# Transcript of Record — Huron Portland Cement Co. v. City of Detroit

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386409_0244%3A1

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Transcript of Record
- **Published:** January 1, 1960
- **Citation:** 362 U.S. 440

## Text

oo. LIBRARY”
SUPREME COURT. U.S.

‘TRANSCRIPT OF RECORD

a .
.

Supreme Court of the United States .

OCTOBER TERM, 1959

sie 86.

HURON PORTL AND CEMENT COMPANY,
ETC., APPE LLANT, ;

Us.

CITY OF DETROIT, ETC, ET AL-

tb
APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF MICHIGAN

.
Ss

FILED JUNE 1, 1959
PROBABLE JURISDICTION NOTED OCTOBER 12, 1959

’

_ SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED ST ATES

bie sean Now 86

APPEAL FROM THLE &UPREM EB COURT OF THE STATE OF MICHIGAN

cone OCTOBER TERM, 1959

HURON PORTLAND CEXIENT COMPANY,
ETC., APPELLANT,

oz.’

CITY OF DETROIT, ETC, ET ALS

.

2% INDEX
Original Print

Record from. the ‘Cirenit. Court -for the County of | =

“Wayne, State of Michigan In Chancery
Notice of appeal to. the Supreme Court of the

Recorp Press, Printers, New York, X\ Y December 14, 1959

.
» :

United States ; ) ° 8=— 36

31°.

ae ee

sued by the United States Coast Guard covering |

moh Res 7 *shaw s . Crapo Z

Plaintiff's. Exhibit A— Consolidated certificate of |

enrollment and license ; aes
( ‘lérk's certificate Comitted in printing )
Order noting probable» jurisdiction

4 38
56. 43 =°
5944
60 44°
Ne

t

e .
4 e aes
‘ ; L
| fol. l ile endors ment oivitted |
, - 4 : - Af ,
a ipl. oi ‘ a nee . ‘
4 ‘

. Ce Stareoor Me HIGAN | .
= THE Cirecir Couns’ Fok THE 4'ountY oF W AYNE

m > — ff
| ek 3 JAIs Ciasxcery
I x. No. DAESIS. * ie hs
ot rae
‘ . ee . ” ‘ sa mn Oh i

Heres PontLasp CEMENT Company,

aw Michigan corpération, Appellant
ae
‘City or Detroit, a Michigan mtnicipal corporation, BEN-
JAMIN ‘Lansky, (Chyef Bureau of Smoke Abatement,
- PL J. Langa, Appellees
° . a ’ Se ne
EE ‘ : .

—

~ None bE OF APPEAL To THE SUPREME CouRT OF ‘THE
Unftrep Sratés—F iled April 9, 1959

I. Notice’ is hereby given that Huron Portland Cenient
Company, a Michigan corporation, the appellant above
named, hereliv appeals te the Supreme Court of the United
States from. the final decree of the Supremeé. Court of the.
State of Mic ‘higan allirming the decree of the: Cireuit Court
for the-County of Wayne,. In “Chanicery, entered in this.
action on January 12, 1959, | ie

This appeal is. taken pursuant to 28 U.S.C.A., Section:
1257 ¢2). - . .

o g 4 : 7 z =
Il. The clerk: will plea Axe prepare a transcript of. the
record, iv this cause for transinissien to the Clerk-of. the
Supreme Court of the United States, and inelude in said:
“tr eb the following:

. s

Bill of complaint ~— | . ibe
> 2. Answer
3. Pre-trial. statement

(fol. 3) 4. Transcript of the testimony, ineludmg Ex-
* hibits 'Z and A. va es

$ .

to

.
\ a . : . ad , \

i°N\ a. Opinion of the Cireuit Court for the ( ‘ounty of Way ne,
Mic ‘higan, in ¢ hane “Ory

. * Decree dis sutissing bill of sbiiphaii filed, bs ap WW Mant’

‘Opinion’of the Stipreme Cow of Michigan

‘
~]}
.

rt of Michigan | ~

L

Decree of thie Supte me Co

1. Notice of apper al to the

a “States

°

Ipreme: Court of the United

HL, The: following questions. ure prese nted by this “tp.
_ peal: - . ‘ “te 4 .

Pst ee a he leare ' Congress has by Statute 45U Pte A Chapter
| 14, provided ‘for. the inspection and licensing of Vessels
engaged in interstate and foreign commerce on the Great
* .. Lakes and appellant's vessels, including their boilers, whieh
are engaged in interstate commerce, have. been inspeeted
by the United States Coast Guard and have been granted
permission to navigate on the Great Lakes and haye been
enrolled and licensed by the Treasury, Department of the
*United States to carry on coasting: and foreign trade,: is
the Smoke Ordinance’ of the’ City of ‘Detroit, Michigan
valid as to said vessels, when such Ordinance .provides
for the inspection of the same boilers and prohibits their
use, and are the penalty provisions’ of said Ordinance valid
as to appellant’ s vessels whén the prohibited suigke can. |
not always be prevented by the boilers Ix pee ‘ted, approved
and licer ised by the U nited States?

‘2.. Whére.the Smoke Ordinance of the ( itv of Detroit,
Michigan provides for the inspection’ of combustion eiuip:
ment and \prohilhits use of certain kinds of boilers and
(fol. 4] equipment. on_vesse Is engaged in_inferstate and
foreign con}merce on. the\Gireat Lakes, and’ prohibits the
‘ "emission of smioke which cannot be prevented at all times
with boilers and equipment conunonly used .on the Great
Lakes, does such Ordinance unduly burden interstate and
foreign commerce in Inatters where uniformity is, nec Ossary
under. the Come ree Clause of the United States: Consti-
tution, Artic le'L, Section 8, ChOt oN cas

-

at

Y : ‘

Pemuriont, Sri th & th urs, Att aets for Huron

Shen cong Mab Ta Appell
_Buildt ss Detparty th, Neigh: ready Wo
. Dated: April “, 190 an

Proof of Serviced (omitted im} printing),

int, Dhow lord
odward ae

!

or W AYNE

trol. oT. Ae ae ike sndorsenient omitted |
slik SPere or MicitGan
Ix tHe Crrerve Cotter vor rig Cov NTY
\ cae ao - Is Waster y
howe 7h oe No SH43IS .

| Title “omitted |

Pint. OF ComPLant— Filed Marely 19,

Let atemporary in janet fon issue as pray ed j in a suh ‘da of

the prayer, eta ; ke
7 nga “ Frank FitzGerald,

[fol Gf Now comes Haren Portland Cement Company, a.

Circuit Judge.

Mic ‘higan corporation, plaiutiff liercin, and: shows unto this

“eHondrable Court as follows

ly It is a corporation organized and txis

by yirtue of the Jaws of the State of Michigan and\ has
its principal place Of business in the City of Detroit, W: ave

County, Mic higan.

ting undin and.

2. The City of Detroit is av a eas oes or-

. ghoiized and existing under and hy virtue
“the State of Mic higan, Benjamin “Linsky is
Bureau of Smoke Abatement of the Depart
ing and Safety Evgineering of said ‘City o

of the-laws of
s Chief of the
ment of Buikl-.
f Detroit. “The

defendant, P?. d, Lareau, is an Inspector of said Bureau

of — Abatement.

ee Plaintiff is engaged in the: huisiness of manufacture

ra? 7 | and sale of cements having a mill at

Alpena, Michi-

gan with distributing plants at Detroit, Saginaw and “Mus-

kevon, Michigan—loledo and Cleveland, Ohi

1O, Bu ffalo and

“Oswego, New York, Duluth, Minnesota, Milwaukee and

Green Bay, Wisconsin,

\

gineer of the S.S..dohn Wy Boardman, on the’ complaint
ok defendant, P. J. Lareau, are charged with allowing the

‘emission, of dense senoke frotn the S.S. Jolin W. Boardihan’s

boiler stacks for a peried of nine Ininutés on a. certain»
day. In ease Na Ko 906-601 ~ plaintiff ard the Captain

and Chief Engineer of the SS. S.T.. Crapo on. the -com-
plaint of de rendant, P. J. Lareau, are charged with allow-

‘ing the emission of dense smoke from the SS. S.'T. Crapo's*

boiler stack for a period of 9°, minutes en a certain date.
On. information and belie? piaintiff. alleges and charges
that defendants do not 6 i that the ‘emission of the:

smoke referred to in the, two si cases: was the result: of

improper firing’ or improper use .of: the equipment. upon *

said vessels. Plaintiff alleges and charges the’ fact to be.

~that on the occasions referred: to, in the said cases the

‘firing was proper and the equipnient was properly used.

and the emission of the smoke complained of could. not:
have been prevented with the equipment on the vessels. »

al

a

——

10. Section 3.20 of Said Ordinance provides that) ans:

person, firm or anvone acting ih behalf of said) perser
or firm viglating any -provision of the Aet, shall upon
conviction Tne sith ject to a fine of get Mere than s208.0
or imprisonment in the Detroit THlouse of} Correttion for:
a period of not morte’ than 30 days, or te:both such fine’
and imiprixonment in the discretion of of the Court. tach day
“that a violation of the Ordinance is continived or-permifted -

shall constitute a separate offense punishable as above set

' forth. Stott Siaeir ae os se ea

11.’ Plaintiff-shows that ae have threatened

to enforce the said ordinance against. it and against tlic”

officers on. its vessels* even where the emission. of the
_objectionable smoke cannot-be prevented, and plaintiff fur

(fol. 10] ther shows that the defendants have threatened. to °

issue warrants for the arrest of the officers of its fleet,

and plaintiff furthey ‘shows that the said ordinance is not—

applicable as to its vessels, except in those cases “where,
the emission of objectionable smoke is cxused by iniproper
firing or through the improper use of the equipment upon
such vessels. * ; :

12. Plaintiff ek th: tit will, stiffer irrepay able: injury
and it willbe subject to continued harassment and abmul-’
tiplicity of suits unless the defendants are enjoined: trom
attempting to enforce, said Ordinance No. 167-E agains:
plaintiff and agaimst its officers and members of its crews,

except where the emision of the objectionable smoke is’

caused by improper firing or by the improper use ofthe
equipment ypon such vessels.) ,.

13. The matters here involved are: in’ eXcess of One
Hundred Dollars ($100.00) and. acai is without remedy, «
—- in a court of be gen : aN .

\

W herefor, plaintiff prays:

(a) That this Court. pending a "Roaridg: in. this ‘catixe

and until further order, restrain and enjoin the déefe ndants,
‘their -agents, employees, « ‘counsellors, attérneys: and solici-
‘tors, and éach and every of them, from the. further: prose-

| -cution. of the: two cases now pe naling: agiiinst plaintiff and.

. : ®@

s

7

e

: Pra nS ee! soe ° f * at

others itt the: iecdnders ( our Yor the ity of Detroit, ’

Trafic and Ordinance Divisian, and frome issuine any tickets
or warrants for sata or i any manner atte mipting to en-
‘force: said Ordinance No. 167-E of ‘the City of Detroit
“against plaantiff, flee officers and anenybers of the. crews
of its vessels, ‘tee the-emission of said smoke he canged?
| fol. 11} by Hnproper fring or ‘by “the fuproper- Use of the
equipment upon. said vessel.

|

(b) That. this Court dietcPiitne and ‘decree’ that ‘Gri
nance’ No, 167-40"is inapplicable, unreasonable and ‘uncon.
stitiitional if, respect to plaintiff, except whe 1: the emission
of smoke is caused: ‘by the iinproper firing or the nproper:
Use of the equi paie nt upon said vessels, .¢

+(e) That: the defendants and each. of them be perma-
nently enjoined from enforcing or attempting to enforce
said Ordinance ° Now 1(j7- I against plaintiff, officers and.
members of the ¢rew of-its vessels, except where the dense
smoke is eased by linproper firing or improper tse - of
the equipment upon said Vessel;.. . : :

And: the plaintiff may have sue i other and furthet li
as.miay he just and equit able. ° a ; i

“Huron Portland Cement) Company, By Paul> He
ete, Townsend, ‘President. | ee

“Daly sworn tor hy Paul HM. Tow ASE nd. juvat omitted in
B leer :

om , : . ° ahh eter °
’ ° a :° ° ‘ . s
° . a
- > ° . Wes,

Hg 84
s . } . é : .
‘Tfol. 12) | | File enidbrsement omitted |

beidaads | ee ay

Swarr or Mica
Is tHe Cinevir Court Fur THE County o¢ WAYNE

Ix C HANCERY —_:
5 No. HS . 9

i Title omitted |
ANSWER OF THe CiTy oF eekans a Muenicivan Cornrorsttox,
Besoamix Linsky, Crier, Bereav or. Soke ABATE. |
Menr. ann J’. J. Lankav, Ixspecron-—Filed April 8, 1956

Now Come the Cit® of Detroity a municipal corporation,

Benjamin Linsky, Chief Sindke Inspector of the Depart-
ment of Buildings and Safety Engineering of the said
City of Detroit, and Py J.-Lareau, an inspector. therein.
devendants herein, and for answer to plaintiff's joull of
complaint, respeetfully represent as follows :

1 Answering paragraph: one, defendants admit the alle.
gations therein contained. :

* Answe ring paragraph two, defendants adinit the alhe.
gations therem contained, 2 :

3. Answering paragraph thine, defendauts not having
sullicie nt knowledge cor information upon. which to base
a belief neither admit nor deny the allegations therein
contained and. therefore leave plaintiff ty its proofs.”

4. Answering paragraph tour, defendants admit the alle:
gations therem contained.’

= Answering paragraph. five, defendants not having
sufficient’ knowledge or information upon which to base’ a
belief neither admit nor deny the allegations Qierein con-
tained and therefore leave’ plaintiff to its proots,

_{felel4| (Or Answering paragraph six, whether or not it
is necessary to keep up full stéam while the vessels are
unloaded and whether or not he fire is cleaned every

four hous, afefendants not having sufficient knowlidge or
information upen whieh to base a belie! thereon, neither

admit wor deny such allegations and therefore leave plain

ili te its preels. Defendants deny the allegation that it
is impossible to prevent the emission of smoke from the
said Vessels’ cof the Kind prohibited by the said Ordinance’
No. 167-1, the Smoke Abatement Ordinance of de fendant
City of Detroit, to which public record reference is hereby
~ expressly prayed as if-specifieally herein set forth, and:
-aver that. the elimination’ of said unlawful emission of

‘smoke is not unavoidable. *

7. Answering paragraph seven, defendants admit thai if
‘in conferences with representatives of plaintiff relative
te violations by the said vessels of the said Smoke Abate-
“nent Ordinayee, that the said representi itives: had asked
what Could be done to reduce th@excessive smoke and were
advised by defendant Linsky that overfire ‘steam Jair jets
were known to be methods for reduci ing the excess, but °
‘that such were not considered’a cure-all and in hfs opinion
such methods. would not be adequate enough to permit .
the said vessels to‘meet the requirement of the said Smoke
Abatement Obdinance, ‘Defendants deny the allege ition that
“plaintiff has-done all. that can be done to reduce the amount
of smoke on said boilers and aver that the said unlawful —
emission of smoke contrary to the:said Ordinance is not
unavoidable.

* oh

8. Answering paragraph eight, defendants adinit that the
Constitution of the United States grants to Congress the
power to regulate interstate and foreign Gommerce but
aver that. such does. not withdraw from the .State and
Inunicipalities power to legislate in respect te their. loea!
or internal concerns, and that any reasonable exercise of
their. police power is valid provided that such—dees not
unduly burden interstate. or, foreign commerce, -Defen-
}fol. 15! dants further aver that the provisions of the
said Sthoke Abatement Ordinance do not unduly. burden:
the interstate and foreign operations of plaintiff's said
vessels, and that such provisions are a reasonable, proper
and valid exercise of the delegated police power of defen-
dant City and are good and sufficient in law.

_ ~ . |

/ - 8

10

Defendants further aver the said inspection and approval

by the said United States Coast Guard in accordance with ,

the said Federal Navigation, Laws embraces only sneli
‘reqgulations for the protection of vessels, their passengers.
crews and freights and such laws do -not. provide for the
protection of persons and property on land including regu
lation of fuel and mie producing characteristics of
equipment. as a result. of its use. Defendants deny the
_ allegation that the pu United States Coast Guard ap-
proved the boilers of the said vessels as to their operation
“and emission of smoke.

0 Answering paragraph nine, defendants admit that
their claims that the provisions of. the said Smoke Abate.

ment: Ordinance. are applicable to- plaintiffs said fleet of
vessels, but. deny the -allegation that ‘the said unlawful’

emission of smoke therefrour cannot be preyented -and
also deny that the said-boilers were approved by the: said
United States Coast Guard as to their operation and emis-
sion ‘of smoke, and aver that the eliniination of said un-
lawful emission of smoke is not unavoidable.

Defendants admit further that the said two cases are
now pending in the said Recorder's Court, Traflie and
Ordinance Division: that at the time of the stated vio-
lation on the SS John W. Boardman it was found that

_the said equipment was properly used, but as to the said,

SSS. T. Crapo the said de rendant inspectay Lareau was
refused ‘access to the vessel and: defendarits cannot ‘state
whether er not the said equipment -was properly used
during the period of the stated violation. Qefendants deny
the allegation that: the-emission of-the smoke “compl: Lined.
[fol 16) of could not have been, prevented, and aver that.
plaintiff is bound to comply with the requirtinents of the
said Smoke Abatement Ordinance. .

10. Answering paragraph ten, defendants admit the al.
legations therein contained. .

ll. Answerit paragraph eleven, defendants admit that

. they intend to enforce the provisions of the said Smoke

Abatement Ordinanée as they legally apply to plaintiffs
vessels, and aver that the’ said previsions thereof are

—_

A > . . °
applicable as to plaintiff each and every time it permits
its vessels to-cmit smbke in excess ef the regulations of.
the said Ordinance,- Defendants further aver that the said
emission of the sinoke Ayy the said vessels as Charged in
the sais complaint, was, and the contintance thereof 43
plaintiff in its Vessels is, a public nuisance thereunder.

Ww Answering paragraph twelve, defendants deny the
alley ations. therein contained,

i3. Answering paragraph thirteer nN, det ‘endants de ny the
allegations therein contained and aver’ that from the alle-
gations in this and in other paragraphs of plaintiff's bill
of ‘complaint, there is no actual or threatyned act or acts >

on the part of the defendants of sueh character as to cause >

irreparable injarys that the plaintiff has not shown suffi
cient facts to confer jurisdiction on a court of equity? and
that it has an adequate remedy at Jaw, . te

Wherefore, Defend: ints further deny that le intiff is
-entitled to the relief prayed. for in its bill. of complaint
and pray thi it the same be dismissed,

City of Detroit, a munic ipal corporation, Benj Jamin
_Linsky, Chief Sinoke Inspector of the Departinent
of Buildings and Safety -Engineering of the City
of Detroit,e Po J. Lareau, Inspector of. the De-
partment of Buildings and Safety. Engineering of
[vol U7 |. the City of Detroit. Defendants, by Paul
ad Races: Corporation Counsel, By > Arthur ‘Le
Barkey, Assistant Corporation ¢ ‘ounselseAttorne ‘VS
for Defendants, 1010: City-Cotnty. Building, De-
“troit 26, Michigans Tele sphone: WOodward 5-4200
Ext. 359. -

Duly sworn to by Arthur L. Barkey, juratComitted in.
Sprinting. 3

e

folk IS]. [File endorsement omitted |

Strate of Miciteas
IN THE (' mewn Coerr Pevik, THE (‘ounry inh WAYNE

[ "Is CHANCERY:
: NXo. A418 ea ’

- [Title omitted |

"Pre-Trial Statement—Filed June 28, 1956

Session | of June 26, 1956.

Present: Jlon. Frank B. Rerguson, Cireuit Judge. .°

APPEARANCES: “e he

Beaumont, Smith &. Harris, 1100 Ford Bldg. Attorneys
for Plaintiff. : nt) an ea Aa Pi gaad O

Pau). T. Dwyer and Arthur‘h, Barkey, 1010 City-County
Dldz., itorneys for Defendants. . ¢
| fol.-19 | ‘Plaintiff. claims that it is in the business of
manufacturing and selling of cement/and that it transports
bulk cement from its mill-in. Alpena by water to Various
destinations throughout the United States, and for that
“purpose owns a fleet of vessels, which Vessels are equipped
with certain t¥pes of boiler, and that during the 1955
shipping season’ they had to dock in Detroit 22 times, stay-
ing fronr three to 34 hours atva-time, and that on the

——_—

hand fired vessels it was necessary to keep up full steam:

while said) vessels were docked in’ Detroit, and that) on
such occasions it is impossible to prevent smoke of the Kind

prohibited by Ordinance 167-E of Detroit.

Plaintiff claims that’ it has attempted in all manner
with the Citw of Detroit to reduce the amount of smoke.

but that it- has: not been able to do so to the satisfaction

of the City of Detroit. |
P laintiff claims that Congress wiliae. is Gamuiianes of

the United States has fuH authority and power to regulate
and control foreign and interstate commerce, and that

: : 13
Congress has provided that all vessels ‘navigating’ the
Great Lakes shall de osubject to the navigation laws of
the United States, and that said hiws cover the construc:
thon, equipment? and operations of the Vessels and provide
‘for an annual ins pection | On such Vesacts by the United,
States Coast Guard.

The defendants claim that said ordinance is applicable
to plaintiffs fleet even as to smoke which cannot be pre
vented with the present boilers On certain ‘of the ves-els:.
Which boilers have been approved by the United States .
_ Coast. Guard, -_- =. - 3 ad
|fol. 20). ~The C ity of Detroit has jnstituted two-eases in
the Traflic and Ordinance Division of the Rqcorder’s-C our
against plaintiff, charging it. with allowing elission of
dense smoke fromi.its’ Vessels, -

The plaintiff cliims ‘that the defendants ae no -an
thority te enforce said ordtnance against the pkaintiff,
and it claims tliat the ordinance, ix hot applice thle. to. said
“vessels because the emission of smoke is not caused by
hproper firing or other proper use of ‘the equipnrent,
and therefore the’ bring this’ action to enjoin the prose-
cution-of the two cases in the Trititic and Ordinance: Divi-
sion of the Recorder's Court of the City of Det troit, and
to enjoin the City brom enforeing said ordinane “against it.

Plaintiff also asks that this ordinance be declared. in-
| Sialic ‘able, unreasonable and unconstitutional, except where
pea is caused by improper firing or the Tupreper Use
of the equipment,

The defendants deny the cl tims of the plaintiff and claim
that said ordinance is: applre able and that the defendant
has vidlated the same, and -that it is uncoastitutional, and
that they are entitled to enforce said ordinance against the
plaintiff.

- Frank a rae Circuit Judge.

14

it ine {File endorsement omitted |
| fol, 21] .
STATE OF > Vac HIGAN
Is rire Crrevier Covrr ror THR County ot vy AYNE

. ‘
. Ix (CHANCERY .
No SS
ae b>. 7 ——— —_ ; nev ash e:
Le "E%"«. .
. [Tithe omitted t

Transcript of Testimony—Filed July 12, 1957

—. Proceedings’ had and testimony.taken. in’ the above-en
* titled cause before Tlonorable George i. -Bowles, © ireuit
Judge, at Detroit, Mic ‘higan, on January 10, Mae. *
Avhasnaxcen: a Sf n
Beaumont, Smith and Ilarris, By: Alfred KE. Lindbloom,
sq. Nppearing?on behalf of Plaintiff, ;
Paul -‘T.-Dwver Bsqy., Corporation Cotnsel, By: Jota.
Hathaway, Esq, Assistant Corporation Counsel, Appearing
- on behalf of the Defendants. = eae

°° e- ..; cnige =. . eo, ae e

ffolfz2| Joseru FL STENGLESS, was) thereupon called as a
witness on Tehalf of the Defendant, ‘and ‘being first duly
sworh, testified as follows: .

. 5 ae ngs

af

: es A ‘ .
. ae sep ° e
‘

* Direct examination.

Bae 2 | -BY Mr. Hathaway:
“Q. What is vour name? _
A. Joseph F. Stenglein.- :;
(). Where do you live? - >."
A. Route I, Box 200, Miamisburg, Ohio,
Q. What is vour present cecupation ?
A. Tam an éxecutive viee president and general man
ager-of the Dayton Automatic Stoker Company. *
(). LLow long have you worked With your present com
pany? »

, a as ; ae

Ad

A. 1 became: associated with this cgmipany: on my ie

ar De ° ° =
- with?) ae particukur, stoker companiés?
A. Lwas the sales manager and connecty] in the engineer
img division of the ¢ meen Stoker © ‘orporation, in Canton!
Ohio. yo

the stoker bus iness?”

“here in the City of De ‘troit.

e ‘In vour occupation. with the stoker sae have
voli become faailiar with the requirements of the sinoke ~

: (Yo. 2) abatement ordinance of the City of Detroit?
2A. Yes. Pain fanilar with, the smoke ordinance.

Q. In your . nt position as Vice president and gren
‘eral manager Dayton Stoker ‘Company what are vour
duties ? 2 . i

AL My duties have “heen entirely aligned with the marine
field anal E handle all of the gontract negotiations, .P aim
responsible for the selection and general engineering tune
tions of the equipment we propose to provide on vessels.

>

I do the survey work and after the layup season. has com:

menced or has prec es “ded | then spend. mv time con the
Vessels, supervising the installations and-then at the sts art
of the sailing season, after fit-out; Po generally sail on
. the vessels that have our equipment installed. | |
“Qo cAt the present time are vou installing any of vour
own unlderfteed stokers in any’ hips that are navigating the
Cireat Lakes? cee :, ;
A; We have e ontrae ts for installation of stokers one eight

scotch marine tired vessels, seven of them or six of them

are in’ American’ ports and two in - Canadian ports and
we have contracts for two installations in water tube
boilers,

~ Q.. Did ’vou state how many underfced stokers you laiwre
already installed prior te this vear? :

NX. We have stoker fired since T8901, lavup season in dle

‘2, 2B vessels on the’ Great Lakes.» -
‘(). Wmaessels? , Me ben
A. Yes,

Prior te May of 1955, whrat other conipanies did vou |

(). Contd: vou tell me further how long ltave you heen in

Ast have beentin the stoke r husiness since 131, starting: |

—

{fol 24] Q. Do you know the steamshipeCrapo ?

A. Yes, d gin: somewhat familiar with the Crapo,

BS Have vou been‘aboard the Crapo? is

A. | boarded the Crapo, believe, it-was either bi last
- week of August or first,week of September Tast, out) in.
Lake Huron, while she was at anchor about three miles
from the port of Alpena. + ,

Q. Do-you know whether or not, an underfeed stoke.
could be installed aboard the ste: unshipy Crapo?
A. Yes, an underteed stoker could) be installed, or an
underfeed stoke ‘ry installation could be made on, that vessel,

Q. Assuming, from your experience in handling: stoke:
equipment and, installing: such equipment aboard marin
“vessels, do. vou know if such a stoker as would be nece-
sary to? be installed aboard the Crapo were installed and:
_ properly: operated, “would you- know whether: such eqnips |
ment would result in that equipment complying with the
smoke i abatement code of the City of Detroit? -

AS The equipment makes it possible to operate =moke
lessly. or-within the qualifving smoke, let’s say,at would
“niake it possible te operate within the seope of the Inter
national Joint Commission's No. 1, objective and the ob
jectives set up by the City of Detroit.. i,

Q). In their smoke abatement: code,
eA. That is correct. | :
> : '
“Mr. Hathaway: That is all.

o * = : * ° * * *

fol. 25].
Strath OF Micrigan: .
TN THe c InCUIT Cov RT FOR THE COUNTY oF WAYNE

e
?

“Is CHANCERY
No. 544-518 ;

[Title omitted | Cea

ae | ” Oprxiox— April 17, 1957 | ned

- laintiff manufactures and sells eeme nt, with aomell at
Alpena, Michigan,. and distributing -plants) at Detroif,

17
, ; | a .
Saginaw and Mus kegon, Michigan, Toledo and Cleveland,

Ohio, sutfato wand CGswego, New York: Duluth, Minnesota -

and Milwaukee. and Green Bay, Wisconsin, It maintains
a flect of vessels to transpert bulk cement from the Alpena
—mill.toe the distributing plants, the fleet consisting of the
steamships John We. Botdredman, S. ‘TL Crapo, Samuel
Mitchell... My Foryland the motor-vessel Paul Hl, Town-
send. An. addional steamship, Ik. €.. Collins, will be added
to its fleet within a vear or two. All of thé vessels with
the exception of the motor vessel Paul HL. Townsend, which

ix diesel ‘powered, are eqenpyen with hand- fired seoteh

niarine boilers.
[fol. 26] Steamships John W. Boardinan and S. * “Crapo

are self unloaders, the power being supplied by boilers:

the Samuel Mitchell has its unloading equipment operated
by electricity from shore ‘installations: only three docks
have such shore: Install (tions so the Samuel Mitchell ealls

only at these ports. The BE. M. Ford has: a djesel motor

Whith powers the unloading equipment, :

The City 6f.Detroit’s smoke abatement ordinance, No.
-167-F, provides that it slfall be unlawful within the city
for any person, firm ar corporation to permit the emission

of -smoke of a density equal.to or greater than ‘density

deseribed as No. 2 on the Ringleinann Chart, with the
‘exception that sinoke equal to No. 2 is permitted for a
period or periods aggregating four Minutes in any 3!)
minutes, and smoke equal to No.3 on the Ringlemann C har,
ix’ permitted for a period: or periods aggregating three
minutes in any 15 minutes when building a new fire or
the like,

The ordinance provides. for, annual inspection of com.
bustion equipment o® furnace ‘used, with some exceptions,
and makes it unlawful-in. Section. 2.16 to use’ such equip-
ment without a certificate of operation which issues only

after inspection, Section 2.20 provides that after ‘any

“owner has been previously notified of three or more vio-
lations within: any consecutive twelve-month period, the
rommissioner ‘shall serve a‘notice ‘upon the owner ‘and
shall) seal pm

that adequate corrective means have been employed. to
correct the unlawful emission. A fine of $100 or imprison-

“qupment unless: the commisstoner finds.

=e

\

mo

° \

ment in the Detroit House of Correction for a period of
fol. 27 | not more than thirty aays, or both, such fine and
huprisomment, are provided. Each day that a violation o}
~ the ordinance is continued or permitted shall constitute a
‘separate offense.

On December 20, 1955, two suits were started in the
Recorders Court for the City of Detroit, Traflie and. Ordi-
nance Division, naming. the. COMpany as, defendant as well
as) Kenneth Sane higrin, Captain, and. Arthur’ Johnson,
Chief Enginéer, of the S.S. Crapo; J. Burke, Captain of -,
the S.S, John W. Boardman; Edward Pugh, Chief Engi-
necr, of the’ Boardman. Suit K 996-600 charged that the
balan W. ‘Boardma un émitted smoke from its stack for a
period, of nine aninutes between 10:42 AM and 11:02 AM,

on December 12, 1955, while docked at the foot of Riopelle
Street in the City of Detroit, dnd suit No. K 996-601,

charged the-S.S. Crapo emitted dense smoke for a period
of 934 minutes between 11:49 AM — 12:05 PM, the same
day. at the same location:

P laintiff herein brought suit to en join the City of Detroit’
from, prosecution’ of its. two ‘suits in Recorders Court
and an order was. entered\against the city. to.desist and
refrain: from the further }ywosecution of ‘tlie two cases
now pending against plaintiff\and others” and “from issu
ing any tickets or warrants for arrest or in any manner
attempting to enforce said ordinance No, 167- I” against
“plaintiff, the officers, membérs of the crews of its vessels;
unless the emission, of said smoke be caused by improper
. firing or by improper use. of the equipnient upon said
"vessel. eo Ne on
\ fol. 28] It is conceded that the equipment on the john
Bi, Boardman Was properly used but the City cannot state
whether the equipment was properly used on the So T.
Crapo since. representatives of the ‘City wiectel bihani ad-
¥ nkission to board this vessel.

It is agreed it is impossible to prevent emission of
the kind of -sinoke prohibited by the smoke :ordinance if
the vessel ix equipped with hand-fired scotch marine
boilers. The Boardman has“ two boilers each with two
doorg and one steam air jet over each door, The Crapo
has t kee boilers, eac ‘th with two doors and one steam air.

a

jet over each door Te steam jets being installed at the

suggestion of Benjamin Linskys, former Chief of the Bure: Mu

of Smoke: Abatement for the City.’

Testine: iW showed also thet the plaintiff used a chemical

In an attempt to reduce the smoke.’ Plaintiff urges it has

done everything that it ‘éould possibly: do with the equip--

‘nent it has to prevent-The'enussion of smoke, At wax sliown

‘ow trial that ‘the fleet is subject to periodic inspection hy
the coast guard, which issues’a search of inspection, The:

Crapo in 10 doe ked at Detroit twenty-two times Tor an

average doc king time of 23.9 houts and the, Boardman

pacts at Detroit 25 times that year With an average stay

16.2 hours. Both vessels: were constantly, engaged in
cana and foreign commerce during this period. »

Plaintiff claims. that the smoke abatement ‘Ordinance
ix unconstitutional as to it except.in those instances where
the objectionable: smoke is caused by improper firing or
.by the pars oi use of the equipment on the vessel.

I fol. 9) | Has C ongres ss ip re-[ ane ted the Mield?. nee ae

Plaintiff arenes ‘that ae oar : tas, pre-ehipted the field

through the enactment of elao.ate and detailed regukations

of steam vessels. 76 OLS. Code Aniolated: See, 932 Sup.
provides thet the coast guard: shievll Tispect, hefore such
vessels are put into service and at least once every two
Years thereafter, the hoilers-on untired pressure vessels
and ayipurtenances thereto: the propelting and auxiliary

machinery, cleetrical apparatus and eqqupmne nt of all vessels.

are subject to Inspection.
It is argued that since C ongress har validly enac ted: » such

statutes and regulations; a state or municipality may not’

pass a stitute or ordinance cévering the same field. Welly v.
Washingtow, 1937, 302 US. p. 1. Hand-fired scotch marine
boilers have been approved by the coast guard. Smoke

of the kind prohibited by the ordinance cannot be. avoided,

Incnee the ordinance prohibits the use ofa hhand- fired : xc oteh
marine boiler. aoe

~The City, it urfes, réquines a eortain kind of equipnient
to comply with its ordinance, other and-difte ‘rent equtip-
ment than. th: nul: whic h the Congress li is provided: Tay he,
used.

NN

. nas : | aS 7 ge
. } a : 4 : ‘ *» !
Reference is mide also by analogy. to the Boiler Inspec.
tion ATT Sees, 22-34 of Title 35, US. Code bunotated,
relating to the inspection of railroad Jocomotives, Napier,
v. Atlantic Coastline Iailroad, 128, 272 U.S. 605.
{fol 304 0 The’ City, on the other hand, urges. that’ the -
Congress has not enacted laws which provide forthe pro->
tection of persons and property on land, including regu-
lations of fuelocand smoke-producing . charac ‘toristics of |
equipment dis a result: gt its use, and that, therefore, there

is no conflict with federal regulations .and. the ordinance, ¢

There are devices and appliances whieh, if installed, would
enable the plaintiff to coniply, and this compliane e may. be
required, :

Under the. Tome Rule ‘Aete MSA 5.207B2. and * 5.2083.
the police power of Detroit asa Scaie rule city is or the,
same general scope and nature as that of the State and
the ordinance is not directed, asare the fe ‘deral revulations,
to the protection of the vessel, its passengers, crews and
freight. Morgan y. Birginia, 90 Liaw Ed. ~, 165 ALR
ot4. This is a case, it is urged, where, Congress has not
acted, and although: the ordinanc ‘eralfects inter ‘state COM,
merce it ix valid.

°

Court's H eet *

The Court has: reviewed the authorities cited in the ex-
cellent briefs of the parties, and \t is our ‘holding that
the federal Congress as not pre-etypted:this particulir
field. “The constitutional grant to’ Congtess of the power
to’ regulate: interstate, commerce, it has “freque ‘ntly been
held, does not forestall all-state action “and: does not pre- -
vent a@ state froin logisiating on acmatter of local concern,
even though interstate commerce may be indirectly and

incidentally affected, provided the Congress has not seen”

fit forenact supéerseding legislation. 15 CJS, Commerce, Sée/

s: p. 2680 Cheyboygan Lumber Co. v. Delta Transpor-
tution Co,, 10 Mich? 16. Burroies v. “Delt ee
[fol Sl] Co. 106 Mich. 582, Smith vo Alabama 124 US,

Hin, Nashville, Cy St. ‘Louis Reiheay Co. y, “Habana.
128 US. 96, 177 U.S. 584, WP. Welch & Co, ¥. State of .
New Mumpshin , 306 uv ., S-- 69. ache .

=

affecting railroads and qaotor Velyeles and are in, point,
the Court believes, as authority for Che validity. of, the
ormlinance soo tar as the doe ‘Urine ét- federal’ — emption. ix
concerned,

The language of the U nite Sti ites Supreme Court in the
Wele ly case, whieh involved a New: Hampstirire statute de-

cliving unlawaal the éperation on state highways of ameter:

Vebicles for specified trawsportation by drivers: wlio haves

been. continuously on duty for More than twelve hours, ix
persuasive, sie iis RP |

It cannot be inferred that C ONgT Ess: intended to shpershde
any state safety ineastire prior to the taking effect of a
federal - qneasuye found suitable sto, put in ite place, [ts
“purpose to displace the Jocal Jawsimust be definitely -ex-

pressed, ln construingetederal statutes _ ted under, the
power conferred. by the commerce k f the Constitution.

it should: never lw’ he Vd that Comper Titends to super.
sede or suspend the exercise of -the reserve powe rs of the
state, evens where that may be done, tinless and except
so far as its purpose to do xo is clearly manifested,

Congress has snot seen, fit to» rewulate the enfssion of

sinoke by ‘yessels cin interstate’ conimerce so far as such
@uiission affects persons and property on dand. Congress,
[fol 32] therefore, has not pre- enipted this particular ‘field
so as to exclude state reguiition.
Bie the Commerce Chaise of the United States ,

Constitution Itself P reclude the Enactment of
Detroit ‘5: Sinoke. Abateme nt Ordinance? - -

| » letra er er
Plaintiff argnes that 3 '

pass: al suioke’ ard mianee
of even oil cquiphuent,-and
even different and. conflicting ordinances “with whieh
would be inipossible for plaintiff to-cotuply.. It is actie MM.
“therefore, it is urged, Where uniformity is necessary in
il constitutional sense ‘in accomplis shing a permitted | pur:
pose, Morqgay v. Virginia, supra. Where uniformity is
necessary, if, k sud, even though Congress has not, acted,
the ¢ ‘onstitutional clause, or the power wiven Phy that. auise

¢
ou

“h e man “2h

rasy 3 ; . js ‘ . ° / . : . : “
These cases are constructions of statutes and ordinances

CIty other thant, Detroit could.
Which: woutd prohibit the use’
ther Municipalities’ could igo

*

to Congress, pre-empts or oecupies the field and precludes:
a stitte or diunicipality: from legislating in respeet to sny-
thing requiring uniformity,
7 Tt would eost roughly $70,000 to equip cither the Board
lian oor the Crape With stokers, and at@deast $500,006
each tocequip them with oil burning equipment. So othe
burden Upon interstate cOmiine ree is very subst: intial and
itis prohibitive if other “@ities pitss contlieting or different
ordinanees, Southern Pacific vy, Arizona, Wd, 825 0 +. wol,
Willy v. Was hington, supra. es ,
Plaintiit has cited a portion of. the Supreme Court
OPIN Lone, in the Kelly case Whic h represents a good state:
hient of its position:

“Hoh 35) The state law jis a comprehensive -code,
While it excepts vessels which are subject to ins speetion:
under the laws of the United States, it, has provisions
Which maybe decmed to fall within the class of re gu.
lations which Congress alone ean provide. For -ex-
seta Congress inay establish standards and designs
for the structure and equipment of vessels, and may
spreseribe rules for their operation, which could not
properly be left te the diverse action “of the States.
The State of W ashington might: preseribe standards,
peti equipment and rules of one sorte Oregon an-

other, California ‘another, and ‘so on. But it does not
follow that in all respects the state aet must fail.

. * ae. : ee *

“Tt, however, ‘the State goes farther and atte Mipts

* to Tnpose particular standards as to structure, design,
equipment and operation which in the judgment of its
authorities mav be desirable but .pass beyond what is
plainiy esse ntiak to‘safety and seaworthiness, tle State
Will encounter the prineiple that such requirements,
if Iiposed: at all, must be through the action of Con-
vress Which can establish a uniform rule. Whether.
the Stite ina particular matter goes too far must be
Jeft to he determined when the precise question arises,”
‘Plaintif® afges that the congressional regulation of motor
driven Vessels is much less complete than thatyor a steam

; 23
; } Biren
Vessel; that even theugh the regulation of motor driven
tugs Was very incomplete, the Sapreme Court tindicated
a state coukl not sia particular standards as to ilesign,
equipment and operation heeause those requirements, if
imposed at all, must) be through the action of Congress,
Which can establish a uniforn) rule.

The City of Betroit-arsites son the other hand, that the
snioke abatement code is net such a law as requires uni-
formity of regulation. Reference is miade to Publie’ Act
159, ‘nacted by the Federal Congress in 1959, wherein it is
provided: in Section: t:

-[fol. 54) “Phat in ree ‘omnition of ‘he danger to public
health and welfare, injury. to agricultural crops and
livestock, danger to, and danger of property and haz.
ards to air and ground transportation, from air pollu-
tim, it is hereby declared to be the poliey of Congress
to. preserve and protect the primary responsibilities
and rights of the states and local governnients in con-
trolling air pollution.”

. ad
*

Reference ‘is. alxoonade_ to Volume 2.°U.S. Code: Con-

yressioual News, Loo, pp. a4 9 and “40, states:

° “The bill docs not _propose any eXETEise of police
power “by the Federal Government and no pravisien
‘in it invades the sovereignty of States, counties, ér
cities. “There‘is no attempt to impose standards of
purity. ett pe win ee seer mre

°*.

. 7 . .

“Moreover, unlike, the water. pollution field in which -
a sitnilar hoard now eNXists, Instances of troublesome
interstate air pollution are few in number and no fed-
eral legal control over interstate air pollution is cur-
rently proposed.”

Reliance is placed upon flautie Coastline Railroad vy.
Georgia, BAUS. 290, construing a Georgia law requiring
railroad locomotives operating on the main lines to” be

» equipped with electric headlights of S00 watt power and
to have ‘reflectors of a certain, dimension, Wherein the
Supreme Court stated in uphoiding the law said:

. .

%

24

“The requirements of a state of course, must hot be
“arbitrary of pass bevond the Himits of a fairy judgment — -
as to What the exigeney ‘demands, bat they are mot.
invalid because another state in the exereise or a simi |
lar power maty jot npose the same regulation.” °

; Hlere a congressional, Net had provided for locomotive
brakes, ladders, grab iréns and other safety requirements.
» [Yoh oo} Reliance was stil irly placest on certain. motor *: nt

vehicle cases: Morris ve Dalby, 274 Us. Wh: Maurer v.
~Mamilton, SOO US, AUS, ~tis well as state regulations of
S seagoing. vessels, Nelly v. Was hington, supra.
Sunmunarizing these cases the City argues that the Su-
— prreme Court will net held a state or lecal law invalid
because Cb) different stQ@tes would reste. different: de-
Vices, or (2) the fact that a state mpay change the Jaw
requiring further changes in equipment, or (3) heeause,
the Federal Govermaent has entered the. field, unless the
local law is proved. to be in direct contliet with the federal
re sulation, . Bs *

Flaten Court's Holding eet

The Court has reviewed the authorities cited by the
parties and concludes that the constitutional control by
the Federal Governnient of interstate commerce does not
preclude a smoke abatement Ordinance suelr as here in-
volved where the Federal Congress has not) seen fit to
“patss spec ifie . lewislation caleulated to protect property
cand persons on land, as opposed to regulations for the
* protection of crews and passengers as well as vessels and

freight on vessels in Interstate commerce

While: it is conceivable that uniformity of regulation

_through an act of Congress might be desits thle, it is ‘not

a subject on which local authority maty net legistiite to

-meetdocal needs, It js readily conceivable, that leeal situ-

ations require different and particular provisions depend-

ing upon the needs and the problems encountered by the ° .

local authorities. re: i

trol. 36] The state regulatory measures upheld as te: .

vessels in interstate commerce and as to railroads and:

‘motor Vehicles in interstate commerce incline the Couft

t | 20

: + -¢ :
‘to such a view: Smoke abatement does not. at this stage
‘of scientific deve lopment, mbit of only one system or plan
of regulation but-is.a subject, it is: be lieved, which bequires
diversity of treatment to meet. low th exigencies,

Ix the Smoke. Akatement. Gidimihes it Valid Exercise —
by the City of Detroit of Its Police Power?

It is well established tliat a considerable discretion: ix
vested in legislative authority to determine not only what

the imterests of the public fequire but what measures are 7

‘necessary for the protection of these interests.. New sub-
. jeets may be embraced within the Police power as changing
conditions ‘require, People ve Se MH, 310 Mich. 500, 516,

Considerable latitude is allowed for differences of view
and possible peculiar conditions. Safec y. City of Buffalo,
IVS NYS p. 649: Cady v. City of Detroit, supra..

“The court ix required, if if can consistently do so,
to give to the provisions such aj reasonable construction
ax will sustain it. Jt has no right to invade the legality
province. Its power is. confined) to those cases in which
a municipal ordinance is clearly and«manifestly made
to appear to be unreasonable or|oppressive in its oper-
ation. (Bialding Comm. v. Aunin, 181 Mich. 611.)

The Court may concern itself ohly with the question of
Whether the legislative authority, assuming: it) las >

power to enact a regulation, has so arbitrarily and. ¢
| pric lously exercised that power as to make the Riese
[fol $7) unreasenable,.in deprivagion: of the constitutional
rights of the complaining parties, Red Star ined Drivers’
| ASSn. Vv. Detreit, 254 Mich. 398.

The eniission of smoke has heen subject to lavfal. regu-
lations for many vears. People ve The Detroit White =
Works, et al., 82 Mich, 471. 7 ple v. Lewis, 86 Mich. 2

Pe ople v. Detroit, Belle Isle rt Windsor Ferry C v., 187 Rig ;

177.
The general subject matter having heen ciated ie
fully, the question hereis whether the particular regulation,

establishing aostandard of proscribed sivoke™ emission,
namely, “density equal to or greater than’ the density of

‘+ No, 2” of the Ringlemann Chart is pe rinissible, and reason-

ably ‘related to the purposes of the ordinance. This stand-

26
card has been sustained in the State of New. Jersey. A{aitic
City’v. France, 69 Atl S94, affirmed, TO Ath 165. This case
on appealetewever, restated the old law dhat a comin liw
nuisance inust still be proved to convict under the ordi. —
nance, — wih

The éase of Board ot, Health of Wee hack ven Tw; D. Ve
New York Central R. Ie Cos 90 Ath 2d, 729, recognized the
proposition that if is not necessary to prove that air pollu.
tion results in a public nuisance in order to have it pre
hibited by ordimanée, and upheld the standard of No. 2-of
the Ringlemann Chart as a reasonable standard for pao,
seribed smoke, even though the partic ular ac tivity. does not
result in a public nuisance. a ;

,
. ; » .

fol. BS] | Coure’s Holding

It ix the view of this Court that the ordinance her -
making unlawful the emission.of smoke of a certain density
ix Necessary and reasonable, and a Valid exercise of local
police power, 4

Scientific development in the field of naake abatement,
‘itis believed, has reached ‘that point where a legislative
‘authority may ‘determine that smoke of a particular density
should be prohibited in the interests of the safety, he alth
and welfare of the general public. This exercise. of legis-
lative judgment should aaa subject to jidicial super:
vision tinless plainly beyond the le sitiInate exeréise of -
police power, We do not helieve that Detvoit’s smoke abate-

aa ordinanep ix an arbitrary or unreasonable eXETCISE
of police power.

That confornity to the requirements extablishid by the

— City will require the discontinuance by plaintiff of some
ofits present equipment does not render ‘the ordinance
‘constitutionally offensive. People \ Consolidated Edison
Co. of New York, 116 NYS: Yd, 590; Northwestern Lawidry
v, Des Moines, 239 U.S. 486, 607 Law had. 396: Burrows v.
Delta Transportation Co. supra.
* It is, therefore, held that Ordinance lo7-h, of: the C itv of
Detroit is constitutional.
A permanent injunction is denied,

George E. Bowles, Circuit Judge,
Dated: April 17, 1957... aaa | ,

[fol 40) °*:. -- Lille endorsement omitted |
STATE OF MICHIGAN
‘is THe Cirevir Court rok THE County OF Warne
Ix CHANCERY
Ni 2 Ne. 44-318
glob

*, {Title omitted) — ,

°

.

DeECREE Axp Orver Dismissing Bune oF CoMPLAIN T+
May 1, 1997 =

; _ ‘ 7 : . ae d oe? ‘ ' .
At a Session of said Court held i in the City-County Build-
ing in the City ef Detroit, County of Wayne, Stave of .
Michigan, on May 1, 1957. a 7 —*

Present: Lonorable George Ek. Bowles, Circuit Judge.

“This cause having come on to be heard upon the -bill-of
complaint and answer thereto and proofs taken. therein
in open Court-and. the matters in issue having been argued
. by counsel for the respective parties and the Gourt being
fully advised im the premises, and thre Court having filed
an Opinion: Which by reference is made a part hereof,
. fniding that the plaintift i ix not entitled to’ the relief prayed
for in its bill of complaint and that Ordinance 167-E is
constitutional, - .

Therefore, Upon notion of the nitorneys for defendants,

‘Tt Is: Ordered, -Adjudged and Decreed that. the bill of
complaint filed in said cause on behalf of plaintiff he dis-
Yissed- and plaintiff's praver for permanent injunction be -
de nied, Witli costs to the defendants to be taxed.

~

George Kk. Bowles, Circuit Judge.
O.IK. as to form.” |
sertumont Smith & Hanir, Attys. for plaintiff. -

-Countersigned, Edgar M. Branigin, Clerk, Barney
>. Barthoural, Deputy Clerk. |

—_—— ~~

OX | ‘

I fol. 41]
Is SUPREME Counn | OF STATE OF Miei WIGAN

Hees ‘Portnasp Cement Combaxy.
a: Michigan” égrporation, Plaimtit® and Appellant,

Vv.

Ciry oF Dereon a Michigan municipal corporacen, Brey-
JAMIN .LaNsky.- Chief, Bureaw of Sinoke Abatement,
Po. Lateav, Detendants and Appellyes.

OrtTstox—Filed January 12. 1959
‘ i a

. ‘ e
* Before the entire bench. ; ,

. Voeiker, J. *: | .

The de Saini city of Détroit hi isa comprehe ansive.ordi
nance (No, 167-h) entitled “Smoke Abateinent: ¢ ‘odes Whiei
provides that it shall be unlawful within that city toe per-
mit the emission of smoke of-a density equal to or greater
than that described as No.2 Ringlemann Chart ¢a stand
ard accepted way. of Ineasuring the densit® of smoke)
This ordinance allows certain temporary exceptions whiel:

“are not now relevant. It also provides that after an owner >

has heen warned of 3 Violations withinea 12 month: period
the commnisstonery 2 city Oficial, shall serve notice on the
owners and .seal the offending ‘cqulpment unless he find.
: steps have: been taken. Lb aise
prov vides for the inspection of equipment, and for fines seni
inprisomuent for failure te comply with the ordisance,-
On December 20, 1955 the-city of Detroit filed complaints
in the traflie.and ordinance division of the recorders court
[Yol. 42] thereof against ‘plaintiffaeppellant, owner of the
steatuships Jolin W. Boardman and Ss. Ty Crapo tor allow
ing the emission of dense sineke at. the port of Detroit
contrary to the provisions of the ordinance in question,
Appellant then filed’ suit: in circuit court to enjoin the
city of Detroit and: the other defendants from prosecuting
the colnplaints, and an order was entered granting such
an injunction during the pendeney of this suit. ‘Thereafter

a. ° >

SS See ee - --

in cirenit court the plaintiff. claumed that the ordinance

-Was- unconstitutional as to cit) except ino those instances

Whe ‘re the objectionable simoke is.caused by improper firing
or by the improper use of the equipment on the: vessel,
It is Goneeded: thatthe’ vessels operate. in interstate com ’
Inerce, The trial court held that the ordinance was con.
stitutional and that it} was a necessary and reasonable
exercise Gf the locak police power, From a decree to that
effect, plaintiff has appealed.

In the exercise of its cons stitution: il power to- contro! in
terstate commerce the Congress of the United: States has
provided for extensive control and inspection of American
vessels on the Great Lakes. [tis the contention of appellant
that by such leislation Congress has pre-empted the field

jaind that there fore the ordiiiznee in question is invalid.

The relationship between state-and congressional power
to control wait ia commerce is Well stated in lo CIS,
.
Commerce , p. 26S as follows: rN

iaceek the constitutional grant to congress ot
power to vegulate interstate commerce, although oper-
ating of its own force to curtail state power ins some
jneasure, doés not forestidl all state action: affecting
interstate commerce; it does not withdraw from. the
states power to legislate in respect of their local con-
cerns, even though such legislation may indirectly and |
incidentally affect interstate commerce, “Although state:
legislation affects interstate commerce incidentally, in--
directly, or remotely, vet where it does not undertake
to regulate such commerce and is no more than a boua
fide, Jegitimate, and’ reasonable exercise of the re
‘served police power of the’state in respect of a matter
of Jocal or internal concer; it is valid and . et ae
stand, in the absence of conflicting ar’ superseding
legislation by congress in the exere ise of its superior au.
_ thority to regul: ite ‘commerce among the states..* * di
| fol. 43] Appellant ~ fir ial ae appeal thus falls
‘naturally inte 3 parts: 1 : Does the ordinance conflict with
any federal legislation? 2: Does it?seek to regulate inter-
state comnierce? 32 Ls it a reasonable exereise of local
police power? * | oe

30° nee
academe a

and then examine the. ordinanee in question to see at it
pertains to the same subject matter, The federal legis
lation eited in appelkant’s brie@ACSC.A, Tithe 46, Che id,
ix, so Taras we ean dete rnine, intended primarily for the
protection and safety of vessels.and their passengers, crew
and cargo. Nong of the federal legislation in this field is
tooour knowledge designed or enacted for the protection
of persons and property on land. Appellant has-cited none

part oft that qitestion Wwe must Took
-at.the scope and‘ intent of the congressional legislation’.

Invits brief. -(See Tol-02 OAG, po oe to theseffect that the’

United States Coast Guard so Interprets the applicable
federal legislation.) Tt appears to us that the ordinance
and the federal legislation deal with basically different
subject inatter and are thus not in such contlivt that the
fornier must bow,

A quick glance at. the. title of the ee een “Sinoke
Abatement Code,” is suflicient to learn its intent. Even
‘the aqnost’ casual reading of it.indi¢ates clearly that its
syle purpose ix. to protect the health and welfare oF the
residents. of Detroit by ‘preventing the emission of dense
smoke inte the sir which the people must breathe: |

Thus pari ass ess Yand 3 of the pret unbie \v the ordinance
—y . wT.

‘hereas, the excessive, emission of dense smoke
within the corporate Jiniits of the ity of Detroit and
the resultant effect upon the publie he alth and welfare

require the adoption of a comprehe nsive and integrated
plan of smoke control; and |. \
“Wlicreas, in. conjunction with the smoke cont:
program it is désirable to adopt appropriate regula
“tions to reduce air pollution caused by excessive soot,
cinders, fly ash, dust, noxious acids, fumes and gases.
the emission of whieh is detrimental’ te the health
and. welfare of the Fesidemts of the Citw: Now, There
fore,”

-

| fol. 44] W eo think the ordinance before us is ¢ dear Iv aimed
at the prevention of air pollution and not at any resulation

‘of interstate commerce.e Hf it affects interstate commerce
"at all we think.it is only indireet and incidental.

31

Ta ie md he said on the subject of whether or not this
ordinauce js acre asonable exercise/or locak, police power.
We think that by now it is sufliciently clear Without citation
of guthority that excessive air pollution by dense sinoke
‘annot be anything but harimful to the health and welfare
of a community. .Indeed in 1955 Congress appropriated
$0,000,000 a vear for oO years for research into and control”
of the iicreasingly vexing problem of air pollution. (We.
also note that the first aational ‘conference en air pollution
_ Was held in Washington, -D. C. during November, 1958,
The Nationad Cancer Institute is presently studying the
problem Iut as| of this writing has announced no results.
See science section of Saturday Review for November. 8
1958.). |

We-note further that. the preamble to the above men-
tioned congressional appropriation statute says in. part:

"—* * it is declared to be the policy of Congress to
preserve-and protect the primary responsibilities. and
rights of the States and local governments “in con-
trolling air pollution, to support) and: aid .technical-
research to devise and develop methods of abating

such pollution, and to provide Federal’ technical ser-
Vices and financial aid to State and local government
air pollution, control agencies and other: publie or pri-
vate agencies and -institutions in the formulation and

~scexecution of their air pollution abatement réseareh
programs, © "°°" USCA, Title 42, Ch. ASB, §T857.

. Reg: nding this appropriation statute appéllant correctly
_ states in its reply brief: .

“* * In that Act Congress was not attempting to

give uy}. its inspection ‘of cvessels,’ locomotives, motor

‘arriers and other things that might cone elvably cause
or be involved in smoke podlution.”

-That however is not the question hefore “us. The point
ix that the ordinance does not seek to supersede orereplace.
any existing provisions of Congress-cither in the realm of
air pollution or for the inspection of vessels, as. already
(fol. 45] noted, Its purpose is simply to control to some
extent the emission of spi sinoke, in a community

. \: .

am

‘

. 32, .

so as to protect the health and welfare of its inhabitants.
The portion @f .the statute quoted ahove. indicates to this
Court that the ordinance’ in, question js not only a redsen-
able exercise of docal police pow ror bat that such actions by
local authorities have the recent, blessing aud financial
encouragement of Congress itself.

‘On the other hand we reluctantly realiz@Vhat the pas-
toral pine-scented \days of yore are gone forever, ane that
our society has bechme dependent upon vast conglomerates:

_ of power of which smoke is all too frequently an unwanted
by-product. Thus the elusive question of the reasonable-
ness of. such loéal legislation boils down to one of rélativity.
An ordinance of this type may be said to be reasonable only
if it does not widuly hamper industry and our continual

‘need for power. It does not follow, however, that i’ we

‘annet have smokeless cities that men must compose them-
selves and dwell in an ever «deepening pall of smoke: if
this ordinance sought to prevent the emission of all smoke,
or iftadequate means of smoke control were not availeble,
then a different question might be before us. But this ,
ordinance concededly secks to outlaw only the emission
of smoke of such density that gan readily he prevented by
the use of modern smoke control equipment. All it costs
is money. We find and hold that the ordinance in question
isa reasonable exercise of the local police power and as
such docs not unduly interfere with interstate commerce.

Appellant also argues that whether or not Congress has
expressly preempted the field) of smoke abatement, the =
Detroit ordinance unduly burdens: interstate and foreign
commerce in matters where uniformity’ is neeessary, Ap:
pellant bases its:arguments on this score primarily on the
| fol. 46] fear that local legislation might be inconsistent,
that is, that upon meeting Detroit's ordinance. it may-in .
the future have to change its-equipment again to meet even -

strieter requirements at some other ‘port. T his is a clear
possibility we certainly do not deny. “We do not see how-
ever why this ordimance should be held invalid simply be-
cause of the possibility that another ‘ordinance might an-_ .

-other day be enacted in another place that is even more
stringent. Sufficient unto the day is the evil thereof: we
will endeavor to CPOs that smoke- fogged bridge when we

‘come tovit. We donot discern it in this ¢ CASCL es

-“?

—_— e 4 .
— ‘

fits 33
As noted, if appellant meets only the minimum require-
ment of this ordinance it might very well become a burden
on it to meet more stringent future requirements as, they ‘> +.
are enacted. Because ‘of this. possibility it would have us.
strike down the present ordinance. We suggest, that» such
a hurden might be avoided if appellant sought to meet the
spirit rather than the letter of this present ordinance. “This: .

could conceedediy he dene by installing modern equipment

and available processes of firing that. would. reduce’ smoke
to the least pessibie density. If some future ordinance

goes beyond this appellant or someone in its ‘shoes mizht

have a better and a more persuasive basis for a-claim of
utireasonable burdensomeness. :. ;
In an analogous case involving a Georgia statute that
required the use of a certaim type of headlight on railroad
engines, the United States supreme court spoke as follows
in answer to arguments strikingly — to those pre-.
sented in. this case (Atlantic C A, R. Co. ‘v. - Georgia, 234
US 280): -—-:-~ : 73

“In thus deciding, the court applied the settled prin-.
ciple that, in the absence of legislation by Congress,-
the states are not-denied the exercise of their power tor -
secure safety ino the physical operation of railraad
trains within their territory, even though such trains
are used in interstate conmerce, That ‘has been the.

law since the heginning of railroad transportation.
I Was not: intended that, pending Federal action, the.

“use of such agencies, which,-unless carefully: guarded,
was fraught with danger to the community, should go
(fol. 47] unregulated, and that the states should be

without authority to secure “needed local ‘protection.
The requirements of a state, Of course, must not he
arbitrary, or pass beyond the limits of a fair judginent -
as to-what the exigency demands, but they are not
invalid because wiothér state, in the exercise of a simi-
lar power, may not impese the same regulation, * * mI

an, “If there Ts a conflict in such local regulations, .by

which interstate commerce may be inconveniericed,—
if there appears to be need of standardization of safety
plianeés, and of ne iding rules of “operation. Whic h

*) .
0 te os

will govern the entire intersiate road, irrespective: of
state boundaries.--there is a siniple weimedy; and it

cannot be assumed that it 4 not he re adily applied,
if there’ he real occasion fort Phat re ‘medy dovs not
rest ina denial to the state, in 1 the absence of confliet-
ing Federal action, of its. power to .protect lite and
property Within its bordérs, but it does lie in the exer-
cise of the: paramount * ‘authority of Congress, in its
controkof interstate commerce, to establish sie ‘h fegu-

lations as, in ifs judgment, may he deemed appropriate
and sufficient. Congress, when it pleases, may give the
rule and: make the standard to be observed on. the
ro on Tee
interstate highway.

We loam that this nn? is one that miceit well call
for uniform lowislation of federal’ scope, but until that
happens we are not persuaded that our citizens must patri-
otically gag, choke and grope with obedient resignation — -

—————antilthat happy day arrives. Nor-are we persuaded that’
short ef any such uniform legislation that local govern- |
ments are in- the meantime power = to make a’ proper
exercise of their police power. .

-Appellant cites MeMorran vy, Cleveland-Cliffs Fron Co.,,
253 Mieh.-65, where this: Court pivotal that portion of the »
~~ chaneetlor’s decree’ below restraining as a nmulsance the

~ smoke from the stacks of Certain-coal-burning lake Vessebks
while tied up at a coating dock at’ Port Huron, No smoke
ordinance was there involved; the opinion does‘ not. indi-
cate that furtger-sinoke abatement was there readily avail-
able; the plaintiff householders, there had. moved into: the
area after these conditions had already long existed: and
the smoke froiuthe lake vessels was but a fraction of the
weneral smoke; soot, dust and noise which had long existed,
emanating mostly from stationary industrial installations,

Our opinion there indicates thatthe smoke from the, ves-

sels was but.a reasonable incident df navigation... That Case

and others cited, by appellant are, not controlling of our -

Alocision here, «.- : . |
"fol. 48]. The’. judgement Cie ‘is affirmed, but without

Costs, both a public een and public legislation being
involved. ’

|

ay

[ fol. 49]

Ix true Su PREME Court OF THE STATE OF Nite HIGAN

Heros, Porttaxp Cement Co.,
Plaintiff and Appellant,
| : Black, George Kdwards, siohn D. Voolker,, Thomas M.

‘

Kavanagh, Assoc iaté Justices, a Se)

January T2y 1999)

his aise having Den brought te this Court, by Appen ul
from the Cireuit Court for the. County of W ayne, in (han-

cery, and. having heen argued by counse I, and due delibera-

tion had thereon, it is now ordered: ‘adjudged and decreed
by the Court, that the decree of the Circuit: Court for the

Caunty of Wayne, in Ch incery be and the same is hereby

invall things Affirmed:
And it is further order ed, adjuded au die reed. that no

rer oxts hie’ awarded herein.

U lerk's » Cortifies ite to foregoing paper (omitted: in. pr int-

ing).
[ fol. 49¢ | | File Fa Wie EF ae omitted): é
{fol. 50) °°... [File endorsement omitted] .

1

36

[fol 51]

; Srave or Muiciidan

Ix the Crreecerr Covurr rok Tne County ofr Wayne

. Ix CHANCERY
oe No. 544-318 .

.
\ --

Ihenon Porrhanp Cement Company,
a Mie ‘higan corporation, Appellant,

4 : 4 VS. ° }

Ciry of Detrotr, a Michigan municipal corporation, Bes-
JAMIN Linsnxy, (Chief! Bureau of Smoke Abatement,
P. J. Lankav, Appellees. * - - , .

-_—_o- oOo e

Choss-DesiGNATION -py APPELLEES OF ADDITION AL
Marrers to be PNcvepep ix Reconp—Filegd April 17, 1959

To the, Clerk of the Court:.

¥ on are hereby aerated pursuant to.the provisions of
tule 12 of the Rules of. the Supreme Court of the United
States, to’ incorporate into the transcript of record on the
appeal herein, in addition to the. portions of the record
designated by ‘appellant Jrerein in .its Notice of Appeal,
the following: — oat ai au be

A: The Preamble to aidan No. iGi-Kof the City of
Detroit and also Sections 2.1. 22a and 22b, and 3.1 of
Ordinance No! 167-F of the City of Detroit.

This: (: ‘ross-Designation, together with Proo, of ‘Ser. :

VCO, :
; Nathaniel Tl. Goldstick, Corporation Counsel, John |
IF. Hathaway,» Assistant Corporation Counsel;
Roger P, O'Connor, Assistant Corporation Coun-
asvle By Roger P. O'Connor, Assistant Corporation’
es *Counse!,, Attorneys for Appellees, City of Detroit,
ete, 1010 ¢ itv-County Building, Detroit 26, —
\ wari, W4). 35-4200, Ext. 070. | .

Dated: April 17, 1959.

{Tol i Proof of Servier (omitted_in staiiia ).

—
-

‘ '

.

ee Olle
SMOKE ABATEMENT CODE |
pein eae

City of Detroit

| Ordinance No. 167-E
As Amended to October 16, 1947

| Official
- SMOKE ABATEMENT CODE

of the

ein of Detroit

Ordinance No. 167-E

As Amended to October 16, 1947

” OFFICIAL :

SMOKE ABATEMENT CODE
| of
Detroit, Michigan

Index to Code . 15

Index to Articles 4 15

Smoke. Abatement Code — . j 1-13 |
'. Index to Charts and Tables" . 15

--.Published by
| Department of Buildings and Safety
Engineering |

112 East Jefferson Avenue

City of Detroit, Michigan

1949

a COBO, Mayor

Louis C. Miriani, President of Council

?

’ Councilmen:

Mary V. Beck ae Charles G. Oakman |
James H. Garlick eters. et William G. Rogell
Edward J. Jeffries, Jr. . | Del A. Smith

John A.Kronk 2 = - Edward Connor.

‘Thomas: D. Leadbetter, City Clerk

Chas. N. Williams, City Treasurer

_ DEPARTMENT OF BUILDINGS AND SAFETY

ENGINEERING
Joseph P. Wolff - . Sylvester A. Maher
Commissioner : Deputy Commissioner

. ¢

John W. Shaw |
Chief Smoke Inspector . 2

PERSONNEL OF DEPARTMENT OF BUILDINGS
| AND SAFETY ENGINEERING: sain.

Telephone.— Woodward 5-3000.

SCE 3s ee is 8 ele te Commissioner.
S.A.Maher . . . . . « «© « « «+ « Deputy Commissioner
a ee ae . . « « Administrative Assistant
‘Alfred C.Brozo . . . . ‘Chief, Bureau of Licenses and Permits
Frank E. Simpson .. . « . . « « ‘Chief, Bureau of Buildings
John C.Rehard . . . . . . Chief, Bureau of Safety Engineering —
H.L. Collins . . ... =. . .. Chief, Bureau of Electrical Inspection

L. Glen Shields . . . . . . Senior Associate Sanitary Engineer,
he. at Dat ~ . » Bureau of Plumbing Inspection

J..W. Shaw . -.°. = . «| » Chief,’Bureau of Smoke Abatement .
a OP ee st . « « « Chief, Laboratory

Chas. A. Daymude . . . Chief, hints of Structural ne -

| BOARD OF RULES AND APPEALS
DEPARTMENT OF BUILDINGS AND ‘SAFETY
- ENGINEERING.

"Joseph ee ert, Chairman

‘S. A. Moher 2 we ww ww eee we es Setretary
Geo. B. Bright . .). . . . . .. « ~~. Mechanical Engineer
*R.C. Lloughead .. . . « © « « «| Fire Prevention Engineer.

_! Wm, Zabriskie. . . . | - Ot Burners. Any device for
the introduction of vaporized or atom-
ized fuel oil inte.the furnace of any
fuel-oil burning furnace or device.

(1.29) Open Fire. Any fire where-.
in ‘the products of combustion. are
emitted into the atmosphere and are
not dirécted thereto, by or through
a smoke stack, chimney or other vent
flue or structure. ‘Z :

(1.30) Person,“ Person or persons,
firms, corporations, institutions,. or-
ganizations or associations of any
Kind-or nature. The masculine, fem-
inine, singular or plural is included —
in any gircumstances

(1.31) pair. Any _ work- which
requires the heating: or power equip-
ment to, be wholly / or partially dis-
‘mantled and which. results in the
restoration of the ‘heating or power’
equipment to its original state.

(1.32) Ringlemann Chart. The
Ringlemann Chart with instructions
for use as published’ by the U. s.
| Bureau of Mines.

SERRE EEE
BEER REESE
ER REE ERE Ea
BENE REE ES
EERE REE
EE ERE
EER ENE Eee
BERBERS Ee
EERE ER EEE
BEER ERENREEG

Place the Chart on.a line with the stack and far

ough away from the left eye so that no white between — -
- nes can be ssen. Then com a a - .
/ - under observation ‘.
: Wa e-.
/ (183) Smoke. The visible, finely} (1.35) Smokeless Solid Fuel. For
© divided material that escapes from a/the purpose of this Ordinance, a solid

fuel, the volatile content.of which is

43% or less on an ash and molsture-

free basis. Except: that if a fuel con-

tains volattle matter in excess of 23%

on an ash and moisture free basis, it

shall be acceptable under the terms of ; .
this Ordinance, provided that it meet«

the same standards with regards to

smoke production as.that of a fuel

less than 23% volatile

substance during combustion, except
such other materials as are covered
by this Ordinance.

(1.34) Smoke Indicator. Any -de-
vice electrically or manually operated.
fixed or movable, consisting of photo-
electric devices, mirrors or series of
mirrors which will allow firemen or
other persons operating boilers and/or
other fuel

burning equipment to
determine the density and color of
smoke and/or the ingredients of
smoke, noxious fumes, acids, oxides
‘or industrial dusts — expelled into

. the eo

-containing

matter on an ash and moisture-free
basis and subject to the following

conditions in order to ascertain

a

whether or not such standards are

met in case of violation : First. com-

an | i

—— + ee 2 cree cee ee a Le

plete apevifications of the fuel and |

description of its processing or manu-
facture must be submitted, to the
Bureau ‘of’ Smoke \Inspection and
Abatement, and from time to time
any additional information.that ee
be reasonably required mug also he
submitted.

Second, an adequate supply ‘of the
finished product must be made avail-
able to. the Bureay, of Smoke Inspec- '
tion and Abatement to conduct what-
ever tests are deemed necessary to
establish its value as a smokeless
fuel. ‘

Third, held tests to determine if
such fuels can be so fired as to com-
ply with the provisions of this Or-
dinance may:be required.

Fourth, any person whose product
4s submitted to such tests must pay
all expenses necessary to the at-
tendant tests, and the Bureau shall
‘furnish the submittor a copy of the

‘\. report of.the results of such tests. .

Fifth, the enforcement of this sec-
“tion with reference to the volatility
standard for fuel shall not apply to
hand-fired combustion equipment in
_ buildings containing .not more than
four one-family dwelling units, until
October 1, 1949, after ‘which date all
the provisions of this section -shall
apply to such equipment.

. (1.36) Solid Fuel. Any mined,

packaged, or prepared coal, coke, pe-
‘ troleum coke, carbonized coal,’ either

natural or manufactured, synthetic,

.processed or patented fuel, not sold by
' liquid 8r metered measure. ;

(1.37) Soot. Aggiomerated particles
consisting essentially of carbonaceous
material.

(1.38) Stokers. Any mechanical or
hand-operated device that provides
for the controlled - -kurning of solid
fuel and the controlled supply of air
for combustion.

(1.39) Surface Burning Type. Any
combustion equipment in which the
fresh fuel can be thrown : directly on
the hot fuel. bed.

(1.40) Umbrascope. An instrument
consisting of. an open tube through
which observations are made to meas-
ure the density of smoke. One end of
the tube is closed except for a small
opening serving as an eyepiece. At
‘the other end, which is open, there
are four semicircular glass light-
filters so adapted as to cover a maxi-

, » mum of one-half the field of vision,

and s0 arranged as to allow their use

singly..or-collectively for’ the purpose |:

of measuring the relative density of
smoke against the ambient sky- The.
results of the. observations are then
compared with the Ringelmann Chart.
and thé equivalent Ringelmann read-
ing obtained. The method used to
\ obtain equivalent readings is out-
‘lined tn a report, in the Department's
- files.

—- —-

(1.41) Volatile Matter. The gaseous :
constituents .of solid fuels.

(142) -Water Tubes. Those tubes
containing water, around which, the
gases of ps mae gee pass. , ;

(1.43) ‘ing Wall and Combustion.
Arch. Any firebrick construction built

| inside a boiler furnace or other fur-

“mace ‘that serves as a deflector of
| Gases in the combustion chamber and
as a@ means of providing radiant heat
to aid’in the combustion process.

Article 2—Administrative

(2.1) ‘The escape of smoke, soot,
cinders, noxious acid’, fumes, gases,
industrial dust or fly ash as herein
prohibited ts hereby declared to be a
nuisance and maybe summarily
caused to be abated by the Commis-
sioner or by anyone whom he may.
duly authorize for such purpose. Such
abatement. may be in addition to the
fines and penalties hereinafter pro-
vided :

Sec. 2.2A.

It shall be unlawful

‘within the City of Detroit for:-any
_person,
the emission of ‘any smoke from any

‘firm or corporation to permit

source whatever of a density equal to
or greater than that density described
as No. 2 on the Ringlemann Chart;:
Provided, That the following excep-
tions to the provisions of this sec vion —
shall .be a tted: ris

(a) the shede or appear-
ance of co Ae is*equal to but not
Garker than No. 2 of the Ringlemann
Chart for a period, or periods, 4ag-
gregating four minutes in any 30
minutes;
- (b) Smoke, the shade of appear-
ance of which-is equal to*but not
darker than No. 3 of the Ringleman
Chart for a period, or periods,
laeee three minutes in

curs such as to make it evident ‘that
the emission was not reasonably pre-
ventable. fuel-burning devices.“
(2.12) Upon the inspection and
approval of said plans and specifica-
tions by the Department and upon
the payment of the fees hereinafter
provided, and. if such plans and
specifications shall show that ade-
quate and approved rovisions for
complete combustion of the
fuel or refuse to be - and for
preventing or eliminating smoke,
soot, cinders, fly ash,- noxious acids,
fumes, gases oi industrial dust have
been made,'a permit for the installa-
tion or for the construction, erection,
reconstruction, repair, or addition to
and operation of such fuel or-refuse-
burning plant shali be issued.

(a) As soon as the permit has’
been issued as above’ provided, it
shall be the duty of t various

- other bureaus of the Debartment,
having charge of thé inspection of
the premises wherein said fuel or
refuse-burning equipment .-is_ lo-*
cated to cooperate with the said
Bureau of Smoke Inspection and
Abatement to see that the execu-
tion of the work so authorized by
said permit shall be done in con-
formity with the approved plans
and specifications. and the stand-

_ ards, rules and regulations fixed by
‘the Denartment.

(2.13). If such plans and specifice-
tions as described above are not sub-

mitted to the Bureau’ for approval.

previous to the installation of any

new fuel-burning plant, addition to .

or. repair. or reconstruction of any
fuel-burning plant -for _ producing
power,- heat, or either of them, or
refuse-burning plant. or any stack
connected with such fuel or refuse-
burning plant, the Bureau is author-
ized to seal immediately such equip-
ment unt§l the owner, contractor, in-

staller or other person has oupues

with these provisions.

(2.14). It shall be unlawful for any
person to use any new, ‘reconstructed
= repaired plant or addition thereto,

or any plant duly sealed under the
provisions of this Ordinance, for the
production and generation of heat
and power, or either of them, or for
the burning of refuse, until he shall
have first procured a certificate from
the Bureau certifying that the plant
is so constructed that it will do the
work required with the type of fuel

‘and tequipment* used; and that, in

the opinion of the head of the Bu-
reau, it can consistently be operated
in sompliknce with the ternis of this

Y

.
——e es

\

.\ : EE ee

Ordinance, when burning the, type of
fuel in the manner specified in the
permit, and until a notice of the
size, type. kind of fuef and the man-
ner of burning the fuel as specified
, in the permit has been prominently
displayed and permanently attached
to said plant
“(2:TS) The issuance and ‘dejivery
by the Bureau of any permit or cer-
tificate for the construction. recon-
struction. alteration, repair. or: addi-
tion thereto, of any plant or stack
connected with a plant or for the
operation of such plant or stack shall
not be held to exempt any person,
firm or corporation to whom any such
permit or certificate has been issued
and delivered, or who ts in ion
of any such permit or certificate.
-from prosecution on account of the
emission of dense smoke, fly ash, soot,

-camders, noxious acids, fumes, gases.

or industrial dusts caused or- per-
mitted by any such person. -
(2.16) It shall be unlawful for any
person, firm or corporation to use or
operate any furnace or other combus-
tion: equipment or device which is
. Subject to annual inspection, as here-
inafter set forth, without a certificate
of operation; provided, however, that
if application for such certificate of
operation has been made and the re-
quired inspection fee -paid, it shall
be lawful to use such furnace or
other fuel-burning equipment or de-
vice ‘until receipt of suclt\ certificate
or until notification by the Bureau
of its refusal to grant such certificate
(2.17) Every furnace or other com-
bustion equipment or device snall be
inspected annually and a report and

permanent record made of such in-.

spection by the Bureau except the

following: :
_ (1) Furnaces or other combus-
tion equipment or devices installed
to heat buildings used exclusively
for private residences containing less
than three dwelling units or flats,
and ‘

, (2) Combustion equipment or
devices used exclusively for private
residences which do not contain a
central heating plant. .

_ (2.18) The Department shall not
issue q building permit for the erec-
tion, construction. reconstruytion or
alteration of any building or struc-
ture where the plans for such bulld-
ing or structure show any stack in
connection with such building or

. structure until such plans have been
submitted to the Bureau and the
dimensions of such stack approved as
“having sufficient capacity and as be-
ing suitable for the type of equip-
ment and fuel to be used. ~

(2.19) The Department shall not
approve pla or issue perraits for
the installation of any [uel-burning
equipment or device of the surface-
burning type unless the fuel to be

used in such device shai! be a smoke-

less solid fuel, as defined tn Article 1

Section 135 of this Ordinance or a

mechanical fuel-burning device ts t»
be used of a type which will_so oper-

ate as not to emit dense smoke. or

|permmt the escape of soot, cinders

noxious at'ds, fumes, gases. fy ash.
‘or industrihl dusts or otherwise pol-

lute the ajr. in Violation of the pro-

_ Visions this Ordiriance. a ke

(220) After any owner. agent. oc-

cupant.” manager or lesseé of any

| premises has been previously notified

‘ef three or more violations of this
Ordinance within any consecutive 12-

month period, in respect to the emis-

sion of smoke, soot. cinders, noxious
acids, fumes, gases, fly ash or’ indug-

trial dusts, the owner, agent, eccu-—
pant, manager or lessee of said prem-

ises shall be notified to show cause
before the Commissioner not less than

ten days from’ the date of notice,

why the equipment causing such vio-

lations should not be sealed.

(a) The notice herein provided
for may be given by mail directed.
to the last known address of the
party to be notified, or if said
party or his whereaboute is un-
known, then by porting a notice
on or near the premises at which
the violations shall have occurred.
Upon said date said violator may
appear and be heard. Upon such
hearing, if the Commissioner finds
that adequate corrective means and
methods have not been employed
to correct the cause of such con-
dition then it shall be his. duty to
seal said equipment until such time
as a permit and certificate as here-
in provided have been applied for.
and issued for sald plant.

(b) shall be unlawful for any
pecson break a seal of any refuse
burning equipment, y boiler or.
any equipment or deVice producing —
heat or power, that has been duly
sealed by the Commissioner or: his
autborized representative.

(2.25) When a-certificate of opera-
tion is refused in the case of an
original inspection or a case of an
annual tnspectior, the Commissioner
is authorized to seal, immediately, the
furaace or other combustion equip-
ment until the owner, lessee or other
person required to procure the cer-
tificate of operation shall have com-
plied with the provisions of thi
Ordinance. .

(2.22) Where the Department finds
it necessary for compliance with the
applicable provisions of this Ordi-
nance, no solid fuel burning. rallroad
; locomotive or other power equipment
“shall used within the corporate
limits of the City of Detroit, unless
such locomotives shall be equipped
With proper combustion devices or
other suitable equipment.

(223) Where the Department finds

ay - eS

it necessary for compliance with the
applicable provisions of this Ordinance
all engine houses in which steam
locomotives are repaired, serviced,
cleaned, and’ ‘or. housed shall - be
equipped with a “airect steaming” or
“fuelless” system or a collector and
gas washing system to prevent the
visible products of combustion either
from solid. or liquid fuel from being
expelled into the atmosphere.

(2.24)* Pailure on the part.of any
person, railroad company, eorpora-
tion, association or their agents to
provide the necessary means, equip-
ment, and or device to prevent the
semission of smoke and cinders as
Prohibited by this -Ordinance, or
failure to instruct the operating
crews, enginemen, firemen, hostlers or
others about proper operation of said
traction equipment, shall be deemed
a violation of this. Ordinance and
shall be ‘subject to the penalties as
hereinafter provided.

(2.25) Failure of the operating
crews, enginemen, firemen, hostlers
or others to comply with the -provi-
sions Of this Ordinance shall be
, deemed a viclation of this Ordinance
and shall be subject to the penal-
ties as hereinafter vided.

- (2.26) Railroad ‘locomotives are
hereby exémpted from the provisions
of the following sections ‘of this Or-
dinance, 2.4. 2.8, 29, 2.10, 2.11, 212,
2.13, 2.14, 2.17, and 2.21; and furt..er,
line locomutives are exempted from
the provisions of Sections 2.6 and 2.7.

Sec. 227. Where a violator of the
provisions of this Ordinance with re-
spect to the emission of smoke, soot,
cinders, noxious acids. fumes, gases.
fly ash or industrial dusts produces
evidence satisfac*ory to the Commis-
sioner that he has taken all : steps
necessary to provide for future com-
Pliance with -the of the
Ordinance but that the acquisition of
the proper device or equipment can-
not be effected immediately, the Com-
-misstoner shall have the authority to
allow a period not exceeding six
months from the effect ve date of the
applicable provision or provisions of
this Ordinancé, within which the
necessasry device or equipment is to
be acquired and installed Provided.
That a written report thereon is filed
by the,.Commissioner with the Com-
mon Counc and that body. by reso-
lution, approves such ‘action. During
any said granted period the violator
of the Ordinance shall not be subject
to the fines or penalties herein pro-
vided; if. however, such -violator fails
in the time allowed to conform with

beginning of the said period.
(228) Any person aggrieved by
any decision, ruling. or order of the

Commissioner may take an appeal to
the Board of Appeals of the Depart-
ment of Buildings ind Safety En-
gineering. Such appeal shall be taken
within ten days after the decision,
ruling or order complained of - by
filing with the Commissioner a notice
of appeal directed to the Appeal
Board, specifying tie grounds thereof
and the relief pra,ed for. The Com-

missioner shall forthwith transmit to _

the Appeal Board all papers con-

decision, rdaling or order appealed
from is taken. The Board shall fix
a reasonable time for the hearing of
the appeal and give due notice there-
of by mail to the parties in interest
and decide the question within a
reasonable time... ~
(a) Such appeal shall act as a
stay of any decision, ruling or order
, ‘until either approved, modified or
set aside by said Appeal Bodrd. At
the hearing any party may appear
in person or by agent or by attor-
ney. . -
‘ (b) A fee as hereinafter spectfied
shall be deposited with the Bureau
at the time the appeal ts filed,

order, it shall be made payable to
the Treasurer of the City of Detroit.

(c) The Board. upon hearing such
appeal. shall either affirm. modify
or set aside any such decision, rul-
ing or order The Board shall re-

dered in favor of the appellant.
(2.29) For the purpose of aiding the
Commissioner in ¢stablishing Rules
and Regulations and in reaching
ptoper and just decisions on aj] mat-
ters pertaining to the enforcement of
the provisions of this Ordinance, an
Advisory Board. to be appointed by
the Mayor, is hereby established.
(a) Said Board smau consist of
five members, three of whom shall
constitute a ‘quorum; and all of

whom will serve without compensa- .

* tion. One member of the Board
shall be a duly registered doctor of
medicine whose status as such has
been unchanged for a period of at
_least five years previous to his ap-
pointment; one member shall be a
combustion ef whose status
as such has been unchanged for a
period not less than five years pre-
vious to his appointment: one mem-
ber sball be an accredited coal

dealer whose status as such pas
been unchanged for a period not
less than five years previous to his
appointment; one member shall be

a bona fide representative of a rail- |

ruad whose stulus as such has been
unchanged for a period not less
+ than five years previous to. his ap-
pointment: there shall be one
woman member whose experience

has been such ‘as to qualify her for
such appointment; one member of

‘

stituting the record upon which the,

and if paid by check or money”

fund the fee if a decision is, ren-

©

the Board will be designated as
Chuirman by the Mayor. J
(b) It shall be the. duty of said
Board to advise .he Coramissioner
on all.rules and regulations of the
‘Bureau, and on technical points
- concerned with the enforcement of
the provisions of this Ordinance;
but the Commissioner shall not be
required to act on the advice of
the Board if, in his opinion, there
is good and sufficient reason to
- believe that’ such advice will not

- serve the best interests of the
public. - ~~ - =
_ (¢) Meetings of the Board shall

be at such times as aeemed neces-
sary by the Chairman or by the
. Commissioner.

. 12.30).
permits and certificates and for hear-
ings before the Board of Appeals
and inspections required under the
provisions of this Ordinance shall be
collected by the Bureau Licenses
and Permits of the Department. Th*
amount of such fees shall be -esta’.-
. Ushed by the Board of Rules of tue

«

Department and shall cover the cost.

of inspectjan and supervision result-
ing from the enforcement of this

Ordinance, but in nt case ‘shall the |

installation permit fee or the hearing
fee be less that’ two dollars ($2.00)
or’ more than iwenty ($20.00); nor
the inspection fee or certificate fee
less than three dollars ($3.00) or
more than fifteer. dollars ($15.00).

(a) The fee for the original in-
spection. shal) include the issiance
of a certificate for operation tn case
such certificate is granted and shall
be paid at the time the permit is
secured.

(b) No charge shall be made for
permits and/or original inspections
relating to combustion equipment
or devices to be installed to: heat
buildings used exclusively for pri-
vate residences that do not contain

' @ central heating: plant.

Article 3—(Penalties, Severability,

Ete.) . * =
(3.1) - If any clause sentence, para-
graph or part of this Ordinance, or
the application thereof to any perscn,
firm, corperation or circumstances,
shall for any reason be adjudged by
a Court of competent jurisdiction to
be- unconstitutional or ‘invalid, said
judgment shall not affect, impair or
invalidate the remainder of this Or-
dinance and-the applicaticn of such
provision, to other persons, firms, cor-
porations or circumsta , but shall
be confined in its tion to the
clause, sentence, - ph or part
thereof directly {nvolved in the con-
troversy in which such judgment
shall have been rendered and to the

person, firm. xorporatien or circum-’

Fees for the issuance of all |

= ———— ee

1 ' = ,
istances involved. It is hereby de-
clared:to be the legislative intent of
this Dody that this Ordinance would
Nave been adupted had such invalid
| provisions not been included.

(3.2) Any person; persons, ° firm,
partnership, association or corpora-
tion or any one acting in behalf of
Said person, persons, firm, partne -
ship, association or -corporation vito-
lating any of the provisions of this
Ordinance shall upon. conviction.
thereof be subject to a fine of not
imore than one hundred doljars
‘$100.00y or to imprisonment in the
Detroit, House of Correction for a
| period of not more than thirty (30)
days, or-to both such: fine and im
prisonment :in, the discretion of the
pcourt. Each day that a. violation of
this Ordinance is continued or per-
mitted to exist without compliance
shall. constitute a separate offense
punishable upon conviction’ tu the
manner prescribed in this section.

(3.3) Any person or persons who
shall refus2. to-comply with or who
shall assist in the violation of any
‘ot the proytsions of this Ordinance,
‘or who, in @ny manner, hinders, ob-
| structs, dejays, resists, prevents, or
jin any way interferes with the In-
| spectional Personnel of the Bureau, —
jor police officérs in the performance
of any duty herein enjoined, or shail
refuse tO permit such inspectors or
officers to- perform their duty by
refusing them, -or either of them

&

+) entrance at reasonable hours to any

premises.in. which the provisions of
this Ordinanee are being violated, or
refuse to permit the inspection or
examination of such building, estab-
lishment, premises or enclosures for .
the purpose of the enforcement of
tnis Ordinance, shall be subject ta
oe and penalties herein pro-
Vv °

consumed and to overcome draft loss
or restrictions in rurnace, boiler set-
ting, gas passages, damper openings.
breechings, and stacks. The chimney

must be of sufficient cross-sectional
“area to allow the free un-restricted
discharge of the products of com-
bustion..

(a) For high pressure boilers the
height and dimensions of the chim- ..
ney shall be figured in_ accordance
ie any acceptable formula, but, 1p

o case shall such height and dimen-
pewther be less than tnat specified’ in
Table No. 1 without specific approval
o7 the Bureau. @

(Table No. 5—S8Sizes of Chimneys for
Steam Boilers Kent's Mechanical n+
‘gineering Handtook 1ith Edition,
1945, Page 6-107.) . ry

(b) For~ low: pressure heating
boilers the height and dimensions of
the stack may be figured in accord-
ance with any acceptable formula,
but in no case shall the height and
dimensions be less than that specified
in Table 2 without specific ee
of the Bureau.

TABLE NO. 2.
Chimney Flue Dimensions

(c) No smoke stack or ciimney,
| irrespective of the above (Sec. 4.1(a)

BOILER RATINGS
SQUARE FEET

Steam Water
300to 600 * $00to 1,000
00 to 1,200 1,200 to 1,800 ~
1,300 to 1,800 2,000 to 2,800
2,000 to 2,500 3,000 to 4,000
3,000 to 3,500 4,800 to 5,600
4,000 to 4,500 6,400 to 7,200
4,500 to 5,000 7,200 to 8,000
5,000 to 5,500 8,000 to 8,600
- §5,500to 6,000 8.800 to 9,600
6,000 to 6,500 9,600 to 10,000
6,500 to 7,000 10,400 to 12,000
7,000 to 8,000 _ 12,000 to 12,800
8,000 to 9,000 12,800 to 14,400
9,000 to 10,250 14,400 ta 16,800
10.250 to 12;750 16,800 to 20,400
12,750 to 15,600 20,400 to 25,000 ~-
15,600 to 18,000 25,000 to 28,800
18,000 to 20,400 28,800 to 32,640

(Prom the Association of Radiator.

CHIMNEY FLUE CHIMNEY
SIZES HEIGHT —PT.
Round Square Minimum
“a 8"x 8” 25’ to 35°
10” 8x12” 35’to 40’
_ 12”x12” 40’to 45’
15" 12x16" 40’ to 465’ .
16” 16x16" - 45’ to 60’
18” 16"x20" ‘ 45’ to 650’
20” 16x20" 50’ to - 55’
20” . 20°x20" 50’ to 55’
20" 20"x20” 55’to 60’
22” 20"x20” 55’ to 60
24” 20"x24" 60’ to 65’
- 24” 20"'x24" 65' to 70°
26" 24"'x24" 70’ to 75’
28” 24"°x28" 75 to 80’
28" 24x28" B80 to 85’
30” 24x28" - 85’ to 90’ ..
32” 28x28" 90" to 100’
32” 36x30" 100° vo 110°

Mfrs. Lab., Geneva, N. Y.)

and ‘b). shall be installed with less
cross-sectional area or with less
+» than those reeommended by the’man-
ufacturers of the’ boiler or boilers
connected thereto.
" (d) No smoke stack or chimney
‘shall have openings other than for
the breeching or breechings for the

boller, boulers or combustion equip-'

ment. served and a clean-cut door. .
(e, . All incinerator stacks and any

other chimney,

which emits

sparks in

smoke stack or flue |
sufficient —

amount or size to cause a hazard to
bulidings or surrounding property
shall be equipped with a spark ar-
ester of-proper size and construction
to prevent the emission of such ‘dan-
gerous sparks.

(f)_ All stacks and chimneys and
parts ®hereof or appurtenances there-
to shall he constructed tn acéordance
with t provisions of Article 22 of
ithe jal Building Code of the
City of Detroit. ©.

-(g) The Departinent may grant

o

.. Table No. 1—Sizes of Chimneys for Steam Bolilers*® o.:
Based on Kent Basie Formula (11) :
Height of Chimney, ft. Equivalent
Effective : P y Square
Area, E.40 50 60 70 -80 90 100 110 125 150 = = 175 200 225 250 275 300 325 350 375 400Chimneys,
am., Area A, A-O. 6VA Commercial Horsepower: of Boiler Side of
in. . sq.ft. aq. ft. . : Square in
sp a . (12 VE) -4
18 1.77 Fe > i a a a el yan rn ae edahias' ie adeonk! eGaninabl. aimee as: eae a 16
21. 2.41 ‘1.47 31 35 ie ir " ocecgdhe seein: > weeds: Senne sje | -wgelaeiin: _ aaabiniinn > weap wok wasentes ages: vatemana lenihaeuiin® Mosbeuiien "ictoiedar ce sie >- oabich eats 24
30 491-. 3.58 ..... 84 2 St ge Cee © i eer oor ep Beene is anna sebsigeiaics “Sevtninne .oreulbued -semguonns “ebeeddioas 27
33 5:94 448 ... ... 118 125 133 141 149. 156 ........ Rc oes vga teasteee 1, wurmacats sine : cntpagean. dlasuaigmteresssieeds ‘wsinlesubs secerigaae deinkania 30
. 36 7.07 5.47- .. a ne ee i ME ME alte ectiouneer | eeemanstes. ‘euelbine ae weeebeeess _Ulianas-scteegtits -wkiibadie” Scat an 32
39 8.30 6.57. ... ek neo a CE, MI huhu: -s>-4ceniie! “aasSbpesas caeltnewetiemietoes |) amsbeewn . Wcbiened. Alevgunts” “phactanias’ nehaasess 35-
42 9.62 - 7.76 a.) eee ae ae ee a ee eee eee 88
48 12.57 10.44 ws eee «=... B11 .830 348 365 389 426 460 MEU novatssine * aaaeveens sipatinn* ;- Gitnindoed Seemann" peapen Mecha Caen. Week otinas x waaccee, elimi’ cakamaea iia “.... 13658 14397 15099 15771 16414 “17034 17632 18210 202
I ne annenins: JORaNi eeeal 15161 15981 16761 ~17507 18222 18909 19573 20215 . 213
*Calculated on basis of 1 Boiler ce equal 5 5 lb. of coal burned per hour. For any other rate of combustion multiply the value in

the table by the ratio of -6 to the ectual rate of combustion.

TT

12

———_

“permission for the construction and

-use of stacks or chimneys for use

. Provided,

with combustion equipment or de-
vices using gaseous or liquid fuels or
, @ combination of such fuels without
“strict compliance with Paragraphs
(a) and (b) of this section (4.1);
{1) such stacks or chim-
neys cannot immediately or at any
time be used with solid fuel burning
equipment in such manner as to vio-
late. the provisions of this Ordinance,
and that (2) such stacks or chimneys
shall otherwise’ comply with the Pro-
visions of this Ordinance.

" (4.2) Where the Department finds
it necessary for compliance with: ap-
plicable provisions of this Ordinance,
all incineratcss shall be equipped with
gas washing devices, settling cham-
bers, or other approved devices for.
the elimination of the nuisance.

(4.3) Breechings of all boilers or

fuel-burning devices shall be of suf- |

ficient cross-sectional asea as to pre-
vent excessive gas velocity and to
defeat the obtaining of complete ‘com-
bustion; and shall have a minimum
number of bends and turns.

(4.4)° Induced draft fans may be
used where necessary or destrable,
_ provided .the requirements concerning
- stack or chimney size and height are
observed in accordance with the pro-
visions herein specified. >:

(a) Case» involving the use of
Venturl stacks'and other stacks or
chimneys not deemed to be within
‘the coverage of this Code shall be
decided upon their merits and the
Commissiéner may grant approval for
the use of such stacks or chimneys.

(4.5) Tube areas and gas passages
through —— a suffaces shall be of'
sufficient area to permit of the ordi-
nary accumulation of soot and fly ash
without such restriction to draft as

‘wouid interfere.with smokeless opera-

tion of the fuel-burning equipment.

Setting Heights

Shall be as f

Eas

Sufficient means must be provided for
the removal of soot, fly ash, dust,

‘and cinders from the heating surfaces,

tube region,-and gas . Baffles
must be of such design and so in-

‘stalled and maintained as to not in-
‘terfere with smokeless combustion

due to the impigning of flame on

heating surfaces where such impinge- |

ment would result in~ reduction of
temperature below the ignition point
of the combustible’ gas.

(4. 6) Furnace Volume
ments for coal, fue} oil, , pulverized
coal, wood-ref
lows:

‘(a). A steam oboler iurnace or
other furnace using hand-method of
firing shall be provided with a furnace
volume of not less than 1 cu. ft. com-
bustion volume for each rated horse-

‘power or for each 140 sq. ft. equiva-

lent direct radiation capacity.
(b) Mechanical
provided with a furnace volume of

require- .

stokers shall. ‘pe’

horizontal boilers .

not less than 1 cu. ft. if rated

| horsepower.
/(c) Purnaces using fuel “onl shall
‘be Provided with a furnace volume of

not less than 1.50 cu. ft. per rated

horsepower or for each 140 sq. tt.
equivalent direct radiation.

(ad) Furnaces using pulverized
coal shall have not less than 3 cu. ft.
furnace volurmhe per rated horsepower.

(e) Wood-refuse burning boilers

or furnaces shall maintain a furnace

volume of from 6 to 10 cu. ft. per
rated horsepower.

(f) Refuse-burnefs and destructor
type of incinerators shall maintain a
furnace volume of 1 cu. ft: per sq.
ft. grate surface.

(4.7) Horizontal. return tubular
boilers not equipped with mechanical
stoKers shall be so set as to provide
adequate combustion facilities, and in
no case shall the distance from shell

aa
for Stoker

: Equipped Boilers

Min.—Absolute minimym

i an cs Ss

eo

P.M.— —Preterred ‘minjeu

Multiple _ :
Retort, ‘ "TYPE OF STOKER
Underfeed . Single Retort Side Front
~ ; Underfeed Overfeed Overfeed Chain Grates
. Type of Boller Min. P.M.Min. P.M. Min.PM.Min.P.M. Min. P.M. Min. P.M. Min. P.M.
' Water Tube: : .
Horizontal 10° 12” 10° 12” 8 10 #8 «AY 8’ 10° 10° 12". 12 1¢
’ Imclined ¢Hor. M. D.) . . , ¢ . = FF @& # eS ¢§ @C Ff SG
Inclined (Vert. M.D)... 5 8 eh
Vertical (Hor. M. ane sT A *°S © FSC FF € 2 a oe ce
Vertical (Vert. M. D.)....:. :
160 h. p.. ......,................ #6" 6 46" §° ¢6" 6° 9°39” -3'6" 46" 41" 4°7" &° B’6”
250 h. p.. went CO FF OE. CF OF F CF. 3°6" 46" 4°1" 4°7" 5° 5’e"
~~ & p.m... EOF. & Fe 6 6'6” 3'3" 3’6” 4'6" “™ eT” eo oe
’ © : 7
-Horizontal Ret. Tubular: : ,
7 &;" ...5« 3 Ae ee oo a oe ae on ee a a
& In. : 8’ 10° Tr sv 8 Ww

13

°

r

to grate be -less> than specified in ‘and/or electricity and excepting coal-

Table 3. jburning boilers of 20 horsepower or
2,500 sq. ft. of equivalent direct radia-
aes i $ , tion = ag shall, provide means
ih ,; whereby the fireman or engineer or
Poller Distance thie person firing the boiler ‘may be
Diameter Shell to grate . enabled to know without leaving the
84” 72” boiler or furnace room whether or not
78” 72” ' dense smoke is being emitted from the
72" 60” | chimney or stack, so that the neces-
66" 60” ‘sary correction may. be made at the
60” E |time. Such means of observation | \shall.
54” a ‘cons.st of one ef the following:
48” er | (a) A window or’ other opening
a 6” through which unobstructed view of —
| the top of stack may be had from
(4.8f Power boilers equipped with the ve. a a.

_ stokers shall be set in accordance |
with the minimum dimensions found,
in Table 4.

(4.9) Forced draft fans maybe)
used provided suitable arrangements |
aré made for the prevention of the
emission of soot, cinders, and fly. ash. |

; (4.10) Use and Installation of Air |
Jets. All high pressure boilers using
solid fuel and -not equipped with |
mechanical stokers or provisions for |
using pulverized fuel shall have at
least one air jet for each 200 sq.
ft. H. S. or fraction peng many In no
case shall there be tian two air!
jets. The jets shall bé installed at or |
under the direction of an inspector of
the Bureau of Smoke Inspection and
Abatement of the Department of
Puildings and Safety Engineering.

(a) Where it is impossible, due to!
“construction, to equip a’ boiler and,
furnace with air jets, it will be neces-
sary to install mechanical stokers on
all boilers having more than 200 sq.
ft. H. S. or 2,500 sq. ft. equivalent
direct radiation.:

(4.11) Fvery owner, -agent; or
lessee of every boiler.plant within the
. corporate limitseof the City of De-
_ troit, except those using gas fuel

(b) A mirror or ceries of mirrors
so placed as to reflect the top of
the stack and be visible from the
boiler or furnace room.

(c) A smoke indicator as approved
by the Bureau of Smoke Inspection
and Abatement of the Department of
| Buildings and Safety Engineering.

(J. C. C.. 1263, May 6, 1947.) —

Passed July 8, 1947. .

Approved July 15, 1947.

A pen July 16, 17, 18, 1947.

14, 1947. P
ec 2.6 amended by Ordinance No.
194E.

(J.C.C. September 16, 1947.)

Passed Séptember 16, 1947.

Approved September 17, 1947. "5
* Published September 18, 19, 20,1947.

Effective October 17,.1947. —

Amended: by atiding Sec. 3.7, Or-.
dinance No. 205E. .

(J.C.C. 2562, Sept. 23, 1947.)
Passed, Oct. 7;- 1947.
Approved Oct. 14, 1947. ~
’ Published Oct. 15, 16, 17, 1947.

~ Effective. Oct., 16, 1947. .
THOMAS D. LEADBETTER,
City’ Clerk.

"(Complete through Oct. 16, 1947

Title \
ADMINISTRATION ‘

DEFINITIONS —_-
: = SEVE

WORK CODE

\-
ALPHABETICAL \INDEX

Section Page 7

&.

Acids (noxious)
Authority . :
Baffing .- ; ate
Board : .

Advisory

Appeals

Boilers
thorizontal,
tubular)
Table 3
Breeching
ie Requirem, ats,
-Bridgewall -
Bureau - Be
Certificate of Operation
Display ‘of
. Refusal of .
. Requirements — for
Where.«required
Chimney
(See Stacks)
Cinders
Collectors
Permits for
Required
Test of
Combustion Arch é
Combustion Equipment .
Annwal Inspection
Approval of
Definition
Fuel for
Installation and syuele
Mechanical
“Permits for
Plans required.
Purchasing
Record of
Sealing
Surface burning ihe
_Use of

return,

~

Commigsioner
Authority
Damper. _
- Department
Dusts
Industrial
(Also see. pollutants)

Dutch oven

Extension furnace
(See Dutch oven)

” Fans ay

Forced ‘draft
Induced - draft
Fees
‘Fire ,
Cleaning.
Open idef.) .
i prohibited )
Kindling
Fly Ash
_ Test for
Quantity allowed
(Also see pollutants) ’
Fuel
Dealer ‘def:

Respdnsibility .
ivery of ;
Emergency : ihe

Y “Sale of

NENNNNN RENNER NN
ee Oe ee Oe Oe

me Oe

—

2: °
ji

4.

ABILITY,

\. No.
\1. 27
2.1

No.
2

1

oe

IM 3-3

=
x
~-

ge
_
nm

eR Se AIA RAMON BRMO DM Nd Ne

.

INDEX TO ARTICLES

Section Page

Title ' No. No.
Solid . 1.36 4
-Equipment for. . ae. 5-

- Smokeless solid 1.35 3-4

Fuel Burnings «Plants .

»tSee Combustion waitom teal y

Fumes (def.)*. Ser 1.20 2
(See pol'utants) y :

Furnace volume ser 1.21. 2\
Requirements °4.6 12

Gases 1.22 2

+ Heating Surfaces 1.23 2

Incinerators 4.2 12
(Sce Combustion Equipment) ’

Indicator (Smoke) 1.34: 3

. 4.11 13.

Inspection :

Annual . ees oe
Original Sai: *

Jets «Air) a re

Requirements * ee 13

+ Lochmotives ‘: :
Engine houses 2.23 a
Equipment for 2.23 vi

. 2.24. 8

Exemptions 2.26" 8
Violations - 2.25 8 8 6§

Oil Burners 1.38 2

Penalties 3.2 9

. 3.3 +]

: 2.20 7

Permits
For Combustion Equipment 2.12 6 -
Limitations, of zis. . 7

Person 1.30 2...

Pollutant: Prohibited | 2.1 4

; 2.2B 4

--Emission of 2.4 4-5
Elimination of 2.12 6.

Pollution .

Atmospheric Kine 12- ,1
, Repairs 1.31 2
Emergency 2.10 ..°6
' Repeal of previous ordinances 3.5 9

Ringlemann Chart 1.72 2

Authority for use "2.5 5
' Saving Clause of O,. dinance 3.1 :

Smoke Abit
Definition 1.33 3.

, Grading of - ae 2,5 5
Permissible. .: - song 22ATa) 4
2.2A(b) 4
Unlawful: crore *§
‘ a -2.2A 4

Soot 1 37 4

_ _ (See Pollution)

Stacks .- 1.8 - 1
Plans for ee 2.11(b) 6
Requirement» for , ) ee
. . 41
Tables 11

12

1 1)

; 2 . ‘10

Venturi. 4.4(a) 12

Visibility of - 4.11 13

Stokers . j
_ . (See Furnace Volume)

Tubes.

Fire LAT 2
Requirements E 4.5 +. 12
Water 1.42 4

Umbrascope 1.40 4
Autnority for use . 2.3 5

Violations
Appeal . ; 2.28 7

“Number of © ety 2.20, 7
Probationary period 2.27 *

Volatilé Matter - 1.3606 6° 3.

1.41 4

Wing Wall 1.43 4

_ ee min sg ree
nag :

.
“ee .

ao —— way -
¥V34 3NO *) Pansee: Aquey's 35ND) PequoTEp-eMyA sy
| Hog. “9 ON emsery

WEN) pp my20170) Asedeg |
° ° es . ee ee aon ;

a

Cy) ;
_ WWaA aS penny Aas 1 ISNADIT Poquotepune sy
= itis “$0 pomseny

_. BYAA ANC %) pansuss Aqaiey 1 aSNaIT PaquapuMin oy

alll

WAL INO "9 pacens Aauig _SSNEON Poquonepanin my

ae

WRK INO AY Pamoues hqneny 8 a5Na0N7 poquanap-ayin oy

oq “peNfemscey

rotons Dass ,
—eeee ++ + + Oo OOO eme tee eee ees es eeeees esses ie,

i

“1 “OM jemcees

WAEMNEE 40 SLNBMESBOGNE

(ROTORS $° #94

oe deatir ll

i ‘ tn oem a ny ps

Maman) fo mey2eypo> Ayndng

‘joan po wowr-unyim 44 40 Ayo pursed 4o 9 ay 4a pean
em op ee ney”

~ 40 Hog
tn

¢ 6) . 5

‘tarnyne) soy 20)70) Ayadag ©

oa ‘yomee Powmwuniia By Jo saysou quataed 40 9) agpantin a

{IS% Oo 94) u9—Dy Burany © --~ ;

oe a TT TE ee oe we ce He

i

sarnsne) fo m420/70) Ayeting

; mas Puce unyin oy sys rad Yo
| GRO Spe rey *

=

“ 4o poy

si HPO ay woqDy Buoy *=

“Sarayne) /O sApDEFOD Ayedog ~—ane-sonsnen

“PHBA POUDU-uyyim 944 yo 1aysDW yuatesd 40 81 “aw; hq panb
HOO yy waqD) Berney © ~ TUpue =
a 5) made i er yo

bk esc etaieee” See Bw

. EE SOND t ‘may Aq paunk

Bro sy 5 ay, NR ak ar
toon -> -—!

eNO Pens hater ae, alae

Rateaesgcnn, i RAB tik?

eae Cs: 2. rs

I neh he" FRA? of

“pan pousuronun my jo sysou yoraed 4

= ix a. Aaa

moog to
. _ (0 ifs
weer) myoie) hmdeg © | : 7 ? | ne : . F432 ¥ -
“|9MSA Pewmu-umpim 94) 40 saysDW yuseed yo 5: dhe eee a 9m poucw-uyyn ay 4 ings yuo os my At past
ee oP Oy. Snes PT Iwry ‘hy y

a

> 40 04
_ 1

—- By oe
_ | OA Powbu-uyyn SUT 40 saysBw yuaseed yo 8: “ay nipente

faa hg (a “gs
i= > 2 a ‘& ‘

[OMA PRHUUDU-UNYYIm 94) 40 1948DW yusseud 4D 81 ‘ma hq
| cae SA dt ae aly 1 ing oan ty "yng! “wa
Rates ; Tae Waisvm 40 veNVIO do iMEMESBONN ae i

Pre prusranyue my Jo yOu warned yo ‘ao Aa pant Ye ete

‘{fol. 54]

. at VesseL S. T. Craro
OFFICIAL No, 226885.
Gross Tgxs - 4,769

‘Pigs kK XWIBIT 2

>.

eo

Tre reasury Department
U.S. Coast Guard
CG-841 (Rev. 9-53 |
| File No. FS
Jan 10 1957° ° or ae
Donald KE. Miller . ' “This Certificate Expires

Official Court Reporter 21 March, 1957 >

3rd Judicial Circuit
Tyrrep States of AMERICA

lL NITED STATES Coast Guarp’

¥ .
---ooOoOo

( ‘ERTIFIC ATE ops] NSPECTION =

3

- .Vesset - S. T. Crapo OFFICIAL No. 296885.

(‘Lass Freight Tons: Gross 4,769 Net 2,942: LeNctr 392.5",

~ Home Port Detroit, Michigan Owwsers Huron Portland:

Cement Co. a
Orerators Huron Portland Cement Co. 13825 Ford Bldg.,
Detroit 26, Mich. are

“Fhe inspection of the above- named vessel having been

completed at Ecorse, Michigan on the 21st day of March,

1956, T hereby Tenetey that the said. vessel was built at

_ River Rouge in the ‘State of Michigan, in the year 1927,

ee

u
rebuilt in the year... ; that the: hull is constructed of
Steel; is provided ae “stateroonts, ee berths; that
the said vessel at*the date hereof is in all things in con-
pe, wt with the applicable vessel inspection laws and the
rules and regulations: preseribed thereunder ; ‘and is al-

'* "TreasUry DEPARTMENT ci gas!

fa : ; -

~ lowed te carry ........ passengers, 5 persons ‘in acidition -to:

-

the crew.

The following ‘iidaadeeaitaa of licensed ifficers and crew
is required to be Garried, included_in which there must be
3 certificated lif eboatinen:

Master & Pilot ....Second Mate 6 Able Seamen |

2 Ast Class P N6ts / ee Third Mate .3 Ordinary
+ Seamen

1 2d Class Pilot aes Inland Mate. . 2s... Vatehmen é
ie Chief Mate Radio Officer ...... Deckhands

1 Chief Engineer . 6 Firemen | .

1 Ist Assistant Enginger 3. Oilers Ay

1 2d Assistant Engineer . Motorboat. Operators

‘1 3d Assistant Engineer ‘3 Coal Passers

and alse may carry 12 persons when needed in the steward’s .

and otlier depiartments not connected With the navigation _»

of the vessel. Total number of persons allowed 46. ie

When this-vessel is navigated on routes of less than, 16:

_hours on Lake Ontario, only 2 of the licensed ‘deck-officers

specified are required to hold license as pilot covering the
waters of Lake Ontario: % eee ed

P

The said vessel is permitted to b fated for one. year
on the Great Lakes ee «Wf, ;

. .
.

| 7 °

- 44 : =

{fol.59] Clerk’s Certificate to
‘(omitted in printing).

° .
=

. [fol. 60] ;

SUPREME Court OF THE r NITED STATES +.

No. 86, October Term, 1959

. . 1.)
. \ pd e+
Hurox PortLaxp Cement Company, eEtc., Appellant,

_—_—_
.

~ VS.

-Crry or .Detroit, ETc., at al.

Appeal from thé Supreme Court of the State of Michigan

.

Orver NotinG Propane J urispiction—October 12, 1959

The statement-of jurisdiction in this case having been
submitted and considered by the Court,
* diction is noted.

os »°%

probable juris-

‘foregoing — transcript |

©

40

bs [ fol. 50]

Data, Particutars oF EqtirMeNt AND
. Pertabic EXAMINATIONS _

.
.

—- —— sd

-W ooden lifeboats for

somal persons

2. - Metal, lifeboats for.

'

0 persons

_.....Moter lifboats for

seen

1 Liferafts for 15 -personss

see e.

Working boats for

aad persons

... Buoyant apparatus for

"...... persons

> Life preservers, adult’s

Life preservers,

Wood floats

children’ s

ty De, line-throwing

.*

Ring Buoys

apparatus

Luminous Ring Buoys

Anchors |
Cables

—-

2 Fire extinguistiers, |
Class All

3 Fire extinguishers,
| Class B II
2 Fire extinguishers,

ateae Fire extinguishers, Semi-
portable Class ......

+ Fire - extingrulubers, Fixed

steam 1 dry CH,3 FL

.8 Fire axes
2 Fire pumps

Fire hose, total length 300 ft.
Inspected and approved for
the carriage of inflamima-
leer combustible liquids

of grade: Sa iemieeaionigsCabiedess ms

Class C I>

tb

41

Stability letter jssued

Dae drydoe ked 24 Keb. 1 1953
Propelled by steam
Tail shaft drawn ; —
raat me er 1800
Pressure ‘vedecls: examined
21 Mar. 1956
Blr. shells drilled
* 28 Feb, 1950, thk 1.23”
- Fuel coal.
Main steam:‘line measuved

10 Jan. 1956, thk. .276”

Aux, piping over 3” 7
dia. tested 21 Dee. 1955

! Mountings ined:

‘Date

Main Borters
Number 3 Year built 1927
Mfr.. Manitowoe Boiler Wks.

Minimum efficiency of weak-
est longitudinal — section
| 84.67 per cent

Ree ‘ord in Office at ;
_ Detroit, Mich. “

23 Jan. 1953
Length blr. 11’ -

Mountings removed
23 Jan. 1953
Diameter hlr: 153”

hydrostatic pressure
applied 21 Dee. 1955 &
{ —-:10- Jan. 1956

.Maximum steam pressure’ _

allowed 185#

Kalhjorn Hansen:

Commander, USCG (Officer in Charge,
- Marine Inspection)

Detroit, Mich.

‘ —————
nl °
———

Srrniarters Exhibit A A Wy a 3)

THE UNITED ST ATES OF = AMERICA

; TREASURY DEPARTMENT Pe ;
—*. | BUREAU OF CUSTOMS

t, Michigan .
%, Michigan 1953

Consolidated Certificate of Znroliment ond License

nee Guameann, Neniemerann, cue Henmeurerane Paswnane a7 wel Cisran Srares, Ovetawee Tuan or. S01)

ln Contarty Ye Ta, “Replat of Vn» Domatie Comma,” f the Rare Sette ofthe Usted Stet
: : f |: |

; mua 8, ou, of 254 tei M0 Grosse Pointe, Michigan, SSORETART
having taken and subscribed the oath ' ee | eee ene required by law, and —s sworn * En BIL EL eee OA I AO LD BL

_ Baron Portland. Oanent —- er eee

, *
a meee - eee: comes oe Oe ES ee ee el ee ee el ict tt: a ll ti

| Tacarperatad under the laws. of the State of Michisn sss its spl cadens tate mete
MA Offoee at 1325 Fora Butlaing, Detroit 26 ei e Oe

eee eee — ee et eee
- o-«* +

-
CO EE EES OD SS

(75 percent of the interest in the corporstion ouniag
ee Site vessel 29 owed by — ~ ae » other spaces (except double
; open peop ..............., open shelter deck . ae) --» Cabins 14.48...
, water-closets 43,82 . anchor gear _. 463 .. Condenser

— let

4 a

i ee ee

having agreed to the description and measurement above specified,

yo ad
the said vessel has been duly ENROLLED gt this PORT:
. LICENSE ts .
And. , the master, having sworn n thes wa is @ citizen of the United

wy. that this license shall not be used ad any ofher : essel ov for « any other employment then is hercin specified, or in any wade

States may be defrauded:

LICENSE is hereby. granted fur the said vessel to b. employed im carrying on the COASTING AND FOREIGN TRADE for

a
-

or business whereby the revenue of the United

OnE veAn from the date hereof, and no lovighe.

a

ay = | . . ; | ?
Mar register length ws. RD. an emeeneenens- Tu jest, ner y reguser PreR PL OR ie Ty feet, her veguter depth : eee 22.0 - feet,
her height... . gy feet; thas she measures as follows: ae Cw eee - SA ee ee
‘Capacity under tonnage deck ae B88 fig A gS oe i OG, oe 6 Se OR ele ake ge we! : gett 3571132
Capacity between decks above tonnage deck sa Ve te See Signs eae eae ear ee he te eee wit) ena % ae Lacan
Capacity of enclosures on ‘the upper deck, viz: Forecastle 91.36 ; bridge. _ createed POOP)... break -_ n boaee “sas .
‘houses—deck A742. sp BOE. asencseennde . date. and place of of euch former document. . wigincl or a eam oi
* ineert the name and businces eddie es of the waner. If there are two or mo Ae ee sgl and , forme document wae wires n tere ye @ the reasom for lseus of the new gocument.
af business whiress of une of the ow ne :e (managing owner, if one Nes been ive eriafed) and the pre fon Write “aeid Pewter.” “adi rallement,” or “ead license.” In the Aref document of a new vessel,
pa by him. followed by the names of the other oanere are 1 the Tertione ce ped by each If any ounce wive the name and tithe of the abatiesee
“aw -rperation. give the corpo rete ame Gath» wed by the eorde >) curporated under the lawe of the Stale * For a veserl having a steam tor an internal combustion) engine write’ *‘steare (or was or ail) eidewheo!.”
tneerting the approrriate State fame . * : - weam tor gaa or ott aterneheet”” “steam tor gas of oil) screw.” as case may be.
ef Ameren delete” ectiten of the Unitet States and a Tr sort the dometishine and tonnages exactly as they appear on the preceding dreument (or the cerubcate

ened by the Unitet State:
£ Hehe So came oom th e. " appends the Preceding derur ent or on the cage of @ Aret document.
° ® eosl © ommler

eas = “esurement in Caer of « chance in tonnage of upon iseuance of the first document)

| rel on thé atthe cat) .
i nants he cum trate ly prwer te be entation oo cmb ecumentation ese ere sme oe camber Um paceh: ioe eter master. ur agert In the Arspdocument, t ame should be thut of the perepa epun
Theme i recestest he te prefaces tents tele. (oe met te herursentest mame ; hy Cert Mente of admeasurement
‘We te) Baal en "atest a ‘ ; ~9183@ 16) & 8 Govescecet SaietiEs errrce
. ~~ ~ o— = - ——— @o = - - - ee » — a "

Tf the weane!l hae bevrne eeother name of @ frertor teat ‘* t. .e@ the name of the wren .“y~ to the deecri and measurement and the capecity in which be °|

+ /* |

: Port of - ra Dae ke ah Pocesevence

| er UF om

’ Date of facial : fetta sities Sasa: sae

| Discharge amount, $.0.2..00-000 0 coool

—— ° r

Qemscen mene att, om ot. @—< 6 ¢. WR @ GUST =

MORTGAGE DESCRIPTION

Mort gagor.

Endorsed cavaictideinsnatiiie 19-—, a. a *

Total amount, a saaninapalinsehtiniehing

», 19-

?

toma}

~ Depety Collector of Customs.

_ MORTGAGE DISCHARGE .
e*. (SuseacTiON os)

Port of —. iS a ee

|

feeewntmmmansey FY........
The iid of $...

Gapdeteadiaicbadnscabte ~<t-Je-.
paid on the above-described mortgage, the certificate
of such discharge being filed in this office and recorded

—-- any 1G... BE i cce-. 9B.

Departs C ollectas of Conomi

+

*

Official No. . 223376

re
\* TREASURY DEPARTMENT
See er Gaeeee
————_——_ -------——

Pevemind

. _——— --——

(Permanent or Temgerary)

FRONTIER.

—.

BOARDMAB <

ment 2 Y Mayes

IssuED AT THE

* iniee’ of Detrott, Michigan

tee cwece wes Knee

May 2, 55

—-—_- — =— ieiadh =

WHERE SURRENDERED: sa
_ WHEN SURRENDERED: :
i:

WHY SURRENDERED:

wis enee ene annem genre ae moe
n
; lo
ae a
’ onwee cone qpa=nyub -
. Deputy Coltpetor of Customs
‘
* : ae Pe

5

j
/

. e
-
.
a? PREFERRED MORTGAGE ENDORSEMENT

- oman] a, eine |

A CDOT CANE AT. SE. e. oa conse owen a
el

Date of maturity...

ve

Discharge amount, $...._....

Port of PR Reo ’ : ‘ ‘

°
BAL es PY
: ; Deputy chit of Canons.

—s

MORTGAGE DISCHARGE

, (QuSSECTION om /

Port of ..... pie ince

ee,

The sum of $.. a | .. hasbeen

paid on the above-described mortgage, the certifi ate
of ‘such discharge being filed in this office and recorded
i) . . :

fp

[ona]

’ Deputy Collector of Custom :

» 19......, @ - me.

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386409_0244%3A1. Public record. Not legal advice.
