# Motion ro Dismiss the Appeal — Pennsylvania v. Board of Directors of City Trusts of Philadelphia

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386408_0288%3A4

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Motion ro Dismiss the Appeal
- **Published:** January 1, 1957
- **Citation:** 353 U.S. 230

## Text

5 5 .
TABLE OF CONTENTS OF BRIEF. .
Orixioxs BELow ............ re a —ͤ—ͤ—ͤ— . 2
JURISDICTION ..... Sy ee eer . . 6 . . 2
Srarute INVOLVED nnn... erin Meese eee a
QUESTIONS PRINT . 1 3:
STATEMENT OF THE CASE ...:.. —V—ͤIV penne e ee 4
SuomMAR OF ARGUMENT ......... „ . d she as eek 8 6
6— 33 eee n 8
.. . V aces 5 8
2. This Court Has No Jurisdiction, Either dy Appeal or
Certiorari, Because the Relief Requested Will Not Be
Affected by a Decision on the’ Federal ‘Question Pre-
—— Metsciccscticees nne 13
3. This Court Has No Jurisdiction 1 Way of Ae No
State Statute Having Been Drawn in Question 2
RNepugnant t td the Fourteenth Amendment n 15
4. Certiorari Should Be Denied Because the Supreme Court
of Pennsylvania Did Not Decide a Federal oe *
6 — ̊ V)). C̃̃̃7.77.½—— . “7? . 3
5. The ke O Was c bud , 25

CONCLUSION 0 hep een’ os see eeeew ences eas, ae

/

"TABLE OF CASES CITED. 5

e v. Baldwin, 287 U. S. 156 (1932) . * 1
" Atchison, Topeka & S. F. R. To. v. Public Utilities Commission, tae
See sy UE COED pe iwecocecsdbocdeccveliccatscus 19
Baltimore City v. Dawson, 350 U. S. 877 (1955) pi ial Daas a
Barrows v. Jackson, 346.U. S. 249 (1953) 296
Brown v. - Boartl of Education of Tope. 34? v. S. 483. (1954) :
: 4, 25
Buchanan v. ‘Warley, 28. U. S. 0 (117)) ) *
California v. San Pablo and Tulare R. R. Co., 149. U. S.
f TT!!! Sige Regen be PCa ̃ lea OE pe 9
Charleston Federal Savings & aie Ass’ nv. ‘Aine 324 U. 8.
182 (1945) VVV 18, 19

Charlotte Park and Recreation Commission v. Barringer, 242
N. C. 311, 88 S. E. 2d 114 (1955), cert. denied sub nom.
Leeper v. Charlotte Park and Recreation Conimission, 350

U. S. 983 (1956) ,....... 5 8 26
Citizens National Bank of Cincinnati v. Gas 2 US. 9. ..
00 Obl 408 Mae Sata eh Aer 18
Corkren Oil and Deren Co. v. Arnaudet 199 U. 8. 182
„ ) 18
Dahnbe- Walker Milling Company v. Bondurant, 257 U. 8. 282 a
ae | perpen 7... ͤ v 19
bepartment of Conservation and Development v. Tate; 231 F. „
615 (4th Cir., 1956), cert. denied, 352 U. S. 888. 25
Dorsey v. Stuyvesant Town Corp., 299 N. V. 512,87 N. KE.
2d 541 (1949), cert. denied, 339 U. S. 981 (1950) 27
Forbes v. State Council of Virginia, 216 U. S. 396 (1910) .... 18
Girard v. Philadelphia, 74 U. S. (7 Wall.) 1 (1869) 10, 14
Godchaux Co. v. Estopinal, 251 U. S. 179 (191999 17

In re Groban. United States Supreme Court, February 25, 1957 27

Hamilton v. Regents of the University of California, 293 U. 82
245 (1934) ...... e VVV 19

*
*

"TABLE OF a CITED (Continued).

‘Illinois ex rel. McColtum v Board of Education, arg U. S. 23 oe
TN ed MEET ee . 19, 20
Jett Bros. Bene Co. v City of Canson. 252 U. 8 1 f
—. 0 00A 18
Lawrence v. Hancock, 76 F. Supp. 1004 (S. D. W. Va, 1948) 25
Leber v. Schroeder, 149 U. S. 580 (1893/)))ʒ)/õ q *
Marsh v. Alabama, 326 U. S. 501 (1946) . 6
Muir v. Louisville Park Theatrical Ass'n, 347 U. S. 971 (1954) 25
‘Norris v. Mayor and City il of Baltimore, 78 F. Supp. .
451 (D. Md, 1948) . e 27
Philadelphia v. Fox, 64 Pa. 169 (1870) 9 9, 10, 11, 16, 21, 22
Radio Station WOW v. Johnson, 326 U. S. 120 (1945) ..... 8
Reuben Quick Bear v. Leupp, 210 U. S. 50 (1908) 5

Rudder v. United States, 226 F. 2d 51 (D. C. Cir., 1955) .. 25
"St. Louis and San FPaaciee R. Co. v Shephird, 240 U. S. 24

(1916) ....... SOE. . e F 18
Shelley v. Kraemer, 334 U. S. 1 (1948) +++ 13, 14, 26
Steele v. Louisville & Nashville R. Co., 323 U. S. 192 (1944). 26
Terry v. Adams, 345 U. S. 461 (1953) ....... . 26
‘Tunstall v. Brotherhood of Locomotive Firemen & W fa!

. Wile wv ͤ ͤům ˙—u epbbacdis Te |
Valle v. Stengel, 176 F. 2d 697 (3d Cir., 1949 a

Vidal v. The Mayor, Aldermen and Citizens of Philadelphia,

. v. S. (2 How.) 127 (1844) ....... n

Wall v. Chesapeale & Ohio Ry. Co., 256 U. S. 125 (1921) .... 17
Waters - Pierce Oil Co. v. Texas (No. 2), 212 U. S. 112 (1908) 18
Wilson v. Board of Directors of City Trusts, 324 Pa. 545 (1936) 21
Zorach v. Clauson, 343 U. S. 306 (1952) es

“TABLE OF STATUTES AND AUTHORITIES CITED.

11
man Charter 0f o 0005033 ee 10, 12
Acts of March 24 and April 4, 1832, P. L. 176, 8 nr 11
r 3 ot 11
Act of 1853 [April 20, P. L. 62ll]]l .. . |
Consolidation Act of 1854 (Act of February 2, F. La, 53
Purdon's Stat. § 6361 et seq.) /) 10
Act of June 30, 1869, P. L. 1276, 53 Purdon's Stat. $6481.
et s). 25, 10, 12, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23
Act of June 8,.1881, P. 1 e d. . 24
Public Contracts Act (Act ay 1, 1933, P. L. 103, art. VIII,
| § 806, as amended, 53 Pu s Stat. § 19093.808 ) 24
Urban Redevelopment Act (Act of May 24, 1945, P. L. 991,
8 11, 35 Purdon's Stat. f 1711 (a) (8) 24
Act of March 10, 1949, P. I. 30, art. XIII, § 1310, as amended, > ;
„ , ey eer rere 24
P lvania Fair Employment Practice Act (Act of Oetober
i e F, ee. $951 ty 5 24
? Cine Aditi Bee.
Revised Rules of the Supreme Court of the United States: a
Rule 16. PPP ieee ee,
: (RE: TOUR GB) sev owes veccdvncodececsctocicoes anise 21
Robertson & Kirkham, Jurisdiction of the 5 Court of the 7
| United States, § 260, p. 467 (1951) eee a
Fr aaa Rule 69 ...... BSA es 17
USC A: BIBI). 65550555. e 1.19, 20
J 2⁰
2 U. S. C. A. 5 2103 . V
42 U. S. C. A. §§ 1981-1983, dia ee eat oS ee
U. S. Constitution: a .
First Amendment „ 28

*
rut or CONTENTS or APPENDIX.

APPENDIX: | .
APPENDIX A: win of Stephen Girard .. e ‘oun ‘eee
APPENDIX B.: Pennsylyania Act of March 11, 1789, 2.

Nites Smith Laws 462, §2, 53 Purdon’s Stat.
86362 —*—*2w¹⸗« ———— .

"APPENDIX c: Pennsylvania Act of March 24, 1832 . i
176 (1831-1832 Volume), 53 Purdon’s

*

Stat. § 7411, § 7433, om 1 8
1 nt
7 ie 1
. * 2
A |
Ns eee
‘
5 85
° *.
ce

IN THE

* ‘Supreme Court of the United States,

‘October 7. 1956.

7 145 No. 769,

*

COMMONWEALTH. OF PENNSYLVANIA, CITY OF
PHILADELPHIA, RICHARDSON. DILWORTH,

hae 5 .
‘ } * .
a. 9 .
F .
* .
5 * 2 4
“ * . 0 *
— oo” Pg at

MAYOR OF THE CITY OF PHILADELPHIA, |

| PHILADELP A COMMISSION ON HUMAN RE.

LATIONS, peg ASHE FOUST AND ROBERT

FELDER, .
“Appellants,

V.

THE e OF DIRECTORS OF CITY TRUSTS OF
THE CITY OF PHILADELPHIA, =~
Ne

*

MOTION TO DISMISS THE APPEAL inp BRIEF IN

OPPOSITION TO PETITION FOR WRIT OF CER-

‘TIORARI.
Appellee, pursuant to Rule 16 of the Revised Rules

of the Supreme Court of the United States, moves that the

appeal from the final judgment and decree of the Supreme
Court of Pennsylvania be dismissed on the ground that the
judgment below cannot be appealed directly to the Su-
preme Court of the United States under 28 U. S. C. A.

51257 (2), and on the furthey ground that no substantial :

federal question is esented. Since this Court is required

‘by 28 U. S. C. A. § 2103 to,treat the appeal as a petition .

for certiorari, appellee requests the Court to deny the peti-

4

2 Motion to Dismiss Appeal and Brie{ Contra Petition |

tiongon the ground that there i is no basis for jurisdiction, q
and 2 the case does not . a substantial federal |

8 5 |
The opinion of the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania
(J. S. 25) 1 is reported as Girard Will Case, 386 Pa. 548,
127 A. 2d 287 (1956). The opinions of the Orphans’ Court
of Philadelphia County (R. 119 a, 170 a) are reported as
Girard Estate, 4 Pa. D. & C. ad 671 (1955), : and 4 Pa.
D. & C. 2d 708 (1956). ; |

2
1 urisdiction.—-

: The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania held thiat to deny
admission of appellants Foust and Felder to Girard College
did not violate the Fourteenth Amendment, since they are
- not poor white male orphans, between the ages of six and
ten years’’ as required by Stephen Girard’s will. ,
That court did not decide, as appellants say it did
(J. S. 2), or even state that the Board of Directors of City
Trusts was acting pursuant to the Act of June 30, 1869
There has been no decision: on the validity or invalidity of
that statute or, any other statute. Accordingly this wer
does not have jurisdiction of this case by appeal. a
Nor does this Court have jurisdiction. by way of cer-
tiorari since the state courts have held that under Penn-
sylvania law the relief requested by appellants cannot be
granted, irrespective of the ultimate conan on the .
constitutionak ame.

5 Statute Involved. |

This proceeding does not involve any statute what-
_ ever, The statute which appellants contend was drawn in
(1) * S.“ refers to appellants’ J urisdictional Statement.

len to the printed record fled. with de Supreme
_ Court of Pennsylvania and certified to this Cour -

&

‘Motion to Dismiss Appeal and Brief Contra a 3

question as repugnant to the Fourteenth . and
allegedly upheld by the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania is-
the Act of June 30, 1869, P. L. 1276, 53 Purdon’s Stat.
7 § 6481 et geg., printed in Appendix B of eke Juris-
PF Ate |
1. Where the state te have * d that irreepestivie ;
of the determination of a federal co titutional d question,
state law requires that the ultima ‘decision bé against
appellants, should this Court assume jurisdiction, either
by appeal or certiorari? |
2. Was the validity of a state stabi creating a Board
to discharge ‘‘all and singular the duties, rights and powers
a the City of ‘Philadelphia, concerning all property and
estatę whatsoever, dedicated to charitable uses or trusts, .
the charge or administration of which are now or shall 1
hereafter become vested in or confided to the City of. Phil.
adelphi „ drawn in question as being repugnant to the

Fourteenth Amendment, and was there a decision in favor ,

ol its validity by the state courts where, prior to a petition
kor reargument in the state court of last resort, no argu-
ment, either oral or written, concerning the statute was

addressed by any party to any of the state courts, and
where no question cbnebrning the validity or invalidity of ©
the statute was mentioned in any of the five opinions filed
1 by the various state court judges?

. 3. Where the terms of a testamentary trust bei
for the erection, operation and continued supporé of an
„ orphan egtablishment for poor white male orphans, be-
‘tween thé ages of six and ten years“, and no funds other
than those of the testator have ever been used therefor,
does administration of such trust in accordance with the
directions of the testator by a municipality, the trustee
designated by the will, acting only in its fiduciary capacity, 5
violate the equal er see of the Fourteenth

Amendment? 8

4 Motion to Dismiss Appeal and Brief Contra Petition
Statement of the Case.

Stephen Girard, by his will, probated 18 31,
1831, made numerous gifts to various named individuals
and organizations, to the cities of Philadelphia and New @
Orleans, and to, the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. He
then gave most of his residuary estate in trust to ereet a
‘‘eollege’’. His will sets forth at great length the details
of the erection of the buildings, the selection of instructors,
the curriculum and many other things. The college was
to admit ‘‘as many poor. white male orphans, between the
ages of six and ten years, as the said income shall be
adequate to maintain’’ (App. 18a),* with preference given
to orphans born in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, New York
City and New Orleans. He named as trustee ‘‘the Mayor,
Aldermen and Citizens of sae the then cor-
porate title of the city (App. 5

Appellanjs Foust and Felder applied for admission
to Girard College on February 1, 1954, and were advised
by the trustee that they could not be admitted because
neither was a poor white male orphan between the ages
of six and ten years, as required by the Will of Stephen
Girard, deceased’’ (R. 70a; 79a). On September 24, 1954,
these appellants petitioned the Orphans’ Court of Phila-
delphia County for an order directing: their ission .
to the college. Petitions were also filed on behalf of the
Mayor of the City of Philadelphia, the City of Philadel-
‘phia, the Philadelphia Commission on Human Relations
and, later, the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, joining
in the prayer for such relief. On July 29, 1955, the hearing
judge denied the petitions on the ground that Stephen
Girard's will was clear and valid and that the operation
of Girard College was lawful. Exceptions were dismissed
by the Orphans’ Court en bane, Appellants appealed to

3 Stephen Girard's will is printed in full in appellee’s ap-
pends ots motion and ri, rl E

App.“

sf

Motion to Dismiss poe and sik Contra Petition: 5.

the Supreme Court of Need which affirmed the
decrees. In a carefully considered opinion, aceompanied
by a concurring opinion by Justice Bell, the court held that
Stephen Girard's purpose was to establish an institution
for poor white male orphans; that will, many times
upheld in the past against other attacks, is entirely valid;
that the will is not discriminatory within the meahing of
any constitutional doctrine; that Girard College is an
: orphan establishment operated entirely by private funds

“under the directions of a private will; that the administr :-

tion of the trust is not contrary to any public policy or the
_ Fourteenth Amendment; and that irrespective of any de-
cision on the constitutional question appellants would not
be entitled under state law to the relief sought. 8
Thereafter, appellants filed a petition for reargument
in which, for the first time, they took the position that the
issue in the case was not the validity of Girard’s will or the
administfation of the Girard Estate by the city as trustee,
but. the itutionality: of the Act of June 30, 1869, P. L.
1276, which created the Board of Directors of. City Trusts
(hereinafter called the Board“) for the discharge of the
fiduciary functions of the City of. Philadelphia. This and
- tion was dismissed without opinion.

*

6 Motion to Dismiss Appeal and Brief Contra Petition

SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT.

The appellants’ Jurisdictional Statement does not
properly state the true i ines in this case. They have given
a wholly false picture vf both the nature of Girard 's gift
which created the college, and of the past.and ‘present con-
tacts and relationship of the city and the state with the
college, and of the opinions below:

ä In the courts below many questions directed to the
Pennsylvania law of wills, trurts and public policy. were
raised and argued by appellants. There was but a single

constitutional question whether the Fourteenth Amend-.

ment forbids the City of Philadelphia to. act as trustee
for Stephen Girard, Wheréas the courts below dealt with
this question, among many others, and indicated that mere
administration of this bona fide charitable trust by the city
is not the type of state action’’ which is prohibited by the
Fourtéenth Amendment, nevertheless each of those courts
recognized that resolution of the constitutional. issue does
not decide the case. The prayer of the petition is that

Fioust and Felder be admitted to Stephen Girard’s college.

The constitutional question concerns itself with the com-
petency of the city to serve as trustee. Thus, even if the
courts below erred in their decision on the constitutional
question—which they clearly did not—still that woüld not
mean that Foust’and Felder would be admitted to the
college. The courts below held that under the law of
Pennsylvania the trust for poor white male orphans’’
would continue as such, irrespective of the competency * |
the trustee. — -

None of the parties to this suit has requested that the
trustee of the Girard Estate be changed. We submit that
appellants, clearly recognizing that this court would not
grant certiorari to review an academic question of consti-

(4) As to Foust this appéal ie mout. Ren oly re
of age (R. ö

d

- Motion-to Dismiss ‘Appeal and Brief Contra Petition 7

tutional aw, however interesting it might - be, have 1
tempted to bring that question before the court by way of
an improper appeal. This appeal i edicated upon a
question of the validity of a state statute which was at no
‘point drawn in question in the state courts, and on which
there has been no decision whatever by any of those courts.
In addition to the non-federal basis for the decision be-
low, and to the fact that the decision below does not support
a direct appeal, this case does not involve a substantial
federal question that would entitle appellants either to an
appeal or to a grant of certiorari. It is not a case of either
discrimination or ‘state action’’, but involves only the right
of ag individual to leave his estate W ans persons of his
choice. Po
In any real the A of the e of the Phila- .
delphia Orphans’ Court and Pennsylvania Supreme Court
"is so clearly in accord with the principles distinguishing .
individual from state action, as announced by this Co
the Fourteenth Amendment cases, that review by this Court
is s not warranted.

8 Motion to Dismiss Appeal and . Contra Petition
Axdumxxr. a
Stripped of misleading statements and arguments,’ this
is not a case of racial discrimination but one involving the
basic eoncepts of the law of charitable trusts. As Mf. Chief

Justice Stern, speaking for the majority of the court below,
said (J. S. 25) a

“While it may seem ‘unfortunate that the court
is obliged to sanction the exclusion of any child from
even a private school or orphanage because of race,
creed or color if otherwise entitled to admission, the
Court is clearly of opinion that the unanimous decision
of the Orphans’ Court, supported by the learned and
comprehensive opinions of Judge Boieer and Judge
Lzrever, must be affirmed, it being clearly understood
at the outset that the beneficiaries of the charity of
Stephen Girard are not being determined by the State
of Pennsylvania, nor by the City of Philadelphia, nor
by this Court, but solely by Girard himéelf in the
exercise of his undoubtéd right to dispose of his
property by will, and, in so doing, to say, within the.

‘bounds of the law, who shall enjoy its benefits.“

1. The Background.

The only difference between Girard College and any
other charitable trust is that the administration of the
Private funds endowing the school has been entrusted to a
public corporation rather than a private body. However,
in an effort to maximize the contacts of the city and
state with Girard College, appellants have given a wholly
false picture of the nature of Girard’s gift,.and have re-

.

6) See the discussion of such statements and 3 in
the concurring opinion of Mr. Justice Belf (J. S. 43).

(6) Of the thirteen ju who heard the case on Lustice
Musmanno dissented. A rea ing of his opinion will show
misunderstood the und of the case, much as appli have
in their Jurisdictional Statement.

|

. * 7

otion to Dismiss Appeal and Brief Contra Petition 9

ferred to a great number of instances of activity by state
or city offidials and public bodies which, under analysis,
either had nothing to do with Girard College or were
simply administrativè rules for trusteeship. _

The Supreme Court of Pefnsylvania expressly held
that Girard’s gift was for the benefit of his named bene-
ficiaries (poor white male orphans) ‘and not a gift to or
for the benefit of the city (J. S. 29, 40-41). The question
of Girard’s intention was elaborately argued) below. The
court held that Girard intended the city to be nierely the
title holder of his estate, that he directed the city to use
his estate only for the purposes sec in the will, and
that he did not intend to empower: the city to conduct the
college in its public or governmental capacity (J. S. 35).
In spite of these conclusions on questions of state law,
appellants state as a fact that Girard left, his estate ‘‘to
the City of Philadelphia for various’ m cipal purposes,
the most important of these being the éstablishment of
Girard College (J. S. 5). In view of tHe decision below
*that the college was, like any other charitable. gift of such
a nature, intended for the benefit of the named beneficiaries,
appellants’ statement obliterates the principal distinction
upon which the judgments below rest. |

To the same effect, and presumably for the same
purpose, is the reiteration of the argument made below
that the operation of Girard College has to be a public
function’’, regardless of Girard’s intent, because the city.
can only-be a trustee for ‘‘ public: purposes, citing Phil-
adelphia v. Fox, 64 Ea. 169 (1870). That decision also
stated that ‘‘all charities are in some sense public’? (Id. at
p. 182), and it is clear that the decisions referring to the
operation of Girard College as public“ mean no more
than that the college is a valid charity. Any other charity, ©
whether the trustee is a public body or not, has to be
public“ in-the same manner in order to be a valid charity.
Any other charity in Pennsylvania would also be entitled
to the tax exemption noted by appellants; Girard College 8

10 Motion to Dismiss Appeal and Brief Contra Petition

en arises from the fact that it is a = purely public

and support of what Firard ed’? (J. S. 7). A study

of these statutes and ordinances and of the background

of the trusteeship as interpreted in court decisions for
over a century, shows this statement as applied to —
College to be flagrantly misleading.

I he city’s trusteeship of Girard College did not arise
from any statute or ordinance passed following Girard's
death, and the city’s competency to act as trustee did not

depend on any such legislative action. From 1701 to 1776
Philadelphia acted under. the charter granted by William
Penn. Following an interim period, the legislature granted
‘the city a charter in 1789, under whith the city was in-
corporated as ‘‘The Mayor, Aldermen and Citizens of
Philadelphia.“ It was in this*charter that this Court
found the inherent power of the city to act as Girard's
trustee. Vidal v. The Mayor, Aldermen and Citizens of
Philadelphia, 43 U. S. (2 How.) 127, 186-189 (1844).
Subsequent changes. in the city and its government, such
as the Consolidation Act of 1854 (Act of February 2, P. L.
/ 21, 53 Purdon’s Stat. § 6361 et seg.), have been held not
to destroy the identity of the old corporation or alter its
powers. Girard v. Philadelphia, 74 U. S. (7 Wall.) 1
(1869). The Act of June 30, 1869, P. L. 1276, creating the.
Board, was likewise held not to alter in any manner the.
identity or powers of the city as trustee: Philadelphia v.
Fos, 64 Pa. 169 (1870). By virtue of its old charter the

‘ ar has continued as a corporation to this day.

The competency of the city to act as trustee is not
8 y of the statutes cited by- appellants.
Clearly. et of 1869, which the appellants are challeng- -

ie (7) The relevant portion ee
is pn net ber (ADD

3

. Motion to Dismiss Appeal and Brief Contra Petition 11
ing specifically, ‘is Rot the source of the trustee’s com-

petency or of the acceptance of the trust; the trust was

over 35 years old when that act was passed and that act
did not change the trustee: Philadelphia v. Foz, 64 Pa.
169 (1870). The Acts of March 24 and April 4, 1832
(J. S. 6-7, 115-116), passed soon after Girard’s death, did
not authorize the city to accept the trust and did not even
purport to be the source of the city’s competency to act
as trustee of the college. These statutes, which Girard
requested, were passed to enable the city to make certain
improvements to the eastern part of the city with gifts
made by Girard’s will. But these gifts had nothing what-
ever to do with Girard College, and the statutes had noth-

ing to do with the city’s trusteeship of the college. Girard

requested no legislation whatsoever with respect to the
college, and indeed he ed none. The whole of the Act
af March 24, 1832, has been printed in appellee’s appendix”
to show-that-the parts of that statute printed in appellants’
appendix do not relate to the city’s trusteeship of the
college (App. 34a). A reading of these statutes, and of this
Court’s opinion in Vidal v. The Mayor, Aldermen and.
Citieens of Philadelphia, 43 U. 8. {2 How.) 127 (1844),
wherein the city’s competency to act as trustee was found
to be inherent in its charter, demonstrates that appellants’
atement thet “the

} 7 H. Carpenter.

ees eee L. BAD,
4 1 ene

Nd December 31, 1831. Then personally

appeared Saml. Arthur and S. H. Carpenter two of the

Witnesses to the foregoing Will and the second Codicil or

republication thereof and on their Oaths did say that they

were present and did see and hear Stephen — the
158

0

SY

rs e 4 A
Teatator i in the said 1 Will and second republication thereof,

named, sign seal publish and declare the same as & for his
last Will and Testament and republication thereof and that
at the doing thereof he was of sound mind memory and un- .
derstanding to the best of their knowledge and belief And

at the same time appeared Jno. Thomson, one of the Wit-
"- nesses to the first republieation of said will, and on his
1 affirmation did say that he was present, and did

see and hear Stephen Girard the Testator in the first

republication of said Will named sign seal publish and de-

clare thé same as and for a republicatiom of his last Will and
Testament and the said Samuel. Arthur, another of the wit-
nesses to said republication of said will on his oath: did

further say that he was present and did see and hear

Stephen Girard the Testator in the first republication. of

said Will named sign seal publish and declare the same as
and for a republication of his last Will and Testament, and

they both did say that at the doing thereof he was of sound
mind, memory and widerstanding; to the best of their knowl-

. and belief.

Coal,
J. Humes, 5
ee Register.

—

December 31, 1831. Timothy W and Thomas N.
Cope; two of the Executors, affirmed- und J oseph Roberts,
William J. Duane, and John A. Barclay. the other Executors
sworn and Letters a were ‘granted unto them.

_ APPENDIX B.

Pennsylvania Act of March 11, 1789, 2 Smith Laws 462, ¢ 2.
: 53 Purdon’s Stat. & 6362.

Be it therefore enacted, and it is hereby . by the
Representatives of the Freemen of the Commonwealth of
Pennsylvania, in General b oa” by the author-

ity of the same, That the inhabitants o city of Philadel-
phia, as the same extends and is laid out between the Tivers

Delaware and Schuylkill, be, and they, and their successors :
for ever, are hereby constituted a corporation and body ‘
politic, in fact and in law, by the name and style of The

Mayor, Aldermen and Citizens of Philadelphia“, and by the

same name shall have perpetual succession; and they and
their successors shall, at all times forever, be able ‘and
capable in law to have, purchase, take, receive, possess and
enjoy lands, tenements and hereditaments, liberties, fran-

chises and jurisdictions, goods, chattels and effects to them

and their successors forever, or for any other or less estate;
and the same lands, tenements and hereditaments, goods,
chattels and effects, to grant, bargain, sell, alien and convey,

mortgage, pledge, charge and encumber, or demise and

* of, at their will and pleasure.

zaa Re Appendis C

* —— 0.

W Act of March 24, 1832, P. L. 176 (1831 1832 :
| Volume), 53 Purdon’s Stat. § 7411, § $433, § 6791. |

| ; K 3 | AN ACT N 1
| To enable the Mayor, e ond citizens of Phila-
_ delphia to carry into effect certain improvements, and
5 certain trusts.
5 ‘WHEREAS, By the last will and teten of Stephen
Girard, late of the city. of, Philadelphia, deceased, the sum
f five hundred thousand d lars is bequeathed to the mayor,
Idermen, and citizens of ‘Philadelphia, in trust among
her things, to apply the income. thereof first, to lay out,
regulate, curb, light and pave a passage or street on the
ehst part of the city of Philadelphia, fronting the. river
elaware, not less than twenty-one féet wide, and to be
ed Delaware Avenue, extending from South or Cedar
treet, all along the east part of Water street squares, and
the. west side of the logs which form the heads of the docks,
or thereabouts; and to this intent, to obtain such acts of
— and to make such purchases or agreements as! will
enable the mayor, aldermen, and citizens of Philadelphia
to remove or pull down all the buildings, fences, and ob-
. structions which may be in the way, and to prohibit all
buildings, fences, or erections of any kind to the eastward
of said avenue, to fill up-the heads of such of the docks as
may not afford sufficient room for the said street, to compel
the owners of wharves to keep them clean, and covered
3 with gravel or other hard materials, and to be
80 levelled that water will nof remahn thereon, after a
shower of rain, to oompletely glean, keep clean, all the
docks within the limits of . fronting on the Delaware;
and to pull down all platf carried out from the east
part of * city, over the river Delaware, on piles or

Appendia C irae 3 35a

pillars.“ 1 To pull down and i remove all wooden ;
„ buildings, as well as those made of wood und other com-

bdustible materials as those called brick-paned; or framed

_ buildings, filled in with bricks, that are erected within the
_ limits of the city of Philadel elphia; and also to prohibit the

erection of such building within the. said city’s limits.
at any future e. „Third, to widen, pave, and curb
Water gtreet, and to 5 distribute the Schuylkill water therein,

upon“ a certain plan therein set forth. Now, for the pur-

pose of gnabling the mayor, aldermen, and citizens of
Philadelphia aforesaid, to effect the improvements con-
templated by the said testator, and to execute in all other
respect the trusts created by his will, to enable the con-
stituted authorities of the city of Philadelphia to carry
which into effect, the said Stephen Girard has desired the.

ee legislature to enact the necessary laws.

Sxor. 1. Be it enacted by the eis tnd House of
| Representatives of the Commonweatth of Pennsylvania, in

General Assembly met, ang it is hereby enacted by the

authority of the same, That it shall and may be lawful for
; the mayor, aldermen and citizens of Phil lelphia, by. ordi-
‘nance lawfully enacted, or the intervéntion gad act of
authorized officers or agents, to lay out, regulate! curb, light,
and pave a passage or street, not less than twentftone feet
in width, on the east part of the city of Philadelphia, front-
ing the river Delaware, at such distance or distances in
the several parts thereof from the eastern line of Water
street as they shall judge proper, extending from Vine to

_ Cedar street, to be called the Delaware Avenue; and that,

having laid out such street, they shall cause a record. of
the same to be made in the court of Quarter Sessions N :
county of Philadelphia.

Sxor. 2. And be it further enacted by the .
aforesaid, That it shall be lawful for the mayor, aldermen,
and citizens of Philadelphia aforesaid, in ‘manner or aforesaid, ;

t 4

1

„„ e Are Y
to lay out Water street, in the said city, anbw,; in such man-

ner as that the same shall be as nearly straight as conven-

: whether erected

iently may be, and of a uniform, or as near as may be uni-
form width Throughout, not less than thirty-nine feet, if
practicable, and the same to open and keep open for ever, as

a common and public highway; and that having laĩd out said

Water street of such increased width, they shall cause a

record of the same to. be made in the ‘court of Quarter

Sessions for the county of Phi elphia. cree Pea
“

Sxor. 3. “And be it further) enacted by the authority
aforesaid, That it shall be lawful for the:mayor, aldermen,
and citizens of Philadelphia aforesaid, to pass ordinances,

or take other measures for regulating, adjusting, and
determining the easternmost lin to which wharves may

thereafter lawfully be constructed on the river Delaware,
fronting said city, and to cause a record of such regulated

line to be made in the court of Quarter Sessions for the

county of Philadelphia; to fix and decide on, or cause their
officers to fix and decide on the levels of all wharves fronting .
the said city, and to declare the regulation thereof; to re-

quire the owners thereof to pave the same or to lay them
with gravel, according to such regulation, so as effectually

to drain and pass off the water from the same, and to require

all persons owning and occupying or using-docks or
wharvqs, to cleanse the Same and to keep the same in
repair / and to prescribe the form, materials, and character

of wo kmanship of all wharves hereafter to be constructed,

and tq require all platforms now projecting inte »_ the river

Delaware, and supported on piles, pillars or piers, to be

removed, and to prohibit the construction, in\ future, of

any such projecting platforms; and to require the removal,

and prohibit the construction, in future, of all buildings,

fencesPand other obstructions, to the eastward of Delaware

constructions w ever, contrary to the.said ordinances, —
ore or after. the passage of the same to

Avenue, above mentioned, ‘and to declare all erections and

joe's 5
* $

— a a 5 * * * on — ome — —

whatever other things shall by them, the said mayor, alder-
men, and citizens of Philadelphia ‘aforesatd, be deemed

rity and governsfent of the said wharves: Provided, That
the easternmost line of the said wharves shall not be: held
to be finally d , and the record theréof shall not

with the —_ interests, which certificate ‘shall also be
record in the said court of Quarter Sessions; but if the

months after application made therefor, the refusal or
omission of the said board of wardens to grant such

interests,
made, an / appeal shall lie therefrom to the said court of
Quarter Sessions, as in other cases, and the judgment of

that such nd incase line is inconsistent with the public

board of wardens: Provided That no herein contained
shall be construed to give authority to any one to erect
wharves, ¢ or piers, extending out as far as the said regulated
easternmost line, without license from me said board of
: e as ee * :

“Seer. 4. “And be it further ed by the 8
ee That it shall be lawful för the mayor, aldermen,
| and citizens of Philadelphia aforesaid, to pass ordinances,

—~ prohibiting the construction , Within the said city, or any

parts thereof, of all ramed or brick-paned or other build-

ings, the walls whereof are not wholly composed of incom-

bustible materials, determining the thicknesses of which
walls of buildings of different dimensions. and character

— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —

necessary or convenient for the good arrangement, secu-

be made, as aforesaid, unless the board of wardens, of the
port of Philadelphia, shall decide and make their certificate
in writing, that such easternmost line is. not inconsistent ,

said cer te shall not be granted by them, within three .
certificate, shall, when duly verified by affidavit, be esteemed

the judgment and decision of the said board of wardens,

the said court, in favor of such regulated lige, shall be, for
all purposes, equivalent to a oo poling bere by the said

be nuisances; and N to devise, ordain and execute

: pags

d in case such a decision shall in any wise be

38a ¢ — 8 Appendia C
shall hereafter be made in the said city, and in making all
such other legal provisions as they shall think expedient |
for preventing the extension of injuries from fire, in the
said city, and to declare all buildings, the walls whéreof —

are not wholly. composed of incombustible sa to be
nuisances. / ee

; Sror. 5. 40 be it further enacted by the e
aforesaid, That when any of the said ordinances shall have
been passed, or other proceedings had in relation to the
said Delaware Avenue and Water street, or either of them,
and the record thereof shall have been made as aforesaid,
it shall be lawful for the mayor, aldermen, and. citizens of
Philadelphia aforesaid, to proceed, from time to time, to
open for public use, any part or parts thereof, and the
‘same to keep open as common and public highWays forever;
and to that end, to enter upon such property as may be-
found to be within the same, construct, wharves extending
14 to the river, within the lines of said Delaware Avenue,

d to a reũsonable distance beyond the same, and fill up
all docks within the limits thereof, and remove all obstruc-
tions, of whatever kind, from within the limits of said
avenue and street, or any parts thereof, and level, drain, |
pitch, and pave the same, as other streets in the said city.
And from and after the passing of such ordinances, and the
record of the said avenue and street, all buildings, there-
after erected or rebuilt on he said avenue and street shall.
conform to the recorded li of the same, and the mayor,
aldermen and citizens of Philadelphia aforesaid, may pass -
ordinances, declaring all obstructions within the same to
be nuisances. 3

| Shor. 6. And be it further . by the authority

aforesaid, That it shall at all lawful for the
mayor, aldermen and citizens of Philadelphia, aforesaid, .
to remove and abate any building; erection or obstruction
whatever, which, by this act, 6P by any ordinance to be

Appendis C wi 25 00

hereafter e by vir of it, may be decline’ a nui--
sance: Provided, That if such building, erection or obstruc-

tion shall have been in existence at the time of the passage

of this act, or of such.ordinance passed by virtue hereof,
the mayor, aldermen. and citizens aforesaid shall give at
least three months notice of their intention to remove the
same to the persons having the ownership, occupation or
use. thereof, or in case no such persons shall be known to
them, then they shall affix a copy of such notice to and upon
such building, erection or obstruction, three months before
e to remove the same.

Seer. 7. And be it further enacted re the authority
aforesaid, That it shall be lawful for the said the mayor,
Haldern and citizens of Philadelphia, aforesaid, to pro-
vide for the punishment of any person or persons who shall

commit any nuisance contrary to the intent and meaning of

this act, and of the ordinances which may be passed by
virtue thereof, and of any person vr persons who having
‘committed any such nuisance, shall, alter tation, refuse or.
neglect to remove the same. 3 N
Axor. 8. Mea be. it further enacted by the authorite
.. aforesaid, That all. persons whatsoever who shall receive
damage to their property by reason of any thing which shall
have been done by the mayor, aldermen and citizens of
Philadelphia, under this act, or any ordinances passed by
virtue hereof, may, after ten days notice of suclf their
intention, to the mayor, aldermen and citizens aforesaid,
apply by petition in writing, to the court of Quarter Ses-
sions for the county o Philadelphia, who shall thereupon
appoint a jury of twelve disinterested freeholders, citizens

of the city of Philadelphia, which jury shall assemble, after

ten days notice of their meeting, given as aforesaid, and
shall be sworn or affirmed to inquire what damages the
petitioners, or any of them, have sustained by reason of any
thing so done, considering as well the advantages which

40a Appendia C

may accrue to such petitioners as the injuries * them
complained of, and the said jury having viewed the
Premises and heard the parties, or their counsel, shall
report in writing, under the hands of at least ten jurors,
and their report having been considered and confirmed by —
the court, the damages thereby found shall be paid by the
mayor, aldermen and citizens aforesaid, in six months after
the confirmation of the said report.

Sacr. 9. And be it further enacted bythe authority
aforesaid, That if the mayor, aldermen, and citizens afore-
said, shall deem it expedient: that the damages should be
legally ascertained before proceeding to enter on premises
for the purpose of removing obstructions, and before ap-
propriating to public use any property of individuals, or
otherwise injuriously affecting the rights and interests of
any proprietor, the mayor, aldermen and citizens aforesaid
may, from time to time. apply to the court of Quarter Ses-
sions for the county of Philadelphia, by petition, in writing,
specifying therein as nearly as may be the persons and
property in regard to which they desire that the damages
should be ascertained, and thereupon the said court shall
appoint a jury of twelve disinterested freeholders, citizens
of the city of Philadelphia, which j jury. shall assemble, after
ten days notice of their meeting given to the owners or oe-
cupiers. of the property, and shall be sworn or affirmed, as
is provided in the foregoing section of this act, and having
viewed and heard, as is therein provided, shall report in
writing, under the hands of at least ten jurors, specifying -

in their said report as well the causes for which damages,

if any should be paid, as the amounts of such damages, and

in such case the mayor, aldermen and citizens aforesaid

may, within the year after the confirmation of such report
by the court of Quarter. Sessions, tender to any owner of

: property named therein, the amount of damages thereby
found in his favor, or may pay the same into court, for his
use and benefit, and may thereafter proceed to enter upon

—

Appendia C . : . ö

6

' * 1

or premises, wai remove the obstructions, or appropriate
the property for which damages shall have been so paid or
tendered, first giving three months notice to the tenant in.
possession, if any: Provided ‘however, That if the amount
o found by such jury in favor of any owner, shal] not be so
tendered’ or paid within one year after the confirmation of
such report, then the proceedings had upon the said petition .
of the mayor, aldermen, and citize oresaid, shall, so far

as relates to the said owner, be null a void, and the mayor,
alderman, and citizens’ aforesaid, may thereafter, present
their petition in writing anew, under this section, as if no
proceedings had before been had: And provided also, That
_ When a report shall have been made by a jury, under the
\ provisions of this section, and damages shall have been
BS eer or paid, in accordance therewith, if thereafter
any damage than that reported on shall be sustainéd, the
party aggrieved may thereafter apply, in regard to. such
other damages, for a jury to assess the same, under the
eighth section of this act: Provided further, That it shall
at all times be competent ‘to the mayor, aldermen, and.
citizens/aforesaid, to agree with any owner or owners of
_ property, so to be taken, removed, or affected for the dam-

ages thereby to be octasioned, and such agreement shall be
instead of any of the proceedings detailed in this or the
foregoing sections of this act: And, forasmuch as in the
course of time it may appear that powers are not vested in
the said the mayor, aldermen, and citizens of Philadelphia
which may be yet required to the full execution of those
parts of the said will of the said Stephen Girard, for the
carrying of which into effect he has in his said will re-
quested legislative provision, and it is the object and intent

of this act fully to confer all such powers.

“Szor. 10. Be it further enacted by the 1
aforesaid, That it shall be lawful for the mayor, aldermen,
and citizens of Philadelphia, to exercise all such _jarisdic-
tion, enact all stich ee and do and execute all such

“ada alk. Appendix C

ä —— ů¶ 58 i
venient for the full and entire acceptance, execution and
prosecution of any and all the devises and bequests, trusts
and provisions contained in the said will, which are the
subjects of the preceding partagof this act, and to enable
the constituted authorities of the city of Philadelphia to
carry which into effect, the said Stephan Girard has desired
the legislature to enact the necessary laws.

Szor. 11. y= be it further enacted by the outhority

- aforesaid, That no road or street shall be laid out, or passed} —

through the land in the county of Philadelphia, bequeathed

by the late Stephen Girard for the erection of a college, un-
less the same shall be recommended by the Trustees or Di-|
rectors of said college, and approved of by a majority of the
select and common councils of the city of. Philadelphia.

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386408_0288%3A4. Public record. Not legal advice.
