# Transcript of Record — Wade v. Hunter

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386406_0132%3A1

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Transcript of Record
- **Published:** January 1, 1949
- **Citation:** 336 U.S. 684

## Text

“TRANSCRIPT OF RECORD:

site és Boe
a +. as ; eee
* a : ; Bs a ° | ° c : ag "i ative . es i sh
PETITION FOR CERTIORSRI FILED NOVEMBER 18, 1918.
F - ae r

. CERTIORARI GRANTED FANUARY 106, 1959.

:.*

- art * 2 \ :
= 7@ : : ° a, e . ;
ane a a a “ . one 5
- nf. : ‘ . : - f ‘ - 2 : are
Prodee tings j in the United State-

“Siren ~ A “Oourt al Appeals... *).° ———=

Ke cord entry: Cause argued -ang submitt&d pains se ie ees
Opinion . As cece PS sarge iat os ER ere Rr QT.
Judgment ._ . tS REE EY a a, ae
Petition for ‘rehearing Sa ERE ee Wes ee 109.

“Order denying petition for. rehéaring We Ci cc eos eS

Order. staying mandate (statement) ....2..000.0 2.2.0.0 . .. 128
Aer 8 COYNE : 1
eae eee ca, = | eral = | ¢ = e-
Order allowing certiorari > a Fe eee 129°

-
* :
vw. ‘ .
»
- @
ee
o rae 1d €
| . &
> ‘ : 3

« Order ex€ending time for docke thaw cause | 120° 7 ona

ak

: Original Print
Trans¢ript of trial proceedings: sree Y an be
Statement on behalf of petitioner 35 lege:

- Statement on behalf of* respondent re id 43 oo MS gg
"Testimony of Frederick W. Wade : idk ee ‘T 41%
Respondent's exhibit B Review WW Assistant Judge — = oc
Advocate, Fifteenth “Army. and concurrence by . aN
Acting?Army Judge Advocate , --B-32— |. 45-66"
Opinion of Board of Review No. 4 is , Belt-' 866-78

“Letter, EL, C. McNeil, Assistant Judge Advocate ,

General, ‘to Commanding | General; eet AS:
Transcript of proceedings on hearing of motion for —.
reconsideration: y ;

_ Statement on behalf of petitioner / s. ; . 116
Statement on behalf of respondent. 113
Court’s opinion .- Seon | eee 113

Clerk's certificate: ey. $2 ieee

; a > s e - °

. é: ; * rn | F =

' +s
~~

‘ e s

P .-° eh, = =

a « *
. ao : . ‘ oe
. : .

N THE UNITED STATES CIRCUIT COURT OF
Mie fom ae FOR THE TENTH CHRCUIF. ?

oH 3575.
. WALTER A. HUNTER, Warden,

. United States Penitentiary, ;
Leavenworth, Kansas, APPELLANT ®

e
. ‘.
es
° : {- ’ r
. : ‘ ‘ : rs 4
. . * - . as
; ‘ - . _ «@

VS. /
FREDERICK W. WADE, APPELLEE.

wntien: . atte ~—p e

Statement of Points Relied Upon by the Appellant.

= fc 4. | P
"That petitioner, appellee, was not placed. in double jeop-
ardy, as contemplated by | the Fifth Amendment to the |
Constitution, in that the first. trial, convened at Pfalzfeld,
Germany, 27 March, 1945, was not complete, that the tac-
tical situation then and there present due to the-combat ©
condition of the United States ina ‘state of war prevented
its Spee: : |
| ‘That the Sourt-martial.by which appellee was convicted,

sentenced and subsequently committed, convened at Bad

Neuenahr, Germany, 30° June, 1945, did not laek juris- ;
diction to'try appellee in. that such proceeding was in vio- .
jation ef the Fifth: Amendment though identical charge,
and specification had been previously submitted to another
Court-martial for trial and had been partially tried but —
completion thereof prevented because of the tactiéal con-

dition then and there present due-to combat. secradeane of

the United States in a state of war.

a.
_That-the- Trial Court erred ‘in. overruling appeltant’ 8.
motion for reconsideration.

JAMES W. WALLACE,
_ Assistant U. S. Attorney,”
zn . -*. Attorney for Appellant, |

Filed October 6, 1947.

> Sle Bae a

ee js Wave v. Hunter, Waroess
‘ \

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE UNITED STAT
_ FOR THE DISTRICT OF KANSAS, FIRST DIVISION®

x=

: pied AND PROCEEDINGS BEFORE THE HONORABLE ARTHUR
J. MELKorT, JUDGE OF THE‘ UNITED STATES DistRIcT COURT
FOR’ THE DISTRICT OF KANSAS, PRESIDING IN THE FOLLOW ING

Os ENTITLED-CAUSE:

oe

~~, FREDERICK W. WADE, rivets

y Seas SS : . ok

‘ Se ee aine > .
&: in. , (ots 3 gees a ene

' WALTER A. HUNTER, Warden, ;
.« United States Penitentiary; ~ i tes

_ Leavenworth, Kansas, RESPONDENT: 2
~ Civil—No. 980°H~C.

°@

. _--—@
Se See were eeten Gr.

Petition for Writ of Habeas Corpus.

To the Honorable Arthur J. Mellott, Judge of the U nited ys |

. States District Court for the District of Kansas:

_xepresents: —- =. tioner; and that said Defense Counsel upon interviewing...
Fe 8 petitioner, learned for the first time that petitioner had
‘been previously tried by a ‘General Court. Martial. for ee.
same offense.

10. That. watibionse’ was on Stine 30, 1945, iintaaihe before
'--a. Fifteenth United States Army Geéngral Court Martial
and arraigned upon the identical charge and specification .
/ upon which he was tried ~ the 76th en: Division
_ Court Martial. |

aor: * That petitioner at the frst Sppectuniny: filed pe
presented his. plea in bar of trial on the ground of former’
aie ea jeopardy and in support thereof introduced into evidence
ae the certified record of the former trial; and thereafter’
said Court Martial lacked jurisdiction to again put peti- |
tioner in jeopardy by trial for the same offense. 7

3° 12. That the Trial Judge Advocate, in opposition 7
; to said plea in bar,. presented. a written brief and .
oral ‘statement containjng misleading and erroneous state- ~
‘ments of fact and law to the General Court Martial upon
the issue of former’ jeopardy, a

13.: That the Gen Court Martial ddisinl upon ‘said ;
misleading and-erroneous staterfents erroneously over--
— ruled. a plea in bar. |

; e 14. That - -petitioner thereupon ‘pleaded not : suits and:
FS evidence was introduted until both prosecution and\the |
_ defenge stated they had no further testimony to offer; |
final arguments were made; and the Court was closed. to
_ deliberate upon its findings. ; ;

. That the Court Martial, by a divided’ court, mee
a erdict of a? and sentenced petitioner to be dishon-
s b - ;

Se ;
_Wapevv. HUNTER; WARDEN ees ae
he : _

o

>

~ orably discharged faa the Servioe: to forfeit all pay all |

allowances due or. to become due, and te be confined to

- hard labor, at such place as the reviewing authority may .

direct, for term-‘of his natural life.

- 16. That petitioner, by written brief prepared ‘se his a

‘: Defense Counsel, requested that the record .be reviewed

, carefully with a view of correcting a grave injustice and ..

‘suggested to the reviewing authority, that it might be
appropriaté to confer with metgbers | Of the Court Martial
and with witnesses, including petitioner. - Said brief. fur-

2a ther stated: Ih og, woh in bar i in this case should have been

sustained, for the reasons set out in argiiment on the plea,

R. 7-12. Without access to law. books, it is impossible ade-_

quately to present the law. However, in the evént the

reviewing authority permits the verdict of guilty to stand, |
we ask permission to. assdtiate United States resident.

counsel to brief and ‘Present the law to the _proper
authority.” , |

17. That. the reviewing authority, ex parte, erroneously

_ affirmed the conviction but reduced the sentence from. life .

“ imprisonment to twenty. (20) years imprisonment. :
18. That petitioner’s Defense Counsel thereafter orally

~..and by written brief presénted the issue of former jeop-

. ardy.to Board of Review No. 4, Branch Office, Judge Advo-
cate General’s pacers. to which board: said case\ had
‘been referred. _ cones 3 . “

19, That said Board of. Review No. 4, a a judicial body :
composed of just and.free men, trained in. the law, ‘held

that the evidence was legally insufficient to support the con- |

/ viction by reason of former jeopardy.’ oi ,; | :

=

4 20. That thereafter the Assistant Judge Advovate

_ General, European Theater, arbitrarily and caprici- .

. ously and without foundation. in fact or law and withput

‘the knowledge of petitioner or Defense Counsel and without 3
giving petitioner. an- opportunity to be heard, or repre-.- —

sented by counsel, and upon:an opinion which the Se¢re-
tary of War, through his authorized representatives, has

refused and still. refuses to furnish petitioner though) re-""
peatedly requested to do so, ‘dissented from ‘said opinion.

of Board of Review No. 4.. | 3 “4h,

. \ *

ieee oe te

ee ? | Wane: v. HUNTER, WARDEN,

21. That haventtie the. Cohimanding General, United.

‘States ‘Forces, ‘European’. Theater,’on January. 10, 1946,

’ and, petitioner states ‘on belief, without consideration’ of

the record or the law, or the opinion of the Board ‘of

Review No. 4, and. without the knowledge of petitioner 6r.

his Defense Counsel (prior to the issuance of the order)
‘and without. giving petitioner an opportunity to be heard

Or represented. by counsel, and without.foundation in fact .

. or law, sustained the dissent of the Assistant Judge Advo-
cate General and issued general urt martial order No.
2, . heretofore referred to in Paragraph 4.

22. That. petitioner upon learning of the. ‘action of the
+ Commanding General, United States Forces, European The- .
- ater and the action of the Board of Review No.4 and the
_ aetion: of ‘the. Branch Judge Advocate General, appealed .
- . to the Seeretary of War to exercise the power and duty .
..-vested in ‘him by law to correct the manifest’ injus-
tice done to petitioner, and release him from unlawful.

- custody and restraint, but that the Secretary of War has

. failed and refused to act and failed and refused to fur-

nish petitioner with, the opinions in his case.

23. Petitioner states that he ‘was furnished an incom- |
} plete’ copy -of the record of trial; that he does not lave.
a complete record because of the omissions resulting from

the actions and failure to furnish g complete record on
- the part of the Secretary of War and the Commanding
-. General. Fifteenth United saateee ry and their repre-

- sentatives.

" 24. Petitioner further shows that-his detention and im-

= a seein as aforesaid, is illegal and void in'this, to- wit:

A. That the Fifteenth: Army General. Court Martial was

without. jurigdiction by reason of foriner jeopardy to try -

the petitioner and that its finding and ee were, a

., nuHlity. Suen a tet . ; fi

2”.°: B. That. " petitioner was tried twice for the same
ce offense in violation of the Constitution of the United
States and more particularly the Fifth Amendment thereof
Jand in violation of the laws of the. United States and more
particularly ‘the Fortieth Article of War (10 U.S.L.A.;
'. See. 1511). |

. = s . ° : °
NE PSS ERON ATHOLL RTS E IES EL ROSELL NT A ATA I DRT a ae

'

. 4 -~ !
. -

. - ~ : 3 . .

: | sa
_ WAbdE v. HUNTER, WARDEN, ape

C. That. the Court -Martial : Order, ‘Headquarters. Fif- 7

| teenth Army, confirming’the finding of guilty and confirm- -—
ing the sentence as modified was iHegal ang void for lack

of jurisdiction. Sage’ “ ake ° ‘
-e. . -

{

ad
e

” Na a ‘ : * =

ce .- -, WADE v. “HUNTER, WARDEN’ » ie ee

Sentence:

e. be dienes discharged. the service, to for-
t all pay gnd allewances dué or to bécome’.due -and to
' be confined at hard labor at such place as the: revieing ~
authority may direct, for the term, of his natural life.
(Two ‘previous. convictions considered. ) Ue ee eg

2

_ The sentence, was adjudged on 1 Tuy, 1945.

i
The a of the. reviewing authority ‘is:

“Headqu ‘ters Fifteenth, U.S. ‘Ariny, Office of the Com: |
_-‘manding Geueral, APO 468, 24 July, 1945.

2 - Ie the foregoing case of Private First Class Frederick
" W. Wade, 39208980, Company K, 385th Infantry, the sen--
fence is approved. but-the period of ‘onfinement is reduced ~
to twenty (20) years. ‘The United States ‘Penitentiary,
Lewisbirg, Pennsylvania, is. designdted as the place of
: confinement. Pursuant to Article of War 501%, the order
ZZ ‘directing the execution of the sentence is withheld.

_ .
= . “~s a re ee
iF i ;
: .
: D . -
. re :
a

fee

%

oe _ L. T. Gerow, eds
10 Lieutenant General. U,5. A. Commanding.’

3 oes

~The sentence thereby having been approved by the re-
. “viewipg authority ‘and the record of trial having been °
examined by the Board, of ‘Review in'the Branch Offtce
of the. Judge Advocate General with the ‘United States -
Forces, Eurogean Theater, and the Board of Review hav-
ing substituted itS opinion that the record of trial is legally
insufficient to supp@rt the findings of guilty and the sen-
tence to the Assistant Judge Adyocate General in charge
, OF said Branch Office, and the Assistant. Judge Advocate
{General having dissented from the opinion of said om
of Review, and. the record of trial, the opinion of the Boar
fe of Review and the dissent of said Assistant Judge Advo-
cate General having béen submitted to the Commanding
General, United States Forces, Eurepean Theater, Under -
the third paragraph of Article of War 5014, and -the said

‘
o

i” .

— L.-S. OSTRANDER, | -

Z

Filed September 28, 1946..

* _ + Opinion.

12 Richard T. ‘Brewster, Fea. of Kansas City, “Mis- |

souri, and N..E. Snyder, Esq., of Kaneas City, oe
for the petitioner. Randolph Carpente*, Esq., Nnited

States Attorney, Eugene W. Davis, Esq., Assistant United

States Attorney and James W. Wallace, Esq., Assistant

' United States Attorney (Colonel William J. Hughes, or:
JAGD, and Colonel Franklin Riter, JAGD, were on the

b Tef ) for the respondent: ; 4

o - MeLLorr, District Judge: Petitioner, an inmate of the
United States Penitentiary at Leavenworth, Kansas, as-
sails, by a petitiond¢or a writ of habeas corpus, the legality

‘of his commitment and detention. Copy of the order of

a General Court-Martial’ under which he is held is attached
to his petition and to the response of the Warden. Peti-
tioner alleges that the order is illegal! and void for several
reasons, the chief one-urged being. that he had been.twice.
put | in jeopardy for the same offense in violation of the

'The- order is dated 10 January, 1946, and itechton that petitioner had

been convicted .before a. general court-martial which convened at Bad

Neuenahr, Germany, on 30 June and 1 July, 1945, pursuant_to paragraph

1, Special Orders No. 143. Headquarters Fifteenth United States Army. 23
June, 1945, as amen@ed by Paragraph 1, Special Orders No. 146, He ait

quarters Fifteenth United States Army, 26 June, 1945, on a charge, 0!
having carnal knowledge of a German female, on or about 14 March, 145

forcibly and féloniously, against “her will. Sentenced off July 1, 1945, to

be dishonorably dis*@harged, to forfeit all pay and allowances and to .be
confined at hard.labor for the term 6f his natural ‘life, the sentence was

‘ . approved by the reviewing autifority but the period of confinement was

reduced to 20 years. The retord of trial having ‘been examined by the
Bbard of Review in the Branch Office of The Judge Advocate General

with the United States Forees, European Theater, the Board (three mem-

bers, Judges Advocate, concurring) submitted its opinicre to the Assist-

sree?
Se

pee

Fifth’ ‘captions to the Constitution, andy a Fortieth,

Article of War.

eee There is no ) controversy hekweun the parties ‘ast
» the facts. Each specifically adopts the statement

of facts ‘set out in. the holding of Board of Review No. 4

of the Braneh Office of the Judge Advocate General with
the European Theater, introduced in evidence in this pro-
ceeding. This Court, therefere, specifically finds the facts
to be as shown in such holding, summarizing them for
present purpose and showing in foot-notes some portions
of the record of trial,.deemed to be ‘essential to an aunder-

atanaieg of the issue.to be determined. ; :

we

Petitioner, then a Private First Claas of Company Ky

385th Infaritry, and Thomas Cooper, a Private First. Class
in the same company, were arrainged separately and tried
together, with their consent, upon charges of violation of
the 92nd Article of War, the specification, in each instance,

.. -being that the accused, on or-about 14 March, 1945, had
+ forcibly and feloniously had carnal knowledge of a dif-.

ferent named German female against her-will. Cooper-was
acquitted and petitioner was convicted.. Petitioner was
sentenced to be dishonorably discharged the service, to
forfeit all pay and allowances due or to become due, and to

cafe Wane v. HUNTER, WARDEN +, °13_

a

be confined ‘at hard labor, at. such place as the review- |

ing* authority should direct, for. ‘the tefm of his natural

= life. ‘The reviewing authority approved ‘the sentence but

reduced the period of confinement to 20 years. '

When the General Court-Martial, which found Ee
guilty, convened at Bad. Neuenahr, Germany, on 30 June,
1945, anges cpap dente a. ail in bar-en-the: oe of

ep te —— —_— ~~ _

ant ‘etge Advécate Seneral | in charge of the Branch Office that the record -

of trial was legaliy insufficient to support the findings of guilty and:
sentence. The Assistant Judge Advocate General dissented from the
oywsnion of .the Board of Review, monumenting his view in an opin-
ion shown in the recerd of trial: The opinion of the Board of. Review
and the dissent of the Assistant Judge ‘Advocate General] were “submitted
to the Commanding 3eneral,- United States Forees, Eurepean Theater,
under the third paragraph of Articl¢ of. War 5012 and upon consideration
thereof and of the record of trial-the sentence was cynfirmed 21. Decem-
ber, 1945,. by command of. Joseph T. MeNarney, General, «VU. S. “Arnry,
commandhmeg. |. : ' :

ps ; F . sf
o 3 P : : .
a ’ — ‘
. ,
o ;

o

c

‘14 | WADE Vv. HUNTER, WARDEN rs
former jeopardy; but, at the simiiadidins of the Court the
plea was reserved until arraignment.- Upon arraignment
the plea in bar was renewed. Extended argument upon
'e the plea in bar ensued ayd.a duly authenticated rec-
14 ord of a former trial of\ the accused at Pfalzfeld,.

Germany, 27 March, 1945, by) a General Court-Martis~
Pome by the Commanding eneral, 76th Infantry Divi- .

_sion, was introduced. \There ig shown in the margin. the

initial statement of cofnsel for. the defendant made at’

that time.” nig

cade,
tenn, =

There is a out, at this juncture; a paragraph: from the
opie of the Board of Review.

_ “The oneal of hovunoe trial discloses that W ae

was wied before a Court of competent jurisdiction upon

the Charge and Specification involved here. He was ar--

raigned and issues were joined by ‘his plea to the general
issue (Def. Ex. A, pp. 5. 6); the prosecution Mmtroduced
‘evidence and rested (Def. ix, A, pp. 7-22); and the defense
introduced evidence and rested (Def: Ex. A, pp. 22-60).

*Major Richard T. Brewster, Cavalry, Headquarters 15th ‘United States
Army, who has since resumed the practice of law and now ‘appears as
eounsel for petitioner, and who was counsel for the defendant, Wade, in
“the Court- Martial proceeding, said: “I. would like to. set out what the
‘record - -shows. ‘The record shows that the case against Private First Class
Wade was tried: that after the prosecution and- the defense ‘rested, the
Court stated it wanted no further evidence, the prosecution stated it had
rio further. evidence, the defense stated it had -no further evidence and
the Court was closed. After deliberating. on the case.—and I state that when

a Court does. Galingzate on’ a case, it. et actpsewisiet places in jeopardy the--

man whose casé is Weihg deliberated-on Court Teopened and reque sted
the calling of certain other witnesses. he case was continued for those
witnesses and I maintain that that Court and no other Court has the right
to~ sit im judgment upon the cases against Pfe. Wade. It would

strange thing if other Courts can-sit in judgment on_ the ‘case, neat only
would it, violate the constitutional rights of -Pfe. Wade given -to him by
_ the Fifth Amendment against twice’ being: placed in jeopardy for the
same offense, not only does it vioiate. the plain language of Article of
of War 48 but it violates every sense of justice and;the due administfa-

tion of justice because when you shift cases around, you allow time to_

lag, you ailow witnesses to die ih action and to disappear and you. allow
memory to fail. [ say that not only cn constitutional and legal grounds

but on common sense grounds, . this-case should be barred as the only -

Court’ which has jurisdigtion ig the Court of the 76th Division of which
Pfc. Wade was a member. I ask the Court to consider those grounds.”

°

D

PCCtaes SP ee Ud

WADE v. HUNTER, ‘WARDEN i aes

-Both ine iaclaaiciniis and the defensé then stated — had
nothing further to offer, the Court stated it did not desire.
_ any witnesses called or recalled, and, after argumients were >

inade; the case’was submitted. and the Court was’closed —
(Def. Ex. A, p. 60). The Court was opened later and’
announced that it desired to hear other named witnesses, |

and continued the case until a date to be fixed: by the Trial
Judge Advocate (Def. Ex: A, p. 60): Seven days there-

‘after, on 3 ‘April, 1945, and prior to further action by -
_ the Court, the ‘appointing authority withdrew the charges,

and dirggted that no further proceedings be taken by the

-' Court in‘connection therewith (Pros. Ex. A). On’ the same

day he transmitted the charges-and allied papers to the

Commanding General, Third United States Army, with a —

recommenuation. for trial by general, court-martial, stat-

‘ing that: the case had been continued because of the un-

availability: of two witnesses due to illness, and that the
tactical situation made the obtainment of the witnesses

2 impracticable and pr ecluded prompt disposition‘of the case.

15... (Charge Sheet; 4th Ind.). Thereafter, on-18 April,
1945, the Commanding General, Third United States

_ Army, -transmitted the charges and allied papers to the.
Commanding General, Fifteenth United States Army, re-. |

questing that. he assume court-martial jurisdiction because
the civilian witnesses were residents of the territory under

his jurisdiction (Charge Sheet, 5th Ind.). The.Command-.

ing General, Fifteenth United: States Army, in compli-
ance withthis ‘request, assumed. court-martial jurisdic-

‘ tion; ard on 26 April, 1945, referred the case for trial by

general court- “martial (Charge Sheet, 1st Ind.).’

The documents referred to in the quoted paragraph are

in eviccnce before this Court. They support the. statements

made by the Board of Review. This opinion will be more
understandable if some of them are referred’ to in more
detail. First, then, reference will bé made to ‘the “closing”
and “opening” of: the court-martial. | Following: the an-

‘ nouncement by counsel that “the defense rests’ the prose-
cution announced that it had ished further to offer

and inquired whether the Court wished to have any wit-

nesses called or recalled. This being answ ered | in the nega- ,

tive.arzuments w ere made and

ya

16. | WADE v. HUNTER,. WARDEN at
“Neither the prosécution nor the defense have
anything further to offer, the Court was closed.

.

“The Court was opened. ~

“Law Member: The Court desives: that further
witnesses be called into the case, and to allow time to

secure. these witnesses, this case ‘will be continued. We:

‘would like to have as witnesses brought before the Court,

the parents of this person making the accusation, Rosa
Glowsky, and also the’ sister-in-law that was in the room
whe could further assist in the identification or identity
of the. accused. The Court will be: continued until a later
date set by the T. J. A. #

2 “The Court then, at 1700 o’clock, Pp. M,
‘March, 1945, adjourned to meet at the call of the soit
dent.” ‘ : -

The withdrawal of the charge and the direction ‘that
no further proceedings be taken by tke Court, referred to
by the Board of Review in the portion of its opinion or.

statement of facets set out above, are indicated | in a com-" ‘

munication from’. Headquarters, 76th Infantry Division.
A. P. 0..76, U. S. Army to the Commanding General, ine
U.S. Army, A. P. O. 493, showa in the margin.’ /

16 After receipt of the charges and alli¢d papers by
. the. Third United States Army on io ‘about 3 April,
1945, and on or about 18 April, 1945, it, through the Assist-

“1. The charges and allied papers in the case. of Pfc. Frederivk W
Wade, 39208980, Co. K, 385th Inf., are transmitted here with with a recon

‘mendation of trial by general court- martial. The case was previous aly
referred for trial by general court-martial and trial was commenced. Two
‘witnesses, the mother and father of the victim of the alleged rape, were
unable to be present due to. sickness, and the Court coniinued®the case

‘se that their testimony could be obtained. Due ‘to the tactical situatio:
the distancé to: the residence of such witnesses. has become so great that
. the case cannot be completed within a reasonable time.

“2. The accused has been served with a copy.of the charges. The

third copy.of the’ supporting pape rs is in the hands of the defense conisel ;

- and’ the same will be forwarded as soon as they are obtained from him
* “3. The Trial Judge Advocate obtained the rame of Mrs. Anni Enact
a: neighbor of the alleged victim, and it is believed that she can further
identify the accused. -
For the Commanding General’

& ao E ey ae :
| | Wave v. HUNTER, WARDEN. oe i 17
ant Adjutant General for the adainandine General,
transmitted ‘the charges and allied papers to the. Com-
manding General, Fifteenth U. S. ‘Army, A. P. O. 408,
ony of this communies tion / being shown jn ‘the margin.’

The Commanding General, ‘Fifteenth United States Army,
in compliance with this request, assumed ‘court-martial
jurisdiction, and on 26 April, 1945, referred the case for
trial by general court- martial. Before doing so, however,
comnfunication was addressed: to Commanding General,

First Army, advising that Wade was claiming prior trial

for game offense and .asking that certified record of trial,
if any, and “copy. of withdrawing order be transmitted.

_ Apparently i in conformity with the request—in any event -

following it in the trial record—a brief of the Trial Judge.
Advoeate on the subject :of “Double Jeopardy” was filed.
The conclusion of aoa Judge Advocate, as therein

expressed, was that “Private Wade has not heen tried on:

a former-occasion for the offense for which he is now
eing put on trial.” This was premised upon: essentially

the same line-of reasoning as that adopted by the Assist- -

ant Judgé Advocate General in his communication to the
Commanding General, United. Statg

“). Transmi itted herewith ‘are chi irges and Hied papers in’ fhe case of
Private First Class Frederick AW-—Wade, 39f08980; Company K, 385th
Infantry,. charged -with rape of a.German w¢man under Article ‘of War

92. The-German civilian against whom the crime was committed and -

other necessary civilian-avitnesses are residents of territory now under
your jurisdiction. aie
‘a. at is. impracticable to ry this case by court-martial appointed at
this headquarters at this time in view ofthe tactical SMuation and
that the, location of the incident and ‘east of "
civilian witnesses are a considerable dist: Without the boundaries of
this command. Standing O sahil Binceders No. 35, Military Justice
Continental’ Operati published 16 July, 1944, by Headquarters Euro-
pean Theater of Operations, U. S. Army, provides that when practicable
the trial of Cases involving the. peace and quict of asc ivil community will
be held ins the immediate vicinity of the alleged offense -s. In order to
accelerate the prompt trial’of these offenses, it is requested that you.
— court- martial jurisdiction in these cases:

. The accused is at present in confiners ent in the Third U. 5S. Army
ickad ‘but will ue delivered upon request to such place as you may
de ssignate.

For the Commanding ‘General:”

4
z

Forces, European.

of necessary -:

- view.

18 , E WADE v. HUNTER, WARDEN .

R

Theater (Main) A. P.O. 757, U.S. Army) advising.

17 ~~ ~«&that he did not concur in the holding of .the Beard o

- Review that the record of trial was legally: 4nsuffi- >
cient and recommending a contrary holding. The brief of
the respondent, filed in this proceeding, espouses the same

4

ardy for the same offense in violation of the Fifth Amend-

ment to the Constitution. A preliminary issue is whether ~

this Court- has any jurisdiction to déterminc the question
in a habeas corpus proceeding. An incidental, although
by no means an inconsequential question, is whether the
doctrinié-of “Imperious Necessity” or “‘Urgent Necessity,”

authorized the Commanding .General of the 76th In-'.
fantry Division, in the-exercise of his sound discretion, to
stop the first trial, withdraw the charges and refer them . |

to the Commanding General of the Third Army for. re-trial

without hazarding the accused’s claim that he had ‘been _
placed in jeopardy by the proceedings before the 76th.

Infantr¥ Division Court.

At the outset it may. be said that this Court recognizes .

‘ the limited scope of its inquiry. under a petition for a writ

of habeas corpus. As learned counsel for the respondent.
- correctly point out upon brief, this Court. is not an appel-

late tribunal sitting in review of court-martial judgments,
and it’ will not. arrogate to itself an examination: of: the

record of trial for the purpose of determining whether. |

_ errors were committed in the reception or rejection of eyi-

dence or whether the finding of guilt was sustained by the

evidence.. Courts-martial are lawful tribunals, with author- .
ity to determine cases over’ which, they have jurisdiction;
and their proceedings, when confirmed as provided by law.
‘are not to be lightly overturned. But it must be borne in

mind that a court-martial is a “creature of statute, and,

as a a body or tribunal, it must: be convened: and constituted .

“The views of counsel] for the petitioner coinciile with those of th’
three Judges Advocate who constituted the Board of Review while the

- views of.the respondent appear to be: supported by at least an equal

number of-elawyers in the Judge Advocate General's Department.

‘

‘The question which evolves amd as to which several weit
‘trained and reputable members of the bar divide about
equally,’ is whether petitioner has been twice put in jeop-*:

mA Me ry Tye rer
7 RE TYR is Ne Sead
elite 7 ot tes eel a ma

wipe MONS a tay het + Ries
Se, SAE OU TY e\ PT trae

Kinks

¢.
WADE ¥. HUNTER, WARDEN . cs

oS - ° . »
- - e

in entire conformity with the provision of the statute or .
‘else it is without jurisdiction.’ The first inquiry, there-

| fore, must be whether the court-martial which com- -
_18 ~° committed petitioner had jurisdiction to do so. .

ss Inferentially, counsel for the respondent seem to be of

the view that this Court is bound by the determination of
the court-martial.that it had jurisdiction to try the accused.
and to issue the commitment in question: This seems to
be premised upon the assumption that the court-martial’s
ruling on the question of “double jeopardy” and non-ap-

: plicability of the Kifth Amendment was a ruling upon a
legal issue arising ng the trial and thereforé may not
be inquired into in a collateral proceeding. While the lan- :
guage of some decisions may tend to support that view,

_ this Court is of the opinion that ldter pronouncements -by:
.the Supreme Court authorize it to determine, in, a habeas -
corpus . proceeding, whether the petitioner: has been twice
put in jeopardy for the same offense ;* for, if the sentence ,
was “beyond the jurisdiction of the Court because it was vA
against ‘an express provision of the Constitution, which.
bounds and limits all jurisdiction” (Ex-parte Hans Niel-
sen, 131 U.S. 176, 185), it is invalid.’

_—

_Before passing upon, the issue of: “double pope
is appropriate to consider another important. qiiéstion
raised by learned counsel for the respondent upon brief.
‘Stated generally it is that one in the military service of
his-country may not be allowed the protection ofthe Fifth
Amendment. Specifically, it is contended that the peti-
tioner at bar must seek his noe under, and =: ‘case
“McCiaughry Vv. Deming, 186 U.S.49.. Cf. Carter,v. Roberts, 117 v S.
496; Carter v. MeGlaughry, 183.U.S. 365; Grafton v. United, States, 206 -
S. 333; Reaves v. Ainsworth, 219 U.S. 296; French v. Weeks, 259 U.S.
a-6; EX pa rte Reed, 100 U.S. 13; Codlins v. Mc Donald, 258 U.S. 416.°.Contra
Sanford v. Robbins, 115 F. 2d° 435. 4 k ca

7
° ~~ —— ©

‘See, e.g. Ex parte Bigelow, 113 U.S. 328.

“Clawens v. Rives, 104 F. 2d 240: _Ex parte -Hans Nielsen, 131 U.S. 17 ‘Sa
_ United Statés v. Bell, 163 U S. 662. : ; o
“aC. Y Resmi v. -Réssell, 150. F. 2d 809; Johnson ¥v. Zerbst, 364 U.S.
458; Bowen v. Johnston, 306 U.S: 19; and Amerine v. Tines, 131 F. 2d 827.

e ; ' :
vd 220 — ‘Wave v. HUNTER, WARDEN

must “be governed exdiaaely by, the. ‘double j jeopardy’
provision of the Fortieth Article of War.” The. Fifih

i Amendment provides that no person “shall be. subject for

‘ the same offense to be twice put in jeopardy of life or limb.”

; e The Fortieth Article of War i is shown in the margin."
19 Under the latter it seems that the pleas “‘Autrefois

acquit” and “Auterfois convict” may be interposed _

but not the plea of “former jeopavdy.” Since neither the
plea of autrefois acquit nor auterfois convict could be sus-

tained upon the present:record, a holding ‘that the Fifth ~

Amendment is not applicable would require. discharge of .

the writ and denial of the petition. No case cited to, or

found by, this Court so holds and it is reluctant ? be"the.

pibaees in such adegision. »

*The argument of counsel proceeds substantially ‘as fol-
‘lows: The Congress has the: pow@ to provide for trial and
punishment of military and naval offenses and has done’

- so, independent of the civil judicial system provided by
. the Constitution. The Courts have held that the-framers -
of the Constitution meant to limit the right of trial by

jury, in the Sixth Amendment, to those persons. who were |

subject to indictment or presentment in the Fifth Amend-

ment, 1..e., to those who were not involved “in cases arising ..

ae | the land or naval forces, or in the Militia, when in actual

Title 16. USCA. Sec 1514. “As to number (article 40). No person

shall, without his consent, be tried a sécond time for the same: offe nse;

but no. proceeding in which an accused has been found guilty by a court-

_ martial upon. any charge or specification shall be held to be a tri ial-in

the sense of this article untjl the reviewing and, if there be one, the con-
firming authority shall have taken. final action upon the case.

“No authority. shall return a record of .trial to any court-martial for —

eerca ear ice, of—_
“(a) An acquital: or |
“(Dd ‘A finding of not guilty of/any specification; or

“(c) A finding 6f mot guilty of any charge, unless the record shows’

a finding of guilty under a specification laid under that charge, whict
— alleges a violation of some article of war; or

“(d) The sentence originally imposed, with a view to increasing its .
severity, unless such sentence iPiess than the mandatory sentence fixed.

- by law for the offense or offenses upon which a conviction has been had.
“And no court-martial, in any proceedings on revision, ‘shall reconsider

its finding or sentence in any particular in which @ return of the record of ©

trial for such reconsideration is, aang pe prohibited. ‘(June 4,. 1920,
. 227 Sn We il, Sec. 1, 41 Stat.-795. :

a

. ‘ ; .
ee

service in time of War or public. danger. "). By analogy, if

by jury notwithstanding the Sixth Amendment, he may

i While some.of the early decisions cottained dicta which
1 “might be interpreted as construed ‘by re
| preme Court, in the judgment of this CouN,
4 cifically so held.’ On the contrary, Be a muc later case,
} also discussed by counsel upon brief,’*- it is pointed out
that while Congress, “hy express constitutional

has not spe-

/ sion in which it is contained seems to -be broader than
*the issue under consideration; but while the question now
_ raised is not precisely the same as the one before the
Court in the cited case, this Court is constrained to accept
_ the quoted statement as a correct exposition of the prin-
| ciple of law to be applied. 3 js

. ‘It is of interest to note that the Board of Review took
essentially the samme view.of t uestion as. this Court

' two inhibitions against double jeopardy—i. e., the Fifth
Amendment ‘and Article of War No. Forty—was ‘essen-.
tially: the-same, pointing out that. the Fifth Amendment
'. “is a. limitation on courts-martial, as they, like other

Courts. deriving: from an exercise of the Federal power,
are subject t to the restrictions of the Bill of Rights except.

' reached.

a 11x parte Milligan, 71 US. 4 Wall.) 2, 123.
‘2Grafton w United States, 206 U.S. 333,
\sSanford Vv. Rebhiné, 115 F. 2d 435, 438; United States ex, rél. Innes v.
Hiatt, 141 F. 2d 664; Ex parte Quirin, 317 U.S. 1. Cf. Schita v. King,
133 F. 2d 283; Shapiro v. United States, 69 F.. Supp. 205. 7

BESS Sarat ae
Koen Me ES ES

; “ ake WADE. v. HUNTER, WARDEN ies S

one in,the military forces may be denied: “the right of trial |

also be denied the protection of the Fifth ‘damental me)
+ against-being twice put in jeopardy for the same offense. __

ndenit, the Su-’.

20° provision, has. the power to prescribe rules for the - |
= government and regulation’ ‘of the Army * * * thosé |’
| rules. must be interpreted in connection with the prohibi- —
» tion against a man’s being put twice in jeopardy: fér.the |
7. same offense.” This language is characterized: by. counsel -
* for respondent as obiter dictum, inasmuch as the discus- |

has indieated it takes. It hei that the intendment of the -

insofar: as. special constitutional provision for them is
_made.” The authorities cited’ _ support the conclusion.

er]

a 3 _ WADE *: HUNTER, Winona

Reapondaiit contends that the portion of Article of War

_ Forty reading: “* * * but no proceeding in which an ac:
- cused has been found guilty by a court-martial upon any”

charge. or specification shall be. held to be a trial in the

- sense of this article until the reviewing dnd, if there be

one, the confirming authority shall have taken final action

‘upon the case’”’ is definitive of * ‘jeopardy” in all cases triable
‘by courts-martial. This Court is constrained to hold,: 4s

did the majority of Board of Review No. 4, that such

. definition is applicable only to those cases in which the-
- accused ha# been found guilty, and that the- purposé of
such, provision is to authorize the. le reviewing or confirming
; authority to remand -A casé for a new trial where

21 ‘the finding of guilty is not. approved. The context

of Article Forty indicates the provision quoted is
but a statement of principles ‘protecting the accused

‘rather than an enlargement, of the power of the reviewing

- .or confirming authority to a point of conflict with the .
-, protection of the double jeopardy clause-of the Fifth

.Amendment. A construction of a statute which does not

conflict with the Constitution is to be ‘preferred 0 over one

which conflicts. with. the Constitution:

Has petitioner ‘Been twice placed in jeopardy for the
same. offense within the purview.of the Fifth Amendment?

“The general rule is that a person is not in jeopardy until
*. he has-been arraigned on a valid indictment or.informa: ~
tion, has pleaded, and a jury has been impaneled’ and ;

sworn; and where a case is. tried to a Court without 2

_ jury, jeopardy begins after accused has been ‘indicted and ~
_ arraigned, has pleaded and the Court has begun to hear -
eviderice.”” McCarthy v. Zerbst, Warden, 85 F. 2d 640, 642. .

The prohibition against double jeopardy is not directed
to the peril.of a second: punishment, but to a second ‘trial

_ for the same offense. Kepner v. U. S., 195 U.S. 100, 130.

The Board ‘of Review expressed the opinion that the
burden of pleading and proving former jeopardy rested

Bs cs | odaitns es

~~

Date St Dg 5 ail Saat Be Vie te i i AB Zs

SS Gea ONL Tee eee Pere

upon petitioner: and, in the event of his failure so to do, ... ©

. waiver would follow. The record clearly indicates, how-

ever, that no waiver occurred, the plea having been prop-

erly made and argued at length: That it should have been -
sustained ° séems to be clear, tested by the rule referred to

r

Wate v. HUNTER, WARDEN 2 eer

in ‘the preceding: Re oy Whether the refusal of the

military authorities to release upon the greund of double,
jeopardy may be passed upon in a habeap corpus proceed- i
- ing has already been discussed. Being of the opinion ‘that |
.. it may, the Court now holds that petitioner ‘was placed in. -
jeopardy by the court-martial cnt by the 76th In-.

fantry Division; that his subsequent trial and conviction

by. the general court-martial convened by the 15th United

States Army at Bad Neuenahr, Germany, placed him in

_ double jeopardy; and that the last-mentionad“trial and

conviction are voiti for lack of jurisdiction unless the doc- 3

trine of “Imperious Necessity” ‘or “Urgent Necessity,’
yet to be considered, justifies a different conclusion,

22 It is significant that the view of this Court, which
is: -éssentially the same as that expressed by the

Board of Review in its opiniori,/-was also shared by the

_ Assistant’ Judge Advocate General (who dissented. from
.the conclusion of the Board of Reviéw) as expressed in

iis communication: to the Commanding General, United —

' States Forces, European Theater. Therein he said:

“IT am in accord‘with the Board of Review in
its analysis of the principles of law applicable to the plea

- of former. jeopardy and subscribe to the doctrine. ex-_ -
pressed in the opinion that in the trial of cases before gen-

eral gp jeopardy within the meaning of the
relevant prov

Constitution may attach prior ito findings by the Court
and approval of the sentence by the reviewing authority.

_ I further agfee with the Board of Review that the 40th —

Article of War must be read in the light of the Fifth
Sr rgcorraaeen and the adjudications of the Federal Courts
respect to the ‘double jeopardy’ clause. therof.”

His difference. with: the Board of Review was stated to

“resolve about the question as to the operative effect’’”

and applicability of the principles discussed in the opinion
ofthe Circuit Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit iri
- the case of. Cornero v. United States, 48 F. 2d 69.

In Cornero v. United States, supra, a jury had been im-
paneled to try- defendants‘charged with a conspiracy to

Violate the National Prohibition Act.’ The —s at-

ion of the Fifth Amendment to the Federal. —

9

’

ere “Wane, v.

~tornéy having ‘announced that he was unable te proceed ®

sd

alleged rape, were unable to be present due to sickness, ‘and

HUNTER,” WARDEN i pee

because of the ‘absence of necessary witnesses, the jury
was discharged. The Court held that jeopardy had at- ©.
tached antt that the doctrine of imperious necessity did
- not extend to the absence of. witnesses.

a The Board of Revi lew, " relying’ upon the. state ment made
in the communication from Headquarters, “76th Infantry
Division to the Commanding General. of the Third Army
isee footnote 3):

ane = “The case was erevioualy referred for
trial by generaf court-martial and trial was commen: 2”
Two witffesses, the mother and father of the victim of the

the Court continued the case so that their reetiony could
be obtained. ah = eu |

applied the: rationale” ‘of ‘the @ornero case, pointing out
that. while sftuations might arise in the administration | of .

military: justice, calling for the: exercise of the doctrine A

of imperious: ‘necessity, the absence of witnesses

ZS aloné “does not sanction the exercise of the dof-

”

trine.”” The Assistant Judge Advocate General took
the view, however, “that the situation disclosed in the

‘ inst&nt case is, in the application of the*doctrine to the

Military Courts, well within the description of ‘urgent cir-) |
cumstances,’ notwithstanding the generally accepted litni-
tation of the Civil Courts.” He placed substantial reliance
upon the sentence in the comnttnication.. immediately fol-.
lowing that set out above (sée footnote 3), reading:

2

“Dye to the tactical situation the distance to
the residence: of such witnesses has become so great that.
the gase cap not be completed within a reasonable time.”

omni for respondent, upon brief, urge that-the sen-
tence last quoted “‘is a finding by the Commanding Gen-
eral of the 76th Infantry Division that a military: situa-
tion existed which required the discontinuance of the —
trial before the Court appointed by him and the transfer
of the cause to .a jurisdiction where military conditions:
permitted the production of the witnesses.”’ This Court ”
doés not so construe the language used, especially when.

$ .

GO ::
_-

/Wabe: ve HUNTER, “WARDEN Tie Detar.

: considered, as it Should be, in its siete In tHis con-

~- nection the record with reference to the closing and re-

opening of the case, shown elsewhere in @is- opinion,

: should likewise be considered.

It woyld serve-no good purpose to. discuss at length the
doctrine of “imperious” or “urgent” necessity. The Board |
of Review defines it as ‘‘a sudden and overwhelming emer-
gency, uncontrollable and unforseeable, infecting the ju-
diciat process and rendering a fair and impartial ‘trial
impossible. .It does not mean expediency.” The Board's
characterization of the term as

66% * *

MF cas
’ an illusive and expansive doctrine, not .

susceptible of precise definition because’it is designed |

| apply to emergent situations Mipsis ee

is approved by ‘the Assistant Judge adedoate Genarad in’
his communication to the Commanding General as is also ~
its statement to the effect that ‘the power should be ex-
ercised with caution, and * * * be limited to the most
urgent. circumstanees”-—“‘a real.emergency which is dil- |
- gence and care could not have been averted.” .Cf. United
States .v.\ Perez, 9 Wheat. 579. .The list of instances in -
which it is to be applied, given in the opinion of the Board

of Review—where a jury is unable to agree;/ mis- .
24 conduct tainting the’ panel; inflammatory press re-
: . leases corrupting the jury; reiationship of a juror to

the accused; incapacity of a.juror, etc.—is illustrative

only. -Other situations come to mind; and if the record
in the case at bar indicated that the “tactical’ situation”
was the motivating reason for. discharging the first court-
martial, this Court would not. hesitate to hold that the
ddctrine is applicable. As previously pointed out, how-
ever, the absence of witnesses, rather than an emergency
- due to the military Situation,.seems to have been the
reason for the withdrawal of the’ case from the court-.
myrtial w which first heard it.

; ARTHUR J. MELLOTT, District Judge.
te May 9, aie ee

26 t) Respondent's s Motion for Reconsideration.

Now comes -the Respondent herein and respectfully |
moyes the Court for reconsideration of its decisign and
opinion heretofore entered in this cause on May 9, 1947,
for the rovowing | reasons. . eh

-

Cw

he EEN pM

‘cee v. Hunter, ‘WARDEN . °99

1. Respondent does not request reargument of. | any of
the legal issues set forth in the opinion. This motion for

recofisideration is addressed solely to that portion of the.- +%

Court’s opinion ‘which reads as fellows: |
»
“* * © the absence of witnesses, rather than
an emergency due to the military situation, seems to

have been the reason for the withdraw al of the cage from :
the court-martial which first heard $,’ Yon: A

2. Respondent is prepared to. prove by reference to
historical fa¢ts showing the movement of the Headquar-
ters of the three units involved- —the 76th Infantry Divi- |
sion, thé Third United States Army and the Fifteenth
United States. Army—that it was the tactical situations
arising out of the .concluding six weeks of hostilities in’
the European Theater of Operations against the armies
of the German Reich which were in fact responsible for

sie! action taken here.

4. Respondent is prepared to show the movement of ;
the. Headquarters of the 76th Infantry Division from «

Pfalzfeld, in the Rhineland, & place near the scene.of the

alleged offense for which petitioner was tried by the 76th

{infantry Division Court to. Limbach, Saxony, many miles

away from the scene of the offense. Respondent lis pre-
pared to show how, from March 20 té April 24, 1945, in

-. connection with. the pursuit of the German arnties the
Headquarters of the 76th Infantry Division was at no

iess than fifteen different places, in four Separate prov-

-inces of Germany.

27 4. Respondent is likewise prepared to prove the

‘location of. the respective Headquarters of the Third
and Fifteenth United States Armies during the same pe-
riod. Such proof will demonstrate that. at the time the
charges against petitioner were transf+rred from-the 76th

Infantry Division to thé Third United. States Army, the
Jatter unit’s Headau 1arters were in the vicinity of the scene

of the offense; and similarly, that at the time of the sec-
ond transfer by the Third United States Army to the Fif-
teenth United States Army, the Headquarters of the last
mentioned organization had moved to the v icinity of the
place of the offense Respondent further is prepared to

A}

28 , _ WADE v. HUNTER, WARDEN

‘show that the critical witnessts, “for whose ‘testimony the
first court-martial trial was adjourned, were ‘finally lo-
cated at a place which was then under the control of said
‘Fifteenth United States Army. :

| a These witnesses would have been produced, not as —
in the United States pursuant to a subpoena supported
‘by statutory authority (See Articlé of War 23; U.S.C.
1594) and not as in England by ‘virtue of an Order in
Council, but simply as a result of the power of the United
States Military Commander, over the inhabitants of con-
quered territory.’ R« :pondent will show, by reference to °
the progress of the Thigd United States Army during the
last weeks‘of the war and particularly at the time whén
the:case was transferred from that Army to the’Fifteenth |
United States Army, that the place of residence of the
witnesses had passed beyond the control of. the 76th In-
fantry Division and the Third United-States Army and. -
was under the —- of the Fifteenth vanes States —
Army. :

6. Respondent. believes that this evidence w ill anaely
- dernonstrate that the term, “tactical situation” as: used -

by the Commanding General of the 76th Infantry Divi- : ~

sion and of the Third United States Army was not a —
mere form of words designed to disguise a matter, of con-
venience but in truth and in faet accurately described the |
- fluid military’ situation which marked the closing days of
the.war in Germany. Consequently Respondent asserts

with confidence that the action taken was consistent «—

28 with the constitutional principles of double jgop- |
. ardy as applied- by Congress to Military Law and
the practical necessities of military justice in the pro-.
visions of the 40th Article of’ War.

me Attached fereto and by this reference incorporated
herein is a map showing the respective movements of the
76th Infantry Division, Third United States Army and
the Fifteenth United States Army and also indicating~
the tactical situations which prevailed with respect to |
said commands during the. period when tha charges
against \petitioner were withdrawn from the jurisdiction
of the 7$th Infantry Division Court and were transfefred’

| >

e

EIR RS Nn ADB GORY AA os:

- necessity | -is applicable.”

~ the proof will show that the tactical situati
-fact, the motivating reason for withdrawi ‘ing the earl f

War v. HUNTER, WARDEN ere
to the Courtof the Fifteenth United States Army through |
the channel of the Third United States ‘Army, :

8. In its opinion this Court. said:

| “e © © If the record in the case ‘at bar indi- .
cates that the ‘tactical situation’ was the motivating rea- -

. son for discharging the first court- martial, this Court

would not hesitate to hold that the doc trine lof imperious

As indicated above, the Respondent is con ineed that
n was, in

from the first court- martial.

Wherefore Respondent prays that the iiennhbite Court
reconsider its decision and opinion herein and make and |
enter its orders fixing the time and. place whereat Re-
spondent may submit additional evidence in-proof of the
facts hereinabove alleged with opportunity afforded Pe-
titioner to submit dees et idence if he may.de-

sire.

Respectfully sideaattted:
RANDOLPH ‘CARPENTER,

United States Attorney, |
District of Kansas, Topeka, Kansas.
’ JAMES W. WALLACE, |

Assistant U.S. Attorney, ae

District of Kansas. Topeka, Kansas.

EUGENE W. DAVIS,
Assistant U.-S. ‘Attortey;” |
District of Kansas, Topeka, Kansas.

Attorneys for Respondent.

OF Counsel:

WILLIAM J. HUGHES, JR. eage
Colonel, JAGD, U. S. Army.

FRANKLIN. RITER, |
~ Colonel, JAGD, U. S. Army. .

Filed June 12, 1947.

- .

s
* a
«
hee
-
pam
e
e
”
. af:
3
ee i a
pe ~

Note: ee ; - ae
A ; : |

Page 30, a large military _
map showing positions and movements,
is not satisfactorily reproducible.

WADE v. HUNTER, WARDEN — "31 @

mm Journal Entry of Order on Rewncetnnt Ss |
Motion: to Reconsider.

Now on this 10th day of buy, 1947, at Kansas City,
Kansas, this proceeding comes regularly on for hearing
_on respondent’ s motion for reconsideration of the decision ,
and opinion entered: in this proceeding on May §, 1947.

Petitioner appears by R. T. Brew ster, and.N. E. Sny der,

his attorneys of record. ¢

‘Respondent appears by James W. Wallace, Assistaht® 2
ULS. Attorney, one of his attorneys of record.

_ Thereupon, the arguments ‘of counsel -are heard ne
considered; and the Court, having examined. the record;
and ° being well and fully advised in the premises, Gada
that -respondent’s motion for recansideration is essen- .

~ tially a motion for a new trial; the motion was not filed —

within ten day ys. after. the final judgment and decision;
and the Court is without. ‘Jurisdiction to entertain the
motion. It is’ therefore 8

) Ordered that respondent's motion for reconsideration
| be and it hereby is denied. . , 7

; ARTHUR J, MELLOTT, . District Judge.
T. BREWSTER,

. E. SNYDER, ©
"gee for Petitioner.

JAMES W:: WALLACE, athe. : :
Assistant U. S. Attorney Se eis
One of Counsei for Respondent. : we ee > . ,

Fited July 11, 1947. _

ae “Bolles: ‘of Appeal...

Notice is hereby given ‘that the respondent, Walter A.
Hunter, Warden of the United States Ji iirc Leav-

4

oe _°. WADE v. HUNTER, WARDEN »

enworth, Kansas, hereby appeals to the Circuit Court of .
Appeals for the Tenth Circuit from the opinion and judg: :
ment entered in this cause on May 9, 1947, and the opinion
and judgment entered on the motion for reconsideration
on July 10, 1947. :

:. par W. ‘WALLACE, ,
Assistant Us 8. Attorney,
Attorney for Respondent.

e

Ste of above Notice of Appeal ‘mailed: to: Richard T.
Brewster, Attorney at Law, 907 Federal Reserve Bank
Building} Kansas ‘City, Missouri, -and Mr. Nona E. Snyder,
Attorney at Law, 210 Brotherhood Building, Kansas City,
- Kansas;-this 25th day-of July,. 1947. Hie

{Sedl.) - HARRY M. WASHINGTON, Clerk:

Aen So .
onmotait
‘ TONE Ee memnin

By. MARY E. CHAPIN, ey © Clerk.
Filed — 29, arora

sof

120 Order Enl¥rging Time.

And now on this 29th day of August, 1947, comes on
for. hearing the motion of the respondent for an order |
enlarging the time in which to file and doekeét the record |
on appeal in this the above-captioned and numbered cause. .

The Court being well and truly advised finds that good
‘ cause appears therefor and mses ‘said motion should be
Sustained. . eae

It is therefore ordered that the respondent, Walter
A. Hunter, Warden, United States Penitentiary, Leaven- ©
worth, Kansas, be and is hereby allowed thirty days addi-
tional time in which to file and docket his record | on appeal
in this cause. ;

o

was not discharged prior to the court-martial.

The Court: You may ask that question. Do you under-
stand the question?—A. Yes, Your Honor.

; The Court: You! 3 Were not discharged nner than us
‘shown by these Court records, is that right?—A. Yes,
__ that’s right. ) :

Mr. Wallace: I think that is all. |
Mr. Snyder: You may stand down, Mr. 'Wade.

a a Se A rR nee Nang nent ey
; 7

WADE v. HUNTER, WARDEN . 45.

Respondent's Exhibit B..

> Headquarters Fifteenth US Army
; Office of the Army Judge Advocate
teats ; “ay APO 408 ;
eae "21 July 1945

B- 324 ‘United States.ys. Beivate First Class Frederick
W. Wade (white), 39 208 980, and Private Thomas

jess (white), 35 766 893; both Company K, 385th In-

‘fantry, rae

Present Ages: Wade: 28 11/ 12, years, Cooper: 314712 |

. years.

Dates of Enliatment: Weds: Si June’ 108%, O6oper?
- May 1941. fart pres .

Prior Service: As to each : None. | |

Date of Confinement: As to. each: 18 N —
: '. Tried at: Bad Neuenahr, Germany. |

Date of Trial: 30 June 1945.

‘Sentence: As.to Wade: DD, TF, and CHL for life. As to.
' Cooper: Acquitted.

*( Maximum Authorized: Death. }

Prior Convictions: As to Wade: SCM, 20 poe 44, AW 61
and 65, failure to repair and willfully disobeying NCO, dis-
respectful manner taward hp Sum. CM, 15 Mar 44, AW
61, AWOL. As to Cooper: None.

Charges: As to Wade: ria: AW 92. Pleas: Not
guilty. Findings: Guilty. qe: sae Pleas: Not guilty.
Findings: Guilty.

Charges: As to Cooper: ‘Charge: AW 92. Pleas: Not
_guilty. Findings: Not guilty. Spec: Rape. Pleas. Not
guilty. Findings: Not guilty.

°

1. Evidence.

Accused Wade was charged witg® the rape of Rosa Glow-
sky, and accused Cooper was charged with the rape of .

%
.
.

3)

4G . - Wape v. HUNTER, WARDEN
z : , on ‘9 : ,

Mathilde Klein, violations of AW. 92, both offenses occur-

ring at Krov, Germany, on 14 March 1945 (R.5, 6). By

.’. direction of the appointing authority (R 2i, a common

trial was ordered, to which both accused consented :

‘open court (R 3}. One of the assistant defense’ iencia

was absent, but both accused agreed to his absence (R.3'.
The Court was ‘properly qualified as to conscientious
scruples against the imposition of the death penalty (R 4).
The Trial Judge Advocate correctly and timely called the’

_Court’s attention to the fact that the Presitlent of the

Court would assume the duties: of the absent Law Member

- in accordance ‘with Article of War 31 and-Paragraph 51,

Manual for Courts-Martial, 1928 (R5). Cooper had no
special pleas and plead not guilty to the specification and
charge (R6). Wade interposed a. special plea in. bar of
trial, based upon claimed former jeopardy (R7}, which
plea was argued at length (R 7-12). The Court closed,

- deliberated upon the plea for ten minutes, and then de-
nied it (R12), following which Wade plead not guilty

to the specification and charge (R 12). After the prose-.
cution rested its case, Cooper interposed a motion for a |
finding of not guitty, which was denied (R63). The Presi- |
dent. of the Court fully ahd properly explained to beth -
accused their rights as.a-witness (R 163, 164), and each
elected to testify under oath (R‘164, 182). Following the
close of its case, the Defense renewed Cooper’s s motion for.
a-finding of not guilty; again it was denied:(R 196).
Cooper was found not guilty of the specification and charge -
(R196) and was acquitted (R 197), but Wade was found ~
guilty of the specification and charge (R 196) -and was
sentenced to dishonorable discharge, total forfeitures and
confinement at hard labor for life (R197).

It was established that. each of the accused were in
the military service of the Uhited States on the date-of
the alleged offenses and at the time of trial (R 61, 62).

Due to the close relationship. of the evidence relating
to both accused, a separate discussion thereof is not
deemed necessary; however, pertinent testimony as to
certain major points of contention, such as time, identifi-
cation of both accused, alibi, etc., will be summarized

“under separate sub-headings.

Wapk v.HUNTER, WARDEN...” 47

a. For the Prosecution.

American troops entered Krov, Germany, about 5:00
P.M., Tuesday, 13 March.1945 «R 21, 55). The next eve-

ning, shortly before 6 o’clock, two American soldiers were -

observed by several German civilians ente ring the Dietrich

- house, located across the street from the house owned by -

Matthias Weiskopf (R 31, 55); then, the same two gol--

_ diers entered the adjoining home of Anni Endt (R 13,43).

It was getting dark as they entered Mrs. Endt’s kitchen

through the back door ‘(R 43).. They stayed. for ten. or —

4

_ fifteen minutes +R 44), during which time Mus. Endt was
rable to ‘closely observe and remember the larger soldier,

but could not remember Gr. recognize the second soldier
(R44, 47). ?

Upon: leaving ‘Mrs. Endt’s “house, .the two. soldiers

pine the street and entered the Weiskopf house through .".
the unlocked front door (R 43, 31, 49,55). At this time,-

Rosa Glowsky, (age -24, married}, one of the daughters
of Matthias Weiskopf, was standing in Widow: Jaeoby’s
barn, on the same side ofthe street and just a’short dis-
tance from the Weiskopf home. She observed the soldiers

_entering her home (R13). Her father and sister, Mathilde

Klein, (age 29, married!, were in their kitchen, in the
front part of the house | R 32, 56), while Regina Weiskopf,
a- daughter-in-law of Matthias Weiskopf, together with
her children, were in their own kitchen, which adjoined .
that .of her father-in-law (R..49}.. After entering the |
house, the two soldiers came into the front kitchen (R56), |
and the smaller, -hheavier-set soldier approached Mathilde;
who was standing at the stove fixing supper (R 32, 56).

He tapped her on the shoulder and indicated that she -

b ua go upstairs with him iR 32, 56, 57:, while the

larger soldier remained in- the kitchen with her father
and seated himself right next to the door «R 34,57). At
this time, it was still daylight «+R 14, 32, 56.
Mathilde and the. smaller spidier, went to the rear
kitchen, where he asked Regina to go out of the room
(R 49), which she did, and accompanied by her children,

‘went into the front kitchen -(R 46). Then, Mathilde and

the same smaller soldier went through all of the rooms * °°"

: upstairs, some store-rooms, other parts: of the house, the.

°

tan

"48 © WADE Vv. Hoszer, WARDEN

barn, and returned to the Kitchen, where Mathilde asked

her father for the key to the basement into which her
male soy Fe ore indicated to her that he wanted to

“go (R 33, 34}. thilde asked her father to come along,

but the larger ae speaking in understandable Ger-
man, said, “Alone” (R 33). .Mathilde and the smaller
soldier went to the basement, observed by Resa, who, a!

this time, was still outside (R 14,33). Upon arriving in.
- ethe basement, the, smaller soldier flashed his hight aroun:

and then forced Mathilde into a.corner upon a large, wine
barrel ‘R 34). He removed her drawers !R.35) and pro-
ceeded to have sexual intercourse with'her, At first, she

resisted, fighting him off with her hands ‘and feet: but
she was nervous ‘(R 34), excited, and afraid he woul | -

shoot her. He penetrated her private parts with his pri-
vate parts .(R 35). She did not comsent to the act and
moaned during its commission (R 35), which lasted about
fifteen minutes. Mathilde tore herself loose and ran to the
door of the basement, but the smaller soldier caught hev

and held ‘her fast, attempting to engage ‘her in conversa->

tion (R 36). After some fifteen’or twenty minutes, Ma-
thilde,ran into the yard upstairs, followed by the smaller
‘soldier AR 36}. ie ’ s

hea hile, Rosa,’ some twenty minutes after first. see >
ing the two soldiers enter her home, went into the front
kitchen, joining her parents, Regina and her children, and

the larger soldier, who, at that particular time, was stand-
ing at the,kitchen cupboard :R 14). He laughed at her
little. and she sat down on a sofa in the corner, facing
the larger soldier, who resumed his seat near the door
(R15). Then, this larger soldier told Ker to wait in the
kitchen, while. he went out, returned, went out a secont
time, ‘and upon returning, motioried to her to come. along

. with him, saying, in German, ‘Come along, lady” :R 15>.

He was armed with a- pistol, carried in a holster (RAS):

Rosa told -her father to come along, but the larger soldier
prevented this (R 16). She followed him, whoily afraid.

i because ‘ ‘everything was so new’... I though? if he told

me to come along, I had to come along” (R. 16:1). to Re--

gina’s kitchen, where she asked the larger soldier that she
permitted to go to the basement to. . get her child (R 19).

os

eo. _ Wade v. HUNTER, WARDEN

~ on -

Instead, the larger soldier drew his pistol and “shut her .

up.’ He ordered her to lie down, with w hich she complied.
afraid. that he would shoot her WR 16). ' He pulled her

drawers down, vpened his pants, laid upon her, and held |

his‘ pistol at her neck (R 1%. At first, she fought him

off with her arms (R17); but she was unable to-resist |

further. The larger soldier penetrated her private parts
with his private-parts, wholly without her consent or
co-operation (R 18:. This incident lasted about five. min-
' utes, followimg which she pulled up her drawers and w ent

into the front kitchen, with the larger sdihier following’.

her (R.18, 36). At this time, Mathilde and the smaller

soldier had not returned, so the larger soldier went to

the house door, where he met: Mathilde and the smaller
_-soldier (R19). The larger soldier took outa book ‘and

showed Mathilde something in it, though-she didn’ t fully

understand. She assumed that he wanted to know her
e ge, so she pointed ata 30 +R 36). The larger soh\er then
returned to the front kitchen with Mathilde, pointéd to
the clock, and said, in German “Anather hour”. (R 36, ‘51,
58). This was shortly before 7:00 P.M.-+R 37:. Both
soldiers then left, taking with them the. key to’ the house:
(R 23, 58):-. -

Thereafter, . the datiire Welahont family went into” a
neighbor’s air-raid shelter and barricaded the door :R 2

oS). Both Rosa and Mathilde were erying, with ‘the iieae Z

more visibly affected «(R 37, 58°. Mathilde went to the
~~ Pommer’s house, excited "(R 37). About 9:00 P.M. that
same evening, Rosa saw another American soldier, who
was billeted next door, and. she told him what. had hap-
pened iR 23}...

On the following Sunday (18th! morning, a group of

10 to Le American soldiers were brot ught to the Weiskopf -

home to participate in an identification ceremony. Both
Wade and Cooper were among this group of men ‘R 62,
Prosecution'’s Exhibit “B’'!. When Mathtide Was told that
American soldiers were being brought into the house, she
had a-nervous breakdown, but treatment by an American
physician made her feel better. iR: 381.° While she re-
mained in bed, the soldiers were marched into her room,
where there was an American soldier anda Polish woman

¢

*

49.

90 | pest WADE v. HUNTER, WARDEN -

conducting the ceremony (R 39). Mathilde was asked to
pick out the man who attacked-her. The officer: moved
agown the row of men, pointing his finger at each miian |
individually, while. Mathilde would nod her head in. ap-
proval or disapproval. Soldiers not identified\ left the
room (R 39). She picked out a black-haired man, who was

not wearing a hat, but who was wearing a -searf and was

‘clean shaver (R 40, 42). After the ceremony was over.
Mathilde was satisfied (R 40). ‘She testified that she did
not hesitate or delay in her selection of the soldiers. lined

up in front of her, and that she did not select Wade, whom

she had previously identified in Court (R 33). A short
while later, Rosa, standing at the window of Mathilde’s
room,- looked out, and immediately spotted Wade standing
_in ‘the outer yard, a few meters distant, with the group .
of soldiers (R_ 21, 25, 30). Rosa was not im Mathilde’s

- room at the/time of the formal identification ceremony
there (R 26, 29:. Rosa went downstairs to.the front dobr-
way and promptly selected Wade out of the entire group
of soldiers as the soldier who had: attacked her (R27).
Matthias Weiskopf also selected Wade out of the outdoar
line-up, after Rosa had told him that he “would be. able .

to. recognize the soldier too,” she having already doné*so
(R 60). Then, Wade and the black-haired soldier w hont
Mathilde had selected were brought into the Weiskopf.
home, where statements: of testimony were taken (R 27,
60:. That same evening, another investigation was held
at Kinderbeuren, where Rosa again saw Wade, as did she
at the former incomplete trial (R. 20).

By stipulation (R 62, ‘Prosecution’s Exhibit “B”s
was established that the 3rd and 4th Platoons of ae,
“K,” 385th Infantry, were the only troops billeted in Krov,

on 14 March 1945. |

=
"Pestimoriy of Prosecution Witnenses 1 as to Time
. of Aileged Offenses... | __———

‘Rosa Glowsky was in Widow. Jacoby’ Ss hare “before 6
o'clock ... . It could have been a quarter to 6 - ten minutes
to 6” iR 13. She remained in the barn about twenty

acting as ‘interpreters, plus ‘the Spietarn ap who was

WADE v. Hu NTER, WARDEN es 51

‘minutes (R13) cats went into the front kitchen, at which
time it was “absolute daylight” «R 14). Fhe criminal at-
tack*by fhe larger soldier took “About five minutes: Maybe
2 little bit more than that’ (R18). After the attack,the -

soldiers did not remain long (R 19}. From the time the |

two soldiers entered until they left, “Alogether, it could ©
have been around an hour... . It was around an hour. They ©

came shortly before 6 o'clock and it could have been close . .

to 7 o’clock when they left... fF still remember well be-
cause he’ pointed to the clock... It was around 7 o'clock

. I don’t know whether it was exacky: 7 o’clock or. a.
few minutes to 7” (R 22, 23).

- Mathilde Klein saw the two soldiers sites the Dietrich
house “around 5:30,” and “about five to ten minutes":
later saw them enter Mrs. Endt’s house | R 31). The crim-
inalattack by the smaller soldier upon her in the basement
lasted “15 minutes; it could have been. more. I can’t say .

-her at the basement door, following the attack “15 to 20
minutes” (R 36). When the larger soldier pointéd to the
clock,.° “it was about 2 minutes tad (Rar).

- Anni Endt testified that the two American soldiers
‘came to her house “Betw een 9: 30 and 6 o'clock” at which
time “It Was getting dark” (R 43), and they saree in
‘her house. “10 to 15 minutes” before leaving (R 44

Regina Weiskopf first saw the two American’ soldiers
“In my kitchen . .. On the 14th of March hefore. 6 o'clock
in the evéning”’ R 49). They stayed in the house ‘“‘frorn
about 6 o’clock until a quarter of 7,”’ which. she oe
remembered because the larger soldier, “When he wa
first at the kitchen, he was saying it is néarly 6 o ‘clock,
and at that time,,I saw that it was nearly 6 o’clock,”*and
_ afterw ards, when the same soldier pointed to the clock;

“It was a quarter of 7° (R51). .

. Matthias, Weiskopf wasn’t too certain as to ‘time be-
cause “I never thought. I'd have to go to court about it
‘and I never looked at the clock” (R 57. He estimated
that two American soldiers entered the Dietrich house’
“after 5 o'clock” (R56), that “it was still daylight’: when.

>

that exactly” .iR 36), and the smaller soldier detained -

~~plete trial; she testified that -he had a good set of upper

52." = WaApE v. HuNTER, WARDEN

they entered his kitchen (R 56), and that they stay ec in
| aa house “at least three- -quarters of an\hour” (R 58%.

Testimony of’ Hriacdetion Wikis to’ ‘denitification
of Accused: ‘ y

“Rosa ici identified Wade at. the trial as ‘the Amer-.

_ ican soldier who atta¢ked her (R 19). When at her house ~
on 14. March 1945, she described him as “very talk had a
reddish mustache and was wearing a steel helmet which,
was covered by a net” (R.14}. He carried a pistol in a
“holster (R15). He spoke German that “was well under-
‘standable” (R15). She-did not notice anything about
his hair, wound or scratches or scars on his face, or his?
teeth, because “I was afraid to look at him: I was afraid.
‘to look at him closely because he always looked at me”;
"yet, she added, “I recognize him also by his look cut of .

~ his eyes. He had such a funny look. Especially today, I «
recognize him again because he has a mustache again. He
looks the same way” (R24). He had thick lips (R 29).
Though he was clean shaven at the identification cere-

-_ mony on the following Sunday and at the investigation
held at Kinderbeuren, she still recognized him imme-
diately (R 20) without rieeding help (R 29). She
identified him at: the former. incomplete trial (R 20),
which time, so far as she knew, he didn’t have any sceth
(R 28). The second soldier who entered her home’ was a.
little shorter than Wade, but she never r got a alte ae
at him (R19).

' Mathilde Klein identified Wade at the fiat iR 33 as
the larger of the two soldiers who entered her home on
14 March 1945 (R 36), wearing a field jacket, steel helmet
covered with a net (R 32). He wore a mustache (R 36)
and spoke some German (R 41). At the former incom-

teeth (R 41), and identified him at the time (Page 21,
Defendant Wade's Exhibit “A”). She did nét select Wade
at ‘the. identification’ ceremony, ‘although he was present
(R 40). The soldier who attacked her was the smaller
of the two soldiers who entered her home and was heavy
set (R32); black-haired ard wore a beard as long as the
width of her little ir ped i 38, 40, 41). He also wore a

+

- Wade v. HUNTER, WARDEN | An Be

.~field jacket, red scarf and a helmet’ (R 40). At the iden-
tification cerernony held in her: room, she picked out a
_ black-haired man, who was not wearing a hat, but who
was wearing a scarf and.was clean-shaven. {R°40). When -.
- confronted with Cooper at the trial, she stated that “This |
. ‘man over here (Cooper) has’ many similarities” to the
man who attacked her, “but I-can’t say it for certain.” He _
locked “very much like that man” she picked out on the
18th; however, “It could’ be him but I don’t want to accuse.
' anyone without being-sure. I just couldn’t say that.. He
looks very much like/him.” (R 38). At-the Kinderbeuren
‘hearing, she could not identify the soldier who attacked

_ her. (R 42). . :

Anni Endt identified Wade i in the Court-room (R 44) as
the tall man with a receding forehead, mustache and wear-
ing a net over his helmet (R 46, 47), who eritered. her
home on ,14 March. She did not recall anything about. his
\ teeth, but.she remembered that he carried a white bottle
.\in his hip pocket and had a flashlight (R 46). She par-

ticularly remembered him, because “f was very afraid just

- when I looked at him’’ (R 45). Prior to taking’ the wit-
' ness.stand, she immediately recognized Wade outside dur;
ing a recess (R 47}. The second soldier entering her home —
- was.of average figure. and wore a red scarf under his
jacket (R 44); however, she could hot identify Cooper

at the trial (B- 44). She was not present at the identifica:
tion ceremony, Kinderbeuren Br ase or cortier mcom-\
plete trial. -- \ \

Regina Weiskopf identified Wade at the trialy/R 50) \
as the larger of the two soldiers she saw in the Weiskopf \;
home on 14 Mar¢h.. He was very tall, with reddish hair, \
mustache (R 49) and beard (R 52). He spoke German. \

(R 50), and she was\“‘certain” that he had upper teeth,
because she observed them when he was “always laugh-
ing” (R'53, 54). She also identified Wade at-the subse-
quent investigation though he’was clean-shaven (R 52).
The smaller soldier who was with. Mathilde (R-49} wore
a red cloth but she couldn't’ be sure of recognizing him
‘again (R50). She did not identify Cooper. at the trial.

Matthias Weiskopf identified Wade at the trial (R.58),_
and described him as being the large e sol dier with a pointed

.) 4A -- WaDbE v. HUNTER, WARDEN °

face that was inot clean-shaven. He had a revolver and a
holster (R 57). He identified Wade, though clean ‘shaven,

‘ following the positive identification made by Rosa, on the

mores of the 18th, but he had had ample time to observe -
Wade following the immediate selection by Rosa (R 60).

oe The second soldier, who took Mathilde, was.small, with a

round face that was not clean-shaven (R56). He did not

. identify Cooper at the trial.

Db. For the defense.

The 3rd_ and 4th Platoons, ae “K,” 385th In-
_fantry, entered Krov, Germany, against no enemy opposi-
tion, about 5:00 P.M., on 13 March 1945 (R 66, 75, 88, 96,
- 109, 127, 142; 147, 154, 165, 183) and stayed there about
five days. (R 76, 101), An undetermined number of
“French, Italian and Polish prsoners of war were liberated
(R 76 88, 148, 154), none of whom wore helmets (R 81,
90), though some did wear American uniforms (R 143,
148}. ;

The ie wake billets the first night in the upper end:
of the town (R 76, 127), but moved. their billets the next’
- morning toward the center of the town (R 67, 77, 127, 143.
-- 148, 167, 183; The 3rd squad, of which Wade was: a
‘rhember, was located about 100 yards below the 1st squad,
of which Cooper was a member (R 66, 89,.166). The Weis-
_ kopf home was about four or five blocks away—a good ten
_ or fifteen minute walk (R 104, 138, 176;:: The enemy;
_across the river, “threw‘in” some mortars and shells, so

‘observers were sent out (R 115, 169, 186), including Wade,

who went out in the morning and returned for the noor
meal, after having made several, trips in the interim, (R

' 185, 186). That. afternoon, Wade visited Cooper at the

latter’s billets, and the two of them observed the enemy
through gp inoculars between 1:00 and 1:30 P.M, (R 171,
186). oa :

The 1st anal e ished a billet guard, composed of
two sentinels, ore of whom was supposed to stand at the.
door of the billet, whjyfe the other was supposed’to patrol
100 yards each way’ in, front of the billet, ready to alert
the squad in the event of an enemy counter-attack | R‘78,

WADE’ V. HUNTER, WARDEN tek ‘ 55 _

_ 169)., Sentinels, serving tours of two hours on duty and

six hours off duty were chosen from a guard roster +R 83,

94, 170). Cooper and Sergeant Levario were on guard
duty from 10:00 A#@M. to 12:00 noon, and ‘from 6:00 until
-°8:00 P.M. on Wednesday, 14 March 1945 (R 67, 168). For

_ the evening tour, they were posted at approximately 6

o'clock ky Sergeant Rogers (R 67, 78, 168) and were

- relieved by Sommers and Shaffer at about 8 o ‘clock +R 68,

77; 170), after which: Cooper and Sergeant ‘Levario, accom-
panied by Sergeant Rogers went upstairs to Cooper's sng -
ters and had coffee and something to eat (R 67, 170..

. While “pulling this guard” tour, it was just turning dark .

aa

\R 74). Cooper stood right beside Sergeant Levario dur-
ing the,entire tour that evening (R 67, 169). ©. =

Wade arose about 6:00 A.M. on the morning ofthe 14th -
and went on guard until 8:00 A.M., after which he ate
(R.189). He Was seen at morning chow by Sergeant Matt-

- son (R97), Pfc Lambel ‘R 137), Pfe Zariila (R 128) and
‘Pic Metzger (R155). Along with the rest of the squad, :

he moved to new billets (R_183), ate,. shaved wth Metz-

ger (R 115, 157) and washed‘ (R 184:. When finished, he

went downstairs, where Sergeant Mattson asked him if.
he’d care to observe the enemy across the river, to which
Wade agreed. 1R 185). BO aye Mattson fixed this time

. «as about 11:00 A.M. (R 102), and Pfc Metzger testified -

that he was with Wade until ponent ‘11 or 12 o'clock that °
morning, though the latter did not recall Wade's going on
this patrol (R 158), Wade went to the river side of town,
in an alley, and observed the enemy across the river, re-
turning several times to the squad’s billet, and upon the

completion of .hig mission, returned for the ‘noon meal

(R 186), where he was seen by Sergeant Mattson /R 97;
and Pfe Metzger (R 158:. After eatifig, Wade went up to
see Cooper, visiting him: between. 12:30 and 2:00 P.M.,

observing the enemy through Cooper’s binoculars +R 186).

vooner fixed this time as between 1:00 and 1:30 P.M.

‘+R 178). Wade then returned to his billets and stayed

around the ‘dining room until about 3:00 or 3:30 P.M.
(R 186), during which Pfe Zarilla saw him, remembering
the time a€ 3:30 because a “chureh rang at that time”

‘R 132)}..Pfe Fessenden also saw. him at this time (R

:

“

wo
ane

al

wi . : : Mane ‘ —
. ty e “= ‘ng

Saar o 4 a : a os : aE? 7
Saeed WADE ‘v- HUNTER, WARDEN |,

113 Wade went upstairs and went to jae not aw waken-

gag antil sometime around 6:00 P.M., finding Pfe Boley

. and-Pfe Fessenden in his. room..(R 186). Pfe Boley fixed

the time of his arrival in Wade’s room as a “Tittle after

- 6:00 P.M.” and Wade ‘wa’ asleep‘at this timé (R- 249 +.
“Pte Fessenden | was also. ‘sleeping in. the same room, “and -
~ testifred that: he was awakened” at 6:15 P.M., at which

-- time. Wade was awake (R 110). The three had a drink
of wine (R 110, 186); after which Pfc Boley ahd Pfe Fes-
‘senden’ went downstairs, followed: ten minutes laterby .
-~Wade Sergeant Mattson testified , ‘that. Cooper had
Ww ore-both GIL. and colored scarves (R-106), but. he. didn’t °
‘ remémber when, nor. was. he cer tain’ that ‘Cooper had one ~
in Krov. (R-1607- ‘Other défense witnesses: stated that -
— Ww ade nor yf Caper wore's scarves. iR 74s 79; 112, 130,

rtheny until after 6.June.1945 i R 124, 185.', Te oe

~O-.. 9 Wabe.v. HUNTER,“WARDEN ~. . “57

137, 149, 173 |. Cooper testified that he never wore a
scarf (R 173). ace Ko: me :
All of the men owisd pacar pistols, including Cooper |
~(R 86), who admitted having one in his billets on the
-14th (R 181), and another defense witness, recalled that
- Cooper had carried a-pistol in a German holster strapped |.
- to his belt (R 134).° Wade stated that he-did not have a
pistol at Krov, but did possess one. priorto that time when
working in supply (R 187), which fact was forrobor ated °

_ by Sergeant! Mattson (R 104). ) 7 “4 ,

- Wade knew a few words’ of German, as ‘did most men

in the squad. iR. 136-137}. Rio ne Se Se Sage

| oo ‘as present’ at the former incomplete trial a

1- Wade, /obut did not participate therein; rather, he was Ee
side of the spread liimacon) awaiting trial hintself (R 175).

|

oe _ Testimony of ae Ww itnessey/s ve Identification
ares Wale ee as Ceremony |

"Though the many defe nse witnesses gave slightly varys
+ versions, it — ‘that the. following occurred :

~~. soldiers ‘were taken. to the Weiskopf home. They went.
"upstairs to Mathilde’ groom, Where she was in bed,-ner-
: Vous, excited and-crying (R 99, 136, 150, 156, 188). One .
of the soldiers and a Polish woman acted as interpreters
“(R 98, 112, 135), while Captain Chambers, who was in |
charge; instructed Mathilde to “pick out the two soldiers.

_ ‘that entered your home” (R 138, 179). Captain Chambers -
“moved down :the row of men (all of whom were wearing
“helmets (R 140) | standing beforé Mathilde and placed

—“ahiy,. after which - Mathilde -would nod: her head. Ti she

failed. to identify. a soldier, he left. the room (R 98, 112, |
“128, 135, 142, 150: 156,173, 187). During this process,

" «Mathilde: ‘hesitated on Pfc Zarillq, Sergeant Mattson and

~ Cooper (R98, 112; 129, 135, 142, 151, 156, 178, 188}, but

' . they were, pé mitted to leave the. room .when she failed

to make’ ‘positive identification; however, though she first.

. indicated negativ rely. as to Wade, she. changed her mind,

eat rs

e fs ¥ 2’ . re . .
ns . -
° era 5
* 2@ ; * \ peti =

Charge: Violation of the-92nd Article of War. |
~ Specification: In’ that Private Thomias Cooper, oe
pany K, 385th Infantry, did, at Krov, Germany, on: or |
about 14 March 1945, forcibly and feloniously ag gaingt he ry

| will, have carnal. knowledge of Mathilde Klein.

_ Each accused pleaded not guilty. ‘after Wade’ g plea in
-bar, hereinafter discussed, was overruled) ant,/ three-
fourths of the members of the Court present. | at: the’
. time the vote was taken concurring, Wade /was found -
' guilty of “the .Charge and Specification * preferred
against him. .Cooper was acquitted. Evidenge of two_pre-
vious convictions was introduced against /Wade, one by
special court-martial for “failure to repair at the. fixed
time to the properly appointed place of -adsembly and will-
ful. disobedience’ of and disrespect tows rd- a noncommis~
sioned officer in violation of Articles 0° War 61.and 65 re-
“spectively, and one by summary court for absence without

*

1944)' 141-F ( 2nd 664:,cf, EX parte Quirin, 1942) 317 4
oe Y8/1, 87 L2 Ed..3). Thus in Sanford -y, Gest ess, ‘supra: _
pS Tae BA, the . irt ‘said: + at el |

>
iad

3 | “We have nd, “ao tha the provision. ‘of the a
‘Ritth. Amenamett,' ‘nar ‘shall any’ person be subject for ~
“the same. offense’ to be twixe ‘put in-jeopardy of ‘life or.’

ib’, is applicable | to courts- martial. The immediately’ a

chy? preceding exception of. ‘cages. arjsing in the land or naval.
Bs forces’ ffom. the requirement of an indictment, abundantly . —
Rah i> shows that such cases were in contemplation but: not Cx: a
f ceptedy from the other provistons.- ep tyr t ats emer

~ Vise . .
rae
: Be : ee : "
. ok * as ey e

-\. lero‘ v..Hudspeth, (C.C.A.10th 1940)

6 ° -
. : .
. . a 3 . .
: m *. s2_s ’
¢-, ae
o

es. Wave v. "HUNTER, WARDEN, =e yy.

Y
Although this provision of the Fifth ‘Apieitmest efeda

\. limitation on -the- power of courts-martial, it is only a ay
‘conditional limitation int Aw the accused may waive what —
h

f for him is a personal rig The purden regts upon, him

- to plead and ‘prove. his: former jeopegdy, and in the’event _

of a failure of pléa ay’ prooft-waiv follows, ( Arti¢le-of
War 40; .Dig. Op. JAG, 1912-40, sec. 397(4), p.24g; Levin

‘vy, Unitéd States, (C.C.A.9th 1928), 5 F (2nd) 598. “Brgdy

v. United States (C.C.A.8th 1928) ; 24 F’ ( 2nd)-.399 -'Cabal-
, sdk PA3 92nd) 545;
7 McGinley: v. Hudspeth, (C.C.A.10 , 16 940);, 120.F, (92nd)
523). Here, showever, Wade ‘pleaded specially at His first -
: opportunity, and offered eompetent evidence in support.
. theréof, and no waiver of his. rights under the’ Fifth
~ Amendment or Article of War 40 may “be. presumed.

In .determining when an accused hag’ been ‘placed: in

ts jeopardy Courts have reached varying answers, but the

- opinions of the Federal Courts, which are “specially or- .
- dained to construe the Cénstitution, are binding as to the.

meaning 01 the language in. the Fifth Amendment. It is,
of course, recdgnized that the prohibition is hoe against’.
. the yperil of second punishment, but against being twice’

. put ‘in. jeopaty (Kepner v.. United States- (1904), 19)
- ' ILS: 100, 49 L. Ed. 114); nor‘is jeopardy limited to’a
second prosecution aftere verdict by, a fact- finding body.
‘ Some expressions may be found in ‘the early. text eas
“tef. Winthrop’s. Military Law and Precedents (Reprint,
1920), ‘p.260)- and cases: which purport to limit jeopardy

6 a second prosecution after verdict or findings put they

. have never been sanctioned by. the Supreme. Court. Ins
_ Kepner#w. United States. supra, the Court held. that jeop:
ardy should not-be construed so narrowly and said (195.

US. bt p. 128, 49 L.Ed. at p. 194) 2". -

ie Hs some of. the scfiitions given: by the
| textbook writers,” and found in the reports, Timit, 3 jegpardy
“to d*gecond “prosecution after verdict by a-jury; *_* * the
weight of authority, as well: as desisions of this Court,
have sanctioned the rule that a person has been in jeop-
verdy when he is regularly charged with a crime before a
* tribunal - ores. or and competent’ “to pik uz

* © en

©

*e

at

2!
1. ©
Wx

Ps ‘6 ea mie
Re ae ‘ . ‘
7 Sf, o- _ hiss : f
‘
a

| | wee oo, ail
- &- " hs . ae eee . £ ~
* a, Mi Aged _ Wade v. HowteR, WARDEN

As determified by. the Federal Courts, jeopardy attaches
’ when an accyised: has been arraigned on a-valid charge,

- has pleaded thereto, and a jury has been impaneled and -

rig and where a .éase is tried to a Court withoutsa ae

ury; jeopardy begins. when he has been validly charged
raigned, has pleaded and the Court has begun to

| oeanoe v. Zerbst (C. C.A.10th 1936, 85
. F (2nd). 640). And_where jeop: ry attaches,. for how-

ever short a.time, the trial must proceed and be, prose-. °.
cuted to a legal. termination, or the accused will be dis- —

eharged arid cannot thereafter be: tried again. ‘under ‘t
same or a subsequent charge for the same offense - (Cor-
- nero v. United States (C.C.A.9th 1931), 48 F (2md)69:

-Unitéd States v. Kraut (SD,NY, 1932), 2 F Supp. 16; . 2

- Wharton's — Law. cae = 1982), sec. — p.
547).. 3

: \ e ?
The power ‘of the Cort to terminate the trial because

’ of imperious necessity, without affording: an’ accused the’

right: to plead former. jeopardy in a subséquent prosecu-

tiom for the same offense, has, however, ‘been recognized:

%, But this doctriné of. imperious. necessity is based on a

.
*

e

¢

sudden and ‘uncontfllable emergency, ounforeseen by

.
|
.

eithér the prosecution or the Court,—a, real emengency. -.

which by‘diligente and care could not have been, averted. :

It has beenbeld applicable to those cages where the jury

is unable to agree -( Dreyer’v. Illinais (1902-), 187 U.S. 71,.
‘47 L. Ed. 79;\ Keerl‘v. Montana (1909), 213 U.S. 135, 53

_ L. Ed. 734; Sey ied States v. Perez (1824), 9 Wheaton 579,
6 L. Ed..165; Logan v. United States (1892), 144 U.S. 263,

v. United States (C.C.A.8th 1931), 49 F (2nd) .177);
where. inflammatory press .releases- may have corrupted

_ the jury’( United States v. Montgomery, (S.D.N. -Y¥.1930)

-42 F (2nd) 254); when. the relationship of a juror fo an

- ‘accused is discovered during trial (United States v. Mc-:

~Cunn -(8.D.N.Y.1929), 36 F (2nd) 52); where a juror

_ becomes ‘iffeapacitated during trial (Simmons v. United . -

States (1891), 142 U.S.148, 35 L. Ed. "968) ; and wherea
| juror is discofered. to haze been a ember’ of the grand
jury wkich returned the indictment (Thompson, v. United

% States’ (1894 hey _ U.S.271, 39 L. Ed. break It is an il-

- ‘e
> \ ‘
Vy

os
.86 L. Ed. 429); ‘to, misconduct tainting the panel. (Klose —

Pa

. 8.

Wane’ v. HUNTER, WARDEN ees a

lusive and expansive Aockeise: not: suscéptitle: -of: precise | ;
definition, because it. is ‘designed to, apply to emergent :
situations, and the restraints which are reasonable today.
-may be arbitrary tomorrow (United States v; Giles (W.D.. -..
' Okla. 1937), 19 F.. Supp. 1009; Pratt v. United Stateg,
( App. D.C.1939), 102°F. (2nd) 275). -All Courts, however,
have recagnized that the power should be exercised with -

caution, and that it shouid be limited te-the most urgent —
circumstances. The rule was.expressed aptly by Story: J.,
‘in United States v. Perez, supra, when he said: (9 Whea-
ton at.p. 580, 6 L. ‘Ed. at p.. 165).

fx eee the: powereought. 0: ‘be used with the

” greatest caution, under | urgent circumstances, and for
very plain and obvious causes}.and in capital casés espe-

_ cially, Caurts should be extremely careful how they inter-
fere with any ‘of the chances ~ life in ese of the pris- *

tis compliance with tide adenonition of ‘the highest court,

ea the power has been charily exercised.
2
The rule. in the ‘Federal Courts, and’ in most Staite

- Courts, is that the. absence of witnesses, or. the unavail-

ability of evidence is not ground for the termination of -- \\ »

the trial by a discharge of the jury under the doctrine\
‘ of imperious necessity, so. as to sanction a second prose- °
cution for the same offénse (Cornero v. United States © —
(C:C.A. 9th 1931),.48 F (2nd) 69; United States v. Wat-..
son, 1868), Fed. Cas. No. 16, 651; Annotation 74 AER.
803; cf..Wharton’s Criminal Law, (12th.Ed.,.1932), sec.
395, p.548 et sec). The same rule is, of course, ‘applicable
to termination by a nolle prosequi.or by a Withdrawal of ."_
charges’, “(United States. v. Kraut (S.D.N.Y.,1932), @F. * .
Supp. 16; pcechcsiesl v. Rives, ies D.C. 1939), 104 F (2nd )
246).- *.. : sce

The question was squarely Wewa in, Sowitado. ve.
United States supra, where a plea of former jeopardy was:
sustained when a jury was impaneled but was discharged >
‘when the prosecuting attorney. announced he was unable, —
to proceed be®ause of the absence of necessary witnesses.

In Wes that jeopardy attached, and that the doctrine of

74 a ; ar WabE ¥. Hunter, WARDEN
> as: é .

7 imperious, neconsity did not extend @ the absence. of wit-

.. Messes,’ _— Court said: (48 F (2nd), at p. 71 and p. 73).

| he hile their absen’ce might have justified a.
enki of the case * *.* the question presented. here -
_ is entirely different from that’ involved in the exercise of
the sound discretion of thagjrial Court in granting a con-
tinuance i in furtherance of jMstice.* The situation presented
is: ‘simply one where ‘the district attorney entered upon .
the: trial of the ease without sufficient evidénee to convict.
This des not take the vase, gut of the rule with reference
to former jeopardy. *-* -* There-is. nothing in the cases
‘cited by the government that militates against the author-
ity of the dases we have cited, which are tothe effect that
mere -abs ce of. witnesses discovered after the jury, is
impaheled |is insufficient to deprive the accused ‘of his
right to cl im former ene upon a Beta trial’ °

a i

_ ‘The court: further said‘ (48 F (2nd } at p. 71):

o We. are here dealing ** * with 4 fundamen ne

right of a person accused of crime, guaranteed. to him

‘the Constitution, and such right Gpnnot be frittered away.

or abridged by general rules concerning the importance
of advancing public.justice. * * *‘no Couxt has gone to

_° the’ extent of holding that, after the impanelment of a

jury éor the trial of a criminal cas® the failure of the
‘district attorney to have preseht sufficient. witnesses, or
evidence to prove_the: offerse charged, is an exception to
the rule that.the discharge of a jury after its impanelment
for the trial of a criminal case ‘operates as a protection
against a retrial ‘Of the same case.”

‘In the instant case Wade was arraigned on a valid
charge and specification before a general court-martial
duly appointed {by~the Commanding General of the 76th
Infantry. Division.. Both the prosecution and the defense
introduced evidence and rested, and the Court. stated it -
' did not desire to have any witnesses called or “recalled
and closed: Applying the rule announced by the Federal
courts in many cases, we have no ‘difficulty in concluding
_ that Wade was placed in jeopardy at that time.. The Court
might has returnéd a finding of guilty or not guilty ith-.

y

. . . ° °
‘

_ WADE ¥. “HUNTER, WARDEN—"" > 75
fs ad ateanatit .

‘stated in Ex.-parte ‘Ulrich (W.D.Mo. 1890) 42 F. 587, 595,
where. a.somewhat similar /factual Situation’ was pres
sented; “The law, will give him the benefit of the pre-

c sumption ae the. sit Jury “ have epics teene
him. * * %o, ’ } = ~%

>

out. further: action. by the ae or defense. As.

We have. Ae that emergent situations, unknown’ .
to the. civil courts;:may arise’in the administration of
military justice which will call for the exercise of, the
doctrine of imperious necessity. The judicial process will’
be equal to such demands. That the absence of ‘witriesses |
* does not.sanction ‘the exercise of,the, doctrine is, howeves.
no longer open to question. The eder al courts have Spor.
ken, and,“ * *-* no Court has gone to # * * [that] *
extent. ” The rule is appli€able to all courts, whether trial
_be with’ or without a ‘jury (Kepner v. United States,” -
supra), and since Grafton v. United States (1907), 206 °

U,S.- 333} 51 L.Ed 1084, if not before, there has been no
doubt that a-_ general court-martial, within its special
framework, is“a court in the fullest Sense of the word,,.

We see nothing which renders the absence of witnésses,_
as shown by the record of trial in this. case, an emergent
situation in exception to the rule in the Federal courts.’
Their witnesses may lie beyond the reach: of process, if
© process issues witnesses may not respond, oral, prom-
_ises to appear: may not be kept, and they may become ill
during trial; but such difficulties in’ proof are not grounds
for a termination of trial and a second prosecution. _Im-
perious necessity means a suddén and overwhelming
emergency, uncontrollable and unforseeable, infecting the
judicial process and rendering a fair and impartial trial
impossible. ‘It does not mean expediency. The absence of
-witnesses, as the Federal courts have unifofmly held, is
not. an emergent condition-infecting the judicial process;
‘it is only one of the hazards of trial known to all coyrts.

As affirmatively disclosed by the record, the continu-
ance of the case was prompted by the court's desire to
hear furthet testimony, and the -withdrawal of the ~
charges and the refefepce of them to another court was

j o¢cagjoned by the absence. of the witnegses from the juris-¢ -
. Bi ; \ : .

oO

ee ---s WADE v. HUNTER; WARDEN |
.~ 2
’ diction of’ the appointing authority. This did not constic -e
'. tute the emergent ‘situation infectjmg the judicial precess
required for the termination of the. case so as to except -
othe’ proceedings from the prohibition . against double
_ jeopardy. in the Fifth Amendment. Wade’s plea in ‘bar in |
_ the instant cage, being-seasonably raised and suppdrted
_ by competent evidence, should, then, have been: sustained,
_“Amprican justice,” as Vinson,-J., said in, oe v. United ;
States. (App. D.C. 1939) 162 F.. (2nd) 278, “will not
- countenance an accused standing trial twice Sot the same
’ offense * ; saeco Be ; .

4?

e ‘

peat al remains for consideration the Janguage
Article of War 40 which provides that: :

: no proceeding in which an accused has . :

been found guilty by a court-martial upon any ‘charge of.
Specification shall be held to be a trial in the sense of.
this article until the reviewing. and, if there be one, the:
confirming authority shall have taken final ‘action upon the . .
case.’ 2 ; Rik t an

“22S

é

It- was. uel =, ‘ha Trial Judge inieciia: at the trial

| (R.9,-10) that -this language precludes a plea in bar.on. / ©

the ground of former jeopardy until action has been.taken -
- by the reviewing authgrity. and, if there be one, the con-
firming authority; but we d6 not agrée. The language, by —
~~, its own terms, is plainly-timited-to those cases © in which

‘ findings of guilty have been rgacHed by ‘the Court, and
does not ‘purport to apply to situations: where. trial is
' termirated prior thereto. ‘It is plain and unambiguous, .
and does noc permit the interpretation suggested. Con-
, gress obviously ‘desired .to provide for a rehearing upon
‘disapproval by the reviewing or confirming authority of
findings of guilty ( Article. of War 50), and the care it took
to limit fhe sentence upon a rehearing and to prohibit

_rehedrings upon findings of not guilty is evidence of the —

concern it entertained that the rights of an accused under .
the Fifth Amendment should ‘not be frustrated. It pro-
vided for the automatic.review-of the. findings an@ sen-
tence, and. the consent of the accused to such review being
true in fact-and presumed.as a matter of law’ {Sanford v.

- Robbins, supra), a plea of former, jeopardy may not: .

Wane v. HUNTER, Wands es um

9 |
necessarily’ bé interposed at the second trial (Sanford y. oe
‘Robbins, supra). This is explainable by “analogy to a. _
_ mistrial for failure of a jury to“’gree, since the rohee! ring .
; authority whbse concurrence is necessary does not agree,
’ defeating the first hearing” (Sanford 'v. Robbins, supra,
115 F. (2nd) at p 439..; or by an analogy t@the vacation —
Pof'a verdict at the instance of an accused whd nana
* waives*his protection against double jeopardy (Pratt v.
_ United States, (App. D.C. 1939), 102 F. (2nd) 27%,
oF _ inasmuch as the consent of an adcused to review by Pa
‘reviewing: or. confirming authorit t,

is presumed as a ma
: ter of law.

o

If; ‘ce: Articia: of War/A0 were senblzuour and.
subject. to constructiom dpubts\,and ambiguities would:
yield to the persuasions ofthe Fifth Amendment, as an
interpretation consistent ith the constitution is .pre- —
ferred to one offensive thereto (MeCullough v. Commott-
wealth of Virginia. (1898) 172: U.S. 102, 43 L.Ed. 382),

', and as a construction leading to absurd ‘consequences is.
avoided: whenever a reasonable one is possible (United -
States v. Katz (1926), 271 U.S. 354, 70 L. Ed. 986}.

Nor ‘can thé provisions | of the Manual for Courts- Mar-
tial 1928,. which provide that a. nolle prosequi may be
—— either before or after arraignment and plea and

___-thgsit-is not. aground of objeetion-or of defense in a sub-

‘ sequ@nt trial (MCM, 1929, par. 72, p. 57), and that the -

! appointing authority may withdraw any specification or
charge at any time unless the Courthas reached a find-
ing thereon (MCM, 1928, par. 5>-p. 4), be construed to
sanction the proceedings inthis case. ‘They too. must be .
construed in sympathy with the Fifth Améndment and

. Article of War 40, which are not limitations on the power ©

of the appointing” authority to direct. the entry of-a nolle
proequi orto withdraw ‘charges, but are. Jimitations on the
power to again try an accused ¢ ier jeopardy has at-.

tached. The appointing authority has ‘the -undoubted
‘power to. ‘direct: the entry of~a nolie’ proséqui .before or. |
after arraignment and plea, or to withdraw ‘charges at ~-

any time prior to the- findings,, but when jeopardy has

- attached, and imperious necessity does not.exist a nolle
prosequiror to withdraw charges, but are limitations onthe . .

»

°

i™

by

-

ee. iaweer : " WADE Vv, ‘HUNTER, WARDEN. ©. oN]

(cae

» 4 © Poa se : ~
. rae i ae
; =. 9 . :

/atitutionality rather than to construe it £6 that. it Sr

_ ran afoul of constitutional prohibitions. The:pewer vested. =

in the’ ap ointing authority to withdraw charges is a valu-

' abie i necessary | adminis ative device and it may be

S \.. preser ved to him if its exercise is based upon the doctrine

\of “imperious necessity” ag such. doctrine is adjusted to ;
- -Theet the needs peculiar to the functioning af a’ courts.

martial, /- \

-A Pranks visemes ‘of. the. leva principle that jeop-,

-ardy ae Seger before: findings by a courts-martial seems Ee
under the approved construction of the “dou- ,

imperativ

"ble jeopardy” clause of the Fifth Amendment. On this A

-majer premise I believe that the doctrine of: “imperious

_ necessity’* may for the reasons herein set forth, be ex-

- panded to include tactical situations which in the opinion.’

of the appointing authority ‘makes impractical the pro-

duction of necessary witnesses.. With™that determination _

he may then exercise ‘the power of ‘withdrawal of t
charges in. accordance with the provisions of the Manu
_ Under such process of reasoning the Manual’ provision

7 — is valid. Stated otherwise: The-appointing athority. may .,

withdraw any specification or charge at his direction at.
any time. hefore jeopardy attaches (CM ETO 9986, Gold-
berg), and he ‘may withdraw any specification or charge
after atrial attaches when “imperious necessity” dic-—

-tatés and “imperious necessity’ in the functioning of

military courts ‘includes military necessity and tactical
considerations. ¢ ,

8 I therefore conelude’ that the Commanding General

of the 76th Infantry. Division was authorized. to withdraw.

the charge in the instant case from the court sitting at

Z. Pfalzfeld. Germany on 27.March 1945 and transmit the
- Santé to another jutisdiction for trial and that his action
did not afford the accused the nent. to plead stains Jeop- a

ardy &t the trial now under review.

9. I concur with the Board of Review in: its eedacs
that accused in the present trial was proved guilty of the
crime charged. No errors ‘prejudicial to the substantial ‘
_rights of accused’ were contmitted at the trial, and the

Qurt ; mad — of the person and the offense. ‘In

port the findings of guilty and the sefitenté. -

os!
10. I transmit herewith forms of action in the alterna-

i tive; one for use -ingsthe- event you are in accord with con- ©
‘. clusion of the Board of Review that the record of trial is

re Fs es “WADE. Vv. “Hunter, WaRvEN, tt ", &

wa oiinbein the record of. “trial is legally sufficient” to. OR

legal insufficient to support the findings and the sentence

‘- and one for use in the event you agree with the conclusion
‘’set forth in this, my dissent, that the record of trial is

legaly sufficient to support | the findings of guilty and the —

mulgating - your conclusions are also transmitted here-
with, : ar Ne ‘ ee

11. “When copies of the Pe Re Be order are forwarded
to this office, they should be accompanied by thexecord of
trial, the foregoing ‘holding and this. indorsement, , The

- sentence. Alternative drafts'of appropriate orders pro--

filé number of -the record in this office is CM ETO 15320. =]

brackets at the end of the order: (CM = Soman

_E.C. McNEIL, .
Brigadier General. United States hia
' Assistant J udge Advocate General.

3 Incls: ay Record of Trial. Incl. 2: Alternative

drafts of action: Incl. 3: Alternative drafts of court mar-
tial orders. “ 4

a ym ah

Transcript of. F Proceedings on Hearing of Respondent's

Motion for Reconsideration, July 10, 1947.

ef wigs bs

* 109 — Hon. ARTHUR J. MELLOTT, Judge, presiding.

,

Appearances: N. E. Snyder. and Richard T. Brewster,

' appeared for Petitioner.“ James W. Wallace, Assistant

'-. For convenience of reference, please place that number in.

Ya

U. S.. Pe cea a appeared for ie ae | °. 5

1:

Be it. remembered, en this 10th hee of. July, A. D. 1947;
the above matter nee on for hearing before. the Hon-'

eo f Wie %. HUNTER, a Me

“orable Arthur J. ‘Mellott, Judge. of. the Diatyict’ ‘Court ot
the United ‘States for the District ‘of Kansas, and the
parties appearing in person and/or by counsel, as herein-
above set forth,: the following proceedings were. had:

Mr. Snyder: Petitioner is ready, if the Court please.

Mr.. Wallace: The. respondent® is ready.

The Court: State ed appe arances for’ ‘the: record, a .
please, gentlemen: wits:

_., Mr. Snyder: R. T. iaiialtnn. and N. E. Snyder appear-
ing for. the petitioner; Frederick .W. Wade.

| iy ase
Mr. Wallace: James Ww. Wallace veers for the | re-
spondent. er ee
The Court: Pais may proceed. ee Spor ee

“Mr. Wallace: If the Court please—

Mr. Snyder (Interrupting ): Mr. Wallace, if I might in-
terrupt youa minute. :

hd

If it please the Court, we . wish at this time to sie

our Objéétion to the-hearing or consideration of this motion:

which has been filed on behalf of the respondent, request-

ing that Your Honor reconsider your decision entered in

‘this cause on May 9, 1947. if I may, I should like briefly
to be heard on that in-advance of any argument on

110 whatever. merits there may be: to = motion. for |
reconsideration. |

es The Court: We will hear you.

ee

=a BG |
Mr. hayden: “As we interpret the Federal Rules of Civil
- Procedure all post- -decision motions are governed by those
rules. The rules specifically state, Rule 81, that they shall .
apply where there is no procedure outlined by other-=
otherwise outlined by statute so far as habeas corpus pro-
ceedings are concerned. That language is as follows: “In
the following proceedings appeals are governed by these
rulés, but they are not applicaBle otherwi ise than on appeal
-” excepteto the extent that the a in such proces ‘dings

bed ; % . ™ . & :

os ‘Wapbe v. H@NTER, WARDEN 89

o

_>.» -_ - all —

G

eee wie v. HUNTER, WARDEN
o

the Coust: upon such terms*as are just, may relieve a
party or his legal representative from a judgment, order,
or proceeding taken against. him through his mistake,
inadvertence, surprise, or excusable neglect.” No one of
those three factors appears in, this case; neither mistake,
inadvertence, surprise or excusable: neglect, those four
factors—correction. They- do not base their motion on
“that ground. pe

There hag been a very recent decision of the United

States Supreme Court construing an analogous provision

in the new Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure: That is .
the case of the United States of America v. Honorable

William F. Smith, a DistricygJudge of the United States.

The case was decided June 2, 1947, and is reported in 91.
Law. Ed. Advance Opinions at page 1203. I will ‘close |

With a brief summary of that case, Your Honof, and point
out the principles which we think are there expounded
and control action in this case. There, the defendant had
been trie® and convicted. He filed a timely motion for a

- new trial and assigned some fifty-four reasons why it .

should be granted. An appeal—the motion was denied.

An appeal was taken and the Circuit Court of Appeals.

for the Third Circuit affirmed. The man was incarcerated
and on the day following that the: judge undertook to
enter an order granting a new trial on the basis that he
. “had reconsideréd the grounds urged by~the defedant in

- support of the motion for -a new trial. In other words, -

‘ the element*there is the same as in this case, a reconsid-
eration. The prisoner was released from the penitentiary
on bail, and the question for decision in this case,

112 Your Honor, was whether-or not the Court had the
power to act after—onhis own initiative after the
expiration of the period provided by the Federal Rules

of Civil Procedure. Rule 30—if I said Civil Procedure that

was a—wiil you correct it? (Speaking to reporter. )

Rule 33 provides—of your Federal Rules of Criminal
Procedure that if the trial was by the Court without a
jury the Court may vacate the°judgment it rendered, take
_additional oe and direct the entry. of a new judg-
‘ment; quite similar to Rule 59 of the Federal Rules of

— Civil Procedure, but the provision is in this rule that a

ad

a = a “wa ad ‘

€

; bd P - , | “ ns s
‘Wave v.. HUNTER, WARDEX 91

motion for a: new trial based on any other ground should
be made within five days after the verdict or finding of —
‘guilty; that is, any other prone than newly discovered |
evidence. .

ee Court discusses that id ends up by holding that.
the Trial Court was without.power to enter that order; ©
_ that the ten-day period limited the right or the request
for relief if not made within that time; the Court was
_ without power to grant it on the Court’s own initiative.

. In the Opinion by Mr, Justice. Jackson it. was said:
“We think that expiration of the time within which
relief can openly be asked of the judge, terminates the
time within which it can. properly be granted on the Court's
own initiative.” They point out in the’course of this opin- -
ion that the Rules of Civil Procedure provide that there
is a timely limit given on which the Court may act on
-his own motion, so for those reasons and on the analogy
of that case, Your Honor, we say that the Court is with-
‘out power to entertain this motion they have. now filed
_ for a reconsideration of Your Honor’s decision: They have
not set up any of the grounds which would entitle them
_ io come under the provisions of Rule 60, and they did
not appear within ten days after the entry of the judg-
ment, and they do not say they have any newly discov- _
ered evidence. They simply ask Your Honor to reconsider.
it. and change your mind. We i now you_are without =
- jurisdiction to-do Sats

113 Mr. ‘Wallace: If . the Court please, I am aw are
: of Rule 59 which requires that in the Rules of Civil -
Procedure that a motion for a new trial or for other relief
_ should ‘be filed within ten days and urged to the Court, .
but it is further the contention that Rule 59 ghould be ©
‘ considered along and in the light of Rule 81 which was
‘just read to the Court, 1 believe, by Mr. Snyder which |
is: “In the following proceedings appeals are governed
by these rules, but they are not applicable otherwise than”
on appeal except to the extent that the practice in such
.proeeedings is not set forth in statutes of the United# -

ad

*
4
a
ne
. » . 5
:
° ‘* °

. See WabE v. HUNTER, WARDEN |
4 : bar : a second ar or aT POR in ‘the event tie ac used pleads |
“tae -and proves his former jeopardy at the soniye trial.

sd

ae ‘Neither the provisions of the Manual nor Article of
° War 40 could confer power inconsistent. with the: Cohsti-
tution. Executive ®rders and. congressional acts have

_ validity only to the — that they are obedient to the ”
" ment to the Federal Constitution may ‘attach prior to

findings by the Court and approval of the sentence by the ~

reviewing authority. I further agree with the Board
of Review that the 40th Article of War must be read in
- the light @f the Fifth Amendment and the adjudications
_ of the Federal’ Courts with respect to the ‘double .jeop-

dardy” “clause thereof. I also believe that the doctrine of —

“imperious | necessity” as defined and dis@ussed in. the
‘opinion of the Board of Review is applicable to courts-

martial. My. difference with the Board of Review revolves .

about the. question.as to the operative effect of the doc- i

trine in trials before courts-martial and in the administra-
-. tion of military justice.. Stated cogently the solution of

the problem largely turns, upon the applicability of the ‘
principles discussed-in the opinion of the Circuit Court ,

- of Appeals (9th Cir.} in the case of Cornerg V. United
States (C.C.A. 9th, 1931) 48 F. (2nd) 69 (cited and dis-
cussed by the Board of Réview) to the facts in this case.

3. I freely grant that in criminal prosecutions in the
civil courts ‘the rule of the Cornero casé is not ‘only fair

and proper but is. also. dictated by sound constitutional -

principles.

The fact ‘that the prosecutor, having entered. upon’ the —

-trial’of an indictment and having thereby placed an
accused in jeopardy, discovers he cannot sustain the same

‘ - 7 g: 2 : . oe
ee, 80 : = WADE v.. HUNTER, WARDEN .. a sons =
without’ additional evidence, presents no legitimate reason :--
for invoking thé doctrine of “imperious necessity” so that -°
the accused may. apa n be tried on the same charge, The i
* - denial of the. applica lon’ of the doctrine under ‘su i cir- -
cumstances is highly necessary if’the constitutiona} pro-
vision against double jeopardy is not to be frittered away
by legalistic sophistries. ‘There are substantial reasons
for. refusing to consider the absence of witnesses as an ~
“imperious necessity” | in the trials of criminal causes in
. the civil courts. The place of the tr ial and the terms of
court. aré fixed and. determified by statute, The Court in
advance of the ‘commencement of the term area to

prosecution™ erefore knows” in_adyancé sdcrielimately
when it zhust. be-prepared-to’ go to. trial and have its wit-
nesses available” to tify in .Court. fait has pro-

- vided by law the . _proe ss. whereby /witnesses -may be.
subpoened or may be held in Custody pending their appear--.
ance at trial. If under these circumstances the prosecution
ventures trial, participates, i in-the selection of the jury and
thereafter presents its available évidence, it does se with
_ the full knowledge of thé risk it incurs by placing. accused go
‘in jeopardy. It is not, however, without remedy to carey
for the situation caused by, unforeseen abserices of wjt*
_nesses, A. motion: for. continuance, validly ‘based, affards.

‘—~ it reasonable’ means to prevent a miscarriage of juStice. .
. Under these circumstances the. prosecution having failed”
to “make a case’ ’ should not be permitted to dismiss the’
ictment and try again for a-conviction undér circum- -
stances - which may be more favorable fo? =) success, Such
methods are not consonant with our jurid al philosophy’
and offend our sense of -fair dpajing and, air trials.

| 4, However, the static ncaa of? the oivit ‘tourts do
. not prevail with respect to the military courts. and particu~
larly the military equrts which must. Functiofy im the field
‘of operations and combat. Courts-marfial are not perma-
nent institutions in the sense of permanency of the civil
‘courts. They are called into being at ‘the: will of ‘the
authority holding courts-martial jurisdiétion. Fheir‘mem- -__
bership is subject to tontinuous: menge depending upon *

a cat
P vy » . — i

O.+4

‘of certainty and acc

oat WADE v. HUNTER, WARDEN” iia

other duties of the per sonnel who are eligible: to be ap-
pointed members of same, They conduct théir. business
at such times and places. as gerieral. conditions in the field

' permit or require. They have no fixed and predetermined
- places of sitting. There are np terms of courts-martial
_ (Cf: CM ETO-16623, Colby), and due .to the exigencies

of the situation under which they operate they cannot

arrange trial calendays in advance “with the same degree
im

_ to perform their. duties efficiently and expeditiously, they

.
~ “a

a high degree of flexibility.. They ‘conduct

itary and_civil:coyrts there is an aspect of the ‘actual

a 5,’ Apres from the ihherent differences between our .

nctioning of the former which must be ‘given proper —
/ weight and. consideration. Witnesses may be compelled,
'- under penalty of law, to attegd and give testimony in the —
civil courts of the’ United States. The witnesses come to.

the court; the court does not go to the witnesses. In this
respect there is a certainty and security ufion which the
prosecutien and defense alike may rely. With respect to
the courts-martial sitti me in the United States the same
condition prevails (A 23).. In the functioning of our

military courts in. the field, however, and particularly in |

foreign countries entirely different eonditions exist.. In
England by virtue of the Untied States of America: ( Vis-

iting Forces) Order, 1942 (SR and-O, 1942 No. 966) and .
orders ofthe (British) Army Council and Air Coundil

_ (SR and O,-1942 No. 1679), compulsory attendance ant

testimony of British civilian witnesses are provided. In

France, the attendance of civil witnesses largely depends.
upon the cooperation of the French police or the volun- —

tary action of the inhabitants.’ In Germany, the compul-

sory attendance of civilian witnesses is. theoretically —

possible because of tle overriding power of.thé conqueror.

- In the case of the latter country, however, practical con-

siderations will weigh heavily against theoretical possi-

bilities. At. the time of. the first or _ incomplete’. trial, in

_ the instant case it is a matter of notorious ‘knowledge that

acy-as do the’ civil courts.-In order ©

under unusual conditions primarily dictated. - | |
ilitary situation and the coridition of the com- —

; eee. _AW ADE Vv. ‘HUNTER, WARDEN

ae

the ordinary means: of one in Germany were. > disrupted
~ and in some areas entirely destroyed. While it is entirely °
possible in spite of combat gonditions then. prevailing at
the time of the first trial on 27 March 1945 at.Pfalzfeld,

Germany, the necessary | additional witnesses might have
been produced by the prosecution at an adjourned session
_of the trial, that fact remains a mattér of speculation.
Mere is nothing in the record of trial upon which to base -

~*- a reasonable assurance that effective means were available

‘to the prosecution, whereby these witnesses could be pro-
duced. The court at the first’ trial after. deliberating in
closed session opened court and. expressed the desire:

. “that further witnesses be called’ into the cage, .
~ and to allow time to secure these witnesses, this case will

be continued. We would like to. have as witnesses brought
before the court, the parents of this person making the,
accusation, Rosa Glowsky, and also‘the sister-in-law that _

- §vas in the room-who could further assist in the identifita-

_ tion or identity,of the accused. The court will be, con- aah
tinued until a later. date set by the TJA” (RB he of De- o
. fendant Wade’s Exhibit me a F :*

Seven ddys later and. prior to ee ee action by the | :

- court the appointing authority, Commanding.General, 76th _
Infantry Division, withdrew ‘the charges from the court
‘ whi Sat Sees appointed by him and to ‘which he had
_ previously referred thé charges for trial ( ; Pros. Ex
A), and directed that, no further jpetion i the case be
taken by the court.. The Board of Review narrates the
subsequent proceedings

[Text truncated at 120,000 characters. The full text is on the page linked above.]

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386406_0132%3A1. Public record. Not legal advice.
