# Reply Brief Petitioner — Martino v. Michigan Window Cleaning Co.

> Briefs, arguments, decisions, and more.

URL: https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386405_0035%3A4

## Record

- **Collection:** Supreme Court brief
- **Document type:** Reply Brief Petitioner
- **Published:** January 1, 1946
- **Citation:** 327 U.S. 173

## Text

is

, a7
°
be No. 21. +

4

Supreme Court of the United States
Octosper Term, 1945

\ THOMAS MARTINO,

PETITIONER,

- Uv.
MICHIGAN WINDOW CLEANING COMPANY,

. RESPONDENT.

\

ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES CIRCUIT
COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE SIXTH CIRCUIT

bs - ‘

PETITIONERS’ REPLY BRIEF

LEON A. COUSENS,
Attorney for Petitioners,
1442 Griswold Street,
_ Detroit 26, Michigan.

~

DANIEL D. CARMELL,

Of Counsel >
130 North Wells Street,
Chicago, Mlinois. ~
EFF 10: THE INLAND PRESS, DETROIT, MICHIGAN
- 9
oe
7

SUBJECT INDEX

q Petitioners Would Be Within the Act If es Directly by the
4 Factories Whose Windows They Wash

S Petitioners Are Engaged in an Occupation ‘ ‘Necessary to the Produc-
: tion” of Goods for Commerce and Do Not Come Within the Ex-
4 emption Provided by Section 13 ‘a) (2) P :

The’ Complaint was Improperly Dismissed

€ w . % ,
Petitioners Are Not Barred from Recovery Under the Act Because
They were Compensated according to the Terms of a Union Contract
.
hd
y

Conclusion ;
Appendix: I
Appendix II
Appendix ITI

‘ cn CITATIONS

CASES

30rden- Co. v. Borella, t5 S. Ct. 1223
Bracey v. Luray, 138.F. (2d) 8

. Gavril v. Kraft Cheese Co., 42 F. Supp. 702
‘) 4 (= Guess v, Montague, 140 F. (2a) 500 3"
j | Kirschbaum v. Walling, 316 U.S. 517 ;
i 5 {Mott v. City of Flora et al, 3 Fed. Rules Decisions 232 od
: re Ise et ak, Mutual Benefit Life Ins. Co., 3 Fed. Rules Decisions 308
a ', ernight Motor Co. v. Missel, 316 U. S. 572...

phittipe v.-Walling, 323 U. S. ——
Schmidt v. Peoples Telephone Union, 138 F. (2a) 13

‘ * 10 East 40th Street Builtling v. Callus, 65 S. Ct. 1227
Walling v. Consumers Co., 8 Wage Hour Rept. 350

~ Walling v. Fred, Wolferman, Inc., 54 F. Supp. 917

Walling ». Roland Electric Co., 146 F. (2d! 745
Walling v. Youngerman-Reynolds Hardwood Co., 65 S. Ct. 1243
White v. Jacobs Pharmacy, 47 F. Supp. 298.
Wilkenson v. Noland Co., 40 F. Supp. 1009

re

R

¥
;

Q

MIUISCELLANEOUS:

Eve Hazards in Industry, by Louis Resnick, National Society for
the Prevention of Blindness, Columbia Py iano Press, 1941,
Rg a RORY tak ON Ae A

Interpretative Bulletin No. 6, issued by Administrator of ‘Wage
& Hour Division, United States Department of Labor. .

Protecting’ Plant Manpower, Practical Points on Industrial
Sanitation and Hygiene, Special Bulletin No. 3, United States
Department of Labor, Division of Labor Standards, Government
Printing Office, Washington. 1941. Article by J. S. rained
Illumination, pp. 63-66 See

Psychology for Business and pues, ~ Herbert Moore, McGraw-
Hill Book Company, Inc., 1942, pages 344-351... Pa

\

Page

1

on

HORNA RQT AO Bw

Ce

10

ll

-

supreme bout’ of the United States
Ocroper T ERM, 1045

_ ao. 32
THOMAS MARTINO,
PETITION ER,

v.

MICHIGAN WINDOW CLEANING COMPANY,

KESPONDENT,

ce.
4
aes .
ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE *UNITED STATES CIRCUIT
’ COURT’ OF-APPEALS FOR THE SIXTH. CIRCUIT

"i PETITIONERS’ REPLY BRIEF
i Petitioners Would Be Within the Act If Employed Directly By
the Factories Whose Windows They wash

The purposes of the Fair Labor Standarils Act cannot,
he evaded by the device of cont geting out to a separate
corporation work which otherwise would be undet the
terinsnebthe, Act. Clearly, General Motors Corporation
would be within the Act if it had employed these window
Washers direetly, and the accomplishing of the same result
by employing the respondent, Michigan Window Cleaning
Company, does not deprive the window washers: of the

»rotection of the law. To construe the statute otherwise

would make possible the destruction’ of its purpose, for
it this were permitted as to an independent contractor it

2

bale be employed to remove more and more employees
from the protection ef the Act through the use of sub
ordinate corporations. ;
/ ; ¢
Nirschbaum v. Walling, 316 UL S.°517, S24, states that
‘.. . the provisions of the Act expressly make its ap
plication dependent upon the character of the employees’
activities,’ * and. establishes, that maintenance employees
may be engaged ih oc cupitions necessary to the produe-
tion of roods. for commgree within the meaning of the
Act even though net emploved by the manufacturer ef
woods. Hf the window washers in the instant case were
Employed by. respondent's customers to perform the same
-kind of work which they now do as employees of re-
spondent, there fs ye question they would be held to -b
engaged in occupations necessary. do the produetion of
goods. As is more | fully developed in Petptioners’ Briel
(pp. 22-51), and emphasized below in this Reply Brief, the
work of window washing, by whomsoever performed, is so
closely related to the physical process of production that
‘to differentiate hetween employees of the factory itself and
employees furnished ‘by an independent contractor ‘is to
make too much turn on the accident of the division of the
whole industMal precess.* (See 10 East 40th Street Build-
ing vy Callus, Go S.Ct. 1227.)

s *

Petitioners Are Engaged In An Occupation “Necessary to the
Production” of Goods for Commerce and Do Not Come

Within the Exemption Provided by Section 13(a) (2)-

The Respondent admits that the question Of the ‘neces-
rie ae ; % : 2. 99 the . .
sity ef window washing” to the production of goods for
commerce or to cemmerce itself, is not an issue in this
case, “Respondent states the oly question to be ‘whether
or not the greater portion of |respondent’s servicing: was
interstate or intrastate’? (Réspondent’s Brief, p. 24),

~ it

Saeed,

= I

‘

? RES ak eee we Vie

~

so a .

as

ars
ih ie

2)

eho ata Es Bnd. 6 cats Gis aoc

gree

et cr)

3 <

and to bolster this contention, the respondent quotes
from Interpretative Bulletin No. bi, lated December 1938
and monkey the argument that the eiterion used in Section -

,

13 (a) (2) ist based upon the nature of the business con.
dreted ly: the employes. On piee O of its Brief f, the re-
-pondent states that ‘with the foregoing citation in mind,
it is plain to see that Petitioner is proceeding upon’ an
erroneous theory which is not supported by law or the
Interpretative Bulletin.’’ The fallacy of the last state-
ment of the respondent arises from the fact that since
41, the original Interpretative Bulictin, which was issued
‘soon after the Wage and Hour Law became effective, has
hoon changed in the light of more mature considerations
and decisions of the courts, so’ that Section 5 of the same
Interpretative Bulletin No: 6 now reads:

“Tt should be noted that the ken} ireacitbes in
Sections 6 and 7 is related to the ndture of employ-
ment of the particular employee. The criterion used
in section 13 (a) (2), on the other hand, is based

( oupon the nature of the establishment in which the
employee is engaged. Thus, under sections 6 and —
7, some employees of a given employer may be
covered and others may not be covered. If, how-
ever, the exemption provided by section 13 (a) (2)
is applicable because the greater part of. the selling
or servicing by the retail or service establishment is
in intrastate commerce, all employees engaged in the
establishment are exempted from sections 6 and 7.?’

This Court pointed out iy Phillips v. W v. Walling, : 323 U. S.

. that ‘** * * the word ‘establishment? ment? [means] a dis-
tinct, physieal place of business.” Ac& ‘ordingly it follows
that even if it is assumed for the purposes of argument
that respondent is a service establishment, the greater part
of Whose servicing is in intrastate commerce, the exemp- ’
tion would in this ease not be applicable for the further
reason that respondent's employees are not engaged in
respondent’s establishment. It is not enough that the em-

~
ve

ae ie 5 » i
e ‘8

plovee be engaged by a service establishment—he must
be engaged ti a service establishment.

> ae
‘

Numerous cases have held the exemption provided by :
Section 13 (a) (2) inapplicable to establishments Sern J Oe

> egg erirn~

substantially for industrial customers. See Bracéy +. Luray, :
138 F. (2d) 8; Guess v. Montague, 140 F. (2d) 500; Walling F
vr. Consumers Ca., 8 Wage Hour Rept. 350. In Schmidt rv. a
Peoples Telephone Union, 138 F. (2d) 13, 15, the Eighth 3
Circuit refused to apply the exemption to a local telephone } ‘
company, Which of course provides ‘*service’’ in the literal \_ 7%
sense, and held that ‘‘the term applies to an altogether ~

different class of business, such as restaurants, hotels,
shana garages, barber ae beauty. _ funeral

the like.” en a

*

EL Oe MALE SSeS, LS yay Seto

It is particularly significant in the instant case that
respondent in its Bricf fails to refute the authorities cited i
in Petitioner’s Brief (p. 22-27)XalDof which esti ablish the es §
close relationship of window washing to the production of 4
goods. The authoritative sources on factory and produe- q
tion problems, such as the United States Department of %

Labor, ' the National Society for the Prevention of Blind-
ness,? and other authorities,® all place great emphasis upon
the need of clean windows for efficiency and safety in pro-
ductron. It is submitted that the conclusion is inescapable
“that the window washers involved in this ease are engaged
in an occupation which is essential to the successful oper-
ation and maintenance, of the manufacturing plants” in
which they werk and is ¢learly necessary to the production
of goods for” commerce: within ‘the meaning of the Act.
. Clearly, the activities of the window washers in this ease
are indistinguishable from the work of the janitors and

—— ee ‘

'See Appendix I. : '
*See Appendix II.
*See Appendix III.

5

‘ - ¥ : ; |
porters In the Airschbaum case and in Borden Co. v.

Borella, 65 S. Ct.-1223. *

In its Brief, respondent states (p. 26). that, ‘*Em-
ployees of respondent are not sent: ‘into’ manufacturing
plants im the sense”’employed by Petitioner. Employees

‘of respondent wash windows. The windows are’ in the

outside walls of buildings.’’ It-was stipulated, however,
that the greater portion of the work done by the em-
ployees in this case was in washing windows located in
factories Which produced goods for interstate commerce.
The respondent wants this C ourt to conclude that such a

‘stipulation means that windows ure on the ‘‘outside walls

of buildings.”’ We merely point. out ‘that those same’
walls have two sides, an ‘tinside’’ and ‘‘outside,’’ and
what we need’ not conclude that window washers climb
ap gn the outside of a building to wash windows, where
the fact is that they go jnio plants and wash the inside °
as well as the outside “of the windows.

Respondent? s Brief ¢ités many District Court opinions, .
none of which is relevant to the. instant case. A lengthy

sanalysis of eaéh of ‘these lower court citations. is nat

warranted, sinee the decisions of this Court make it
‘ear that the arguments advaneed by Fespondent are with-

o . oe

mer.’ =.” - :

«

nut

‘An examination of some of the District Court cases cited by respon-
dent discloses that they are not applicable.
Walling v. Fred Wolférman, Inc. (D.C. Mo. 1944), 54 F.. Supp. 917,

_ was erroneously decided. This Court’s subsequent decision th Phillips ».

Walling, supra (see p..20 of Petitioners’ Brief) completely répudiates the
broad construction given by the Wolferman case to the word “establish-
ment.” A reading of the context of the Court's opinion in Gavril v.
Kraft Cheese Co., 42 F. Supp. 702, indicates that this decision supports
petitioners’ position, rather than that of respondent. In the Gevril case.
the employees were held to be engaged in commerce within the meaning
of the Act and the exemption in Section 13 (a) (2) was rejected; but
the complaint Was dismissed because of the applicability of Section 13
‘b» (1), a factor wholly foreign to the issues here. Respondent cites
the decision of the District Court in Walling v. Roland Electric Co., 54
F. Supp. 733, in support of its position, but fails to disclose the fact that
this decision was reversed by the Fourth Circuit, 146 F (2d) 745, and is
now pending on certiorari in this Court. White v. Jacobs Pharmacy, 47 F.
Supp. 298, is also inconsistent with this Court’s decision in the Phillips case
and reveals a misapprehension of the scope of Section 13 ‘a) (2) into
which the court was led because of its reliance on the 1938 edition of
Interpretative Bulletin No. 6 which is discussed more fully above.

ca)

4
.

|
|
= %
:

5 ae : |
6 7 !
The Complaint Was hingreperty Dismissed ,

The objection raised by respondent's Brief . 27), that
Petitioners have introduced the question as to the pro-
priety of the dismissal of the complagnt for the first time
in this Court is net supported by the reeords The record
makes it clear (R, 23, points 3 and 4) that the point was

raised en October 29, 1943, whew petitioners. filed their

“Statement of Points’* in the Cyeul/ Court of Appeals.

. . a °
As the record will als@ disclose, no motion to dismiss

the complaint or motion for summary judgment of dis-
»missal was ever filed hy respondent and no proofs had

heen taken at the time the District a dismissed the.

complamt ae sponte, after petitioners, at the District
Court’s direction, had renewed their ‘motion for summary
judgement... The language “in accordance with the instrne

tions of the Court”? w hich. appears in the Renewal of Motion

* for Summary Judgment was inserted in the motion for the

purpose of indicat ing that. petitioners w

acting at the
Court’s order.
Instead of it being ‘‘unfair for petitioners to be permitted

to_go off into realms of possibilities, conjectures, and sup-
feritions, as respondent (p. 28)- characterizes\ the dis-

cussion of the proof which could have -been adduced, the”

Rules of Civil Procedure require that on a motion to dis-
miss the complaint, all allegations of fact in the complaint
be taken as true, in the factual light most favorable to the
plaintiff's position. Mott v. City 6f Flora et al, 3 Federal

~ Rules Decisions 232; Nye et alr. Mutual Benefit Life Ins. *

Co. et al, 3 Federal Kules Decisions 308.
i)

SE TT pia i?

SE te

2:

——
—

—

pike ‘ ae fon oo

; P
SA Ne Te eae, pry ee Wy Se ae 23 POST.
A CLI EI CER BN NORD DLED. 2 oo hi ia M8
. :

os

7
Petitioners Are Not Barred from tsekwniy Under the Act
Because They Were Compensated According to the

: —_— of a Union Contract

The contention of the respondent that the -petitioners
are estopped because of a private trade union contract
lias been consistently and unanimously rejected by this
Court. Private contracts made before or after the pas-
sage of the Wageand Hour Law regulating” overtime can-
not take the overtime transactions “from the reach of

dominant constitutional power’’ and any contract falling.

short ef the basie policy of the Act cannot be utilized to
deprive employees of “their statutg#y rights. See Over-
night Motor Co. v. Missel, 316 U. S. 572; Walling v.
Youngerman-Reynolds Hardwood Co., 65 S. Ct. 1243;
Wikenson vs. Noland, 40 F. Supp. 1009.

sf

oO

-

: ee ON ‘ | P
CONCLUSION

It is therefore agam submitted that. the judgment. be
low should be reversed and the cause remanded with
instructions to enter judgment for the Petitioners.

.

Respectfully submitted, .

Leoy A. Cousens, ;
Attorney for Petitioners.

Danien D. CarMELt,

Of Counsel, et

POPE Soe LE oy Safe

—-

APPENDIX I

ILLUMINATION *
By J. S. Rogers

‘Poor lighting harms eyes and may effect entire body—Uniform
light distribution important—General illumination—Local illu-
mination—Natural light—Recommended levels of illumination.

g

* ° e
rn

Work and safety depend upon seeing, but eyes are use-
less without light. * .* * Estimates have been made
by those interested in safety which indicate that poor ’
illumination contributes to at least 25 percent of industrial

_aceidents, , mm
¥ : ; <

Not only is it a well-established fact that poor lighting
adversely effects the eye itself, but recent ‘investigations
have confirmed a long suspected effect of. unsatisfactory
lighting conditions upon, the general health of the human e
body. All organs of the body are integrated to form a‘
luman working machine, and imperfections im one organ ”
often effect others. Thus, eye fatigue induced by the
unnecessary strain re sulting from poor lighting does effect 8

‘the general health of those who are subjected to such a
harmful environment. j .

Regardless of its source, whether it be daylight or arti-
ficial light, light obeys the same nataxal laws. Eves require |
light of not less than certain minimim quality uniformly
distributed over work areas. any

NATURAL ILLUMINATION Q
Natural illumination through windows and -skylights 1s
desirable because of its spectral quality, * " *

~ Besides directly reducing accidents and improving pro-

duction, good factory lighting aids in maintaining a clean

~ and orderly plant. Dirt hidden in corners by shadows is
~ os | '

~ Protecting Plant Manpower, Practical Points on Industrial Sanitation
and Hygiene, Special Bulletin No. 3, United States Department of Labor,
Division of. Laber Standards, Government Printing Office, Washingtdn.
1941, pages 63-66. m5

x

_ately under the glass roof of the plant

oe | 10

unnoticed Scattered material and general unkeptness are
not obvious under poor light. Beeause cleanliness and
orderliness are considered by sound nianagement definite
fagtors in the effietent and economical operation of fae-
tories, itis important from the operating point of view
that good lighting be; provided. Cleanliness and orderli-
ness mean VOGT “house ‘keeping’? [which is] an essential
ele jen i in well organized safety programs.

APPENDIX II

EYE HAZARDS IN INDUSTRY “
By Louis Resnick ©

Natural lighting—Maintenance. ot

Clean windows are essential to proper utilization of
natural light, and this simple rule of good housekeeping
will go far toward solving the lighting problem in many
plants. In plants having extensive window space but
inadequate window-cleaning service, aceumulated dust,
grease, and grime om window panes may cut natural
illutnination to zero, so that it is necessary during prac-
tically all hours of the day to resort to artificial light. The

cleaning of luminaires and of light bulbs themselves As:

equaily important.

The fact that dight ‘is a factor which increases the effici-

ency and safety of every other tool is fully appreciated

by progressive designers and owners ef medern plants. It
is not uncomufion to build track systems for window wash-
ers’ trucks upon roof and walls of factories so as to facili-
tate window and skylight working.

An example may be cited which shows the importarice .

“placed on ¢ leagy Windows by progressive industries in a
steel plant in Pennsylvania. $50,000.00 was spent for éon-
struction of a window washer’s railway .system immedi-

* * * :
.

‘Published by the National Society for the Prevention of Blindness,
Columbia University Press, 1941, p. 18-190.

4

A

\

pel
°
The proper and adequate maintenance of equipment is
essential for both hatural and artificial lighting. The factory
awner should establish a regular definite system of main-
tenance so as to insure that skylights, side windows = ag
are at all times kept clean ie

fret metemsnepenes ~e

APPENDIX Il

PSYCHOLOGY FOR BUSINESS AND INDUSTRY °
By Hervert Moore, Ph.D.

The importance .6f proper lighting can best be shown by
- civinegsome fucts that have been discovered regarding the
effeet@of poor illumination on beth efficiency and accident
frequeney. ;

A. -Effects on Efficiency. The decrease inefficiency be-
quse of inadequate iumination is shown, in a study inade
by the National Industrial Fatigue Research Board. [This

study} gives the record of work under two conditietts,——-—

whieh differ from one another only in the degree of.

lamination present. It will be noticed that not only was
‘he output lower in the first hour of the morning when
artificial lamination was used, but that it remained lower
during every hour of the day, with the exception of one
period, ns

; ae

Studies made by. the Departméntal Committce on Light-

ing of factories and workshops in Great Britam report

c
ile percentage inereases in accidents attributable to poor
artificial lighting . . . The striking fact about these

reports is that on docks and in shipyards and metal foun-
dries there were twice as many accidents dre to persons
falling during artificial as during natural I'ght.

_A study made ‘hy Stephenson on the effects ‘of artificial
light, as compared with natural light, on accident rate
showed an average increase of 36 per cent undef artificial
light. His résults Showed a‘significant increase in accident
vate during the first hour of each day when-artificial light

~

* McGraw-Hill Book Company, Inc., 1942. pages 344-351.

a

is used; that is succeeded by a period of adaptation with
approximately daylight accident rate; and then follows
a large increase in rate (140 per cent in his study), due
to the more rapidly fatiguing eve condition under artificial
light.

we

_ Percentage Loss in Reading Efficiency Under Different
Systems of Illumination

»

; Per cent loss after
System of illumination Two hours Three hours
Daylight... 22S PARR ae ae 6
REAL EN PROSE SOOT RENCE 10 i)
Semi-indirect ...........2.../........ ates 5 72

es | oneal 37 A — 8]

“2

---

Source: Frix Law Library, https://www.frixlaw.com/law-library/documents/brief%3Amicro_IA40386405_0035%3A4. Public record. Not legal advice.
