# Petition for Writ of Certiorari Supporting Brief — Transcontinental & Western Air, Inc. v. Civil Aeronautics Board

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386406_0127%3A2

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Petition for Writ of Certiorari Supporting Brief
- **Published:** January 1, 1949
- **Citation:** 336 U.S. 601

## Text

_ LIBRARY-
SUPREME Court, U.S.

IN THE

Supreme Court of the United States

Ocrose r-Term 1948

| #
No.

2

TRANSCONTINENTAL & & Ww ESTERN. AIR, INC.,
te ; sek hel Sn Petitioner,
i eee _ 3 against

CIVIL AERON AUTICS BOARD,
Respondent.

PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO
_.. THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
“. FOR. THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA AND |
. _ SUPPQRTING . BRIEF

. & .

te.

Gerap .B. Broeny,

Attorney for .—
Transcontinental & Western Air, Inc.,
“ee Sigh "Petitioner, .. | .
| es eer ; oe 25 Broadway,

ites Ot Rie -” New York 4, N. Y.

Cuapsourne, W ALLACE, p ARKE & W HITESIDE,
25 Broadway,
- New York 4, N. Y.
of Counsél.

. °
. . . t é
cnn seen eigen cane aS

INDEX
: Le x Baae a? ¢ | PAGE
PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI .............% 1
STATEMENT OF THE MATTER INVOLVED ..... Tame Ach vtaaes >
od. The Petition for a New Rate ....:.....60:8.. sian 2
2. The Procedure Below .............-045- SPE ere re 4
JURISDICTIONAL STATEMENT «22... 520i bs cece ce es sore eR
THE QUESTIONS PRESENTED” ........ ERA Ee Ree Aa keke oe
Reasons For THE:-ALLOWANCE OF THE WRIT .......-.- ian 6
BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF PETITION FOR CERTIORARI +9
eNO OE OE NE UO os ss gov sce nscscceesccctcss -9
Jurisdiction oc. ce ccc ese eee. Saeaaeeant OT ame
meabewient Of the. Case i iin. ce cc eecsccens EE KKER RGSS
Specification of Errors ...... Seth Vue hate sks Rpaexck,
tions may have existed under earlier Mail Pay Statutes .. 34
A. The Railway Mail Pay Act of 1916-..... cick chnapene. ae
B. The Air Mail Act of 1934..7..:5.:...... ee Ke eae aa elbd - 38,
C. The Changes Made by the Civil Aeronautics Act — 40
D. The “Legislative History” of Section 406(a)(1) ...... 413

Pe,

" ti . ;
| a | . PAGE
Point V. The decision below thwarts the hasic policies of the

Act and defeats the airlines’ ‘consututional mght to just:

COMPCNSRIIE 5 ik ys ee i j.
if

—

- BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF PETITION FOR CERTIORARI

Opinion of the Court Below _

The opinion of the U nited States Court of Appeals for
the District. of Columbia has not yet been reported. © It
appears in the. certified copy of the Transcript of ‘Record
(111-115). The opinions of the majority and dissenting
members of the Board also appear: in the Transcript (60-
108).

& "Rileee ae y Be ‘o
- aed . * .
ff? . Jurisdiction

Reference ix made to the jurisdictional statement in the
petition (supra, p. 9).

Statement of the Case
’ Reference is made to the ‘statement of the matter in-
volved’ in the petition (supra, p. 1). °
. QO ; . : 76
Specification of Errors

1: The Court of Appeals erred in holding that the Act

-- does not empower the Board to make a new mail rate ef-

fective from a date prior to the initiation of a proceeding

to revise a rate Bits! fixed.

2. The Court. of Appeals sca in failing to hold that
the Act, and particularly $406(a) (1) thereof, delegates to
the Board the power of Congress to revise mail rates retro-
spectiv ely to any past date determined to be proper.

3. The Court of Appeals erred in holding that the
Board’s power under the Act was limited. by ‘‘an almost

conclusive presumption against power. to take retroactive
action,’’ when no such presumption exists.

4. The Court of iets erred. in holding that
$406(a) (1) of the Act should be judicially circumscribed

by false analogies:to other statutes, which differ completely

in language and -purpose, ‘and particularly to statutes regu-
lating the rates of public utilities engaged in two-dimen-
sional transit,

5 The Court of Appeals ena in holding Ahat. on
Boat dis empowered to change mail ratés only prospectively
aud in failing to hold that the practical considerations which
compel public utility rates to be changed only. prospectively

that
Congréss had, through the Act, adopted a policy of gov-
ernmental financial aid to the airlines (p. 100), | concluded :

nS :

* “We consider that direct Government financial
aid to commercial air lines is fully “justified on
erounds of tational security and economie welfare.
We believe the air transport system of this country
can, With sfich aid now, become self-supporting: in the
future. We are convinced that any impartial. in-
vestigators of, air transport would endorse’ the use
of public funds to obtain such a seund air transpor-

ation’ system. This means the continued granting,
je subsidies to air lines for an additional” period’?
(p. 102). oy —- |

a

oe

°

_ Since the date of the: Commission’s report, the airlines’
situation has, if anything, grown worse. . The Aomestie’
trunk lines suffered further operating losses approximating
$15, 500, O00 -in the twelve months endutg June 30, 1948. .
The Civil Aeronautics Board hus found: that TWA arid
United Air Lines, Inc., two-of the nation’ s largest air ear-
riers, are in ‘‘critical financial condition’? (Transcontinen-
tal & Western Air, Inc., Order No. E-1520, May 7, 1948, p-
1). Two months ago the President found it necessary to
ask the Reconstruction Finance Corporation to find suitable -
means by which the air.transport industry.can obtain proper
financing.** °‘Meanwhile, the need for national prepared-

“ness has increased and the airlift program into Berlin has.
graphic: ally demonstrated the value of transport aviation
‘as a military aAEEEATY, 3

* American Atation Daily, Stats Supp, ‘Sept. 40, 1947; —
22, 1948); Oct. 14, 1948.
** American Aviation Daily, es 12, 1948, p. *

6

The decision below places a formidable obstacle in the
_. path of the industry’s recovery, A series of” groundings,
strikes, crashes and other crises, together with generally in-
creased postwar operating costs, have’ proven the current
‘‘service’* mail rates, set in 1944 and 1945 in rather’ op-
_timistie expectations of future operations, to be woefully
inadequate. These rates did not, of course, contemplate
the crises which have occurred. Future measures: alone
may be utterly insufficient to restore the industry's health.
When a: soldier’s strength has been sapped because his
preseribed diet has proved too scanty, the Army medical
officer .does not content himself with i increasing his rations
in the future. If needed to repair the ravages of past mis-
takes,. plasma is administered promptly, and its quantity is
‘determined by the actual necds of the patient, not by the
date on which he reported at sick call. The air transport
: industry occupies a precisely similar situation. Yet the
~ decision below prevents “the Board from remedying inade-
-quacies:of its past rate predictions by confining it to future
palliatives." * The Board is held impotent to take all neces-
sary measures, irréspective ‘of the urgeney of the case and
the paramount.needs of the national interest. That holding
has been reached by a process of strained interpretation
and a complete disr egard of the principle enunciated by this
Court in Chicago & Southern Airlines, Inc. v. Waterman
Steamship Corp., 333 U. S.103, 107- 108/when discussing this
‘Act that ‘‘we see no reason why the efforts of thie Congress
to foster-and regulate development of a revolutionary com-
meree that operates in t@ree dimensions should be judicially
circumscribed with. analogies taken over from two- »-dimen-
sional transit.’’

* Whether the petitioner is Or is not entitled to. relief, on the
merits, is not the question here. ‘The merits have not heen exam-
ined—the Board has been held powerless to examine them.

16

POINT I

The ia died delegates to the Board the power
which is now held non-existent. _ , .

Determining ihe compensation for tarrying the mails
in the future always involves a prophecy. Especially is
that true where air transportation is concerned. “In air
transportation we can see but dimly the shape of thgngs ‘to
come’’ (American Airline Inc.—Mail Rate Proceeding,
3.C. A. B. 323, 339). ‘*The determination of a fair rate
necessarily. includes consideration of the susceptibility of

- the industry to large and unpredictable fluctuations of ‘net

ssaapcap! income’? (Delta Air Corp. —-Mait Rates for Route
Nos: 24.and 54, 3 C. A. B. 261,285). . The Board recently”

; aati on ‘*the inherent weakness in prophecy as to rev-

enues and expenses’ ’ (Pan American Airways, Inc., Order
No. E-771, p. 6, Aug. 25, 1947), and emphasized that fact
when it set TWA’s mail rates in 1945. Transcontinental &

Western Air, Inc., Mail Rates, 6 C. A. B. a wad asc, 600,

601.

Any determination of air mail rates for ‘the future is
therefore peculiarly ‘‘a forecast subject to all the frailties

- of prophecy ”’ (United Air Lines, Inc. v. Civil Aeronautics

Board, 81 App. D. C. 89, 95; 155. F. [2d] 169, 175). “Events

often belie the prophecy. When a rate becomes unfair,

revision of the prophecy in light of the actual facts is de-

sirable and, when the carrier is obliged to carry the majl—

as here—constitutionally mandatory. | =

Congress has repeatedly adjusted mail rates retroac-
tively by specific legislation—both-downwards* and up-

wards.** Changing rates by special legislation is, however,

_a cumbersome and slow process. Adjustmeiit by an admin-

‘istrative agency is flexible and less dilatory. ‘Hence Con-

gress created the Board to take over the burden for it.
Presumably Congress intended to confer sufficiently

br oad-power. to enable the Board to cope with all situations

: that might arise, thus reducing appeals for Congressional

: relief to a minimum... In fact, by the unique language of © |

§406(a)(1) of the Act—itself a unique statute+Congress
clearly delegated: to the Board plenary power to correct

false prophecies by. adjusting ‘mail. rates retroactively,

irrespective of the filing date’ of the rate proceeding.
By §406(a)(1) the Board is “empowered and directed”’
to ‘‘make such rates effective from svch date as it shall

determine to be praper. ° On its face, this language is per- ‘
fectly clear. Indeed, in 1943 the Board remarked on ‘‘the |

plaim language of “es statute relative to the Board’s dis-

°

* See, ¢.g., M issouri, & Texas Ry. Co. vy. U. S., 256 U: S.

610, 614; Eastern Rd. Co. v. U. S., 129 U. S. 391, 395; Jacksonville, .

Pensacola & Mobile Rd. Co. y. U. S., 118 U. S. 626; Wisconsin

Central, Rd. Co. v. UL S.,.164 U. S. 190; Chicago, Milwaukee Gi.

_ Ste Paul Ry. Co. v. U.S , 198 U. S. 385.

** See, for instance, Act of July. 28, 1916, 'c. 261, 39 Stat. es

mentioned in St. Louis Southwestern Ry. Co. v. U. S., 262 .
70, 73, footnote 2. Seealso Act of August 14, 1935, c. 530, 49 Sur

* 617, §8, providing that compensation for carrying ,air mail pinder

certain contracts should be p-id “on and after March 1, 1935 .

at the rate fixed by, order ot the Commission,” applied in. 4ir Mail

st, 222 1. C. C. 602, 606; Air Mail Rate for Route No. 33,
216 1. C. C. 38 401-4023 Atr Mail Rates for Route No. 8, 227
AE a 509, 9105 Air Mail Kate for Route No.2, 231. CC. 229
2: 231. Bere

7

ta?

: sa, he - ; , . a Ss . € » |
-eretvonadry ssi to make rates effective from such date as

it deems proper”? (4 American Airlines, Inc. et al., Mait Rates,

mere Ss B. 90, 93). In 1947, curiously enough, it found that
“ambiguity isicl clearly present”’ (68). .
More, Samprehénsive words. than are found in §406-

(a) (1) w ould be’ hard to imagine. - “The language of section ;

- £064 (a) g vives td the Authority [Board] the right to exercise’

a sound discretion lr determining the proper date on which
a rate shall be made effective” (Pui. Americ ‘an Airways Co.
lof. Nevada|—Mail Rates, 1 C..A. A. 385, 409). No limi-

wk

‘tations on that discretion are ‘imposed, although of course:

the Board must- regard the statutory objectives. In 1942-

Nhe Board stated this force ‘fully in American dirlines, Inc—

Mail we’ Proce¢ ding, 3C. . B. 323, 331:

Nes “We conclude. that section 406(a) of the "Act
vests in the Board: complete discretion to determine —

tlie date u_er which its orders thereunder shall be-
- come.e etfecti¢ e.- In exercising. this discretion, we are

°

limited only by the procedural ‘requirements of -no-

tice and hearing and_ by: the necessity of promoting
the broad objectives, of the Act.”’

.
‘

“Tt reiterated. thitt. conclusion in Ame rican Airlines, Ine.
cé al, Mail Rates, 4€.9 'B. 90, 92. :
Thus. the unwieldy process

of petitioning Congress for
legislation: incfeasing a rate retroactively | has been dis-

carded, df: course the Board is net compelled to make re-

‘troactive changes: but it must weigh’ gll the facts of. each’

particular case and “@eleet that- date which will be proper— .

wv hethe + fhe day on which its order is issued, a future day,
“ora past day which may or ‘may not antedate_ the institution
of the. rate proceeding. C omplete pliability is the essence
of the statutory scheme in this respect.

The sweeping’scope of §406(a) (1) is iHuminat. ‘d by. the
coytrast with other parts’ of the. Act dealing | Wi h public
utility rates for carrying passengers and cargo.| -

All air carriers Must file with the Board ‘ Griff -show-
ing all- rates, fares: and charges for air transportation, ”’
under + 5403 (a) of the’ Act (52 Stat. 992, 49-UL S.C: 6483(a)).
‘The carrier may. change thetrates, but only prospectively.

‘‘No change shall be made. in any rate, fare, or charge...
specified in any effective t tariff . - . except after thirty days’
‘notice of the proposed change . The Board may -in the
public interest . ,-. illow such slibege upon notice less than .
_ that herein specified -. 2’? (§408(e) of the Act: o2 Stat.
— U.S. C. 6483(¢)): - Likewise the Board may review
the | filed rates and prescribe different ones, but only
“futuro; for $g002(d) of the Act prov ides (92 Stat. 1018,
19 UL S.C. CD) |

| “Wherever, after notice and hearing i . \. the.

Board shail be of the opinion that any individunl on: ”’
joint rate, fare, or charge demanded, charged, col-
lectéd or received by any air carrier

\

24 P “ ;
“specifies such power” (112). . The court's — of Neild —
v. District of ¢ ‘olumbia, “1 App. 1). C. 306, 110 F. (2d) 246,
—shoWs that it‘completely misapplied the familiar principle
that ‘unless the contrary plainly appears a statute applies
prospectively only ”’ (110 I. [2d], at p.: 2+).

of eis avery law t that -is to have an operation hefore. the

“making. thereof, as to commente at an gftecedent time
Yall, hig S.] 386,
at the lawmaking

t for thé past”’

. Is retrospective” (Calder v. Bull, :
391). ‘Since “the. court will presume t]
pe acting Tor the jeep only and 1
(White v. U.'S., 191 U. 8.545, 552y, “law
pina as nes to cases Which arosé before their -

s are not to’be

passage unless that intention be clearly declared’? (Shwal
‘y. Doyle, 258 U. 029, 034). That is all ~ presumption
against retroactitity means. ;
A statuteis not interpreted soleus ely. whei-—as here
winoll operates. only -On situations diininn tet existence after
its passage. ~ Moreover r, a “statute is not rendered’ retgo- -
- active merely because the facts or requisites upon which its
subsequent action depends, or some of them, are drawn
from a time antecedent _to the enactment’’ (Reynolds + ve
U.S. 292 U.S. 4455, 449) 8 See also, Cox v: Hart, 260 U.S
427, 435; Great Northe rn Ry. Co. v. Sutherland, 273 U.S.
182,.192; Lewis v. Fidelity & De aes Co. of Maryland, 292 :
U.S. 559, 971; U.S. v. Jacobs, 306 U.S. 603, 367. Indeed, the
Neild case actually applied that very ere (110 F. [2d],
at p. 255). Henee there can . ng **claim of retroactivity”?
where a statute involv es a “‘recomputation by. the state
[Board] of taxes [mail pay] under a statute which was
existent throughout the whole period i in question”? (1llinats
Central Rd. Co. v. Minnesota, 309 8, Ss. bags 164). Ch. U.S.
‘vy. New York Ble Rd. Co., 279 U.S. 75, 79! American.

_
Airlines, Tne, Mail Rate Proceeding, 3 oe 323, 3:8.

& - - ” mS ¥

95

POINT III

. *
_ The Court of Appeals relied on a wholly false analogy |
to public utility rate statutes. ie .

The vourt relied heats ‘ily on RY supposed analogy fo public .
utility rate statutes. .** The whole’ * Act, 1 thought, “is |
cast in the. form of the usual public utility rate- determina-
tion measur e. Such micasures are, frequently made effective
as of the date ot the sevens, velit the proceedings, but
never, so far as) we know, for period's prior thereto’’ (114).
Ther ‘etore the unique language of $4 1G(a) ( | )w ‘hich i is found
in no public utility rate statute, | was cut down to mean some-

=

thing less than it says. ;

Even.if thé court’s major premise—that $406 of the Act
is the ‘‘usual utility rate-determination measure’’—were
correct, its conclusion would not follow. “A restrictive .

interpretation should not be given. a_statute merely beeause————
a Congress has yaar to depart from custom’’ (U. Sy vy.

Sulliv an, 332 U.S, 689, 695). And there were excellent rea-:
sons why Congress did not apply public utility. rate prin-
ciples to airmail pay. | as ee

1. Carrying the mail is not a public utility function.
‘That was settled long ago. “*The company in carrying the —-
mails was not hauling freight, nor was it acting as7t com- | -
mon carrier with corresponding rights, and liabilities but
in this respect it Was serving as an agency of government”

{ Atchison, Topeka & Santa Fe'R y. Co. v. U. S.,,225 U. S. .
64), 649). *, That rule’ reflects vital practical differences

» _

* *See also, .U. S. | Hambury-. Iniertkani sthe Packetfahrt Actie n
Gesellschaft, 212 F es mM, 45 00. C. A. 2); Bankers’ Mutual ( ‘asualty
Co. ‘ U ry. ®: Griffin, 303-U. a:

-—226, 237-258. ~ Since ‘the re: ason. underlying the tradition al

public utility rule is inapplicable to mail pay, it is hardly
surprising that (406(a)(1)-of the Act docs not embody that
rule, but permits mail pay: crates to be changed ‘‘effective.

,

from such date ‘as. the Board “shall determine to be

oe

— .

proper.’ "¢ oan is Fe _———

at

The diffe rence in-teeatment- Was pointed out on May 1 1,
1947, by a member of the Board when testifying before the
Subcommittee of the Se ‘nate Conffiittee on Appropriations,
sour org., Ist Session, on H. R. 2436 (Hearings, p. O04):

~

ec -
. “Mr. Ryan. When we fix passengers and eargo
rates, those rates, are prospec tive in their oper ration.

They do hot relate back. co . a:

: _-**Now, of course you; ean understand the prac-
tical reasons for that. Passengers are scattered all
over, and their identity ix lost. G

N. 8

.
.

ae ‘Senator Saltonstall: You have only one mail
vust ‘mer. Pe a , ..
ws ee
‘Mr. Ryan. That is right. There is just the
Postmaste 4 General, and if he overpays as a result
of one of our decisions, he, will not pay the following
year and even up.”’

2. Moreov ¢r, it is ‘quite iucorrect to supposé that, where

mail pay is cone ernedMhe Act is a traditional regulatory
publie utility statute. ‘‘It must not’ be rier that the
Civil Aeronauties Act is fashioned to a dev elopmental as
_well as a regulatory objective. Nowhere is this faet made
clearer than in those provisions which set forth the stand.
ards for the Board’s guidance in the exercise of its air mail

rate: making function* ~€Pan Ame rican-Grace Airways, Inc.

—Muil Rates, 3-C. A; B.550, 563). **¢ ‘ertainly, the deelara-
tion of policy Contained in section 2 differentiates the Act
in many important respects from the usual form of public
utility regulatory statutes’’ (American Export Airlines,
Ine-—Certificate of Public Convenience and Necessity,

-C. A. Bo16, 30; appeal dismissed Pan American Airways,
~ Ine. v. Civil Aeronautics Board, 121 F. [2d] $10 ic. Cc, A.
2]).

_ Under the Act, mail pay ds ifot determined by “public
utility” principles. ‘*This Board in exercising i its. rate-
‘teakine functions has ne¥er and does liot now measure the
reasonableness of the rate in terms of a fair return upon
the so-called ‘fair value’ of the prope rty used and useful
oin the public service’* (Ame rican Airlines, Tue., Mail Rate

- Procevding, 3. A. B. 770, 788). Section 406(b) prescribes
: strikingly unique - standards for det termining - mail- pay.
~ “Tn determining the rate in ach case, the Board shall take
into consideration, among other factors oe. the need of

JOE . \

Re

: ¥: za .
Les a ae ;
« a

each such’ ‘dir carrigg for compensation for the transporta-
tion of mail sufietnt Yo 2insure the performance. of such
service, cand, together with all other revenue of the air
‘arrier, to enable such air carrier tinder honest, economical,
sad eficient management, fo maintain and continue the de-
velopment of air tragsportation to the extent cand of the
character. and quality. required for the commerce of ‘the
United States, the Postal Service, and the national defeuse””
(52 Stat. 998,49 U.S. C. $486(b)).* a eee

“—

rant

**Segtion . 406(b), more than any other “section of the

Civil Aeronautics, Act, discloges the basic difference: be-

tween the dual dey elopmental anid regulatory objective of

this:Act and the regulatory. objective e of- ‘the ordinary. stat-
ute designed for the control of public utility rates’? (Ameri-
can Airlines, Inc —Mail Rate Pr raceeding, 3°C. A. B. 323,
339). Actually mail pay is ‘‘Government subsidy in the

form of mail piiy’? ( Ajinual Report of the Civil Aeronautics

Board, 1947, ps). ~The 1 use of mail payments. isa stétu-

tory ‘device for the acconiplishment of statutory objectives.

that transcend the interests of the postal service-. . . The
‘compensation’ which *he carrier receives thes % ey com-

pensation not only for carrying the mail but for the build-

gy up of a system of air transportation which wilkgerve

‘ the nation’s commerce and security as well’? (American Air-

lines, Inc., Mail Rate Proceeding, 3° C. A. B. 323, 335).

. **Thus section 406(b) of the Aet departs from the cus-. |
‘tomary rate standards”’ ‘if Ame rican President Lines, Ltd.,

ef al. Petition, 7 i CoA. B_799, 802 note.9),'and the Board’s
mal pay task differs “fundamentally from that: which faces,

* Cf. the much more convention: il factors whet the Dierds must

“i » consider in se ting: rates for the common carriage tof persons ‘and
«property. $1002 (e); 52 Stat. POD, ot, 5 co. $6424).

v2

a

x ee |

“Unlike ‘thal case, the instant proéecding does. not |
involvé a relatiofship between a private shipper and

e& :

~e * - ‘
—— a common carrion, Tf it did, then the carrier's argu-:
“o8 ment “that, the Board ‘niay “retroagively’ ‘inerease 5 *
rates apparently has no force in view of the prin-,
ciple that a- privpte shipper, once havi ing paid a pub- ‘.
_ lished rate, need not concern himself “with ‘subse-
quently having to. pay more. On the contrary, the
Postmaster: General, uilike the private shipper, is.
ithe medium through. w hich continuous financial sup- ¢ “J
"port necessary for the-carri¢ ‘rs to fulfill the purposes. —
of. the Act is “extende d. Org obligatign is to see ta
it that the rates he pays are at all times slfficient
to enable- the carriers to accomplish and maintain
those purposes.. l,ikewise, our ‘obligation is also toe
see that the rates do not at any time exceed those
which are’ proper under .the statute. We must dis- _
charge‘both te ee :

“
° e

é 1 ;
3 ‘The court was, led to espouse the false analogy to
ag utility’ ‘rate cases by its assumption that the only
alternative was a “Gost- -plus”’ paynient in: which ‘the net:
to-the contractor is the same lo matter what the quality of.
the performance may be”? (114). ‘4We cannot find in ,

this statute,’ ’ said the’ court, ‘“any aia which indicates
‘that Congress intended to guarantee to every carrier: a
profit”? (114). | “ i
» No one aims that ‘Congress intended to “guarantee : .
ies every carrier ir profit’’ regardless of the +‘quality of :

As the Board can, must and always:

29)

the performance.
does review costs, ‘ind is ever alert to allow only reasonable
costs i in the Aight of actual expert lence, this bugaboo i is simply oo
imaginary.* =. - . . 3

) bs Section 406(b) refers to the carrier’s need for compensation to.

enable it to carry out the purposes of the Act “under honest, éco-
nomical, and efficient management”, eR,

o

The Board itself ha iS pointed out several times that the .
**cost- plus’? argument ’ affords to reason for adhering dog-
’ gedjy toa false prophecy w nu > a have proved it wrong.

* Althougitt i is not thee Board FyMnteytion, i in rate proceed-
ings involving the. fixing of mail rates for past periods, to
determine niail rates merely on*a cost- plus basis, it. must
‘be Fecognized that the process of fixing rates for a past
period’” on a retroactive basis ‘*does assure the atr carrier
substantial protection against unforeseeable contingencies
for whith a prospective fair and reasonable rate pight well
have made inadeqiate allowance’? (Pan American Airways,
Liuc., Transatlantic Mai Ratés, 8 C. A. B. 267,. 291, note
22).* Certainly Congress was amply justified in-aceepting
that view, whether the Board now likés it or not. |

In point of fact, whenever the Board raises “rates re-

troactively to the date when the proceeding was bégun,
necessarily it reviews the airline’s actual costs and deter-
mines the rate in the light of experience. Indeed, since the.
airline must receive *Sjust compensation, ** the Constitution —
—- that to he done, U.S. v. Ne w York Central Rd, Co.,
279 U.S. 73. Likewise, when the Board.fixes Seenperety

‘ . ="

*See also, Pan Américan Airways, Inc., Latin-American avd
Miami-Leopoldville Services Mail Rates, Order No. E-738, -p- 42
(July 24, 1947); Alaska Airlines, Inc., Order No, E-1665, spp. 40-41 +
( June 4, 1948). “Tt has been the praciee to previde a Somewhat
lower rate of return for a past period than for a ‘future period in view
of the fact that for a-past period the probability of- error. in estimates
of operating résults is removed and other operating risks have been
realized in substantial part” 4 Braniff Airways, Inc., Order No. E- .

1931, p. 24, Sept. 2, 1948)... See also, Chicago & Southern Airlines,
Inc.; Order No. E-1740, p. 29 4 July-1, 1948); Delta Air Lines, Inc.,

Order No; E-1959, p. 20-4 Sept. 7, 1945).
?

rates} asit freque aitly does, At follows the same procedure
» wher it revises them retroactively.’ *

o
. ° . .
@ :

‘In short, the dilet mama which the court posed is ~unply

. non-existent. © Its analogy to. public utufty rate ~tatutes
igneres the practical reasons which explain why the Act

“deliberately differentiates between the Board's power to
change public utility rates: prospectively “and its power to

change mail _pay rate retrospectively as well as prospec-

tively. It ignores the faet that the air mait provisions of

the Act. deliberately departed from tr: dition: il public utility

rate principles. And it ignores the admonition of ¢ ‘hicago

€ 5 eye Airlin s, Ine JW aterman Steamship $ orp,

333 U. _ 103, where, after noting that ‘all forms of trans-

eevee had ‘common fee uures,’’ this Court said (pp. 107-
108) : . gO TET :

‘*But. these resemblances must not blind us-te the _
fact that legally as well as literally, air commereé,
whether at home or abroad, soared into a different.
realm’ than any that had gone before... . However

*At one time, .indeed, the Board declined to set rates en a.”
“tentative basis, subject to change according to future operating re-
sults” because that “would, in effect, result im the establishment of a
‘cost-plus’ System of rate making” (All) American: Aviation, Imnc.,
Mail Rate for Route No. 49, 4 C. A. B. 354, 357). It has"long since
abandoned that position, arid fixes “temporary” rates, which will be
revised%retroactively, both when dealing with new routes '( see, ¢.y.,
Essair; Inc. deve lopme ut of arev olutionary commerce that opr
ates in three. dimetsions “should be judicially circu?
scribed with analogies taken over from tivo-dimep-
sional transit.’ sae - x

‘

| pdftey to ite: the Authority ieavady in fixing | such

“rates and enables the Authority [Board] to adjust

rates'so that the policy of Congress may be properly

carricd out in the pase of each carrier or class of

carrjyers according to the. meeds of the particular

, cast... . These provisiotis Hppear in thesconfer-
ence agreeme ut dis section 406 ( (x), (b) and (¢).. & ne

3

Yet the decision ‘below. holds that, even though ‘*the
needs. of, the. particular case’? require that’ the Board

°

Madjust rates’ retrospectively, in order fog the airline to

earry out ‘‘the poliey of C ongress,.’ the Board is powerless |

to achieve that’ be neficent. restit. «= 4

y

: - The Railway Mail Pay ‘Act of 1916

: Translation mf an implication drawn from the special _

aspects of ore statute to a totally different statute is

treacherous business’? as ederal Trade Comm: v. Bunte-

~ Brothers, Inc., 312 U.S. 349, 353). . This warning is es-
; : ’ en)
pecially pertinent ae sunning tes Civil Aeronautics

-Act with the Railway Mail Pay Act of 1916 (Act of July -

28,1916, ec. 261; 39 Stat. 425. ff., 39. U.-S. €. §524 ff.), and

” Air Mail Acts of 1934 and 1935 (Act of June 12, 1934,

. 466; 48 Stat. 933, amende d by Act. of August 14, 1935,

930; 49 Stat. 614), modelled on it. A det tailed comparisoff :

Z the statutes appears in Appendix A hereto.
“The Railway Mail P: iy Act terminated ‘the system
theretofore prevailing of servicé under voluntary’ con-

tracts’? (U.S. v. Griffin, 803 U.S S,.226, 229). Under it the -

railroads ‘were “entitled to. receive fair and reasonable
compensation’? (39 U.S. C. $541). This compensation. was

fixed purely on a quanti meruit basis. U.S, v. Griffin:

U.S. 226, 2837. [Under the Civil Aeronautics Act, air-

>) °

a

36 aor

lines are not paid for transporting mail on any such re-

Str ictive basis. ] +

Railroad mail rates were fixed by the Interstate Com-
nierce C ommission. Once fixed, they remain in effect until
changed. The Commission Was “to. fix and determine
from time’ to time the fair and reasonable rates and, com-.
pensation for the transportation of such mail matter...

‘and to publish the same, and orders so made and published

“shall continue in forée until changed by the Commission
after due notice and hearing”? (39 U: 8. C. 6542). [The

difference between this: language and 406(a) ( 1) of the
Civil Aeronautics Act is.obvious,| There was no provision
for a judicial rev ie W; the statute pe mitted only: ‘agmin-

S

~~ istrative review by ‘reexamination’ of ar order”? (U. S. v.

Griffin, 303 U.-S. 996. 331). [The ¢ ‘ivil. Ae ronauties -

_ contains in §1006(a), 49 U. S.:-&. (646(a), an express: pro-

vision for judicial rev iew. 3

Sh order could not be reexamined yall it had remainéd
in effect six months. ae ither the Postmaster General, or
any such carrier may cat any ‘time after the lapsé of six
months from the entry. of ‘the. order assailed apply fora
reexamination and thereupon substantially similar proceed-
ings shall be had with respect to the rate or rates for serv-
ice covered by said applications . . .’? (39 U. S.C. §553).
[N 0 comparable provision appears in the Civil Aeronautics
we ae \ | |

Plainly ree xamination was to be purely prospective.

° .

In view of the highly: restrictive language of the Railway

Mail Pay Act, it- would hardly be surprising if no power

ever existed thereunde r to increase mail pay retroactively. -
Yet this Court held that power to increase the rate retro- *
actively to the date of the petition for-reexaminatidn. existed

ea

y “reasonable impli ‘ation,”-although it was.**quite aware -
hat minutiae of expression may be found that show Con-
ress to hate bee ‘n thinking of the future”’ (Holmes, J., in
1. S.v. New YorkCentral Rd. Co. » 219 U.S. 73, 49).° **This
onclusion was“reached despite the fact that the applicable
tatute contained no express authority, such as is contained
n section 406(a) of the Civil Acronauties Act, to determine
he date on which rate orders should become effective’?
American Airline s, Inc.-—Mail Rate Proceeding, 3 C. A. B.

23, a 327).

a.
.

* No issue existed in the New York Central case whether mail
ay could’ be ‘inc reased to a date earlier than the application for re-
Savannah Rd. Co. v. U. S.. 78 GC. Cl. 251. There
ie Commission found tbat plainuff and other short-line: railroads,
hich filed petitions for reexamination in May 1931, were actually
separately operated” as of July 5, 19230, but it refused to award
1dditiohgl compensation for setvtces rendered prior to the. filing
| their applications with us” (Railway Mail Pay, 185 1. C. C. 715,
20). Plaintiff sued in the Court of Claims for the additional, pay
om July 3, 1930, to May 1931. A demurrer to its complaint was
verruled: “Congress reposed in the Commission the primary duty
| determining just compensation, not whether by some’ act on the
urt of the carrier it was estopped as a matter of law from receiving
ist compensation in its entirety” (78 C.’Cl., at p. 256): The period
| underpayment without protest was not “so protracted as to estab-
sh, affirmatively, with all the other circumstances, including the fact
at Plaintiff was not free to decline performance, the defense of
quiescence” (p. 258). Final judgment was later given for. plain-_
ff, 79 C. Cl. 298. While. the’ case pfimarily involved the question
hether plaintiff was entitled to one previously determined rate rather -
an another, it shows tly under the Railway Mail Pay -Act—despite
: severely restrictive language—it was possible for’a railroad to
tain an inerease-in mail pay. retroactive tora time antedating. its
‘titien for reex xamunation.

38

sae B. The Air Mail ie ot: 1934 | -

“This statute was even more restrictive than the Railway
Mail Pay Sect on which it was based. -Airlines were not
Mail Pay law to carry mail. They assumed that obli-
gation only by making contracts with the Postmaster Gen-
eral (S3(a) e458 Stat> 933-9: 34), which, could be terminated
‘“by the contractor at its option upon. sixty days’ notice’’
($6(e), 48 Stat. 955). The rates. werg negotiated by the
contracts, which were let by competitive bidding, subject
to a specified ceiling (3a), 48 Stat. 934). Contracts were ©
to be ‘*subject to any reduction in the rate of payment
theretor” (S6(c), 48.Stat. 9385). & i i

‘The Commission was authorized to-fix by order “rates
“of compensation for fhe transportation of air mail by: air-
plane . . . but not in ‘excess of the rates provided for in-
this Act . . . and to_publish the same, which shall continue
in force until changed by the said Commission after due
notice and hear ing’? (S6(a), 48 Stat.935). The limited pro-
cedure under.the Railway Mail Pay Act for reexamination
of a rate after six months was taken over-by a section mak-
ing applicable the whole procedure ‘‘for the adjustment of
rates for ¢ ‘arriage of mail by railroads’? (S6(d), 48 Stat.
935): In fact t, a special requirement was imposed tbat rates
be reviewed annually ‘‘in order to be assured that no. un-
reasonable profit is resulting or accruing’ ' ($6(b), 48 Stat.
935).

Thus Congress

,

whole effort was to kedp air mail pay
as low.as gossible.* Indeed, it took elaborate reasoning |

* Mail pay was determined only by “the amount of air mail so.
carried, the facilities supplied by the carrier, and its revenue and
profits from all sources” ($6(e), 48 Stat. 936). This provision was
amended in 1935 to-require .the Commission to disregard losses: re-
sulting trom the unprofiti ible maintenance of non-mail ‘schedules ‘4

e

——

==

’ for lack of power.

eR

to es stablish that the Commission baa au power to increase
the contract rates, Air:Mail Compr vsation. 206 7. C. f.
679, 688-694, Yet despite the statute's nainifold restrictions
the Commission repeatedly held that it ‘gould increase air
mail rates retroactively to thealate of the application for
reexamination.* é

In tivo cases, airlines sought to have rate increases made
effective earlicr than-the time of their applications for ad-
justment. ~The’ requests were denied, "but onthe merits, not-
** Tn one case, however, the Commission

«49 Stat. 616). The Commission was directed to “keep the aggregate

cost of the transportation of air mail on aud after July 1.1938, within
‘the, limits of the anticipated postal revenue therefrom” (Sb e), 4s.
Stat. 936). |

* Commissioner Mahaffic dissented because he hoists: that the
rule to this effect under the Railway Mail Pay Act Was inapplicable °
since airlines, unlike railroads, were not oblig ed to carry:the mail.
Air Mail CompenSation, 216 1. C. C. 166, 1925 \ir Mail Compensa-_

gtion, 222 1. C. C 602, hy Air Mail Rates fokAmerican ‘Airlines,

Inc., 225 1. C. G@ 12, 463 Ate Mail Rates for Braniff Airi ie a oe
226 I. C. C. 752, 768; yi Mail Rates for Route No. 8, 227 | oa

509, 516: Air Mail Rates for Route No. 26, 229 1, C. C..373, 383;
dw Mail Rates for none

No. 29,229 1. C. C. 623,.6382; Air Mail,.
Rates for Route No. 2,°231-1..C.«C7 229, 250; Air Mail Rates for
Route No. 13, 2311. C. C. 623, 68:33.

pangs a previously stated; petitioner seeks to have the findings
herein made-effective from May 1, 1936, ag" to the date its pefition
was filed. © In, lir-Mail Compe nsation, 216 1. C. C. 166, the rates
found fair and reasonable for routes nos. ; and 16 were, for the
reasons there stated, made applicable from the date of filing of.the
petition. This record affords iio basis for any different conclusion,

especially, in’ view of the fact that the relief sought will, in part at
least, be obtained through the proper application of the order in fir

Mail Compensation, supfa, during the, period prior to the date of
filitig the petition” (National Parks dlirways—Base Rate Mileage,
220 1. C. C. 149, 154). s

“.. thers is.no indication on this record that any modification
of ‘the base rat¢ forrherly. determined and fixed as fair and reasonable
is warranted” )( Boston-Maine Airways, Inc.. Base Rate Mileage,

229 1. C. C. 343, 350). ; ‘
2 F “) > ; . . « é \

os

40
* é & . . P
actually made such a retroactive’ increase on. its own mo-_
tion.” °Moreover, rates, wére decreased retroactive ‘ly toa

day antedating thie rate review yp. oceeding:**

C.. The Changes Sade: by. the Civil Aeronautics Act

The Civil Aeronautics Act of 1938 completely revolu-
_‘tionized the status of the airlines and ‘the nature of mail
pay. Congress recognized that air carriers subserved na-
tional inter¢ s of far ereater importance than cheap postal |
service, and fhat air mail pay Was a micans of developing
an imfant industry to effectuate those. interests. Henee in
62 Congress: enunciated a ‘new national poliey’ “to foster
‘the continued development of an air ‘transportation sys-
tem adequate to the partmouit national needs. not only of
the postal Service but also of our commerce and our national

*In diy Mail Comperisation, 252 1. C. Co 608, the Commission
eliminated On its own motion a proviso 1 in an earlier Order, nade two
years before, which had reduced air mail pay retroactively. Ehimina-
tion of the proviso necessarily increased the airlines? compensatioi
retroactively, “We have authority en. our own motion -to correct
an error in our former findings and to make such finding in the
form 6f-an amendment towur original findings and order” .(p. 613),
In ir Mat! Rate for ‘Route No, 33, 216-1. C. C. 3st, 401-402, the
Commission made an initial rate retroactivesto March 1, 1935, al-
though the rate proceeding was begun thereafter. It @id so because
eft the August 135 amendment, supra, page 38,note *.

‘e
** The Commission consistently reviewed operations for periods
antedating the ‘proceeding for reviston. a e.g. Wyoming stir
‘Service, Inc:, Rat? Review; 225-1. C: C. 1; Western Air Express
Corp... Rate Revi ’, 225 l. Ces Cc. 743; peer ligqways, Ine. Rate
Review, 226 1. C. C. 40096 Ilantord Aine s, Ine.. 223 1. C. C. 593.
dn oonly two cases, however. dideat actually lower previous rates. . In
heth or-them the decrease was adjusted by the Postmaster-General,
retroactively to Mareh 2b. 1955, although the changes were made by
proceedings started thereafter. The cases are described ino finerican
Airlines, Inc., Mail Rate Proceeding, 3 C. A. Be 523, 327 note 12.

defense’™* (¢ hhicuge dad. Southern Air Lines, luc.— Miri Rates

for Routes Nas. 5 and 55,30. A. BOL, ASL),
No lonyver were airlines bree to carry mail « or fiot ae
they saw fit. Thef were compelled to carry the mails,

s401Qm) (02 Stat. 990, A i. oa aa Ast(im)) 3. WL ta) (on:

stat. LOES, 49 ‘U. S, «, O22(a)), and’ ‘necessarily were
afforded just compensation as a matter of right. 401 (1m)
and 406(a). |

Provisions designed to held mail pay ax low’as possible,

so that it would’ not. exceed postal re venue, disap ipeared.
The voluntar V contract system-—under whic h airlines would

bid nominal rates in order to obtain certifie tites to operate®

~-was abolished. ¢ ‘eilings On max ium rates were -elimi-
nated. Mail. pay “was not to be computed on a. narrow

quantum meruil basis, but was to be ample enough to enable -

the airlines to ‘time tain and continue the dev _levelopinent of ———

a Se
air traisportation © The extent and of the character and 3

quality required ft © the commerce of the \ hited States, the

* Postal Service, ‘ id the natiqnal dle Tense! (46(b)). “The

mail provisio, of the Net ‘tenacted the oly of govern-
:* 225 1+)

ee
The Post. Offive Department felt hat control should
rest large lv With it.” ' Therefore it and its champion, Sen-
ater Make lary. vigorously “opposed the proposed bill, and
proceeded to attack the Commission's administration, of
eNistiig law ona wide front. eae the « course of the ensuing
asgument, thie «question arose whether the Commission was |

justified under the existing ir Mail Acts in. granting any

« .retroac ‘tive rate Tcreases, P

eget “On that subject, there had. been some. difference of
opinion in thes ¢ ‘ommisgion. Commissioner Mahaiffie had
- held.out against retrospective ingreases, differentiating the-
rule under the Railway Mail Pay Act on the ground that, un-
like that statute, the Air Mail Acts imposed no obligation”
to‘carry the mais. His views never prevailed in.the Com,
mission and. the Post Office never tried to sustain them. by A

a caurt test. ** “Nonetheless, they ‘were aired by the Post

2

*Ibid., pp. WI. ee a 3
*** For example, the Commission was charged with being: too $
liberal im, iricreasing ur ‘mail pay, and teo reluctant. to reduce it
cud... pp. 116, 122, 160-161). A list was submitted showing that —
rates had be&g raised on most rottes, and decreased or left un-
changed «en relatively few (pp. 124-1347 5 ut ‘sHowed_ that-irr a a pro-,
ceeging instituted on July 22, 1955, the Coimmussion * ‘increased the
bid rate or retroactively to March 1, 1935" Ap: 130). So, also, ;
“the Commisston was chi irged with not making a y prope’ investigation . +
and audit before increasing rates and net disclosing the evidence on
- which it based its finditigs. (ihid., pp. 163, 172-174). of employing’ a
“tnan “unduly friendly to the air-maid companies” (p. 167), and of
dhtferentiating unduly between the “subsidy” rafes given to competing
airlines pp. 16-14 0). aa
-*** The Act, like the bill which was. the subject of discussion in
raz, completely cut the ground from under Mr Mahaffie’s argu-
ment, for it imposed on airlines the duty to carry the mails. Even
it the “take effective’ language of $406:a)(1) had never been
‘ added, thercfore, anquestionably the Board: would have had at leas
the same power in this respect which the Commission in fact CXF:
cised in 1937. ;

45
‘
,. & . pa Se es.

Office in response to questions by. Senator MeKellar. “On
what possible theory: or what possible claim of law,’’ he
inquired, “were - retroactive rates established 277" Ile
elicited testimony from a Witness sharing’ his views that
increases were gr arited retroac tively ‘even further than the.”
appli vation.’"** Repeatedly he tried to show that thé Com-
mission had ho ‘‘right ‘to make their acts retroactive in.
fixing .rates.”’ ees

The proponent of the bill, Senator MeCarran, countered
this broad attack. He endeavored go show that this court
eh eee

‘In other
words, (fr esti ablishes the principle of the propriety of .a

had sustained “ret ranetiv e rate decisions.
91060¢0. 1p estimony, wi is © ‘litited to show ]
t Congress itself ‘had authorized rates to be made: re-/ °
troactive to: March 1, 1935. *sees* Later Mr: Gor rell dis-
cussed at length, **the power of the Interstate ‘Commerce
C ommission to make a retroactive award’’ and’ vigorously
contended that it existed.******* :
Manifestly, when Mr. a said, in. proposing—the.
‘make effective’? language Which now appears in §406(a )- *

retroactive deci is ion.

(1), that the ‘‘present authority of the Commission ‘to fix _
appropri iately the effective date of its rate dec isions. is like-

‘ @

* Hearings, p. 179... ee.

** Ibid. He brought out that the Commission went back to ) “dif
ferent dates.. The first date the payments were adjusted was to
March 1, 1935, I believe. In the least case they were hxed back to —.
the date of the filing of the petition.” * - : . os

_ *** Thid., pp. 239, 201. |
eee Ibid., p: 1S0. . |
_ Ibid. p. 43. ‘ he ;
ies p. 230, ae ieee wae

+eteeee Ibid. pp. 4s3-454,

ts
«/

“>

ae a 46 : TSS ees “y

5 eo ae
wise specifically preserved,’? he was addressing himself to
the. broad question raised by Senator MeWellar—did the

“Commission have any authority to grant retrospective in-

creases? The whole debate was over the ‘‘principle of the
propriety of a retroactive decision.’” There is not the slight-
est? reason ‘to suppose that Mr. Gorrell thought that au-
thority to ‘fix appropriately, the effective date. of its rate
decisions’’ was ‘limited by the date of the start ‘of the rate
proceeding." Neither he’ nog” aa else. addresséd him-
self to that Narrower question.” tert ae -e
Nor is there. anything to show that Congress, wlen- it
passed the Act in the summer of 1938) saw AyS406(a) (1)
those subtle nuances now. attr ibuted to Mr. Gor rell when he
testified j i the spring of 1937. It took the language at-its

broad face value. (Seo ( ‘onference Report, supra, pp. 34-35. y
>The plain words and meaning of a statute cannot be over-

come by a _legislative history which, ‘through ‘strained:

| processes. of, deduction from events of wholly. ambiguous

significance, nity ‘furnish “dubious basés for inference in
every. direetion”’ (Gemsco, Inc. v. Walking, 324. U.-S. 244,
260). >No member of Congress ever referred to. Gorrell’s
testimony. ‘‘ The interpretation of statutes cannot safely

i As already seen, p. “39, note **, and p. 40, notes * and **, supra,

rates liad been changed retrospectively back of the date of the pro-

ceeding, and that fact had been dev eloped i in the hearings.
** Cf. Ame rican Steve dores, Inc. ‘v. Porello, 330 U.S: 446. Tigre.

. the question was, whether a statute permitted suit for personal in-

juries as well as injury to property. The Representative proposing
‘the bill stated that it “simply allows ‘suits in. admiralty to be brought by

owners of: vessels whosé property has been damaged” _ and that
“where a man’s property is damaged, he can bring a suit.” He said
nothing about st* for personal injuries.. This Court isan

-these remarks, *. ‘se statements were not, however, answers
“que stions whether the “Act would provide al remedy for injury to the

person as well as to property, nor (loés it appear that the speaker

Was at the time attentive to such possible distifigtions . ip, 452).
F aa

od
>

o

be made to rest upon mute intermediate legislative maneuv-
| ers”? (Trailmobile Co.y » Whirls, 331, U. t 40), 61).

Had Congress wished to’ codit's she h power? as existed

a. under the: Railway: Mail’ Pay Act, it Had only to copy its
words. and Impose: on- airlines, like thie railroads, the obli- :
gation to carry the mails. Inste: dit chan Sell the words

anguage.

of the earlier acts radically by patently, broad r
If it had wanted to confine the Board’ s power to Adjust_mail
pay’ by the: filing date of the rate proceeding, all it had to
“do was to copy the language used in other parts af the “Aet® ,
~ (supra, pp. 19. 20). it did nothing of the ‘sort. |

‘The legislative histor v of the Act only confirms the. fact
that §406(a) (1) means just what it. says. . Congress’ de--
liberately departed from the wording of earlier, restrictive
legislation, Drawing a unique statute, it used in °406(a) (1) -
unique language of a breadth consonant with its broad pur-
pose to foster the development of commercial aviation
until it reaches such stature. in passenger and cargo ea-

‘pacity as ‘fo constitute in crises an adequate logistical air.
arm of the: National Defense Establishment’? (Report oj
the Congressional | Aviation Policy Board, p. 5—March 1 1,
1948). - That language ‘should, not be whittled down by:
a construction which ignores vate e objectives.

era POINT ‘

we ” i ; : : ‘ .
\The decision below . thwarts the basic..policies of the

‘Act and ian aes irlines* constitutional right to just |
compensation.

Ze The court low was largely influence 6d by the ‘*re.
sult which would ensue if the statute were.given unlimited

retroactive effect’ (114). **No rate order would be final’’

ve . ° ©
‘ 4 ‘ ¢
. sa -

: ) ;
(114). But no one suggests that the Board should exam‘fne.
rates ‘*back to 1938"" (81), or that it -is required to re-.
examine rates based on facts which it has. once reviewed.
It does have full power to examine rates based on prophe-
cies-which have been belied by facts which have never been
reviewed. ee z

That power, the court thought, necessarily implied the
power to redetermine rates for “past periods ‘‘when the
earrier lias made more than an adequate profit”’ (114).
There is nothing inevitable about that implication. _ It is_
one thing to give an airline*tt fair amount for past services
rendered at a_rate which events have proved unduly low.
It is utterly different: to subject it to liability to return
money which it has disbursed by a ‘‘dividend declaration,”
or on the faith of which it -has entered into a ‘large com-
mitment’? or issued an ‘‘offering of securities’’ or uiberwise
changed its position (115). . i

Because of compelling economic and policy’ considera-
tions, the Board lis declined to exercise retroactive power
with respect to overpayments. Pan-A merican-Grace: Air-
ways, Inc.—Mail Rates; 3 C. A. B. 550, 565; Pan American
Airways, Inc., et al, Latin-American Rate Case, 3 C. A. B.
657, 669; Eastern Air Lines, Inc., Mail Rate Proceeding,
3.C A. B. 738, 743; Americ an Airlines, Inc., Mail Rate Pro- .
ceeding, 3 C.A. B. 770, 776 “The power is not rendered non-
ex sistent, however, because PORE SIP it might be abused—
in which easé doubtless the Board’s action would be re-
versed on appeal. And we ‘see no compellin

reason to
deny that the Board has power in appropriate cases to de-
clare that excessive amounts have, been .paid for carrying

‘ .

ail : _” -49 : es ‘ r 7 .
the. mails, however rarcly it should: exercise that powe r ad a
iz matter of sound discretion." ine

a The Board’s basic complaint was ‘that “until a pe--
tition is filed by the ‘arrier-we have ho notice that an exist-
ing.rate’is regardéd as unsatisfactory, and we thus have

ho opportunity to take?’ appropriate action (S7). Apart
from the fact that the Board is directed to act on its own
initiative, lack of notice would -be no reason for denying

‘ that power exists to take vomplete. remedial action: when .
the situation is called tothe Board’s hotic ‘e, “Besides, there
“are compelling constitutional and statutory reasons why
{406(a)(1) should not be vitiated by any such considera-
tions of administrative convenience. ae *2

(a) “Rules of comits or convenience must give way
to constitutional righis’ * (Oklakoma Natural: Gas Co. v.
“Russell, 261 U. S. 240, 293). Section 406(a) (i) Was oe
enacted to serve the Board’s convenience. It was exsen-
tial to save the Act: from unconstitutionality. As the sir-’
‘lines. were compelled to carry the mails, of course they
“were entitled to just “compensation.**
__ The Board says that ‘‘a ‘rate is constitutionally adequate
. fait affords a carrier an opportunity to earn a fair return”

* Historically the’ “Gevernment has been able to recover past
over-payments of mail pay, no matter “how long a time elapsed before
the error in making the overpayment. was discovered or “how lotig
the attempt to recover it was deferred” (Grand Trunk Western Ry
Co. v. U. §.,.252 U.S. 112, 121). See = U.S. v. Carr, 122 U. S.
644; Wisconsin Central Ra. Cov. US. WARS. Wy |

** The opinion below states. that only the que stion of power was
Faised below (112). Thar is incorrect; the question of constitu
“tionality” Was also raised in both TWA’s main and reply briefs.

“3

50 | | : |

(S&).° That” is true dake when the ‘cate is initially set—
when it is in the prophecy’ stage. When it ceases to: be
-ad@quate in Tact, it ceases to be constitutionally adequate,

-as U.S. v. New York Central Rd. Co., 279 U.S. 735 shows:

A confiscatory rate does not cease to be confisecatory
beeause it- takes time.1 ror the Board, or the airline affected,

fully to appreciate the fact. Indeed, we have already scen
_ (pp. 21-22) that it is. impossible for an airline to file its
petition immediately even when it knows the facts. Hence,

unless the Board has the power claimed, a part of-the air-—
lines’ constitutional rights is left unprotected. Plainly

.. an interpretation of the Act should net be reached.

U. New York Central Rd. Co., 279 U, S. 73 792°"
at The purposes of the Act, moreovety transcend” con-

siderations Sf administrative convenience. Congress im-

posed on the Board the*‘obligation . . ..to see to. it that
the rates’? paid by the Postmaster Gad “are at all —
times stflictent to erable the earriers to.accomplish and

* The: Board relied on pitti utility’ cases (69-10). In theory
exactly the same principle applies to public utility rates. ‘ Oklahoma
Natural Gas Co:.y. Russell, 261,U. 8. 290, 293. Manifestly, ‘how-
ever, it would be unjust to impose the burden of past losses on those‘
future customers of the utility who‘ did not receive. the benefit of
the unduly low past rates. And, as already seen, for practi¢al rea-
sons public utility rates cannot -be retroactively incréased when ex-
perience proves thenr to: be inadequate. Hence there is no way to
et oct such a retatiactive increase in the.case of public utilities. “The
& ons stipaeatr® ‘as a continuously operating charter of government does
not demand the impossible or the impractical” Pierabayashs et 34
320 U. S. 81, 104; Bowles y. W llingham., 321 U. 503, 515).

* Und mbtedly. constitutional rights can be cated But failure to.
hile a tage for an increase in rates is not a waiver as a matter of
law. See Macon, Dublin & Savannah Rd. Cé.v- TS, 23.0.0
ere ine p. B..arote *; lluska Airlines, Inc., Order. No, E-1885
“Aug. 13; 1948).

maintain those purposes’? (American Airlines, , Ine a
Rate Proceeding, 3 C. A. B. 323, 330). It regarded the
fostering of a strong comme r¢ial aviation industry as vital
‘to national. defense and polity. Mail pay was the device
used by the airlines in fulfilling that purpose. |

A earrier cannot properly attain: that legislative gasil
when its financial strength has been, impaired. because
events have-belied the Board’s rate prophecies. The Board

must be able to afford the full relief needed to make good

the impairment. . We submit that the Act -confers on thie
Board full power to effectuate the purposes.of Congress,
“and that the result below flies i in the face of the clear words
of the viarety ots

¢ . CONCLUSION *

The petition for a writ of certiorari should be granted.

Respectf ully's ubmitted,

seat GekaLp B. Bropuy,
Attorney for Petitione ,,:
¥ 7 25 Broadway,
‘e | New York 4, N. Y.

Crappourner, Wauiacr, Parke & Wuiresive,
20 Broadway, . |
New York 4, N. >
of Counsel. | 5

Dated: New York, N. Y., October 29, 1948.

APPENDIX A |
a . Relevant Statutory Provisions
Railway Mail Pay Act of 1916

39 Stat. 425, 39 U. S. C. §§ 524-579 48 Stat. 933, 49 Stat. 616

Declaration of Policy

None None.

Air Mail Acts of 1934 and 1935

‘Service,

Civil Aeronautics Act of 1938
52 Stat. 977, 49 U. S. C. §§ 401-691

‘Sh

DECLARATION OF PoLiIcy

See. 2 (52 Stat. 980, 49 U.S. C.
§402) In the exercise and perform-

~ ance of its powers and duties under

this Act, the Authorrty shall con-

‘sider the following, among other

things, as being in the publie in-
terest, and in accordane e with the
public | convenience and necessity—

(a). The encouragement and de-
Ree sone -of an air-transportation
system properly adapted to- the
present and future needs of the
foreign and domestic commerce of
the United’ States, of the Postal
and of the national’ de-
fense; a

(b) The regulation of air trans-

‘portation in such manner as to rec-

ognize and preserve the inherent

- advantages of, assure the highest -

degree of. safety in, and foster
sound economic conditions in, such
transportation, and to improve the

relations between, and coordinate .

transportation by, air carriers;

@

GV

*

Railway Mail Pay Act of 1916

- 39 Stat. 425, 39 U. S. C. §§ 524-579

s

™

Air Mail Acts of 1934 and 1935
48 Stat. 933, 49 Stat. .616

Civil Aercnautics Act of 1938
52 Stat. 977, 49 U. S. C. §§ 40T-691 :

(c) The promotion of adequate,
economical, and efficient service by
air carriers at reasonable charges,
without unjust: discriminations, un-
due preferences or advantages, or
unfair or destructive competitive
practices;

(d) Competition to the. extent
necessary to’ assure ‘the sound de-
velopment of an air-transportation
system “properly adapted to the
needs of the, foreign and domestie
commerce of the United States, of
the Postal Service, and of the na-
tional defense; ;

(e) The regulation of air com-
merece in such’ manner as to best
promote its development and
safety; and

(f) The encouragement and de-
velopment, of civil areonauties.

Sec. 5, subd. 27 (39 Stat. 429, 39
tT. 8s. c. 9541) _ All railway comman

et ea we bes ares eanven ee. retey No air carrier
shall abandon any route, or part
thereof, for which a certificate has °
been issued by the Authority, un-

less, upon the applic: ition of such

air carrier, after notice and hearing, °
the Authority shall find such aban-
donment. to be:in the publie inter-
est. Any interested person may file.
with the Authority a protest or,
memorandum of opposition to or in
support of any, such abandonment.

The Authority may, by regulations
or otherwise, ntithorize such tem-
porary suspension of service as may
be i in the public interest.

TENDER or Mam

995, 49.
U.S. C. $485(¢)) From and after
the issuance of any certificate au-
thorizing the transportation of mail
by aircraft, the Postmaster General
shall tender mail. to- the holder

Bt Bl

Railway Mail Pay Act of 1916. Air Mail Acts of 1934 and 1935 Civil Aeronautics Act of 1938
39 Stat. 435, 38 U. S. C. §§ 524-579 48 Stat. 933, 49 Stat. 616 52 Stat. 977, 49 U. S.C. §§ 401-691

thereof, to the extent required by

, the Postal Service, for transporta-
“tion between the points named ih
such ce ‘rtificate for the transporta-
Oe replies eee te pe ete. tion _of ‘mail, and such mail shall be
ae Te ee ee : _ transported tiv the Tir earHer bold.
* —~— eet ing such certificate in’ awecordance
| 3 with such rules, regulations, and re-

gotcha, . quirements as maybe premulgated
af, eae . es "by the Postmaster General under
. ; ~ . this section. . roe

“e

SaFeTy AND PostaL OrreENSES
See. 901(a) (52 Stat. 1015, 49
U.S. C.-62F (a)) Any person who

‘violates (1) any provision of titles -

V, VI, and V II of this Act, or any
provision of subsection (a) (1) of
section 11 of the Air Commerce Act
; a | of 1926, as amended, or (2) any
&b . : 7 . ‘ | rule or regulation issued by- the
i » . Postmaster General under this Act,
es) shall be subject to a civil penalty of
: not to exceed $1,000 for each such
‘violation. Any such penalty may
a eer ; nn: be compromised by the Authority or
, ’ ; Ge - the Postrhaster General, as the case
ek : may be. The amount of such pen-

a exe a | . alty, when finally determined,
; the amount agreed upon in com-

promise,,. | be deducted from any
sTaTEDss ow inear by the United States to

tV

(‘niMinalr. Penarrins. CGiexenat.

See. M2 (a) (52 Stat. OLS, 49

. . sy UL S.C. (622(a)) Any person who

Boe es | “knowingly and willfully violates any

ae provision of this Act (except titles

V, VI, and VIE), or any order, rule,

or regulation issued under any such

provision or any term, condition, or

limitation of any certificate or per-

mit issued ‘under tithe IV , for which

no penalty is otherwise-herein pro- .
vided, shall be deemed guilty of a
misdemeonor and tponm convietion
_thereofpshall be subject for the first,

See. 5, subd. 10 (39 Stat. 427, 39°

U. S. (. $565). The Postmaster

Gieneral is authorized to make spec-

ial contracts with the railroad com-
panies for the transportation of the
mails where his judgment the
coriditions warrant the .application
of higber rates than those herein
specified, and make report: to Con-

gress of all cases where such special °

Authorization to Award
Mail Contracts

Sec. 3(a) (48 Stat. 933). The

Postmaster General is authorized to
award contracts for the transpor-:

tation of air mail by airplane be-
tween such points as he may desig-
nate, and for initial periods of -not
exceeding one year,® to the lowest

* W are “one vear” changed to “three
years” by ame ndment of August ‘14, 1935
(49 Stat. 616).

may be.

——_——— oo

of 1926, ¢ as amended, or (2 ») any

rule or regulation issued byt the
Postriaster General under this \Act,
shall be subject to a civil penalty of
not to exceed $1,000 for each-such
violation. Any such penalty may
be compromised by the Authority or
the Postmaster General, as the case
The ameunt of such - n-
alty, when finally determined,

the amount agreed upon in nse

promise, may be deducted from any
UD TED SS, owing by the Unite ad States ms to

t Bax rer e-reeven «*Bnee e-srer space, or

“establish Iyy orale ' a fair,

| .
See. 5. subd. 28 (89 Stats 429, 39,

WS. C. §542) The Interstate Com-

merce Commission is -hereby @m-
powered and directed to fix and de>
termine from: time toxtime the fair
and reasonabie rates and compen-

sation for the transportation of

such mail matter 1h railway com-
mon. be gic end and t 1c service con-

—_~ ity i. seater bet ease Fie

method or methods by weight, or
both, or otheBwise, for

ascertaining such rate or Compensa-

tion; and to publish the same, and

orders so made and published shall
—_ continue in’ foree-until eh: invedgby

_the commission after due hotice and .

hearing. . | oe

See, WW subd. DOCeY (39 Stat. 450,
BOUL SL GS 551) At the conclusion
of the ie iving the Commission shall
reasonable

‘otherwise, for
rates of compensation, and to pub-.

“Commisston

"Air Mail Acts of 1934-and 1935
48 Stat. 933, 49 Stai. 616

ere Commission may preseribe,
which shall be consistent -with the
requirements of this Act; but: any

contract so continued an effect niay -

be terminated by the said Commis-
sion upon sixty days’ notice, upon
such: hearing and notice thereof: to
interested parties as the Commis-
ston may determine to be reason-
able; and may also be terminated
by the contractor at its option upon
sixty days’ notice. On the termina-
tion of any air-mail contract,
cordance with any of the provisions
of. this of

such mail matter ny railway com-
AEASORS ee. rr ie = and the S@ 2° Vv ie 2 ¢ —ea* :

wee t Race eres wit bes pararrads a RP et wage t bax

method or methods ‘by weight, or
space, or both, or otherwise, for
ascertaining: such rate or compensa-
tion, and to publish the same, and
orders so made and published shalt

continue in force until changed by

the commission atter due notice and
heart ing. ;

See. mi Pesos BO(@) (59 Stat..430,
At the conclusion
of the ohes the Commission shall
establish by order a fair,
rate or compensation to be received,
at such stated times as may be
named in the order, for the trans-
portation of mail matter and the

service Connected therewith, and

during the continuance of the order
the Postmaster General shall Spay

+ the carrier from*the appropriation

for inland, transportation by rail-
road routes such rate or " compensa-
tion.

‘s

See. 3 (39 Stat. 425). That on ac-
count of the increased weight of
mails resulting from Postmaster

reasonable.

_ Power to Fix Rates From an
Effective Date

See.6 (a) (48 Stat. 935) The In-

terstate; Commerce Commission is
hereby empowered and ‘directed,
after notice and hearing, to fix and
determine by order, as soon as prae-
ticable and from time to time, the
fair and reasohable rates of com-
‘pensation [within the limitations of
this Ac a¢ tg for the transportation of

suite wee Bane sel i

s
.

connected therewith over each air-
mail route, [but not in excess of

the rates provided for in-this Act, | +:

{and over each section thereof cov-
ered by a separate contract,|*
preseribing the method or methods
by weight or space, or both, or
otherwise, for aseertaining such
rates of compensation, and to pub-
lish the same, which shall continue
in foree until -chinged by the said
Commission after due notice: and
hearing, [and so much of subsection
(¢) of section 3 of this Aet as is in
conflict with this section Ys re-
pealed. *,

© Pencketed words added by amend;
ment of August 14,1955 (49 Stat.-616)

+ Bracketed words deleted -by amend-
ment of August 14, 1933 (49 Stat. 616).

Express Power to Make Retroactive

Adjustments in Specific Situations

Sec. 6(c) (49 Stat. 617) Any ecen-
tract (1) let, extended, or assigned
pursuant to the provisious of ‘this

AvutTHuority: To Fix Rates

Sec. 406 (a) (52 Stat. 998, 49
U.S.C. $486 (a) The Authority is

empowered and directed,. upon its

own initiative or upon petition -of
the Postmaster General or an air

_earrier, (1) to fix and determine
afte ot notice vend
eFate

from time to time,
Pe ee ee @ Dees Poets

ee ee oe |

/ pates of Compensation for the trans

portation of mail by aircraft, the
facilities used and useful therefor,

and the services connected there-

with (includitig the transportation
of mail by aw air carrier by other

means than aircraft whenever such,

transportation is incidental to the
transportatian of mail by aitcratt
or is made necessary by conditions
of emergency arising from ‘alreratt
operation), hy each holder of a’eer-
tificate authorizing the transporta-

tion of mail by aireraft, and to make.

such rates effective from such date
. it shall determine to be proper;

~) to preser ibe the method or meih- :

a by aireraft-mile, pound-mile,
weight, space, or any combénation
thereof, or otherwise, for ascertain-
ing such rates of compensation for
each air carriezlor,elass of air ear-
riers; and-(3) to publish the. same;
and the ratés so fixed. and deter-

‘mined shalt’ be: paid by the Post-

master General from. appropria-

tions forthe transportafion of mail.

by aireraft. ;

t

‘See Seetion 406(a)(1) (supra, pp.
AS. AQ),

;

OLV

Railway Mail Pay Act of 1916

39 Stat. 425, 39 U. S. C. §§ 524-579

General’s-order numbered: seventy-
seven hundred and twefity, of De
cember eighteenth, nineteen hun-
dred and thirteen, respecting’ rates

“upon and, limit of weight of pareel-
post packages,, effective fron Jan-

uary first, nineteen hundred aid

_ fourteen, the Postmaster General is

authoyized to add to the Compensa-
tion paid for transportation on rail-
road routes on and after January
first, nineteen hundred and
teen, for the remainder of the con-
tract terms, not exceeding one per

-centum thereof per annum.

Stat. 425) That on ae-
increased weight of
from Postmaster
General’s order numbered seventy-
three hundred avid forty- nine, of
July twenty-fifth, nineteen hundred
and thirteen, respecting rates upon
the limit of weight of parcel-post
packages in the loeal, first, and see-
ond zones, and effective from Au-
gust.fifteenth, nineteen hundred and
thirteen, the Postmaster General is
authorized to add to the compensa-
tion paid for transportation on rail-

road routes on and after August fif-
teenth, nineteen hundred ind thir

Raresus, Pave tQbeee saceensetesels erat tVeee craves

See. 4 (39
count of the
mails resultmg

tract te rimns,gnot excee clings one-half

of one per ceytum théreof per

num.
See. 5, Subd. 1 (39 Stat. 425) That
the Postmaster General is author-
ized and directed to readjust the
compensation to be paid to railroad
companies from and after the thir-
tieth day of June, nineteen hundred

and Bcoe thee

430,

of [the Railway Mail Pay Act] the
Intestate Commerce Commission is
hereby vested with all the powers

whic h it is authorized by\law to ex-

ercise jn the investigation and vest

cértainment of the justhess and rea
sonableness of freight, passenger,

and express rates to be paid by pri-

vate shippers.

q

' Thents,

disregard losses

airmail transportation, the
mission shall vive
the amount of air

| (‘orn
cotisideration to
mail so carried,

the factities suppled by the carrier,

and its revenue and profits from all
sources, and from’ acconsideratton
of these and. other material ele-
shall ‘tix and establish rates
for each route which, in connection
with the rates fixed by it for

other routes, shall be designed to
keccecpe theee sepeareacsreater cent cof Chee tesennns

air tnail em ame) after
July 1, 1958, within the limits of
the anticipated postal revenue
therefrom. [In arriving at such de-
termination the Commission shall
resulting, in. the
opinion of the Commission, from the
unprofitable maintenance of non-

prortation aot

mal schedules, in cases where the’

Commission may. find that-the gross
receipts from such schedules fail to
meet the additional- operating ex-
pense occasioned thereby. In fixing
and
shall be contended or alleged by the

~holder of an air-mail contract that |

the rate of compe nsation im foree
for: the service Involyed is insuffi-
cient, the burden .of establishing
such ‘insufficiency aml the extent
thereof shall be assumed by him.
In no case shall the rates fixed and
determined by the said Commission
hereunder exceed thé: limits) pre-
seribed (in section 3(a) of this
Act. 7
added by. amend-
135 (49 Stat.

° Br: ic keted . ewords
ment of August 14,

acters, thiee

. Copmstaherations, mrneoryes other

determining such rates, if it.,

616).

UL S.C. 486(b)),
termining fair and reasonable rites
of compensatio& under this sectlon,
the Authority,
ditions peculiar to transportation
by. aireraft and to the particular
air carrier or chtss of air carriers,

may fix different rates for different.

air carriers or Classes .of air ear-
riers, nnd different classes of serv-
ice. In determining the rate im each
Neattrese ity: sberadl traleer inafas

factors,
the condition that such air carriers
may hold and operate under certi-

In fixing and de-.

conside ring the Curt -

ficates authorizing the carriage of ~

mail only by providing. necessary
and adequate facilities and service
for the transportation of mail; such
standards respecting the . . " °
- - + 2 : o -
s . . : . : ‘ - . . ‘ ; 7 p
> a ‘ a } ‘ P : ‘ e

companies or has purchased such
goods and services from any com.

pany or corporations in which any
of the individuals employed bv oy

owning? stock in the alz-mail ceon-
tracting company have any interest
or from which such purchases or
rents any of the employees or stoek-
holders of air-mail contracting ¢om.
panies would be direetly or
rectly benefited. Within thirty diay 8
after a decision has beén reached
upon such review by the Interstate
Commerce -Commission touching

such en a full report thereof
shall omancee to ‘the Postmaster

indi-.

5

None
Griffin, 303 U.S

99

.

{See United

6.]

States

Cdeoonme om ie ter thee Heeretary «of t Bae
‘United States Senate, and to the

Clerk of the House of mopeosenta-
tives.

Requirement That Carrier -
Estimate Fair Rate

None

. Judicial Review of Rate Orders

_ the fixing’ of, fair

STATEMENT OF PosTMASTER GENERAL ©

‘ AND CARRIER
See. 406(c) (52 Stat. 998, 49

U.S. €. §486(e)). Any petition for

and reasonable

rates of compensation under this.

“section shall include a statemént of

the rate the petitioner believes to
be fair and-reasonabje. The Post-
master General shall introduce as
part of the record in all. proceed-
ings under this section a compre-
hensive statement of all service to
be required of the air carrier and

-such other information in his pos-

session as may be deemed” by the
Authority to he material to the in-
quiry.

Orpers or AttTuority SuBJECT
a To Review ;
See. 1L006(a) (52 Stat. 1024, 49-
U.S. C. $646) Any order, affirm-
ative or negative, Issued by the Au-
thority under this Act, except any

order in respect of any foreign air

SIV.

Railway Mail Pay Act of 1916
39 Stat. 425, 39 U. S. C. §§ 524-579

Air Mail Acts of. 1934 and 1935
48 Stat. 933, 49 Stat. 616

a.

\

te) a
."
*%

Civil Aeronautics Act of 1938
52 Stat. 977, 49 U: S. C. §§ 401-691 |

carrier subject to the approval of
the President as provided in section
S01 of this Act, shall be subject to
review by the cireuit courts of ap-
peals of the Enited States‘or the
United States Court of Appealsfor
the Distriet/of Columbia Upon per
tition, filed within sixty days after
the entry of such order, by any per-
son disclosing a substantial interest
in such order. After the expiration
of said sixty days a petition may be
filed only by leave of court upon a
showing of reasonable grounds for
failure to-file-the petition thereto-
fore.

VENUE

(b). A petition under this section
shall be filed in the. court for the
circuit wherein the petitioner re-
sides or has his principal place of
business or in the United States
Court of Appeals for the District
of Columbia. |

Novice or AvtTuority; Finine’

| OF 'PRANSCRIPT

(c) A copy of the petition shall,
upon filing? be forthwith trans-.
mitted to.the Authority .by the clerk

the: court: sergl thre MNertheorits
” 5 > la ‘@
shall fhereupon certify and file in
the court a transcript of the record,
if any, upon which the order com-
plained of was entered.

Power OF Court
(d) Upon transmittal of the pe-
tition to the Authority, the court
shall have exclusive jurisdiction .to-
affirm, modify, or set aside thie or-
der complained of, in whole or in
mf neal he ta order ‘fir

yr “)

)

OlV

(b)- A petition under this section
shall be filed in the court for the
cireuit. wherein the petitioner re:
sides or has his principal place of
business or in the United States’-
Court of Appeals for. the District
of Columbia,

sNovice of Atrnoriry:—Fuiss
oF TRANSCRIPT. +
(ec) A copy of the petition shall,

upen filing, be ferthwith trans-—
mitted to the Authority by the-elerk

eo thie) ccotart ; seneed tee Narthronrits

shill there pom certify ame file in

“the court a transcript of the record,

if any, upon which the order com-

plained of was entered.

Power oF Court

(d) Upon transmittal of -the pe-
tition to. the Authority, the court
shall have exclusive jurisdiction to
affirm, modify, or set aside the or-
der complained of, in whole or -in
part, and if need be, to order fur-
ther proceedings by the Authority.
Upon good cause shown, interlocu-
tory relief may be granted by stay
of the order-or by such mandatory
or other relief as may be appro-
priate: Provided, That no interloc-
utory. relief may be granted except
upon at least five davs’ notice to
the Authority.

FINDINGS or Facr py AUTHORITY
(‘ONCLUSIVE: .

(¢) -The findings of facts by thc

- Authority, if supported by substan-

tial evidence, shall be conclusive.
No objection to an order of the Au-
thority shall be gonsidered by the
court unless such objection’ shall
have been urged before the. Author-
itv or, if It was not so urged, unless
there weré reasonable grounds for’
failure to do so.

Railway Mail Pay Act of 1916 —-—« Air Mail Acts of 1934 and 1935

39 Stat. 425, 39 U. S. C. §§ 524-579 48 Stat. 933, 49 Stat: 616

Civil Aeronautics Act of 1938
52 Stat: 977, 49 U. S. C. §§ 401-691

CERTIFICATION OR CERTIORARI

(f).The judgment and decree of
the court. affirming, modifying, or

“setting aside any such order of the

Authority shall be subject only to

review by the Supreme Court of the.
‘United States upon certification or

certiorari as provided in sections

239 and 240 of the Judicial Code.

Note: The Authority is now known as
the Board. |

?

=

A21
Other Relevant Provisions of the Civil Aeronautics ‘>t

NOTICE OF Tarirr CHANGE

_ See. 403(¢) (52 Stat. 993, 49 UL S.C. A483 ( (¢)).2 No change

‘shall be made in any rate, fare, or charge, or any classifi-

cation, rulé, regulation or practice: affecting such rate,
fare or charge or the value of the service thereunder spe-
cified in,any effegtive tariff of any air carrier or foreign

- air carrier, except after:thirty days’ notice of the proposed

change filed, vosted, and publishe di in ac cordance witli sub-
section (a) of this section. Such notice shall plaitily state
the change proposed to be miade and the time such change
will take effect. The Authority may in the public interest,
by regulation or otherwise, allow such change ‘upon notice.
less than that herein specified, or.modify the requirements
of this séction with respect to filing and posting of tariffs,
either in particular instances or by general order applicable
to special or, ‘peculiar circumstances or conditions.

e)

pares TO hana Rares AND Practices ny AIR CARRIERS .

See. 1002(d) (52 Stat. 1018, 49 U. S. C. 642(d)).- When-
ever, after notice and liearing, upon complaint, or upon its
own initiative, the Authority shall be of the opinion that
any” individual or joint rate, fare, or charge demanded,
charged, collected or received by any air carrier for inter-.
state or overseas, air transportation, or any classification,
rule, regulation, or practice affecting such rate, fare, or
charge, or the value of the service thereunder, is or will be

unjust or unreasonable or unjustly discriminatory, or-un-
. : .

referential, or unduly prejudicial, the Authority shall”
‘mine and prescribe the lawful rate, fare, or charge (or

*.

id F ’
7 ” : ' ee aia “ . . > ‘

the: maximum, wr sminixgam, or the ‘maxinium and minimum: |
thereof) thereafter: to he demanded, charged, collected, or |

practice theres ufter to be: made plfertive Provided, That

aus to rates, fares, and charges ‘for overseas air transporta- ‘

tion,.the Authority shall determine and pr rescribe only a

2 received, or. the’ “awful: classification, rate, regulation or

just -and reasonable. maximum or minimum or maxinium

and. thinimum rate, fare;-o or: : charge. - oe ou

Sim ‘ Ree OF Rare Maxrxa

Gea. “tperte) (52 Stat. 1018, 49 WS... 6642(e))s_ “In ex-
ereising and’ performing its powers and duties with respect —

to the determination’ of rates for the: carriage of persons:
or property, the Authority shall’ take into: consideration,

* among other factors— eet es a oF
ni t 1) The effect of such raites: Upor the movement

(2) The ed in phe public interest OF adequate
and ethiciont transportation, of persons and property

_bysair carriers at the lowest cost consistent with the .

furnishing of” such service; @ «

-

a A ‘ e e
. °

a

quality of: service to be rendered by air carriers as
may be prescribed by or. pursuant to law;

(4) The inherent advantages. of transportation.
by "aircraft ; and i > ey

9 .
(5) The ‘need of each air “atten Tora revenue

(3) Such standards respecting the character and ;

sufficie ‘nt ‘to enable ‘such airsearrier, under honest, - ~

‘economical, and bfficient management, ‘to . provide
adequate and effici ienit air carrier. service.

” . Pa *

>
,

>

; , b
“Pow ER TO p RESC RIBE Divisions or Rates

ae. 1002(h) 2 stations, 49 US. C.5642(h)).. Whien-
ever, after. notice and he ‘aring, upon complaint or upon. its
own initiative, thé Authority is of the opinion that the divi-
sions of joint, rates, fares, or charges for air transportation
are or will be unjust, unreasonable, inequitable, or unduly
preferential or. prejudicial as between the air carriers or
_ foreign air carriers parties thereto, the Authority shall
_ prescribe the just, reasonable, -and* equitable divisions
* thereof to be received . by \thie ‘several alr carriers. The
Authorjty. may require the Adjustment of divisions between

“such air carriers from the. date of filing the complaint or

entry of order of investigation, or such other date subse-
quent thereto as the Authority. finds to be just,. reasonable,
_ a eae

4 .
\.
i ;
\° ‘
¥ pee \ s; ctiee
nd \ an eco
2» oe ’
1 best : hee
) Pak ae
‘
, Rhos ad
a
. Vv
a x
ae a ; eS}
ae

rs

rt Bl

.

" APPENDIX seis aiac ttle
> The Board’s previous exercise of power to set rates

troactively as of a date prior to the institution of a rate
P ceding. SE Year oes, ie

» 4 *

lu-this Appendix we shall reyjew the proceedings in
which the Beard lias recognized or exercised the‘ power to.

change rates retrospectively to a date prior to'the intsti-

9

tution of a irate pr oceeding.* Cee eo

ae A. The New Route Cases”

Occ dinate an airline has begun operating a new rotte
without filing a rate petition. . In such cases the Boz

and made
‘its final rate. retroactive to the time when opel itions started.
All American Av iatic i, Inc., Mail Rate for Route No. 49;
°3 C. 4. B. 79 (route operated 4 months before proceeding

gotie back of the date,when the petition was fil

begun); United Air Lines Transport ,Corp., Nail Rate for.

Itoute No. 57, 3 C. A. B. 381 (route operated.9 days before
proceeding begun); Pacific Alaska Airways, i et ‘al.,
Alaska Mai Rates, 6 C. A. B.-61 (route opera

before ceding. begun) ; Carihbean- Atlantic: Airlines,

“* Of course a “temporary” rate is frequently incest retro-
actively to a ri prior’to the institution of the proceeding brought
~ change that rate. See, ¢.g., Northwest Aivlines,-Inc., Order No.

E-721, July 29,1947; Florida Airways, Inc., Order No: E-765, Aug.
19, 194%; Monarch Air Lines, Inc.,;Order No. E-898, Oct. 20, 1947;

Empire Air Lines, Inc,, Order Xo. E-896, Oct. 20, 1947; Florida
Airways, Inc., Order No. E897, Oct. 20,1947; Southwest Airways
Co., Order No. E-899, Oct. 20), 1947; Chicago & Seuthern Air Lines,
Inc., Order No. E+1096, Jan. 5, 1948. In its opinion-last adjusting
TWA\'s domestic rates, the Board said it was establishing a “tentative
rate” (Transcontinental & Western Air, Inc., Mail Rates, 6 €. A. Bu

595, 602), but the magic word “tentative” or “témporary”: did not i

appgat in the order.

Woe
Eek | g

,

o4 a .

»

os

ae a Sayeine ae : . a

Inc., Mail Rates, 6 C, A. By 407 (route Copirinted 27 months

before proc ‘eeding eins Pioncer Air Lines rae. arti

Ratés, 8¢Gs. A. B. 175 (route operate ed 20 day's before “- ~

ceeding begun). — 7 ae
The Board- tried t- justify this cee gn the ground of

neces ssity. ‘*Obv iously when anew operation is commenced |

.

the question | of mail compensation. for that operation from |
its commengement must be decided?’ (81-82). Of course
some procedure for: affording Pie : airline full. compensation *
must exist. But it is equally obvious, however; that such
a. procedure does exist In new route cases, Without conjur-
ing up some special power to set rates prior tothe time when. .
a petition is filed. All the airline’ need do, to get full relief,
is to. file a petition when it starts operatfons. Indeed, it
can petition for a rate even before it has begun to operate.”
The Board’s attempt to distinguish the new route cases of
the ground of supposed necessity-:is utterly unsound.
The Board then noted that new route cases involve ‘‘no
“question of the retroactiye revision of a final rate, since no
rate at all was in effect for the new routes’’ (82, footnote
32): Recently it recognized that this position was too broad,
and that it makes no difference that ‘‘no rate at.all was in
* See, C.J. Mid- Costiasus “Airlines, Inc Mail. Rate for Route ;
Va. 48, 2 C. A. B. 392; : Northwest geo Inc.—Mail. Rate Pro- +
coeding for Reute No. 45,2 C. A. B. ; Trans-Trxas Airways,
Order. No. E-900 (Oct. 20, 1947); Pac in dirlings, Iné., Beryiuda
Services Mail Rates, Order No, E-1143 (Jan, 26, 1048): Predmont
Aviation, Inc., Order No. E-1277 (Mar. 9, 1948). “permanent”
rate can be—and has been—fixed even before ory have begun.

See, ¢.g., Continental Air Lines, Ine—Mail Rates fdr Route No. 43,

1QA. A. 182, 189; _ American Airways Co, (of Delaware)--

Mail Rates, 1 C. A. A. 220, 258. More recently, gnly a temporary

tate has been established whe operations have not-yet started. “See,
_ e.g. Brant Airways, Iné., Ordet No, E-966-( Nov. 10, 1947).

oe

ee Bo f Lees

‘effect for the new routes. Moreover, the Act draws no

‘se

distinction between the Board's power to fix anew rate by

al rate’’ and its power to fix
eVvision is involved. In one case,
. the carrier is made whole by retrdactively increasing its

~ compet nsatidn from an: inadequate amount to a fair one; in.

the other, the increase is from another inadequate amount
—zero—to the same fair rate.

Indeed, the Act ‘does not talk about “final”? rates at’

all. There is no period during’ which a rate necessarily
will bé ‘final’? in the sense of being certain to remain in
vom unchanged. ..Untike the situati igsunder the Railway
Mail Pay. Act and the Air Mail Act, under which a.rate could
not be reexamined for six manths, there is ne period during
_ which the Beard’s mail rates are frozen and ineapable of
being changed. *For thie Act t per mits a new rate proceeding
to be instituted at any time. 4

Thus, on March 1 the Board may fix a prosnedtine rate,

based on evidence taken months before, to take effect on
Mareh 2 or some future date, Anyone is free to start a
new. proceering: on 1 March 2 to efféet a cliange in that rate.

2

“*1In Alaska Airlines, Ine, Order No. E-1885 ( Ave. 1, 1948),

a carrier Was operating star routés and. geceiving mail pay utider
coritracts with the Postmaster General. On September 4,-1945,- it
filed a petition to have the Board. fix-rates. Later it amended the

petition fo ask that rates be fixed as of January 1, 1945. By analogy, .

to the “new route” cases, the-Board held that it had power to grant
such retrospective relief. “The .fact that inthis case the carrier

received some compensatioss, while in the.new route cases there was °

‘po compensation, is not determinative of the real issue’ The im-
portant point is that in neither case was there a previously fixed rate

for the required service in.decdrdance with the standards of Section -

- 406" (p. 5). Because the “carrier waited such a long time to file
its petition” it imposed the burden of proof of inadequacy on it'(p. 6).

’

Prd

While that proceeding ix pending, and until the Board makes
a new order; mail compensation will be paid on the basis of
the prospective rate. Even the Board adinits, however,
that it has power in the new procevetyg’ to fix a different .-
rate. which will be retrospectively effective as of March. 2.
In that event the-accounts between the Post Office and the.
airline will be adjusted back to March 2. .. Thus the prospec-
tive rate fixed, on March 1, will never have .been** final’’ in
the sense of bbing immune.from revision fof any period of
a ae OS, ¢

Once a mai rate is fixed, therefore, it is-*‘final’’ only
in the sense that) w,
action of.the parties. In practice, that *‘finality’’ will con--
tinue if the Board is held to have the power to revise rates

ile it persists unchanged, it-controls the

\retrospectively back-of the filing date of a petition. Few
prospective rates willrequire such retroactive change. Rates
will be revised retroactively only.in appropriate cases of ©
need, when the Board’s prediction is’shown to hav€ been
substantialiy wide of the mark, A rate order will there-
fore be no more.and no less ‘‘final’’ than it is today, when
concédedly its’ supposed ‘“finality’’ can be destroyed: by
filing a petition the day after its issuance. ri

Apart from that, the Board has actually undertaken
revision of what it is pleased to call *‘final’’ rate orders.

B. The “Nunc Pro Tunc” Petition Device

In May 1942 the Armed Forces took over many of the

-air carriers’ planes, and severe restrictions on service were
imposed. To alleviate the resulting hardship, the Board”
issued two ‘*general memoranda’ to all airlines, which-are
set forth in full: in Appendix C, infra. In. the first,’ the
Board, calling attention to its nolicy of not making rates
effective prior to the institution of'a proceeding” (pp. C1-

=, : ; ‘ é .

_ BD

.

Ci, infra), sugge wind that it might institute. whew rate pro-
ceeding: on June 1, 1942, tor the benefit of carriers having
no such proceeding pending: The second me anorandumy ot
June 3, 1942, stated: ee
| ““The Board Will-not initiate new rate proceed-
ings as of Jane 1, 1942, as was stated in the Board’s~> . +
prev ae Consequently, it will be’
‘. .- necessary for any carrier Which does not row ilave .
-- avate proceeding pending but which wishes its rates
to be subject to review by the Board for the period
beginning June 1, 1942, to file a petition under Sec-
tion 406 of the Act requesting such review. The -
Board, will accept any such petition filed within’ the -
next.two weéks as being dated June 1; 1942, tf the ©
carrier canepraes so desires.’ vos

a

Perhaps the Board thought that in this fashion it could ©

,

pay lip service to its ‘‘policy’? while avoiding prejudice »
to any carrier whick had ‘withheld a_petition in the hope

that the, Board would start a*proceeding itself. But if the. —_

4b

Toe me Pe

a

BG

filed on Dee rember 26, 1941. On Seer es 15,. 1941, one of

‘the carrier's se hydules tad’ been discontinued by the Post

Office Department. This caused a reduction in. its: total

. mail compensation. In January 1942 the carrier asked that '

-its petition be amended so as to ‘ask an adjustment of the

rate as of December 15, 1941. The Board did | ot want thes =

earrier’s total mail compensation reduced. , * Hence it al-

lowed the amendment and then adjusted the:rate on the °
route upwards as of December 15 (p. 292). To-be sure, the .

earrier’s total mail conmpensation was not ‘substantially ”’
affected, but. the fact remains that the Board actually in-
creased the rate as of a date before the petition was actu-

ally filed, thus ¢ exercising pow er which it now “claims did not

exist.

~

° : .
‘ °

C. Retroactive “Reopening”. of “Final” Rate ‘Orders

: > “e ; - “oor ; .
In one of its earliest rate cases, the Board retroactively

increased a rate, long after it had become ‘final’, without

paying even lip service to its ‘general poliey.”’
on June 1939 certain transatlantic mail rates were estab-

lished, effective. May 20, 1939. Pan American Airways-Co. *.

{of Delaware )—Mail Rates; 1 C. A, A, 220. The order
set excess rates for loads over 1,600 pounds, ‘* provided
such trip shall have been compicted at least as far as
Foynes, Ireland or Lisbon, Portugal’? (p. 258). It was

—very clear -that excess rates were not allowed for mail
carried only as far as the Azores (pp. 257, 258). Eight

months ‘later the Board ‘‘reopened’’ the proceeding on its
own motion ‘‘toGetermine whether the rate of compensa-

tion being paid : . . for the transportation ‘between the
United States and . . .xthe Azores’? was fair ‘‘and in case.-
such rate should not ‘be found to be fair and reasonable,
a ee

—

the proceeding ¥ was “Teopened’ ’? and the rate ‘‘placed un-
"der general review” (6 C. A. B., at p. 92).* Then by an

* The earrier had previously filed a petition to reopen ‘the so
ceeding. It had been granted on November 25, 1942, but only “w
respect to certain limited issues,’ ’-and the proceeding had not been
reopened with respect. to the rate in question. The order of Feb-
ruary 28, 1944 (Serial No. 2326), recitéd “that review and possible* _
revision of the rate of compensation effective from‘and after Sep- —-
"tember 1; 1942 . .. is necessary” and that “review and revision of.
the rate previously fixed in this proceeding . . ..is not within the
- scope of the issues now pending. before the Board ptrsuant to its ,/
order of. November 25, 1942, reopening this proceeding,” and ex-
pressly ordered thit the proceeding be “reopened for the purpose of |
- sehearing, reargument and reconsideration with Tespect to the rate -
of compensation to be paid Pan American Airways, Inc. for the
transportation of mail ‘by aircraft on the Latin American routes
from and after September 1, 1942. bs

»

? i. . z aN . yr 2 TaN Ge tae Wr ace 5 SPS RIEL Peer mata hs Bike *
Op She PECTS ROA aI! DD hiss ery ees Le omeds Intalio ps Lv y ee e
- BS

2

rane of July 17, 1944, the’ Board reduced the mee to 13.2997
per. airplane mile, effective September 1, 1942.
If.the Board has wo power to revise rates retreact: i vely

_in a new proceeding, manifestly it cannot create that power

by the transparent device of éalling the new proceeding a
“reopening” of the old one, for **the subsequent proceed-

ing was, in efiect, a new proceeding which by reason of its

character invoked an auth8rity not possessed’’- (U.S. v.
Mayer, 235 U.S. 55, 70). See, e.g., Delaware, Lackawanna

; & Western Rd. Co. v. Rellstab, 276 U.S. 1, 4-5; Realty Ac-

ceptance Corp. v. Montgomery, 84 U. S. 547, 549, 992; In
re Metropolitan Trust Co., 218 U. S. 312, 320. Hence these
decisions necessarily recognized that the: Board has power

to change a rate retroactively as of a.time antedating the
‘proceeding instituted to effect that change.

?, ae
-D. The “System”. Cases Satan

1. Wasvng Air Lines, Inc.. Y .

~~

af

ee :
lene BLA is yt

‘ ,
Tat Se ON sce,

. EDS aera Se %,
OF ey AREA he eh SCORES, CY, OLLI HY

a

several times.
rates on the old routes-in a system is not at all mandatory

“hh
rs es -. » Blo.
Nee é > he: ee
compensation had been. ad. Th fie absence of hike»
unusual circumstances the Board will adhere to its
policy not to revitw rates prior ‘to the instifution of
a proceeding by petition or order.” ;

a 7

Actiaally the riew route did not ‘pecensitate” the Board’s :

action at all. The Board is able to tit rates ora ‘‘sy: stem’’

or over-all basis, rather than for each route, because ‘‘the -
Act does not require the maintenance of the route concept:’’* ©

But the Act does not require the ‘‘system’’ basis of rate-
making either. . The ‘Board has recognized that ‘“‘we may

fix a rate for a single route’ if_sueh a review indicates the .

necessity therefor’* (Transcontinental & Western Air, lae:,

Mail Rates, 4 C.cA. B. 139, 143), and has: done just that

sik Thus retroactive revision of the previous

merely because a new route is begun.

* Inland’ Air Lines, Inc—Mait Rates for Routes Nos. 28 and 35,

_3C. A. B, 491-492. See also, Eastern Air Lines; Inc., Mail Raté-

Proceedinys, 8 C. A. B. 733, 740; Penns ylvania-Centrl Airlines Corp.,
Mail Rates, 4 C. A: B. 22, 25.
** See, ¢.g., Mid-Continent Airlines, Ini. —Mail Rate for. Route’

No. 48, 2 C. A. B. 392, 393; Pan Amerigun Ajrways, Inc., Latin- |

American & Miami-Lé opoldville Seruices, Mail Rates, Order No.
E-738, July 24, 1947, p..12. Indeed, in certain cases the: Board
regards itself as constitutionally obligated to fix a rate for a “seg-
regated” route rather. than, he whole system. ‘Pacific Alaska Atr-
ways, Inc., et al., Alaska Meil’ Rates, 6 C. A. B. 61, 68.:

*4** Unquestionably the Board must ‘take into consideration the
airline’s revenue frorn other sources when fixing the amount_of,com-

pensation to be paid for a new route. [ut the airline must be paid -

some compensation for the additional service on that route. Pan:

American Airways -Co. (of De laware )— = Transatigntic ‘Mail Rates, .
1.C. A. A. 650, 652. The “rate of compensation cannot be less than —

the reasonable value of that se rvice; based on quantum meruit prin-
ciples. Pen American Airways Co. (of De laware )—Mail Rates, 1
C.-A. A. 220, 252.

—

Oe

i,

_

a

. F 7 : aoa : . ; ; | Bil

fe e

“If the Act confers no power to reduce tlie vinndidies rates |
at whiclran airline has been paid on certain routes, because - ees
those rates are ‘final,’ the Board canndt accomplish that ’
_result indireetly when the airline later begins -w hey’ route.
* Yet'that is ‘what it did ‘in the WwW ‘estern case. Nominally it
left the old rates oi the- system unchanged, and gaye the
airline nothing-for ¢ carrying mail oyer the new route. - Re- nace
__alistically, it reduced the compensation’ on the system re- ere

troactively back of thie date of the. petition, since’ the airline Mae

isa

received no miore mail. ‘pay although ‘iit rendered more mail

+. service. - ool
‘The. Board now says that the sichatiliaen in the
Western ‘case weres quite different. from those here, and

‘neither ‘the grounding of planes”’ nor “labor nape eo
‘are “particularly unusual’’ (82- 83, and footnote: 33). -

course there is nothing at all unusual about opening a a new
| route. But the argument completély qnisses- the} point.
°° Section 406( (a) (1) does not give tlie Board special power
wy “* where a’ carrier adds ‘a new route to its sy stem, or where .
*unusual’’ circumstances, arise. Its language is completely
general. Certainly it creates no hierarchy-of ‘‘unusual’’
ciréumstances, ‘drawing fine- -spun distinctions between one
‘‘unusual’”’ situation and another. If the. Board lacks power
‘to make a ‘retroactive revision of a fixed rate” on old
routes, it cannot. usurp that power just beeause a new-route —

has been inaugurated and it usually likes to set a rate for « i

an entire —_ Saree 2 ? ve
. ee aes be

Th the .W ee: case the old rate was nominally left
‘ ‘ eidictertibd. ‘Quite recently the Board: modified an old rate
in ‘terms as well as in fact.
The Board feels tig ‘the course of sahil rate cases will

be clarified and * expedited if . eBFoard could have in ad- '

vance such criticism, modification or ‘Amplification of hase :
suggestions as the carriers-deem warrantéd or desirable.

‘

WwW il you, therefore, please transmit twelve copies of any |
comuient of your company to the Board by May 29, 1942.
T he question of oral présentation of views is reserved for

a cohtsideration in the light of subsequent developments.

oA copy of this memorandum i is being sént to all counsel -
for the carriers.

7 ee : Pope: L. Wetcu Pocus
Ropes : pak L. Welch Pogue
eh Sates 4 Chairman —
. Attachment ‘ | roche . :

- ¢ .

2: it is uci ‘that, in so far- “as possible, for pro-
cedural purposes in connection: with mail rate cases, the
date of the changeover to the Kew service pattern be re-.
garded as having occurred on thd same date for all carriers

- and that such uniform daté be the last day of a month.
For this parpose May 31, 1942 is suggested.
wei ae "% = as
' 3. Because of the uncertainties inherent in the present -
situation and the period of time which ‘will ‘undoubtedly 4
be required to adjust. to the new se rvice pattern, it is not)
feasible to fix fair and reasonable rates for the future on
the information presenthy available or which will be avail:
able until the process of adjustment has been substantially :
completed. Therefore, all rates effective on and after the
date of the changeover to the new service pattern should be
temporary in character, and should be subject to review awd
adjustment as to such period as experience, may shew the _
necessity for adjustment after a reasonable period of time..
At the same time it is s considered desirable i in the case of all,

o -*

C8 ;

catyiers who now have rate proceedings “pending to fix as
rapidly as aepouans a final rate to be effective for all per iods
under .rev iéw up to the date of the changeover to-the new —
service pattern. :

>

4, F or ‘the: purposes of accomplishing the above objec-
tives, it is proposed in all pending rate cases of carriers
alfected by the new service pattern, including tlfose in which
show cause orders have already been issued, to fix a rate

. Which wil be final for all past ‘periods under review. down .
‘to May 31, 1942, and te porary for the period thereafter.
With respect to-all carriers who do not ‘now have a. rate
proceeding pending, it is proposed, im view of the Board’s
(policy of not making.rates. effectivé.prior to the institution
‘-of a proceeding, to issue an order instituting a proceeding
to'fix and determine the fair and reasonable rates for each
such carrier from and after the date of the changeover to
the new sery ice pattérn. It is the intention that this order
will bring into issue the rate presently being paid such car-
rier and: make such” rate for the’ period subsequent to June
1, 1942 subject to review and adjustment after sufficient Be
experience has been, accumulated. .

*

the carrier conce rned desires any, adjustment in this rate in.
the future, it will be necessary for it to file a petition in - is
_ the normal way.

The Board recognizes that in soosial instane es unusually’ 1a

5

expeditious treatment of rate proceedings will be necessary,
and it will do its utmost to ‘provide such tre: afment in those
cases. ae

_ A copy of this memorandum i is being sent to all counsel .
for the. carriers... a ; ;

Bre .

WEALD AD WEES

‘adapendaests

Civil Aeronautics Board -~, } os |
é 4 : .* ; : fi

ee

- June 3, 1942 |

PAIL AGRA MAMMALS PAE

ao
Rael dope AN

!
sr.
z ob fetes

-
.
wee
Pid Pe wigad CoeeAte sc

yo

Maddy Fhe ag el

oxy

-

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386406_0127%3A2. Public record. Not legal advice.
