. R. Van Fleet dated
ee i cvccecseece aceenae

Mets of the Meeting a ‘ae ‘Es
ecutive Committee of Vanadium Cor-
poration of America, dated April 4,
1935 z ee J Cacia ee
Memorandum be Dias Burwell en-
titled American Uranium Resources
dated July 8, 1949 prepared for Sen-
Stor Meee oe... a
Memorandum by Blair Burwell en-
titled Memorandum on Vanadium and
the Operations of the United States
Vanadium Corporation dated Janu-
ary 4, 1956 aes

Proposed contract exec mated by Ww. E.
Remmers, Executive Vice President,
United States Vanadium Corporation
for Blair Burwell, dated February 2,
1948 together with correspondence re-
garding same .

67A to67F. Series of inter-office ‘Guten: Seinen

personnel of United States Vanadium
and, or Electromet dated in 1934 —_.

Original

318

337

341

343

302

367

Vii

Print

33]

336

351

398

360

371

Vili

Plaintiffs’
Exhibit No.

for

Identification

only

80.

81.
82.

83.
84.
85.
86.
87.
88.
89.
90.
91,
92.
93.
94.
95.
96.
97.

98.

INDEX

Letter 1/19/43, Leir to G. B. Walker,
Electromet —_......
Letter 1/29/43, Leir t ‘Arrouet
Letter 2/10/43, Bravin, Llectromet
of Canada, to Continental Ore ~
Letter 2/11/43, Continental Ore to
BOON vcccen
Letter 2/17/43, ‘Beavis in to » Continental
I Dneekinctenconrs si nutcagethasceniadsaicntaentantiecs
Wire 2/18/43, Continental Ore to
OER IETS AT RR ei LER IESE ERE RNY
Letter 2/23/43, Bravin to Continen-
f. . Seana
Wire 3/1/48, Continental ‘Ore to
|, acer
Letter 3/3/43, Continenial ‘On ‘to
Electromet of Canada
Letter 3/10/43, from Continental ra
Electromet of Canada -
Wire 3/19/43, Continental Ore ‘to
7 Pas Nath ee ROR IEA OR
Wire 3/20/43, Bravin to Continental
sce
Letter 4/26/43, “Wolf. . Office” ‘of
Metals Controller, Canada _..
Letter 4/29/43, Dawson, Office of
Metals Controller to Continental Ore
Letter 5/4/43, Wolf to Electromet of
INI dicgactscchenlesanesicecconcbbinadeeiannen.
Letter §/17/43, Wolf to Electromet of
Canada —......
Letter 5/20/43, Wolf t to » Bioctoemet of
CI vecscctithccines
Letter 6/1/43, Blectromet a Canada
: Continental Ore -
Wire 6/1/43, Continental Ore to Elle.
tromet of Canada

Original

409
410

Print

438
439

441

455

456

Plaintiffs’
Exhibit Noe.

for

Identification

only

99.

100.

103.

105.

106.

107.

108.

109.
121.

123.

124.

125.

126.

133.

INDEX

Letter 6 29,43, Continental Ore to
Electromet of Canada

Letter 7,5.43, Bravin to Continental
Ore eel

Letter 7/30 43, Leir to Electromet of
Canada ih

Letter 8/2/43, Bravin to Continental
Ore i sath ECP CIR Rl, Bie

Letter 9/23 43, Continental Ore to
Electromet of Canada

Letter 10, 4.43, Bravin to Continental
OE as PP EAE Wee Ia ;

Letter 10 5,43, Leir to Electromet of
Canada =

Letter 10 27,43, Leir to Electromet
of Canada

Letter 10/30/43, Bravin to Continen-
tal Ore . :

Letter 2 2 44, Leir to Electromet of
Canada -

Memoranda of M. Wolf dated 6 11°43
Balance Sheets and Profit and Loss
Statements of Continental Ore Cor-
poration and Continental Ore Coni-
pany

Tabulation of Net Worth of Coenti-
nental Ore Conipany, 1939-1949
Tabulation of Net Worth of the Con-
tinental Ore Group, 1950-1957
Tabulation of Fluorspar sales by Con-
tinental Ore Company 1939 to 1957
Tabulation estimating sales of vana-
dium products based on sales of fluor-
spar, 1939 te 1949

Computation entitled “Tlnstration of
Gross Profit on Sale of Van Ex”

Original

428

429

430

431

432

433

434

435

436

437
438

439

DOG

507

209

v1

512

Print

457

458

459

460

461

462

463

464

465

466
467

469

af

x

Plaintiffs’
Exhibit No.
for
Identification
only

139.

140.

141.

INDEX

Computation entitled ‘Continental
Ore Group Ferro-vanadium—Calcu-
lation of Profits Lost on Assumption
That Continental Would Have Had
the Same Percentage of the Market
RN ea
Caleulation of Lost Profits Based on
MR: SIND 5 pieces ceca.
Calculation of Lost Profits Based on
Various Percentages of the Market -

Original

514

Print

INDEX

Defendant Union Carbide’s Exhibits:

No. U-V_ (excerpts)—Contract No. W-7405 eng-
201, dated September 1, 1943, between U.S.A.
and United States Vanadium Corporation

No. U-W (excerpts)—Contract No. W-7405 eng-
250, dated June 26, 1944, between U.S.A. and
United States Vanadium Corporation

No. U-X (excerpts )—Contract No. W-7405 eng-
32, dated January 25, 1943, between U.S.A. and
United States Vanadium Corporation

No. U-3-G—Letter, dated January 26, 1944, from
Continental Ore Company to Imperial Paper
and Color Corporation

No. U-3-J—Interchange of letters, dated Decem-
ber 1, 29, and 31, 1947, between Imperial Pa-
per and Color Corporation and Continental
Ore Company re

No. U-3-K—Letter, dated April 9, 1945, from
Imperial Paper and Color Cerporation to Con-
tinental Ore Company

No. U-3-M—Letter, dated January 29, 1944, from
Continental Ore Company to Imperial Paper
and Color Corporation

No. U-3-N—Letter, dated Deccuber 4, 1944, from
Continental Ore Company to Imperial Paper
& Color Corp. .......

No. U-3-R—Letter, deta May 11. 1943, from
William A. Baehr Organization, ine. to Conti-
nental Ore Company Se

No. U-3-T—Memorandum, dated December &,
1943, from Morris Welf to North Continent
eo pocanacectecon vans an

ma 4-C—Letter, “dated March 5, 1943, from
— Reserve Company to Continental Ore
COURS | oe :

No. U ee ey ‘dated April 9, 1943, from
Continental Ore Company to Electro Metallur-
gical Co. a
No. U-4-E—Letter, dised dort ‘4, 1943, from
Continental Ore Company to Electro Metallur-
ues nee CED. os ee

Origitial

o24

526

530

031

932

533

534

Print

d47

dot

561

562

o64

d65

566

567

569

xii INDEX

Defendant Union Carbide’s Exhibits—Continued

No. U-4-F—Memorandum, dated April 29, 1943,
from Morris Wolf te Metals Reserve _
No. U-4-G—Invoice No. 24892, dated April 30,
1943, from Electro Metallurgical Sales Cor-
poration to Continental Ore Corp. ~
No. U-4-I—Letter, dated May 11, 1943, from
Continental Ore Company to Electro Metallur-

gical Sales Corp. ......

No. U-4-J—Letter, dated May 18, 1943, ‘from
Electro Metallurgical Sales Corporation to
Continental Ore Company

No. U-4-K—Letters, dated May 19, 1943, from
Continental Ore Company to Electro Metallur-
gical Sales Corp. . DOR

No. U-4-L--Letter, dated May 20 20, 1943, from
Electro Metallurgical Sales Corporation to
Continental Ore Company

No. U-4-M—Letter, dated May 21, 1943, frem
Continental Ore Company to Electro Metallur-
gical Sales Corp. .

No. U-4-N—Letter, dated May 25, 1943, from
Electro Metallurgical Sales Corporation to
Continental Ore Company

No. U-4-O—Letter, dated May 26, 1943, from Con-
tinental Ore Company to Electro Metallurgi-
eal Corp.

No. U 4.P—Letter, dated May 27, 1943, from
Contixental Ore Company to Electro Metallur-
gical Sales Corp.

No. U-4-Q—Letter, dated June 1, 1943, from
Electro Metallurgical Sales Corporation to
Continental Ore Company

No. U-5-G—Memorandum from Electro Metal-
lurgical Company to Continental Ore Cem-
pany re Order No. 7460 ee ssa 24,

Original

539

541

551

552

593

Print

571

576

581

583

584

INDEX Xill

Defendant Union Carbide’s Exhibits—Continued
Original Print
No. U-5-I—Letters, dated November 20, 1943,
February 18, 1944, and June 2, 1944, from
Continental Ore Company to North Continent
eae Nye ae ARE d54 556
U-5-L—Intere henge of letters, dated July
or and 28, 1939, between R. Poliakoff and
Electro Metallurgical Sales Corp., and letter,
' dated August 28, 1939, from Continental Ore
forporation to R. Poliakoff. 55
No. U-5-N—Continental Ore Corporation's In-
voices. Nos. S704, dated September 16, 1940;
S715, dated September 30, 1940; S749, dated
October 4, 1940; S761, dated October 29, 1940;
credit memorandum, dated October 30, 1940;
S774, dated October 29, 1940; credit memoran-
dum, dated October 30, 1940; S814, dated No-
vember 19, 1940; Ss27, dated December 6,
1940; S834, dated December 19. 1940; and
$1004, dated July 19, 1941, to various corpo-
NE nipetinreteniacahhenceesen aindia 560 591

qy
st
wD

Defendant Vanadium Corporation of America’s
Exhibits:
No. V-1-Z—-Wire, dated February 13, 1942, from
LL to Continental Ore Corp. 571 602
No. V-2-A—Letter, dated February 16, 1942,
from Continental Ore Corporation to Apex
Smelting Company 572 603
No. V-2-F—Interchange of letters, dated April 7
and 8, and September 30, 1942, between Con-
tinental Ore Corporation and Apex Smelting
Cn ee ents 576 608

” ed Arter, AM Hn tm ———E7/~”"

[fol. 1]
In Unitep States District Court

PLaintirFs’ Exuisit No. 1

vA + ‘ g ‘ ‘ *y,
Wiliaiat feo sli wl felt
gb

UNITED STATES VAMA IY CORPO LUTION

PNG 2 6SE 8 i oS! o ye ot 4 ORE te
FOR Til, Pi tho) ou HY 1, 1223 70 DECEMBER_31, 1947

ie et ee Be Sie RE POU eo?

ager ere Foe

Urpavan iifle iupsn_o Totn
33,546 - 33,44
1,218,063 - 1,214,@3
1,875,¢€9 - 1,975,C4H
2,008,993 - 2,008,552
2,175,873 . 2,174,028
2,37¢,701 - 2,37b, 702
2,178,433 1,035,073 30272, 532
1,734,230 1,32L,tct 3,023,0H
722,293 1,357,007 170,175 7 4247,857
- 1,544,259 35%,052 1,741,152
~ 1,221,933 p aaeres OR ree
- 2,e%,0%2 2,pen,cr1

ifol. lal

Sf

wMuNDDdH OrNAd
TwaannNtodnaann?e
z.

re

| fol. 3}

>
JRISRRUATORY NO. Ble)
AIUION CARDIPE PD CARBON CORPURETION Mul SUD "IDIARIES ConconIDs ED

SPACLILNT SMOWLIG GUANTIVY OF VANALIG:: CXINE AND Aru. JT Ui
HLTAVAADACS SOLD Lent Me PLATOD g*hurs hy 2, 1933 vo AND
PPR AGD Cb FED UR pipers 2h: 4

VARADIUM CXIDS AobIL PUCAVANADATS
(Lb. Contained V2.0.) Yer (cb. of Petertel)
£17,333-67 1933 2,591
766,735.30 1534 1,09
573,054.40 1y35 ou
377,068.51 12:36 1,402
83,397.75 1457 «,431
1,255,ccc-1l 523 EY)
1,13),10).70 153) 120
743,675.55 1940 233
363,534.74 1941 TH |
341,236.00. Ss 4 l/r
247,745.34 1443 © $1.90 per lb.
Less than 1,000 Whceneeoeeetee"” Ze 4 ® bal

Delivered f.o.b. cars works or warehouses of the Seller with

railroad freight charges allowed to destination.

VANADIUM PENTOXIDE
FUSED AND RED CAKE

———

In Any Quantity gaeaennseseeste** $1.10 per pound
contained ¥205

Delivered f.oeb. cars works or warehouses of the Seller with

ao

rai) road freight charges allowed to destination,

27
[fol. 24]
Ix Unitrep Srates District Court
J PLaintives’ [xniBit No. 5
{Handwritten notation—V CA }
1933 FERRO ALLOY PRICES 12-20-32 Sheet 5
FERRO VANADIUM
CONTRACT
AND Grade “A” Open Hearth $2.60
SPOT
Grade “B” Crucible 2.70
Grade “C” Primos 2.80

Per pound of contained Varadium, F.O.B. ears Bridgeville,
Penna. with Freight allowed and prepaid to points east of
the Mississippi and north ot Baltimore. (SPOT :— freight
allowed only-on quantities of 00> and over)

VANADIUM PENTONIDE (TECHNICAL)
Ton lots and contract ........--------------+ $1.05
Less ton lots, SPOt .....----------2-e---e-eerte7* 1.15

Per pound of V205 contained, F.0.B. Bridgeville, Penna.
with freight allowed and prepaid to points east of the Mis-
sissippi River and north of Baltimore (Spot:— freight
allowed on quantities of 0|0+ and up)

AMMONIUM META VANADATE (TECHNICAL)
Spot and contract .....--.------------- $1.90

- Per pound net, F.O.B. Bridgeville, Penna. with freight al-

lowed and prepaid to points east of the Mississippi River

and north of Baltimore. (Spot :— freight allowed on quanti-

ties of over 50+)

TERMS :— NET CASH THIRTY DAYS — NEW YORK
, EXCHANGE
S

25
[fol. 25]
PAGE FIVE 2/18/33
FERRO VANADIUM
[ Handwritten notation—1934 |
CONTRACT & SPOT PRICES

Grade “A” Open Heart’ — $2.70 per lb contained Vanadium

Grade “B” Crucible 2p ss 4“ ‘6
Grade “C” Primos ao 6S oe ed ‘

F.0.B. cars Bridgeville, Penna. with freight allowed
and prepaid to points east of the Mississippi River
and north of Baltimore. (Freight allowed only on
quantities of 504% and over.)

VANADIUM PENTOXIDE (TECHNICAL)

Contract, any quantity
and 500# or more, spot ......................00.00. $1.10
Rp ce OG a ee 1.20

Per pound of contained V205 F OB Bridgeville,
Penna. with freight allowed and prepaid to points
east of the Mississippi River and north of Balti-
more. (Freight allowed only on quantities of 50%
and over.)

AMMONIUM METAL VANADATE (TECHNICAL)
PE OE COUT, (Scie iisceincone $2.00

Per pound net F.O.B. Bridgeville, Penna. with
freight allowed and prepaid to points east of the
Mississippi River a 1 north of Baltimore. (Freight
allowed on quantities of over 50%.)

LOW CARBON FERRO TITANIUM
Contract and spot ............ $1.40 per lb. contained Ti

E.O.B. Suspension Bridge, ©. ¥. or Bridgeville, Pa.
TERMS :— NET CASH 30 DAYS — NEW YORK FUNDS

99

| fol. 26]

Page Five January 22, 1935

FERRO VANADIUM FERRO VANADIUM

{Handwritten notation—1935 |
CONTRACT AND SPOT PRICES

Grade “A” Open Hearth $2.70 per Ib contained Vanadium
Grade “B” Crucible 2.80 per Ib contaimed Vanadium
Grade “C” Primos 2.90 per lb contained Vanadium

F.O.B. ears Bridgeville. Penna., with efreight allowed and
prepaid to points east of the Mississippi River and north of
Baltimore.

(Freight allowed only on quantities of 50 Ibs and over)

VANADIUM PENTOXIDE (TECHNICAL) VANADIUM PENTOXIDE
Contract, any quantity
rt A coccinea ugetsdemns teenie $1.10
es cc 1.20

Per pound of contained V205

F.0.B. Bridgeville, Penna., with freight allowed and prepaid
to points east of the Mississippi Rr and north of Baltimore.
(Freight allgwed only on quantities of 50% and over)

AMMONIUM META VANADATE (TECHNICAL) AMMONIUM VANADATE

I a TT ge nas cia aesncnuninnas £2.00

Per pound net

F.O.B. Bridgeville, Penna., with freight allowed and prepaid
to points east of the Mississippi Rr and north of Baltimore.
(Freight allowed on quantities of 502 and over)

LOW CARBON FERRO TITANIUM LOW CARBON FERRO TITANIUM

Contract and Spot ........................ $1.40 per lb. contained Ti
F.O.B. Bridgeville, Pennsylvania

TERMS: NET CASH THIRTY DAYS—NEW YORK FUNDS UNLESS OTHERWISE

SPECIFIED

30

[fol. 27] Page 5
12/11/35
{Handwritten notation—1936}

FERRO VANADIUM FERRO VANADIUM
CONTRACT & SPOT PRICES

Grade “A” Open Hearth ... $2.70 per pound of contained Vanadium

Grade “B” Crucible ........... 2.80 “ = “ - 2g

Grade “C” Primos ................ a0. * = “y 2 o

F.0.B. Cars Bridgeville, Penna. with freight allowed and
prepaid to points east of the Mississippi River and north of
Baltimore.

(Freight allowed only on quantity of 50% and over)

VANADIUM PENTOXIDE, TECHNICAL VANADIUM PENTOXIDE, TECH.
Contract, any quantity,
I I Aa tecnamtancicannnntacctenonkansenys $1.10
OR a cevoceicuaniscoeetanomenie 1.20

Per pound of contained V205

F.0.B. Bridgeville, Penna. with freight allowed and prepaid
to points east of the Mississippi River and north of Baltimore.
(Freight allowed only on quantities of 50% and over)

AMMONIUM META VANADATE (TECHNICAL) AMMONIUM VANADATE
Oe IE i os achondeneoalsaisaeed $2.00
1,000% or over pine sditder Sere ae nek SIC NOE 1:90
Contract minimum over period of one year

fee ee RCRD Titan AMR De Es ki ROT STARA Sapte RET OO ne Ce ON Se 1.90

All per pound net, F.O.B. Bridgeville, Penna. with freight
allowed and prepaid to points east of the Mississippi River
and north of Baltimore.

(Freight allowed on quantities of 50% and over)

TERMS: (NET CASH THIRTY DAYS— NEW YORK FUNDS UNLESS OTHERWISE
SPECIFIED—ON ALL PRODUCTS LISTED IN THIS PRICE LIST).

31

[fol. 28}
December 10, 1936

VANADIUM PENTOXIDE, TECHNICAL

Air Dried
and
Fused

Contract, any quantity, and
0004 or more, spot . $1.10 per pound of contained V205

Spot, 1 to 9# lots _.. 1.25 per pound net
“ 10 to 499% ...... 1.15 per pound contained V205

F.0.B. Bridgeville, Penna. with freight allowed and pre-
paid to points east of the Mississippi River and north of
Baltimore.

(freight allowed only on quantities of 50% and over)

Terms :—net cash 30 days

32

[fol. 29}
December 10, 1936

FERRO VANADIUM
CONTRACT AND SPOT PRICES

Grade “A” Open Hearth .... $2.70 per pound of contained Vanadium
«. Sr Cee 2.80 per pound of contained Vanadium
eR Ie ciccseasentens 2.90 per pound of contained Vanadium

F.0.B. cars Bridgeville, Penna. with freight allowed and prepaid to

points east of the Mississippi River and north of Baltimore.
Freight allowed only on quantities of 50% and over.

Terms: Net cash 30 days.

w
x

| fol. 30)

—
‘
J
i 93+
vice Lirt
4 etiwe i142 3
Le 32 7 A” 1
i ‘ 5
Gpeée 7." Ones “errt! 3* /40 i leu. sO .e¢.
Gre e *7* SCmcidle st /at 5. . io -
urade “Pi¢.evfile, Ir. igpet — eB ewO ti yh.

«wet at cr ~ 4@ ene ellow’, o- SOv ©24 over exc-ot to coin’
ret. oj) emeess of tre st. imis, ao. rete.
rexiioow fri ht ellnence beaed or rete to st. ionic, +o. 30

Terms: «t crs” thirt: tevs

> fe i
1339

JO

{ fol. 31]

1938
Price List
Sf-ective 1/1/38
VACADI'S PSVTONIM, TEC LIC
e¢ oF fused form
°
gontrect Frice
Amy cweatity ........ weeedas «+ $1.10 cer vound of contained Vp0«
Spot Prices

SOOP and ower .6.........-cee0e ol® ner -9und comtrined Vp0s

10 to 4994 COcsece @reeseseses . 1.20 Der noun‘ cort: ired Ve0n 2

OF cad UMEOT cece e ee eeeeceees + 29°F -er round net Vaos — Pa10

gek fica — -33
Yedss %4 203 48

@ise3 — «af
Se — .a¢
— — S89

7.0.5. Our Yorks, Sridrevilic, Pr. een shhe — =”

Preieht -=-neié ené allowed, or SCs and ower, exce>t fe ama

tekine « rate in excess of the 3t. Louis, .o. rate. 009

Lexie freirht rllorrace besed o- rete to 3st. Louis, io. _ — -@aA

Terme: Xet crsa tiirty éevs

Sind 30 mad 6 * Sex has

daw head Mmid- a tin thy werk by, Reraty
been acae

—
35
[fol. 32]
1939
Price List
Effective 1/1/36
FERRO VANADIUM
%V % Si %C
Grade “A” Open Hearth ...... 35/40 12 max. 3.50 max.
Grade “B” Crucible .............. 35/45 3.50 max. .30 max.
Grade “C” Primoc ................ 35/45 1.25 max. .20 max.
* CONTRACT PRICES SPOT PRICES
Grade “A” Open Hearth ............ $2.70 $2.80
Grade “B” Crucible .................... 2.80 2.90
ot “OC Pee * 2.90 3.00

All per pound of contained Vanadium

F.O.B. our works, Bridgeville, Pennsylvania.

Freight prepaid and allowed, except to points taking a
rate in excess of the St. Louis, Missouri rate, on fifty
pounds and over. Maximum freight allowance based on
rate to St. Louis, Missouri.

Terms: Net cash thirty days.

36
[fol. 33]
1939
Price List
Effective 1/1/39
VANADIUM PENTOXIDE, TECHNICAL
Air Dried or Fused Form
CONTRACT PRICE
Any quantity .............. $1.10 per pound of contained V,O,
; SPOT PRICE
500 pounds and over .. $1.15 per pound of contained V,O,
10 to 499 pounds ........ 1.20 per pound of contained V,O,

9 pounds and under .. 1.25 per pound net

F.O.B. our works, Bridgeville, Pennsylvania.

Freight prepaid and allowed on quantities of fifty pounds
and over except to points taking a rate in excess of the
St. Louis, Missouri rate. Maximum freight allowance based
on rate to St. Louis, Missouri.

Terms: Net cash thirty days.

37
| fol. 34]
1s40
Price List
Brfective 1/1/42
TEEBO VakDI
lemme, _ crushed or ground as fine as 2 mesh = down

Grade "B* Crucible 35/45 3.50 maz. 50 aux
Grade *C* Primos 35/45 1.25 anx .20 mz
QOWFTRACT PRICES SPOT PRICES
Grade “4° Open Hearth $2.70 $2.80
Grade *B* Crucible 2.80 2.90
Grade “C* Prisocs 2.90 3.00

Prices per pown’ of contuine’ Vanudiue

¥.0.3. curs Bridgeville, Penntylvania. Freight
allowed on quan*ities of twenty-five pounds and
over provided that the freight rate does not

the rate to St. Louis, Missouri. In
euch case the anziaus freight allewance vill
be based on the freight rete to St. Louis

Pet cash thirty days 34

38

| fol. 35}

1940
Price List
Effective 1/1/40
VANADIUM PESTOKIDE TECHNICAL

Air Dried or Fused Fora
CONTRACT PRICE

Any quanthty ccc. cece ee cee eeeeseeeG$l.1O per pound contained ¥205

OO pounds and OPFOR... ..ccccceecess cet. 15 per pound contained V205
10 to 4% pouride ....60.0...ecceeeee0 1,20 POF pound contained V205
Ynder 10 pounds ......ccccccsecsescce 12d POF nowund net ?

STANDARD S12KS:
Air Dried - Powder

Pied -»Crushed approx, 3/4" x down, however will furnish
material at no extra crushing charge for siges down
to and including 1/4 x down, Cruehing extras for
mmller sites 28 follows:

@ ves x down 20 vesh x dow

Tor Lets £0,015 per 1b ctdé V205 *O,C17S per lb ctd V2C5

Less Ton Lois
20C pounds and up 0.02 per 1d ctd W205 0.03 fer 1b etd Ve205
Tier 200 powds 0,03 per 1b ctd WCS 0.04. per 1b ctd W205

For siges mealler than 2C mesh x dow: refer to ‘ew York -ffice,

¥.0.3, care Bridgeville, Pen-aylwania, Freight alloved on quantities
of twenty-five pounds and over orovided that the freight rate does
not exceed the rate to St, Louis, Missouri, Is such case the maximm
freight *llorance will be based o- the freight rate to St. Louls,
Miegsour!,

Terts: Yet ced trirty days.
Page 14
1940

Grade
Grade
Grade

@rade
Grade
Grade

Wr:

| fol. 36]
VAA>IUM aATION OF RISA
Price List
“ffective
Janu.r, lst, 194)
FZRRO VARA. le
Lamp, crushed or ground as fine as 20 mesh x down
v $i c

"A" Open Hearth ou I> max, aa max.

*B* Crucible 5/45 3.50 max, .50 max,

"Cc" Prinos 35/45 1.25 max. 270 max,

QOBTRACT PRICES SPOT Parces

*"a*® Open Hearth $2.70 $2.80

*B" Crucible 2.60 2.90

*C* Primos 2.90 3,00

Prices per pound of contained Vanadium

7.0.3. cars Bridgeville, Pennsylvania, Freight
allowed on quantities of twenty-five pounds ani over
provided that the freight rate does not exceed the
rate to §t, Louis, i:issouri, In such case the
maximum freight allowance will be based on the
freight rate to St, Louis, Missouri,

Terms; Wet cash thirty days

The above prices shall be in effect until March 3f, T941 and
thereafter for each calendar quarter-yesr unless revised in

writing by Seller at least fifteen days prior to such quarter-
year,

Page 13

36

40

{ fol. 37 |
VAMADIM QORPOBATION OF AMERICA
Price List
Effective
Jamary ist, 1941
Air Dried or Fused Fors
QOMTAACT PRICE
aay Gmatity « M.0 per pound ~omtatned VE05

35
220
>)

eeececssecceeese Be
4006606666662 68° 3
1

i

o.@ por abe etd.
0.0% per lb. etd.

amt =|

Under 200 pounds

Per sises amliler than 20 mes: x deum refer to Sew York Office.

Bet cash thirty days

Terme;

[ fol. 42)

SY » a Le a
@rade “A” Qen Hearth +*/ 12 -_ 3 °C wax
Qvede "FP" crucib:e 35/45 3 °C ao. max
@rade “C" Pris + 35/45 2° gen. . oz

CORMmACT PRICES SYOT PRICES
Grade “A Open Hear’ $27 62“
Grade "BR Cru trie 2% 2m
G@rede “C’ Pria + 2% 300

Prices per pound! of - n*:ined Vanadiu:

5.0.8. .ere Britgev' \e, Fernaylvanie freigh 4 wec
quantities - co Loupe fig:
Gage priev to cush quarter: -5 cr

(fol. 44)

Price List
ew en ey) ateniee
demeary 1, 1%‘
CR ae
lame. Grushet or groust oo fine 2c 2 ech 4 som

ar an ac
Qveae °4° Gpen learth 35/0 12 am. 3.50 max
Qrede °B* Crucible 35/45 3.50 max. 2 nx
Grade “C* Prinses 35/45 1.25 oax. 2 aux
CUBR acT 21) ot ocd balce

@ve@e *2° Gpen Bearth $27 6 2.0

@rete °# Grusibie 2.0 29”

Grate “C° Priase 2.9 9.@

Prices per pound of comaimd Vaiad' us

P.O.B. a Ponmaglvania§ fFreigtt cellos on
bog pat y $-doy provided thet the
gate dean ast exceed We retc« te %. Louis, Kissceri.
Im ouch case, the aumia freigh ellowa.ce will tw based on
the freight rete te BR. Levis, Uisouri.
ose

eal] be in effect until Marci 31. 1%K5
aaa for each calender qusrter-year, unless re
Choo’ in eritiag Seller at leust fifteen days pricr to

[ fol. 45 |

~-------- - 621.10 per pound contained 125

any quantity -

aip Dried - Pori-r

&
i

i: i
i
ity 8
sik o
=. sf
LaF
Ht
Hy
}

¥Ds

per lb. etd.
0.0h per lb. etd. V5

0.03

0.02 per lb. etd. Vs

200 ibe. and «=p

1

0.03 per lb. etd. BOs

Under ZO lbs.

’

for cises ecaller than 2 aesh x dom refer io new York Office.

)

Met cash thirty days.

forus:

{ fol. 46)
Ix Usrrep States District Court

PLAINTIFFS’ Exuistt No. 10

AN r
UNITED STATIS Comm, Couar

NJ
i
*
Gt

uh Ps!

VANADIUM CORPORATION OF AMERICA
PURCHASING PEPARTMENT

420 LEXINGTON Avr. New Yoru, N.Y.

?. 4 8. 1. corr

Kheewre Metallnrgics) Selec Corperetion Rovemer 18, 19 36,
_ Mew Vert City wee wo

PUEEEES UO TED SOLAoUwe Batemans SUBJECT TO ALL CONDITIONS PRINTED ON REVERSE BE OF
2 Ee Wt TRIPLICATE AND BILL OF LADENOG cuowwe ssere

Material - “Electvemst® Brand Venedtem Pentezide (VgG_) oe previous.
Quantity ) ye, 00/7. T*

eee

Gu @a...
eae - ae, i a A free sas ai

bunts @ehPG Chr de WH. a leo WON

Cenfimming errengenents
ana Mr. P. J. Gidbvens.

[ fol. 48]
In Unrrep States District Court
Piarstirrs’ Exuisrt No. 14
BN UlUTED S.ATE uv Y...- « COvaT
ixen_2 — Purcneses
Tear Commodity Prise
1933 Venecium Ore Concentrates $ .60 per Le. 1205 Delivered
1934 Flue Dust a ° ¢ * Shipping Point
1935 Vaenediue Ore Concentre’es _ 7 * " Delivered
1936 o .* 7 9] 7 * . .
* Pentoxide —- = r as Plus Buergency
Freight Charge
i707 . 7 m8) . . o 7 o .
lve *. J 1.10 . *. * .
. . m9) 7 7. . 7.
1939 e e ae e e Lees Freight
7 4 . . . .
1940 . . 75 . . . *
Vanadium bearing Petroleum Reasigue —_ e as lees Freight
Catalytic Mass Waste Material 7 ” . es . °
damoni-m Meta VYanedate ia. *- ” a
1941 Flue Dust wore ° Mew York
femonium Mete Vanadate — = = ad Delivered
Vanadium Bearing Petroleum itesidue oo = ° Mew York
Sodium Vanadate a. s e Delivered
Flue Dust - » ed e New
4 “ 665° ° ° ad " Plus 1/2 analysis
cost
Vanadium bearing Petroleum Residue os > > - - 2
. 7 Sleg 260 . - ; . . J
Calcium Vanadate 6.50 per lo, Delivered Hew York
Venacius Bearing Flue Dust «65 * * W205 Mew York Plus 1/2 analysis
cost
1942 Flue Dust ag ¢ @ * ew York
Sodium Vanadate a * ¢ * Delivered Less Frei->
Vanadium Oxide ae e val
° Bearing Residue > ili " Wew York :
Flue Dust. (2,000 Lbs.) 10.00 for let Delivered Buffalo
*" © Trial Let fie Mew York
Vanecium bearing Petroleum Residue 255 per Lb. ¥205 Delivered Sew York
. . " FOB Perv Ocean Freight
Gas Dried Hed Cake am © @ * Delivered
Vanadium Slag a * * * Shipping Point Plus
Prepaid
Vanadic Acid am ¢ 8 " Delivered
Purnace Bottoms i * ¢ e ad

51

52

[ fol. 49]

Year Commods ty
1942

(Cont'd) Pused Vanadium Oxide

1943

19 lade

Venediva Concentrates

Pentoxide
Vanadium Petroleum Residue
Sodium Vanadate

Vanadium Pentoxide
Flue Dust

w -

” J

Vanadium Bearing Slag
Vanadium Bearing Slag
Flue Dust
* o
Sodium Vanadate
Flue Dust
n *
Vanadium Ashes
Flue Dust
Vanadium Residue

Flue Dust
Residue Vanadium Pentoxide

Price

$ 1.00 per Lb. V205 Delivered Plus 1/2 Analysis
Cost

8 8

8

1,00 ® *

so" *
“st

FH)
1.90 per Lb.
mT Ee 05 Men Sieh Pave 1/8 Seatgate

or *
* ®

New York —_ 1/2 analysis
st
Delivered Plus 1/2 Analysis
Cost
Bayonne, N. Je
New York Plus 1/2.jnalysis
J * ae °

Delivered

Bayonne, N. J.
Less Freight

val

Int

v 7
3/ mF Ge! aa {ty ff o

[ fol. 50)

Ix Usirep States District Court

WIELD STATS Laces Covad
, ~

oh! t 24

47
STATEMENT OF PURCHASES

(EXCLUDING VANAD
VANADIC ACID AND FERROVANADIUM

-
‘ i
st. te

DUST,

PiarxtiFrs’ Exxnrert No. 15

Date oi Price Any
Article Purchase Seller Quantity Paid Allowances
Electro Metallurgical Co.
Niagara Falis, W.Y.
ammonium Metavanadate 9/25/33 Vanadium Corp. of America 300 Lbs. $1.4500 Lb.

" " 10/12/33 " Ty) " " 200 " 1.4500 "
Ferrovanadi um 7/6/44 Vanadium Corp. of America 60000.54 Lbs.V 2.90 "V -«
Vanadium Oxide 6/10/41 Vitro Mfg. Co. 31390 Lbs.Vo05 1.025 "V205 -
; . 7 11/4/42 . =. \3 ye — " ” -«

" " 12/30/41 " " 16979. 44 " " 1.075 " " .

" " 2/10/42 " " " 9846.16 “ " 1.075 " =

7 " hehe . sane 10416.47 " " 1.075 " .

" ” 4 /2 2 " " " 1365.73 " " 1.075 " a

‘ : 4/2/k2 ‘ - 3 6591.88 " " 1.075 ° -

53

«i

Date
Paid

7/31/*0

8/26/s0
8/12/s0
7/12/61
7/11/21

7/15 /ee

UNITED STATES VANADIUM CORPORATION, PLANT VP
URAVAN, COLORADO
VANADIUM-BEARING MATERIALS PURCHASED (EXCLUDING VANADIUM ORE)

January, 1936, to July, 1945

Purchase Date Pounds
Vendor Order Received v205 Value
J. B. Claybaugh & Ben H. Simpson PC#7963 4/3/40 234.53 25
J. B. Claybaugh & Ben H. Simpson PC#7963 4/40 1,079.87 917.8y
Mesa Mines PCHE063 5/40 680.17 576.14
Brown & Bowman PC#8608 7/40 ¥, 186.50 8,267.85
Brown & Bowman PC#8772 8/15/40 1,460.00 ( 250.00
PC#8857 ( - 105.00
Gateway Alloys, Inc. PC#8716 6/12/40 1,042.01 88a .88
Nisley & Wilson PC#3106 7/41 k , 336.20 3,642.41
Nisley & Wilson PC#3108 109.00 91.56
North Continent Mines, Inc. PC#7936 10/42 9, 383.517 5,160.93
(11/3/42)
North Continent Mines, Inc. PC#8951 3/83 4,250.6 2,337.83
(3/18/43)
Nisley & Wilson PC#9152 4/1/43 to * 235.99
(Hauling on above tailings) (4/22/43) 4/14/43 2,461.03
BH. I. Gardner PCHO55¢ b/43 * 305 .Be
(Hauling on above tailings) (6/26/43) 720.09
Nisley & Wilson PC#11401 = 33/2/es 2,164.48 1,082.2%
Anaconda Copper Mining Company 10927 5/1 36,583.20 25,608 .2h
Anaconda Copper Mining Company 11277 6/u1 36,984.19 25 , BEE .93
Anaconda Copper Mining Company 11986 8/41 46,100.20 33,670.14
Anaconda Copper Mining Company 290 10/1 40,205.10 25,143.57
Anaconda Copper Mining Company 900 1/2 50,397.60 35,278.32
Total Anaconda Delivered to Uravan 212,270.29 148,580.20
E. o. Simms PCHTSYE 5/40 1,226.25 502.76
Louis Ackerman PCsé915 146.73 58.69
North Continent Mines PC#T255 7/8/42 &

6/e&5 /e2 14, 345.40 7, 889.97
* Vanadium Ore Mill Tailings (No V205 Content Available)

PC - Petty Cash Check Number

Ore Tailings
“Red Cake
Red Cake
Fused Oxide

(Furnace Brick 14205
(Fused Oxide 4Oy

Red Cake
Red Cake
Red Care

Fusion Furnace Residue
& 210 Red Cake

Fusion Furnece Residue

Gateway Tailings.

No V205 content shown.
Paid for as 235.488
dry tons - $1.00 per
ton.

Gat way Ter.ings.

No V205 content shown.
Paid for as 365.875
dry tons € $1.00 per
ton.

Fusion Furnace Residue
Car lio. NP9743 Red Cake

Car No. NP30424
Red Cake

Red Cake
Red Cake

Red Cake

This appears to be
vanadium-bearing brick
reclaimed from old
Rifle Mill and paid
as purchased ore.

Loma Fusion Fur. Brick

Fusion Furnace Residue

Si

LI¢ 193]

$¢

Vondo=

Phillip Bros.,Inc.
Phillip Bros. ,Inc.
Phillip 3ros.,iInc.
Phillip 3ros.,Inc.
Phillip Bros. ,Inc.
Phillip Bros.,Inc.
Phillip 2os.,Inc.
Phillip 3ros.,Inc.
Phillip 3ros.,Inc.
Phillip 3ros.,Inc.
Phillip Bros.,inc.
Phillip 3ros.,inc.

Philiip Bros. ,Inc.

Total Flue Dus:

Phillip Bros.,Inc. *

Phillip 3ro6.,Inc.
Phillip 3ros.,inc.
Phillip 3ros.,iInc.
Phillip 3ros.,Inc.
Phillip Sroc.,iIn:.
Phillip 3ros.,iInc.

Phillip Bres.,inc.

Flue Dust

Vand itn
Vanadiun
Vanadiun
Vanad iun
Vanadium
Vanadium

Vanad ‘wn

Total Vanadium Sluz

URAVAN, COLORADO

UNTTED STATES VANADIUM CORPORATION, PLANT VP

VANADIUM-SEARING MATERIALS PURCHASED BY ELECTRO METALLURGICAL. COMPANY

Date
Rec'd.

12/39
12/39
2/39
3/%o
4 /&o
5 /ao
5/49
7/4
9/40
10 "ho
12/4
12/%o

1/41

o/s1

Slas 1/bo-
Slag 2/40
Slag 7/40
Slag 3/40
Slag 7/40
Slag 10/4
Slaz 11/44

FOR UNITED STATES VANADIUM CORPORATION

Car
Number

N&W 120710

wre 131785

»!

39,077

CMBTP&P QUOR Ly,A14

MILW 18201
DLAW 45058
NYC 9503
NYC 93149
SP 23328

PRR 123428

WKP 21175

Cal 5304
aw 5150°

PM 25332

SAL 17979
PRR 573057
MYC 132725
PRR 57376

bo 528
51,500
47,689
35 aT
47,9

43,917
43,193
&5 ,230
4S O52

41,470

334 995

47 ,22h

53 ,285

42 09

341,347

Pounds
V205

7,976.39
10,123.29
5,059.9
5, 94.50
0,269.17
0 258.27
© 356,84
2,214.49
2,194.79
5,930.35
15,515.89
5,080.42

7,917.82

100 ,542.15

Vendor's

Inv. Value

$ © ,527.04
7,262.53
3543.19
& 280.40
b 513.58
4,505.7:
3,866, 2b
5,914.43
5 398.9
& ,269,8¢

11,172.4°
5,935.40

5 9790.9

$ 72,507.90

3,262.80
5,999.42
2,470.20

1,957.10

2,349.69
3,338.92
3,657.6

Sample
and

$ 22.68
23,34
47.83
28.70
36.20
36.20
28.70
26.86

5450
28.25
0.51
9.49
42,47

33.56

$ 820.88
635.81
714.5°
751.44
818.99
765.70
575.05
762.29
596 BA
69226
78k. 38
7238.%

61.5%
$ 9,40".37

757.70

880.09
1,148.05
596.16
523.05
759.81
826.63

Hauling
Cost at

Uravan

Y
$ 48.14

$ 450.51

100.60
172.9
47.95
59.83

681.05 Est. -

32,591.78 3 23,466.07 $139.11 $ 5,61¢.8b

* A@ditional car received from Phillip Bros.,Inc. to fulfill deficiency of V205 in Receipte listed above.

$ 391.33

[8g 193)

(fol. 53)

VANADIUM-BEARING MATERIAIS PURCHASED (EXCLUDING VANADIUM ORE)

RIFLE, COLORADO

UNITED STATES VANADIUM CORPORATION, PLANT VR

Vendor

BEE
i
if
if
Hl

i
i
i
EF
i

HELE
TE
EET
ALLL

October 1, 1941, to November 11, 1944

Date

Received

8/44
aap

Pounds
V205

43 495.40
46,776.60
50 ,694. 60
45,576.12
42,196.10
52,960.00
45,735.60
4h 631.96
53,685.20
55,174.77
51,237.60
46,277.00
45,357.10
52,074.20
49,490. 30
50 ,611.50

Value

30 446.78
32,743.62
35,486.22
31,903.28
29 537.27
37 ,072.00
32,014.92
31,242.37
37 579.64
36 ,622. 34
35 ,866.32
32,393.90
31,749.97
36,451. 94
34 ,643.21
35 ,428.05

| fol. 54]
Ix Unitep States District Court

PLaintirrs’ Exnuipit No. 16

a
e
eo
a

’
*
*
&
*

ae
*
&
eo
*
*
*
*
*
*
*

Te,

—
4

oui?

STA

YALE
{ee ee ae a a ; se eS ee

vE

UNioN CAE

ii i aly Hh Ht Th

i He nul i

-£-

IST OF PONCHASE?S OF = Pot -j
oh — 964 pho Me
ae ee ae ee es ae. ee. ie, ae, Re. |
Bey City Electric Stee. Castings .o. * e
J. B. Beaird Corperatiocn ,
Beil Telephone Laboratories .
Belmont Smelting & Refining Works . ° * * . 7a -
Bergstrom Steei Company *
SethleRes Foundry @ Machine Company .
Bethlenem Steel Company . - . . * . . . *
Birdsbore Steel Foundry @ Machine * ¢ . «

hii |

i It ant ih ait Hat
pile i iin ih na
in HTT thal 3 pe

ae

Acme Poundry Co.
Actarc, Ine.
A@irondack Piries & Stl. Inc.

American Optical Co.

American Pipe & 8tl. Corp.
American Radiator & Std.
American Wheelabrator & Equip.

Babcock & Wilcox Tube Co.
Barium Steel Corp.

Battelle Memoria. institute
Bell Telephone Labs.

Belmont Smelting & Refining Wks.

Beacon Tooi Co.
James ©. Beans Piry.

64

| fol. 61]

‘ : ee ey ee
ornare
mm fo wk

é i 3
hi Hi,
Ht Hy iif

in AH

@ Steal Co.

Hitt
att

7

a]

Walleck Foundry Company
J. P. Ward Foundries, Inc.
Warmen Stee] Casting Company
Wastburn Wire Company
Washington Iron Forks
Weatherly Steel Castings Co.
Wehr Steel
West Steel Castings Company
Welding Equipment & Supply Co.
Western Electric Company
Wertern Poundry Sand Company
Weetern Steel Casting Company
Westinghouse Electric & Mfg. Co.
Westlectric Castings Company
iavstatent Castmmant Company

H. A. Wilson & Company
Wisconsin Alloys Company
Alan Wood Steel Company

Xenia Foundry & Machine Co.
Youngstown Alloy Casting Corp.
Youngstown Foundry & Machine Co.

PBD
8/u

ais
LIST OF PURCHASEPS OF VANADIUM PRODUCTS
1955 - 1944 INCLUSIVE

azs5 1254 «(1955 «(1956 «AST «BSS «1959 Ol)

+ * * * -
*
*
* . = *
* * * * * * * e *
* * * * * *
*
- * * *
* *
*
*
o
*
* * * *
— se
*
* * 7
* * *
*
*
* * * * *
* * * * © * *

2242

2245

1c9 "OJ |

-?-
LIST OF PURCHASERS OF VANADIUM PRODUCTS

Chat): ee) ee we. tas Me! Ree. Re

Pitteburgh Metallurgical Gompany bal
Pittebargh Stee. Company .

:

Saginas Malleeble Irom Div.-Generel Motors Corp. ®
Seovill Mamafacturing Company *
Soullin Steel Company > - . .

1
|

4Y

| sy [OJ

Bendix Avaition Corp.
Berkley Machine Wks. & Piry. Co.

Cabot Shops, Inc.

Calif. Inst. Technology

Calif. Precision Cstgs.
Canadian Brake Shoe & Firy. Co. Ltd.
Camadian Car & Piry. Co. Lt¢.

CarpenterStl. Co.

Central Iron & Stl. Co.

Champion Rivet Co.

Chapman Valve Mfg. Co.

Ceramic & Color Chemical Mfg.

Charlotte Chemicals Lab.

8. Cheney & Sor

Chicage Stl. & Wire Co.

Curysler Corp.

Cineinmati Milling Machine Co.

Columbia Stl. Cstgs. Co.

Columbis Tool Stl. Co.

Continental Machines, Inc.
—Continental Ore Cc.

Cooper Alloy Piry. Co.

Centrifuge. Casting Co.

Crucible Sti. Co. of America

Curtiss-Wright Cor;.

D & M Machine Works

Davison Chem. Corp

Dayton Malleable Iron Co.
Detroit Gray Iron Piry. Co.
Dibert, Bancroft & Ross Co.
B. F. Drekenfeld & Co.

Du Pont de Nemours & Co.
Duriron Co.

te

LIST OF PURCHASERS OF VANADIUM PRODUCT. Page

igs _- FIRST 7 MONTHS ‘+

L 7 Months
CPi peas e > sal EF A > ae
Edgewater St... C .
Edmas Precision Castin Cor,. .
Eimer & Ame. . °
"4 Exstrand & Thuland inc. .
Peirmount Chemica: Co. . .
Ferro Enazve. Cor). . .
Pirtn-Sterling Sti. & Carbide “>. * . . . .
Florida. Machine & Foundry ~ . . . * . °
Foote Minera. —-. ° 7 . .
. Gardner-Denver Co. .
¥ General Aircraft Equip. ->- .
3 General Al.oys © * .
® General Electric Co. * . . . ‘
: General Meta.s Corp. * . . °
‘ General Motor . . °
© Glover Machine Works ®
2 Gorham Too. C.. .
Goyne Steam Purp ©. .
4 C. Paul Bageniocner .
8 Hamburg Piow ©.. .
Pe Wanford Foundry Cc. . . . .
Ms Harnischfeger Cor, . . .
ae Harshev Chemical Co. . .
Pas Hartford Electric Sti. Corr. .
Hayden Chemical Com. .
Haynes Stellite Co. (Al.ied . . . . .
tall co. ° +.
Hetheringto:, & Rerner .
Highland Prints Inc. .
B. F. Mirech, inc. .
fughes Tool Co. . . .

Rydrocarbon Res. Inc. .

LIcT OF PURCHASERS OF VANADIUM PS oly ~~

li.&s - FIRST 7 MONTHS °4

Indians Stee. Produsts .
Ingersol. Sti. & Disc Di .
Internationa. Micke. —>.
Ieaaceor iron Wks.

Jessop “eel Co.
Jones | Laughiir Stee. Com.

L'Air Liquide Society

Lame City Malleabie Co.

Latrobe Elec. Stl. Co. .
Lebanon Sti. Poundr, °
Linde Air Products

Limeoln Electric ©o. .
lankenheimer Co.

Marces* ©orp.

Marquette Mig. ©o- .
Massillon Sti. “st«. ©.

MeArtgur Chemica. °
Mellon Inst. of ind. Aes.
Metals Disintecrat.™~
Meta. & Thernit Cor.
Michiger S-l. Cstys. ©
mid Weet Alloys Inc.
Midvale Co.

Millmaster Chemica. -o.
Monsanto Cherical co.
Motor & M&cghinery Cstes. ©). .
Mountain State Stl. Piries.

Pacific Stl. Cetgs. Co.
Pennsylvania Elec. Stl. Cstgs. Co.

BE. A. Quirin Machine Shop & Piry.

Rockwell Mfg. Co.

LIST OF PURCHASERS OF VABADIUM PRODUCTS
1 sorts '
1265 1gn6 1247
. .

. .
7
.
7
.
. .
*
.
. . *
*
*
*
. *
* «
*
.
* .

[29 “125 ]

Standard Ultremarine Co.

David Taylor Co.

Timken Ro..er Bearing Co.
Tri-State Piries. Inc.
Truseli Piry Co.

Unexceiled Chem. Co., Inc.

Universal-Cyclope Steel Corp.
Utility Elec. Stl. Miry.

Vanedivwe-Alloys Sti. Co.
Vanadium Corp. of Americe
Vitro Mfg. Co.

Vulcen Crucible Stl. °o.

Warwan Stl. Cste. Co.
Washington Iron Wks.

Webeter Mfz. Co.

Wehr Stl. Co.

Welding Equipment & Supply Co.

LIST oF OF VANADIUM PRODUCTS
2285 - FIRST 7 MOWTES ‘+>
aye 1pe6 2247
pa

(g9 193]

TZ

Welland Elec. Stl. Firy.
West Stl. Cetgs. Co.
Westveco Chen.

Western Alloyed Stl. Catg. Co.
Western Elec. Cstg. Co.
Western Electric Co.

Western Industrial Supply
Western Stl. Cstg. Co.
Westlectric Cstgs. Co.
Whitman Co. —

Wield Mold

H. A. Wilson & Co.
Winchester Repeating Arms Co.
University of Wisconsin

Youngstown Alloy Cstg. Corp.
Yulcan Crucible Stl. Co.

PBD:1c
10/8/56

67

[69 193]

ol

[ fol. 70]
In Unitep States District Court

PLAINTIFFS’ Exuisit No. 17

ElkibS Np. 17

Sales of Vanadium Ore, Flue Dust, Vanadie Acid (Vanadium Pentoxide) and
Ferro Vanadium and Price Ranges.

A 935
Domestic
Customer Meterial
American Cyanamid & Chem. Co, VPent
Allegheny Steel Co. FeV

Alloy Cast.Steel Co.

American Arc Welders

American Steel Foundries

Andrews Steel Co.

Apex Foundry Co.

Arneson Foundry Co.

Banner Iron Works

Batavia Foundry Co.

Bell Telephone Lab.

Bethlehem Steel Co.

Rinney Castings Co.

Blaw Knox Co.

Bonney-Floyd Co.

Braeburn Alloy Stee! Corp.

brighton .Llec.Steel Cast.Co,

buffalo Fdry & Mach.Co.

Colonial Steel Co,

Crucible Steel Cast.Co,

Crucible Steel Co. of America

Detroit Alloy Steel Co.

Henry Dieston & Sone

Duriron Co.

Electro Alloys

Electrocant Steel Fdry Co.

Electromet Co.

kmpire penstall Co,

Hercules Powder Co.
Fobart Mfe. Co.

Foopstadt E. ¥.

Hommel Co. 0.

Pushes Tool Co,

Rydro Eng. & Chen. Co.
Industrial Castings Co,
Incersoll Steel & Dise
International Harvester Co,!
International Nickel Co,

Jessop Steel Co.
Jones & Leurhlin Steel Ccrp.

Kincatd-Osburn Flee, Steel Co,
Kahl Iron Co,

Keneas City Lab. Supply
Fen: ington Steei Co.
Keopuk Stee] Cetg. Co.
Filly Car @ Fary,. Co.
lotrobe Flec, Steel Co.
Lebanon Stee] Fdry. Co,
Lehigh Foun'ries

Lennig & Co., Chas,
Levey & Co. Fred'k,

Lindsay Light & Chee. Co.
Locomotive Fin, Mat'l Ceo.
Loxenstein & Sons, T.H
lakens Steel Co, .

Machined Stee] Cetgs. Co,
A. D, Mackay

Vae

Mallory oe Co., P, R.
Marion Stean Shovel Co.

97

[fol 95)

Mass. Inst. ef Tech.

Elec. Steel Cetgs. Co.
MeArttwr Chenieal Co.
Michiana Products Corp.
Michigan Stee] Castings
Midvale Co.

Miller C. Frank

Mile wee Stee] Fcary. Co.
Molybdenum Corp. of Anerica
Monroe i teel Castings Co.
Munning & Kunning, Inc.
Muskegon Piston Ring Co.

Bations) Analine & Chem. Co.
Rational Dyeing & Printing Co.
Bationsl Forge & Urdnance Co.
Bationsl Yell & Steel Castings
Bational Supply Co. of Del.
Hew Jersey Zinc Co.

BWobilium Products

Ohio Steel Pdry. Co.

Pacific Mille

Paniplus Co.

Parke Davis & Co.

Parker Ten Co.

Pa. Llec. Steel Cetg. Co.
Perkins Sechine & Gear Co.
Permtit Co,

Phillips @Co. C. £,
Phillips Dental Lab,
Pittevurgh Firy. & Machine
Pittsourgh Plate Glass Co,
Polluck, Alex w

Pon! Lily Co.

Porcelain inamel & Mfg.
Prescett ¢ Co.

Purvue University

Redwig Pocteries, Inc.
Reilly Tar & Chemteal Co.
Reliance Steel Castings Ce.
Republic Steel Corp.
Rescarch Products Co.

[ fol. 96]

Domestics

Rouse & Shearer Inc.
Rustless Iron & Steel Corp.

Saginaw Mall. Iron Div. G.M.C.

Sandell H. K.

Sterling Steel Castings Co.
Sterling Steel Fdry. Co.
Stefel & Sone J. L.

L. E. Stone

Stoody Co.

Sulmet Alloys

Swedish seat Co.

Titanium Alloy fg. Co.
Tolick Jr.
Toye Co. Joseph

Turner Co. - Joseph

Union Spring & Mfg. Co.
Union Steel Castings Co.
Unitcast Corp.

U. S. Steel Corp.
Universel—Cyclops Steel Co,
University of Florida
University ef Illinois

Volles Paint & Chemical

Valley Steel Casting Co.
Vanadium Alloys Stee) Co.
Var-Lar Ord. Chemical Co.

sad Vitro Mfg. Co.

100
[ fol. 97]

Domestic

Vulean Alley Corp.
Vulean “rucible Steel Ce.

Wileon Welder Metals

Pel Gi - $2.70 te .2.00 per 1d. od. v
Pov Cra - $2.60 to 32.90 per ld. etd. v
Pel Pri - 62.90 to 25.00 * * * ®*
V Pent ~ $1.10 per lv. ctd. Va05 te 61.25 per lb. mat'l
Aamii¥en ~ $1.90 to : S Pe. V
Consolidated? Bintang 6 , Cae Vv. Pent.
Demiaien Pounérics 6 Steal Lad. Pe. ¥
Deniaten Tar & Chen, Co. dam U Ven

1941 Domestic and Canadian Prices Range

Po, Vol $2.70 te 2.80 per 1b.914.7

Be. V Gru. 2.00 te 2.90 °* e

Po. V Pri. 2.90 te 3.00 ° ®

Vv. Pent. 1.10 pareld.Ctd.V205 to 1.25 per lb.Matl.
aan 1. Ven 1.90 te 2.20 per lb.

V.Metal 995 ohD to ohS per gras

Vv. Pent.cP 7.00 per pou
Aun..Ven CP 87.00 per pound
8ed.0 Van 29 to 2.20 per poand

“eye

118

[ fol. 115}
VANADIUM CORPORATION of AMERICA
Salee of Vanadium Ore, Flue Dust, Vanadiec Acid
(Vanadium Pentoxide) & Ferro Vanadius
and Price Ranges
Domestic SHAR _=_ 19%...
CS TOMER Material
Abbott Laboratories Van Pent CP
Advance Foundry Co. Fe V
Acme Steel & Malleable Iron Works .
Adirondack Foundries & Steel, Inc, °
The Aetna-Standard ing. Co. ’
Ahern Textile Print Am K Van
Alan Wood Steel Co. Fev
Allegheny Ludlum Steel Corp. ®
- 7 . * Van Pent
Allies Foundry Produete, Inc. Fe ¥
American Cyanamid & Chemical Co. Van Pent
American Locomotive Co, Pe ¥
American Molling Mill Co. Fe ¥
American melting & Nefining Co. Van Pent
Arerican Steel Foundries Fe ¥
Azerican Kell & Prosp. Co. FeV
Atlas Steels, Lid. Fe ¥
Babcock & Kileox Co. Fe ¥
J. T. Baker Chemical Co, Ams M Van
Bass Foundry & Machine Divn, Fe ¥
Bell Telephone Lab. Van Metal
Bethlehem Steel Co. Pe V
- o 7 Van Pent
Bonney Floyd Co. Fe V
Braeburn Alloy Steel Corp. Fe V
Braun Corp. Ame M Van CP
Brocker Chemical Co, Van Pent
Bucyrus Erie Co. Fe V
Burnsids Steel Foundry Co. Fe ¥
A. M. Byers Co, Fe V
Carbic Color & Chemical Co, Ama * Van
Carns Chemical Co., Inc. Van Pent
Celanese Corp. of America .. Ss
Chapman Valve Manufacturing Co. FeV
Chicago Steel & Wim Co, Fev
Ciba Co., Ine. Van Pent
Cold Spring Bleachery Ame M Van
H. Cole Co. Van Pent CP
The Caleman & Bell Co., Inc. Van Pent
The Colonial Poundry Co. Fe ¥
Colonial .teel Co. FeV

Consolidated Chemical Industries, Inc. Van Pent

119

itol. Lilo!
Domestic TEAR 1942 - Page 2
CUS TOMER Meterial

Continental Koll & Steel Foundry Ge, Fe V
Copperweld Steel Co, Pe V
Crobalt, Inc. Vv Metal
Crucible Steel Co. of America fe ¥

. . 7 * . Van Pent
Henry Dieston & Sone, Inc, Fe V

o 7 a * Van Pent
E, 1. Du Pont de Neaoure & Co, Aom M Van CP
Ths Duraioy Co. Fe ¥
b. A. Laboratories, Inc. Van Pent
Biwer & Amend as
Electric Boat Co. Amm KM Van
Electric Steel Castings Co, Fe V
Electrocagt Steel Foundry “c. Fe V
Bepire Ordnance Co, Fe V
Ensign Foundry co, Fe V
Erie Forge Fe V
Erie Porge & Steel Co, Fe V
Palk Corp. Fe ¥
Paurot Protective & Id@emtification Sys. Sod Van
Verro tnamel Corp. Ame K Yan
Firth-Sterling Steel Co. fe ¥
Pollansbee Steel Corp. Fe V
Ford Motor Co. Fe V )
Forging & Casting Corp. re V pes
General Color & Chemical Co. Yan Pent v

xe ™ “i ° Am MK Van
General Dysstuff Corp. Am K Van
Gornmam Tool Co. Fe Vv
fail Greinic Co. Ame M Van
Charles Hardy, Inc, Vv Metal
Harrison Steel Castings Co. Fe VY
Marshaw Chemicel Co, Van Pent
Marvard University Van Pent CP
Heppenstall Co. Fe V
0. Hommel Co, Van Pent
Mytensil Aluminum Co. Vv Metal
Ingerscll Steel & Dise. Dirr Fe V
Inland Steel Co. re ¥
International Harvester Co., inc. re V

120

| fol. 117]

CUSTOMER

Jessop Steel Co.

Jones & Laughlin Steel Ceo.
Frederick Kahl Iron Co, -

MK. M. Kellogg Co.

Latrobe clectrie Steel Co.
Lebanon Steel Foundry
Lewis Co.

Lukens Steel Co.
A. D. Mackay

Machined Steel Caating Co.
Mason Color & Chemfical Works
Master Mix Paint & Lacquer Corp.
Maynard Elec. Steel Castings Co.

Mesta Machine Co.

Metal & Thermit Corp.
Michigan Steel Castings Co.
Midvale Co.

Monroe Steel Castings Co.
Mapco, Inc.

Nathan Chemical Co.

Bational Analine Divwn.
7 - -

National Bureau of Standards
National Forge & Ordnance

National Lead Co,
Mational Malleable & Steel Castings Co.
National supply Co.
Newport News Shipbuilding & Drydock Co.

Nixon Nitration ‘orks
Nobilius Products, Ine.

YEAR 1942 - Page 5

Ohio Steel Poundry Co. (»pringfield, 2hio)

Osalid Proautts Lim.

Parker Pen Co.

Tne Patterson Sereen Co,
Penn clectric Steel Castings Co.
Pitteburgn Plate Class Co.
Mayrex Printers, Inc.
mCA Manufacturing Co.
meilly Tear & Unemical Corp.

2 o 7 .

Republic Steel Corp.

mnode Island State College
Rotary Eleetric Steel Co.

&. HK. Sargent Co.

i

[ fol. 118}

Domeotis FEAR 1942 - Page |

Shell Development Co.
Sherwin Williams Co.
Simonds Saw & Steel Co.
Sirtex Printing Co.
George F. Smith
Solar Aircraft Co.
Standard Klectric Steel Castings Co.
Standard Steel Works Co.
Standard Ultramarine Co,
Stauffer Chemical Co.
Sterling Steel Casting Co.
The Stoody Co.
Superior Steel & Malleable Castings Co,
Textile Chemical Co,
Timken Holler Bearing Co.

® * 2 eo

Tinnite Co.
Treadwell Engineering Co.
Union Electric Steel Corp.
Union Steel Castings
Unitecast Corp.
United Brass & Aluminum Co.
U.S. Fingerprint Procucts, Inc.
U.S. Foundries, Inc.
U.S. Steel Corp.

= . .

Universal-Cyclope Steel Corp.
* . a 8

University of Pitteburgh
Valley steel Castings Co.
Vanadiu ‘lLioys Steel
Vulean Crucible Steel Co.
7 . = s
Waldrich Co.
George T. Walker
7 o oe

T. F. Washburn Ce.

Washburn Wire Co,

West Steel Castings
Westinghouse Elec. & Mfg. Co.
Wilkens Anderson Co.

Worth Steel Co.

121

122
[ fol. 119}
Demeotic TEAR 1942 ~ Page 5
CUSTOMER Material
Toungetowm Pout ry & Machine Co, Pe V
Zenit roundry Co. FeV
Leroy Van Pent
Cauadtan
one Coneo | 4\tec Mining & Smelting Van Pent
Delom -ae.cing & “efining Ltd. V Metal
Dominion founcries & Steel Ltd, Fe v
Dominion Tar 4 Chent-al Ce, Ame M Van
McArthur Chemical Co . Ltd, Agm ™ Van

Fe ¥ ~ OH aad saree 2 82-40 ver tb Cee tan
PeV¥-Cm- 2.80 * 2.90 " © «
FeV-Pri- 2.90 * 3.00 " 8 «# «
Vv Pent - 2-10 per Lb Ct ¥20s to $1.25 pe LB myperts’
Am-*M Van - 1.90 te 2.20 per Lb
V Metal 90% 3.30 * 3,50 © "Cea Vv
¥ Metal 9*%f- 40" 4k gram
¥Y Pent CP . 7,00 per Lh
ns Am ¥ Van CP. 7,00 oe
Sod Van - a 2.20 per Lh

Prices the sam to al) custone-s for similar quantities,
@iser = on contract and spot bases. Special erindéng an:
quality extne net indicated in above standard prices.

123

| fol. 120)

VANADIUM CORPO" ATION OF AMERICA

Sales of Vanadium Ore, Flue Dust, Venadie Acid (Vanadium
Pentoxide), Perro Vanadium and Price Ranges

YEAR 193

i
Domestic
— MATER AL
A. C. Spark Plug Div. ¥ Pent
Actare, e Fev
AG@irondack Poundries & Stee) Fev

Fev

Allegheny Ludlum Stee) Corp,

american Enka Corp. Amt Ven
Ame Yan CP
American Hoist & Derriek Co, Fev
American Locomotive Co, FeV
American Smelting & Refiring Co. Vv Pent.
Apex Cnemical Co. v Pent.
Apponaug Co, Ame Van
Armstrong Cork Co, ¥ Pent CP
Baker & Co, V Metal
J. T. Baker Chemical Co, amma Van CP
Co, Vv Pent
Bell Telephone 0 oer Fev
Bethlehem Steal Co, Pev
B. G. Corp, ¥ Pent
Bonney-Fleyd Ce. Fev
Bonnet Co, Fev
Borden & Remington Co, am Van
Braeburn Allay Steel Corp. Fev
Braun-Enecht Neiman Co, VY Pent cP
v Pent
A. KM. Byers Co, Fev
Carbtie Coler & Chemical Co, Ammh Van
Carus Chemical Co., Inc. ¥ Pent
Central Iron Poundry Co. Fev
Central Seientifie Co, Sod # Van
Sed * Van Comm.
Chematar, Ine. Sod 0, Van
Chicago Poundry Co, Pev
City Chemical Co, _
Clark ‘Squat pment Co e
M. Cole Co, : ¥ Pent CP
Combustion Engineering Co., Ine. ¥ Pent
Commercial Salvente Corp. —

10%
120

124

fol. 121]

QUSTOPER_

Copperweld Steel Co,
Crane Co.
Crobalt, Ine.

Crucible Steel Co. of America

W. H,. Curtin & Co,

Derver Pire Clay Co,
Dickson Cun Plant

Henry Dieston % Sons
Dew Chemical Co.

5. 1. Duvont de Nemours

Dye Specialties Corp.

Eastman Kodak Co,

Eimer & Amend

Eril Engel

Empire Ord‘nance Corp.
Erie Porge Co,

Erte Forge & Stee) Co,
Faurot Protective System
Foote Mineral Co.

Pard Motor Co.

Porging & Casting Corp.
Freechi Brothers
General Exiline Worke

General Dyestuff Corp,
G. W. Cesing

Gorham Tool Co.
Mempton %o,
Maneell-Eleock Co.
Tharles Hardy, In-,
Harehaw Chemical Co,
Heil Corp.

Heopenstall Co,
O, Homme) Co,

Ingereol) Steel & Diese Div.

Jeseop Steel Co,

sones & Laughlin Steel Corp,

Kil) ien Research Laboratories

Koleman Instr. Div,

aa

12/

[ fol. 122]

-3+

CUSTOMER

Latrobe Eleetric Steel Co,
Lehigh University
Lukens Steel Co,

A. D, Mackay

Malleable IronFittings Co.
Mallinckrodt Chemical Works
Mason Color & Chenier] Worke
Meeta Mrchine Co,

Metal & Thermit Corp,
Midvale Co,

Milweukee Steel Foundry Co.
Mine & Smeltere Supply Ce.

Muskegon Pieton Ring Co,
National Aniline Co,

National Forge & Ordnance Co.
Naugatuck Chemical Div,

Newport News Shinbu‘ld‘ng & Dry Dock Co.

Niazara Alekali Co,

Niagara Falls Smelting Corn.
Niagers Sprayer Co,
Kobilium roducts, Ine.
Nu-Rali‘ur, Ine.

Ohio Stee) Foundry Co,
E, Dewitt Osborne
Otis Elevator Co,

Pacific Vanasit Co,

Pan American Alloys, Ine.

Pa. Eleetric Steel Castings Co,
Pa. State College

Penn Rivet Corp.

Pnaillips Petrmleum Co,

Pitteburgh Rolle Div (Blaw ¥ncex “%e,)

Raw Chemicels, Inc,

RCA Victor Div. of RCA
Reduction & Hefining Co.
Reichhold Chemicals, Ine.
Reliable Ink & Stationery ¢«,
Reliance Steel Castince co.
Reprocuc*ion Products Co,
Republic Steel Corp,
Reynolds Metals Co,

Roeter Drug Co.
Ratary Fleetrie Steel Co,

124

126

[ fol. 123]

GUSTOMER

Rotomet Corp.
Rustless Iron & Steel Co,

Saginaw Malleable Iron Div.
Scientific Glase Apparatus Co,
EB. H. Sargent Co,

Simonds Saw & Steel Co,
Sirtex Printing Co.

Standard Electric Steel Cetge. Co,

Standard Steel Works Co,
Standard O11 Development Co.

Standard Ultramarine Co,
Stauffer Chemical Co,
Sterling Steel Casting Co,
Stvoody Co.

Strong Cobb & Co,

Strong Steel Foundry Co,
S)ivania Eleetrie Products

Textile Chemical Co.
Timken Koller Bearing Co,
Titanium Alloy Mfg.

The Tredegar Co,

Tungsten Alloy Mfg.

Union Electric Steel Corp.
Union Steel Castings Div.
United Brass & Aluminum Co,
U. S$. Steel Corp.

Universal Cyclops Steel Corp.

Universtiy of California
University of Florida
University of Pittsburgh

Valley Steel Casting Co.
Vanadium Alleys Steel Co,

Vulean Crucible Steel Co.
Waldrick Co.

Geo, T. Walker & Co,
Wall-Colomony Corp.
Wallwork Foundry Co.
Warren Foundry & Pipe Corp.

[ fol. 124]

GUSTOMER

Waehburn Wire Co,
Weet Steel Casting Co,
Westinghouse Electric & Mfg.

Well Corp.

CANALIAN
CUSTOMER

Deloro Smelting & Refining Co,
Electrometallurgical Co. of Canada

127

1943 DOMESTIC & CANADIAN PRICE RAMOES

FeVOH $2.70 to 2.80 per lb, etd.
FeV Cu “a ase = OF
FeV Pri 2.90 to 3.00 = * *®
V Pent 1.10 per

Am ¥ Van 1.90 to 2.20 per pound

V Metal 90% 3.30 to 3.59 per lh. etd.
V Metal 95% 8.40 to .45 per eras

Vv Pent CP 7.00 per pound

Ama © Van CP 7,00 * ”
Sod 0 Van 090 to 2.20 per pound

Prices ‘he same to all -vetomere for similar cuantities,
sx.ras not

and spot bases. Sr ‘>
standard prices.

Ll grinding and qunlity

lb, etd ¥205 to 1.95 per 1b, mati,

sisees - on contrect
indlerted in abeve

fay

128
[ fol. 125]

Domestis

VANADIUM CORPORATION OF AMERICA

Selee of Vanadium Ore, Flue Duet, Vanadic Acid
(Vanadium Pentoxide) and Ferro Vanadcivm

ard Price Ranges

TEAR £19k

SUSTOMER

Artare, Ine,

~

Adirondack Fdries & Steel Co.
Air Reduction Sales Co,

Alan Wood Steel Co,

Allegheny-Ludlum Steel Corp.

Allie Chalmers Mfg. Co.
Alten's Foundry & Machine Co.
Alumirmum Co, of America

Aluminum Forgings, Inc.
american Cyanamid & Chem, Co,
American Fdry. Equipment Co,
American Locomotive Co,
American Viscose Corp.

American Well & Prospecting Co,

arcrods Corp.
Baker & Co,

J. T. Baker Chem. Co,

Barrett Co,

Batelle Memorial Inst,
Bay State Abrasive Prod. Co,
Belmont Smelt. & Ref. Co,

Bethlehem Steel Co.

Braun Corp .
Brown Industries

Buffalo Apparatus Co,
Brunside Steel Fdry. Co.
Burrell Tech. Supply Co,

Burt Foundry Co,
A. M. Byers Co.
Calif. Research Co,

Campbell Wyant & Cannon Pdy. Co.
Carbic Color & Chen. Co,
Carbide & Carton Chem. Corp.

Carus Chemical Co,

ry

129

[ fol. 126]

Domestic YEAR — 1944 Page 2
CUSTOMER MATERIAL
Case “fg. Co., Wr. A. & Son V Pent
Central Iron Foundry Fov
Chapman Valve Mfg. Co, .
Chematar, ine. Vv Pent CP
Cnemical Product Corp. V Pent
Chemo Puro Mfg. Co. V Pent CP
City Chemital Co, So Van
Clark Equipment Co, Fev
Climax Molybdenum Corp, Vv Metal
Sigmond Cohn Co, Fev
Cold Spring Hleachery Arm M Van
H. Cold Co, V Pent CP
Coleman & Bell Co. Vv Pent
Colonial Foundry Co. Fev
Colonial Steel Div, 7
Combustion Engineering Co, Vv Pent
Continertal Fdry. & Mach. Ce, Fey
Copperweld Steel Co, “g
Corning Glass works Vv Pent
Crucible Steel Caet. Co. (Mil.) FeV
Crucible Steel Co. of America )

¥ Metal
Dareis Emergency Equipment Co, P V Pent

V Pent CP
Dehydro.lo,. Fel

Vv Metal
Diekeon Gun Plant Fev
Henry Diseton & Sone, Ine. °s
Low Chemical Co, Sod © Van
B. F. Drakenfeld Co, V Pent
Drug Producte, Ine. Asi Van CP
E. I. DuPont Nemours, V rent

V Pent CP

Ane‘ Van

Area’ Van CP

So Van
Eagle Grinding Wheel Co, Vv Pent
Eastman Kodak Co, Am Van
Eimer 4 Amend Co, V Pent
Electrie Auto Lite Co, FeV
clectro Metallurgical Co, 6
Erie Porge Co, , °
Erie Forge & Steel Co, e
Fairbanks Moree Co, “s
Fairmont Chemical Co, ¥ Metal
Falk Corp. FeV
Ferro Enamel Corp, Am=M Van
Follansbee Steel Corp, FeV
Foote Mineral Co, Vv Pent
Ford Motor Co, FeV
General Aireraft Equip. Co, ®

126

130

| fol. 127}

Domestic

CUSTER

General Chemical Co.

General Color & Chem. Co,
General Dyeetuff Corp.
General Motore Corp.
Glasgo Finishing co.

Geodall-Sanford, Inc.
B. F. Geodrich Co.
Gorhan Tool Co.
Goulds Pumre,
Great Lakes Steel Corp.
Guseack Machined Prods. Co,

Kamcton Co.

Mansell Eleock Co,

varbison walker Refractories
Charles Hardy, Ine,

Karshaw Chemical Co,

Harvel Research Corp.
Joshua Hendy Iron Works
Feppenstell Co.
hercules Powder Co,

Hinderliter Tool Co,
Hoffman-La Roche, Inc.
CO. Homael Co,

Johns Hopkins Univ.

Hypex Co,
Infilco Co,

Ingersoll Stee) & Diec Div.
Interchemical Corp.
International Harvester Co,
International Min. & Chem. Corp,
Jessop Steel Co,

Jones & Laughlin Steel Cerp.
Frederick Kahl Iron Poundry
Kimble Glaes Co,

Koppers Co,

Lakeside Laboratories
Latrobe Elee. Steel Co,

Locomotive Fin. Materiel Co.
Lukens Steel Co,

Lynchburg Founcry Co.
Machined Steel Cstg. Co.

A. D. Mackay

P. R. Mallory & Co.
Marion Steam Shovel Co.
Mass. Inst. of Tech.

Maytag Co.

131

| fol. 128 |
Domectie TEAR — L2bb Peso 4
CUSTORR WATEUAL
Mesta Machine Ce, rev
Metal Hydrides Ine, Vv Pent CP
Metal & Thermit Corp. Fev
Midwale Co, e
Mine & Smelter Sup. Co, ¥ Pent CP
Monroe Steel Castings Co. Fev
Motor & Machinery Cstgs. Co. °
Muskegon Pieton Ring Co, e
National Alley Steel Div. ®
Nat. Aniline Div. Aum Yan
National Forge & Ordnance Co, FeV
Niagare Falle Sm. & Ref. Co. V Metal
hichol Straight Poy Corp. FeV
Nobilium Producte, Inc. V Metal
Nordberg Mfg. Co, Fev
Onio Steel Pdary. Co, .
Ortho Products Ine. Ama Var, CP
Otis levator Co, FeV
Pacific Aille hmm Van
Ava Yan CP
Parker ’an Co, Asad{ Van
Pennsylvania Elec. Steel Crystal Co, PeV
Penn State College AcmM Van CP
Peru Poundry Co, FeV
Phillips Petroleum Co, Acer Van CP
Vv Pent CP
Pitteburgh Pdry. & Mach. Co, Fev
Pitteburgh Rolle Div. e
Pitteburgh Steel Poundry Corp. e
Riytecnhnical Inet. of Brooklyn Vv Pent cP
Primos Chemical Co, Sod © Van
Publicker Com. Alcohol Co, V Pent
Pullman Standarc Car & Pdry. Co, FeV
Pusey & Jones Corp. *
Rare Chemicals Inc. Vv Pent
Raytheon Mfg. Co, V Meta
Reliance Steel Cast. Co, FeV
Rensselaer Valve Co, Fev
Re, uolie Steel Corp.
Roemer Drug Co, Ama Yan CP
Rose Meehan Pdries. FeV
Rotary Elec. Steel Co, ‘sf
Roxboro Steel Co, *
Rustiess Iron & Steel Co, ¥d
Saginaw Mall. Iron Div. ’
E. hk. Sargent Co, V Pent
Sharon Steel Corp. Fev
Sherwin-Williams Co, Ace Var
Simonds Saw & Steel Co. Fev
Vv Metal
Sirtex Printing Co. Arm Van

132

| fol. 129}

Demeetise TEAR — 1 36h

CUSTER awa

A. ©. Smith Corp.
Standard lec, Steel Cetyse. Co.
Standard ©il Develop. Co.

Standard O11 Co, of La.

Standard See) Works Dir.
Standerc Ultramarine Co,
Standard Varnieh Works
Steuffer Chemical Co,

Sterling Steel Casting Co.

Stoody Co, -
Strook & Wittenberg

Tennessee Eastman Co,

Textile Chem. Co,

Timken Roller Bearing Co.
Titeniumalldy Mfg. Co.

Union Steel Cetae.

United Breese & Alusa. Co,

United Engineering & Foundry Co,
United Mercnante & Mfgre. Coip.
U. S. “teel Corp.

Universal Cyclops Steel Corp.

Univ. of Californie
Univ. of Lilinote

Valle, Steel Casting Co,
Vanadium-Alloye Steei Co,

Vicar laborstories
Victoreen last. Co.

Vulcan Cru. Steel Co.
Waldrich Co.
Walker & Co,

Relleoch Parry. Co.

Weapdurn Wi. Lo,

West Steol Ceca. co,
Westinghouse Flec, & Mig. Co.

While Laboratories
@ilkening mfg. Co.

Will Corp.

dorth Steel SC.

Youngstown /dry & Mach. Co,

Tease 2

MATER AL

Vv Pent
Fev
*

AmaM Yan Cr
V Pet

Vv Pent CF
AomM Yan CP
Sod 0.Van
Fev

Vv Pent

Vv Pent CP
Act¥ Van

¥ Pent

FeV

Vv Pent CP
Vv Pent
Aco Van
Fev

VV Peat

v Metal
Fev

Fev

Vv Fent
Fev
7.

V Metal
VY Pent

VY Metal
Acc’ Van CP
VY Pent Cr
fev

Arc Van
Aco™ Van CP
Vv Pet CF
FeV

.

[ fol. 130]

Canadian YEAR —— 1 Page 6
CUSTOMER MATERIAL
Canadian Copper Refiners Sod 0 Van
Canadian Laboratory Supplies V Pent
Dominion Tar & Chem. Co, AmmM Van

V Pent

FeV

1944 Domestic & Canadian Price Ranges

Fe VOH = $2.70 to $2.80 per lb. Ctd. Van.

Fe V Cru = $2.80 to $2.90 per lb. Ctd. Van.

Pe Vv Pri cad $2.90 to $3.00 pe> Lb. Ctd. Van.

V Pent - $1.10 per lb. V205 Ctd to $1.25 per lb. Mat'l
Am=M Van - $1.90 to $2.20 per pound

V Metal 90% - $3.30 to $3.50 per lb Cta V

V Metal 95% - $ .40 to $ .45 per gram

V Pent CP = $7.00 per pound

AmmM Van CP - $7.00 per pound

Sod 0 Van - $ .90 to $2.20 per pound

Prices the same to all customers for similar quantities, sizes - on contract
and spot bases. Special Grinding and Quality extras not indicated in above
standard prices,

140

133

134

(fol. 131]
Ix Unrrep States Ihstrict Court
Praintirrs’ Exuisrrt No. 18
__. Compllation of United states tanadimm Corp: 1205 Protea Dita
v
— 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 3
Rifle Pred. Uraven Pred. Tet.Rifle Dareage Gateway Alloys Garfield Plant-s Tet .08V
Lbe-, V205 Lbs. OSs Uravag WBV-YR = Ine.-YEV-UR | Vap-Corp. Or. Jpt Eretz 1901.
Dereanage, Pred .Pred.ine. Lee. ¥205 eUSY- USV Centreaet ageneics
ibe. 1205 ¥205 MAC, Lhe. V205 acct. _ioe- 05
The .¥2706
1998 ) 1,875,695 1,875,695 Q 1,¢75,695
1999 0 1,995,717 1,995,717 1,000 (B) 1,9,5,717
1g@o - 2,134,1>5 2,194,125 §,000 (8) 2,194,145
igi ) 4537 4700 2,376,700 ) 5,000 (B) 2,376,700
1ff2 Bifle Plant Reorened 1,285,417 2,224,831 3,510, 248 186,632 40,000 (3) 0 3,736,880
193 1, 567,685 1,734,229 3,301,914 852,684 80,000 (J) vy 185,620(J) 4,420,418
1986 Grav-n Plant Closed June 1,852,921 103,174 2,554,095 300,377 8,500 (J) 257,192 820,606(5) 3,940,770
ifts 4 1,729,260 83,901 (a) 1,813,162 365,616 *) f°) 916,095(5) 3,094,872

rp. V Predws ti t a United States Imports and Comparisen of Same
v
: 8 9 10 ll 12 ls 14 15 lo 1? l. 19 20
Plant-s Tot .U8V Wa Wa-¥ eran t b— Vitro Chem. Ne.Cont Blanding Tet .U.8. {Tet . Rifle {Tet .USY Tet. Imp. Tet . 205 LTet .Ugy
Gr.Jgt. Incl. Naturita Montigeglle St.Anthony Co. Prod. Sm ttuck Chem. Prod. Lbs Demestie Uraven Pred. Inc +l) Inte [.8- avai le in Pred.Lac. ;
U8V Contract iaaesien ial. ed — te Lbe-V205 Cea yoo v20F Pred.ibe. Durangl -_ Pate : agensics is rag ary one s tp ,
5 acct. _ibe-¥205 Lbs. V205 lbs.¥ e Loe- ¥20 ~YR2-__} ete Tote os 6 Semantic e *
The .¥205 Lobe. ¥205 -5.Dem. Prod hb Ser 1e Le 0.s.
1,075,695 166,600 (8) 140,309 = 2,100,000 65.7% 1,854,000 [B) 5,082,660 au .eu,
1,9/5,717 20,000 (@) 161,410 xs 2,175,127(m) 91.624 2,856,090 (8) 5,034,227 19. 64h
2,194,165 0 128,007 (B) 172,750 . 2,499,925(4) 87.77% 3,448,590 (8) 5,948,505 je b9%
2,376,700 400, 000(K) ) 141,600 (S) 175,00\4) 5% 0 3,096, 300(M) 46.529 2,864,175 (B) 5,962,475 39.86%

c 3,736,880 439,500(J) 235,000 (J) 125,000 (J) 35,000(7) 85,000(J) 59,0U0(J) 4,725,380 14.444 19-2 3_244,200 (..) 7,959,580 46.95%
185,620(3) 4,420,418 752,000(J} 817,000 (J) 44,700 (J) 12,000(J) 20,000(J) 11,000(J) 6,076,118 54-344 12.3 2.749,006 (8) 6,825,118 50.09%
820, 606(J) 3,940,770 786,000(J) 150,000 (3) 6,000 (1) Q (J) ,99800(7) 12,010(7) 4,903,580 54-91% 80.36L 1,720,425 (8) 6,624,005 59-49)
916,095(3) 3,094,872 §05,000(J) 130,000 (J) ) 74, 000( J) 2,000( J) 0 4,405,872 41.15% 10.24% =. 2,078, 925 (m8) 6,484,797 41.72%

1,922,321 32113,864 2,882,5w 1,937,000 R38, 405 941,289 161,000¢ 81,010 39,012,068 _ r2,5)% _ Bzaizh 30,078,185 49,069,253 hath
a) a Aorverrenes . --e Seite _ on 26 — oe = —— hd,
Sleetro-Met lectro-Met Tote) r-¥ rier to Metals weerve) ee
*' (6) Shatteck Chemical Ce. pred. enly 85% recevery Ferro~
»* (BD) Vitre Chemical Ce. pred. caleulated frem 85% recovery of Utah reduction as
cis (R) Mamecth-St. Anthea; vrod. ealemlated at 70% reeever, ‘ Birger
** = (0) Mammoth ee ne ee ee ee Serer ee
1927 331,028 (2) 331,028 92-65% 22, 300 3555328 B.a1t 10.31%
1928 984,994 (FP) 964,994 69-94% 555134 1,040,126 64.220 13-85%
1929 690,444 (P) 690,444 17-85% 21,002 712,445 59.06% 18.39%
1930 296,716 (P) 296,716 1) .89% 83 296,803 21-47% 11.90%
1932 327,420 (PF) =: 1,072 319,092 13.4% 3,969 323,061 18.12 18.12% (¥)
2932 131,536 (P) 9,090 140,626 19.4% ) 140,626 19.41% 19-41% (¥)
1933 544,400 (Pr) 27,614 512,074 10,023-49% 21,334 789,408 14659.38% 14659.38% (¥)
1934 430,300 (P) 25,200 455,500 19-15% 788,138 12,045 1,255,683 7425.444 229 84%
1935 430,638 (8) 18.900 449,538 231.7% 499,664 21,449 970,652 1427-43% $60. 344
1936 460,836 (7) 20,338 481,174 14.50% 366,439 11,691 859,302 459-98 133-05%
1937 583,808 (7) 32,554 616, 360 19.63% 551,565 37,105 1,2U5,030 62.844 38.37%
1938 251,150 (?) 11,830 202,980 651% 152,376 20, 357 435,713 19-918 10078
1939 541,088 (7) 15,934 557,002 11.068 ‘ 16,624 1,249,510(A) 57.378 24-82%
1920 880,988 (P) 155,484 (B)1,036,472 11-42% ae Hi 135,186 1,914,852(8) 16-60% 32-19
1941 0 -24.666,806 (FP) 242,028 2,909,432 48.19% vhs 48,074 34145,349 101.5% 52-15%
1942 2,625,024 (P) 181,918 2,600,942 35 026% 277,088 32,675 3,116,705 6b «10% 390164
1943 3,094,880 (P) 262,280 3,357,860 38.05% 195,413 1,896 3,561,171 58.61% 40.35%
1944 1,864,970 ,.) 101,876 1,9n6,846 29-69% 118,589 29,738 251155273 43.14% 32-932
1945 1,220,590 (7) 132,128 1,352,728 20.8.4 64,872 374309 1,474,898 33-472 22.744
wth - = — ieee
TOTALS 18,347,676 1,240,122 P)19,587,798 (P) 26.35% 4,900,292 470,751 24,958,841 63.98% 3e-17
_—__- 1,040,655(U)

(fol 132]

135

Ix Usirep Stares District Court

PLAINTIFFS’

Exuipir No. 19

Contrecte Por Ferro-

van*@iu3

103,178.09
154,398.80
177, 721.29
336,798.16
636, 948.69
190,797.79
455,171.33
791,287.94
4,416, 645.22
4,233,613.18
1, 099,552.38
910,074.60
1,152,268.07
537 268.75
508, 317.02
660,298.20
371,515.01

136
{ fol. 133)

Oaiet’ Cet.

INTERROGATORY KO. 28

The number of total requirement contracts under which
sales of ferrovanadius or vanadium oxide were mace for
each of the years indicated below, toyvether with the quan-
tity sold thereuncer, is as follows:

Ferrovanacius
Pounds
Contained
No. of Vanadium
Year Contracts lelivered
1937 2 130,044
1936 3 55,113
1939 33 v4,1,50
1g4&c ‘ou 150, 3
1yal 52 L554 4%
1942 36 $22,199
1343 27 277,009
1944 40 204,450
1945 40 100,875
ly4o 23 153,15
1947 a 117,U4
1340 29 l2l,uy
1949 (7 mos.) 22 45,049
Vanacium Oxide
Pouncs
Contained
No. of 4295

Year ontracts Leliverec
193 3 574 %20
1930 3 12,053
isk 3 Td» or)
1 . 115,500
1341 4 71,102
iy42 3 vd, 91
1943 3 #J,108
1944 2 Su, 747
1945 ; 6/, 414%
ly4o . 2l,rvv
1947 2 30,273
lyfe 2 61,722
1349 (7 mos.) fe) hone 3

137

[ fol. 134 |

PERCENTAGE OF GCLOSIWS PERC VEST OD VeeeIm PPTs
ComTRACTS TO TOUL FERRO VaeRIE AD VeeRTE PEVTORIDS CONTRACTS
he.

vo quantity sold 57.98 25 .0at

138

{ fol. 135)
Ix Uwsitep States District Court
PLaintirrs’ Exuisit No. 21
L: Gis & theta re ee es ‘ ey et ie =" |
' pee "tah fel tt
me
INTER2CGATO*Y MO. UY (a
VANADIUM BEARING O.ES NINLD DY UNITED CTATES
VANADIUM CUPORATICN P.iCh COMPANY Curop 422
LEASD CLAIR 1333 to cue. Bl, lyt/
Tons

19 None
133 C
935
1337 - Yoeicre’ D1
1353 71,C0c~.& 1
1933 boi g02 30
1550 (Tat3he38
141 O71 92s 36 Q 23
i;-2 115,105. Ls
1383 170,057. 244
144 Cue. 2OWe LD
194 t(,clvely ?
18e % 34534 007

17 Ci en 241.45,
28

139

[fol. 136]
INTERROGATORY NO. & (b)

VANADIUM-BEARING ORES PURCHASED BY
UNITED STATES VANADIUM CORPORATION
FROM INDEPENDENT PRODUCERS 1933
to DECEMBER 31, 1947

Tons

1933 None
1934 *
1935 %
1936 urchased
from Metals Reserve Company, which had been
wined end solé by Vana¢cius Corpor-tion of
/merica curing yeors 1941 throuch 1944 to
Yetals Peserve Company end reportec as "mined"

ore in Frhibit I.
| 3$

143

142
| fol. 139] [ fol. 140}
Ix Unitep States District Court
PLawntirFs’ Exnuisit No. 24
EXEIBIT Vit
P CUANTITY OF VANADIUM-BFARING ORES
.
Mee UTED SUATES DI PxicT COURT xear Dry_ Tons
| De on nF 1945 30,342
[Ylanlpebdol 1 Af
/ CUANTITISS& CF VANACDIOM OXIOF oR
ibis CHAEED
Total quantity of vensdium-bearing ores, vanadium oxide Year Lbs e v.20,
and ferrovansdius purchased from Ketsle Reserve Company.
1942 127,332.07
UHLON CANBIDE AND CABUN CORPORATION 1943 854,107.15
PURCHASE OF VANADIUM OXIDE (¥205) 1
‘ai 459,802.76 *%-. 944 774,145.63
pe 59,520.75 Ibs. 1945 101, 363.61
M917 yo3.s!
Pah UNITED STATES VANADIUM COPPONATION x

+ PURCHACES OF YAMADIUN-RSARINO. OR OUR USTITY OF FERROVAKADI OM
\) 1945 3,523.18 dry tons. d :

Tear Lbs. ¥
1945 101,383.62 | 40

144

| fol. 141]
In Unitep States District Courr

PuLaintiFFs’ Exuisir No. 33

United States Vanadium Corp.
New York City

September 14, 193s

Outside Vanadium Ore Production

Mr. Blair Burwell
United States Vanadium Corp.
Uravan, Colorado

Dear Blair:

As I discussed with you the other night on the telephone,
it has become very important that we find out accurately
and definitely who is producing vanadium ore and where
it is going. Along with this, we want to know the quality
of the ore shipped so that we can get a line on the pounds
of V.O;. I realize that some of the quality will have to be
estimated, but we ought to get a very aceurate line on what
the shipments have been from southeastern Utah and south-
western Colorado. We may have to do something about this
production, and if information could be obtained on what
they get for this ore, it would help out. For instanee—
Harbison told me that he received 42¢ per pound for V.O
and 60¢ per pound for U,O, on a low-grade Polar Mesa ore,
but if the V.O, went over 7%, and the U.O, over 26, he
received 45¢ per pound of V.O, and S0¢ per pound for U,Q..
These are pretty high prices for us, but it ay be necessary
to finally do something about it.

I have an idea that this production of ore which is going
to Europe and Japan is quite a quantity of V_O., and more
than we think it is. IT have been talking about this for some
time here in New York, stating that the high prices main-
tained for V.O, in Europe invite and stimulate this kind
of competition and can eventually support a considerable
vanadium business, with possibly later on a plant.

145

In this respect I have had some correspondence with
King about the application made by Balsley and Kipe for
a freight rate on vanadium ore to Casticton, N. Y. where
it is claimed the ore will be reduced. We cannot get any
line on this plan here, and at Castleton there is no plant
now available for this kind of work.

I hope you will be able to put somebody on this and make
a very careful canvass of the situation. If you could have
a talk personaly with Balsley you could probably tind out
all about it. In talking to Balsley it would be to his ad-
vantage to give you this ihformation beeause L have an idea
that he is not making any too much money out of this busi-
ness, and it might be made easier for him on some kind of
a combination with us if we decide to do something about it,
rather than to fight it. We could, of course, run all this
business out—but it would not be good policy to hint of
this or threaten.

In this connection, | would like to have a line on the
Shattuck Chemical Company production. They are selling
fused oxide not only in this country, but in Europe. Their
oxide is low-grade containing only a little over 50% V.O.,
{fol. 142] but they are selling it for less money. I have an
idea their production is about 25 tons of fused oxide a year,
but you may be able to get a closer line on this. From the
record, you will be able to gather on the shipments to Vitro,
we can get a line on their production of V.Q..

I have a pretty good line on the production of vanadium
in Mammoth, Arizona, as it is all sold through a friend of
mine here in New York.

Will you please sce what you can do about this for me.
Very truly yours,

J.R. Van Fleet/mm
1c

146

[fol. 143]
In Unitep Srates District Court

PiarntiFFs’ Exuisit No. 34
{Handwritten notations—Vanadium Situations—Extra]

General Mining Department
New York City
September 19, 1938
Mr. F. P. Gormely

Room 1813

Building

Mr. J. D. Swain Competitive Vanadium Ore
Mr. W. H. Sneath Production

Dear Mr. Gormely:

A preliminary investigation of the vanadium ore produc-
tion in southeastern Utah and southwestern Colorado has
been made. The investigation is being continued and will
be made complete at a later date. Preliminary figures indi-
cate that the V.O, content of the ore which has been shipped
already this year up to September Ist amounts to approxi-
mately 225,100 Ibs. It is thought that for the balance of
this year production will be at about the same rate, and the
total ore production will amount to approximately 338,000
pounds contained V.O,.

The preliminary report docs not give exports to Europe,
bui 7 cars containing 34,000 Ibs. V.O, have been shipped to
Japan already this year. An approximate list of these
shipments to September 1, 1938 follows:

Japan 7 cars 34,000 Ibs. V.O,
Vitro Mfg. Co. ,.' ime be | | ile .
Shattuck Chemical Co. oat, 5,600 * -
North Continent Mining Co. (Produced) 40,000 “ “
Misceilaneous 20,000 * ”

225,100 “ ve

147

The 7 ears of ore which were sent to Japan were pro-
duced from the Temple Mountain, Yellow Cat and Polar
Mesa properties in southeastern Utah. A Japanese outfit
started to build a mill at Temple Mountain to concentrate
ore from the many dumps. They worked about 60 days,
apparently ran out of money and left the property—leaving
unpaid bills. The ore shipped from Yellow Cat and Polar
Mesa was purchased from the operators of those properties.

The Vitro Manufacturing Company has purchased 29 cars
containing 125,500 lbs. V.O,. This ore also contains better
than 2% U.O.. The Vitro Manufacturing Company process
this ore from the uranium and sell the vanadium residue
in some convenient form, recently reported as being fused
oxide. It is not known at present where this vanadium goes,
About half of these 29 cars have been produced at Polar
Mesa by Harbison and Kipe. They receive high prices for
this ore, viz., 45¢ per pound of V.O, and 80¢ per pound of
UO. contained in the ore. Vitro pays the freight from
Utah.

(fol. 144] The Shattuck Chemical Company of Denver has
purchased 2 cars of rather low-grade ore containing 95,600
Ibs. of V.O,. These 2 cars were specially selected uranium
ore and contained higher uranium in proportion to V0,
than most shipments.

The North Continent Mining Company has a small plant
in the Paradox Valley and has produced about 40,000 Ibs. of
VO, so far this year. This production is sent to the Shat-
tuck Chemical Company in Denver. This production of the
North Continent Mining Company purchased by Shattuck
rather checks previous information that Shattuck Chemical
Company produces and markets between 50,000 and 75,000
lbs. of V.O, yearly. They put this in the form of fused
vanadium oxide with varying degrees of purity and con-
taining from 51 to 75% V.O:.

There has been an estimated miscellancous production
of approximately 20,000 Ibs. V.O, from various sources.

If the production for the rest of 1938 is in proportion, the
entire 1938 production will amount to approximately 338,000
lbs. contained V.O, from these ore sources.

148

The Mammoth Mine in Arizona has an appreciable pro-
duction of vanadium. Several years ago the Molybdenum
Corporation of America built a mill at Mammoth with which
to process ores extracted from the New Year and Mohawk
properties. They entered into a contract with the owners
of the Mammoth mine adjoining, to also treat ores from
that mine. The treatment and recoveries were not satis-
factory to Mammoth. Consequently, about January 1, 1938
Mammoth purehased the mill from the Molybdenum Cor-
poration and took over the milling operation. Concentrates
are made in this mill containing gold, lead, molybdenum and
vanadium. The concentrates contain about 5° VQ. and
7% MoQ,.

We have looked over this operation, obtained samples
of concentrates and are able to cheek up fairly weil the
production. The present capacity of the Mammoth mill
would yield approximately 100,000 Ibs. V.O, vearly, which
checks closely with the 1987 production amounting to 90,000
Ibs. V.O, purchased by Assofiated Metals and Minerals
Company.

The Mammoth mine is owned by Llovd-Smith, owner of
Time, Life and Fortune magazines, and it is incorporated
under the name of Mammoth Saint Anthony Company.
Foster Naething is the General Manager of this company
and is a very competent mining engineer.

If we add this 100,000 Ibs. V.O, to the competitive ore
production listed above, the total competitive production
for 1938 will be approximately 458,000 Ibs. V.O.. There are
many attractive occurrences of carnotite ore in the South-
west, and the production could easily be twice as much—
given adequate financing and management.

(fol. 145] One potential producer of V.O. is the Anaconda
Copper Company. In Idaho they preduce phosphate rock,
moving it to Anaconda, Montana for processing into fer-
tilizer and phosphoric acid. The plant for this purpose at
Anaconda is in connection with the smelter where they
obtain cheap acid. This phosphate rock all contains a small
amount of vanadium, and a process has been developed for
recovering the vanadium from the phosphoric acid solution.

149

They expected to be producing vanadium this vear, after
installing equipment costing about $200,000, but they did
not feel inelined to proceed with this expenditure this year.
] imagine when business is better they will begin producing
fused oxide. It is estimated that this plant will produce
approximately 100000 Tbs. VO yearly, and we have agreed
to purchase the output,

The International Vanadium Corporation has taken over
the lead vanadate property at Dripping Springs, Arizona.
It ix now being managed by one de Villiers, whe was for
a time employed at Rhodesian Broken Hills. The companys
is now well finaneed and the plan is to produes lead vanadate
concentrates containing 17% V.O.. de Villiers elaims that
he can do this for 19 per pound of VO), producing 4 tons
of concentrates per day. This production, if earried through.
would amount to approximately 40,000 Ths. VO monthly,
or 480,000 Ibs. vearly. They expeet to be in production in
about 3 months.

E have reeently made two visits to Dripping Springs and
one of our field engineers has sampled the Dripping Springs
mine. We have paid particular attention to this operation
from its inception several vears ago. We could never cheek
the quality or quantity of ore claimed. The last sampling,
which was very comprehensive, confirmed our previous
impression, and we cannot see how a profitable operation
ean be maintained at this place. The ore is entirely too
low-grade—containing approximately 20% VO. with a
small tonnage. There will be however, some concentrates
made at this place, as in the past, but we anticipate that
after a few months this operation will have te close.

For the last two vears we have been making a compre
hensive investigation of all vanadium reseurees in the
Southwest. whieh we expeet to finish this season. Several
attempts have been made to ereet small roasters, mills and
other equipment for processing these ores on a small scale,
Se far all of these attempts have met with failure. Ther
i.

Receipt is acknowledged of your letter dated February 24,
in which you submit us yeur proposal for four carloads of
Black Vanadium Oxide at the contract price of $1.10 per
pound contained V.O, f.0.b. your works, Bridgeville, Penn-
sylvania with freight charges allowed to destination, unless
such freight charges are in excess of the rate to St. Louis,
Missouri. In such case freight charges to St. Louis will
be allowed.

We have submitted your proposal to our buyers and have
been informed that our price is out of line with current
market offerings. From what we have been able to ascer-
tain in our subsequent discussions, the oxide would have
to be made available to us around $1.00 to $1.05 in order
to permit doing the business. We would thank you to give
consideration to a revision in your price te conform with
the price indicated above as we believe prospects appear
favorable for doing the business at our indicated figure.

Very truly yours,

CONTINENTAL Ore Company

/s/ Joeu A. Mrreu
J. A. Mirel
JAM /vi

[Stamp--Mar. 10, 1947—Sales Dept.]

181
[ fol. 178]

|Stamp—Teo WAM)\—GL, —JBG\ —JHM, —RHUF \y
AJS\/—Return to JBG}

| Handwritten notation—file |
March 13, 1947

Continental Ore Company
500 Fifth Avenue
New York 18, New York

Attention: Mr. J. A. Mirel

Gentlemen:

With reference to your letter of March 7 relative to our
offer to sell Black Vanadium Oxide Fused, we regret that
you are not interested in our proposal for the sale of this
material at $1.10 per pound contained V.O, as quoted in
our letter of February 24.

We are not prepared at this time to consider making a
reduction in our current prices. ;

Very truly yours,
John B. Girdler
Assistant General Manager of Sales

JBG:HK

In Unirep States Districr Courr
Puaintirrs’ Exutsir No. 111

| Letterhead of Climax Molybdenum Company,
New work, New York |

February 10, 1945

Mr. Henry J. Leir, President
Continental Ore Company
O00 Fifth Avenue

New York. N.Y.

Subject: Ferrovanadium
Dear Sir:

In reply to your letter of February Sth we herewith
submit to vou, in duplicate, the following contract offer with
the understanding that your acceptance at the place desig-
nated therefor at the bottom hereof shall constitute a
mi ctual binding agreement between us, our successors and

-7L 342,025.25
1,115,597.01 824,513.00 232,013.22
973,063.90 732, T5169 230,310.95 =
2,£2!:, 303.02 1,277, 095.22 5AC 453.40 =
1,709,554.32 54h, 288.86 765,305.05 |:
2,506,129.30 1,090, 222.39 1,407,316. =
2,532, 01 .% 1,198, 912.96 1,332,902-20 >
BACK, 7675 «3,073, 463655 1,320,908.20
&, 310,215.81 3,007 ,253.16 $33,560.65 =
5,41, 423.72 & 753,997 027 707,436.55 =
3,890,539.05 2,053,031.09 1,002,953.06 =
2,60), 3662 1,972,421.00 634,452.62 =
2,270,02)9.07 2,454,002.20 li s,775-13 ;

&, 302,154.03 3,152,€33.31 1,149,4L5.77

+t)

HLic 18d]

LUO) LORELSIG, SALVE GHLIN PONY

EXHIBIT IX

YEARLY TOTAL COST (INCLUDING PROPORTION OF GENERAL
ADUIBISTRTIVE AND SULLING FXPENES') OF ALL VARADI IE
JNO ORANIUN PRODUCTS AND THEIR RFSPFCTIVE COMPOUNDS
AND TOTAL VALUE OF CALFS REALIZED TUERPFROY — YFARS

70.7
= ata %

year Tot#l Cort frles Value
1933 r1, 389,933 $1,235,641
1934 , 546,518 1,502,004
1935 22 348,128 1,523,689
1936 1,655,717 2,198,957
1937 129, °7% 3,157,734
1938 1, 276,871 2,569,591
1939 2,951,519 4,879,016
1949 3,063,910 5,054, 587
1941 4,620 155 7,680,176
1942 6,320,550 8,574,993
1943 2,443,468 3,996,464
1944 5,306,279 6,886,049
1945 39235,019 3,992,324
1946 2,133,027 taizeod cn5 portion will be arilycc’ by the buyor, one by the
ecllor en4 a third persica ili bo rotaincd for anrlycis dy LeCouz & Company es
t=pire eh-—=‘st in tho ovent buyer and sellor are unable to agree on their rosulte

odtaines frea the jJoind ocomilo.

The buyer and ecoller, in their respective lebcratories, will analyse their
portion of the joins es=mle, and, if the resulte obtai nod by each laboratory ere in
01059 egre-—-a8 with tho analysis on which the material was billed, no edjustrsnt

will be xr*s.

R In the event of a wide discrepancy in the results obtained dy the rese-
pective laboratories on said e=ple or in the event of a dispute, Messrs. Ledour &
Company eb=l) analyse tho retaincy your ir.
MelNNeill and further development work on our part will prove
to be satisfuctory for all crades.

As you know, we sent you our check for one-half of
your original invoice for the first four cars and in early
February you will receive chece for the balunce dus.

. You are authorized to ship us for receipt ‘n early
February and for Varch account one car of the higher grade oxide
in conformity with Iir. MoNeill's letter of December 27, 1955.

Immediately after running this car through our oper-
ations, I shall be pleased to com-unicate with you with respect
to results obteined and at the same time discuss with you the
cuestion of further deliveries.

Yours very truly,

eZ

Preaident.

Copy «-? P.J.S5.

November 7, 19%

Mre J. Ve Price, President,

Sleetro Metallurgical Sales Corporation,
3O East 42nd Street,

New York City.

Dear Nr. Price:

This will confirm my statement over the
phone to you this afternoon to the effect that we will
accept imrediate shipment of two cars of Vanadium Oxide
under the existing contract.

It will also confirm my additional state-
ment that I would be dropping in to see you either to-
morrow or Friday or early next week to disaues the bal-
anoe aue ano other mattore,

@
Yours vwery truly,

(eit a

President.

Copy to P.J.G.

Use de bAs 110s... cceccessceenes

ELECTRO METALLURGICAL COMPANY
3O CASY a2ee S~ RELY

FH. HaeogRreon NEW YORA
eaceiecar

November 1E&, 19.5.

kr. E. D. Bransore,
President, Vanadium Corporation of Amcrica,
120 Broadway,
New York, N. Y.
Dear Kr. Fransonmet
I expect that we will be
getting s. touch with you sometime within the
next ten days with regard to the price on Oxide.

Very truly yours,

a a

\ \ es
Ay ¢ . es
METALLURGICAL service CABLE ADOSENS PERROALL OV :
OoLurveR SuUNDmNs. PITTSBUROK PA CODES WESTERF UMN AND LISBERD
ELECTRO METALLURGICAL SALES CORPORATION
Unit of Union Carbide and Carbon Corporation
M
h i DISTRIBUTORS “ELECTROMET™ BRAND
\ FERRO-ALLOYS AND OTHER ELECTRO METALLURGICAL PRODUCTS

adage 82 CARBIDE AND CARBON BUILDING
61 EL 30 EAST 42ND STREET, NEW YORK

At

e . November 172th, 1°74,
\ “ae
A “i

ate A. A. Corcy, Jr., Presicent,
Vanec Lum Coroorst!on of Averter,
12? Oro: Awey,

Noo Yor", | ee Za

Necr Nr. Coreys

Confirminep convereration had with you in my office on Friday of
last wee-, nieere be acviced that we are arrenginr to ship to vour rorks be-
tween n-w and December Zlet three edditioneal cerloads of vanediun oxide to
coply efeins*t our controct N-19970, wich consletes the minimum of 1,9299,09)
sounds of oxide due on th’s contract. The terns to epnly on these three edci-
tionel cerlords rill be 39-80-20 deys from January lst.

We are elso arrenging to ship you an additional 250,990 pounds of

th's oxide curing the mont»s of April, ‘lay and June, 1925 with the reruler

*“erns es ortlinec ‘n the contrect applying and et the orice stipulated im t': ALLOY, W.VA.> OLEN FIDUUS, W.VA.- MOLCOMB ROC... ~

OLIVER SURDIe. prTTSDUREX PA CODES WEOTERE UMC AND UZBERE

LCi. METALLURGICAL SALES CORPORATION

Unit of Union Carbide and Carbon Corporation
C3
DISTRIBUTORS “ELECTROMET™ BRAND
FERRO-ALLOYS AND OTHER ELECTRO METALLURGICAL PRODUCTS

CARBIDE AND CARBON BUILDING
30 EAST 42ND STREET. NEW YORK

April 2nd, 1925.

ae
\ \e
A
Mr. A. A. Corey, Jr., President /
Vanedium Corvoretion of America
120 Broecway

New York, N. Y.
Dear Mr. Corey:

Pursuent to my letter of September 15, 1938 and
confirming the conversetion hec with the writer in my off ce
this morning, we will extend *he delivery dete of the 259,99
pounds of vanedium oxide still due on your contrect to *he
third end fourth cuarters of this year insteac of shioment
being made in the second onerter.

you!

lee

As arranged thie morning, a cer of *his oxide wil)
be shioped in eech of the foll winp rorths: July, Sentenher and
December, 195.

Assuring yo of our slersire in betnge able *o neve
this change for you, I an, with kind rerarcs

° Very truly yours,

y Py

(. , eg * AE

| / i : ——s
Predicent

J

J¥>: AP

24 5, 1955

x. ie Price, iresident, ™
Elee =o weteliurgical Sales Corporation, sa Pe
oC Re «2nc Street,

Deer i~e Frice:

This morning J have your confirmation of
our verbel arrangement with respect to the remaining 250,000
pounds of vanadium oxide under our contract, dated September

, & a"
~~: ~ we

‘Ye appreciate your action in this matter very
much indeed.

Youre very truly,

President.

4
40

6. J. & 0.239. —— Vv

hovember 15, 1935

ire Fe Fe Haggerson, President,
Zleetro vetellurciceal Company,
3O Tast 42nd ctreet,

Tew York, te Yo

Dear -‘r. Harcgerson:

Please do not think I a= hurrying you
as there is no real rush adout getting a price on Oxide,
but it nappened *o be an item of unfinished business and
I am wontering if you heave hd a chance to e:rive at any
conclusions ec yote

Very truly yours,

WAS

irae as

‘OI

i resicent.

(+(

cars © 6 @. @.

. (amy acon 2. *PERROALLOV? u J, EX. KO. STC os wees Fide

. ELECTRO METALLURGICAL SALES CORPORATION

CARBIDE AND CARBON BUILDING. NEW YORK
@ermevress -EL.ecrRowEgr-
AND OTHER ELECTRO-METALLURGICAL PROOUCTS *

Carcee seewre
& 2. CAVING © COMPANY. QULLITY BUILDING. PHILaAcEL PNA
CCHIBAS. WILLJANS © COMPANY. PITTSBURG. CiMCINMAT!. CHICAGO. SY. LOUIS. DETROIT. CLEVELAND. NEW YORE. PHILADELPHIA.

MEMORANDUM OF SALE comrrmacr wo.)-1Q.7C

11 OvPrrcare, Jurmery srd - 36.

Eascreo MevauivesicaL SAice CORPORATION A CORPORATION OF NEW YORK NERESY AGREES TO Of. ANNO

Vane@ius Corporetion of Arwrice __ og __Kew York, N, Y. meneev seneee TO euv

A minimm of 250,000 pounds tut not over 6 meximum of 375,000 no -~'s tobe oo tamn.

wareatat | “ELECTROLAT® Brand Venedium Pentoxide (Vp05) - Speci ficetions as per letter
atteched.

price Righty cents (80g) per pound of V90., f.0.d. care at Sallar’s works or warehouses,
with freight charges allowed to Bridgeville, Pea., surcharge for Buyer's sccount.

TERMS Bet cash thirty (30) days fram dete of inwice.

neuiveny | Ae required, in es nearly equal mnthly quantities from cate to Decender Uist, 1956
' incluai ve.

REMANE® | Seo letter attached whid is pursuant to md part of this contract.

©
we

Payments to be made in U. S. lawful currency with exchange on New York. Each delivery to constitute a separate independent
contract and to be governed by the terms hereof. Works’ tests of the Manufacturer of sad material to govern settlements.

All agreements of the Seller herein are subject to and contingent upon strikes, riot, war, commandeering of requisitioning of allot-
ing to others in priority to the Buyer by the Government, invasion. fre, explosion. accident, delays in procuring sufficient and suitable raw
materials, curtailment of failure in obtaining sufficient electrical power, delays of carriers, and/or other delays beyond the reasonable
contro! of the Seller and/or the Manefacturer, affecting either the Seller and/or the Manufacturer of such ferro-alloy, PROVIDED,
HOWEVER, that in case of and upon happening of any such event whereby the tutal output of the Manufacturer's plants of ferro-
alloys and/or other products which the said’ plants are or may be then engaged in producing. is curtailed, of @ portion or all ofvsaid
output is commandeered of requisitioned of allotted to others in priority to the Buyer by the Government, then the Seller shall use its
best efforts to fairly and equitably pro rate any ferro-alloys, which may be produced at said plants and which are not commandeered or
requisitioned or allotted to others in priority to the Buyer by the Government, between the Buyer and its other customers of ferro-alloys

‘ pemere | 4 7 dee n+ -f the mantiontae facen atlaw ta he delivered ta the Buver and

- —-

| fol. 22+ |
Ix Unirep States Districr Courr
lexcErprs FROM Prainrives’ Exutprr No. 47
FOR LDEN TIFICATION
SpeEcIAL Report
ON
VANADIUM
C.K. MacQuigg

June 1935

[fol. 225 | INDEX
SUBJECT PAGE NO.
Aluminum 13, 14, 1a 27. 18.
Appendix, correspondence on
vanadium— 44 et seq.
Automobile, steels used in the—- 49 to 52 inclusive.
Castings, vanadium in steel—- 10, 25, 45.
Cast Lron MM, 21. 22. 39, 45, 46.
Catalyst 40)
Cleanliness of Steel 17
Conclusions 42
Costs, steels- Bey Bas Ee;

* vanadium— 23
Dveing of Leather 3M
Keonomies a es 04.0 36, Ff = oo; 41,

42,48,53 to 61 inclusive.
Equilibrium, effect of vanadium
on— 6

SUBJECT

Fatigue of Steels, effect of
vanadium on-—

Figures—1 and 2

(Girain Size in Steels, effeets of

High Speed Steels, vanadium
in—

Mechanical Properties (
Merit Index

Non-Ferrous
Opinions-of Vanadium Steel
Profits

Railway Steels, vanadium in—-
Recommendations
Research Program

Scavenging Action of

Vanadium

Selling Prices

Springs

Statisties

[ fol. 226]

Tables, I
I]
III e
IV
y
VI
Via
VII
VIII

Toughener, molybdenum and
Vanadium as-—

Worth, of steels—

231

PAGE NO.

6

Last two pages of
Appendix.

16, 47.

18, 19, 44.

g

9, 11, 19, 24.
22, 40.

11

ah, Ob. Oo. 4:
26, 45.

43

39

4,30, 33: 14, To.

25 Py Gh, BO, By Ol

4, 48,

ol, 32, 34, 37, 46, 47, 48, 53
to 61 inclusive.

g
3, 11, 19, 24.

232

[fol, 227]

REPORT ON VANADIUM
by

C. kb. MaeQuigg

UNION CARBIDE AND CARBON RESEARCH
LABORATORIES, INC.

30 East 42nd Street,

New York City.

June 1935

Synopsis

The study that is the subject of this Report was made to
correlate the information available on the question of
vanadium production and markets in the United States
today. Particular emphasis has been laid on the metal-
lurgical uses of vanadium, and certain conelusions drawn
regarding the probable trend of the future market.

The conclusion is drawn that a material reduction in
selling price will be necessary to stimulate, or even to
maintain, vanadium in its position as an alloying element.
A tentative selling price is suggested after a review of the
vanadium economics of the Electro Metallurgical Company.

{ fol. 228]

VANADIUM MARKET POSSIBILITIES

INTRODUCTION:

The ability to decide as important and complicated a
question as the matter of the Corporation’s policy on vana-
dium obviously requires a knowledge of all the facts, in-
cluding the newest ones bearing on the subject. Some of

999
eat

these facts have been obtained and arranged under the
following headings:

I METALLURGICAL ADVANTAGES RESPECT-
ING THE USE OF VANADIUM

This is a subject upon which there is much informa.
tion and well-defined opinion, and it is realized that
we ourselves are not un-informed on the matter: how-
ever, it is worth while to re-examine the faets aud
opinions extant af present, since there is evidence that
the favor with which alloys are regarded changes trom
time to time—somewhat like the “change of style” in
other commodities. This leads to a changing emphasis
Which follows in part the new developments im require-
ments, and in part the successful sales propaganda.

II. ECONOMICS OF A “COME-BACK” FOR VA-
NADIUM. COST OF PRODUCTION AND PROB-
ABLE MARKET VALUE AT THE STEEL MILL

In this section, the production costs and sales prices
are discussed in an attempt to determine how far a
»)

| fol. 229] eut in prices could be expected to go without
rendering the manufacture and sale unprofitable to the
Corporation. This material enables a conclusion to be
drawn concerning the ability to win back the market
already lost.

IH]. NEW POSSIBILITIES FOR EXPANDING

e THE MARKET INO METALLURGY AND FOR
OTHER USES IN TECHNOLOGY. CONCLUSIONS
AND RECOMMENDATIONS

Markets other than the use in steel are considered
for expanding the consumption of vanadium. Possibili-
ties of different methods of utilization for metallurgical
purposes are also developed. Conclusions are drawn,
and recommendations made.

IV. APPENDIX. COLLATERAL INFORMATION

Data are shown respecting the economics of the
vanadium situation.

234

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS:

The writer is indebted to Mr. Van Fleet for assistance
on production costs, and to Mr. Critechett for helpful
criticism.

—3—
[ fol. 230]
I. METALLURGICAL ADVANTAGES RESPECTING
THE USE OF VANADIUM

It may be recalled that a survey of the automobile indus-
try was made in 1931. At that time it was learned that the
unbiased views of the automobile metallurgists indicated
that vanadium was on the way out, the reason being that
it was too costly; other combinations, such as molybdenum
steels and silico-manganese, were able to perform satis-
factorily and at a considerable saving in cost to the car
builder. At that time there was little or no indication that
other alloy combinations were better than vanadium, but
simply that they would perform satisfactorily and were
much cheaper. Since the time of the survey mentioned,
still further reduction in the use of vanadium has taken
place, and it is hardly too much to say that its large-scale
use in the automobile industry is now practically eliminated.
Doubt has been expressed as to whether the preference
today might still be for vanadium—even though the price
differential were reduced or eliminated—and this justifies
some study of whether the “style” in metallurgical thought
has altered and the former real or fancied advantages of
vanadium would now be admitted. These remarks apply
to all types of steels utilized in the automobile, but it should
be pointed out that the last stand of vanadium was in
springs. The present status with respect to vanadium in
the automobile is summarized by Table Vla in the Ap-
pendix, which was prepared by Mr. R. C. Good.

It will be noted that the metallurgists of the Vanadium
Corporation of America stresses the beneficial effect of
—t—

(fol. 231] vanadium on the qualities of springs; in our

'“Summary of the Present Status of Vanadium Steels in the
Automobile Industry,” by C. E. MacQuigg and S. C. DuTot. May
11, 1931.

oF

wt)

report’ made in 1931, the matter of vanadium springs was
earefully looked into, and at that time the situation was
not particularly pleasing, nor was the outlook reassuring
as to future developments. For example:

“Leaf springs: From an unsatisfactory interview at
the Mather Spring Company in Toledo, it was gathered
that vanadium steel was largely used for leaf springs
in automobiles; however, with few exceptions it was
later found that silico-manganese was used and that
Mather’s business must be chiefly in other lines (pos-
sibly railroad). There is also a tendency to use plain
carbon steel in some of the leaves and the alloyed stee]
in the main leaf only. It was learned that Hupp is
changing to a new steel with manganese 0.75 to 0.95
and 1.0 to 1.20°C chromium. This steel was recom-
mended by the Mather Company and is cheaper than
chrome-vanadium. (We were led to believe that) the
steel was worked out by Timken metallurgists, as Mr.
Mather is a Director of the Timken Company.) This
information would lead to the conelusion that the
Mather Company—who apparently were the avowed:
champions of the vanadium bearing springs—were also

_ seeking cheaper substitutes. It was learned elsewhere
that the prineipal reasons for the Mather predilection
for vanadium springs were that their shop praetice and
heat-treating equipment were built up around the
chrome-vanadium steels.

As will be seen from the summary, Chevrolet) consti-
tutes about the only large-scale user of chrome-vana-
dium steel in springs. It is proving entirely satisfac-
tory, but Mr. Spear, the Metallurgist. is looking for a
cheaper steel. A pertinent portion of the detailed: re-
port on the Chevrolet: interview is quoted: ‘As a
matter of fact, the chrome-Vanadium is now out of
the leaf springs in the truck, and it would have lost
out in the passenger car also were it not for the fact
that they might have to increase the weight of the
spring slightly and since this is tied in with riding

1MacQuigg and DuTot, loc. cit., pages 5 and 6.

236

quality they hesitate to make the change; however, as
soon as the spring designer can bring out a little better
spring so that they ean lighten its weight, they will
discard chrome-vanadium.’

One car advertises chrome-vanadium leaf springs but
does not use it because it costs too much!

Coiled springs: The situation with respect to coiled
springs presents a number of different angles and is
more involved than with the other components studied.
Influences adverse to vanadium have resulted from
several causes and these have combined to greatly
reduce its consumption in spring wire. As estimated
ai

[fol. 282] by Mr. Pickwell of the Gibson Spring Com-
pany in Chicago, they are ‘not making 1°20 or 1 25
of the vanadium coiled springs they made three years
ago.’ Briefly stated, the adverse influences are:

(a) Swedish carbon steel has been making great in-
roads quite recently. The Swedish interests have
brought their design and manufacturing experts to this
country to work with the American customers and then
have striven in every way to meet the requirements of
the trade. This effort has no doubt stimulated the
American stee! makers, with the net result that coiled
spring wire (plain carbon) may be purchased with a
feeling of assured quality. From two sources it was
learned that the Swedish carbon spring steel also has
a better surface than the chrome-vanadium. Duplicate
test specimens are cut from each end of a coil of the
carbon steel wire and are tested for quality by coiling,
and experience has shown that this is adequate. On the
other hand, the chrome-vanadium is not so uniform
and the acceptance tests need to be much more com
prehensive.

(b) Chrome-vanadium has not been as free from sur-
face defects as has the carbon steel. There was a
tendency to place the blame for this on the steel] makers
who apparently do not or cannot properly deseam their

go”?
wt

billets. Swedish chrome-vanadiume steel has better sur
face and is found superior to the domestic product,

(c) A further complaint against chrome vanadium
spring wire was that it is net obtainable in heat
treated condition. While the imitial cost of the chrome
vanadium versus the carbon steel is about equal —in
fact, it is in faver of the chrome-vanadiam-—the tina!
cost Is nearly two to one in faver of the carbon steel,
since the latter is bought in its finished heat-treated
state and needs only to be wound inte the required helix
and given a light tempering to remove working strains.

(d) In most cases the carbon steel has proved satis
factory, and being much cheaper it is naturally used
by the spring maker when he is not tied down spe
cifically to chrome-vanadiam by the purchase specitica
tions. In some cases as in the aircraft mdustry (ai
cooled engines) the chrome-vanadium wire is still pre
ferred. A few minor uses from the tonnage standpoint,
as in cluteh springs. still prevail.

One spring metallurgist stated that chrome vanadium
might come baek if ci) the American makers wouid
use greater care in its manufacture, and (ii) the cost
were sufficiently lower to prave competitive.”

The subject has not been further investigated at th
®present moment, but it is thought that no general mereas:
in the consumption of vanadium in spring manutacture
has taken place, nor is indicated as being about to take
place.

pan Sexe

fo]. 283) The writings of numerous recognized author:
ties were consulted, and their views pre and con were
abstracted to give a cross-section of what the literature
contains as a result of laboratory and practical experiences:

Moore’ found that the addition of vanadium te a plain
carbon steel did not raise the endurance limit te an

> “Resistance of Metals to Repeated Static and Impact Stresses.”
R. R. Moore, A.S.T.M. Vol. 24.

238

appreciable degree. His vanadium steel, however, did
have a high Izod value. On the other hamd. the vana-
dium steel with a different heat treatment*had an Izod
Value five times that of the plain carbon steel whereas
its endurance limit was Jess,

Oya’ has studied the equilibrium diagram of the iron-
Vanadium system, and concludes that these metals form
an obbroken series of solid solutions. With the addi-
tion of vanadium, the A, transformation is lowered:
A, is raised, so that the two curves meet at 25°) vana-
dium to form a continuous phase boundary. The A.
point is raised gradually at first up to maximum at
nearly 15 vanadium, then rapidly lowered until it
reaches room temperature in an alloy containing nearly
$0 vanadinm. Solubility of carbon in gamma solid
solution is markedly decreased by addition of vana
dium. The A, point—that is, the eutectoid temperature
—is raised 15° in the iron iron-earbide system by the
addition of 0.5 vanadium. (Vanadium operates to
widen the heat treatment temperature ranges of
steels.)

Losana states that vanadium acevlerates the corrosion
of steel at high temperatures in air and in internal
combustion engine exhaust gases.

The mechanical properties of carbon-vanadium cast.
ings are generally superior to those of plain carbon
steels, but there is little advantage in shock value.’
Also, it is better to normalize than to anneal.

Steels containing 0.14 and 0.30 vanadium were eom-
pare as regards tensile properties with plain strue.
tural steel, nickel-chromium and chrome-vanadium

*“Science Reports of Tohoku Imperial University,” Vol. 19. See
also the Transactions of the British Tron and Steel Institute, 1930,
Part Il. p. 626A.

* “Corrosion of Steels at High Temperatures.” L. Losana. British
Jron and Steel Institute, 1931, Part I, p. 727A.

‘Knowlton. AS.S.T. Transactions, September 1927, Vol. 12. p.
482.

wg

es

a
(fol. 234] steels.) Vanadium was found to raise the
elastic limit and ultimete strength, and 4o lowerthe
elongation, contractions and notch toughness. Raeme
of the quenching temperature affects all these prop
erties in the same, direction respectividy. Nickel
chromium steels are equal ino strength te chrome: .
vafiadium steels where small sections are concerned.
but are superior if the section is heavy. 7 «

With the exeeption of the sales propagaudit of the Vana-
dium Corperation of America, the rows of laboratory,
tests have not always been uniformly tavorall to the use
of vanadium in steels. Its chief recommendations for use
have been the following two: (2) The ability te widen the
range of heat treatment and thus lessen the “touchimes“Wanadium in Structural Steels.” R. anaes? er A. Grutzner
British Iron and Stee) Institute, 1925, Part 1. aSO.A. See also
Stahl und Eisen for December 1s, 1924. Vol. i pp. Wislsa7

240

competition with the other well-established deoxidizers for
such a purpose only. At any likely cost, therefore, vana-
dium would seem to fail as a serious competitor for the
deoxidizer business as such, although it will always have
that added merit.

Next consider the toughening quality of vanadium when
added to steel, especially heavy castings. This is no doubt
the greatest single asset from vanadium additions. In a
later section, it will be shown that this is probably the
greatest stronghold of vanadium today. Vanadium with
chromium or nickel has a peculiar merit which cannot be
successfully controverted; here again there is a rift in
the lute, inasmuch as molybdenum has been gaining in favor
as a toughener of steel. It is the writer's reasoned judgment
that molybdenum is not as effective a toughener of high
strength steel as is vanadium, but it is so nearly com-
parable that the approach to parity of the two classes of
steels will operate to require just that much more effort
to maintain vanadium as a competitor.

It is difficult to compare steels of different analyses
for their intrinsic worth or usefulness. Several methods’
have been suggested for making such comparisons; the chief
difficulty results from the fact that applications differ to
some extent respecting the quality of the steel considered
of greatest importance. For example, a rivet steel must

ra Se
[fol. 256] be ductile, ard although strength would also be
desirable, ductility must come first. On the other hand, a
cutting tool must be hard above other properties; never-
theless, ductility cannot be entirely sacrificed.

Some comparisons of wrought chrome-molybdenum,
chrome-vanadium and chromium-nickel steel? have been
made and are shown in Table I. This method makes use of
a purely empirical formula which serves to arbitrarily set
down a so-called “merit index.” This merit index is ob-

*“Chrome and Nickel-Molybdenum Steels,” C. N. Dawe, Iron
AGE for March 16, 1922, Vol. 109, p. 725.

“Evaluation of the Technical Worth of A Steel from Physical
Test Data,” A. B. Kinzel, A.S.M.E. 192s.

7C.N. Dawe and A. B. Kinzel, loe. cit.

241

tained by adding together the yield point and maximum
stress, multiplying that figure by one-half the elongation
in 2 in., and dividing therresult by 100 minus the reduction
of area. In the original article the author, C. N. Dawe,
shows results obtained on forged steels of the analyses
noted and for different sized bars. The 2 in. square section
was selected for reproduction here because it: would tend
to favorably accent the good obtained from vanadium re-
specting its toughening effect. Ductility, however, does not
seem to be favorably influenced by vanadium as against
molybdenum additions. This is true tor all of the heat
treatments noted, in which the molybdenum produced better
results. (Mr. Dawe at the time of the publication of his
test data was a metallurgist for the Studebaker Corpora
tion, and it is presumed that the tests shown were the
result of unprejudiced experimentation. )

Following the same methed of caleulation in Table I,
the writer made some comparisons of the properties of cast
steels containing different alloying elements, the tensile
properties being taken from reliable sources.’ Here again
the merit indices were ealeulated by Dawe’s formula, and

—10—¥«
(fol. 237) again attention is called to the fact that no par-
ticular brief is held for this type of calculation except that
it does enable the visualization of all four of the mechanical
properties between given steels by comparison of gigle
figures. It may be claimed that this metliod Is unfair in that
it fails to properly accent one or more given qualities which
possibly should be accented for a given applieation. No par-
ticular property is singled out by this method, which may
be thought of as an “over-all” comparison. Zuege’s re-
marks on the effect of vanadium on steel are as follows:

“Vanadium is a very powerful deoxidizing agent, and it
ix believed that the beneficial effects obtained through
its use are largely due to its elimination of impurities
although it also forms complex carbides. In rolled
steels it is believed to produce a very fine-grained

1“Alloy Cast Steels.” D. Zuege. Transactions of the American
Foundrymen's Association, 1929, Vol. 37, p. 361.

242

structure. In castings it is used largely in heavy,
irregularly-shaped castings in which it raises the ratio
of yield point to tensile strength with no decrease in
ductility.

The vanadium steels have in the past been used to a
considerable extent in castings where an exceptionally
clean metal was desired or where castings of intricate
design were required, since vanadium does not confer
marked air-hardening properties. It was believed that
vanadium imparted to steels the ability to resist re-
peated stress to a marked degree, but some reeent
investigators believe that its importance in this respect
has been exaggerated.”

Recognizing the objections to Dawe’s method of compari-
son, the writer has calculated the properties of two S.A.
steels from the Society’s publication just off the press.’
Kinzel’s method of calculation has been used for the re-
sults shown in the last column of Table II], the emphasis
being placed on elastic ratio and ductility, and the relative

ae. |, ae
[ fol. 238] weightings being given by the following exponen-
tials:

Maximum stress = %
Elastic ratio — %
Elongation = 1.0

From Table III it is seen that the vanadium steel is defi-
nitely superior. No particular justification is offered for
the selection of the exponents, since they would be subject
to change for different conditions of service; it is felt that
they are as fair as,any others for conditions where light-
ness must be corfffined with resistance to shock.

In conversation with Mr. Bob Byrd of the Midvale Com-
pany concerning the relative costs of A.A.R. steels, Classes
A and B, he made the statement that the differ ontial against
Class B steel was in part due to the high manganese con-

'“Tron and Steel Specifications,” Reprint from the 1935 S.A.E.
Handbook, March 1935.

7

245

tent, which is specified somewhat higher than that of Class
A and to the presence of which he quite firmly insisted
the major portion of the additional physical properties were
due. His personal feelings were quite “bearish” on the
merits of vanadium. He further stated that vanadium was
used by many steel makers for its deoxidation properties
alone, so that the residual vanadinm was very low-—in
other words, the addition of a mere pinch which might
entirely disappear and certainly was not left to the extent
of more than 0.03 or O04 .

He went still further and stated that in his own personal
experience, vanadium in combination with chromium made
one of the most diffieult steels with which to meet specifica:
tion requirements. He much prefers the chrome-molyb-
denum compositions. His final thought was that vanadium
was due to continne its decline because of its lack of merit
in comparison with molybdenum. These remarks of an
experienced steel maker are included here to illustrate the

a —12-.
[fol. 239] widely opposing opinions that may be obtained
respecting the desirability of any given steel analysis.

In Table V will be found the relative costs of a number
of S.A.E. alloy steels, some of which are comparable to
vanadium steel and others are not, the figures being taken
from IRON AGE for April 25, 1985. It is thus seen that
the most expensive vanadium steel is fourth in order of
costliness of all of the steels shown, while the cheapest
vanadium steel is only eighth among the eighteen steels
listed, thus placing vanadium steels at present among the
most expensive of alloy types.

There are more sides to the cost of vanadium steels
than appear in a mere cataloging of the selling price, among
them being the matter of mill losses. Due to the fact that
one steel is harder to work than another, heavy rejections
may be encountered because of such causes as poor ingot
surface which will lead to seams and fissures, thus giving
rise to excessive chipping costs. It is alse a fact that some
steels will cause heavy rejections from difficulties in roll-
ing. such as corner cracking, which also is an adverse
factor; the sens

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386410_0122%3A08. Public record. Not legal advice.
