# Brief for Jungersen — Jungersen v. Ostby & Barton Co.

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386406_0086%3A04

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Brief for Jungersen
- **Published:** January 1, 1949
- **Citation:** 335 U.S. 560

## Text

“LIBRARY: |
SUPREME COURT,US.

| Supreme Court of the Huited States

October Term, 1948 |

Nos. 7, 8 and 48

~

‘Tuoskn Gronperc JUNGERSE N,

Petitioner: Re ‘-sponde nt,
mie Vv.

fu>
°o

Ostspy anp Bartos Company, ef al.,

*

Respondents-Petitioners,

and
THOGER GRONBERG JUNGERSEN, :
Re eee: ; Petitioner,
. 7 .

?

Rosier BaDEN, Rose Baven, Arseat Foss, et al.,

*9

nigaties

SS ee ee

- BRIEF F on JUNGERSEN ©

*
WituiaMm H. Davis,
| Georce E. Farrarvtt,.
’ ioe Kart W. Frocks,
ee ane Attorneys for Jungersen.

New York, N.Y.
October 15, 1948.

e

»
_
‘ ~~
.

- ©

INDEX
PAGE.
Tue Opixioy: MME ac oy Cacen enn ; oY eneee- sh
JURISDICTION ® «04. : Nice wa ks zs . roe Peta Rekeees ;
STATEMENT ie al PO os nao ce eee .
‘The Parties ....... Sas eas oe uaa isi era mee:
The Jewelry Manufacturing Art rior to’ Jungersen 4:
1 he Story of the Jungersen i a ee emer an
The Junsorsen Patent :.... POT rere ues seen Pane
The Effect of Jungersen’ S : Method on Jewelry Man- |
ck, ab OT OT ee Corer yey erry eee i,
Karly Applications in “the. Fine Arts of the “Lost :
Wax’. | eee sree ter ee se eerr Te sae Ae
Sixteenth Century Treatises of Hetievenate Cel-
lini on ‘‘Goldsmithing and Sculpture’’ ...... 13 _
La Gravure publication bt) eee ee > ~
Cire Perdue Process (Enéyelopedia ia Brittanies, .
SE TR Vee MD. iva ties iecet cankaesnss> 16
Die Casting Practice’ , hy Mare Stern (1930). 17
~The Use: of the-*Lost Wax’?-Process in Dentistry. . W
Huseltine’s British Patent No. 2467, of 1875 ...... 18
: Spencer’ s Patent No. 748,996, of 1906 ..... 39
28 U. S. Code, See. Wks: err eitvess*- @
35 U.S. Code, See. 38-—R. S.See. 48a... Sataei 38

‘Supreme Court uf the Hnited ‘States

Oc Ti BER Term, 194%:

‘Mos. 7, 8 and 48

7

a oe
THOGER GRONBERG ,J UNGERSEN,
Petitioner-Respondent, .
Vv. ‘a , ;
Ostspy anp Barron Company, et al.,

Respondents-Petitioners, :
and |

THOGER Guownene 30 NGERSEN,

,

: es es! _ ZL

sen‘s method is a patentable invention, then the question
arises whether claims 5 and, 6: can and should be inter-
preted to embrace that invention (including recognized °
equivalents) and nothing more; and whether certain/of the «
alleged infringing operations are within the moriopoly. of
claims 5 and 6 HO interpreted,

Three writs of certiorari (C ases 7:°-8 and 48) ‘issued’
because of conflict in decisions of the Third Circuit Court
of Appeals and of. the Seeond Cireuit Court of Appeals.

Two writs (Cases 7 and 8): issued to the Third Circuit
Court of Appeals which affirmed in’a per curiam opinion
(378a*; 163 F. 24-312, Case 3) the decision of the New /
Jersey District Court (Meaney, D. J. 65 F. Supp. 653;/
22a) holding claims 1 to 4 valid and claims 5 and 6 inv -alid

* . because anticipated by Kralund patent No. 1,238,789. 1e

writ in No. 7 was issued on the petition of: the patentee

7 Jungersen for a |

I. poured: some wax into the opening. That was an

open mould, if F could express it that way, just like a_

. flat piece of rubber With a design of the pendant on the
‘one side. That was on one side. Then I poured the

wax in there and most jugt stuck | to the mould. ; a

wy

didn’ t get. far with it. ©

.
o

“Then I tried to squeeze it down with my fingers and

‘with a backirg first of plggt or of Paris, later of a piece:

-of type metal, and that di “work. J got fins all over
‘it and I couldn't. get the patterns out.

“Then I came to think about, well, if I pour.the wax
in from one end, if I could fill it that way, and I tried,
oand the wax did not: fill the piece all the way down.

Some place it filled fairly good, and some plaee it did

not. fill at all: Some place there was a very poor im-
pression, like there were on those pictures on that
exhibit.

“AeThen T discarded that. I,took-a cloth — from
approximately. an, eighth of an inch thick steel.”

- 8
— “Q. A coat hanger? A. Yes, one o&-these regular
coat. hangers, - srk

“*Q. Yes, - all right. A coat hanger. A..A coat
changer; and I made a little swing’ out of it and I took
it so I could Swing it with centrifugal foree, and then |
took an old.tin can and made myself a little crucible
out of this tin can and pointed the nozzle of the cruci-
ble into my mould.- Then I melted some wax and ©

poured it into my little crucible and swung it around,
and. that filled the mould with the finest interior that
you- could ever. wish. Then it was: just a question of
some of it may be a little too hot and some of,it may :
be a little too cold; and after yOu try it two or three
times, then yqu get them perfect’’ (77a, ff. 231-78a,
f. 234). | : | re
. e . oe ; e ys

After he had produced the wax-pattern in that way he
went .to ;‘a mechanical dentist * * * one who-had. been
casting for.different dentists in Toronto’? who was ‘‘very
' much interested. It turned out that this gentleman had
been a jeweler before, and he was most surprised to see |
what IL. was doing,- and he said that I could use his shop,
and I-did.’’* fit. the dentist’s shop he made his first casting
in meta} and took it down to.the jeweler. ‘‘I went. back
to Mr. Fremes and showed him the casting, and then he
said it was one of the finest castings he had ever. seen,
or the finest’? (78, ff. 233-4). He* proceeded to work at
this jewelry place ‘to develop it further.and make it a
. well workable. process’” (79a, f. 237). and took out patents
in Canada, the United States, Great Britain, and many —
other countries. . He eventually sold the Canadian patent
for $5,000 (82a, ff. 245-246) and. went on with the exploita- :
tion of hig patents in, other countries, - selling licenses’ in
the United States, England, .Sweden, * Norway, Finland, .
Germany, France, Belgium, Australia, India, Brazjl, Argen- °

tina, Java, etc. He issued somewhere between sixty and |

seventy licenses. in the United States (80, f. 238; SI, f. 242;

ae ey a ee, a i |
$2, f. 244). Fron LOBB te Ocetoher 16, 1945 ‘Sapproximately
~ $120,000"" in ‘royalties were colieeted of which $10,250 was

troni foreign licenses (Werner, 07a). 0 02 a

The Jungersen Patent —— ame ele, oe a mate
_ Jungersen’s method, as ‘described “and claimed in his

| patent, (185-187), ds. a" series of sixyprocess steps in, or-
dered sequence, as follows (185/1/28-2/54):

1.) Producing a model of the piece of jewelry or other .
small article ‘tin wood,. metal, or other suitable material;
and this may have undereut surfaces, hollows or perfora-

ee of any desirable kind”’ (185/1/30-32). ; : :
ase Nee am = setae ;
2. “Producing a Grimary mold by: building up- around

. the model a flexible mold-formiutg waterial such as rubber,

_and then vuleanizing to cause the rubber **to flow intimately
-about the detail structure of the model and thus assumes :

a permanent shape having a cavity the exact ‘shape and
detail of the model embedded therein’? (185/1/52-55), the:

flexible nature of the rubber permitting withdrawal. from
hollows, undereut portions and perforations (185/2/29-31).

od

3. Producing any desired number of dispensable patterns — «
(replicas of the niodel) ‘tofa very low: temperature fusing
- material which” may -be wax’ ora metallié alloy, such as
Wood’s inetal’? which is. melted: and forced into the pri--
inary mold.by centrifugal action.” The melted. wax or like
tnaterial ‘‘is‘poured into the gate and the mold is rotated
rapidly in the centrifugal casting machine. ‘The wax or
metal is thus foreed into the mould and by the centrifugal
‘action displaces the air within the mould, the molten ma-
terial congealing first against ‘the exposed surfaces of the
cavity formed in‘ the ‘mould and any air which may be |
trapped in a-recess of the mould wil) be crowded back into_
the fluid body under the pressury applied thereto and the .—
“ fluid material wit] advanee into the recess as.it crowds the

« Oe

’ .?

e .
A; * : m . ee

10 cae,

air therefrom and will progressively ‘congeal against the
wall of the recess. until ‘the extreme limit is reached.so that

_ the finest of cavities will be completely filled. It is essen-
tial that thé air be expelled from the’ mould progressively

as the molten material flows in so that all interstices
whéther undereut or otherwise, are completely filled’?

alae! ae) BG bbe ene

‘4. Produciig any desirable panier of secondary. cast-

~— dng molds’ by. pouring around the dispensable patterns a-

“fluid mixtire of water ’ and a mold-forming investment. .
material. such as plaster: of Paris (185 /2/33- 40, and

seta -10).

\ 3 |
D. ae and hardening: the ieccubaesitn by heat: to
melt the wax or. other material of which “the | temporary

patterns are made and all traces of the wax are competely

removed from ee mold ‘ese iba ck

a

6. Casting the final products, in any. iigiion: number by
projecting the molten metal ‘‘under applied ‘foree into the

_ fine recesses preferably by- the centrifugal action.”’ Finally;
_the mould is separated from the casting (185/2; /48-54).°

The final result is, as the patentee say s, a cast article”
‘‘which is the exact replica of the original model. It will
he readily understaod that once. the original flexible mould

4s made any desirable. number of the patterns of fusible

material nray be produced to bé invested i in metal-receiving °
material to form moulds and any desirable number of
metal casting moulds may thus be prodneed from the same

model. All will be équally- accurate and as the final moulds
. is a complete investment SF the wax or other fusible pat-
} tern, there will be a minimum of irregularities to be

removed. The ultimate result is that metal, castings
of rings, brooches and many. pieces of jewelry which are |
frequently very fine ‘and intricate ay be produced at the
very minimum of cost’’ (185/2/55- 186/1/15).

-

The patent sp “fication then contrasts the labor and-cost
of his process with, (1). ‘the previotsly-known processes of :

casting r mys (1396/1 645-30) and’ (2) the known die-stamping.
process ( IS621, Bs. 0), :

2

The ideas of decienaia s method
on jewelry manufacture RET a

That the Jungersen method is, far superior to vifher
cuttle ‘fish casting or ‘sand casting and has practically
¥ superseded those former processes is thé concurrent find-

‘ing vf the courts below;‘and the evidence ‘is. that. in so,
superseding the old casting processes the new method, be- -
- cause of its economies and_its capability of reproducing
designs of greater intricacy, encroached even' upon die
stamping, and furthermore made possible thé manufacture
of fine’ and intricate articles that theretofore could be
produced anly by the handwork of master craftsman, if at
‘all (119-120; 120a, 122a, 12 da, f. 368). Bon ee ie es

“We have noted on page 2 ? ahove what Judge Meaney ‘said
in the New Jersey case about. the old casting process andy
Jungerser’s s improvement. He also said (25a, f , T34%

“It was not until Jungérsen: ‘added the vy er
step of casting the wax pattern in the primary mould
by the. use of centrifugai force, ‘that jewelry casting
beeaine a practically and commercially, successful art.

and he found (Findings 14, 15, 35a; Finding 27, 37a) :

“1d, The Jungersen process. -is admitted’ to be far
superior, to either ‘cuttle-fish’ casting or to ‘sand’,

casting. UE ee ‘i ee

**15,.. The Jungersen method of ease reproduces
intricate .pieces having undercuts, hollows and per-
forations without loss of detail and in exact duplica-
‘tion in any number, and reduces to an absolute mini-
-mium the skilled labor necessary to a finished product.

.

- the: New York case, J udge

sol he found (Finding y 5: 45, f. 135): °

fr . : : ° . °
if :
- °

bag” Deinonstration and commercial SUCCESS at st

‘to the success, of. the Jungersen method ot elry’
casting. ‘Such ise : resulting in the repro ele

to the finest detail of. intricate pieces of y elry, are

_.the first to be completely ‘satisfactory, and result. from:

the- combination of steps described inthe, Junge: rsen
seen

ifkind said’ (30, £ 4h): ;

** Today cuttlefish eating and sand ceasting are ot:
‘little commercial Significance. Die stamping and the +

‘lost_ wax? process are pre-eminent: in thre production,

> Of rings. ‘ o
“*The evidencé clearly supports a ealidliae that t, after

Jungersen, the lost wax process. as refined by inn bein

been extensively empltoved’ in’ .the manufacture of

——-——tngs; ; and | shall therefore er to the patent

‘commercial. success,” 72° - piace

“5, Since the introductior into the jewelry frade of;

the Jungersen : process, cuttlefish ca asting and sand —
-easting are of little commercial significance. Die
stamping and. the. process of the Jur¢ersen patent

are the only substantial methods now commercially
used in” the production—of—jewelry. “His process, as’
described and claimed in the patent in suit, has been
extensively employed in the- manufacture of jewelry 7
and is entitled to the attribute of commercial sue-

9% ~

cess.’” ae
- a }
Early Applications i in the Fine. Arts o — 4
the “Lost Wax” Process. | Res

s

The Orig in the fine arts of tha casting’ of bronze by
the *‘iost wax’ * process is obscured in the mists-of antiquity,

ae

It is-said to have been described by the monk Theophilus -
(Encyclopedia Britannic a, k4th Ed; Vol. 4. 248). The ree-.,

ords here-include a. nambe Y of extracts from the sixteenth
century / treatises ’ of Benvenuto Cellipi’ on **Goldsmithing
and Setlpture’’ (1h 448a-469a). “Several applications of
the process are deseribed; The deseription is’ vivid and
fascinating, but not too, easy to: follow. Conece ntrating,

however, on the several ways in which Cellini produced his

wax models .or- patter ns, we can: identify the following pro-
-Onmren : at | :

é ¢
" :

(1) Describing a unique silver vase he made for Francis
I, he explains the painstaking handw ork by whieh the body
of the vase was produced and says (450a): as. “After this

you may -proceed to fashion in wax whatever graces may

have place at lip ar handle,- improving. ‘on ‘the model. or
design with whieh you started”’. “These wax ‘graces’ =

modeled by -hand were reproduced: in metal. by investing

thenrin-a mixtnre-of pulverized: earth; fine ctoth shearing ae

and: ‘‘a little cows’ dung,. sifted. through a sieve, then. I
heat it all well together’’.: After painting - the wax orna-

ments witli a pigment made from tripoli and. adding inlet:

_ holes and vent chanrels, he proceeded with the investment,
heated the investment te. melt the wax and let it run out

. through the vent holes and finally east’ the molten silver.

into the cavity. In this cise the first. part of the invest-
ment was formed -about the “*oraces”’ _while_.they were
still upon the vase, thus making a ‘hollow mold portion like

an intaglio; after melting out the wax the investment was -.

remoy ‘a from ‘the vase and the opening. where the wax

4”

had, Aeen attached tothe vase was closéd up: with the in-

vestinent material (40 AOa-451a). When s‘you have. oe
And suchlike coneéeits to apply to -your -vase'’’ (442a),

f somewhat diferent procedure was followed. After fashion.

ing them care fully in wax, they avere taken off the vase

and molds. ‘made of* them by investment and. baking to

:
— —— ¢
. . 5
P ; ye a .
/ re = ¢ 7

‘* Zee Appendix, 7) fon *

-

ee eee

remove the wax. Then a coating of wax, ‘ta thin knife's
back more or less in thickness, or of such thickness as you
wish your mask to be’’, was laid into the hollow of the’
mold equally all over, the channels*and ventholes added
and the whole filled with clay, bound ‘around with wire,
‘and cast in the saine‘way as before. The cavity was, df
course, the space left between the- hollow mold portions
‘and the clay core by. melting out the thin layer of wax.
In another place (455a), Cellini describes how he made
‘‘the Perseus for the most illustrious Duke Cosimo’’. This
large figure -was first modeled in a clay composition and
finished ‘‘one finger’s thickness under actual size’’, baked
-and modeled over with a coat of wax. -He' then coats
his waxed figure with certain unguents, and with two or ,
_* three coats of clay. to form his investment, and then he
says “‘I cast it’? (455a, ff. 1363-4). Presumably before

made (454a).” Then he makes a gesso mold of ‘‘as many
small pieces as when put together would make. a complete
man, and that without any uhdercutting—as ‘for instance
feet, hands, head’’ -(456a, f. {366). Over ‘these built-up
-. small pieces, he forms a ‘mother mold’? in two or tore
pieces depending on the size of .the figure’ (457a-458a).
Then after all of the little pieces have been fitted into the
mother mold, he coats the inside of the mold with ‘‘about
a good knife’s back thick of wax or clay or paste’’, which’
. he-said-is technically termed the-lasagna. Part of the
|. remaining description is not too clear but, as’ we under-

**Plaster of Paris or gypsum as prepared for painting ‘or in
making. bas-relief” ; Webster. _. eager s

°° ‘ Lhe

stand it, he then builds over an iron frame a clay core :

which fits accurate ‘ly within the mold, heing spaced there-
frdim by the “thickness of the lasagna: ‘The [asagna is then
rel oved, and he Says

pour your wax and -fit the kernel into the mold;
then stand the figure up straight make at Jeast ‘four

vent holes, two at the feet and two at the hands, the 7

more’ vouanake the suref you will be to fill your. figure
with wax’’ (459a, f. 1876).
‘The heated wax ig thet poured into the cavity between the
gesso mold and the core (460a). After the wax has stood
for a day or two to harden or shrink a little, the mold

is opened and the wax pattern nicely polistied to rémove-

all the rough edges Ieft by the joinings of all the different

__+_pieees and-te- touch up the whole. ‘In doing this, morever,

_ the whole to melt it out, and the molten bronze cast into »

‘if you oh apie to add any subtle labor or fancy to your:
work you dre easily able to do it’’ (460a). After this, the.
avax pattern was invested, the wax removed by heating

- the eavity left ‘py. the removal of the wax. By this method

——$——

Cellini’ was able ‘to preserve his original model, which he
says enables you to work to great-advantage because
elie: IB aan

———

“many youths & able workmen can help } you clean the
bronze figure up, while if you have-no model to work.

to, this cleaning up takes a long time, is little to the
poor master’s liking, and has but a sorry result’ |

(454a, f. 1362).

The record also includes a translation of “La Geavine’ a
ete., published in Paris in 1924.” After deseribing. plaster

‘molding, tle author says (470a, f. 1409): -

: “The. moulding of pieces which are not stripped or
ofa full relief piece, is. more. difficult; it is even, in

certain cases, impractieable i in plaster, ‘and we use flex-

/ ible materials —_ as gelatin.”

‘Then you make the inlet Holes in alia you a to -

ma
\

16.
f eno, .
method Tf is ‘commercially, practice ible’’ to produce’ cast-
mes er eo sueh castings are of sufficiently great
bulk. The method, ‘however, is: not particularly adaptable |
to the production of small eastings by re ason of the rela--
tively greater expense as compared with a pressure die

asting.’’ (415a/128.4162/3).. He ends iis’ specifications:

by: saying that it is aot his ‘‘intention to claim broadly the
unaking of a plaster mold about a-fusible pattern and the -
evacuation of. said mold by. subjeeting it, and the pattern

> therein contained, ‘te a temperature which will fuse. the
pattern. “What I desire to claim, is a method -utilizing
these old practices, and in conjunction therewith the domi-.
nant and essential step of preparing ‘the pattern in a inetal
mold, which step is essential in the — of commer-_
celal castings wiry (416a; 30-52).

~

McManus Patent No. 1 ,457,040, of 1923. ( 417)

bh his patent discloses an improvement in centrifugal
casting machines. Since centrifugal gasting of molten metal -
into investment. molds is conceded to have been common
practice in dentistry’ long before | MeMfungs’ patent, the

, . : y : os 24 | ext

outs part of his disclosure we néed direct attention to is
“the following statement (418a/17 32): :

“While the: macliine. iHustrated in ‘this applic ation
and those illustrated in my former patents have been
designed more with a view to their utilization in con-
-nection with the making of dental castings, sue has for.
inlays, crowns, bridges, porcelain work, ete., the samr -
principle, with slight modifications in the structure of
the ‘apparatus, may be equally as well applied ‘to, the
.castiig of jewelry, suchas gold rings, small trinkets,
ete., where metal or other dies or moulds may be ng
to be filled by centrifugal casting mtethods, and,
course, if larger scale. operations are desired, maitable
modifications in design will readily adapt the appara- .
tus to-such purposes.’

MeManus discloses nothing about how to make initial

molds tor intricate. patterns or spite to‘get wax into such a -

- mold. ; | -
Specifications of Errors e

In case No.7, the errors urged ave that the. Cireuit
Court: of Appeals for the Third Circuit erred { Petition,
No, 467, 1947 October Term, pp, 14- 13) ;

1. In failing to hold claims 5 and 6. of the Fungersen
patent in suit valid,

2. In failing properly to interpret claims 5 and 6 on s
‘the ~— of the ‘disclosure in the specification,

‘Incase No. 48, the errors urged are that tlie- ‘Gireuit :
_ Court of- Appeals for the Second Cireuit er red (Besition
776, 1947. October Term, pp. 3-4) :

1. In failing to hold claims 1-6 inclusive valid.

2 05 holding elainis 1-5 inclusive invalid for want of
‘invention.

3. in holding: claim 6 invalid for lack of ‘nov eltv.

4. In- afirniing the, jitigment of the district court.

Oo

4 , dF ;

ARGUMENT | ee
a * Despite a long-felt wens which had existed unsatisfied
for many ‘many years, Jungersen’s methdd in its entirety

had never been assembled before. Its production by him

was a substantial—even revolutionary—technical innova-
tion, for which society is ‘truly indebted to him. The test-of
history, as it.appears from the record, conclusively proves
that Jungersen’s forward step was not obvious; that it did
require more angemnimty than thé work of a mechanic skilled
in the art. . ;

II. The lneiiina claims 5 and 6 can be and should be so
construed as to embrate but not to extend beyond what.
Jungersen truly invented; the new method specifically de-
scribed when--practiced with the substitution of known
equivalents for some of the steps particularly~defined in
narrower terms in claims 1 to 4. When so construed, -claims
5 and 6 are infringed by the low pressure injection of the.

melted wax into built-up soft. metal molds by the. force of a_

syringe or the like, sometimes substituted for. centrifugal
force by the alleged infringers.

The making of small articles of jewelry of intricate de-
tail with hollows, undercut portions and perforations runs.
back to the earliest times of recorded history.’ in the fine

arts, the casting -of bronze by the ‘‘lost wax” casting °

process also emerges from prehistoric times. The fascinat-
ing sixteenth century manuscripts of Benvenuto. Cettini-~
disclose a number of ingenious and skillful. applications of’.
- the ‘lost wax”’ process by that master craftsman; but not-
its extension to. the: field- opened up by Jungersen—the
repetitive : production of small metal articles of jewelry of.
intricate detail, designed with hollows; undercut portions
and perforations. : , ws

The bafic tools employed by Jungersen ‘in 1933 were

available to Cellini and his confreres 400 vears ago. .The

‘ ) ———_—

a

\

making of the wax model, its investiture, the evacuation:
of the investiture, and Sib casting of the metal into the

: dispe isable mold, were studio: tools in the process of cast-
ing bronze and precious metals. The building up, about
‘the meidel of a primary mold of glue or gelatin was also
known ‘and, With the-advent of vuleanized rubber; that ma-
_ terial was employed for the purpose, as’ disciosed “in the
Haseltine British patent more than half ‘a century before
Jungersen, and again, more than a quarter of a century
‘before Jungersen in Spencer’ s United States patent. The
casting. of precious metals into. itivestment molds “by
centrifugal force has béen practiced in the dental art at
least since the beginning: of this eentury and, in MyManus
“patent: 1,457,040 of 1923, the use of cenfrifugat foree_to
cast molten metal ‘into “metal. or other dies or. molds”’

> to produce ‘ ‘castings of jewelry, such as gold rings, small
‘trinkets, ete.’’, is proposed: Yet such small articles” of:
jewelry continu€d, as the record shows, to be manufac*
~~ tured erty, by handeraft er by die-stamping or by the two
primitive and inadequate casting. nethods, cuttle fish cast-
ing and sand casting, which were incapable of producing
more than a ‘“Geenmny?”? that had to be finished by skilled
artisans. . The diffictilties lay in the inability te establish
and fo maintain through the successive steps of the casté
ing process the intricate detail, with hollows, underetits and
"perforations. | - Jungersen overcame those difficulties and
“revolutionized the procedure in the commercial manufac.
ture of such articles by, his ‘six-step process, and partien-
larly by building up about the first model.a primary mold
_of plastic mold-forming material such as rubber and then
projecting the wax into the fine interstices of the rubber
‘mold by centrifugal force. med

a
a

~The résult: was 4 procedure which rendered, ‘chsolete the
old casting. procésses used in the manufacture of jewelry,
‘and even encroached ‘upon, the old die- stamping process;
extending the art. into the .production of intricacies of de-
sign which cannot ‘be fashioned by. die-stamping, and re-~
ducing the cost wherever, even in —_— designs, the

27 me
quantity of finished articles to be produced ix insufficient
to offset the relatmwety high cost of fhe stamping dies. The
art now has a commercial practicable inechod of casting:
articles which formerly could not bg repetitively, produced
-at all or could he produced in quantity only with the help
of skifled artisans. at substantially vreater expense.

t

Her e is the nub of the ease: There is no dehatable Tale
of law involved. > It is conceded tliat mere absence of
anticipation-——inere novelty alone—-is not enough; that the
subject matter must display invention; more inge nuity
than the work of a mechanie skilled. in the art. The ap-
plication ot that long-established rule-in partic ilar ¢ases
rests in each case, upon. a finding of ultimate fact. The
‘concurrent findings of the lower courts agree as a matter
of fact, that there was the long-felt want unsatisfied for
many, many years;.that with all the prior knowledge of
the men -skilled in the art, they had not gone beyond the
use of the inadequate methods: ‘od vuttle fish casting and
sand casting in’ the production of these intricate articles
of jewelry until Jungersen came forward, and that when
‘“Jungersen did bring his method’ into public know wage it
~ quickly superseded the old casting processes ‘and, as is
usually. the case with such technological icesbattann ‘tee
surpassed their possibilities: Mm intricacy. of detail and =o
eneroached economically: upon the manufacture of such,
articles by die stamping -while extending the manufactur-
ing. possibilities into more refined and. extensive’ fields.
“On this evidence, the factual conclusion must be, we sub-
mit, that Jungersen’s forward step was not obvious and
that it did require more ingemuity than the work of 4
mechanic skilled in the art. ;

‘The validity of the patent should therefore be sustained
unless ‘there ‘is now unearthed in this or in some 6ther
related art.an anticipation of Jungersen’s methods ¢ some:

> thing an whiels the Court can‘say that Jungersen’s method

Was not new; something. of which a jew eler grappling with |

the problem solved by Jungersen, and havi ing: no » know!

edge of Jungersen’s method, wontd say, if his attention
- were directed to ‘it, “That gilyes me what’ wish'’.* .

It is clear that there

fx no such anticipation of Junger-
sen’s method. ee: a |
° er aes

mt

It seents fo ‘us that the nearest approximation to it is,
the, procedure disclosed in British: patent of 1875 to Hasel-”
| tine-or equivalently in the United States patent of 1904
to Spencer. This was recognized by Jungersen in his
British patent where he said (495a/1-19-28):

‘In the casting of metal it i8 not broadly new to
make an elastic mould from an original sample or
“model, to: produce a wax or fusible pattern with the
aid of the elastic anould and to remove the pattern -
from the latter and invest it in a final. mould from
which the wax or fusible pattern is subsequently
melted out to permit of the pouring of met tal. into
the mould’ cavity thus vacated.” | ee

awe ~~

t

And the claims of Jungersen’s British patent were
_ distinguished from that -prior ‘knowledge by. defining. a |
method (496a/112-121) ‘‘characterized by the. centrifugal
_easting of a model of wax or other readily- fusible material
within a flexible, mould which has been prepared from an
original model or sainple, effectively.to displace the air
‘the mould cavity and force the model,forming material
intimately into p
we , _! : . . a y.

35 oo. eo,

ro

pressure of prluye die casting as Krahind “proposed to
use it*— a pressure which he says is too great to he with
stood even by the. pWRter.of Paris. investment molds. (See

also 97a, f. 291; 98d, f. 294; 145a, f. 494.)**. We can nqw see,
therefore, in our backward look after the solution has been,

disclosed, that Jungersen hit upon the only one of the
several kinds of force previously. used for metal casting
‘that would ‘be of any ‘use in the introduction of wax into
the intricacies of the flexible rubber molds.

a

This review of oul hindsight, however, is only anatlaie
way of saymg that it is a w aste of time to speculate about
what might have been When ‘the evidence upon tlose’
examination with all proper safeguards, shows that the’
solution was not appareut to men skilled in the art through-
-out a long, long period of ‘existing want. The probative
force of this evidence is not te be overthrown by any
rationalizations after the event that anyone could have
‘done what Jungersen did.:

*,

; 4 ‘ ‘

* In Jungersen’s patent “th€ effect was the application of force, .

a small amount of force; to catse-it to. flow a_little better into the

- details” Tour, 159a, f. 477), ahd “if * * * the casting , to be made
in: the mould is going to: take’ considerable pressure or ‘must be very
acctrate in dimensions, then the flexible moulds are too, yielding jo.
permitef. the high pressure, ur give the accuracy required” (Tour,
LSla, f. 454).

P ¢ .
Pe act: lx addition, Kralund’s process produces a pattern which must
be finished before it isiuvested and used as a fusible pattern. Fins
- are formed at the joints-of the mold yections ane at the vent
: Ie ces (ante, p. y 4) re ; ,

‘
,

The broader claims 5 and 6 can be ind should a so con-
strued as to embrace but not to extend beyond what Junger-
sen truly invented; the ‘new method © specifically described
when practiced with the substitution of known equivalents
for some ‘of the steps particularly defined in narrower terms |
in claims 1 to’4. When so construed, claims 5 and 6 are in-

_ fringed by the low pressure injection of the melted wax into
built up soft-metal molds by the force of a syringe-or the -
like, sometimes substituted for sentrifagel force by the al-
: leged infringers.

’ When claim 5° is compared with claim 1, for example, it
. is seen -that they. differ: in two significant partic vulars :
(1) Where claim 1 defines, the method of making’ a primary
mold‘as ‘‘then forming about said model a primary mold -
_of a plastic material which will retain ret shape
through subsequent treatment” , claim 5 says mnore broadly
‘then forming about said model a primary mold’’; and
(2) where claim 1 defines the method of introducing the
wax into the’ primary mold as ‘then by centrifugal action
foremg into the primary mold molten wax or other ma-
terial of:a low fusing point -that will not-injure the pri-_
mary mould’’, claim 5 says ‘‘then-intrpdueing into the’
mold “by force ‘sufficient to deposit the material into the

depression or depressions of the primary mould molten

wax or other material of low fusing point: that will not
injure the primary mould.” |

Judge Meaney held that claims 5 and 6 ‘in the light
of the prior art and more particularly in_view of Kralund
Lseruecrs aaah ‘are anticipated and: invalid” (29a, f.

—

4 Jtidige Rifkind found article claim 6 \“alsé invalid because it
describes an old article in terms of a process of manufacture” (39, - °
f. 117).° The Second Cireuit Court of Appeals, having found lack ‘o
invention in Jungersen’ s method said ‘““What we have said, of ee”
disposes of ciaim 6, the product claim. There is’ nothing new infthe
— — f. 647).

cD lend
oi . ae « ¢

Seat
86). That © nelusidn rests upon an interpretation of those:
claims ne extends ‘their beyond Jumgirsen’s. true
inve ntion. © That must be ro since Judge Meaney found
that the method discloSed- in Junge rsen's specification afd
defined i in claims 1-4 was something patentably new he yond. -

“the reach of the man skilled in the art. « ae

se ope

‘Judge Meaney’ (29a, f. 86-3la,. f. 91) ‘ipecadia that the
patentee’s s contention of novelty and validity of elaims %,
and 6 presented the following dilemma: Either those. claims
(1) ‘clearly and specifically claini the use of applied force
in depositing molten wax into the, primary mold’

(2) “by implication they ask: the Court to. read the use of ©
‘centrifugal force into the specifications of “claims 5 and 6°’
(29a, f. 87). He held that ‘*The use of ‘centrifugal force’

' to deposit the material’’ could not ‘*be read into and made
a part of the, specification of claims 5 and "6"? (2 30a, f. SS) -
and the other alternative, construing them so. breadly as
to cover the’ use of any and all kinds of applied free in
depositing molten wax in the primnary mold, led-him tg the
finding of anticipation by the ‘Kralund patent in the light.
_of the prior art... as ~

But the fact is that the éorrect ‘interpretatfon of claims

is 5 and 6 lies between those two extremes... The true posi-_
“tion is
been interpreted to embrace the whole of ‘put nothing more.
than,what Jungersen invented; that they are properly inter-
preted to cover, and are properly restricted to, the use-of
centrifugal foree and any similar fot#e, wv thich ws recognized
to be the equivalent of centrifugal force when applied in‘
the environntent defined by the other steps_of Jungersen’s:
‘ process That interpretation would have excluded Kra:—
lund’s procedure which is not at. all the equivalent of, and.
cannot be siibstituted for, Jungersen's and vet it would
have-avoided a construction of Fungerse n’s patent exelud-
ing all equivalents. /

or else -

, we submit, that élaims 5 and 6 could and should have _

. kis A put it into the ce ntrifugal casting machine
and lay this:in here, with the gate hole up towards the
erncible; then I just take a little spoontul of wax and
pour it in like this here and let her swing. = ™®
‘Tye Court: Now, —- ‘throws the wax into the
R mould. | : sili
“The Witness:> That po the. wax into the
mould, and the air will escape out through the same
entrance where the wax entered in. |
“ 2 . Ps .
.

The ‘ytill used is ‘ta soft-alloy” (S48a, Q. 83).

In No. 48, some of the alleged infringers* yse soft me ‘tal
~ moulds cs well as ribber mou I Is°. (Cpiaion, 20, f. 86; and
see 123-B29). ss |

From the evide nee it appears that the satt metal niold is
formed about the origma! model, by castiag a soft metal
alloy which«melts above the beiling point of water about
successively. exposed sections of the original smodel about
which the soft metal flows and takes the shape in negative

ot the mold, ‘This procedure is differentiated fromr.that.

when the die ts formed by Hiae chining . into hard metal as

* Claim 3'1s subordinate to claim ‘1. °

= ‘Taim 4 ts wished to claim 2. : RY Ts ; -

see At the trial eviderice on ve subject was, lithiited to this state
ment m the Partgculars (135a, , 404). tesa
o ;
; ‘ 6. 3

\
\

+

46

jn presstire die casting; im whic li case there ix ne need of
a model (Tour 153, f. 458)", abe

The men skilled in the ayt had known for many vegrs
‘several équivalent ways of forming a primary. mold of a
flexible mold-forming material sugh as rubber abort al
| medel, In. the practice of the ** lox Wax" | Process, oe

Tlie testimony of respénde nt” ide ‘fendants’ expert Tour
in. No . 48 is (161, f. 482):

**Now, you referred to thie several diffe ‘rent types of
mold; the rubber mold of Hazeltine and Spencer, the
gelatin mold of ‘La Gravure’ and the multipart cerami¢
wie} Log Cellini. You have alse referred to the mold or ;
‘die of Kralund. .W ill you eXplain whether or not molds
of these various types are and have been ~~ ‘rally and
infere ‘hangeably used in the casting.art? A. They have. :
been ‘used generally and still are used semerally and .
interchangeably. in the casting art. W herever a specitic
thing or ‘method seems most applicable that is the one
that is used. — 2 : “6
“Q. And for how long has that been true? -A.-Pre-_
sumably ever since the days of C ‘ellini for his me thod ms
and so on for the other methods; certainly as long a
| have. been acquainted with the casting art, whie ‘h is
some 27 years,” a 3 ors °

Just as, when the\hing disclosed by a patentee pos:
sesses: originality the kiowledge and capabilities of men

-. skilled in the art- must be looked at to decide whether it

possesses also the quality -of invention, so in considering
infringement of a- patent for a meritorious invention the
knowledge and capabilities of men trained in the teeh-
nology of the art must be taken. into account, Sue ‘+h men
niay be trusted to find a variety of physic ‘al embodiments

, ‘ "a

ee 7
~

# See 126, f. 377-131, ¢. 391: 137, f. 410;. 138, f.-414; 145,
t. 435. ee i :

“47. . . 2 2
2 ae, od we ss . ‘ ~ .

~

of the dea oaf tiveans whieh is the true. substamee 4 the

pate nted Inve ntions & tubodiments which are the ecfivale nt

of what is disc dosed- anid claimed in the patent. Pi mathe
matties, this gineralizdtion is. expressed incthe. phri ix that
things, which, are eal to the same thing are equal to each

‘other. dm the pate nt\ le AW, a Classie statement Af thi¢ mule |
Was given by Mr.Justice ¢ ‘Vifford: itr Machiive Co. ve Miir-

phy, C Otte 120, 125: , eet

‘Authorities cone ur ahat the. substantial equivalent
of a thing, in. the, sense of the patent law, is the same (

as the thing itself; so that if two devices do the saine
work in substantially, the same way; and acconiplish
2 pt substantially the sad: result, they are the same, even
though they. differ in.\name, form, or shape. Curtis,
Patents (4th ed. sect,’ 310.7 ‘
‘ ‘ \ e ; 4
W e venture the suggestion that: this disteine of equiva”
dents is nothing. more than the reflection of the’ reluctance
ot sophistic: ited judges to be hoodwinkéd by superficial
appearances, and -their determination in the administration

of justice for the public good to look through the form
to the substance of things. Looked at in that way, we.,

~ submit that the use by the alleged infringers,of other
known types of plastic materials than rubber and of other
injection forces than centrifugal force which act upon thre
melted wax-in'the same way to produce the same result,
is an -encréachinent irpon the true invention deseribed and
claimed in Jungersen’s patent and is the eforean infringe.
" nfent.- ss :

Rees -.. Respectfully submitted,
ice ny ; —Winwian JH. Davis,
i Grorce BE. Farruruun,
Kart W. Fiocks,
Attorneys for Jungersen.

*

es rete Appendix

“ - ‘ oe. -
oO. .

Scutprere “PecuNigue. ENevenorenia Burtaystc A,
T4tH_Ep., VoL. 20, pr 229. ‘eo

‘

°

, Cire Perpve, or Low W AX PROCESO = SThe first stage of
this process, after receiving the model}- from the: artist, con-
sists in preparing a negative made of plaster_or velatine.
This is merely a coating of thé outside of the model. In

..this negatiye, which shows all the details of the model im 5.

the reverse, a wax coating is applied in a molten state with

“a brush: until it has acquired \sufticie nt t thic kness, ne

“on the size of the figure. . \ f
At this stage, we will have a’ partes replica of, the se eulp-
ture in wax, and: sufficiently hard to. permit handling. The
artist can work on it as muchas he pleases, obtaining rare.
results of details, which makes fhis process of casting. in--
valuable. Gates-and vents in the shape of wax rods aré

‘then properly attachéd to the wax Tigure,

Finally, the mould for the metal is. formed by blowing:
or pouring ‘inside and around the wax a’ semi-liquid com-
position, which’ hardens in a few minutes. This coamposi-
tion. of silica, plaster and other chemicals can resist high
temperature, and, of course, all the waxginside of it will
inelt away, leaving a hollow space. This operation is ae-
- complished in large ovens, by baking the: moulds over a
slow fire. As soon as all the wax-is surely melted away,
the mould is removed from the oven and packed in foundry
earth ‘in’a pit provided in the floor. The bronze is the
poured from crucibles, ‘and the moltgn ietal will run
through the gates (inelted away) an ne the: space left
empty by the wax figure algo melted away (Iggt wax). The |
figuire im hrenze is then removed froin. the silt ‘a mould and.
dipped in-acid for a propet cleaning. 7 |

. ®& a
“sce F eas

ee 2

a Bes , _ _Appendis eos

a s : ‘

6 Q
Ww ith this process, the cast bronzes require very little

‘finishing or chiselling. and the results are far ahove the
sand process. — | ‘ | °

Bronze AND. Brass Onx~amentaL Work. BM NCYCLOPEDIA
‘Brrrannica,. 14rn Bo.,- Vou. 4¢ p. 240.

\ Bronze AND » BRAss Ouxaiter rat Work. The use of. bronze
~\ dates. from rémote antiqiity. ~This important metal’ is an
7 “alloy ‘composed of copper. and tin, in propostions which

yary slightly, but. may be hormally considered a& nine

parts of copper to one of tin, Other ingr edients. which are

occasionally found are more or less accidental. The -result

‘is a metal of a‘rich gelden brown colour, capable of being

worked by easting—a. process little applicable to its eom-

" ponent .parts, but peculiarly successful with brenze, the
density and hardness, of the metal allowing Tt. to take any
\ > impression of a mould, however "delicate. :

’ This process is ‘inion. as* cire perdue, and. is the most—
“primitive and most conimonly employ ed through the. cen-
turies, having been described by the monk Theophilus, and
alse -by Benvenuto Cellini. Briefly, it is as. follows: . to be produced, is made of pounded brick,’ plaster or other.
| similar ‘substance and thoroughly dried. Upon this: the
artist overlays his wax, which he models to the degree re-
quired in hi: finished wotk. -Passing from the core through
the wax and p ojecting beyond are ‘metal rods. © The model-
ling being completed; thé outer covering which will form
the mould has to he applied; thjs is a liquid férined of clay’
~ and plaster sufficiently thin to find its way into every de-
tail of the wax model, Further coatiffgs of liquid are ap-“
plied, so that there is, when dry, a.solid outer coating and
a solid 1 inner core held toge ‘ther by the metal rods, with the

\ ° “-
\

. ‘ . X
. « $ -
. * : : . -

feniomes teak

Saat A ppendia :

c
. .

“work of art modelled i in wax between. -Heat is applied and
the wax melts and uns out, aml the molten metal ts poured |
in and oceupies every detail which the wax had filed.
Wien: cool, the outer casing is carefully broken aw ay, the
core raked out as far a8 ‘possible, the projecting rods. are
removed and th object modelled i in wax appears: in bronze.
If further finish is required } it is obtained by, tooling.

‘
e o

(wow. W.)

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386406_0086%3A04. Public record. Not legal advice.
